1. science
2. physics

Spontaneous crystallization noise in mirrors of gravitational wave detectors
N. M. Kondratiev1,2 , V. B. Braginsky1 , S. P. Vyatchanin1 , and M. L. Gorodetsky1,2∗
arXiv:1507.00252v1 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci] 1 Jul 2015
1
Faculty of Physics, Moscow State University, Moscow 119991, Russia
2
Russian Quantum Center, Skolkovo 143025, Russia
(Dated: July 2, 2015)
Core optics components for high precision measurements are made of stable materials, having
small optical and mechanical dissipation. The natural choice in many cases is glass, in particular
fused silica. Glass is a solid amorphous state of material that couldn’t become a crystal due to
high viscosity. However thermodynamically or externally activated stimulated local processes of
spontaneous crystallization (known as devitrification) are still possible. Being random, these processes can produce an additional noise, and influence the performance of such experiments as laser
gravitational wave detection.
PACS numbers: 04.80.Nn, 07.60.Ly, 05.40.Ca
I.
INTRODUCTION
High-precision measurements always face a lot of noises
and instabilities. The LIGO project [1, 2] have to account
many fundamental sources of fluctuations. Fluctuations
of temperature, which are translated into displacement
of the mirror’s surface through thermal expansion (thermoelastic noise) [3, 4] and change of optical path due to
fluctuations of refraction index (thermorefractive noise)
[5] combine producing generalized thermo-optical noise
[6, 7]. Better known Brownian fluctuations causing displacement of the mirror’s surface [8, 9] and photoelastic
effect [10] produced by these fluctuations form the Brownian branch of noises.
Not all of noise sources are easy to identify. In this
work we are trying to estimate a noise coming from structural transformations in material. Fused silica is a glass –
neither crystal nor liquid. It is one of polymorphic forms
of silicon dioxide and its internal energy is higher than
that of crystalline state. The process of glass to solid
crystallization at temperatures bellow glass transition is
often called devitrification and was observed during longterm heating, under high-intensity laser exposition[11] or
ballistic impact[12]. It is essential that different states
have different material parameters (see table I), specifically density and refractive index.
As one can see from the Table I the density of fused silica is smaller than that of crystalline quartz. In this way
Density, g/cm3
Heat Capacity, J/(kg×K)
Refractive index
Fused silica α-quartz Stishovite
2.20
2.65
4.29
1.052
0.740
0.834
1.46
1.54
1.80
Table I. Material parameters of polymorphic forms of silicon
dioxide
∗
[email protected]
some contraction of fused silica samples in time should
be observed if devitrification takes place. This effect
of contraction is indeed known for glasses and its rate
for different materials was measured [13–15]. From the
other hand, each event of local crystallization is a discrete event causing small perturbations. The aim of the
paper is to calculate the influence of possible local crystallization/reordering processes in the bulk of the matter
on its surface and to calculate the spectral density of the
surface fluctuations produced by this effect. We also give
the empirical estimation of the rate at which such processes can happen in fused silica suspension fibers and
use it to find the absolute values of the corresponding
noise using the approach introduced in [16].
II.
NOISE OF COLLAPSING BUBBLES
We start considering a piece of glass constituting the
mirror, a small part of which (which for simplicity we
shall call a bubble) has changed it’s state. This transition results in a local change of material parameters
and also in equilibrium state parameters of such a bubble. One of these parameters is obviously the equilibrium volume, that is the volume of non-strained matter
or exactly mb /¯
ρc (where mb is the mass of the bubble,
ρ¯c is the density of the crystal phase). But as a part
of the bulk matter in the glassy state, this bubble still
preserves the volume of the previous state’s equilibrium
volume mb /¯
ρg , where is the density of glass. In this way,
from the difference of the equilibrium densities of the two
phases we are getting an initial strain.
We now have a binary system with the first component
being a crystal bubble with a deformation ub
u~¨b + c2 rot rot ~ub − c2 grad div ~ub = 0,
(II.1)
tc
~ub |t=0 = ~u0 .
lc
(II.2)
ctc and clc , consequently ctg and clg are transversal and
longitudinal speeds of sound in a crystalline or glassy
state, ~u0 is time-independent initial deformation field.
The second component is a glass. As a model task
to understand the influence of such bubbles on the sur-
“Validation of the ultrastable low-noise current amplifier as travelling standard for small direct currents”
D. Drung, C. Krause, S. P. Giblin, S. Djordjevic, F. Piquemal, O. Séron, F. Rengnez, M. Götz, E. Pesel, and H. Scherer, 2015
Validation of the ultrastable low-noise current amplifier as travelling
standard for small direct currents
D. Drung1, C. Krause2, S. P. Giblin3, S. Djordjevic4, F. Piquemal4, O. Séron4, F. Rengnez4, M. Götz2, E. Pesel2, and H.
Scherer2
1
Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt (PTB), Abbestraße 2-12, 10587 Berlin, Germany
2
Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt (PTB), Bundesallee 100, 38116 Braunschweig, Germany
3
National Physical Laboratory (NPL), Hampton Road, Teddington, Middlesex TW11 0LW, United Kingdom
4
Laboratoire national de métrologie et d'essais (LNE), 29 avenue Roger Hennequin, 78197 Trappes, France
Abstract
An interlaboratory comparison of small-current generation and measurement capability is presented with the ultrastable
low-noise current amplifier (ULCA) acting as travelling standard. Various measurements at direct currents between
0.16 nA and 13 nA were performed to verify the degree of agreement between the three national metrology institutes
involved in the study. Consistency well within one part per million (ppm) was found. Due to harsh environmental
conditions during shipment, the ULCA’s transfer accuracy had been limited to about ±0.4 ppm. Supplemental
measurements performed at PTB indicate that further improvements in accuracy are possible. Relative uncertainties of
0.1 ppm are achieved by applying on-site calibration of the ULCA with a suitable cryogenic current comparator.
PACS 2010 Keywords:
Amplifiers - electronic, 84.30.Le
Calibration, 06.20.fb
Electric current measurement, 84.37.+q
Electronic circuits, 07.50.Ek, 84.30.-r
Measurement units and standards, 06.20.FResistance measurement, 84.37.+q
Superconducting devices, 85.25.-j
1 / 13
Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay
arXiv:1507.00170v1 [hep-ph] 1 Jul 2015
Heinrich P¨
as1 and Werner Rodejohann2
1
Fakult¨
at f¨
ur Physik, Technische Universit¨at Dortmund, D-44221 Dortmund,
Germany
2
Max-Planck-Institut f¨
ur Kernphysik, Postfach 103980, D-69029 Heidelberg,
Germany
E-mail: [email protected], [email protected]
Abstract. We review the potential to probe new physics with neutrinoless double
beta decay (A, Z) → (A, Z + 2) + 2e− . Both the standard long-range light neutrino
mechanism as well as short-range mechanisms mediated by heavy particles are
discussed. We also stress aspects of the connection to lepton number violation at
colliders and the implications for baryogenesis.
Submitted to: New J. Phys.
Bottomonium Mesons and Strategies for Their Observation
Stephen Godfrey∗ and Kenneth Moats
arXiv:1507.00024v1 [hep-ph] 30 Jun 2015
Ottawa-Carleton Institute for Physics, Department of Physics,
Carleton University, Ottawa, Canada K1S 5B6
(Dated: July 2, 2015)
The B-factories and Large Hadron Collider experiments have demonstrated the ability to observe
and measure the properties of bottomonium mesons. In order to discover missing states it is useful
to know their properties to develop a successful search strategy. To this end we calculate the
masses and decay properties of excited bottomonium states. We use the relativized quark model to
calculate the masses and wavefunctions which are used to calculate the decay properties. The open
bottom decay widths are calculated using the 3 P0 model. We also summarize results for radiative
transitions, annihilation decays, hadronic transitions and production cross sections which are used
to develop strategies to find these states. We find that the b¯b system has a rich spectroscopy that
we expect to be substantially extended by the LHC and e+ e− experiments in the near future. Some
of the most promising possibilities at the LHC are observing the χb(1,2) (3P ), χb(1,2) (4P ) and ηb (3S)
states in γµ+ µ− final states that proceed via radiative transitions through Υ(nS) intermediate
states and 13 DJ and 23 DJ into γγµ+ µ− final states proceeding via 13 PJ → 13 S1 and 23 PJ → 23 S1
intermediate states respectively. Some of the most interesting possibilities in e+ e− collisions are
studying the 13 DJ states via 4γ cascades starting with the Υ(3S) and the 33 PJ states in γγµ+ µ−
final states starting with the Υ(4S) and proceeding via Υ(nS) intermediate states. Completing the
bottomonium spectrum is an important validation of lattice QCD calculations and a test of our
understanding of bottomonium states in the context of the quark model.
