2014 | City of Vancouver CORPORATE BUSINESS PLAN An overview of the City of Vancouver’s citizen and customer service priorities and delivery strategies. From the City Manager This Corporate Business Plan reflects the City of Vancouver’s ongoing Through the City’s 2013 employee engagement survey, staff expressed commitment to provide high-quality municipal programs and services a desire to clearly understand the City’s overall strategic direction and at the best possible value for the City’s taxpayers and ratepayers. This key priorities, so they can be better informed about how their daily work Plan encompasses all City departments, and includes the Vancouver fits into this larger picture. Every member of the City’s staff can find Park Board, the Vancouver Public Library and the Vancouver Police their place in this Plan – some of us are directly involved in the Plan’s Department. It is an important strategic tool developed by the City’s short-term priority initiatives, and others are contributing to one or more Corporate Management Team, designed to help focus and align our of the Plan’s long-term strategic goals through our work on specific work in order to achieve City Council’s priorities, continuously improve projects and/or day-to-day operations. While this Plan is by no means a service delivery, and ensure that our regulatory obligations are met. comprehensive list of all the City’s initiatives and priorities, it highlights those initiatives that the senior management team believes are critical to Through the work accomplished over the past several years, the City making progress toward our long-term strategic goals. has several important long-term directional plans in place, including the Economic Action Strategy, the Housing and Homelessness Strategy, I encourage all staff members to review this Plan, and to understand how the Greenest City Action Plan, Transportation 2040 and the Corporate each one of us can contribute toward its success, as we continue to strive Digital Strategy. The focus of this current Plan is to implement the to make Vancouver a great city of communities that cares about our highest-priority actions and initiatives from these strategies. people, our environment and our opportunities to live, work and prosper. Penny Ballem City Manager 5 Table Of Contents Purpose of The Corporate Plan 2 Progress on Previous Plan 3 The Corporate Plan Foundation 4 Overview of the Plan’s Long-Term Strategic Goals 6 Goal No. 1: The City Provides Excellent Service 8 Goal No. 2: The City is Financially Healthy and Administratively Effective 10 Goal No. 3: The City Leads the Way on Green Issues 12 Goal No. 4: The City Inspires Excellence in the Workplace and in its Employees 14 Goal No. 5: The City Optimizes Strategic Partnerships and Collaborations 16 Goal No. 6: Vancouver is a Sustainable, Affordable, Liveable and Inclusive City 18 Goal No. 7: Vancouver’s Business Climate is Dynamic and Robust 20 Goal No. 8: Vancouver is a Safe City in Which People Feel Secure 22 Goal No. 9: Vancouver Offers Extraordinary Civic Amenities 24 Goal No. 10: Vancouver’s Assets and Infrastructure Are Well-Managed and Resilient 26 APPENDICES Appendix 1: City of Vancouver Value-For-Money Planning Process 28 Appendix 2: City of Vancouver Organization Structure 29 Appendix 3: 2012-2021 Corporate Plan Key Achievements 30 Appendix 4: Vancouver Services Review Initiatives 43 Appendix 5: City of Vancouver Long-Term Plans Appendix 6: City of Vancouver 2014 Corporate Business Plan Overview 51 54 1 Introduction PURPOSE OF THE CORPORATE PLAN The City of Vancouver’s Corporate Business Plan lays out the •benefit from regular Corporate Management Team focus. organization’s highest priorities, to be initiated and/or completed This Corporate Plan is one piece of the City’s value-for-money in 2014. This Plan is one of the key tools used by the City’s senior approach to planning, a cycle that starts with public priorities and executive team to ensure Council priorities are delivered, ongoing the City’s legal requirements driving resource allocation decisions, work gets done, and regulatory obligations are met. and includes ongoing financial and service delivery performance The Plan’s ten long-term goals provide strategic framework that is used to align all of the City’s programs and projects. In order to keep the Plan flexible and relevant, the initiatives associated with each long-term goal are refreshed annually. Those initiatives selected for inclusion in the Corporate Plan are seen by the Corporate Management Team as critical to moving forward toward one or more of the Plan’s long-term strategic goals. All initiatives included in this Plan must be started, but not necessarily completed in 2014, and as well, must: •be a critical enabler of one or more Council priorities, •be a discrete deliverable, e.g., a strategy or plan, or a new, amended or expanded service, •be a highly complex and/or large initiative, with significant cross-departmental responsibilities and/or impact, •be high-risk, associated either with undertaking or with not undertaking the initiative, and/or 2 tracking and modification as appropriate (Appendix 1). The Corporate Plan is an important part of this holistic approach to resource allocation, designed to ensure that over time, the public funds in the trust of Vancouver City Council are allocated to top public priorities, invested effectively and spent efficiently. PROGRESS ON PREVIOUS PLAN Significant progress has been made on the last Corporate Plan, published in January 2012. Some highlights: •A suite of long-term directional strategy documents are in place, providing coordinated roadmaps for service planning and delivery, notably, the Corporate Digital Strategy, the Economic Action Strategy, the Housing and Homelessness Strategy, Transportation 2040, and the Climate Change Adaptation Strategy. •The City has hired the first-ever Chief Risk Officer, Chief Digital Officer and Chief Housing Officer, reflecting a concentrated focus on these service areas. •City-wide implementation of weekly organics solid waste collection from single-family residential properties was successfully launched. •A modernized, user-centric public website was designed and deployed. •A Green Operations Strategy has led to improvements in GHG emissions associated with City operations, as well as diversion of almost 70% of waste generated by City operations, up from 15% prior to this program implementation. •The City’s first-ever corporate performance development program was launched, with over 85% of City management staff •Over 280 new interim housing units, 160 winter response shelter beds, and 250 supportive housing beds were created. •A rental standards database was created to help renters understand the condition of rental buildings, and turnaround time to address bylaw infractions by owners of rental buildings has been reduced from 250 days to 125 days. •The Vancouver building code was updated to align with the City’s Greenest City Action Plan and other key objectives. •An updated earthquake preparedness strategy has been put in place. •A more detailed exploration of achievements on the previous having in place a performance plan aligned to the City’s long- Corporate Plan is shown in Appendix 3, and a full list of long-term term strategic goals. directional plans in Appendix 5. 3 I. City of Vancouver’s Mission The City’s mission is to create a great city of communities that cares about our people, our environment and our opportunities to live, work and prosper. II. Corporate Values The City’s corporate values describe the way staff collectively conduct themselves in the workplace. Responsiveness Corporate plan foundation Excellence Fairness Integrity Leadership Learning 4 We are responsive to the needs of our citizens and our colleagues. We strive for the best results. We approach our work with unbiased judgement and sensitivity. We are open and honest, and honour our commitments. We aspire to set examples that others will choose to follow. We are a learning workplace that grows through our experiences. III. Business Planning Principles IV. Culture Goals The City’s business planning principles describe how staff translates The City’s culture goals direct how staff work together to achieve the organization’s corporate values into behaviours; they are the our goals and get our work done. lens through which staff plan, make decisions and take action. We align our decision-making and We are committed to transparent decisionAccountability Fiscal responsibility Long-term perspective Economic perspective making, engaging our stakeholders, and Think strategically behaviours with our long-term goals, encourage more innovative thinking and measuring and reporting our performance to enable measured risks. the public. We know how our individual role We serve as responsible stewards of the public’s money, ensuring the best value-for- influences the City’s long-term goals, Be accountable behaviour and good judgment, and take money for the City’s taxpayers and ratepayers. ownership for our work. We integrate financial, social, environmental and cultural sustainability considerations into our decisions and actions. are outcome-focused, exercise ethical We embrace a one-team mindset, build Act as a team relationships and access talent across the organization and celebrate together. We take into account the impacts on Vancouver’s businesses and economy when making decisions and taking actions. We consider the impacts on and implications Corporate for the organization as a whole when we perspective make decisions and take actions as individual departments and agencies. Innovation and improvement We cultivate a progressive and creative approach to our work, incorporating continuous improvements into what we do and how we do it. 5 people Cultivate and sustain vibrant, creative, safe and caring communities for the wide diversity of individuals and families who live in, work in and visit Vancouver. + prosperity Overview of the plan’s long term strategic goals Provide and enhance the services, infrastructure and conditions that sustain a healthy, diverse and resilient local economy. + environment Protect and enhance Vancouver’s climate, ecology, natural resources and connections to the city’s remarkable natural setting for future generations. 6 6. VANCOUVER IS A SUSTAINABLE, AFFORDABLE, LIVEABLE AND INCLUSIVE CITY: The City strives to make Vancouver a sustainable, affordable, inclusive and liveable city with a strong sense of place, through planning that ensures land use, transportation, energy, public realm, community amenities, social services, and food delivery systems are well integrated into our diverse communities and across the city. 2. THE CITY IS FINANCIALLY HEALTHY AND ADMINISTRATIVELY EFFECTIVE: The City sustains longterm fiscal health and administrative effectiveness through responsible financial stewardship and robust internal administrative structures and processes. 