Circulor
Office of 'rhe Principol Controller of Accounts (Fys)
l0-e,, S. K. Bose Rood, Ko/kofo-7)1 001
No. Poy/Tech-l/Ol (6ih CPC) /2A1
s
Dote: 16/03/2015
/03
To
Ail
G
Controllers
Subiect: Recovery oction to the Hon'bie Supreme Court of lndio common
Judgement eioted 09/12/14 in respect of Doto Entry Operotors in
Ordnonce & -Src.lnonce equipment Foctories.
Ref: oFB Nr - OFB No-340/O A_01 /09 /v A/ 1l 5 /HApp /A/Nt,
doted i7lA2/15
ln the motter oi r'riohe, F,,:,y sr:ole in re:;pect of Doto Entry Operotors of
Ordnonce Foctories Orqcjnisotion, o copy of Hon'ble Supreme Court of Indio common
Judgement doreel (lt9,r i2,/',!. rereivec vide oFB l\o-340/oA-ol /og/vA/I15
/HAPP/A/Nl, dot.erj 14/fi.,'1::., hes hr:an cirr:irlolerj to oll concerned Gr. Controller
vide rhis office even i.lr.'rty /')',eclr.l,/o i (6r" ci)c)/2015/01, doted 03/03/2015.
All the Br. AOs uricer your iui'irdiction nroy ;oieose be directed occordingly to refix the poy scole of [rriis ;i,ci'virnr:!1'r-rr,y i-r,11[1i;.r ?a'y Scole if oll reody gronted, initiote
necessory oction for rec;vr:,r'y'of e)(c€:ss 6rcryment cue to gi-ont of higher poy scole by
following due proce.iur-' . i, crfier issuirrg the shovr couse notice to the individuol for
recoYery of excess pcyn=, r.
Addl. C of e (Eys) nor se..ri
-s)'-of Accounts (Fys)
Assislr-.l,lt Co:'i:r.oller
C
, ic' in{.-r:'lcticn \\,,r.to ohcl'e, it is requested to
Cell
MO Locol
,*,-'ii.,uc! ihe CIFB lr:-tter in the net, pleose.(_.qr CIr.l-,*L)
The AO OFNi
, t:or irra,i'mction w.r.to obove, pleose.
Roigir-8
31
AO F (P) kor !'r';!
Luckno 2OA'' \r( i.ir: '
The
;
for informotion w.r.to obove, pleose.
a-q-,
Sr. A:counr( Cfficer (Fys)
tF
\y
lJr
L>/ )
/
YR?I RrGER
./.{
rqII
oA' qrgq Frqi4r i.B, qrlls qri
lo+,
ts-EGRA
qt<
r*r ltq
*Fcm
ri
ilft
nR ft,
- 7oo ool
.
,
zra
ArEliIT
)uqrA
Ct{
TELEPHOi{E 2at-St21-26 / 24C_5077-CO EXTN
: (o3a) z/rg-786s
tfi
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
litlNlSTRY OF DEFENCE
oRoNANCE FACTORY BOARD
FA)( (033) 21E-7e65
sr
..i AYUDHBHAVAN
1oA,jsl-lMeeo KHUDtR^ilt BosE RoAo
]i ,KOLKATA-Tooool
rar EFTFE dEr t qE !d hEfi
m
6n 3Dondlnca rhNld b€ .ddrc!.€d to the
SEdary and nd lo any omff by nrm€
Al
I
Dated
-
lT-02-201s
Sr.'General Manager / General Manager
.l
Sub
:
Recovery action subject to the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India common Judgment dated
09-12-2014 in respect of Data Entry Operators in Ordnance & Ordnance Equipment Factories.
Ref
:
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India common Judgment dated 09- l2 -ZOl4 arising out of SLp ( C
)
No' 28595/2010 ( S D Bhangale ),28596 of 2010 (S H Patil and SLp (C 31613 of 201 (Shri
)
)
V Ambi & Ors )
In the matter
of
Higher Pay scale in respect of DEOs of Ordnance Factory Organisation, various court
/ High courts for final iudgment of Hon,ble Supreme Court of
India. Hon''oie Supreme Court in the order dated Ol-n-zOtl has alloweithe appeal and held as follows
:
cases are pending before different Tribunals
"
We hold that Data
Entry Operators Grade -A are nor enfirledfor scale of pay of Rs. l3S0 2200
w'e'f' 01-01'1986 or thereafter merely on the basis of their qualiJi"oiion or
ine Tict that lhey have
foi
cotnple.led their period of requisite service. We
further how nit aiy decision renderei by any Tribunal or
an! High Court conlrary to our decision is wrong. Further in view of the reasons and
Jindings recortled
above while we hold that the respondenls are not entitled to the beneJir is ney
sought for Oe1ore ite Tribunal
o|:'lhe Hisl Coult,.all the impigned ordered passed by the CAT Binches and the
High Courts in favour o/
lhq respondents being illegal are sel side.,,
":,
;i
1
,
02.
Since the case has reached finality i.e. question of grant of Higher pay Scale to DEOs
in O.F.
been struck down by Hon'ble Supreme Court. By this verdict as stated above, many factories
-h-as
granted__Higher
Pay Scale to the DEOs w.e.f. O t -01-l 986 rvhich is not in order as well as Hon,bie Supreme
!1Ve
c$..t.The Higher Pay Scale already granted to these employees (DEos) has to be brought down to the
originalpay scale and excess payment made hitherto has to be recovered.
Organization
031
All the factories are therefore, directed to re-fix
the pay scale of DEOs and withdraw Higher pay Sc:ale
granted and initiate necessary action for recoverytf .*""., payment due
4lready
to grant of Higher pay Scale
if
by.following due procedlte i'.c,after issuing the Show Cause Notice for iecovery of excess p"y..-rt.
'-':
'/"
,
4:'-''
i
''
" /'
'
;'
'-)r
'iJz
-'$. '.r,-'r ',
t,,t'
,7
DirectOr/ NI
Ibr Director General ordnance Factories.
-2-
4,
;
K Bose Road
of X(FYs) ,10A S
action please'
For information necessary
action please'
For information necessary
t
!:
lr
.1t
ii
I
l.