Environment for Europeans Magazine of the Directorate-General for the Environment Green week supplement 2014 CIRCULAR ECONOMY saving resources, creating jobs Environment Editorial Green Week 2014, Europe’s largest environment conference, held in Brussels in the first week of June, was about the ‘Circular economy – saving resources, creating jobs’. More than 3000 participants, including policy-makers, scientists and stakeholders from business and civil society, took part in wide-ranging debates on policy frameworks, business models, green jobs, eco-innovation and many other facets of the circular economy. European Commissioner for the Environment Janez Potočnik set the scene, noting: “Europe’s competitiveness will be determined by its ability to use resources efficiently and there will be no place for waste. We need to move away from our throwaway culture and switch to a more circular model, cutting waste and turning it into a resource.” Green Week debate and discussion demonstrated the benefits of a circular economy, but also showed that to succeed, the required transition from a linear to a circular economy would need all stakeholders on board. This means policy-makers too – listening and learning from examples and experience, ensuring a consistent and objective approach. Looking back on the week, Commissioner Potočnik told participants that he felt optimistic about a switch to the circular economy: “I know it can happen, I know it will happen, I know it is inevitable – and after seeing so many bright ideas, and so much willingness to confront change, I am starting to sense some reassurance that we can do it before we are forced to do it.” The aim of the EU’s 7th Environment Action Programme is “Living well, within the limits of our Planet”. This supplement of Environment for Europeans magazine spotlights the various debates during Green Week on how to achieve this – and showcases some of the stakeholders in the exhibition area. We hope you enjoy this special edition. Environment for Europeans ec.europa.eu/environment/news/efe/index_en.htm EDITORIAL INFORMATION Environment for Europeans is a quarterly magazine published by the Directorate-General for Environment of the European Commission. It is available in Bulgarian, Spanish, Czech, German, Estonian, Greek, English, French, Italian, Lithuanian, Polish, Portuguese and Romanian. Subscription is free. You can subscribe online at http://ec.europa.eu/environment/news/efe/ subscribe/subscribe_en.htm Editor-in-chief: Bettina Doeser Co-ordinator: Jonathan Murphy For more information, please contact the Communication Unit: http://ec.europa.eu/environment/contact/form_en.htm Information and documents: http://ec.europa.eu/environment/contact/form_en.htm Environment for Europeans website: http://ec.europa.eu/environment/news/efe/index_en.htm ENVIRONMENT ONLINE Do you want to know what the European Union is doing to protect the environment, what an integrated policy product is or how to qualify for an ‘Ecolabel’? Find out all this and more at DG Environment’s website: http://ec.europa.eu/environment/index_en.htm NOTICE Neither the European Commission nor any person acting on its behalf may be held responsible for the use to which information in this publication may be put, or for any errors which, despite careful preparation and checking, may appear. Printed on recycled paper that has been awarded the EU Ecolabel for graphic paper. (http://ec.europa.eu/environment/ecolabel) Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union, 2014 ISSN 1563-4183 (print version) ISSN 2363-1287 (epub version) © European Union, 2014 © Cover : European Commission, 2014. All photos: EU-Patrick Mascart, except p. 10 and 13 © Thinkstock, p. 15 © Paolo Andrea Montanaro - Courtesy Slow Food, p. 15 © Cor Kuyvenhoven; backcover: © Umicore Reproduction of the text is permitted provided the source is acknowledged. Reproduction of the photographs is prohibited. Printed in Italy Contents 03 Fresh air for the environment03 Setting the scene05 Green jobs for inclusive growth06 Getting the framework right08 12 06 Green urbanism10 Sharing best practice11 New greener business models12 A nudge in the right direction14 Green Week 2014 Exhibition15 10 MAGAZINE OF THE DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR THE ENVIRONMENT | SUPPLEMENT »» ECONOMICS, STRATEGY AND INFORMATION Fresh air for the environment Has progress towards a better environment ground to a halt? If so, what and who can trigger the changes needed? Is a ‘New Environmentalism’ likely to win the middle ground between the sceptical and the converted, and inspire the public’s imagination? Green Week 2014 opened with a summit that brought together leaders from the arts, business, policy, academia and campaigners to debate how to make environment policies and actions more effective. “For all the investment in cutting-edge clean technologies, the popular support of vast swathes of society, and the political rhetoric committing to urgent action, greener economic models are not cutting through into the mainstream at the pace that is required,” said James Murray, Editor of BusinessGreen, who introduced the summit. “There is a kind of paradox in that we know we have the potential for a sustainable economy but can’t seem to get on track,” said Jeffrey Sachs, Director of The Earth Institute, explaining this seeming paradox by the momentum and inertia of the global economy. The challenge of our generation … is how to live together in a crowded world – bursting at the seams in both human and ecological resource terms. “ We have the know-how, the technology and the need. Let’s do it! ” Different actors and actions have to be aligned to win the fight for sustainable development, he said, finishing on an optimistic note: “We have the know-how, the technology and the need. Let's do it!” Poetry as well as prose Film-maker Yann Arthus-Bertrand said: “To be an environmentalist is to love life and others.” Looking back over his books, films and projects, he called for a transformation that was spiritual, and not just technological and economic: “We have talked too much about guilt and