PACS numbers: 12.39.Pn, 13.25.-k, 13.25.Gv, 14.40.Pq
I.
INTRODUCTION
The Large Hadron Collider experiments have demonstrated that they can discover some of the missing bottomonium states. In fact, the first new particle discovered at the LHC was a 3P bottomonium state [1, 2].
The Belle II experiment at SuperKEKB will also offer
the possibility of studying excited bottomonium states
[3]. At the same time, lattice QCD calculations of bottomonium properties have advanced considerably in recent years [4–7] so it is important to expand our experimental knowledge of bottomonium states to test these
calculations. With this motivation, we calculate properties of bottomonium mesons to suggest experimental
strategies to observe missing states. The observation of
these states is a crucial test of lattice QCD calculations
and will also test the various models of hadron properties. Some recent reviews of bottomonium spectroscopy
are Ref. [8–10].
We use the relativized quark model to calculate the
masses and wavefunctions [11]. The mass predictions for
this model are given in Section II. The wavefunctions are
used to calculate radiative transitions between states, annihilation decays and as input for estimating hadronic
transitions as described in Sections III-V respectively.
The strong decay widths to open bottom are described
in Section VI and are calculated using the 3 P0 model
[12, 13] with simple harmonic oscillator (SHO) wavefunctions with the oscillator parameters, β, found by fitting
∗ Email:
[email protected]
the SHO wavefunction rms radii to those of the corresponding relativized quark model wavefunctions. This
approach has proven to be a useful phenomenological tool
for calculating hadron properties which has helped to understand the observed spectra [14–18]. Additional details
of the 3 P0 model are given in the appendix, primarily so
that the various conventions are written down explicitly
so that the interested reader is able to reproduce our results.
We combine our results for the various decay modes
to produce branching ratios (BR) for each of the bottomonium states we study. The purpose of this paper
is to suggest strategies to find some of the missing bottomonium states in pp collisions at the LHC and in e+ e−
collisions at SuperKEKB. The final missing input is an
estimate of production rates for bottomonium states in pp
and e+ e− collisions. This is described in Section VII. We
combine the cross sections with the expected integrated
luminosities and various BR’s to estimate the number
of events expected for the production of bottomonium
states with decays to various final states. This is the
main result of the paper, to identify which of the missing bottomonium states are most likely to be observed
and the most promising signal to find them. However,
there are many experimental issues that could alter our
conclusions so we hope that the interested reader can use
the information in this paper as a starting point to study
other potentially useful experimental signatures that we
might have missed. In the final section we summarize the
most promising signatures.
MITP/15-046, SLAC-PUB-16319, TKK-15-15
Symmetry Restored in Dibosons at the LHC?
Johann Brehmer1 ,∗ JoAnne Hewett2 ,†
Joachim Kopp3 ,‡ Thomas Rizzo2 ,§ and Jamie Tattersall4¶
1 Institut
f¨
ur Theoretische Physik, Universit¨
at Heidelberg, Germany
National Accelerator Laboratory, Menlo Park, USA
3 PRISMA Cluster of Excellence and Mainz Institute for Theoretical Physics,
Johannes Gutenberg University, Mainz, Germany
4 Institut f¨
ur Theoretische Teilchenphysik und Kosmologie, RWTH Aachen, Germany
(Dated: July 2, 2015)
arXiv:1507.00013v1 [hep-ph] 30 Jun 2015
2 SLAC
A number of LHC resonance search channels display an excess in the invariant mass
region of 1.8 - 2.0 TeV. Among them is a 3.4 σ excess in the fully hadronic decay of
a pair of Standard Model electroweak gauge bosons, in addition to potential signals
in the HW and dijet final states. We perform a model-independent cross-section fit
to the results of all ATLAS and CMS searches sensitive to these final states. We
then interpret these results in the context of the Left-Right Symmetric Model, based
on the extended gauge group SU (2)L × SU (2)R × U (1)0 , and show that a heavy
right-handed gauge boson WR can naturally explain the current measurements with
just a single coupling gR ∼ 0.4. In addition, we discuss a possible connection to dark
matter.
CONTENTS
I. Introduction
2
II. Experimental measurements and cross-section fits
3
III. Interpretation in the Left-Right Symmetric Model
10
IV. A connection to dark matter?
18
V. Conclusions
∗
†
‡
§
¶
23
Note
24
Acknowledgements
24
References
24
Email:
Email:
Email:
Email:
Email:
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
CP violation: Dalitz interference, CPT and FSI
J. H. Alvarenga Nogueiraa, I. Bediagab, A. B. R. Cavalcanteb, T. Fredericoa , O. Louren¸coc
arXiv:1506.08332v1 [hep-ph] 27 Jun 2015
a
Instituto Tecnol´
ogico de Aeron´
autica, DCTA, 12228-900, S˜
ao Jos´e dos Campos, SP, Brazil
b
Centro Brasileiro de Pesquisas F´ısicas, 22290-180, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil
c
Departamento de Ciˆencias da Natureza, Matem´
atica e Educa¸c˜
ao, CCA,
Universidade Federal de S˜
ao Carlos, 13600-970, Araras, SP, Brazil
(Dated: June 30, 2015)
Resonances and final state interactions (FSI) play a role in the formation of CP violation (CPV)
constrained by CPT invariance. We provide a general formulation of CPV including resonances and
FSI starting from the CPT constraint. Our discussion is elaborated within a simple B decay model
with the ρ and f0 (980) resonances plus a non resonant background including the ππ → KK coupled
amplitude. We consider few illustrative examples to show the interference patterns appearing in
the CP asymmetry, namely, that from the ρ resonance plus a non-resonant amplitude, and that
from the interference of the ρ and f0 (980) resonances. We perform the fit of the CP asymmetry
for the charmless three-body B ± decay channel B ± → π ± π + π − and obtain as outcome the B ± →
π ± K + K − for ππ channel asymmetry in the mass region below 1.6 GeV in fair agreement with the
new data LHCb data. Analogously, we also describe the CP asymmetry of the B ± → K ± π + π −
decay, with that from the B ± → K ± K + K − channel obtained as output. As in the previous case,
we also found agreement with LHCb experimental data.
PACS numbers:
I.
INTRODUCTION
The exact CPT invariance implies the identity of the lifetime of a particle and its charge conjugate. Therefore,
when the individual partial decay widths of CP conjugate channels are different, due to the CP violation (CPV), the
other channels must have equal amount of CP violation, with opposite sign, such that the total width of the particle
and antiparticle are equal. Final state interaction must be the responsible to distribute the CP asymmetry among
the different conjugate decay channels such as the sum of partial widths provides identical total width for the particle
and its anti-particle.
The common belief says that CPT invariance is not a practical constraint to be taken into account when computing
CP violation in charmless B decays. It is naively expected that CP violation is distributed among several different
coupled final state channels with two, three, four and more hadrons [1]. Therefore, the CPT constraint should
be realized, in principle, by summing up over many hadronic decay channels. However, since hadronic many-body
rescattering effects are far from being understood, it is evident that this phenomenological hypothesis should be better
understood before consider its important consequences for the description of the CP violation phenomena.
In an opposite direction to the common believe, we shown in detail in a previous paper [2], that the coupling
between several final states must be suppressed at least in some charmless three body B decays. A quick observation
to the event distribution of these decays shows that they are placed basically at the boundary of the Dalitz plot, in a
region dominated by light two-body resonances. This dominance can be directly associated with the non-perturbative
regime at the B mass energy [3]. In addition, by considering the observations made by early experiments [4, 5] that
the low mass ππ and Kπ region is dominated by the elastic regime, the number of coupled channel expected for
charmless three-body B decays should be very restricted. There is a significant exception to this general picture for
the two-body mass distribution: the S-wave ππ → KK re-scattering process between 1 to 1.6 GeV [6, 7], that was
also discussed in detail in our previous paper. So, at least for this class of decays, the existence of few possibilities
of coupled hadronic channels demands the explicit consideration of the important constraint from CPT invariance
in the study of CP violation. Unfortunately little is known, either theoretically or experimentally, about the event
distribution for others coupled channels with four or more hadrons in the final state. However, by looking at the
profusion of observed low mass vector-vector charmless B decays, it seems that they are also dominated by low mass
resonances [8].
