TREATMENT OF WINGED PECTORALIS MAJOR JOHN From We report Toronto the transfer SCAPULA ICETON, General of the sternal Hospital part BY TRANSFER W. R. HARRIS and the University of the pectoralis major of Toronto to the lower pole of the scapula in 15 patients with winged scapula. At follow-up after 1 to 16 years nine had a satisfactory result and were gainfully employed, though in four of these re-operation had been necessary. Two patients had fair results; the transplant functioned, but they had limited voluntary control. Four were failures: two had had paralysis of other shoulder discussed. of Winging paralysis shoulder the girdle scapula is disabling; during abduction muscles in addition caused by is usually caused which stretches serratus serratus anterior patients cannot stabilise the and forward flexion and have muscular fatigue pain. The cause long thoracic nerve or neuropathy Injury girdle, to the is either an injury to the of the brachial plexus. by depression of the the long thoracic nerve shoulder over the anterior. The indications objects heavy usually or pulling immunising Mulder In both recover, within Swann minor on a pyrexial follows recent and or repetitive episodes stiff illness by Marmor Bechtol and of the tendon Operative publication types of winging support is helpful (Johnson correct diagnosis is often delayed vative management, bodesis or muscle consider (Tsairis, the majority of patients and Kendall ; many cases to have had a rotator patients with a shoulder injury winging of the scapula. When winging has persisted Of the or Dyck influenza 1972). are first considered potential Neuropathy as should after surgical correction transfer is helpful. it because offers cuff injury. be examined prolonged We dynamic by either prefer control for nearly normal scapulothoracic various transfers which have been that moving the insertion All MD, FRCS(C), W. R. Harris, MD, EN. 1-234 Toronto Ontario M5G 2C4, Requests for © 1987 British 030l-620X/87/1006 108 reprints Orthopaedic FRCS(C), General Canada. details have (Gozna and should Editorial $2.00 Surgeon Elizabeth be sent W.R. Street, who major been Harris Society of Bone and Harris. Joint Surgery elongation a fascia described 1979). there of them downward been had depression in lata graft. an earlier in 1 3 men 1 to 16 years. also caused accidental resection a single injury causing of the shoulder; a brachiab division of the first plexus injury. in one One of the long thoracic rib for thoracic outlet had 2 and In 10 severe this had suffered nerve during syndrome. In two cases the onset followed repeated minor trauma, one had brachial plexus neuropathy and one had facioscapubo-humeral dystrophy. The clinical details are summarised in Table I. RESULTS scapumuscle and the part of Patients winging, Toronto, were and each ofthe assessed for for the range principal shoulder an electromyographic muscle was made. further operation, four were the presence of movement functions. assessment In 1 5 patients, nine failures. results The or absence and power In most of the four of in patients transplanted of whom were successful, patients with had had a two fair, successful results had no scapular winging, a normal range of scapulohumeral and scapubothoracic movement and normal power of abduction and forward flexion, but they had to Dr described with We report the results of this operation women, who have been followed from conser- Surgeon Orthopaedic Hospital, 200 are PATIENTS and J. Iceton, operation for movement. described we of the sternal (1963) of pectoralis lifting usually within six months after injury and two years after brachiab plexus neuritis (Foo and 1983). Early treatment is expectant and the use of a scapular 1955). The transfer levers. such in the arm injections when the the pectoralis major to the lower pole of the scapula most closely replaces the normal function of serratus anterior. This was first described by Tubby (1904) and modified prominence of the second rib (Gozna and Harris 1979), either a single severe incident such as a weight falling on the shoulder, for minor weakness of shoulder their former fatigue pain. studies normal action potentials of transplanted In adduction. All were free those who had EMG were obtained from the muscle. THE JOURNAL OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY TREATMENT OF WINGED SCAPULA BY PECTORALIS The two patients with fair results had no winging when their arms were adducted against resistance, but showed variable and incomplete control of winging Transfer satisfactory of the sternal other. In the scapulodesis be felt EMG While but the patients traces, dystrophy were in the completely unable scapular winging. Four patients had had a second operation initial failure. In one case the fascia lata extension transfer had avulsed from the scapula and in three Table Case number but I. Details two of remain 15 patients transfer of the Age (years) Occupation Cause 1 24 Welder Repetitive 2 55 Carpenter Fall 3 17 Student Crashed playing 4 29 Hairdresser (male) Brachial 5 33 Security guard latrogenic division long thoracic nerve 6 54 Labourer 7 9 lifting on shoulder boards ice hockey plexus Severe of the neuropathy traumatic of depression major Student Facio-scapulo-humeral 30 Miner Severe the Utility Arm jerked Fall from of shoulder suddenly downwards (Whitman at of 1932). 1951) it is a and pectoralis major transfer does not work and some of scapulodesis is indicated. All our patients have slight weakness of shoulder adduction. Although most were aware of it, none was troubled by it and all regarded it as a minor form for winged scapula Delay In diagnosis Onset to first operation Final result Comments 6 months 7 months Good working 17 months 20 months Failure Associated working 2 weeks 2 years Good Working as a prospector None 14 months Good Working as a hairdresser None 17 months Good Working as a security I week 1 1 months Fair Not at work. Transplant when arm adducted (see Failure Re-operation but remains a failure. Working as a crop insurance adjuster dystrophy depression and, theoretically the various forms that have been described shoulder 18 28 pectoralis is a anterior probably functions only as a tenodesis. When shoulder girdle muscles other than serratus anterior are paretic, after of the it had as failures. having fashion than major serratus of the pectoralis minor (Chaves also mimic the function of serratus anterior, muscle, with a short range of contraction weak been replaced by scar. Substitution of a new fascia lata extension was successful in two