Developed By: Price Baum Laverne Buchanan, Ed.D. Lisa Cuozzo Ann Deschamps, Ed.D. José Luis Díaz Suellen Farrington Saundra Hathaway Nancy Horton Maggie Leedy Richard Luecking, Ed.D. Rachel Margolis Kathleen Desmond Porter George Tilson, Jr., Ed.D. Marian Vessels TransCen, Inc. 451 Hungerford Drive Suite 700 Rockville, MD 20850 (301) 424-2002 Voice (301) 309-2435 TTY (301) 251-3762 FAX www.transcen.org Introduction Special thanks to the ADA & IT Information Center www.adainfo.org The ADA & IT Information Center is funded by the National Institute on Disability and Rehabilitation Research of the U.S. Department of Education, Grant # H133D010212. Workforce Discovery: Diversity and Disability in the Workplace Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] How to Use this Guide Workforce Discovery: Diversity and Disability in the Workplace is an in-depth training on disability awareness with the provisions of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) integrated throughout each training module. Each manual is divided into five modules that focus on the following areas: Module 1: Typecasting: Understanding Disability Module 2: Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act Module 3: Reasonable Accommodation Module 4: Etiquette: Communication and Interaction Module 5: Best Practices for Trainers All of the contents of this manual are included on a CD located inside the front cover. This will allow the trainer to customize the training as needed and provide materials in alternate formats (e.g. Braille, large print, etc.). Features of the Modules Module Goals The module goals outline the specific knowledge and/or skills that participants can expect to attain. The Equipment and Materials The sections describe any necessary supplies, including audio/visual equipment necessary to conduct training for that module. Trainers without access to a laptop computer and LCD projector to show the PowerPoint slides can copy the slides onto transparencies and use them with an overhead projector. Time An estimate of the time required to conduct the module is provided. It is, however, important to note that as each trainer develops his or her own style and responds to the specific needs of each audience, the amount of time needed to conduct each module may vary. Notes Each of the module’s pages is formatted into two columns. The left column includes the information and directions for conducting the training. The right side is titled “notes” and is blank so that the trainer can record notes for each activity. Handouts Copies of the handouts are located at the end of the module inside the plastic covering. Handouts are also included within the module for the trainer’s use. Handouts of the PowerPoint presentations are also included in this section, for distribution among the participants. Introduction Workforce Discovery: Diversity and Disability in the Workplace Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Acknowledgements The footnotes in each module refer to citations which can be found in the acknowledgements section. Format of the Modules Regular print material may be read verbatim, but it is best if the trainer adapts the general idea to his or her own word choice. All words in grey italics are directions or discussion tips for the trainer. Show PowerPoint indicates that a PowerPoint slide should be shown. For the convenience of the trainer, the actual slide is pictured directly below this icon. The slide’s text is also reprinted immediately after its picture, to ensure easy reading. To ensure that the training is accessible for all participants, it is very important that the trainer reads all of the text that appears on the PowerPoint and describes any graphical images. This five-module training may be used in a variety of ways to customize presentations for specific groups. All of the modules may be used separately as stand-alone workshops. It would take at least one full day to conduct a training using the first five modules to ensure adequate time for questions and discussion. A half-day training on the ADA and employment issues could be conducted using modules 2 and 3. A half-day training on disability awareness could be conducted using modules 1 and 4. Module 5 is designed to develop training and presentation skills rather than knowledge about the ADA. Introduction Workforce Discovery: Diversity and Disability in the Workplace Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 1 Typecasting: Understanding Disability MODULE GOALS: To understand the concept of stereotyping and how it affects people with disabilities To identify and dispel myths, stereotypes, and common misperceptions concerning people with disabilities EQUIPMENT: PowerPoint Presentation (or alternate format) LCD Projector Computer / Laptop Flip Chart Flip Chart Markers Masking Tape TIME: 45-60 minutes (time may vary) Typecasting: Understanding Disability 1-1 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Review module before training and prepare necessary materials. On a flip chart, prepare three pages with the headings: Teenagers, Computer Programmers, and People from New York. Show PowerPoint: Module 1 Typecasting: Understanding Disability Module 1, Typecasting: Understanding Disability This module provides accurate and up-to-date information about people with disabilities. Interacting comfortably with someone we perceive as different can be difficult. The more we understand and accept differences in people, the better we can move beyond disability/differences toward the acceptance of people for who they are. Show PowerPoint: Goals To understand stereotyping and how this affects people with disabilities To identify and dispel myths, stereotypes, and common misperceptions concerning people with disabilities Module Goals: To understand the concept of stereotyping and how it affects people with disabilities To identify and dispel myths, stereotypes, and common misperceptions concerning people with disabilities Activity: Examining Attitudes Greet the group. I have met many of you this (morning, afternoon) and you have seen me getting ready for this workshop. Typecasting: Understanding Disability 1-2 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Show PowerPoint: What is your initial impression of me? What is your initial impression of me? I am going to ask you some questions. I’d like to find out about your initial impression of me. On a flip chart list the responses to the following questions: Pick 5 or 6 to discuss. Where was I born? In what kind of house do I live? How is it decorated? Am I married? Do I have children? If so, how many? Do I have any pets? If so, what kind? What sports do I enjoy? What kind of car do I drive? What is my favorite kind of food? List all of the group’s responses on a flip chart. Everyone forms opinions based on first impressions. These opinions are also called assumptions. They are based on how someone dresses, their appearance, the way they talk, and other personal characteristics. Sometimes these assumptions are accurate and sometimes they are not. Review the list and tell the group what was accurate and what was not. We all make assumptions about a person based on first impressions. This is human nature and normal. However, it is important to remember that these impressions are often false and we should not judge someone or make decisions about them until we get to know the Typecasting: Understanding Disability 1-3 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S person. Give an example from the list of false assumptions. Have any of you ever been in a situation in which a person made an inaccurate assumption about you based on their initial impression? Ask for a few volunteers to describe their situations. If there are no volunteers, be prepared to tell a personal story. Here are a couple of ideas to get you thinking: A man who loves to bake A woman who is very handy around the house An obese marathon runner A football star who loves to knit Although we can laugh at these stories now, it is important to remember how these misunderstandings occur. It is important not to let our first impressions influence how we treat someone. Activity: Stereotypes What is the definition of a stereotype? Possible responses: When certain characteristics are generalized to an entire group of people. An idea that is standardized for a group. A fixed or conventional image of a person or group of people. Show PowerPoint: Stereotypes are: Assumptions that are made about a person or group’s character or attributes, based on a general image of a particular group of people. Stereotypes are: Assumptions that are made about a person or group’s character or attributes, based on a general image of a particular group of people. Typecasting: Understanding Disability 1-4 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S We are going to see how well you can identify the stereotypes of some very common groups of people. Show PowerPoint: Describe some common stereotypes for the following: • Teenagers • Computer Programmers • People from New York Describe some common stereotypes for the following: Teenagers Computer Programmers People from New York Tape three separate flip chart pages to the wall so they are easily visible in the room. List one of the three categories (Teenagers, Computer Programmers, People from New York) on each page. If space is limited, do these one by one on the flip chart. What are some of the stereotypes our society has for these groups? Trainer can spend about 1-2 minutes on each, starting with number 1. This should be a quick brainstorming activity. If the group is quiet, prompt them with some of the responses listed. Possible responses: Teenagers Lazy Irresponsible Disrespectful Loud Act like they know everything Computer Programmers Socially inept Nerdy Wear pocket protectors Quiet People from New York Typecasting: Understanding Disability 1-5 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Pushy Rude Fast drivers Funny accent Loud If the group names both positive and negative stereotypes, continue with the following discussion. If the group only names negative stereotypes, question why. Ask if there are positive stereotypes that are associated with these groups. Possible responses: Teenagers: Active Technology-savvy Computer programmers: Good problem solvers Very smart People from New York: Live exciting lives Persistent Great job, you really know your stereotypes! How many of you actually know people from these groups who fit these stereotypes? Most people will raise their hands. How many of you know people from these groups who do not fit these stereotypes? Most people will raise their hands. Tell me about some of these people. Where do stereotypes originate? Possible responses: Personal experience with one person from the group Media portrayal Family and peer influences When we judge people based on stereotypes, whether positive or negative, we miss the true character of the individual. When the stereotypes we associate with people are negative, the consequences Typecasting: Understanding Disability 1-6 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S are even more dangerous. What can happen to people when negative stereotypes are held about them? List responses on the flip chart. Possible responses: Avoided socially Persecuted Discriminated against Ostracized Denied opportunities Ignored Harassed Read the responses from the list out loud to the group. Add all of these responses to the list, even if the group did not mention all. Each response we just discussed is a form of discrimination. When someone is avoided socially, not hired, harassed on or off a job, based on negative thoughts or stereotypes of a group, they are being discriminated against. Stereotypes are often the reason that this discrimination takes place. Although many people would argue that they do not base decisions on stereotypes or personal biases, it is clear that these actions do take place every day. We have focused on teens, people from New York, and computer programmers. Let’s take a minute and think about discrimination and how it specifically affects people with disabilities. Are people with disabilities discriminated against? Show PowerPoint: EEOC Discrimination Complaints • 79,432 total • Categories include: - Age - Sex - Religion - National Origin - Race - Retaliation - Disability (19.4%) EEOC Discrimination Complaints: 79,432 total1 Categories include: - Age - Sex Typecasting: Understanding Disability 1-7 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S - Religion - Race - Disability (19.4%)2 - National Origin - Retaliation In the 2004 fiscal year, 79,432 individuals filed discrimination complaints with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.1 The charges fell under the categories of age, sex, religion, national origin, race, retaliation, and disability. Of the 79,432 people who filed discrimination charges with the EEOC in 2003, 15,376, or 19.4% of those were people with disabilities.2 These numbers suggest that discrimination against individuals with disabilities does exist. Just like with teens, New Yorkers, and computer programmers, stereotypes often lead to unfair treatment, like employment discrimination. Let’s examine some of the stereotypes we have about people with cerebral palsy. Cerebral Palsy Below average intelligence Unable to walk Cannot communicate How about people with mental illness? Mental Illness Dangerous Hospitalized Unstable Most (or all) of the stereotypes we just named are negative. There are also positive qualities that can also be associated with these groups. Can you think of any? Name and discuss these responses if they are not mentioned Cerebral Palsy The average person with cerebral palsy has at least average intelligence. 3 Cerebral palsy is not progressive, and therefore does not worsen over time.4 Typecasting: Understanding Disability 1-8 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Mental Illness Statistics show that the incidence of violence in people who have a brain disorder is not much higher than it is in the general population.5 Mental illness can be a treatable disability.6 In addition, there are also various studies that combat the stereotypes put forth by popular culture. For example: Most people with disabilities, even severe disabilities, do not receive public assistance.7 A DuPont Corporation survey found that 90% of employees with disabilities received average or better job performance ratings.8 Unfortunately, negative stereotypes are often more pervasive than the facts from these studies. Where do stereotypes about individuals with disabilities originate? Just like other stereotypes, disability-based stereotypes come from personal experiences with one individual, family / peer influences and media portrayal. Let’s focus on media portrayal for a few minutes. Think about different movies that you have seen that include characters with disabilities. Lead a brief, informal conversation about the way disability is portrayed in film. The conversation will vary with each training group, based on which movies the participants have seen. You can choose from the questions below to steer the conversation. How is the character with a disability represented (pitiful, childlike, bitter, heroic, etc.)? Does the character with a disability play a particular role in the story (victim, villain, hero, etc.)? Why was disability used in this film? Did the disability itself serve a purpose in the story? How is normality defined or portrayed? What was the overall message about disability? Has the role of disability in film changed over time? Questions adapted from ‘Resisting Hollywood’s Take on Disability.’ 9 The following is a list of characters with disabilities to prompt the trainer. Typecasting: Understanding Disability 1-9 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Many of these characters are portrayed as villains Peter Pan , Captain Hook - Missing his hand Silence of the Lambs, Hannibal - Mental illness Psycho, Norman Bates - Mental illness Unbreakable, Elijah Price - Fragile bones Many of these characters are portrayed as victims Rear Window, L.B. “Jeff” Jeffries - Wheelchair-user The Hunchback of Notre Dame, Quasimodo - Physical deformation Beauty and the Beast, The Beast - Physical deformation Million Dollar Baby, Maggie Fitzgerald - Spinal Cord Injury Many of these characters are portrayed as bitter war veterans The Deer Hunter, Steven - Missing a leg Born on the Fourth of July, Ron Kovic - Paralysis Forrest Gump, Lt. Dan Taylor - Missing a leg Many of these characters are portrayed as innocent and child-like Of Mice and Men - Lenny, Mental retardation Forrest Gump - Forrest Gump, Mental retardation I Am Sam, Sam Dawson - Mental retardation Radio, Radio - Mental retardation Stereotypes about individuals with disabilities may also result from our personal experience (or lack thereof). Many of us grew up in a time when people with disabilities were not around us on a daily basis. People with disabilities were often segregated from the community. After all, it wasn’t until 1975 that a “free and appropriate public education” (FAPE) was mandated for students with disabilities. So, many people who started school before 1975 probably had few, if any, classmates with disabilities. Without this exposure, how was one expected to be able and/or comfortable learning, working, and interacting with people with different disabilities? We started to learn about how to treat people with disabilities when we are very young. Remember the special education classrooms? What lesson did those classrooms teach us? Elicit responses from the group. People with disabilities couldn’t learn with us People with disabilities shouldn’t be in the same classroom, gym Typecasting: Understanding Disability 1-10 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S or lunchroom with us By separating students with disabilities, it taught that people with disabilities didn’t even exist It is for this reason, as well as many others, that today we conduct and attend trainings like this. Hopefully we have seen the last generation of disability segregation. Today’s children learn, laugh, and play with kids with disabilities. Therefore, this generation is more likely to have the experiences necessary to be comfortable hiring, managing, and working with and for people who have disabilities. Stereotypes are assumptions that are made about a person or group's character or attributes, based on a general image of a particular group of people. Stereotypes are not inherently negative; we can also attribute positive characteristics as stereotypes. It is very important to remember that when we define people based on stereotypes, we often make false assumptions and we always fail to recognize the person as an individual. Show PowerPoint: “When you see a person with a disability, presume competence.” From: Snow, Kathy, Disability is Natural, 2001 “When you see a person with a disability, presume competence.” From: Snow, Kathy, Disability is Natural, 200110 Typecasting: Understanding Disability 1-11 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module One Acknowledgements 1. U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. “All Statutes: Fiscal Year 19922004.” www.eeoc.gov/stats/all.html. Page last modified 1/27/05. Information retrieved 2/24/05. 2. U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. “Americans with Disabilities Act Changes: Fiscal Year 1992-2004.” www.eeoc.gov/stats/ada-charges.html. Page last modified, 1/27/05. Information retrieved 2/24/05. 3. WebHealth. “A-Z of Health: Cerebral Palsy.” www.webhealth.co.uk/a_to_z_of_health/cerebral_palsy.asp. Information retrieved 2/24/05. 4. National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Strokes. “NINDS Cerebral Palsy Information Page.” www.ninds.nih.gov/disorders/cerebral_palsy/cerebral_palsy.htm#What_is. Page last modified 2/9/05. Information retrieved 2/24/05. 5. National Alliance for Research on Schizophrenia and Depression. “NARSAD Publishes Top 10 Myths About Mental Illness Based on Nationwide Survey.” www.narsad.org/news/press/pr2003-07-01d.html. Information retrieved 2/24/05. 6. National Alliance for the Mentally Ill. “About Mental Illness.” www.nami.org/Content/NavigationMenu/Inform_Yourself/About_Mental_Illness/Ab out_Mental_Illness.htm. Information retrieved 2/24/05. 7. U.S. Census Bureau. “Meeting the Challenge: Americans with Disabilities, 1997.” www.census.gov/population/pop-profile/2000/chap19.pdf. Internet release 2000. 8. DuPont Corporation Study: U.S. Department of Labor. “Myths and Facts about People with Disabilities.” www.dol.gov/odep/pubs/fact/mythfact.htm. Information dated October 1994. Information retrieved 2/24/05. 9. PowerPoint Presentation. “Resisting Hollywood’s Take on Disability.” Zach Rossetti and Christy Ashby. Syracuse University. 2004. 10. Snow, Kathy. “Disability is Natural.” www.disabilityisnatural.com/store/index.html. Copyright 2001. Information retrieved 3/5/05. Typecasting: Understanding Disability Module 1 Acknowledgements Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 1 ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Module 1 Typecasting: Understanding Disability ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 2 ___________________________________ Module - Goals To identify and dispel myths, stereotypes, and common misperceptions concerning people with disabilities To understand stereotyping and how this affects people with disabilities ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 3 ___________________________________ What is your initial impression of me? ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Typecasting: Understanding Disability Module 1 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Slide 4 ___________________________________ Stereotypes are: ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Assumptions that are made about a person or group’s character or attributes, based on a general image of a particular group of people. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 5 Describe some common stereotypes for the following: ___________________________________ ___________________________________ • Teenagers • Computer Programmers • People from New York ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 6 ___________________________________ EEOC Discrimination Complaints • 81,293 total • Categories include: - Age - Religion - Race - Disability (18.9%) ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ - Sex - National Origin - Retaliation ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Typecasting: Understanding Disability Module 1 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Slide 7 ___________________________________ “When you see a person with a disability, presume competence.” From: Snow, Kathy, Disability is Natural, 2001 ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Typecasting: Understanding Disability Module 1 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) MODULE GOALS: To understand the history of Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and related legislation To increase comprehension of the Americans with Disabilities Act and its employment provisions EQUIPMENT: PowerPoint Presentation (or alternate format) LCD Projector Computer / Laptop Flip Chart Flip Chart Markers Masking Tape MATERIALS: Quiz: Get the Facts! Quiz: Get the Facts! 10 T/F pages for “around-the-room-activity” Handout: The Americans with Disabilities Act - Summary TIME 45 – 60 minutes (time may vary) Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-1 N O T E S Review module before training and prepare necessary materials. Show PowerPoint: Module 2 Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Module 2: Legal Implications of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Show PowerPoint: Module Goals • To understand the history of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and related legislation • 9 • To increase comprehension of the Americans with Disabilities Act and its employment provisions Module Goals: To understand the history of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and related legislation To increase comprehension of the Americans with Disabilities Act and its employment provisions This module will focus on legislation impacting the employment, training, and reasonable accommodation of people with disabilities. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-2 N O T E S Show PowerPoint Laws created in order to “level the playing field” • Architectural Barriers Act of 1968 • Rehabilitation Act of 1973 • Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) formerly Education for All Handicapped Children’s Act of 1975 • Fair Housing Act, as amended in 1988 • The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 Laws created in order to “level the playing field” Architectural Barriers Act of 1968 Rehabilitation Act of 1973 Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) formerly Education for All Handicapped Children’s Act of 1975 Fair Housing Act, as amended in 1988 The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 Years ago, there were no laws protecting people with disabilities from discrimination. After the Civil Rights Movement in the 1960s, the Disability Rights Movement began to form based on the same principles. Legislation such as the Fair Housing Act, the Rehabilitation Act, and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act were passed by Congress and signed into law. Over the years, the equity theme became the moral force behind the Disability Rights Movement. In the late 80s, the Americans with Disabilities Act, or ADA, was introduced for the first time in Congress. The ADA prohibits discrimination against people with disabilities in employment, public accommodations, activities of State and local government, transportation, and telecommunications. The ADA was eventually passed by Congress and signed into law on July 26, 1990. Let’s begin with a quiz about the Americans with Disabilities Act. Then we will talk in more detail about Title I: Employment Provisions. Activity: ADA Quiz / GET THE FACTS The ADA Quiz - Get The Facts As the trainer, you can choose how to present this quiz to your Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-3 N O T E S audience. It is included as part of the PowerPoint presentation, as a handout, and as an “around-the-room-activity.” You can also combine two or more methods. Possible ways to use the ADA Quiz: 1. PowerPoint slides – All of the T/F questions and answers are displayed on the slides below. If you are short on time, you can just go over the questions and answers as a large group. 2. Handouts – You may wish to distribute the quiz questions as a handout for the participants, and then review the answers on the PowerPoint Slides. 3. You could also review the quiz solely as a PowerPoint presentation and then distribute the handout at the conclusion of the training. 4. Around-the-room-activity – To create a more active environment, you can place all of the T/F statements (found in the handouts section) around the room on 8.5x11 pieces of paper or cardstock. Participants could be given dots (or different color markers) for this activity. They should then move around the room, read each T/F statement, and place their dot in the T or F section, whichever they believe to be correct. You can then review the correct answers using the PowerPoint slides. Show PowerPoint TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #1 The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) mandates the hiring of individuals with disabilities. TRUE OR FALSE – QUESTION #1 - The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) mandates the hiring of individuals with disabilities. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-4 N O T E S Show PowerPoint FALSE ANSWER #1 The ADA says you should hire the most qualified applicant. It does not mandate that you hire individuals with disabilities; it just ensures equal access to the employment process. FALSE – ANSWER #1 - The ADA says you should hire the most qualified applicant. It does not mandate that you hire individuals with disabilities; it just ensures equal access to the employment process.1 Show PowerPoint TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #2 Businesses with 15 or more employees are covered by Title I (the employment provision) of the ADA. TRUE OR FALSE – QUESTION #2 – Businesses with 15 or more employees are covered by Title I (the employment provision) of the ADA. Show PowerPoint TRUE ANSWER #2 Businesses with 15 or more employees are covered by Title I (the employment provision) of the ADA. TRUE – ANSWER #2 - Businesses with 15 or more employees are covered by Title I (the employment provision) of the ADA. 1 Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-5 N O T E S Show PowerPoint TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #3 Sixty-five percent (65%) of working age individuals with disabilities are unemployed. TRUE OR FALSE – QUESTION #3 - Sixty-five percent (65%) of working age individuals with disabilities are unemployed. Show PowerPoint TRUE ANSWER #3 Among working-age individuals with disabilities, only 35% work full or part-time. (2004 National Organization on Disability / Harris Survey) TRUE – ANSWER #3 – Among working-age individuals with disabilities, only 35% work full or part-time (2004 National Organization on Disability / Harris Survey). 2 Show PowerPoint TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #4 There is a toll-free number that I can call to discuss the ADA and get confidential technical assistance to help my business. TRUE OR FALSE – QUESTION #4 - There is a toll-free number that I can call to discuss the ADA and get confidential technical assistance to help my business. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-6 N O T E S Show PowerPoint TRUE ANSWER #4 The ADA & IT Information Centers (also known as DBTACs) have a toll-free number and provide free technical assistance! 800-949-4232 Voice / TTY TRUE – ANSWER #4 - The ADA & IT Information Centers (also known as the DBTACs) have a toll-free number and provide free technical assistance! 800-949-4232 Voice / TTY Show PowerPoint TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #5 Governments must make all of their facilities fully ADA accessible. TRUE OR FALSE – QUESTION #5 - Governments must make all of their facilities fully ADA accessible. Show PowerPoint FALSE ANSWER #5 Governments need to provide full program access. Their programs and services must be accessible when examined as a whole. This does not mean that each building must be fully accessible. FALSE – ANSWER #5 - Governments need to provide full program access. Their programs and services must be accessible when examined as a whole. This does not mean that each building must be fully accessible.1 Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-7 N O T E S Show PowerPoint TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #6 Two out of three unemployed people with disabilities would prefer to be working. TRUE OR FALSE – QUESTION #6 - Two out of three unemployed people with disabilities would prefer to be working. Show PowerPoint TRUE ANSWER #6 Two out of three unemployed people with disabilities would prefer to be working. (2000 National Organization on Disability / Harris Survey) TRUE – ANSWER #6 - Two out of three unemployed people with disabilities would prefer to be working (2000 National Organization on Disability / Harris Survey). 3 Show PowerPoint TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #7 Employees with disabilities are unable to meet performance standards. TRUE OR FALSE – QUESTION #7 - Employees with disabilities are unable to meet performance standards. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-8 N O T E S Show PowerPoint FALSE ANSWER #7 According to a 1990 DuPont survey, 90% of employees with disabilities rated average or better in job performance compared to 95% for employees without disabilities. A similar 1981 DuPont study found that 92% of employees with disabilities rated average or better in job performance compared to 90% of employees without disabilities. FALSE – ANSWER #7 - According to a 1990 DuPont survey, 90% of employees with disabilities rated average or better in job performance compared to 95% for employees without disabilities. A similar 1981 DuPont study found that 92% of employees with disabilities rated average or better in job performance compared to 90% of employees without disabilities. 4 Show PowerPoint TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #8 Employees with disabilities are more likely to have accidents on the job than employees without disabilities. TRUE OR FALSE – QUESTION #8 - Employees with disabilities are more likely to have accidents on the job than employees without disabilities. Show PowerPoint FALSE ANSWER #8 In the 1990 DuPont study, the safety records of employees with and without disabilities were identical. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-9 N O T E S FALSE – ANSWER #8 – In the 1990 DuPont study, the safety records of employees with and without disabilities were identical. 4 Show PowerPoint TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #9 Companies report that employees with disabilities have better retention rates, reducing the high cost of turnover. TRUE OR FALSE – QUESTION #9 - Companies report that employees with disabilities have better retention rates, reducing the high cost of turnover. Show PowerPoint TRUE ANSWER #9 Companies report that employees with disabilities have better retention rates, reducing the high cost of turnover. (Unger, 2002) TRUE – ANSWER #9 - Companies report that employees with disabilities have better retention rates, reducing the high cost of turnover (Unger, 2002). 5 Show PowerPoint TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #10 There is a forty percent (40%) chance of acquiring a disability if you live to the age of 80. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-10 N O T E S TRUE OR FALSE – QUESTION #10 - There is a forty percent (40%) chance of acquiring a disability if you live to the age of 80. Show PowerPoint FALSE ANSWER #10 There is a 73.6% chance of acquiring a disability if you live to age 80. (U.S. Census Bureau, 1997) FALSE – ANSWER #10– There is a 73.6% chance of acquiring a disability if you live to age 80 (U.S. Census Bureau). 6 GENERAL ADA OVERVIEW You can summarize what is written below in your own words, or read it as it is written. You may also distribute the ADA Summary Handout. To the more than 50 million Americans with disabilities, the Americans with Disabilities Act is an unprecedented opportunity to eliminate barriers to independence and productivity. The ADA is modeled after the Civil Rights Act of 1964. It is based on a bill originally drafted by the National Council on Disability that was supported by major constituency groups and disability organizations. The purpose of the ADA is to extend to people with disabilities civil rights similar to those that were available on the basis of race, color, sex, national origin, and religion through the Civil Rights Act of 1964. It prohibits discrimination on the basis of disability in private sector employment, activities of State and local governments (including employment), places of public accommodation, transportation, and telecommunication services. The ADA has five titles. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-11 N O T E S Show PowerPoint: The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) • Title I: Employment • Title II: Public Services • Title III: Public Accommodations • Title IV: Telecommunications • Title V: Miscellaneous The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA): Title I: Employment Title II: Public Services Title III: Public Accommodations Title IV: Telecommunications Title V: Miscellaneous TITLE I: EMPLOYMENT The ADA prohibits discrimination against a qualified individual with a disability in employment and includes specific features related to reasonable accommodation, qualification standards, and other labor management issues. The law specifically says “no covered entity shall discriminate against a qualified person with a disability because of the disability of such individual in regard to job application procedures, the hiring, advancement, or discharge of employees, employee compensation, job training, and other terms, conditions and privileges of employment” [Section 102 (a)]. 1 Generally, employers must provide “reasonable accommodations” to qualified employees with disabilities, unless providing the accommodation would be an undue hardship. Title I defines “qualified person with a disability,” “reasonable accommodation,” and “undue hardship.” TITLE II: PUBLIC SERVICES (STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT) The ADA addresses services and activities of State and local governments, including public transportation provided by public entities. The transportation provisions of the Act are intended Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-12 N O T E S to improve access in vehicles, facilities, and systems. Title II requires that all public entities provide “program accessibility” to people with disabilities. It also requires that State and local governments modify policies, practices, and procedures to prevent discrimination against people with disabilities. Finally, Title II requires public entities to ensure effective communication with people with sensory disabilities (e.g. blindness, deafness, etc.). TITLE III: PUBLIC ACCOMMODATIONS The ADA addresses public accommodations, also known as businesses and services operated by private entities. Title III covers different types of public accommodations, such as hotels and motels, movie theaters, grocery stores, retail stores, and many others. Privately owned transportation services are also included. The ADA specifically states "no individual shall be discriminated against on the basis of disability in the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages or accommodations of any place of public accommodation" [Section 302(a)]. 1 Businesses may need to modify their policies and practices and remove barriers to improve access. Public accommodations must also ensure effective communication for people with sensory disabilities. Title III also contains the ADA Accessibility Guidelines (ADAAG), which include the specifications for architectural accessibility. TITLE IV: TELECOMMUNICATIONS The ADA mandates that companies offering telephone service to the general public must offer telephone relay services to individuals with communication disabilities who use TTYs or similar telecommunications devices. Every state must have a relay system in place. The law specifically states the requirement to... "ensure that interstate and intrastate telecommunications relay services are available... to hearing impaired and speech impaired individuals..." [Section 225(b)(1)]. 1 The relay system enables people with communication disabilities who cannot use a regular telephone to communicate with anyone. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-13 N O T E S For example, Sally, who is deaf, wants to order pizza. Using a TTY, she calls the relay service by dialing 7-1-1. Once the relay operator answers, Sally types a message that she wants to call a pizza restaurant and types in the number for the operator to dial. The operator then calls the restaurant. The operator reads to the restaurant employee what Sally types, and then types back the reply from the restaurant to Sally. The operator continues to relay the questions, answers, and comments until the conversation is completed. Show PowerPoint: Understanding RELAY Understanding RELAY: This PowerPoint slide is a graphic which illustrates a typical relay conversation. One picture shows a woman using a TTY. There is an arrow pointing towards a male communication assistant who has both a TTY and a voice telephone. Another arrow points to a woman who is speaking into a telephone. TITLE V: MISCELLANEOUS Title V addresses the relationship between the ADA, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, and state laws. Whichever law provides the most protections to people with disabilities takes precedent over the other laws. In addition, the Act provides for administrative remedies comparable to those of Title II and VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Perhaps the most significant part of Title V is that it covers Congress and other agencies of the legislative branch of government. The ADA was passed to protect civil rights for people with disabilities. The law does not mandate preferential treatment. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-14 N O T E S CIVIL RIGHTS ACT OF 1964 AND THE REHABILITATION ACT OF 1973 (BEFORE THE ADA) The Civil Rights Act of 1964 laid the earliest groundwork for disability rights by establishing a framework prohibiting discrimination on the basis of race, religion, national origin, and sex. It addresses private employment, public accommodations and programs and activities receiving federal funds. The Civil Rights Act does not talk about disability. Disability rights came to the forefront when the Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act was enacted in 1973. The Rehabilitation Act prohibits discrimination against people with disabilities in programs and activities receiving federal funds. For the first time, people with all kinds of disabilities were recognized as belonging to a protected class. Now that you have a general overview of the law, we are going to talk in more detail about the employment provisions. After providing the brief ADA overview, you may wish to include more detailed information, depending on the needs of your audience. (Do not attempt to address these issues if you are not knowledgeable about the ADA). Let’s look at who is protected by Title I, the employment provisions of the ADA. Show PowerPoint: Definition of Disability An individual with a disability is one who: has has a record of, or is regarded as having a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity. Definition of Disability: An individual with a disability is one who: has has a record of, or is regarded as having a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-15 N O T E S Show PowerPoint: Definition of Disability Continued An individual with a disability is one who has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity. Definition of Disability Continued - An individual with a disability is one who has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity. Emphasize: "Substantially limits" is a very high standard. Basically, it means that the person must have a disability that really limits their ability to perform a major life activity. Can anyone tell me some major life activities? Field responses from the audience. One method for soliciting information would be to ask participants to list the physical or mental tasks they needed to arrive at this training. You can compare the responses with the information. Show PowerPoint: Major Life Activities These are basic activities that the average person in the general population can perform with little or no difficulty. • • • • • • Caring for Oneself Performing Manual Tasks Walking Seeing Hearing Speaking • • • • • • • Breathing Concentrating Learning Working Sitting Standing Lifting Major Life Activities: These are basic activities that the average person in the general population can perform with little or no difficulty. Caring for Oneself Performing Manual Tasks Walking Seeing Hearing Speaking Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-16 N O T E S Breathing Concentrating Learning Working Sitting Standing Lifting Let’s examine some disabilities that we are familiar with and the major life activity that is substantially limited. Individuals who are deaf are substantially limited in their ability to hear. Individuals who use wheelchairs are substantially limited in their ability to walk. Individuals who have cerebral palsy may be substantially limited in their ability to perform manual tasks. The key is to look at each person individually. Not all cases are clear-cut. There are some individuals with impairments that may or may not be covered by the ADA. It all depends on how the impairment affects the individual. For example, what about individuals with asthma? Whether they are considered a person with a disability depends on how the asthma affects their ability to perform major life activities. It is important to remember that people with the same disability may function very differently—some may be substantially limited and some may not. We now know the ADA’s definition of who a “person with a disability” is. The ADA only protects a qualified person with a disability. Let’s look at the ADA’s definition of qualified. Show PowerPoint: Qualified Individual with a Disability A qualified individual with a disability means one who satisfies the requisite skill, experience, education, and other job-related requirements of the position such individual holds or desires, and who: • with or without reasonable accommodation can perform • the essential functions of such a position Qualified Individual with a Disability: A qualified individual with Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-17 N O T E S a disability means one who satisfies the requisite skill, experience, education, and other job-related requirements of the position such individual holds or desires, and who: with or without reasonable accommodation can perform the essential functions of such a position Always remember you never have to consider anybody who is not qualified for the job!! The person, regardless of disability, must be qualified and the employer determines who is qualified. Let’s see what the term reasonable accommodation means. Show PowerPoint: A Reasonable Accommodation is: • Any change in the work environment or way things are done that enables a person with a disability to enjoy equal employment opportunity • Must be provided to qualified individuals unless it poses an undue hardship A Reasonable Accommodation is: Any change in the work environment or way things are done that enables a person with a disability to enjoy equal employment opportunity Must be provided to qualified individuals unless it poses an undue hardship Show PowerPoint: Reasonable Accommodation Means: • Modification to the job application process • Modification to the work environment or the manner under which the position held is customarily performed • Modification that enables an employee with a disability to enjoy equal benefits and privileges of employment Reasonable Accommodation Means: Modification to the job application process Modification to the work environment or the manner under which the position held is customarily performed Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-18 N O T E S Modification that enables an employee with a disability to enjoy equal benefits and privileges of employment The term reasonable means plausible or feasible in this context. We are discussing accommodations that are effective for both the individual and the employer. Employers must make effective accommodations to the known physical or mental limitations of a qualified applicant or employee with a disability, unless the employer can demonstrate that the accommodation would pose an undue hardship. Show PowerPoint: Reasonable Accommodations are Dependent Upon: • The specific requirements of the job • The particular needs of the employee or applicant • The extent to which modifications or aids are available without causing undue hardship Reasonable Accommodations are dependent upon: The specific requirements of the job The particular needs of the employee or applicant The extent to which modifications or aids are available without causing undue hardship Accommodations are made to alleviate or lessen the effects of a specific barrier. Obviously, accommodations are dependent on the disability and the specific job requirements. Let’s look at some examples: Show PowerPoint: Reasonable Accommodations can include • Flexible work schedules • Providing qualified readers or interpreters • Adjustment or modifications of examinations, training materials, or policies • Rearranging workspace to accommodate necessary equipment • Reassignment to vacant positions Reasonable Accommodations can include: Flexible work schedules Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-19 N O T E S Providing qualified readers or interpreters Adjustment or modifications of examinations, training materials, or policies Rearranging workspace to accommodate necessary equipment Reassignment to vacant positions Have you ever known an employer to make provisions to help their employees be more productive? Try to think of some examples of non-disability related accommodations. Prompt: for people who work at computers—glare guards for people who answer several phones—headsets for parents with child care needs—flexible schedules All of these are examples of accommodations that employers may currently provide for all workers. Who is the first consultant or expert you should talk to about providing an effective accommodation? the accommodation! The Job Accommodation Network (JAN) is an information and consultation service providing individualized accommodation solutions via a dedicated 800 line and website. JAN’s purpose is to make it possible for employers and others to share information about job accommodations. Their website is an excellent resource of accommodation ideas for specific disabilities. The telephone number is 1-800-ADA-WORK voice/TTY or on the web at www.jan.wvu.edu. JAN conducted a survey of employers to examine the cost of reasonable accommodations. It found that: Show PowerPoint: Reasonable Accommodations Average Cost of Job Accommodations: – 20% of all accommodations suggested had no cost – 51% cost between $1 and $500 – 11% cost between $501 and $1,000 – 3% cost between $1,001 and $1,500 – 3% cost between $1,501 and $2,000 – 8% cost between $2,001 and $5,000 – 4% cost more than $5,000 Source: Job Accommodation Network Survey Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-20 N O T E S Average Cost of Job Accommodations 20% of all accommodations suggested had no cost 51% cost between $1 and $500 11% cost between $501 and $1,000 3% cost between $1,001 and $1,500 3% cost between $1,501 and $2,000 8% cost between $2,001 and $5,000 4% cost more than $5,000 (Source: Job Accommodation Network) 7 There is a four-step process used to determine a reasonable accommodation. The most important step is consulting with the individual with the disability while keeping an open mind. Show PowerPoint: Determining Reasonable Accommodation: Review the particular job and determine its purpose and the essential functions Consult with the individual with a disability to determine his or her need for accommodation Identify potential accommodations in consultation with the individual Should alternatives be discovered in the accommodation process, consider the preference of the individual and select the method that best serves both the individual and the employer Determining Reasonable Accommodation: Review the particular job and determine its purpose and the essential functions Consult with the individual with a disability to determine his or her need for accommodation Identify potential accommodations in consultation with the individual Should alternatives be discovered in the accommodation process, consider the preference of the individual and select the method that best serves both the individual and the employer The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission emphasizes that this process should be an interactive one between the employer and the employee. The ADA says that you are obligated to consider providing a reasonable accommodation only for a qualified person with a disability who discloses the need for an accommodation. Generally, it is the individual’s responsibility to request an Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-21 N O T E S accommodation. Now we are going to review exactly what an employer can and cannot ask during an interview according to the ADA. First let’s looks at what questions an interviewer may ask. Show PowerPoint: Disability Related Inquiries Interviewer May Ask Questions About: • An applicant’s ability to perform jobrelated duties • An applicant’s previous job experience • Skills required to perform the job • Educational background Disability Related Inquires: An Interviewer May Ask Questions About: An applicant’s ability to perform job-related duties (e.g. Please look at the attached job description. Can you perform these tasks with or without an accommodation?) An applicant's previous job experience (e.g. What were your responsibilities at your previous place of employment?) Skills required to perform the job (e.g. Tell me about your skills and how they will allow you to perform this job.) Educational background (e.g. Where did you attend school? What did you study?) Emphasize: Basically, you can ask anything you need to know about the applicant’s skills and ability to perform the job. Always ask questions that focus on the job and its essential functions. Concentrate on the individual’s ability rather than disability. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-22 N O T E S Show PowerPoint: Disability Related Inquiries Interviewer May Not Ask About: • The nature or extent of the applicant’s disability • If the applicant or anyone in his/her family has a disability • The applicant’s health • If the applicant has a history of emotional illness • If the applicant has ever had an injury or disease • If the applicant has ever seen a psychiatrist • If the applicant has ever had a drug or drinking problem Disability Related Inquiries: Interviewer May Not Ask About: The nature or extent of the applicant’s disability If the applicant or anyone in his/her family has a disability The applicant’s health If the applicant has a history of emotional illness If the applicant has ever had an injury or disease If the applicant has ever seen a psychiatrist If the applicant has ever had a drug or drinking problem The law says that you cannot make any disability-related inquiries before a conditional offer of employment is made. Keep the focus on the job and the requirements for the job. Generally, these questions can be asked post-offer and before employment begins, as long as they are asked of all applicants. All policies prohibiting current illegal drug use, drinking alcohol on the job, or administration of drug tests are permissible. It is important to remember that many people with disabilities are already on the job, and may need accommodations at any point during employment. Show PowerPoint: Disclosure Under the ADA, an employer must provide reasonable accommodations to the known physical or mental limitations of a qualified applicant or employee with a disability. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-23 N O T E S Disclosure: Under the ADA, an employer must provide reasonable accommodations to the known physical and mental limitations of a qualified applicant or employee with a disability. It is important to remember that employers do not have to provide accommodations for disabilities that they do not know about. If an individual wants an accommodation, he or she must disclose their disability (assuming it is not apparent). For many individuals with hidden disabilities, disclosure is a tough and personal decision. One potential benefit is improved communication with a supervisor. Another is that once an individual discloses a disability, he or she is entitled to request a reasonable accommodation, which often results in increased satisfaction in the workplace and the ability to maintain and exceed professional goals. Still, there are possible risks for disclosure. While the ADA regulates how medical documentation can be used and demands confidentiality, it is unable to regulate attitudes and discrimination does sometimes follow disclosure. Individuals can disclose their disability during any point in the employment process. However, if an individual is having trouble meeting performance or conduct standards in the workplace because of the disability, it is not advisable for the employee to wait until problems become serious, as employers are not required to rescind any legitimate disciplinary actions that are taken prior to disclosure. An employer only has to provide reasonable accommodations that may enable the individual to meet the requirements after gaining the knowledge about the disability. The ADA does not say how an employee should disclose or request an accommodation. However, requesting an accommodation in writing and in person keeps communication clear. Of course, for individuals who do not need a reasonable accommodation, there is no need to disclose a disability. In circumstances when a disability is hidden or not obvious, the employer can ask for documentation to verify that the person has an ADA disability. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-24 N O T E S Show PowerPoint: Disclosure: Reasonable Documentation • Documentation from an appropriate professional concerning the individual’s disability and functional limitations • To verify the existence of a disability and the need for an accommodation Disclosure: Reasonable Documentation Documentation from an appropriate professional concerning the individual’s disability and functional limitations To verify the existence of a disability and the need for an accommodation Keep in mind the purpose of the documentation is to confirm that the individual has a disability and determine how to accommodate the individual on the job, not to find out everything about the person’s health and medical history. Therefore you are limited in what you can ask for, specifically, confirmation of disability and some explanation of the limitations imposed by the disability that are be relevant to the job and accommodation issues. Once a person discloses their disability, it is important to keep this information confidential. Show PowerPoint: Disclosure: Confidentiality • An employer must keep all information concerning the medical condition or history of its applicants or employees confidential and separate from personnel files • This includes medical information that an individual voluntarily tells his/her employer Disclosure: Confidentiality: An employer must keep all information concerning the medical condition or history of its applicants or employees confidential and separate from personnel files This includes medical information that an individual Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-25 N O T E S voluntarily tells his/her employer Finally, let’s look at the options a person with a disability has if they feel they have been discriminated against. Show PowerPoint: Title I Enforcement • File a complaint • EEOC • State FEPA • File a lawsuit • Alternative Dispute Resolution Title I Enforcement File a complaint (EEOC, State FEPA) File a lawsuit Alternative Dispute Resolution There is what’s called an exhaustive requirement under Title I of the ADA. A person must file a complaint with EEOC or the state FEPA (Fair Employment Practices Agency) before he or she can file a lawsuit. Once the EEOC or FEPA has investigated the complaint, they may issue a right to sue letter. At that point, the person can file a lawsuit. Finally, there is an option called Alternative Dispute Resolution. Both parties have to agree to have their case resolved by an ADA-trained mediator. Both EEOC and the Department of Justice have successful mediation programs. You may want to go into more detail on the employment provisions depending on the needs of your audience. (Do not attempt to address these issues if you are not knowledgeable about how the ADA applies to them.) Supplementary publications are available for most of these topics. The ADA & IT Information Center can provide you with this material (800-949-4232 voice / TTY and www.adata.org) Some other topics you might consider covering follow: Tax credits for employers Direct threat Qualification standards Illegal use of drugs and alcohol Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-26 N O T E S Medical exam requirements General non-discrimination requirements Relationships with other laws Insurance Worker's Compensation enforcement In summary, the ADA was passed to protect the civil rights of people with disabilities, the one minority group that anyone can join at any time. It cuts across national origin, gender, socioeconomic level, profession, race, religion and all other demographic factors. If you have not already, you may choose to distribute the ADA Summary at this point. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2-27 The AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT GET THE FACTS! TRUE / FALSE 1. ____ The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) mandates the hiring of individuals with disabilities. 2. ____ Businesses with 15 or more employees are covered by Title I (the employment provision) of the ADA. 3. ____ Sixty-five percent (65%) of working age individuals with disabilities are unemployed. 4. ____ There is a toll-free number that I can call to discuss the ADA and get confidential technical assistance to help my business. 5. ____ Governments must make all of their facilities fully ADA accessible. 6. ____ Two out of three unemployed people with disabilities would prefer to be working. 7. ____ Employees with disabilities are unable to meet performance standards. 8. ____ Employees with disabilities are more likely to have accidents on the job than employees without disabilities. 9. ____ Companies report that employees with disabilities have better retention rates, reducing the high cost of turnover. 10. ____ There is a forty percent (40%) chance of acquiring a disability if you live to the age of 80. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Handouts THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT GET THE FACTS! ANSWERS 1. FALSE – The ADA says you should hire the most qualified applicant. It does not mandate that you hire individuals with disabilities; it just ensures equal access to the employment process.1 2. TRUE - Businesses with 15 or more employees are covered by Title I (the employment provision) of the ADA.1 3. TRUE - Among working-age individuals with disabilities, only 35% work full or part-time (2004 National Organization on Disability / Harris Survey).2 4. TRUE - The ADA & IT Information Centers (also known as the DBTACs) have a toll-free number and provide free technical assistance! 800-949-4232 Voice / TTY 5. FALSE - Governments need to provide full program access. Their programs and services must be accessible when examined as a whole. This does not mean that each building must be fully accessible.1 6. TRUE - Two out of three unemployed people with disabilities would prefer to be working (2000 National Organization on Disability / Harris Survey).3 7. FALSE - According to a 1990 DuPont survey, 90% of employees with disabilities rated average or better in job performance compared to 95% for employees without disabilities. A similar 1981 DuPont study found that 92% of employees with disabilities rated average or better in job performance compared to 90% of employees without disabilities.4 8. FALSE - In the 1990 DuPont study, the safety records of employees with and without disabilities were identical.4 9. TRUE - Companies report that employees with disabilities have better retention rates, reducing the high cost of turnover (Unger, 2002).5 10. FALSE - There is a 73.6% chance of acquiring a disability if you live to age 80 (U.S. Census Bureau, 1997).6 Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Handouts The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) mandates the hiring of individuals with disabilities. TRUE FALSE Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Handouts Businesses with 15 or more employees are covered by Title I (the employment provision) of the ADA. TRUE FALSE Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Handouts Sixty-five percent (65%) of working age individuals with disabilities are unemployed. TRUE FALSE Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Handouts There is a toll-free number that I can call to discuss the ADA and get confidential technical assistance to help my business. TRUE FALSE Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Handouts Governments must make all of their facilities fully ADA accessible. TRUE FALSE Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Handouts Two out of three unemployed people with disabilities would prefer to be working. TRUE FALSE Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Handouts Employees with disabilities are unable to meet performance standards. TRUE FALSE Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Handouts Employees with disabilities are more likely to have accidents on the job than employees without disabilities. TRUE FALSE Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Handouts Companies report that employees with disabilities have better retention rates, reducing the high cost of turnover. TRUE FALSE Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Handouts There is a forty percent (40%) chance of acquiring a disability if you live to the age of 80. TRUE FALSE Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Handouts AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT SUMMARY TITLE I: EMPLOYMENT The ADA prohibits discrimination against a qualified individual with a disability in employment and includes specific requirements related to reasonable accommodation, qualification standards, and other labor management issues. The law specifically says “no covered entity shall discriminate against a qualified person with a disability because of the disability of such individual in regard to job application procedures, the hiring, advancement, or discharge of employees, employee compensation, job training, and other terms, conditions and privileges of employment” [Section 102 (a)].1 Generally, employers must provide “reasonable accommodations” to qualified employees with disabilities unless providing the accommodation would be an undue hardship. Title I defines “qualified person with a disability,” “reasonable accommodation,” and “undue hardship.” TITLE II: PUBLIC SERVICES (STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT) The ADA addresses services and activities of State and local governments, including public transportation provided by public entities. The transportation provisions of the Act are intended to improve access in vehicles, facilities, and systems. Title II requires that all public entities provide “program accessibility” to people with disabilities. It also requires that State and local governments modify policies, practices, and procedures to prevent discrimination against people with disabilities. Finally, Title II requires public entities to ensure effective communication with people with sensory disabilities (e.g. blindness, deafness, etc.). TITLE III: PUBLIC ACCOMMODATIONS The ADA addresses public accommodations, or businesses and services operated by private entities. Title III covers different types of public accommodations, such as hotels and motels, movie theaters, grocery stores, and retail stores, among others. Privately owned transportation is also included. The ADA specifically states "no individual shall be discriminated against on the basis of disability in the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages or accommodations of any place of public accommodation" [Section 302(a)].1 Businesses may need to modify their policies and practices and remove barriers to improve access. Public accommodations must also ensure effective communication for people with sensory disabilities. Title III also contains the ADA Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Handouts Accessibility Guidelines (ADAAG) which include the specifications for architectural accessibility. TITLE IV: TELECOMMUNICATIONS The ADA mandates that companies offering telephone service to the general public must offer telephone relay services to individuals with communication disabilities who use TTYs or similar telecommunications devices. Every state must have a relay system in place. The law specifically states the requirement to..."to ensure that interstate and intrastate telecommunications relay services are available... to hearing-impaired and speechimpaired individuals..." [Section 225(b)(1)].1 The relay system enables people with communication disabilities who cannot use a regular telephone to communicate with anyone. For example, Sally, who is deaf, wants to order pizza. Using a TTY, she calls the relay service by dialing 7-1-1. Once the relay operator answers, Sally types a message that she wants to call a pizza restaurant and types in the number for the operator to dial. The operator then calls the restaurant. The operator reads to the restaurant employee what Sally types, and then types back the reply from the restaurant to Sally. The operator continues to relay the questions, answers, and comments until the conversation is completed. TITLE V: MISCELLANEOUS Title V addresses the relationship between the ADA, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, and state laws. Whichever law provides the most protections to people with disabilities takes precedent over the other laws. In addition, the Act provides for administrative remedies comparable to those of Title II and VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Perhaps the most significant part of Title V is that it covers Congress and other agencies of the legislative branch of government. The ADA was passed to protect civil rights for people with disabilities. The law does not mandate preferential treatment. CONTACT YOUR REGIONAL DBTAC FOR MORE INFORMATION ABOUT THE ADA (800) 949-4232 VOICE / TTY www.adainfo.org Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Handouts Module Two Acknowledgements 1. The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. Public Law. www.ada.gov/pubs/ada.txt. All specific references are quoted in text of Module. 2. 2004 National Organization on Disability / Harris Survey. “Landmark Disability Survey Finds Pervasive Disadvantages.” www.nod.org/index.cfm?fuseaction=pa ge.viewPage&pageID=1430&nodeID=1&FeatureID=1422&redirected=1&CFID=32 44897&CFTOKEN=30732700. Information dated 6/25/04. Information retrieved 2/24/05. 3. 2000 National Organization on Disability / Harris Survey of Americans with Disabilities. “Executive Summary: 2000 N.O.D./Harris Survey of Americans with Disabilities.” www.nod.org/index.cfm?fuseaction=page.viewPage&PageID=861. Information dated 7/10/02. Information retrieved 2/24/05. 