Management and Conservation of Marine Biodiversity in Sudan Dirar H. Nasr ; Mohamed E. Hamza ; Moamar E. Ali; Ahmed E. Hamad Management and Conservation of Marine Biodiversity in Sudan Dirar H. Nasr;* Mohamed E. Hamza; Moamar E. Ali; Ahmed E. Hamad ** Abstract Several studies have been carried out in Sudan by national and international scientists with emphasis on the status of coral reefs and their biodiversity. Little work has been done with regard to mangroves and sea-grass beds compared with that donne with regard to coral reefs. These studies reflected the threats facing marine biodiversity including habitat destruction, environmental degradation from oil related, and pollution from land based activities. in this paper trends in conservation of marine biodiversity including past activities and recent initiatives were described. The role of the Regional Organization for the Conservation of the Environment of the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden (PERSGA) is highlighted with regard to legal aspects, capacity development, and promotion of on-the-ground projects concerning conservation of marine ecosystems and their biological diversity. Introduction The Red Sea itself is probably one of the most biologically diverse tropical seas in the world outside the IndoPacific centre of marine biodiversity in the Indo-malay region. The Sudanese Red Sea coast has a total length of approximately 750 km including inlets and bays. There are 7 ecosystems recorded from the Red Sea and Sudanese coast which include “Sabkhats”, Marshes and Wetlands, Sandy Shores, Rocky Shores, Mangroves, Coral Reefs and sea grasses; more than 200 species of corals recorded, of which about 6% are endemic; 170 species of echinoderms, of which 5.3% are endemic; about 500 species of benthic algae have been recorded and over 1,000 species of fish (Sheppard et al., 1992). General works on the hydrology and oceanography in Sudanese waters was reviewed by UNEP/N (1988) and Sheppard et al. (1992). The climate is arid with an average annual rainfall of 111 mm, falling mostly in the wet season of November to February. Sea * Faculty of Marine Scinces, Red Sea University. ** Faculty of Animal production, University of Sudan for Science and Technology Red Sea University Journal, Refereed scientific biannual Journal Vol.(2)Jun -2012 7 Management and Conservation of Marine Biodiversity in Sudan surface temperatures measured in the Port Sudan area range from 26.2°C to 30.5°C, with salinities from 38to 41‰ (Records of the Institute of Marine Research, Red Sea University). Both parameters tend to increase in semienclosed sheltered bays and coastal lagoons. Generally, winds are from a northerly direction, and near-shore surface currents follow the prevailing wind direction. It is well known that coral reefs contain the richest marine biodiversity among other ecosystems. In Sudan, they have attracted the attention of many scientists. Species from Sanganeb (Schroeder and Scheer, 1981), Wingate (Scheer and Pillai, 1983) and Suakin (El Mak, 1988), and the reefs in the vicinity of Port Sudan (Schroeder and Nasr, 1983) and the Towartit reef complex (Vine and Vine, 1980) have been listed and extensively described. Comparative ecological analysis of biota and habitats in littoral and shallow sublittoral waters has been carried out in Sudanese Red Sea with emphasis on Sanganeb Atoll (Krupp et al., 1993). Plankton fauna (Nasr, 1980; El Hag and Nasr, 1989), seaweeds (Dafalla and Karim, 1980), the biology of pearl oysters (Nasr, 1982, 1984), penaeid shrimps (Elhag, 1978; Branford, 1980, Ahmed, 2003), fishes (Abu Gideiri, 1984), molluscs (Mastaller, 1978), sea cucumber (Ibrahim, 2001) and seabirds (Elsheikh, 2007). Increasing threats to Sudan’s coral 8 Dirar H. Nasr ; Mohamed E. Hamza ; Moamar E. Ali; Ahmed E. Hamad reefs have been reviewed (UNEP/ IUCN, 1988, Schroeder et al. 1980, Nasr, 1985, Elhag, 1999), but recent analysis by PERSGA (2001) addresses current causes of concern in a greater depth. Efforts for the conservation of such diverse coral reefs and associated fauna and flora in Sudan have taken place since early seventies (Schroeder et al. 1980, Nasr, 1985). Recently, institutional and legal frameworks have been developed to protect the marine environment and their biodiversity through the activities of the