Download Report

Abovet
heLaw
andUndert
heRadar
TheBi
l
l
boar
dI
ndus
t
r
y’
sFai
l
ur
et
oCompl
y
wi
t
hLoc
al
,St
at
e,andFeder
alLaws
BySar
ahG.Ri
c
har
ds
SamuelS.Fel
sFund
J
anuar
y2
01
3
Table of Contents
Executive Summary…………………………………………………………………………………………………………….….…2
Introduction……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….……..3
Background & History of Signage Regulation in Philadelphia…………………………………………………..4
Timeline of Billboard Regulation in Philadelphia……………………………………………………………………..5
Study Results………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….……….10
Appendix A: Compliance Study……………………………………………………………………………………….…….12
Methodology……………………………………………………………………………………………….……12
Findings…………………………………………………………………………………………………………….14
Study Issues……………………………………………………………………………………………...………16
Conclusion & Extension………………………………………………………………………………………………………..…18
About the Author………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….…19
Appendix A: List of Compliant Signs……………………………………………………………………………………….20
Appendix B: List of Signs with One or More Violations…………………………………………………….…...22
Appendix C: Baker Study Comparison……………………………………………………………………………………28
Appendix D: PennDOT Agreement with the FHA…..………………………………………………….…...….….31
Appendix E: Certification of the City of Philadelphia to Enforce Pennsylvania Regulations….42
Appendix F: Map of Interstate and Federal-Aid Primary Highway System……………………….…..43
1
Executive Summary
The Federal Highway Beautification Act
(HBA) of 1965 mandated consistent regulation
and enforcement of non-accessory, outdoor
advertising signs along the National Highway
System and all federal and primary aid highways.
Each state was required to sign a Federal/State
Agreement affirming that they would uphold the
federal laws regulating size, lighting and spacing.
The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, signed its
Federal/State Agreement in 1972.1
Based on Philadelphia’s desire to take
control of its outdoor advertisements, on June
10, 1974, Commonwealth Secretary of
Transportation Jacob Kassab certified to the
Federal Government that the City of Philadelphia
had “established and will enforce like regulations Figure 1: Although Philadelphia’s Sign Codes prohibit signs
higher than 25 feet above the roadway they face, some
with respect to size, spacing and lighting” and
ignore the law, like this sign at 939 N. Front St.
thus signed the state/city agreement enabling
the City of Philadelphia to enforce and uphold the HBA . 2
This report examines whether the City of Philadelphia’s obligations with the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania has been properly enforced and upheld as required by federal law.3 Prompting this study
was the City’s entrance into a settlement agreement, effective August of 2006, with multiple major
outdoor advertising companies, including Free Speech LLC, CBS Outdoor Inc., Clear Channel Outdoor,
Inc., and H.A. Steen Industries, which legalized certain signs that were and are located along Federal and
Primary Aid Highways.4
This 2006 Settlement Agreement was created under the auspices of addressing a challenge to
permit fees. In the process, however, the Agreement fails to enforce the HBA and the City’s own sign
code, all of which incorporated the terms of the state/city agreement and the state/federal agreement.
The 2006 Settlement Agreement certified all non-compliant billboards contained in the inventories
submitted by the companies to the City as being legal/compliant, despite the fact that many of these
signs had never been compliant, as the City has had laws in place that upheld the HBA since 1977. This
report shows that the bulk of the violations reported in the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation-
1
See Appendix E
2
See Appendix F
See Appendix F
4
See Appendix G
3
2
sponsored outdoor advertising inventory of 20065, authored by Michael Baker Jr., Inc., as well as those
violations that were self-reported by the companies, have not been legalized or corrected or removed
by the responsible parties.
The City’s failure to enforce the HBA is a violation of its agreement with the State and
jeopardizes the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania’s Federal Highway funding allocation. Based on the
findings of this report, it is recommended that the Federal Highway Administration conduct an audit
of the permits and licenses issued by the City of Philadelphia for outdoor advertising signage along
Federal Aid highways in order to determine whether the City/State agreement should be revoked.
Presently, the City of Philadelphia is preparing to enact new signage regulations. These new
proposed regulations fail to remove illegal billboards currently allowed under the 2005 Settlement
Agreement which terminates in August of 2014. There are hundreds of billboards incorporated in this
Agreement, many of which are located in violation along Federal and Primary Aid highways. This report
helps the City identify those billboards which should be removed or altered because of their
noncompliance.
Introduction
"Getting on the subject of beautification is like picking up a tangled skein of wool. All the threads are
interwoven -- recreation and pollution and mental health, and the crime rate, and rapid transit, and
highway beautification, and the war on poverty, and parks -- national, state and local. It is hard to hitch
the conversation into one straight line, because everything leads to something else." - Lady Bird Johnson,
in her diary in 1965 6
The Highway Beautification Act of 1965 began largely because of the vision of one woman, First
Lady “Lady Bird” Johnson, for a cleaner, safer, and more beautiful America. She was distraught by the
overgrown and trash-strewn lots, junkyards full of scrap materials, and the proliferation of billboards
that had become increasingly commonplace alongside the nation’s highways. She pressed her husband,
then-president Lyndon B. Johnson, to do something about it. The result was the 1965 Highway
Beautification Act. The Act stipulated in part that "the erection and maintenance of outdoor advertising
signs, displays, and devices in areas adjacent to the Interstate System and the Primary System should be
controlled in order to protect the public investment in such highways, to promote the safety and
recreational value of public travel, and to preserve natural beauty." 7
The Act controls signs within 660 feet of the edge of an interstate highway and those highways
that are designated as being part of the Primary System. It requires that non-accessory advertising
signage (billboards) be limited to industrial and commercially zoned areas, and that the sign’s size and
lighting be regulated. It also stipulates that the signs cannot be less than 500 feet apart along the
5
Michael Baker Jr., Inc.. Philadelphia Outdoor Advertising Inventory, as of June 22, 2006. Pennsylvania
Department of Transportation: Harrisburg, 2006
6
PBS. 2001. 19 Jul.2012.<http://www.pbs.org/ladybird/shattereddreams/shattereddreams_report.html>
USDOT/Federal Highway Administration. 2012. 19 July 2012. <http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/realestate/oacprog.htm#HISTORY>
7
3
Interstate Highway and the Primary System. All states and municipalities are required to enact
regulations consistent with the federal regulations.
Since the law was passed in 1965, the Highway Beautification Act has been amended several
times. It has been a controversial and much-debated act of federal legislation. Scenic America, an
organization dedicated to preserving scenic beauty and protecting public space, contends that the Act is
“broken”. This contention is based on the continued violation of the Act. According to Scenic America’s
publication “The Highway Beautification Act: A Broken Law”, despite the original intentions to “protect
the public investment in highways, to promote the safety and recreational value of public travel, and to
preserve natural beauty”, illegal billboards continue to proliferate along the nation’s highways
destroying scenic views and degrading the public environment. 8
Background & History of Signage Regulation in Philadelphia
Philadelphia has a long
history regarding its attempts to
regulate outdoor advertising. The
first reference to outdoor
advertising was in the 1938
ordinance, which required a license
(renewable annually), to operate an
outdoor advertising firm. It also
required that billboards be
inspected for safety. A violation of
the ordinance resulted in a $50
fine.
Figure 2: Construction on the elevated Delaware Expressway in Philadelphia in
1968. (Photo by Delaware Regional Planning Commission)
The 1965 Highway Beautification Act (HBA) represented a landmark change in signage
regulation—before, it had been up to municipalities to decide individually how to regulate advertising.
The HBA allowed room for elaboration and expansion of regulations, but mandated several specific
requirements regarding size, lighting and placement of non-accessory billboards now called Outdoor
Advertising Devices (OAD). In 1972, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania entered into an agreement
with the federal government, pledging to abide by the tenants of the HBA. Two years later, as a result
of an agreement with Philadelphia, the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation (Penn DOT) certified
to the Federal Highway Administration that the City of Philadelphia had agreed and would abide by state
and federal signage regulations. Below is a brief timeline of billboard regulation in Philadelphia, with a
summary of notable regulation requirements.9
8
9
The Highway Beautification Act: A Broken Law. Washington, D.C.: Scenic America, 1997.
Compiled by Scenic Philadelphia employee Nicole Seitz in 2006; edited by Sarah Richards October 2012
4
Timeline of Billboard Regulation in Philadelphia
1938: Philadelphia enacts sign ordinance regulating outdoor advertising, setting an annual license fee,
exemptions and penalties for failure to comply.
1963: Philadelphia passes a sign ordinance setting distance requirements from residential districts
1965: Congress enacts the Federal Highway Beautification Act
1971: Pennsylvania passes the “Outdoor Advertising Control Act,” exercising the powers given to it
through the Federal Highway Beautification Act to control Outdoor Advertising Devices.