not enough about personal responsibility,” he said. Environmentalists need to leave their comfort zone, to get to “where the magic happens”, according to Marco Lambertini, Director General of WWF. To convert awareness into action, environmentalists need to talk to wider circles of interest and connect with people. “By mobilising billions of people … we will trigger change,” he said. “We need to win the huge middle ground between the sceptical and the converted,” he added, stressing the importance of empowering local people in their local battles. Sandra Steingraber, biologist and author of Living Downstream, a documentary about the relationship between environmental factors and cancer, began with a warning: “We are 65 % water by weight and we breathe a pint of air with each breath.” Due to our reliance on fossil fuels, she said, we are facing two crises – climate change and chemical pollution – and the science says we must leave 80 % of remaining carbon in the ground. For this reason, “fracking is a bridge to nowhere”, she said. Fracking has environmental consequences, and expanding it holds back the circular economy, she argued, calling for a comprehensive health-impact assessment. Positive vision Achim Steiner, Executive Director of UNEP, agreed that fracking contributes to the illusion of “buying time”, but he also gave a more positive message: "We are privileged; we have never had so much information or so much attention." Even if the graphs are all pointing in the wrong direction, he argued, environmentalists are “on the right side of history”: 12 % of land area is already under some kind of protection, it has only been 25 years since the first high-level scientific discussions on climate change, and yet we are now transforming our economy. Last year, he noted by way of illustration, more was invested in renewable energy infrastructure than in oil, gas and coal combined. Although we have allowed the economic paradigm to define prices for environmental resources, he said, we have seen new concepts emerge: gross national happiness, green economy, resource efficiency and, from China, the ‘ecological civilisation’. He concluded that the New Environmentalism will need to be economically literate, to address finance and to articulate opportunities and solutions – not just problems. 3 4 According to Mitch Hedlund, Founder and Executive Director of the NGO ‘Recycle Across America’, US recycling has plateaued at 34 %. But if it increased to 75 %, it would create 1.5 million new jobs. Noting that global waste is projected to double by 2025, she spoke about the problem of poor labelling on bins: public recycling bins are confusing, leading to scepticism and mistakes. Her organisation provides a standardised recycling label system. The campaign uses media and big brand collaboration, which can lead to 50-100 % improvement in recycling rates. Their target is to distribute 1 million standardised labels by the end of 2014, and they have already donated 250 000 to schools. "Make it easier and people will do the right thing," she concluded. For Jacques Perrin, film-maker and actor, life is about connection: “No living being in the world is truly alone.” Stressing the need to explore new concepts, he said that the future of Europe lies in diversity, both cultural and natural. We need “solidarité écologique” and a “Declaration of Interdependence”! Circular path forwards European Commissioner for the Environment Janez Potočnik started by quoting the Polar explorer Robert Swan: “The greatest threat to our planet is the belief that someone else will save it.” “The vast majority of individuals and businesses make choices based on what seems to be best for them,” said the Commissioner. So we need national and international policies and agreements which restrict individuals’ and companies’ behaviour. Without them, the environment will suffer. But the paths to economic well-being and environmental sustainability are the same: “Today we need a new revolution”. “I believe that in the face of resource scarcities and rising prices we will be able to perform miracles in raising resource productivity,” he said. “To get there we will not only need technological development and innovation; we will also need new business models that decrease impact across the whole life cycle of products.” For PotoČnik, old and New Environmentalism need to go hand in hand in the same way that the economy and the environment do. “Together we need to make our governments – and yes, the EU also – realise that it’s not just the economy, stupid,” he said. Summing up, Murray concluded that protecting the planet is linked to protecting the quality of life: clean technology is better, renewables have lower operating costs, green businesses are safer, low-carbon investment delivers jobs – but perhaps most of all, this stuff is cool! More information »» http://ec.europa.eu/environment/greenweek/ MAGAZINE OF THE DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR THE ENVIRONMENT | SUPPLEMENT »» RESOURCE EFFICIENCY Setting the scene Moving to a circular economy requires systemic change, affecting all stakeholders in the valuechain, and substantial innovations in technology, organisation, and society as a whole. Green Week opened with an introductory session that set the framework for the discussions to come. “We can live well, and within the limits of our planet, but we cannot do it by continuing as we are,” said Karl Falkenberg, Director-General for Environment at the European Commission, in the opening session of Green Week. In some ways, the efficiency of our current economic system is our worst enemy, said Janez Potočnik, the European Commissioner for Environment. “The linear system is actually working very well. It is just that the world is changing to make it no longer fit-for-purpose.” Resource-poor, crowded and ageing, “Europe's comparative advantage in the coming decades will be defined by the relative availability of resources – and our ability to maximise their productivity,” he said. We need to move away from our throwaway culture and switch to a more circular model. That means innovative