PERSGA. Status of Marine Biodiversity in Sudan The most widely used definition of biodiversity considers three levels: genetics, species and ecosystem diversity (Norse et al., 1986). Conservation of the Biological Diversity in the sea has been neglected more than that on land, yet the sea is rich in genetic, species and ecosystem diversity (Norse, 1993). The biodiversity at the genetic level is the least visible and the least studied compared with the ecosystem and species levels. The coastal and marine environments of the Sudan consist of: an arid coastal zone, coastal wetlands (in some areas), mangroves, seagrasses, and coral reefs. These ecosystems are the basis of much of the Sudan’s coastal and marine biodiversity. They Red Sea University Journal, Refereed scientific biannual Journal Vol.(2)Jun -2012 Management and Conservation of Marine Biodiversity in Sudan are also vital to the livelihood of the coastal populations from fisheries and recreational point of view. They stabilize and protect the coastline; moreover, they are linked by the movement of water through them, and decline in the health of one will have impacts on the others. The aridity of the coastal zone and availability of water supplies concentrated human settlement at Port Sudan and Suakin and created a reliance on the marine environment as a source of food. Coral reefs: some scientists referred to these reefs, in the past, as being among the most diverse in the Red Sea (UNEP/IUCN, 1988). However, the reality is more complex due to the interplay of many physical and environmental factors (Vine & Vine, 1980). Others considered these reefs to be in moderate to good health, despite recent reports of extensive coverage of algae over a high proportion of the fringing reefs (Pilcher and Nasr, 2003). The Towartit reef complex, has been studied extensively by Vine and Vine (1980) who report poor hard coral growth and high algal covering on the fringing reef south of Port Sudan. Hard corals comprise significantly more of the substrate offshore in the Towartit complex (Head, 1980), and the high density of the offshore reefs of Suakin decreases as one proceeds towards the coastal fringing reef. Surveys by Nasr and Al-Sheikh Red Sea University Journal, Refereed scientific biannual Journal Dirar H. Nasr ; Mohamed E. Hamza ; Moamar E. Ali; Ahmed E. Hamad (2000) at Abu Hashish Jetty (Port Sudan) revealed that the percentage of livehard coral (HC) ranged from 23.5 % at 10 m depth and 50 % at 5 m, while dead coral (DC) ranged from 2.5 % at 10 m depth and 0 % at 5 m depth suggesting that the area was comparatively healthy. The Suakin Archipelago consists of a number of offshore islands rising from relatively deep water. They contain coral reefs with a diverse fauna. The Archipelago is a nesting site for marine turtles and some sea birds. Dungonab Bay and Mukawar Island (180 km north of Port Sudan) are home of coral reefs, whale sharks and the largest aggregations of manta rays in the Red Sea, and contain many important nesting beaches for turtles and sea birds (PERSGA/GEF. 2004). Dungonab Bay has also been known for years as an important area for the cultivation of the pearl oyster, Pinctada margaritifera. Mangroves: There are extensive mangrove stands in Sudan especially south of Port Sudan. Mangroves are an important ecosystem. Their extensive root systems stabilize sediments and protect the coastline; they provide shelter for various marine animals, birds and the juveniles of commercially important fish and crustaceans eg. Mullets and shrimps–thereby enhancing overall biodiversity. The dead leaves and branches of mangroves are a Vol.(2)Jun -2012 9 Management and Conservation of Marine Biodiversity in Sudan source of food within the mangrove ecosystem and also offshore, such as in shrimp communities. The low tidal range of the Red Sea naturally limits the expansion and width of mangrove stands in Sudan. It is evident from recent assessments (PERSGA/GEF, 2001; Wilkie, 1995) that mangroves are diminishing through anthropogenic influence. However, little work has been done with regard to mangroves and seagrass compared to coral reefs. The status of other associated flora and fauna were reviewed by UNEP/IUCN (1988) and PERSGA/GEF (2004). Living Marine Resource: The fisheries of the Sudanese Red Sea are of considerable