4. DuPont Corporation Study: U.S. Department of Labor. “Myths and Facts about People with Disabilities.” www.dol.gov/odep/pubs/fact/mythfact.htm. Information dated October 1994. Information retrieved 2/24/05. 5. Department of Education / Unger. “Disability Employment 101: Introduction.” www.ed.gov/about/offices/list/osers/products/employmentguide/introduction.html. Information dated 2/1/01. Information retrieved 2/24/05. 6. U.S. Census Bureau. “Meeting the Challenge: Americans with Disabilities, 1997.” www.census.gov/population/pop-profile/2000/chap19.pdf. Internet Release 2000. 7. Job Accommodation Network. “Accommodation Benefit / Cost Data.” www.jan.wvu.edu/media/Stats/BenCosts0799.html. Information tabulated through 7/3/99. Information retrieved 2/24/05. Quiz The Americans with Disabilities Act -- Get the Facts! Compiled by TransCen, Inc. “The Americans with Disabilities Act -- Get the Facts!” www.transcen.org. Specific facts from quiz cited individually above. Compiled February 2005. Handout The Americans with Disabilities Act – Summary Compiled by TransCen, Inc. “The Americans with Disabilities Act – Summary” www.transcen.org. Compiled November 2004. Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 Acknowledgements Slide 1 ___________________________________ Module 2 ___________________________________ Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 2 Module Goals • To understand the history of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and related legislation • 9 • To increase comprehension of the Americans with Disabilities Act and its employment provisions ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 3 Laws created in order to “level the playing field” • Architectural Barriers Act of 1968 • Rehabilitation Act of 1973 • Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) formerly Education for All Handicapped Children’s Act of 1975 • Fair Housing Act, as amended in 1988 • The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 PowerPoint Handouts Slide 4 ___________________________________ TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #1 The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) mandates the hiring of individuals with disabilities. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 5 ___________________________________ FALSE ___________________________________ ANSWER #1 The ADA says you should hire the most qualified applicant. It does not mandate that you hire individuals with disabilities; it just ensures equal access to the employment process. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 6 TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #2 Businesses with 15 or more employees are covered by Title I (the employment provision) of the ADA. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 PowerPoint Handouts Slide 7 ___________________________________ TRUE ___________________________________ ANSWER #2 Businesses with 15 or more employees are covered by Title I (the employment provision) of the ADA. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 8 ___________________________________ TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #3 Sixty-five percent (65%) of working age individuals with disabilities are unemployed. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 9 ___________________________________ TRUE ___________________________________ ANSWER #3 Among working-age individuals with disabilities, only 35% work full or part-time. (2004 National Organization on Disability / Harris Survey) ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 PowerPoint Handouts Slide 10 ___________________________________ TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #4 There is a toll-free number that I can call to discuss the ADA and get confidential technical assistance to help my business. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 11 ___________________________________ TRUE ___________________________________ ANSWER #4 The ADA & IT Information Centers (also known as DBTACs) have a toll-free number and provide free technical assistance! 800-949-4232 Voice / TTY ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 12 TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #5 Governments must make all of their facilities fully ADA accessible. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 PowerPoint Handouts Slide 13 ___________________________________ FALSE ___________________________________ ANSWER #5 Governments need to provide full program access. Their programs and services must be accessible when examined as a whole. This does not mean that each building must be fully accessible. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 14 TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #6 Two out of three unemployed people with disabilities would prefer to be working. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 15 ___________________________________ TRUE ___________________________________ ANSWER #6 Two out of three unemployed people with disabilities would prefer to be working. (2000 National Organization on Disability / Harris Survey) ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 PowerPoint Handouts Slide 16 ___________________________________ TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #7 ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Employees with disabilities are unable to meet performance standards. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 17 ___________________________________ FALSE ___________________________________ ANSWER #7 According to a 1990 DuPont survey, 90% of employees with disabilities rated average or better in job performance compared to 95% for employees without disabilities. A similar 1981 DuPont study found that 92% of employees with disabilities rated average or better in job performance compared to 90% of employees without disabilities. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 18 TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #8 Employees with disabilities are more likely to have accidents on the job than employees without disabilities. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 PowerPoint Handouts Slide 19 ___________________________________ FALSE ___________________________________ ANSWER #8 In the 1990 DuPont study, the safety records of employees with and without disabilities were identical. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 20 ___________________________________ TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #9 Companies report that employees with disabilities have better retention rates, reducing the high cost of turnover. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 21 ___________________________________ TRUE ___________________________________ ANSWER #9 Companies report that employees with disabilities have better retention rates, reducing the high cost of turnover. (Unger, 2002) ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 PowerPoint Handouts Slide 22 TRUE OR FALSE? QUESTION #10 There is a forty percent (40%) chance of acquiring a disability if you live to the age of 80. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 23 ___________________________________ FALSE ___________________________________ ANSWER #10 There is a 73.6% chance of acquiring a disability if you live to age 80. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ (U.S. Census Bureau, 1997) ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 24 The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) • Title I: Employment • Title II: Public Services • Title III: Public Accommodations • Title IV: Telecommunications • Title V: Miscellaneous ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 PowerPoint Handouts Slide 25 ___________________________________ Understanding RELAY ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 26 ___________________________________ Definition of Disability An individual with a disability is one who: has has a record of, or is regarded as having a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 27 ___________________________________ Definition of Disability Continued An individual with a disability is one who has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 PowerPoint Handouts Slide 28 Major Life Activities These are basic activities that the average pers on in the general population can perform with little or no difficulty. • • • • • • Caring for Oneself Performing Manual Tasks Walking Seeing Hearing Speaking • • • • • • • Breathing Concentrating Learning Working Sitting Standing Lifting ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 29 ___________________________________ Qualified Individual with a Disability A qualified individual with a disability means one who satisfies the requisite skill, experience, education, and other job-related requirements of the position such individual holds or desires, and who: • with or without reasonable accommodation can perform • the essential functions of such a position ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 30 ___________________________________ A Reasonable Accommodation is: • Any change in the work environment or way things are done that enables a person with a disability to enjoy equal employment opportunity • Must be provided to qualified individuals unless it poses an undue hardship ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 PowerPoint Handouts Slide 31 ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Means: • Modification to the job application process • Modification to the work environment or the manner under which the position held is customarily performed • Modification that enables an employee with a disability to enjoy equal benefits and privileges of employment ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 32 ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodations are Dependent Upon: ___________________________________ • The specific requirements of the job ___________________________________ • The particular needs of the employee or applicant ___________________________________ • The extent to which modifications or aids are available without causing undue hardship ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 33 Reasonable Accommodations can include • Flexible work schedules • Providing qualified readers or interpreters • Adjustment or modifications of examinations, training materials, or policies • Rearranging workspace to accommodate necessary equipment • Reassignment to vacant positions ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 PowerPoint Handouts Slide 34 ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodations Average Cost of Job Accommodations: – 20% of all accommodations suggested had no cost – 51% cost between $1 and $500 – 11% cost between $501 and $1,000 – 3% cost between $1,001 and $1,500 – 3% cost between $1,501 and $2,000 – 8% cost between $2,001 and $5,000 – 4% cost more than $5,000 Source: Job Accommodation Network Survey ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 35 Determining Reasonable Accommodation: ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Review the particular job and determine its purpose and the essential functions ___________________________________ Consult with the individual with a disability to determine his or her need for accommodation ___________________________________ Identify potential accommodations in consultation with the individual Should alternatives be discovered in the accommodation process, consider the preference of the individual and select the method that best serves both the individual and the employer ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 36 ___________________________________ Disability Related Inquiries Interviewer May Ask Questions About: • An applicant’s ability to perform jobrelated duties • An applicant’s previous job experience • Skills required to perform the job • Educational background ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 PowerPoint Handouts Slide 37 Disability Related Inquiries ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Interviewer May Not Ask About: • The nature or extent of the applicant’s disability • If the applicant or anyone in his/her family has a disability ___________________________________ • The applicant’s health • If the applicant has a history of emotional illness • If the applicant has ever had an injury or disease • If the applicant has ever seen a psychiatrist • If the applicant has ever had a drug or drinking problem ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 38 ___________________________________ Disclosure ___________________________________ Under the ADA, an employer must provide reasonable accommodations to the known physical or mental limitations of a qualified applicant or employee with a disability. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 39 Disclosure: Reasonable Documentation • Documentation from an appropriate professional concerning the individual’s disability and functional limitations • To verify the existence of a disability and the need for an accommodation ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 PowerPoint Handouts Slide 40 Disclosure: Confidentiality ___________________________________ ___________________________________ • An employer must keep all information concerning the medical condition or history of its applicants or employees confidential and separate from personnel files • This includes medical information that an individual voluntarily tells his/her employer ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 41 Title I Enforcement • File a complaint ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ • EEOC ___________________________________ • State FEPA • File a lawsuit • Alternative Dispute Resolution ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Legal Implications: An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 2 PowerPoint Handouts Module 3 Reasonable Accommodation MODULE GOALS: To understand the concept of reasonable accommodation, its process, and the circumstances under which it is required To learn how to problem-solve situations where reasonable accommodation might be necessary in the workplace EQUIPMENT: PowerPoint Presentation (or alternate format) LCD Projector Computer / Laptop Flip Chart Flip Chart Markers Masking Tape MATERIALS: Handout: EEOC Reasonable Accommodation Process (in 6, 12, and 18 point fonts. Quiz: Famous People with Disabilities Handout: Famous People with Disabilities Quiz: Facts and Figures Quiz: Crossword Puzzle Handout: Accommodation Worksheet (with and without scenarios) Handout: JAN Accommodation Solutions for Functional Limitations TIME 45-60 minutes (time may vary) Reasonable Accommodation 3-1 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Review module before training and prepare necessary materials. Show PowerPoint: Module 3 Reasonable Accommodations Module 3: Reasonable Accommodations Before we begin, I’d like for you to review the following handout about the EEOC’s recommendations for the reasonable accommodation process. Distribute handouts in 6 point font. Wait for “grumbles” in the group and tell the group you have the same material in a larger font. Ask for a show of hands for those who would like a larger font. (Distribute 12 point font for those requesting). After distribution, tell the participants you also have the handout in an even larger font. Ask for a show of hands for those who would like an even larger font. Then distribute the handout in 18 point font. How many of you found a larger font easier to read? This example shows how some people who are experiencing vision problems might be accommodated when reading is required. Most reading material is provided in 10-12 point fonts. The last handout was in 18 point font, which is considered “large print,” and may be a form of reasonable accommodation. Many employers provide accommodations for their employees. Can you think of some examples? Prompt: flexible work schedules ergonomic office chairs PDAs desktop calendars changes of lighting These are all accommodations that make doing the job a bit easier. Reasonable Accommodation 3-2 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Why do employers do this? So that employees can be more productive and business can be more successful. The Americans with Disabilities Act requires that employers provide reasonable accommodation for qualified individuals with disabilities. So although employers have been accommodating their workers for many years, the law formalizes this process for people who may need an accommodation to perform the essential functions of their job. This module provides the definition and examples of reasonable accommodation, as well as actual scenarios where we will use a proven process to identify effective accommodations. Show PowerPoint: Module 3 Goals • To understand the concept of reasonable accommodation, its process, and the circumstances under which it is required • To learn how to problem-solve situations where reasonable accommodation might be necessary in the workplace Module Goals: To understand the concept of reasonable accommodation, its process, and the circumstances under which it is required To learn how to problem-solve situations where reasonable accommodation might be necessary in the workplace ----- If you are using Module 3 as a stand alone section and have not discussed the definition of disability materials from Module 2, it would be helpful to introduce this concept before proceeding with this section. Determining whether or not an individual is considered to be an “individual with a disability” under the ADA is the first step in the reasonable accommodation process. Although employers may choose to provide accommodations for any employees, the ADA only requires that employers provide reasonable accommodations for employees who meet the statutory definition of disability. ----- If you have already discussed the definition of disability in a previous module, or choose not to discuss it in Module 3, please skip to page 6 on this module. Reasonable Accommodation 3-3 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Let’s look at who is covered by Title I, the employment provisions of the ADA. Show PowerPoint: Definition of Disability An individual with a disability is one who: has has a record of, or is regarded as having a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity. Definition of Disability: An individual with a disability is one who: has has a record of, or is regarded as having a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity. Show PowerPoint: Definition of Disability Continued An individual with a disability is one who has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity. Definition of Disability (continued) - An individual with a disability is one who has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity. Emphasize: "Substantially limits" is a very high standard. Basically, it means that the person must have a disability that really limits their ability to perform a major life activity. Can anyone tell me some major life activities? Field responses from the audience. One method for soliciting information would be to ask participants to list the physical or mental tasks they needed to arrive at this training. You can Reasonable Accommodation 3-4 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S compare the responses with the information. Show PowerPoint: Major Life Activities These are basic activities that the average person in the general population can perform with little or no difficulty. • • • • • • Caring for Oneself Performing Manual Tasks Walking Seeing Hearing Speaking • • • • • • • Breathing Concentrating Learning Working Sitting Standing Lifting Major Life Activities: These are basic activities that the average person in the general population can perform with little or no difficulty. Caring for Oneself Performing Manual Tasks Walking Seeing Hearing Speaking Breathing Concentrating Learning Working Sitting Standing Lifting Let’s examine some disabilities that we are familiar with and the major life activity that is substantially limited. Individuals who are deaf are substantially limited in their ability to hear. Individuals who use wheelchairs are substantially limited in their ability to walk. Individuals who have cerebral palsy may be substantially limited in their ability to perform manual tasks. The key is to look at each person individually. Not all cases are clear-cut. There are some individuals with impairments that may or may not be covered by the ADA. It all depends on how the impairment affects the individual. For example, what about individuals with asthma? Whether they Reasonable Accommodation 3-5 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S are considered a person with a disability depends on how the asthma affects their ability to perform major life activities. It is important to remember that people with the same impairment may function very differently, some may be substantially limited and some may not. ----- If you chose to skip the definition of disability, please resume here. Suggested language for the transition: Now that you all already know the ADA’s definition of disability from our previous workshop… Let’s take a minute to look at our list of major life activities in a slightly different way. Which of these activities might individuals with hidden disabilities have substantial limitations in? Elicit responses Are individuals with hidden disabilities entitled to reasonable accommodation under the ADA? Elicit responses The ADA protects all people with impairments whether hidden or visible that meet the definition of disability. Simply put, a hidden disability is exactly that – a disability that is not recognizable from the outside. We may never know if some of our coworkers, acquaintances, or friends have hidden disabilities, if they choose not to tell us. Did you know that these famous people all have disabilities? Pass out Famous People Quiz and have participants complete it. After everyone is finished, go over the answers with the group. Show PowerPoint: Answers to the Quiz A B C D E F 7 4 8 6 10 5 G H I J K 2 11 9 3 1 Reasonable Accommodation 3-6 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Answers to the Quiz: A-7, B-4, C-8, D-6, E-10, F-5, G-2, H-11, I-9, J-3, K-1. Was any of this information a surprise to you? Does this information make you feel any differently about these people? Why? Why not? You may wish to distribute the supplementary handout about famous people with disabilities now to review with the group. You may also choose to distribute it at the end of the module to prevent distractions during the training. Depending on the needs of your audience, you may choose to highlight the prevalence of different diseases and disabilities in today’s society by distributing the Facts and Figures Quiz. Suggested language to accompany this quiz: Just like celebrities, many individuals have hidden disabilities. Please complete this quiz to fully comprehend the prevalence of these disabilities in our society. Many celebrities, just like other people, have disabilities that we are not aware of. Hidden or invisible disabilities may include emotional or behavioral disorders, learning disabilities, chronic or episodic illnesses, impairments of hearing, vision or speech, and the list goes on. Of course, the ADA’s definition of disability includes individuals with various impairments, who are limited in different major life activities. What is important is that they have an impairment which causes a substantial limitation. We now know the ADA’s definition of who a “person with a disability” is, and we know that it includes individuals with both visible and hidden disabilities. The ADA only protects a qualified person with a disability. Let’s look at the ADA’s definition of qualified. Show PowerPoint: Qualified Individual with a Disability A qualified individual with a disability means one who satisfies the requisite skill, experience, education, and other job-related requirements of the position such individual holds or desires, and who… Reasonable Accommodation 3-7 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Qualified Individual with a Disability: A qualified person with a disability means one who satisfies the requisite skill, experience, education, and other job-related requirements of the position such individual holds or desires, and who… Show PowerPoint: With or without reasonable accommodation can perform the essential functions of such a position. With or without reasonable accommodation can perform the essential functions of such a position. Essential functions mean job tasks that are fundamental—not marginal. Show PowerPoint: What makes a job task essential? • If the position exists to perform the function • If there are a limited number of employees among whom the task can be distributed • If the function is highly specialized What makes a job task essential? If the position exists to perform the function If there are a limited number of employees among whom the task can be distributed If the function is highly specialized The employer has the right to determine the essential functions, educational training requirements, and the performance standards of the job, as long as standards and requirements are consistently applied and are not established specifically to discriminate against people with disabilities. Reasonable Accommodation 3-8 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Show PowerPoint: Evidence of Essential Functions • Employer's judgment as to which functions are essential • Written job descriptions prepared before advertising or interviewing applicants • Amount of time spent performing the function Evidence of Essential Functions: Employer's judgment as to which functions are essential Written job descriptions prepared before advertising or interviewing applicants Amount of time spent performing the function Show PowerPoint: Evidence of Essential Functions Continued • Consequences of not performing the function • The terms of a collective bargaining agreement • Work experience of past incumbents on the job • Current work experience of incumbents in similar jobs Evidence of Essential Functions (continued): Consequences of not performing the function The terms of a collective bargaining agreement Work experience of past incumbents on the job Current work experience of incumbents in similar jobs When the functions of a particular job are being performed by a new employee, with or without a disability, barriers may exist that prevent that person from performing the job effectively. These barriers may, for example, include inexperience or may, in fact, be related to disability. In the case of disability, the ADA requires employers to consider whether a reasonable accommodation could remove the barrier. Reasonable Accommodation 3-9 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Show PowerPoint: Accommodations are: Any changes in the work setting that enable qualified workers to accomplish their tasks. Accommodations are: Any changes in the work setting that enable qualified workers to accomplish their tasks. Show PowerPoint: Scope of Reasonable Accommodation: • Modification to the job application process • Modification to the work environment or the manner in which the position held is customarily performed • Modification that enables an employee with a disability to enjoy equal benefits and privileges of employment Scope of Reasonable Accommodation: Modification to the job application process Modification to the work environment or the manner in which the position held is customarily performed Modification that enables an employee with a disability to enjoy equal benefits and privileges of employment The term “reasonable” means plausible or feasible in this context. The accommodation must be effective for the employer and effective for the employee. Show PowerPoint: Accommodations are dependent upon: • The specific requirements of the job • The particular need(s) of the employee or applicant • The extent to which modifications or aids are available without causing an undue hardship on the employing organization Reasonable Accommodation 3-10 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Accommodations are dependent upon: The specific requirements of the job The particular need(s) of the employee or applicant The extent to which modifications or aids are available without causing an undue hardship on the employing organization Who is the first consultant or expert you should talk to about providing an effective accommodation? The person needing the accommodation! When we start to think about possible reasonable accommodations, we are often too focused on the medical aspect of the disability. It is more important to focus on how a disability affects an individual rather than the medical diagnosis. This is especially significant when determining reasonable accommodation for individuals with hidden disabilities. When we think about how a hidden disability affects an individual, we are thinking about the individual’s functional limitations. As a large group, let’s work together to think of common functional areas in which individuals with hidden disabilities may face limitations. Using a flip chart, ask the audience to name functional limitations. If they need prompting, you can name a hidden disability and ask the audience what the functional limitation may be for an individual with a certain disability. If the audience finds this too difficult, you can use the PowerPoint Slides to explain the concept of functional limitations. Show PowerPoint: • • • • • Possible Areas of Functional Limitations Reading Writing Mathematics Organizational Skills, Memory and Time Management Managing the Physical Environment Possible Areas of Functional Limitations: Reading Writing Reasonable Accommodation 3-11 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Mathematics Organizational Skills, Memory and Time Management Managing the Physical Environment Show PowerPoint: Possible Areas of Functional Limitations Continued • Working at Full Productivity • Maintaining Stamina • Working Effectively with Supervisors • Interacting with Coworkers Possible Areas of Functional Limitations (continued): Working at Full Productivity Maintaining Stamina Working Effectively with Supervisors Interacting with Coworkers Show PowerPoint: Possible Areas of Functional Limitations Continued • Handling Stress and Emotions • Concentrating on Work Details • Completing Projects and Meeting Deadlines • Maintaining Tasks/Sequences and Maintaining Daily Information Possible Areas of Functional Limitations (continued): Handling Stress and Emotions Concentrating on Work Details Completing Projects and Meeting Deadlines Maintaining Tasks/Sequences and Maintaining Daily Information After we finish this workshop, I will distribute a handout with possible accommodation solutions for each of these functional limitations. Here is a relatively simple way to categorize accommodations: Reasonable Accommodation 3-12 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Show PowerPoint: Categorizing Accommodations • Physical Modifications • Managerial Action • Provision of Services Categorizing Accommodations: Physical Modifications Managerial Action Provision of Services For example, physical modifications can include: changes to facility changes to equipment Managerial Action can include: providing a flexible schedule providing unpaid leave restructuring job tasks Provision of Services can include: qualified interpreters qualified readers job coaches There are as many different accommodations as there are disabilities. Some examples include: Show PowerPoint: Examples of Reasonable Accommodation: • Making existing facilities used by employees readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities • Job restructuring • Part-time or modified work schedules Examples of Reasonable Accommodation: Reasonable Accommodation 3-13 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Making existing facilities used by employees readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities Job restructuring Part-time or modified work schedules Show PowerPoint: Examples of Reasonable Accommodation: Continued • Adjustment or modifications of examinations, training materials, or policies • Providing qualified readers or interpreters • Reassignment to vacant positions Examples of Reasonable Accommodation (continued): Adjustment or modifications of examinations, training materials, or policies Providing qualified readers or interpreters Reassignment to vacant positions Remember, a reasonable accommodation must work for both the employer and the person with the disability. The best person to identify the most effective accommodation may be the person with the disability. Show PowerPoint: The Job Accommodation Network is: An information and consultation service providing individualized accommodation solutions via a website and an 800 number. JAN’s purpose is to make it possible for employers and others to share information about job accommodations. The Job Accommodation Network is: An information and consultation service providing individualized accommodation solutions via a website and an 800 number. JAN’s purpose is to make it possible for employers and others to share information about job accommodations. JAN conducted a survey of employers to examine the cost of reasonable accommodations. The survey indicated the following:1 Reasonable Accommodation 3-14 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Show PowerPoint: Average Cost of Job Accommodations – – – – – – – 20% of all accommodations suggested had no cost 51% cost between $1 and $500 11% cost between $501 and $1,000 3% cost between $1,001 and $1,500 3% cost between $1,501 and $2,000 8% cost between $2,001 and $5,000 4% cost more than $5,000 Source: Job Accommodation Network Survey1 Average Cost of Job Accommodations – 20% of all accommodations suggested had no cost – 51% cost between $1 and $500 – 11% cost between $501 and $1,000 – 3% cost between $1,001 and $1,500 – 3% cost between $1,501 and $2,000 – 8% cost between $2,001 and $5,000 – 4% cost more than $5,000 (Source: Job Accommodation Network Survey)1 You may be surprised to learn that 82% of accommodations cost under $1,000. There is a four-step interactive process that the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission recommends employers follow to determine accommodations for employees. This is the same information that we distributed earlier in font size 6, 10, and 12. Show PowerPoint: Determining Reasonable Accommodation • Determine the essential functions of the job • Consult with the employee to determine his or her abilities and specific needs • Identify potential accommodations in consultation with the individual • If two or more possible accommodations exist, consider the preference of the individual, and then select the method that best serves both the individual and the business Determining Reasonable Accommodation Determine the essential functions of the job Consult with the employee to determine his or her abilities and specific needs Identify potential accommodations in consultation with the individual Reasonable Accommodation 3-15 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S If two or