1. No category

1
arXiv:1501.04885v1 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci] 20 Jan 2015
Powder diffraction in Bragg-Brentano geometry with
straight linear detectors
Dominik Kriegner,a * Zdeněk Matěj,a,b Radomír Kužela and Václav Holýa
a Department
of Condensed Matter Physics, Charles University in Prague, Ke
Karlovu 5, 121 16 Praha 2, Czech Republic, Czech Republic, and b Max IV
Laboratory, Lund University, Ole Römers väg 1, 223 63 Lund, Sweden.
E-mail: [email protected]
powder diffraction; Bragg-Brentano; linear detector; line shape; resolution function
Abstract
A common way of speeding up powder diffraction measurements is the use of one or
two dimensional detectors. This usually goes along with worse resolution and asymmetric peak profiles. In this work the influence of a straight linear detector on the
resolution function in the Bragg-Brentano focusing geometry is discussed. Due to the
straight nature of most modern detectors geometrical defocusing occurs which heavily influences the line shape of diffraction lines at low angles. An easy approach to
limit the resolution degrading effects is presented. The presented algorithm selects an
adaptive range of channels of the linear detector at low angles, resulting in increased
resolution. At higher angles still the whole linear detector is used and the data collection remains fast. Using this algorithm a well-behaved resolution function is obtained
in the full angular range, whereas using the full linear detector the resolution function
varies within one pattern which hinders line shape and Rietveld analysis.
PREPRINT: Journal of Applied Crystallography
A Journal of the International Union of Crystallography
arXiv:1501.04880v1 [physics.ins-det] 20 Jan 2015
Status of the AlCap experiment
R. Phillip Litchfield∗†
UCL
E-mail: [email protected]
The AlCap experiment is a joint project between the COMET and Mu2e collaborations. Both
experiments intend to look for the lepton-flavour violating conversion µ + A → e + A, using tertiary muons from high-power pulsed proton beams. In these experiments the products of ordinary
muon capture in the muon stopping target are an important concern, both in terms of hit rates
in tracking detectors and radiation damage to equipment. The goal of the AlCap experiment is
to provide precision measurements of the products of nuclear capture on Aluminium, which is
the favoured target material for both COMET and Mu2e. The results will be used for optimising
the design of both conversion experiments, and as input to their simulations. Data was taken in
December 2013 and is currently being analysed.
16th International Workshop on Neutrino Factories and Future Neutrino Beam Facilities - NUFACT2014,
25 -30 August, 2014
University of Glasgow, United Kingdom
∗ Speaker.
† On
behalf of the AlCap Collaboration
© Copyright owned by the author(s) under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike Licence.
http://pos.sissa.it/
R. Phillip Litchfield
Status of the AlCap experiment
Figure 3: (Left) Timing of hits in detector arms with respect to the matched muon beam tag. A fit to an
exponential decay including background terms results in a measured lifetime of the µ − in silicon very close
to the published result, confirming that the majority of events selected come from decays of captured muons.
(Right) A plot of the energy in the thin silicon (δ E) as a function of the total energy deposited in both thick
and thin silicon (E + δ E), showing the proton / deuteron / triton region. This simple dE/dx measurement
nevertherless provids an excelent PID.
of the total particle energy in both thick and thin silicon (E + δ E). The clear separation between
bands demonstrates how these measurements can be used for particle identification, with the lowest
is identified as being due to protons. The clarity of the bands also suggests this data can be used
to cross check the energy scale of the detectors—providing a supplement to dedicated calibration
runs taken using radioisotopes.
Although the experiment is designed to require very little input from Monte Carlo simulations,
a GEANT4-based simulation does exist, and can be used to refine the analysis and account for
systematic uncertainties. Low-level data, such as the plots shown in Fig 3 are being used to tune
and validate this Monte Carlo. Importantly, there is a wealth of information that is separate from
the properties we actually wish to measure. For instance, the shape and rate information that are
the ultimate goal of WP1 correspond to the colour axis on the the right-hand plot, but the particle
bands are sufficiently clear that their shape and location can be considered separately from the
colour axis.
5. Another run?
Although the analysis of the 2013 run is not yet complete, there appears to be sufficient data
after quality cuts that analyses of the charged particle spectrum and normalisation using X-rays
(WP1 & WP2) are possible using just this run. However there are several further studies we would
like to do. Neutron studies (WP3), and data on a titanium target were in the original plan for a
second run. Additionally, the it would be good to get the segmented silicon detector working and
revisit the measurements on a thin active target, as at present we have only a small quantity of data
in this configuration. We are currently working on a request for more beam time at PSI in 2015,
and it would be beneficial to do this sooner, before to many students and postdocs move on.
7
arXiv:1501.04779v1 [physics.ins-det] 20 Jan 2015
Commissioning of the new taggers of the KLOE-2
experiment
D. Babusci, P. Ciambrone, M. Mascolo
INFN-LNF, Frascati, Italy
R. Messi
`
Universita e INFN Sezione di Roma “Tor Vergata” , Rome,
Italy
D. Moricciani
INFN Sezione di Roma “Tor Vergata”, Rome, Italy
S. Fiore
ENEA - Casaccia e INFN Sezione di Roma, Roma, Italy
P. Gauzzi
` La Sapienza e INFN Sezione di Roma, Roma, Italy
Universita
on behalf of the KLOE-2 Collaboration
In order to fully reconstruct the γγ processes (e+ e− → e+ e− γ ? γ ? )
in the energy region of the φ meson production, new detectors along the
DAΦNE beam line have been installed in order to detect the scattered
e+ e− .
PACS numbers: 29.40.Mc, 29.40.Vj
1. Introduction
The renewed interest in γγ processes (e+ e− → e+ e− γ ? γ ? → e+ e− X)
is due to the possibility to contribute to the calculation of the hadronic
Light-by-Light (LbL) scattering diagram that plays a relavant role in the
theoretical evaluation of the muon anomaly, (g-2)µ . Accurate measurements
of the radiative width of the pseudoscalar mesons (X = π 0 or η) and of the
transition form factors at space-like q 2 can help in constraining models to
be used in the LbL calculation[1]. Also the dipion final state (X = ππ) can
(1)
Creation of a neutrino laboratory for search for sterile neutrino at SM-3 reactor
A.P. Serebrova*, V.G. Ivochkina, R.M. Samoylova, A.К. Fomina, V.G. Zinovieva, P.V. Neustroevа,
V.L. Golovtsovа , N.V. Gruzinskyа, V.A. Soloveya, A.V. Cherniya, O.M. Zherebtsova,
V.P. Martemyanovb, V.G. Zinoevb, V.G. Tarasenkovb, V.I. Aleshinb, A.L. Petelinc, S.V. Pavlovc,
A.L. Izhutovc, S.А. Sazontovc, D.K. Ryazanovc, M.О. Gromovc, V.V. Afanasievc , L.N. Matrosova,
M.Yu. Matrosovaa
a
Petersburg Nuclear Physics Institute, Gatchina, 188300 Russia
b
с
NRC «Kurchatov institute», Moscow, 123182 Russia
JSC “SSC RIAR”, Dimitrovgrad, 433510 Russia
Abstract
In connection with the question of possible existence of sterile neutrino the laboratory on the
basis of SМ-3 reactor was created to search for oscillations of reactor antineutrino. A prototype
of a neutrino detector with scintillator volume of 400 l can be moved at the distance of 6-11m
from the reactor core. The measurements of background conditions have been made. It is shown
that the main experimental problem is associated with cosmic radiation background. Test
measurements of dependence of a reactor antineutrino flux on the distance from a reactor core
have been made. The prospects of search for oscillations of reactor antineutrino at short distances
are discussed.
Introduction
At present there is a widely spread discussion of possible existence of a sterile neutrino having
much less cross-section of interaction with matter than, for example, reactor electron
antineutrino. It is assumed that owing to reactor antineutrino transition to sterile condition,
oscillation effect at a short reactor distance and deficiency of a reactor antineutrino beam at a
long range are likely to be observed [1, 2]. Moreover, sterile neutrino can be regarded as being a
candidate for the dark matter.
Ratio of the neutron beam observed in experiments to the predicted one is estimated as
0.927±0.023 [1]. The effect concerned comprises 3 standard deviations. This is not yet sufficient
to have confidence in existence of the reactor antineutrino anomaly. The method of comparing
the measured antineutrino beam with the expected one from the reactor is not satisfactory
because of the problem of accurate estimation of a reactor antineutrino beam and efficiency of an
antineutrino detector.
The idea of oscillation can be testified by direct measuring of a beam variation effect and
antineutrino spectrum at a short reactor distance. A detector is supposed to be movable as well as
spectrum sensitive. Our experiment focuses on the task of either confirming at a certain
confidence level a possible existence of sterile neutrino or disproving it. For seeking oscillations
to sterile neutrino, it is necessary to register variations of the reactor antineutrino beam. If such a
process does occur, it can be described by an oscillation equation:
P(ν e → ν e ) = 1 − sin 2 2θ14 sin 2 (1.27
2
∆m14
[eV 2 ]L[m]
)
E ν [MeV]
1
(1),
Design of A Conduction-cooled 4T
Superconducting Racetrack for Multi-field
Coupling Measurement System
CHEN Yu-Quan(陈玉泉)1,2:1) MA Li-Zhen(马力祯)1 WU-Wei(吴巍)1 GUAN Ming-Zhi(关明
智)1 WU Bei-Min(吴北民)1 MEI En-Ming(梅恩铭)1 Xin Can-Jie(辛灿杰)3
1
Institute of Modern Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Lanzhou 730000, China
2
University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China
3
Key Laboratory of Mechanics on Environment and Disaster in Western China, The Ministry of
Education of China, College of Civil Engineering and Mechanics, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou,
730000, P.R. China
Abstract—A conduction-cooled superconducting magnet producing a transverse field of 4 Tesla has been
designed for the new generation multi-field coupling measurement system, which was used to study the
mechanical behavior of superconducting samples at cryogenic temperature and intense magnetic fields.
Considering experimental costs and coordinating with system of strain measurements by contactless signals
(nonlinear CCD optics system), the racetrack type for the coil winding was chosen in our design, and a
compact cryostat with a two-stage GM cryocooler was designed and manufactured for the superconducting
magnet. The magnet was composed of a pair of flat racetrack coils wound by NbTi/Cu superconducting
composite wires, a copper and stainless steel combinational form and two Bi2Sr2CaCu2Oy superconducting
current leads. All the coils were connected in series and can be powered with a single power supply. The
maximum central magnetic field is 4 T. In order to support the high stress and uniform thermal distribution
in the superconducting magnet, a detailed finite element (FE) analysis has been performed. The detailed
design of superconducting racetrack magnet system is described in this paper.
Index Terms—conduction-cooled, superconducting magnet, multi-field coupling measurement system,
mechanical and thermal analysis
1 Introduction
Cryocoolers have been used to diverse applications, such as space, accelerators and medicine [1].
And with the development of superconducting magnet technology, many superconducting magnet
systems have been required to use cryocoolers alone as the heat sink, instead of liquid helium or
nitrogen, to achieve increased simplicity, compactness, and efficiency. As we know, conduction-cooled
high magnetic field superconducting magnet possesses many advantages over the pool cooling
superconducting magnet. The technology can also make the user obtain high magnetic fields in a
common laboratory, where the use of liquid helium is difficult or expensive.
Recently, in Lanzhou University, China, the multi-field coupling measurement system have been
funded and built at LZU. Different from some similar instruments in other countries [2-5], which were
built mainly based on engineering detection of material at fixed field, the coupling measurement
system can be an integrated test facility and system of measurements by contact transducers and
contactless signals for temperature/magnetic/electric/mechanical properties at variable complicated
field. Considering experimental costs and coordinating with system of strain measurements by
contactless signals (nonlinear CCD optics system), for superconducting magnet applications in this
Multiplexed readout demonstration of a TES-based
detector array in a resistance locked loop
arXiv:1501.04661v1 [physics.ins-det] 19 Jan 2015
Accepted for publication in IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity, DOI 10.1109/TASC.2015.2393716
Copyright has been transferred to the IEEE.
Jan van der Kuur∗ , Luciano Gottardi∗ , Mikko Kiviranta† , Hiroki Akamatsu∗, Pourya Khosropanah∗,
Roland den Hartog∗ , Toyoaki Suzuki∗, Brian Jackson∗
∗ SRON,
Sorbonnelaan 2, 3584CA Utrecht, the Netherlands
Email: see http://www.sron.nl
† VTT, Tietotie, Espoo, Finland
Abstract—TES-based bolometer and microcalorimeter arrays
with thousands of pixels are under development for several spacebased and ground-based applications. A linear detector response
and low levels of cross talk facilitate the calibration of the
instruments. In an effort to improve the properties of TES-based
detectors, fixing the TES resistance in a resistance-locked loop
(RLL) under optical loading has recently been proposed. Earlier
theoretical work on this mode of operation has shown that the
detector speed, linearity and dynamic range should improve with
respect to voltage biased operation.
This paper presents an experimental demonstration of multiplexed readout in this mode of operation in a TES-based
detector array
√ with noise equivalent power values (NEP) of
3.5 · 10−19 W/ Hz. The measured noise and dynamic properties
of the detector in the RLL will be compared with the earlier modelling work. Furthermore, the practical implementation
routes for future FDM systems for the readout of bolometer and
microcalorimeter arrays will be discussed.
