Headline MediaTitle Date Section Page No Language Journalist Frequency How to survive a bank foreclosure New Straits Times 24 Aug 2012 Supplement 8,9 English N/A Daily Color Circulation Readership ArticleSize AdValue PR Value Full Color 136,530 330,000 1431 cm² RM 46,507 RM 139,521 How to survive a bank foreclosure? hope against homelessness: Now is the time to avail yourself of five defences against bank foreclosures Let me now take us on a journey In my previous article (NSTRED 17th August 2012), I asked Malaysian through Malaysia's National Land Code banks a question: Can Malaysian banks be relied upon to selfregulate and to act with caution and compassion and not to commence with wholesale foreclosure proceedings against their defaulting borrowers that would cause not only the economic destruction of their borrowers but would The requirement for strict compli of 1965 to understand the respective ance of statutory rules by Malaysian rights and obligations of Malaysian banks (with penalties for their failure to comply) provides distressed banks and their housing loan borro borrowers with plausible defences that they can avail wers. themselves to when faced For many average Malaysians, to with foreclosure procee dings by the banks. have an encounter with the law can prove to be an unpleasant and some times traumatic experience. also precipitate a crash of the Malaysian property market with dire consequences Property as collateral for loans: When for all Malaysians?" a person borrows money from a bank, The worst case scenario: I hope that normally the bank will require that the Malaysian banks will voluntarily impo borrower provides the bank se upon themselves a Malaysianwide with a security (collateral) Housing Loan Repayment Moratorium for durations of between three to five for the loan. For housing loans, the security is usually years. I also hope that Datuk Seri Najib in the form of the subject Tun Razak, Malaysia's Prime Minister property and the value of and Finance Minister will intervene the property should be hig and instruct Bank Negara Malaysia her than the amount of the to impose a Malaysianwide Housing loan granted by the bank. Loan Repayment Moratorium to be The property that is implemented by Malaysian Banks for durations of between three to five offered by the borrower to the bank as security for the years. loan will then be "charged But, what if none of the above to the bank". The borrower Borrowers 1st line of defence: When a borrower fails to pay the monthly housing loan instalment for four consecutive months and the lending bank com mences with, foreclosure proceedings against him, before the bank can apply to the High Court for an "Order for Sale", Section 254 of the NLC requires that the bank issues to the borrower a "Default Notice" in Form 16D, a form prescribed in the NLC. This Form 16D must be served on the borrower in person. It is mandatory for the bank to comply with the requirements stated in Sec happens? Faced with these onslaughts is known as "chargor" while from Malaysian banks, can the the Bank is known as "char thousands of distressed borrowers defend themselves? gee". When the borrower fails Playing field is not level: Until now, with a few exceptions, when Malaysi to repay the loan, the bank in order to recover the loan an banks commenced with foreclosure proceedings against their borrowers, amount will proceed to "the field is not level". It is a slippery apply to the High Court or field for the borrowers. Even when the the Land Office for an "Order banks have a weak case, by the sheer for Sale" to sell the subject weight and power of their money and property that is charged to their battery of highpowered liti the Bank by way of a public auction. In short, the bank tion 254 of the NLC. If the bank fails to comply and did not issue and did not personally serve on the bor rowerthe "Default Notice" in Form 16D, all subsequent foreclosure proceedings commenced by the bank, all the way to the issuance of the "Order for Sale" by the High Court would be considered irregular and cannot be enforced on the borrower. There have been many previous gation lawyers, Malaysian banks will Malaysian court judgments upholding invariably prevail and win against their will try to auction off the the doctrine of "Strict Compliance" with charged property when the borrower Section 254 of the National Land Code hapless borrowers. defaults on the loan. 1965. Justice requires level playfield: This Foreclosure under NLC: The NLC gives article is not written against Malaysi Malaysian banks the right to foreclose Served with a court summons?: When an banks. The objective of this article on the properties of their defaulting you are served by your bank with a is to educate and inform the thousands of distressed borrowers who cannot afford to pay the lawyers' fees to get the appropriate advice. They need to know their rights as provided for in the borrowers and to sell these foreclosed properties through public auctions to recover the loans. court summons to foreclose your pro perty, first and foremost, you should check your memory and your records to However, there are very strict sta make sure "if you have personally been served by the lending Bank through tutory rules that Malaysian banks are National Land Code of 1965 (NLC) and their lawyers with the "Default Notice required to comply with before they how they can stand up for themselves in Form 16D". I emphasise the word and know what to do when they are can foreclose and sell their borrowers' properties. If they fail to comply with "personally". If you did not personally faced with foreclosure proceedings. any one or more of these statutory receive from the bank's lawyers the Malaysian banks' lawyers always rules, they will fail in their attempts to "Default Notice in Form 16D", even claim that their clients have solid and foreclose and to sell their borrowers' watertight cases against the borro properties. wers. Are the banks' lawyers correct? though it may have been given to your wife or left at your house or sent Headline MediaTitle Date Section Page No Language Journalist Frequency How to survive a bank foreclosure New Straits Times 24 Aug 2012 Supplement 8,9 English N/A Daily to you by post, for as long as you did Color Circulation Readership ArticleSize AdValue PR Value Full Color 136,530 330,000 1431 cm² RM 46,507 RM 139,521 When the bank's lawyer applies to in their opinions of value with the dif not personally receive from the bank's the High Court for an "Order for Sale", ference between the lowest value and lawyers the 'Default Notice in Form the bank's lawyer will have to submit to the highest value ranging from 50 per 16D", the lending Bank did not comply the High Court a copy of the Valuation cent (at the lower range) to 400 per with Section 254 of the NLC and the Report. The report will state the "mar cent (at the higher range). In absolute consequences for the bank will follow. ket value" of your property as at the figures, Valuer A may value the 50acre When you are sure you did not per date of the Valuation Report. land at RM10 Million whilst Valuer B may value it at RM15 Million (50 per sonally receive from the bank's lawy cent higher) or even RM40 Million (400 Reserve Price of foreclosed property: er the "Default Notice" in Form 16D, per cent higher). immediately get yourself a lawyer and Section 257(l)(d) of the National Land Code of 1965 states that: tell him the whole story. Your lawyer will know what to do next and he will take care of you from then on. Borrowers' 2nd line of defence: After Can either of the valuers be wrong "Every order for sale made by the or can they both be wrong? Who will Court under section 256 shall requi decide which valuer is right and which re the Registrar of the Court to fix a one is wrong? you have ascertained that you did per reserve price for the purpose of the sonally receive from the bank's lawyer sale, being a price equal to the estima the "Default Notice", you now have OverseasChinese Banking Corpo ted market value of the land or lease ration Ltd vs Kredin Sdn Bhd to study the form carefully. Is it Form in question." 16D or Form 16E? Why the splitting This is a foreclosure dispute bet ween OverseasChinese Banking Cor of hairs? Does it matter whether it is poration Ltd (OCBC) and Kredin Sdn The definition of "Market Value" as Form 16D (issued under Section 254) adopted by the Board of Valuers, App Bhd (the "Borrower") that was heard or Form 16E (issued under Section raisers and Estate Agents, Malaysia is and decided by the Kuala Lumpur High 255)? Yes, it does matter if you want to stop the bank's foreclosure procee as follows: dings against you. "Market value is the estimated 31106986 between OCBC and amount for which an asset should Kredin Sdn Bhd (Kredin), OCBC had In essence, the difference between Form Court in December 1995. In the Originating Summons No exchange on the date of valuation bet in November 1988 appointed Encik ween a willing buyer and a willing seller Sulaiman Mustafa of Jones Lang Woo when the loan granted by the bank to in an arm's length transaction after pro ton to value five contiguous plots of the defaulting borrower is repayable by per marketing wherein the parties had residential zoned land located next to instalments over a period of time, like each acted knowledgeably, prudently the Kuala Lumpur City Centre (KLCC), 16D and Form 16E is: Form 16D is a default notice issued a Housing Loan repayable in monthly and without compulsion." instalments over a period of 30 years. Right to challenge Valuation Report: As off Jalan Ampang, Kuala Lumpur (the subject properties). Form 16E is a default notice issued the owner of the property that is being In November 1988, Sulaiman valued when the loan granted by the bank to foreclosed, the borrower has the right the 206,531 sq ft (4.74 acres) land at the defaulting borrower is repayable on to challenge the accuracy and correct RM19.000 (RM0.09 per sq ft). demand in one payment like an Over ness of the Valuation Report prepared In April 1993, the same Sulaiman by the bank's valuer and to challenge prepared an update Valuation Report draft granted to businesses. the valuer's opinion on the "Market and revalued the land at RM42.000 If you have been granted by your Value" of the borrower's property that (RM0.20 per sq ft). is the subject of the foreclosure pro In July 1993, Kredin appointed Dr Ernest Cheong of Ernest Cheong PTL bank a Housing Loan to be repaid in ceedings. Chartered Surveyors (this writer) to monthly instalments over a period In my previous article (NST RED of say, 30 years, and you personally 10th August 2012), I suggested