1972: Pennsylvania Transportation Secretary signed the State/Federal Agreement requiring the
Commonwealth to enforce federal standards governing the size, lighting and spacing or risk losing 10
percent of its Federal highway funding. The Commonwealth was and still is responsible for the
enforcement of this Agreement which applies to every city and municipality.
1974: Philadelphia is granted certification by the Commonwealth to enforce the Federal/State
Agreement controlling size, spacing and lighting within the City’s commercial and industrial areas. Under
the terms of this Agreement, Philadelphia must enforce the 1972 State/Federal Agreement’s controls
regulating size, spacing and lighting along its Federal and Primary Aid Highways.
1977: Philadelphia enacted Bill No. 436 which Amended section 14-102 of the Philadelphia Code relating
to definitions, by providing an expanded definition of a sign, and by providing additional definitions
dealing with various types of signs.
1977: Philadelphia enacted Bill No. 437-A which amended chapters 14-300 and 14-500 of the
Philadelphia Code relating to commercial districts and industrial districts by amending Sections 14-303,
14-304, 14-305, 14-306, 14-506, 14-507, 14-508, 14-509 and 15-510, relating to the C-2, C-3, C-4, C-5
Commercial Districts, L-4 Limited Industrial, G-2 Industrial, L-R Least Restricted Industrial and Port
Industrial Districts, by permitting outdoor advertising signs, under certain terms and conditions.
1977: Philadelphia passed Bill No. 438-A which amended chapter 14-1600 of the Philadelphia Code by
adding a new section relating to outdoor advertising or non-accessory signs and structures by providing
size, height, illumination and spacing requirements, established minimum distances from residential
properties, and established areas in the City in which such signs are prohibited, including those within
660 feet of the outward edge of the right-of-way lines of all bridges over the Schuylkill River. The City
also set spacing requirements, maximum sign area and number of structures and sign faces permitted
on any one lot, set limitations on illuminated, animated, flashing and revolving signs and height
restrictions of 25 feet from the bottom of the sign.
5
1979: Philadelphia passed Bill No. 2064 which prohibited outdoor advertising signs between 6th Street
and Delaware Avenue from South Street to Washington Avenue.
1985: Philadelphia amended Section §14-303 of the Philadelphia Zoning Code prohibiting outdoor
advertising in areas zoned C-2 Commercial.
1988: Philadelphia amended the Sign Code to include Section §14-1604.1 “Special Sign Controls for the
area surrounding the Vine Street Parkway and the Benjamin Franklin Bridge Approach” prohibiting
outdoor advertising and limiting the size and height of accessory signs.
1991: Philadelphia amended the Zoning
Code for outdoor advertising signs and
Section §9-602, which regulated the
business aspects of outdoor advertising.
Signs were prohibited within 660 feet from
parks, playgrounds, schools, historic areas
and within 300 feet from residences.
2005: Philadelphia amended Section §9602, regarding the conditions for issuance
of licenses, applicable fees, imposing
safety requirements, reporting
requirements and increasing penalties.
Figure 3: An oversized sign in the heart of Center City Philadelphia
violates the maximum sign face area restriction of the HBA.
2005: Source: Bill No. 050451, approved June 15, 2005
Creation of new Chapter §19-3400, Excise Tax on Outdoor Advertising Transactions which imposes a 7%
excise tax on the purchase, rental or licensing of any space, building, parcel or structure for the purpose
of maintaining outdoor advertising signs
2006: Settlement Agreement between the City of Philadelphia and Free Speech LLC, CBS Outdoor Inc.,
Clear Channel Outdoor, Inc., and H.A. Steen Industries addressing violations found by the Penn
DOT/Baker Inventory. The Settlement temporarily legalized previously un-permitted and illegal
billboards for specific billboard owners, removed requirements for safety inspection of billboard
structures and reduced annual license fees from 650 dollars to 50 dollars per sign face.
Conclusion
The results of this report show that a lack of enforcement of outdoor advertising regulations is
an ongoing problem in the city of Philadelphia. Many billboards that are not in compliance with
Philadelphia’s certification and, by extension, the Highway Beautification Act of 1965, have been
allowed to remain standing along Philadelphia’s highways. According to the Act, if the state of
6
Pennsylvania is found to be out of compliance with its agreement of 1972 with the U.S. Government
regarding the Highway Beautification Act, the state stands to lose 10% of its federal highway funding.10
The actions taken (or not taken) regarding enforcement of outdoor advertising regulations by the City of
Philadelphia could impact federal funding for the entire state.
Using the Federal regulations set forth in the 1965 Highway Beautification Act which have been
incorporated into the Philadelphia Zoning Code, this study shows for instance the number of outdoor
advertising signs along I-95 in Philadelphia that are not in compliance with local, state, and federal
regulations. Although not as
lengthy or extensive, this report
uses the 2006 Philadelphia
Outdoor Advertising Inventory,
developed by the Michael Baker
Corporation in partnership with
Penn DOT, as a model.11 This
report uses the same or similar
categories to those used in the
2006 study. It is important to
note that many of the signs
Figure 4: An oversized billboard in front of 30th Street Station violates the HBA’s restrictions
found in violation of
on maximum sign face area and spacing requirements.
Philadelphia’s certification still
have not been brought into compliance, despite the fact that it has been six years since the study was
conducted and the information published. This report and the Baker study find 113 signs in common.
This report also contains billboards not found in the Baker inventory, and the Baker inventory contained
signs not included in this report (not through deliberate omission but perhaps because of differing
survey methodologies). Only 20 of the billboards that the two reports have in common were found to
be in compliance with all regulations, including having valid permits.
Appendix A: Compliance Study
Methodology
There were several different variables used to determine whether the outdoor advertising signs
surveyed fell into compliance with local, state, and federal signage regulations. The scope of this study
focused on OADs (outdoor advertising signs or “billboards”) along the I-95 corridor within the City limits;
along I-676, which runs through the heart of the City, and a sampling of signs along the Schuylkill
Expressway (I-76). In total, 183 signs within 660 feet of the highways were photographed, inventoried,
and analyzed for compliance with local, state, and federal laws.
10
See Appendix E
Michael Baker Jr., Inc.. Philadelphia Outdoor Advertising Inventory, as of June 22, 2006. Pennsylvania Department of Transportation:
Harrisburg, 2006.
11
7
The photos and best available address data from the survey were then compared with address
data using Google Maps. The address data was then researched in
the Office of Property Assessment’s (OPA) online database, and an
address was selected from that list based on a) whether or not the
OPA listing stated that the land was being utilized for a billboard, or
b) the closest possible geographical match. Permits for these signs
were then researched, based on the best available address data
found through OPA, utilizing Philadelphia’s Licenses and
Inspections’ online zoning archive. Permits found were then saved
in a file along with photographs taken of the sign during the survey.
Then, five variables were examined to determine the
compliance of these signs with the Highway Beautification Act, as
amended, and with state and local regulations. The variables were:
1. Whether or not a permit for the sign could be located.
2. The total area of the sign face of the billboard. Anything
over 1,200 square feet was considered a violation.
3. The height of the sign above the roadway that it was
Figure 5: Vertical signs like this one
facing. Anything over 25 feet high, from the bottom of the violate the Pennsylvania State
Agreement, which requires sign
sign face to the surface of the road it was facing was
face height to be no higher than 30
considered a violation.
ft. This sign is 60 ft. tall.
4. The spacing between outdoor advertising structures. Any
OAD that was less than 500 feet away from another OAD was considered a violation.
5. Zoning compliance. According to the Highway Beautification Act, OADs can only be located in
areas zoned commercial or industrial. A sign located in any other zoning classification was
considered a violation of the Certification.*
Additionally, signs that were found by the 2006 Baker OAD Inventory to be in violation of one or
more tenants of Philadelphia’s certification and which have not been found to have been corrected in
the intervening 6 years since the study was published, were compared with this study. OADS discovered
during this survey that were not found in the Baker Study were left blank.12
Using the best available parcel information from OPA, the addresses were then entered into
Google Earth, and the distance between signs was measured using the “Ruler” tool. The “Ruler” tool
was also used to measure the size of the top of the sign face, and then proportions were used to
approximate the square footage of the sign face. Signs classified as a size violation were found to be
above the Philadelphia code’s square footage limit of 1,200 square feet. All signs that were classified as
a “distance between OADs” violation were measured to be less than 500 feet apart. Height violations
were also found using proportions from examining photographs. According to the Philadelphia Code
“the bottom edge of any outdoor advertising sign shall not be located more than 25 ft. above the road
12
See Appendix D
8
surface from which the advertising message is visible,” so signs whose bottom edges were obviously
higher than 25 feet above the road surface were categorized as a height violation.13
A list of eighty-nine signs for which permits could not be located on the online database was
then taken to the office of Licenses and Inspections where an examiner was unable to locate the permits
for these signs.