The inclusive CP asymmetry recently released by the LHCb collaboration for four charged B charmless threebody decays, gives a hint about the correlation among the asymmetries in the coupled decay channels [9]. Actually,
the experimental results for strangeness ∆ = 1 decays ACP (B ± → K ± π + π − ) = +0.025 ± 0.004 ± 0.004 ± 0.007 and
ACP (B ± → K ± K + K − ) = −0.036±0.004±0.002±0.007 multiplied by the observed number of events [9] and corrected
by the branching fractions (see [8]), which represent approximately the efficiency not reported in the paper, show that
the number of events involved in the CP asymmetry in one decay channel is approximately the same in the other
channel but with opposite sign. The same happens, within the experimental errors, to the coupled decay channels with
EUROPEAN ORGANIZATION FOR NUCLEAR RESEARCH (CERN)
CERN-PH-EP/2015-135
2015/07/02
CMS-FSQ-12-032
arXiv:1507.00233v1 [hep-ex] 1 Jul 2015
Production of leading charged particles and leading
charged-particle jets at small√transverse momenta in pp
collisions at s = 8 TeV
The CMS Collaboration∗
Abstract
The per-event yield of the highest transverse momentum charged particle and
charged-particle jet, integrated above a given pmin
threshold
starting at pmin
= 0.8
T
T
√
and 1 GeV, respectively, is studied in pp collisions at s = 8 TeV. The particles and
the jets are measured in the pseudorapidity ranges |η | < 2.4 and 1.9, respectively.
The data are sensitive to the momentum scale at which parton densities saturate in
the proton, to multiple partonic interactions, and other key aspects of the transition
between the soft and hard QCD regimes in hadronic collisions.
Submitted to Physical Review D
c 2015 CERN for the benefit of the CMS Collaboration. CC-BY-3.0 license
∗ See
Appendix A for the list of collaboration members
arXiv:1507.00096v1 [astro-ph.CO] 1 Jul 2015
The Hubble Flow of Plateau Inflation
Dries Coone,a,b Diederik Roesta and Vincent Venninc
a Van
Swinderen Institute for Particle Physics and Gravity, University of Groningen, Nijenborgh 4, 9747 AG Groningen, (The Netherlands)
b Theoretische Natuurkunde, Vrije Universiteit Brussel and The International Solvay Institutes Pleinlaan 2, B-1050 Brussels, (Belgium)
c Institute of Cosmology & Gravitation, University of Portsmouth, Dennis Sciama Building,
Burnaby Road, Portsmouth, PO1 3FX, (United Kingdom)
E-mail: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]
Abstract. In the absence of CMB precision measurements, a Taylor expansion has often been
invoked to parametrize the Hubble flow function during inflation. The standard “horizon
flow” procedure implicitly relies on this assumption. However, the recent Planck results
indicate a strong preference for plateau inflation, which suggests the use of Pad´e approximants
instead. We propose a novel method that provides analytic solutions of the flow equations
for a given parametrization of the Hubble function. This method is illustrated in the Taylor
and Pad´e cases, for low order expansions. We then present the results of a full numerical
treatment scanning larger order expansions, and compare these parametrizations in terms
of convergence, prior dependence, predictivity and compatibility with the data. Finally, we
highlight the implications for potential reconstruction methods.
Keywords: physics of the early universe, inflation
Modified Eddington-inspired-Born-Infeld Gravity with a Trace Term
Che-Yu Chen
1,2,3 a
, Mariam Bouhmadi-L´opez4,5,6,7,b and Pisin Chen
1,2,3,8c
1
arXiv:1507.00028v1 [gr-qc] 30 Jun 2015
Department of Physics, National Taiwan University, Taipei, Taiwan 10617
2
LeCosPA, National Taiwan University, Taipei, Taiwan 10617
3
Graduate Institute of Astrophysics, National Taiwan University, Taipei, Taiwan 10617
4
Departamento de F´ısica, Universidade da Beira Interior, 6200 Covilh˜
a, Portugal
5
Centro de Matem´
atica e Aplica¸c˜
oes da Universidade da Beira Interior (CMA-UBI), 6200 Covilh˜
a, Portugal
6
Department of Theoretical Physics, University of the Basque Country UPV/EHU, P.O. Box 644, 48080 Bilbao, Spain
7
IKERBASQUE, Basque Foundation for Science, 48011, Bilbao, Spain
8
Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology,
SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, U.S.A.
(Dated: July 2, 2015)
In this paper, a modified Eddington-inspired-Born-Infeld (EiBI) theory with a pure trace term
gµν R being added to the determinantal action is analysed from a cosmological point of view. It
corresponds to the most general action constructed from a rank two tensor that contains up to first
order terms in curvature. This term can equally be seen as a conformal factor multiplying the metric
gµν . This very interesting type of amendment has not been considered within the Palatini formalism
despite the large amount of works on the Born-Infeld-inspired theory of gravity. This model can
provide smooth bouncing solutions which were not allowed in the EiBI model for the same EiBI
coupling. Most interestingly, for a radiation filled universe there are some regions of the parameter
space that can naturally lead to a de Sitter inflationary stage without the need of any exotic matter
field. Finally, in this model we discover a new type of cosmic “quasi-sudden” singularity, where the
cosmic time derivative of the Hubble rate becomes very large but finite at a finite cosmic time.
PACS numbers: 98.80.-k, 98.80.Jk, 04.50.Kd, 04.20.Dw
Keywords: modified theories of gravity, early time universe, Eddington-inspired-Born-Infeld theories, cosmic
singularities
I.
INTRODUCTION
Undeniably, Einstein’s theory of general relativity
(GR) has been an extremely successful theory for around
a century [1]. However, the theory is expected to break
down at some points at very high energies where quantum
effects are expected to become crucial, such as in the past
expansion of the Universe where GR predicts a big bang
singularity [2]. This is one of the motivations for looking for possible modified theories of gravity, which are
hoped to not only be able to preserve the huge achievements of GR, but also to shed some light on smoothing
the singularities predicted in GR. Such theories could be
seen as effective/phenomenological approaches of a more
fundamental quantum theory of gravity.
In 1934 Born and Infeld proposed a non-linear action
for classical electrodynamics, which is characterised by
its grand success in solving the divergence of the selfenergy of point-like charges [3]. This action for electromagnetism has an elegant determinantal structure which
reads:
Z
q
1
SBI =
(1.1)
d4 x |gµν + κFµν |,
κ
with gµν and Fµν being the metric tensor and the electromagnetic field strength. Here κ is a dimensional constant.
a
b
c
[email protected]
[email protected]. On leave of absence from UPV and IKERBASQUE.
[email protected]
Note that the Born-Infeld action (1.1) recovers Maxwell
action for small amplitudes.
Since the proposal of the Born-Infeld action, modified
theories of gravity with a Born-Infeld-inspired action, initiated by the pioneering work of Deser and Gibbons [4],
have received much attention; c.f. Refs. [5–10]. These
theories of gravity not only maintain the properties of
GR for small curvatures, but provide various interesting
deviations from GR at high curvature regimes. Most of
these works start with a general gravitational action of
the form
Z
q
1
d4 x |gµν + κGµν (R, Rαβ , Rµναβ )|, (1.2)
Sdet =
κ
where Gµν represents a linear Ricci term Rµν , plus higher
order curvature terms containing R, Rµν , and Rµναβ .
Rather than amending the higher curvature terms in Gµν ,
we can also modify the action by multiplying the metric
term in the determinant by a factor 1 + α1 R, where α1 is
a constant with length square dimensions. This approach
does not lead to a violation of the requirements in the low
curvature limit, i.e. we can still recover GR at low energies. Actually, a gravitational action with this pure trace
term has been considered in Ref. [5] within a pure metric
formalism. The theory thus inevitably suffers from the
presence of troublesome fourth order derivatives in the
field equations or ghost instabilities [4].
