20150327i.pdf
IR-4 Ornamental Horticulture Program
Research Report Cover Sheet
Researcher(s) Tom Freiberger
Affiliation:
Trial: 2014 NJ
USDA-ARS
Rutgers University IR-4 Ornamental Pro
283 Rt. 539
Cream Ridge
NJ
08514
PhoneNumber: (609) 758-7311
[email protected]
Email:
ProjectTitle:
Protocol #:
PR#
31731
31724
31738
Crop/Plant
Product
31691
31696
29325
EPA Reg. # Production Site
Phytotoxicity
Angelonia
Sultan
-
Phytotoxicity
Angelonia angustifolia
Cyflumetofen
BASF
Phytotoxicity
Calibrachoa
Sultan
-
Phytotoxicity
Calibrachoa sp.
Cyflumetofen
BASF
Phytotoxicity
Dracaena
Sultan
-
Phytotoxicity
Dracaena sp
Cyflumetofen
BASF
Protocol #:
31689
14-008
Research Target
ProjectTitle:
PR#
Cyflumetofen Crop Safety
C
Greenhouse
C
Greenhouse
C
14-008
Crop/Plant
Product
EPA Reg. # Production Site
Status
Phytotoxicity
Calibrachoa
Rycar (SP3009/NNI-0101)
71711-37-6769 Greenhouse
Phytotoxicity
Calibrachoa sp.
Pyrifluquinazon
SePro
Phytotoxicity
Phytotoxicity
Tickseed
Coreopsis sp.
Rycar (SP3009/NNI-0101)
Pyrifluquinazon
71711-37-6769 Greenhouse
SePro
C
C
Phytotoxicity
Dracaena
Rycar (SP3009/NNI-0101)
71711-37-6769 Greenhouse
Phytotoxicity
Dracaena sp
Pyrifluquinazon
SePro
Phytotoxicity
Pansy
Rycar (SP3009/NNI-0101)
71711-37-6769 Greenhouse
Phytotoxicity
Viola sp.
Pyrifluquinazon
SePro
Protocol #:
C
C
Tolfenpyrad Crop Safety
14-008
PR#
Research Target
Crop/Plant
Product
31697
Phytotoxicity
Calibrachoa
Hachi-Hachi SC
-
Phytotoxicity
Calibrachoa sp.
Tolfenpyrad
SePro
Phytotoxicity
Phytotoxicity
Tickseed
Coreopsis sp.
Hachi-Hachi SC
Tolfenpyrad
Phytotoxicity
Dracaena
Phytotoxicity
Dracaena sp
31704
Greenhouse
Pyrfluquinazon Crop Safety
Research Target
ProjectTitle:
31699
Status
EPA Reg. # Production Site
Status
Greenhouse
C
SePro
Greenhouse
C
Hachi-Hachi SC
-
Greenhouse
C
Tolfenpyrad
SePro
Ornamental Horticulture Program
Research Report Form
Researcher:
Dave Bodine, Tom Freiberger
Project Title: Crop Safety of New Insecticides and Miticides
Protocol #: 14-008
p1
Date: February 19, 2015
PRnumbers:29325, 31731, 31697, 31689, 31724,
31699, 31691, 31704, 31696, 31738,
Narrative Summary (Results/Discussion)
Please keep text to one page if possible. Include summary of trial results and a brief discussion including how any
changes from the protocol may have affected results. Results for multiple PRnumbers can be summarized together, but
please list all PRNumbers in the header and in the summary data table.
Pansy, Dracaena, Calibrachoa and Coreopsis were purchased as plugs from Kube Pak and potted up on
11/25/2014 in fafard #2 growing mix (70% peat, 20% perlite and 10% vermiculite) using classic 300S pots. Angelonia
were purchased as seeds from Stokes seed and seeded on 11/3/2014 in classic 300S pots and fafard #2 growing mix.
Dracaena and pansy were placed in greenhouse #1 while Calibrachoa and Coreopsis were placed in greenhouse #2. All
pots were placed on a black woven porous weed mat and both greenhouses had overhead irrigation on a timer and
overhead and floor heat. Osmocote Plus 15-9-12 granular fertilizer was applied at a rate of 6 grams per pot. Beginning
plant height and width measurements were done on 12/19/2014 for Dracaena and Coreopsis, 12/22/2014 for Calibrachoa
and Pansy and 1/5/2015 for Angelonia. The first application was done on 12/23/2014, the second application was done on
1/6/2015 and the final application was done on 1/20/2015. For the Angelonia, the first application was done on 1/6/2015.
