$2.00/APRIL 2 - 8, 2012 Expecting shortage, insurers tout jobs Bank files foreclosure on Tower at Erieview Lawsuit includes garage, but not adjacent Galleria Demand likely will rise, so sales pitches intensify By STAN BULLARD [email protected] After nearly a decade of trying to make a go of the 40-story Tower at Erieview, an investor group led by co-owner Werner Minshall is in danger of losing the landmark property in downtown Cleveland to its lender. The office building and its 400-car underground parking garage are the subject of a foreclosure action filed March 23 by U.S. Bank in Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court. The lawsuit against Mr. Minshall’s Erieview Tower & Parking LLC looks to satisfy a $44 million mortgage issued by the bank. However, the attached, glasstopped Galleria, 1301 E. Ninth St., is exempt from the foreclosure action as it was financed separately and Mr. Minshall controls it through a different company. Mr. Minshall said last Tuesday, March 27, he was surprised the bank filed to foreclose. The real estate owner based in Bethesda, Md., said he hopes to retain the asset. “We’ve been trying to work it out for more than a year. They must have gotten tired of talking to me,” Mr. Minshall said. “We’re making a lot of progress (with the complex). It’s not been an easy deal, but there are reasons for them to back off and let me continue it.” He declined to See ERIEVIEW Page 21 By TIMOTHY MAGAW [email protected] JASON MILLER PHOTOS SPECIAL REPORT REMAKING WEST 25TH AND THE MARKET DISTRICT ◆ Driving forces ◆ Financial needs ◆ Residential growth ◆ Full coverage: PAGES 11-18 www.CrainsCleveland.com/W25th David Hazen isn’t surprised young professionals aren’t flocking to the insurance industry. After all, he said, it isn’t perceived as the most riveting career. But there are jobs to be had in the business — and more likely are on the way. “When you were growing up and your uncle asked what you wanted to do for a living, you probably said you wanted to be a teacher, fireman or a doctor,” said Mr. Hazen, vice president for commercial insurance lines at Huntington Insurance in Salem. “The last thing you would have said is that you wanted to be an insurance agent or in the insurance business.” That situation creates a problem, industry insiders say, as the state’s insurance work force by 2016 is expected to grow by 7.1% due to heightened demand, bringing along 16,900 new jobs, according to market research from Kent State University. Moreover, other studies suggest as much as 50% of the insurance industry’s current work force will reach retirement age by 2016. As such, local insurance companies and brokerage firms are looking to expand in-house training programs to lure young employees, partner with local colleges to beef up the talent pool and, perhaps most importantly, better sell their industry as a See INSURERS Page 20 Next for Cedar Fair CEO: Take record years to greater heights By TIMOTHY MAGAW [email protected] 14 Matt Ouimet’s biggest challenge these days is tearing people away from their jam-packed schedules so he can scare them to death on a 400-foot-tall roller coaster. OK — maybe the new Cedar Fair LP CEO wasn’t that dramatic in his assessment of the challenges facing the amusement park industry, but he said the company’s largest hurdle is what he’s characterized as a “time poverty” issue. The former longtime Disney executive admitted spending a lot of time thinking about how to convince consumers to spend their time and hard-earned cash at Cedar Fair’s 11 amusement parks and six water parks throughout the country, including Cedar Point in Sandusky. “Because we are such an extraordinary value, we tend to win that battle, but I think about it a lot,” Mr. Ouimet said in an interview last week with Crain’s Cleveland Business. “If you’re off doing something else besides coming here in July, I call you a ‘why not?’” Getting those so-called “why nots” into the parks will be one of Mr. Ouimet’s paramount tasks during his first full season with the company since becoming Cedar Fair’s president last summer. He stepped into the CEO role Jan. 3 after longtime executive Dick Kinzel retired. This year, the company is rolling out a new marketing campaign, an upgraded online platform to sell tickets and, in See HEIGHTS Page 19 Ouimet 0 NEWSPAPER 74470 83781 7 INSIDE Stow golf agent R.J. Nemer struck while the time — Tiger’s time, specifically — was right ■ Page 4 PLUS: RENTAL RATES RISE ■ AGILE SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT FIRM ON THE MOVE ■ & MORE Entire contents © 2012 by Crain Communications Inc. Vol. 33, No. 14 SPECIAL REPORT REMAKING WEST 25TH STREET AND THE MARKET DISTRICT In outlying parts of Ohio City, work to do Leaders aim to extend progress to Lorain Ave. By SCOTT SUTTELL [email protected] A Ohio City’s residents always have been fiercely independent, and the neighborhood in 1836 — then its own municipality — even waged a war of sorts with Cleveland by bombing a portion of Cleveland’s Columbus Road Bridge, which Ohio City residents felt hurt the commercial interests of their own neighborhood. Annexed by Cleveland in 1894, Ohio City became a hub for European immigrants and became one of the most ethnically diverse areas of the city. With its construction in 1912, the West Side Market, which now brings in about a million t least a couple times a month, Julia Martin makes the short trip from her apartment on the West Side of Cleveland to Ohio City, usually to visit the West Side Market. The area around West 25th Street has almost everything Ms. Martin says she values about city life — interesting restaurants, eclectic local retail and a “distinct feeling” she can’t get elsewhere. “I definitely could see myself living here when I’m ready to buy a house,” says Ms. Martin, 25, who hopes to do just that in about a year. Ohio City has picked up that kind of momentum as its Market District concept, which is focused on artisanstyle businesses around the West Side Market, has struck a chord and attracted growing numbers of residents and visitors. But outside the Market District, particularly along stretches of Lorain Avenue, there’s a less-enticing Ohio City marked by older and struggling retailers, particularly used car lots. The rejuvenation efforts in Ohio City to date have been extensive, neighborhood advocates say, but they are by no means complete. “When you see some of those used car lots, it just cries out for something better,” says Cleveland City Councilman Joe Cimperman, who represents Ward 3, which includes Ohio City. That’s obvious to the naked eye. Mr. Cimperman, working with fellow Councilman Matt Zone and the city of Cleveland’s Planning Department, last year helped do something about it by passing a Pedestrian Retail Overlay (PRO) zone on Lorain Avenue, between