products designed to last, to be repaired and to be recycled, and innovative business models to match. Recycling our riches Karl Falkenberg agreed: “Waste is too valuable to be wasted.” Recycling and 'urban mining' can now produce 350g of gold from one tonne of electronic waste – many times more efficient than traditional mining. Andreas Papastavrou, Deputy Permanent Representative of Greece to the EU, added that if just 3 % of existing gold supplies were recycled in this way, from mobile phones, for example, it could satisfy 100 % of new demand. He also emphasised that the EU needs to strengthen the environmental element of the Europe 2020 Strategy to meet the coming challenges, with approaches optimised to suit conditions in the Member States. “In the near future, we will be left with fewer resources for more people,” said Cyndi Rhoades, Founder and Executive Officer of Worn Again, a company she described as part of “a closed-loop revolution in the fashion industry”. “We are high-consumption countries, so we have the recyclable resources here in Europe”, she added. Her company has focused on 'upcycling', using innovative design to turn old textiles into products of higher value, and are now investigating technologies to recover mixed fibres. She emphasised that businesses need to change the way they measure and report on performance, explaining that PUMA had pioneered the 'environmental profit and loss' concept, and considered that a single model of financial, social and environmental reporting was needed for the whole industry. On 2 July, the Commission adopted new policies on the circular economy, which set out relevant instruments, a lifecycle approach, and new long-term recycling targets for Europe. Measuring the circular economy With so many stakeholders and policy areas involved, Europe needs a resource-efficiency target to give “clarity in the direction of travel”, said the Commissioner. The Commission has chosen Raw Material Consumption relative to GDP as the best candidate for such an indicator. “The circular economy is exciting, it is where it's happening,” he concluded, and it will be “the great innovation challenge of the next decades.” More information »» http://ec.europa.eu/environment/greenweek/ »» http://webcast.ec.europa.eu/eutv/portal/archive. html?viewConference=23014&catId=22743 »» http://ec.europa.eu/environment/circular-economy/ 5 6 »» ECONOMICS, STRATEGY AND INFORMATION Green jobs for inclusive growth A circular economy in Europe will need a skilled workforce, trained and equipped for greener jobs. The Green Week session on 'Green jobs and skills' focused on how private firms and public bodies are gearing up for the expected transformation. Speakers agreed on the need for a coherent legislative framework at EU level, covering all relevant policy areas, so that businesses have the confidence and certainty that investing in new jobs requires. Dr Cristina Martinez, from the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), emphasised that green jobs must create not only a sustainable economy but also a fairer and more inclusive society, with greater coherence between environmental and employment targets. “Traditionally, these two areas have been separate,” she said. “What we need is multi-sectoral engagement.” “ Green policy does not automatically generate jobs, or destroy them. It's a question of how we do it. ” She presented two recent OECD reports on Greener Skills and Jobs and Making Inclusive Growth Happen. According to the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), employment in green sectors such as wind and solar energy and water purification is growing strongly. Restructuring and retraining is needed in a wide range of traditional industries including mining, cement, oil and chemicals, because innovations in those fields are generating the need for a workforce with very different skills from the traditional ones. But new positions, for example in green business management, tend to be held by men. “We need to focus on areas where gender is playing a role,” she argued. Some sectors, like recycling and waste management, have in the past employed mainly low-skilled workers, who will need to be offered the option of retraining where possible. Another example is the mining industry, which is not only gender- but also age-specific. “Many miners are 50-plus, and if there is restructuring they are stuck with old skills. The greening of the economy must be an opportunity for inclusive growth,” she said. Return on investment José Lopes, Head of Technical Excellence at Jaguar Land Rover Ltd, described how the company is reskilling its engineering workforce, making processes more efficient and using materials in a more sustainable way. “It's important to show that we develop all our products not only according to what our customers require, but also what's needed for a sustainable business.” Jaguar has been running its Technical Accreditation Scheme for five years in collaboration with eight UK universities. “As we progress towards the greening of the economy, we have to embrace new, emerging technologies,” he explained. Jaguar has developed a 50-module programme for up-skilling its engineering workforce. A comprehensive evaluation of the programme showed a return on investment of more than 200 %. A persistent problem is that only 7 % of engineers in the UK are female, and efforts to recruit more women have had no significant impact. This is “very worrying”, he said. Industrial collaboration across national frontiers is important. “The technological challenges facing the automotive industry have probably never been greater. Industry, universities and governments must work together collaboratively in advancing new research areas,” said Mr Lopes. Building skills Austria has the highest proportion of green products and services in the EU. Johannes Fechner coordinates vocational education and training for the national climate initiative klimaaktiv. He noted that the country's green sector is developing well, with an increase in turnover from €31 billion in 2008 to €35 billion in 2012 (12 % of GDP). The approach to the