7. VANCOUVER’S BUSINESS CLIMATE IS DYNAMIC AND ROBUST: The City fosters the relationships and provides the services and regulatory environment that support a flourishing local economy, and ensures that the City’s land use planning reflects the diverse needs of industry and businesses of all sizes over the long-term. 3. THE CITY LEADS THE WAY ON GREEN ISSUES: The City develops and maintains the internal corporate systems, policies, practices and asset-management plans that emphasize reducing carbon dependency, enhancing energy resilience, conserving energy and resources, reducing waste, creating a green corporate culture and protecting and enhancing the health of the ecosystem. 4. THE CITY INSPIRES EXCELLENCE IN THE WORKPLACE AND IN ITS EMPLOYEES: The City develops and sustains a dynamic, healthy and safe workplace environment that consistently attracts and retains top-quality people and enables them to perform at their best. 5. THE CITY OPTIMIZES STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIPS AND COLLABORATIONS: The City cultivates strong intergovernmental relationships and seeks opportunities to leverage benefits from strategic partnerships and collaborations. CITY-BUILDING GOALS GOVERNANCE GOALS 1. THE CITY PROVIDES EXCELLENT SERVICE: The City integrates a service focus into all dealings with citizens and customers, ensures they are appropriately informed and included in municipal decision-making, and maintains the corporate knowledge, data and information in a robust and accessible network of systems, to ensure the right information gets to the right people to inform decision-making. 8. VANCOUVER IS A SAFE CITY IN WHICH PEOPLE FEEL SECURE: The City provides the high-quality and effective police, fire, emergency preparedness and regulatory services that make Vancouver safe and enjoyable for residents, businesses and visitors. 9. VANCOUVER OFFERS EXTRAORDINARY CIVIC AMENITIES: The City provides high-quality recreational, social, cultural and lifelong learning amenities that provide everyone in the city the opportunity to develop and enjoy themselves, and help attract the talent needed in our city to maintain a strong economy. 10. VANCOUVER’S ASSETS AND INFRASTRUCTURE ARE WELL-MANAGED AND RESILIENT: The City plans for, develops and sustains the low carbon, energy resilient, environmentally sound, cost-effective, reliable and safe public works and infrastructure that play an essential role in making Vancouver a healthy, safe and prosperous city. 7 GOAL 1 THE CITY PROVIDES EXCELLENT SERVICE LONG-TERM STRATEGIC GOAL The City integrates a service focus into all dealings with citizens and customers, ensures they are appropriately informed and included in municipal decision-making, and maintains the corporate knowledge, data and information in a robust and accessible network of systems, to ensure the right information gets to the right people to inform decision-making. MEASURED BY • Percentage of 3-1-1 calls answered in 30 seconds or less • Percentage of 3-1-1 calls that meet quality target • Percentage of 3-1-1 Engineering asset service requests closed on time • Major Engineering Services Interruptions Index 8 2014 SHORT-TERM PRIORITIES 1A. Advance City’s Digital Citizen and Customer Services 1B. Permits and Licences Transformation Project 1C. Improve Public Engagement and Outreach Implement the City of Vancouver Corporate Digital Strategy top priorities, with a focus on (a) developing a standard and user-friendly customerfacing interface that integrates the City’s suite of digital services and online transaction processing, (b) enhancing mobile accessibility to City digital services, (c) advancing availability of the City’s open data, and (d) optimizing digital governance. Substantially improve the systems, processes and customer service associated with the issue and enforcement of municipal permits and licences, bringing the business processes in line with best practices, including the replacement of up to forty existing systems with a single, state-of-the-art integrated system. Implement the Vancouver Mayor’s Engaged City Task Force priorities, with a focus on (a) operationalizing the City’s social media strategy, (b) refreshing the City’s Development Services’ consultation and communications approach, including new notification design, new web pages, new methods of gathering input online, standardized reporting tools for consultation results, and guidelines for developers, (c) building membership and the overall effectiveness of Talk Vancouver, the City’s online consultation platform, and (d) establishing and operationalizing standards for internal and public reporting/ information-sharing concerning public consultation findings. GM, Community Services Director, Corporate Communications EXECUTIVE SPONSORS GM, Human Resource Services Chief Digital Officer GM, Planning and Development Services Chief Digital Officer 9 GOAL 2 THE CITY IS FINANCIALLY HEALTHY AND ADMINISTRATIVELY EFFECTIVE LONG-TERM STRATEGIC GOAL The City sustains long-term fiscal health and administrative effectiveness through responsible financial stewardship and robust internal administrative structures and processes. MEASURED BY • City of Vancouver credit rating • Current quarter net operating surplus/deficit, % • Projected annual net operating surplus/deficit, $ • Cost of government per capita 10 2014 SHORT-TERM PRIORITIES 2A. Development-Related Benefits Plan Improve the alignment of development-related benefits with corporate priorities and processes by (a) using relevant metrics to optimize allocation of developmentrelated benefits, (b) evaluating and planning for the long-term financial implications of new development-related benefits, (c) updating and rationalizing existing development cost levy bylaws, and (d) exploring new tools/approaches to achieve and manage developmentrelated benefits. 2B. Enterprise Risk Management and Business Continuity Planning Develop and implement an enterprise risk management framework, organizational structure, that assists Council and staff in strategically assessing and addressing the various risks facing the City over time, including a business continuity planning function. 2C. Business Intelligence Program 2D. Warehousing and Inventory Optimization Develop and implement a coordinated strategy for enhancing internal decision support and analytic capabilities, that considers metric development, business intelligence tools, internal skills/ capacities, and existing software system capabilities; deliverables to focus on public works planning, land development planning, human resources and financial information/data. Enhance warehouse and inventory management, streamlining and standardizing operations across the City’s warehouses, and optimizing site layouts and equipment to provide a single view of the City’s inventory operations and ensure the right supplies are available and delivered as needed in the most sustainable and cost-efficient way. GM, Financial Services Group GM, Financial Services Group EXECUTIVE SPONSORS GM, Financial Services Group GM, Financial Services Group GM, Planning and Development Services 11 GOAL 3 THE CITY LEADS THE WAY ON GREEN ISSUES LONG-TERM STRATEGIC GOAL The City develops and maintains the internal corporate systems, policies, practices and assetmanagement plans that emphasize reducing carbon dependency, enhancing energy resilience, conserving energy and resources, reducing waste, creating a green corporate culture and protecting and enhancing the health of the ecosystem. MEASURED BY • Tonnes of GHG emissions from City facilities and operations • Share of waste diverted from City facilities and operations 12 2014 SHORT-TERM PRIORITIES 3A. City Fleet Optimization 3B. Climate Change Adaptation Implement the City’s Green Fleet Plan, with a focus on developing and initiating implementation of a plan to leverage technology such as GPS to optimize City vehicle fleet in terms of cost, customer service and GHG efficiencies, with a target of reducing size of overall vehicle fleet by 20%. Implement the top priorities of the City’s Climate Change Adaptation Strategy, including (a) completing a coastal flood risk assessment, (b) updating regulated flood construction levels, (c) developing a back-up power strategy, (d) developing an extreme heat response plan, and (e) developing an integrated storm water management plan. 3C. Update Solid Waste Strategies and Services to Adapt to Changing Landscape Update the City’s solid waste strategies and operations to respond to the changing regulatory landscape and to operational requirements, with a focus on (a) developing a long-term strategy for the Vancouver Landfill that includes the City’s landfill gas collection targets, (b) developing a strategy to respond to Metro Vancouver’s waste-to-energy plans, (c) aligning the City’s recycling collection/disposal operations with changes arising from new “extended producer responsibility” legislation, (d) developing an action plan to respond to imminent/potential legislative changes such as the construction demolition ban, organics waste ban, and zero waste legislation, and (e) expand the City’s compostables collection and disposal program to include multiunit residential buildings. 3D. Urban Forest Strategy Develop and implement an urban forest strategy and management plan. EXECUTIVE SPONSORS GM, Engineering Services Deputy City Manager Deputy City Manager GM, Engineering Services GM, Engineering Services GM, Park Board Deputy City Manager 13 GOAL 4 THE CITY INSPIRES EXCELLENCE IN THE WORKPLACE AND IN ITS EMPLOYEES LONG-TERM STRATEGIC GOAL The City develops and sustains a dynamic, healthy and safe workplace environment that consistently attracts and retains top-quality people and enables them to perform at their best. MEASURED BY • Employee absenteeism rate • Employee workplace injury rate 14 2014 SHORT-TERM PRIORITIES 4A. Employee Engagement Action Plan and Internal Communications Implement the top priority actions arising out of the 2013 employee engagement survey aimed at improving employee engagement, including development and implementation of an internal communications strategy. 