West 24th and West 65th streets. As its name implies, the PRO is intended to protect and encourage pedestrian-oriented, mixed-use development in the district it covers. The designation requires, See ALIVE Page 14 See OUTLYING Page 18 JASON MILLER The West 25th Street/Market District area, as seen from the top of the United Bank Building The awakening of a sleeping giant New resident pool in ’90s, last decade help cool prior prickly politics, propel growth By TIMOTHY MAGAW [email protected] W hen Pat and Dan Conway opened Great Lakes Brewing Co. in 1988 in Ohio City, their cousin — a Cleveland homicide detective — told them they were crazy. Crusty bars with questionable clientele, constant threats of break-ins and regular drug peddling in a nearby park were daily realities in the district. Still, the area near the historic West Side Market off West 25th Street, which at one time was home to as many as 30 breweries, had character. “We felt there was so much possibility still in front of us, especially these old brick buildings that conjured up the romance of brewing days past. … They fit perfectly with the concept we had INSIDE: The West Side Market’s centennial celebration offers a chance to lure new customers, bring back old ones. Page 17 in mind,” Pat Conway said. And as Great Lakes Brewing Co. grew into a regional powerhouse, the small district it called home steadily evolved from one of Cleveland’s most downtrodden neighborhoods to what’s now marketed as the city’s “artisan neighborhood.” What’s brought Ohio City out of the ditch is by no means secret — the venerable West Side Market, the presence of long-standing institutions such as St. Ignatius High School and Lutheran Hospital, the proximity to downtown Cleveland, and a group of community and political organizers dedicated to revitalizing the blighted neighborhood. “The giant’s always been there, but the giant woke up,” said Cleveland City Councilman Joe Cimperman, whose ward includes Ohio City. A storied past ON THE WEB For expanded online coverage, including photo slideshows and video interviews, visit www.crainscleveland.com/w25th. 12 SPECIAL REPORT: REMAKING WEST 25th CRAIN’S CLEVELAND BUSINESS APRIL 2 - 8, 2012 NEIGHBORHOOD LONG IN THE MAKING GETS NEW LIFE MORE THAN 20 BUSINESSES HAVE OPENED IN THE MARKET DISTRICT IN THE PAST 18 MONTHS. 1 Soho Kitchen and Bar 2011 Nolan Konkoski and Molly Smith always have loved Ohio City, so when they were looking to open their first restaurant the pair kept returning to the neighborhood. As luck would have it, a space once occupied by a Cuban bakery was available. “This neighborhood has such a buzz about it,” he said. The 65-seat restaurant serves “modern southern food,” and it currently employs about 15 people. Mr. Konkoski said that with no advertising he opened the doors to his restaurant late last year, and it’s been packed ever since. “We felt it would be very difficult to fail in this neighborhood,” he said. 2 Joy Machines Bike Shop 2011 Alex Nosse grew up in Ohio City, so it wasn’t a stretch when he located the bike shop he owns with Renato Pereira-Castillo on West 25th. Mr. Nosse describes Joy Machines Bike Shop as a shop for everyday riders, with many of the store’s customers coming from within a couplemile radius. As a native to the West 25th area, the swift pace of development is not lost on Mr. Nosse, who points to it as proof of a “healthy urban neighborhood.” “All of the business owners feel a great sense of camaraderie,” he said. Of course, he noted, he’d love to see more businesses that sell necessities — like a shoe store. 3 Campbell’s Sweets Factory 2011 Jeff Campbell loves popcorn. And well he should; his business is on track to do $800,000 in sales this year, and he projects that number to increase to $2.5 million by the end of 2014. His West 25th Street store is an outgrowth from his space at the West Side Market, where Mr. Campbell first opened about eight years ago. While he’s since expanded his venture to include selling cupcakes and juice, popcorn represents 60% of Campbell’s business, with its famed Dichotomy (a delectable mix of cheddar and caramel) selling 3-to-1 over any other flavor. Indeed, Mr. Campbell estimates he orders roughly 19,500 pounds of corn a year to keep his business popping. (Mr. Campbell’s favorite popcorn flavor, by the way: white cheddar jalapeno.) 4 United Bank Building (Penzey’s Spices, 2010; Crop Bistro & Bar, 2011) The bank vault in the basement of the United Bank Building might represent a time from days long past, but its use today as a private dining space for Crop Bistro & Bar represents a rebirth for the landmark structure. In addition to Crop, the building currently houses Penzey’s Spices and the Alcohol, Drug Addiction and Mental Health Services Board of Cuyahoga County, with Bonbon Pastry & Café next door. Ari Maron’s MRN Ltd., the developer behind the remake of East Fourth Street, not only has committed to the redo of this structure, but it has scooped up a number of nearby buildings. “This is a particularly exciting neighborhood within the city,” Mr. Maron said. Work is still taking place on the top floors of the United Bank Building, which Mr. Maron anticipates eventually will be filled with office tenants. 5 Market Square Park 2012 (projected) Greg Peckham, managing director of LAND Studio, can walk across the street from his new offices on West 25th and see the results of his organization’s work. The under-renovation Market Square Park, a project in which he was involved, is expected to be done in May. The park’s design is tied into the idea of harvest and the neighborhood being the center for the city’s food culture. “A lot of it was understanding how the park fit into the development agenda of Ohio City,” Mr. Peckham said. “That park alone becomes a sort of a gateway into the rest of the business district.” (Park rendering courtesy of artist Mark Moskovitz.) 6 Market Garden Brewery 2011 It is entirely possible that Sam McNulty will wear out a path across West 25th Street. In addition to living there, last year he opened his fourth business on the street, next to the West Side Market and across from his other ventures: McNulty’s Bier Markt (2005); Bar Cento (2007); and Speakeasy (2009). Market Garden, which is slated to have a rooftop patio this summer, offers 12 of its own beers at any one time under the direction of brewmaster Andy Tveekrem. For Mr. McNulty, not only is Market Garden his first step into the world of brewing (and soon, distilling), it also may end up being a segue into his next move — he has dreams for a 70,000-square-foot production facility located within a 15-minute bike ride of West 25th. 7 Salty Not Sweet 2011 Candra Squire is a letter-press printer who was looking for a permanent place beyond the typical craft show to show her wares, which are greeting cards she jokingly characterizes as “horrible” and “ridiculous.” Her store, a venture she runs with Melissa Major, is just that place. Originally located in the Waterloo Arts District before moving last year to its bigger, 1,200-squarefoot space on West 25th, the store features everything handmade and offers workshops for aspiring artisans. For her part, Ms. Squire said being among so many entrepreneurs in Ohio City has a strength-in-numbers kind of appeal: “It’s so hard for one little tiny shop to get people to come out to buy local. … It doesn’t feel like you’re out here alone.” 