Figure 6: Map showing signs in compliance with the HBA
Figure 7: Map showing compliant AND noncompliant signs
Finally, compliance with zoning was examined using the Office of Property Assessment online
database which lists the zoning for the parcel. As previously mentioned, according to the Highway
Beautification Act and the Philadelphia Code, billboards are only allowed to be erected in areas zoned
commercial or industrial. Billboards found in areas not zoned commercial, industrial, or in some
combination thereof were listed as in violation.
13
American Legal Publishing. The Philadelphia Code. Section 14-905. 10th Edition. 2011. July 19, 2012.
9
Findings
Study Results Dated August 2012
Table 1: Summary of Permits
Permit Research (L&I Online Database) Number of Structures % of Total
No File Found
Permit Found
Permit Questionable*
TOTAL
89
67
27
183
49%
36%
15%
100%
*Permit appears to be revoked, expired, or inconsistent with sign(s) located on parcel
This survey identified 183 sign structures, supporting 331 sign faces. Out of those 183 sign
structures, only 32 were in compliance with all local, state, and federal regulations, and had valid
permits.14 27 signs had some sort of permit, but it was either revoked, expired, difficult to read, or
difficult to discern the sign that the permit belonged to—those permits were categorized as
“questionable.” No permits could be located for the remaining 89 structures.
Table 2: Zoning
Zoning Compliance
Industrial
Commercial
Total In Compliance
Residential
Food Distribution Center
Sports Stadium
Waterfront Redevelopment District
Unknown
Possible Noncompliant Zoning
TOTAL
Number of Structures % of Total
116
38
154
15
3
3
2
6
29
183
63%
21%
84%
8%
2%
2%
1%
3%
16%
100%
Zoning was also analyzed; again, consistent with the Highway Beautification Act of 1965, billboards are
only permitted in areas zoned commercial and industrial, according to the Philadelphia Code. 84% of
the structures were found to comply with zoning regulations, with 16% of the signs being in areas zoned
anything other than commercial or industrial.
14
See Appendix B
10
Table 3: Sizing
Sizing Consistency
Number of Structures % of Total
Area Violation (>1,200 sq ft)
Height Violation (>25 ft)
Outdoor advertising sign face area was
another category that was examined. According
to the Highway Beautification Act, as amended,
sign face area cannot exceed 1,200 square feet
per face; again, the Philadelphia Code is
consistent with the Act on this matter. In this
survey, 11 of the 186 structures were found to
have sign face areas that exceeded 1,200 square
feet. This same table also tabulates signs that
were found to have a sign face that was higher
than 25 feet above the roadway, which is
prohibited in the Philadelphia Zoning Code,
section 14-905.15
11
24
6%
13%
Figure 8: This billboard in South Philadelphia not only exceeds the
maximum sign face area set forth by the HBA, but it also has a
smaller sign attached to the same structure, which violates
Philadelphia signage laws.
Table 4: Spacing
Spacing Consistency
OAD within 500' of Another
Number of Structures % of Total
66
36%
The Highway Beautification Act also stipulates that OADs along an Interstate Highway or Primary
Aid Highway can be no closer than 500 feet apart. The distances between OADs were measured, and 66
structures were found less than 500 feet apart and thus violated the distancing regulations of the
Philadelphia Code
Study Issues
Obtaining Accurate Parcel Address Information
Difficulty in obtaining accurate address data was one of the primary issues of this study. As
previously mentioned, addresses were located first by pinpointing the sign on Google Maps; then,
similar addresses to the one found were researched on the Office of Property Assessment’s online
database. The addresses were then cross checked again with Google Maps for accuracy of location. The
address found to be most accurate was then entered in a master table under “Alternate Address”. This
15
American Legal Publishing. The Philadelphia Code. Section 14-905. 10th Edition. 2011. July 19, 2012.
11
address was used to search for permits on the Department of Licenses and Inspections’ online database.
Although multiple measures were taken to ensure
accuracy, certain parcels were very difficult to locate,
particularly those along railroad right-of-ways or on very
large parcels of industrial land.
Licenses & Inspections Online Database
The online database that the office of Licenses &
Inspections has for searching permits is set up in such a
way that it is difficult to find a permit if the address is not
exact. The search only returns one address at a time, so
Figure 9: This sign at 121 Fairmount Ave sits less than five
unlike the OPA database, it is not possible to find similar
feet away from this residence, which violates the zoning
addresses in an easy way. It is also no longer possible to
requirements of the HBA that billboards not be erected in
search the archives manually as apparently they are now districts zoned for residential use.
stored offsite. As previously mentioned, a list of addresses where permits could not be found was
submitted to L&I for review. But with the inability to cross-check multiple addresses with other
information, it was difficult to search. Also, the permits viewed were scanned hard copies, and many
were torn, faded, or are generally difficult to read. Thus it was difficult to determine which signs they
pertain to - hence the category “Permit Questionable” in Table 1.
Photographing and Cataloging Signs
Signs along railroad right-of-ways, on large parcels, or blocked by buildings, foliage, etc., were
difficult or impossible to safely photograph. The first part of the inventory was done by finding outdoor
advertising signs located along side streets that run parallel to the Interstate Highways. Then, photos
were taken from the highway itself in an attempt to capture any signs that were missed previously.
However, the high speeds and volume of traffic made it difficult to take accurate photos. Therefore, it is
possible that some signs were missed in the inventory due to these difficulties.
Sign Measurement
The size of the OAD sign faces was estimated using the “Ruler” tool in Google Earth to measure
the top width of the sign, and then proportioned out using a frontal photograph. For example, a
standard 1,200 square foot sign face has a face width that is approximately three times the height of
the sign, making for a sign that measures roughly 60’ wide by x 20’ high. Any sign that appeared
significantly over these dimensions was recorded as a size violation; however, it is important to note
that this was a finding based on a best estimate.
Non-conforming Signs
The list of non-compliant signs (Appendix 2) includes a column for the date of the zoning permit,
if found. There are many signs that have no permits.
12
Non-accessory advertising signs built before 1972 were listed as “non-conforming signs.” In other
words, they did not have to adhere to the new regulations, if they had a permit. Based on the
information available, out of 151 non-compliant signs, only 13 were erected prior to 1972.
Non-conforming signs are those signs which are located in areas that no longer allow outdoor
advertising signs. These signs were permitted at the time that they were constructed, but as new laws
were passed, many areas no longer permit advertising signs. These non-conforming signs, according to
the Philadelphia Code, “shall be maintained in good condition,” but “shall not be structurally altered so
as to enlarge or extend the area or height of the sign,” and “shall not be reconstructed if for any reason
it becomes necessary to replace the entire sign.”16
Additionally, constructing a new OAD within 500 feet of a prohibited sign is not allowable under the
code, nor are any changes to the nonconforming sign allowed, including conversion to a digital sign.
Figure 10: This building along the Vine Street Expressway in Center City Philadelphia has
multiple signs on one roof, which violates the spacing requirements of the HBA.
Conclusion and Extension
Based on the results of this study, as well as the City’s actions subsequent to the settlement
agreement reached with Free Speech, LLC, CBS Outdoor Inc., Clear Channel Outdoor, Inc., and HA Steen
Industries in 2005, it appears that the City of Philadelphia has violated its agreement with the
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. The City is bound by this agreement to enforce its laws, which were
originally created to protect the health, safety, and welfare of the City’s residents, as well as preserve
16
American Legal Publishing. The Philadelphia Code. Section 14-905. 10th Edition. 2011. July 30, 2012.
13
Philadelphia’s unique and beautiful natural resources and built environment for the enjoyment of
residents and visitors alike.
In addition, the proposed new signage code regulations to be added to Philadelphia’s newly
enacted zoning code do not address the hundreds of signs covered by the 2005 settlement agreement
that is set to expire in August of 2014. As a result of this study and the proposed new signage code
regulations, as well as the continued obvious violations of the Highway Beautification Act, the Federal
Highway Administration is being asked to perform an audit on the City’s compliance with the HBA.
Furthermore, in November of 2011, University of Pennsylvania graduate Jonathan Snyder
published a groundbreaking study revealing the negative impact of billboards on property values in
neighborhoods and communities. Not only did he find that properties located within 500 feet of a
billboard were worth on an average $30,826 less than their counterparts that were not in close
proximity to outdoor advertising signage, but that homes within a census tract where billboards were
present, even those not within 500 feet of a sign, experienced a decrease of $947 in property value for
every billboard in that tract.17 His research clearly supported the need for complying with sign control
regulations in a way that reaches beyond questions of aesthetics, and touches on an area that is
currently one of the primary concerns of local, state, and national government: economic stability and
prosperity.