socio-economic importance to Sudan in terms of national food security and income generation for rural communities. Fisheries resources are exploited by artisanal subsistence fishers and local commercial fisheries targeting invertebrates, demersal finfish and pelagic finfish. The shark resources are heavily fished in Sudan by fishers, working outside their normal territorial boundaries for the SouthEast Asia shark-fin market (PERSGA/ GEF. 2003a). Traditional fisheries for sea cucumber have declined in Sudan because of overexploitation for export markets. Seagrass beds: Seagrass roots stabilize sediments, and in conjunction with nearby mangroves, protect the coastline. 10 Dirar H. Nasr ; Mohamed E. Hamza ; Moamar E. Ali; Ahmed E. Hamad Water currents are reduced in the vicinity of seagrass beds leading to the deposition of fine sediments and the clarification of surrounding waters. Many marine animals rely upon seagrass beds for shelter and food, including water birds, fish and crustaceans, and the internationally important dugong and green turtles. Commercially, important fish and crustaceans use seagrass beds as nursery grounds. Nocturnally, active fish migrate at night from the nearby coral reefs to the seagrass beds to feed. Globally important species: The Sudanese waters support some internationally important species, notably marine cetaceans mammals represented by dolphins, dugong, sea turtles and seabirds. Resident and migratory bird Populations: Coastal wetlands, the shallow waters adjacent to reefs and islands, and the scattered islands provide ideal habitat for a large number of seabirds. Studies on seabirds for the whole Red Sea and Gulf of Aden region (RSGA) are few and carried out one to two decades ago (PERSGA/GEF 2003b).Studies recorded 17 true seabird species and 14 other water bird species. Many of those recorded in the RSGA Region are found in Sudanese coastal waters such as the White–eyed Gull (Larus leucophthalmus), Sooty Gull (Larus hemprichii), White-cheeked Tern (Sterna repressa), Swift Tern Red Sea University Journal, Refereed scientific biannual Journal Vol.(2)Jun -2012 Management and Conservation of Marine Biodiversity in Sudan (Sterna bergii), Brown Noddy (Anous stolidus), in addition to Sooty Falcon, Osprey, Bridled Tern and Crab Plover. ( Elsheikh,2007) Threats facing marine biodiversity The threats facing marine biodiversity include habitat destruction, over– exploitation of living marine resources, environmental degradation from petroleum development, significant risks from marine transportation, and pollution from industrial activities. Coral reefs, mangroves and seagrass beds are being damaged by a variety of coastal developments notably landfilling for urban expansion, and as a direct result of human activities. The major threat of marine turtle are from a variety of activities including eggs poaching, direct and indirect incidental catch through fishing operations, and marine pollution including persistent marine debris.The threats facing seabird populations include human disturbance, human exploitation, habitat destruction (especially from urban expansion) and pollution. In Sudan, extensive agricultural use of pesticides, insecticides and herbicides is known to occur along the coast of Sudan. Potential hazards include the Tokar Delta Agricultural Scheme and the country’s Locust Control Programme. The black rat, Rattus rattus, was observed preying on birds’ eggs and chicks, and attacking gulls (PERSGA, 2003). Red Sea University Journal, Refereed scientific biannual Journal Dirar H. Nasr ; Mohamed E. Hamza ; Moamar E. Ali; Ahmed E. Hamad There are large numbers of nesting Osprey (Pandion haliaetus) in the Mukawwar Island and Dungonab Bay MPA. Of particular note is the occurrence of occupied and undisturbed nests close to human settlements within the MPA (PERSGA/GEF 2004). However, detailed research is needed to investigate the effects of these threats. Yet, seabird must be given priority in conservation. Trends in the conservation of biodiversity Past activities Initiatives to aware the officials and public of the importance of coral reefs and their conservation in Sudan were initiated in early 1980 (Schroeder et al. 1980 and Nasr, 1985). Such initiatives were guided by the Sudan Marine Conservation Committee under the leadership of the former Institute of Oceanography and with the support of IUCN/ WWF and PERSGA following the signing of the Jeddah Convention (1982). These initiatives included public education, improvement of legal protection and comprehensive scientific baseline studies. Recent Initiatives At the regional level, PERSGA took the initiative to conserve key habitats and key species in the region, through five steps towards their protection. The first step was developing a set Vol.