8 Mitchell’s Ice Cream 2012 (projected) An ice cream destination. That’s what brothers Pete and Mike Mitchell hope their location becomes when it opens on West 25th later this year. The space long ago occupied by a vaudeville theater — and more recently the night club Moda — will be home to Mitchell’s eighth shop and its production. “There’s going to be as thin a layer of glass as possible … you’re going to see everything just a few feet away,” said Mike Mitchell of the two shifts a day that will be crafting frozen goodness out of local, homemade ingredients. “It’s like an ice cream show.” The Mitchells, who are preserving their building under historic standards, also hope to tap into some of the neighborhood’s resources — namely, make more ice cream with Great Lakes beer as an ingredient. 9 Cleveland Hostel 2012 (projected) When Mark Raymond was in preschool, his teacher asked him for what he was thankful. His answer: the Terminal Tower. Today, the Geneva native with an urban planning degree can get a bird’s-eye look at that landmark by standing on the roof of his future Cleveland Hostel. Work on the circa-1900 building started in January, and it will have 15 rooms, accommodating 60 guests, as well as a community kitchen. Room rates will range from $25 to $70 a night, with private and nonprivate rooms available. As for Mr. Raymond, he will live on the hostel’s third floor — close to that spectacular view. It is anticipated the hostel will be ready in time for the festivities surrounding the West Side Market’s centennial. 10 LAND Studio 2012 LAND Studio’s space on West 25th Street represents a new start for this organization, which is the result of the partnership between ParkWorks and Cleveland Public Art. The nonprofit, whose name stands for landscape, art, neighborhoods and development, is focused on “how good design is part of making a competitive city,” said Greg Peckham, managing director. The organization moved last month into 6,000 square feet above PNC Bank, marking an important step in the organizations coming together as one, said Mr. Peckham, whose previous office also was located on West 25th. “There is a real strong community and family of nonprofits centered around the Market District,” he said. “We have a window out to a very healthy, active neighborhood.” Video coverage: What’s different about doing business on West 25th? www.crainscleveland.com/section/W25thMap OTHER NEWCOMERS 11. Alaturka 12. Bonbon Pastry & Café 13. Market at the Fig 14. Johnnyville Slugger 15. Maggie’s Vegan Bakery 16. Orale Contemporary Kitchen 17. Proactive Controls Group (PCG) 18. Room Service 19. Vision Yoga 20. Deering Vintage 21. Bogtrotter’s Doorstep tL.E.A.P. (office tenant) (Lorain Avenue) tCigar Cigars (Lorain Avenue) t Urban Orchid (Bridge Avenue) Source: Ohio City Inc. (The Market District is West 25th to 28th; Chatham to Jay.) SPECIAL REPORT: REMAKING WEST 25th APRIL 2 - 8, 2012 CRAIN’S CLEVELAND BUSINESS 1 2 Ohio City Farm Bridge Fulton District LONGTIME COMMUNITY ANCHORS 1 St. Ignatius High School 1886 2 Lutheran Hospital 1896 West Side Market 1912 3 Ask any of the business owners in Ohio City, and they’ll tell you the West Side Market is the lifeblood of the neighborhood. The venerable market, which turns 100 years old this year, brings more than a million people a year into the growing district. Home to more than 100 vendors, ranging from butchers to bakers, the market has gained national recognition as one of the premiere public markets in the country. Often touted by some of the region’s most popular chefs, the market draws its patrons from all over Northeast Ohio and even across the country. Christine Zuniga Eadie, 1 the market’s director, said while the market’s centennial celebration is a huge opportunity for the market’s vendors, it also has the potential to spotlight the entire region. Video coverage: Hear longtime vendors talk about how West 25th has changed. www.crainscleveland.com/section/W25thMap 4 Great Lakes Brewing Co. 1988 When Great Lakes Brewing Co. opened shop in the late 1980s, it was the only craft brewery, not only in Cleveland, but the entire state of Ohio. And since then, the company’s assorted libations have helped jumpstart a craft brewing craze (particularly around the holiday season with its sought-after Christmas Ale) that’s extended well beyond the brewery’s home in Ohio City. In 2010, the company invested $7 million in capital improvements to expand its brewing capacity in the district, and now distributes is roster of beers in 13 states and Washington, D.C. Last year, the company churned out 120,000 barrels of beer. And according to Pat Conway, the company’s co-owner, the company is running out of room to expand because, well, there are “just too many mouths to feed.” Video coverage: Pat Conway discusses setting up shop in Ohio City almost 20 years ago. www.crainscleveland.com/section/W25thMap Business profiles by Amy Ann Stoessel and Timothy Magaw Layout and map design by Lauren Rafferty 13 14 SPECIAL REPORT: REMAKING WEST 25th CRAIN’S CLEVELAND BUSINESS APRIL 2 - 8, 2012 Alive: Anchor institutions contribute to district’s vitality continued from PAGE 11 people a year, became a focal point by bringing various ethnic groups together under one roof. Despite a residential boom in the 1960s spurred by historic preservationists, political discord hindered the development of the area for decades, resulting in the creation of two community development corporations with differing missions. However, in the 1990s and 2000s, a group of people started moving into the area who appreciated the urbanism and economic diversity the area offered. ON THE WEB For smart phone users, scan this QR, or “quick response” code, with any QR code reader to view more photos from the present-day West 25th Street and Market District area. are intertwined, said Christine Zuniga Eadie, the manager of the West Side Market. “We’re rebuilding a partnership,” she said. “When something works “We have a dynamic group of leaders at neighborhood institutions, a dynamic group of investors ... and strong political leadership.” – Eric Wobser, executive director, Ohio City Inc. “That was the group that really started to calm the