Philadelphia has experienced something of a renaissance in the past several decades; however,
these non-complying outdoor advertising signs are a deterrent to further revitalization. In addition, two
years ago, architect and graduate of the University of Pennsylvania Gregory Young conducted a study on
the energy consumption of digital billboards. He found that these signs can consume up to 162,902
kilowatt hours per year. The average U.S. home consumes about 11,040 kilowatts per year. This means
that one digital billboard consumes nearly 15 times the energy of an average home.18 Digital billboards
are increasing in popularity with billboard companies, due to the fact that multiple messages can be
displayed on one sign, and the brightness and movement of the sign attracts more attention than a
regular billboard. If Philadelphia is striving to be the “greenest” city by 2015, the environmental impacts
of these signs must be considered.
There are many cities that prohibit billboards. In doing so, places like Sao Paolo, Brazil and
Houston, Texas have attracted more of the “creative class” and catalyzed additional economic
development in the process. If Philadelphia wants to compete with other cities in the U.S. for people,
jobs, and “creative capital,” it must emphasize the qualities that make Philadelphia such a unique and
wonderful place to live and work, and reject those elements, including illegal billboards, which block the
city’s iconic skyline and make it look more like “Anywhere, USA.”
17
18
Snyder, Jonathan. Beyond Aesthetics: How Billboards Affect Economic Prosperity. Scenic Philadelphia: Philadelphia, 2011.
Young, Gregory. Illuminating the Issues: Digital Signage and Philadelphia’s Green Future. Scenic Philadelphia: Philadelphia, 2010.
14
Figure 11: Billboards blocking the Philadelphia skyline on I-95.
About the Author
Sarah Richards is currently in her second year of the Master of City Planning program in the Graduate
School of Design at the University of Pennsylvania, with a concentration in land use and environmental
planning. She received her Bachelor of Arts from Virginia Commonwealth University in Architectural
History in 2008. This report was made possible by an internship grant provided by the Samuel S. Fels
Fund.
15
Appendix A: List of Compliant Signs
Address
Board ID
99 E. Laurel St.
CBS
ID #
1005 Germantown Ave. Steen
1513 N. Delaware Ave. CBS
Side Structure
165 s 2 Single Pole
Facing Property Owner
I-95
Lawrence M Krain Assoc.
BRT
57171500
121.1
2 Single Pole
I-95
Steen, Anita & Terry L
884588970
178
2 Roof of
building
2 Single Pole
I-95
Dekap Properties LP
884342827
I-95
Berry and Homer Inc.
884104900
2035 Richmond St.
?
2801 E Ann St.
Steen
147.4
2 Single Pole
I-95
Petraccio, Joseph F
884670600
2905 E. Ontario St.
Clear Channel
41443
2 Single Pole
I-95
Pak Safe Industries Inc.
884838200
2840 E. Tioga St.
Clear Channel
2 Single Pole
I-95
Kingston Street Assoc.
884191607
2673 Salmon St.
CBS
I-95
2663 Partnerships Limited
884346495
2415 Salmon St.
Clear Channel
2 Six Pole
Structure
2 Single Pole
I-95
Port Richmond LLC I
882086204
I-95
I-95
Third Federal Bank
Steen, Terry L
884018964
451092920
10122
2 Single Pole
2 Quadruple
Pole
2 Single Pole
I-95
Garonski, Vincent
884196655
2 Roof of
2 building
Roof of
I-95
Power Plant Productions
882307400
30040
I-95
Landmark One
884020005
41571
building
2 Single Pole
I-76
Procacci, Teresa
884149100
40132
2 Single Pole
I-76
Procacci, Teresa
884149100
10100
2 Roof of
building
2 Single
Pole
I-95
I-95
Goldenberg Assoc. LP
Rollins Outdoor
Advertising
Inc. L
Cantor, Richard
882055305
885061700
1141 N. Delaware Ave. ?
3610 E. Allen St.
Steen
2752 E. Butler St.
Clear Channel
227 N. 2nd St.
CBS
413 N. 2nd St.
Clear Channel
n/a
?
181
41381
n/a
131.3
?
2914 S. Front St.
Clear Channel
3098 S. Front St.
Clear Channel
31 Snyder Ave.
6209 Tacony St.
CBS
Clear Channel
6245 Tacony St.
6201 Keystone St.
Clear Channel
Clear Channel
41411
10101
2 Roof of
2 building
Single Pole
I-95
I-95
7023 State Rd.
Clear Channel
30020
2 Single Pole
I-95
Robbins Ave Center
Associates
Commonwealth of PA
DOT
B & B Foundry Inc
?
6101 Keystone St.
Clear Channel
10104
2 Single Pole
I-95
5590 James St.
Clear Channel
10113
2 Single Pole
I-95
5500 James St.
CBS
?
5101 Cottman Ave.
Clear Channel
?
8322 State Rd.
Keystone
?
1 Roof of
building
2 Roof of
2 building
Single Pole
8362 State Rd.
Keystone
206
8418 State Rd.
Clear Channel
8486 State Rd.
Clear Channel
71 Moore St.
Liberty Outdoor ?
3660 S. Lawrence St.
Clear Channel
2501 E. Bristol St.
CBS
884803900
882058100
412465200
884803700
453429820
I-95
Garbon, Anthony &
Shirley
City of Philadelphia
I-95
Gottesman, Ted
884936200
I-95
High Bay Owner SPE LLC
884262010
2 Single Pole
I-95
884262562
10074
2 Single Pole
I-95
10071
2 Single Pole
I-95
A Partnership & JRM
Developers
Shaughnessy, Mary &
William F
Shaughnessy, Mary &
2 Single Pole
I-95
William F
1700 Columbus Associates
882055550
2 Single Pole
I-95
PIDC Financing Corp.
884154000
2 Double Pole
I-95
Holy Redeemer Cemetery
777067010
41582
07523A
652400105
885079600
885079600
16
Appendix B: List of Signs with One or More Violations
Address
Board ID
ID #
334 N. Front St.
Steen
n/a
408 N. Front St.
Clear Channel
501 N. Front St.
Steen
n/a
501 N. Front St.
Steen
n/a
111 Brown St.
Steen
121 Fairmount Ave. Steen
1024 Leopard St.
Sides Structure
1 Triple Pole
I-95
C3
2 Single Pole
I-95
C3
2 Single Pole
I-95
C4
2 Single Pole
I-95
C4
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
1 Triple Pole
I-95
R10A
938
2 Single Pole
I-95
78.6
1 Double Pole I-95
10148
119.2
n/a
CBS
1009 Frankford Ave. Clear Channel
Facing Zoning Property Owner
Steen, Anita &
Terry L
QRed LLC
BRT
Permit? < 500 s.f. from Sign Face Over 25 ft
over 1,200 above
Y/N
Another Sign s.f.
roadway
884980510 n
y
n
n
55016400 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
n
n
n
?
?
884019032 ?
n
n
y
?
?
55174600 n
y
n
y
n/a
n/a
55161210 y
y
n
n
L5
57178330 n
n
n
n
G2
Steen, Anita &
884961819 y
y
n
n
884961819 ?
y
n
n
?
?
884961819 ?
y
n
n
?
?
884587220 y
y
n
n
884961822 y
y
n
n
884961836 n
y
n
n
Terry L
Steen, Anita &
Terry L
Steen, Anita &
Terry L
Kissling Realty Co
1973
G2
1009 Frankford Ave. Clear Channel n/a
1 Triple Pole
I-95
G2
147 Richmond St.
2 Triple Pole
I-95
G2
1 Roof of
building
1 Roof of
building
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
I-95
G2
I-95
G2
Steen, Anita &
Terry L
Frankford Ave.
Properties Inc.
Steen, Anita &
181308400 y
n
n
y
882929817 y
y
n
n
110 E. Wildey St.
Clear Channel n/a
365 Richmond St.
Steen
n/a
n/a
205228
n/a
1982
I-95
1077 Frankford Ave. Clear Channel n/a
n/a
884019032 ?
1 Triple Pole
10144
Permit #
Cold Storage
Co/Phila
Warehousing
Cold Storage
Co/Phila
Warehousing
Vanderwende,
Russell J
Steen, Anita &
Terry L
Pignetti, Gianni
1009 Frankford Ave. Clear Channel n/a
Clear Channel
Year Permit
Issued (if
applicable)
n/a
302213
1970
180400
1972
198896
n/a
1970
180974
1973
n/a
I-95
G2
I-95
G2
Conboy, James
884019050 n
y
n
n
n/a
207412
n/a
I-95
G2
Conboy, James
884019050 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
169
1 Roof of
building
1 Side of
building
1 Side of
building
2 Single Pole
Terry L
United Pirates LLC
I-95
G2
Calabrese, Edward
884456241 n
n
n
y
n/a
n/a
10141
2 Triple Pole
I-95
G2
885049010 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
I-95
G2
884297850 ?
n
n
n
?
?
Steen
127.3
I-95
C2
n
n
n
?
?
Steen
129.2
I-95
C2
882561000 ?
n
n
n
?
?
Clear Channel
10127
2 Triple Pole
I-95
C2
882561000 ?
n
n
y
?
?
