April 2015 Equity Webinar

FACULTY COLLABORATIVES
Webinar #2
April 29, 2015
Susan Albertine and Tia McNair
leap.aacu.org/toolkit/projects/faculty-project/participant-resources
Explaining our work
“Begin where people are,
not where you want them to be.”
Thanks to Dan McInerney, Utah State University
Where Are People?
Collaboration for Liberal Education for All Students
Faculty Collaboratives State Hubs
P2
P2
MSC
P2
P1
MSC
P1
P1
P1
MSC
P2
P2
HUBS
IUPUI
P1
USU
CSU
Legend
Phase 1
WI
DFW
Phase 2
MSC States
5
All Those Initiatives!
And Acronyms!
• LEAP ELOs HIPs
• DQP
•
•
•
•
Tuning
DQP/Tuning
GEMs
VALUE MSC
?????????????????
Project Architecture
Are our initiatives
separate and discrete?
Do we pull colleagues in six
different directions at once?
How do the initiatives fit
together?
Think of the initiatives as
answers to six closely related
questions.
What should post-secondary education
aim to achieve?
What can we do to improve general education?
HIPs
What qualities of learning and practice do educators
develop at different degree levels?
What should students’ majors aim to achieve –
overall and at different degree levels?
What is one way of determining if we are
achieving our goals?
How can we help students transfer?
We have many good frameworks and tools.
Yet how should FACULTY
COLLABORATIVES put all of these
frameworks and tools, all this information
together so that more people can use it?
Might EQUITY be the answer?
Ask the Audience
Can EQUITY serve to
unite all of our work?
Are institutions prepared to
serve today’s college student?
Created by designer Eleanor Lutz and journalist Linda Kennedy for the Gates Foundation
Read more: http://www.businessinsider.com/heres-what-america-would-look-like-as-100-college-students-2015-1#ixzz3Xaz5A0r6
AAC&U Centennial Publications
Critical Questions
• How are institutions preparing all students for
the kinds of challenges they will confront in
life, work and citizenship, both U.S. and
global?
• How can we help students to integrate and
apply their knowledge and skills to complex,
unscripted problems and new settings?
LEAP Challenge
20
Signature Work
Signature Work projects are related to a
question or problem that is important to
the student and important to society.
Signature Work allows students to connect
liberal and general learning with the world
beyond college.
“High-Impact Practices” that Help
Students Achieve Learning Outcomes








First-Year Seminars and Experiences
Common Intellectual Experiences
Learning Communities
Writing-Intensive Courses
Collaborative Assignments & Projects
Undergraduate Research
Diversity/Global Learning
Service Learning, Community-Based
Learning
 Internships
 Capstone Courses and Projects
Intentionality of HIPs
• Selection
• Design
• Access
HIPs
Learning
Outcomes
• Defined
• Evidence
• Assessment
• Data Disaggregated
• Integrated
Equity
Making Excellence Inclusive
“Through the vision and practice of inclusive
excellence, AAC&U calls for higher education to
address diversity, inclusion, and equity as critical to
the wellbeing of democratic culture.
Making excellence inclusive is thus an active process
through which colleges and universities achieve
excellence in learning, teaching, student development,
institutional functioning, and engagement in local and
global communities.”
Clarity in goals,
language, & measures
Students
Institutional Climate
Disaggregated Data
Equity-Minded
Paradigm Shift
Asset-Based
Diversity
Equity
Culturally Competent
& Inclusive Pedagogy
Inclusion
Quality learning
Growth
Assessments
Guided Learning
Pathways
America’s Unmet Promise
BY Keith Witham, Lindsey E. Malcom-Piqueux, Alicia C. Dowd, & Estela Mara Bensimon
For additional information on “equity-mindedness” see Estela Mara Bensimon, “The Underestimated Significance of
Practitioner Knowledge in the Scholarship of Student Success,” Review of Higher Education 30, no. 4 (2007): 441-69.