politics of the neighborhood,” said Eric Wobser, the executive director of Ohio City Inc., which was the product of the two community development corporations that ultimately merged. It’s all about the food While the West Side Market’s centennial celebration this fall wasn’t the main driver for the development of the district, it’s provided Ohio City’s business and civic leaders a timeline to work along and helped accelerate the rate at which the area is being transformed. The idea of one of Cleveland’s premier institutions turning 100 years old offered the opportunity to showcase the neighborhood in addition to the market, Mr. Wobser noted. After all, the success of the market and its surrounding neighborhood for the market, it has an impact on the market district and vice versa.” The West Side Market has been a pillar for the growing food movement in Northeast Ohio with some of Cleveland’s most famous chefs, such as Jonathon Sawyer and Michael Symon, regularly touting the value of the market. In 2010, the local food movement received another jolt when the sixacre Ohio City Farm — the largest contiguous urban farm in the nation — opened at West 24th Street and Bridge Avenue. The farm’s bounty has gone to local businesses, including Great Lakes Brewing, one of the farm’s co-developers. Great Lakes Brewing’s success, coupled with the allure of the market, has attracted a number of other local, and now-thriving, operations such as Sam McNulty’s Bier Mrkt and the Market Garden Brewery. Also, local ice cream JASON MILLER A runner takes advantage of one of a spate of warm March days to exercise in the Market District area. For more present-day photos from the neighborhood, visit www.crainscleveland.com/W25thGallery. purveyor Mitchell’s plans to move into Ohio City. “To be in the shadows of the tower of the West Side Market, making gourmet beer, ice cream, breads or artisan cuisine … it’s perfect,” Great Lakes’ Mr. Conway said. Strong partners While the West Side Market could be considered the heart of Ohio City, the neighborhood’s two other anchor institutions — St. Ignatius High School and the Cleve- land Clinic’s Lutheran Hospital — also have invested heavily in the redevelopment of the area. “We’ve served the community for well over 100 years, and we are extremely excited about the continued rejuvenation of West 25th Street,” Lutheran president Dr. Brian Donley said. Collectively, Mr. Wobser said both institutions have contributed about $200,000 to the effort to clean up a blighted portion of the neighborhood as part of the creation of a special improvement district. While both institutions fall outside the borders of the SID, Mr. Wobser said the notion that both would commit resources to the effort speaks volumes about their commitment to the neighborhood. As part of the SID, neighborhood property owners in Ohio City last year agreed to assess themselves a fee to pay for better security and maintenance than Cleveland could provide. It’s that sort of unified vision, community leaders say, that’s driving the success in Ohio City, which is bringing young people in droves to live in the area. “A number of good things are coming together at the right time,” Mr. Wobser said. “We have a dynamic group of leaders at neighborhood institutions, a dynamic group of investors, both real estate developers and entrepreneurs, and strong political leadership. We have the right people at the right place at the right time.” Mr. Cimperman said he’s heard from companies interested in setting up shop in Ohio City, and the neighborhood’s best days are right around the corner if the momentum can hold. Moreover, Mr. Cimperman said what’s happening in the neighborhood could be viewed as a model to help jumpstart the redevelopment of other neighborhoods in and around Cleveland. “Nobody involved with this is tired,” Mr. Cimperman said. “It’s 7 a.m. in Ohio City, and there’s still a full day ahead.” ■ Allen Business Park 895 HAMPSHIRE ROAD, STOW Presented by In partnership with the CITY OF CLEVELAND AND OHIO CITY INCORPORATED CENTENNIAL KICK OFF Saturday, June 2nd, 6–9pm in Market Square Park STREET FESTIVAL + PARADE CENTENNIAL GALA Sunday, October 7th, 11am–8pm on W. 25th Saturday, November 3rd, 6-11pm at the West Side Market BECOME A SPONSOR TODAY AND BE THE FIRST TO SECURE GALA TICKETS! CONTACT AMANDA AT [email protected] OR 216.781.3222 X108 $9$,/$%/()25/($6( WR6)RI)OH[6SDFH 8QLWV ¶&OHDU+HLJKW 'ULYH,Q'RRUV &RPPRQ'RFN (DV\$FFHVVWR5RXWH )RUPRUHLQIRUPDWLRQFRQWDFW &+5,6+21'/,. FKULVKRQGOLN#RPFOHFRP ZZZRVWHQGRUIPRUULVFRP SPECIAL REPORT: REMAKING WEST 25th APRIL 2 - 8, 2012 CRAIN’S CLEVELAND BUSINESS 15 Monetary muscle still needed for market, district fixups By STAN BULLARD [email protected] D efining the difference in today’s West 25th Street near the West Side Market from hard-scrabble conditions for much of the time since the late 1960s takes one four-letter word. Cash. Millions of dollars — which will have to be raised from multiple sources in coming years — are needed in order to ensure a legacy fund for the West Side Market and to continue the transformation of the surrounding Market District. In the meantime, more than $50 million already has gone into West 25th near the market, remaking it into what it is today: a vital food resource with genuine character as well as an active entertainment, residential and commercial district that is a must-see for the social set, tourists and foodies. Two immediate financial tasks face the neighborhood today linked to the centennial of the West Side Market this year and its focus as the site of the International Public Markets Conference. First, the Centennial Commission and Cleveland Mayor Frank Jackson both want to use the celebration as a means to create a legacy fund to maintain the market. Meanwhile, Ohio City still needs to raise the last $200,000 to meet the $900,000 budget for centennial events. The tasks do not daunt Eric Wobser, executive director of Ohio City Inc., which the city of Cleveland has authorized to oversee the market’s centennial celebration. Planning is a big part of his solution, and a surprise source of funds — corporate sponsorships — is an evolving part of the solution of the funding challenge. Planning comes into play because an architectural study of the West Side Market building’s condition will not be finished until later this year. That study is crucial to determining how much repair work the brick landmark and adjoining wood market stands need to make it another century. As a result, Mr. Wobser said, the market’s legacy campaign will kick off at a Nov. 3 gala chaired by Cleveland celebrity chefs Michael Symon and Jonathon Sawyer. The Jackson administration already has earmarked $2.3 million for West Side Market capital needs. Even without the study, Councilman Joe Cimperman, whose