I. I NTRODUCTION
Imaging detector arrays based on Transition Edge Sensors
(TES) are a maturing technology for a range of both earth
and space-base applications, such as infrared astronomy, X-ray
astronomy, and material analysis. SQUID-based multiplexed
readout is needed to obtain a detector noise limited readout
chain. Multiplexing in this context implies that multiple TES
signals which overlap in time and phase space are made
mathematically independent so that they can be transported
through a shared readout chain without losing information, by
multiplying each TES signal with an independent carrier and
subsequently adding these modulated TES signals.
The various multiplexing variants which are being developed can be ordered based on their modulating element. We
distinguish the variants in which the SQUID is the multiplying
element which mounts the signal on a carrier, and the variant
in which the TES mounts the signal on the carrier (FDM).
For the first category the TES is biased with a direct voltage
(DC), and the modulated signals are separated in the time
domain (TDM)[1], or frequency domain (microwave SQUID
multiplexing [2] or code domain multiplexing [3]). For the
second category the TES is biased with an alternating voltage
(AC), and the modulated signals are separated in the frequency
domain (FDM)[4], [5].
For both variants of multiplexing the signals have to be
bandwidth limited to prevent addition of wide-band noise
by using an inductor as low-pass filter, or an inductor and
capacitor in series as band-pass filter, respectively. An important difference between the two categories of multiplexing
within the context of this paper, is the property that for case
of SQUID-based modulation the bias sources of the TESes
are commonly shared between pixels to lower the total wire
count, with the consequence that the set points of the pixels
cannot be chosen individually, whereas for the case of TESbased modulation the TES bias sources are independent and
therefore multiplexed. This reduces the wire count and makes
the working points of the pixels individually adjustable.
The individual bias setting per pixel can also be used to
change the impedance of the TES bias source for each pixel
by applying feedback to the applied bias voltage based on
the measured TES current. This type of feedback has been
proposed in different incarnations and for different purposes.
It has been shown [6] that with this type of feedback the
effective thermal decay time of X-ray detectors can be made
shorter when the effective internal resistance of bias source is
made negative, i.e. R0 < RL < 0, where R0 is the operating
resistance of the TES, and RL the total series resistance in
the TES bias circuit. The same feedback topology has also
been applied to compensate parasitic resistances in the TES
bias circuit [7], to increase the stiffness of the voltage bias and
thereby the electro thermal feedback (ETF) loop gain, leaving
a (slightly) net positive resistance 0 < RL ≪ R0 in the voltage
source. Recently, the authors of this paper proposed [8] to use
the regime of RL = −R0 for bolometer operation, so that
the TES resistance is kept constant under optical loading, and
that the small signal parameters of the TES change minimally
under optical loading. As a result, the linearity of the detector
is optimised, and the dependence of the cross talk on the signal
level is minimised.
In this paper, we show the first experimental results which
demonstrate that operation in the regime where RL = −R0
is stable both for single pixel and for multiplexed operation,
and that the signal-to-noise ratio of the TES-based detector
is conserved under the RLL with respect to voltage bias.
For practical reasons the experiments have been divided over
Cavendish-HEP-15/01
KEK-TH-1790
IPMU15-0008
arXiv:1501.04794v1 [hep-ph] 20 Jan 2015
Associated jet and subjet rates in
light-quark and gluon jet discrimination
Biplob Bhattacherjee,a Satyanarayan Mukhopadhyay,b Mihoko M. Nojiri,b,c
Yasuhito Sakakic and Bryan R. Webberd
a Centre
for High Energy Physics, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, India
b Kavli
IPMU (WPI), The University of Tokyo, Kashiwa, Chiba 277-8583, Japan
c KEK
Theory Center and Sokendai, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-0801, Japan
d Cavendish
Laboratory, J.J. Thomson Avenue, Cambridge, UK
E-mail: [email protected], [email protected],
[email protected], [email protected],
[email protected]
Abstract: We show that in studies of light quark- and gluon-initiated jet discrimination, it is important to include the information on softer reconstructed jets (associated jets) around a primary hard jet. This is particularly relevant while adopting
a small radius parameter for reconstructing hadronic jets. The probability of having
an associated jet as a function of the primary jet transverse momentum (pT ) and
radius, the minimum associated jet pT and the association radius is computed upto
next-to-double logarithmic accuracy (NDLA), and the predictions are compared with
results from Herwig++, Pythia6 and Pythia8 Monte Carlos (MC). We demonstrate
the improvement in quark-gluon discrimination on using the associated jet rate variable with the help of a multivariate analysis. The associated jet rates are found to be
only mildly sensitive to the choice of parton shower and hadronization algorithms,
as well as to the effects of initial state radiation and underlying event. In addition,
the number of kT subjets of an anti-kT jet is found to be an observable that leads
to a rather uniform prediction across different MC’s, broadly being in agreement
with predictions in NDLA, as compared to the often used number of charged tracks
observable.
Prepared for submission to JHEP
MCnet-15-01
CERN-PH-TH/2015-006
arXiv:1501.04637v1 [hep-ph] 19 Jan 2015
Finite quark-mass effects in the NNLOPS
POWHEG+MiNLO Higgs generator
Keith Hamilton,a Paolo Nason,b Giulia Zanderighi1c
a
Department of Physics and Astronomy, University College London,
London, WC1E 6BT, UK
b
INFN, Sezione di Milano Bicocca, Piazza della Scienza 3, 20126 Milan, Italy
c
Theory Division, CERN, CH–1211, Geneva 23, Switzerland
E-mail: [email protected], [email protected],
[email protected]
Abstract: We include finite top- and bottom-mass effects in the next-to-next-to-leading
order parton shower (NNLOPS) event generator for inclusive Higgs boson production in
gluon fusion based upon the POWHEG+MiNLO approach. Since fixed-order results for quarkmass effects only reach NLO accuracy, we add them to the NNLOPS generator at that
accuracy. We explore uncertainties related to the unknown all-order logarithmic structure
of bottom-mass effects by comparing the assumption of full exponentiation to no exponentiation at all. Phenomenological results showing the effects of finite quark-masses in the
NNLOPS simulation are presented. These suggest that the aforementioned uncertainty is
well contained within the envelope of plain renormalization and factorization scale uncertainties.
Keywords: QCD, Higgs Physics, Monte Carlo, LHC
1
On leave from Rudolf Peierls Centre for Theoretical Physics, University of Oxford, 1 Keble Road, UK
Evidence for Narrow Resonant Structures at W ∼ 1.68 and W ∼ 1.72 GeV in Real
Compton Scattering off the Proton
V. Kuznetsov1,∗ , F.Mammoliti2,3 , V.Bellini2,3 , G.Gervino4,5 , F.Ghio6,7 ,
G.Giardina8 , W. Kim9 , G. Mandaglio2,8 , M.L. Sperduto2,3 , and C.M. Sutera2,3
arXiv:1501.04333v1 [nucl-ex] 18 Jan 2015
1
Petersburg Nuclear Physics Institute, Gatchina, 188300, St. Petersburg, Russia,
2
INFN - Sezione di Catania, via Santa Sofia 64, I-95123 Catania, Italy
3
Dipartimento di Fisica ed Astronomia, Universit´
a di Catania,
4
Dipartamento di Fisica Sperimentale, Universit´
a di Torino, via P.Giuria, I-00125 Torino, Italy
5
INFN - Sezione di Torino, I-10125 Torino, Italy
6
INFN - Sezione di Roma, piazzale Aldo Moro 2, I-00185 Roma, Italy
7
Instituto Superiore di Sanit´
a, viale Regina Elena 299, I-00161 Roma, Italy
8
Dipartimento di Fisica e di Scienze della Terra - Universit`
a di Messina, salita Sperone 31, 98166 Messina, Italy and
9
Kyungpook National University, 702-701, Daegu, Republic of Korea∗
(Dated: January 20, 2015)
First measurement of the beam asymmetry Σ for Compton scattering off the proton in the energy
range Eγ = 0.85 − 1.25 GeV is presented. The data reveals two narrow structures at Eγ = 1.036
and Eγ = 1.119 GeV. They may signal either narrow resonances with the masses near 1.68 and 1.72
GeV, or can be generated by the sub-threshold KΛ and ωp production. Their decisive identification
requires additional theoretical and experimental efforts.
PACS numbers: 14.20.Gk,13.60.Rj,13.60.Le
The observation of a narrow enhancement at W ∼ 1.68
GeV in η photoproduction [1–5] and Compton scattering off the neutron [6] (the so-called “neutron anomaly”)
is of particular interest because it may signal a nucleon resonance with unusual properties: the mass near
M ∼ 1.68 GeV, the narrow (Γ ≤ 25 MeV) width, the
strong photoexcitation on the neutron, and the suppressed decay to πN final state [7–11]. Such resonance
was never predicted by the traditional Constituent Quark
Model [12]. On the contrary, its properties surprisingly
well coincide with those expected for an exotic state predicted in the framework of the Chiral Soliton Model [13–
15].
On the other hand, several groups [16] explained the
bump in the γn → ηn cross section in terms of the interference of well-known wide resonances. Although this
assumption was challenged by the results on Compton
scattering off the neutron [6] (this reaction is governed
by different resonances), it is widely discussed in literature.
Another explanation was proposed by M. Doring and
K. Nakayama [17]. They explained the neutron anomaly
as virtual sub-threshold KΛ and KΣ photoproduction
(“cusp effect”).
At present, the decisive identification of the narrow
peculiarity at W ∼ 1.68 GeV is a challenge for both
theory an experiment.
One benchmark signature of the N ∗ (1685) resonance
(if it does exist) is the strong photoexcitation on the neu-
∗ Electronic
address: [email protected]
tron and the weak (but not zero) photoexcitation on the
proton. Such resonance would appear in cross section on
the proton as a minor peak(dip) structure which might
be not (or poorly) seen in experiment. However its signal
may be amplified in polarization observables due to the
interference with other resonances.
The recent high-precision and high-resolution measurement of the γp → ηp cross section by the A2@MaMiC
Collaboration [18] made it possible to retrieve a small
dip at W ≈ 1.69 GeV which was not resolved in previous experiments. At the same time the revision of the
GRAAL beam asymmetry Σ for γp → ηp revealed a resonant structure at W = 1.685 GeV [19, 20] (see also [21]).
The bump in the Compton scattering off the neutron
at W = 1.685 GeV was observed at GRAAL [6]. The
motivation for this work was to search, in analogy with
η photoproduction, a resonant structure in polarization
observables for Compton scattering on the proton.
In this Letter, we report on the first measurement of
the beam asymmetry Σ for Compton scattering off the
proton in the range of incident-photon energies Eγ =
0.85 − 1.25 GeV. The data was collected at the GRAAL
facility [23] during 1998 - 2003 in a number of datataking periods. The main difference between the periods was the usage of either UV or green laser light. A
highly-polarized and tagged photon beam was produced
by means of backscattering of this light on 6.04 GeV
electrons circulating in the storage ring of the ESRF
(Grenoble, France). The tagged photon-energy range was
∼ 0.8 − 1.5 GeV with the UV laser and ∼ 0.65 − 1.1 GeV
with the green one. The linear beam polarization varied
from ∼ 40% at the lower energy limits up to ∼ 98% at
the upper ones. The results obtained with two different
Comments on “Interference phenomena in the J p = 1/2− - wave in η photoproduction”
by A.V. Anisovich, E. Klempt, B. Krusche, V.A. Nikonov, A.V. Sarantsev, U. Thoma,
D. Werthmuller, arXiv:1501.02093v1 [nucl-ex].
Viacheslav Kuznetsov
arXiv:1501.03961v1 [nucl-ex] 16 Jan 2015
1
Petersburg Nuclear Physics Institute, Gatchina, 188300, St. Petersburg, Russia
The authors of Ref. [1] claimed that “ ... narrow structure observed in the excitation function
of γn → ηn can be reproduced fully with a particular interference pattern in the J p = 1/2−
partial wave...” while a narrow structure in Compton scattering off the neutron is “...a stand-alone
observation unrelated to the structure observed in γn → ηn...”. The source for the second statement
may be a simple numerical error. If so, the interpretation of the narrow structure in γn → ηn as
interference effects in the J p = 1/2− -wave and some conclusions from Ref. [1] are questionable.
The observation of a narrow enhancement at W ∼ 1.68
GeV in η photoproduction [2–5] and Compton scattering off the neutron [6] (the so-called “neutron anomaly”)
raised intensive debates about its nature. One possible
explanation is a signal of a nucleon resonance with unusual properties: the mass near M ∼ 1.68 GeV, the narrow (Γ ≤ 25 MeV) width, the strong photoexcitation on
the neutron, and the suppressed decay to πN final state.
A new one-star N ∗ (1685) resonance was included into
the listing of the Particle Data Group [7].
On the other hand, several groups tried to explain the
bump in the γn → ηn cross section in terms of the interference of well-known wide resonances. The recent
attempt was done in Ref. [1]. The authors concluded
that it can be full explained by the interference of wellknown resonances while the inclusion of N ∗ (1685) only
deteriorates the data fit.