4B. Recruitment Strategy Develop and implement an updated recruitment strategy to support City management in attracting the best talent to work at the City, including specific strategies around how to best leverage technology and social media for these purposes. EXECUTIVE SPONSORS GM, Human Resource Services Director, Corporate Communications GM, Human Resource Services 15 GOAL 5 THE CITY OPTIMIZES STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIPS AND COLLABORATIONS LONG-TERM STRATEGIC GOAL The City cultivates strong intergovernmental relationships and seeks opportunities to leverage benefits from strategic partnerships and collaborations. MEASURED BY • Share of total capital funding provided by external partners • Share of total operating funding provided by external partners 16 2014 SHORT-TERM PRIORITIES 5C. Healthy City Strategy Partnership with Vancouver Coastal Health 5D. Municipal Access to Fraser River Shoreline and Other Provincial Land In collaboration with Vancouver Coastal Health, the Vancouver Police Department, and a number of other key stakeholders, develop an long-term integrated strategy that focuses on advancing the overall health of Vancouver’s citizens, communities and local environment, focusing on mental health issues and sex trade workers, and aligned to key strategies such as the Vancouver Police Department 2012-2016 Strategic Plan, the City’s Greenest City Action Plan, the Vancouver Economic Action Strategy, the Housing and Homelessness Strategy and Transportation 2040. Engage the BC provincial government to secure long-term recreational and other municipalpurpose access to the north shore of the Fraser River as well as other key locations. GM, Financial Services Group GM, Community Services Director, Legal Services GM, Engineering Services GM, Park Board GM, Park Board Chief Librarian Deputy City Manager 5A. First Nations Collaboration Initiative 5B. Regional Funding Allocation Decisions Create an internal organizational structure for enhancing collaboration among the City and local First Nations leadership both within the local bands and within the urban aboriginal communities, by tracking and ensuring alignment among relevant initiatives being led by disparate City departments that include External Relations and Protocol Office, City Clerk’s Department, Engineering Services, Community Services, Vancouver Police Department, and Park Board. Improve the City’s ability to influence key regional funding allocations in order to ensure fair and equitable outcomes, including the Broadway rapid transit project and upcoming Metro Vancouver liquid waste and solid waste capital investments. EXECUTIVE SPONSORS City Clerk Chief Constable 17 GOAL 6 VANCOUVER IS A SUSTAINABLE, AFFORDABLE, LIVEABLE AND INCLUSIVE CITY LONG-TERM STRATEGIC GOAL The City strives to make Vancouver a sustainable, affordable, inclusive and liveable city with a strong sense of place, through planning that ensures land use, transportation, energy, public realm, community amenities, social services, and food delivery systems are well integrated into our diverse communities and across the city. MEASURED BY • Tonnes of Vancouver residential garbage collected • Number of City of Vancouver housing units committed and completed/open 2014 SHORT-TERM PRIORITIES 6A. Refine Policies and Structures to Advance Housing Availability and Affordability Using the City’s Housing and Homelessness Strategy as a guiding framework, develop a set of clearly articulated deliverables associated with meeting the City’s housing, affordability and homelessness objectives, to include (a) evaluating options for establishing a City of Vancouver housing development company that acquires and develops new homes, (b) exploring how community amenity contributions can be leveraged to create more family-oriented housing, (c) working to improve the capacity of the nonprofit and co-op housing sectors to enable them to help meet the City’s housing availability and affordability objectives, and (d) regularly reporting to Council on progress toward meeting the City’s housing targets. EXECUTIVE SPONSORS Chief Housing Officer GM, Financial Services Group GM, Community Services 18 6B. Support Shift to Transit, Cycling and Pedestrian Transportation Support the goals articulated in the City’s Transportation 2040 Plan, by focusing on (a) by working with Translink to support/optimize Broadway Corridor rapid transit planning, (b) implementing a public bike share system, and (c) developing a comprehensive parking strategy for Vancouver. 6C. GHG Reduction Plan for New and Existing Buildings Develop and implement an action plan for achieving the Greenest City Action Plan goals of (a) reducing energy use and GHG emissions from existing buildings citywide by 20% over 2007 levels, and (b) requiring all buildings constructed from 2020 onward to be carbon neutral in operations – articulating the City’s tactics to achieve these goals, as well as associated costs to the City and to building owners/occupiers. GM, Engineering Services Deputy City Manager GM, Planning and Development Services GM, Community Services 6D. Community Planning Ensure future growth meets the needs of Vancouver communities and contributes to sustainable, affordable, livable and inclusive neighbourhoods, by (a) undertaking GrandviewWoodland, Northeast False Creek, Eastern Core, South Shore of False Creek and Cambie Corridor community plans, and (b) developing an enhanced approach to the conservation of heritage properties. GM, Planning and Development Services 6E. Downtown and Cambie Corridor District Energy Working with the appropriate private industry and public sector partners, enable the delivery of (a) the Cambie Corridor district energy system, (b) the downtown Vancouver district energy system, and (c) the BC Children and Women’s Hospital district energy system. Deputy City Manager GM, Engineering Services 19 GOAL 7 VANCOUVER’S BUSINESS CLIMATE IS DYNAMIC AND ROBUST LONG-TERM STRATEGIC GOAL The City fosters the relationships and provides the services and regulatory environment that support a flourishing local economy, and ensures that the City’s land use planning reflects the diverse needs of industry and businesses of all sizes over the long-term. MEASURED BY • Total floor area from approved building permits 20 2014 SHORT-TERM PRIORITIES 7A. Vancouver Innovation Hub 7B. Supporting and Enabling the New Economy 7C. Local Entrepreneur Proof of Concept Program Update key City regulations, policies and infrastructure to help the creative, digital and green economies thrive locally, with a focus on and (a) supporting small business, (b) modernizing the City’s Sign Bylaw, (c) creating more job space in Vancouver’s industrial-use zones, (d) establishing a “digital district” in Vancouver that concentrates the presence digital businesses in order to enhance visibility, synergies and collaboration, (e) establishing a “green enterprise zone” in the False Creek Flats neighbourhood, designed to promote research and development related to environmental sustainability, to attract “green” research, service and manufacturing jobs to Vancouver, and to advance energy efficient construction, (f) developing and implementing a public wireless internet access strategy, including the Granville Street wifi pilot project. Launch a program that supports local innovation in the rapidly-emerging clean technology and digital industries, by leveraging the City’s assets, infrastructure, and procurement and sustainability policies, in order to assist local entrepreneurs in proof-ofconcept initiatives, pilot projects and/or showcasing new products and services. GM, Real Estate and Facilities Management GM, Planning and Development Services GM, Financial Services Group CEO, Vancouver Economic Commission CEO, Vancouver Economic Commission CEO, Vancouver Economic Commission Facilitate the establishment of an early-stage technology and social enterprise incubator/ accelerator in downtown Vancouver that is inclusive and collaborative, and that complements the existing local array of business incubators and accelerators. 7D. Green Jobs Action Plan Develop and implement an action plan to address the City’s Greenest City Action Plan and Economic Action Strategy target of doubling the number of green jobs over 2010 levels by 2020. EXECUTIVE SPONSORS CEO, Vancouver Economic Commission 21 GOAL 8 VANCOUVER IS A SAFE CITY IN WHICH PEOPLE FEEL SECURE 2014 SHORT-TERM PRIORITIES 8A. Earthquake Preparedness Advance the City’s ability to respond 8B. Marine and Shoreline Safety and Environmental Protection to an earthquake as articulated in Monitor, evaluate and respond the City’s Earthquake Preparedness to the proposed Kinder-Morgan Plan, with a focus on (a) seismically oil pipeline expansion in order reinforcing vulnerable components of to ensure that the appropriate the City’s water distribution system risk mitigation and emergency and enhancing post-earthquake response measures are in place access to firefighting water supply, if the project advances, and, in (b) refining ability to predict collaboration with Port Metro consequences by updating the City’s Vancouver and inner harbour earthquake hazards map, (c) updating municipalities, establish a emergency communications plan and renewed marine fire response public education program, targeting program to replace the existing • Number of fires with damage per 1,000 population residents as well as small and medium- Fireboat Consortium. • Average dollar loss per fire options to maintain post-earthquake LONG-TERM STRATEGIC GOAL The City provides the high-quality and effective police, fire, emergency preparedness and regulatory services that make Vancouver safe and enjoyable for residents, businesses and visitors. MEASURED BY • Response time to highest priority fire emergency calls • Number of medical incidents per 1,000 population sized businesses, (d) exploring transportation access to the downtown peninsula, and (e) developing community disaster support hubs to • Average response time of VPD to highest priority emergency calls facilitate community-based response. • Total number of property crimes reported per 1,000 population EXECUTIVE SPONSORS • Total number of violent crimes reported per 1,000 population Deputy City Manager Deputy City Manager Fire Chief Director, Legal Services 22 8C. Community-Focused Policing Initiatives 8D. Crime Reduction Initiatives Implement the initiatives 8E. Vehicle, Cyclist and Pedestrian Safety 8F. Fire Hall Renewal Plan reduction targets through Meet VPD and Engineering renewal plan that is formulated articulated in the Vancouver the initiatives identified in Services’ reduction targets for using evidence-based service Police Department’s 2012- the VPD 2012-2016 Strategic motor vehicle collisions involving requirement projections, and 2016 Strategic Plan, with a Plan that entail reducing the injury or death, through increased that takes into account factors focus on developing and number of violent incidents enforcement and education for other than fire hall locations that maintaining positive working through preventative drivers, cyclists and pedestrians, can impact service levels, such relationships within the measures, investigating the and via collaboration among as road design. VPD and between the VPD violent incidents that do the VPD, the City of Vancouver and stakeholder agencies, occur in an effective manner, Engineering Department and providing public educational communicating as appropriate ICBC, with a focus on improving outreach on policing-related with the public about police the safety of roadways. issues, and providing socially incidents, and meet VPD responsible programs and property crime reduction initiatives that benefit youth. targets through heightening Meet VPD violent crime Create a long-term fire hall community awareness and targeting chronic offenders. Chief Constable Chief Constable Chief Constable GM, Engineering Services GM, Real Estate and Facilities Management Fire Chief GM, Financial Services Group 23 GOAL 9 VANCOUVER OFFERS EXTRAORDINARY CIVIC AMENITIES LONG-TERM STRATEGIC GOAL The City provides high-quality recreational, social, cultural and lifelong learning amenities that provide everyone in the city the opportunity to develop and enjoy themselves, and help attract the talent needed in our city to maintain a strong economy. MEASURED BY 2014 SHORT-TERM PRIORITIES 9A. Focus Arts and Culture Support Refresh the 2008-2018 Culture Plan for Vancouver, with a focus on (a) developing new investment strategies for public art, (b) proactive sustainability planning for cultural organizations, (c) establishing a new approach to developing and securing arts and cultural spaces such as artist production spaces, and (d) streamlining • Number of childcare spaces in Vancouver