dublin city development plan 2016-22 issues paper dublin city development plan 2016-22 Welcome from the Chief Executive The new City Development Plan 2016 – 2022 will be a key strategy document setting the vision and direction for the future development of our city. Following a period of economic challenges, Dublin City Council is once again preparing a new City Development Plan at a time of change, but with emerging signs of growth indicating a more optimistic outlook for our city and country. The next City Development Plan is important as it sets out a shared vision to guide future development for the benefit of the city and all its citizens. The success of Dublin as a capital city is critical to the future performance of the city region and the wider national economy. Recent years have seen Dublin’s emerging reputation as an international technology hub with significant regeneration of the city’s docklands and strong export-led growth. The challenge now is to build on the progress made under the previous plan and to capitalise on new opportunities to build towards a sustainable future. Public participation at the early stage is important, so that the final plan can address our aspirations for the city. In this regard, I would encourage you the citizens, the communities and organisations you represent, businesses and stakeholders, to become involved and help us plan for the future of Dublin as a great city to live in, do business and enjoy. We have put this document together to highlight what we consider are some of the ’big picture’ priority issues for the city over the next six years. These are set out under a number of broad chapter headings in the following pages. At this early stage, we are looking for your input on these broad ‘big picture’ issues, but not on specific proposals relating to zoning of land. If you think we have left out any important issues, please let us know. There are a number of ways you can share your views; either online, at your local library, or at a number of drop-in sessions, and you can find out about the latest public consultations on www.dublincitydevelopmentplan.ie 1 Owen Keegan Chief Executive, Dublin City Council dublin city development plan 2016-22 2 dublin city development plan 2016-22 CONTENTS DUBLIN CITY DEVELOPMENT PLAN 2016 - 2022 THE BIG PICTURE ISSUES 1. Introduction 4 2. Shaping the City 6 3. Climate Change Adaptation and Mitigation 9 4. City and Regional Economy 11 5. Movement and Transport 13 6. Population and Housing 17 7. Sustainable Environment and Infrastructure 8. Green Infrastructure, Landscape, Open Space & 20 23 Recreation 9. Retailing 26 10. Culture and Heritage 11. Community Infrastructure and Social Inclusion 12. Environmental Assessment 29 35 38 13. Appendices: Objectives to be provided for in the development plan (Section 10 of Planning Act) 40 Development Plan Timeline 41 3 dublin city development plan 2016-22 1 - Introduction Introduction to the new City Development Plan 2016–2022 Dublin City Council is starting the preparation of the new Dublin City Development Plan on 10th November 2014. The plan-making process will review and build on the progress made under the previous City Development Plan and set the direction for the future growth of the city. The new plan will be completed within 2 years and will outline a long-term vision and medium-term strategy for the sustainable development of the city for the six-year period from 2016 to 2022. The plan will provide for new development policies, and the delivery of specific objectives, in line with development standards, guidelines and land use zoning maps, updated as necessary. To inform this process, this Issues Paper has been prepared to give a broad overview on what we consider should be included in the new City Development Plan and to prompt debate about new policy ideas to improve our city socially, physically and economically. Planning for the Future of Our City The review period for the new City Development Plan has come at a time of change. After years of economic downturn, there has been a recent upturn in the Irish economy with strong performance in export, technology and financial services sectors and Dublin’s emerging reputation as an international technology hub. The economic growth of Dublin is critical to the future performance of the national economy and it is important that the new City Development Plan is ready to capitalise on new opportunities to build towards economic recovery. Quality of life is a key factor that makes the city attractive to its citizens, visitors and to foreign investment, which is central to our future economic performance globally, so there will be an emphasis on good quality of life and the wellbeing of our growing population. The city is also faced with a number of challenges including the need to invest in new infrastructure while maximising the value of existing assets, to build sustainable communities and meet a renewed demand for development and good quality residential accommodation, to promote opportunities for healthy living and recreation while protecting the environment. Priority Issues for the new City Plan The next step is to consider these ‘big picture’ issues in collaboration with local communities, business and other stakeholders. Please tell us what you think to help us plan for the future of Dublin as a great city to live in, do business and enjoy. We would ask that you concentrate on the broad issues at this early stage, rather than specific proposals such as rezoning of particular parcels of land. 4 The following are what we consider to be the priority issues for the next City Development Plan. These priorities are a first step and are not set in stone. 1. Prosperity To support economic growth and improve Dublin’s attractiveness as a place to live, work and invest in, with an emphasis on providing for good quality of life to sustain a growing population 2. Sustainable Neighbourhoods To link landuse with public transport and make the best use of available land to support the development of sustainable neighbourhoods which have a range of facilities and a choice of quality residential accommodation. 3. Resilience To promote a balanced approach that promotes healthy living and recreational use of Dublin’s unique natural amenities while protecting the environment and building resilience to cope with climate change. To set the context and inform the review of the new City Plan, research has been undertaken into a number of topics, which are set out in the following pages of this Issues Paper. You can follow each stage of the two-year process and find out about the latest public consultations on www.dublincitydevelopmentplan.ie dublin city development plan 2016-22 Background and Strategic Context International Dimension Dublin operates in a globalised world where city regions are increasingly important economic drivers. These city regions are competing with each other internationally to attract inward investment. International benchmarking is becoming increasingly important in terms of measuring and comparing the performance and attractiveness of cities. To build our international status, Dublin needs to meet key environmental, social and cultural benchmarks so we can continue to attract and keep talented people. We also need to build partnerships with other city regions and develop a strong brand identity to promote Dublin as a world-class city. The National Development Plan sees the implementation of Transport 21 as a way to consolidate the city by integrating land use and transport. However, it should be noted that the more recent ‘Infrastructure and Capital Investment Framework 2012-21016’ had deferred certain large infrastructure projects such as Metro North, Metro West and Dart Underground. Other key national policies reaffirm the need for a compact city with consolidation achieved by increased densities of development along sustainable transport corridors and the optimisation of under-utilised lands. There are also forthcoming changes in planning legislation to include new social housing requirements for developers, the introduction of a vacant site levy and ‘Use it or Lose it’ clauses with planning permissions. Statutory Context European: The City Development Plan sits within a framework of higher-level policies to ensure the strategic development of the city in the broader regional, national and European context. European Directives require early and ongoing assessment of a Development Plan in terms of their potential impacts on the environment. These are applied through Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) and Appropriate Assessment (AA). A Flood Risk Assessment will be aligned with the SEA process. Considerations for the Development Plan in relation to these are outlined in this Issues Paper. National: The National Spatial Strategy (NSS) sets out a 20-year framework for balanced regional development across Ireland between 2002 and 2020. The Strategy recognises the key role that Dublin plays as an economic driver of the national economy and on the international stage. The Strategy also recognises the importance of Dublin Airport, the Dublin-Belfast economic corridor and the role of the capital city as a gateway to Ireland. Region: The Regional Planning Guidelines (RPGs) for the Greater Dublin Area (GDA) 2010 to 2022 set out a settlement strategy for the Dublin and Mid-East Region that also promotes consolidation of Dublin’s metropolitan core, which includes the entire administrative area of Dublin City Council. The RPGs set ambitious housing targets to be achieved by Dublin City Council by 2022 along with the delivery of public transport and community infrastructure, although these are based on population projections prepared before the last census. While it is anticipated that new regional guidelines will be prepared during the preparation of this Plan, it should also be noted that the population of the city is increasing. The need for a strategic approach to the provision of housing in the Dublin Area was recently underlined in the Government’s ‘Construction 2020’ strategy. City: Taking account of the higher-level policy development framework, the medium- to long-term vision for Dublin will be set out in an evidence-based ‘core strategy’. The Development Plan incorporates the 5 RPGs into a settlement hierarchy to focus investment and growth into strategic locations. ‘Local Area Plans’ may also be prepared for areas in need of renewal or for areas subject to large-scale development ’Strategic Development Zones (SDZ)’ can be prepared, for example the Grangegorman SDZ and North Lotts and Grand Canal Dock SDZ Planning Schemes were prepared during the lifetime of the current Development Plan. Format of this Issues Paper The format of this Issues Paper is based on a number of strategic topics, which are outlined in the following chapters: Shaping the City Climate Change Adaptation and Mitigation City and Regional Economy Population and Housing Movement and Transport Sustainable Environment and Infrastructure Green Infrastructure, Landscape and Open Space Retailing Culture and Heritage Community Infrastructure and Social Inclusion Environmental Assessments dublin city development plan 2016-22 2 - Shaping the City Dublin is shaped both by its natural and man-made features. The River Liffey, together with the area between the canals, containing both the old city and the world famous Georgian Squares, all help to convey the city’s strong character and identity. The basic building blocks of this unique urban character consist of buildings, streets, urban spaces and neighbourhoods. At all levels, it is important to foster character and coherent patterns of urban structure, to make the city more legible and create a sense of place. The core strategy of the existing development plan seeks to create a compact, quality, green, well-connected city with a mix of uses that generates real long-term economic recovery with sustainable neighbourhoods and socially inclusive communities. It establishes a spatial hierarchy for the city, which prioritises the inner city, key developing areas, key district centres, and strategic development and regeneration areas. The strategy seeks to: expand the city centre towards the Docklands, Heuston and Grangegorman; develop sustainable urban villages such as Rathmines and Crumlin; and make new developing / regeneration areas such as the North Fringe and Docklands. This creates the opportunity for new place-making in areas such as the North Fringe and Pelletstown, which have rail transport, streets, boulevards, and parks forming an extension to the city character areas. The recently approved Planning Scheme for the Docklands Strategic Development Zone also provides the opportunity for new place-making in the creation of an urban quarter with a city block structure and good public transportation including the Luas and ‘dublinbikes’. Grangegorman is a substantial inner city area that has been under-utilised for decades. A Strategic Development Zone Planning Scheme has been approved to guide the redevelopment of Grangegorman as a consolidated campus for the Dublin Institute of Technology and healthcare facilities for the Health Service Executive. Development has started at Grangegorman and later phases will integrate the campus with Broadstone and the new Luas cross-city line. Traditionally, the Liberties had a more organic spatial structure. Further consideration needs to be given as to how new development in and around the Liberties, such as on Thomas Street, the Guinness lands, and the new children’s hospital site can further integrate the area into the city. The Dublin Port Company Masterplan 2012 has a core aim of integrating Dublin port with Dublin city and its people. The Masterplan provides for soft boundaries, viewing points, new footpaths and new amenity areas. The identity of Dublin city is closely associated with Dublin port. Now there is an opportunity to reintegrate the city with its maritime character and enhance the ability to experience the Bay. Height as part of the Shape and Structure of the City Dublin contains a wide range of buildings that contribute to its streetscape from Victorian terraces, to office quarters, to educational institutions, to Liberty Hall and the Alto Vetro building at Grand Canal Dock. In this context, the current development plan protects the historic city centre including the Georgian Squares whilst providing for 6/7-storey development in the inner city, 6-storey development near heavy rail / underground stations, and 4-storey development in the rest of the city. High buildings may be permitted in a number of areas including Docklands and Heuston, subject to the provisions of a relevant Local Area Plan or Strategic Development Zone. Do the prescribed building heights allow sufficient flexibility to consider local circumstances? For example, the Docklands SDZ allows for the possibility of an additional set-back floor and the recently completed extension to the Mater Misericordiae University Hospital is nine storeys in an inner city location. Should the new development plan allow for some limited flexibility in relation to building height, and provide opportunities to make quality additions to the skyline? Urban Form & Density Vacant Land One of the main objectives of the current development plan is to create a sustainable compact city with good public transport, less reliance on cars and a sustainable mix of services and amenities including schools, libraries, shops, and parks for each neighbourhood. Dublin is now recognised as a thriving European city with a growing number of areas providing accommodation at sustainable densities such as Docklands, Ashtown/ Pelletstown and Ballymun. 