The second application was done on 1/20/2015 and the final application was done on 2/3/2015. All foliage was dry prior
to all applications and a single nozzle boom was used to treat all 12 pots of the same treatment sprayed over the top on a
single pass. Plants of the same treatment were sprayed out of the same spray bottle mixture. This procedure was used for
all foliar applications. Phytotoxicity ratings were taken every week after the initial application for six weeks. Final plant
height and width measurements were taken on 2/3/2015 and 2/18/2015 for Angelonia. See “protocol 14-008 GH#1, 2”
spreadsheet for evaluation ratings.
Results Table
Please insert results table here. Include PRnumbers for each treatment if multiple PRnumbers are included in this
summary. Please include product, active ingredient, and statistics.
See “protocol 14-008 GH#1, 2” spreadsheet.
No stats were run on this data.
The Dracaena spikes and Coreopsis were not affected in any way at any of the rates by their applications.
Calibrachoa suffered no damage at any rate with Hachi-hachi SC and SP3009. Both of these chemicals looked like they
helped kill off the aphids and thrips that were damaging the other groups of Calibrachoa since these groups suffered little
to no insect damage.
Calibrachoa applied with Sultan and both control groups suffered major damage from thrips and aphids. Maintenance
sprays were done to try to kill them off, but we had trouble controlling them. Once we did get control of the aphids and
thrips, all plants began to improve and grow vigorously again. This was not until after the pictures were taken and the
final evaluation was done. New, updated pictures were taken (3/4/2015) to show the improvement.
The pansies had a few die off, but otherwise the rest grew well having SP3009 not affecting them.
Angelonia suffered no damage from Sultan with the few that died being from natural causes. Being planted from seed,
not enough grew so we had to exclude the surfactant only control group.
Ornamental Horticulture Program
Research Report Form
Researcher:
Dave Bodine, Tom Freiberger
Project Title: Crop Safety of New Insecticides and Miticides
Protocol #: 14-008
p2
Date: February 19, 2015
PRnumbers:29325, 31731, 31697, 31689, 31724,
31699, 31691, 31704, 31696, 31738,
Materials & Methods/Recordkeeping
Please fill out the information below or attach a separate document with comparable information.
Name(s) of Personnel Conducting Research: Dave Bodine, Tom Freiberger
Location of Trial (city/state): Cream Ridge, NJ
Use Site (greenhouse/shadehouse/field container/etc): Greenhouse
Crop History
Crop Cultivar/Variety:
Date of Seeding:
Date of Emergence:
Date of Transplanting:
Potting Mix:
Pot size & spacing:
Row spacing:
Pansy: Matrix Blue Frost, Angelonia: Serena Blue, Dracaena: Spikes, Calibrachoa:
Kabloom White, Coreopsis: Early Sunrise Yellow
Angelonia- 11/3/2014
Angelonia- 11/12/2014
Pansy, Dracaena, Calibrachoa, Coreopsis- 11/25/2014
Fafard #2 Growing Mix (70% peat, 20% perlite, 10% vermiculite)
Classic 300S, .66 gals.
NA
Product(s) applied prior to start of experiment:
Product
Rate
Application
Type
Osmocote Plus 15-96 grams per pot
Granular
12
Awaken (Foliar
10 mL. per 1 gal. Foliar
fertilizer)
Date of
Application
11/26/2014
Crop Growth
Stage
Vegetative
Application
Volume
NA
11/26/2014
Vegetative
Spray until
drip
Topsin-M 70WSB
(thiophanate-methyl)
12 oz per 100
gals.
Foliar
11/26/2014
Vegetative
Spray until
drip
Warrior II with Zenon
Technology (Lambdacyhalothrin)
5 fl oz per 100
gals.
(GH #2,
calibrachoa only)
3 fl oz per 100
gals. (GH #2,
calibrachoa only)
Foliar
12/12/2014,
12/15/2014
Vegetative
Spray until
drip
Foliar
12/19/2014
Vegetative
Spray until
drip
Admire II
(Imidacloprid)
Add more rows as needed.
Ornamental Horticulture Program
Research Report Form
Researcher:
Dave Bodine, Tom Freiberger
Project Title: Crop Safety of New Insecticides and Miticides
Protocol #: 14-008
Experiment Information
Experimental Design:
Number of Reps:
p3
Date: February 19, 2015
PRnumbers:29325, 31731, 31697, 31689, 31724,
31699, 31691, 31704, 31696, 31738,
12 pots per treatment
Materials & Methods:
Insert materials & methods here only if information is not presented elsewhere.
Include any changes from protocol.
Application Equipment: CO2 backpack sprayer with single nozzle boom
Product(s) applied during experiment (including treatments, fertilizers, etc):
Product
Rate(s)
Application
Date of
Crop Growth
Type
Application
Stage
Hachi-hachi SC
21 fl oz per 100
Foliar
12/23/2014,
Vegetative.