the City’s cultural grant process, • Square feet of outdoor parks and temporary activations space per 1,000 residents including a pilot project to process applications online. • Square feet of indoor library and recreation space per 1,000 residents • Total hours of accessible indoor library and recreation space per 1,000 residents • Total dollars received/committed from development cost levies and community amenity contributions 24 EXECUTIVE SPONSORS GM, Community Services 9B. Optimize Vancouver Civic Theatres Business Operations 9C. Enhance the City’s Network of Community Centres 9D. Vancouver Art Gallery Relocation 9E. Vancouver Public Library Digital Inspiration Lab Implement recommendations Optimize the development Undertake the appropriate Launch the Digital Inspiration from the 2013 Vancouver and delivery of recreation measures to support the Lab at the Vancouver Public Civic Theatres (VCT) programs and services at the Vancouver Art Gallery’s move to Library Central Library, with the business review to enhance City’s network of community the Larwill Park site, targeted to objective of providing access alignment of theatre centres in neighbourhoods take place in early 2015. to creative digital technology operations with the City’s throughout Vancouver, and and related skills-building Culture Goals, and to improve advance plans to redevelop opportunities for residents, customer service, revenue- those community centres providing a gateway into generation and efficiencies scheduled for replacement on digital expression for residents for the Queen Elizabeth, the the near horizon. and serving as a catalyst for Vancouver Playhouse, the community creativity and Orpheum Theatre and other capacity building. VCT venues. GM, Community Services GM, Financial Services Group GM, Park Board GM, Community Services Chief Librarian GM, Planning and Development Services 25 GOAL 10 VANCOUVER’S ASSETS AND INFRASTRUCTURE ARE WELL-MANAGED AND RESILIENT LONG-TERM STRATEGIC GOAL The City plans for, develops and sustains the low carbon, energy resilient, environmentally sound, cost-effective, reliable and safe public works and infrastructure that play an essential role in making Vancouver a healthy, safe and prosperous city. MEASURED BY • Share of major public works assets in poor condition • Share of civic use buildings where detailed external condition assessment completed • Value of infrastructure (tangible capital assets) per capita 26 2014 SHORT-TERM PRIORITIES FOR LEASE 10A. Strategy for City-Owned Property Leased to Non-Profit Agencies Implement an effective business strategy that establishes a centralized structure and process for managing and overseeing the City-owned property leased to non-profit agencies. 10B. Capital Projects Operational Efficiency Enhance management and coordination of all capital projects undertaken by the City, including public works and facilities renewal/development, with the objectives of maximizing efficiencies and value-for-money, and minimizing disruptive impacts on the public and other stakeholders, to include development of project management protocols, expectations and training, and a center of expertise in project management for all of the City’s major capital projects. 10C. Maintenance, Safety and Energy Performance of City-Owned Buildings Optimize the management of City-owned buildings, with a focus on (a) completing and maintaining condition assessment data, (b) developing and implementing a seismic strategy, and (c) developing and implementing a facility energy management plan. EXECUTIVE SPONSORS GM, Real Estate and Facilities Management GM, Community Services GM, Financial Services Group GM, Engineering Services GM, Real Estate and Facilities Management GM, Real Estate and Facilities Management 27 Appendix 1 CITY OF VANCOUVER VALUE-FOR-MONEY PLANNING PROCESS INPUTS This figure shows the City’s value-for-money planning cycle that starts with the various drivers that inform City services and service levels, which leads to standardized evaluation of new initiatives, through to annual service planning, financial allocations, and performance reviews. REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS PUBLIC PRIORITIES COUNCIL/BOARD PRIORITIES SERVICE AND FINANCIAL PLANNING ANALYSIS DIRECTIONAL PLANNING CMT PRIORITIES CORPORATE BUSINESS PLAN EMERGING PRIORITY/ISSUES STRATEGIC ANALYSIS AND VALUE PROPOSITION LONG-TERM FINANCIAL PLAN SERVICE PLANNING BUDGET 28 POLICY DIRECTIONS SERVICE AND PERFORMANCE REVIEWS Appendix 2 CITY OF VANCOUVER ORGANIZATION STRUCTURE THE COMMUNITY MAYOR AND CITY COUNCILLORS VANCOUVER LIBRARY BOARD OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER VANCOUVER POLICE BOARD BOARD OF PARKS AND RECREATION CITY CLERK'S DEPARTMENT COMMUNITY SERVICES CORPORATE COMMUNICATIONS ENGINEERING SERVICES FINANCIAL SERVICES GROUP FIRE AND RESCUE SERVICES HUMAN RESOURCE SERVICES LEGAL SERVICES PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT SERVICES REAL ESTATE AND FACILITIES MANAGEMENT 29 Appendix 3 2012-2021 CORPORATE PLAN KEY ACHIEVEMENTS This table shows key progress and achievements since January 2012 on the short-term priorities of the previous Corporate Plan version. 2012-2021 CORPORATE PLAN SHORT-TERM PRIORITY ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE JANUARY 2012 1A. Corporate Digital Strategy • See Appendix 4, Vancouver Services Review Initiatives. Develop a strategy that unifies the City’s vision and goals around digital service, considering access to digital technology, e-government and open data, citizen engagement and digital community, and supports for a robust digital media sector and the technology needs of Vancouver business community. 1B. Public Engagement Strategy Update the City’s public engagement and consultation strategies and tactics to ensure the City’s various external stakeholders are appropriately involved in City decisionmaking, including an enhanced public hearing process. 1C. Corporate Customer Service Strategy: Permits and Licences Transformation Project Under the leadership of the VSR Office, substantially improve the systems, processes and customer service associated with the issue and enforcement of municipal permits and licences, specifically (a) move the four highest-volume, simple permits and licences to a fully online, self-service system (dog licences, alarm permits, business licences and residential parking permits) and (b) bring business processes in line with best practices, including replacement of up to forty existing systems with a single, state-of-the-art integrated system. 30 • Established the Mayor’s Engaged City Task Force, published Quick Start report Q2-2013. • Several public engagement initiatives underway/completed, including launch of Talk Vancouver, an innovative online community to broaden and enrich civic engagement, development, implementation of a corporate Social Media Strategy, and execution of a pilot project evaluating a new site sign and notification style designed to improve City communication associated with property development projects. • See Appendix 4, Vancouver Services Review Initiatives. 2012-2021 CORPORATE PLAN SHORT-TERM PRIORITY ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE JANUARY 2012 2A. Development-Related Benefits Plan • Standardized DCL rates, resulting in a simpler and more equitable application of development charges. Improve the alignment of development-related benefits (DRBs) with corporate priorities and processes by (a) using new/emerging metrics from improved DRB tracking/reporting to improve assessment and allocation of DRBs, (b) assessing and planning for the long term financial implications of new DRBs, (c) updating and rationalizing the existing systems of development cost levy bylaws, (d) exploring new tools/approaches to achieve and manage DRBs, (e) integrating with key corporate initiatives especially the City-wide Land Use Plan and Social Amenity Plan. 2B. Enterprise Risk Management Function and Business Continuity Planning Develop and implement an enterprise risk management framework, and organizational and operational structure, that assists Council and staff in strategically assessing and addressing the various risks facing the City over time, including a business continuity planning function. 2C. Business Intelligence Program Develop and implement a coordinated strategy for enhancing internal decision support and analytic capabilities, that considers metric development, business intelligence tools, internal skills/capacities, and existing software system capabilities; deliverables to focus on public works planning, land development planning, human resources and financial information/data. 2D. Corporate Granting Strategy • Council approved implementation of City-wide development cost levies (DCLs) in Oakridge-Langara, resulting in improved public benefits delivery in this area. • Council approved new fixed-rate Community Amenity Contribution (CAC) targets in Norquay Centre, Little Mountain Adjacent Area and the Cambie Corridor Phase II Area, with over one-third of all rezonings now processed using the fixed-rate target approach (90% in Cambie Corridor). • Enhanced annual reporting and forecasting of the value of DCLs and CACs secured by the City. • Hired the City’s first-ever Chief Risk Officer. • Phase 1 of comprehensive business continuity plan completed, identifying implications of a business disruption for all business processes. • Phase 1 of issue management plan completed (requirements assessment). • Financial BI tool Park Board pilot successfully completed and Phase 1 of financial BI tool subsequently implemented corporate-wide, has improved management’s ability to use data to manage business. • Vancouver Fire & Rescue Services BI tool successfully implemented, has enhanced management’s ability to optimize staffing, training schedules and service levels. • Human resource BI tool successfully implemented, regular corporate-wide reporting on key HR statistics has enhanced management’s ability to manage staff scheduling, attendance and job applications. • Project has been placed on hold due to other priorities. Develop and implement a corporate granting strategy that coordinates all City granting programs and initiatives to align with corporate priorities, leverage external resources and maximize efficiencies. 31 2012-2021 CORPORATE PLAN SHORT-TERM PRIORITY ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE JANUARY 2012 3A. Corporate Climate Change Adaptation Strategy • Surface heat, social vulnerability, flood hazard and canopy cover mapping complete. Work with departments across the organization, with external partners and other levels of government to complete the City’s climate change adaptation strategy and to integrate into City operations and concurrently manage short term issues arising from the sea level rise guidelines being developed by the Province. • Successful Carbon Talks event held on flood resilience, bringing together a wide range of stakeholders to discuss ideas and opportunities. • Several flood planning and management initiatives underway/ completed, including: -- formal regional collaboration on flood management, -- increasing required flood construction level by one metre, -- comprehensive coastal flood risk assessment in partnership with Port Metro Vancouver, supported by significant third-party funding (underway), and -- integrated stormwater management strategy development (underway). • Urban Forest Strategy recommendations reported to Council in Q4/2013. 