Project DATA: A School-based Model to Provide Evidence

Project DATA: A School‐based Model to Provide Evidence‐Based Intervention to Toddlers and Preschoolers with ASD Ilene Schwartz
University of Washington
[email protected]
Learning Objectives
1. Participants will be able to identify the essential
components needed to provide an effective program for
toddlers and preschoolers with autism and their families.
2. Participants will be able to identify evidence-based
instructional strategies to use with toddlers and
preschoolers with autism.
3. Participants will have strategies that can be used to
implement these programs in their communities
Autism is a collection of overlapping groups of symptoms
that vary from child to child
Siegel, 1996, p.301
“No treatment method completely ameliorates the symptoms of ASD and no specific treatment has emerged as the established standard of care for all children with ASD.”
Stahmer, Scheibman, & Cunningham (2011, p. 230)
NO ONE WAY TO EDUCATE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM!!!
There are no instructional strategies that are autism‐
specific Think, Pair, Share

What is your experience with inclusive early childhood
education?

What is your experience working with children with ASD?

What do you want to get out of this session? (write at least one
item on a post-it)

What do you want to share with you colleagues in this session?
(write at least one item on a post-it)

Share with your neighbor
Children with ASD require:

Instruction to be more explicit

Reinforcement to be more explicit and perhaps
extrinsic to start

More opportunities to practice with feedback

Planned instruction to facilitate generalization
Preschool students with autism:

Are children first

Have diverse strengths and needs

Most often need explicit instruction across curricular domains

May be gifted academically or have cognitive impairment

Will need specialized instruction in social skills and
communication
Guiding Questions to Implement Best Practices for Young Children With ASD

Comprehensive intervention planning
across domains

Use of evidence-based instructional
practices

Data-based decision making

Technical and social support for family
members

Access to typically developing peers

Access to quality of life influenced
curriculum
Comprehensive intervention planning across domains:

Does the program address any identified needs from the assessment in
areas of social, play/leisure, adaptive skills, cognitive, communication?

Is the planned intervention or specially designed instruction across all
levels of learning (e.g., acquisition, fluency, maintenance, generalization)?

Is the planned intervention or specially designed instruction implemented
at the level of intensity that progress can be determined?
Use of evidence‐based instructional practices:

Is the chosen intervention for a particular skill
considered an evidence-based practice?

Has the context, child characteristics, or family
preferences been considered when choosing a
particular practice/intervention?

Does the team have appropriate training and
adequate resources to implement the practice with
fidelity?
Data‐based decision making:

Are data being collected on a frequent enough basis to
determine progress on a particular skill?

Is the data collection system likely to be implemented and does
it provide a measure of progress for the particular skill?

Are the data reviewed frequently (at least twice monthly) and
are instructional decisions made, communicated to the team,
and implemented as a result of the data reviews?
Technical and social support for family members:

Has the family’s input during the assessment process been
solicited?

Has the family’s need for technical support (e.g., parenting
classes) been assessed and have these services been
provided?

Has the family’s needs regarding social support been assessed
and suggestions provided?
Access to typically developing peers:

Does the program provide the children
with ASD opportunities to interact with
typically developing peers at least 3 days
a week?

Does the program staff use appropriate
classroom activities, room arrangement,
and instructional strategies to promote
positive social interactions between
children with ASD and typically
developing children?
Access to quality of life influenced curriculum:
 Are
family members involved in setting the goals for
intervention?
 Do
intervention goals align with parents’ values, preferences,
and identity?
 How
will the targeted skills and behaviors increase the child’s
independence and increase his or her overall quality of life
Project DATA -- Current
Extended,
Intensive
Instruction
Technical and
Social Support
for Families
Integrated Early
Childhood
Experience
Collaboration
and
Coordination
Quality of Life
Influenced
Curriculum
High Quality Early Childhood Program

Inclusive

Intentional teaching

Supportive child teacher relationship

Class membership
Using a Variety of Instructional Strategies
 Peers
 Explicit
instruction
 Embedded
instruction
 Other
teachers or
building staff
 Areas
around school
outside the classroom
Extended instructional day

Inclusion + intensive instruction

The goal of the extended instructional day is to help children
access and succeed in “general education”

Behaviorally based

Data-based decision making
Highly Supported Instructional Time 1:1 or 2:1 Student:Teacher ratio
Switch it up
Do a variety of activities each
day

Science, art, blocks,
imaginative play, etc.
Move around the classroom




We are not restricted to the
table!
Outside
Book area
Swings
One goal of instruction is to make
the abstract concrete