One major challenge for this interpretation is the observation of a narrow peak at the same energy in Compton scattering on the neutron at GRAAL [6]. The
authors of Ref. [1] estimated the total cross section of
N ∗ (1685) in γn → γn assuming the mass M = 1670
MeV, the width Γtot = 30 MeV, and (a priori) the quantum numbers P11 . The result σres = 10.8 pb led to a
conclusion that “...this value is far below the sensitivity
of the GRAAL experiment. If it is not a statistical fluctuation, ... it is a stand-alone observation unrelated to
the structure observed in γn → ηn...”.
Unfortunately, there might be a simple numerical error: if to check Eq.(1) from Ref. [1], the correct number
is σres = 10.8 nb (i.e. 1000 times larger).
Even this number may be pessimistic. The results from
GRAAL and CBELSA/TAPS suggest Γtot ≤ 25 MeV. If
to set Γtot = 20 MeV then σres = 24.3 nb. If in addition
to assume that N ∗ (1685) is a higher-spin resonance, σres
may be significantly larger.
The peak in γn → γn at GRAAL was observed at
157◦. The measured differential cross section of Compton
scattering on the proton at 160◦ and Eγ = 1.025 GeV
is 27.1 ± 5.4 nb/str [8]. In accordance with dispersionrelation calculations [9] Compton cross section on the
neutron (without narrow resonance) at 160◦ and Eγ = 1
GeV may be significantly (∼ 5 times) smaller than that
on the proton. The peak of N ∗ (1685) on the top of the
flat γn → γn cross section could and, if N ∗ (1685) does
exist, should be seen at GRAAL.
The observation of the peak in Compton scattering at
the same energy as in γn → ηn challenges the explanation of the neutron anomaly in terms of interference
effects. The specific interference of wide resonances cannot generate a narrow peak in η photoproduction which is
governed by only isospin-1/2 resonances, simultaneously
generate a peak at the same energy in Compton scattering which governed by both isospin-1/2 and isospin-3/2
resonances, and generate neither of peak in γn → π 0 n
which is governed by the same resonances as Compton
scattering.
At present, the only available explanation is the existence of N ∗ (1685).
[1] by A.V. Anisovich, E. Klempt, B. Krusche, V.A. Nikonov,
A.V. Sarantsev,
U. Thoma,
D. Werthmuller,
arXiv:1501.02093v1 [nucl-ex].
[2] V. Kuznetsov et al., Phys. Lett. B 647, 23 (2007).
[3] I. Jaegle et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 252002 (2008); I. Jaegle et al., Eur.Phys.J. A47, 89 (2011).
[4] F. Miyahara et al., Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 168, 90
(2007).
[5] D. Werthmulleret al., Phys.Rev.Lett. 111 (2013) 23,
232001; Phys.Rev. C90, 015205 (2014).
[6] V. Kuznetsov et al., Phys. Rev. C83, 022201 (2011).
[7] K.A.Olive et al., [the Particle Data Group Collboration],
Chin. Phys. C38,090001 (2014).
[8] Y. Wada et al., Nucl. Phys. b247, 313 (1984).
[9] A. Lvov, V. Petrun’kin, and M. Shumacher, Phys. Rev.
C55, 355, (1997), and A. L’vov, Private communication.
EUROPEAN ORGANISATION FOR NUCLEAR RESEARCH (CERN)
CERN-PH-EP-2014-262
arXiv:1501.04943v1 [hep-ex] 20 Jan 2015
Submitted to: Journal of High Energy Physics
Evidence for the Higgs-boson Yukawa coupling to tau leptons
with the ATLAS detector
The ATLAS Collaboration
Abstract
Results of a search for H → τ τ decays are presented, based on the full set of proton–proton
collision data recorded by the ATLAS experiment at the LHC during 2011 and 2012. The data corre√
spond to integrated luminosities of 4.5 fb−1 and 20.3 fb−1 at centre-of-mass energies of s = 7 TeV
√
and s = 8 TeV respectively. All combinations of leptonic (τ → `ν ν¯ with ` = e, µ) and hadronic
(τ → hadrons ν ) tau decays are considered. An excess of events over the expected background from
other Standard Model processes is found with an observed (expected) significance of 4.5 (3.4) standard deviations. This excess provides evidence for the direct coupling of the recently discovered Higgs
boson to fermions. The measured signal strength, normalised to the Standard Model expectation, of
µ = 1.43 +0.43
−0.37 is consistent with the predicted Yukawa coupling strength in the Standard Model.
c 2015 CERN for the benefit of the ATLAS Collaboration.
Reproduction of this article or parts of it is allowed as specified in the CC-BY-3.0 license.
arXiv:1501.04875v1 [hep-ex] 20 Jan 2015
Constraints on models of the Higgs boson with exotic spin and parity using the full
CDF data set
T. Aaltonen,21 S. Ameriokk ,39 D. Amidei,31 A. Anastassovw ,15 A. Annovi,17 J. Antos,12 G. Apollinari,15
J.A. Appel,15 T. Arisawa,52 A. Artikov,13 J. Asaadi,47 W. Ashmanskas,15 B. Auerbach,2 A. Aurisano,47 F. Azfar,38
W. Badgett,15 T. Bae,25 A. Barbaro-Galtieri,26 V.E. Barnes,43 B.A. Barnett,23 P. Barriamm ,41 P. Bartos,12
M. Baucekk ,39 F. Bedeschi,41 S. Behari,15 G. Bellettinill ,41 J. Bellinger,54 D. Benjamin,14 A. Beretvas,15
A. Bhatti,45 K.R. Bland,5 B. Blumenfeld,23 A. Bocci,14 A. Bodek,44 D. Bortoletto,43 J. Boudreau,42 A. Boveia,11
L. Brigliadorijj ,6 C. Bromberg,32 E. Brucken,21 J. Budagov,13 H.S. Budd,44 K. Burkett,15 G. Busettokk ,39
P. Bussey,19 P. Buttill ,41 A. Buzatu,19 A. Calamba,10 S. Camarda,4 M. Campanelli,28 F. Canellidd ,11 B. Carls,22
D. Carlsmith,54 R. Carosi,41 S. Carrillol ,16 B. Casalj ,9 M. Casarsa,48 A. Castrojj ,6 P. Catastini,20 D. Cauzrr ss ,48
V. Cavaliere,22 A. Cerrie ,26 L. Cerritor ,28 Y.C. Chen,1 M. Chertok,7 G. Chiarelli,41 G. Chlachidze,15 K. Cho,25
D. Chokheli,13 A. Clark,18 C. Clarke,53 M.E. Convery,15 J. Conway,7 M. Corboz ,15 M. Cordelli,17 C.A. Cox,7
D.J. Cox,7 M. Cremonesi,41 D. Cruz,47 J. Cuevasy ,9 R. Culbertson,15 N. d’Ascenzov ,15 M. Dattagg ,15
P. de Barbaro,44 L. Demortier,45 M. Deninno,6 M. D’Erricokk ,39 F. Devoto,21 A. Di Cantoll ,41 B. Di Ruzzap ,15
J.R. Dittmann,5 S. Donatill ,41 M. D’Onofrio,27 M. Dorigott ,48 A. Driuttirr ss ,48 K. Ebina,52 R. Edgar,31 A. Elagin,47
R. Erbacher,7 S. Errede,22 B. Esham,22 S. Farrington,38 J.P. Fern´andez Ramos,29 R. Field,16 G. Flanagant ,15
R. Forrest,7 M. Franklin,20 J.C. Freeman,15 H. Frisch,11 Y. Funakoshi,52 C. Gallonill ,41 A.F. Garfinkel,43
P. Garosimm ,41 H. Gerberich,22 E. Gerchtein,15 S. Giagu,46 V. Giakoumopoulou,3 K. Gibson,42 C.M. Ginsburg,15
N. Giokaris,3 P. Giromini,17 V. Glagolev,13 D. Glenzinski,15 M. Gold,34 D. Goldin,47 A. Golossanov,15 G. Gomez,9
G. Gomez-Ceballos,30 M. Goncharov,30 O. Gonz´alez L´opez,29 I. Gorelov,34 A.T. Goshaw,14 K. Goulianos,45
E. Gramellini,6 C. Grosso-Pilcher,11 R.C. Group,51, 15 J. Guimaraes da Costa,20 S.R. Hahn,15 J.Y. Han,44
F. Happacher,17 K. Hara,49 M. Hare,50 R.F. Harr,53 T. Harrington-Taberm ,15 K. Hatakeyama,5 C. Hays,38
J. Heinrich,40 M. Herndon,54 A. Hocker,15 Z. Hong,47 W. Hopkinsf ,15 S. Hou,1 R.E. Hughes,35 U. Husemann,55
M. Husseinbb ,32 J. Huston,32 G. Introzzioopp ,41 M. Ioriqq ,46 A. Ivanovo ,7 E. James,15 D. Jang,10 B. Jayatilaka,15
E.J. Jeon,25 S. Jindariani,15 M. Jones,43 K.K. Joo,25 S.Y. Jun,10 T.R. Junk,15 M. Kambeitz,24 T. Kamon,25, 47
P.E. Karchin,53 A. Kasmi,5 Y. Katon ,37 W. Ketchumhh ,11 J. Keung,40 B. Kilminsterdd ,15 D.H. Kim,25 H.S. Kim,25
J.E. Kim,25 M.J. Kim,17 S.H. Kim,49 S.B. Kim,25 Y.J. Kim,25 Y.K. Kim,11 N. Kimura,52 M. Kirby,15 K. Knoepfel,15
K. Kondo,52, ∗ D.J. Kong,25 J. Konigsberg,16 A.V. Kotwal,14 M. Kreps,24 J. Kroll,40 M. Kruse,14 T. Kuhr,24
M. Kurata,49 A.T. Laasanen,43 S. Lammel,15 M. Lancaster,28 K. Lannonx ,35 G. Latinomm ,41 H.S. Lee,25 J.S. Lee,25
S. Leo,22 S. Leone,41 J.D. Lewis,15 A. Limosanis ,14 E. Lipeles,40 A. Listera ,18 H. Liu,51 Q. Liu,43 T. Liu,15
S. Lockwitz,55 A. Loginov,55 D. Lucchesikk ,39 A. Luc`a,17 J. Lueck,24 P. Lujan,26 P. Lukens,15 G. Lungu,45
J. Lys,26 R. Lysakd ,12 R. Madrak,15 P. Maestromm ,41 S. Malik,45 G. Mancab ,27 A. Manousakis-Katsikakis,3
L. Marcheseii ,6 F. Margaroli,46 P. Marinonn ,41 K. Matera,22 M.E. Mattson,53 A. Mazzacane,15 P. Mazzanti,6
R. McNultyi ,27 A. Mehta,27 P. Mehtala,21 C. Mesropian,45 T. Miao,15 D. Mietlicki,31 A. Mitra,1 H. Miyake,49
S. Moed,15 N. Moggi,6 C.S. Moonz ,15 R. Mooreeef f ,15 M.J. Morellonn ,41 A. Mukherjee,15 Th. Muller,24
P. Murat,15 M. Mussinijj ,6 J. Nachtmanm ,15 Y. Nagai,49 J. Naganoma,52 I. Nakano,36 A. Napier,50
J. Nett,47 C. Neu,51 T. Nigmanov,42 L. Nodulman,2 S.Y. Noh,25 O. Norniella,22 L. Oakes,38 S.H. Oh,14
Y.D. Oh,25 I. Oksuzian,51 T. Okusawa,37 R. Orava,21 L. Ortolan,4 C. Pagliarone,48 E. Palenciae ,9 P. Palni,34
V. Papadimitriou,15 W. Parker,54 G. Paulettarr ss ,48 M. Paulini,10 C. Paus,30 T.J. Phillips,14 G. Piacentinoq ,15
E. Pianori,40 J. Pilot,7 K. Pitts,22 C. Plager,8 L. Pondrom,54 S. Poprockif ,15 K. Potamianos,26 A. Pranko,26
F. Prokoshinaa ,13 F. Ptohosg ,17 G. Punzill ,41 I. Redondo Fern´andez,29 P. Renton,38 M. Rescigno,46 F. Rimondi,6, ∗
L. Ristori,41, 15 A. Robson,19 T. Rodriguez,40 S. Rollih ,50 M. Ronzanill ,41 R. Roser,15 J.L. Rosner,11 F. Ruffinimm ,41
A. Ruiz,9 J. Russ,10 V. Rusu,15 W.K. Sakumoto,44 Y. Sakurai,52 L. Santirr ss ,48 K. Sato,49 V. Savelievv ,15
A. Savoy-Navarroz ,15 P. Schlabach,15 E.E. Schmidt,15 T. Schwarz,31 L. Scodellaro,9 F. Scuri,41 S. Seidel,34
Y. Seiya,37 A. Semenov,13 F. Sforzall ,41 S.Z. Shalhout,7 T. Shears,27 P.F. Shepard,42 M. Shimojimau ,49
M. Shochet,11 I. Shreyber-Tecker,33 A. Simonenko,13 K. Sliwa,50 J.R. Smith,7 F.D. Snider,15 H. Song,42
V. Sorin,4 R. St. Denis,19, ∗ M. Stancari,15 D. Stentzw ,15 J. Strologas,34 Y. Sudo,49 A. Sukhanov,15 I. Suslov,13
K. Takemasa,49 Y. Takeuchi,49 J. Tang,11 M. Tecchio,31 P.K. Teng,1 J. Thomf ,15 E. Thomson,40 V. Thukral,47
D. Toback,47 S. Tokar,12 K. Tollefson,32 T. Tomura,49 D. Tonellie ,15 S. Torre,17 D. Torretta,15 P. Totaro,39
M. Trovatonn ,41 F. Ukegawa,49 S. Uozumi,25 F. V´azquezl ,16 G. Velev,15 C. Vellidis,15 C. Vernierinn ,41 M. Vidal,43
3
46
Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Roma 1,
qq
Sapienza Universit`
a di Roma, I-00185 Roma, Italy
47
Mitchell Institute for Fundamental Physics and Astronomy,
Texas A&M University, College Station, Texas 77843, USA
48
Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Trieste, rr Gruppo Collegato di Udine,
ss
University of Udine, I-33100 Udine, Italy, tt University of Trieste, I-34127 Trieste, Italy
49
University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305, Japan
50
Tufts University, Medford, Massachusetts 02155, USA
51
University of Virginia, Charlottesville, Virginia 22906, USA
52
Waseda University, Tokyo 169, Japan
53
Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan 48201, USA
54
University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin 53706, USA
55
Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520, USA
(Dated: January 21, 2015)
A search for particles with the same mass and couplings as those of the standard model Higgs
boson but different spin and parity quantum numbers is presented. We test two specific non-standard
Higgs boson hypotheses: a pseudoscalar Higgs boson with spin-parity J P = 0− and a graviton-like
Higgs boson with J P = 2+ , assuming for both a mass of 125 GeV/c2 . We search for these exotic
states produced in association with a vector boson and decaying into a bottom-antibottom quark
pair. The vector boson is reconstructed through its decay into an electron or muon pair, or an
electron or muon and a neutrino, or it is inferred from an imbalance in total transverse momentum.