In order to keep the theory free from aforementioned
problems, alternative theories formulated within the
Palatini formalism and teleparallel representation have
Nonperturbative pair production in interpolating fields
Anton Ilderton,1, ∗ Greger Torgrimsson,1, † and Jonatan Wårdh1, ‡
1
Dept. Applied Physics, Chalmers University of Technology, SE-41296 Gothenburg, Sweden
We compare the effects of timelike, lightlike and spacelike one-dimensional inhomogeneities on
the probability of nonperturbative pair production in strong fields. Using interpolating coordinates
we give a unifying picture in which the effect of the inhomogeneity is encoded in branch cuts and
poles circulated by complex worldline instantons. For spacelike inhomogeneities the length of the
cut is related to the existence of critical points, while for lightlike inhomogeneities the cut contracts
to a pole and the instantons become contractable to points, leading to simplifications particular to
the lightlike case. We calculate the effective action in fields with up to three nonzero components,
and investigate its behaviour under changes in field dependence.
arXiv:1506.09186v1 [hep-th] 30 Jun 2015
PACS numbers: 11.15.Tk, 12.20.Ds
I.
INTRODUCTION
Pair production in strong fields gives us insight into
nonperturbative fundamental physics [1–3]. Advances in
technology have in recent years driven interest in observing nonperturbative pair production using intense
lasers [4–12], which presents a veritable experimental
challenge even with optimally focussed laser light [10].
It has been found that the pair production probability
tends to be higher (relative to the locally constant approximation) in time-dependent electric fields E(t), and
lower in position-dependent inhomogeneous electric fields
E(z) [13]. In the latter case there is even a critical point
beyond which the probability is identically zero [14, 15].
Between these two cases is an electric field with lightlike inhomogeneities, E(t + z). In this case the probability is given exactly by the locally constant approximation [16, 17].
Here we would like to understand more about how the
spacetime dependence of an electric field affects the pair
production probability. Note that the three cases above
cannot be related by a Lorentz transformation. In order
to investigate the transition between spacelike and timelike field inhomogeneities we will therefore consider electric fields depending on a single interpolating coordinate
of the form (1 − α)t + αz for α ∈ [0, 1], following [18–20].
We will use the worldline formalism (see [21, 22], and
e.g. [23–25] for recent applications), and in particular
worldline instantons [13, 22, 26, 27]. These are periodic, in general complex [28–31], solutions to the classical equations of motion. The classical action evaluated on these solutions, together with the contributions
of fluctuations around the instantons, gives a semiclassical approximation of the effective action, and of the pair
production probability. We will see that this contribution is an integral over the instanton itself. Since the
instantons are complex, these contributions depend, by
Cauchy’s integral theorem, only on the structures which
the instantons circulate in the complex plane.
This allows us to unify, and extend, previous observations on the impact of field inhomogeneities on pair
production. We will see that for timelike and spacelike
inhomogeneities the instantons circulate differently orientated branch cuts and so are fundamentally extended objects. As the field dependence becomes lightlike, though,
the branch points coalesce and become poles, so that the
instantons are contractable to points [32]. We will see
that this leads to the known localisation of the effective
action in the lightlike limit [16, 17].
Another motivation for this paper is recent interest in
pair creation in two-component, rotating fields, which
model the electric antinodes of a circularly polarised
standing wave [33–36]. We will here extend these calculations to electric fields depending on our interpolating
coordinates, and with up to three components.
This paper is organised as follows. In the remainder
of this introductory section we recall the worldline approach to pair production in strong fields, introduce our
interpolating fields and outline the calculation to be performed. In Sect. II we present an explicit example of the
instantons in an interpolating Sauter pulse, and relate
the field inhomogeneity to the structures circulated by
the instanton. In Sect. III we complete the calculation
of the effective action in electric fields with up to three
nonzero components depending on the interpolating coordinate. In Sect. IV we analyse the behaviour of the
effective action as a function of the interpolating parameter in several examples. We conclude in Sect. V.
A.
Pair creation in interpolating fields
The probability P of pair production in an external
field is related to the effective action Γ by
Ppairs = 1 − e−2Im Γ .
∗
†
‡
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
(1)
Our starting point is the one-loop worldline representation of Γ in terms of an integral over proper time T and
Prepared for submission to JHEP
CERN-PH-TH-2015-149
UUITP-13/15
NORDITA-2015-79
Edinburgh 2015/11
arXiv:1507.00332v1 [hep-ph] 1 Jul 2015
Color-Kinematics Duality for QCD Amplitudes
Henrik Johansson,a,b,c Alexander Ochirovd
a
Theory Division, Physics Department, CERN, CH–1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland
Department of Physics and Astronomy, Uppsala University, Box 516, SE-75120 Uppsala, Sweden
c
Nordita, KTH Royal Institute of Technology and Stockholm University, Roslagstullsbacken 23,
SE-10691 Stockholm, Sweden
d
Higgs Centre for Theoretical Physics, School of Physics and Astronomy,
The University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh EH9 3JZ, Scotland, UK
b
E-mail: [email protected], [email protected]
Abstract: We show that color-kinematics duality is present in tree-level amplitudes of
quantum chromodynamics with massive flavored quarks. Starting with the color structure of QCD, we work out a new color decomposition for n-point tree amplitudes in a
reduced basis of primitive amplitudes. These primitives, with k quark-antiquark pairs and
(n − 2k) gluons, are taken in the (n − 2)!/k! Melia basis, and are independent under the
color-algebra Kleiss-Kuijf relations. This generalizes the color decomposition of Del Duca,
Dixon, and Maltoni to an arbitrary number of quarks. The color coefficients in the new
decomposition are given by compact expressions valid for arbitrary gauge group and representation. Considering the kinematic structure, we show through explicit calculations that
color-kinematics duality holds for amplitudes with general configurations of gluons and
massive quarks. The new (massive) amplitude relations that follow from the duality can
be mapped to a well-defined subset of the familiar BCJ relations for gluons. They restrict
the amplitude basis further down to (n − 3)!(2k − 2)/k! primitives, for two or more quark
lines. We give a decomposition of the full amplitude in that basis. The presented results
provide strong evidence that QCD obeys the color-kinematics duality, at least at tree level.
The results are also applicable to supersymmetric and D-dimensional extensions of QCD.
Prepared for submission to JHEP
arXiv:1507.00328v1 [hep-ph] 1 Jul 2015
Renormalization Group Evolution of Flavour Invariants
Thorsten Feldmann,a Thomas Mannel,a and Steffen Schwertfegerb
a
b
Theoretische Elementarteilchenphysik, Universit¨
at Siegen, 57068 Siegen, Germany
Physik Department T31, Technische Universit¨
at M¨
unchen, 85748 Garching, Germany
E-mail: [email protected], [email protected],
[email protected]
Abstract: The fermion spectrum in the Standard Model (SM) exhibits hierarchical structures between the eigenvalues of the Yukawa matrices which determine the fermion masses,
as well as certain hierarchical patterns in the mixing matrix that describes weak transitions between different fermion generations. A basis-independent description of the SM
flavour structure can be given in terms of a complete set of flavour invariants. In this
paper, we construct a convenient set of such invariants, and discuss the general form of
the renormalization-group equations. We also discuss the simplifications that arise from
exploiting hierarchies in Yukwawa couplings and mixings which are present in the SM or
its minimal-flavour violating extensions.
Keywords: Flavour Symmetries, Renormalization Group Equations
1
Preprint SI-HEP-2014-15, QFET-2014-10
arXiv:1507.00269v1 [hep-ph] 1 Jul 2015
IFIC/15-27
TUM-HEP-998/15
On the minimality of the order p6 chiral Lagrangian
P. Ruiz-Femen´ıaa and M. Zahiri-Abyanehb
a
Physik Department T31,
James-Franck-Straße, Technische Universit¨at M¨
unchen,
D–85748 Garching, Germany
b
Instituto de F´ısica Corpuscular (IFIC), CSIC-Universitat de Val`encia
Apdo. Correos 22085, E-46071 Valencia, Spain
Abstract
A method to find relations between the operators in the the mesonic Lagrangian of
Chiral Perturbation Theory at order p6 is presented. The procedure can be used
to establish if the basis of operators in the Lagrangian is minimal. As an example,
we apply the method to the two-flavour case in the absence of scalar and pseudoscalar sources (s = p = 0), and conclude that the minimal Lagrangian contains 27
independent operators.