3B. Corporate Green Operations Strategy Develop a corporate-wide Green Operations Strategy based on the City’s Environmental Framework for Municipal Operations, focusing on the zero carbon, zero waste and healthy ecosystems objectives. • City facilities and operations -- Upgrades to City of Vancouver facilities have reduced greenhouse gas emissions by 25% over 1990 levels. -- Have developed and implemented a Corporate Fleet Plan to reduce the environmental impact caused by the City’s vehicles and heavy equipment. -- Sustainable commuting program offers incentives to City employees to commute via walking, biking or carpooling, funded through employees parking charges. • Healthy ecosystems through City operations -- Action plan for increasing local and sustainably produced food purchased by City facilities under development. -- The City is the first Canadian municipality to adopt a 100% post-consumerrecycled copy paper purchasing policy, incorporating sustainable considerations into procurement processes. • Diversion of City-generated waste -- Corporate Zero Waste Plan developed and implemented, referenced in ShortTerm Priority 3D. 32 2012-2021 CORPORATE PLAN SHORT-TERM PRIORITY ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE JANUARY 2012 3C. Soil Remediation Strategy • Established centre of excellence for contaminated sites management under the GM, Real Estate and Facilities Management, resulting in: Develop and implement corporate soil contamination policies and practices that are rational, sustainable, protective of human health and City infrastructure, and that facilitate development, while not exposing the City and its taxpayers to unreasonable levels of financial risk and liability. 3D. Corporate Waste Diversion Plan Develop a corporate waste diversion plan that considers integration of consumption reduction strategies into City policies and processes, including corporate procurement. -- enhanced clarity concerning the City’s and the landowners’ roles and responsibilities regarding contaminated sites, and -- improved environmental due diligence and reduced risk related to the purchase, sale, lease, ownership and development of contaminated sites for the City’s civic use, Property Endowment Fund and Park Board real estate portfolios. • Launched the Corporate Zero Waste Program at forty-one civic office and recreation facility sites, resulting in significant share of City facilities’ waste being diverted from the landfill (based upon weight): -- Pre-program: 15% -- Average 2013: 66% -- 2015 target: 80% -- 2020 target: 90% 4A. Employee Engagement Action Plan Continue implementation of the City’s 2011 Employee Engagement Action Plan and related measures aimed at improving employee engagement, including development of an internal communications strategy that includes the appropriate governance structure, tools and tactics supporting a standard, efficient and effective approach to communicating to staff across the organization. • Implemented the City’s first-ever corporate performance development program; in the first year of the program: -- 85% of all managers have completed performance plans aligned with the City’s leadership competency model and long-term strategic goals. -- performance reviews were completed for 46% of all City staff. • Completed the City’s second employee engagement survey in Q3/2013, with over 3,200 employees participating. • Launched a leadership development program, with approximately 100 mid-level managers taking part in the first year of the program, with measurable results: -- participants have reported a 15% increase in their own leadership skills, and -- managers have reported a 25% increase in their employees’ leadership skills. • Phase 1 of enhanced internal communications plan completed (needs assessment). 33 2012-2021 CORPORATE PLAN SHORT-TERM PRIORITY ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE JANUARY 2012 4B. Health, Wellness and Safety Program • Organizational safety achievements include: Embed the corporate safety management system across the City's operations, evaluate existing programs and adjust as necessary to improve effectiveness, improve outcome reporting and management tools, and bring the attendance promotion program that has been designed and implemented by the VSR Office to steady state. -- Have developed clearly articulated safety goals and quarterly progress reporting to the Corporate Management Team, developing a workplan for enhancing safety programs. -- Corporate injury rate has declined by 16% since 2010 due to improved awareness and work design. • Organizational health achievements include: -- Restructured claims management system to better support stay-at-work and early return-to-work outcomes. -- Secured new supplier contracts with key health, wellness and benefits partners, improved services at a lower overall cost. -- Successful stay-at-work/early return to work pilot project has demonstrated reduced injury-related absentee durations by 16% between Q3/2012 and Q3/2013, organization-wide implementation underway. -- WorkSafeBC claims duration have been reduced by an average of seven days. • Corporate attendance management program is fully implemented, a City-wide reduction in absenteeism equivalent to 26 FTEs since implementation 5A. Vancouver Charter Stewardship Strategy • Project has been placed on hold due to other priorities. Create an internal structure and process for understanding the strategic potential of the Vancouver Charter to support the strategic priorities and goals of the organization as articulated in the Corporate Business Plan. 5B. First Nations Collaboration Initiative Create a structure for enhancing collaboration among the City and local First Nations leadership both within the local bands and within the urban aboriginal communities. • Completed City Council dialogue sessions with each of Vancouver’s three host First Nations. • City was an active participant in the 2013 Year of Reconciliation programs and activities. • City has completed a draft archaeological site construction protocol, tested on the Point Grey/Cornwall Seaside Greenway project. 34 2012-2021 CORPORATE PLAN SHORT-TERM PRIORITY ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE JANUARY 2012 6A. Housing and Homelessness Strategy Priorities • Resourcing: Implement the ten priority actions in the City’s 2012-2021 Housing and Homelessness Strategy, with the goal of (a) increasing the supply of affordable housing, (b) encouraging a housing mix across all neighbourhoods that enhances quality of life, and (c) having the City provide strong leadership and support partners to enhance housing stability. -- Hired the City’s first-ever Chief Housing Officer; implemented annual Housing Report Card report to City Council. • Addressing homelessness: -- Purchased or otherwise facilitated creation of new interim housing units, through conversion of hotels: * Kingsway Ramada Hotel – 123 rooms * East Hastings Ramada Hotel – 58 rooms * Kingsway Howard Johnson Hotel – 100 rooms -- Enabled 160 winter response shelter beds to accommodate street homeless individuals -- Opened 257 new supportive housing beds through the City of VancouverBC Housing Fourteen-Site Partnership • Protecting renters: -- Developed a public searchable rental standards database, designed to help renters understand the condition of rental buildings in terms of outstanding bylaw infractions; average time to achieve related bylaw compliance has been cut in half, from 250 days to 125 days. -- Vancouver Rent Bank established offering short-term funding to families and individuals at risk of eviction or essential utility disconnection due to a temporary shortage funds. • Affordability: -- Development of land trust underway, to create a consortium of agencies under the Co-operative Housing Federation of BC, with objective of creating 355 rental units, 75% below-market rent -- Have initiated development of 755 incremental non-market housing units through redevelopment process -- Have permitted construction of over 1,000 laneway houses 35 2012-2021 CORPORATE PLAN SHORT-TERM PRIORITY ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE JANUARY 2012 6B. Transportation 2040 Plan Priorities • Improvements to the south end of the Burrard Bridge underway, with target completion of May 2014 will result in safer navigation for motorists, cyclists and pedestrians. Complete the development of the City’s Transportation 2040 Plan, and implement key priority actions in the Plan, with a focus on developing a corporate parking strategy, implementing a public bicycle sharing system, and furthering the development of the Broadway corridor rapid transit line. • Development of the Seaside Greenway and York Avenue bikeway underway; will add approximately two km to each of the greenway network and the bikeway by 2015. • Created a new “parklet” program, in which businesses and organizations fund conversion of street parking stalls to public gathering spaces; concept demonstrated through successfully piloting concept in three locations. • Design and planning for rehabilitation of False Creek pedestrian/cycling bridge improvements underway, will result in improved safety and accessibility, ultimately contributing to higher cycling and pedestrian trips between downtown Vancouver and the Broadway corridor. 6C. Greenest City Action Plan Track the implementation and accomplishments of the Greenest City Action Plan approved in principle by City Council in July 2011. • Significant progress made toward GCAP targets through a wide range of initiatives: -- Reduction of total solid waste going to the landfill or incinerator by 11% from 2008 and 2012 -- Share of trips via green transportation modes (walk, bike and transit) increased from 40% to 44% from 2008 to 2012 (10% increase) -- Overall water consumption reduced by 16% from 2006 to 2012 -- Planted 12,513 new trees planted between 2010 and 2012 -- Installed 88 electric vehicle charging stations (70 public and 18 private) for City-owned fleet between 2011 and 2013 -- Greenhouse gas down 4% from 2007 to 2012 • Several key strategies related to GCAP underway or completed, including: -- District Energy Strategy -- Transportation 2040 Plan -- Updated Vancouver Building Code -- Vancouver Food Strategy -- Climate Change Adaptation Strategy 36 2012-2021 CORPORATE PLAN SHORT-TERM PRIORITY ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE JANUARY 2012 6D. Water Conservation Priorities • Improved lawn sprinkling management via enforcement and education program, with approximately 900 warnings issued per year, as well as a small number of bylaw infraction tickets. Complete the development of a city-wide water conservation program that addresses the City’s Greenest City Action Plan targets, and implement this Plan’s highest priority actions. • Fifteen public drinking fountains and six water bottle filling stations created in various high-traffic locations around the City. • Water-efficient retrofits: -- Successfully completed pilot project replacing approximately 250 toilets and 100 shower heads in select City-owned low-income rental buildings, demonstrating a resulting 25%-30% reduction in water consumption. -- Partnership between City of Vancouver and Concert Properties underway, will retrofit approximately 1,500 toilets within ten multifamily rental buildings. 