We use expected kinematic differences between events containing exotic Higgs bosons and those
containing standard model Higgs bosons. The data were collected by the CDF
√ experiment at the
Tevatron proton-antiproton collider, operating at a center-of-mass energy of s = 1.96 TeV, and
correspond to an integrated luminosity of 9.45 fb−1 . We observe no significant deviations from the
2
predictions of the standard model with a Higgs boson of mass 125 GeV/c , and set bounds on the
possible rate of production of each exotic state.
PACS numbers: 13.85.Rm, 14.80.Bn, 14.80.Ec
The observation of a narrow bosonic resonance H with
mass near 125 GeV/c2 by the ATLAS [1] and CMS [2]
Collaborations at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) in
the H → γγ and H → ZZ → `+ `− `+ `− decay modes,
and the evidence of such a particle at the Tevatron, primarily in association with a vector boson and in decays
to bottom-antibottom quark pairs [3, 4], shifted the focus
of the Higgs boson experimental program to the determination of the properties of the newly discovered particle.
The central question that needs to be addressed experimentally is whether only one Higgs boson is sufficient to
explain the observed data. Specifically, the spin and parity of the Higgs boson should be established in order to
determine if it plays the role predicted for it by the standard model (SM) of particle physics or if it represents
the first hint of more exotic interactions.
The properties of the new particle observed at the LHC
are consistent with those predicted by the SM for the
Higgs boson. The products of cross sections and branching ratios are as predicted [1, 5–7]. The decays of the new
particle to ZZ (∗) , γγ, and W W (∗) final states, where the
asterisk indicates an off-mass-shell Z or W vector boson,
provide excellent samples for testing its spin and parity
quantum numbers J and P , due to the measurable angular distributions of the decay products [8, 9], which
depend on the quantum numbers of the decaying particle. The tests at the LHC in the bosonic decay channels
exclude exotic states with spin and/or parity different
from the SM prediction of J P = 0+ with high confidence
level.
At the Tevatron, the primary sensitivity to the Higgs
boson comes from modes in which it is produced via
its coupling to vector bosons but decays to a pair of
fermions. While CMS has reported strong evidence for
fermionic decays of the Higgs boson [10], spin and parity
quantum numbers have not been tested in these decays.
Testing the spin and parity of the Higgs boson at the
Tevatron therefore provides independent information on
the properties of this particle.
The Tevatron data can test alternative J P hypotheses in the WH, ZH production modes with H → b¯b, by
examining the kinematic distributions of the observable
decay products of the vector boson and the Higgs-like
boson [11]. Testing the spin and parity of the Higgs boson in H → b¯b decays provides independent information
on the properties of this particle. The models tested are
described in Ref. [12]. For the SM case, Higgs boson associated production is an S-wave process (i.e. the VH
system is in a state with relative orbital angular momentum L = 0, where V = W or Z), with a cross section
that rises proportionally √
to the boson speed β close to
threshold. Here β = 2p/ s, where p is the momentum
√
of the Higgs boson in the VH reference frame and s is
the total energy of the VH system in its rest frame [12].
−
In the 0 case, the production is a P -wave process and
the cross section rises proportionally to β 3 . There are
Studies of the ω meson with the KLOE detector
arXiv:1501.04848v1 [hep-ex] 20 Jan 2015
¨ ld, W. Ikegami Andersson
L. Heijkenskjo
on behalf of the KLOE-2 collaboration
Uppsala University, Department of Physics and Astronomy
Box 516, 751 20 Uppsala, Sweden
The paper presents status of three studies involving the ω meson using
data collected by the KLOE detector. The first two projects are feasibility
studies performed on simulated data concerning an upper limit measurement of BR(φ → ωγ) and the form factor measurement in the ω → π 0 l+ l−
dalitz decay. The third study shows the effect π 0 − π 0 interference has in
the ω → π + π − π 0 Dalitz plot when ω is produced through the e+ e− → ωπ 0
channel.
PACS numbers: 13.66.Bc, 13.20.Jf, 13.25.Jx
1. Introduction
The study of the light mesons is a rich and active field which provides
valuable insights into strong interactions taking place at energies where
perturbative quantum chromodynamics is no longer valid. Instead effective
field theories or dispersion relation calculations can be used. Both of these
however need experimental results either as input or as a verification of
predictions.
The KLOE detector is situated at the e+ e− collider DAΦNE which operates in the φ meson mass region. The huge available data sets are ideal
when searching for the forbidden decay channel φ → ωγ. The possibility of
such a measurement is presented in the first study below.
At these centre of mass energies there is also a large amount of ω
mesons produced, either accompanied by an Initial State Radiation photon or through the e+ e− → ωπ 0 production reaction. In the second study
presented below both these production channels are used when estimating
how many events of the ω → π 0 l+ l− decay can be found. In the third
study only the e+ e− → ωπ 0 production channel is used to investigate the
dynamics of the dominant ω decay channel, ω → π + π − π 0 .
(1)
Kaon physics with the KLOE detector ∗
arXiv:1501.04807v1 [hep-ex] 20 Jan 2015
C. Bloise, E. De Lucia, A. De Santis, P. De Simone
Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati dell’INFN, Frascati, Italy
´ ski, A. Gajos, D. Kamin
´ ska, P. Moskal, M. Silarski
E. Czerwin
Institute of Physics, Jagiellonian University, Cracow, Poland
A. Di Domenico
Dipartimento di Fisica, Sapienza Universit`a di Roma, Roma, Italy
INFN sezione di Roma, Roma, Italy
A. Passeri
INFN sezione di Roma Tre, Roma, Italy
W. Wi´
slicki
National Centre for Nuclear Research, Warsaw, Poland
on behalf of the KLOE-2 collaboration
In this paper we discuss the recent finalized analyses by the KLOE experiment at DAΦNE: the CPT and Lorentz invariance test with entangled
¯ 0 pairs, and the precision measurement of the branching fraction of
K 0K
the decay K+ → π + π − π + (γ) .
We also present the status of an ongoing analysis aiming to precisely measure the K ± mass.
PACS numbers: 13.25.Es,14.40.Df
∗
To appear on a special issue of Acta Physica Polonica B
(1)
arXiv:1501.04801v1 [hep-ex] 20 Jan 2015
Study of the KS KL → π`ν3π 0 process
for time reversal symmetry test at KLOE-2
Aleksander Gajos
on behalf of the KLOE-2 collaboration
The Marian Smoluchowski Institute of Physics, Jagiellonian University,
Lojasiewicza 11, 30-348, Krak´ow, Poland
[email protected]
This work presents prospects for conducting a novel direct test of timereversal symmetry at the KLOE-2 experiment. Quantum entanglement
of neutral K meson pairs uniquely available at KLOE-2 allows to probe
directly the time-reversal symmetry (T ) independently of CP violation.
This is achieved by a comparison of probabilities for a transition between
flavour and CP-definite states and its inverse obtained through exchange
of initial and final states. As such a test requires the reconstruction of
the KL → 3π 0 decay accompanied by KS → π ± `∓ ν with good timing
information, a new reconstruction method for this process is also presented
which is capable of reconstructing the KL → 3π 0 decay with decay time
resolution of O(1τS ).
PACS numbers: 14.40.Df, 24.80.+y
1. Introduction
Well known for CP-violating phenomena, neutral kaons may also be
used to study directly the time-reversal symmetry although special care is
necessary to prepare a T symmetry test which should be independent of
CP-violation effects. Such a test is possible with entangled neutral kaon
pairs uniquely available at the DAΦNE φ-factory [1]. Kaon transitions between flavour-definite and CP-definite states constitute processes for whom
an exchange of initial and final state only corresponds to the time-reversal
operation and not CP nor CPT conjugation. This allows for a direct test
by comparison of amplitudes for a transition and its inverse independently
of CP and CPT . A similar principle was recently used by the BaBar experiment to observe T -violation in the neutral B meson system [2, 3]. In
turn, KLOE-2 is capable of investigating time-reversal violation with neutral kaons.
(1)
DCPT-15/03
Gravity and the stability of the Higgs vacuum
Philipp Burda1 , Ruth Gregory1,2 , and Ian G. Moss3
1
Centre for Particle Theory, Durham University, South Road, Durham, DH1 3LE, UK
2
Perimeter Institute, 31 Caroline St, Waterloo, Ontario N2L 2Y5, Canada
3
School of Mathematics and Statistics, Newcastle University, Newcastle Upon Tyne, NE1 7RU, U.K.
(Dated: January 21, 2015)
We discuss the effect of gravitational interactions on the lifetime of the Higgs vacuum where
generic quantum gravity corrections are taken into account. We show how small black holes can act
as seeds for vacuum decay, spontaneously nucleating a new Higgs phase centered on the black hole
with a lifetime measured in millions of Planck times rather than billions of years. The constraints
on parameter space of corrections to the Higgs potential are outlined, and implications for collider
black holes discussed.
arXiv:1501.04937v1 [hep-th] 20 Jan 2015
PACS numbers: 04.70.Dy,12.60.Fr,11.15.Tk
With the discovery of the Higgs boson at the LHC
[1, 2], and the measurement of its mass, it seems we
live in interesting times: the running of the coupling of
the Higgs quite possibly means that our vacuum is only
metastable, and the true Higgs vacuum in fact lies at
large expectation values of the Higgs and negative vacuum energy. Although this metastability at first might
seem alarming, in order for the vacuum to decay, it must
tunnel through a sizeable energy barrier, and the probability for this typically has an exponential factor,
Γ ∼ Ae−B/~
(1)
where B is the action of a solution to the Euclidean field
equations, “the bounce”, which interpolates between the
metastable (false) and true vacua; the prefactor A is determined from fluctuations around the bounce. Since the
action B is usually large (we will set ~ to 1 for the rest of
this discussion) the probability of vacuum decay is very
low. For the decay of a false vacuum, the process was
understood and the probability computed in a series of
papers by Coleman, Callan and de Luccia [3–5]. This
‘gold standard’ calculation is now used ubiquitously to
estimate decay rates and the half life of a false vacuum
state in field theory, and for the Higgs vacuum predicts
a lifetime well in excess of the age of the universe.
The Coleman et al. picture of vacuum decay is however very idealized, in that an exactly homogeneous and
isotropic false vacuum decays into a very nearly as symmetric configuration: a completely spherical bubble of
true vacuum which expands outwards with uniform acceleration. In everyday physics however, first order phase
transitions are far from clean, and often proceed not via
some perfect nucleation process but rather by impurities
acting as sites for the condensation of a new phase. Recently in [6] we investigated the impact of gravitational
impurities, in the guise of black holes, on the usual Coleman de Luccia picture, and found a significant enhancement of vacuum decay in a wide range of cases – the
intuition of an impurity seeding nucleation of a true vacuum bubble was entirely borne out by the analysis.
To recall Coleman’s original intuition: the nucleation
of a bubble costs energy because a wall with energy and
tension is formed as a barrier between the false and true
vacua, but to counter that, energy is gained by the volume of space inside the bubble having lower energy by
virtue of having transitioned to the true vacuum. A bubble of just the right size then optimises this energy pay-off
and once formed, grows. The picture with a gravitational
inhomogeneity is similar; the bubble forms around the
(euclidean) black hole but because of the distortion of
space the payoff between volume inside a bubble and its
surface area is changed, and bubbles form at a smaller
radius and hence the ‘cost’ of forming them is lower: the
instanton has a smaller action and the decay process can
be significantly enhanced.
Can this process affect the lifetime of the Higgs vacuum? We will show that it can, although only if small
black holes nucleate the decay. Such black holes could result from gradual evaporation of primordial black holes
formed in the early universe [7]; alternatively, if there are
“large” extra dimensions [8, 9] responsible for producing
a hierarchically large Planck scale in our universe, then
small black holes can be produced at the LHC [10]. Depending on the tension of the bubble wall, which is directly related to parameters in the Higgs potential, the
enhancement of vacuum decay can be large.