that value the same land. In his Valuation Report dated 27th received the "Default Notice" from when two valuers are instructed at the the bank's lawyer but it was Form 16E same time to value a residential pro July 1993, Dr Ernest Cheong valued that you received instead of Form 16D. perty like an apartment, terrace house the 4.74 acres land at RM134,245,150 When you did not receive Form 16D, or detached house located in Kuala (RM650 per sq ft). the Bank did not comply with Section Lumpur, the valuation of the property After hearing the evidence of 254 of the NLC and the consequences by the two valuers will not differ much both Sulaiman and Dr Cheong, Justice for the lending Bank will follow. one from the other. They will likely have Rahmah Hussain held that: When you are sure you did not adopted the same method, namely the "I am of the opinion that this Court receive the "Default Notice" in Form Direct Comparison Method for their can still follow the general guideline as 16D even though you were served valuations. Similarly, the valuation of laid down in that case (Supreme Court with Form 16E by the bank's lawyer, a valuer appointed by the borrower case of NKM Properties Sdn Bhd v immediately get yourself a lawyer and to value his house, a straightforward Rakyat First Merchant Bankers Berhad residential property in Kuala Lumpur [1992] 2 MLJ 349) that is the reserve tell him the whole story. is not likely to differ much from the price is a price equal to the estimated Borrowers' 3rd line of defence: After valuation of the same property by the market value of the land in question." you are sure that you personally did receive from the bank's lawyer the "Default Notice" in Form 16D, you will now instruct your lawyer to request bank's valuer. However, when these two valuers "In his valuation report dated 27 are instructed at the same time to value July 1993, Mr Ernest Cheong gave the from the bank's lawyer a copy of the a 50acre plot of vacant land in Kajang, basis of his valuation whereas in Encik Selangor, they will likely produce Valu Valuation Report on your property pre ation Reports that are vastly different Sulaiman's update of his 1988 report, pared by the bank's valuer. Headline MediaTitle Date Section Page No Language Journalist Frequency How to survive a bank foreclosure New Straits Times 24 Aug 2012 Supplement 8,9 English N/A Daily Color Circulation Readership ArticleSize AdValue PR Value Full Color 136,530 330,000 1431 cm² RM 46,507 RM 139,521 dated 5 April 1993, it was stated that also the bank s borrower. even sold your property at a public auc the update was undertaken without re Do Malaysian banks have the right tion, is this the end of the road for you? inspection of the subject property and to apply for Replacement Titles on their You still have one last line of defence available. conducting title check but was based own? on information received in the earlier report." Section 166(l)(d) of the National Extension of time to settle balance Land Code 1965 provides for the "Cir purchase price: The usual requirement As such, I am more inclined to cumstances in which title in continua under the Proclamation of Sale is that accept Mr Cheorag's report. Furthermo tion may be issued to land as a whole", the Purchaser at the Public Auction is re, Encik Sulaiman has totally disregar and for the application of Replacement normally required to settle the balance ded potential advantages of the said land. Mr Cheong however has given the fair market value at RM650 per sq ft. I am of the opinion that this is rather on the high side and that if I follow the value as suggested, the reserve price will be too high and there will be no bidders and the auction will be aborted. Titles when the original issue document of the Purchase Price within 90 days of title "has been lost or wholly or par after paying the requisite 10 per cent tially destroyed, or is being improperly of the Purchase Price. or wrongfully withheld". The Chargor (borrower) must Section 166(2) of the NLC stipula be consulted and his consent obtai ned if there is any application by the tes that the person or body to apply for Purchaser for any extension of time to replacement titles are as listed below: settle the balance of the Purchase Price. As such to my mind, a reserve price at a) The proprietor of the land in question The Bank cannot on their own, unilate RM525 per sq ft is more reasonable in b) Any person or body claimingthrough rally grant the Purchaser the extension the proprietor the circumstances". of time they applied for. The Court ordered that the Reserve Section 166(2) of the NLC as quoted Failure on the part of the len ling RM108,428,775 for the 206,531 "Chargee" to be included in the list of ding Bank to obtain the Chargor's sq ft (4.74 acres) land comprising the person or body permitted to apply for (borrower's) consent to grant the Purchaser's application for the exten subject properties. the replacement title. sion of time to pay the balance of the A summary of the valuations are Section 168 of the NLC stipulates Purchase Price will render the Sale of represented as follows (see Table 1): that "Before issuing title in continua the borrower's property at the Public Price be fixed at RM525 per sq ft tota above did not provide forthe "Bank" or Auction void (has no legal effect and