Smilegov lessons learned.pptx

The ESIN cluster in
the SMILEGOV project
Smilegov project: Lessons learned 1 15 small islands
Smilegov project: Lessons learned 2 40 great people
Smilegov project: Lessons learned 3 Fifteen energy-focused small island reviews)
!
!
!!
!
!"!#$%&!'()"%"$!!"#!"#!
!
!
!
IJ"DFJKF"J!
!
!
!
!!
!
!"!#$%&!"#$%!!"#!"#$%&'()#*"+$!
!
Energibed!mning av Ven
"##$%&''
"! #$%&'$($)!
*!
*! +&,-.(/$($)!0/!1&$!
2!
2! 3$&.)(4&.5-$($)0.!
6!
(
)(
"#'$*#+#,(
LMN!O62!9:P:2!3!:7!935:7!4Q696?!!)!:55!OF
46M1R99:!4SM!/:7!1R7T:2!6996!U2NTS2!
S<1!4P62!3753M5!31S>V!1R2!WS2!MO;93TF
1:5:276! S<1! >2SW9:M:7! PRTT! 3! PRTT?!
(:7SM! 437! 935:71:5! S<1! 6PT2R74737T!
R2!/:7!:55!W:T23>93T5V!U655W625!4X45:M!
Y! 46M53Z3T5! 4SM! Z:7! SU56! 46Q762!
:T:7M6Q5!S<1!2:4[24:2?!
!
!
!
!!
!
!"!#$%&!"#$%!!"#$%&%#'()*"+!
!
!
!
KL"FHLMHKL!
!
!
!
!
!!
!
!"!#$%&'("!#%"$)&*)%!"#!
!
!
GH"CD"HDGG!
!
!
012345367!89:3;:9!
<12345367=>9:3;:9?6@!
A:9!BCDEFGDHFCGI!EE!ID!
%&%'()*%+,-&)&(!./!/%&!
!
!
!
/:7WS276! 4Q6>62! :QS9ST34Q6! US56PF
52X<Q!>N!437!O!S<1!4Q6>62!:QS9ST34Q6!
4P699! 3! 437! 4;O! 4SM! N5:2P:2Q737T62! 6P!
Z:7!:7:2T3!Z:!539946MM674!UO2W2[Q62V!
Z:5!P655:7!Z:!67PR7Z:2!S<1!Z:5!6PU699!
Z:!>2SZ[<:262?!%7!935:7!O!R2!:7!4S<3SF
W3S5S>! 4SM! 9:P:2! [7Z:2! 452R7T6! P399F
QS2! P39Q:5! W:4OQ6276! 4SM! W626! 4:2!
!
!
!!
!
!"!#$%&'("!#%"$)&*)+!""#$%&!
!
"!#""$!
!
!
$J"EGJKG"I!
!
!
!
!
,!
,!
-./%&0*%!!
!
!
!
1!
"!
#$%&'$($)!
!
!
!
*!
1!
20*%/!
!
!
!
3!
*!
+,--&.($)!
!
!
!
/!
3!
456!*)7%)&6!0$(!+(6$%+%8!'9!:6&6!#/70$(!
!
";!
/!
01231!
!
!
<!
=>%+?+/?!
!
!
!
""!
4!
05.&6(%'&.!
!
!
@!
A6//+?+/?!
!
!
!
""!
8!
9(:2&.!;<=!=;3!
!
!
!
"/!
B!
A'//+.+7+%+6/!
!
!
!
",!
>!
?,%3,.@!('&$3(3&3!;<=!,AAB133$($)1.!
!
"4!
C!
-*%+'$!A70$!
!
!
!
"1!
!C!
D5E%()=&3&.!
F!
H!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!&'&()*!+,-./!0'!1&(&!.23+'-!
!
!
!
!
IJ"EG"JGDJ!
!
4567897:;!<=>7?>=!
!
@567897:;AB=>7?>=C:D!
/>=!E$FGHIFJH$IK!GG!KF!
!!
!"!#$%&!"#$%!!"#!"#$$%&'!
!
"#$%&'()*#$%'#&!(+!,-../#&*!
#$$%&!''
#$%&'()*%+'$!
!
!
0##$1+))
"!
$!
D!
4!
!
"7!
!
!
!
">!
G1$'%($):A%1$!
!
!
!
"C!
?I%%;.! !
!
!
!"!#$%&'()*+!!"#!"#$%&!
"F!
!
!
!
LM"GI"MI"H!
!
012345367!+893:98!
;12345367<=893:98>6?!
@98!ABC$DECFDBEG!$$!GC!
&'&()*+,-'&(*')!+.!*'*/!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!!