6 Recent surveys indicate that there are approximately 300 vacant sites on 65 hectares of inner city land in Dublin. This together with the proposed vacant land levy represents a significant opportunity to encourage infill development in the heart of the city. How can these vacant brownfield sites contribute to the character of the city? dublin city development plan 2016-22 A Coherent, Connected City The city centre contains new clusters of development such as at Docklands, Temple Bar, and Heuston. Others are emerging, including the DIT/HSE campus at Grangegorman and the Digital Hub. In addition, a number of civic spaces have been created, for example, the GPO plaza on O’Connell Street, Smithfield and at the City Hall. The City Council has implemented a wayfinding scheme to link these clusters and spaces and assist visitors in finding their way around the city and experience Dublin’s unique character and atmosphere. The Dublin City Public Realm Strategy 2012 contains long-term actions and assigned projects including: the Grafton Street quarter public realm plan; the Trinity to IMMA ‘Dubline’ route; and the project to connect Grangegorman to the city. An outdoor advertising strategy based on the sensitivity of differing geographical zones has been adopted and included in the development plan. What needs to be done to further improve urban public space in Dublin city? Urban Design / Architecture Expanding the City Urban design is essentially a tool to assist in the craft of creating quality urban spaces; it is about how buildings are put together to shape and enliven our streets and civic spaces. Good urban design supports the economic, social, cultural and sustainability goals of the city. Dublin’s built-up area is now extending out to the city boundaries, with new communities at the North Fringe, Pelletstown and Park West. The strategy in the current development plan is to promote a hierarchy of mixeduse centres ranging from key district centres down to neighbourhood centres. The challenge is to ensure that these areas are integrated into the structure of the city. Architecture, if done properly, contributes to the quality of urban life, civic pride and city identity. Good architecture recognises that most buildings work quietly as a backdrop to the city and, in turn, allows the city to be distinctive. A City of Neighbourhoods All neighbourhoods serve a local community. A common theme across the city is that good neighbourhoods serve as focal points for the surrounding community with a range of services and facilities, typically in a vibrant and attractive physical environment. Progress has been made with the significant improvements in the residential amenity and urban design quality of developments, with new mixed-use, family-friendly neighbourhoods and communities emerging in areas such as Ballymun, Pelletstown and the North Fringe. The Docklands is another distinctive cluster of neighbourhoods in the city. Consideration needs to be given to the integration of policies in the DDDA Masterplan, supporting these neighbourhoods, into the new City Development Plan. Urban Public Space The public realm is an important part of Dublin’s identity, of how we understand ourselves and how we want to present ourselves to others. It contributes to Dublin’s competitiveness both by influencing the image of the city abroad and by being attractive for people who live in, work in or visit. The public realm is vital to our city life and this importance requires us to understand it and influence its future. The current development plan supports the concept of good sustainable neighbourhoods which are areas where an efficient use of land, high quality design, and effective integration in the provision of physical and social infrastructure combine to create places people want to live in. How can the new development plan promote the creation of good sustainable neighbourhoods? 7 dublin city development plan 2016-22 Some Issues for Consideration What more needs to be done to improve urban public space in Dublin city? How can vacant sites best contribute to improving the character of the city? How can the city best provide new additions to the skyline which will accommodate sustainable residential and economic development, which will in turn provide for investment in the built heritage? In what way can the new Development Plan enhance Dublin’s uniqueness in this era of globalisation? How can the new Development Plan ensure that the design of new buildings meets the quality, adaptability and longevity of earlier periods? How can the structure of the city facilitate sustainable patterns of settlement and employment? How can we retain urban grain and texture, given global trends for larger floorplates and buildings? How do you think new development can help to integrate regeneration areas and new communities into the city? What are the most important requirements for creating safe and pleasant pedestrian routes across the city? In your opinion, what are the important aspects of the Docklands Masterplan (2008) that should be included in the new Development Plan to support both existing and new Docklands neighbourhoods? How can the new Development Plan encourage the creation of good sustainable neighbourhoods? How can the new Development Plan improve integration between Dublin port and the city? How can we achieve sustainable densities and create places where people will want to live and work? Should the new Development Plan allow for some limited flexibility in relation to building heights to take account of particular local circumstances? 8 dublin city development plan 2016-22 3 - Climate Change Adaptation and Mitigation It has been confirmed by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change that warming of the ocean and atmosphere is happening and that there is clear human influence on climate. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) assessed Ireland’s climate in 2012 and found causes for concern; average annual surface air temperatures and sea surface temperatures are rising, and this is impacting on climate and ecology. Available data suggests that sea level is rising at approx. 1.7mm per year. The number of frost days has decreased while the number of warm days has increased. Projected impacts of climate change in Ireland include; more extreme weather conditions, changes in species distribution, water shortages in the east of the country, and an increased likelihood of coastal and river flooding. We now need to both reduce the impact of the city’s activities on the climatic environment through mitigation measures, and secondly to adapt to the changing climate. The city needs to develop resilience to climate change and its impacts such that any negative impacts from events such as storms or floods are not lasting ones with consequences for residents and businesses. Reducing greenhouse gas emissions is one effective way of reducing the influence of climate change. Increasing our share of renewable energy and adopting measures to conserve energy is, therefore, important, and the Government has adopted a national strategy for renewable energy for the period 2012-2020. Ireland’s National Renewable Energy Action Plan (“NREAP”), required under an EU directive in 2009, set a target for 40 per cent of Irish electricity consumption to come from renewable sources by 2020. Dublin City now encourages sustainable energy generation and use through its Sustainable Energy Action Plan 2010-2020, and monitors sustainability indicators to gauge progress. This is an important element of mitigation. 2014 saw the release of the National Energy Efficiency Action Plan (Department of Energy Communications and Natural Resources) which again works towards energy savings targets for 2020, drawing together many actions and policies. In 2012, the ‘National Climate Change Adaptation Framework’ (Department of Environment, Community and Local Government) was published, and Local Authorities have been asked to prepare local adaptation plans as part of the development plan process. Adaptation actions will be required as part of these plans in order to avoid or reduce the adverse impacts of climate change and take advantage of any positive impacts. This will involve an inter-disciplinary approach, focusing on influential factors at local level - including energy use, settlement patterns, transport, and green infrastructure. Overall, the City Council has made progress since the adoption of the last development plan in regard to both mitigating climate change and implementing adaptation measures. 9 In addition to the aforementioned progress, initiatives include: At a general level, the city promotes a more compact city in order to reduce urban sprawl and reduce unsustainable travel patterns. Examples include the Docklands SDZ and the new Grangegorman Campus. The publication of ‘Sustainability Report 2013’. This used a wide range of sustainability indicators to help us understand the condition of our environment. This forms a useful baseline for evaluating future indicators. A variety of work has been done in relation to assessing flood risk and devising or implementing designs to protect the more vulnerable parts of the city – a key element of climate change adaptation. In 2013, DCC adopted a major emergency plan which sets out co-ordinated systems for effectively responding to emergency situations caused by severe weather, or major fires (for example). This improves the city’s resilience to such emergencies. The Council works continuously with Dublin’s energy agency, Codema, on projects aiming to reduce energy use, both through improved awareness and by changing behaviour. The Council is active in looking at new ways to make the city more resilient and now works with universities and communities to pilot new ideas such as the EU-assisted TURAS project in collaboration with UCD. TURAS is an acronym for ‘Transitioning towards Urban Resilience and Sustainability’. dublin city development plan 2016-22 Some Issues for Consideration To what extent can settlement patterns, live/work proximity and urban design influence climate change/resilience in the city? How can the Development Plan address the range of challenges associated with climate change to ensure Dublin successfully adapts to climate change and implements appropriate mitigation measures? Energy usage in the city is necessary to serve residents, businesses and transport. In addition to current measures, are there further ways of reducing energy use, conserving energy, or generating renewable energy that may benefit the city? Are there opportunities for sustainable district heating schemes? Given the likelihood of increased flood events, measures such as green roofs, planted areas, and sustainable drainage systems can all help reduce surface water run-off and hence improve resilience. How can the forthcoming Development Plan minimise volumes of surface water draining from new development? Green industry has been promoted in the city by encouraging low-energy buildings and also through specific projects. Are there specific areas of the city that need attention to address energy concerns? The new Development Plan is likely to contain revised standards for development. To what extent should sustainability goals influence these standards? Are there opportunities to increase solar energy in the city? 10 dublin city development plan 2016-22 4 - City and Regional Economy Changes in Context since the adoption of the current Plan in 2010 The current Development Plan sets out economic development Policies and Objectives in areas such as: Enterprise, Innovation, Clusters and Corridors, Offices/ Commercial/ Employment Space, Economic Area Regeneration, Vacant Lands and Buildings, Tourism, Visitors, International Education, and Conventions. The economy is recovering; development has recommenced in Dublin and there is a growing understanding of the role of Dublin as the national economic engine. However, there are supply problems and associated price rises in the office and housing sectors that, in turn, present challenges to our international competitiveness. Supply shortages of offices has seen prime rents in Dublin 2/4 growing by 15% in the first half of 2014 and 46% on an annualised basis. There is an enhanced economic role for local government, particularly through the Local Economic and Community Plan to be prepared under the Local Government Reform Act 2014. NAMA now has a developmental role in the supply of housing and office space. The involvement of major international investors in property development in Dublin is a recent innovation, facilitated by recent legislation to allow for Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs). There are proposals to introduce a vacant land levy in a Planning Bill to be introduced in this term. This was initially proposed in 2013 by a task force set up by the then Lord Mayor Oisín Quinn1. The abolition of Dublin Tourism, with its role now incorporated into Fáilte Ireland, presents a new tourism role for Dublin City Council, with ambitious tourist targets set for Dublin to double the number of visitors by 20202. Changes to the visa programme have been introduced by the Government to make it easier for tourists, such as those from China, for example, to visit Ireland as well as improving attractiveness for international entrepreneurs. The City Council has a growing International Relations role and this has great potential in promoting international investment and economic links with countries such as USA and China. In addition, various other economic agencies and functions such as Digital Hub, Dublin Docklands Development Authority, the City of Dublin Enterprise Board etc., are/will be incorporated into Dublin City Council. The extended ‘dublinbikes’ scheme has significantly increased the connectedness of the city; and as such, will enhance the potential of its various economic clusters; e.g. Digital Hub to Docklands. The Local Enterprise Office (replacing DCEB) is now based in the Civic Offices supporting local enterprise and entrepreneurs.The introduction of Strategic Development Zone (SDZ) planning schemes for areas such as the Docklands will bring socio-economic benefits to the areas and the State. 