Great ideas, big data and little privacy? Bart Preneel iMinds and COSIC KU Leuven 2 3 NSA calls the iPhone users public 'zombies' who pay for their own surveillance 4 Snowden revelations • NSA: “Collect it all, know it all, exploit it all” • most capabilities could have been extrapolated from open sources • But still… • massive scale and impact • redundancy: at least 3 methods to get to Google’s data • many other countries collaborated (beyond five eyes): economy of scale • industry collaboration through bribery, security letters, 5 Snowden revelations (2) • Most spectacular: active defense • networks • Quantum insertion: answer before the legitimate website • FoxAcid: specific malware • devices • supply chain subversion • Translation in human terms: complete control of networks and systems, including bridging the air gaps • No longer deniable 6 Lessons learned • Never underestimate a motivated, well-funded and competent attacker • Pervasive surveillance requires pervasive collection and active attacks (also on innocent bystanders) • active attacks undermine integrity of and trust in computing infrastructure • Economics of scale play a central role: • it is not about the US or US/UK or even five eyes • other nations have or are developing similar capabilities • organized crime and terrorists working on this too 7 The state of cybersecurity • Governments are undermining ICT systems rather than improving cybersecurity (and part of industry is helping) • Problems at network level • • • • end-to-end deployment of encryption meta data: IP address, location, … network protocols such as BGP, DNS Problems at system level: • • • secure execution and update supply chain security 0-day market 8 IoT security risks • More pervasive and intrusive: building, car, body • • • • low cost larger attack surface harder to update Security • • • • bringing down the grid hacking cars and drones burglary hacking medical devices 9 OWASP IoT top 10 2014 https://www.owasp.org/index.php/OWASP_Internet_of_Things_Top_Ten_Project • • • • • • • • • • 1 Insecure Web Interface 2 Insufficient Authentication/Authorization 3 Insecure Network Services 4 Lack of Transport Encryption 5 Privacy Concerns 6 Insecure Cloud Interface 7 Insecure Mobile Interface 8 Insufficient Security Configurability 9 Insecure Software/Firmware 10 Poor Physical Security 10 IoT privacy nightmare? • • • What is privacy? What are the limitations of the current approach? What are the risks? HP IoT study: 90% of devices collected at least one piece of personal information via the device, the cloud or its mobile application 11 What is privacy? • Abstract and subjective concept, hard to define • Depends on cultural aspects, scientific discipline, stakeholder, context • Conflicts are inherent discretion transparency harmony social control 12 Legal approach • Data controller: trusted • Limited purpose: can be hard to define • Consent: how will this work in IoT? transparency discretionIrish privacy commissioner here harmony social control 13 Privacy problems • • • • • • Data breaches Profiling Discrimination Manipulation Prediction Mass surveillance 14 Architecture is politics [Mitch Kaipor’93] Need to rethink centralized architectures with massive storage of raw data (designed for advertising/search/cost) Avoid single point of trust that becomes single point of failure 15 Governance and Architectures: Back to principles • Data minimization through infrastructure • Minimum disclosure: avoid centralized massive amounts of data • “cryptomagic” • local computations with proof of security • centralized storage but encrypted under local key (can still do computations!) 16 Open Solutions Open source solutions with effective governance • who adds code • who does code reviews 17 Conclusions • • • • • IoT technologies bring major privacy and security risks • we cannot afford to continue the “deploy now and fix later” model Need to rethink everything • architectures: where is the data? • building blocks • deployment (including supply chain) • update mechanisms Need open solutions with open audit Support: legislation (economic incentives) and non-proliferation treaties Essential to maintain our European sovereignty and values 18 CONTACT DETAILS Bart Preneel, iMinds and COSIC KU Leuven ADDRESS: WEBSITE: EMAIL: TELEPHONE: Kasteelpark Arenberg 10 Bus 2452, 3000 Leuven homes.esat.kuleuven.be/~preneel/ [email protected] +32 16 321148 www.facebook.com/iminds @iminds 19 THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME
© Copyright 2024