Simple Non-Abelian Extensions and Diboson Excesses at LHC
Qing-Hong Cao,1, 2, 3, ∗ Bin Yan,1, † and Dong-Ming Zhang1, ‡
1
Department of Physics and State Key Laboratory of Nuclear Physics and Technology,
Peking University, Beijing 100871, China
2
arXiv:1507.00268v1 [hep-ph] 1 Jul 2015
3
Collaborative Innovation Center of Quantum Matter, Beijing, China
Center for High Energy Physics, Peking University, Beijing 100871, China
Abstract
The ATLAS collaboration reported excesses at around 2 TeV in the di-boson production decaying
into hadronic final states. We consider the possibility of explaining the excesses with extra gauge
bosons in two simple non-Abelian extensions of the Standard Model. One is the so-called G(221)
models with a symmetry structure of SU (2)1 ⊗ SU (2)2 ⊗ U (1)X and the other is the G(331) models
with an extended symmetry of SU (3)C ⊗ SU (3)L ⊗ U (1)X . The W 0 and Z 0 bosons emerge after the
electroweak symmetry is spontaneously broken. Two patterns of symmetry breaking in the G(221)
models are considered in this work: one is SU (2)L ⊗ SU (2)2 ⊗ U (1)X → SU (2)L ⊗ U (1)Y , the other
is SU (2)1 ⊗ SU (2)2 ⊗ U (1)Y → SU (2)L ⊗ U (1)Y . The symmetry breaking of the G(331) model is
SU (3)L ⊗ U (1)X → SU (2)L ⊗ U (1)Y . We perform a global analysis of W 0 and Z 0 phenomenology
in ten new physics models, including all the channels of W 0 /Z 0 decay. Our study shows that the
leptonic decays of W 0 /Z 0 impose a very stringent bound on the parameter space in several new
physics models. We argue that it is difficult to explain the W Z and W W excesses around 2 TeV in
the G(221) and G(331) models. If the diboson excesses persist at the LHC Run-2 and are confirmed
robustly, then the G(221) and G(331) models are disfavoured.
∗
[email protected]
†
[email protected]
‡
[email protected]
1
Noname manuscript No.
(will be inserted by the editor)
Configuration Mixing of Quark States in Baryons⋆
B. Saghai Saghai
Institut de Recherche sur les lois
Fondamentales de l’Univers,
DSM/Irfu, CEA/Saclay, 91191 Gif-sur-Yvette,
France
E-mail: [email protected]
arXiv:1507.00236v1 [hep-ph] 1 Jul 2015
and
Z. Li
SGT Inc, 7701 Greenbelt Road, Greenbelt,
MD. 20770, USA
the date of receipt and acceptance should be inserted later
Abstract
Mixing angles are used to describe the SU (6) ⊗ O(3) symmetry breaking in
70, 1− multiplet in the sector of the lowest mass nucleon resonances, which are investigated extensively in constituent quark models for baryon spectroscopy. The transition
amplitudes for the meson photoproduction off nucleon can also be expressed in terms
of the mixing angles to take into account the configuration mixing. Those amplitudes
are derived as a function of the mixing angles between |N 2 PM J − i and |N 4 PM J − i
states, with J=1/2 and 3/2, for the processes γp → ηp, K + Λ, K + Σ ◦ , K ◦ Σ + . The
present status of our knowledge on the mixing angles between S11 (1535) and S11 (1650)
(θS ), as well as between D13 (1520) and D13 (1700) (θD ) is reported. Since these resonances play very important role in the threshold region for both η and kaon production
mechanisms, they are expected to provide crucial tests of different quark models for
the baryon spectroscopy.
Keywords Baryon resonances · chiral quark models · Symmetry breaking
PACS 14.20.Gk · 12.39.Fe · 11.30.Qc
1 Introduction
Discovery of the first baryon resonance, ∆, goes back to 1952, when Fermi and collaborators released [1] unexpected experimental results on the π ± p interactions, followed
by Impulse approximation [2] and phase shift analysis [3, 4, 5]. In the late 1950s and
early 1960s the road to The Eightfold way was paved and by the mid-sixties a proliferation of discovery of mesons and baryons, including nucleon resonances, received a
⋆ Manuscript dedicated to Professor Willibald Plessas for his sixtieth birthday.
Published in: Few-Body Syst 47, 105 (2010).
Address(es) of author(s) should be given
Second order gluon polarization for SU(N) theory in linear covariant gauge
Fabio Siringo
Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia dell’Università di Catania,
INFN Sezione di Catania, Via S.Sofia 64, I-95123 Catania, Italy
(Dated: July 2, 2015)
arXiv:1507.00122v1 [hep-ph] 1 Jul 2015
The gluon polarization functional is evaluated for a generic linear covariant gauge and for any
space dimension in pure Yang-Mills SU(N) theory up to second order in a generalized perturbation
theory, where the zeroth order action is freely chosen and can be determined by some variational
method. Some numerical data are given for the gluon propagator in Landau gauge and compared
with Feynmann gauge. A comparison is given for several variational methods that can be set up by
the knowledge of the second-order polarization.
PACS numbers: 12.38.Lg,12.38.Aw,14.70.Dj,11.15.Tk
I.
INTRODUCTION
In spite of its phenomenological relevance, the infrared
(IR) limit of QCD has not been fully studied yet because
of non-perturbative effects that limit the power of standard tools based on perturbation theory. Our current
knowledge of the IR limit relies heavily on lattice simulations while, usually, analitycal non-perturbative techniques can only describe the phenomenology by insertion of some free parameters that emerge by some unknown sector of the theory like vertex functions[1–6],
counterterms[7–16] or renormalization schemes[14]. A
mass parameter for the gluon has been shown to capture most of the non-perturbative effects, leading to a
reasonable fit of lattice data[17–19], but we still miss a
fully consistent and analytical ab-initio theory without
spurious fit parameters.
Quite recently, an optimized perturbation theory has
been discussed[20], with zeroth order trial propagators
that are optimized by some variational ansatz. Many
variational strategies can be set up by the simple knowledge of self-energy and polarization functions, going from
the Gaussian effective potential[21–36] up to Stevenson’s
minimal sensitivity[37] and the novel method of stationary variance[38–40] that has been shown to be viable
for pure Yang-Mills SU(3) in Feynman gauge[41]. At
variance with other analytical approaches, these variational methods have the merit of reproducing some lattice
features, like the existence of a dynamical mass for the
gluon[41], without any free parameter, because the trial
quantities are all optimized by the variational ansatz. Of
course, the agreement with lattice data is not as good
as for a fit, but the approximation can be improved order by order and gives an ab-initio description that is
only based on the original Lagrangian, without spurious
parameters nor undesired counterterms that would spoil
the symmetry of the Lagrangian.
As discussed in Ref.[20], several variational approaches
can be implemented if the self-energy (the polarization) is
known, order by order in the optimized perturbation expansion, as a functional of the trial propagators. On the
other hand, some internal symmetries of the theory could
result broken by the truncated expansion and would turn
out to be only approximately satisfied, so that the actual
result would depend on further parameters that have to
do with the gauge choice, the renormalization scheme
and even the Renormalization Group (RG) invariance.
All these parameters can also be optimized by a variational ansatz, yielding an optimal gauge or an optimal
renormalization scheme[42, 43]. Thus it would be desirable to have a general set of explicit expressions for the
polarization functionals, holding for any gauge, for any
renormalization scheme and for any trial propagator. Actually, most of these functionals have been reported for
a free-particle propagator and in dimensional regularization where many terms vanish. A further proliferation
of terms arises from the use of a generic covariant gauge
since the trial propagator would be described by two independent functions for the transversal and longitudinal
part. Despite of many technical problems, the study of a
generic linear covariant gauge has attracted some new interest in the last years and the features of the gluon propagator have been investigated on the lattice[44, 45] and
in the framework of Dyson-Schwinger equations[13, 46].
Moreover, it has been recently shown that even if some
IR properties of the gluon propagator, like the dynamical mass, have no effects in the ultraviolet (UV) perturbative regime, they can drive a quark-quark interaction that is equal to that extracted by the ground-state
observables[47], thus enforcing our interest on the gauge
dependence of the gluon propagator in the IR.
In this paper we report general integral expressions
for the ghost self-energy and the gluon polarization, up
to second order in the optimized perturbation theory, as
functionals of trial propagators in a generic linear covariant gauge, for pure Yang-Mills SU (N ) theory in any
space dimension d. The integral expressions hold for
any renormalization scheme and have been checked by
a comparison with known results in dimensional regularization and in special gauges like Feynman and Landau gauge. Then, we use that result for extending to
Landau gauge a previous calculation of the gluon propagator by the method of stationary variance[20, 38, 39].