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
884190512 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
Clear Channel
10124
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
451123300 y
y
n
n
3417 E. Allen St.
Clear Channel
41491
2 Roof of
I-95
G2
Steen, Anita &
Terry L
Polish American
Assoc.
Polish American
Assoc.
Keiser General
Partnership
Richmond
Holdings LLC
Richmond
251154600 ?
2818 E. Allegheny
Ave.
2814 E. Allegheny
Ave.
2850 E.
Westmoreland St.
3400 E. Allen St.
1 Side of
building
1 Side of
building
2 Single Pole
Columbus Blvd.
Assoc
Weiss, Howard
451123300 n
y
n
n
n/a
407730
n/a
3490 E. Allen St.
Steen
131.1
building
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
451123400 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
2863 Kingston St.
Clear Channel
41051
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
451065201 ?
n
n
n
?
?
2776 Salmon St.
Clear Channel
30028
2 Single Pole
I-95
C1
251186610 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
2502 Salmon St.
?
314042610 ?
n
n
n
?
?
882086204 y
n
n
y
181330100 ?
n
n
n
?
?
884587010 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
923 Frankford Ave.
Clear Channel
10703
13 E. Laurel St.
Clear Channel
97612
13 E. Laurel St.
Clear Channel
97606
939 N. Front St.
CBS
2024 Richmond St.
Clear Channel
2839 Richmond St.
?
2981 Richmond St.
Steen
?
?
n/a
2420 Aramingo Ave. Steen
126.2
1 Roof of
I-95
building
2 Double Pole I-95
R10A
623 E. Wildey St.
Clear Channel
30023
2 Single Pole
I-95
R10A
1588 N. Delaware
Ave.
Clear Channel
30024
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
G2
Holdings LLC
Richmond
Holdings LLC
City of
Philadelphia
Keenan, James
Carlin Miles A
Etux
Port Richmond LLC
I
Derkotch, Wayne
C
Commonwealth
of PA DOT
1995
2010
284961
17
Appendix B Continued
Address
Board ID
2950 Castor Ave.
Clear Channel
41512
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
2749 Wheatsheaf Ln. Clear Channel
41031
2 Single Pole
I-95
R9A
2617 Wheatsheaf Ln. Clear Channel
41322
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
4035 Aramingo Ave. Clear Channel
97849
G2
10725
4 Single Pole
Stacked
2 Triple Pole
I-95
4271 Aramingo Ave. Clear Channel
I-95
G2
n/a
1 Roof of
I-95
?
building
2 Roof of
2839 Richmond St.
?
ID #
Sides Structure
Facing Zoning Property Owner
PIDC Financing
Corp.
Commonwealth
of PA DOT
Rispo,
James Sr.
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
Commonwealth
of PA DOT
Ermel, Donald R
786019725 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884847595 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
G2
Weiss, Howard
884297850 ?
n
y
n
?
?
I-95
C3
Philadelphia
771034500 y
n
n
y
building
3 Single Pole
I-95
C3
884441412 n
n
108165
n/a
I-95
C3
884450111 n
n
y (one
n
sign face
n
y
n/a
2 Single Pole
n/a
n/a
2 Six Pole
Structure
2 Single Pole
I-95
R10
884449307 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
I-95
G2
Veterans MUL
Second and Race
Sts LP
Klawitter,
Deborah
Steen, Anita &
Terry L
ALDI Inc
882054500 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
2 Single Pole
Stacked
2 Roof of
building
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
Mannepuli, Giri B
882731200 y
y
n
n
I-95
LR
882682190 y
y
n
n
I-95
G2
882682185 ?
y
n
n
?
?
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
Lucidonio,
Nicholas
26 E Oregon Ave.
LP
Paladinetti, Frank
882055050 n
n
y
n
n/a
n/a
884140610 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884781502 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884135716 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
884780900 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
884139061 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
882055300 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884213600 n
y
n
y
n/a
n/a
884213605 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
453467300 n
n
n
y
n/a
n/a
884350375 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
885061510 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
882938550 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
882938550 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884212390 y
y
n
n
Steen
212 N. 2nd St
Keystone
247 Wood St.
CBS
728 N. Hancock St.
Steen
?
2603 S. Front St.
CBS
?
2706 S. Front St.
39 E. Oregon Ave.
Clear Channel 093355/
093360
Clear Channel
91345
26 E. Oregon Ave.
Steen
2811 S. Front St.
?
12 E. Oregon Ave.
Clear Channel
10165
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
2573 S. Swanson St. Clear Channel
30042
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
2 Roof of
building
2 Roof of
building
2 Roof of
I-95
G2
I-95
?
I-95
ASC
Devon Oregon
Ave LLC
Leisure Time
Tours Corp
RF Sylk & Hance
Bros.
Stein & Silverman
Family
Tungsten Realty
LLC
Goldenberg
Assoc. LP
Lamson, Michael J
116.1
n/a
13 W. Ritner St.
Steen
20 Wolf St.
Clear Channel
41121
2384 S. Swanson St. Clear Channel
41112
38 Snyder Ave.
?
?
n/a
10112
building
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
4546 Aramingo Ave. ?
135.2
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
4611 Aramingo Ave. Clear Channel
10125
2 Single Pole
I-95
R10A
Haines
Automotive
Service John &
DiJoseph,
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
Lacroix, Tom
Rt 413 LP
4847 Tacony St.
CBS
2200 Carver St.
Clear Channel
41302
2 Single Pole
I-95
REC
5382 Tacony St.
Clear Channel
10116
2 Single Pole
I-95
?
5376 Tacony St.
Clear Channel
10120
2 Single Pole
I-95
?
5701 Tacony St.
Clear Channel
97857
2 Single Pole
I-95
LR
CBS
6064 Tacony St.
Clear Channel
?
41042
1963
1983
4501 Aramingo Ave. Clear Channel
5701 Tacony St.
Permit? < 500 s.f. from Sign Face Over 25 ft Year Permit Permit #
over 1,200 above
Issued (if
Y/N
Another Sign s.f.
roadway applicable)
884192855 y
n
n
y
1970 180713
786573800 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884841710 n
213 N. 4th St.
131
BRT
2 Single Pole
I-95
LR
2 Single Pole
I-95
R9
Interstate
Outdoor
Advertising
Inc
Arsenal
Associates
Arsenal
Associates
Dietz & Watson
Inc.
Dietz & Watson
Inc.
Tacony Dean LLC
312537
1965
12985
?
1998
884212390 ?
y
n
n
411120500 y
n
n
n
?
?
?
1970
4925 Van Kirk St.
Clear Channel
10106
I-95
G2
30094
1 Roof of
building
2 Single Pole
I-95
C7
Olesniewicz,
Elizabeth & Jerry
Craig, Kathleen &
6301 Keystone St.
Clear Channel
6341 Keystone St.
Clear Channel
10105
1 Single Pole
I-95
C7
Thomas
6341 Keystone
Realty LP
884802000 y
y
n
n
882665500 y
y
n
n
882280000 y
y
n
n
1967
143775
1989
370271
?
2003
18
Appendix B Continued
Address
Board ID
ID #
Sides Structure
Facing Zoning Property Owner
6400 Keystone St.
CBS
?
2 Triple Pole
I-95
C2
Mui, Tony & Victor
?
1 Single Pole
I-95
C2
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
Commonwealth
of PA DOT
Kaufman, Virginia
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
2 Six Pole
Structure
2 Single Pole
Stacked
1 Roof of
building
1 Roof of
building
2 Double Pole
I-95
G2
I-95
C2
I-95
G2
I-95
L3
I-95
L3
Sentenari, Janet &
Peter
Brenntag
Specialties Inc
Emmess
Associates Ltd
Emmess
BRT
Permit? < 500 s.f. from Sign Face Over 25 ft Year Permit
over 1,200 above
Issued (if
Y/N
Another Sign s.f.
roadway applicable)
411171710 ?
n
n
n
Permit #
1960
7100 Wissinoming St. ?
6918 State Rd.
Clear Channel
6612 New State Rd.
Keystone
6736 New State Rd.
Clear Channel
6701 State Rd
5700 Tacony St.
Clear Channel 097527/
097526
Clear Channel
10108
7332 Milnor St.
Clear Channel
7360 Milnor St.
CBS
5135 Bleigh Ave.
CBS
5014 Bleigh Ave.
Clear Channel
10093
?
41402
10090
?
y
y
n
884804410 y
n
n
y
& William C
NF 6601 New
884179500 n
n
n
n
n/a
714833
n/a
State Rd PA
Hull Bros Inc
884804600 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
882923386 y
y
n
n
884213400 n
n
n
n
n/a
342491
n/a
651329900 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
651329900 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
884252506 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
1961
1986
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
Associates Ltd
Northeast
10085
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
Properties Inc
SPS Holdings LP
651324910 n
n
n
n
137.3
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
Commonwealth
884938100 y
y
n
y
884257530 n
n
n
n
n/a
129613
n/a
884257540 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884253510 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884262550 ?
n
n
n
?