"7!! J(%1)1K!?&(:3(5!L(%%1)&!%()=3$($)!1$'!M($'!3,.6($&!
"!#"$%!
!
Energy audit on Oile!n Chl"ire
"!
#$%&'()*%+'$!
!
!
,!
-./%&0*%!!
!
!
1!
20*%/!
!
!
!
3!
3!
456!*)7%)&6!0$(!+(6$%+%8!'9!:+76;$!<57=+&6!
!
",!
>!
:?%+@+/@!
!
!
!
"1!
A!
B6//+@+/@!
!
!
!
"3!
"!
#$%&'()*%+'$!
C!
:??'&%)$+%+6/!
!
!
!
">!
,!
D!
-*%+'$!B70$!
!
!
!
"A!
!
!
,!
!
!
1!
Energy audit on the Aran Islands
!
!
!
-./%&0*%!!
!
!
!
1!
20*%/!
!
!
!
3!
!
3!
456!*)7%)&6!0$(!+(6$%+%8!'9!%56!-&0$!#/70$(!
!
":!
#
;!
<=%+>+/>!
!
!
!
",!
?!
@6//+>+/>!
!
!
!
",!
A!
@'//+.+7+%+6/!
!
!
!
"1!
B!
-*%+'$!@70$!
!
!
!
"3!
!
!
!
!
"!#"$%!
! !&'&()*!+,-./!0'!0.1&2'!3415.(&!
"!#"$%!
H!
E!
U!
!I!
!F!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
PR5<S6;L<5!
!
!
(67Q<5!T>4!4T8!
!
!
VW;8W5X!6L<:868<8!T>4!W@@O988:6:M95!
YR=;6M4<8<5!
Z9:L;6:M7@;9:!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!!
&'&()*+,-'&(*')!+.!/0112')-!
!
!"!#$%&!"#!$!!"#!"#$!
!
!
!
*:;<L:6:M!
!
/9NN9:O988:6:M! !
P9Q89! !
!
!
$!
D!
H!
"E!
"F!
"K!
$J!
$"!
!
,!
1!
!
!!
!
!
!"!#$%&'("!#%"$)&*)+!"#$%&'!
!
!
!
IJ"DF"JFCJ!
"!#$"%!
!
34567869:!+;<6=<;!
!
>4567869:?@;<6=<;A9B!
1<;!CDEFGHEIGDH$!FF!$E!
!
!
!
*!
*!
+,--&.($)!
!
!
!
/!
/!
01231!
!
!
!
4!
4!
05.&6(%'&.!
!
!
!
""!
7!
8(92&.!:;<!<:3!
!
"7!
=!
>,%3,.?!('&$3(3&3!:;<!,@@A133$($)1.!
!
"7!
B!
C5D%()<&3&.!
!
!
!
"=!
E!
F1$'%($)9@%1$!
!
!
!
!
"B!
!
!
!
!
!
L!isola Verde"
#
$%&'(&'
!
!
KL"$H"LHFL!
"!#"$%!
!
!
!
.:85LMN?86L:!
!
!
F!
T!
J!
34567869:!+;<6=<;!
!
>4567869:?@;<6=<;A9B!
!"!#$%&!"#!$!!"#!!!!!!!!!"!!
C<;!DEFGHIF$HEIJ!GG!JF!
&'&()*+,-'&(*')!+.!/*0/12,-!
!
"!
$!
E!
I!
!!
!
!!
#$$%&!''
#$%&'$($)!
4567897:;!<=>7?>=!
!
@567897:;AB=>7?>=C:D!
!
/>=!EF$GHI$JHFIK!GG!K$!
$K"FH"KH$$!
!
!
!
!
!
!"!#$%&'()*+!!"#$%&'$(!
Energiplanering p! Simsk"la
"!
"!#"$%!
! &'&()*!+,-./!0'!/1&!+(+'!.23+'-2!
36789:8;<!=>?8@?>!
!
A6789:8;<BC>?8@?>D;E!
!
/?>!FGHIJKHLJGKM!II!MH!
JK"FHKLHJL!
!
!
!
!
!
"!
!
!
KL"$H"LHKK!
!
!
!
Energiplanering p! Ini"
!
!
!
Energy audit on Bere Island
!!
!"!#$%&'()*+!!"#!"#$%&%'$()*%'+)!
!
!"#$%&'$()*+%,-#)."/%
!
!
!
!
!
MN"HJNOJMN!
!
!G!
!
!
!
$!
0A86S67S!
!
!
!
!
!
E!
F!
"I!
+?86L:!;<9:!
!
!
!
$"!
;=776S67S!
