Center for Research on Women Examining Issues of Gender and Social Inequality Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women CONTENTS Prepared By: Ace F. Madjlesi, M.A. Sarah Hoover Lynda M. Sagrestano, Ph.D. Ruthbeth Finerman, Ph.D. Joy Clay, Ph.D. Published by: Center for Research on Women 337 Clement Hall Memphis, TN 38152 901-678-2770 [email protected] www.memphis.edu/crow April 2014 Layout and Design by: Mindy Schaper and Ace F. Madjlesi Introduction.....................................................................................................................3 Description of Program................................................................................................4 Description of Participants.......................................................................................... 6 Case Study: Alisa............................................................................................................ 7 Evaluation Findings and Recommendations Mechanisms of Service Delivery Individualized Support...................................................................................8 Peer Support.....................................................................................................9 Case Study: Paul...........................................................................................................10 Material Support............................................................................................. 11 Case Study: Simone..................................................................................................... 12 Referrals..............................................................................................................13 Goals of Service Delivery Healthcare.........................................................................................................14 Education......................................................................................................... 15 Parenting...........................................................................................................17 Case Study: Calvin........................................................................................................18 External Challenges................................................................................................. 19 Implementation Challenges..................................................................................20 Recommendations for Program Sustainability................................................21 Appendices Appendix A: Summary of Research Methods.................................................. 22 Appendix B: Summary of Tracking Data Extracted from ShelbyConnect...................................................................................23 Appendix C: Summary of Housing, Transportation, and Food Security Survey Data........................................................................................26 Appendix D: Summary of Interview Data.......................................................... 30 Appendix E: Summary of Focus Group Data....................................................33 References...................................................................................................................... 35 Acknowledgements: The Center for Research on Women would like to thank the numerous individuals whose help was integral to our work. Most importantly, we wish to thank the pregnant and parenting teens as well as the service providers and administrators who participated in this study. We would also like to acknowledge the tremendous community contribution made by the tireless efforts of Success Coaches funded by this project. Special thanks to Lydia Walker, Johnnie Hatten, Connie Booker, Janon Wilson-Wilbourn, and Tameka Daniel for facilitating data collection. Thanks also to Tiffany Lewis and Charlie Caswell at Rangeline CDC for providing pictures for this report. This project is funded by the US Department of Health and Human Services Office of Adolescent Health, Grant # SP1AH000018-02-00, through the State of Tennessee Department of Maternal Child Health. 2 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women INTRODUCTION Adolescent pregnancy significantly impacts the educational attainment, economic security, and well-being of teen parents and their children (Hoffman & Maynard, 2008). In 2009, over 15% of all Shelby County births were delivered by women under the age of 19, totaling an estimated public cost of $10,179,826 (Ciscel, 2011). In addition to its prevalence, teen pregnancy has demonstrable longitudinal effects on a woman’s ability to achieve economic security (Hoffman & Maynard, 2008) and contributes to systemic issues related to poverty in Shelby County (Ciscel, 2011). Eliminating teen pregnancy presents a complex challenge for any community. However, due to its documented economic significance to individuals, families, and society at large, this goal should remain a priority for Shelby County to systematically address. In 2011, Tennessee was one of 17 states that received funding from the US Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Adolescent Health to design, implement, and evaluate a program aimed at supporting and improving outcomes for pregnant and parenting teens. The resulting project, Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success (branded as Teen+, based on input from local teens), was coordinated by the Shelby County Office of Early Childhood and Youth (SCOECY) and designed to be a system of care that connected schools, faith-based organizations, healthcare facilities, and social service providers. The success of Teen+ was to be facilitated by ShelbyConnect, an electronic shared-data system that would allow Success Coaches (social workers employed through various grantee agencies to work directly with teen participants) to make seamless referrals, thus creating a continuum of care for teen parents across Shelby County. Primary goals of the grant included improved health, educational, and parenting outcomes for Teen+ participants. As part of this initiative, The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women (CROW) was tasked with first conducting a preliminary needs assessment that would inform the design of the system of care, followed by an outcome evaluation after Year 3, based on data entered into the ShelbyConnect system by grantee partners. Several barriers to implementation of the shared data system emerged throughout the project, making an outcome evaluation at the end of Year 3 unfeasible. Instead, this evaluation includes a summary of the data available in ShelbyConnect as of December 2013, but relies on the primary qualitative and quantitative data collected by CROW, with a special emphasis on programming recommendations that can be used to strengthen Teen+ in Year 4. The outcome evaluation using data from ShelbyConnect will be the focus of a report addendum to be completed at the end of Year 4, pending resolution of challenges to the shared data system. Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 3 The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women DESCRIPTION OF PROGRAM Administered by the Shelby County Office of Early Childhood and Youth (SCOECY), and facilitated by local consultants from Consilience Group, LLC, the Teen+ implementation team included multiple agencies with Success Coaches and/or Baby Stores. Agencies and individual Success Coaches recruited pregnant and parenting teens, and the program was advertised publicly throughout Shelby County. Teens could contact an agency directly or contact the SCOECY to be assigned to a provider. Teens who were enrolled in the Memphis City Schools worked with on-site Success Coaches dedicated to Teen+ (see Diagram 1), whereas teens who were not in school worked with Success Coaches through one of four community-based partners (see Diagram 2): AGAPE Child & Family Services, Cathedral of Faith, Rangeline CDC, or South Memphis Alliance. Success Coaches worked directly with teens to provide case management services and identify individually tailored needs and goals. In addition to entering a Teen+ participant’s demographic and household information into the ShelbyConnect system, Success Coaches entered needs and made referrals across agencies registered on ShelbyConnect. As teens completed specific tasks demonstrated to contribute to goal-centered success (e.g., receiving prenatal care, attending parenting classes, maintaining good grades), they earned points which could then be used in Baby Stores to purchase items for their children (e.g., bottles, diapers, clothing, strollers). Baby Stores were administered by several community partners, including Cathedral of Faith, Hickory Hill Community Redevelopment Corporation, Rangeline CDC, South Memphis Alliance, and Impact Baptist Ministries. Teen+ also convened a teen advisory committee that provided teenbased feedback on the system of care, helped develop the name and recruitment materials, and helped to plan a large community-based event open to all Teen+ participants, which drew over 250 teens and raised awareness of the Teen+ system of care in the community. Very importantly, the various services and agencies participating in Teen+ were linked through a “continuum of care” principle. The continuum of care component focused on the VanDenBerg or “wraparound” process, which is characterized by an individualized, needs-driven, and family-centered approach to community-based service provision, and relies on cooperation among multiple agencies and stakeholders (VanDenBerg, Bruns, & Burchard, 2008). This principle was agreed to by all partner agencies, who went through extensive training on providing services using this model. 4 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 5 The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women DESCRIPTION OF PARTICIPANTS The CROW evaluation team coded and analyzed data entered by Success Coaches into the ShelbyConnect system. A full analysis of this data can be found in Appendix B. As of December 2013, 603 client records were input into the ShelbyConnect system. Although participant records were often incomplete (i.e., missing items), a review of ShelbyConnect records reveals some information about the Teen+ participant population. Demographics The majority of Teen+ participants (89%) were girls and 92% of participants were African American. The average age of participants in 2013 was almost 18 years old. The majority of Teen+ participants with data in ShelbyConnect were served by Memphis City Schools (70%; with consolidation, now Shelby County Schools). This was followed by Cathedral of Faith (15%), AGAPE (14%), and South Memphis Alliance (1%). Educational Attainment The majority of Teen+ participants with data in ShelbyConnect were enrolled in school (83%), whereas 11% were not enrolled in school. Of the 603 cases in ShelbyConnect, 3% were reported as enrolled in elementary or middle school, 59% were in high school, 5% had a high school diploma, and 1% had completed some college. Pregnancy and Parenting Overview Of the 603 Teen+ cases entered into ShelbyConnect, 42% were pregnant at the time of enrollment in Teen+, and 57% were parents at the time of enrollment. The majority of parenting teens (n=344) in Teen+ had one child (69%) and 8% had two children. Almost all of the pregnant participants in the program reported receiving prenatal care (93%). The ShelbyConnect system included birth outcomes data reported by parenting teens, as well as some data for pregnant teens that gave birth while working with a Success Coach. Overall, birthdates were entered for 182 babies, birth weights for 159 babies, and gestational ages for 114 babies. Of the 159 babies with birth weight outcomes data entered, 23 babies (14%) were born at low birth weight (less than 5.5 pounds). Of the 114 babies with gestational age data entered, 8 babies (7%) were born preterm (less than 37 weeks). Of note, the majority of these babies were born before their mothers entered Teen+. Goal Data Each participant in Teen+ was asked by Success Coaches to set goals. Ten categories of goals were identified in the system, and within each category there were several specific goals that teens could select as a priority. Teens could have multiple goals in one or more category, but were not expected to have goals in all categories. The ten categories of goals were economic, education, employment, financial stability, health, housing stability, interpersonal relationships, mental health treatment, self-sufficiency, and social development. The vast majority of goals identified by Teen+ participants in the ShelbyConnect system were related to education (73%), in part because the Success Coaches working in the schools focused primarily on identifying educational goals, whereas Success Coaches outside the school system tended to help teens identify a broader range of goals. Most teens identifying educational goals were working toward graduating from high school or obtaining their GED (92%). Among those who identified non-educational goals, employment (n=28), and housing (n=17) were the areas in which teens were most likely to seek improvement. 