In fact, the gluon propagator was studied in Feynman
gauge in Ref.[41], while fixed-gauge lattice data are only
available in Landau gauge. Here, the numerical results
IPMU-15-0099
July 2, 2015
arXiv:1507.00119v1 [hep-ph] 1 Jul 2015
Dynamics of Peccei-Quinn Breaking Field after Inflation
and
Axion Isocurvature Perturbations
Keisuke Harigaya(a,b) , Masahiro Ibe(a,b) ,
Masahiro Kawasaki(a,b) and Tsutomu T. Yanagida(b)
(a) ICRR,
(b) Kavli
University of Tokyo, Kashiwa, Chiba 277-8582, Japan
IPMU (WPI), UTIAS, University of Tokyo, Kashiwa, Chiba 277-8583, Japan
The Peccei-Quinn mechanism suffers from the problem of the isocurvature perturbations. The isocurvature perturbations are suppressed if the
Peccei-Quinn breaking scale is large during inflation. The oscillation of the
Peccei-Quinn breaking field after inflation, however, leads to the formation
of domain walls due to the parametric resonance effect. In this paper, we
discuss the evolution of the Peccei-Quinn breaking field after inflation in detail, and propose a model where the parametric resonance is ineffective and
hence domain walls are not formed. We also discuss consistency of our model
with supersymmetric theory.
CETUP2015-005
Distinguishing LSP archetypes
via gluino pair production at LHC13
Baris Altunkaynaka∗ , Howard Baera† , Vernon Bargerb‡ , Peisi Huangc,d§
arXiv:1507.00062v1 [hep-ph] 30 Jun 2015
a
Homer L. Dodge Department of Physics and Astronomy,
University of Oklahoma, Norman, OK 73019, USA
b
Dept. of Physics, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53706, USA
c
The Enrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637, USA
d
HEP Division, Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne, IL 60439, USA
(Dated: July 2, 2015)
Abstract
The search for supersymmetry at Run 1 of LHC has resulted in gluino mass limits mg˜ & 1.3 TeV
for the case where mq˜ mg˜ and in models with gaugino mass unification. The increased energy
and ultimately luminosity of LHC13 will explore the range mg˜ ∼ 1.3 − 2 TeV. We examine how
the discovery of SUSY via gluino pair production would unfold via a comparative analysis of three
LSP archetype scenarios: 1. mSUGRA/CMSSM model with a bino-like LSP, 2. charged SUSY
breaking (CSB) with a wino-like LSP and 3. SUSY with radiatively-driven naturalness (RNS)
and a higgsino-like LSP. In all three cases we expect heavy-to-very-heavy squarks as suggested by
a decoupling solution to the SUSY flavor and CP problems and by the gravitino problem. For
/ T channel. The CSB
all cases, initial SUSY discovery would likely occur in the multi-b-jet + E
scenario would be revealed by the presence of highly-ionizing, terminating tracks from quasi-stable
charginos. As further data accrue, the RNS scenario with 100-200 GeV higgsino-like LSPs would
be revealed by the build-up of a mass edge/bump in the OS/SF dilepton invariant mass which
is bounded by the neutralino mass difference. The mSUGRA/CMSSM archetype would contain
neither of these features but would be revealed by a buildup of the usual multi-lepton cascade
decay signatures.
PACS numbers: 11.30.Pb, 12.60.Jv, 14.80.Ly, 14.80.Va
∗
†
‡
§
Email:
Email:
Email:
Email:
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
1
CERN-PH-TH-2015-148, CP3-15-18, Edinburgh 2015/08
Three-loop corrections to the soft anomalous dimension in multi-leg scattering
Øyvind Almelid,1 Claude Duhr,2, 3, ∗ and Einan Gardi1
arXiv:1507.00047v1 [hep-ph] 30 Jun 2015
1
Higgs Centre for Theoretical Physics, School of Physics and Astronomy,
The University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh EH9 3JZ, Scotland, UK
2
CERN Theory Division, 1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland
3
Center for Cosmology, Particle Physics and Phenomenology (CP3),
Universit´e Catholique de Louvain, 1348 Louvain-La-Neuve, Belgium
We present the three-loop result for the soft anomalous dimension governing long-distance singularities of multi-leg gauge-theory scattering amplitudes of massless partons. This establishes the form
of the first corrections to the dipole formula as ‘quadrupoles’, or four-parton correlations. We compute the set of non-planar connected gluon webs involving four semi-infinite Wilson lines at three
loops. The calculation is set up for non-lightlike Wilson lines, from which we extract the asymptotic lightlike limit using Mellin-Barnes techniques. The knowledge of these graphs, combined with
constraints from the Regge limit, is sufficient to obtain the complete three-loop correction to the
dipole formula, which can be expressed in terms of a pure combination of single-valued harmonic
polylogarithms. Finally we observe that, in contrast to previous expectations, the quadrupole term
in the soft anomalous dimension does not vanish in two-particle collinear limits. This implies that,
starting at three loops and beyond leading colour, splitting amplitudes do depend on the colour and
direction of the other partons participating in the scattering.
Infrared (long-distance) singularities are a salient feature of gauge-theory scattering amplitudes, and a detailed understanding of their structure and how they cancel in measurable cross sections is key to precision collider physics. For this reason, there has been a continuous theoretical interest in the factorization and exponentiation properties of the singularities, and their use
for resummation of large logarithmic corrections, starting from the analysis of the form factor in the early
days [1–10] through to many recent studies of multi-leg
amplitudes of both massless [9, 11–28] and massive partons [29–39] at the multi-loop level, and the formulation
of the non-Abelian exponentiation theorem in the multileg case [40–44].
The focus of this paper will be the infrared (IR) structure of a scattering amplitude for n massless partons.
More precisely, if the external legs have momenta pi ,
i = 1..n, with p2i = 0, long distance singularities (both
soft and collinear) can be factorized as follows
Mn ({pi } , αs ) = Zn ({pi } , µ, αs ) Hn ({pi } , µ, αs ) , (1)
where µ is a factorization scale, αs ≡ αs (µ2 ) is the
renormalised D-dimensional running coupling, Hn is a
finite hard scattering function, and Zn is an operator
in colour space that collects all IR singularities in the
form of poles in the dimensional regularization parameter = (4 − D)/2. The IR singularities contained in
Zn have their origin in loop momenta becoming either
soft or collinear to any of the scattered partons (see e.g.
ref. [45]). Collinear singularities depend on the spin and
momentum of that particle, and decouple from the rest of
the process. In contrast, soft (non-collinear) singularities
∗ On
leave from the “Fonds National de la Recherche Scientifique”
(FNRS), Belgium.
are independent of the spin, but they depend on the relative directions of motion and the colour degrees of freedom of the scattered particles. Hence, soft singularities
are sensitive to the colour flow in the entire process, and
their structure is a priori rather complex. Nevertheless,
they are significantly simpler than finite contributions to
the amplitude. They can be computed by considering
correlators of products of Wilson-line operators emanating from the hard interaction, following the classical trajectory of the scattered particles and carrying the same
colour charge.
Specifically, Zn can be obtained as a solution of a
renormalization-group equation as
(
)
Z 2
1 µ dλ2
2
Zn = P exp −
Γn {pi } , λ, αs (λ ) , (2)
2 0 λ2
where Γn is the so-called soft anomalous dimension matrix for multi-leg scattering, and P stands for pathordering of the matrices according to the order of scales λ.
We stress that Γn itself is finite, and IR singularities are
generated in eq. (2) owing to the fact that Γn depends on
the D-dimensional coupling, which is integrated over the
scale down to zero momentum. The functional form of Γn
is highly constrained, and owing to factorization and the
rescaling symmetry of the Wilson line velocities [17–20],
through three loops it must take the form
Γn ({pi } , λ, αs ) = Γdip.
({pi } , λ, αs ) + ∆n ({ρijkl } , αs ) ,
n
(3)
with
Γdip.