;L776O6<686=7!
!
#
&'&()*!+,-./!0'!.123.+!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!"!#$%&'"!!"#$%&'!
!
!
!
+O7859?8!
!
!
P9?87! !
!
!
/4=!6M=:868Q!9:M!?N<8N5=!LR!.7?469!
!
!
!
!
!!
"J!
"G!
"U!
!
!
HI"CEIJE"I!
"!#$"%!
!
24567869:!;<=6>=<!
!
?4567869:@A<=6>=<B9C!
/=<!DEFGHIFJHEI$!GG!$F!
!
!
!
!
!"#$%&'()*"$+,-"."/01#$
Energy audit on Ouessant
!"#$%&#%'()*+(#*,#-*./"&#
#$%&'()*%+'$!
!
!
!
,!
,!
-./%&0*%!!
!
!
!
1!
1!
20*%/!
!
!
!
3!
3!
456!*)7%)&6!0$(!+(6$%+%8!'9!:'7;$6!
!
",!
<!
=>%+?+/?!
!
!
!
"1!
@!
A6//+?+/?!
!
!
!
"3!
B!
=>>'&%)$+%+6/!
!
!
!
"<!
C!
-*%+'$!A70$!
!
!
!
"@!
D!
E')&*6/! !
!
!
!
"B!
"!
,!
1!
!&'&()*!+,-./!0'!0,&11+'/!
!
!
!
!
234567589!:;<5=<;!
>34567589?@;<5=<;A8B!
/<;!CDEFGHE$GDHI!FF!IE!
#$%&'()*%+'$!
-./%&0*%!!
20*%/!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
Energy Check on Sein
"! #$%&'()*%+'$!
!
"!
,! -!.&+/0!(/1*&+2%+'$!
!
,!
1!
3! 4$/&56!*78*)87%+'$1! !
9!
3!
9! :'$*8)1+'$!
9!
456!*)7%)&6!0$(!+(6$%+%8!'9!:'7;$6!
!
",!
<!
=>%+?+/?!
!
!
!
"3!
@!
A6//+?+/?!
!
!
!
"3!
B!
=>>'&%)$+%+6/!
!
!
!
"<!
C!
-*%+'$!A70$!
!
!
!
"@!
D!
E')&*6/! !
!
!
!
!&'&()*!+,-./!0'!1023'&!
!
"!#"$%!
!
!
!
!
,!
3!
!
!
!
Energy audit on Molene
"!
!
The Árrain Mhór lighthouse is located at Rinn Ramharois Point at the north west corner of the island
!
"!
!
!"
"@!
4567897:;!<=>7?>=!
@567897:;AB=>7?>=C:D!
/>=!EFGHIJGKIFJL!HH!LG!
!
"!#"$%!
#$%&'()*%+'$"
07! IJ"DK! /:37! ;L37:M! 51:! /N0O&).P"!
>2L;:<5! 512LQR1! 354! S:ST:2413>! 37!
!"#$$%&'()'%*+ ,-$! .!-$+ /0+ 1%*(*)+ #U08%+
67M! 4QT4:VQ:759W! 37! 51:! 203%4-(*+
56(!!+ 7$!(*/$+ 8-/-3()'%*! #&/0'%?! A1:!
LT;:<53X:4!LY!/N0O&).PK!YQ7M:M!TW!51:!
&Q2L>:67! +LSS3443L7K! 34! 5L! :456T9341!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"!155>Z[[\\\?4Q456376T9:34967M4?:Q[!
!
6! <9:62! >3<5Q2:! LY! 51:! 34967M]4! :7:2RW!
<L74QS>53L7K!354!:S3443L74!67M!1L\!35!
34!35!4Q>>93:M!\351!:7:2RWK!SLX37R!375L!
67! 6<53L7! >967! YL2! 6! SL2:! 4Q456376T9:!
YQ5Q2:K! 67M! 5L! 37X35:! 51:! 34967M! 5L! ;L37!
51:!86<5!LY!04967M4I?!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I!155>Z[[\\\?349:>6<5?:Q[15S9[37M:@?64>@!
&'&()*!+,&+-!.'!/&0'!
!
!
!
Energy check on Árrain Mhór
+12345367!89:3;:9!
<12345367=>9:3;:9?6@!
A:9!BCDEFGDHFCGI!EE!ID!
K!
F!
I!
$!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
1:85MNO?86M:!
!
D4=!67<9:N=57!
!
)MP=5:9:?=!
!
D4=!67<9:N!97!9!A<98QM5R!
D46:S6:T!MO8!MQ!84=!UMC!
!
!&'&()*!+,&+-!.'!/((01'!2,3(!