more possible accommodations exist, consider the preference of the individual, and then select the method that best serves both the individual and the business Emphasize that the most important steps are consulting with the individual with the disability and keeping an open mind. The ADA says that you are obligated to consider providing accommodations only for a qualified person with a disability who discloses the need for an accommodation. Distribute crossword puzzle to group. Show PowerPoint: CROSSWORD PUZZLE 1 2 2 3 4 3 4 Across: 1. Mosquitoes do it 2. Dogs do it 3. Horses do it 4. Children do it Down: 1. Insects that sting 2. Organs of vision 3. Big brothers do it to little sisters 4. Without effort This PowerPoint slide shows a blank crossword puzzle with four vertical columns intersecting four horizontal columns. It does not look like a typical crossword puzzle; rather it looks like one big square divided into 16 smaller squares. To fill in the puzzle, the clues for the across squares are: (1) Mosquitoes do it, (2) Dogs do it, (3) Horses do it, and (4) Children do it. The clues for the down squares are: (1) Insects that sting, (2) Organs of vision, (3) Big brothers do it to little sisters, and (4) Without effort. Take a few minutes to complete this simple crossword puzzle. After participants have spent 2-3 minutes on the crossword puzzle, walk around room to see how they are doing. Some participants may seem frustrated because a “logical” solution is not evident. Has anyone completed the puzzle yet? The answer should be “no.” Who would like to review the correct answers? Distribute answer sheet for the crossword puzzle and review. Reasonable Accommodation 3-16 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Show PowerPoint: CROSSWORD PUZZLE 1 2 3 4 B I T E B I T E B I T E B I T E 2 3 4 Across: 1. Mosquitoes do it 2. Dogs do it 3. Horses do it 4. Children do it Down: 1. Insects that sting 2. Organs of vision 3. Big brothers do it to little sisters 4. Without effort This PowerPoint slide shows the completed crossword puzzle. It includes the same clues as a reminder. The clues for the across squares are: (1) Mosquitoes do it, (2) Dogs do it, (3) Horses do it, and (4) Children do it. The clues for the down squares are: (1) Insects that sting, (2) Organs of vision, (3) Big brothers do it to little sisters, and (4) Without effort. Each horizontal row spells out the same word, “BITE.” To this effect, the first vertical row contains four Bs, the second row contains four Is, the third four Ts, and the fourth four Es. First – how would you typically complete a crossword puzzle – what do you already KNOW about crossword puzzles? Although the solution to this crossword puzzle was not found in the “typical” way, there was a solution. This puzzle illustrates one situation which could not be solved using prior knowledge and experience. Rather, you need to look at it in a new and different way. After I told you the correct answers, many of you said, “Ah ha!” Although the solution really was easy, it was not what immediately came to mind. This exercise shows that the more experiences we have, the greater our ability to think broadly, and expand our knowledge and experience in order to create easy solutions. Things are not always as difficult as we fear. Activity: Identifying Accommodations Now that you have practiced “thinking outside the box,” we will now complete an activity that involves determining reasonable accommodations based on different scenarios. Divide participants into groups and distribute two or three reasonable accommodation scenarios to each group. Prior to the training, read the scenarios below and pick which ones Reasonable Accommodation 3-17 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S you would like to use. Trainers can either pick one category, mix and match from different categories, or complete them all. Base this decision on the needs of your audience. They have been categorized based on type of disability. The handouts have one accommodation per page, so you can decide the variety in quantity and disability-based variation each group should discuss. The group can use the extra space on each piece of paper to brainstorm different ideas. There is also a PowerPoint slide for each of the accommodation scenarios. Direct each group to: (1) Review the steps necessary to provide reasonable accommodation; (2) Identify the barrier(s) in the scenario and at least one possible accommodation; (3) Categorize each solution under the appropriate heading (i.e., physical, managerial, services); and (4) Identify the resources possible to assist with implementation of these accommodations. As you work together, remember that there are multiple solutions. Many accommodations fall under "managerial action." Remember to focus on the individual’s functional limitations, not just their disability. Remind the groups to focus on a specific barrier, not disability. Do not assume the disability is the real barrier. Stress the need for creativity. This activity will take approximately 20 minutes (or more, depending on the size of your audience and how many scenarios you choose to use). Remember to leave time to discuss the Undue Hardship Section. When the small groups have finished, bring the whole group together again. Have each of the small groups present their accommodation plan using flip chart paper. Put all the suggested accommodations in the appropriate category. Reasonable Accommodation 3-18 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Deaf / Hard of Hearing #1 Juanita is a 32-year-old Postal Worker who communicates through handwritten notes, gestures and partial lip reading. She is in line for a promotion to the position of Time and Attendance Clerk. In the past, the person who was the Time and Attendance Clerk answered the telephone as a back up to the regular receptionist in addition to other duties. Juanita's supervisor is concerned about her ability to do the job and is considering denying Juanita this promotion because of his concerns. Possible Solution: Reassignment of telephone duties. #2 Saundra, who is applying for a position as a Data Process Entry Clerk, requires a sign language interpreter for the interview. The supervisor has some concerns that the company will need to hire a full-time interpreter for the employee to successfully perform her job duties. Possible Solution: Provide the interpreter for the interview, analyze the job and ask the applicant how he or she will perform the essential functions of the job. Possible Solution: Provide an occasional interpreter for such activities as trainings or staff meetings. #3 Laverne works in a formal, corporate office. The office staff communicates with each other through the use of an office intercom. Laverne is hard of hearing and finds the intercom difficult to use. She continually chooses not to use the office intercom to talk to her supervisor, as requested. Instead, she frequently poses questions to him in a loud boisterous voice that is an irritating disruption for her co-workers and supervisor. Possible Solution: Suggest that Laverne write her questions and then take them to her supervisor at a pre-arranged time. Possible Solution: Based on the level of Laverne’s hearing loss, a telephone amplifier may allow her to use the office intercom effectively. Mobility Impairments #4 Roberto, who uses a wheelchair, has just been hired by an accounting firm. His office is accessible but the conference room where all the staff meetings and trainings are held is not accessible. Possible Solution: Hold meetings and trainings in another, accessible location. Possible Solution: Depending on the size of the business and the costs involved, make the conference room accessible. Reasonable Accommodation 3-19 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S #5 Shirley uses a wheelchair and desires a job in the field of video and film. Shirley has several years of experience, but the only available position is entry-level labeling and packaging film cartridges. She feels this position is beneath her capabilities. Possible Solution: No accommodation required. She either chooses to accept the position or she doesn't. #6 Brian uses a wheelchair. His Mail/Messenger job also includes major photocopying jobs. He is unable to reach the selection button mounted on the rear of the photocopier. Possible Solution: Construct a stick with a rubber-tip to push the button or purchase a device that could be used for that purpose. #7 Jonathan, a Chef, is a paraplegic and uses a wheelchair needs to access several different areas in the restaurant kitchen. His co-workers prefer to continue standing as they cook. Possible Solution: The restaurant could install adjustable height workstations. They could also purchase a stand-up wheelchair, allowing the chef to remain in his wheelchair but work at standing height when necessary. (JAN solution) Speech Disability #8 Joe has a significant speech and articulation problem. His speech is considered unintelligible at times; he stutters and has many involuntary facial movements. Joe's supervisor is very patient and understanding, but shares the concern of others about the extra amount of time required of her and co-workers to understand and direct Joe. Possible Solution: Talk to Joe and ask for his suggestions, which might include the purchasing of a communication board or having Joe write his responses. Visual Impairment #9 An employer is interested in hiring Adam as a Paralegal. As a Paralegal, Adam would be responsible for conducting background research on various legal issues. Adam would also edit his supervising attorney’s cases, interview potential plaintiffs, and draft legal briefs. Adam has had experience doing this type of work in two previous positions. He is blind and the employer is concerned about how he could perform these tasks. Possible Solution: A screen reader might need to be purchased to enable Adam to conduct all of his computer work. The potential employer should discuss with Adam what types of programs have worked for him in the past and then adopt or create a similar effective accommodation. #10 Jeanette is a Radio Broadcast Announcer. She is blind and Reasonable Accommodation 3-20 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S needs to read the Associated Press wire news which she receives over the phone lines connected to a printer. Possible Solution: The station could supply the announcer with a Braille printer, which could be connected to the Associated Press wire. A switch would allow any user to quickly move between the Braille and regular printer. (JAN solution) Heat Sensitivity #11 Maya has multiple sclerosis and is extremely sensitive to heat. When she requests that the office thermostat be adjusted to meet her needs, her colleagues explain that they will be very cold. The company is unable to provide her with a private office. Possible Solution: The individual could be provided with a cool vest that keeps her body temperature down without affecting her colleague’s comfort. (JAN solution) Hidden Disabilities (Learning, Psychiatric) #12 Mohammed has held his position as Manager of the Communications Department for five years. His boss notices that he has become withdrawn in meetings, his work is late and he appears preoccupied while discussing business matters. When his supervisor shares his concerns, Mohammed explains that his doctor recently diagnosed Mohammed with depression. Possible Solution: Ask Mohammed how you can work together to adjust his workplace to accommodate him. Mohammad might need a flexible work schedule or a job coach. #13 Mark experiences a stress disorder and becomes easily overwhelmed. His company recently received a large work order and everyone is working under deadline to fill the order. Possible Solution: First, talk with Mark and solicit accommodations ideas from him. Then, consider dividing his responsibilities into smaller tasks that would be easier to handle one at a time. Possible Solution: Plan a schedule to prevent bottleneck of workflow and to allow adequate breaks for Mark. #14 Susie is applying for a job as a Stock Clerk. Part of the application process involves taking a multiple-choice test. Susie meets all of the qualifications for this job. However, she has a learning disability and has difficulty taking written tests. Possible Solution: Give an oral test or job try-out as an alternative. #15 William has a variety of tasks to perform at the plant nursery where he works. His duties consist of sweeping the floors, dusting Reasonable Accommodation 3-21 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S the shelves, restocking, watering the plants and collecting and restocking the carts from the parking lot. He often forgets to do some of his tasks. Possible Solution: Prepare a daily checklist of job duties and have William check them off as he completes them. Possible Solution: Pair William with a co-worker to act as a mentor. #16 Bob has Attention-Deficit / Hyperactivity Disorder. He is easily distracted on the job site and has a history of frequently engaging in loud, inappropriate conversation. Bob's work area faces a busy walkway into the office. Due to lack of office space and other factors, Bob can not move to another cubicle. Possible Solution: Re-arrange the way his desk faces, if possible. Possible Solution: Partition off his work area. Possible Solution: Instruct co-workers not to respond to inappropriate behavior and to reinforce appropriate behavior. #17 Tovah has mild mental retardation. She has the basic skills necessary for the job of Administrative Assistant, likes the work and shows potential. When she finishes one task, however, she tends to stand in one place and look around, unsure of what to do next. One of her co-workers has noticed this and will periodically give her small assignments to keep her busy. Possible Solution: Prepare a daily checklist of duties that Tovah can check off after completing and which will act as a prompt to begin the next activity. Possible Solution: Designate a co-worker as someone she can consult with when her supervisor is not around to answer questions or provide instruction. #18 Chen's job mandates a higher production rate than he is currently achieving. He was hired with the understanding and intention that his production rate would increase over a threemonth period. After several weeks, however, Chen is still performing below the mandated production rate for the position, and errors are increasing. Before determining an accommodation, the supervisor must identify the reasons for the decreased productivity and increased errors (e.g. skill issue, communication issue, training issue, etc.) Possible Solution: Provide re-training, as necessary. Possible Solution: Set realistic production goals that can be achieved gradually. If problems cannot be resolved, follow company procedures for termination. Reasonable Accommodation 3-22 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S #19 Jane has a learning disability, but her supervisor thinks that she has the skills to succeed. Lately, however, Jane has had problems with dressing inappropriately and making personal telephone calls during work. Her supervisor has discussed these problems with Jane and she made some improvements in her dress, although she still wears inappropriate shoes. Jane also continues making personal calls during work time. The supervisor admits that they do not have a formal company policy, but insists that Jane only use the phone during her breaks. Jane expresses her confusion, as she sees her co-workers making and receiving personal calls during work time. Possible Solution: Prepare a formal company policy and hold all employees in compliance. Possible Solution: Address each inappropriate behavior (telephone usage, dress, etc.) individually instead of together and devise a plan for achieving performance standards. #20 Given a specific mailing job duty that occurred only once a week, Rayford has difficulty remembering all the steps involved with the process. His supervisor is tired of having to repeat the directions each week. Possible Solution: Mark the mailing dates on a calendar and prepare written directions. Possible Solution: If the mailing tasks in this job are a marginal function, reassign task. #21 A Job Coach had been on the job site with Connie for two weeks, giving constant support to the supervisor and to Connie. The entire office was supportive of Connie and responded well to the Job Coach. It is now time for the Job Coach to reduce her time from the job site and let the supervisor assume more of a support role for Connie. The Job Coach senses panic from the supervisor and receives several calls each day with complaints like "Connie just walked into our boss's office and sat down at his desk." Possible Solution: Decrease working time with Connie and increase training time with the supervisor. Prepare a schedule for reducing the time the Job Coach will spend at the job site. #22 Sally, who has a developmental disability, works at a warehouse. For two weeks, Sally’s Manager trained her and directed her when to take a lunch break. At the end of the second week, the Manager was transferred. On that same day, her new manager did not direct her to take a break and so she worked six hours without a lunch break. Sally is very concerned that she may never be given an opportunity to take lunch breaks. Reasonable Accommodation 3-23 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Possible Solution: Provide an orientation and training for her new manager. Possible Solution: Provider Sally with a watch/timer device. Possible Solution: Designate a co-worker to act as a "buddy" telling Sally when it is time for her to go on break. #23 Rebecca, who has a spinal cord injury, loves her job, her coworkers and her supervisor. Recently, however, she has had difficulty making it to work on time and has been missing days due to problems with childcare. Possible Solution: It appears that the problem is unrelated to disability and specific to childcare. Rebecca’s employer does not have an obligation under the ADA to accommodate her childcare needs. However, if other employees are allowed consideration for childcare or other needs, Rebecca cannot be denied equal consideration. Show PowerPoint: Undue Hardship Significant Difficulty or Expense Undue Hardship: Significant Difficulty or Expense It is important to note in any discussion about reasonable accommodation that an employer must provide the accommodation unless it would pose an undue hardship. Undue hardship means significant difficulty or expense. The concepts of reasonable accommodation and undue hardship depend on the specifics of the particular situation and personnel involved. When determining whether a particular accommodation would pose an undue hardship, the employer must base the decision on an individualized assessment. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) states that the following factors must be considered when determining undue hardship: the nature and cost of the accommodation needed; the overall financial resources of the facility making the reasonable accommodation; the number of employees at this facility; the effect on expenses and resources of the facility; Reasonable Accommodation 3-24 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S the overall financial resources, size, number of employees, and type and location of facilities of the employer (if the facility involved in the reasonable accommodation is part of a larger entity); the type of operation of the employer, including the structure and functions of the workforce, the geographic separateness, and the administrative or fiscal relationship between the facility involved in making the accommodation and the employer; the impact of the accommodation on the operation of the facility. The next slides list examples of accommodations that are not considered to be reasonable. Show PowerPoint: Examples of Accommodations that are NOT REASONABLE • Placing an applicant with a disability in a job for which he/she did not specifically apply • Placing an individual with a disability into a job if doing so would create a direct threat to the health or safety of the individual or others • Maintaining the salary of an employee reassigned from a higher-paying job to a lower-paying job, if the employer does not do so for other employees Examples of Accommodations that are NOT REASONABLE: Placing an applicant with a disability in a job for which he/she did not specifically apply Placing an individual with a disability into a job if doing so would create a direct threat to the health or safety of the individual or others Maintaining the salary of an employee reassigned from a higher-paying job to a lower-paying job, if the employer does not do so for other employees Show PowerPoint: Examples of Accommodations that are NOT REASONABLE Continued • Eliminating essential functions of the job • Lowering production standards • Providing personal use items (e.g. prosthetic limb, eyeglasses, hearing aids, wheelchair, hot pot or refrigerator) • Creating a job • Promoting an employee • Bumping another employee from his/her job Reasonable Accommodation 3-25 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Examples of Accommodations that are NOT REASONABLE (continued): Eliminating essential functions of the job Lowering production standards Providing personal use items (e.g. prosthetic limb, eyeglasses, hearing aids, wheelchair, hot pot or refrigerator) Creating a job Promoting an employee Bumping another employee from his/her job Undue hardship is an extremely high standard and this decision is best left to management or the head of the company and should be documented. It is important to put the concept of reasonable accommodation in perspective and remember that most employers are providing accommodations for their workers all the time just by being “good” employers. Since the ADA went into effect, we have seen that providing reasonable accommodation is generally not difficult for employers. Most employers who engage in the interactive process find it to be beneficial. When employers engage in this process, they often are able to provide very effective reasonable accommodations for their employees. Even if an employer eventually concludes that a reasonable accommodation does not exist, all parties involved typically feel confident that the decision was made in good faith and without haste. Employers should be aware that if the accommodations do not enable the person to do the job, or if work is not performed adequately, and all other avenues for providing accommodations have been exhausted, the same disciplinary actions taken with any employee should be enforced. It is important to understand the intent of the law with regard to reasonable accommodation so that when the issue does arise in the workplace everyone will be well equipped to address it. If you did not already do so, you should distribute the additional handouts / quizzes for this Module. (Handout: Famous People with Disabilities. Quiz: Facts and Figures, JAN: Example Accommodation Solutions for Functional Limitations). Reasonable Accommodation 3-26 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] A Process for Identifying a Reasonable Accommodation Recommendations from the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission 1. Look at the particular job involved. Determine its purpose and its essential functions. 2. Consult with the individual with a disability to find out his or her specific physical or mental abilities and limitations as they relate to the essential job functions. Identify the barriers to job performance and assess how these barriers could be overcome with an accommodation. 3. In consultation with the individual, identify potential accommodations and assess how effective each would be in enabling the individual to perform essential job functions. If this consultation does not identify an appropriate accommodation, technical assistance is available from a number of sources, many without cost. There are also financial resources to help with accommodation costs. 4. If there are several effective accommodations that would provide an equal employment opportunity, consider the preference of the individual with a disability and select the accommodation that best serves the needs of the individual and the employer. Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] A Process for Identifying a Reasonable Accommodation Recommendations from the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission 1. Look at the particular job involved. Determine its purpose and its essential functions. 2. Consult with the individual with a disability to find out his or her specific physical or mental abilities and limitations as they relate to the essential job functions. Identify the barriers to job performance and assess how these barriers could be overcome with an accommodation. 3. In consultation with the individual, identify potential accommodations and assess how effective each would be in enabling the individual to perform essential job functions. If this consultation does not identify an appropriate accommodation, technical assistance is available from a number of sources, many without cost. There are also financial resources to help with accommodation costs. 4. If there are several effective accommodations that would provide an equal employment opportunity, consider the preference of the individual with a disability and select the accommodation that best serves the needs of the individual and the employer. Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] A Process for Identifying a Reasonable Accommodation Recommendations from the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission 1. Look at the particular job involved. Determine its purpose and its essential functions. 2. Consult with the individual with a disability to find out his or her specific physical or mental abilities and limitations as they relate to the essential job functions. Identify the barriers to job performance and assess how these barriers could be overcome with an accommodation. 3. In consultation with the individual, identify potential accommodations and assess how effective each would be in enabling the individual to perform essential job functions. If this consultation does not identify an appropriate accommodation, technical assistance is available from a number of sources, many without cost. There are also financial resources to help with accommodation costs. 4. If there are several effective accommodations that would provide an equal employment opportunity, consider the preference of the individual with a disability and select the accommodation that best serves the needs of the individual and the employer. Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] FAMOUS PEOPLE QUIZ The following famous personalities are individuals with hidden disabilities. Identify the paragraph that describes each person. Write the number next to the person’s name on the blank to the left of the paragraph. 1. 2. 3. 4. Thomas Edison Vincent van Gogh Albert Einstein Winston Churchill 5. 6. 7. 8. Abraham Lincoln Patty Duke Tom Cruise Walt Disney 9. Leonardo DaVinci 10. Harriett Tubman 11. Earvin “Magic” Johnson a. _____ I am currently a very popular movie star. Some of the movies I have starred in are “Top Gun,” “Rain Man,” “A Few Good Men,” and “Jerry Maguire.” I learn my lines by listening to a tape because I have dyslexia. b. _____ I struggled through grade school and lived with bipolar disorder. I later served as the Prime Minister of England. c. _____ I was slow in school and had a hard time doing my work. I didn’t do anything well until I realized a real strength of mine was drawing. I became a well-known cartoonist and movie producer. Some famous amusement parks have my name. d. _____ In the 1960s, I starred in a television show bearing my own name. I’m also an academy award winner. I co-authored a book and made for TV movie about my bipolar disorder. e. _____ As a child, an overseer struck me. The blow fractured my skull causing me to have narcolepsy for the rest of my life. I rescued hundreds of slaves through the Underground Railroad. f. _____ As the sixteenth president of the United States, I contributed to the end of slavery. I also suffered from a severe and incapacitating depression, which often led to thoughts of suicide. g. _____ I was a brilliant artist with several famous paintings, including my own self portrait. I had severe mental illnesses, including bipolar disorder. h. _____ I played NBA basket for 13 years with the LA Lakers. I played in 12 NBA All-Star games and won three MVP awards. In the early 1990s, I was diagnosed with HIV. i. _____ I always had trouble learning. My teachers said I was “obnoxious” and had “artistic talent.” During my lifetime my artistic talent was expressed through architecture, painting, sculpture, and engineering. One of my best-known paintings is the Mona Lisa. j. _____ My teachers thought I was slow and a dreamer. I didn’t learn to read until I was nine. I couldn’t get into college until I spent an extra year in preparation. After many failed jobs, I developed the theory of relativity. k. _____ Because my head was very large at birth, people thought I was abnormal. My mother took me out of school and taught me. As an adult, I invented the electric light bulb and the phonograph. Adapted from Everybody’s Different: Understanding and Changing our Reactions to Disabilities, Miller, Nancy B. and Sammons, Catherine C. (1999) Original Source: Unknown. Reproduced from Take A Walk In My Shoes - A Guide Book for Youth on Diversity Awareness Activities. Also found on: www.ldonline.org/kidzone/inter_act/celebrity_quiz.html. Page last modified 2/22/05. Information retrieved 2/24/05. With information from NAMI: People with Mental Illness Enrich Our Lives. www.nami.org/Template.cfm?Secti on=Helpline1&template=/ContentManagement/ContentDisplay.cfm&ContentID=4858. Information retrieved 5/2/05. Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] FAMOUS PEOPLE QUIZ Answers a. 7 - Tom Cruise b. 4 - Winston Churchill c. 8 - Walt Disney d. 6 - Patty Duke e. 10 - Harriett Tubman f. 5 - Abraham Lincoln g. 2 - Vincent van Gogh h. 11 - Earvin “Magic” Johnson i. 9 - Leonardo DaVinci j. 3 - Albert Einstein k. 1 - Thomas Edison Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Famous People with Disabilities Jim Abbott Stephen Hawking Terence Parkin Franklin Roosevelt Leo Tolstoy Lionel Aldridge Henry Holden Itzhak Perlman Marla Runyan Heather Whitestone Chris Burke Marlee Matlin Christopher Reeve Mike Utley Virginia Wool Jim Abbott Jim Abbott has thrown a no-hitter, won Olympic gold in 1988, and been on “Letterman”. He is one of a handful of professional players who never once put on a minor-league uniform, jumping instead straight from college baseball to the big league. But those aren’t the only reasons we know Jim Abbott. He is the only player in major league baseball who was born with one hand. Abbott was able to reach the major league without having a right hand, and he quickly became one of the better pitchers in the game during the early 1990s. Lionel Aldridge A defensive end for Vince Lombardi's legendary Green Bay Packers of the 1960s, Aldridge played in two Super Bowls. In the 1970s, he suffered from schizophrenia and was homeless for two and a half years. Until his death in 1998, he gave inspirational talks on his battle against paranoid schizophrenia. His story was featured in numerous newspaper articles. Chris Burke Chris Burke, best known for the character Corky, played for four years on the television series, Life Goes On, and became one of America’s favorite personalities. Through his work, he was able to transform America’s image of people with disabilities. Ever since Chris spoke his first word, it became clear that he was a remarkable individual with many talents. Chris Burke was the first person with Down syndrome to star in a weekly television series. Currently, he serves as the National Down Syndrome Society (NDSS) Ambassador. Chris had the faith in his own abilities and the courage to face prejudice as he pursued his dream to become an actor. Today Chris travels all around the country delivering inspirational speeches to various groups of children, students, parents, and professionals. He not only serves as editor-in-chief of the NDSS magazine for teens and young adults with Down syndrome, but also writes a column and responds to readers and correspondence in a regular question-and-answer feature in the magazine. Stephen Hawking Stephen Hawking knew what he wanted to do by the time he was eight years old. He did not want to study medicine, a career his parents hoped he would follow. Instead, Hawking decided to be a scientist and chose physics. Stephen was interested in studying the universe. He attended Oxford University in England as an undergraduate student. He received his PhD in 1966 from Cambridge University. By the time he was 35 years old, Hawking was Cambridge’s first Gravitational Physics professor and received the Lucasian Professor of Mathematics award. Stephen Hawking has also published a book called A Brief History of Time: From the Big Bang to Black Holes. The book tries to explain many of Hawking’s physical and mathematical ideas and calculations without using math. The book became a best seller and was made into a movie. When Stephen Hawking was 21 years old, he was diagnosed with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), also know as Lou Gehrig’s disease. This disease attacks the nerves that control a body’s voluntary movements. It affects walking, speaking, breathing, swallowing, etc. At the time of his diagnosis, the doctors gave Hawking Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] two years to live. Hawking has defied this time frame and is still working. Today, Stephen uses a wheelchair, cannot move much at all, has trouble holding his head up, and cannot speak. He now uses a special computer that displays the text he types and speaks what he types with an electronic voice. Henry Holden From the time he was a young child, Henry Holden’s dream was that of becoming an actor. To date Henry has numerous acting credits to his name. He has made appearances on T. J. Hooker, M.A.S.H., AFTERmash, Hill Street Blues, Knots Landing, Hunter, Dear John, and Kids Incorporated. Henry also starred in a rock video, entitled, "I Got News for You." In addition to acting, Henry is an athlete, stand-up comic, and activist. Henry’s athletic accomplishments include downhill skiing, certified scuba diving, bowling a high score of 196 in league competition, flying gliders and single engine airplanes, riding at the National Horse Show at Madison Square Garden in New York City, and finishing in the Los Angeles Marathon. Finishing the New York City Marathon is on Henry’s "To Do" list! Henry Holden contracted polio during the 1952 epidemic. He was four years old at that time. His disability has never stopped him from pursuing a path of excellence in his life, even though he wears leg braces and uses crutches. In addition to his acting career he now speaks on the guest lecture circuit on college campuses across the country. Henry is a tireless advocate for the inclusion of people with disabilities in all forms of entertainment and media. He is the founder of Performers with Disabilities for the Screen Actors Guild, and recently, he was the recipient of the very first American Scene Award given by the Screen Actors Guild and the American Federation of Television and Radio Arts for the rock video he starred in entitled "I Got News for You." Henry’s motto is "Attitudes are the Real Disability!" Marlee Matlin Marlee Matlin is an actress. Some of her films include Dead Silence, It’s My Party, Hear No Evil, Bridge to Silence, Walker, and Children of a Lesser God. In 1987, she captivated the world by winning the Academy Award for Best Actress in the film Children of a Lesser God. Marlee Matlin became deaf in infancy due to Roseola infantum. However, deafness has not disabled her or her career. Terence Parkin Many swimmers competed in multiple events during the 2000 Olympics in Sydney, Australia. One of them was Terence Parkin of South Africa. Terence's events included the 200 and 400 meter individual medley, the 4x100 meter free relay, and the 100 and 200 meter breaststroke. He swam in a total of eight different qualifying and final races in five days during the Olympics. Terence finished fifth in the 400 meter individual medley. In the 200 meter breaststroke, he finished second to win the silver medal. What makes this 20-year-old Olympic swimmer somewhat unique is that he has never been able to hear a race starter's signal. Born deaf, Terence uses a strobe light similar to a camera flash to signal the beginning of the race. The Olympic competitor only began swimming at age 14. Now he holds three national records in South Africa and owns a silver medal from the Sydney Olympics. Itzhak Perlman Perlman began his music career at the Academy of Music in Tel-Aviv, Israel. In 1958, at the age of 13, Itzhak Perlman won an Israeli talent competition. This win made it possible for Perlman to travel to the United States to tour and appear on television. He then stayed in the U.S. and continued his musical training at the Juilliard School in New York City. In 1964, Perlman won a contest among young musicians known as the Leventritt Competition. Winning this competition opened the door for young Perlman to perform his violin music all over the world. Itzhak, now one of the most acclaimed violinists of his generation, has performed with every major orchestra and in recitals and festivals the world over. In 1986, he received the nation’s Medal of Liberty from U.S. President Ronald Reagan. His joy in making music has captivated audiences and earned Perlman a great level of respect and admiration among people of many nations. Great violin concertos make up the core of Perlman’s recorded music, ranging from the baroque to the contemporary. Most recently, Perlman is featured in the hit new movie "Music of the Heart." Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Born (1945) in Tel Aviv, Israel, Itzhak Perlman contracted polio at age 4, permanently paralyzing his legs. He performs his music while seated and walks with crutches. Itzhak is a well known advocate for people with disabilities, actively promoting laws to ease access to buildings and transportation. Christopher Reeve Christopher Reeve grew up in Princeton, New Jersey, with his mother and his stepfather. In 1977 Reeve was chosen from 200 hopefuls to star in Superman, for which he won the British Academy Award as best actor. During a cross-country event in May 1995, his horse balked at a rail jump, pitching Reeve forward where he landed head first. His injuries left the actor paralyzed, unable to use any of his limbs or even to breathe without the help of a respirator. Reeve dedicated much of his life to increasing public awareness about spinal cord injury and to raising money for research for a cure. He chaired the American Paralysis Association and served as vice chairman of the National Organization on Disability. Furthermore, Reeve founded the Christopher Reeve Foundation in 1996 to raise research money and provide grants to local agencies which focus on the quality of life of people with disabilities. Franklin Roosevelt In 1928, Franklin Roosevelt was elected as the governor of New York. He then started campaigning for the presidency, and he became the 32nd president of the United States in 1932. Furthermore, by defeating Alfred Landon in 1936, Wendell Wilkie in 1940, and Thomas Dewey in 1944, he became the only American President to serve more than two terms. In 1921, Franklin Roosevelt contracted a near fatal case of polio that left him with limited physical mobility. He established a foundation at Warm Springs, Georgia to help other people who had polio, and he directed the March of Dimes Program that eventually funded an effective vaccine. As a result of polio, Roosevelt used a wheelchair and stood with the aid of steel leg braces. He tried numerous treatments, but was never able to walk on his own again. Marla Runyan One of the women representing the United States in the 1500 meter track event at the 2000 Olympics was Marla Runyan. The American runner finished seventh in her preliminary heat and rose to sixth in the semifinals to qualify for the finals. During the final race, Marla lost track of the major competitors. She finished in eighth position, 3.20 seconds behind the gold medal winner. In 1996, Marla set several track and field records at the Paralympics in Atlanta, Georgia. Following that success, Marla wanted to compete in the 2000 Olympics in Sydney -- even though she is legally blind. The 31-year-old runner has been diagnosed with Stargardt disease. This is a condition that leaves her with a limited ability to see what is in front of her. In Sydney, Marla became the first legally blind athlete to compete in an Olympics. Leo Tolstoy Author of War and Peace, Tolstoy revealed the extent of his own mental illness in the memoir Confession. His experiences are also discussed in The Dynamics of Creation by Anthony Storr and The Inner World of Mental Illness: A Series of First Person Accounts of What It Was Like by Bert Kaplan. Mike Utley Mike Utley was the greatest football player in the history of John F. Kennedy High School in Seattle, Washington. He became only the second player at Washington State University to earn consensus first team All American Honors. During the Rams game in November 1991, he fractured his 6th and 7th cervical vertebrae and became paralyzed. Through his own fight to walk again, Utley founded the Mike Utley Foundation in 1991. The Foundation is dedicated to supporting research to cure paralysis and to help all people with spinal cord injuries. Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Heather Whitestone “The new Miss America for 1995 is...(drum roll)...Heather Whitestone of Birmingham, Alabama! There she is...Miss America.” But unlike other Miss America crown holders, Heather never actually heard those words in 1995 as she was crowned. Miss Whitestone was the first person with a disability ever to be selected as Miss America. Heather had been deaf since the age of 18 months. Doctors told Heather’s parents that she would never read beyond the third grade level, nor learn to speak. In response to the judges’ question about her aim in life, she replied that she would like to assist children from all backgrounds to reach their fullest potential in life, to set high goals, and achieve them, as she had done. Heather’s special talent for the Miss America talent portion of the contest was ballet. Heather Whitestone is currently the spokesperson for the Helen Keller Eye Research Foundation and the Starkey Hearing Aid Foundation. She has also authored a book entitled, Listening with My Heart. Ms. Whitestone is a motivational speaker who believes in and promotes following your dreams. Virginia Woolf The British novelist who wrote To the Lighthouse and Orlando experienced the mood swings of bipolar disorder characterized by feverish periods of writing and weeks immersed in gloom. Her story is discussed in The Dynamics of Creation by Anthony Storr. If you are interested in information about other people with disabilities, check out the following resource: Hent, D. & Quinlan, K. A. 1996. Extraordinary People with Disabilities. Danbury, CT: Children's Press, a Division of Grolier Publishing. Adapted from Indiana Institute on Disability and Community: Center for Disability Information and Referral. “Famous People with Disabilities.” www.iidc.indiana.edu /cedir/kidsweb/fpwdinfo.html. Page last modified 7/29/02. Information retrieved 2/24/05. With information from NAMI: People with Mental Illness Enrich Our Lives. www.nami.org/Template.cfm?Secti on=Helpline1&template=/ContentManagement/ContentDisplay.cfm&ContentID=4858. Information retrieved 5/2/05. Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Facts and Figures From the choices below, fill in the appropriate answer to complete the statement: Anxiety Disorders Asthma Cancer Diabetes Major Depression Arthritis Blind Chronic Kidney Disease HIV / AIDS Schizophrenia 1) _____________ is a chronic disease resulting from the inability of a body to efficiently use or create insulin. It usually manifests itself as one of two major types and about 800,000 new cases are diagnosed each year, or 2,200 per day. 2) This chronic pain condition called _________ affects more than 15 percent of the U.S. population—over 43 million persons—and more than 20 percent of the adult population, making it one of the most common conditions in the U.S. 3) ___________ is the second leading cause of death in the United States. During 2000, an estimated 1,220,100 persons were expected to be diagnosed with this. 4) Current estimates indicate approximately 10 million persons aged 12 years and older have some form of __________. Dialysis and transplantation are common treatments of this disease. 5) ________ has been reported in virtually every racial and ethnic population, every age group, and every socioeconomic group in every State and most large cities in the U.S. Estimates of the number of people with this disease in the U.S. range from 800,000 to 900,000. This infectious disease was first identified in the United States in 1981. 6) With modern treatments, increasing numbers of persons with __________ can and do view recovery as an achievable goal. More than 2 million people are affected by this disorder that is characterized by profound disruption in cognition and emotion. 7) _________affect as many as 19 million people in the U.S. annually. They encompass several discrete conditions, including panic disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder, and phobia. 8) About 6.5 percent of women and 3.3 percent of men will have _______ in any year. It differs both quantitatively and qualitatively from normal sadness or grief. 9) An estimated 14.9 million persons in the U.S. have _______. The worsening of this disease has been associated with exposure to tobacco smoke, sulfur dioxide, nitrogen dioxide, and acid aerosols. 10) An estimated 80 million people have potentially blinding eye diseases, 3 million have low vision, 1.1 million people are legally ______, and 200,000 are more severely visually impaired. Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Facts and Figures Answers 1) Diabetes 2) Arthritis 3) Cancer 4) Chronic Kidney Disease 5) HIV / AIDS 6) Schizophrenia 7) Anxiety Disorders 8) Major Depression 9) Asthma 10) Blind Compiled by the ADA & IT Information Center. Statistics from Center for Disease Control: Healthy People 2010. www.healthypeople.gov/document/html/volume1/toc.htm. Compiled December 2004. Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] CROSSWORD PUZZLE 1 2 3 4 2 3 4 Across: 1. Mosquitoes do it 2. Dogs do it 3. Horses do it 4. Children do it Down: 1. Insects that sting 2. Organs of vision 3. Big brothers do it to little sisters 4. Without effort Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] CROSSWORD PUZZLE 1 2 3 4 B I T E B I T E B I T E B I T E 2 3 4 Across: 1. Mosquitoes do it 2. Dogs do it 3. Horses do it 4. Children do it Down: 1. Insects that sting 2. Organs of vision 3. Big brothers do it to little sisters 4. Without effort Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Reasonable Accommodation Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Example Accommodation Solutions for Functional Limitations Reading Books on tape (people with learning disabilities qualify for this service) Tape-recorded directives, messages, materials Reading machines Screen reading software for computer use Colored mylar templates for reading and scanning Color-coded manuals, outlines, maps Scanners, which allow the user to enter hard copies into the computer system Writing Personal computers/laptop computers Voice output software that highlights and reads (via a speech synthesizer) what has been keyed into the computer. Voice input software that recognizes the user's voice and converts it to text on the computer screen. Locator dots for identification of letters/numbers on the keyboard Word processing software Spell checking software/electronic spell checkers Software with highlighting capabilities Grammar checking software Word prediction software Form producing software that computerizes order forms, claim forms, applications, credit histories, equation and formula fields Carbonless notetaking systems Mathematics Fractional, decimal, statistical, scientific calculators Talking calculators Computer Assisted Instruction (CAI) software for arithmetic/mathematics Computer Assisted Design (CAD) software for architecture/engineering Large display screens for calculators, adding machines Colored mylar templates, colored coding for maintaining ledger columns Organizational Skills, Memory, and Time Management Day planners Electronic organizers/schedulers Software organizers with/without highlighting capabilities LCD watches, data bank watches, timers, counters, alarms Personal Information Managers (P.I.M.S.) Use of electronic mail (E-mail) for memory deficits Managing the Physical Environment Room enclosures/cubicles to reduce auditory and visual distractions A private office space Use of "white noise" by using a sound soother/environmental sound machine Use of colored files Mapping of the workspace/office Working at full productivity A self-paced work load and flexible hours Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Backup coverage for when the employee needs to take breaks Time off for counseling An environment that encourages supportive employment and job coaches Work from home during part of the day or week Maintaining stamina A self-paced work load and flexible hours Flexible scheduling Longer or more frequent work breaks Additional time to learn new responsibilities Job sharing opportunities Working effectively with supervisors Establish written long term and short term goals Recognize that a change in the office environment or of supervisors may be difficult Maintain open channels of communication between the employee and the new and old supervisor in order to ensure an effective transition Provide weekly or monthly meetings with the employee to discuss workplace issues and productions levels Interacting with coworkers Educating all employees on their rights to accommodations Not mandating that employees attend work-related social functions Encouraging all employees to move non-work related conversations out of work areas. Handling stress and emotions Provide praise and positive reinforcement Refer to counseling and employee assistance programs Allow telephone calls during work hours to doctors and others for needed support Provide sensitivity training to coworkers Concentrating on work details Providing written job instructions when possible Allowing periodic rest breaks to reorient Minimizing distractions with sound absorption panels, cubicle walls and doors, and environmental sound machines Moving to a private office or area with fewer distractions Using watches and timers with prompts Allowing employee to use headset to listen to music. Completing projects and meeting deadlines Make daily TO-DO lists and check items off as they are completed Use several calendars to mark meetings and deadlines Remind employee of important deadlines Use electronic organizers Divide large assignments into smaller tasks and steps Remembering tasks/sequences or maintaining daily information Allow the employee to tape record meetings Provide type written minutes of each meeting Provide written instructions Allow additional training time Provide written checklists From JAN (Job Accommodation Network) http://www.jan.wvu.edu Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Examples for Hidden Disabilities A computer programmer with a learning disability experienced difficulty with reading, mathematics, and spelling. As an accommodation, her employer provided a schematic chart which summarized procedures to assist with her tasks. The programmer was an “auditory learner” and had problems with visual discrimination, so her employer also provided tutorial readers and "talking back" tapes. The total cost of the accommodations was $30. A clerk with a learning disability needed to maintain files, but had difficulty categorizing and sorting paperwork. As a result, the office was rearranged to eliminate visual distractions and task sequencing was utilized. The employer also provided reading templates, colored marker tabs, and incandescent lighting for the clerk. The total cost for these accommodations was $20. A rehabilitation counselor for a state agency had Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD). He had difficulty completing paperwork on time because he continually checked and rechecked it. The employer encouraged him to make a checklist for each report and to check off items as they are completed. This way, when the counselor felt the urge to recheck the report, he could do this quickly by using his checklist. Additionally, the counselor was allowed a certain amount of time away from the telephone each day to allow time to complete paperwork and file information. An administrative assistant with a learning disability had difficulty taking notes. His employer provided him with a tape recorder to record meetings and allowed the tape to be transcribed at the assistant's own pace. The cost of the accommodation was $60 for the tape recorder. A clerk/receptionist with a learning disability had difficulty typing from the printed original, as she often skipped lines. To avoid this problem, her employer provided an automatic “line guide” to avoid skipping lines. The total cost of the accommodation was $256 for the copyholder/line guide, and also for a lamp and magnified cursor. An administrative assistant in a social service agency had bipolar disorder. Her duties included typing, word processing, filing, and answering the telephone. Her limitations included difficulties with concentration and short-term memory. Her employer provided her with assistance in organizing her work and a dual headset for her telephone that allowed her to listen to music when not talking on the telephone. This accommodation minimized distractions, increased concentration and helped her relax. Also, the employee and her supervisor held meetings once a week to discuss workplace issues. Each meeting was recorded so the employee could remember issues that are discussed and replay the information to improve her memory. A typist with dyslexia was having trouble typing telephone numbers accurately. The typist was given verbal verification of the phone numbers and extra time to proofread letters. These accommodations were at no cost to the employer. A clerk needed extra reinforcement when performing duties, which included answering the phone, distributing pamphlets, entering "leads" into the computer, and answering questions. His employer provided a job coach for two weeks, with follow-up as needed for reinforcement. This accommodation was at no cost to the employer. A repairperson with severe depression needed to attend periodic work related seminars. The person had difficulty taking effective notes and paying attention in the meetings. The accommodation Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] implemented was to provide a coworker with a notebook that made a carbon copy of each page written. At the end of the session, they would tear out the second copy of the notes and provide it to the repairperson. Since he was able to give full attention to the meetings, he was able to retain more of the information. A record maintenance clerk with a learning disability and epilepsy was responsible for filing claims, searching for materials, and classifying material. The employee was provided a job trainer, and was retrained on many aspects of the job. There was no cost to the employer for this accommodation. An office manager who has been treated for stress and depression was unable to meet crucial deadlines. She had difficulty maintaining her concentration and staying focused when trying to complete assignments. She discussed her performance problems with her supervisor and accommodations were implemented that allowed her to organize her time. By scheduling "off" times during the week where she could work without interruptions. She was also provided a flexible schedule that gave her more time for counseling and exercise. The supervisor trained her coworkers on stress management and provided information about the company employee assistance program. Adapted from JAN (Job Accommodation Network) http://www.jan.wvu.edu Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #1 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Juanita is a 32-year-old Postal Worker who communicates through handwritten notes, gestures and partial lip reading. She is in line for a promotion to the position of Time and Attendance Clerk. In the past, the person who was the Time and Attendance Clerk answered the telephone as a back up to the regular receptionist in addition to other duties. Juanita's supervisor is concerned about her ability to do the job and is considering denying Juanita this promotion because of his concerns. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #2 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Saundra, who is applying for a position as a Data Process Entry Clerk, requires a sign language interpreter for the interview. The supervisor has some concerns that the company will need to hire a full-time interpreter for the employee to successfully perform her job duties. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #3 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Laverne works in a formal, corporate office. The office staff communicates with each other through the use of an office intercom. Laverne is hard of hearing and finds the intercom difficult to use. She continually chooses not to use the office intercom to talk to her supervisor, as requested. Instead, she frequently poses questions to him in a loud boisterous voice that is an irritating disruption for her co-workers and supervisor. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #4 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Roberto, who uses a wheelchair, has just been hired by an accounting firm. His office is accessible but the conference room where all the staff meetings and trainings are held is not accessible. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #5 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Shirley uses a wheelchair and desires a job in the field of video and film. Shirley has several years of experience, but the only available position is entry-level labeling and packaging film cartridges. She feels this position is beneath her capabilities. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #6 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Brian uses a wheelchair. His Mail/Messenger job also includes major photocopying jobs. He is unable to reach the selection button mounted on the rear of the photocopier. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #7 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Jonathan, a Chef, is a paraplegic and uses a wheelchair needs to access several different areas in the restaurant kitchen. His co-workers prefer to continue standing as they cook. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #8 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Joe has a significant speech and articulation problem. His speech is considered unintelligible at times; he stutters and has many involuntary facial movements. Joe's supervisor is very patient and understanding, but shares the concern of others about the extra amount of time required of her and co-workers to understand and direct Joe. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #9 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). An employer is interested in hiring Adam as a Paralegal. As a Paralegal, Adam would be responsible for conducting background research on various legal issues. Adam would also edit his supervising attorney’s cases, interview potential plaintiffs, and draft legal briefs. Adam has had experience doing this type of work in two previous positions. He is blind and the employer is concerned about how he could perform these tasks. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #10 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Jeanette is a Radio Broadcast Announcer. She is blind and needs to read the Associated Press wire news which she receives over the phone lines connected to a printer. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #11 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Maya has multiple sclerosis and is extremely sensitive to heat. When she requests that the office thermostat be adjusted to meet her needs, her colleagues explain that they will be very cold. The company is unable to provide her with a private office. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #12 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Mohammed has held his position as Manager of the Communications Department for five years. His boss notices that he has become withdrawn in meetings, his work is late and he appears preoccupied while discussing business matters. When his supervisor shares his concerns, Mohammed explains that his doctor recently diagnosed Mohammed with depression. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #13 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Mark experiences a stress disorder and becomes easily overwhelmed. His company recently received a large work order and everyone is working under deadline to fill the order. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #14 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Susie is applying for a job as a Stock Clerk. Part of the application process involves taking a multiple-choice test. Susie meets all of the qualifications for this job. However, she has a learning disability and has difficulty taking written tests. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #15 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). William has a variety of tasks to perform at the plant nursery where he works. His duties consist of sweeping the floors, dusting the shelves, restocking, watering the plants and collecting and restocking the carts from the parking lot. He often forgets to do some of his tasks. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #16 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Bob has Attention-Deficit / Hyperactivity Disorder. He is easily distracted on the job site and has a history of frequently engaging in loud, inappropriate conversation. Bob's work area faces a busy walkway into the office. Due to lack of office space and other factors, Bob can not move to another cubicle. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #17 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Tovah has mild mental retardation. She has the basic skills necessary for the job of Administrative Assistant, likes the work and shows potential. When she finishes one task, however, she tends to stand in one place and look around, unsure of what to do next. One of her co-workers has noticed this and will periodically give her small assignments to keep her busy. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #18 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Chen's job mandates a higher production rate than he is currently achieving. He was hired with the understanding and intention that his production rate would increase over a three-month period. After several weeks, however, Chen is still performing below the mandated production rate for the position, and errors are increasing. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #19 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Jane has a learning disability, but her supervisor thinks that she has the skills to succeed. Lately, however, Jane has had problems with dressing inappropriately and making personal telephone calls during work. Her supervisor has discussed these problems with Jane and she made some improvements in her dress, although she still wears inappropriate shoes. Jane also continues making personal calls during work time. The supervisor admits that they do not have a formal company policy, but insists that Jane only use the phone during her breaks. Jane expresses her confusion, as she sees her coworkers making and receiving personal calls during work time. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #20 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Given a specific mailing job duty that occurred only once a week, Rayford has difficulty remembering all the steps involved with the process. His supervisor is tired of having to repeat the directions each week. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #21 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). A Job Coach had been on the job site with Connie for two weeks, giving constant support to the supervisor and to Connie. The entire office was supportive of Connie and responded well to the Job Coach. It is now time for the Job Coach to reduce her time from the job site and let the supervisor assume more of a support role for Connie. The Job Coach senses panic from the supervisor and receives several calls each day with complaints like "Connie just walked into our boss's office and sat down at his desk." Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #22 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Sally, who has a developmental disability, works at a warehouse. For two weeks, Sally’s Manager trained her and directed her when to take a lunch break. At the end of the second week, the Manager was transferred. On that same day, her new manager did not direct her to take a break and so she worked six hours without a lunch break. Sally is very concerned that she may never be given an opportunity to take lunch breaks. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Accommodation Scenario #23 Read each scenario. Identify the problem(s) and any possible solutions to the problem(s). Rebecca, who has a spinal cord injury, loves her job, her co-workers and her supervisor. Recently, however, she has had difficulty making it to work on time and has been missing days due to problems with childcare. Worksheet 1. Do you have enough information to determine a reasonable accommodation? 2. Potential barriers: 3. Three Potential Solutions: Physical ModificationsManagerial ActionProvision of Services- 4. Resources: Reasonable Accommodations Module 3 Accommodation Scenarios Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module Three Acknowledgements Acknowledgements 1. Job Accommodation Network. “Accommodation Benefit / Cost Data.” http://www.jan.wvu.edu/media/Stats/BenCosts0799.html. Information tabulated through July 30, 1999. Information retrieved 2/24/05. General information about the ADA and reasonable accommodations can be found in two publications from the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC): a) EEOC. “Title I Technical Assistance Manual.” www.adaportal.org/Employment/Browse_TAM_I/Browse_TOC.html. Manual dated January 1992. b) EEOC. “Enforcement Guidance: Reasonable Accommodation and Undue Hardship under the Americans with Disabilities Act.” www.eeoc.gov/policy/docs/accommodation.html. Guidance dated 10/17/02. Quizzes Facts and Figures: Compiled by the ADA & IT Information Center. Statistics from Center for Disease Control: Healthy People 2010. www.healthypeople.gov/document/html/volume1/toc.htm. Compiled December 2004. Famous People: Adapted from: Everybody’s Different: Understanding and Changing our Reactions to Disabilities, Miller, Nancy B. and Sammons, Catherine C. (1999) Original Source: Unknown. Reproduced from Take A Walk In My Shoes - A Guide Book for Youth on Diversity Awareness Activities. Also found on: www.ldonline.org/kidzone/inter_act/celebrity_quiz.html. Page last modified 2/22/05. Information retrieved 2/24/05. With information from NAMI: People with Mental Illness Enrich Our Lives. www.nami.org/Template.cfm?Section=Helpline1&template=/ContentManagement/ ContentDisplay.cfm&ContentID=4858. Information retrieved 5/2/05. Crossword Puzzle: Original author unknown. Modified by TransCen, Inc. www.transcen.org. Modified December 2004. Handouts Famous People with Disabilities: Adapted from Indiana Institute on Disability and Community: Center for Disability Information and Referral. “Famous People with Disabilities.” www.iidc.indiana.edu/cedir/kidsweb/fpwdinfo.html. Page last modified 7/29/02. Information retrieved 2/24/05. Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Acknowledgements Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] With information from NAMI: People with Mental Illness Enrich Our Lives. www.nami.org/Template.cfm?Section=Helpline1&template=/ContentManagement/ ContentDisplay.cfm&ContentID=4858. Information retrieved 5/2/05. Accommodation Scenarios JAN Example Accommodation Solutions for Functional Limitations: Job Accommodation Network. www.jan.wvu.edu. Information retrieved December 2004. Adapted from the Job Accommodation Network. www.jan.wvu.edu. Modified by TransCen, Inc. www.transcen.org. Compiled June 2004. Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 Acknowledgements Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 1 ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Module 3 ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 2 Module 3 Goals • To understand the concept of reasonable accommodation, its process, and the circumstances under which it is required • To learn how to problem-solve situations where reasonable accommodation might be necessary in the workplace ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 3 ___________________________________ Definition of Disability An individual with a disability is one who: has has a record of, or is regarded as having a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 4 ___________________________________ Definition of Disability ___________________________________ Continued An individual with a disability is one who has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 5 Major Life Activities ___________________________________ ___________________________________ These are basic activities that the average pers on in the general population can perform with little or no difficulty. • • • • • • • • • • • • • Caring for Oneself Performing Manual Tasks Walking Seeing Hearing Speaking Breathing Concentrating Learning Working Sitting Standing Lifting ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 6 ___________________________________ Answers to the Quiz A 7 B C 4 8 D 6 E 10 F 5 ___________________________________ G 2 H 11 I 9 J 3 K 1 ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 7 Qualified Individual with a Disability ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ A qualified individual with a disability means one who satisfies the requisite skill, experience, education, and other job-related requirements of the position such individual holds or desires, and who… ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 8 ___________________________________ With or without reasonable accommodation can perform the essential functions of such a position. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 9 What makes a job task essential? • If the position exists to perform the function • If there are a limited number of employees among whom the task can be distributed • If the function is highly specialized ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 10 ___________________________________ Evidence of Essential Functions • Employer's judgment as to which functions are essential • Written job descriptions prepared before advertising or interviewing applicants • Amount of time spent performing the function ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 11 ___________________________________ Evidence of Essential Functions Continued • Consequences of not performing the function • The terms of a collective bargaining agreement • Work experience of past incumbents on the job • Current work experience of incumbents in similar jobs ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 12 ___________________________________ Accommodations are: Any changes in the work setting that enable qualified workers to accomplish their tasks. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 13 Scope of Reasonable Accommodation: • Modification to the job application process • Modification to the work environment or the manner in which the position held is customarily performed • Modification that enables an employee with a disability to enjoy equal benefits and privileges of employment ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 14 Accommodations are dependent upon: • The specific requirements of the job • The particular need(s) of the employee or applicant • The extent to which modifications or aids are available without causing an undue hardship on the employing organization ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 15 • • • • • Possible Areas of Functional Limitations Reading Writing Mathematics Organizational Skills, Memory and Time Management Managing the Physical Environment ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 16 Possible Areas of Functional Limitations ___________________________________ Continued • Working at Full Productivity • Maintaining Stamina • Working Effectively with Supervisors • Interacting with Coworkers ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 17 Possible Areas of Functional Limitations ___________________________________ Continued • Handling Stress and Emotions • Concentrating on Work Details • Completing Projects and Meeting Deadlines • Maintaining Tasks/Sequences and Maintaining Daily Information ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 18 Categorizing Accommodations ___________________________________ ___________________________________ • Physical Modifications • Managerial Action • Provision of Services ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 19 Examples of Reasonable Accommodation: • Making existing facilities used by employees readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities • Job restructuring • Part-time or modified work schedules ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 20 ___________________________________ Examples of Reasonable Accommodation: Continued • Adjustment or modifications of examinations, training materials, or policies • Providing qualified readers or interpreters • Reassignment to vacant positions ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 21 ___________________________________ The Job Accommodation Network is: An information and consultation service providing individualized accommodation solutions via a website and an 800 number. JAN’s purpose is to make it possible for employers and others to share information about job accommodations. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 22 Average Cost of Job Accommodations – – – – – – – 20% of all accommodations suggested had no cost 51% cost between $1 and $500 11% cost between $501 and $1,000 3% cost between $1,001 and $1,500 3% cost between $1,501 and $2,000 8% cost between $2,001 and $5,000 4% cost more than $5,000 Source: Job Accommodation Network Survey 1 ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 23 Determining Reasonable Accommodation • Determine the essential functions of the job • Consult with the employee to determine his or her abilities and specific needs • Identify potential accommodations in consultation with the individual • If two or more possible accommodations exist, consider the preference of the individual, and then select the method that best serves both the individual and the business ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 24 ___________________________________ CROSSWORD PUZZLE 1 2 3 4 2 3 4 Across: 1. Mosquitoes do it 2. Dogs do it 3. Horses do it 4. Children do it Down: 1. Insects that sting 2. Organs of vision 3. Big brothers do it to little sisters 4. Without effort ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 25 ___________________________________ CROSSWORD PUZZLE 1 2 3 ___________________________________ 4 B I T E B I T E 2 3 B I T E B I T E 4 Across: 1. Mosquitoes do it 2. Dogs do it 3. Horses do it 4. Children do it Down: 1. Insects that sting 2. Organs of vision 3. Big brothers do it to little sisters 4. Without effort ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 26 ___________________________________ Accommodation Scenario #1 • Juanita is a 32-year-old Postal Worker who communicates through handwritten notes, gestures and partial lip reading. She is in line for a promotion to the position of Time and Attendance Clerk. In the past, the person who was the Time and Attendance Clerk answered the telephone as a back up to the regular receptionist in addition to other duties. Juanita's supervisor is concerned about her ability to do the job and is considering denying Juanita this promotion because of his concerns. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 27 ___________________________________ Accommodation Scenario #2 • Saundra, who is applying for a position as a Data Process Entry Clerk, requires a sign language interpreter for the interview. The supervisor has some concerns that the company will need to hire a full-time interpreter for the employee to successfully perform her job duties. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 28 ___________________________________ Accommodation Scenario #3 • Laverne works in a formal, corporate office. The office staff communicates with each other through the use of an office intercom. Laverne is hard of hearing and finds the intercom difficult to use. She continually chooses not to use the office intercom to talk to her supervisor, as requested. Instead, she frequently poses questions to him in a loud boisterous voice that is an irritating disruption for her co-workers and supervisor. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 29 ___________________________________ Accommodation Scenario #4 • Roberto, who uses a wheelchair, has just been hired by an accounting firm. His office is accessible but the conference room where all the staff meetings and trainings are held is not accessible. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 30 ___________________________________ Accommodation Scenario #5 • Shirley uses a wheelchair and desires a job in the field of video and film. Shirley has several years of experience, but the only available position is entry-level labeling and packaging film cartridges. She feels this position is beneath her capabilities. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 31 Accommodation Scenario #6 • Brian uses a wheelchair. His Mail/Messenger job also includes major photocopying jobs. He is unable to reach the selection button mounted on the rear of the photocopier. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 32 Accommodation Scenario #7 • Jonathan, a Chef, is a paraplegic and uses a wheelchair needs to access several different areas in the restaurant kitchen. His coworkers prefer to continue standing as they cook. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 33 Accommodation Scenario #8 • Joe has a significant speech and articulation problem. His speech is considered unintelligible at times; he stutters and has many involuntary facial movements. Joe's supervisor is very patient and understanding, but shares the concern of others about the extra amount of time required of her and co-workers to understand and direct Joe. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 34 Accommodation Scenario #9 • An employer is interested in hiring Adam as a Paralegal. As a Paralegal, Adam would be responsible for conducting background research on various legal issues. Adam would also edit his supervising attorney’s cases, interview potential plaintiffs, and draft legal briefs. Adam has had experience doing this type of work in two previous positions. He is blind and the employer is concerned about how he could perform these tasks. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 35 Accommodation Scenario #10 ___________________________________ ___________________________________ • Jeanette is a Radio Broadcast Announcer. She is blind and needs to read the Associated Press wire news which she receives over the phone lines connected to a printer. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 36 ___________________________________ Accommodation Scenario #11 • Maya has multiple sclerosis and is extremely sensitive to heat. When she requests that the office thermostat be adjusted to meet her needs, her colleagues explain that they will be very cold. The company is unable to provide her with a private office. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 37 Accommodation Scenario #12 • Mohammed has held his position as Manager of the Communications Department for five years. His boss notices that he has become withdrawn in meetings, his work is late and he appears preoccupied while discussing business matters. When his supervisor shares his concerns, Mohammed explains that his doctor recently diagnosed Mohammed with depression. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 38 Accommodation Scenario #13 ___________________________________ ___________________________________ • Mark experiences a stress disorder and becomes easily overwhelmed. His company recently received a large work order and everyone is working under deadline to fill the order. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 39 Accommodation Scenario #14 ___________________________________ ___________________________________ • Susie is applying for a job as a Stock Clerk. Part of the application process involves taking a multiple-choice test. Susie meets all of the qualifications for this job. However, she has a learning disability and has difficulty taking written tests. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 40 Accommodation Scenario #15 • William has a variety of tasks to perform at the plant nursery where he works. His duties consist of sweeping the floors, dusting the shelves, restocking, watering the plants and collecting and restocking the carts from the parking lot. He often forgets to do some of his tasks. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 41 Accommodation Scenario #16 • Bob has Attention-Deficit / Hyperactivity Disorder. He is easily distracted on the job site and has a history of frequently engaging in loud, inappropriate conversation. Bob's work area faces a busy walkway into the office. Due to lack of office space and other factors, Bob can not move to another cubicle. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 42 Accommodation Scenario #17 • Tovah has mild mental retardation. She has the basic skills necessary for the job of Administrative Assistant, likes the work and shows potential. When she finishes one task, however, she tends to stand in one place and look around, unsure of what to do next. One of her co-workers has noticed this and will periodically give her small assignments to keep her busy. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 43 Accommodation Scenario #18 • Chen's job mandates a higher production rate than he is currently achieving. He was hired with the understanding and intention that his production rate would increase over a three-month period. After several weeks, however, Chen is still performing below the mandated production rate for the position, and errors are increasing. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 44 Accommodation Scenario #19 • Jane has a learning disability, but her supervisor thinks that she has the skills to succeed. Lately, however, Jane has had problems with dressing inappropriately and making personal telephone calls during work. Her supervisor has discussed these problems with Jane and she made some improvements in her dress, although she still wears inappropriate shoes. Jane also continues making personal calls during work time. The supervisor admits that they do not have a formal company policy, but insists that Jane only use the phone during her breaks. Jane expresses her confusion, as she sees her co-workers making and receiving personal calls during work time. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 45 Accommodation Scenario #20 • Given a specific mailing job duty that occurred only once a week, Rayford has difficulty remembering all the steps involved with the process. His supervisor is tired of having to repeat the directions each week. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 46 Accommodation Scenario #21 • A Job Coach had been on the job site with Connie for two weeks, giving constant support to the supervisor and to Connie. The entire office was supportive of Connie and responded well to the Job Coach. It is now time for the Job Coach to reduce her time from the job site and let the supervisor assume more of a support role for Connie. The Job Coach senses panic from the supervisor and receives several calls each day with complaints like "Connie just walked into our boss's office and sat down at his desk." ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 47 Accommodation Scenario #22 • Sally, who has a developmental disability, works at a warehouse. For two weeks, Sally’s Manager trained her and directed her when to take a lunch break. At the end of the second week, the Manager was transferred. On that same day, her new manager did not direct her to take a break and so she worked six hours without a lunch break. Sally is very concerned that she may never be given an opportunity to take lunch breaks. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 48 Accommodation Scenario #23 • Rebecca, who has a spinal cord injury, loves her job, her co-workers and her supervisor. Recently, however, she has had difficulty making it to work on time and has been missing days due to problems with childcare. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 49 ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Undue Hardship Significant Difficulty or Expense ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 50 Examples of Accommodations that are NOT REASONABLE • Placing an applicant with a disability in a job for which he/she did not specifically apply • Placing an individual with a disability into a job if doing so would create a direct threat to the health or safety of the individual or others • Maintaining the salary of an employee reassigned from a higher-paying job to a lower-paying job, if the employer does not do so for other employees ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 51 Examples of Accommodations that are NOT REASONABLE Continued • Eliminating essential functions of the job • Lowering production standards • Providing personal use items (e.g. prosthetic limb, eyeglasses, hearing aids, wheelchair, hot pot or refrigerator) • Creating a job • Promoting an employee • Bumping another employee from his/her job ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Reasonable Accommodation Module 3 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module 4 Etiquette: Communication and Interaction MODULE GOALS: To increase comfort levels for communicating and interacting with people with disabilities To recognize the inherent “sameness” in people in order to promote a greater inclusion of people with disabilities in the workplace EQUIPMENT: Television VCR MATERIALS / HANDOUTS: Quiz: Disability Awareness Activity Handout: Ten Commandments of Communicating with People with Disabilities (in 6, 12, and 18 point fonts) Handout: Ten Commandments of Interacting with People with Mental Health Disabilities Video: The Ten Commandments of Communicating with People with Disabilities (Copyright 1994, Irene M. Ward & Associates, 4949 Hayden Run Road, Columbus, OH 43221-5930, 614/889-0888) TIME 45 – 60 minutes (time may vary) Etiquette: Communication and Interaction 4-1 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Review module before training and prepare necessary materials. View “Ten Commandments of Communicating with People with Disabilities” video, handout, and read over Disability Awareness Survey. Depending on the needs of your audience, you can also distribute and discuss the Ten Commandments document which was adapted specifically to address interactions with people with mental health disabilities. The handout is included in this Module’s handouts section. This module will feature effective ways to communicate with people with various disabilities. Participants will learn how to communicate with people who have limitations in vision, hearing, speech, or cognition. Have you ever wondered how to refer to someone with a disability? Words are very powerful and the language a society uses is reflective of its values. At one time, it was acceptable to refer to people with disabilities by their disability (e.g. epileptic, blind, retarded). This reflected a focus on disability and devalued a person’s abilities or individuality. No one wants to be stereotyped based on one characteristic, especially when that characteristic is usually pitied, feared, and or in some way causes discomfort. The term “handicapped” came into use to describe people with disabilities – any disability – in the early 20th century. Most people with disabilities do not like this term. Many people believe that the term handicapped derived from the time when people with disabilities were limited to begging for a living, with their caps held out in their hands. Today, although this version of the term’s origin is widely regarded as inaccurate, use of the word has taken on a negative connotation. Today, referring to someone by his or her disability is thought of as depersonalizing. The term "disabled people" or "the disabled" also has problems, since it suggests that a disability is a person’s defining feature. There is still no perfect term to use, but today, “person first” language is recommended (i.e., “person with a disability”). By putting the “person” before the “disability,” we tend to focus on the individual. For example, "person with a spinal cord injury" instead of "quadriplegic," or "person with diabetes" instead of "diabetic,” or better still, just refer to people by their names (Tim, Sharon, Carmen, etc.). Let’s see how disability “savvy” you are. Etiquette: Communication and Interaction 4-2 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Distribute the Disability Awareness Activity. Please take 10 minutes now to complete this activity. Be prepared to discuss the correct answers after viewing the video. When the group completes the survey (10-15 minutes), introduce the video. Depending on the needs of the group, and the amount of time you have for the training, you may wish to focus on certain aspects of the video. For example, if you do not have 26 minutes to watch the whole video, you could show three commandments and ask specific discussion questions about them. The “Ten Commandments of Communicating with People with Disabilities” is a video that has been developed as a tool to help increase sensitivity about people with various disabilities. The goal of the video is to provide an understanding of disability and for viewers to recognize that all of us, no matter how different we may appear to each other at first, share many of the same values, interests, hopes, and dreams. In the workplace, it is these commonalities that often serve as the first bridge between employees with disabilities and their co-workers. As you watch the video, please keep a few different questions in mind. For those of you who are new to this subject matter: With which characters do you feel the most comfortable? With which one do you feel the least comfortable? Do you know why you feel this way? For our experienced viewers: What types of workplace accommodations would benefit each of the characters? After the video, we will discuss all of these questions. View video (26 min) and allow time for discussion. It is recommended to use the open captioned version of the video. Review the questions listed above. The following are possible discussion questions for each of the ten commandments. Instead of using every question, you should pick and choose based on the needs of your audience. You can supplement the conversation with the additional topics listed below Etiquette: Communication and Interaction 4-3 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S each commandment, as long as you are knowledgeable. The Ten Commandments and potential discussion topics: Commandment #1. Speak directly to the individual rather than through a companion or sign language interpreter who may be present. Has anyone used a sign language interpreter to interact with an individual who is deaf? What was the experience like? Has anyone used message relay to communicate? o 711 national number and service What other accommodations might a person who is deaf or hard of hearing need? o A sign language interpreter o Assistive listening devices o TTY and TTY pay phones o Captioning of videos or other audible info o Access to voicemail phone system o Written information o Different types of communication used by people with hearing disabilities including sign language, speech reading, cued speech, writing, and typing. Commandment #2. Offer to shake hands when introduced. People with limited hand use or an artificial limb can usually shake hands and offering the left hand is an acceptable greeting. Practice shaking hands with group not using primary hand. Discuss this experience if appropriate. What other accommodations might someone with limited mobility need? o Computer assistive technology What are other appropriate greetings? Commandment #3. Always identify yourself and others who may be with you when meeting someone who is blind or has low-vision. When conversing in a group, remember to identify the person to whom you are speaking. When dining with a friend who has a visual disability, ask if you can describe what is on his or her plate. Have group pair off and practice this tip. How does it feel to be so conscious of yourself and your words? Etiquette: Communication and Interaction 4-4 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S How are activities advertised and information disseminated to ensure that persons with vision disabilities have access to this information? o Web site accessibility and assistive technology issues. o The use of Braille, CDs, large print, diskettes and electronic methods. Please note that many people who are blind prefer to feel the food on their plate rather than asking for a description. Share personal experiences if appropriate. Commandment #4. If you offer assistance, wait until the offer is accepted. Then listen or ask for instructions. What type of assistance are you comfortable providing? What type of assistance might a person request? Have you ever had assistance forced on you? How did that make you feel? Commandment #5. Treat adults as adults. Address people with disabilities by their first names only when extending that same familiarity to all others. Never patronize people in wheelchairs by patting them on the head or shoulder. Discuss language and people first terminology. How do we treat older persons? Is it similar? How would you respond to the woman of short stature? Would you think she would need an accommodation? Other ideas. What are ways to offer assistance? Who feels comfortable having a door opened for you? See the variety of responses. The same differences in the disability community. Commandment #6. Do not lean against or hang on someone’s wheelchair. Bear in mind that people with disabilities treat their chairs as extensions of their bodies. And so do people with guide dogs and service animals. Never distract a work animal from their job without the owner’s permission. When might it be helpful to make additional seating available to provide opportunities to interact comfortably Etiquette: Communication and Interaction 4-5 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S with people at different heights? o Access to stage areas and podiums, etc. What is the difference between a service animal and a pet? Where are service animals permitted? o Service animals are trained to perform specific tasks on an individual’s behalf. They should not be disruptive. Commandment #7. Listen attentively when talking to people who have difficulty speaking and wait for them to finish. If necessary, ask short questions that require short answers, or a nod of the head. Never pretend to understand; instead repeat what you have understood and allow the person to respond. Discuss potential options to facilitate communication o Speech-to-speech relay available at 711 national phone #. o Use of pen and paper or other tools. o Importance of eye contact and nonverbal communication. Commandment #8. Place your self at eye level when speaking with someone in a wheelchair or on crutches. Pair off the group and have one person in each pair stand up and carry on a conversation with the other person seated. How does this feel from each person’s perspective? o Integrated seating. o Dispersed seating at cinemas, stadiums and other venues. Commandment #9. Tap a person who is deaf or hard of hearing on the shoulder or wave your hand to get his or her attention. Look directly at the person and speak clearly, slowly, and expressively to establish if the person can read your lips. If so, try to face the light source and keep hands, cigarettes and food away from your mouth when speaking. If a person is wearing a hearing aid, don’t assume that they have the ability to discriminate your speaking voice. Never shout at a person. Just speak in a normal tone of voice. Tips to facilitate communication: o Arrange office seating so a person with a hearing Etiquette: Communication and Interaction 4-6 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S disability can see who enters the office area. Discuss personal preferences about being touched and ways to get the person’s attention. Explain that speech reading is difficult. o Example of “island view” and “I love you.” Discuss: o Some people with hearing disabilities use hearing aids only to alert them of danger or loud noises. o Effective communication under the ADA and options. It is important to get a person’s attention before beginning to speak. o Assistive listening devices. Discuss the different types of hearing loss and variety of accommodations. Commandment #10. Relax. Don’t be embarrassed if you happen to use common expressions such as “See you later” or “Did you hear about this?” that seem to relate to a person’s disability. You may wish to tell stories about your personal interactions with individuals with disabilities. Perhaps some individuals you know prefer the guidelines explained in the video, and perhaps some do not. The purpose of this video is to introduce us to individuals with different disabilities. The more individuals with disabilities we meet and the closer we become, the more comfortable we will be. For some of us, this video might be the first step towards feeling comfortable around some individuals with disabilities. Now let's go back and look at the Disability Awareness Activity. After watching this video, perhaps some of our answers have changed. Review Activity with the group, referring to the answer sheet for discussion points. Answer each question, spending as much or as little time as necessary. I’d like to distribute one last handout. Before we leave, please stay in your seats and take a moment to read it. If you are short on time, you may skip the following activity and solely distribute the 10 commandments handout in the 12 point font. Or, if you conducted Module 3 with the same audience and Etiquette: Communication and Interaction 4-7 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S already used the 6, 12, 18 point font exercise, it may be best to skip the following activity and just distribute the handout in the 12 point font. Distribute handouts in 6 point font. Wait for “grumbles” in the group and tell the group you have the same material in a larger font. Ask for a show of hands for those who would like a larger font. (Distribute 12 point font for those requesting). After distribution, tell the participants you also have the handout in an even larger font. Ask for a show of hands for those who would like an even larger font. Then distribute the handout in 18 point font. You can explain that 18 point font is typically considered large print. How many of you found a larger font easier to read? Increasing the font size is just one simple way to improve your ability to communicate with an individual with a vision disability. Both the video and etiquette exercise introduced great guidelines for communication. Still, it’s important to remember that an individual with disability is a person first. Just like people without disabilities, individuals with disabilities have personal preferences for communication. Always remember that communication is a lifelong learning process! Etiquette: Communication and Interaction 4-8 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Disability Awareness Activity People are often uncomfortable interacting with individuals who have disabilities. The discomfort often stems from limited experience, and can be dispelled with increased knowledge and familiarity. This activity is designed to provide you with some basic dos and don’ts when encountering someone who has a disability. Language: Listed below are terms commonly used to describe people with disabilities. Match the unacceptable term listed under the “Instead Of” column with the correct corresponding term in the “Say” column. Instead Of… Say…. A. Handicapped or the disabled ___ Person with a learning disability B. Mute or dumb ___ Person without a disability C. Dwarf or midget ___ Person with autism D. Emotionally disturbed ___ Person with epilepsy E. Autistic ___ Congenital disability F. Suffers from, victim of ___ Person with mental retardation G. Learning disabled ___ Person who uses a wheelchair H. Normal ___ Person with Down syndrome I. Birth defect ___ Non-verbal J. Retarded ___ Person with … K. Handicapped parking ___ Person of short stature L. Epileptic ___ Person with a developmental delay M. Quadriplegic, paraplegic ___ Person with an emotional disability N. Mongoloid or downs ___ Person with quadriplegia O. Developmentally delayed ___ People with disabilities P. Confined to a wheelchair ___ Accessible parking Etiquette: Communication and Interaction Module 4 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Personal and Professional Interactions: 1. As you are meeting or being introduced to someone, you notice they have a prosthesis and shake with their right hand. You should: ___ A. Withdraw your hand and continue to introduce yourself. ___ B. Offer your right hand as you would with anyone. ___ C. Offer your left hand. 2. When meeting someone who is deaf and accompanied by an interpreter, you should: ___ A. Maintain eye contact with the person who is deaf. ___ B. Maintain eye contact with the interpreter. ___ C. Look back and forth between them. 3. You are speaking with someone who is deaf or hard of hearing and they ask you to repeat a statement. You should: ___ A. Repeat the statement in a louder voice. ___ B. Repeat the statement more slowly. ___ C. Rephrase the statement. ___ D. Use gestures to act out your statement. ___ E. Offer to write your statement. 4. You see someone who has a disability and they appear to be struggling. You should ignore them so as not to embarrass, draw attention, or infringe upon their independence. ___ True ___ False If your answer was True, move to question 6. 5. If your answer to the last question was false, what would you do in this situation? ___ A. Watch for a while to determine if they need assistance. ___ B. Offer to assist the person. ___ C. Assist the person. Etiquette: Communication and Interaction Module 4 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 6. You are conversing with a person who has difficulty speaking. You are only able to understand a few words and phrases. What should you do? __ A. Pretend you understand what was said. __ B. State what you understood and ask the person to repeat the rest of the information. __ C. Smile and walk away as soon as you can. 7. When conversing with a person who uses a wheelchair, it is preferable to pull up a chair, if available and convenient, and converse at eye level. ___ True ___ False Employment Myths and Facts: 8. Review each of the statements below. Write a “T” next to each true statement, and an “F” next to each one that is false. ___ A. All people who are blind live in total darkness. ___ B. People with mental retardation always enjoy jobs with repetitive tasks. ___ C. People with quadriplegia are totally dependent on others for daily support. ___ D. All people who are blind can read Braille. ___ E. People who are deaf make ideal employees in a noisy work environment. ___ F. People with emotional disabilities cannot work in a stressful environment. ___ G. The unemployment rate for people with disabilities is equal to that of people without disabilities. ___ H. New workplace technologies make it more difficult for people with disabilities to secure and maintain employment. ___ I. Accommodating people with disabilities is often cost prohibitive. ___ J. Employing and managing employees with disabilities requires unique skills. Compiled by TransCen, Inc. “Disability Awareness Activity.” www.transcen.org. Etiquette: Communication and Interaction Module 4 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Disability Awareness Activity – Answers Language Instead Of… Say…. A. Handicapped or the disabled Person with a disability B. Mute or dumb Non-verbal C. Dwarf or midget Person of short stature D. Emotionally disturbed Person with an emotional disability E. Autistic Person with autism F. Suffers from, victim of Person has…. G. Learning disabled Person with a learning disability H. Normal Person without a disability I. Birth defect Person with a congenital disability J. Retarded Person with mental retardation K. Handicapped parking Accessible parking L. Epileptic Person with epilepsy M. Quadriplegic, paraplegic Person with quadriplegia N. Mongoloid or downs Person with Down syndrome O. Developmentally delayed Person with a developmental delay P. Confined to a wheelchair Person who uses a wheelchair Personal and Professional Interactions 1. Offer your hand as you would anyone. Discussion: The key is to treat people with disabilities as you would anyone. Remember, however, that each person is an individual and how he or she will react to a particular situation may differ. For example, in this situation, the person with a disability may extend his/her prosthesis or may choose not to extend his/her hand at all. Etiquette: Communication and Interaction Module 4 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 2. Maintain eye contact with the person who is deaf. Discussion: You are speaking directly to the person who is deaf; therefore it is appropriate to maintain contact with this person, not with the interpreter. 