({pi } , λ, αs ) = −
n
+
X
1
−sij
γ
bK (αs )
log
Ti · Tj
2
λ2
i<j
n
X
i=1
γJi (αs ) ,
(4)
Prepared for submission to JHEP
IPPP/15/35, DCPT/15/70, MCNET/15/14
arXiv:1507.00020v1 [hep-ph] 30 Jun 2015
Automated event generation for loop-induced
processes
Valentin Hirschia Olivier Mattelaerb
a
b
SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, 2575 Sand Hill Road, Menlo Park, CA 94025-7090 USA
Institute for Particle Physics Phenomenology (IPPP), Durham University, Durham, DH1 3LF,
United Kingdom
E-mail: [email protected], [email protected]
Abstract: We present the first fully automated implementation of cross-section computation and event generation for loop-induced processes. This work is integrated in the
MadGraph5_aMC@NLO framework. We describe the optimisations implemented at the
level of the matrix element evaluation, phase space integration and event generation allowing for the simulation of large multiplicity loop-induced processes. Along with some selected
differential observables, we illustrate our results with a table showing inclusive cross-sections
for all loop-induced hadronic scattering processes with up to three final states in the SM
as well as for some relevant 2 → 4 processes. Many of these are computed here for the first
time.
Disentangling Mass and Mixing Hierarchies
Simon Knapen and Dean J. Robinson
Department of Physics, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA and
Ernest Orlando Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory,
University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA
arXiv:1507.00009v1 [hep-ph] 30 Jun 2015
We present a fully perturbative mechanism that naturally generates mass hierarchies for the Standard Model (SM) fermions in a flavor-blind sector. The dynamics generating the mass hierarchies
can therefore be independent from the source of flavor violation, and may operate at a much lower
scale. This mechanism operates by dynamically enforcing simultaneous diagonalization – alignment
– among a set of flavor-breaking spurions, as well as generating highly singular spectra for them. It
also has general applications in model building beyond the SM, wherever alignment between exotic
and SM sources of flavor violation is desired.
Introduction. The origin of the large mass and mixing hierarchies among the Standard Model (SM) fermions
– the flavor puzzle – is a significant open problem in
particle physics. Attempts to resolve this problem have
been carried out with a variety of approaches. The
most well-known is perhaps the Froggatt-Nielsen mechanism [1], which assigns different charges of a pseudoanomalous symmetry among the different SM generations. It thereby can physically distinguish fermion flavors and generate a hierarchy of masses and relative mixings for them. There exist multiple alternate formulations or extensions of this general idea, that seek to assign
various types of horizontal dynamics to the SM generations (see e.g. [2–9] among very many others).
Approaches of this style intrinsically link the origin of
the mass and mixing hierarchies. This can lead to flavor model-building challenges. For instance, considering
the first two quark generations, the Cabibbo-KobayashiMaskawa (CKM) quark mixing matrix element |Vcd | ∼
0.2, while the mass hierarchy mu,d /mc ∼ 10−3 . Similarly in the lepton sector, the charged leptons exhibit
a large mass hierarchy, while the PMNS mixing matrix
elements are all O(1).
In this Letter we present a mechanism that dynamically and naturally generates SM mass hierarchies without charging the SM fermions under any Froggatt-Nielsen
style horizontal symmetries. The SM fermions need only
be charged under their U (3) flavor symmetries, and couple universally to the physics that generates their mass
hierarchies. The question of the origin of the quark (lepton) flavor mass hierarchies is then disassociated from
the origin of the textures of the hierarchical CKM (nonhierarchical PMNS) flavor violating matrices.
Strategy. Specifically, we show how to dynamically
generate vacuum expectation values – spurions – for a
set of bifundamental flavon fields, {λα }, with the ‘aligned,
spectrally disjoint and rank-1 ’ pattern

hλ1 i = U 
r1

0
..
.
V † ,

0
hλ2 i = U  r2

..
.
V † ,
(1)
and so on, with U and V unitary matrices; the same
for each flavon. (This is inherently different to a rank1 projector approach, see e.g. [10].) Applied to the
SM with three generations, these spurions each break
U (3)×U (3)-type flavor symmetry to a different subgroup,
such that collectively the flavor symmetry is broken down
to baryon or lepton number. With spurions of the form
in eq. (1), one may then naturally construct mass hierarchies among the SM fermions by assigning extra symmetries or dynamical effects horizontally among the flavons
themselves. For instance, for a set of three up-type
flavons {λt,c,u }, bifundamental under U (3)Q ×U (3)U , the
up-type SM Yukawa terms could be generated from the
irrelevant operator
)
(
λ
s
λ
s
λ
s
t
c
c
u
u
t
¯L
UR ,
(2)
+
+
H †Q
ΛH ΛF
ΛH ΛF
ΛH ΛF
where ΛF ∼ hλα i is the scale of flavor breaking. The
sα are U (3) × U (3) singlet operators – in this sense they
are flavor-blind – that encode a hierarchy hst i hsc i hsu i, generated at some other scale ΛH . The up-type
quark mass hierarchies follow immediately from the pattern (1), independently of the structure of the matrices,
U and V , that encode flavor-violating effects. (We focus here on up-type quarks, but the generalization to the
down-type quarks and leptons follows analogously.)
This approach contrasts with Froggatt-Nielsen style
horizontal charges, that are assigned directly to the SM
fermions. Instead, the SM fermions are coupled universally to the flavor-blind, hierarchy-generating operators
sα . While the ratio hsα i/hsβ i is fixed by the observed SM
mass hierarchies, and while the scale of flavor-breaking,
ΛF , is bounded by precision flavor constraints, the hierarchy scale ΛH is unconstrained by these effects. As such
it may be sufficiently low to be detectable, for instance
at the LHC.
The particular scenario we have in mind is as follows.
Consider three sectors: a SM sector, a ‘flavor’ sector,
and a ‘hierarchy’ sector. The dynamics of the flavor
sector breaks the U (3)Q × U (3)U flavor symmetries at
a scale ΛF , by generating spurions of the form (1) for
arXiv:1507.00325v1 [nucl-ex] 1 Jul 2015
First measurement of the helicity asymmetry E in η photoproduction on the proton
I. Senderovich,2, ∗ B.T. Morrison,2 M. Dugger,2 B.G. Ritchie,2 E. Pasyuk,35, 2 R. Tucker,2 J. Brock,35
C. Carlin,35 C.D. Keith,35 D.G. Meekins,35 M.L. Seely,35 D. R¨onchen,13 M. D¨oring,12 P. Collins,6
K.P. Adhikari,28 D. Adikaram,28, † Z. Akbar,11 M.D. Anderson,38 S. Anefalos Pereira,16 R.A. Badui,10 J. Ball,7
N.A. Baltzell,1, 33, † M. Battaglieri,17 V. Batourine,35 I. Bedlinskiy,21 A.S. Biselli,9 S. Boiarinov,35 W.J. Briscoe,12
W.K. Brooks,36, 35 V.D. Burkert,35 D.S. Carman,35 A. Celentano,17 S. Chandavar,27 G. Charles,20
L. Colaneri,18, 29 P.L. Cole,14 M. Contalbrigo,15 O. Cortes,14 V. Cred´e,11 A. D’Angelo,18, 29 N. Dashyan,42
R. De Vita,17 E. De Sanctis,16 A. Deur,35 C. Djalali,33 R. Dupre,20 H. Egiyan,35, 25 A. El Alaoui,36 L. El Fassi,28
A. Fradi,20 L. Elouadrhiri,35 P. Eugenio,11 G. Fedotov,33, 30 S. Fegan,17 A. Filippi,19 J.A. Fleming,37 B. Garillon,20
Y. Ghandilyan,42 G.P. Gilfoyle,31 K.L. Giovanetti,22 F.-X. Girod,35, 7 D.I. Glazier,38 J.T. Goetz,27 W. Gohn,8, ‡
E. Golovatch,30 R.W. Gothe,33 K.A. Griffioen,41 M. Guidal,20 L. Guo,10, 35 K. Hafidi,1 H. Hakobyan,36, 42
C. Hanretty,40, 11, † M. Hattawy,20 K. Hicks,27 D. Ho,5 M. Holtrop,25 S.M. Hughes,37 Y. Ilieva,33, 12 D.G. Ireland,38
B.S. Ishkhanov,30 D. Jenkins,39 H. Jiang,33 H.S. Jo,20 K. Joo,8 S. Joosten,34 D. Keller,40, 27 G. Khachatryan,42
M. Khandaker,14, 26 A. Kim,8 F.J. Klein,6 V. Kubarovsky,35 M. C. Kunkel,23 P. Lenisa,15 K. Livingston,38
H.Y. Lu,33 I.J.D. MacGregor,38 P. Mattione,5 B. McKinnon,38 C.A. Meyer,5 T. Mineeva,43 V. Mokeev,35, 30
R.A. Montgomery,16 A. Movsisyan,15 C. Munoz Camacho,20 P. Nadel-Turonski,35, 6, 12 L.A. Net,33 S. Niccolai,20
G. Niculescu,22 I. Niculescu,22 M. Osipenko,17 K. Park,35, 33, 24, § S. Park,11 P. Peng,40 W. Phelps,10 S. Pisano,16