1 See http://www.dublincity.ie/sites/default/files/content//Planning/Documents/Vacant%20Land%20 Memorandum.pdf 2 Destination Dublin – A Collective Strategy for Growth to 2020’; Grow Dublin Taskforce http://www.failteireland.ie/FailteIreland/media/WebsiteStructure/Documents/4_Corporate_Documents/ Strategy_Operations_Plans/Dublin-a-Collective-Strategy-for-Tourism-Growth.pdf 11 Some Emerging Sectors and Areas with Growth Potential Dublin is successful in attracting international students and English language students in line with national and City Council Development Plan policies. However, while there is a growing shortage of student accommodation, there are international investors and providers willing to develop, such as the scheme currently under construction at Digital Hub. In other cities, clusters of professionally managed student accommodation are significant forces for regeneration of areas. The various food sectors in the city are a growth industry. In 2011, the City Council produced a discussion document “Food and the City” that outlined the employment and economic development potential of the various sub-sectors3. The café/restaurant sector is thriving in the city; they are important sources of employment, and critical in making the city attractive for workers, visitors and residents. Craft distilleries and breweries with visitor centres are major, long-established economic generators in US cities. Currently, three are proposed in Liberties, with one already under construction. Indoor and outdoor markets for food and other goods are increasing and successful. In other cities internationally they are major tourist attractions as well as a service for residents4. The Lord Mayor’s Taskforce on Hotel Capacity in Dublin (2014) set out: “A new plan for tourism in Dublin: Destination Dublin – A Collective Strategy for Growth to 2020 (and) identified that if Dublin showed a return to growth, then an additional 5,000 rooms would be required. The supply of registered self-catering units, at 50, is very low for a city of Dublin’s size.” 3 See http://www.dublincity.ie/sites/default/files/content//Planning/EconomicDevelopment/Documents/ food_and_city_final_april.pdf 4 The Part 8 planning application to include retail and generally radically improve the City Council Fruit and Vegetable Market has been submitted. dublin city development plan 2016-22 Some Issues for Consideration How can the development plan promote a greater supply of offices, housing and hotels where shortages are emerging? How can we encourage more FDI investment in the physical development of the city? How do we optimise the potential of Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs)? Many of the city’s most important visitor attractions are in regeneration areas with significant challenges in terms of vacant land and buildings, and with a public domain in need of improvement. How can we extend the ‘Dubline’ tourist route investment project to other parts of the city? How do we release the economic potential of the Georgian quarters whether as visitor attractions or unique places to live, as set out in “The Future of the South Georgian Core” (Dublin City Council 20136)? How can we encourage the further development of the various food sectors in the city? What kind of planning approach should be taken towards the role of cafes and restaurants in the city? The Z6 employment zone includes office districts in the city centre (e.g. Harcourt Street) and suburban industrial estates. Do we need to refine this zoning? The Development Plan states that the inner city area is the key national innovation resource. It also recognises the need to improve the linkages (proximity) between key economic generators such as Docklands or the Digital Hub and the core city centre. How can we best implement this objective, including improved public domain and better provision for pedestrians? There is significant international investment interest in developing and managing high quality student accommodation in Dublin. This is a great opportunity in providing high quality accommodation, enlivening the city, regeneration etc. Do we need to refine existing policy to optimise the benefits for the city? The extensive 63 hectares of vacant land in Dublin’s inner city is both a great challenge and an opportunity for the city. How can we expedite the early and high quality development of these c. 300 sites? The current Development Plan states that the transformation of regeneration areas, especially inner city areas, is a “key policy priority” as this area is the city’s “core economic generator”. What new policies or approaches do we need to achieve the transformation of these regeneration areas? The Quality of Place in the City/Quality of Life/ the Liveable City/ Safe, Clean, Green; are key international competitiveness issues for cities to attract FDI; mobile talent; tourists, international students etc. How can we ensure that Dublin is world-class in terms of these international attractiveness factors? The Development Plan recognises that openness and diversity are economically beneficial to the city. Can planning policy help implement the new statutory duty on public bodies to have regard to human rights and equality in the carrying out of their functions5 in a way that is beneficial to the city and its economy? Density drives productivity and innovation in a city; do we need to assess our Plot Ratio/Site Coverage standards for its economic impacts? Tourism is set out as one of Amsterdam’s five economic pillars. How do we enhance existing Development Plan policies and objectives on tourism to deliver on its great potential for the city? 5 Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission Act 2014. See also “Globalisation, Diversity and Economic Renewal”, Dublin City Council (2011). 12 6 http://dublincity.ie/sites/default/files/content/Planning/OtherDevelopmentPlans/AreaActionPlans/ Documents/DCCSCSISouthGeorgianCore.pdf dublin city development plan 2016-22 5 - Movement and Transport The current City Development Plan seeks to promote the integration of land-use and transportation in order to accommodate as much movement as possible by high quality public transport, by walking and by cycling. Whilst the approach of the current plan remains valid, the policy context has changed significantly, and cooperation between various agencies responsible for public transport is a key requirement. The transportation policies and objectives of the new City Development Plan will be guided by the objectives of the National Transport Authority’s (NTA’s) draft transport strategy 2011-2030 and the related 2013-2018 integrated implementation plan. The document ‘Smarter Travel – A Sustainable Transport Future‘ (Department of Transport, Tourism & Sport) is also influential in encouraging the growth of more sustainable modes of transport. It set out ambitious national-level targets for the period 20092020 which included a reduction in the total share of car commuting from 65% to 45%, and a related increase in walking, cycling and public transport modes to 55% of total commuter journeys to work. Within Dublin, the number of persons crossing the canal cordon in the morning peak provides useful information. In the period 2006-2013, the proportion of commuters walking and cycling increased while the proportion using public transport declined. Looking closer at public transport, an increase of 20% in LUAS use during this period was offset by significant reductions in bus and rail use. Meanwhile, cycling increased by 87% during this period, with the ‘cycle to work’ and ‘dublinbikes’ schemes incentivising cycle use. A key challenge for the next plan is to achieve significant gains in public transport use and further increases in numbers walking and cycling. Numbers of persons crossing the canal cordon inbound between 7 and 10 a.m. – 2006-2013. 2006 2013 Persons crossing the canal ring total By public transport 207,379 192,188 % change 20062013 - 7.3% 102,437 91,981 - 10.2% By car 76,850 68,072 - 11.4% Walking 17,114 17,495 + 2.2% Cycling 4839 9061 + 87.2% Source; NTA 2014 The integration of land use and transportation has a key role to play in delivering social, economic and environmental sustainability. Higher residential densities can be sustained in areas proximate to public transport corridors, where mixed-use neighbourhoods reduce the need to travel elsewhere for services. 13 Transport Strategy & the Importance of a Regional Approach Following the Government’s earlier ‘Transport 21’ strategy and the economic difficulties encountered nationally over the last 5-6 years, the planned public transport network has been modified in recent NTA proposals. Some objectives may take longer to achieve than originally envisaged and therefore interim measures are proposed; for example, Bus Rapid Transit routes are being planned to serve areas that will be eventually served by METRO routes. The next development plan must take account of the expected sequence of planned public transport delivery so as to maximise sustainable transport usage. Dublin as the capital city and a regional employment centre must accommodate journeys not only generated in the city area, but also those originating in surrounding counties. The challenge is how to integrate policy approaches with similar policies of surrounding counties, thereby ensuring a consistent approach across the region. In this regard, policies for the City will be guided by strategic recommendations set out in statutory ‘Regional Planning Guidelines for the Greater Dublin Area 2010-2022’, the proposed new Regional, Spatial and Economic Strategies (2016 onwards) and also NTA policy. dublin city development plan 2016-22 Future of the City Public Transport & Mobility Management Cycling & Walking Currently, over 190,000 people travel to the city centre in the mornings and this is projected to increase significantly by 2020. The challenge is how best to manage access to, and mobility within the city. Because the City Centre is the most accessible area in terms of public transport, it is therefore the most appropriate area to consolidate, as intensification here can be accommodated in a sustainable manner. A major issue we need to address is how the city’s limited road space can accommodate the spatial needs of public transport, pedestrians, cyclists and the private car. Provision of an efficient and integrated public transport system promotes sustainable development, helps improve the urban environment, and helps sustain economic progress and competitiveness. The National Transport Authority’s ‘2030 Vision’ for the Greater Dublin Area will now guide policy to the year 2030. This includes proposals for the rail interconnector, bus investment, two Metro routes (Metro North and Metro West) and further Luas line construction, with a strong focus on the integration of routes and services. Given that responsibility for public transport rests with a range of separate agencies, strategic co-ordination of planning objectives along with integration of services remains a key requirement. Cycling infrastructure has improved in recent years, and the number of cyclists crossing the city’s canals increased by 87% in the period 2006-2013. The ‘dublinbikes’ free bike scheme has also gained popularity, resulting in the scheme’s recent expansion into new areas. The NTA has carried out extensive work leading to the publication of a detailed Cycle Network Plan for the Greater Dublin Area, and this will help inform the next development plan. The question now is - how can more people be encouraged to cycle (or walk) instead of using private cars for short journeys? For cycling to increase in popularity, appropriate infrastructure must be provided – and this includes improved layouts at junctions (for example) and also the availability of high-quality, cycle parking, particularly in the city centre. Kerbside space and infrastructure for electric cars and car clubs increase the competition for street space. Clearly a balance must be struck between meeting these demands and keeping the city moving from a commercial point of view. Volumes of through-traffic in busy mixeduse areas remain an issue to be addressed. Mobility management aims to reduce demand for, and use of cars by increasing the attractiveness and practicality of other modes of transport. Collaboration with communities, schools, workplaces and agencies can bring about modal shift on the ground. Projects such as ‘Hike It Bike It Like It Drimnagh!’ demonstrate that a partnership approach between the City Council and local communities can be successful in changing how people in an area travel from day to day. Similarly, under the ‘Green Schools’ initiative run by An Taisce, environmental sustainability is encouraged, and this includes the promotion of walking/cycling to school. Of course, the design of new areas can also assist in minimising the need to travel by car. 14 The quality of the pedestrian experience of the city centre is important to our perception of the city – whether as part of journeys to work or more leisurely trips. It influences people’s enjoyment of the city and is dependent on quality public realm including pedestrian routes and public spaces. More people will use public transport in the future when new facilities are provided, and this will put further pedestrian pressure on certain areas as footfall increases. This requires consideration as part of the development plan review. As more and more space is given over to public transport and cycling, it is crucial to ensure that sufficient space is retained for pedestrians, and to increase this space where possible. dublin city development plan 2016-22 Car Parking and Car Sharing Provision of car parking is necessary for the functioning of the city, and as part of an effective land-use and transportation policy. Current policy is to restrict parking to encourage both public transport use and walking/ cycling, particularly in the City Centre which is well served by public transport. Technology is likely to play an increasingly important role in helping motorists both find parking spaces and paying for them, thereby improving convenience. In reviewing the City’s interaction between land uses and transportation options, it will be essential to ascertain the success or otherwise of parking standards which have previously been implemented. The preservation of onstreet car parking as a resource for residents, visitors and businesses is becoming increasingly important as competition for road space increases. In particular, increasing pressure to remove on-street parking in order to facilitate other uses means that it is becoming more important that new private developments meet their own needs without relying on the public street. Car sharing and the sharing of private vehicles reduce numbers of vehicles on the streets whilst ensuring users are not solely dependent on public transport. Whilst car sharing is a relatively new concept in the city, the expansion of such schemes has potential to significantly reduce car ownership and also to reduce demand for parking in the city. Environmental Considerations Environmentally damaging emissions and noise pollution from motorised transport can impact on public health and on the perception of the city generally. In Dublin City, transport accounts for 25% of the primary energy consumption and 26% of CO2 emissions. Emissions must be minimised to achieve a sustainable transport network, reduce associated health effects, and to lower impacts on climate change. A shift from private transport use to public transport, cycling and walking therefore has multiple benefits, yet the proportion of commuters travelling to work by car in the Greater Dublin Area actually increased in the period 2006-2011. This remains a significant challenge to be addressed 15 dublin city development plan 2016-22 Some Issues for Consideration What measures would encourage a more significant changeover from private car to public transport, cycling and walking? Can local community initiatives help? What is the role for the car, pedestrian and cyclist within the City Centre area? Are existing car parking standards appropriate? Are there possibilities for further limiting car-parking provision? Should private developments accommodate their own car and cycle parking and loading and servicing needs within their own sites and not be reliant on this occurring on the public road? How can the cycling environment be improved for cyclists in the city? What form should any new cycle-parking facilities take? What measures are needed to create a high quality street environment, providing a safer and more attractive setting for people to move around, socialise and to do business? Should the function of city streets be considered in detail? Should the pedestrianised street network in the City Centre be extended? At what scale or threshold of proposed development should Mobility Management Plans (MMPs) be a requirement? How could Dublin City Council be more proactive in engaging with communities, businesses, schools, hospitals and other agencies etc., to promote more walking, cycling and public transport use? Do current parking standards need critical review? Should there be tighter controls on parking provision in the vicinity of public transport routes? Should there be greater provision for park-and-ride? What policies and objectives can be used to encourage modal change from private car use to more sustainable forms of transport? How can the Development Plan promote the use of cleaner, more environmentally-friendly vehicles? Should specific public road space be reserved for car club parking and for the charging of electric vehicles across the city, including residential streets? How can the new Development Plan facilitate improved coordination between land-use and transportation facilities in order to achieve more sustainable development? 