!
!
!
"! #$%&'$($)!
*!
*! +,-.!/&01-(2$($)!32!4(0($)05!
F!
J!
G!
"K!
!
"!#$%!
"##$%!&&
K!
!
!
!
!
Energisyn p! Nagu
6!
6! 7$&-)(/&-81$($)3-!
9!
:! ;5<%()=&.&-!
""!
!
'(
+4567869:!;<=6>=<!
?4567869:@A<=6>=<B9C!
D=<!EF$GHI$JHFIK!GG!K$!
"!#"$%!
"#&$)#*#+!
*KL!M62!89N92!3!97!83597!4O686>!!)!955!ME
46K1P889!4QK!&6RS!1P7R92!6886!T2LRQ2!
Q;1! 4N62! 3753K5! 31Q=U! 1P2! VQ2! KM:83RE
1959276! Q;1! =2QV89K97! NPRR! 3! NPRR>!
(97QK!437!83597195!Q;1!6NR2P74737R!P2!
97! M! 955! V9R23=83R5U! T655V625! 4W459K! X!
46K53Y3R5! 4QK! Y97! QT56! 46O762! 9R97E
!
K6O5!Q;1!294S2492>!Z9!4QK!VQ2!=L!M7!X!
1986!L295!98892!Y98!6N!L295!X!4O6=62!9OQE
8QR34O6! TQ56N52W;O! =L! M7! Q;1! 9OQE
8QR34O6! 4N688! 3! 4:M7! 4QK! P2! L592N92OE
737R62! 6N! Y97! 9792R3! Y9! 538846KK674!
TM2V2SO62U!Y95!N65597!Y9!67NP7Y92!Q;1!
Y95!6NT688!Y9!=2QYS;9262>!!
%&%'()*+&!,-!&.(/!
!
!
!
012345367!,893:98!
;12345367<=893:98>6?!
@98!ABCDEFCGEBFH!DD!HC!
"!#""$!
!
!
!"#$%&'()*+',%-./)0%11'21)$%3+2%4)
8)
The Pact of Islands
15 small islands who want to be active contributors to
the European 2020 targets, new signatories to the Pact
of Islands, and maybe a few more to come…
Smilegov project: Lessons learned 5 Lessons learned
Smilegov project: Lessons learned 6 Population according to census (dark blue)
and the total human pressure (light blue)
1)
Ischia’s population is 63,730 / 82,798
Smilegov project: Lessons learned 7 Total energy use of kWh per capita and year (grey), whereof ferry energy consumpGon per capita and year (blue), popula&on counted on census data 1)
No data for Aran ferry and air transports
Smilegov project: Lessons learned 8 Total energy use in kWh per capita and year (green), whereof ferry energy consumpGon per capita and year (blue), popula&on counted as total human pressure 1)
No data for Aran ferry and air transports
Smilegov project: Lessons learned 9 Emissions, in-island and ex-island
Big variations but generally islands have a high ability to
absorbe CO2 especially when accounting for the sea.
Huge impact from sea traffic – in-island end ex-island.
Sottunga in the Åland Islands has 3,000 ship passing
through its waters per year, causing 400 times more
emissions per year as the island does itself.
Ven in the narrow Baltic strait has 75,000 ship
movements passing close by the island a year.
Emissions not calculated.
Smilegov project: Lessons learned 10 Governance, inside the box
A simplified model with the island as ”a box” defined by (1) the
people on it, (2) the political system we use to maintain and
develop the island, and (3) the island itself and its
infrastructure, for example energy
Smilegov project: Lessons learned 11 Governance, outside the box
Outside the box the world is changing: the way we interact
with politicians, the terms under which politicians act, and
what we demand in terms of services and infrastructure.
We cannot stay inside the old box if we want change.
Smilegov project: Lessons learned 12 What we want to do
For a full list, see http://europeansmallislands.com/smilegov/
Lowering energy
consumption
Renovation, isolation of houses:
Molène, Aran, Árrain Mhór,
Sein, Ouessant, Bere, Chléire,
Sottunga
Stocking of energy, planning for
peak hours: Molène, Chléire
Exchange of household appliances:
Sein, Ouessant, Molène
Mobility in general: Ischia
Electric vehicles: Aran, Visingsö
Electric ferry: Simskäla
Producing local renewable
energy
Hydroelectric turbines: Ouessant,
Small-scale wind energy: Chléire,
Iniö, Visingsö
Photovoltaic generation: All
Micro grids: Visingsö, Vinön,
Molène
Biogas: Nagu, Ven
Smilegov project: Lessons learned 13 Yes we can.
Smilegov project: Lessons learned 14