O. Pogorelko,21 J.W. Price,3 Y. Prok,28, 40 A.J.R. Puckett,8 M. Ripani,17 A. Rizzo,18, 29 G. Rosner,38 P. Roy,11
F. Sabati´e,7 C. Salgado,26 D. Schott,12, 10 R.A. Schumacher,5 E. Seder,8 A. Simonyan,42 Iu. Skorodumina,33, 30
G.D. Smith,37 D.I. Sober,6 D. Sokhan,38 N. Sparveris,34 S. Stepanyan,35 P. Stoler,32 I.I. Strakovsky,12
S. Strauch,33 V. Sytnik,36 Ye Tian,33 M. Ungaro,35, 8 H. Voskanyan,42 E. Voutier,20 N.K. Walford,6
X. Wei,35 M.H. Wood,4, 33 N. Zachariou,33 L. Zana,37, 25 J. Zhang,35, 28 Z.W. Zhao,28, 33, 35 and I. Zonta18, 29
(The CLAS Collaboration)
1
Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne, Illinois 60439
2
Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona 85287-1504
California State University, Dominguez Hills, Carson, California 90747
4
Canisius College, Buffalo, New York 14208
5
Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15213
6
Catholic University of America, Washington, D.C. 20064
7
CEA, Centre de Saclay, Irfu/Service de Physique Nucl´eaire, 91191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France
8
University of Connecticut, Storrs, Connecticut 06269
9
Fairfield University, Fairfield, Connecticut 06824
10
Florida International University, Miami, Florida 33199
11
Florida State University, Tallahassee, Florida 32306
12
The George Washington University, Washington, DC 20052
13
HISKP and BCTP, Universit¨
at Bonn, 53115 Bonn, Germany
14
Idaho State University, Pocatello, Idaho 83209
15
INFN, Sezione di Ferrara, 44100 Ferrara, Italy
16
INFN, Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati, 00044 Frascati, Italy
17
INFN, Sezione di Genova, 16146 Genova, Italy
18
INFN, Sezione di Roma Tor Vergata, 00133 Rome, Italy
19
INFN, Sezione di Torino, 10125 Torino, Italy
20
Institut de Physique Nucl´eaire, CNRS/IN2P3 and Universit´e Paris Sud, Orsay, France
21
Institute of Theoretical and Experimental Physics, Moscow, 117259, Russia
22
James Madison University, Harrisonburg, Virginia 22807
23
Forschungszentrum J¨
ulich, Institut f¨
ur Kernphysik, 52425 J¨
ulich, Germany
24
Kyungpook National University, Daegu 702-701, Republic of Korea
25
University of New Hampshire, Durham, New Hampshire 03824-3568
26
Norfolk State University, Norfolk, Virginia 23504
27
Ohio University, Athens, Ohio 45701
28
Old Dominion University, Norfolk, Virginia 23529
29
Universita’ di Roma Tor Vergata, 00133 Rome Italy
30
Skobeltsyn Institute of Nuclear Physics, Lomonosov Moscow State University, 119234 Moscow, Russia
31
University of Richmond, Richmond, Virginia 23173
32
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy, New York 12180
33
University of South Carolina, Columbia, South Carolina 29208
34
Temple University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19122
3
2
35
Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility, Newport News, Virginia 23606
36
Universidad T´ecnica Federico Santa Mar´ıa, Casilla 110-V Valpara´ıso, Chile
37
Edinburgh University, Edinburgh EH9 3JZ, United Kingdom
38
University of Glasgow, Glasgow G12 8QQ, United Kingdom
39
Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, Virginia 24061-0435
40
University of Virginia, Charlottesville, Virginia 22901
41
College of William and Mary, Williamsburg, Virginia 23187-8795
42
Yerevan Physics Institute, 375036 Yerevan, Armenia
43
University of Waterloo, Institute for Quantum Computing, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada
(Dated: July 2, 2015)
Results are presented for the first measurement of the double-polarization helicity asymmetry E
for the η photoproduction reaction γp → ηp. Data were obtained using the FROzen Spin Target
(FROST) with the CLAS spectrometer in Hall B at Jefferson Lab, covering a range of center-ofmass energy W from threshold to 2.15 GeV and a large range in center-of-mass polar angle. As an
initial application of these data, the results have been incorporated into the J¨
ulich model to examine
the case for the existence of a narrow N ∗ resonance between 1.66 and 1.70 GeV. The addition of
these data to the world database results in marked changes in the predictions for the E observable
using that model. Further comparison with several theoretical approaches indicates these data will
significantly enhance our understanding of nucleon resonances.
Much activity is being devoted to establishing the details of the excitation spectrum of the nucleon in order to
deepen our understanding of this fundamental stronglyinteracting three-quark system. Due to the broad widths
of the nucleon excitations (of the order of 100-300 MeV),
the states overlap in the mass spectrum. Thus, disentangling the individual states to identify their exact
masses and quantum numbers has been quite difficult.
While some resonances are well established, fewer states
have been observed than most constituent quark models
and Lattice QCD calculations predict [1]. An additional
complexity arises because, beyond resonance states with
typical widths, approaches based on chiral quark solitons also predict states with far narrower widths than
do constituent quark models, including, for example, an
N 12 + state with a width of 40 MeV or less [2–6] at about
1.7 GeV; this particular state may have been observed in
η photoproduction on the neutron [7–9].
Since differential cross section measurements alone are
insufficient to locate the underlying resonance states or
determine their properties, attention has turned to polarization observables. Polarization observables involve
interferences between sets of amplitudes, so their measurement can provide stringent tests for predictions of
the photoproduction process and help sort out ambiguities in the theoretical description of the reaction in terms
of which resonances might be involved. One such polarization observable is the helicity asymmetry E in pseudoscalar meson photoproduction, which is the normalized
difference in photoproduction yield when spins of the incident photon and a longitudinally-polarized target are
parallel and anti-parallel. Formally, this observable is
defined as a modulation of the center-of-mass differential
dσ
cross section dΩ
through the relation
0
dσ
dσ
=
1 − PzT P◦γ E ,
dΩ
dΩ 0
(1)
where PzT specifies the degree of longitudinal target polarization and P◦γ is the circular polarization fraction of
the incident photon beam. This asymmetry is generally
expressed as a function of the center-of-mass energy W
and the polar angle of the produced meson in the centerof-mass frame cos θcm .
Though pion photoproduction offers a larger cross section, the photoproduction of η mesons exhibits the interesting feature that the process excludes contributions
from resonances with isospin I = 3/2, thereby isolating
the N ∗ (I = 1/2) states. The η photoproduction process
on the proton thus acts as an “isospin filter” for the nucleon resonance spectrum, resulting in a useful tool for
disentangling the different states.
The measurements of the helicity asymmetry reported
here are an integral part of a program being conducted
at Jefferson Lab to achieve a “complete” experiment for
the η photoproduction process, whereby all the helicity
amplitudes are determined for photoproduction of that
pseudoscalar meson. Using the large solid angle CEBAF
Large Acceptance Spectrometer (CLAS) [10], this program began with measurements of the unpolarized differdσ
ential cross section dΩ
[11, 12] using the bremsstrahlung
0
photon tagger in Jefferson Lab Hall B [13]. For the
measurements reported here, circularly polarized photon beams were produced by polarization transfer from
the polarized electron beam of the CEBAF accelerator,
which was incident on an amorphous radiator of the photon tagger.
The target nucleons for the photoproduction process
were free protons in frozen butanol (C4 H9 OH) beads inside a 50 mm-long target cup. [14]. The protons of the hydrogen atoms in this material were dynamically polarized
along the photon beam direction. The longitudinal target polarization PzT was determined using nuclear magnetic resonance measurements, and averaged 82±5%. To
minimize systematic uncertainties, the orientation of the