Ward 3 includes the area, knows more will be needed without the study. “The last time the city of Cleveland really spent money on the market was in the (Mayor Ralph) Locher administration,” Mr. Cimperman said of a regime that ended in 1967. the West Side Market,” Mr. Wobser said, “businesses are finding their way to the market for exposure.” For example, Charter One, the presenting sponsor for the West Side Market Centennial, has invested $500,000 in the Market District and the West Side Market Centennial. The bank counts $100,000 of its contribution to the neighborhood as sponsorship, according to Carrie Carpenter, senior vice president and director of public affairs at Charter One Ohio. Sponsorship funds directly benefit the bank through promoting its name, she said, while its foundation, to satisfy tax laws, can generate the bank nothing of value. Charter One decided the Market District provides the bank with an opportunity to put its name before people from the neighborhood and region, Ms. Carpenter said, as well as banking on food’s new celebrity. “Our brand is that good banking is good citizenship,” Ms. Carpenter said, so signs and advertising at Ohio City events benefit the bank’s image. The decision is based on estimates of attendance and value of signage at events as well as entertaining bank clients at events. Some funds went directly to six different nonprofits, from Neighborhood Progress Inc. efforts to revitalize West 25th through several city neighborhoods to LAND Studio, the organization formed from the merger of Cleveland Public Art and a banker can’t know your business without knowing your community Unlock a local approach to business banking. At KeyBank, we have tailored solutions to help finance the future of your business. We’re also part of your community and understand the marketplace. That means credit decisions happen faster, so you can quickly respond to new or unexpected business opportunities. It’s a more personal approach with a bank that is committed to helping the businesses in your local community thrive. Start a conversation. And unlock your possibilities. go to key.com/business call 877-KEY2BIZ Money doesn’t grow on trees Mr. Wobser argues the remainder of the legacy funding will come from philanthropic and corporate sources, and others see room for individual contributors. For example, while final centennial gala ticket prices have not been set, there most likely will be tiered ticket price options ranging from $150 to $500 with different event entry times. The other new-breed funding source is corporate sponsorships from others besides neighborhood bastions Lutheran Hospital and St. Ignatius High School. “Just like politicians for years have known it is good to be seen at ParkWorks, to design the stand for the urban farm near the market. Other funds went into a $15,000 grant that helped 11 market vendors improve signs, lighting or shelving. And $40,000 went for a small business idea competition whose five winners now occupy neighborhood storefronts. Charter One’s funding for the small business idea competition worked so well — it even attracted applicants who did not get grants to the street — the bank and Ohio City Inc. are doing it again this year with grants of $5,000 to $20,000 for new or expanding businesses in the Market District. Requests for proposals for grants are due at 5 p.m. May 21 and avail- Credit products are subject to credit approval. ©2011 KeyCorp. KeyBank is Member FDIC. ADL2662 able at Ohio City Inc.’s website, www.ohiocity.org. Mr. Wobser hopes the competition fills the last five vacant storefronts. Iconic campaign Contributing to the West Side Market centennial and the legacy program brings to mind the massive corporate and public campaign to rejuvenate the Statue of Liberty for its 1986 centennial. “The West Side Market is an international icon,” Mr. Cimperman said. “If I’m a CEO and have a chance to have my company associated with something with more visitors than the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Museum or Great Lakes Science Center, why wouldn’t I?” ■ 16 SPECIAL REPORT: REMAKING WEST 25th CRAIN’S CLEVELAND BUSINESS APRIL 2 - 8, 2012 Housing interest in step with commercial improvement New development luring prospective residents, though maintaining affordability a priority ON THE WEB By MICHELLE PARK [email protected] “Y ou can’t miss ’em,” Greg Peckham assured. “One is covered in scaffolding, and they both look like hell.” No understatement there. Located at Randall Road and John Avenue in Cleveland’s Ohio City neighborhood, the two houses Mr. Peckham bought this year are eyesores — for now. The one slated to be a new home for Mr. Peckman’s family stands largely untouched by construction workers, its greenish paint peeling off, windows boarded up, door padlocked. The other two-unit building is covered in scaffolding, upon which workers are perched this March Tuesday, nailing shingles to the porch roof. Mr. Peckham’s renovations are two of many investments being made or already made in this historic district, where new schools have opened and more family-friendly activities, including a babysitting co-op, now exist. “What’s happening in this neighborhood, I think, is evolutionary,” Mr. Peckham said. “There’s a growing number of people who could be anywhere, and they’re choosing to be here.” While the population in Cleveland dropped 17% from 2000 to 2010, the area that comprises Ohio City rose in population by 1.2% during the same decade, said executives with Ohio City Inc. who analyzed U.S. Census data. Ohio City Inc. is the area’s community development corporation. Once in the “shadows” of other neighborhoods such as Tremont, Ohio City is in higher demand today, said Chris Schlenkerman, a real estate agent who manages the Ohio City office of the Howard Hanna brokerage. He observes the trend not only in closed sales, but in busy open houses, too. The surge in interest really began last year and has continued into this year, Mr. Schlenkerman said. For the people The most recent census revealed that the neighborhood’s population of 25- to 34-year-olds increased most, but empty nesters also are settling in, said Eric Wobser, executive director of Ohio City Inc. The group talks to people “all the time who can’t find an apartment,” Mr. For smart phone users, scan this QR, or “quick response” code, with any QR code reader to view before-and-after photographs of home rehabilitations in Cleveland’s Ohio City neighborhood. Wobser said. Mr. Schlenkerman said the big attraction to Ohio City “right now has quite a bit to do with the commercial growth that’s occurring in the district.” Already, Ohio City has townhomes, both new and renovated, and a former department store converted into condominiums in The Fries and Schuele Building. There’s more to