6 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women Case Study: Alisa Alisa was fifteen years old when she found out she was pregnant. She was afraid to acknowledge that her symptoms might point to pregnancy, so she did not schedule an appointment with a doctor until she was in her seventh month of pregnancy. She worried about how her father, who she described as “hard on her,” would react, so she did not tell anyone about her condition. She recalled that her family and friends discovered her pregnancy after her eating habits changed and her pregnancy showed. “I was hiding it from everybody. They knew about it though. My dad was the first one that said something. He was like, ‘I know she pregnant. She be eating all night!’” After facing complications during her pregnancy, resulting in an induced labor, Alisa gave birth to a boy. Her son is now two years old and she is currently trying to gain employment through Job Corps. Alisa found out about Teen+ through a friend, and began working with a Success Coach who worked to help her re-enroll in high school at the Adolescent Parenting Program (APP) in downtown Memphis. After a lifetime of unstable living arrangements, Alisa faced “a big confusion” in regards to identification documents needed to re-enroll in school and couldn’t access sufficient childcare and transportation to sort it out. Eventually, she gave up on returning to school. Alisa has already identified a potential employment opportunity and received bus passes through Teen+ to help her obtain the identification necessary to start working. She would like to apply for childcare subsidies through Families First, but does not qualify as she remains classified as a dependent on her grandmother’s Department of Human Services case. Teen+ has helped Alisa learn how to parent her son more effectively, and to handle stressful situations in constructive ways. She noted that she also benefitted from access to the Baby Stores and referrals to Job Corps and WIC. She said, however, that she still needs assistance to move out of her grandmother’s home and into a place of her own. Alisa hopes to become more independent, and to provide the care her child needs. This has proven to be a challenge, as both her father and her child’s father have passed away, and she does not get along with her mother. Many teen parents like Alisa find themselves in situations in which they feel alone. “So it’s like I’m just on my own, then his [her son’s father] folks’ll get mad at me about something, and they’ll take it out on the baby. … So I be just on my own, doing it by myself and stuff.” Although Alisa has faced hardships over the past two years, she expressed gratitude for the support provided by the Success Coaches who worked with her through the Teen+ Program. “I just need some help, that’s all.” Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 7 The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women EVALUATION FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS The following sections represent findings of the evaluation team’s primary data collection, based on structured surveys, interviews, and focus groups with Teen+ participants, Success Coaches, partner agency staff, and/or program administrators. Data collection methods are described in Appendix A. This section is organized by six key themes that relate to service delivery and program goals. Strengths and challenges are noted throughout, and focused recommendations are made related to each theme. Mechanisms of Service Delivery Individualized Support Pregnancy and childbirth can be an isolating experience for teens. Among Teen+ participants, pregnant and parenting girls in particular reported experiencing shame, stigma, and social isolation. Girls also report more frequent voluntary or involuntary withdrawal from peer networks and social engagements in order to focus on parenting responsibilities. The issue of isolation was especially significant for children in foster care as these teens are less likely to have consistent family support. “What we’ve found is the majority of our teens just like the fact that we are encouraging them. That they have now a relationship with someone that has bought into that, “I can do this and she believes that I can do it, and so I am going to do this.” Relationship for us has been very, very important with our teens.” - Success Coach Boys also experienced some form of social isolation, although they were more likely to report withdrawal from school and/or social activities as a result of pressure to seek work and provide financially for offspring. Teen+ participants interviewed by the CROW evaluation team cited two primary sources of support: Success Coaches and pregnant or parenting peers. The overwhelming majority of teens interviewed expressed appreciation for their relationship with Success Coaches. They stressed that Coaches often went above and beyond their prescribed program responsibilities. In addition to connecting teens to resources, many Success Coaches provided emotional support and cultivated rapport with the teens, offering a relationship that many teens lacked with their own family and peers. Teens professed gratitude for the opportunity to speak openly without fear or shame, and with the assurance that Coaches would maintain confidentiality. Service providers also acknowledged the importance of individualized support in working with teens. A few teens did not seem to forge strong relationships with their Success Coaches. These teens attributed the problem to lack of communication and/or not seeing their Success Coaches as often as they would have liked. Similarly, providers explained that they regretted not being able to provide consistent extended support for their clients due to their large case loads. 8 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women Recommendations (Individualized Support) • • • • • • • Consider the capacity of caseloads for individual Success Coaches and set standards/expectations for each agency based on the number of Success Coaches funded by the program. Take into account time needed to effectively provide and sustain the personalized services and support teens need. Take into account the time needed to manage case records and input data into ShelbyConnect. Connect teens to the Memphis Crisis Center, 901-274-7477 (CRISIS-7), which offers a 24/7 hotline for parents in distress. Use the Memphis Crisis Center hotline as an after-hours resource when Success Coaches are not available. Contract with CRISIS-7 to provide a Teen+ hotline with standardized materials relevant to the core goals of the program. Consider creating a 24/7 hotline specific to Teen+, which could be staffed by alternating “on-call” Success Coaches. Peer Support Along with support provided by community connectors, teens and Success Coaches stressed the importance of peer support provided by other teens in Teen+. Many teens expressed the need for increased networking among Teen+ participants, explaining that friendships among teen parents who were experiencing similar situations provided a level of support and information exchange that could not be found in other parts of their lives. Teens also enjoyed the social component provided by Teen+, such as the book signing event, and requested more opportunities such as these. “I like coming together with different girls, and hearing their side of the story, and what they go through, and you know, learning new things. Like, everybody pitch in, and we talk about things. Something I might not know that she knew, that she said that was helpful to me.” - Teen “I’ve got plenty of friends and A few teens interviewed by the evaluators were also participants in another family, don’t get me wrong, but local program, Centering Pregnancy, which delivers prenatal care in a sometimes I feel [alone] through group setting. These teens reported satisfaction with the program’s social this whole thing.” dynamic. - Teen Recommendations (Peer Support) • • • • Provide more opportunities for peer networking through group-based programming and social events for pregnant and parenting teens. Capitalize on the groups formed when administering the ACT curriculum in schools, and follow up with another relevant curriculum such as Nurturing Parent or Community Voice to keep teens engaged with each other while providing additional group-based support. Form a “mother-to-mother” group in which teen mothers can come together to share advice and develop bonds with each other. Utilize existing local and national web and mobile resources that connect teens to support networks and information resources (e.g., B4BABYLIFE and BABY2SLEEP mobile apps from the Shelby County Health Department). Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 9 The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women Case Study: Paul Paul is a notable Teen+ success story. He is seventeen years old, and recalls that when he found out his girlfriend was pregnant, he wasn’t ready to have a child. He wanted to wait at least until after high school before starting a family. Even so, Paul was happy to be a father and enthusiastic about taking on the responsibility of parenthood. “It happened, it’s a miracle, and it’s a blessing, and so I’m happy I got [her].” Paul and his girlfriend enrolled in Teen+ when she was in her fifth month of pregnancy. Throughout the pregnancy, Paul supported his girlfriend. He was told by doctors, among others, that they rarely see teen fathers who are so involved. “Everybody said that’s good, because mostly every father don’t go to all the appointments, they glad to see a young man to be at all her appointments and stuff.” Paul was grateful for Teen+, especially for the material support they accessed through the baby stores. He is motivated to continue in Teen+ even when his girlfriend withdraws next year, since she will be attending college. Paul and his girlfriend’s Success Coach helped reduce the burden of completing a pregnancy and managing a child in their teen years. The relationship that Paul and his girlfriend have with their Success Coach has been supportive and encouraging. “She helps us out when we need help, and she gives us rides to the meetings. She told us to call her when we need anything, she’ll do it.” He also learned about caring for his child from the parenting classes they attended through the program. Paul and his girlfriend’s initial plans are to secure jobs, and move out of their parents’ homes and into an apartment together. Teen+ is helping him work towards their goal, not only through material support, but also by providing opportunities to develop independent life skills. He plans to attend college after completing high school, and is hopeful that his athletic abilities will secure admission, and his aspirations will help him achieve success. He explained, “I got plenty of college recruiters looking at me. [The University of Memphis] came to me my tenth grade year and liked how I played, so I’m trying to come over here so I won’t go far from my family… I want to be the first one to graduate out of my family and go to college, play football so I can go pro, help my family out.” It is important to Paul to stay close to his girlfriend and daughter, and to provide a better life for them. “My favorite part about being a parent is taking care of my child, and seeing the smile on her face, cause she shows – she smiles every day… like she gonna be a daddy’s girl. But, I hope she do. But, right now, I’m still trying to go to college and go pro and stuff, so she can have a beautiful future for herself.” 