(2)Jun -2012 11 Management and Conservation of Marine Biodiversity in Sudan of Standard Survey Methods (SSM). The second step involved training regional specialists in these methods. The third step was conducted to determine the status of these habitats and species in each country. The fourth step was the development of Regional Action Plans (RAP) for the Conservation of these marine habitats and species. Finally, PERSGA supported the RSGA countries to develop National Action Plans (NAPs) as a fundamental step harmonizing the RAP to suit each particular country case. At the national level, therefore, conservation initiatives in the Sudanese Red Sea continued with the support of PERSGA. An ICZM plan for Sudan has been developed; National Action Plans for the conservation of mangroves, marine turtles and seabirds were prepared; on-the- ground projects are being funded by PERSGA and developed by the Sudan according to the needs of the country. A Regional Environmental Monitoring Programme has been prepared by PERSGA and implemented by its member countries. In Sudan, these projects included conservation of coral reefs, rehabilitation of mangroves (Faculty of Marine Science and Fisheries) and continuous monitoring of the quality of sea water (Institute of Marine Sciences). The National Action Plans for coral reef and mangrove ecosystems define a set of priority actions pertaining 12 Dirar H. Nasr ; Mohamed E. Hamza ; Moamar E. Ali; Ahmed E. Hamad to specific objectives aimed at ameliorating the predicted impacts on reefs, mangroves and associated coastal habitats; implementation of ICZM planning, enhancement of public education and awareness, management of MPA, ecologically sustainable reef fisheries and mangrove utilization, impacts of shipping and marine pollution, conducting research and monitoring. These priority actions resulted in the declaration of Dungonab Bay and Mukawar Island as a Marine Protected Area following comprehensive surveys and development of Site-Specific Management Plan and an Oil Spill Response Centre at Port Sudan. Legal aspects At the regional level, although Sudan has ratified a number of regional and international Conventions and Protocols which are relevant to the protection of the environment in general, the national legal framework for the protection of the environment in Sudan can be described as weak. In accordance with Article III of the Jeddah Convention (1982), PERSGA formulated two additional protocols: (a) Protocol concerned with the Conservation of biodiversity and the Establishment of Network of Protected Areas in the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden and (b) Protocol concerned with the Protection of the Marine Environment from Land-Based Activities in the Red Sea and Gulf of Red Sea University Journal, Refereed scientific biannual Journal Vol.(2)Jun -2012 Management and Conservation of Marine Biodiversity in Sudan Aden. The two Protocols were signed by Plenipotentiaries during 2005. Article 4 of the Biodiversity Protocol takes into consideration the following general obligations: protection, conservation and management of natural biological diversity with particular emphasis on threatened species; establishment of protected areas; adoption of strategies, plans and programmes for the conservation of biodiversity; adoption of appropriate measures for contingency plans for environmental emergencies; adoption of comprehensive Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and control land-based and sea-based sources of pollution that pose a significant impact on habitats and species. At the national level, several national legislative frameworks are in place that relate to coral reefs: the Sudanese Fishery Ordinances and Regulations of 1937 amended in 1975 prohibits overfishing, dumping of any harmful substances including oil into the sea and the collection