16 dublin city development plan 2016-22 6 - Population and Housing Population Change Population Targets Density and Standards For the 20-year period between 1991 and 2011, intercensus population change data shows a growth rate of 9.8% for Dublin City, 23.9% for the Dublin Region, and 63.1% for the Mid-East Region. This indicates that Dublin City has a relatively low population growth rate in regional terms and that population dispersal is continuing across the Dublin region and beyond. It also emphasises the need for Dublin City to provide quality housing in sustainable neighbourhoods to meet the future needs of all members of the community. The Regional Planning Guidelines (RPG) for the Greater Dublin Area 2010 contains a population target for Dublin City of 606,110 in 2022. Some 21,000 residential units were completed in the city between 2006 and 2013; however, the number of completions in recent years has fallen to around 500 per annum. A very sharp rise in housing completions in the order of 7,000 plus per year would be required to make up for the shortfall in completions in recent years and meet the current RPG target for 2022. In 2011, the population of Dublin City was 525,383, which is almost 10% higher than it was in 1991. However, population change is not evenly distributed, with the population of the inner city growing by 61.6% whilst the population of the outer city fell by 1.2%. This reflects the significant amount of higher density apartment and mixed-use development in the inner city whilst development in the outer city has been counterbalanced by de-population in mature suburban areas. The 2012 housing land availability survey estimated that there were 440 hectares of zoned land in Dublin City suitable for residential and mixed-use development. It is vital to optimise this potential, particularly as the city has a finite supply of land. In this context, measures may need to be taken to increase housing capacity in the city such as increasing residential densities or altering zoning objectives to allow for more residential development in order to demonstrate that the new development plan provides sufficient capacity to meet the current Regional Planning Guidelines target. Dublin City needs to encourage innovation in housing typology which delivers on peoples preferences in a sustainable manner. Currently, there are pressures to provide low-density suburban houses juxtaposed with pressures to provide studios or micro-apartments. A recent report from the Housing Agency indicates that 57% of the demand for new housing in the Dublin region will be for one and two person households in the 2014 2018 period and this has consequences for the type and density of housing supply required. An issue is how can the development plan encourage the provision of house types for all life stages and potentially facilitate stock rotation to ensure existing larger homes are available for families? The range of accommodation options available for single-person occupancy (or smaller households) is a related concern. There were 208,008 private households in Dublin City in 2011. Dublin City has a higher proportion of oneperson households and a lower proportion of couples with children compared to State averages. Furthermore, the average number of persons per household in Dublin City dropped from 2.6 in 2002 to 2.4 in 2011. Falling household size will increase the need for homes suitable for 1 to 2 people. Notwithstanding the above, the regional targets are to be reviewed shortly and may be reduced on the basis of the most recent population projections from the Central Statistics Office in 2013, which take account of 2011 census data, and indicate that an appropriate population target for Dublin City is 580,000 in 2022, or some 26,000 less than the current Regional Planning Guidelines target. 17 Furthermore, the Government’s construction strategy ‘Construction 2020’ indicates that good quality homes are needed and that it is time to learn from past mistakes. Making apartments attractive to live in for a wider variety of households is an important argument to maintain and perhaps even enhance standards, particularly in inner city locations. The population of the city is ageing, and we may need to explore special retirement style accommodation. dublin city development plan 2016-22 Housing Supply Vacancy There are particular concerns about housing supply in the Dublin region, with only 1,360 homes completed in 2013, or about 16% of the national total. There has also been a reduction in mobility in the housing market for a range of reasons including negative equity, protection of tracker mortgages, and financing constraints. Limited supply combined with a significant reduction in the number of second-hand houses being placed on the market has resulted in increased upward pressure on prices, especially in Dublin. The Central Statistics Office monthly Residential Property Price Index indicates that Dublin residential property prices grew by 25.1% in the year to August 2014. There are some unfinished estates in the City Council area, though these tend to be relatively small in scale, with the problem more significant in outer commuter and rural areas. Dublin City had a vacancy rate of 10.7% in 2011 which is high considering a typical vacancy rate in a functioning market would be expected to be about 4.56%. A challenge for Dublin City is to establish effective means to encourage the use of existing vacant stock, including disused upper floors in order to address rising housing demand in the city. Dublin City Council is part of a regional Housing Supply Coordination Task Force focusing on monitoring trends in the supply of approved developments and working to identify and address any obstacles to viable and appropriate development. The forthcoming Planning Bill will include measures to enhance housing supply with the introduction of a vacant land levy aimed at incentivising the development of vacant sites in urban areas and enabling planning authorities to modify the duration of planning permissions where larger developments do not keep to a submitted schedule for construction. In addition to the development of a new funding and management model, the priorities of the Dublin City Council Housing Department are to: increase the supply of social housing; improve existing housing stock; support independent living; improve housing services; and address the needs of people experiencing homelessness. The forthcoming Planning Bill is likely to include new Part V provisions requiring developers to provide up to 10% of their housing units for social housing, and will ensure that social housing units will be located predominantly on the site where the original development is located. Housing Regeneration & Social Housing Homelessness Dublin City Council’s Public Private Partnership projects collapsed with the downturn in the economy and the associated decline in the property market in 2008. In this context, a multi-disciplinary task force was established by Dublin City Council, which has secured permission for the initial phase(s) of regeneration at O’Devaney Gardens, Dominick Street, St. Teresa’s Gardens and Dolphin House. A challenge for Dublin City Council is the growing demand for social housing and how to increase the provision of social housing in regeneration areas and elsewhere in the context of constrained exchequer funding and restricted capital expenditure. The Council in consultation with institutional investors is seeking to reduce its reliance on Exchequer funding and devise a model that will not negatively impact on the public sector borrowing requirement. 18 Dublin City Council is the lead statutory authority for homelessness in the Dublin region and continues to implement the Homeless Action Plan. The main emphasis of the Homeless Action Plan and a major challenge for the Council is to continue to provide for long-term accommodation in line with Government policy which is to take a housing-led approach to tackling homelessness. dublin city development plan 2016-22 Student Accommodation There is a need for high quality, purpose-built and professionally managed student accommodation in Dublin City. The student accommodation provisions of the development plan need to be updated to encourage the provision of additional high quality accommodation for a growing sector of the economy. Some Issues for Consideration How can Dublin City provide for the housing needs of all groups, including older people, students, people with disabilities, the homeless, etc.? Where should new social housing be provided in the city? How can the provision of social housing be increased in the context of constrained exchequer funding and capital expenditure? Inclusive Communities Dublin is now a culturally diverse cosmopolitan city which: promotes the provision of new accommodation for older people with housing associations; addresses traveller disadvantage issues at inter-agency and local traveller accommodation consultative committee level; promotes citizen engagement through various initiatives including the EU TURAS project which aims to empower citizens to create sustainable and resilient urban areas. How can the new City Development Plan encourage innovation in housing typology which delivers on peoples’ preferences in a sustainable manner? How should the new Development Plan respond to the changing demography of the city including falling household size, which will increase the need for homes suitable for 1 to 2 people? For example, should retirement villages be considered? How can the new Development Plan encourage the provision of house types for all life stages and potentially facilitate stock rotation to ensure existing larger homes are available for families? How can the residential potential of the city be optimised in the context of limited land availability and increasing demand? 19 What are the obstacles to viable and appropriate development which the forthcoming Development Plan should seek to address? What measures should be considered to encourage the use of existing vacant stock, including disused upper floors, in order to address rising housing demand in the city? Where should high quality student accommodation be provided and what standards should apply? dublin city development plan 2016-22 7 - Physical Infrastructure Introduction Energy Water Supply & Wastewater Treatment The efficient and timely delivery of necessary infrastructure capacity in advance of the planned quantum of development is a prerequisite for successful urban development. Ensuring the delivery of this infrastructure in a sustainable manner, which enhances the quality of the city’s environment and facilitates the sustainable economic growth and co-ordinated development of the city, is also an essential requirement. On a global level, climate change is recognised as an issue of increasing significance to the environment. Fossil fuel use is responsible for over half of all Greenhouse Gas Emissions (GHG) globally, and the majority of these emissions come from energy supply, transport, residential and commercial buildings, and industry. Reducing energy consumption and finding alternative renewable sources for energy and transportation are the most prominent issues targeted by national and international policies in order to reduce CO2 contributions. 7 The Dublin region faces a number of infrastructural challenges particularly in the supply and demand of a high quality drinking water and also for wastewater treatment. Dublin City Council needs to look to more sustainable energy technologies that are clean sources of energy and which have a lower environmental impact on the receiving environment. Sustainable energy sources can reduce air emissions as well as water consumption, waste, noise and adverse land-use impacts. At a more strategic level, climate change is one of the most significant and challenging issues currently facing humanity. Increased levels of greenhouse gases, such as CO2, increase the amount of energy trapped in the atmosphere which leads to global impacts such as increased temperatures, melting of snow and ice and raising the global average sea-level. It is important that Dublin City responds to these challenges. The European Union (EU) has set ambitious targets of 20% reduction of CHGs from 1990 levels, 20% of energy consumption to come from Renewable Energy Sources (RES) and 20% improvement in Energy Efficiency (EE) by 2020, also known as the ‘’20-20-20’’ targets. The two main EU Directives that set about achieving these targets are the EU Efficiency (EE) Directive (2012/27/EU) and the EU Renewable Energy Sources (RES) Directive (2009/28/EC) which requires that 20% of the energy consumed within the European Union is renewable. The target set for Ireland is 16% of national gross final energy consumption to come from renewable energy sources (RES) by 2020 across the electricity, heat and transport sectors. The Regional Planning Guidelines (RPGs) identify the need for a more sustainable mix of energy sources, and to support low carbon technologies and sustainable modes of transport. The RPGs identify the need to develop Energy Action Plans and Climate Change Strategies at a local level. 7 Energy Issues and Climate Change Mitigation; Background Paper, Codema September 2014 20 Irish Water is responsible for public water services, and for capital and investment decisions regarding the country’s water infrastructure on a national basis. Irish Water was established in 2013 as a semi-State company under the Water Services Act 2013. From 2014, Irish Water took over responsibility from the Local Authorities on a phased basis for the operation of public water services including management of national water assets, maintenance of the water systems, investment and planning, together with the management of capital projects. Ringsend Waste Water Treatment Plant serves Dublin City and parts of neighbouring counties. Its contributing residential population is in the order of 1.1 million and the total load is 1.7m PE (population equivalent) on average, with significant daily fluctuations. Irish Water has stated that the current works which were commissioned in 2003, and the subsequent improvements during the 10 years of operation, have greatly improved operating performance and stability of the process and the odour issues which arose during the plant’s first years of operation, and this has been essentially eliminated. Dublin City Council will continue to work closely with Irish Water and endeavour to ensure that the Dublin City Council Core Strategy continues to align with the Regional Planning Guidelines and that the provision of water/wastewater services will not be a limiting factor in terms of forecasted growth. dublin city development plan 2016-22 Surface Water & Flood Risk Management Climate change brings with it new challenges for Dublin City in the area of flood management. The challenges relate to extreme weather events (including pluvial/ monster rain) and the rise in mean sea-level with potential storm surges. Dublin City Council, in conjunction with the Office of Public Works, has responsibility for surface water drainage and Flood Risk Management. The Department of Environment, Communities and Local Government (DECLG), in conjunction with the OPW, produced Guidelines for Planning Authorities on ‘The Planning System and Flood Risk Management’, 2009. The guidelines will ensure that where relevant, flood risk is a key consideration in preparing development plans and local area plans and in the assessment of planning applications. Planning Authorities and An Bord Pleanála are required to have regard to these guidelines in carrying out their functions under the Planning Acts. Dublin City Council is committed to assisting the Office of Public Works (OPW) in relation to the Eastern Catchment Flood Risk Assessment and Management (CFRAM) Studies. CFRAM Studies have been completed by the OPW in conjunction with local authorities for the River Liffey and River Dodder catchments, which identify flood risk areas, and the structural and non-structural measures and options for managing flood risks. The associated flood maps will be incorporated into the Dublin City Development Plan. Under the Waste Management Act 1996, as amended, a Development Plan is required to include the objectives of the Waste Management Plan for its area. Any waste management policies and objectives contained within the new Regional Plan will be reflected within the new Dublin City Development Plan 2016-2022. Waste Management In Dublin, the blueprint for the development of drainage services and flood protection over the next quarter century is set out in the Greater Dublin Strategic Drainage Study (GDSDS). That study identified, at a strategic level, the infrastructure required to service existing and new development in the context of dealing with storm water and foul effluent. As part of the production of this study a detailed report was prepared on climate change impacts and this document gives coherent guidance, particularly to new development, on how climate change impacts should be addressed. In addition, the regional waste-planning framework is to be re-shaped to allow for greater resource efficiencies in the implementation of the plans and to better reflect the movement of waste. The transformation from ten regions to three has been formally completed with the new regions as follows (a) Eastern-Midlands Region, (b) Connacht-Ulster Region; and (c) Southern Region. The Draft Eastern and Midlands Regional Waste Management Plan (2015-2021) is currently being prepared and its main purpose is to provide a planning, policy and implementation framework for the prevention and management of non-hazardous wastes generated in the region. The Waste Framework Directive sets out the approach for the sustainable management of waste in the Member States of the European Community and this has been transposed into Irish law by the European Communities (Waste Directive) Regulations 2011. The transposing regulations led to amendments of the Waste Management Act and the requirement to review and, if necessary, prepare regional waste management plans within the State remains. In July 2012, the latest Government National Waste Policy document, A Resource Opportunity, recommended the consolidation of the waste regions to a maximum of three, providing greater consistency and co-ordination with other planning frameworks. 