To briefly review the Higgs potential, note that at large
values of the Higgs field, we can pick any component φ
and approximate the potential using an effective coupling
constant λeff ,
V (φ) =
1
λeff (φ)φ4 .
4
(2)
The effective coupling is obtained by combining the running of λ under the renormalisation group with the lowenergy particle physics parameters. Two-loop calculations of the running coupling [11], including contributions
from all of the standard model fields, yield a high-energy
approximation
2
φ
λeff ≈ λ∗ + b ln
,
(3)
φ∗
where the fit to the results of [11] give parameter ranges
−0.01 . λ∗ . 0, 0.1Mp . φ∗ . Mp and b ∼ 10−4 . These
Extragalactic star-forming galaxies with hypernovae and supernovae
as high-energy neutrino and gamma-ray sources:
the case of the 10 TeV neutrino data
Nicholas Senno,1 Peter M´esz´
aros ,1 Kohta Murase,1, 2 Philipp Baerwald,1 and Martin J. Rees3
arXiv:1501.04934v1 [astro-ph.HE] 20 Jan 2015
1
Dept. of Physics, Dept. of Astronomy & Astrophysics,
Center for Particle and Gravitational Astrophysics,
Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802, USA
2
Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA
3
Institute of Astronomy, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB3 0HA, U.K.
(Dated: January 21, 2015)
In light of the latest IceCube data, we discuss the implications of the cosmic ray energy input
from hypernovae and supernovae into the Universe, and their propagation in the hosting galaxy and
galaxy clusters or groups. The magnetic confinement in these environments may lead to efficient pp
collisions, resulting in a diffuse neutrino spectrum extending from PeV down to 10 TeV energies,
with a spectrum and flux level compatible with that recently reported by IceCube. If the diffuse
10 TeV neutrino background largely comes from such the CR reservoirs, the corresponding diffuse
gamma-ray background should be compatible with the recent Fermi data. In this scenario, the
CR energy input from hypernovae should be dominant over that of supernovae, implying that the
starburst scenario does not work if the supernova energy budget is a factor of two larger than the
hypernova energy budget. Thus, this strong case scenario can be supported or ruled out in near
future.
I.
INTRODUCTION
The detection of PeV and sub-PeV astrophysical neutrinos by IceCube [1–3], which more recently has been extended down to 10 TeV energies [4], is a major development. The origin
of these neutrinos is a matter of intense interest
(for recent reviews, see e.g. [5, 6]). A promising
type of candidates for this may be star-forming
galaxies including starbursts [7–12], in which the
major contributing sources may be not only supernovae (SNe) but also hyper-energetic supernovae so-called hypernovae (HNe) [8, 13–17] and
active galactic nuclei (AGN) [10, 18]. Other
possible candidates include low-luminosity classes
of gamma-ray bursts [19, 20], radio-loud active
galactic nuclei (AGNs) [18, 21–24] that may accelerate cosmic rays (CRs) to higher energies [25, 26],
galaxy clusters and groups [8, 27] with accretion
shocks [28, 29] or other CR sources, and galaxy
mergers in clusters [30].
In this work, we will concentrate mainly on the
hypernovae/supernovae origin of neutrinos from
pp interactions in the starburst and normal starforming intragalactic material and intracluster
medium. In particular, we discuss their implications in light of the latest IceCube data in the 10
TeV range. Constraints from the diffuse gammaray background measured by Fermi are even more
pronounced in this case.
II.
HYPERNOVA AND SUPERNOVA
ENERGY INPUT RATE
HNe are are a sub-class of Type Ib/c SNe
with ejecta kinetic energies of order Ek =
1052 Ek,52 erg, representing a fraction ξhn ' 4 ×
10−2 ξhn,−1.4 of all core-collapse SNe, with substantial uncertainties, (e.g. [31–33]), which are
usually classified as broad-line Type Ibc SNe.
The rate of all core-collapse SNe is 1.06 ×
10−4 Mpc−3 yr−1 [e.g., 34], which implies a local
HN rate of Rhn ∼ 4 × 10−6 ξhn,−1.4 Mpc−3 yr−1 . If
fraction of the HN remnant kinetic energy transferred to cosmic rays to cosmic-rays is Ecr,hn '
2.8 × 1051 ergs, the CR energy density input
rate in the Universe is U˙ cr ' Ecr,hn Rhn '
1.2 × 1046 ξhn,−1.4 Ecr,51.4 erg Mpc−3 yr−1 . If the
CRs are protons with a power law distribution
N (εp ) ∝ ε−Γ
between εp,min ∼ 1 GeV and
p
εp,max <
∼ 1017 εp,17 eV, the energy density input
rate per logarithmic interval of energy is εp Qεp '
U˙ cr /C ergMpc−3 yr−1 , where the bolometric correction is C = ln (εp,max /εp,min ) for a spectral
index Γ = 2 [35]. Assuming Γ ∼ 2 and taking
C ∼ 18C18 the local (z = 0) CR energy input per
logarithmic interval in the Universe due to hyper-
Unresolved issues in the search for eta-mesic nuclei
arXiv:1501.04666v1 [nucl-th] 19 Jan 2015
N. G. Kelkar
Dept. de Fisica, Univ. de los Andes, Cra 1E, 18A-10, Bogota, Colombia
Even if the theoretical definition of an unstable state is straightforward, its experimental identification often depends on the method used in
the analysis and extraction of data. A good example is the case of eta mesic
nuclei where strong hints of their existence led to about three decades of
extensive theoretical and experimental searches. Considering the still undecided status of these states and the limitations in the understanding of the
eta-nucleon as well as the eta-nucleus interaction, the present article tries
to look back at some unresolved problems in the production mechanism
and final state interaction of the eta mesons and nuclei. An unconventional perspective which provides a physical insight into the nature of the
eta-nucleus interaction is also presented using quantum time concepts.
PACS numbers: 21.85.+d,13.60.Le,13.75.-n,03.65.Xp
1. Introduction
The strong nuclear interaction which is usually understood as the interaction between two nucleons is by now quite well known. However, the
interaction is mediated by mesons which are also strongly interacting objects and it makes sense to have a good understanding of the meson-nucleon
and especially the meson-nucleus interaction too. Hadron-nuclear interactions in general can be probed either via scattering experiments or the study
of bound states. It has been possible to investigate the pion-nucleus interaction through elastic scattering experiments, but the same is not true of
the heavier eta meson due to its being extremely short lived. Due to the
non-availability of eta beams, the eta-nucleon (η-N) interaction can only
be deduced via the eta-nucleon or eta-nucleus interaction in the final state.
Fortunately, its interaction with the nucleon in the s-wave (which proceeds
through the formation of an N∗ (1535) resonance) is attractive and leads to
the possibility of forming and studying unstable bound states of eta mesons
and nuclei [1] (see also [2, 3, 4] for an extensive list of references). After
about 25 years of investigations in this field, a lot of progress has been made
(1)
arXiv:1501.04655v1 [hep-th] 19 Jan 2015
typeset using the style of the
International Journal of Modern Physics B
c World Scientific Publishing Company
UTTG-05-15
ITEP-TH-46/14
TAUP-2991/15
HOLOGRAPHIC BARYONS AND INSTANTON CRYSTALS∗
VADIM KAPLUNOVSKY
Physics Theory Group and Texas Cosmology Center
University of Texas, Austin, TX 78712, USA
[email protected]
DMITRY MELNIKOV†
International Institute of Physics, Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte,
Av. Odilon Gomes de Lima 1722, Natal, RN 59078-400, Brazil
[email protected]
JACOB SONNENSCHEIN
The Raymond and Beverly Sackler School of Physics and Astronomy,
Tel Aviv University, Ramat Aviv 69978, Israel
[email protected]
In a wide class of holographic models, like the one proposed by Sakai and Sugimoto,
baryons can be approximated by instantons of non-abelian gauge fields that live on
the world–volume of flavor D–branes. In the leading order, those are just the Yang-Mills
instantons, whose solutions can be constructed from the celebrated ADHM construction.
This fact can be used to study various properties of baryons in the holographic limit.
In particular, one can attempt to construct a holographic description of the cold dense
nuclear matter phase of baryons. It can be argued that holographic baryons in such a
regime are necessarily in a solid crystalline phase. In this review we summarize the known
results on the construction and phases of crystals of the holographic baryons.
Keywords: cold dense nuclear matter; Sakai-Sugimoto model; holographic baryons; instantons.
1. Introduction
The 1980’s witnessed a revival of interest in the Skyrme model of baryons.1 At the
time there was a growing evidence that the correct low-energy description of baryons
is that of solitons of meson fields.2 The chiral Lagrangian, unknown at the time of
the Skyrme’s original work, provided a natural framework for the realization of this
idea.3 Starting with the work of Adkins, Nappi and Witten4 , many static properties
of baryons were computed using the Skyrme model. The approach produced many
∗ Prepared
for the special issue Skyrmion of the IJMPB, ed. by M. Rho and I. Zahed.
at the Institute for Theoretical and Experimental Physics, B. Cheremushkinskaya 25, 117218
Moscow, Russia.
† also
1
Holography and off-center collisions of localized shock waves
Paul M. Chesler
Department of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA∗
Laurence G. Yaffe
Department of Physics, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195, USA†
(Dated: January 21, 2015)
arXiv:1501.04644v1 [hep-th] 19 Jan 2015
Using numerical holography, we study the collision, at non-zero impact parameter, of bounded,
localized distributions of energy density chosen to mimic relativistic heavy ion collisions, in strongly
coupled N = 4 supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory. Both longitudinal and transverse dynamics in the
dual field theory are properly described. Using the gravitational description we solve 5D Einstein
equations, without dimensionality reducing symmetry restrictions, to find the asymptotically anti-de
Sitter spacetime geometry.
Introduction.— The recognition that the quark-gluon
plasma (QGP) produced in relativistic heavy ion collisions is strongly coupled [1] has prompted much work
using gauge/gravity duality (or “holography”) to study
aspects of non-equilibrium dynamics in strongly coupled
N = 4 supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory (SYM), which
may be viewed as a theoretically tractable toy model for
real QGP. Work to date has involved various idealizations
(boost invariance, planar shocks, imploding shells) which
reduce the dimensionality of the computational problem,
at the cost of eliminating significant aspects of the real
collision dynamics [2–7]. In this letter, we report the
results of the first calculation of this type which does
not impose unrealistic dimensionality reducing restrictions. We study the collision, at non-zero impact parameter, of bounded, localized distributions of energy density
which mimic colliding relativistic Lorentz-contracted nuclei and form stable incoming projectiles in strongly coupled SYM.
In the dual gravitational description our initial state
consists of two localized incoming gravitational waves, in
asymptotically anti-de Sitter (AdS) spacetime, which will
collide at non-zero impact parameter. The pre-collision
geometry contains a trapped surface and the collision results in the formation of a black brane. We numerically
solve the full 5D Einstein equations for the geometry after the collision and report on the evolution of the SYM
stress-energy tensor T µν .
Gravitational formulation.— We construct initial data
for Einstein’s equations by superimposing the metric of
gravitational shock waves moving in the ±z directions at
the speed of light. In Fefferman-Graham coordinates, the
metric of a single shock moving in the ±z direction is
2
2
ds2 = r2 −dt2 + dx2⊥ + dz 2 + dr
r 2 + h± (x⊥ , z∓ , r) dz∓ ,
(1)
where x⊥ ≡ {x, y}, z∓ ≡ z ∓ t, and
Z
d2 k ik·x⊥ e
8I2 (k/r)
e
H± (k, z∓ )
.
h± (x⊥ , z∓ , r) ≡
2
(2π)
k2 r2
(2)
The AdS curvature scale has been set to unity. The
boundary of the asymptotically AdS spacetime lies at
r = ∞. The single-shock metric (1) is an exact solution
e ± [8]. This geto Einstein’s equations for any choice of H
ometry represents a state in the dual SYM theory with
stress-energy tensor [15]
T 00 = T zz = ±T 0z = H± (x⊥ , z∓ ),
(3)
(and all other components vanishing), where H± is the
e ± . We choose H±
2D transverse Fourier transform of H
to be Gaussian,
H± (x⊥ , z∓ ) =
− 1 z 2 /w2
e √2 ∓
2πw2
2
1
e− 2 (x⊥ ∓b/2)
/R2
,
(4)
with transverse and longitudinal widths R = 4 and w =
1
3
ˆ
2 , respectively, and impact parameter b = 4 R x. Hence,
the stress tensor (3) describes localized lumps of energy
centered about x = ±b/2, y = 0, and z = ±t. Our
choice of H± fixes units in the results presented below;
the maximum longitudinally integrated energy density of
a single shock has been set to unity.
For early times, wt 1, the Gaussian profiles H± have
negligible overlap and the pre-collision geometry can be
constructed from (1) by replacing the last term with the
sum of corresponding terms from left and right moving
shocks. The resulting metric satisfies Einstein’s equations, at early times, up to exponentially small errors.
To evolve the pre-collision geometry forward in time
we use the characteristic formulation of gravitational dynamics in asymptotically AdS spacetimes discussed in
detail in Ref. [9]. Our metric ansatz reads
ds2 = r2 gµν (x, r) dxµ dxν + 2 dr dt ,
(5)
with Greek indices denoting spacetime boundary coordinates, xµ = (t, x, y, z). Near the boundary, gµν =
(4)
(4)
ηµν + gµν /r4 + O(1/r5 ). The sub-leading coefficients gµν
determine the SYM stress tensor,
(4)
T µν = gµν
+
1
4
(4)
ηµν g00 .