?
884462990 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884262550 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884263425 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884263425 y
y
n
n
884263590 y
y
n
n
882898220 ?
n
n
n
?
?
884260030 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884260000 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
885079600 ?
y
n
n
?
?
885079600 ?
y
n
n
?
?
884001007 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884001900 y
n
n
y
884781540 n
n
y
n
n/a
375836
n/a
?
7132 Wissinoming St. Steen
438449
651004600 n
2 Single Pole
I-95
WRD
10070
2 Single Pole
I-95
WRD
41102
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
?
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
?
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
I-95
G2
?
2 Six Pole
Structure
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
8800 State Rd.
Clear Channel ?
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
8900 State Rd.
CBS
?
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
9430 State Rd.
Steen
?
2 Single Pole
I-95
R13
8825 Torresdale Ave. Clear Channel ?
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
8700 Torresdale Ave. Steen
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
2 Six Pole
Structure
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
I-95
G2
1100 S. Christopher Clear Channel ?
Columbus Blvd.
1530 S. Christopher Clear Channel
41351
Columbus
Blvd.
12
E. Oregon
Ave.
Clear Channel
10161
2 Single Pole
I-95
C3
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
of PA DOT
Churchill
Commercial
Churchill
Residential
Development
12th
& Wood LP
Associates
PIDC Financing
Corp.
Bell Telephone Co
of PA
PIDC Financing
Corp.
Ruball Associates
LLC
Ruball Associates
LLC
Waskiewicz Group
LLC
Punjab Properties
LLC
Wolf Investment
Corp 7
Wolf Investment
Corp Numb
Shaughnessy,
Mary & William F
Shaughnessy,
Mary & William F
Riverview
Development Co
1530 Delaware
Associates
Driscoll, James C
7 Pattison Ave.
CBS
2 Single Pole
I-95
LR
& Michael J
BDB Company
884351455 ?
n
n
n
?
?
7 Pattison Ave.
Clear Channel
2 Single Pole
I-95
LR
BDB Company
884351455 ?
n
n
n
?
?
7 Pattison Ave.
CBS
?
2 Single Pole
I-95
LR
BDB Company
884351455 ?
n
n
n
?
?
10 Pattison Ave.
CBS
?
2 Single Pole
I-95
LR
781401601 n
y
y
n
n/a
n/a
10 Pattison Ave.
CBS
?
2 Double Pole I-95
LR
City of
Philadelphia
City of
Philadelphia
781401601 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
7777 State Rd.
CBS
7777 State Rd.
Clear Channel
4992 Rhawn St.
Clear Channel
8354 State Rd.
CBS
8382 State Rd.
CBS
8360 State Rd.
Clear Channel
8730 State Rd.
CBS
8408 State Rd.
Clear Channel
8408 State Rd.
Steen
?
10076
?
10073
43
?
30010
1968
1989
380732
2008
1988
164164
19
Appendix B Continued
Address
Board ID
60 Pattison Ave.
Clear Channel
60 Pattison Ave.
Keystone
3658 S. 3rd St.
Clear Channel
3864 S. 11th St.
CBS
3734 S. Darien St.
Clear Channel
3734 S. Darien St.
Clear Channel
1256 Summer St.
Fuel
306 N. 11th St.
Steen
276 N. Juniper St.
ID #
Sides Structure
Facing Zoning Property Owner
41372
2 Single Pole
I-95
LR
226
2 Single Pole
I-95
LR
41641
2 Single Pole
I-95
LR
2 Single Pole
I-95
SS
40122
2 Single Pole
I-95
SS
10174
2 Single Pole
I-95
SS
?
?
Intertrust
Holdings
Intertrust
Holdings
Maglio Bros Inc
Philadelphia Belt
Line RR Co
Philadelphia Belt
Line
RR Co Belt
Philadelphia
Line RR Co
Commonwealth
of PA DOT
Steen, Anita &
Terry L
Centra Associates
BRT
Permit? < 500 s.f. from Sign Face Over 25 ft Year Permit Permit #
over 1,200 above
Issued (if
Y/N
Another Sign s.f.
roadway applicable)
885052610 y
y
n
n
1989 379153
885052610 y
y
n
n
1984 323419
884151087 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884354200 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884354200 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
884354200 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
781645600 n
y
n
y
n/a
n/a
882856210 y
n
n
y
882855200 n
y
n
y
771037500 y
y
n
y
882937830 y
n
n
y
884023300 n
n
n
n
2 Single Pole
I-676
?
186.2
2 Single Pole
I-676
G2
Clear Channel
41521
2 Single Pole
I-676
?
239 N. Broad St.
Clear Channel
1
I-676
C4
1437 Vine St.
Clear Channel 093117/
093118
Interstate
1608
I-676
C4
I-676
G2
The Pennsylvania
Prison Society
Philadelphia
Health & EDU
Telwell Inc
I-676
L4
Kee Corp
884451000 ?
y
y
I-676
L4
Kee Corp
884451000 ?
y
I-676
C3
781182600 n
I-676
L4
Delaware River
Port Authority
TCG Associates LP
56239100 y
439 New St.
CBS
513
501 Callowhill St
Keystone
502
501 Callowhill St
Keystone
501
5 N. 22nd St.
?
?
2400 Market St.
?
?
2951 Arch St.
Clear Channel
30001
1 Roof of
building
2 Roof of
building
1 Side of
building
1 Roof of
building
1 Roof of
building
1 Roof of
building
1 Roof of
building
1 Roof of
building
1 Roof of
building
2 Roof of
building
2 Roof of
building
1 Roof of
building
1 Roof of
building
2 Single Pole
2323 Race St.
Clear Channel
10346
1 Multipole
436 N. 31st St.
Clear Channel
30017
532 N. 31st St.
Steen
532 N. 31st St.
Steen
3200 Mantua Ave.
CBS
3200 Mantua Ave.
CBS
3372 Mantua Ave.
Steen
3372 Mantua Ave.
Steen
2951 Arch St.
Clear Channel
2814 E. Allegheny
Ave. E. Allegheny
2814
Steen
Steen
Ave.
3900 Almond St.
Steen
1202 Vine St.
304 N. Lawrence St. Clear Channel
41481
304 N. Lawrence St. Clear Channel
41481
244 N. Lawrence St. Clear Channel
41502
307 N. Randolph St. Clear Channel
30097
307 N. Randolph St. Clear Channel
10300
Interstate
395848
n/a
1974
214612
1963
n/a
113923
n/a
n
?
?
n
n
?
?
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
y
n
y
?
1946
I-676
L4
TCG Associates LP
56239100 y
y
n
y
?
1946
771198200 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
G2
St. Augustine's RC
Church
YSI II LLC
884028510 ?
y
n
n
?
?
I-676
G2
YSI II LLC
884028510 ?
y
n
n
?
?
I-76
C5
881035600 y
n
y
y
I-76
C4
2121 Market St
Association
MPDC LP
884054000 n
n
y
y
n/a
107057
n/a
I-76
C5
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
RC4
Pennsylvania Econ
Dev
Auth
NM Edgewater
883410400 n
I-676
881555000 n
n
y
n
n/a
n/a
2 Single Pole
I-76
G2
884345052 n
n
y
n
n/a
n/a
9
1 Triple Pole
I-76
G2
JointofVenture
City
Philadelphia
City of
884345052 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
8
1 Triple Pole
I-76
G2
884345052 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
?
1 Double Pole I-76
G2
Philadelphia
City of
Philadelphia
Amtrak
884352425 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
?
1 Double Pole I-76
G2
Amtrak
884352425 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
11
1 Triple Pole
I-76
G2
Amtrak
884352425 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
?
I-676
C3
I-676
1963
12
1 Triple Pole
I-76
G2
Amtrak
884352425 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
30014
2 Triple Pole
I-76
C5
Pennsylvania Econ
883410400 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
127.8
2 Single Pole
2 Single Pole
I-95
I-95
C2
C2
Dev Auth
Polish American
Assoc. American
Polish
882561000 ?
882561000 ?
n
n
n
n
n
n
?
?
?
?
133.1
1 Single Pole
I-95
G2
884847710 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
135
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
884213647 n
y
n
y
n/a
n/a
2 Single Pole
I-95
L4
453067200 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
?
4300 Aramingo Ave. Steen
2493 Orthodox St.
2012
n/a
Assoc.