come, too: One crew wants to redevelop a group of former warehouse buildings into 72 apartment units, and another has a 10- to 20-unit apartment development planned for the old Jay Hotel, Mr. Wobser said. All the while, rental rates are rising. One 20-unit building that used to pull 95 cents per square foot is pulling roughly $1.30 per square foot today, Mr. Wobser said. He also knows a homeowner who is renting at a rate twice his mortgage. Ohio City needs to maintain affordable housing, though, Mr. Wobser and others stressed. “We want to make sure that folks other than bankers and lawyers can afford to live here, and that won’t be easy,” he said, citing how property values are rising. The upward trajectory is easy to see. During a drive through the streets of Ohio City in February, Mr. Wobser points seemingly to every other house, describing renovations that have been done or will be done. “This was an empty house when I took this job,” Mr. Wobser says, pointing to a well-maintained house. “It was just falling apart, boards on the windows.” There’s also the large maroon house whose owners won an award from Ohio City Inc. for residential renovation, and the former YMCA, where a transformation into condominiums won it the same recognition two years ago. “Until recently, things changed slowly,” Mr. Wobser said. “Two businesses would open, one would close. But I think, always, things were moving to a positive momentum.” That neighborhood feel As Ohio City’s commercial district booms, more visitors flock to the area and get a taste of what living there could be like, Mr. Wobser said. Dave’s Supermarket and the West Side Market are neighborhood anchors, but other service businesses such as a florist, a bike shop and a fitness studio have hung their shingles, too. As they do, the neighborhood’s convenience grows. Lynn Phares — another person investing in the neighborhood — moved with her husband to Ohio City in 2007 from Washington, D.C., and formed the block club for their section of the neighborhood in early 2008. Such block clubs and the family-friendly events they coordinate — ice cream socials, pumpkin-decorating events and the like — are a common reason offered for the area’s influx of residents. Also, life is being breathed back into local parks, including renovations to Novak Park in 2010 and Fairview Park in 2004. A master plan for Greenwood Park is under way. And there are new schools, including Near West Intergenerational, a public charter school that opened in 2011, and Urban Community, a private school that opened in 2005. “Now there’s an educational opportunity that parents feel they can consider an option to stay in the neighborhood and not have to leave and go to the suburbs,” said Ms. Phares, who’s on the board for Near West and is in the process of renovating her house and another property she plans to rent. The Cleveland Metropolitan School District also plans to break ground in Ohio City this spring on two elementary schools, Paul Dunbar School and Orchard School, both of which are slated to open in August 2013. Many hope the momentum spreads to Lorain Avenue, a corridor that still has substantial blight, Mr. Wobser said. “If we can revitalize Lorain, we can unite the neighborhood,” Mr. Wobser said. Battling the naysayers Though a lot of good is occurring, house seekers often ask how safe Ohio City is, real estate agents say. Many residents interviewed for Did you know your ears never stop growing? this piece have been victims of crime, but they are quick to note that they’ve been victimized infrequently. “If we were getting broken into every year, we wouldn’t be here,” said Mr. Peckham, whose house has been broken into once in the 14 years he’s lived in the neighborhood. This spring, Ohio City will have its own special improvement district, where property owners in a defined area will pay an assessment to pay for the kind of street cleanup, graffiti removal and visible security presence that has improved the image of downtown. Even without the extras of a special improvement district, though, Brandon Sitler sees a difference in the neighborhood. An Ohio City resident for eight years, Mr. Sitler opened his flower shop, The Urban Orchid, on Bridge Avenue last August. “When I first moved here, it was kind of scary to walk home,” Mr. Sitler said. “Now it’s like there’s always people walking around, laughing, hanging out. It seems more like a neighborhood than it did before.” It’s not just the perception of crime, though, that may deter people. Another issue for the neighborhood is the behavior of some people who come there for social services provided by places such as local churches, said Kathleen Knittel, a longtime resident. Though most of those people cause no problem, some act in ways that “at times has negative impacts on our quality of life,” she said. Hurdles to home renovations also can be a deterrent, Mr. Peckham said. It took him 18 months to unravel his family’s properties from a tangled history of previous ownership and to bring them up to code through costly work. “The number of curveballs that get thrown your way is unimaginable,” Mr. Peckham said. He suggests policy and finance improvements to facilitate more projects like his. Ms. Phares said she hopes Ohio City will continue to promote itself. Still, she said, critics will remain. “I don’t know what you do about the naysayers — the people who live in the suburbs and never have something good to say about Cleveland,” Ms. Phares said. “Some people, you’re never going to change their minds, and you’re never going to get them to give it a shot.” ■ A CLOSER LOOK To see these homes postrenovation, go to www.crains cleveland.com/W25thGallery. ■ David Hovis calls this renovation a “total gut job.” He and his wife, Jen, bought this fire-damaged W. 32nd Street house and the adjacent property for $45,000 in 2010 and poured roughly $400,000 into it. The most expensive renovations were energy efficiency upgrades, including new insulation. The work slashed the home’s energy costs to $2,000 from $8,000 a year, Mr. Hovis said. ■ At one time, this Lorain Avenue property was the Northeast Ohio headquarters for the Communist Party, according to property owner David Fleming, whose family purchased it in April 2007. During renovations that spanned nearly two years, they finished three upstairs residential units, including a different, very spacious unit in a former ballroom. The project’s cost exceeded $300,000, Mr. Fleming estimated. ■ The work done to this historic Italianate mansion cost more than $700,000, involved more than 30 contractors and took 18 months to complete, according to owner Norma Makar. Norma and Lou Makar purchased the Clinton Avenue home, built in the 1860s, when it was just a “big pile of bricks” without heating or electricity and transformed