low-carbon economy in Austria has three pillars: legislative, economic and education and training. A dual vocational education system enables young people to learn while they work as apprentices. He described the 'Build Up Skills' scheme for training blue-collar workers in the building sector. The EU Buildings Directive sets ambitious energy-saving targets which demand high-quality construction, and therefore additional skills. With state support, klimaaktiv has developed a freely available building standard which provides a guiding principle for environmental and energy-efficient design, with training and assessment tools. MAGAZINE OF THE DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR THE ENVIRONMENT | SUPPLEMENT The three key words are “governance, networking and integration,” said Mr Fechner. Creating green jobs requires cost transparency – and this should include incorporating the price of limited resources – as well as integration and coordination between national and European strategies, and where the development of new technical skills is concerned. The challenges On behalf of the European Commission's Directorate-General for Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion, Detlef Eckert, Director of Europe 2020 and employment policies, highlighted two challenges facing the EU. The first is how to create the right conditions for more new jobs in the wake of the economic crisis. Second is the fear that strict environmental obligations could jeopardise jobs and competitiveness. “Green policy does not automatically generate jobs, or destroy them,” he argued. “It's a question of how we do it.” Speculating on what the EU's role should be, he said the recent European election results underlined that Brussels could not provide all the answers. Nonetheless, the EU does have a role to play in fostering skills, promoting mobility – since skilled people do not always live where they are needed – and supporting industrial restructuring, in cooperation with the social partners, particularly to counter people's fear of unemployment. As regards education and training, Mr Eckert said public policy should be about “developing a skills-enabling infrastructure, at the disposal of the private sector” – especially SMEs. The Commission is already cooperating with international organisations such as the OECD, and organising sectoral initiatives on strategies to move faster towards the prosperity that EU citizens expect. The Italian EU Presidency, along with Member State environment and employment ministers, is developing proposals that will be put to the new Commission. Coherence between EU financial and R&D policies is crucial to ensure that the EU is advancing technically and technologically. Although no additional funding will be available for reskilling within the existing EU budget, “We need to make the existing funds more efficient in this area. Member States should learn from one another and set reforms in motion. The challenges will be enormous,” said Mr Eckert. More information »» http://webcast.ec.europa.eu/eutv/portal/archive. html?viewConference=23014&catId=22767 »» http://www.oecd.org/knowledge-sharing-alliance »» http://www.klimaaktiv.at/english.html »» http://www.jaguarlandrover.com/gl/en/innovation/ research-and-development 7 8 »» ECONOMICS, STRATEGY AND INFORMATION Getting the framework right What obstacles prevent the EU from becoming a circular economy? How can we use targets, taxes, industrial policy and other instruments to address them? These were the issues discussed at the Green Week session on ‘Creating the framework conditions for a circular economy’. s ervices. If the world consumed at the EU rate of consumption, two planets would already be needed. Bas de Leeuw, Managing Director of the World Resources Forum, opened the session by asking contributors to focus on the policies that were needed to support the circular economy. Much over-consumption is linked to waste and inefficiency: “The world wastes 1 billion tonnes of food every year”, he said, “even as 1 billion people are starving.” “For 100 years, the prices of commodities and energy steadily declined,” said Jocelyn Blériot, Head of Editorial and European Affairs at the Ellen MacArthur Foundation, “but in 2002 this trend hit a turning point.” He explained that a century of decline in the price of raw materials has been erased in just 10 years. “ 80 % of environmental policies in Europe are set by the EU, and 95 % of Europeans believe protecting the environment is important ” Basing their approach on lessons learned from long-distance sailing – travelling light, managing resources and reducing waste as much as possible – the Foundation has developed a four-point approach to moving our current linear economy towards a circular model. It involves design for reuse, enabling business models that favour access over ownership, reverse logistics for the return and reclaiming of products, and greater collaboration across sectors and industries. Incentivising these changes, he said, would need a shift in the tax burden from labour to resources, a change in producer responsibility, and a greater focus on eco-design. Preserving natural capital, he explained, requires a transformation in the political and economic system, addressing governance and finance in particular. The key is to cut resource consumption in absolute terms, not just make savings. We need consumption to decrease even as GDP grows. Looking to solutions, Godinot called for ambitious targets for energy and climate, including mandatory targets for energy efficiency; an EU framework for resource efficiency with targets for carbon, water and land footprints; indicators such as Natural Capital Accounting, which can be integrated into policy processes; green public procurement; and a supportive industrial policy. He reminded the audience that the WWF is calling for 10 % of EU tax revenue to come from green taxes by 2020, a four-percentage-point increase from the current average in OECD countries. The EU also needs to provide international leadership, moving from the post-2015 Millennium Development Goals towards Sustainable