(tolfenpyrad)
gals.
1/6/2015,
Flowering
1/20/2015
42 fl oz per 100
SP3009
(pyrifluquinazon)
Sultan (cyflumetofen)
Onyx Pro (bifenthrin)
Hachi-hachi SC
(tolfenpyrad)
Overture (pyridalyl)
Add more rows as needed.
gals.
84 fl oz per 100
gals.
6.38 fl oz per 100
gals.
12.76 fl oz per
100 gals.
25.52 fl oz per
100 gals.
13.7 fl oz per 100
gals.
27.4 fl oz per 100
gals.
54.8 fl oz per 100
gals.
8 fl oz per 100
gals. (GH #2,
calibrachoa only)
30 fl oz per 100
gals. (GH#2,
calibrachoa only)
8 oz per 100 gals.
(GH #2,
calibrachoa only)
Application
Volume
Spray until
drip
Foliar
12/23/2014,
1/6/2015,
1/20/2015
Vegetative.
Flowering
Spray until
drip
Foliar
12/23/2014,
1/6/2015,
1/20/2015,
(2/3/2015:
Angelonia
only)
Vegetative.
Flowering
Spray until
drip
Foliar
1/13/2015
Vegetative.
Flowering
Spray until
drip
Foliar
1/26/2015
Vegetative.
Flowering
Spray until
drip
Foliar
1/26/2015,
1/29/2015
Vegetative.
Flowering
Spray until
drip
Ornamental Horticulture Program
Research Report Form
Researcher:
Dave Bodine, Tom Freiberger
Project Title: Crop Safety of New Insecticides and Miticides
Protocol #: 14-008
Date: February 19, 2015
PRnumbers:29325, 31731, 31697, 31689, 31724,
31699, 31691, 31704, 31696, 31738,
Photos
Please embed photos here or send jpg, tiff, or bmp.
Sent separately.
Data Collected
Please describe data collected and scoring system. Also include the dates data were collected.
Plants were evaluated on a scale of 0-10. 0 being no phytotoxicity and 10 being a complete kill.
Beginning plant height and width measurements taken on 12/19/2014 for Dracaena and Coreopsis, 12/22/2014 for
Calibrachoa and Pansy, 1/5/2015 for Angelonia.
The first application was done on 12/23/2014, for angelonia 1/6/2015.
The second application was done on 1/6/2015, for angelonia 1/20/2015.
The third application was done on 1/20/2015, for angelonia 2/3/2015.
The first evaluation was done on 12/30/2014 and 1/13/2015 for angelonia.
The second evaluation was done on 1/6/2015 and 1/20/2015 for angelonia.
The third evaluation was done on 1/13/2015 and 1/26/2015 for angelonia.
The fourth evaluation was done on 1/20/2015 and 2/3/2015 for angelonia.
The fifth evaluation was done on 1/26/2015 and 2/10/2015 for angelonia.
The sixth evaluation was done on 2/3/2015 and 2/18/2015 for angelonia.
Final height and width measurements were done on 2/3/2015 and 2/18/2015 for angelonia.
Pictures were taken on 2/4/2015 and 2/18/2015 for angelonia.
Picture retakes for Calibrachoa were done on 3/4/2015.
Raw Data
Insert raw data below or send separate file containing raw data.
See “protocol 14-008 GH #1, 2” spreadsheet.
p4
Ornamental Horticulture Program
Research Report Form
Researcher:
Dave Bodine, Tom Freiberger
Project Title: Crop Safety of New Insecticides and Miticides
Protocol #: 14-008
p5
Date: February 19, 2015
PRnumbers:29325, 31731, 31697, 31689, 31724,
31699, 31691, 31704, 31696, 31738,
Environmental conditions during the experiment:
Insert temperature, precipitation and/or irrigation, and relative humidity with a minimum of high, low and average daily
temperatures. Or send separate file with this information.
Include a statement about any significant weather or environmental events during the course of the experiment.
Greenhouse #1 and GH#2 had four overhead sodium lamps that provide additional lighting between 6 a.m. and 10 p.m.
Overhead heat was set to 66oF and floor heat was set to 62oF. The exhaust fans and louvers were set to 88oF.
Overhead Irrigation for Greenhouse #1
Date
11/25-11/28
11/29/2014-2/18/2015
Amount in inches
.125
.25
Overhead Irrigation for Greenhouse #2
Date
11/25-11/28
11/29-12/22
12/23/2014-1/20/2015
1/21/2015-2/4/2015
Amount in inches
.125
.25
.125
.25
Irrigation timers were set to either 15, 30 or 60 minutes depending on the amount needed. 15 minutes equals .125, 30
minutes equals .25 inches and 60 minutes equals .5 inches.