6E. Zero Waste Priorities Develop and implement detailed plans and programs which address the Highest Priority Zero Waste Short Term Actions identified in the Greenest City Zero Waste Plan, with a focus on implementing an expanded compostable pickup service for single-family residences and development of a multi-family residence compostable service strategy. • Successfully launched city-wide implementation of weekly organics solid waste collection from single-family residential properties. • Have completed evaluation of options for transferring responsibility for single-family recycling collection to the private sector, in response to upcoming legislation that will make the private sector responsible for the lifecycle management of a designated set of products (“extended producer responsibility”). 37 2012-2021 CORPORATE PLAN SHORT-TERM PRIORITY ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE JANUARY 2012 7A. Vancouver Economic Action Strategy Priorities • In collaboration with the provincial government and a number of other Lower Mainland municipalities, launched the Multi-City Business Licences pilot program in October 2013, significantly improving customer service by allowing various construction tradespeople to operate in six municipalities under a single business licence (Vancouver, Burnaby, New Westminster, Surrey, Delta and Richmond). Support the Vancouver Economic Commission staff in implementing the highest-priority actions identified in the Vancouver Economic Action Strategy, to (a) leverage Vancouver’s core strengths to enhance the quality of the local business environment, (b) enhance existing business attraction, business retention and job creation activities, and (c) support the attraction and retention of human talent. • Attracted ten visual effects studio openings between 2010 and 2012. • Hosted a number of significant economic development programs, including: -- Cities Summit 2012 brought together approximately 500 local, national and international business and policy leaders for a dialogue on leveraging technology and innovation to optimize city-building. -- Created a marketing and outreach program that leveraged the world’s largest gathering of digital media and graphic companies at Vancouver’s 2011 SIGGRAPH conference, efficiently and effectively communicating to this key audience why Vancouver is a compelling and competitive business destination. -- The London 2012 Olympic Business Program connected over 300 business executives and officials from London, the UK and the European Union with approximately thirty Vancouver companies, in order to promote Vancouver as a business destination; has generated $2 million of announced trade arrangements in the film and visual effects (VFX) industry, and another $93 million underway. 7B. Municipal Regulation Review Work with the Vancouver Economic Commission to create and implement a plan to optimize major municipal policies and regulation vis-à-vis their impact on local businesses and economic development, with a focus on land use planning, permits and licences, and other regulatory areas identified as highest priority for the business community. 38 • Project has been placed on hold due to other priorities. 2012-2021 CORPORATE PLAN SHORT-TERM PRIORITY ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE JANUARY 2012 7C. Property Tax Policy Strategic Analysis • Property Tax Policy Review Commission launched April 2013, stakeholder dialogues completed, final report delivered to City Council Q4/2013. Undertake a strategic analysis of the City’s property tax policy as part of long term financial planning and revenue strategy that recognizes the critical importance of property taxes as a municipal revenue source, and considers senior government fiscal capacity, tax distribution among property classes, tax volatility and implications for economic development. 8A. Earthquake Preparedness Strategy Create a governance structure to oversee the development and implementation of (a) the City’s earthquake preparedness strategies, to include public awareness, urban search and rescue response, special operations and emergency exercises, and (b) a corporate plan that prioritizes seismic enhancement of civic facilities and infrastructure. • Earthquake Preparedness Strategy presented to City Council in Q4/2013. • Seismic upgrades to First Avenue viaduct, Burrard and Granville Street bridges. • Prioritized demolition of Vancouver City Hall East Wing building to address significant seismic concerns. • Operationalized six disaster staging areas, pre-defined locations where emergency responders, volunteers, equipment and other resources are assembled in the case of an emergency. • Have put in place a structure and toolset to facilitate post-earthquake command and control, damage assessment and coordination of field staff. • Conducted a large functional exercise including activation of the emergency operations center, area command posts in the field, and a pilot of new public mustering points for earthquake response. • VF&RS leading the way on the development of the Vancouver Volunteer Corps volunteer program, to be deployed in the case of an earthquake or other large-scale emergency. 39 2012-2021 CORPORATE PLAN SHORT-TERM PRIORITY ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE JANUARY 2012 8B. Community-Focused Crime Prevention Initiatives • Per capita crime rates down in following key areas between 2010 and 2012: Achieve the community-focused goals articulated in the VPD’s 2012-2016 Strategic Plan, to (a) develop and maintain positive working relationships, including sharing information, within the VPD and with stakeholder agencies in the community, (b) provide public educational outreach on policing and police related issues, and (c) provide socially responsible programs and initiatives that benefit youth. -- Violent crime down by 6.7% -- Property crime down by 3.6% -- Drug crimes down by 21% • Personal safety of women has been advanced through educational efforts such as the Women’s Safety Fair, and the “Don’t Be That Guy” Campaign in partnership with BarWatch; safety of women in the Downtown Eastside has been advanced via SisterWatch program. • VPD’s Neighbourhood Crime Alert, Block Watch, Citizens Crime Watch, business liaison programs and increased social media presence have actively worked alongside community policing centres to educate and engage the community and businesses about safety issues, including property crime and nuisance behaviour. • Various efforts to divert youth from gangs and other criminal behaviour include athletic events involving police and youth participants via the Police Athletic League and student challenge programs. 8C. 2011 Stanley Cup Riot Report Recommendations Enhance the City’s emergency response capabilities by prioritizing key recommendations from the various reports on the 2011 Stanley Cup riot and ensure they are being implemented, and work with partners including emergency response agencies to track the implementation of recommendations. • Clearly articulated plan in place for future playoff celebrations, addressing issues identified in the various 2011 Stanley Cup riot review reports (City of Vancouver, VPD, Ottawa Police Service and Province of BC). • Have addressed over 90% of all recommendations from the four 2011 Stanley Cup riot review reports, concerning alcohol availability and movement, event planning and public safety, emergency response, communication and CCTV, media messaging, and the role of volunteers. • Key achievements: Formalized event management toolkit, improved special events planning process, training exercises with other key public safety agencies, regional policing partners special events MOU. 40 2012-2021 CORPORATE PLAN SHORT-TERM PRIORITY ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE JANUARY 2012 9A. City-Wide Land Use and Comprehensive Social Amenity Plan • Project has been placed on hold due to other priorities. Develop a City-Wide Land Use Plan that integrates the City’s environmental sustainability, affordability, liveability goals, and within this context develop a comprehensive social amenity plan that establishes a long-term strategic framework and sets standards for planning social infrastructure such as libraries, childcare, neighbourhood houses, sports and recreation facilities and community centres. 9B. City of Vancouver Culture Plan and Civic Theatres Review Using the City’s Culture Plan (2008-2018) as a foundation, identify the City’s key cultural strategies that advance the long-term sustainability of Vancouver’s arts and cultural sector, and within this context, review the business model and develop a strategic plan for the Vancouver Civic Theatres facilities that optimizes the recently-upgraded facilities and supports the long-term sustainability of the local performing arts sector. • Added significant number of new artist production spaces, including the Arts Factory (281 Industrial Avenue, 21,000 square feet), two new studio spaces awarded to emerging and established professional visual artists, as well as an innovative program that transformed twelve Parks Board field houses sited in City parks into artist production space. • Restored the hundred year old, 365-seat York Theatre on Commercial Drive, adding to the city’s performing arts venue inventory. • Reported focused set of five-year Cultural Plan strategic directions to City Council in Q4-2013. • Established the Arts and Culture Policy Council, a set of experts and stakeholders that report directly to City Council, with a mandate to advise Council and staff on all civic programs that relate to arts and culture. • Regulatory changes to facilitate arts and culture include the introduction of a one-stop arts event licence, and allowance of artist studios in industrial zones. • Have identified a City-owned site in downtown Vancouver for the new Vancouver Art Gallery. • Civic Theatres Business Review targeted completion December 2013. 41 2012-2021 CORPORATE PLAN SHORT-TERM PRIORITY ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE JANUARY 2012 10A. Corporate Asset Management Strategy • See Appendix 4, Vancouver Services Review Initiatives. Develop a corporate asset management strategy that includes the governance structure, data, tools, and tactics required to support effective planning, maintenance, rehabilitation and replacement of the City’s capital assets, with a focus on City-owned public works infrastructure and civic/Property Endowment Fund facilities. 10B. Strategy for City-Owned Property Leased to Non-Profit Agencies Implement an effective business strategy that establishes a centralized structure and process for managing and overseeing the City-owned property leased to non-profit agencies. 10C. Combined Sewer Overflow Regulatory Target Strategy Update and refine the strategy to ensure the City meets its regulated combined sewer overflow 2050 regulatory requirements as cost effectively as possible. 