it with new roofing, exterior paint and $50,000 in new windows alone. Another little-known fact: As a COSE member your business can continually grow with new ways to generate leads, expand your knowledge and build profitable connections. And those are just some of the benefits of an annual membership that works out to about $25 a month. Find out how COSE can help your business grow. CALL 216.923.0838 OR VISIT COSE.ORG/ANSWERS2 Health plans insured by Medical Mutual SPECIAL REPORT: REMAKING WEST 25th APRIL 2 - 8, 2012 CRAIN’S CLEVELAND BUSINESS 17 Market, vendors hope for boost from centennial events T he West Side Market’s centennial celebration this year is as much a time to celebrate its rich (and tasty) history as it is to figure out how to make the market sustainable for at least another 100 years. Some of the goals this year are to increase the number of new shoppers coming to the market and bring back old customers who had left, according to Christine Zuniga Eadie, the West Side Market’s manager. The idea, Ms. Eadie said, is to ensure the West Side Market remains a living, breathing and usable market and doesn’t transform into a museum like other public markets around the country. Part of that, she said, is showing the community what the market’s vendors have to offer. “The vendors are by far the greatest asset the market has,” Ms. Eadie said. The celebration officially kicks off with fireworks and an ice cream social on June 2; a street festival and parade on Oct. 7; and culminates with a gala — co-chaired by renowned local chefs Michael Symon and Jonathon Sawyer — on Nov. 3. The gala will serve as the launching point for a fundraising campaign to help offset the costs of the market’s ON THE WEB For smart phone users, scan this QR, or “quick response” code, with any QR code reader to watch videos of West Market vendors talking about their experience there. The videos can be found at www. CrainsCleveland.com/W25thGallery. mounting capital needs. “It’s a huge opportunity for not only the vendors here but the Greater Cleveland region,” Ms. Eadie said. “So many local chefs grew up shopping here.” Terry Frick of Frickaccios Pizza Market at the West Side Market said she’s already seen an influx of new customers at the market, as younger people have taken an interest in locally produced food. With the centennial events approaching, she anticipates the momentum only will grow stronger. “This is just the way shopping should be,” Ms. Frick said. “That’s what I believe.” For a full list of centennial celebration events, visit www.westside market.org. — Timothy Magaw Working with You to Build Success At Taft, building relationships that help our clients build their businesses is our top priority. From development, finance, construction, acquisitions, dispositions, exchanges, leases, and property operations, we have the extensive toolbox of legal resources to efficiently address every need. Learn how our 126-year track record of performance can help build your business success. Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP www.taftlaw.com 200 Public Square, Suite 3500, Cleveland, OH 44114-2302 U P: (216) 241-2838 Business and Finance U Litigation U Labor and Employment U Business Restructuring, Bankruptcy and Creditor Rights i>Ì Ê>`ÊviÊ-ViViÃÊUÊÌiiVÌÕ>Ê*À«iÀÌÞÊU Tax U Private Client U Environmental Law U Real Estate OHIO CITY THROUGH THE YEARS THE PRACTICAL PHOTO COURTESY OF OHIO CITY INC. ABOVE: The West Side Market under construction in 1911. ■ Ohio City originally was part of Brooklyn Township, founded in 1818. On March 3, 1836, two days before Cleveland’s incorporation, it became an independent municipality. On June 5, 1854, it was annexed to Cleveland. ■ Ohio City became known as the Near West Side when it was annexed to Cleveland. In the late 19th century, the area attracted those seeking jobs at the docks, mills, foundries, distilleries and bottling works. ■ The West Side Market is built on a site the first mayor of Ohio City, Josiah Barber, and another pioneer, Richard Lord, deeded to the city on condition it be kept a marketplace. Market Square was the site of the Pearl Street market, a one-story wooden market built in 1868 at Lorain Avenue and Pearl Road (West 25th Street). ■ Present-day Ohio City is home to more than 90 nonprofits. ■ In 1896, Lutheran Hospital opened at Fulton and West 29th Street in a residence that was ON THE WEB For smart phone users, scan this QR, or “quick response” code, with any QR code reader to view more historic photos from the West Side Market and the Market District. The photos can be found at www. CrainsCleveland.com/W25thGallery. rented for $42 per month, and 25 patients were admitted the first year. Lutheran Hospital in 1898 moved to Franklin Avenue. In addition to several expansions and construction projects through the years, a new lobby and hospital entrance facing West 25th Street was built in 1997, the same year it became part of the Cleveland Clinic. ■ James A. Garfield, 20th president of the United States, in 1857 was pastor of Franklin Circle Christian Church. SOURCE: WWW.OHIOCITY.ORG; WWW.LUTHERANHOSPITAL.ORG MBA …online Learn more at a Virtual Open House Wednesday, April 11 www.bw.edu/mba-online Multiple responsibilities, a demanding schedule, travel…any of these make it difficult to pursue an advanced degree, no matter how much it might benefit your career. That’s why Baldwin-Wallace College is now offering its MBA in Management in a hybrid format—in the two-year program, 75% of the coursework is online and the remaining work completed in seven weekends on our Berea campus. You will study Baldwin-Wallace’s distinctive, systems approach to management, the same program (with the same faculty) that is offered in the traditional classroom. Its combination of sound theory and realworld application has produced effective managers for organizations of all types for more than 30 years. 275 Eastland Road Berea, Ohio 44017 Start the next phase of your career. Learn more about B-W’s online MBA at www.bw.edu/mba-online. Classes begin in August 2012. Baldwin-Wallace College does not discriminate on the basis of race, creed, age, disability, national origin, gender or sexual orientation in the administration of any policies or programs. 