Development Goals and providing financial support for climate and biodiversity actions in poor countries. He suggested phasing out harmful subsidies such as those for fossil fuels, and using these efforts to help tackle problems like youth unemployment. From his analysis of the EU budget, he concluded that conservation, resource and energy efficiency and renewable-energy spending are the most effective in terms of job creation. Godinot concluded by emphasising the importance of EU policy frameworks. “80 % of environmental policies in Europe are set by the EU”, he said, “and 95 % of Europeans believe protecting the environment is important.” Industrial policy Absolute decoupling Jean-Paul Albertini, Executive Commissioner for Sustainable Development at the Ministry of Ecology, Sustainable Development and Energy, France, reviewed the policies that governments could use. They should include bringing stakeholders together, investing in R&D, and formulating sectoral, value-chain and territorial approaches. Sebastien Godinot, Economist at the WWF European Policy Office, explained how the WWF uses the Living Planet Index and the Global Ecological Footprint as indicators. “Currently, we globally need 1.5 planets per year,” he said, due to the overuse of natural resources and stress on ecological A sectoral approach should encourage cooperation, support voluntary agreements and extend producer responsibility, he explained. He also suggested involving local and regional governments in a new industrial policy, as is now the case in France, where each region develops strategies for the MAGAZINE OF THE DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR THE ENVIRONMENT | SUPPLEMENT circular economy and industrial ecology. Turning to R&D, he called for more eco-design for products, processes and services, a greater understanding of consumer behaviour, and a systemic approach to the innovation chain. Speaking of the French government’s current initiatives, he referred to the recent launch of a national strategy for green jobs and policies to address consumer law, longerlived products and product lifetime labelling. France is also planning to halve the 2010 national waste levels by 2020, with more support for local policies on waste sorting, and an effort to include social costs in landfill prices. He added that the French government is working on ecological taxes and better performance indicators. Moving to the EU level, Albertini emphasised the need for full implementation of the 7th Environmental Action Programme, as well as the greening of the European Semester of economic governance under the Europe 2020 strategy, with the inclusion of the “material productivity” indicator in the process. William Neale, Member of Commissioner Potočnik’s Cabinet, noted how the circular economy is essential for attracting industry to Europe and keeping it there. Previewing the policy package launched on 2 July, he noted the important role played by European waste legislation in the past as a driver for change. The coming proposals, he said, preserved the existing waste hierarchy, and aimed to raise average recycling rates in Europe to the levels that are current in the Member States where rates are now highest. The circular economy would not be driven by technology alone, he said, but also by changes in demand, which makes policy more important in setting up the enabling factors. These include the Single Market, looking at product life cycles and footprints, eco-labels, eco-design, market-based incentives, pull-and-push policies for innovation, and longerterm financing. As for shifting taxes, the EU can set targets, he said, but it is up to the Member States to choose their actions. Landfill charges, he remarked, were one such effective policy. More information »» http://ec.europa.eu/environment/greenweek 9 10 »» URBAN, NOISE AND HEALTH Green urbanism High population density means that cities can be more resource-efficient than smaller agglomerations, with lower pollution and emissions per inhabitant, acting as hubs for innovation. Cities can be incubators for new business models and lifestyles, said Francoise Bonnet, Secretary General of ACR+, an association of cities and regions for recycling and sustainable resource management, at the Green Week session on ‘Gearing up cities for the circular economy’. “Cities can do a lot within a small geographical territory,” she said. Speaking about recycling, she noted the need to prioritise symbiosis and the shortest loop, from neighbourhoods – via city, region, country and the EU – right up to the global scale. Urban agriculture, for example, can supplement food production, and food waste can be used for home composting. This can work in synergy with rural efforts, working towards local, sustainable and seasonal agriculture, and global efforts, where we need sustainable and fair trade, she said. Professor Maarten Hajer, Member of the UNEP International Resource Panel and Director of the PBL Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency, linked the urban and global environment, referencing the PBL’s new ‘Smart about cities’ report. “We need ‘smart urbanism’, not just ‘smart cities’,” he said. “We have to ask, “What kinds of technology do we want?” In informal settlements in the global South, for example, we see uses of off-grid technologies that allow people to organise themselves.” He spoke of the need for new ideas to help the South to leapfrog the mistakes of the developed world. Some 800 million people are expected to move to African cities in the coming decades, he added, so globally-networked urbanism would be required. Innovative champions Hajer spoke of the advantages of horizontal learning between cities, including pooling data, collaboration, innovative approaches and public engagement. Temporary pedestrian zones set up in New York, for instance, had avoided the legal barriers that blocked permanent ones, and their popularity had generated the political will to make them permanent. Merete Kristoffersen, Head of Sustainability Unit for the City of Copenhagen, agreed. As European Green Capital 2014, the city wants