of corals, shells and aquarium fish; the Environmental Health Act of 1975 prohibits dumping into the sea of any item that is harmful to humans or animals in addition to the Sudanese Maritime Law which has been approved in 2009. Dirar H. Nasr ; Mohamed E. Hamza ; Moamar E. Ali; Ahmed E. Hamad international levels. These would strengthen Sudan’s legal framework benefiting coral reefs and their biodiversity. At the same time, there is a need for a planned research and monitoring programme on coral reefs in addition to the enhancement of community participation and awareness. An integrated coastal management plan which takes into consideration shipping, coastal development, pollution and natural resources, has been prepared for Sudan through the assistance of PERSGA; if its implementation is effectively enforced, it should cater for most of the impacts on the biodiversity at ecosystem and species levels. Conclusion In spite of the approved legislation, several legislative decisions are needed at both national and Red Sea University Journal, Refereed scientific biannual Journal Vol.(2)Jun -2012 13 Management and Conservation of Marine Biodiversity in Sudan Dirar H. Nasr ; Mohamed E. Hamza ; Moamar E. Ali; Ahmed E. Hamad Bibliography Abu Gideiri, Y. B. (1984). Fishes of Sudan, Khartoum University Press, 166 pp. Ahmed, M. A. O. (2003). Some aspects of shrimp fishery in Sudanese Red Sea coast M. Sc., Thesis. Department of Zoology, Faculty of Science, University of Khartoum. Branford, J. F. (1980). Penaeid shrimps in the Tokar Delta region of the Red Sea. Proc. Sympos. Coastal and Marine Environment of the Red Sea, Gulf of Aden Tropical Western Indian Ocean. Khartoum, pp 246 - 273. Dafalla, A.G. and A. Karim, A. G. (1980). Zonation of seaweeds along a stretch on the Red Sea coast (Sudan). Proc. Sympos. Coastal and Marine Environment of the Red Sea, Gulf of Aden Tropical Western Indian Ocean. Khartoum, pp 419-452. Elhag, A. E. (1978). Ecological and some biological aspects of the Sudanese estuarine prawns (penaeidae). M. Sc., Thesis. Department of Zoology, Faculty of Science, University of Khartoum. El Hag AG. D. and Nasr D. H. (1989). Studies in planktonic populations in Port Sudan coastal area. Sudan J. Sci. IV. Elhag, A. D. (1999). Biodiversity assessment, threats and sustainability of marine ecosystems in Sudanese Red Sea coast. A report for the National Biodiversity Strategy and Action Plan. El Mak Anna, M. (1988). Zonation and community structure of the fringing reefs of Suakin (Sudanese Red Sea). M. Sc. Thesis, Department of Zoology, Faculty of Science, University of Khartoum. Elsheikh, Freeda H. (2007). The feeding biology and behaviour of the lesser creted tern Sterna bengalensis at Dungonab Bay, Sudan. M. Sc., Faculty of Marine Sciences and Fisheries, Red Sea University, Port Sudan. Ibrahim, Muna Y. (2001). Some studies on holothurian species at the Sudanese Red Sea coast. A Thesis submitted for the Degree of Master of Science at the University of Khartoum, Khartoum. Krupp F.; Türkay M.; El Hag A. D. and Nasr, D. (Editors). 1993. Comparative ecological analysis of biota and habitats in littoral and shallow sub-littoral waters of the Sudanese Red Sea, based on the study of marine fauna and flora. Report for the period of April 1991 to December 1993. Forschungsinstitut Senckenberg, Frankfurt and Faculty of Marine Science and Fisheries, Sudan. 89 pp. Mastaller, M. (1978). The marine molluscan assemblages of Port Sudan, Red Sea. Zoologische Mededelingen 53: 117-144. Nasr, D. H. (1980). Coastal plankton fauna of the Sudanese Red Sea. Proc. Symposium Coastal and Marine Environment of the Red Sea, Gulf of Aden 14 Red Sea University Journal, Refereed scientific biannual Journal Vol.