Port Richmond
Self Storage
Ijan-PA Realty LLC
Choplinsky,
Ronald & Moore,
20
Appendix B Continued
Address
Board ID
5135 Bleigh Ave.
Clear Channel
9215 Keystone St.
Steen
9215 Keystone St.
Steen
ID #
Sides Structure
10082
8215 Torresdale Ave. Clear Channel
Facing Zoning Property Owner
BRT
Permit? < 500 s.f. from Sign Face Over 25 ft
over 1,200 above
Y/N
Another Sign s.f.
roadway
884252505 n
n
n
n
Year Permit
Issued (if
applicable)
n/a
Permit #
884351860 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
45
2 Multipole
I-95
G2
Northeast
Properties Inc
Path Inc
144
2 Multipole
I-95
G2
Path Inc
884351860 n
y
n
n
n/a
n/a
2 Six Pole
Structure
2 Single Pole
I-95
G2
786537201 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
I-95
C3
City of
Philadelphia
United States of
America
United States of
America
United States of
America
United States of
America
United States of
America
United States of
America
City of
Philadelphia
788004001 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
788004001 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
788004001 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
788004001 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
788004001 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
788004001 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
788020600 n
n
n
n
n/a
n/a
30031
3848 S. Broad St.
Interstate
1524
3848 S. Broad St.
Interstate
?
2 Single Pole
I-95
C3
3848 S. Broad St.
Interstate
?
2 Single Pole
I-95
C3
3848 S. Broad St.
Interstate
?
2 Single Pole
I-95
C3
3848 S. Broad St.
Interstate
?
2 Single Pole
I-95
C3
3848 S. Broad St.
Interstate
?
2 Single Pole
I-95
C3
3601 S. Broad St.
Interstate
?
2 Single Pole
I-95
LR
n/a
21
Appendix C: Baker Study Comparison
Address
Alternate Address Baker Study Address
Baker Study Finding Summer 2012 Inventory Finding
334 N. Front St.
408 N. Front St.
501 N. Front St.
501 N. Front St.
334 N Front
420-434 N Front
?
?
SW CORNER FRONT & BROWN,
SE CORNER I-95 @ BROWN ST
121 Fairmount Ave
73R-81 Laurel
73-81 E Laurel St
1003 Germantown Ave
4-18 Richmond St.
?
1011 Frankford Ave
1011 Frankford Ave
1011 Frankford Ave
145-49 Richmond St
145-149 Richmond St
1011 Frankford Ave.
1045-1055 Frankford Ave
1111-1113 Frankford Ave. 1045 Sarah St
320-322 Richmond St.
?
951 Frankford Ave.
1000 Frankford Ave
982-88 N Delaware Ave 1033 N Delaware Ave
982-88 N Delaware Ave 1033 N Delaware Ave
939-41 N Front St
927-31 N Front St
1513 N Delaware Ave
2005 Richmond St
?
2035 Richmond St
2857 Richmond St
?
2928-36 Richmond St
ES I-95, 110' NO ANN ST
2983 Richmond ST
2983 Richmond St
2814-18 Allegheny Ave. ES I-95, 150' SO ALLEGHENY AVE
2814-18 Allegheny Ave. 2804-2808 Allegheny
2825 E Westmoreland St 2901 E Westmoreland
3480 E Allen St.
3400 E Allen St
2905 E Ontario St
3480 E Allen St.
?
?
2839A E Tioga
2839 E Tioga
2865-67 Kingston St.
?
2768 Salmon St.
?
2663-73 Salmon St.
2671-73 Salmon St
2401 Aramingo Ave.
2401-2499 Aramingo
2725 E Cumberland St.
?
2401 Aramingo Ave.
2401-2499 Aramingo
623-25 E Wildey St
S-W CORNER WILDEY & BERKS
1143-51 N Delaware Ave. ?
1532 N Delaware Ave
1522-1532 Delaware Ave
?
2834 E Victoria St.
2834 Victoria St
2748 E Butler St.
2735 E Butler
2701 Wheatsheaf Ln
2702-06 Wheatsheaf Ln
NEC WHEATSHEAF LN, 150' WO I2651 Wheatsheaf Ln
95
4050 Aramingo Ave.
?
505' EO ARAMINGO AVE, 15' NO
4219 Aramingo Ave.
CHURCH ST
2857 Richmond St
?
213-17 N 4th St
?
226-30 N 2nd St
?
205-211 N 2nd
311 N 3rd St.
220-228 Wood St
707 N Hancock St
?
412-26 N 2nd St
?
22 Shunk St
2601 S Front St
80 Oregon Ave.
80 E Oregon Ave
39 E Oregon Ave
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
111 Brown St.
121 Fairmount Ave.
99 E. Laurel St.
1005 Germantown Ave.
1024 Leopard St.
1009 Frankford Ave.
1009 Frankford Ave.
1009 Frankford Ave.
147 Richmond St.
1077 Frankford Ave.
110 E. Wildey St.
365 Richmond St.
923 Frankford Ave.
13 E. Laurel St.
13 E. Laurel St.
939 N. Front St.
1513 N. Delaware Ave.
2024 Richmond St.
2035 Richmond St.
2839 Richmond St.
2801 E Ann St.
2981 Richmond St.
2818 E. Allegheny Ave.
2814 E. Allegheny Ave.
2850 E. Westmoreland St.
3400 E. Allen St.
2905 E. Ontario St.
3417 E. Allen St.
3490 E. Allen St.
2840 E. Tioga St.
2863 Kingston St.
2776 Salmon St.
2673 Salmon St.
2415 Salmon St.
2502 Salmon St.
2420 Aramingo Ave.
623 E. Wildey St.
1141 N. Delaware Ave.
1588 N. Delaware Ave.
2950 Castor Ave.
3610 E Allen St.
2752 E Butler St.
2749 Wheatsheaf Ln.
2617 Wheatsheaf Ln.
4035 Aramingo Ave.
4271 Aramingo Ave.
2839 Richmond St.
213 N. 4th St.
227 N 2nd St.
212 N. 2nd St
247 Wood St.
728 N. Hancock St.
413 N. 2nd St.
2603 S. Front St.
2706 S. Front St.
39 E. Oregon Ave.
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Permit Questionable
Permit Questionable; Height Violation
Spacing Violation
Zoning Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation; Height Violation
Zoning Violation
Compliant Sign
Compliant Sign
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation; Permit Questionable
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation; Permit Questionable
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation; Permit Questionable
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation; No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Height Violation
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation; No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation: No Permit Found
Compliant Structure
Height Violation; No Permit Found
Compliant Structure
Compliant Sign
No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Compliant Sign
Permit Questionable
Only Permit # Provided
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
Permit Questionable
Only Permit # Provided
Permit Questionable
Spacing Violation
Permit Questionable
Spacing Violation
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Size Violation with Permit Compliant Sign
Permit Questionable
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
Compliant Sign
Zoning Violation; Permit Questionable
Spacing Violation
Height Violation
Spacing Violation
Zoning Violation; Permit Questionable
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation; No Permit Found
Height Violation
Compliant Structure
Compliant Sign
Compliant Structure
Compliant Sign
Compliant Structure
Zoning Violation
Compliant Structure
No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
No Permit Found
Size Violation; Permit Questionable
Height Violation
Compliant Sign
Size Violation; No Permit Found
Height Violation
Zoning Violation; No Permit Found
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation; No Permit Found
Spacing Violation; No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
Compliant Structure
Compliant Structure
Permit Revoked
Compliant Structure
Compliant Structure
22
Address
Alternate Address Baker Study Address
26 E. Oregon Ave.
2811 S. Front St.
2914 S. Front St.
3098 S. Front St.
12 E. Oregon Ave.
2573 S. Swanson St.
13 W. Ritner St.
20 Wolf St.
2384 S. Swanson St.
38 Snyder Ave.
31 Snyder Ave.
2805-09 S Front
3051 S Front St
3051 S Front St
10 Oregon Ave.
2431 S Swanson St
16 Ritner St
22 Wolf St
2351 S Swanson St
30-48 Snyder Ave.
31-49 Snyder Ave.
?
?
3333 S Front St
3333 S Front St
12 Oregon Ave
2501 S Swanson St
?
22 E Wolf
2300-2348 S Swanson
?
?