“Being equity-minded thus involves being
conscious of the ways that higher education—
through its practices, policies, expectations, and
unspoken rules—places responsibility for student
success on the very groups that have
experienced marginalization, rather than on
individuals and institutions whose responsibility it
is to remedy that marginalization.”
How do you translate a
commitment to equity and
inclusive excellence into campus
practice?
Ask the Audience
Does your campus have equity goals?
Yes or No
Critical Questions
•
What does it mean to be an equity-minded
practitioner? What does it mean to have an
equity-minded pedagogy?
•
How do we value and embed students’
“cultural wealth” and diversity in educational
designs and strategies?
For additional information on community cultural wealth, please see Yosso, Tara J. (2005). Whose culture has capital? A
critical race theory discussion of community cultural wealth. Race Ethnicity and Education, 8(1), 69-91.
Ask the Audience
Which statement contains “equity-minded” language?
Statement A
“The Pathways to Academic Success
Program is designed to help at-risk
students make good choices about
courses in order to make timely
progress toward earning a credential
or transferring.”
Statement B
“The Pathways to Academic Success
Program is designed to make
academic requirements and
sequences more clear and
accessible, and to remove barriers
that delay students’ progress,
particularly for underrepresented
students toward earning a credential
or transferring.”
Source: America's Unmet Promise: The Imperative for Equity in Higher Education (2015), by Keith Witham, Lindsey E. Malcom-Piquex, Alicia C.
Dowd, and Estela Mara Bensimon
Ask the Audience
Which statement contains “equity-minded” language?
Statement A
“A large public university develops a
new first-year experience program in
which student success courses and
academic advising are embedded in
student housing. A large portion of
the university students are
commuter students.”
Statement B
“A large public university develops a
first-year experience program
organized around cohorts of
students, including cohorts of
residential, commuter, and transfer
students. Academic and social
supports are built into students’
schedules depending on the times
when they are most likely to be on
campus.”
Source: America's Unmet Promise: The Imperative for Equity in Higher Education (2015), by Keith Witham, Lindsey E. Malcom-Piquex, Alicia C.
Dowd, and Estela Mara Bensimon
Critical Questions
•
How can we move the dialogue about student learning and success
from deficit-minded approaches to asset-based approaches?
•
How can we build capacity for educators to ask and respond to
questions about equity that can lead to campus change?
•
What spoken and unspoken assumptions about low-income
students, first-generation students, and students from racial and
ethnic minority groups underlie our efforts?
•
How do we motivate faculty and staff to address equity as intrinsic
to higher education’s mission?
Committing to Equity and Inclusive Excellence: A
Campus Guide for Self-Study Guide and Planning
(AAC&U, 2015)
• Knowing who you students are and will be
• Committing to frank, hard dialogues about the
climate for underserved students on your
campus, with the goal of effecting a paradigm
shift in language and actions
Committing to Equity and Inclusive Excellence: A
Campus Guide for Self-Study Guide and Planning
(AAC&U, 2015)
• Investing in culturally competent practices that
lead to the success of underserved students
• Setting and monitoring equity-minded goals—
and devoting aligned resources to achieve
them
Committing to Equity and Inclusive Excellence: A
Campus Guide for Self-Study Guide and Planning
(AAC&U, 2015)
• Developing and actively pursuing a clear vision
and goals for achieving high-quality learning
• Expecting and preparing all students to produce
culminating or Signature Work
• Providing support to help students develop
guided plans to achieve ELOs, prepare and
complete Signature Work, and connect college
with careers
Committing to Equity and Inclusive Excellence: A
Campus Guide for Self-Study Guide and Planning
(AAC&U, 2015)
• Identifying HIPs best suited to your students and
your institution’s quality framework
• Ensuring that ELOs are addressed and HIPs are
incorporated across all programs
• Making student achievement—including
underserved student achievement—visible and
valued
Questions / Comments?
Contact Information
• Susan Albertine
[email protected]
• Tia McNair
[email protected]