(2)Jun -2012 Management and Conservation of Marine Biodiversity in Sudan Dirar H. Nasr ; Mohamed E. Hamza ; Moamar E. Ali; Ahmed E. Hamad and Tropical Western Indian Ocean. Khartoum. pp 561 - 581. Nasr, D. H. (1982). Observations on the mortality of the pearl oyster, Pinctada margaritifera, in Dongonab Bay, Red Sea. Aquaculture, 28: pp 271 - 281. Nasr, D. H. (1984). Feeding and growth of the pearl oyster, Pinctada margaritifera, in Dongonab Bay, Red Sea. Hydrobiologia, 100 241 - 246. Nasr, D. H. (1985). Coral reef conservation in Sudan. Proceedings of the Fifth International Coral Reef Congress, Tahiti 27 May - 1st June 1985, Vol. 4:243-246. Nasr, D. and Al-Sheikh, K. (2000). Assessment of coral reefs in the Sudanese Red Sea in the context of coral bleaching. In Proceedings of the International Workshop on the Extent and Impact of Coral Bleaching in the Arabian Region (H. Tatwany, ed.). National Commission for Wildlife Conservation and Development, Riyadh. Norse, E. A.; Kenneth L. R.; David S. W.; Bruce A. W.; William H. R.;David W. J.; and Martha L. S. (1986). Conserving Biological Diversity in our National Forsts. The Wilderness Society, Washington, D.C. (USA). Norse, E. A. (Edit.). (1993). Global Marine Biological Diversity, A strategy for Building Conservation into Decision Making, Centre for Marine Consrvation, Washington, D.C., USA. PERSGA/GEF. (2001). Strategic Action Programme for the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden, Country Reports. PERSGA, Jeddah and the World Bank, Washington. 205 PERSGA, 2003. Status of Breeding Seabird in the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden, PERSGA Technical Series No. 8. PERSGA/GEF. (2003a). Status of the Living Marine Resources in the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden and Their Management. PERSGA Technical Series No. 4. PERSGA, Jeddah. PERSGA/GEF (2003b). Regional action plan for the conservation of mangroves in the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden. PERSGA, Jeddah. PERSGA/GEF (2004). Survey of the proposed marine protected area at Dungonab Bay and Mukawwar Island, Sudan. Report for PERSGA. PERSGA, Jeddah. Pilcher, N. and Nasr, D. (2003). The Status of Coral Reefs in Sudan. In. Coral Reefs in the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden, Surveys 1990 to 2000; Summary and Recommendations. PERSGA Technical Series No. 7, PERSGA, Jeddah. Scheer, G. and Pillai, C.S.G. (1983). Report on the stony corals from the Red Sea. Zoologica, 130:1-198. Schroeder J. H.; Nasr, D. H. and Idris, F. H. (1980). Coral reef conservation in the Sudanese Red Sea. Proc. Sympos. Coastal and Marine Environment of the Red Sea, Gulf of Aden Tropical Western Indian Ocean. Khartoum, pp 163 - 178. Red Sea University Journal, Refereed scientific biannual Journal Vol.(2)Jun -2012 15 Management and Conservation of Marine Biodiversity in Sudan Dirar H. Nasr ; Mohamed E. Hamza ; Moamar E. Ali; Ahmed E. Hamad Schroeder, J. H. and Scheer, G. (1981). Corals of Sanganeb Reef, collected by J.H. Scroeder, identified by G.Scheer. Institute of Oceanography, Port Sudan. Typescript. 6 pp. Schroeder, J. H. and Nasr, D. H. (1981). The fringing reefs of Port Sudan, Sudan. 1. Morphology, Sedimentology, Zonation. Essener Geographische Arbeiten. 6:29-44. Sheppard, C.; Price, A. and Roberts, C. (1992). Marine Ecology of the Arabian Region: patterns and processes in extreme tropical environments. Academic Press, London. UNEP/IUCN (1988). Coral Reefs of the World. Vol. 2: Indian Ocean, Red Sea and Gulf. UNEP Regional Seas Directories and Bibliographies. IUCN, Gland, Switzerland and Cambridge, UK/UNEP, Nairobi, Kenya. Vine, P. J. and Vine, M. P. (1980). Ecology of the Sudanese coral reefs with particular reference to reef morphology and distribution of fishes. Proceedings of the Symposium on the Marine Environment of the Red Sea, Gulf of Aden, and Tropical Western Indian Ocean. Khartoum 1:87-140. Wilkei, M.K. (1995) Mangrove Conservation and Management in the Sudan. FAO Report. Ministry of Environment and Tourism, Khartoum& FAO, Rome. :مستلخص ودوليني عن حالة الشعاب،لقد مت إجراء دراسات عدة يف السودان من قبل علماء وطنيني ، غري أن ما مت القيام به من عمل فيما يتعلق بأشجار املانغروف.املرجانية وتنوعها البيولوجي وقد عكست هذه الدراسات.ومسطحات احلشائش البحرية قليل باملقارنة مع الشعاب املرجانية والتدهور البيئي من،التهديدات اليت تواجه التنوع البيولوجي البحري مبا يف ذلك تدمري املوائل يف هذا البحث قد مت وصف. والتلوث الناجم عن األنشطة الربية،جراء أنشطة متعلقة بالزيت االجتاهات السائدة يف جمال احملافظة على التنوع البيولوجي البحري مبا يف ذلك األنشطة السابقة ومت تسليط الضوء على دور اهليئة اإلقليمية للمحافظة على بيئة البحر األمحر.واملبادرات احلديثة وتشجيع تنفيذ مشاريع على أرض، وتنمية القدرات،وخليج عدن فيما يتعلق باجلوانب القانونية .الواقع فيما يتعلق باحملافظة على النظم االيكولوجية البحرية وتنوعها البيولوجي 16 Red Sea University Journal, Refereed scientific biannual Journal Vol.(2)Jun -2012
© Copyright 2024