(6)
The time-dependent non-Abelian Aharonov-Bohm effect
Max Bright∗ and Douglas Singleton†
Department of Physics, California State University Fresno, Fresno, CA 93740-8031, USA
(Dated: January 19, 2015)
Abstract
arXiv:1501.03858v1 [hep-th] 16 Jan 2015
In this article, we study the time-dependent Aharonov-Bohm effect for non-Abelian gauge fields.
We use two well known time-dependent solutions to the Yang-Mills field equations to investigate
the Aharonov-Bohm phase shift. For both of the solutions, we find a cancellation between the
phase shift coming from the non-Abelian “magnetic” field and the phase shift coming from the
non-Abelian “electric” field, which inevitably arises in time-dependent cases. We compare and
contrast this cancellation for the time-dependent non-Abelian case to a similar cancellation which
occurs in the time-dependent Abelian case. We postulate that this cancellation occurs generally
in time-dependent situations for both Abelian and non-Abelian fields.
∗
Electronic address: [email protected]
†
Electronic address: [email protected]
1
UWThPh-2015-2
arXiv:1501.04942v1 [hep-ph] 20 Jan 2015
A complete survey of texture zeros
in general and symmetric quark mass matrices
P.O. Ludl∗ and W. Grimus∗∗
University of Vienna, Faculty of Physics
Boltzmanngasse 5, A–1090 Vienna, Austria
January 20, 2015
Abstract
We perform a systematic analysis of all possible texture zeros in general and
symmetric quark mass matrices. Using the values of masses and mixing parameters
at the electroweak scale, we identify for both cases the maximally restrictive viable
textures. Furthermore, we investigate the predictive power of these textures by
applying a numerical predictivity measure recently defined by us. With this measure
we find no predictive textures among the viable general quark mass matrices, while
in the case of symmetric quark mass matrices most of the 15 maximally restrictive
textures are predictive with respect to one or more light quark masses.
∗
∗∗
E-mail: [email protected]
E-mail: [email protected]
1
On relevance of triple gluon fusion in J/ψ hadroproduction
Leszek Motyka∗ and Mariusz Sadzikowski†
Institute of Physics, Jagiellonian University, Łojasiewicza 11, 30-348, Kraków, Poland
(Dated: January 21, 2015)
A contribution to J/ψ hadroproduction is analyzed in which the meson production is
mediated by three-gluon partonic state, with two gluons coming from the target and one
gluon from the projectile. This mechanism involves double gluon density in one of the pro-
arXiv:1501.04915v1 [hep-ph] 20 Jan 2015
tons, hence this contribution enters at a non-leading twist. It is, however, relevant due to
an enhancement factor coming from large double gluon density at small x. We calculate
the three-gluon contribution to J/ψ hadroproduction within perturbative QCD in the kT factorization framework. Results are obtained for differential pT -dependent cross-sections
for all J/ψ polarizations and for the sum over the polarization components. The rescattering contribution is found to provide a significant correction to the standard leading twist
cross-section at the energies of the Tevatron or the LHC at moderate pT . We suggest J/ψ
production in proton-nucleus collision as a possible probe of the triple gluon mechanism.
I.
INTRODUCTION
Production of heavy vector quarkonia in proton collisions has been a subject of intense experimental
and theoretical investigations since CDF found huge excess of the measured cross-sections of prompt
J/ψ [1] with respect to the standard theoretical predictions in QCD. Initially the theory predictions
were based on a leading order collinear QCD approximation, in which the hard matrix element of a
partonic color singlet subprocess gg → J/ψg gives the dominant contribution. This approximation,
however, underestimates badly the measured cross-section and yields an incorrect pT distribution of the
produced mesons, so it was necessary to consider alternative mechanisms of quarkonia hadroproduction.
In particular, two theoretical concepts received a lot of attention: the so called color octet model (COM)
[2–9] and the other approach based on the kT -factorization (KTF) scheme [10–15]. For a comprehensive
theory review of various approaches to quarkonium hadroproduction see [16].
The COM is based on the fact that the hadron wave functions contain higher Fock components. For
∗ Electronic
address: [email protected]
† Electronic
address: [email protected]
Constraining spacetime variations of nuclear decay rates from
light curves of type Ia supernovae
Ivan Karpikov, Maxim Piskunov and Sergey Troitsky1
arXiv:1501.04909v1 [hep-ph] 20 Jan 2015
1
Institute for Nuclear Research of the Russian Academy of Sciences,
60th October Anniversary Prospect 7a, Moscow 117312, Russia∗
(Dated: January 20, 2015)
Abstract
The luminosity of fading type Ia supernovae is governed by radioactive decays of
56 Ni
and
56 Co.
The decay rates are proportional to the Fermi coupling constant GF and, therefore, are determined
by the vacuum expectation value v of the Brout–Englert–Higgs field. We use the publicly available
SNLS and UNION2.1 sets of lightcurves of type Ia supernova at various redshifts to constrain
possible spacetime variations of the
56 Ni
decay rate. The resulting constraint is not very tight;
however, it is the only direct bound on the variation of the decay rate for redshifts up to z ∼ 1.
We discuss potential applications of the result to searches for non-constancy of GF and v.
PACS numbers: 06.20.Jr, 95.30.Cq, 97.60.Bw
∗
[email protected]
1
arXiv:1501.04883v1 [hep-ph] 20 Jan 2015
Exploring NSIs in B + → π +υυ and B → Xsυυ
with three generations of quarks
Shakeel Mahmood(1) ; Farida Tahir; Azeem Mir
Comsats Institute of Information Technology,
Department of Physics, Park Road, Chek Shazad,Islamabad
(1)
shakeel [email protected]
Abstract
We study the rare decays B + → π + υυ and B → Xs υυ for the search
of NSIs. We want to constraint the NSIs by using these reactions. We
show that there is a strong dependence of thse reactions on new physics
parameter ǫQL
τ τ ,where Q = u, c, t. We include second and third generation
of quarks in the loop for these decays. We further point out that the
tL
uL
constraints for ǫcL
τ τ are more precise as compared to ǫτ τ and ǫτ τ . We further
point out that for B → Xs υυ, the u quark induce NSIs are giving very
very small contribution
Keywords: NSIs, rare decays, B decays.
PACS numbers: 12.60.-i, 13.15.+g, 13.20.-v
1
Introduction
After the remarkable discovery of Higgs by the ATLAS [1] and CMS [2] collaboration and confirmation in [3] that it is Standard Model (SM) higgs, one
important question arises. Is there any room for new physics (NP) beyond SM?
No doubt SM predictions have been verified experimentally to the highest level
of precision [4][5]. But, along with other limitations, SM lacks any explanation for a possible pattern for particle mass, known as mass hierarchy problem.
SM can not predict top quark mass without experimental evidence. The experiments on B meson [6][7][8] are also giving some cracks in standard model.
We are yet unable to explain dark matter and matter anti-matter asymmetry.
Gravity is not included in the SM. Theoretically SM is thought to be unsatisfactory and there can be some new particles as well as new interactions. It
has been believed that standard model is a low energy approximation of more
general theory. So, many theoretical extensions of SM has been presented. But,
so far, the only concrete evidence against it has been provided by the neutrino
oscillations [9] [10][11][12][13][14][15]. To explore NP the study of mesonic rare
decays involving neutrinos in final state, can be interesting. These decays proceeds through flavor changing neutral currents (FCNC), highly suppressed [16]
1
January 21, 2015
arXiv:1501.04838v1 [hep-ph] 20 Jan 2015
Summary of the CKM 2014 working group on rare decays
Thomas Blake1 , Akimasa Ishikawa2 , David M. Straub3
1
Department of Physics, Univeristy of Warwick, UK
Department of Physics, Tohoku University, Japan
3
Universe Cluster, TU Munich, Germany
2
Rare flavour changing neutral current decays of strange, charm and beauty
hadrons have been instrumental in building up a picture of flavour in
the Standard Model. Increasingly precise measurements of these decays
allow to search for deviations from predictions of the Standard Model
that would be associated to contributions from new particles that might
arise in extensions of the Standard Model. In this summary, an overview
of recent experimental results and theoretical predictions is given. The
new physics sensitivity and prospects for the different observables is also
addressed.
PRESENTED AT
8th International Workshop on the CKM Unitarity Triangle
(CKM 2014), Vienna, Austria, September 8-12, 2014
1
Introduction
Weak flavour-changing neutral current (FCNC) decays of hadrons are loop and CKM
suppressed in the Standard Model (SM). These rare decays played an important role in
formulating the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa picture of quark mixing. They continue
to play an important role in theory and experiment as they are potentially sensitive
to contributions from heavy physics beyond the SM. Compared to meson-antimeson
mixing, rare decays provide a much larger number of observables susceptible to such
new physics effects. The flavour, CP , and chirality structure of new interactions can
be probed by branching fractions and various decay asymmetries in decays of strange,
charm, and beauty hadrons. In the SM, lepton flavour is conserved by accidental symmetries and searches for charged lepton flavour violation can also provide important
null tests of the SM.
The past two years have seen a wealth of new measurements of rare b- and chadron decay processes by the ATLAS, CMS and LHCb experiments at the LHC and
from the legacy datasets of the BaBar and Belle experiments. There have also been
updated limits on lepton flavour violating processes, including results from the MEG
experiment and first results from a pilot run of the KOTO experiment. An overview
of the experimental and theoretical status of these measurements is given below.
2
Rare b-hadron decays
Rare FCNC decays of b-hadrons are described by the weak effective Hamiltonian
e2 X
4 GF
(Ci Qi + Ci0 Q0i ) + h.c.,
Heff = − √ Vtb Vtq∗
16π 2 i
2
(1)
where q = d, s for processes based on the quark-level b → d, s transition. Among the
dimension six operators contributing to these transitions, the operators most sensitive
to new physics effects are
q(0)
Q7
q(0)
Q9
q(0)
QS
QqL(R)
mb
(qσµν PR(L) b)F µν ,
e
= (qγµ PL(R) b)(`γ µ `) ,
=
= (qPR(L) b)(``) ,
= (qγµ PL(R) b)(νγ µ PL ν) .
q(0)
Q8
q(0)
Q10
q(0)
QP
mb
(qσµν PR(L) T a b)Gaµν ,
e
= (qγµ PL(RR b)(`γ µ γ5 `) ,
=
= (qPR(L) b)(`γ5 `) ,
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
Here, PL,R denote left and right-hand chirality projections and F µν and Gaµν are the
electromagnetic and chromagnetic field strength tensors, respectively. The electro(0)
(0)
magnetic and chromomagnetic dipole operators (Q7 and Q8 ) contribute to radiative
(0)
and semileptonic decays. The semileptonic operators Q10,S,P contribute to leptonic
1
Explaining the CMS eejj and ep
/T jj Excess and Leptogenesis in Superstring Inspired
E6 Models
Mansi Dhuria,1, ∗ Chandan Hati,1, 2, † Raghavan Rangarajan,1, ‡ and Utpal Sarkar1, §
1
arXiv:1501.04815v1 [hep-ph] 20 Jan 2015
2
Physical Research Laboratory, Navrangpura, Ahmedabad 380 009, India
Indian Institute of Technology Gandhinagar, Chandkheda, Ahmedabad 382 424, India.
(Dated: January 21, 2015)
We show that superstring inspired E6 models can explain both the recently detected excess eejj
and ep
/T jj signals at CMS, and also allow for leptogenesis. Working in a R-parity conserving low
energy supersymmetric effective model, we show that the excess CMS events can be produced
via the decay of exotic sleptons in alternative left-right symmetric models of E6 , which can also
accommodate leptogenesis at a high scale. On the other hand, either the eejj excess or the ep
/T jj
excess can be produced via the decays of right handed gauge bosons, but some of these scenarios
may not accommodate letptogenesis as there will be strong B − L violation at low energy, which,
along with the anomalous fast electroweak B + L violation, will wash out all baryon asymmetry.
Baryogenesis below the electroweak scale may then need to be implemented in these models.
PACS numbers: 98.80.Cq,12.60.-i,12.60.Jv,14.60.St,11.30.Fs
I.
INTRODUCTION
Recently the CMS Collaboration at the LHC at CERN
announced their results for the right-handed
√ gauge boson
WR search at a center of mass energy of s = 8TeV and
19.7fb−1 of integrated luminosity. They detect a 2.8σ
excess in the pp → ee + 2j channel at 1.8TeV < Meejj <
2.2TeV, which however can not be explained by WR decay in Left-Right Symmetric Models (LRSM) with strict
left-right symmetry (gauge couplings gL = gR ) [1]. The
CMS search for √
di-leptoquark production, at a center of
mass energy of s = 8TeV and 19.6fb−1 of integrated
luminosity has reported a 2.4σ and a 2.6σ local excess in
eejj and ep
/T jj channels respectively, and has excluded
the first generation scalar leptoquarks with masses less
than 1005 (845) GeV for β = 1(0.5), where β is the
branching fraction of a leptoquark to a charged lepton
and a quark [2]. A few attempts have been made to explain the above CMS excesses in the context of different
models. The excesses have been explained in the context of WR decay by embedding the conventional LRSM
(gL 6= gR ) in the SO(10) gauge group in Refs. [3, 4]. The
eejj excess has been discussed in the context of WR and
Z 0 gauge boson production and decay in Ref. [5]. The
excesses have also been interpreted as due to pair production of vector-like leptons in Refs. [6]. In Refs. [7, 8],
the excess of eejj events has been shown to occur in Rparity violating processes via the resonant production of
a slepton.