21 dublin city development plan 2016-22 Telecommunications Dublin City Council recognises the importance of telecommunications infrastructure to the city of Dublin. The availability of services such as high-speed broadband is essential to the national economy but also to local communities in everyday life. Telecommunication infrastructure in Ireland is generally provided on a private basis and is regulated by the Commission for Communications Regulation (ComReg), which is a statutory body responsible for the regulation of the electronic communication sector. Air & Noise Quality Dublin EU Directives set out air quality standards in Ireland and other member states for a wide variety of pollutants. The EU Commission set out the principles to this approach in 1996 with its Air Quality Framework Directive. Four ‘daughter’ directives lay down limits for specific pollutants. The Ambient Air Quality and Cleaner Air for Europe (CAFE) Directive (2008/50/EC) replaced the Framework Directive and the first, second and third ‘Daughter Directives’. The fourth Daughter Directive (2004/107/EC) will be included in CAFE at a later state. Some Issues for Consideration According to the Environmental Protection Agency emissions from road traffic are now the primary threat to the quality of air in Ireland; the pollutants of most concern in this regard are nitrogen dioxide (NO2) and fine particle matter, expressed as PM10 & PM2.5. The EU Environmental Noise Directive (2002/49/EC) put in place a Europe-wide system for identifying sources of environmental noise, informing the public about relevant noise data and taking necessary steps to reduce noise. All member states are required to develop strategic noise maps. Dublin City Council has adopted a number of new policies to help manage environmental noise exposure throughout the city and has cooperated with the three County Councils of Dublin to produce a combined Noise Action Plan for Dublin, which covers the period from 2013 to 2018 and lays out the measures for the management of environmental noise exposure. How can we ensure the timely provision of major physical infrastructure projects to facilitate the sustainable economic growth of the city? How should flood risk be addressed and what further mitigation measures/projects are needed to minimise potential flooding in the city? How should we further encourage renewable energy use along with energy supply? What further measures can be introduced to improve energy efficiency in our current building stock, and to encourage the use of large-scale District Heating for new and existing building stock? How can the new City Development Plan meet its national targets for renewable heat, and to increase the amount of sustainable fuels and high efficiency technologies used to supply heat in the city? What measures can be provided in the new Development Plan to ensure that Dublin City is well served in terms of telecommunications infrastructure, including broadband? The introduction of the ban on the sale of bituminous fuel in 1990 led to a dramatic and sustained improvement in air quality in Dublin. While some major sources of air pollution have been largely eliminated, others such as emissions from the transport sector have emerged. The Clean Air Package announced by the European Commission in 2014 will involve a fundamental shift in tackling air emissions at source, with the possibility of introducing even tighter air quality standards from 2020 onwards. What can the City Council do to further promote waste reduction, and to encourage recycling? What measures are needed to improve our Air Quality and reduce Noise Pollution in the City? 22 dublin city development plan 2016-22 8 - Green Infrastructure, Landscape, Open Space & Recreation Dublin is shaped by its major landscape features – the Phoenix Park, the Liffey, Dublin Bay and the river valleys of the Tolka and Dodder. These features are complemented by the man-made amenities and green spaces of the city squares and historic gardens, the canals and waterfront promenades. All of these features contribute to the city’s high quality environment. Green Infrastructure The city’s green infrastructure – the network of green areas around us, the natural heritage and recreational amenities – plays a key role in creating and sustaining places, making the city an attractive place to live, benefiting health and well-being and making sure that the essential components of environmental sustainability are safeguarded Green Infrastructure (GI) can therefore be described as the interconnected networks of land and water around us that help sustain environmental diversity and enrich our own quality of life. Dublin City has valuable natural resources and the city’s Green Infrastructure Network incorporates the following range of assets: a) Parks, gardens, institutional grounds, allotments and community gardens. b) Green and blue corridors, including rivers and canals, including their banks, streets, road and rail corridors, cycling routes and rights-of-way. d) Archaeological and historic sites and sites of natural heritage or ecological value. e) Functional spaces such as flood storage areas and sustainable drainage schemes. f) Buildings and hard-surfaced areas incorporating greening initiatives such as green roofs, green walls, and planters. Green Infrastructure presents a tool for providing ecological, economic and social benefits through natural solutions. It helps us to understand the value of the benefits that nature provides to human society and to mobilise investments to sustain and enhance them. It also helps avoid relying on infrastructure that is expensive to build when nature can often provide cheaper, more durable solutions (for example, GI can reduce volumes of surface water and related pipework). Many of these green infrastructure solutions also create and support local job opportunities. It is crucial that the City Council, through the new Development Plan, raises the profile and awareness of Green Infrastructure over “grey” solutions. Traditional “grey” infrastructure solutions to storm water management require expensive pipes, detention basins and storage tanks. They can entail increased energy costs associated with pumping water. Typically built for only a single purpose, they can also be difficult to site in built-up places. c) Natural and semi-natural green spaces including, wetlands, grassland, brownfield sites, and coastal areas. 23 dublin city development plan 2016-22 A successful Green Infrastructure strategy in the city will improve the city’s visual appeal because green space makes places more inviting and attractive and enhances a sense of wellbeing. People living and working with a view of natural landscapes appreciate the various textures, colours, and shapes of native plants. Birds, butterflies, and other wildlife attracted to the plants add to the aesthetic beauty and appeal of green spaces and natural landscaping. Green space also offers possibilities in terms of increasing social activity, improving community cohesion, developing local attachment and lowering crime levels, particularly in deprived communities. In addition, there is much evidence of Green Infrastructure delivering key benefits for public health and wellbeing, including: • Increased life expectancy and reduced health inequality • Improvements in levels of physical activity and health • Improved psychological health and mental wellbeing Ecosystem-based strategies that harness the adaptive forces of nature are among the most widely applicable, economically viable and effective tools to combat the impacts of climate change. When appropriate, such strategies use Green Infrastructure solutions. Green Infrastructure will also be a necessary addition to reducing the carbon footprint of transport and energy provision. Green Infrastructure solutions will contribute significantly to the development of Green Transport Corridors, using the potential of healthy ecosystems to sustainably mitigate carbon emissions. A Green Infrastructure Strategy as part of the Development Plan review can make a significant contribution in the areas of development management, climate change, disaster risk management, and the environment. In most cases, the contribution that Green Infrastructure can make is already recognised. What is needed now is to ensure that it becomes an integral part of Development Plan implementation. Many aspects of Green Infrastructure may also increase property values by improving the aesthetics, visual amenity, drainage, local flood protection and recreation opportunities of an area. These in turn can help restore, revitalise, and encourage growth in economically distressed areas. 24 Landscape and Open Space Landscape and key open spaces give people a sense of identity and place. Dublin’s setting on the River Liffey, with the Dublin Mountains to the south, Howth to the north, and also the amenities and wildlife of Dublin Bay, are key landscape and open space features which offer so much to the city in terms of amenity and character. The City Council manages over 1,400 hectares (3,460 acres) of public open space and creating additional areas of urban green space is a priority in both newly developing and regeneration areas. Existing areas and streets in the urban environment can be invigorated through greening initiatives; for example, provision of green roofs and green streets can create new habitats. Dublin has a proud heritage of parks. The City Council is very conscious of this heritage and the value of our network of green spaces and urban trees for the physical and mental health and wellbeing of its citizens providing as it does opportunity for rest, relaxation and recreation. The aim of the City Council is to ensure that all citizens of the city have reasonable and proximate access to quality open space, nature, play and recreational facilities. dublin city development plan 2016-22 Sports and Recreation Dublin City Council’s Sports and Active Recreation Strategy (2009-2016) has been developed to deliver enhanced services to encourage healthy and active living. The Council is promoting accessible communitybased sports & recreational facilities and programmes, to encourage sustainable development and drive participation rates in all sports. The Sports & Recreation Section of the Council provides a wide range of sports from indoor & outdoor sports to watersports. The City Council is also a key provider of children’s play facilities. Meeting the increased demand for sports facilities is a major challenge, both in terms of resources and in finding suitable locations for new facilities. The issue of informal recreation is also increasingly recognised as important, particularly to encourage out-of-doors activity for children and teens. There is a need to provide spaces for unstructured play, for casual games, for minority sports, and also spaces for young people to meet in our public spaces and parks. Some Issues for Consideration What role should Green Infrastructure have with respect to spatial planning/land use, infrastructure development, landscape/ biodiversity and drainage? Should the role change depending on the area? What are the barriers that may impede the integration of Green Infrastructure in spatial planning? How can these barriers be overcome? How can existing buildings in the city be retrofitted with Green Infrastructure? For new developments, what standards should be sought? What incentives could be provided? Should the efficiencies associated with Green Infrastructure be highlighted, so that decisionmakers can determine the cost effectiveness of using GI solutions? How can the Development Plan facilitate the provision of more publicly accessible open space and ensure that the new spaces are located to address deficiencies in open space? Are current standards (in terms of both quantity and quality) for public open space in new developments appropriate? How might new standards meet objectives for sustainable urban development? 25 How can we provide for additional greening of the city landscape and the protection of existing natural features including trees and hedgerows? What greening initiatives should be considered for the city and incorporated into new developments? How should the key areas and features of natural beauty or interest and the landscape of historic value be identified and conserved? How can we make sure that the increasing demand for sports and leisure facilities can be met and that all new developments are addressing the sport and recreation needs (including minority sports) of their communities, including new communities? How can we provide for local informal recreation and play areas suitable for all ages including older persons and teenagers? dublin city development plan 2016-22 9 - Retailing Introduction Retail Provision and Statutory Guidance City Centre Dublin is the primary retail destination in the country and home to many prestigious outlets. The city is served by a retail hierarchy ranging from large shopping centres at the top, down to small local shops. The current development plan aims to maintain and enhance this retail structure through a co-ordinated approach via the development, management and local area planning processes. It takes account of architectural and historic context – providing appropriate guidance for sensitive areas. The development plan is also guided at regional level by the ‘Retail Planning Strategy for the Greater Dublin Area 2008 – 2016’. The established retail hierarchy within the city aims to ensure an appropriate degree of retail provision at each level from local level upwards. The city centre retail core remains the premier shopping destination in the country, attracting shoppers from both within and well beyond the city’s boundaries. The city centre also has significant cultural, sporting and retail attractions all within walking distance of each other, a combination that gives variety of experience for those visiting the city. Maintaining and improving the status of this area involves a range of policy areas including retailing, public realm, and accessibility – and therefore a number of policy areas must function in tandem. How various forms of retailing and non-retailing uses are regulated in core areas of the city remains a matter for review. This is particularly relevant in architecturally sensitive areas of the city where poor quality shopfronts or signage can have a negative impact. Whilst recent years have seen a decline in retail sales (particularly for comparison goods), current indications suggest that consumer sentiment will slowly recover. The context is changing, however, with both discount retailing and online retailing (or ‘e-tailing’) emerging as major new components of retailing in the city. Planning for the future, therefore, requires consideration of these changes. Level in hierarchy Example City Centre Retail Core O’Connell Street, Henry Street, Grafton Street and environs Ballymun, Ballyfermot, Northside, Clongriffin, Rathmines Key District Centres Neighbourhood Centres Local/Corner Shops Raheny, Fairview, Ranelagh Typical newsagents It remains a challenge to ensure there are sufficient populations to keep suburban retail services viable and self-sustaining within this hierarchy; particularly in newly planned areas where recent Local Area Plans or Strategic Development Zones are in place. Such areas include Clongriffin/Belmayne, Ashtown/Pelletstown, and Dublin’s Docklands. Of course, the quality of the retail offer in older established centres is also important, with some centres in need of redevelopment or refurbishment. Local markets can also play a role and these add diversity to the shopping experience. The statutory Guidelines for Planning Authorities on Retail Planning and related Retail Design Manual (2012) set out best practice for retail development and include policy objectives of promoting city/town centre vitality through a sequential and plan-led approach to development, enabling tailored proposals, a preference for public transport access to such outlets, and ensuring that new development is of a high design standard. 