to be carbon neutral by 2025. “Our 2015 goal of decreasing CO2 emissions by 20 % relative to 2005 has already been achieved,” she said, helping the city to develop around a new set of values. Public procurement has great potential to be a pull factor for the circular economy, said Mark Hidson, Director of the Global Sustainable Procurement Centre, ICLEI. He recommended greater use of life-cycle analysis in spending decisions by city administrations, and taking environmental benefits into account. Greener approaches could also be incentivised through contract management, results monitored via e-procurement, and training offered at open days and workshops. He used the example of Amersfoort and Utrecht, which have committed to using 10 % of their procurement budget on circular-economy projects. A Dutch ministry used their procurement process so successfully that they now sell waste paper for pulping, instead of paying a company to remove it. “We need brave politicians willing to take the long view,” he concluded. “We need champions.” More information »» http://ec.europa.eu/environment/greenweek/ »» http://www.pbl.nl/en/ MAGAZINE OF THE DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR THE ENVIRONMENT | SUPPLEMENT »» INTERNATIONAL ISSUES Sharing best practice The transition to a circular economy requires private and public sectors to work together, as well as international, national and local-level initiatives and policies. The Green Week session on ‘Circular economy: scaling up best practices worldwide’ was on the lookout for successes, examples and lessons from around the world. Taking a holistic view “Consumers of new technologies are also ready for new business models,” explained Hermine, noting how electric vehicle customers are interested in buying 'kilometres of mobility' and leasing rather than buying batteries. “We also need tax-deductible incentives, such as VAT reductions for reused products,” he added. Friends of Europe Trustee Monica Frassoni kicked off the discussion, asking: “How can best practice become mainstream, in order to change the world?” “Technology alone is not delivering”, said Michael Kuhndt, Director of the Collaborating Centre on Sustainable Consumption and Production (CSCP), “we need to address consumption itself.” He recommended exploring lending and leasing models, although he warned that consumers can never be sustainable when surrounded by unsustainable infrastructure. Social inclusiveness is vital, said Valdemar de Oliveira, Impact Business Director for Fundación Avina, making the case for price-points and uses that are accessible to the poor, as “new technology only reaches the poor decades after it has become obsolete”. “Technological progress is step by step,” said Zhou Hongchun, Director of the Department of Social Development Research at the Development Research Centre of the State Council of China, who also emphasised the needs of poorer consumers. Jean-Philippe Hermine, Vice President for Strategic Environmental Planning for Renault-Nissan Alliance, said that the company is developing a closed loop for plastics, copper and catalytic convertors. “Around 70 % of our R&D budget is dedicated to reducing consumption and emissions”, he said, because “20 % of a car's price is now the cost of the raw materials.” “Today, there is a mismatch between demand and supply systems,” said Jane Feehan, Natural Resources Specialist at the European Investment Bank (EIB). “Resource-use is out of step with what the planet can sustain.” Investors have a role in making the circular economy a reality, and the EIB has put social and environmental safeguards in place – such as excluding tropical logging to protect biodiversity. The bank also has a target to make 25 % of its loans to climate actions. “The circular economy is not just about waste,” said Kuhndt. “Products are manufactured by many companies with different philosophies in the value chain. We need a holistic understanding.” De Oliveira agreed: “We need to design new business models based on understanding the value chain.” “The EIB has an increasingly transparent process for investment decisions,” said Feehan. Investors need to make information on sustainability criteria available to the public. Kuhndt noted how 50 % of products stay in our homes for only one year. “We can't wait for consumers to change. In a world where marketing often glamourises unsustainable behaviour, supply-side solutions are key, with 'smart, sustainable business models',” he said. More information »» http://ec.europa.eu/environment/greenweek/ 11 12 »» ECONOMICS, STRATEGY AND INFORMATION New greener business models What can business do to speed up the transition towards a more sustainable society? And how can it be made profitable for them? Experts discussed recent innovations and experiments, as well as the challenges still to come, during the Green Week session on ‘New business models for sustainable lifestyles’. “Ecosystems set an absolute limit on our resource use and offer a compelling argument for a circular economy,” said Hans Bruyninckx, Executive Director of the European Environment Agency, setting the scene. “To live well, within the limits of the planet,” he said, “we need the circular economy, where nothing is wasted.” He talked about the possibility of selling services rather than products, using the example: “I don’t need a drill – I need a hole in my wall.” He also suggested modifying the waste hierarchy to reflect the desirability of reduced consumption: before we think about “reduce, re-use, repair and recycle”, we should start by thinking, “refuse”. “ ” I don’t need a drill – I need a hole in my wall. New business models promoting this approach are already emerging, he said, noting trends such as “collaborative consumption” that change the relationship between producer and consumer, and the growing importance of “urban mining” – extracting materials from old cars, electronics and other devices no longer in use. Johnson Yeh of the Environment Initiative at the World Economic Forum (WEF) detailed the advantages of a more circular economy. The WEF has estimated that materials worth $1 trillion could be saved per year by 2025, generating $500 million in benefits within 5 years – and creating 100 000 new jobs. But while technology has helped to increase labour productivity, significant improvements in resource productivity have yet to materialise. “The circular economy has not become mainstream,” he said, blaming a lack of connections between industries and along supply chains. “We need a multi-stakeholder approach.” This would bring the next industrial revolution, he concluded. Retailers and consumers Bart Goetzee of the Philips International Senior Group on Sustainability explained that his company was already committed to the circular economy. Philips is now using more recycled materials, and operating 'trade-in schemes' to collect used products and harvest re-usable components from them. Philips is also looking at service and repair models, which favour renovation over replacement. Design for modularity and repair is a challenge for engineers and designers, as is the need for innovation in packaging to cope with product returns and supplying spare parts. The company is also exploring models that emphasise access rather than ownership, and sees some opportunities in the business-to-business sector. Social housing corporations, said Goetzee, could include a menu of shared appliances for residents in the rental agreement, making the latest models more accessible and easing collection and returns. Increasing the durability and lifetime of products has clear advantages for consumers, according to Carina Törnblom, Head of Unit for Consumer Strategy, Representation and International Relations at the European Commission’s Directorate General for Health and Consumers (DG SANCO). She stressed the need for rental business models that represented a good deal for consumers. “Consumers are often less informed and assertive than we assume,” she said. When it comes to environmental labelling, “only 22 % can correctly identify the meaning of logos on products”. She cautioned against legislative gaps that opened up as the distinction between producers and consumers became more blurred in some new business models. The energy sector, for example, is likely to see an increase in micro-generation, collective switching and energy cooperatives, but consumer protection legislation has yet to catch up. There is also a grey area, she said, when people are selling energy back to the grid: “When do you become a business?” she asked. Collaborative consumption is another interesting model, she continued, but it requires careful monitoring and analysis. The circular economy must avoid “rebound effects”, where consumer savings lead to an increase in spending on other goods with a significant environmental impact. MAGAZINE OF THE DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR THE ENVIRONMENT | SUPPLEMENT Challenges ahead The biggest challenge for Philips, said Goetzee, has been convincing retailers of the value in new business models, as many of them resist the extra work involved in offering product collection schemes. For Yeh, the challenge was how to ensure that consumers appreciate real improvements, and how to get companies to collaborate on changing their supply chains. Bruyninckx felt that public funds and EU pressure should be used to get circular economy thinking into the mainstream – by removing environmentally harmful subsidies, for example. He reminded the audience that 35-50 % of GDP flows through the state in European countries, and this is a powerful lever. Yeh agreed that shifting subsidies and using public procurement, as well as standard-setting, was the way to go. Industry also needs cross-governmental, public-private dialogues, he said. As a large company, Philips has the power to push circular economy models through their own procurement, said Goetzee. He also noted new insurance and ownership issues raised by the leasing economy, and suggested that people consider “sell and buy-back” approaches, or contracts that specify “repair first, then replace” with a second-hand product, and only replace with a new model after the full term of the lease. “We need to green the whole economy,” Bruyninckx concluded, to avoid money being pushed into negative activities. “We need to focus on greening the fundamental system of production and consumption.” He finished with an ambitious plea: “We have to move away from incremental changes, and towards systemic change,” he said. “We can make the car engine more efficient, but if we don’t change our system of mobility, specifically re-thinking private car use, we’re not going to reach the decarbonisation of our transport system.” More information »» http://ec.europa.eu/environment/greenweek/ 13 14 »» ECONOMICS, STRATEGY AND INFORMATION A nudge in the right direction Influencing the way people behave, so as to lessen their impact on the environment, is a complicated business. Money matters, but is not the only incentive. In the Green Week session on 'Changing behaviour; people's green choices', Ysé Serret from the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development in Paris presented the OECD's latest survey of 12 000 homes, in 11 countries, on Greening Household Behaviour. It confirmed that environmental attitudes play an important but subtle role alongside financial incentives and how easy it is to change. “ Stimulating desirable behavioural changes ultimately requires a mix of policy instruments. ” When it comes to buying a car for example, safety, price and reliability are the main considerations. A significant number of people would be willing buy an electric vehicle, even if it was more expensive, but this willingness varies across Europe – from 38 % of respondents in the Netherlands to just 13 % in France. Lack of recharging infrastructure was the main disincentive. “So it is important for governments to work on the supply side,” said Ms Serret. "Stimulating desirable behavioural changes ultimately requires a mix of policy instruments." The appeal of rational choices ‘Nudge theory’ is about changing behaviour through incentives rather than closing down options. While economists