The conventional LRSM (even embedded in higher
gauge groups) are inconsistent with the canonical mechanism of leptogenesis in the predicted range of the mass
∗ Electronic
address:
address:
‡ Electronic address:
§ Electronic address:
† Electronic
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
of WR (∼ 2 TeV) at CMS [9]. In these models, leptogenesis can generate the lepton asymmetry in two possible ways: (i) decay of right-handed Majorana neutrinos
which do not conserve lepton number [10] (ii) decay of
very heavy Higgs triplet scalars with couplings that break
lepton number [11]. Since the right-handed neutrinos
interact with the SU (2)R gauge bosons, the WR interactions with the right-handed neutrino N can wash out
any existing primordial B −L asymmetry, and hence also
baryon and lepton asymmetry in the presence of anomalous (B + L) violating interactions before the electroweak
phase transition. Successful primordial leptogenesis involving N decay for mWR > mN then requires mWR &
2 × 105 GeV(mN /102 GeV)3/4 if leptogenesis occurs at
T = mN and mWR & 3 × 106 GeV(mN /102 GeV)2/3 if it
occurs at T > mWR . Note that the mN > mWR option is
excluded in supersymmetric theories with gravitinos [9].
Thus, the observed 1.8 TeV < mWR < 2.2 TeV bounds at
CMS imply that the decay of right-handed neutrinos can
not generate the required amount of lepton and baryon
asymmetry of the universe in the conventional LRSM.
Such models would then require some other mechanism
to generate the baryon asymmetry of the universe. With
regards to the interpretation of the excess events as due to
leptoquarks, it is difficult to accommodate any scenario
that allows a light leptoquark in any simple extension of
the standard model.
In this article, we attempt to find other simple extensions of the standard model which can explain the excess CMS events and simultaneously explain the baryon
asymmetry of the universe via leptogenesis. To this end
we explore whether superstring inspired models have all
the necessary ingredients embedded in their effective lowenergy theories. We first study the possible decay modes
of right-handed gauge bosons in the three effective lowenergy subgroups of the superstring inspired E6 model.
We point out that it is not possible to explain the excess
of both eejj and ep
/T jj events from the the right-handed
gauge boson decay and accommodate leptogenesis simul-
Nuclear Physics B
Proceedings
Supplement
Nuclear Physics B Proceedings Supplement 00 (2015) 1–7
State-of-the-Art Predictions for C-parameter and a Determination of α s
Andr´e H. Hoang1,2 , Daniel W. Kolodrubetz3 , Vicent Mateu1,∗ , Iain W. Stewart3
1 University
arXiv:1501.04753v1 [hep-ph] 20 Jan 2015
2 Erwin
of Vienna, Faculty of Physics, Boltzmanngasse 5, A-1090 Wien, Austria
Schr¨odinger International Institute for Mathematical Physics, University of Vienna, Boltzmanngasse 9, A-1090 Vienna, Austria
3 Center
for Theoretical Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA
∗
Speaker
Preprint numbers: UWTHPH 2014-24, MIT–CTP 4601, LPN14-122
Abstract
The C-parameter event-shape distribution for e+ e− annihilation into hadrons is computed in the framework of
SCET including input from fixed-order perturbation theory. We calculate all missing ingredients for achieving N3 LL
resummation accuracy in the cross section, which is then matched onto O(α3s ) fixed-order results. Hadronization
power corrections are incorporated as a convolution with a nonperturbative shape function. Wide-angle soft radiation
effects introduce an O(ΛQCD ) renormalon ambiguity in the cross section, which we cure by switching to the Rgap
short-distance scheme. We also include hadron mass effects, but find their effect is rather small. Performing fits to
the tail of the C-parameter distribution for many center of mass energies we find that the strong coupling constant is
α s (mZ ) = 0.1123 ± 0.0015, with χ2 /dof = 0.99.
Keywords: QCD, Jets, Event Shapes, Precision Physics, Higher Order Computations, Effective Field Theories
1. Introduction
+ −
The LEP e e collider, previously located at CERN,
has delivered an enormous amount of highly accurate
experimental data, which can be used to explore the theory of strong interactions in its high-energy regime. To
study Quantum Chromodynamics (or QCD) at high energies one needs to deal with jets: highly boosted and
collimated bunches of particles that can be seen as the
remnants of the underlying partons created at very short
distances. One appealing strategy for describing jet dynamics is through event shapes, infrared- and collinearsafe observables which are constructed from the energy
and momenta of all the produced hadrons (in this sense
event shapes are global quantities). They are designed
to measure geometrical properties of the distribution of
particles, and in particular they quantify how “jetty” the
final state is. Additionally, being global observables, it
is possible to compute high-order perturbative correc-
tions, carry out log resummation to higher order, show
factorization and exponentiation properties, and use factorization to control power corrections.
One of the main uses of event-shape distributions is
the determination of the strong coupling constant α s .
The advantage of event shapes over other inclusive observables is that they are essentially proportional to α s ,
rather than probing α s via corrections to a leading term
(as is the case, for example, of DIS or the total hadronic
cross section). Thus, event shapes are very sensitive to
the strong coupling constant. On the other hand, event
shapes are afflicted by nonperturbative power corrections and by large double Sudakov logarithms, which
necessitate resummation.
Here we study the C-parameter which can be written
as [1, 2]:
P
2
3 i, j |~pi ||~p j | sin θi j
.
(1)
C=
P
2
pi | 2
i |~
Generalized Parton Distributions of proton for non zero skewness
in transverse and longitudinal position spaces
Narinder Kumar and Harleen Dahiya
Department of Physics,
arXiv:1501.04745v1 [hep-ph] 20 Jan 2015
Dr. B.R. Ambedkar National Institute of Technology,
Jalandhar, 144011, India
Abstract
We investigate the Generalized Parton Distributions (GPDs) of proton by expressing them in
terms of overlaps of light front wave functions (LFWFs) using a simulated model which is able
to qualitatively improve the convergence near the end points of x. We study the spin non-flip
H(x, ζ, t) and spin flip E(x, ζ, t) part of GPDs for the particle conserving n → n overlap in the
DGLAP region (ζ < x < 1). The Fourier transform (FT) of the GPDs w.r.t. to the transverse
momentum transfer as well the FT of the GPDs w.r.t. ζ have also been obtained giving the
distribution of partons in the transverse position space and the distribution in the longitudinal
position space respectively. Diffraction pattern is obtained for both H(x, σ, t) and E(x, σ, t) in the
longitudinal position space.
1
Fluctuating Heavy Quark Energy Loss in Strongly-Coupled Quark-Gluon Plasma
W. A. Horowitz
arXiv:1501.04693v1 [hep-ph] 20 Jan 2015
Department of Physics, University of Cape Town,
Private Bag X3, Rondebosch 7701, South Africa∗
Results from an energy loss model that includes thermal fluctuations in the energy loss for heavy
quarks in a strongly-coupled plasma are shown to be qualitatively consistent with single particle
data from both RHIC and LHC. The model used is the first to properly include the fluctuations
in heavy quark energy loss as derived in string theory and that do not obey the usual fluctuationdissipation relations. These fluctuations are crucial for simultaneously describing both RHIC and
LHC data; leading order drag results without fluctuations are falsified by current data. Including
the fluctuations is non-trivial and relies on the Wong-Zakai theorem to fix the numerical Langevin
implementation. The fluctuations lead to surprising results: B meson anisotropy is similar to that for
D mesons at LHC, and the double ratio of D to B meson nuclear modification factors approaches
unity more rapidly than even predictions from perturbative energy loss models. It is clear that
future work in improving heavy quark energy loss calculations in AdS/CFT to include all energy
loss channels is needed and warranted.
PACS numbers: 12.38.Mh, 24.85.+p, 25.75.-q
Keywords: Quark-Gluon Plasma, AdS/CFT Correspondence, Heavy Quarks
I.
INTRODUCTION
The goal of heavy ion collision research is to map out
the many-body properties of quantum chromodynamics
at extreme temperatures. Simultaneously, this research
provides insight into the confinement transition of QCD
matter and yields information on the earliest moments of
the Universe’s existence: currently, no other experimental program can reach back as far in time [1].
The fireballs created in central RHIC and LHC heavy
ion collisions reach temperatures of a trillion degrees [2–
5]; at this temperature the many-body dynamics of colored material is very different from that of normal nuclear matter [6]. The best way of theoretically understanding this material is not yet known. Simple questions such as “What are the relevant degrees of freedom
for the system?” do not yet have a clear answer. At the
most basic level, it is not clear how to reconcile experimental results that, na¨ıvely, simultaneously suggest a
strongly-coupled plasma that evolves hydrodynamically
and a weakly-coupled gas of slightly modified quarks and
gluons that yields a plasma relatively transparent to hard
probes.
In order to make progress as a field it is necessary to
attempt to effect such a reconciliation of ideas of the nature of the plasma into a consistent theoretical picture
that yields quantitatively consistent comparisons with
experimental data. Focusing on two major avenues of
investigations, low transverse momentum (low-pT ) observables that are described well by near-ideal relativistic hydrodynamics switched on very soon after the initial collision overlap [2–5] and high-pT observables associated with hard production described by perturbative quantum chromodynamics (pQCD) [7–9], the low-pT
∗
[email protected]
observables appear readily understood within a strongcoupling paradigm for the plasma in which calculations
are performed using the AdS/CFT correspondence [10–
12] while the high-pT observables appear readily understood within a weak-coupling paradigm for the plasma in
which calculations are performed using pQCD [7].
Specifically, leading order derivations exploiting
the AdS/CFT correspondence found that quark-gluon
plasma (QGP)-like systems have thermodynamic properties such as entropy density similar to those seen from
the lattice [6, 10]; rapidly hydrodynamize after a heavy
ion collision-like event [13], i.e. nearly ideal relativistic
hydrodynamics approximates well the dynamics of the
system soon after a heavy ion collision as is inferred from
data; and have a very small shear viscosity-to-entropy ratio η/s ∼ 0.1 in natural units [10, 11], again as inferred
from hydrodynamics studies of data [2–5]. At the same
time, leading order derivations based on pQCD show differences to thermodynamic properties [14], do not hydrodynamize rapidly [15], and have a viscosity-to-entropy
ratio η/s ∼ 1 [16] at least an order of magnitude larger
than that inferred from hydrodynamics.
On the other hand, energy loss models for light and
heavy flavored particles based on calculations using leading order pQCD show broad qualitative agreement with
data from both RHIC and LHC [7–9]. At the same time,
early light flavor [17] and leading order heavy flavor [18]
energy loss models using AdS/CFT found or suggested
a massive oversuppression of high-pT leading particles
compared to data.
Much work has been done to improve perturbative
field theoretic treatments of soft, or low-pT , observables.
For example there are high-order thermal field theory
calculations of thermodynamic properties of the QGP
[19] and recent work suggested that pQCD can yield
rapid isotropization times of 0.2 − 1.0 fm [20]. The
small viscosity-to-entropy ratio inferred from hydrody-
Renormalization group improved QCD prediction for Υ(1S) leptonic decay
Jian-Ming Shen, Xing-Gang Wu,∗ Hong-Hao Ma, Huan-Yu Bi, and Sheng-Quan Wang
arXiv:1501.04688v1 [hep-ph] 20 Jan 2015
Department of Physics, Chongqing University, Chongqing 401331, P.R. China and
Institute of Theoretical Physics, Chongqing University, Chongqing 401331, P.R. China
(Dated: January 21, 2015)
The complete next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order short-distance and bound-state QCD corrections to Υ(1S) leptonic decay rate Γ(Υ(1S) → ℓ+ ℓ− ) has been finished by Beneke etal. [5]. Based
on those improvements, we present a renormalization group (RG) improved pQCD prediction for
Γ(Υ(1S) → ℓ+ ℓ− ) by applying the principle of maximum conformality (PMC). The PMC is based
on RG-invariance and is designed to solve the renormalization scheme and scale ambiguities. After
applying the PMC for Υ(1S) leptonic decay, all known-type of β-terms at all orders, which are controlled by the RG-equation, are resummed to determine optimal renormalization scales for its strong
running coupling at each perturbative order. We then achieve a more convergent pQCD series, a
scheme-independent and more accurate pQCD prediction, i.e. ΓΥ(1S)→e+ e− |PMC = 1.361+0.154
−0.214 keV,
where the uncertainty is squared average of the mentioned pQCD error sources. This RG-improved
pQCD prediction agrees well with the experimental measurement within errors.
PACS numbers: 13.20.-v, 13.20.He, 12.38.Bx, 11.15.Bt
Heavy quarkonium provides an ideal platform for
studying non-relativistic theories, such as the nonrelativistic Quantum Chromodynamics (NRQCD) [1]
and the potential NRQCD (PNRQCD) [2]. In general,
because vb2 < vc2 and αs (mb ) < αs (mc ), the perturbative
results for the bottomonium will be more convergent over
the αs - and v 2 - expansion than the charmonium cases,
where v(b,c) stands for the relative velocity of constituent
b or c quark in the bottomonium or charmonium rest
frame. If enough bottomonium events can be generated
at an experimental platform, we can achieve a relatively
more definite test of those non-relativistic theories than
the charmonium cases.