26 dublin city development plan 2016-22 It is considered desirable to improve the retail connectivity between the main retail cores of Henry Street/O’Connell Street and Grafton Street, with new retail outlets in the connecting areas and an improved pedestrian environment. Also, larger retail buildings and units are at a premium in the city centre, particularly around Grafton Street, which may lead some retailers with specific requirements to seek units further from the retail core or outside the city boundary. Paradoxically, there are also areas in other prime locations (such as O’Connell Street) where plans for extensive multi-storey retail developments have been postponed. Vacancy of retail units in parts of the city has been a problem for some time now, and the City Council is open to new ways of addressing this issue. New Retailing Options Retail and Urban Experience The continued rise of online retailing, or ‘e-tailing’ mainly for comparison shopping - presents a challenge to and also new responses from comparison retailers, leading to changes in the retail offer, including targeted advertising and in-store online shopping. The model for fashion and luxury retailing has been changing and is now integrated with tourism, leisure, and ‘wellness’ concepts, with leisure facilities in some cases mixed with the more traditional retail offer. Large suburban centres such as Dundrum Town Centre have been very successful and this is not only because of the broad retail offer but also because of the general ambience within the complex and accessibility options. In response, DCC and the Business Improvement District scheme (BID) have promoted initiatives to make the city centre a more pleasant place to shop by initiating street enhancement schemes, such as currently being undertaken on Grafton Street, or by ongoing litter/graffiti removal. This is a result of floor areas being freed up as demand for comparison goods moves online. Given emerging retail practices, the provision of adequate broadband coverage and smart technology may well be as important a factor for generating sales as floorspace currently is doing. Also, the growth of cruise tourism in Dublin has taken place relatively recently, and there may be options to expand or improve the retail offer available to these visitors. Some existing district centres and shopping centres across the city are of an ageing typology and are difficult to upgrade without great expense, whilst in some city streets, particularly off the main shopping thoroughfares, there is a proliferation of non-retail uses such as mobile phone outlets, coffee shops and other services which can sometimes impact on the retail character of these streets. There is also recognition, however, that such uses offer a supporting ancillary role to retail, so it is therefore important to achieve a satisfactory balance between these uses and core retailing. Part of the development plan review process will therefore examine how streets function in relation to core retail provision, service provision or both. 27 dublin city development plan 2016-22 Some Issues for Consideration What is the best means of improving the retail viability of the city? The existing retail hierarchy descends from the city centre through district centres down to neighbourhood and local centres. How are changing patterns of retailing impacting on this? Vacancy has been an ongoing problem in some areas. Should more be done to encourage temporary uses and pop-up shops in these units? The city centre retail core includes two significant attractors centred around Henry Street/O’Connell Street on the northside and Grafton Street on the southside. How can the retail offer of these areas be better connected? How can local markets including farmers’ markets be supported and developed further? What role can the City Council play in assisting their progress? Luxury retail tourism driven by overseas visitors has increased in the last few years. How can this benefit the city whilst also improving choice and convenience for these tourists? Is there an appropriate balance/distribution between retail and restaurants/cafes in different Category 1 and Category 2 Shopping Streets (see Chapter 10 and Figure 18 of the current Development Plan)? Has the growth of supermarkets and convenience stores had an impact on local shopping or provided greater access for all to convenience (food) shopping? Has the growth of online retailing diminished the vitality of retail centres? Will the development of smart technology reduce the need for product display? The catchment areas of some major retail centres located outside the city boundary extend significantly into the Dublin City area. How can the City maximise shopping opportunity and choice for those who live/work or visit the city? 28 dublin city development plan 2016-22 10 - Culture and Heritage 10.1 Built Heritage Introduction Dublin City Council aims to identify and protect the special qualities of the city’s historic features, whilst also promoting greater awareness of their character and value. There is a strong cultural and economic justification for valuing and protecting our built heritage as it is a tangible link with the past and also constitutes a vital tourism revenue stream for the city. Built heritage in the development plan spans across the three realms of conservation, archaeology and heritage and each in turn are examined below. Conservation There is commitment in the current development plan to designate Architectural Conservation Areas (ACAs) with a particular focus on suburban residential areas of the city. To date, five such ACAs have been completed and are located in Westmoreland Park, Temple Place, Colliers Avenue, Elmwood Avenue Upper & Lower & Elmpark Avenue and Ranelagh Avenue. Work to identify areas where ACA designation is desirable is ongoing. Possible ACAs for consideration in the forthcoming draft development plan may include some areas of civic or industrial heritage importance. The ACA designation process is beneficial too in that the information collated contributes to considerations regarding the Record of Protected Structures (RPS). It is also worthwhile to review existing policy concerning the protection of historic street furniture within the wider debate of public realm provision, management and maintenance. These measures are particularly relevant in the context of implementation of the Dublin City Public Realm Strategy (2012) which aims to achieve a better quality environment through agreed process and agreed standards whilst using limited resources. There are two major concentrations of Georgian architectural heritage in the city situated in the North Georgian Core (Parnell Square environs) and the South Georgian Core (Fitzwilliam Square environs) and both are the subject of regeneration proposals. The Parnell Square Cultural Project includes proposals to provide a variety of public cultural facilities, including a new City Library, complementing the landmark Hugh Lane Gallery and the Dublin Writer’s Museum. The South Georgian Core is in need of a policy approach to stimulate a revitalisation of this part of the city where residential can again be a common use. The North Georgian Core may, however, present a different set of challenges in terms of the level of residential sub-division of the former townhouses, a lack of higher end uses and, what some would consider as a marginal north inner-city location. However, in both instances it is important to encourage suitable uses given they are in such central locations. 29 Conservation initiatives for individual structures have been implemented, particularly where these were for unique uses or exemplified a particular social strata. For example, the Mansion House has undergone repair and enhancement and the late Victorian-style Fruit & Vegetable Market in the north inner city is being renovated as part of an innovative food market project. The recent conservation of the City Assembly House that forms part of one of the most complete surviving groupings of eighteenth century merchant’s houses in the city, on South William Street, has also been a success. Central Government is proposing an initiative for the refurbishment of historic buildings in city centre areas through the ‘Living City Initiative’. Under this, homeowners and commercial property owners would be able to apply for tax relief on the refurbishment of buildings in designated areas built prior to 1915. Also important is how contemporary design in historic areas accords with conservation philosophies and best architectural practice. Thus how we approach design for sensitive infill sites is a challenge. The development plan process presents an opportunity to review and rationalise the Record of Protected Structure (RPS) which currently includes approximately 9,000 structures. This process will also take into consideration work done for the National Inventory of Architectural Heritage (NIAH) as part of the reassessment. dublin city development plan 2016-22 Archaeology Archaeological investigative techniques are used for development sites where items of heritage value may be present. In recent times these same techniques have been used to gain further knowledge of historic graveyards and ascertain if there are heritage sites in amenity areas such as parks. Such initiatives result from objectives in the City Heritage Plan. Other objectives in the City Heritage Plan that have been fulfilled include a new Dublin City Archaeological Archive, co-ordinated citywide 1014 millennium celebrations and organised events relating to the Vikings and Medieval Dublin. However, there is potential for greater interpretation and promotion of archaeological heritage on an area basis to both local communities and visitors. Embracing the concept of community archaeology, one option would be to engage in educational and community archaeological projects, for example a road show on historic graveyards in the city. There is also an opportunity to develop the river, canals and maritime waterbodies as a heritage resource in tandem with recreational amenity. Similarly, there is potential to link archaeological and heritage sites with public open space and public realm initiatives, especially in the city’s medieval core. Progress has been made in terms of promoting the heritage of the old city, most notably in terms of the wayfinding system which plays an important role in linking areas of cultural significance. For example, a Dublin Discovery Trail which extends from College Green to Kilmainham, incorporating the medieval city, represents a collaborative project between the City Council and other stakeholders. Such initiatives are also important during a time where limited development has meant there are fewer opportunities for archaeological investigation, particularly of medieval sites. Archaeological surveys and investigations can often be initiated on church and graveyard sites as these are not subject to the same development pressure as other sites. The curtilage of a church often provides an important historical resource and can be an attraction for visitors, which accords with an emerging interest in graveyards and genealogical research. Also, such land can be utilised for recreation and amenity purposes which raise issues of possible disturbance of archaeological remains. As those historic sites pose their challenges so do those sites that are the most ‘recent’ in heritage terms. Identification and protection of the city’s industrial heritage remains a priority. A particular challenge is the safeguarding of industrial buildings or structures which are not listed for protection or in active use, thus potentially leading to dereliction and loss of historic fabric. The National Monuments Acts protects sites and monuments up to 1700 AD, but not thereafter, when industrialisation commenced. Therefore, it will be important to record and evaluate for protection, examples of industrial heritage in Dublin City. 30 Further protection measures for identified heritage sites that could be considered for completion over the course of the next development plan includes the implementation of the City Walls Conservation Plan, St Luke’s Church and Graveyard (the Coombe) Conservation Plan and initiating educational and community archaeology projects. These projects relate primarily to the understanding, conserving and renewal of the medieval city with a focus on conservation plans for key sites. There is also an emphasis on making archaeology more widely accessible through initiatives including community archaeology projects and easy access to archaeological research data sets. dublin city development plan 2016-22 Heritage The Dublin City Heritage Plan, as an integral part of the development plan, sets out priorities to identify, enhance, and increase awareness of Dublin City’s heritage vis-àvis the historic built environment. A key challenge will be balancing the on-going implementation of projects developed under the previous heritage plan and delivering on new areas of interest in the next one. Under the Dublin City Development Plan 2011-2017/ Heritage Plan various projects have been initiated such as a research project to understand and assess a potential UNESCO Designation for Dublin’s historic centre, an Architectural Study & Inventory of 20th Century Architecture in the City and the preparation of guidance documents such as Historic Street Surfaces in Dublin. Conservation Plans in particular are an effective mechanism in outlining the relevant heritage issues at hand and prescribing practical conservation solutions. The City Council will seek the continued implementation of existing Conservation Plans such as the Henrietta Street Conservation Plan. Conservation Plans may be undertaken through the life of the next Development Plan/Heritage Plan on a strategic basis where there are competing priorities impacting on sensitive sites. Moreover, a wider role for heritage in the city is emerging, with a greater emphasis on the active promotion of heritage in the community. Following the recent successes of the 1913 Lockout (2013) centenary events and the Battle of Clontarf Millennial (2014), the Dublin City Heritage Plan commits to a programme reflecting on the events to be marked by the Decade of Centenaries, particularly centenary commemorations for 1916. Such projects may include conferences on rebuilding cities after conflict, and site-specific theatre commissions. By the provision of information and access, the City Council will during this period develop and maintain strong links with other agencies such as Fáilte Ireland who promote tourism and cultural infrastructure. The City Council has also developed the Walking Dublin App which identifies and provides mobile information on sites of cultural, historic and tourism interest. An inventory of the former Civic Museum’s collection has been completed. The next steps need to be carefully considered but could include a feasibility study to identify the remit and appropriate location for a new City of Dublin Museum incorporating the Civic Museum’s collection. To build on this civic identity, the historic centre of Dublin is on Ireland’s Tentative List of UNESCO World Heritage Sites. Dublin City Council and the Heritage Council are currently investigating the management implications of such a nomination for the city of Dublin. This includes a research agenda focused on ascertaining those sociocultural characteristics that are unique to Dublin. The City Council will continue the existing programme of management and maintenance of public monuments and sculpture with a focus on activities and events relating to the 2016 Centenary. Arising from this centenary and other upcoming commemorative dates will be proposals for commemorative monuments, memorials and plaques. The recently produced ’Commemorative Naming’ document (2012), sets out the City Council’s criteria regarding commemorative structures, and any commemorative proposals received by the City Council will have to satisfy these criteria. In conjunction with the City Council’s ‘Public Realm Strategy’ (2012), this document will ensure the continued integrity of the public realm in architectural and design terms. 