3. Discussion: Any, a combination, or all of these answers may be appropriate, depending on the person and the circumstances. The best recommendation is to use your judgment based on the individual situation. 4. False. Discussion: The best response in this situation is to offer the person assistance and then proceed according to his or her response. It is important to remember that each person is an individual and some people may be grateful for the assistance while other may decline assistance…as would anyone else. 5. Offer to assist the person. Discussion: See discussion in #4 above. 6. State what you understood and ask the person to repeat the rest of the information. Discussion: It is always best to be honest and politely tell a person if you are having difficulty understanding them. Stating what you think you understand is a way to make sure that your understanding really is correct, then ask them to repeat the parts of the conversation that you did not understand. 7. True. Discussion: If possible, the appropriate response is to pull up a chair and converse with this person at eye level. It is not appropriate, however, to kneel, bend over the person or lean on the wheelchair as support. If a chair is not available, maintain a regular stance and continue the conversation. Employment Myths and Facts A. False – Many people who are blind can see some levels of light and/or colors within various fields of vision. B. False – People with mental retardation are individuals and vary in ability, as do all individuals. C. False – Different people with quadriplegia have differing levels of independence. D. False – Only an estimated 10% of people who are blind read Braille. E. False – Some people who are deaf have various types and levels of residual hearing, and some may be bothered by noisy environments, just as some hearing people are. As always, the type of work a person is suited for will depend on the individual’s preferences. F. False – This answer will depend on a person’s definition of “stressful environment,” and how different kinds of stress affect (or don’t affect) an individual. G. False – The unemployment rate for people with disabilities is far greater than that of people without disabilities.1 H. False – Technological advances have opened many doors for some individuals with disabilities. I. False – The majority of accommodations required for the workplace cost under $1,000. Source: Job Accommodation Network.2 J. False – Managing employees with disabilities requires the same kind of good management skills that are needed to manage all workers. Etiquette: Communication and Interaction Module 4 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] The Ten Commandments of Communicating with People with Disabilities 1. Speak directly rather than through a companion or sign language interpreter who may be present. 2. Offer to shake hands when introduced. People with limited hand use or an artificial limb can usually shake hands and offering the left hand is an acceptable greeting. 3. Always identify yourself and others who may be with you when meeting someone with a visual disability. When conversing in a group, remember to identify the person to whom you are speaking. When dining with a friend who has a visual disability, ask if you can describe what is on his or her plate. 4. If you offer assistance, wait until the offer is accepted. Then listen or ask for instructions. 5. Treat adults as adults. Address people with disabilities by their first names only when extending that same familiarity to all others. Never patronize people in wheelchairs by patting them on the head or shoulder. 6. Do not lean against or hang on someone’s wheelchair. Bear in mind that people with disabilities treat their chairs as extensions of their bodies. And so do people with guide dogs and help dogs. Never distract a work animal from their job without the owner’s permission. 7. Listen attentively when talking with people who have difficulty speaking and wait for them to finish. If necessary, ask short questions that require short answers, or a nod of the head. Never pretend to understand; instead repeat what you have understood and allow the person to respond. 8. Place yourself at eye level when speaking with someone in a wheelchair or on crutches. 9. Tap a person who has a hearing disability on the shoulder or wave your hand to get his or her attention. Look directly at the person and speak clearly, slowly, and expressively to establish if the person can read your lips. If so, try to face the light source and keep hands, cigarettes and food away from your mouth when speaking. If a person is wearing a hearing aid, don’t assume that they have the ability to discriminate your speaking voice. Never shout to a person. Just speak in a normal tone of voice. 10. Relax. Don’t be embarrassed if you happen to use common expressions such as “See you later” or “Did you hear about this?” that seems to relate to a person’s disability. The Ten Commandments of Communicating with People with Disabilities (Copyright 1994, Irene M. Ward & Associates, 4949 Hayden Run Road, Columbus, OH 43221-5930, 614/889-0888.) Etiquette: Communication and Interaction Module 4 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] The Ten Commandments of Communicating with People with Disabilities 1. Speak directly rather than through a companion or sign language interpreter who may be present. 2. Offer to shake hands when introduced. People with limited hand use or an artificial limb can usually shake hands and offering the left hand is an acceptable greeting. 3. Always identify yourself and others who may be with you when meeting someone with a visual disability. When conversing in a group, remember to identify the person to whom you are speaking. When dining with a friend who has a visual disability, ask if you can describe what is on his or her plate. 4. If you offer assistance, wait until the offer is accepted. Then listen or ask for instructions. 5. Treat adults as adults. Address people with disabilities by their first names only when extending that same familiarity to all others. Never patronize people in wheelchairs by patting them on the head or shoulder. 6. Do not lean against or hang on someone’s wheelchair. Bear in mind that people with disabilities treat their chairs as extensions of their bodies. And so do people with guide dogs and help dogs. Never distract a work animal from their job without the owner’s permission. 7. Listen attentively when talking with people who have difficulty speaking and wait for them to finish. If necessary, ask short questions that require short answers, or a nod of the head. Never pretend to understand; instead repeat what you have understood and allow the person to respond. 8. Place yourself at eye level when speaking with someone in a wheelchair or on crutches. 9. Tap a person who has a hearing disability on the shoulder or wave your hand to get his or her attention. Look directly at the person and speak clearly, slowly, and expressively to establish if the person can read your lips. If so, try to face the light source and keep hands, cigarettes and food away from your mouth when speaking. If a person is wearing a hearing aid, don’t assume that they have the ability to discriminate your speaking voice. Never shout to a person. Just speak in a normal tone of voice. 10. Relax. Don’t be embarrassed if you happen to use common expressions such as “See you later” or “Did you hear about this?” that seems to relate to a person’s disability. The Ten Commandments of Communicating with People with Disabilities (Copyright 1994, Irene M. Ward & Associates, 4949 Hayden Run Road, Columbus, OH 43221-5930, 614/889-0888.) Etiquette: Communication and Interaction Module 4 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] The Ten Commandments of Communicating with People with Disabilities 1. Speak directly rather than through a companion or sign language interpreter who may be present. 2. Offer to shake hands when introduced. People with limited hand use or an artificial limb can usually shake hands and offering the left hand is an acceptable greeting. 3. Always identify yourself and others who may be with you when meeting someone with a visual disability. When conversing in a group, remember to identify the person to whom you are speaking. When dining with a friend who has a visual disability, ask if you can describe what is on his or her plate. 4. If you offer assistance, wait until the offer is accepted. Then listen or ask for instructions. 5. Treat adults as adults. Address people with disabilities by their first names only when extending that same familiarity to all others. Never patronize people in wheelchairs by patting them on the head or shoulder. 6. Do not lean against or hang on someone’s wheelchair. Bear in mind that people with disabilities treat their chairs as extensions of their bodies. And so do people with guide dogs and help dogs. Never distract a work animal from their job without the owner’s permission. Etiquette: Communication and Interaction Module 4 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] 7. Listen attentively when talking with people who have difficulty speaking and wait for them to finish. If necessary, ask short questions that require short answers, or a nod of the head. Never pretend to understand; instead repeat what you have understood and allow the person to respond. 8. Place yourself at eye level when speaking with someone in a wheelchair or on crutches. 9. Tap a person who has a hearing disability on the shoulder or wave your hand to get his or her attention. Look directly at the person and speak clearly, slowly, and expressively to establish if the person can read your lips. If so, try to face the light source and keep hands, cigarettes and food away from your mouth when speaking. If a person is wearing a hearing aid, don’t assume that they have the ability to discriminate your speaking voice. Never shout to a person. Just speak in a normal tone of voice. 10. Relax. Don’t be embarrassed if you happen to use common expressions such as “See you later” or “Did you hear about this?” that seems to relate to a person’s disability. The Ten Commandments of Communicating with People with Disabilities (Copyright 1994, Irene M. Ward & Associates, 4949 Hayden Run Road, Columbus, OH 43221-5930, 614/889-0888.) Etiquette: Communication and Interaction Module 4 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Ten Commandments of Interacting with People with Mental Health Disabilities I. Speak Directly Use clear, simple communication. Most people, whether or not they have a mental health disability, appreciate it. If someone is having difficulty processing sounds or information, as often occurs with people who have psychiatric disorders, you are more likely to be understood if you use clear, simple communication. Speak directly to the person; do not speak through a companion or service provider. II. Offer to Shake Hands When Introduced Always use the same good manners in interacting with a person who has a psychiatric disability that you would use in meeting any other person. Shaking hands is a uniformly acceptable and recognized signal of friendliness in American culture. A lack of simple courtesy is unacceptable to most people, and tends to make everyone uncomfortable. III. Make Eye Contact and Be Aware of Body Language Like others, people with mental illness sense your discomfort. Look people in the eye when speaking to them. Maintain a relaxed posture. IV. Listen Attentively If a person has difficulty speaking, or speaks in a manner that is difficult for you to understand, listen carefully, then wait for them to finish speaking. If needed, clarify what they have said. Ask short questions that can be answered by a "yes" or "no" or by nodding the head. Never pretend to understand. Reflect what you have heard, and let the person respond. V. Treat Adults as Adults Always use common courtesy. Do not assume familiarity by using a person 's first name or by touching their shoulder or arm, unless you know the person well enough to do so. Do not patronize, condescend, or threaten. Do not make decisions for the person, or assume their preferences. VI. Do Not Give Unsolicited Advice or Assistance If you offer any kind of assistance, wait until the offer is accepted. Then listen to the person's response and/or ask for suggestions or instructions. Do not panic, or summon an ambulance or the police if a person appears to be experiencing a mental health crisis. Calmly ask the person how you can help. VII. Do Not Blame the Person A person who has a mental illness has a complex, bio-medical condition that is sometimes difficult to control, even with proper treatment. A person who is experiencing a mental illness cannot "just shape up" or "pull himself up by the bootstraps." It is rude, insensitive, and ineffective to tell or expect a person to do so. Etiquette: Communication and Interaction Module 4 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] VIII. Question the Accuracy of Media Stereotypes of Mental Illness The movies and the media have sensationalized mental illness. In reality, despite the overabundance of "psychotic killers" portrayed in movies and television, studies have shown that people with mental illness are far more likely to be victims of crime than to victimize others. Most people with mental illness never experience symptoms that include violent behavior. As within the general public, about 1-5% of all people with mental illness are exceptionally easily provoked to violence. (National Alliance for the Mentally Ill, 1990). IX. Relax! The most important thing to remember in interacting with people with mental health disabilities is to BE YOURSELF. Do not be embarrassed if you happen to use common expressions that seem to relate to a mental health disability, such as "I'm CRAZY about him" or, "This job is driving me NUTS." If you are afraid you have made a faux pas, ASK the person how he feels about what you have said. Chances are, you'll get a flippant remark and a laugh in answer. X. See the PERSON Beneath all the symptoms and behaviors someone with a mental illness may exhibit is a PERSON who has many of the same wants, needs, dreams, and desires as anyone else. Don't avoid people with mental health disabilities. If you are fearful or uncomfortable, learn more about mental illness. Kindness, courtesy, and patience usually smooth interactions with all kinds of people, including people who have a mental health disability. Adapted by Mary Lee Stocks, MSW, LISW, from The Ten Commandments of Communicating with People with Disabilities, originally developed by the National Center for Access Unlimited/Chicago and United Cerebral Palsy Associations/Washington, DC; and a video and script developed by Irene M. Ward & Associates/Columbus, Ohio, partially supported through Ohio Developmental Disabilities Planning Council Grant #92-13(1993). Available online: www.abilitycenter.org/webtools/links/factsheets/tencommandments-mental.html Document retrieved April 2005. Etiquette: Communication and Interaction Module 4 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module Four Acknowledgements Quiz Disability Awareness Activity: Compiled by TransCen, Inc. “Disability Awareness Activity.” www.transcen.org. Compiled November 2004. Video and Handout The Ten Commandments of Communicating with People with Disabilities (Copyright 1994, Irene M. Ward & Associates, 4949 Hayden Run Road, Columbus, OH 43221-5930, 614/889-0888.) Handout Ten Commandments of Interacting with People with Mental Health Disabilities. Adapted by Mary Lee Stocks, MSW, LISW, from The Ten Commandments of Communicating with People with Disabilities. (Copyright 1994, Irene M. Ward & Associates, 4949 Hayden Run Road, Columbus, OH 43221-5930, 614/889-0888. Available online: www.abilitycenter.org/webtools/links/factsheets/tencommandment s-mental.html. Document retrieved April 2005. Etiquette: Communication and Interaction Module 4 Acknowledgements Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Module 5 Best Practices for Trainers MODULE GOALS: To gain confidence by learning innovative training techniques, new training principles, and addressing concerns about public speaking To become more effective trainers through practice sessions and a review of best practices EQUIPMENT: PowerPoint Presentation (or alternate format) LCD Projector Computer / Laptop Flip Chart Flip Chart Markers Masking Tape MATERIALS: Handout: Best Practices Handouts Handout: Training Prospect Information Sheet Handout: Materials Request Form Handout: Trainer’s Feedback Form Handout: Evaluation Forms (3) Handout: Sample Schedule for Training Handout: Training Tips: Ten Commandments of Communicating with People with Disabilities Handout: Example Icebreakers TIME: 45-60 minutes (time may vary) Best Practices for Trainers 5-1 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Review module before training and prepare necessary materials. Show PowerPoint: Module 5 Best Practices for Trainers Module 5: Best Practices for Trainers Show PowerPoint: Module Goals • To gain confidence by learning innovative training techniques, addressing concerns about public speaking, and learning new training principles • To become more effective trainers through practice sessions and a review of best practices Module Goals: To gain confidence by learning innovative training techniques, addressing concerns about public speaking, and learning new training principles To become more effective trainers through practice sessions and a review of best practices This module will recommend best practices in training, provide an opportunity for participants to discuss concerns about public speaking, and, if time allows, provide a forum for delivering a portion of this training for practice and feedback. Have you ever noticed that your brain starts working the moment you are born and stops the moment you stand up to give a speech? Many people are afraid of public speaking. Some individuals claim to fear it even more than death. Best Practices for Trainers 5-2 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Show PowerPoint : When you think about standing in front of a group of people to speak, what are some of your concerns? When you think about standing in front of a group of people to speak, what are some of your concerns? List concerns on a flip chart. If the group is having difficulty identifying concerns, share some of these examples to get them started: Participants asking questions that I cannot answer Participants interrupting my train of thought Not enough time for the planned activities Participants do not appear to be interested in the subject material After listing 1-5 pages of concerns, address each one of in turn. Begin by turning the question or concern back to the audience. For example: You are speaking and lose your train of thought. Ask the audience, “Has this ever happened to anyone here?” “What did/would you do?” Let the audience provide some input, then summarize by providing one or two methods that will alleviate this concern or question, and then move on to the next concern. Remember, questions and concerns will differ each time you conduct this module. Experienced trainers will know most of the responses for the questions and concerns, and will be able to give examples of how they handled similar situations (and lived to train again!). Distribute and review “Best Practices in Training – Tips for Success” handout. The following discussion and activity will take you through this handout. Best Practices for Trainers 5-3 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Show PowerPoint: Best Practices • Planning and Preparation • Opening and Introduction • During your Training • Closing Remarks and Evaluation Best Practices: Planning and Preparation Opening and Introduction During your Training Closing Remarks and Evaluation Planning and Preparation Each participant should now have a copy of the handout, “Best Practices in Training – Tips for Success.” Go through and highlight the most important training tips about the planning process before discussing needs assessments in greater detail. One important part of the preparation process that trainers often overlook is a “needs assessment.” This is a great tool to help you develop a training. There are various reasons that you might be called in to conduct a training. It’s possible that a business wants to maximize their customer service for people with disabilities. Maybe an employer wants to understand their responsibilities. Or, sometimes, the training is a result of a lawsuit. Your audience and their attitudes will vary based on the reason for the training, so make sure you are aware of this ahead of time! As you prepare for your training, get answers to the following questions! Best Practices for Trainers 5-4 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Show PowerPoint: Conduct a needs assessment • Why are you doing this training? • Why are you doing this training NOW? • What are the desired goals or outcomes of the training? • Is attendance at this training mandatory? Conduct a needs assessment: Why are you doing this training? Why are you doing this training NOW? What are the desired goals or outcomes of the training? Is attendance at this training mandatory? Show PowerPoint: Don’t forget to ask… • Substantive Questions – What topic needs to be covered? – Will there be time for a question and answer period? – How many people will make up my audience? – What is the mix of people in the room? Businesses? People with disabilities? Employers? Don’t forget to ask: Substantive Questions – What topic needs to be covered? – Will there be time for a question and answer period? – How many people will make up my audience? – What is the mix of people in the room? Businesses? People with disabilities? Employers? Show PowerPoint: Don’t forget to ask… • Logistical Questions – Who will be providing the equipment? – How do I access the site? – Is there parking? – Do I have to pay for parking? – Will you feed me? – How should I dress? Best Practices for Trainers 5-5 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Don’t forget to ask: Logistical Questions – Who will be providing the equipment? – How do I access the site? – Is there parking? – Do I have to pay for parking? – Will you feed me? – How should I dress? Activity: Planning Process The purpose of the following activity is to have participants practice asking questions necessary to complete a needs assessment. Before the workshop, think about what type of training you will pretend to request, its purpose, the audience make up, and its logistics. It’s time to role play – let’s pretend that I would like to schedule a training for my business. You are the potential trainer and need to conduct a needs assessment. You can ask me any question to ensure that you have all of the information necessary to organize this training. Participants should now start to ask you questions and plan this training. Make sure to mention any important questions that they omit and explain what would happen if they forgot to ask that question during a real needs assessment. For example, if I don’t know how many participants are in the audience, I will not have enough handouts. If I don’t ask if lunch is included, I might be hungry during the training. Great job! It is always helpful to have a “Training Prospect Information Sheet” while discussing a prospective training. We have one example of this type of information sheet, along with a sample of a “Materials Request Form.” Feel free to use these forms as you conduct a needs assessment. At this time, you can distribute the example forms or tell the participants where they are in the Manual. Opening and Introduction Most trainers do not immediately delve into their training’s content when starting a training. By opening with an icebreaker and housekeeping information, participants more comfortably transition Best Practices for Trainers 5-6 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S into a training. Providing housekeeping information answers logistical questions typically on participants’ minds. Sharing information like where the bathrooms are located, what time lunch will be served, even what will be served for lunch are simple but important details to share with your audience. What are icebreakers? Why do we have them? Elicit responses from audience Exactly. Icebreakers are structured activities that are usually unrelated to the training material. Icebreakers are one great way to open a training because they create a positive group atmosphere. They help audience members relax, energize and motivate them to participate through the training. Depending on the type of training, icebreakers can help participants think outside the box and encourage them to get to know one another. It is important to know who is in your audience when selecting an appropriate icebreaker. Some icebreakers are inaccessible for individuals with disabilities. For example, icebreakers based solely on reading are inaccessible for individuals who are blind. It is important to use an icebreaker that will be accessible for all participants. Examples of icebreakers are included in your manual. You may choose to distribute the examples at this time. If you do, you can then ask the audience if they have other example icebreakers to share with the group. You can highlight any other best practices about opening a training here. Best Practices for Trainers 5-7 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S During the presentation Show PowerPoint: …and what about DURING your presentation? • Audience members…come in many “shapes and sizes” • PowerPoint presentations (or alternate format) • Using a Flip Chart • Model disability etiquette … and what about DURING your presentation? Audience members…come in many “shapes and sizes” PowerPoint presentations (or alternate format) Using a Flip Chart Model disability etiquette This is a good time to discuss best practices for conducting the presentation, specifically handling participant questions. It is also an appropriate time to discuss the various types of audience members (information can be found in the handout section). Make sure to review disability etiquette and audio visual training information. Activity: Trainer Problem-Solving Now that we are all becoming expert trainers, let’s put what we have learned into practice. Divide the audience into four small groups. Give each group a scenario (below) and have them brainstorm solutions. A. You have been invited to speak to a group of 50 high school students about the Americans with Disabilities Act. Midway through the presentation, a participant starts to argue with you and continues to interrupt. How do you handle this? Possible solution: Take a short break to speak with the person, or tell the person that you need to move on, but offer to discuss the person’s concerns at the next break. Best Practices for Trainers 5-8 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S B. You have been invited to address an employer group about concerns related to employing people with disabilities. Do you have any questions or concerns? Possible Solution: Be prepared with information and resources. Anticipate that the group will have questions about insurance implications of hiring a person with a disability, tax credits, and comfort level. C. You are standing in front of a group – and midway through your presentation on hidden disabilities, you lose your train of thought. What do you do? Possible Solution: Wait and try to find the thought. Make a joke about it if you like. Be honest and communicate what is happening with the group and move on. D. You are presenting “Typecasting: Understanding Disability” and you notice that there are many audience members with disabilities. Any questions or concerns? Possible Solution: Ask if anyone from the audience would like to share their experiences or ideas, but do not draw attention to a specific individual. Bring the small groups back together and ask a representative of each group to present the scenario and their solutions. Give other participants a chance to provide feedback or suggest alternative solutions. If this is not a two-day workshop, skip ahead to section about Evaluation and Closing Comments. Participant Homework - (2-Day Workshop) If you are conducting a 2-day “Train the Trainer” session, it is advisable to have participants prepare a 5-10 minute “presentation” from the manual to present to the group on Day 2. Your homework assignment for tomorrow is to prepare a 5-10 minute presentation from this manual. Best Practices for Trainers 5-9 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S Show PowerPoint: Homework • Prepare a 10 minute presentation from the manual • Any topic from the manual • Include a brief introduction, presentation of topic, and a closing • Prepare to provide and receive feedback from peers Homework: Prepare a 10 minute presentation from the manual Any topic from the manual Include a brief introduction, presentation of topic, and a closing Prepare to provide and receive feedback from peers Because this is a “Train the Trainer” session, we not only want to provide you with the training materials and subsequent tips, but also with an opportunity to actually stand before a group and practice. Please pick a topic from the manual – the choice is yours. Your presentation should include a brief introduction, presentation of the topic, and a closing. This homework will provide you the opportunity to review and use your manual. It will allow you to practice, as well as obtain feedback from your peers. Depending on your training site, you may or may not be able to offer participants the use of audio visual equipment. Tomorrow, you will be divided into smaller groups for your presentations. After your presentation, you will receive immediate feedback from your group members. Pick a particular aspect of your presentation style that you want to improve (e.g. voice projection, eliminating “uh”, handling a small group activity). This is a great opportunity to get peer feedback. On Day 2, divide your audience into smaller groups, preferably 510 per group. If possible, include both experienced and inexperienced trainers in each group. It is preferable to provide separate rooms for each group, in order Best Practices for Trainers 5-10 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S to limit disruption. If this is not feasible, provide as much separation as possible. Each member will present to the group. After each presentation, the group members will provide immediate feedback/critique. Provide groups with enough Trainer’s Feedback Forms to evaluate the presentation of each group member. Explain that on the feedback form there are three lines for “positives” and only one line for “in the future, you may wish to consider.” Ask each person to tell the group a particular aspect of their presentation style on which they would like feedback. This will help the group focus its attention on specific areas that the participant is ready to address. When the “trainer” has finished presenting, give him or her the first opportunity to do a self-critique to open up areas for discussion. Then, as a role-model, you may want to provide a comment as a way to demonstrate how the feedback should be provided, with a focus on the positive and support for the areas needing improvement. You may prefer to have the group provide their written comments to the presenter as well as their verbal comments so the person can look them over later. During the presentations, the trainer should mingle within each group. After the small group presentations, gather the group back together as a whole. How was this exercise beneficial? What did you learn about your own presentation style? Did it generate any other questions/concerns about the manual and/or public speaking? Address these questions/concerns as time allows. Evaluation and Closing Comments It is important to use this section, even if this is not a two-day training. Pass out all three evaluation forms. Evaluation is a very important part of the training, but is usually conducted in a hurried fashion as participants rush out the door. To Best Practices for Trainers 5-11 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S prevent that from happening, sufficient time must be scheduled for the evaluation process. Explanation is needed to ensure that the evaluation forms are completed accurately and that the information collected is of value. Evaluation forms may serve a variety of purposes and for this reason they should be customized for the specific training activity. The first evaluation example shows a breakdown of each module and requests specific information about knowledge of the subject matter. This evaluation form is from a training session that was conducted for the first time and the presenters wanted very specific feedback about how to improve the modules. The second evaluation is more general. It can be used for a variety of types of workshops where the focus is more on the overall quality of the program, than on specific learning objectives. The third evaluation form is more extensive, asks many more questions, and requires participants to rate their level of understanding of specific information before and after the seminar. As more and more agencies move towards an outcome based evaluation approach this type of format is often needed. Many grant programs also require this level of evaluation detail. Along with evaluations, closing comments provide a wrap-up for the day’s activities. The trainer may take a few moments to summarize some of the learning from the day or ask participants to share one thing they learned. It is important to end on a high note. The trainer may also share ways in which they have learned from the group or share a story that incorporates ideas from the training, in order to leave the participants with a positive picture. It is also helpful to stay after the session to speak with any participants that might have had questions or comments that they did not wish to share in front of the group. Make sure that you stick to your time schedule, and if possible, end a couple of minutes early. This will ensure that participants pay attention until the end and are not worried about sitting in traffic. You may wish to share any additional best practices tips about closing a training at this time. Remember—evaluation is an important part of the training. Always leave sufficient time for participants to complete the evaluation form. To guarantee that evaluation forms will be completed, the trainer may stand by the door and collect them as participants Best Practices for Trainers 5-12 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] N O T E S leave the room. The trainer may also wish to reward each participant with a small give-away type prize as evaluations are collected. Show PowerPoint: This PowerPoint slide is a graphic of a certificate with a red ribbon. Remember, if you are conducting this Module as a “Train the Trainer,” plan time to distribute your own evaluation. You can modify any of the three included evaluations to meet your needs. Of course, it is only appropriate for me to lead by example. Please do not leave without completing my evaluation form. You may exchange a completed form for a goodie in the back. Thank you! Best Practices for Trainers 5-13 Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Best Practices in Training – Tips for Success TRAINING TIPS PLANNING Ask questions!! Determine the motivation behind the training. There are various reasons that you might be called in to conduct a training. It is possible that a business wants to maximize their customer service for people with disabilities. Maybe an employer wants to understand their responsibilities. Or, sometimes, the training is a result of a lawsuit. Your audience and their attitudes will vary based on the reason for the training, so make sure you are aware of this ahead of time! Ask questions to help develop your training’s content: What topics need to be covered? Will there be time for a question and answer period? How many people will make up my audience? What is the mix of people in the room? Businesses? People with disabilities? Employers? Be sure to ask the following logistical questions so your training day runs smoothly: Who will be providing the equipment? How do I access the site? Is there parking? Do I have to pay for parking? Will you feed me? How should I dress? Find out ahead of time if accommodations are needed for individuals with disabilities. To accommodate individuals with learning disabilities and vision impairments when using presentation slides, be sure to explain what is on the slide. Highlight points and convey enough information to describe pictures to someone who has no vision. Also, provide information in several types of alternative formats (tapes, Braille, diskette) if needed for participants with disabilities. Watch for inadequate lighting, which inhibits communication by persons who have hearing and learning limitations. APPEARANCE The better you look the more comfortable you will feel. Be careful with your dress. Anything too wild will distract from your presentation. Avoid perfumes and scented lotions. Many audience members may experience discomfort or hypersensitivity to fragrances. ON THE DAY OF THE TRAINING Expect to be nervous. Accept being nervous. Arrive early, get used to the surroundings, and prepare the room. Make sure all of your audiovisual equipment is functioning and ready to go. Remember an audience rarely notices your anxiety. Get to know your audience - what is their experience with disability? Is this a voluntary or mandatory training (do the people want to be there?) Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] The success with your presentation all depends on the relationship you establish with the audience from the beginning. If they like you, they will like your presentation and vice versa. Opening Introductions YOU MAY: Say something dramatic or news worthy Give a startling fact or statistic Compliment your audience Share a personal story or human-interest story Ask a rhetorical or challenging question Give historical background Cite a familiar quote Refer to the site, building, city of training Tell a joke (only if you can!!!) HELPFUL HINT If asked to send a bio or information for your introduction, offer to write your own introduction. This way you will be sure the audience knows what you want them to know about you. DURING PRESENTATION Remember that you are the subject matter expert and everyone in the room sees you as such. Maintain eye contact with group (don't face the screen). Guide the group to where you want them to go. Continually read your audience – do they understand what you are talking about? Do they need a break, or even an end to the session? (If you see people stirring or not being attentive, offer a break, even if it is not scheduled). If you... are boring and uncomfortable, your audience … will be bored and uncomfortable. If you enjoy your presentation, your audience will enjoy your presentation. Be very familiar with your objectives and keep in mind what you want your audience to learn. Ask open-ended questions, not yes or no questions. After you ask a question, count to three. If there is no response, give a hint, if still no response, give answer. Provide participants with a name tag and/or table tent for their name. Use people's names - it makes people feel comfortable. Demonstrate friendliness towards your audience, laugh or smile at their jokes (even if they are not funny). Use proximity control, walk around the room, if two people are talking, go stand by them (they will stop quickly). Manage your time well. If you are running late, you may have to decide whether it’s more important to cover all the material or address the audience's questions. Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Never tell your audience you are behind schedule or that you are moving ahead and skipping portions of your training. (This may make the audience resentful that they are missing much needed information.) If you move ahead or skip portions of your training, no one will know. Keep things moving, nothing is deadlier than a dragged-out presentation. Remember: you cannot expect to cover everything about a particular topic. Handling Questions Repeat audience questions if necessary to ensure that all audience members have heard the question. During question and answer sessions, remember, you are in control. Always stay calm and reasonable. Never get into an argument or shouting match. Listen to each question without reaction. Take questions from the whole audience. Treat each question equally. Repeat positive questions. If a participant makes a negative comment, consider ways to address it positively. Answer questioner by first looking at him/her, then the whole audience. Respond simply and directly (Example: Don't tell someone how to build a clock if they have only asked "what time is it?"). Don't announce, "This is the last question." What if it is negative? When you want to conclude, simply don't ask for more questions. If you don't know the answer, say so, promise to get it–and follow up. Closing Remarks This may be the only thing the audience remembers. Challenge, call to action. Make a stirring statement. Predict the future. Give a quotation. Share a personal story or anecdote. Make a declaration. Refer to or repeat parts of the opening introduction. Offer a piece of advice. AUDIENCE MEMBER TYPES The informal leader is the person in the group who people automatically look to – a powerful person, not an enemy. It is important to establish a relationship here; and acknowledge their power. The eternal pessimist sees everything from a negative perspective. Don't ignore the detractor, take the negative comments and turn them into positive questions. If they become too obnoxious, the group will usually gang up on them. The big shot, know-it-all will announce at the beginning that they have as much or more expertise than you do. Realize they are scared or uncomfortable; they feel that they are Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] above your training. Fall all over them and make them feel special. ("I'm so happy you are in this workshop.") Wait until the first break and ask the person to "go along with you during your exercises." Also ask him/her to write down ways you can improve your presentation - then ask them to share their ideas with you after the presentation. This should keep them quiet during your presentation. The introvert - don't try to pull out the introvert. The talker is the most dangerous person during a presentation. S/he will try to take over your workshop, will dominate the conversation, and won't allow you to move along with your agenda. If they make a comment that you do not want to deal with at that time state: "I will get back to that comment." If they want you to deal with it then, you must do so. If you deal directly with the chatterbox and they continue to argue with you, you have the rest of the group on your side. If they are still not satisfied with your response, ask them to wait until the next break and talk to them then. Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] ADDITIONAL TIPS FOR TRAINING SUCCESS: Overhead Transparencies/PowerPoint 1. Use active words and short phrases (rather than sentences that go on for several lines) 2. Read everything on the screen, and highlight key points. 3. Focus a single idea on one visual. 4. Generally follow the 4 by 6 rule: Try to use a maximum of 4 lines per transparency and up to 6 words on a line. 5. Use both upper and lower case letters except for headings when you may want to use upper case only. 6. Use at least 18 point type. 7. Apply the 6 foot rule: If it can be read from 6’ away, then it can be used. 8. Use bullets, not numbers for non-sequential items. 9. Use, but do not overuse, color. Blue and yellow make good contrast. 10. Always make your overheads or PowerPoint presentation part of your hand-out packet. Using a flip chart – Flipping with flair Make sure your chart is readable / legible. Letters should be at least 1 ½ inches high and you should leave 2 inches between lines. Use as few words as possible and center your message. Brighten visual appeal. Underline and box key words. Use color, graphic designs and geometric shapes. Use flip charts to record information. For example, during a brainstorming session, quickly write key words that reflect contributors’ ideas. Use different colored markers to alternate ideas. Hang flip chart pages around the room. Be careful about using strongly scented markers. Some audience members may experience discomfort or hypersensitivity to smells. Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] TRAINING PROSPECT INFORMATION SHEET Date _________________________ Trainer _________________________________________ Contact Information Name ______________________________ Company _________________________________ Telephone __________________________ E-mail_____________________________________ Address ______________________________________________________________________ City _____________________________________ State _______ Zip _____________________ Billing address, if different _______________________________________________________ How did you hear about us? _______________________________________________________ Training Information Sponsoring organization _________________________________________________________ Date(s) of training _________________________ Length/Time _________________________ Topics to be covered ____________________________________________________________ Why do you want / need this training? ______________________________________________ What is your desired goal / outcome for this training? __________________________________ What is the makeup of the audience (Businesses? People with disabilities?) ________________ Is attendance in this training mandatory? __________________ Audience size ______________ Location ________________________________ Directions _____________________________ Materials (Can use materials request form) ___________________________________________ Alternate formats? Braille_____ LP _____ Disk_____ Tape_____ Other___________________ Bring? ___________ Mail? (write address below) __________ Date Needed ________________ If mailed, address _______________________________________________________________ Audio visual: TV/VCR ____ Laptop ____ LCD Projector ____ Bring? ____ Provided? _____ Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] MATERIALS REQUEST FORM Materials Needed by: _____________________________________________________ Date of Activity: _________________________________________________________ Name of Group: _________________________________________________________ Location: _______________________________________________________________ Trainer/Presenter: _______________________________________________________ Publication Name/Number Number of Copies Requested Number of Copies Returned Number of Copies Used Other instructions (if requesting more items, use a second request form:) ______________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________ Trainer/Presenter: Remember alternate formats, evaluation forms, sign-in/mailing list forms, regional/national rolodex cards, regional/national brochures, publications lists, newsletters, quiz book exercises, CDs, videos/DVDs, business cards, samples, displays, flip charts, and giveaways. ** Remember alternate formats ** Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] TRAINER’S FEEDBACK FORM TRAINER’S NAME / TOPIC: POSITIVES IN THE FUTURE, YOU MAY WISH TO CONSIDER: ____________________ ____________________ ____________________ ____________________ TRAINER’S FEEDBACK FORM TRAINER’S NAME / TOPIC: POSITIVES IN THE FUTURE, YOU MAY WISH TO CONSIDER: ____________________ ____________________ ____________________ ____________________ Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Workforce Discovery: Diversity and Disability (Evaluation Form #1) Feedback and Evaluation Form Help us to make this training better! Please give us your comments/ideas. The training was divided into six modules, please rate each one. SCALE: 4 = Substantial 3 = Moderate 2 = Limited 1 = None Module 1: Typecasting: Understanding Disability Did your knowledge of the subject increase as a result of participation in this activity? 4 3 2 1 List strengths: List weaknesses: Module 2: Legal Implications: An Overview of the ADA Did your knowledge of the subject increase as a result of participation in this activity? 4 3 2 1 List strengths: List weaknesses: Module 3: Reasonable Accommodation Did your knowledge of the subject increase as a result of participation in this activity? 4 3 2 1 List strengths: List weaknesses: Turn over please……………………………………………………….. Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] SCALE: 4 = Substantial 3 = Moderate 2 = Limited 1 = None Module 4: Etiquette: Communication and Interaction Did your knowledge of the subject increase as a result of participation in this activity? 4 3 2 1 List strengths: List weaknesses: Module 5: Best Practices for Trainers Did your knowledge of the subject increase as a result of participation in this activity? 4 3 2 1 List strengths: List weaknesses: Other Comments: Thank you for your time and assistance! Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] SAMPLE EVALUATION FORM Feedback and Evaluation Form (Evaluation Form #2) Please take a few minutes to give us your feedback. Your comments are anonymous, confidential, and greatly appreciated. Thanks! Participant information: Please put a check mark next to your role as a participant in the training activity: (Check all that apply) __ Business Owner __Employer __Service Provider/Advocate __Person with a Disability __ Other, please specify____________________ Please circle your responses: None Limited Amount Moderate Substantial Amount Amount 1. Did your knowledge of the subject increase as a result of participation in this activity? 1 2 3 4 2. To what extent will you be able to apply this information? 1 2 3 4 Poor Fair Good Excellent 3. The overall quality of the program. 1 2 3 4 4. Knowledge/ability of the facilitator. 1 2 3 4 5. The strengths of the program were: 6. The weaknesses of the program were: 7. Other comments and suggestions: Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Reasonable Accommodation Training Survey (Evaluation Form #3) The <insert name> Center is seeking the following information as part of our on-going evaluation of the effectiveness of the program we provide. This information will be utilized as part of the reporting requirements to our funding agency (US Department of Education, National Institute on Disability Rehabilitation and Research). Please assist us by completing this survey. All responses are confidential. 1. How would you describe your role at the training seminar? (circle one) a. Private employer b. Public employer c. Other (please specify) ______________________ Section 1. Note that a rating of 1 is “strongly disagree” and 6 is “strongly agree” Rate your level of agreement with these statements as a result of this training. Strongly Disagree Disagree Disagree a Little Agree a Little Agree Strongly Agree The meeting rooms were professional and comfortable 1 2 3 4 5 6 The presentation was accessible to me 1 2 3 4 5 6 The pacing of the training was appropriate 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 Statement: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. The presenters stimulated the interest and involvement of participants The goals for the training were well presented The content of the training was relevant to my situation or interests The training increased my understanding of the ADA and employment issues I plan to review Reasonable Accommodations policies and practices for compliance I plan to modify or enhance Reasonable Accommodations practices Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Section 2. Note that a rating of 1 is “None” and 5 is “Very high” In the 1st column, rate your level of understanding BEFORE the training. In the 2 nd column, rate your understanding to show any improvement AFTER the training. My Level of Understanding TOPIC: BEFORE the Seminar None 1. The topic of Reasonable Accommodations 2. How to determine the purpose and essential functions of a particular job 3. How to identify abilities and limitations, barriers, and appropriate accommodations 4. The definition of disability 5. The definition of reasonable accommodation 6. The definition of undue hardship 7. The definition of direct threat 8. Responsibilities of employer and employee in the reasonable accommodations process 9. Responsibility of the employer to ensure that the choice of a reasonable accommodation is effective. Very Low Moderate High AFTER the Seminar Very High None Very Low Moderate High Very High 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 Section 3. 1. How would you rate your overall satisfaction with the training seminar? (Circle one) a. Very Satisfied b. Satisfied c. Somewhat Satisfied d. Dissatisfied e. Very Dissatisfied 2. Do you have any other comments on the training? Please write them here or on back of this page: Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Workforce Discovery: Diversity and Disability in the Workplace Train-the-Trainer Workshop SAMPLE SCHEDULE DAY ONE – 9:30 a.m. – 9:00 a.m. – 9:30 a.m. – 9:40 a.m. – 10:10 a.m. – 10:30 a.m. – 11:30 a.m. – 4:00 p.m. 9:30 a.m. 9:40 a.m. 10:10 a.m. 10:30 a.m. 11:30 a.m. 12:00 p.m. 12:00 p.m. – 1:00 p.m. 1:00 p.m. – 2:00 p.m. 2:00 p.m. – 2:15 p.m. – 2:30 p.m. – 3:45 p.m. – 2:15 p.m. 2:30 p.m. 3:45 p.m. 4:00 p.m. DAY TWO – 9:30 a.m. – 4:00 p.m. 9:00 a.m. – 9:30 a.m. 9:30 a.m. – 9:40 a.m. 9:40 a.m. – 10:45 a.m. 10:45 a.m. – 11:00 a.m. 11:00 a.m. – 12:00 p.m. 12:00 p.m. – 1:00 p.m. 1:00 p.m. – 2:30 p.m. 2:30 p.m. – 2:45 p.m. 2:45 p.m. – 3:30 p.m. 3:30 p.m. – 4:00 p.m. Continental Breakfast Review Agenda and Housekeeping Items Introduction - Ice Breaker Activity The Purpose of Ice Breakers Discussion (Module 5) Module 1: Typecasting Small Group Discussions on Adapting Module 1 for Individual Needs Lunch Break Module 2: Legal Implications – An Overview of the ADA Supplemental ADA Materials and Resources Break Module 3: Reasonable Accommodation Review and Questions –Homework Assignment –Evaluation Form for Day One Continental Breakfast Check-In Activity Module 4: Etiquette: Communication and Interaction Break More ADA Materials and Resources Lunch Break Presentations and Feedback Activity Break Best Practices (Module 5) Evaluation and Closing Comments –Evaluation Form for Day Two Thought for the day: “You must do the very thing you think you cannot do” ~Eleanor Roosevelt Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] TRAINER’S TIPS: Ten Commandments of Communicating with People with Disabilities The following are possible discussion questions for each of the ten commandments. Instead of using every question, you should pick and choose based on the needs of your audience. You can supplement the conversation with the additional topics listed below each commandment, as long as you are knowledgeable. Commandment #1. Speak directly to the individual rather than through a companion or sign language interpreter who may be present. Has anyone used a sign language interpreter to interact with an individual who is deaf? What was the experience like? Has anyone used message relay to communicate? o 711 national number and service What other accommodations might a person who is deaf or hard of hearing need? o A sign language interpreter o Assistive listening devices o TTY and TTY pay phones o Captioning of videos or other audible info o Access to voicemail phone system o Written information o Different types of communication used by people with hearing disabilities including sign language, speech reading, cued speech, writing, and typing. Commandment #2. Offer to shake hands when introduced. People with limited hand use or an artificial limb can usually shake hands and offering the left hand is an acceptable greeting. Practice shaking hands with group not using primary hand. Discuss this experience if appropriate. What other accommodations might someone with limited mobility need? o Computer assistive technology What are other appropriate greetings? Commandment #3. Always identify yourself and others who may be with you when meeting someone who is blind or has low-vision. When conversing in a group, remember to identify the person to whom you are speaking. When dining with a friend who has a visual disability, ask if you can describe what is on his or her plate. Have group pair off and practice this tip. How does it feel to be so conscious of yourself and your words? Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] How are activities advertised and information disseminated to ensure that persons with vision disabilities have access to this information? o Web site accessibility and assistive technology issues. o The use of Braille, CDs, large print, diskettes and electronic methods. Please note that many people who are blind prefer to feel the food on their plate rather than asking for a description. Share personal experiences if appropriate. Commandment #4. If you offer assistance, wait until the offer is accepted. Then listen or ask for instructions. What type of assistance are you comfortable providing? What type of assistance might a person request? Have you ever had assistance forced on you? How did that make you feel? Commandment #5. Treat adults as adults. Address people with disabilities by their first names only when extending that same familiarity to all others. Never patronize people in wheelchairs by patting them on the head or shoulder. Discuss language and people first terminology. How do we treat older persons? Is it similar? How would you respond to the woman of short stature? Would you think she would need an accommodation? Other ideas. What are ways to offer assistance? Who feels comfortable having a door opened for you? See the variety of responses. The same differences in the disability community. Commandment #6. Do not lean against or hang on someone’s wheelchair. Bear in mind that people with disabilities treat their chairs as extensions of their bodies. And so do people with guide dogs and service animals. Never distract a work animal from their job without the owner’s permission. When might it be helpful to make additional seating available to provide opportunities to interact comfortably with people at different heights? o Access to stage areas and podiums, etc. What is the difference between a service animal and a pet? Where are service animals permitted? o Service animals are trained to perform specific tasks on an individual’s behalf. They should not be disruptive. Commandment #7. Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Listen attentively when talking to people who have difficulty speaking and wait for them to finish. If necessary, ask short questions that require short answers, or a nod of the head. Never pretend to understand; instead repeat what you have understood and allow the person to respond. Discuss potential options to facilitate communication o Speech-to-speech relay available at 711 national phone number. o Use of pen and paper or other tools. o Importance of eye contact and nonverbal communication. Commandment #8. Place your self at eye level when speaking with someone in a wheelchair or on crutches. Pair off the group and have one person in each pair stand up and carry on a conversation with the other person seated. How does this feel from each person’s perspective? o Integrated seating. o Dispersed seating at cinemas, stadiums and other venues. Commandment #9. Tap a person who is deaf or hard of hearing on the shoulder or wave your hand to get his or her attention. Look directly at the person and speak clearly, slowly, and expressively to establish if the person can read your lips. If so, try to face the light source and keep hands, cigarettes and food away from your mouth when speaking. If a person is wearing a hearing aid, don’t assume that they have the ability to discriminate your speaking voice. Never shout at a person. Just speak in a normal tone of voice. Tips to facilitate communication: o Arrange office seating so a person with a hearing disability can see who enters the office area. Discuss personal preferences about being touched and ways to get the person’s attention. Explain that speech reading is difficult. o Example of “island view” and “I love you.” Discuss: o Some people with hearing disabilities use hearing aids only to alert them of danger or loud noises. o Effective communication under the ADA and options. It is important to get a person’s attention before beginning to speak. o Assistive listening devices. Discuss the different types of hearing loss and variety of accommodations. Commandment #10. Relax. Don’t be embarrassed if you happen to use common expressions such as “See you later” or “Did you hear about this?” that seem to relate to a person’s disability. Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] You may wish to tell stories about your personal interactions with individuals with disabilities. Perhaps some individuals you know prefer the guidelines explained in the video, and perhaps some do not. Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] EXAMPLE ICEBREAKERS Icebreaker Move around the room and practice introducing yourself, making eye contact, and shaking hands with each person you encounter. Without mentioning your profession or education, find one thing you both have in common and one thing you do not. You cannot use the same characteristic more than once. Scavenger Hunt The Scavenger Hunt in this case is a hunt for information. Find the person who meets the criteria. For example: 1. Find a person that traveled here from West Virginia. ______________ 2. Find a person who knows sign language._______________________ 3. Find a person who is wearing the same color shoes that you are wearing._________________________________________ 4. Find a person who went to college in Maryland._________________ 5. Find a person who has a pet monkey.________________________ 6. Find a person who was born in the south._____________________ 7. Find a person who has visited China.________________________ 8. Find a person who loves to garden.__________________________ It is helpful to know your audience and plan the topics around areas that they represent and that are not controversial or too personal. Design the form so that people can sign when they match so that each person can sign only once. Famous people/cities As each participant arrives, tape a 3 x 5 index card on their back with the name of a famous person or city. They must circulate in the room and ask questions that can ONLY be answered with a YES or NO to identify clues that will help them find out the name of the person or city on their index card. Ex: Paris, Madonna, Santa Claus, John Wayne, Casablanca Comic Strip Chaos Each participant takes a turn at picking a comic frame out of the large container. After the entire group has each chosen one, the participants begin to search for others with the same comic strip sequence. After the participants have found everyone in their group, they must arrange themselves so that the sequence of frames are in chronological order to form the comic strip correctly. Upon completion of sequence, the newly formed group sits down together. This is a great exercise to break large group into smaller groups. Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Alphabetic Introductions Each participant is asked to choose a letter of the alphabet. Duplicate letters are permitted. They are then given five minutes in which to describe themselves using single words beginning only with that letter. You could award a small prize for the person with the most number of words. A further optional stage is to ask participants to write down their chosen words on a sheet of paper with their name at the top and display it on the wall for the duration of the event. Others could be asked later on in the event as to whether the words accurately describe the individual. Non-verbal Introductions Divide the group into pairs. Taking turns, each member of the pair should communicate to their partner as much about themselves as they can without speaking or writing (drawing pictures is allowed). For example they might point to a wedding ring or draw a picture of their house. To make the exercise slightly easier, and to keep the group to time, the facilitator could call out the topics and when to changeover. Finish the exercise by having everyone introduce their partner (verbally). Also allow the partner to make corrections and fill in missing details. Leave Your Baggage at the Door Make a flip chart sheet so that, when folded, it resembles a suitcase. Distribute paper cutouts in the shape of clothing, workfiles, etc. and explain that they represent baggage. Explain that you understand outside distractions, but today you are asking them to “leave your baggage at the door.” You can demonstrate with your own contribution (ex: “I’m behind on my performance reviews.”) Then tape your note to the “suitcase” flip chart sheet. Invite participants to take their own notes to the suitcase – as participants post their notes, ask them to explain what it is they are leaving at the door – and why. Then fold the suitcase so that all of the items are inside and leave it at the door. This technique gives everyone a chance to vent and say that they don’t have time for the training. Participants at least know that you are aware and sympathetic, and might be more receptive to training. Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module Five Acknowledgements Handouts Best Practices Handouts: TransCen, Inc. www.transcen.org. Modified October 2004. Training Propsect Information Sheet TransCen, Inc. www.transcen.org. Modified April 2005. Materials Request Form TransCen, Inc. www.transcen.org. Modified April 2005. Presenter’s Feedback Form: TransCen, Inc. www.transcen.org. Modified February 2005. Evaluation Forms: TransCen, Inc.www.transcen.org. Compiled January 2005. Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 Acknowledgements Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 1 ___________________________________ Module 5 ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Best Practices for Trainers ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 2 Module Goals • To gain confidence by learning innovative training techniques, addressing concerns about public speaking, and learning new training principles • To become more effective trainers through practice sessions and a review of best practices ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 3 ___________________________________ When you think about standing in front of a group of people to speak, what are some of your concerns? ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 4 ___________________________________ Best Practices ___________________________________ • Planning and Preparation ___________________________________ • Opening and Introduction ___________________________________ • During your Training • Closing Remarks and Evaluation ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 5 Conduct a needs assessment • Why are you doing this training? • Why are you doing this training NOW? • What are the desired goals or outcomes of the training? • Is attendance at this training mandatory? ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 6 Don’t forget to ask… • Substantive Questions – What topic needs to be covered? – Will there be time for a question and answer period? – How many people will make up my audience? – What is the mix of people in the room? Businesses? People with disabilities? Employers? ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 7 Don’t forget to ask… • Logistical Questions –Who will be providing the equipment? –How do I access the site? –Is there parking? –Do I have to pay for parking? –Will you feed me? –How should I dress? ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 8 …and what about DURING your presentation? • Audience members…come in many “shapes and sizes” • PowerPoint presentations (or alternate format) • Using a Flip Chart • Model disability etiquette ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Slide 9 ___________________________________ Homework • Prepare a 10 minute presentation from the manual • Any topic from the manual • Include a brief introduction, presentation of topic, and a closing • Prepare to provide and receive feedback from peers ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Slide 10 ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ Best Practices for Trainers Module 5 PowerPoint Handouts Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05] Module Review Name of Module _______________________________________________________ Date of Training ________________________________________________________ It is our goal to create the most effective ‘Train-the-Trainer’ program possible. We genuinely value your opinion and appreciate your feedback. Which part of this module was the most effective? What part of this module might you change or adapt? What other resources or information might you use in this module? Please use this space to provide any additional feedback. Thank you. Module Review Copyright © 2004 by TransCen, Inc. [Ver. 10/05]
© Copyright 2024