Being an important high-energy process, the leptonic
decay of the ground-state bottomonium Υ(1S) has been
studied up to next-to-leading order (NLO) [3], next-tonext-to-leading order (N2 LO) [4], and next-to-next-tonext-to-leading order (N3 LO) [5]. However, even by including the recent complete N3 LO QCD corrections for
both short-distance and bound-state parts, the pQCD
prediction for the decay rate ΓΥ(1S)→e+ e− is about 30%
lower than the PDG value, i.e. ΓΥ(1S)→e+ e− |Exp. =
1.340(18) keV [6]. Even worse, its pQCD convergence
is questionable and one does not know what’s the optimal behavior of the running coupling. It is noted that the
questionable pQCD series is caused by using conventional
scale setting, in which the renormalization scale is simply
fixed to be ∼ 3.5 GeV that leads to maximum decay rate
and the renormalization scale uncertainty is predicted by
varying it within the range µr ∈ [3, 10] GeV [5]. To solve
such renormalization scale ambiguity and to improve the
pQCD prediction, we shall use the principle of maximum
conformality (PMC) [7–11] to deal with Υ(1S) leptonic
decay rate up to N3 LO level.
The PMC provides a systematic procedure to set the
optimal renormalization scale for high-energy processes
at any order. The behavior of the running coupling is
governed by renormalization group (RG)-equation, i.e.
the β-function [12, 13]. This provides underlying principal for PMC, i.e., the optimal behavior of running coupling is achieved by resumming all those β-terms related
to the renormalization of running coupling into the running coupling. The PMC scales of the running coupling
at each order are determined such that no terms proportional to the β-function remain. Such a kind of βresummation shall in principal improve the QCD convergence due to the elimination of divergent renormalon
terms. The resulting pQCD series is thus identical to a
scheme-independent conformal series. It has been found
that the PMC follows the RG-invariance and satisfies all
the RG-properties [14]. In the paper, we shall show that
after applying the PMC, a more accurate Υ(1S) leptonic
decay rate can indeed be achieved.
The decay rate for the channel, Υ(1S) → ℓ+ ℓ− , can be
formulated as
ΓΥ(1S)→ℓ+ ℓ− =
[email protected]
(1)
where α is the fine structure constant, mb is the b-quark
pole mass, and Z1 stands for the residue of the 1S-wave
two-point correlation function near b¯b-threshold, which
can be written as [15]
dv
E1
2
+ · · · , (2)
cv +
Z1 = |ψ1 (0)| cv cv −
mb
3
where cv and dv are matching coefficients of the leading
and sub-leading b¯b currents within the NRQCD, whose
perturbative forms are
cv = 1 +
n
X
k=1
∗
4πα2
Z1 ,
9m2b
ck aks ,
dv = 1 +
n
X
dk aks ,
(3)
k=1
where as = αs /4π. Here |ψ1 (0)| and E1 are renormalized
wavefunction at the origin and binding energy of Υ(1S),
‘Exotic vector-like pair’ of color-triplet scalars
Andrea Addazi
1
Dipartimento di Fisica, Universit`a di L’Aquila, 67010 Coppito AQ and LNGS, Laboratori Nazionali del Gran Sasso, 67010 Assergi AQ, Italy
arXiv:1501.04660v1 [hep-ph] 19 Jan 2015
Abstract
We propose a minimal extension of Standard Model, generating a Majorana mass for neutron, connected with a mechanism of Post-Sphaleron
Baryogenesis. We consider an ‘exotic vector-like pair’ of color-triplet scalars,
an extra Majorana fermion ψ, and a scalar field φ, giving mass to ψ. The
vector-like pair is defined ‘exotic’ because of a peculiar mass term of the
color-triplet scalars, violating Baryon number as ∆B = 1. A Post-Sphaleron
Baryogenesis is realized through φ-decays into six quarks (antiquarks), or
through ψ-decays into three quarks (antiquarks). This model suggests some
intriguing B-violating signatures, testable in the next future, in NeutronAntineutron physics and LHC. We put direct limits from top-jet and dijets channels on exotic vector-like pairs around 1 TeV (top-jet 900 GeV, dijets 1.2 TeV). We also discuss limits from FCNC. Alternatively, the exotic
vector-like pair may have a mass higher than 103÷4 TeV, and sterile fermion
can be light as 1 − 1000 GeV. In this case, the sterile fermion could be
(meta)-stable and n − n
¯ oscillation can be indirectly generated by two n − ψ,
ψ−n
¯ oscillations, without needing of an effective Majorana mass for neutron. Majorana fermion ψ can be a good candidate for WIMP-like dark
matter; but the proposed Post-Sphaleron Baryogenesis is not compatible
with this scenario.
1
Introduction
Has the neutron a Majorana mass or not? This is not just an academic question.
Majorana himself proposed in ‘37’, that neutron could have a Majorana mass term
δm nn + h.c [1]. We do not know if Majorana understood immediately the depth of
his proposal; but today we get that existence of a ”Majorana’s fermion” is related
to baryon or lepton numbers’ violations. In particular, a Majorana mass for neutron
implies a neutron-antineutron transition, violating baryon number by ∆B = 2 [2,
3, 4]. The current limit on n − n
¯ is τn¯n = 1/δm > 0.86 × 108 s with 90% C.L.,
implying δm < 7.7 × 10−24 eV [5]. This corresponds to a constraint M > 300 TeV
on the effective operator (udd)2 /M5 . This limit is particularly loose with respect to
1
E-mail:
[email protected]
1
The twofold emergence of the a1 axial vector meson
in high energy hadronic production
Jean-Louis Basdevant∗
Physics Department, Ecole Polytechnique, 91128 Palaiseau, France
Edmond L. Berger†
arXiv:1501.04643v1 [hep-ph] 19 Jan 2015
High Energy Physics Division, Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne, Illinois 60439, USA
The high statistics COMPASS results on diffractive dissociation πN → πππN suggest that the
isospin I = 1 spin-parity J P C = 1++ a1 (1260) resonance could be split into two states: a1 (1260)
decaying into an S-wave ρπ system, and a′1 (1420) decaying into a P-wave f0 (980)π system. We
analyse the reaction by incorporating our previous treatment of resonant re-scattering corrections
in the Drell-Deck forward production process. Our results show that the COMPASS results are fully
consistent with the existence of a single axial-vector a1 resonance. The characteristic structure of
the production process, which differs in the two orbital angular momentum states, plays a crucial
role in this determination. Provided the theoretical analysis of the reaction is done in a consistent
manner, this single resonance produces two peaks at different locations in the two channels, with a
rapid increase of the phase difference between their amplitudes arising mainly from the structure of
the production process itself, and not from a dynamical resonance effect. In addition, this analysis
clarifies questions related to the mass, width, and decay rates of the a1 resonance.
PACS numbers: 12.40.Yx, 13.25.Jx
I.
INTRODUCTION
Results of unprecedented precision are emerging from
the COMPASS experiment at the CERN SPS where
beams of 190 GeV pions interact with proton or nuclear targets, providing new insight into the properties
of light mesons [1]. This investigation is of significant
interest since it is bound to clarify low-energy hadron
spectroscopy, where the situation of some states is somewhat confused compared to expectations in a naive view
of the standard model.
In this paper, we concentrate on a question of importance for many reasons: the isospin 1 axial-vector resonance a1 (reported in the Particle Data Compilation
as a(1)(1260) [2].) Evidence emerges in the COMPASS
data for a new narrow J P C = 1++ axial-vector state
with isospin 1, strongly coupled to the πf0 (980) system.
This observation of a peak in the axial-vector two body
πf0 (980) P-wave intensity at a mass of 1.42 GeV, combined with a phase motion close to 180◦ with respect to
other waves, appears at face-value to mean that a second axial-vector resonance is present, close in mass to
the known broad a1 (1260) that couples mainly to the πρ
meson channel [1]. While these three features, i.e. two
peaks at different masses and a rapid phase variation, are
clearly present, there are reasons to be surprised, among
which we mention the following:
1. The a1 (1260) is a central member of the axialvector nonet, which, together with the J P =
∗ Electronic
† Electronic
address: [email protected]
address: [email protected]
0− , 1− , and 0+ (the latter being somewhat illdetermined yet) form the ground-state of the light
quark-antiquark spectrum. A newcomer in the
family would be difficult to accommodate.
2. It is peculiar to have two J P C = 1++ three-pion
states, with identical quantum numbers, close in
mass (within a full width of each other), with
orthogonal decay modes, without the presence of
some new quantum number. The KS0 − KL0 system
led to decisive discoveries in fundamental physics;
neutrino mixing is a spectacular current example.
However, in the a1 case, we see no candidate for a
distinguishing quantum number.
3. In the succesful quark-antiquark potential model
approaches to the hadron spectrum, there is no sign
that two bound states with identical quantum numbers and comparable masses could be constructed
from the u and d quarks (unless the potential is
pathological). One would have to resort perhaps to
a four-quark or molecule-type object.
4. Regarding the COMPASS data, we may mention
that a similar situation may exist in the case of
the production of the π2 (1670) and a π2′ as s- and
d-waves of πf0 (1270). We defer this consideration
and report here only on the a1 .
Our basic approach to high energy forward production
of three pion states in pion-nucleon interactions is the
Drell-Deck model [3]. This model has been studied
extensively in the production of the J P = 1+ ρπ system
[4, 5], and here we extend the analysis to the J P = 1+
f0 (980)π system.
An important difference is that
whereas the ρπ system is in an orbital S-wave state, the
Color confinement and screening in the θ -vacuum
Dmitri E. Kharzeev1, 2, ∗ and Eugene M. Levin3, 4, †
1
arXiv:1501.04622v1 [hep-ph] 19 Jan 2015
Department of Physics and Astronomy, Stony Brook University, New York 11794-3800, USA
2
Department of Physics and RIKEN-BNL Research Center,
Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York 11973-5000, USA
3
Department of Particle Physics, School of Physics and Astronomy, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, 69978, Israel
4
Departamento de F´ısica, Universidad T´
ecnica Federico Santa Mar´ıa and
Centro Cient´ıfico-Tecnol´
ogico de Valpara´ıso, Casilla 110-V, Valparaiso, Chile
(Dated: January 21, 2015)
QCD perturbation theory ignores the compact nature of SU (3) gauge group that gives rise to
the periodic θ-vacuum of the theory. We propose to modify the gluon propagator to reconcile
perturbation theory with the anomalous Ward identities for the topological current in the θ-vacuum.
As a result, the gluon couples to the Veneziano ghost describing the tunneling transitions between
different Chern-Simons sectors of the vacuum; we call the emerging gluon dressed by ghost loops a
“glost”. We evaluate the glost propagator and find that it has the form G(p) = (p2 + χtop /p2 )−1
where χtop is the Yang-Mills topological susceptibility related to the η 0 mass by Witten-Veneziano
−1/4
relation; this propagator describes confinement of gluons at distances ∼ χtop ' 1 fm. The same
functional form of the propagator was originally proposed by Gribov as a solution to the gauge
copies problem that plagues perturbation theory. The resulting running coupling coincides with the
√
perturbative one at p2 χtop , but in the infrared region either freezes (in pure Yang-Mills theory)
or vanishes (in full QCD with light quarks), in accord with experimental evidence. Our scenario
makes explicit the connection between confinement and topology of the QCD vacuum; we discuss
the implications for spin physics, high energy scattering, and the physics of quark-gluon plasma.
PACS numbers: 25.75.Bh, 13.87.Fh, 12.38.Mh
QCD possesses a compact gauge group that allows for topologically non-trivial gauge field configurations. These
configurations realize homotopy maps from the gauge group to the space-time manifold. For example, the homotopy
map from the SU(2) subgroup of the gauge group to the Euclidean space-time sphere S3 describes the instanton
solution [1]. However the compactness of the gauge group is ignored in perturbation theory, and this may be at the
origin of problems marring the perturbative approach.
In QCD, one of these problems is the existence of Gribov copies [2] – multiple solutions of the gauge-fixing condition
that make the perturbative approach ambiguous. In Coulomb gauge, the emergence of Gribov copies can be traced
back to the existence of energy-degenerate vacua with different Chern-Simons numbers [3]. A natural question arises
– is it possible to formulate QCD perturbation theory in a way that is consistent with the topological structure of
the theory? In this Letter we argue that the answer to this question is positive. We find that the resulting gluon
propagator naturally describes confinement, i.e. non-propagation of color degrees of freedom, and the running coupling
displays the screening of color charge at large distances.
In Minkowski space-time, instanton solutions represent the tunneling events connecting the degenerate vacuum
states with different Chern-Simons numbers
Z
X(t) = d3 x K0 (x, t),
(1)
where K0 is the temporal component of topological current
g2
1 abc ρ σ
ν,a
ρ σ,a
A
∂
A
+
gC
A
;
Kµ =
A
µνρσ
b c
16π 2
3
(2)
the first term in K0 is the density of Abelian “magnetic helicity” while the second term is its non-Abelian generalization.
The chiral anomaly in QCD leads to non-conservation of the axial current
X
µ
∂µ JA
= 2Nf Q(x) +
(2imf )¯
qf γ5 qf ,
(3)
f