31 Some Issues for Consideration Are there additional streetscapes/areas worthy of Architectural Conservation Area (ACA) consideration? How can we encourage appropriate uses back into the North and South Georgian Cores, particularly residential uses in historic buildings? How can we best create linkages between the built heritage and other cultural forms such as the city’s social or literary history? Should we celebrate and protect outstanding examples of 20th Century architecture? How should this be done? How can we make archaeological information more accessible to the community and professionals? What type of archaeology projects would you like see undertaken? How can policies assist in protecting important elements of our industrial heritage? Do we have too many protected structures, given that all such structures have the same status? Has ‘open house’ or ‘culture night’ increased appreciation of our heritage? dublin city development plan 2016-22 10.2 - Arts, Culture & Tourism Introduction The promotion and enabling of arts, cultural and tourism activities is central to the role of a city. A vibrant cultural environment can enhance the city’s international image and improve the vitality and attractiveness of the city’s environment. Culture can also help address social inclusion and regeneration. The City Development Plan, the Arts Plan and the Culture Strategy are key documents in promoting arts, culture and tourism in the city. The Arts Dublin City has a remarkable artistic heritage and is home to most of our National Cultural Institutions. The City Council plays an important role locally, citywide and nationally to sustain the Arts in all forms. Art forms are varied and include visual arts, theatre, literature, music, dance, opera, film, circus and architecture, etc.1 It is important that the new City Development Plan includes policies aimed at establishing equal access to quality arts experience appropriate to age, ability and cultural tradition. According to the Arts Council of Ireland, there are ‘some one million citizens, who might be characterised as the ‘target population’ of Young People, Children and Education (YPCE) provision’.2 The Dublin City Arts Strategy 2014-2018 sets out the main aims of the City Council, which should be reflected in the new Development Plan. The City Arts Strategy promotes access to the arts in public spaces in partnership with other units of the Council, and encourages the Council to actively use public spaces for the enjoyment of individuals. It is DCC policy to support artists working in all art forms and all forms of expression, permanent, temporary and time-based. 1 Definition of the arts from Arts Act 2003 2 Source www.artscouncil.ie ‘Young People, Children and Education’. It is also DCC policy to ensure the continued development of Dublin as a culturally vibrant, creative and diverse city with a board range of cultural activities provided throughout the city. Dublin City Council would like to see a vibrant artistic programme in every area of the City. Within the city centre, the Cultural Quarter in Temple Bar has grown into a major destination for tourists. The activities and functions of Temple Bar Cultural Trust are now wholly managed by Dublin City Council. DCC is also developing proposals for a new Cultural Centre at Parnell Square, with a new site for the City Library, a new Civic Cultural Centre and joining with the worldrenowned Hugh Lane Gallery. 3 The Dublin City Arts Office provides a wide range of art facilities and services to the people of Dublin and visitors to the city. Artists’ studios, exhibition and workshop spaces are also provided in the Red Stables, St. Anne’s Park, Raheny. A wide programme of events, including exhibitions, workshops, open days and performances are held there. 3 Dublin City Council City Arts Office Draft Arts Plan 2014-2018. 32 A range of national-level arts facilities and also local facilities are present in Dublin. Some centres focus on diverse areas such as theatre, dance, photography and community activities. A vacant spaces initiative has recently been undertaken to facilitate temporary use of under-utilised space by artists. The Arts Office has also engaged in a research project regarding immigrant artists and their needs in the city. Dublin City Council will develop a Public Art Programme which will offer opportunities for artists to engage with the city, making new work that responds to the context of Dublin as capital of Ireland, international city, and city of communities and localities. The Programme intends to create connections and collaboration between different areas of the city council’s work and also interconnection between art, city and the public. 4 The libraries and city galleries provide extensive services and facilities that are free for public use. A ‘Development Plan for Dublin City Public Libraries 2012 – 2016’ has been produced, seeking to maximise opportunity for all through guided access to ideas, learning, literature and heritage resources. As mentioned above, it is proposed to move the city’s main library to Parnell Square from its current location in the ILAC Centre on Moore Street/ Parnell Street, and this development is part of a wider initiative to revitalise the area. The annual ‘One City- One Book’ event helps generate public interest in Dublin’s literary history, and the International IMPAC Dublin Literary Award (managed by Dublin City Public Libraries) is awarded annually. 4 Policies and Strategies for Managing Public Art, Dublin City Council Public Art Advisory Group. dublin city development plan 2016-22 Culture It is proposed that Dublin City Council’s policies and objectives in the new Development Plan must be strong and ambitious enough to support, facilitate and encourage investment in quality cultural infrastructure in the city, allow for the development of a leading cultural capital where the cultural needs of all citizens are met and support a city which is capable of attracting talented, international workers for the city’s growing economy. The Dublin City Council Culture Strategy 2010-2017 sets out the vision and themes for Culture in Dublin. The vision set out is that ‘culture is integral to Dublin City’s identify and quality of life’, with main themes as follows: Lead and support the development of culture and the arts for the city Support established and emerging artists Create opportunities for everyone to participate in the city’s cultural life Lead the development of excellent cultural infrastructure Recognise that culture is essential to the city’s economic vitality Ensure that culture plays a significant role in urban regeneration and reflects the identity of Dublin’s neighbourhoods. The concept of ‘Cultural Quarters’ needs to be examined in the preparation of the new Development Plan, with attention given to emerging cultural areas and potential for clustering of cultural activities, which can generate new cultural destinations. The new proposals for the Parnell Square Cultural Quarter, referred to above, represent one such emerging quarter. Other Events and Festivals: Dublin City Council’s Integration Unit supports the celebration of ethnic diversity in the city through annual events including Chinese New Year Festival, Africa Day, and Diwali (Indian ‘festival of lights’). In addition to this, the annual ‘Culture Night’ celebrates culture by encouraging public involvement in a diverse range of cultural events around the city. ‘Open House Dublin’ organised by the Irish Architecture Foundation, is Ireland’s largest annual architectural event, inviting everyone to explore and understand the value of a well-designed built environment. Many buildings normally off limits to the general public are open for viewing and events are organised to coincide with visiting times. A second large-scale event, ‘National Heritage Week’, aims to build awareness about our heritage, and the focus is on preservation and promotion of our natural, built and cultural heritage. There are, of course, other arts, festivals and culture-based annual events including; Dublin Theatre Festival, Dublin Film Festival, the Fringe Festival, TradFest (based on traditional music events), Phizzfest (Phibsborough Community Arts Festival), Dublin Festival of History, St. Patrick’s Festival, Pride Festival, Bloomsday Festival, etc. Irish language and cultural events are also promoted and supported by the City Council. Census 2011 identified that Dublin City was the city/county with the lowest percentage of Irish speakers (35.2% of the population) in the country. This may in part reflect the large non-Irish proportion of the city’s population (18%). In addition to the language, Irish dance and music are also important facets of culture to be supported and promoted for the future. 33 In addition to the above-mentioned events and festivals, the following are examples of the range of annual events supported by Dublin City Council. These range from architectural and heritage-based events to those more focused on celebrating the city’s vitality diverse ethnicity; dublin city development plan 2016-22 Tourism Dublin City Council recognises the importance of tourism to the business and social life of the city, and actively works with Fáilte Ireland and other stakeholders in the Tourism Industry. The Council is a key partner in the ‘Grow Dublin Tourism Task Force’ which produced the recent strategy ‘Destination Dublin – A Collective Strategy for Tourism Growth to 2020’. Tourism is Ireland’s largest indigenous industry, contributing almost 4% of GNP and providing employment for over 200,000 people in every community throughout the island. In the above report, it is noted that since 2007, when 4.5 million visitors from overseas brought €1.45 billion into Dublin, the city and region has experienced a decline in tourist numbers and revenue. Numbers in 2012 were down 18% from the 2007 peak, and revenues were down 12.6%. Over that period, Dublin has lost tourist business to cities that are positioned with greater clarity, stronger impact and more competitive appeal.5 Competitor cities have shown sustained levels of 5-8% growth to which Dublin must aspire.6 As the national gateway, Dublin is ideally located to benefit from the influx of tourists to the country. There is a steady recovery in the tourism industry in Ireland, and the new Development Plan should consider measures to improve opportunities for an increased number of tourism products and services across the City. Closing gaps in the provision of reasonably priced, low-cost and hosteltype accommodation is a key component in the delivery of a competitive range of tourism products. Dublin’s Docklands are well positioned to benefit from business tourism, and the City Council will work with Fáilte Ireland, Dublin Convention Bureau and trade to ensure that these opportunities are converted to increased business tourism. The amenity value of the water bodies of Dublin City is also under-utilised for tourism. The Liffey Voyage, Sea Safari and Viking Splash Tours are indicators of future tourist potential. At a larger scale, cruise tourism is one of the fastest growing sectors of world travel and Dublin as a destination has increased significantly in the last decade with record cruise vessels numbers in 2010. The Dublin Cruise Traffic and Urban Regeneration Plan aims to attract more cruise ships into Dublin by improving facilities for cruise ships. Making cultural destinations within the city more accessible has been prioritised through initiatives such as Dublin Bikes, public realm enhancements and the new way-finding signage. Whilst not exclusively developed for tourists, these are clearly beneficial. Webbased applications help with accessing information and apps such as the ‘Dubline’, ‘Walk Dublin’ and ‘Culture Fox’ help improve access and information on the go – reducing the need to research destinations in advance. Some Issues for Consideration Does Dublin City adequately promote its rich cultural heritage to tourists? How can the new Development Plan help develop and support the growth of cultural and creative industries in the City (e.g. filmmaking, digital media etc)? Are there any arts/cultural facilities that you feel are lacking in the City? If so, how should they be provided? Are there sufficient libraries across the city to serve the expanding population and its diversity? What planning initiatives can be undertaken to further advance Irish language and culture within the city? What is the potential future role for ICT including mobile/web apps in facilitating the development of diverse arts & culture? How can we nurture new cultural initiatives that support emerging cultural clusters? How can local arts be developed further? What policies could be included in the Development Plan to ensure equal access to quality arts experience appropriate to age, ability and cultural tradition? What measures could be included in the Plan to assist public access to the arts, facilitate artists’ development and enrich the cultural experience of the city? 5 Destination Dublin A Collective Strategy for Tourism Growth to 2020, Grow Dublin Taskforce (GDT) 6 Destination Dublin A Collective Strategy for Tourism Growth to 2020, Grow Dublin Taskforce (GDT) 34 dublin city development plan 2016-22 11 - Community Infrastructure and Social Inclusion Introduction A successful neighbourhood is one that is sustainable. It provides not just a place in which to live or work, but also allows ease of access to a range of facilities including education, recreation and healthcare facilities. In setting out policies and objectives for Dublin, the City Council is required to plan for social infrastructure and sustainable communities. The Regional Planning Guidelines also require the Local Authority to examine issues of social inclusion in preparing a Development Plan, on the basis of the life cycle approach, i.e. giving consideration to children, people of work age, older people and people with disabilities – all groups which can experience social exclusion. 