10 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women Material Support Teen pregnancy is strongly correlated with poverty, and nearly 80% of Shelby County teen mothers live in households with incomes below $10,000 per year (Sagrestano, Finerman, Clay, Diener, Edney, & Madjlesi, 2012). Many teen parents in Shelby County grow up in low-income neighborhoods and remain there after giving birth (Sagrestano et al., 2012 ). As a result, the task of meeting their children’s material needs may be disproportionately difficult for teen parents. Teen+ sought to mitigate this burden through the Baby Stores, which was among the most popular aspects of Teen+. As teens completed specific evidencebased tasks shown to contribute to goal-centered success (e.g., receiving prenatal care, attending parenting classes, maintaining good grades), they earned “points” which could be used to purchase items in affiliated Baby Stores (e.g., bottles, diapers, clothing, strollers). No cash was exchanged in Baby Stores. Almost all teens interviewed by the CROW evaluation team expressed gratitude for this service, stressing that they could spend their limited incomes on essentials like rent, transportation, or nutritious food. When asked in interviews about their favorite aspects of Teen+, teens almost always listed the baby stores first. The point system used by the Baby Stores likely provided additional long-term benefits as the activities teens completed to earn points have been demonstrated to improve outcomes for parents and children. Baby Stores were situated in five different areas of Memphis: Cathedral of Faith in Midtown, Hickory Hill CRC in Hickory Hill/East Memphis, Impact Baptist Ministries in Northhaven, Rangeline CDC in Frayser, and South Memphis Alliance in South Memphis. Most teens interviewed were satisfied with the Baby Stores in terms of location, hours of operation, selection of products, and staff, and only a few reported difficulties in accessing Baby Stores. Some service providers expressed confusion in the protocol for awarding points, as well as the verification and tracking process for earning and spending points. Many Teen+ participants have children up to the age of five and initially reported that most Baby Store merchandize was designed for newborns and infants. Teen+ administrators amended subsequent supply purchases to reflect this feedback from Success Coaches and participants. Success Coaches also reported that some of the unique challenges faced by pregnant and parenting teens (e.g., medically-ordered bed rest, transportation, childcare, or the health risks associated with lifting or carrying heavier items while pregnant) complicated participants’ access to Baby Stores. Since the initial funding of the Teen+ program has ended, representatives from each Baby Store, along with additional service providers, have formed a “Baby Store Consortium,” which represents an important sustainability component for Teen+. Recommendations (Material Support) • • • Develop the protocol for point verification and train all Success Coaches and Baby Store employees (including volunteers) on this protocol prior to system implementation. Offer Baby Store ordering options online or over the phone, using a personal password system. Utilize Baby Store visits as teaching opportunities for core messaging. Stock the physical sites with standardized materials on health, education, parenting, and other relevant information. “It is very, very, very helpful, and it relieves a lot of stress.” - Teen Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 11 The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women Case Study: Simone Simone is a sixteen-year-old mother with a five-month-old daughter. She is a junior in high school, and has been able to continue her education despite having a child, at least partially because she has managed to access childcare through a combination of Families First subsidies and financial support from her mother. Simone often worries about the burden her pregnancy might place on her mother, with whom she lives. “I don’t want to depend on my momma, because it’s not her fault that I have a baby, it’s mine, so it’s pretty much that I ain’t got no job, and I ain’t got no money to take care of her.” The father of Simone’s daughter is four years older than Simone. During her pregnancy, Simone found it difficult to communicate with her child’s father and his family because his step-mother denied that the child could be his. After a DNA test, however, paternity was confirmed, and he and his family are beginning to play a more active role in caring for the baby. Initially, Simone was afraid to tell her mother that she might be pregnant; instead she told an older cousin who took her to a doctor who verified her status. She then informed her mother and received prenatal healthcare. After discovering that she was pregnant, Simone enrolled in Teen+, but health problems experienced during her pregnancy made it difficult for her to earn enough points to get everything she needed from the Baby Store when she “had to go back and forth to the hospital.” It is common for teen parents to juggle high-risk pregnancies while trying to balance other demands on their time and attention. Simone did benefit from Teen+ despite the difficulty she had with earning points. In particular, she learned parenting techniques that will help her raise her daughter. “It helped me… learn how to bond with my baby and cope and all that stuff.” She asserted that the parenting classes taught her and other teen parents “how to play with your baby, the difference between discipline… and punishment, and … not to let them look at TV all day. Get them to play with games, like learning games.” Simone also found that Teen+ helped her change behaviors that were not conducive to nurturing her child. “It helped me become a better mother. I don’t party; I don’t go to clubs no more. I basically stay in the house with my baby. … Because I like being with her, it makes me happier than out there, fighting and stuff like that.” 12 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women Referrals Connecting teens to existing resources and helping teens navigate barriers to these services throughout Shelby County is a major goal of Teen+. Such resources include healthcare for pregnant teens and their children, parenting classes, home visitation programs, childcare, employment opportunities, and subsidy programs such as WIC. The wraparound component of the Teen+ model is reflected in the referral system structure intended to make these connections across Shelby County. This model was facilitated by the Early Success Coalition Network (ESCN), which includes a network of community-based agencies and providers who are available for referrals across a range of potential needs. Teen+ Success Coaches worked with teens to identify needs and then made a referral based on expressed needs to the appropriate agency within ShelbyConnect. These actions were designed to facilitate tracking of the referral by the Success Coach, the agency or individual to which the teen was referred, and the evaluation team. The internal referral system was designed to ensure that referrals are followed-up on, that teens’ needs are appropriately addressed, and that evaluators can measure the success of referrals. However, this internal system can only work with all partners on board, and several anticipated partners did not join ShelbyConnect, or joined at a late date, leaving service providers confused as to who was available for referrals or which technological mechanisms should be used for communication. As a result, the majority of referrals were made outside of ShelbyConnect, making them difficult to track. “I’ve been waiting for them for the longest to call me, and this all happened, like I said, my phone and getting turned off, I lost connections, and I never heard from anyone there again.” - Teen Most teens interviewed indicated they did not receive a referral , but those who did receive referrals reported little or no difficulty in accessing the resources to which they were referred, as that service was most often a home visitation program. In only a few cases, teens were aware of a referral being made, but were not able to access that referral, for a variety of reasons. Recommendations (Referrals) • • • • Develop comprehensive and consistently reviewed lists of available referral partners and ensure partners can easily access this information. Encourage all Early Success Coalition Network providers to join the ShelbyConnect system, including providers of ancillary services. Develop a mechanism for all referral agencies that do not purchase seats on ShelbyConnect to participate in the referral feedback loop. Provide incentives to Success Coaches and/or their agencies for making referrals and following them through to completion. Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 13 The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women Goals of Service Delivery Healthcare Prenatal care is a crucial component of a healthy pregnancy and research suggests that teen parents are less likely than adults to receive prenatal care (Harville, Madkour, & Xie, 2012). However, all of the teens interviewed reported that they or their pregnant partner received some form of prenatal care. Even so, few teens were connected to their prenatal care provider through Teen+, usually because they began receiving care prior to their enrollment in Teen+ or enrolled in Teen+ after the birth of their children. Teens who received prenatal care followed different healthseeking trajectories: Some teens (or their mothers) suspected a pregnancy and went directly to an OB-GYN, based on their previous pregnancy experiences or those of their mothers and/ or friends. Other teens experienced symptoms associated with pregnancy and visited a primary care physician, who then provided prenatal care or referred them to an OB-GYN. A few teens sought care from the Regional Medical Center at Memphis (The MED), where they were automatically enrolled in prenatal care. Relatively equal numbers of teens expressed satisfaction and dissatisfaction with their prenatal care providers. “I went to the doctor, because I had an infection somewhere, I thought. The test came back that I was actually pregnant.” - Teen Some teens reported transportation as a barrier to accessing prenatal care, but many agency supervisors and administrators believed that late disclosures of pregnancy was the primary reason teens did not receive prenatal care. The issue of late disclosures was especially true for teens within the school system who had the opportunity to receive prenatal care from internal school-based healthcare services, but disclosed their pregnancy after the deadline to qualify for such services. Of the 51 teens interviewed, 33 reported finding out about their or their partner’s pregnancy during the first trimester, 8 during the second trimester, and 4 during the third trimester (6 teens interviewed did not disclose this information). “We catch the teens late in their pregnancies. When we engage them, everything is an emergency.” - Agency Supervisor “I know that since we have started, we’ve had one premature baby delivered, and one still birth, still born baby. Again, those teens, we did not have access to until their eighth and ninth month of pregnancy.” - Succcess Coach When asked what kinds of activities teens completed in order to earn points, many participants mentioned that attending doctor’s appointments for themselves and/or their children was a major point-earning activity. This may be listed as a success of the program as it incentivizes sustained compliance with prenatal and postnatal healthcare appointments. In addition to increasing pregnant teens’ access to prenatal care, another goal of Teen+ was to postpone subsequent pregnancies, specifically through education and contraception. Some program grantees partnered with local programs (e.g., Free Condom Memphis, A Step Ahead Foundation) to ensure that participants had access to contraception after childbirth. Some partners were unable or unwilling to discuss contraception with teens, as per agency policies. Some Success Coaches also felt unprepared to converse with teens about birth spacing strategies, as they were not trained healthcare providers or educators. 14 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women Recommendations (Healthcare) • • • • • • • Develop core messages related to healthcare, based on grant goals. Provide Success Coaches with a standardized set of information and trainings based on these core messages and make resources based on core messages available to teens, through online and mobile resources. Make print materials related to core messaging available in Baby Stores. Provide standardized training to all program partners to increase content knowledge and comfort discussing healthy sexuality and contraception. Continue incentivizing healthcare visits, and expand this to include behaviors that encourage pregnancy prevention and good interconception health, including birth spacing. Create new opportunities to discuss healthy sexuality topics within programming that participants already receive. Require funded partners to fully enact the core programmatic goals. Education Educational attainment is often problematic for pregnant and parenting teens. Pregnancy or childbirth can prevent a teen from attending school due to the sociocultural stigma associated with teen pregnancy, healthcare issues, or lack of childcare. One of the goals of Teen+ was to help teen parents stay in school. Many teens were able to accomplish their educational goals, sometimes due to the personalized services provided to teens through their Success Coaches. Many of the teens interviewed had recently graduated high school, and others were looking forward to graduation in the near future. A few were enrolled in local colleges whereas others were not attending school, but reported plans to return to high school, obtain a GED, or enroll in college. Few participants interviewed had not obtained a high school diploma or GED, were not attending school, and had no plans to re-enroll in school. Overall, teens were optimistic about their educational goals. “She [Success Coach] has changed my life about me going back to school, because at first I didn’t want to go back to school, I just wanted to get a job and just settle down and be on my own. But she told me that going back to school would help me succeed more, so now she’s helping me get back into [school] so I can better myself.” - Teen “Most of us don’t have babysitters. And most folks don’t trust a lot of people with their babies, and sometimes they don’t want go to school no more, because they don’t trust other people.” - Teen “Well, the only reason I haven’t put her in daycare, I saw this daycare on Facebook. The little boy was kicking the babies in the head, and he was shaking them.” - Teen Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 15 The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women The primary barrier to attending school reported by teens was childcare. Many teen parents rely on family members for childcare, which can be inconsistent and/or contingent on volatile relationships. Because teens living in poverty are often considered dependents of their parents, they may not be eligible for their own case with Department of Human Services, which disqualifies them from subsidized childcare services. Teens and service providers acknowledged that in some cases, childcare is a barrier because teens do not trust center-based care and so opt to stay home from school if they cannot secure childcare from a family member. “What became a problem with quite a few of my students is, ‘Well, I don’t have anyone to watch my child, so I couldn’t come to school today.” - Success Coach Other barriers to education reported included lack of support from family members, the fatigue associated with managing school and parenting, transportation, lack of school uniforms that fit pregnant teens, and bullying or harassment from classmates in regards to their pregnancy. For some teens, the barriers to completing high school were mitigated by the SCS Adolescent Parenting Program, which provides on-site childcare. Other teens reported that Teen+ incentivized their success in school by rewarding points for reports of good behavior and/or grades. One Success Coach in particular worked to make college recruiters aware of the special needs of teen parents who want to go to college. Other Success Coaches provided resources and support that helped teens re-enroll or encouraged them to stay in school, obtain their GEDs, or fill out college applications. Recommendations (Education) • • • • • • • Create standardized materials and resources about quality childcare and the Tennessee childcare rating system to address distrust in public childcare facilities. Include information that empowers parents to make informed decisions about childcare options. Request input from the Department of Human Services to develop toolkits that allow Success Coaches to help teens more successfully navigate the childcare subsidy application process. Invite DHS to train Success Coaches on the childcare subsidy application process. Facilitate a discussion with the Department of Human Services to review policies that do not accommodate the unique circumstances of teen parents. Regularly assess barriers to educational goals. Invest resources in the Adolescent Parenting Program (APP) to increase accessibility of the program. Allow students to complete their high school degree (or equivalent) at the APP. Provide transportation to increase the range of students who are able to attend this school. Increase the support and safety net around kids who are in school to help keep them continuously enrolled and progressing and reduce barriers to re-enrollment for students who drop out after a pregnancy/birth. Expand access to high quality, subsidized childcare on school grounds so that teen parents can attend classes while remaining on-site with their children. 16 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation The University of Memphis Parenting Center for Research on Women “I already know about parenting. My mom got nine kids. My auntie got nine right behind her. I know about kids.” - Teen Becoming pregnant and having a child at a young age forces a teen to assume adult responsibilities at an earlier age than they would otherwise. Some teens have prior experience caring for younger siblings or other children, but many are unprepared for the challenges of parenting. To address this issue, Teen+ included “They are watching their parents, and they are a focus on connecting teens to existing parenting programs, parenting the way they have been parented, although there were a range of service delivery experiences. which is not always the best.” - Success Coach Programming for Teen+ participants enrolled through SCS focused almost exclusively on the Adults and Children Together Against Violence (ACT) curriculum, an evidencebased, primary prevention program designed for caregivers. Non-SCS “It’s helping me learn about more participants received either individualized parenting counseling with their about her and how her mind Success Coaches, classes offered by the Teen+ agency with which they works …The parent’s class—it were enrolled, or were referred to parenting classes provided by partner broadened my horizon.” agencies in Shelby County. Such programs ranged from group-based - Teen curricula to home visitations. Some examples of non-Teen+ parenting class providers include LeBonheur Children’s Hospital, Porter-Leath, and the Healthy Start Initiative. Specific parenting skills that teens reported learning included the benefits of and strategies for successful breastfeeding, promoting cognitive development, and infant mortality prevention. Students who received the ACT curriculum primarily reported learning about discipline techniques and violence prevention. In addition to parenting skills, an emergent area for Teen+ to address, as reported by teens and service providers, was support for cultivating independent living skills and strategies for teens to grow into responsible adults. Success Coaches accomplished this through personalized services, guiding teens through activities such as balancing a budget or preparing for higher education. Teens could also attend healthy cooking classes provided by partner agencies. Incentivizing school attendance and health-seeking behaviors with points that could be spent at Baby Stores imparted lessons on responsibility and budgeting. Recommendations (Parenting) • Identify relevant partners for life skills training referrals (e.g., financial literacy, nutrition) and include them in ShelbyConnect. • Create a standardized list of skills that each teen should master, assess during intake, and refer to appropriate partners for skills that need support. • Identify culturally-relevant curricula that address a wider variety of needs and are specific to programming goals. • Based on programmatic goals, develop standardized messaging about parenting and provide training and resources to Success Coaches. Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 17 The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women Case Study: Calvin Calvin is nineteen years old, and he and his girlfriend have one child. After enrolling in Teen+, they benefitted from the point system and the material support offered by the Baby Stores. This helped them manage their newborn’s immediate material needs, “like getting things outta the way, like, big things … we had got mostly things like baby seat, car seats, and strollers, and stuff like that. We basically got the big stuff out the way now… So it’s basically really helpful. It’s a good program.” Calvin is not currently attending school, but he hopes to enroll in a trade school in the near future, saying “it kind of sounds hard, but I know I can do it.” He is on probation at the moment, and is struggling with finding employment to support himself and his family. When asked to identify the most difficult part of being a young parent, he responded “When you’re unemployed, the hardest thing is getting a job. That’s basically the hardest thing. I mean, you can do all this old application stuff, it just don’t work no more.” Problems at home add to the stress of Calvin’s life as a teen parent. He and his girlfriend live apart with their respective families, and he explained that their housing conditions are neither ideal nor conducive to raising a healthy family. However, he finds encouragement in his interactions with their Success Coach, and in the education he receives from the Coach and the Teen+ parenting classes. “She asks us what we need and we just work it out from there. She makes sure everything go as planned, she makes sure we working, makes sure we’re doing our part as a parent.” Despite the barriers Calvin and his girlfriend face, Teen+ has provided a support system that increases the prospects that they will achieve their goals as a family and Calvin is grateful for new opportunities to succeed. “It’s a good program, love the program. It’s one of the best programs I’ve ever been in, really.