18 SPECIAL REPORT: REMAKING WEST 25th CRAIN’S CLEVELAND BUSINESS Outlying: Growth leads to challenges continued from PAGE 11 for instance, that new buildings be set back no more than five feet from a street right-of-way. It also requires that parking lots, where feasible, be located in the rear of buildings. Most importantly, Mr. Cimperman said, it “specifically prohibits” new uses that detract from the pedestrian-oriented character of the district — automobile sales lots, gas stations, car washes and restaurant drive-throughs among them. “It’s about creating an environment that allows for dynamic spaces” in Ohio City, Mr. Cimperman said. The West Side’s main street A major element of helping to create those dynamic spaces and generally raising the quality of life in Ohio City is a renewed focus on the health of Lorain Avenue and the neighborhood south of Lorain — a more working-class area, with longer-term residents, than the more gentrified area north of Lorain. Last November, Ohio City Inc. and Kent State University’s Cleveland Urban Design Collaborative kicked off what they called a community design charrette — a term for a brief, intense planning exercise — dubbed Launch Lorain to begin rethinking development along Lorain from West 20th Street to West 52nd, south to Interstate 90. Two community meetings held to collect input drew more than 200 stakeholders, including businesses, nonprofits and residents. Almost everything is on the table for Lorain Avenue, which is, essentially, the main street of the West Side; the exercise includes a look at transportation, safety issues, retail development, housing, and parks and recreational space. The focus on Lorain is badly needed, said Eric Wobser, executive director of Ohio City Inc., the community development organization that serves as a fulcrum for initiatives aimed at improving the neighborhood. “As a corridor, Lorain has not functioned well for a long time,” Mr. Wobser said. “A more vibrant Lorain Avenue would bring people together.” Broadly speaking, Launch Lorain is designed to produce a long-term plan that would create better connections to adjacent residential areas along Lorain; bolster private investments already occurring there; and identify new opportunities for development and urban amenities. There’s no shortage of ideas for reaching those goals, Mr. Wobser said. “I think what you see from the community is a sense that yes, things are getting better, but there are a lot of things that still need to be done to reach our potential,” he said. The initial Launch Lorain report touches on its share of small issues — fixing sidewalks and filling potholes among them — but it doesn’t shy away from thinking big on infrastructure improvement. For instance, one possibility it raises is a reconfiguration of the intersection of Lorain Avenue and Fulton Road so that Fulton meets Lorain at a right angle rather than diagonally. That would make the intersection safer, improve the pedestrian environment and create opportunities for more green space, as well as making it more conducive for private development. Making connections Development in Ohio City, which boasts more than 12,000 residents, is helping the neighborhood become something of a rarity in Cleveland — an area with nearly 24-hour activity on some days, starting with the West Side Market’s opening at 7 a.m. and going to the closing of bars early the next morning. That kind of activity inevitably brings parking challenges. Ohio City Inc. is in the midst of a study of parking issues near the West Side Market. Depending on its findings, the group could begin a push to construct a parking garage that would make it easier for visitors to come to the neighborhood. APRIL 2 - 8, 2012 There’s “not much news yet on the parking structure front,” Mr. Wobser said, other than that the need exists and that discussions have begun with city officials. But Messrs. Cimperman and Wobser noted that public transit is a key part of the future of Ohio City, with the Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Authority playing a key role. The Launch Lorain report raises the possibility of an “enhanced transit waiting area for Bus Rapid Transit” — in the style of the Health Line on the East Side — on Lorain adjacent to the Breen Center parking lot on the iconic St. Ignatius High School campus. Another possibility is a Red Line stop at Fulton Road. “The easier it is to connect from Ohio City to downtown and other parts of the region, the better the opportunity for growth,” Mr. Cimperman said. Physical and infrastructure connections are important to the neighborhood, but so are those among businesses and nonprofits. Natalie Leek-Nelson, president and CEO of crisis nursery Providence House, is heading an effort to foster more collaboration among nonprofits based in Ohio City. In January, she said, several Ohio City nonprofits began a program to reduce their costs by jointly purchasing office supplies. Next up could be joint buys of informational technology services and equipment as well as janitorial and sanitation supplies. “I think we’re just starting to see what can be accomplished with a more collaborative approach,” Ms. Leek-Nelson said. At play Mr. Wobser is aware of the importance not just of economic development and infrastructure issues, but also what might be thought of as the “softer side” of life in the neighborhood — parks, festivals, sports leagues for children and the like. “These are the kinds of things that make a big difference in how people perceive the place they live,” he said. The park — the most visible and heavily used public space within the Market District — is getting a $1.5 million makeover from the city. The renovation incorporates design ideas from Cleveland Public Art and ParkWorks, and it will double the amount of programmable space in the park. Separately, RTA is investing $80,000 to replace outdated bus shelters in the park with more modern facilities. To make the neighborhood more appealing to young families, Mr. Wobser envisions the creation of youth sports leagues in, say, baseball and soccer. Ohio City families currently look to nearby suburbs for those amenities, he said. Mr. Cimperman, for one, thinks of the neighborhood as “a potential giant that’s just woken up. “But we can’t lose sight of how much work has to be done,” he said. ■ MARKET PLACE Ohio Savings Bank Opening in 1901 Ohio City, West 25th Street From the making and “remaking” of Ohio City, Ohio Savings Bank will be here. Thank you Cleveland and Ohio City for welcoming us to the neigborhood! It has been a pleasure to serve you over the past 6 months. XXXDSPQCJTUSPDPNr$301 2537 Lorain Ave, Cleveland 44113 ROOM SERVICE 2078 West 25th Street Cleveland, OH 44113 (216) 696-6220 R/S boutique offers Jewelry, Home Goods, Gifts and we now carry Women’s Apparel in addition to our popular Cleveland-centric tshirts and gifts for Men and Women. R/S also plays host to the MADE IN THE 216 event every holiday season. Have a retail business or business idea? We want you to be a part of the Ohio City Market District! Win up to $20,000 to open or grow your business in the Ohio City Market District by applying for the Charter One Growing Communities 2012 Ohio City Market District Small Business Development Grant Competition. Visit www.ohiocity.org for RFP and details Brought to you by:
© Copyright 2025