4501 Aramingo Ave.
4546 Aramingo Ave.
4533 Aramingo Ave
4501 Aramingo Ave
4533 Aramingo Ave
4611 Aramingo Ave.
4847 Tacony St.
2200 Carver St.
5382 Tacony St.
5376 Tacony St.
5701 Tacony St.
5701 Tacony St.
4624 Aramingo
4853 James St
5601 Tacony St.
5301 Tacony St.
5301 Tacony St.
6064 Tacony St.
6209 Tacony St.
6245 Tacony St.
4925 Van Kirk St.
6301 Keystone St.
6201 Keystone St.
6341 Keystone St.
6400 Keystone St.
7100 Wissinoming St.
7023 State Rd.
6918 State Rd.
6612 New State Rd.
6736 New State Rd.
6701 State Rd
6101 Keystone St.
5700 Tacony St.
5590 James St.
5500 James St.
7332 Milnor St.
5000 Comly St
6201 Tacony St.
6241 Tacony St.
7360 Milnor St.
5135 Bleigh Ave.
5014 Bleigh Ave.
5101 Cottman Ave.
7132 Wissinoming St.
7777 State Rd.
7777 State Rd.
4992 Rhawn St.
8322 State Rd.
8354 State Rd.
8362 State Rd.
8382 State Rd.
8360 State Rd.
7390 Milnor St
8418 State Rd.
8486 State Rd.
8730 State Rd.
8800 State Rd.
8900 State Rd.
9430 State Rd.
8825 Torresdale Ave.
8700 Torresdale Ave.
8408 State Rd.
8408 State Rd.
8400 State Rd
8400 State Rd
8800 State Rd
4900 Levick St.
5013 Princeton Ave
6918-20 State Rd
6700 New State Rd
5021-23 Unruh St
5622R Tacony St
9201R Eadom St
7390 Milnor St
7385-87 Melrose St
7128-32 Wissinoming St
7777R State Rd
8320-40 State Rd
8354-58 State Rd
8362-80 State Rd
8382-98 State Rd
8354-58 State Rd
9430-36 State Rd
8801 Torresdale Ave
8701 Torresdale Ave
8400 State Rd
8400 State Rd
?
4851-83 James St
5600 Tacony St
?
?
5701 Tacony St
5701 Tacony St
PARCEL OF LAND BETWEEN VAN
KIRK & COMLY AND PA RR &
DELAWARE EXPRESSWAY
6201 Tacony St
?
4925 Van Kirk St
6301 Keystone St
6201 Keystone St
?
6401 Keystone
5015 Princeton Ave
7029 State Rd
6900 State Rd
6601 New State Rd
?
5021-23 Unruh St
6101 Keystone St
5701 Tacony St
?
?
7340 Milnor St
SWC OF BLEIGH AVE & MILNOR
ST
NEC MILNOR ST & BLEIGH ST
7373-75 Melrose St
5101 Cottman Ave
7146 Wissinoming St
7777 State Rd
7777 State Rd
4901 Rhawn St
?
8362 State Rd
8362 State Rd
?
?
1625' SO ASHBURNER ST, 700'
WO STATE RD
?
8820 State Rd
8820 State Rd
8900 State Rd
?
8801-8837 Torresdale Ave
?
?
?
Baker Study Finding Summer 2012 Inventory Finding
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Compliant Structure
Compliant Structure
Spacing Violation
Compliant Structure
Spacing Violation; Permit Questionable
Size Violation; No Permit Found
Compliant Sign
Compliant Sign
No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation; No Permit Found
Spacing Violation: No Permit Found
Spacing Violation; No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation; Height Violation; No
Permit Found
Spacing Violation; No Permit Found
Height Violation; Zoning Violation; No
Permit Found
Spacing Violation
Zoning Violation; No Permit Found
No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Zoning Violation
Compliant Sign
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
More signs on structure thanPermit
specified
Questionable
in permit
Size Violation
Size Violation; Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
Height Violation
Permit Revoked
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation; No Permit Found
Compliant Structure
Spacing Violation
Compliant Structure
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
No Permit Found
Compliant Sign
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Compliant Structure
Compliant Structure
Compliant Structure
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
Zoning Violation; No Permit Found
Zoning Violation; No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Compliant Sign
Permit Questionable
Compliant Sign
No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
Compliant Sign
Compliant Sign
Size Violation with Permit No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Zoning Violation; Permit Questionable
Spacing Violation
No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation; Permit Questionable
Spacing Violation; Permit Questionable
23
Address
Alternate Address Baker Study Address
26 E. Oregon Ave.
2811 S. Front St.
2914 S. Front St.
3098 S. Front St.
12 E. Oregon Ave.
2573 S. Swanson St.
13 W. Ritner St.
20 Wolf St.
2384 S. Swanson St.
38 Snyder Ave.
31 Snyder Ave.
2805-09 S Front
3051 S Front St
3051 S Front St
10 Oregon Ave.
2431 S Swanson St
16 Ritner St
22 Wolf St
2351 S Swanson St
30-48 Snyder Ave.
31-49 Snyder Ave.
?
?
3333 S Front St
3333 S Front St
12 Oregon Ave
2501 S Swanson St
?
22 E Wolf
2300-2348 S Swanson
?
?
4501 Aramingo Ave.
4546 Aramingo Ave.
4533 Aramingo Ave
4501 Aramingo Ave
4533 Aramingo Ave
4611 Aramingo Ave.
4847 Tacony St.
2200 Carver St.
5382 Tacony St.
5376 Tacony St.
5701 Tacony St.
5701 Tacony St.
4624 Aramingo
4853 James St
5601 Tacony St.
5301 Tacony St.
5301 Tacony St.
6064 Tacony St.
6209 Tacony St.
6245 Tacony St.
4925 Van Kirk St.
6301 Keystone St.
6201 Keystone St.
6341 Keystone St.
6400 Keystone St.
7100 Wissinoming St.
7023 State Rd.
6918 State Rd.
6612 New State Rd.
6736 New State Rd.
6701 State Rd
6101 Keystone St.
5700 Tacony St.
5590 James St.
5500 James St.
7332 Milnor St.
5000 Comly St
6201 Tacony St.
6241 Tacony St.
7360 Milnor St.
5135 Bleigh Ave.
5014 Bleigh Ave.
5101 Cottman Ave.
7132 Wissinoming St.
7777 State Rd.
7777 State Rd.
4992 Rhawn St.
8322 State Rd.
8354 State Rd.
8362 State Rd.
8382 State Rd.
8360 State Rd.
7390 Milnor St
8418 State Rd.
8486 State Rd.
8730 State Rd.
8800 State Rd.
8900 State Rd.
9430 State Rd.
8825 Torresdale Ave.
8700 Torresdale Ave.
8408 State Rd.
8400 State Rd
8400 State Rd
8800 State Rd
4900 Levick St.
5013 Princeton Ave
6918-20 State Rd
6700 New State Rd
5021-23 Unruh St
5622R Tacony St
9201R Eadom St
7390 Milnor St
7385-87 Melrose St
7128-32 Wissinoming St
7777R State Rd
8320-40 State Rd
8354-58 State Rd
8362-80 State Rd
8382-98 State Rd
8354-58 State Rd
9430-36 State Rd
8801 Torresdale Ave
8701 Torresdale Ave
8400 State Rd
?
4851-83 James St
5600 Tacony St
?
?
5701 Tacony St
5701 Tacony St
PARCEL OF LAND BETWEEN VAN
KIRK & COMLY AND PA RR &
DELAWARE EXPRESSWAY
6201 Tacony St
?
4925 Van Kirk St
6301 Keystone St
6201 Keystone St
?
6401 Keystone
5015 Princeton Ave
7029 State Rd
6900 State Rd
6601 New State Rd
?
5021-23 Unruh St
6101 Keystone St
5701 Tacony St
?
?
7340 Milnor St
SWC OF BLEIGH AVE & MILNOR
ST
NEC MILNOR ST & BLEIGH ST
7373-75 Melrose St
5101 Cottman Ave
7146 Wissinoming St
7777 State Rd
7777 State Rd
4901 Rhawn St
?
8362 State Rd
8362 State Rd
?
?
1625' SO ASHBURNER ST, 700'
WO STATE RD
?
8820 State Rd
8820 State Rd
8900 State Rd
?
8801-8837 Torresdale Ave
?
?
Baker Study Finding Summer 2012 Inventory Finding
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Compliant Structure
Compliant Structure
Spacing Violation
Compliant Structure
Spacing Violation; Permit Questionable
Size Violation; No Permit Found
Compliant Sign
Compliant Sign
No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation; No Permit Found
Spacing Violation: No Permit Found
Spacing Violation; No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation; Height Violation; No
Permit Found
Spacing Violation; No Permit Found
Height Violation; Zoning Violation; No
Permit Found
Spacing Violation
Zoning Violation; No Permit Found
No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Zoning Violation
Compliant Sign
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
More signs on structure thanPermit
specified
Questionable
in permit
Size Violation
Size Violation; Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
Height Violation
Permit Revoked
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation; No Permit Found
Compliant Structure
Spacing Violation
Compliant Structure
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
No Permit Found
Compliant Sign
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Compliant Structure
Compliant Structure
Compliant Structure
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Compliant Sign
Spacing Violation
Zoning Violation; No Permit Found
Zoning Violation; No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Compliant Sign
Permit Questionable
Compliant Sign
No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
Compliant Sign
Compliant Sign
Size Violation with Permit No Permit Found
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Spacing Violation
Zoning Violation; Permit Questionable
Spacing Violation
No Permit Found
No Permit Found
Spacing Violation; Permit Questionable
24
Appendix D: PennDOT Agreement with the FHA
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
Appendix E: Certification of the City of Philadelphia to Enforce Pennsylvania Regulations
36
Appendix F: Map of Interstate and Federal-Aid Primary Highway System (Source: Penn DOT)
37