11.1 Creating Sustainable Neighbourhoods People People are the basic necessity for lively engaged communities, and for sustaining a diverse and wide range of community facilities. Having sufficient numbers of people to join local sports teams, support local shops, keep schools open is a simple yet fundamental idea. Also important is the need to attract a diverse spectrum of people into neighbourhoods via varied housing typologies to help foster diversity and integration. Making neighbourhoods attractive places where people want to live is the key. Timing Safety In emerging or expanding neighbourhoods, an important challenge is to identify the community and social infrastructure requirements of the growing population, and where such facilities are best located. Good planning is required to put in place appropriate phasing mechanisms to ensure that communities do not become abandoned or isolated. The use of Local Area Plans, Environmental Improvement Plans and Regeneration Plans are important tools in this process. Where largescale planning applications are submitted applicants are required to submit Social Audits of existing facilities in the area and how the new scheme will enhance the existing social and community infrastructure. Safe environments tend to be those that are well used, well designed with good lighting and passive surveillance. Creating opportunities within communities that maximises opportunities for meeting and greeting helps to make people feel safer in their environment. Encouraging more people to walk or cycle rather than drive is a good example of encouraging ‘street talk’. Designing public spaces that invite and encourage people to use the space; that have quality materials, appropriate planting and signage, are all important. The City Council aims to ensure that all new proposals design out opportunities for crime and design in for maximum accessibility. Accessibility 11.2 Accessibility within the public realm, to parks, open spaces, buildings, programmes and services is important for a community to be sustainable. Policies and objectives which focus on accessibility cover a broad spectrum of topics, including access to good quality public transport to enable people to reach amenities and facilities easily and in a timely manner; a quality public domain that is welcoming and easy to move about in for children, older people and those with disabilities; and also ensuring that those who may be marginalised feel empowered to use various spaces and places. Putting in place suitable land use transportation policies and engaging with people to optimise the use of our community resources are important elements for consideration. Services and facilities considered necessary for the community include hospitals and healthcare facilities; centres for social and cultural development; facilities for the elderly and those with disabilities; places of worship and meeting halls; recreational facilities and open spaces; shopping and banking facilities. A good community caters for its entire population from cradle to grave, with a full range of social infrastructure in place. 35 Supporting Infrastructure Healthcare Facilities The provision of quality healthcare facilities is vital for the city. Key requirements include the provision of hospitals and, in particular, the identified need for a new National Paediatric Hospital, primary care centres, step-down and long-term facilities, and community care facilities such as day care centres for older people. dublin city development plan 2016-22 Childcare The provision of childcare facilities in suitable locations and facilities is fundamental. For new development areas and large schemes, the City Council has regard to the Dublin City Childcare Committee and their identification of areas that are under-provided or, indeed, overprovided. Play Facilities In keeping with the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, and the National Children’s Strategy, the provision of places and spaces, and opportunities to play is considered vital. Access is needed to free outdoor play spaces that are safe, welcoming and well maintained. Overcoming barriers such as access and insurance need to be dealt with in a coordinated manner to allow optimum use of resources and thus help make communities more sustainable. Education Education, from pre-school to 4th level education facilities, is vital for community wellbeing and for driving Dublin City as a knowledge-based economy. Ensuring that schools are provided in tandem with growing populations is a priority, as is the continued development of the DIT Grangegorman campus. Community centres, youth centres, outreach centres and day-care centres all play a key role in providing hubs for community activity. In recent years, Dublin City Council has provided new community centres at Donore Avenue and Bluebell and has refurbished many existing centres. The promotion of inclusive neighbourhoods that cater for all age groups, all abilities, and all ethnic and cultural groups is a key priority of the City Council. Lack of engagement within a community may be linked to lack of money or resources, or it may be due to certain discriminations, or people not having the confidence to participate. In the 2011 Census, 17.2% (88,000 persons) of Dublin City’s population was made up of non-Irish nationals, an increase of 14,049 persons since 2006. Providing for and facilitating minority groupings are key considerations in providing a sustainable city. The City Council currently provides a range of services and provisions, including the work of community development officers, the work of the Social Inclusion Unit and the Office of Integration, all aimed at maximising community engagement and involvement. Empowering communities to become actively involved in the planmaking process, both for the city and at local level, is significant in ensuring that the needs and desires of the community are reflected and ultimately helps communities and places to work better. Libraries Community Centres 11.3 Supporting Communities / Social Inclusion Libraries provide a resource for citizens to enable them to maximise their potential, to participate in decision making, to access education and to contribute to the cultural life of the city. The enhancement of existing libraries and the development of a new City Library at Parnell Square is a key objective of Dublin City Council. A key issue the city faces is maximising the use of facilities which currently exist but are under-utilised, e.g. school and parish halls. 36 The City Council recently established a new Public Participation Network under the Local Government Reform Act 2014, which will allow individuals and organisations to play a more formal role in the development of City Council policies and objectives. dublin city development plan 2016-22 The newly established Local Community Development Committee (LCDC) will input into a Local Economic and Community Plan for the city. More recently, the launch of the ‘Dublin Age Friendly City Strategy 2014-2019’ aims to improve the quality of life for those aged over 55. This strategy has been agreed by an alliance of organisations led by Dublin City Council and encourages the direct of involvement of older persons through local action plans. Some Issues for Consideration Does the city currently provide adequate facilities to cater for residents from cradle to grave, and to allow people to fully participate in society and local communities? If not, what are the major gaps, and how should they be addressed? What range and scale of community facilities are required at the local and neighbourhood level, and what measures are required to render such facilities economically viable? What policies are required to ensure that the city becomes a universally accessible city? Are educational needs addressed within the city? How can the new Development Plan best facilitate the provision of childcare facilities in the right locations? How can the new Development Plan facilitate the appropriate provision of healthcare and elderly care facilities in the city? Should existing community centres including school and parish halls be made more widely accessible? How can this be achieved? Are the needs of the vulnerable and minority groups adequately met in local communities? Are new policies and objectives required? 37 being adequately dublin city development plan 2016-22 12 - Environmental Assessments Background Dublin City Council will carry out a number of environmental assessments of the draft Dublin City Development Plan 2016-2022, which include a Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA), an Appropriate Assessment (AA) and also a Flood Risk Assessment (FRA). These assessments will commence jointly with the review process of the Development Plan and will be published alongside the draft City Development Plan. Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) is a statutory process, involving the systematic evaluation of the likely significant environmental effects of implementing the new Development Plan before a decision has been made to adopt it. It is being carried out as a parallel process to the Development Plan Review. The objective of the SEA process is to provide for a high level of protection of the environment and to promote sustainable development by contributing to the integration of environmental considerations into the preparation of specified plans and programmes. The steps involved in the SEA process include: Screening (determining whether or not SEA is required) Scoping (determining the range of environmental issues to be covered by the SEA) The preparation of an Environmental Report The carrying out of consultations The integration of environmental considerations into the Plan or Programme The publication of information on the decision (SEA Statement). When the Development Plan is published, an Environmental Report (ER), Appropriate Assessment and Flood Risk Assessment will also be published. The Environmental Report sets out the details of the environmental baseline, trends and environmental objectives. It will show how the Development Plan has been assessed against the environmental objectives during its preparation and seek opinions from interested parties. Where conflict occurs, it will show what alternatives were considered and demonstrate informed decision-making on these issues. Dublin City Council will invite submissions on the Environmental Report (as well as the Draft Development Plan) at a later stage. You may have an opinion on environmental issues and objectives at this current pre-draft stage. 38 An SEA was previously carried out on the existing 2011-2017 Dublin City Development Plan and that Plan contains a robust set of policies and objectives in relation to protection of the environment. The new development plan provides an opportunity to develop these policies and objectives further and build on the knowledge already obtained, in light of emerging new information. Habitats Directive (HD) and Appropriate Assessment (AA) The development plan will be subject to Appropriate Assessment, as required by the European Habitats Directive (92/43/EEC). Appropriate assessment is a focused and detailed impact assessment of the implications of the plan, alone and in combination with other plans and projects, on the integrity of Natura 2000 sites in view of the conservation objectives of the sites. Natura 2000 sites consist of Special Protection Areas (SPAs) or Special Areas of Conservation (SACs). SPAs are largely concerned with protecting bird species while SACs relate to habitats and wildlife. An example of an SAC would be the South Dublin SAC, Site Code: 000210, and its qualifying features listed on Annex i include tidal mudflats and sandflats, and under Annex ii Petalwort. An example of an SPA would be Howth Head Coast SPA, Site Code: 004113, and its qualifying species include Kittiwake. Whilst the AA process is a separate process to the SEA, it runs in parallel with the SEA and the outcomes of both feed into and inform the SEA. dublin city development plan 2016-22 Flood Risk Assessment (FRA) A Natura Impact Report outlining the impact of the Plan on Natura 2000 sites will be available alongside the Draft Plan, the Strategic Environmental Assessment and the Flood Risk Assessment. The EU Floods Directive (FD) 2007/60/EC on the ‘Assessment and Management of Flood Risks’ requires member states to assess and manage flood risks. The Office of Public Works (OPW) is the lead agency is implementing this process. A National Preliminary Flood Risk Assessment (PFRA) was completed to identify areas where significant flood risk exists. Areas of further assessment were identified throughout the country and were subject to more detailed analysis. These steps are being carried out as part of the National Catchment Flood Risk Assessment and Management (CFRAM) Studies, which must be completed by 2015. These CFRAM Studies will contain objectives and actions and remedial measures to be taken for managing floods. The Department of the Environment, Community and Local Government (DECLG) & OPW prepared the ‘The Planning System and Flood Risk Management – Guidelines for Planning Authorities (DECLG & OPW, 2009) in order to integrate the assessment and management of flood risk into the planning process. The Guidelines indicate that Flood Risk Assessment (FRA) should be integrated into the SEA process. Planning Authorities are required to introduce flood risk assessment as an integral and leading element of their development planning functions under the Planning Code. The Flood Risk Assessment will be aligned with the existing Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) process. Scoping of the SEA will normally include flood risk as an environmental criterion. 39 Whilst the review of the Development plan will be informed by national planning policy such as the Guidelines on Flood Risk Management and also regional planning guidelines, they must take all practicable steps to ensure the prior identification of any areas at risk of flooding and flood zones in order to effectively shape the drafting process. A Strategic Flood Risk Assessment will be available alongside the Draft Plan, the Strategic Environmental Assessment, and the Appropriate Assessment. dublin city development plan 2016-22 APPENDIX 1 The following objectives must be included in a development plan: The zoning of land The provision of infrastructure including transport, energy, communication facilities, water supplies, waste recovery and disposal facilities The conservation environment and protection of The provision of community services including schools, crèches and other education and childcare facilities Climate change and energy reduction measures Rights of way to the seashore, mountains, etc. the The integration of the planning and sustainable development with the social, community and cultural requirements of the area and its population The preservation of the character of the landscape and of architectural conservation areas The protection of structures of special architectural, historical, archaeological, artistic, cultural, scientific, social or technical interest The preservation of the character of Architectural Conservation Areas The development and renewal of areas in need of regeneration The provision of accommodation for Travellers The preservation, improvement and extension of recreational amenities The control of establishments under the E.U. Major Accidents Directive Note: For full details, see Section 10 and First Schedule of the Planning & Development Act 2000, as amended. 40 dublin city development plan 2016-22 APPENDIX 2 Development Plan Timeline 41 dublin city development plan 2016-22 Send your views on the questions posed in this Issues Paper or on any Big Picture Issues you think should be addressed in the new Development Plan. ? We want to hear what you think about the city. Development Plan Team How has it changed since the last Development Plan was adopted in 2010? Planning, Property, Enterprise & Economic Development Department What do you think the Big Picture Issues facing the city up to 2022 are going to be? Civic Offices Block 4, Floor 3 Wood Quay Dublin 8 or to [email protected] Updates on the new Development Plan will be regularly available at www.dublincitydevelopmentplan.ie Please check in often and keep letting us know what you think! 42 dublin city development plan 2016-22 43 dublin city development plan 2016-22 44
© Copyright 2026