patients, both now fully employed, isolated transfer would to control for It acts in a dynamic is more physiological palsy. least, of the pectorabis portion treatment other two failures, the transplanted muscle could to contract by palpation and showed normal muscular 109 TRANSFER DISCUSSION during normal active movement. Ofthe four failures, two had had associated paralysis of other shoulder girdle muscles, due to brachial plexus injury in one and facioscapulo-humeral MAJOR as a welder brachial plexus injury, not guard functions text) 6 months 4 years Good Working as an importer 13 months 23 months Good Working as a technician None 4 years Failure Successful at first but winging recurred after loading bales of hay. After reoperation remains a failure, but works a farmer technician 10 20 Farmer 11 32 Labourer Fall while depressing 12 30 Car 13 42 Labourer mechanic motor cycle carrying shoulder wood, 2 days 2 years Fair Had primary neurolysis, and muscle transfer 1 year later. Poor voluntary control but is at work Shoulder depressed truck fell when 1 year 1 year Good After re-operation, as a mechanic Shoulder depressed belt in collision by seat 1 year 2.5 years Good Remains 14 21 Waitress Fall downstairs, ipsilateral elbow 15 28 Seamstress Repetitive a machine 69-B, No. 1, JANUARY 1987 is working litigation not settled dislocating movement operating 5 weeks 4 years Good Diagnosis made when plaster removed from dislocated elbow. Wound infection with failure but successful one year after re-operation. Working as cashier 18 months 2 years Failure Transplant completely unemployed VOL. unemployed, as functions controlled. but winging Remains is not 110 J. ICETON, inconvenience in exchange for their function. Asymmetry of the anterior improved axillary obvious in some patients and negligible two women there was no asymmetry, in others. was not very early recovery Electromyography used to evaluate because electrodes paralysis that the shoulder fold was physiotherapy In the nor any change in or appearance of the breast on the side of There were no significant cosmetic problems. the height operation. be W. R. HARRIS helpful. It cannot from the original postoperative evaluation contraction in the transplant can easily be detected by palpation. It was of some use in the assessment of failure since the demonstration of normal potentials in the transplant suggested that other factors were responsible for the poor result. The four cases which required re-operation were transplant failed after functionAt the first operation the fascia split into two tails each of which instructive. In one, the ing well for 10 months. lata extension had been was inserted At the re-operation insertions ; they extension. and was a separate through were two drill tails replaced hole had by a new Two years later the patient working as a mechanic. In the second winging recurred loading several the patient their fascia lata had case also the initial result three months later after hundred with at single bales of hay. The a good dystrophy, facio-scapulo-humeral from the beginning in the series, had had infection, and her transfer functioned well at winging slowly recurred. In each of these three re-operation the fascia lata extension had been transfer fourth, had not worked one of two women by a mass of scar of the transferred which muscle. from which scar and attached was passed through Only one operations had normal gave a good prevented This muscle result, although and forward weaker in all and the a wound first but cases at replaced free three and intensive It is interesting his transfer anterior, to note that directly must to have the provided of attachment. point The question which of exploration and possible repair of the long thoracic nerve arises in the treatment of traumatic winged scapula. The nerve was explored in one patient in our series and a 1 cm neuroma in continuity was found at the level of the second rib. Neurolysis was performed, but there was no recovery and a successful. pectoralis major transfer transfer major isolated serratus subsequently is a satisfactory anterior scapulodesis was palsy method and of can provide is preferred. 3. Failed transfers are probably desis if their scapular winging re- a best treated by scapulocontinues to be disabling. REFERENCES Chaves JP. anterior. Pectoralis J Bone Foo CL, Swann 20 cases. Gozna be felt to contract, and all We have no satisfactory flexion, an even these whose was dissected of and almost normal function. 2. It is an unsatisfactory procedure for patients who have paresis in muscles in addition to the serratus anterior. In The two fair results showed poor voluntary control of the transplant. Scapular winging disappeared when the arm was adducted against resistance but occurred in abduction too slack. attached serratus . was explanation for these failures and we now believe that failed transplant may be better treated by scapulodesis. active (1904) 1 Pectoralis to a new facia lata extension a new drill hole in the scapula. the transplant could EMG recordings. the transfer making Tubby contraction effective tendon major, that when it is short sutures do not hold well it to pull partly out of the fascia lata extension, treating result case considerable CONCLUSIONS was good but heavy work third seen the V-shaped of pectoralis speculate and allow in the scapula. frayed We have the length of the sternal part of paralysed it is technically difficult to be certain are in the serratus anterior, and in not help. did in variability insertion minor transplant for paralysis Joint Surg [Br] 1951 ;33-B :228-30. M. Isolated J Bone Joint paralysis of the serratus Surg [Br] 1983;65-B:552-6. ER, Harris WR. Traumatic Surg [Am] 1979;6l-A:1230-3. winging Johnson JTH, Kendall HO. Isolated muscle. J Bone Joint Surg [Am] of the P, Dyck PJ, neuropathy: Tubby AH. Mulder report scapula. paralysis of the 1955;37-A:567-74. A case the serratus illustrating magnus DW. Natural the by muscle Arch JOURNAL Neurol operative grafting. Whitman A. Congenital elevation of serratus magnus muscle: operation. THE history on 99 patients. the the anterior Marmor L, Bechtol CO. Paralysis of the serratus anterior shock relieved by transplantation of the pectoralis case report. J Bone Joint Surg [Am] l963;45-A:l56-60. Tsairis of treatment Br MedJ serratus : a report J Bone Joint serratus anterior due major to electric muscle :a of brachial plexus 1972;27:109-l7. of paralysis 1904;ii AND JOINT of :1159-60. scapula and paralysis JAMA 1932;99:1332-4. OF BONE of SURGERY of
© Copyright 2024