10D. Public Works Operational Efficiency Plan Develop a strategic, integrated approach to planning and scheduling public works projects in order to minimize disruption to citizens and environmental impacts, and to maximize efficiencies gained from economies of scale and shared resources, with the objective of creating an outside utilities coordinating committee and, where appropriate, integrating the public works projects of the City and other agencies. • Completed condition assessment of 26 of the 70 City-owned properties (400,000 of 1.4 million square feet) that are leased to non-profit agencies, remaining conditions assessments are underway. • In Q4/2012, completed comprehensive sewer separation plan aligning forecasted sewer asset replacement requirements to regulatory requirements concerning 2050 combined sewer overflow targets. • In Q3/2013, initiated development of city-wide and Musqueum integrated stormwater management plans. • Successful completion of West 4th Avenue pilot project evaluating an innovative approach to road and infrastructure work that reduced construction time by approximately 40%, from eight to five months, and significantly reduced impact on local businesses, residents and traffic. • Implemented PlanIT, a map-based online tool for medium-term road and infrastructure project planning, facilitating coordination of projects within the City and with other agencies responsible for underground infrastructure (e.g., energy utilities and telecomm companies), to ensure that project schedules are appropriately aligned in order to minimize the impacts of public works on local businesses, residents and traffic at a single site, to the greatest extent possible. • Projects with similar traffic impacts are now coordinated to occur around the same period to reduce the duration of impacts. • Developed draft construction signage for review to inform public of the benefits, impact and schedule. 42 Appendix 4 VANCOUVER SERVICES REVIEW INITIATIVES The Vancouver Services Review (VSR) is the City of Vancouver’s program management office. The tables below list current and completed VSR projects. The projects are a combination of strategic priorities for the City, business transformation initiatives, as well as some crossdepartmental and departmental priorities. While championed by the Corporate Management Team and senior leaders across the organization, the Directors of the Vancouver Services have primary responsibility for executing these initiatives. PROJECTS UNDERWAY VSR INITIATIVE DEPARTMENT KEY ACHIEVEMENTS TO DATE SCHEDULED COMPLETION DATE 1. Sign Bylaw Planning & Development Services, City-Wide & Regional Planning • Significant progress has been made in revising the sign bylaw March 2014 Park Board • Implemented OneCard, a universal access pass to Vancouver recreation facilities, over 86,000 cards issued as of Dec 2013 Modernize the sign bylaw and administrative processes to promote better signage, reduce non-compliance and increase consistency 2. Community Centre Associations Amalgamate the facilities design and management functions across the organization • Evaluated applicability of outcome-based regulation June 2014 • Interim agreement reached between Park Board and collaborating Community Centre Associations in June 2013 Increase equity, access, operational sustainability and accountability for community centre operations 3. Consolidated Facilities Services • Completed small-scale compliance study • Negotiations underway with collaborating Community Centre Associations regarding a Joint Operating Agreement Real Estate & Facilities Management • City’s current facilities planning and development function deemed leading practice against Canadian comparators by independent consultants October 2014 • Based on leading practices, realigned key facilities operations as well as management and administrative functions • Deployment underway of an enhanced enterprise approach to work flow management 43 PROJECTS UNDERWAY VSR INITIATIVE DEPARTMENT KEY ACHIEVEMENTS TO DATE 4. Financial Shared Services Financial Services Group, Financial Planning & Analysis and Financial Services • Created a comprehensive budget and service plan for 2014 Amalgamate the financial management and support functions across the organization, consolidate transactional services and enhance strategic business support 5. Asset Management Conduct detailed condition assessments of the ~ 500 City-owned facilities (totalling 8 million square feet) which supports long-range capital planning and maintenance 6. Legal Services Transformation Provide a single view of the City’s inventory operations and ensure the right supplies are available and delivered as needed in the most sustainable and cost-efficient manner 44 December 2014 • Created a City-wide metrics master list for all services • Conducted a Business Intelligence (BI) report pilot Real Estate & Facilities Management, Facilities Planning & Development • Completed condition assessments of over 200 buildings based on their priority, representing 50% of total square footage June 2015 • Have initiated development of a long-term plan for major building system repair and replacement in City-owned buildings • Completed risk-based evaluation concerning seismic risk to City-owned buildings, action plans to address highest risks under development Legal Services • Project is currently in pre-planning June 2015 • Goal is to stabilize technology architecture currently in use and develop future state vision and transformation strategy Support the evolution of Legal Service’s service model through updated technology 7. Warehousing and Inventory Optimization • Consolidated departmental finance managers into one group SCHEDULED COMPLETION DATE Financial Services Group, Supply Chain Management, Warehouse & Logistics • Phase 1 of the project is underway, focusing on warehouse and inventory operations at Central Stores, Evans Yard Stores, National Yards Stores and HUSAR (Heavy Urban Search and Rescue) September 2015 PROJECTS UNDERWAY VSR INITIATIVE DEPARTMENT KEY ACHIEVEMENTS TO DATE SCHEDULED COMPLETION DATE 8. Permits and Licences Planning & Development Services, Community Services and Engineering Services, Street Use • Reduced wait times for one- and two-family dwelling permits by 60% (from 15-18 weeks to 6-8 weeks) December 2015 Transform the process of submitting, tracking, reviewing, issuing and enforcing permits and licences issued by the City, with a focus on improved customer service 9. Inspection Services Transformation Transform inspections through organizational changes, enhanced service leveraging technology and a risk-based approach 10. Library and Archives Co-locate the City of Vancouver Archives and Vancouver Public Library’s Special Collections Department • Most used licences and permits, dog, business, security alarm and residential parking, are now available online • Improvements to business processes and online services for remaining complex permits are underway • In the process of reducing business licence types from approximately 650 to less than 100 Community Services, Licences & Inspections • Restructured Inspections Division Vancouver Public Library and City Clerk’s, City of Vancouver Archives • Renovations to VPL Central Library levels 7-9 approved in principal June 2016 • Reduced inspector travel time • Plans underway to leverage new technology for risk-based inspections June 2018 • Funding to be requested through 2015-2017 Capital Plan for levels 7 and 8, and fundraising for level 9 45 PROJECTS UNDERWAY VSR INITIATIVE DEPARTMENT KEY ACHIEVEMENTS TO DATE SCHEDULED COMPLETION DATE 11. Waste Management and Resource Recovery Engineering Services, Waste Management & Resource Recovery MURB 2015 i. Multi-Unit Residential Buildings (MURB): Meet Metro Vancouver’s statutory ban on compostable organics’ disposal at the landfill by 2015, and move as many of the 1,342 City-serviced MURBs into the Green Bin Program with minimized contamination ii. Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR): Implement an expanded printed paper and packaging (PPP) collection and recycling program by May 2015 in accordance with provincial regulation, and negotiate a mutually agreeable contract with MMBC that enables the City to continue providing recycling services to Vancouver residents 46 • Developed a food scraps source separation program and implementation plan • Contacted property contacts, conducted site assessments for Green Bin program eligibility • Launch expected February 2014 EPR • Completed financial, legal and operational analysis of MMBC contract • A five-year contract between the City and MMBC was reached November 2013 in which the total estimated revenue to the City for program operations is $42 million PROJECTS COMPLETED VSR INITIATIVE DEPARTMENT KEY ACHIEVEMENTS TO DATE 1. Sanitation Services Engineering Services, Vancouver Sanitation Services • Combined residential and park sanitation services Financial Services Group, Financial Services, Revenue Services • Wait times reduced from two years to two and a half months Financial Services Group, IT • Created single point of contact through a City-wide IT Help Desk Merge Engineering Services and Park Board sanitation services and reduce route duplication 2. Bylaw Adjudication Improve the process for disputing parking tickets and the collection of unpaid parking tickets 3. Information Technology Services Optimize and centralize the sourcing and procurement of goods and services December 2010 • Cumulative operational savings are $26 million May 2011 • Since implementation, 3,040 hearings held with 89% of tickets upheld • 80% of tickets now voluntarily paid May 2011 • Consolidated IT management and staff Consolidate IT functions across the organization including help desks, network services, data centres and applications development 4. Supply Chain Shared Services • Maximized green opportunities by reducing vehicle routes SCHEDULED COMPLETION DATE • Implemented new IT policy and standards framework • Generates $1 million in annual operating savings Financial Services Group, Supply Chain Management and Financial Services • Launched new procurement policy January 2012 • Centralized procurement and accounts payable services and updated technology platform • Reduced the value of sole sourced contracts, now 97% through competitive bid • Over $32 million cumulative savings through strategic sourcing 5. Capital Program Optimize the City’s investment in and management of capital assets Financial Services Group, Financial Services, Long-Term Financial Planning • Created City’s first Ten-Year Strategic Outlook February 2012 • Conducted City-wide inventory of capital assets and initial condition assessment • Reduced borrowing and capital from revenue for 2012-14 Capital Plan 47 PROJECTS COMPLETED VSR INITIATIVE DEPARTMENT KEY ACHIEVEMENTS TO DATE SCHEDULED COMPLETION DATE 6. Attendance Management Human Resource Services, Organizational Health • Implemented City-wide attendance management approach March 2012 Develop strategies, tools and tactics to reduce employee absenteeism 7. Electronic Pay Notices Move employee pay statements from print to electronic 8. Communications Shared Services Optimize communications functions across the organization to create a centre of expertise 48 • Achieved a City-wide reduction in absenteeism equivalent to 26 full-time employees’ year over year • In 2013, the department