Schedules

activity matrix

Visual supports

Environmental arrangements
An Activity Matrix
1. Is an effective way to organize teaching and
learning opportunities.
2. Maximizes learning time by planning for
teaching to occur throughout all activities,
routines, and transitions.
3. Helps all staff be aware of individual child
learning objectives.
4. Matches the child’s learning objective to the
activity.
5. Can be implemented for any child, but is
especially useful for those who need extra
support.
Activity Matrix -- Individual
Comm.
Social
Circle
Color and Answer
shapes
questions
Snack
Request
Free
Choice
Respond
to peers
Motor
Conversa
tions with
peers
Adapt.
Pouring
Writing/co
loring
Activity Matrix -- Class
Connie
Circle
Color and shapes
Answer questions
Snack
Request
Conversations
Pouring
Free
Choice
Respond to peers
Writing/coloring
Greg
Eric
Lee
+
Make it your own
Example Activity Matrix
Nathan
Matt
Play with toys at table
12:45 – 1:00
Gaining a peer’s attention by
saying his/her name
Responding to peers
Following Directions
Responding to peers
Book
1:00 – 1:10
Answering WH Questions
- Answering WH Questions
- Pronouns
Board Game
1:10 – 1:20
Asking for a turn
Gaining a peer’s attention
- Commenting to peers
Gaining a peer’s attention
Bathroom & wash hands
1:20 – 1:30
Following Directions
Following Directions
Snack
1:30 – 1:45
- Responding to peers
- Greetings
- Gaining a peer’s attention by
saying his/her name
- Responding to peers
Group Activity
1:45 – 2:00
- Following Directions
- Respond to peers
- Respond to peers
- Following Directions
Table Work
2:00 – 2:30
- Feature, Function, Class
Feature, Function, Class
- Pronouns
- 1:1 Correspondence
Circle 2:30 – 2:50
Following Directions
Answering WH Questions
Following Directions
Answering WH Questions
Activity
Schedules
Line
drawings
Pictures
Lists
Visual
Supports
Graphic
displays
Calendars
Smart Phones
Notes
To Do Lists
Maps
Planners
Visuals Give Children Extra Information •
•
•
Reduce anxiety
Prompt
Help express wants &
needs
•
•
Focus on a specific
message in a direction
Clarify expectations
Classroom Expectations
Ears are Listening
Listening Friend
Raise a Quiet Hand
Snapping Fingers
Touch Gently
Quiet Mouth
Walking Feet
For Individual
Children
For the Whole
Class
But…We must TEACH children how to use visuals! Count
to ten
Eenie Meenie
Minie Moe
Raise a
quiet hand
Trade
Talk to
friends
Framework for Teaching Visuals
Brainstorm
Teach
Embed
Fade
Evaluate
Brainstorm
What function should visuals
serve?
If a child is engaging in challenging
behavior, what function does this serve?
• Escape an activity that’s too hard?
• Are directions too complex for him to follow?
Collaborate with classroom
team and families
Teach
Explain the meaning of
each visual
Model target behavior
Provide feedback
Embed
More embedded learning  faster
learning
Opportunities to use the visual
throughout activities & receive feedback
Develop independence
Progress monitoring & data based
decision making
Our goal =
independence
Fade

As child learns to use the visual,
consider how to decrease support

Not eliminate, but teach the child how to
use the visual independently

Consider making visuals smaller, using
text vs. symbols, or place in different
areas (in cubbies, on children’s tables,
etc.)
Evaluate Throughout
all phases
Questions
to Ask
• Examine data and monitor progress
• Evaluate all aspects of the visuals
• Modifications are necessary as children learn to
use these independently
• Does the child understand what the visual means?
• Do data show visuals are helping the child engage
in more appropriate behavior?
• Can he use it independently?
• Is everyone on the team implementing the visual
the same way?
• Can he use this across settings?
Technical and Social Support for Families

Home Visits

Transition Support
“In promoting a partnership between
parents and teachers, home visits provide
the means for effective team problem
solving, observing children in their home
environment, and encouraging parent
involvement,”
(Beardmore et. al., 1999)
Home Visits
Monthly, two hour visits

At home, at school, in the
community, at day care, play
dates, collaboration with private
consultant, etc.

Family/Caregiver driven: parents
own the agenda

Support the family in working on
high priority skills at home
Example: Will’s Trying New Foods Plan at school

High priority for family at home: trying new“super foods”(fruits
and vegetables)

At school, we are working on Will taking a bite of a“super
food”before eating the rest of his snack

W.B. bite of orange
Transition Support

Accompany family on school tours

Communication with child’s new teachers in the
next educational setting at the beginning of the
school year

Supplemental transition report to accompany the
preschool report

School visits if necessary
Quality of Life Influenced Curriculum

Goal of DATA Project is for
children to participate in a
meaningful way in their family
and community

We embed explicit instruction
into every activity and fade
supports as soon as children
are independent

Our assessment process
includes family input

Generalization and
maintenance are key

We are heavily focused on
social, communication, and
independence skills
Schedule for Toddler DATA
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Integrated
Play Group
Extended,
Intensive
Service
Integrated
Play Group
Extended,
Intensive
Service
Extended,
Intensive
Service
Home vist
Schedule for Preschool DATA
Monday
Tuesday
Preschool
Preschool
Extended
Day
Wednesday
Extended
Day
Thursday
Friday
Preschool
Preschool
Extended
Day
Two New Reviews of EBP

National Standards Project from the National Autism Center


http://www.nationalautismcenter.org/
Evidence-Based Practices for Children, Youth, and Young
Adults with Autism Spectrum Disorder by the National
Professional Development Center on Autism Spectrum
Disorder

http://autismpdc.fpg.unc.edu/how-do-i-find-out-more-aboutebps
Antecedent
Target Behavior
Consequence
DTT (Discrete Trial Training) What is it? 
Breaks a skill into very small parts

Teaches each sub-skill to mastery before
moving on

Provides concentrated teaching

Response is initiated by teacher

A response by child is required
A Discrete Trial

Instruction

Prompt (if necessary)

Child’s Response

Consequences

Inter-trial Interval
A Discrete Trial (Teaching Loop)
Instruction or Discrimitive Stimulus (SD) Antecedent
Prompt if
necessary
Child’s
Response
Behavior
Consequence Consequence
Inter-trial Interval
Questions?