… I just want to say thank y’all. … Thank you, and thank you again, and thank you some more.” 18 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women External Challenges Teen pregnancy and parenting strongly correlate with poverty. Research indicates that nearly all teenagers giving birth in Shelby County in 2009 lived in poverty (Sagrestano et al., 2012). Success Coaches provided feedback which indicated the ways in which issues related to poverty impacted the implementation of Teen+. Based on this feedback, the evaluation team designed survey measures to assess levels of housing, transportation, and food security among a non-random sample of program participants. The survey was completed by 50 Teen+ participants and the full results of this data can be found in Appendix C. Teens also reported information on this topic in interviews. A summary of interview data can be found in Appendix D. Almost half of survey respondents (46%) reported that their families supported them, and a quarter (24%) relied on Families First as their main source of income. Teens and service providers often reported that teen parents have significant financial and employment concerns. In interviews, 14 teens expressed a need for employment assistance, with several others reporting that they experienced transportation and/or childcare barriers to employment. Only 36% of teens responding to the survey reported consistent access to reliable transportation. In interviews, many teens indicated that they received transportation assistance from family members or their Success Coach, but 21 teens specifically reported needing “You’re dealing with the inner help securing reliable transportation. Teens and Success Coaches noted city. Transportation is a huge that transportation vouchers provided by grantee agencies alleviated some problem, huge.” transportation barriers, but the need was not addressed systematically by - Success Coach Teen+. A series of survey items asked teens about their experiences with housing and housing “Safe housing is insecurity. Although the majority (76%) reported that they always had a regular, safe, one issue, because and secure place to live, fully 24% reported at least some experience with housing out of the whole insecurity, and only 58% of the teens reported that they never worried about losing week, I’ve heard their housing. In addition, almost half of teens indicated on the survey that they were gunshots across forced to move out of their family home because of pregnancy or the birth of a child, my door, back-toand 30% felt unsafe in their current neighborhood. Finally, 6% had spent the night in back.” a shelter and 8% had spent the night outside or on the street. Although not every teen - Teen disclosed their current living arrangements during interviews, many teens discussed the insecurity of their housing arrangements. Some teens remained in foster care, but the majority of teens interviewed lived with family members other than their partners, although many of these expressed the desire to live with their partner and child in a single-family housing arrangement. During interviews, 4 teens described being forced to move due to their pregnancy and 14 teens expressed an explicit need related to housing. More than a quarter of the teens in the survey sample reported worrying about their safety or the safety of their children because of someone close to them. This suggests that the link between interpersonal violence (IPV) and housing insecurity found in other samples may be partially responsible for housing difficulties experienced by some of the teens in Teen+. “I think the most difficult thing for me is ... being stable enough for my baby. Having a stable place to stay, a stable job, stable transportation and reliable transportation.” - Teen Food insecurity was more prevalent than housing insecurity in the sample of teens surveyed. More than half (54%) reported running out of food before they had money or food stamps, at least some of the time. One quarter (26%) cut the size of their meals because there was not enough food in the household. Finally, at least one fifth reported worrying that they or their children were not receiving the amount of food needed. Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 19 The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women Other external challenges proved to be less tangible. Both teens and “They [family members] expected service providers spoke about the sociocultural stigma related to moral for me to just go to school and go characterizations of teen pregnancy. Pregnant and parenting teens to college without children. And sometimes experienced verbal harassment from peers, relatives, and/ then, when they found out I was or community members in regards to their pregnant or parenting pregnant… they just act like they status. The stigma related to teen pregnancy was also experienced didn’t trust me no more.” as an internalization of others’ unexpressed perceptions or a fear of - Teen anticipated rejection or harassment. In the experiences of teens and service providers, pregnant teens often wait to disclose their pregnancy status due to this fear. Teens may tell a friend or their sexual partner about their pregnancy, but wait to tell other relatives or peers. Out of 51 teens interviewed, several mentioned negative perceptions or stereotypes of teen parents, and 17 teens indicated that they waited to tell an adult that they were pregnant. In some cases, teens faced consequences for their disclosure, including loss of housing or financial support from parents or other family members. This delay in disclosure can result in a subsequent delay in seeking prenatal care and/or exclusion from programs like Centering Pregnancy, which require women to enroll during their first trimester. “What I like about Teen+ is that it gives young ladies my age range a look at what we can do. And, it also help us as young women to grow older and know what’s best for us in life.” - Teen Teen+ was effective in mitigating some of the stigma experienced by participants through support from Success Coaches and peers. Some interviewees voiced surprise that anyone would help teen parents, especially to do so without judgment, and were grateful for the safe spaces that Teen+ created. Recommendations (External Challenges) • • • Screen regularly for housing, transportation, and food insecurity as well as for interpersonal violence. Allow ample time to identify and respond to external challenges when developing a system of care. Financially structure grant proposals to address external challenges that have a significant impact on teens’ pregnancy and parenting experiences. Implementation Challenges Pilot Programs require continuous appraisal and adjustment to produce more efficient and effective programming. During the first three years of Teen+, issues related to process and communication emerged as barriers to successful implementation. Some of these issues were outside the control of program administrators or service providers, but merit coverage in this evaluation. Multiple levels of bureaucracy resulted in delayed funds, which stalled the process of program design and delivery. Insufficient time allocated for planning before implementation led to simultaneous design and implementation of the system of care, which in turn led to policies and trainings for service providers being developed or changed throughout implementation. Success Coaches requested standardization related to messaging around core goals, policies, and trainings to facilitate a more standardized experience for participants and ensure quality control. 20 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation The University of Memphis Within Teen+, some service providers reported communication challenges among other service providers and administrators. Success Coaches expressed frustration with policies regarding enrollment territory and noted overlap in case management services provided to participants. Service providers also described the ShelbyConnect system as “not user-friendly at all” and the first three years of implementation focused on inputting information into ShelbyConnect as opposed to using the system as a service provision tool. A few Success Coaches added concerns about wording within the system. Center for Research on Women “How does that information get back to the case manager? Do I know the case manager well enough? Do I send an email? What happens with their care beyond that? Who is the person who signed this point sheet? Do I have their email address when I send it? Do we actually follow up?” - Success Coach “I feel like it just never was taken into account what we, the field people, hands-on, are actually experiencing.” - Success Coach It should also be noted that the overwhelming majority of program participants were female, although efforts were made to recruit more teen fathers. This disparity in enrollment may reflect age-discordant relationships, in which the fathers of children born to teen mothers are older. In addition, the gendered context of teen pregnancy results in girls disproportionately shouldering the burden of responsibility, both physically and socio-culturally (Sagrestano et al., 2012). As one teen boy remarked in an interview, “Pregnancy is for the ladies, and Teen+ is for the ladies.” Recommendations (Implementation Challenges) • • • • • • Develop standardized messaging on all core goal topics, accompanied by training, outreach materials, and web-based resources. Create greater specificity with respect to action-based protocols for Success Coaches in the system of care manual and flowcharts. Establish clear communication guidelines among partners. Facilitate peer networking among Success Coaches to provide mutual support and insight. Hire both men and women as Success Coaches to increase likelihood of teen father participation. Recruit program participants directly from community-based organizations or programs geared specifically towards young men. Recommendations for System Sustainability Teen+ has made progress towards addressing teen pregnancy and parenting in Shelby County. Over 600 teens were served, with many reporting satisfaction with their experiences. As the system transitions into its last funded year, grantees should consider plans for the future. The following are recommendations from the evaluation team in regards to sustainability: • • • • • Develop sustainability/transition plans as part of program design and implement in the last year of funding. Facilitate networks of service providers that build partnerships that can continue post-funding. Consider scaling down and providing all coaching in the context of the Baby Stores. Standardize policies, protocols, and training. Develop infrastructure that allows agencies to continue programming after start-up money is depleted. Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 21 The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women APPENDIX A: SUMMARY OF RESEARCH METHODS The evaluation team used multiple methods to collect primary and secondary data on the Teen+ Program in Shelby County. Primary methods included surveys, interviews, and focus groups. Secondary data was also collected from the ShelbyConnect system. For all methods, the evaluation team collaborated with grant partners in designing and executing collection protocols. Participation in the evaluation did not affect the services received by Teen+ participants, although Teen+ enrollees who participated in the evaluation did receive incentives from CROW in the form of gift cards, as well as an incentive from the Teen+ program in the form of Baby Store points. Parental Consent was obtained for all participants under the age of 18. Participants over the age of 18 gave consent for themselves, and all participants provided informed consent. All methodologies were reviewed and approved by the University of Memphis Institutional Review Board for the protection of confidentiality and the rights of participants. All data and recordings are securely stored in locked cabinets accessible only to the research team, and all identifying information has been removed. Secondary Data. The evaluation team received training for the ShelbyConnect system and was granted access to data entered by all grantee agencies. CROW received data from system administrators, which was then coded and analyzed by the evaluation team using statistical software. Survey. A 10-page, self-administered survey was given to 50 teens enrolled in the Teen+ program. The survey included eight pages that were used during the Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Needs Assessment, which elicited a broad range of information from teens, including demographic and background information, sexual history and behavior, pregnancy and parenting history, family dynamics, and mental health factors. The evaluation team developed two additional pages for the evaluation survey, which included measures of housing, transportation, and food security based on measurements used by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. Teens were recruited in by Success Coaches in Summer 2013 for interviews and surveys, and surveys were completed while teens waited to be interviewed. Collection sites were determined collaboratively by the evaluation team and Success Coaches. Names were not associated with surveys in any way. Survey participants received a $10 gift card immediately upon completing the survey. Survey data was processed, coded, and analyzed by the evaluation team using statistical software. Teen+ Participant Interviews. Semi-structured, one-on-one interviews with Teen+ enrollees were conducted by trained members of the evaluation team. Interview measures were designed to elicit information from teens in regards to both their pregnancy experiences and their experiences in the Teen+ program. Teens were asked to provide direct feedback on the successes and challenges of the program and recommendations for improvement. A total of 55 interviews were conducted. Interviews were digitally recorded with consent from teens. Names were not used in recordings or transcriptions of interviews. Teens who were interviewed received a $25 gift card immediately upon completing the interview. Interview data was transcribed, coded, and analyzed by the evaluation team using qualitative analysis. Focus Groups. Two focus groups were conducted simultaneously with participants separated into direct service providers (i.e., Success Coaches) and administrators. The administrative group included agency supervisors and program administrators. An additional focus group was conducted on a different date with Shelby County School system Success Coaches. Focus group participants were asked to provide their understanding of the program, perspectives on the strengths and challenges of the program, and recommendations for improvement. Names were not used in focus group transcripts and responses were kept confidential. Focus group data was transcribed and analyzed by the evaluation team using qualitative analysis. A total of n participants participated in the three focus groups. Online Satisfaction Survey. A survey regarding user satisfaction with the ShelbyConnect system was created using Qualtrics survey software. An individualized link was distributed to all funded partners via e-mail on five separate occasions over the course of a month. The survey could be taken only once and respondents provided their initials to indicate informed consent. No names were attached to the survey and responses were kept confidential. However, only 10 grantee partners responded to the survey so those results were regarded with caution. 22 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation Center for Research on Women The University of Memphis APPENDIX B: SUMMARY OF TRACKING DATA EXTRACTED FROM SHELBYCONNECT Data from the ShelbyConnect data system was downloaded on December 9, 2013, and included all entered cases for teens enrolled in Teen+ from implementation through August 31, 2013, or 603 cases. The variables selected for presentation include basic demographic information, provider information, pregnancy and parenting information, educational information, and goals identified by teens. Participants for whom data had not been entered into the ShelbyConnect system are listed as missing. Demographic Data Participants included 603 teens aged 19 and under at the time of enrollment. The demographics of the sample are as follows: • • • Gender: 89% girls, 8% boys Race: 92% African American, .5% White, 3% other Average Age in 2013: 17.9 years DEMOGRAPHIC INFORMATION 600 555 535 TEEN YEAR OF BIRTH 200 173 180 160 500 NUMBER OF TEENS 140 400 121 120 101 100 300 80 200 64 60 45 39 40 100 48 20 19 8 20 White Missing 20 Boys Missing African American Other 17 4 2 0 0 Girls 30 6 1992 (21) 1993 (20) 1994 (19) 1995 (18) 1996 (17) 1997 (16) 1998 (15) 1999 (14) 2000 (13) 1 2003 Out of Missing (10) Range Success Coach Information The majority of Teen+ participants with data in ShelbyConnect were served by the Memphis City Schools (70%; now Shelby County Schools). This was followed by Cathedral of Faith (15%), Agape (14%), and South Memphis Alliance (1%). NUMBER OF TEENS ENROLLMENT BY AGENCY 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 425 83 88 Agape Cathedral of Faith 7 MCS/SCS South Memphis Alliance Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 23 Center for Research on Women The University of Memphis Educational Outcomes The majority of Teen+ participants with data in ShelbyConnect were enrolled in school (83%), whereas 11% were not enrolled in school. Of the 603 Teen+ participants, 3% were in elementary or middle school, 59% were in high school, 5% had a high school diploma, and 1% had some college. 200 CURRENT EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT 188 180 SCHOOL ENROLLMENT 160 600 140 499 NUMBER OF TEENS NUMBER OF TEENS 500 169 400 300 200 120 100 92 80 60 69 100 34 0 In School Not in School 49 48 40 20 Missing 30 19 6 Missing Some college/ college degree HS diploma 12th (no diploma) 11th 10th 9th 5th-8th 0 Pregnancy, Parenting, and Birth Outcomes Of the 603 Teen+ participants entered into the ShelbyConnect system, 42% were pregnant at the time of enrollment in Teen+, and 57% were parents at the time of enrollment. The majority of parenting teens (n=344) in Teen+ had one child (69%), whereas 8% had 2 children. Almost all of the pregnant participants in the program were receiving prenatal care (93%). PREGNANCY AND PARENTING STATUS 254 290 Pregnant NUMBER OF TEENS WITH CHILDREN 59 250 238 213 Parenting Yes 46 No Missing 0 150 100 77 50 235 13 6 Prenatal Care (pregnant only, n=254) NUMBER OF TEENS 200 344 28 0 One Child 100 200 300 Two Children 400 NUMBER OF TEENS 24 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation Missing The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women The ShelbyConnect system included birth outcomes data reported by parenting teens, as well as some data for pregnant teens that gave birth while working with a Success Coach. Because it is unclear how many children should be represented in the system, it is impossible to accurately calculate percentages, however, there were birthdates for 182 babies, birth weights for 159 babies, and gestational ages for 114 babies. Of those with birth outcome data entered, 23 babies (14%) were born low birth weight (less than 5.5 pounds), and 8 babies (7%) were born preterm (less than 37 weeks), although the majority of these babies were born before their mothers entered Teen+. NUMBER OF CASES WITH CHILD BIRTH DATE, BIRTH WEIGHT, AND GESTATIONAL AGE INFORMATION IN SHELBYCONNECT 200 182 180 159 NUMBER OF CASES 160 140 114 120 100 80 60 40 23 8 20 0 Birth Date Birth Weight Gestational Age LBW (<5.5 Preterm (<37 lbs) weeks) Goal Data Each participant in Teen+ was asked to set goals. Ten categories of goals were identified in the system, and within each category there were several specific goals upon which teens could choose to work. Teens were not expected to have goals in all categories. The ten categories of goals were economic, education, employment, financial stability, health, housing stability, interpersonal relationships, mental health treatment, self-sufficiency, and social development. The vast majority of goals identified by Teen+ participants in the ShelbyConnect system were related to education (73%), in part because the Success Coaches working in the schools focused primarily on identifying educational goals, whereas other Success Coaches helped teens identify a broader range of goals. Most teens identifying educational goals were working toward graduating from high school or obtaining their GED (92%). Among those who identified non-educational goals, employment and housing were the areas teens were most likely to want to improve. GOAL CLASSIFICATION EDUCATIONAL GOALS 513 500 400 300 200 100 0 121 1 28 3 5 17 2 3 6 2 NUMBER OF RESPONSES NUMBER OF GOALS 600 500 458 400 300 200 100 0 4 Re-enroll in HS Graduate HS 13 7 Get GED Enroll in classes 27 Graduate College 2 2 Improve Educational Achievement Improve Attendance Over School Term Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 25 The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women APPENDIX C: SUMMARY OF HOUSING, TRANSPORTATION, AND FOOD SECURITY SURVEY DATA The CROW housing survey was completed by 50 Teen+ participants at the time of their qualitative interview. Because the majority of the sample (90%) was girls, comparisons were not made by sex. The sample is not a random sample of the teens that participated in Teen+, and should not be considered representative of all teens participating in the program. Demographic and Background Data Participants included 50 adolescents aged 19 and under. The demographics of the sample are as follows: • Gender: 90% girls, 10% boys • Race: 96% African American, 2% Hispanic, 2% other • Sexual Orientation (self-identified): 96% heterosexual, 2% bisexual • Employment: 22% currently employed, 44% had been employed at some point in their lifetime Almost half of the sample (46%) reported that their families supported them, and a quarter (24%) relied on Families First as their main source of income (Note: Participants could choose more than one main source of income). Only 36% of teens reported consistent access to reliable transportation. MAIN SOURCE OF INCOME 50 46 45 40 Percent 35 30 24 25 20 14 15 10 10 10 10 6 5 0 Full-time job Part-time job Families First SSI/SSDI Partner Family Other HOW OFTEN CAN YOU ACCESS RELIABLE TRANSPORTATION WHEN YOU NEED IT? 40 30 Percent 36 32 26 20 10 6 0 Never Sometimes Often Always 26 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation Center for Research on Women The University of Memphis Housing Security A series of items asked teens about their experiences with housing and housing insecurity. Although the majority (76%) reported that they always had a regular, safe, and secure place to live, 24% reported at least some experience with housing insecurity, and only 58% of the teens reported that they never worried about losing their housing. In addition, 22 teens (44%) were forced to move out of their family home because of pregnancy or birth of a child, and 30% felt unsafe in their current neighborhood. Finally, 6% have spent the night in a shelter and 8% have spent the night outside or on the street at least once. HOW OFTEN DO YOU HAVE A REGULAR, SAFE, AND SECURE PLACE TO LIVE, WITHOUT FEAR OF BECOMING HOMELESS IN THE NEAR FUTURE? 