assume that informed individuals will make rational choices, “the real world is more complex,” said Stephen White from DG Environment. People are influenced as much by habits and routines, time and convenience, “so very small adjustments in information or legislation can make a difference,” he said. Psychologists study 'nudge tactics', and the UK government even has a dedicated 'nudge unit'. Experts are looking for innovative ways to influence both households and businesses. “Where do we go from here?” Stephen White challenged his audience. Is nudging easier at EU or local level? And how can it be linked to price incentives? Pricing strategies Dominic Hogg, from Eunomia Research & Consulting, focused on the range of economic instruments available to environment policy-makers, including taxes, procurement, non-compliance fees, deposit refunds, subsidies and charges. Major corporations have been showing a growing interest in the circular economy since commodity prices started to rise around 2000. Yet costs were even higher 100 years ago, and could fall again. “Future strategy should not be based on the assumption that commodity prices will continue to rise,” warned Dr Hogg. Despite the fact that environmental taxes are less damaging to economies than levies on labour and income, they make up just 6 % of all taxes across the EU, equivalent to only 2.8 % of GDP. Few countries impose levies on primary materials, yet such measures in the UK have successfully cut the use of primary aggregates used in construction, for example. Britain now uses the highest proportion of recycled aggregates (29 %) in the EU. In other words, “prices matter”, Hogg concluded, raising the question of whether pricing strategies should be more ambitious and better coordinated across the EU. More information »» http://ec.europa.eu/environment/greenweek/ »» http://www.oecd.org/env/consumption-innovation/ greening-household-behaviour-2013.htm »» http://webcast.ec.europa.eu/eutv/portal/archive. html?viewConference=23014&catId=22767 MAGAZINE OF THE DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR THE ENVIRONMENT | SUPPLEMENT 15 Green Week 2014 Exhibition The Green Week conference was accompanied by an exhibition in Brussels and satellite events across Europe. Slow Food Slow Food is a global grass-roots organisation which envisions a world in which all people can access and enjoy food that is good for them, good for those who grow it and good for the planet. The stand promoted ‘agriculture with values’: more holistic, with fewer inputs and using traditional know-how. Slow Food gathers millions of people in over 160 countries, and organises events such as the Salone del Gusto, dedicated to artisan and small-scale food and wine producers, and Terra Madre, the global meeting of food communities – scheduled in Turin, Italy, from 23-27 October 2014. »» http://www.slowfood.com Healthy Seas The ‘Healthy Seas, a Journey from Waste to Wear’ initiative – a collaboration between the European Expertise Centre for Biodiversity and Sustainability, the Aquafil Group and Star Sock – aims to remove waste, in particular fishing nets, from the seas. In an example of the circular economy in action, the recovered fishing nets are transformed into recycled nylon yarn, a high-quality raw material used to create new products – such as the unique socks that were available as prizes from the stand. »» http://healthyseas.org/ Green Growth the Nordic Way This stand represented the Nordic Council of Ministers – the official governmental cooperation among the five Nordic countries (Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway, Sweden) along with Greenland, and the Faroe and Aaland Islands. Among other things, Nordic cooperation focuses on sustainable development, including green growth and the bioeconomy, from a regional perspective. At the stand, the Nordic Council was promoting an initiative on recycling and sustainable textiles, involving collaboration with major companies such as H&M and Ikea. »» http://www.norden.org RREUSE Reuse and Recycling EU Social Enterprises (RREUSE) is a European umbrella organisation representing national and regional networks of social enterprises active in reuse, repair and recycling. The stand focused on repair and reuse, using design to ‘upscale’ products, and the potential of these labour-intensive activities for job creation – they can create five times more jobs than simply recycling. The organisation also works on re-entry to the employment market: 42 000 full-time equivalent employees and over 43 000 volunteers and trainees work throughout its 25 member organisations across 15 EU Member States. »» http://www.rreuse.org KH-AD-14-S01-EN-C Seas at Risk and the Surfrider Foundation Europe Seas at Risk is a European association of non-governmental environmental organisations working to protect and restore the marine environment of European seas and the North East Atlantic. They have called for a strengthened reduction target for marine litter in Europe, and welcome the Commission proposal for an 80 % reduction in lightweight bags and the European Parliament’s support for it. The stand was shared with one of the association’s member organisations, Surfrider Foundation Europe – a non-profit organisation dedicated to defending, saving, improving and sustainably managing the ocean, coastline, waves and the people who enjoy them. »» http://www.seas-at-risk.org »» http://www.surfrider.eu Umicore Umicore is a global materials technology and recycling group focusing on application areas such as materials science, chemistry and metallurgy. In particular, it is active in ‘urban mining’ and recycling metals from technological waste. Egbert Lox, Umicore’s Senior Vice-President for Government Affairs, said: “Today’s vehicles have catalysts, electronic components and Li-ion batteries that contain valuable metals that merit being recycled. Recycling of emission-control catalysts is a running business – a substantial amount of the platinum-group metals needed for new catalysts is already supplied today through these recycling activities.” »» http://www.umicore.com
© Copyright 2024