paragraph (c) or (d) of subsection (1) unenforceable) (refer to M&J Frozen you have been granted the housing of section 166, the Registrar or [Land Food Sdn Bhd v Siland Sdn Bhd & tion in the circumstances described in Borrowers' 4th line of defence: After loan and before the loan amount was Administration] shall: Anor [1994] 1MLJ 294 SC). released to you, you signed all the legal (a) cause notice of his intention to Even after your property has been documents to "charge" your property/ do so to be published in the Gazette in sold by the bank at the public auction, house to the lending bank. After the you will need to monitor the progress "Legal Charge" was registered by the Form 10D; and (b) cause copies of the notice to be of the sale. You will know when the Land Office in the name of the bank, the "Original Copy" of the title docu served on every person or body having balance 90 per cent of the Purchase ment would be returned to the Bank a registered interest in the land, and to Price has to be paid by the Purchaser for safekeeping as your "Trustee and be published in accordance with the (90 days from the date of the public auction). On the 91st day from the date Custodian" for the safety of your Title provisions of Section 433 of the public auction, go to the bank Document. Request for copy of Title Document to ask if the Purchaser has paid the 90 from Bank: When you are served by Have you ever wondered if the "Ori per cent of the Purchase Price which ginal Copy" of the title document to your Bank with a Court Summons to should have been paid to the Bank the your house is safe in the bank's custo foreclose your property, immediately day before. dy? Did you ever consider it possible the request from your Bank a photocopy If the bank refuses to answer your bank would lose the "Original Copy" of of your Title Document that you had your title document? It is a fact Malay deposited with them as your "Trustee query or gives you a vague answer, and Custodian" for the safety of your immediately get yourself a lawyer and sian banks have actually lost the "Ori Title Document. tell him the whole story. ginal Copies" of their borrowers' title Your bank has to give you what you Calling all distressed borrowers: If you documents kept with them as "Trustee requested for as it is your right to' ask have been served with a court summons and Custodian". them to give you a copy of your title to foreclose your property, please write document. to DatukSeri Najib and appeal to him to When your bank gives you a copy of save you and your family from financial they had lost the "Original Copy" of a your Title Document and you find that ruin. Please request him to intervene to borrower's title document, they would it is not a copy of your Original Title have Bank Negara Malaysia impose a instruct their lawyers to apply to the but a copy of a Replacement Title, and Malaysianwide Housing Loan Repay Land Office concerned for a "Replace you are sure that you were not involved ment Moratorium to be implemented ment Title". I am also informed by the in the application for the Replacement by Malaysian banks for durations of se bank officers that their bank did not Title, immediately get yourself a lawyer between three to five years. inform and did not get the borrower and tell him the whole story. The Prime Minister's address is: I am informed by officers of Malay sian banks that when the bank realised concerned to be involved as they consi Borrowers 5th line of defence: When Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak, Prime der that as the "Chargee", the bank has after you failed to stop the bank and Minister's Office, Blok Utama, Bangu the right to apply for the "Replacement they succeeded in obtaining an "Order nan Perdana Putra, Pusat Pentadbiran Title" without the involvement of the for Sale" against your property and Kerajaan Persekutuan, 62502 Putra property owner (the proprietor) who is Headline MediaTitle Date Section Page No Language Journalist Frequency How to survive a bank foreclosure New Straits Times 24 Aug 2012 Supplement 8,9 English N/A Daily Color Circulation Readership ArticleSize AdValue PR Value Full Color 136,530 330,000 1431 cm² RM 46,507 RM 139,521 jaya. Please send me a copy of your let ter to the Prime Minister. I will try to help you get help from "public spirited" lawyers who may be willing to help you at reasonable legal fees. Send me an email at enquiriesiipecptl.com This column is endorsed by the National House Buyers Association of Malaysia (HBA) to educate, inform and empower house buyers in Malaysia. Dr. Ernest YY Cheongholdsa Doctor of Busi ness Administra tion (DBA) and an MBA. He is also a Chartered Surveyor, Reg istered Valuer, Auctioneer, Arbitrator and Principal of Ernest Cheong PTL Chartered Surveyors. Contact him at enquiries@ ecptl.com or visit www.ecptl.com Valuer/Court Valuation (RM) ; Value psf(RM) i Times Sulaiman Mustafa 42,000 0.20 1 Dr. Ernest Cheong 134,245,150 i 650.00 : 3,196 Court ordered Reserve Price 108,428,775 ; 525.00 i 2,581 Headline MediaTitle Date Section Page No Language Journalist Frequency How to survive a bank foreclosure New Straits Times 24 Aug 2012 Supplement 8,9 English N/A Daily Color Circulation Readership ArticleSize AdValue PR Value Full Color 136,530 330,000 1431 cm² RM 46,507 RM 139,521
© Copyright 2024