piloted a stay at work/early return to work approach in Parks Board that supported a 16% reduction in absenteeism in one year, approach being implemented Citywide in 2014 Financial Services Group, Financial Services, Payroll Department • Cumulative savings of 6,553 kgs of paper and 122 trees Corporate Communications • Aligned policies and procedures across the City April 2013 • 98% employee participation • Approximately $100,000 annual operating savings, totalling approximately $0.5 million to date • Consolidated communications staff and created an internal communications team May 2012 PROJECTS COMPLETED VSR INITIATIVE DEPARTMENT KEY ACHIEVEMENTS TO DATE 9. Digital Strategy Human Resource Services, Digital Services • Created Canada’s first municipal digital strategy, approved by Council April 2013 Build a roadmap for Vancouver to become an open, connected and digitallyenabled city 10. Parks and Public Works Consolidation Identify opportunities for streamlining public works services within the City (Including parks) 11. Web Redevelopment Redevelop the City’s website to allow for enhanced online information delivery, transactions and stakeholder consultation SCHEDULED COMPLETION DATE October 2013 • Extensive consultation including crowd-sourcing, Mayor’s Digital Leaders Roundtable and an External Advisory Council • Recruited City’s first Chief Digital Officer in October 2013 Park Board and Engineering Services, Streets Division • Identified key opportunities for streamlining November 2013 Human Resource Services, Digital Services • Launched new website - vancouver.ca in August 2012 December 2013 • Reduced website from over 60,000 to approximately 4,000 pages • Implemented improved navigation and new visual design and enhanced citizen engagement • Centralized website management • Optimized content for mobile devices expected June 2014 49 50 Appendix 5 CITY OF VANCOUVER LONG-TERM PLANS This appendix lists the City’s key longer-term strategy direction documents, along with the top-level goals associated with each. A. Vancouver’s Housing and Homelessness Strategy, 2012-2021 • Increase the supply of affordable housing • Encourage a housing mix across all neighbourhoods that enhances quality of life • Provide strong leadership and support partners to enhance housing stability B. Greenest City 2020 Action Plan, July 2011 • Green economy: To secure Vancouver’s international reputation as a mecca of green enterprise • Climate leadership: Eliminate dependence on fossil fuels • Green buildings: Lead the world in green building design and construction • Green mobility: Make walking, cycling and public transit preferred transportation options • Zero waste: Create zero waste • Access to nature: Vancouver residents enjoy incomparable access to green spaces, including the world’s most spectacular urban forest • Lighter footprint: Achieve a one-planet ecological footprint • Clean water: Vancouver will have the best drinking water of any city in the world C. Economic Action Strategy, December 2011 • A healthy climate for growth and prosperity: Expanding the City’s global brand on liveability, by strengthening and promoting a prosperous business climate • Support for local business, new investment and global trade: Promoting business growth and new investments that drive employment, exports and global trade. • Attracting and retaining human capital: Boosting efforts to attract and retain the human capital that powers the future. D. Vancouver Board of Parks and Recreation Strategic Framework, June 2012 • Parks and recreation for all: Accessible, diverse and quality amenities and services that encourage participation and meet current and future needs. • Leader in greening: Through our actions we demonstrate leading green and horticultural practices and preserve, protect and create green space. • Engaging people: Working openly together to understand and achieve goals and strengthen relationships. • Excellence in resource management: Use existing resources effectively and efficiently, and be innovative in developing additional resources to deliver best value for money and meet community needs. • Clean air: Breathe the cleanest air of any major city in the world • Local food: Vancouver will become a leader in urban food systems 51 CITY OF VANCOUVER LONG-TERM PLANS This appendix lists the City’s key longer-term strategy direction documents, along with the top-level goals associated with each. E. Climate Change Adaptation Strategy, July 2012 • Increase in intensity and frequency of heavy rain events: Increased surface water flooding, sewer back-ups and combined sewer overflows due to heavy rainfall. • Sea level rise: Increased flooding, storm surge damage, saltwater intrusion and erosion to the coastline. impacts to gravity drainage of low lying storm sewers and potential impacts to groundwater levels. • Increased frequency and intensity of storms and weather extremes: Increased public safety and health risks; increased resources required to respond and recover following events. • Transit: Support transit improvements to increase capacity and ensure service that is fast, frequent, reliable, fully accessible, and comfortable. • Motor vehicles: Manage the road network efficiently to improve safety and support a gradual reduction in car dependence. Make it easier to drive less. Accelerate the shift to low-carbon vehicles. • Hotter, drier summers: Water supply shortages in late summer, increasing respiratory illness, health and safety risks for vulnerable populations. • Goods, services and emergency response: Support a thriving economy and Vancouver’s role as a major port and AsiaPacific gateway while managing related environmental and neighbourhood impacts. Maintain effective emergency response times for police, fire, and ambulance. • Overall changes: Maladapted buildings; decrease in durability and lifecycle of infrastructure; increase in impacts to urban forests, green spaces and trees; changing pests, vectors for disease and air quality. • Education, encouragement and enforcement: Encourage sustainable transportation choices and educate all road users to promote safe and respectful behaviour. Support legislation and enforcement practices that target dangerous conduct. • Organizational adaptive capacity: Incorporation of climate change in risk management and project planning across departments. F. Transportation 2040, October 2012 • Land Use: Use land use to support shorter trips and sustainable transportation choices. • Walking: Make walking safe, convenient, comfortable, and delightful. Ensure streets and sidewalks support a vibrant public life and encourage a walking culture, healthy lifestyles, and social connectedness. 52 • Cycling: Make cycling safe, convenient, comfortable, and fun for people of all ages and abilities. G. Vancouver Food Strategy, January 2013 • Support food-friendly neighbourhoods • Empower residents to take action • Improve access to healthy, affordable, culturally diverse food for all residents • Make food a centrepiece of Vancouver’s green economy • Advocate for a just and sustainable food system with partners and at all levels of government H. Corporate Digital Strategy, April 2013 • Engagement and access: Improve delivery of high demand services through the use of digital tools • Infrastructure and assets: Optimize digital infrastructure and physical assets • Economy: Develop, attract and retain talent and business in the digital sector • Organizational digital maturity: Develop a culture that empowers City staff to innovate with digital technologies I. Vancouver Mayor’s Engaged City Task Force Quick Starts, May 2013 • Engagement at a neighbour level • Improve civic education K. Vancouver Police Department 2012-2016 Strategic Plan • Crime reduction goals: Reduce violent crime, reduce property crime, disrupt organized crime, combat low-level crimes and problems that impact perceptions of neighbourhood safety, reduce motor vehicle collisions • Community-focused goals: Develop and maintain positive working relationships, including sharing information, within the VPD and with stakeholder agencies in the community, public outreach on policing issues, socially responsible initiatives that benefit youth • Organizational development goals: Career development and succession planning within VPD, appropriate human resources and training, employee wellness, streamline administrative processes, leverage technology and infrastructure to assist officers in the investigation and enforcement of crime • Improve the development process • Social media for civic events L.Vancouver Public Library 2013-2015 Strategic Plan • Inspire and support a community of learning J. Earthquake Preparedness Strategy, December 2013 • Connect people with each other and our city • Assess risk • Provide engaging spaces to create and share our stories • Reduce risk • Nurture a strong organization • Prepare to respond/recover 53 Appendix 6 City Of Vancouver 2014 Corporate Business Plan Overview 54 SHORT-TERM PRIORITIES GOAL 1. EXCELLENT SERVICE A. Advance City’s Digital Citizen and Customer Services B. Permits and Licences Transformation Project C. Improve Public Engagement and Outreach GOAL 2. FINANCIALLY HEALTHY A. Development-Related Benefits Plan B. Enterprise Risk Management and Business Continuity Planning C. Business Intelligence Program GOAL 3. LEADS THE WAY ON GREEN ISSUES A. City Fleet Optimization B. Climate Change Adaptation C. Update Solid Waste Strategies and Services to Adapt to Changing Landscape GOAL 4. WORKPLACE AND EMPLOYEE EXCELLENCE A. Employee Engagement Action Plan and Internal Communications B. Recruitment Strategy A. Refine Policies and Structures to Advance Housing Availability and Affordability B. Support Shift to Transit, Cycling and Pedestrian Transportation C. GHG Reduction Plan for New and Existing Buildings D. Community Planning E. Downtown and Cambie Corridor District Energy GOAL 7. DYNAMIC BUSINESS CLIMATE D. Urban Forest Strategy GOAL 8. SAFE CITY WHERE PEOPLE FEEL SECURE GOAL 9. EXTRAORDINARY CIVIC AMENITIES A. Earthquake Preparedness A. Focus Arts and Culture Support B. Supporting and Enabling the New Economy B. Marine and Shoreline Safety and Environmental Protection B. Optimize Vancouver Civic Theatres Business Operations D. Green Jobs Action Plan B. Regional Funding Allocation Decisions D. Municipal Access to Fraser River Shoreline and Other Provincial Land A. Vancouver Innovation Hub C. Local Entrepreneur Proof of Concept Program A. First Nations Collaboration Initiative C. Healthy City Strategy Partnership with Vancouver Coastal Health D. Warehousing and Inventory Optimization GOAL 6. SUSTAINABLE, AFFORDABLE, LIVEABLE, INCLUSIVE CITY GOAL 5. PARTNERSHIPS & COLLABORATIONS C. Community-Focused Policing Initiatives C. Enhance the City’s Network of Community Centres D. Crime Reduction Initiatives D. Vancouver Art Gallery Relocation E. Vehicle, Cyclist and Pedestrian Safety F. Vancouver Public Library Digital Inspiration Lab GOAL 10. WELL-MANAGED ASSETS & INFRASTUCTURE A. Strategy for City-Owned Property Leased to Non-Profit Agencies B. Capital Projects Operational Efficiency C. Maintenance, Safety and Energy Performance of City-Owned Buildings F. Fire Hall Renewal Plan 55 Printed on 100% post-consumer paper © City of Vancouver, February 2014
© Copyright 2024