80 76 70 60 Percent 50 40 30 20 10 0 14 4 Never 6 Sometimes Often Always HOW WORRIED ARE YOU THAT YOU MAY LOSE YOUR CURRENT HOUSING BECAUSE YOU CAN'T AFFORD IT? 70 60 58 Percent 50 40 30 22 20 10 10 10 Very worried Don't Know 0 Not worried Somewhat worried Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 27 The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women HOUSING SECURITY EXPERIENCES 74 Were you forced to move out of your family's home because of pregnancy or birth of a child? 22 66 Are you currently staying in a neighborhood that you think is unsafe? 30 No 92 Have you ever spent the night in a shelter? 6 Have you ever spent the night outside or on the street because you didn't have any place else to go? Yes 92 8 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 Percent More than a quarter of the teens in the sample reported worrying about their safety or the safety of their child because of someone close to them. This suggests that the link between interpersonal violence (IPV) and housing insecurity found in other samples may be partially responsible for housing difficulties experienced by some of the teens in Teen+. Percentage Responding Yes HOW WORRIED ARE YOU ABOUT THE SAFETY OF YOU OR YOUR CHILD BECAUSE OF SOMEBODY CLOSE TO YOU? 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 72 22 Not worried Somewhat worried 4 2 Very worried Don't Know 28 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation Center for Research on Women The University of Memphis Food Security Food insecurity is more prevalent than housing insecurity in this sample in this sample of teens. More than half (54%) reported running out of food before they had money or food stamps at least some of the time. A quarter (26%) cut the size of their meals because there was not enough food in the household. Finally, at least a fifth reported worrying that they or their children were not receiving the amount of food needed. FOOD SECURITY EXPERIENCES 4 How often do you run out of food before you have the money or foodstamps to buy more? 12 38 46 Always Often 2 How often do you cut the size of your meals because there is not enough food for everyone in the house? Sometimes 4 Never 18 74 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Percent Percent HOW WORRIED ARE YOU THAT YOU OR YOUR CHILD IS NOT RECEIVING THE AMOUNT OF FOOD S/HE NEEDS? 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 78 Not worried 10 10 Somewhat worried Very worried 2 Don't Know Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 29 The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women APPENDIX D: SUMMARY OF INTERVIEW DATA Interviews were conducted with 55 Teen+ participants by trained members of the evaluation team. Interviews were recorded and transcribed and qualitative analysis was performed on the data. Four recordings were lost due to technological issue. The summary included here represents 51 interviews with 46 girls and 5 boys. Although this sample size represents about 10% of the number of teens enrolled in Teen+, interviews were conducted with a non-random sample of participants recruited for interviewing by Success Coaches. Thus, the representativeness of this data should be regarded with caution. Individualized Support Many teens reported that a lack of support from their partner or families was one of the most significant hardships they or other teen parents faced. The majority of teens expressed high levels of satisfaction with the relationship they had with their Success Coaches and often referred to this relationship as a major source of support in their lives. Teens sometimes used familial terms to describe their Success Coaches, especially in instances where teens had little or no support from their biological families, as was often the case with teens in foster care. Teens reported receiving tangible attention or support from their Success Coach in the form of home visits, teaching parenting skills, or assistance applying for schools, jobs, and/or a variety of social services. Teens also reported receiving emotional support from Success Coaches in the form of listening and advisement or encouragement. All but one teen interviewed described their Success Coach in positive terms. Peer Support When asked to describe their favorite aspects of the Teen+ program, teens often spoke about the peer support they received during group-based programming. Teens explained that they often felt judged or rejected by peers or relatives due to their pregnancy status and that Teen+ provided a space free of judgment. In addition to feeling comfortable around teens with similar experiences, interviewed teens stated that they exchanged information about parenting strategies and resources with other pregnant and parenting teens. Increasing social networking opportunities among teen participants was a top suggestion from teens for programmatic improvement. Teen mothers specifically requested “mother-to-mother” groups and programming to which they could bring their children. Food Security Food insecurity is more prevalent than housing insecurity in this sample of teens. More than half (54%) reported running out of food before they had money or food stamps at least some of the time. A quarter (26%) cut the size of their meals because there was not enough food in the household. Finally, at least a fifth reported worrying that they or their children were not receiving the amount of food needed. Material Support Teens expressed a high level of satisfaction with the material support they received from Baby Stores and generally regarded Baby Store products to be of high quality, while also acknowledging that Baby Store inventories were limited in their offerings for children older than one year. Very few teens reported difficulties in accessing the Baby Stores and these difficulties were typically related to hours of operation. Baby Stores were overwhelmingly reported to be the most popular aspect of the program and the component that distinguished Teen+ from other programs available to teen parents. Many teens indicated that they did not think they would have been able to meet their children’s needs without this source of material support. 30 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women Referrals Teens were asked about referrals made through Teen+. Many teens were unfamiliar with the referral process and almost no teens reported receiving a referral from Teen+, although this may be due to a lack of familiarity with the terminology used during interviews. The few teens who reported a referral indicated that they had been referred to services or programming from Porter Leath. Some teens reported that their Success Coach had helped them enroll in WIC or Families First, although many were already connected to such services. Program Enrollment and Outreach. About half of all teens interviewed enrolled in Teen+ after being referred by a friend, family member, classmate, or partner. Twelve teens interviewed said they enrolled through a school staff member, with some of those reporting that they were called to the school office to discuss Teen+. Teens who were called to the school office were not sure how the counselor knew they were pregnant or why they had been called. Teens also reported hearing about Teen+ from a DCS caseworker, direct contact from a Success Coach or grantee agency, or a healthcare facility. One teen interviewed reported seeing a Teen+ advertisement on a bus. Some teens felt that not enough people knew about Teen+ and that the program needed wider outreach and advertisement. Although some interviews did not include this topic, the majority of teens said they either had referred Teen+ to other teens or that they would do so, given the opportunity. No teen said that they would NOT recommend Teen+ to others. Healthcare Although 11 teens did not disclose how they found out they (or their partner) were pregnant, other teens reported a variety of mechanisms for confirming a pregnancy. Of the 51 teens interviewed, 31 reported seeking medical care after experiencing physiological indicators of pregnancy (e.g., nausea, fatigue) although many did not initially recognize these as pregnancy symptoms, and 12 of the 31 teens reported that their mothers took them to their initial doctor visits. Five girls indicated that they were told they were pregnant during a routine checkup and 2 girls said they experienced no symptoms but intuited they were pregnant and sought confirmation from a doctor. One girl interviewed reported seeking medical care after being raped and one girl reported that school personnel instructed her to take a pregnancy test at the school clinic. Of the 51 teens interviewed, 33 reported finding out about their pregnancy during the first trimester, 8 during the second trimester, and 4 during the third trimester. Six teens interviewed did not disclose this information. All teens interviewed reported receiving some form of prenatal care. Teens did not access prenatal care through Teen+ because they began prenatal care prior to enrollment in Teen+. In instances where teens initially sought care at The Med, teens reported being automatically enrolled in prenatal care as well as various other prenatal and parenting programs offered by The Med. A small number of teens reported transportation as an occasional barrier to accessing healthcare, but no other barriers were reported. Teens indicated that they received points for doctor visits for themselves and their children. Education Teens who were interviewed reported a range of educational attainment and goals. The majority of teens interviewed said they were able to stay in school and/or graduate high school because they received accommodations or attended the Adolescent Parenting Program. Some teens also attributed their academic successes to the support, assistance, and/or encouragement they received from their Success Coach. Teens most commonly listed childcare as a barrier to education, with several reporting that they had to drop out because of childcare concerns. Teens enrolled at the Adolescent Parenting Program expressed satisfaction with being able to have their children on-site with them while they attended classes. In addition to childcare, a few teens listed transportation and financial barriers to education; the latter was reported by teens pursuing post-secondary education. Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 31 The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women Parenting Teens who were interviewed often mentioned parenting classes offered through Teen+ partners as a primary source for earning Baby Store points. Participants listed breastfeeding, discipline techniques, anger management, infant mortality prevention, and cooking nutritious foods as topics they recalled covering during classes. Some teens said they were exposed to parenting techniques and information prior to Teen+ enrollment. These teens had cared for younger siblings or other relatives, or enrolled during a second pregnancy. Some teens reported struggling with independent living skills and indicated that their Success Coach had helped them meet a variety of needs outside of parenting skills. Teens also noted that their involvement with Teen+ had led to a change in attitude as well as certain behaviors. Behavioral changes listed by teens included smoking cessation, eating more nutritious foods, reconsidering breastfeeding when they had previously decided against it, and engaging more directly with their child’s early cognitive development. External Challenges Teens listed several unmet needs in their lives, most commonly housing, transportation, employment, and childcare. Although not every teen disclosed their current living arrangements during interviews, many teens discussed the variability of their housing arrangements. Some teens remained in foster care, but the majority of teens interviewed lived with family members other than their partners, although many of these expressed the desire to live with their partner and child in a single-family housing arrangement. Four teens reported being forced to move due to their pregnancy and 14 teens expressed an explicit need related to housing. In interviews, many teens indicated that they received transportation assistance from family members or their Success Coach, but 21 teens interviewed specifically reported needing help securing reliable transportation. Teens often reported experiencing significant financial and/or employment concerns and 14 teens interviewed indicated they were actively seeking jobs whereas several others reported they faced transportation and/or childcare barriers to full-time employment. Childcare was listed as a barrier to both education and employment. Teens acknowledged that they and/or other teen parents they knew were wary of center-based childcare and did not trust their child’s care to nonfamily members. However, although many teens indicated that they received childcare assistance from family members, this assistance was sometimes seen as problematic because it depended on a volatile relationship or an otherwise unstable arrangement. Teen parents who did want to enroll their children in center-based daycare reported difficulties applying for Families First childcare subsidies. Some teens indicated that they needed assistance with the application process and others indicated that they could not qualify for these benefits while still considered a dependent of a relative who already received Families First funding. Stigma During interviews, teens discussed certain sociocultural stigmas associated with teen pregnancy. Some teens reported experiencing harassment from peers, relatives, and/or community members in regards to their pregnancy. Some teens reported feeling fear or anxiety of rejection or harassment. Out of 51 teens interviewed, 17 indicated that they waited to tell an adult they were pregnant because of this fear. In some cases, teens faced consequences for their disclosure, including loss of housing or financial support from parents or other family members. Teens also said that they or teen parents they knew sometimes avoided school or other social interactions because they were concerned about other’s perceptions of teen pregnancy. Some teens suggested that Teen+ publicize their stories as a means of changing negative stereotypes of teen parents. 32 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women APPENDIX E: SUMMARY OF FOCUS GROUP DATA Three focus groups were conducted: one with Teen+ administrators, one with Success Coaches who work in the Shelby County School (SCS) system, and one with Success Coaches who work in non-SCS partner agencies. Data collected during focus groups revealed key themes related to the successes and challenges of the Teen+ program, according to both those who oversee the program and those who work directly with participants. Individualized Support Success Coaches explained that they actively individualized their interactions with teens and that this allowed them to go above and beyond their standard duties as social workers. The relationships built between the Success Coaches and their teen clients provided teens with a support system that they may not otherwise have had in their lives. Coaches wanted to be able to provide this type of support for every teen they served, but they explained that their large caseloads make this difficult. It was suggested that the Teen+ Program hire more social workers in order to decrease each worker’s case load and allow them to provide increased individualized support for each client. Administrators also voiced concerns about increasing buy-in from the parents of teens in Teen+ in order to include parental interaction in the teen-coach relationship. User Experiences of ShelbyConnect Data System Focus group participants agreed that the shared data system was useful in theory, but had not been successfully implemented or utilized during the grant period. Agency supervisors and Success Coaches both reported that in their experiences, the system was not user-friendly, was difficult to navigate, and contained technological glitches that made communication between partners frustrating and sometimes impossible. Success Coaches were tasked with entering what they sometimes perceived as a large amount of information for each teen. Focus group participants voiced concerns that issues with the system’s design required Success Coaches to enter information multiple times, which slowed down Success Coach productivity. Other technical difficulties reported included printing problems and the absence of an auto-fill feature on repetitive forms. Service providers suggested that Baby Store points be tracked by the system and made accessible to all relevant users, including Baby Store workers. This would prevent forgery on handwritten point sheets and improve the overall process for Baby Store workers and customers as well as all providers involved with a teen’s services. Impact of Service Delivery Focus group discussions included the perceived impact of Teen+ participation in teens’ lives. Focus groups participants showed satisfaction with the progress they saw teens make towards a variety of goals, but especially in regards to educational goals and attainment. Success Coaches reported concerns over teens’ ability to secure employment, due to both a lack in skills or training and to the local availability of employment. Success Coaches also reported that teens need training on life skills outside the scope of programmatic focus, specifically financial literacy and other independent living skills. Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 33 The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women Experiences with Implementation The majority of focus group discussions focused on programmatic implementation. Participants explained that they were satisfied with the networking that occurred among their agencies because of Teen+ and discussed how these networks allowed them to more efficiently connect teens to resources in the community. Success Coaches expressed a desire for more opportunities to network across agencies and share information and resources with other Success Coaches. To better serve the diverse and dynamic needs of pregnant and parenting teens, respondents also recommended a closer relationship with the local Department of Human Services and programmatic curricula that is more relevant to teens, both culturally and in terms of literacy levels. A common problem reported by focus group participants was a general disconnect between program administrators and Success Coaches, which was attributed to communication issues. Communication issues were sometimes exacerbated by technological problems. Many Success Coaches felt they did not receive adequate training to carry out their jobs, both in regards to technical skill using the ShelbyConnect data system and in terms of content knowledge on specific topics such as birth spacing and contraception. Focus group participants expressed strong concerns about the non-uniform quality of Teen+. Respondents explained that the various names that Teen+ was known by throughout the county (e.g., TPPS and then Teen+) made it difficult for teens to understand what program in which they were actually participating. It also created a barrier to raising awareness about Teen+ and to recruit teens who did not fully understand the purpose. It was suggested that the name, procedures, and educational information be standardized in order to create a more cohesive vision to present to the community, and to ensure that all teens receive the same services and education, no matter when or where they enroll. 34 | Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation The University of Memphis Center for Research on Women REFERENCES Ciscel, D. (2011). The economic impact of teen pregnancy in Memphis/Shelby County, TN. Memphis, TN: Memphis Teen Vision. Harville, E. W., Madkour, A. S., & Xie, Y. (2012). Predictors of birth weight and gestational age among adolescents. American Journal of Epidemiology, 176(7), S150-S163. Hoffman, S., & Maynard, R. A. (Eds.). (2008). Kids Having Kids: The Economic and Social Costs of Teenage Pregnancy (2nd ed.) Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press. Sagrestano, L. M., Finerman, R., Clay, J., Diener, T., Edney, N., & Madjlesi, A. F. (2012). Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Needs Assessment. Memphis, TN: Center for Research on Women, The University of Memphis. VanDenBerg, J., Bruns, E. J., & Burchard, J. (2008). History of the wraparound process. In E. J. Bruns & J. S. Walker (Eds.), The resource guide to wraparound (pp. 1-5). Portland, OR: National Wraparound Initiative, Research and Training Center for Family Support and Children’s Mental Health. Shelby County Teen Pregnancy and Parenting Success Outcome Evaluation | 35 Visit us on the web at http://memphis.edu/crow Like us on Facebook! Current Research Agenda Child Care Poverty Teen pregnancy and sexual risk-taking Sexual harassment in middle and high school Infant mortality Transportation Center Staff Lynda M. Sagrestano, Ph.D., Director Ace F. Madjlesi, M.A., Research Associate Sarah Hoover, Graduate Assistant Adriane M. F. Sanders, M.S., Graduate Assistant Alicia Clark, Graduate Assistant Mindy Schaper, Undergraduate Assistant Center for Research on Women University of Memphis 337 Clement Hall Memphis, TN 38152 901-678-2770 [email protected] http://memphis.edu/crow The Center for Research on Women at the University of Memphis has investigated issues of gender, race, class, and social inequality for more than a quarter century. Our mission is to conduct, promote, and disseminate scholarship on women and social inequality. An interdisciplinary unit within the University’s College of Arts and Sciences, this thriving academic center is home to collaborative researchers committed to scholarly excellence and deep community involvement. The Center is regarded as a national leader in promoting an integrative approach to understanding and addressing inequities in our society. The Center’s approach to research, theory, and programming emphasizes the structural relationships among race, class, gender, and sexuality, particularly in the U.S. South and among women of color. This kind of action-oriented, communitybased research strengthens the public’s understanding of women’s experiences and informs local, regional, and national public policy. The University of Memphis, a Tennessee Board of Regents Institution, is an Equal Opportunity / Affirmative Action University. It is committed to educating a non-racially identifiable student body. UOM559-FY1314/1C50
© Copyright 2024