1. health and fitness
2. disease

PHILIPPINE
HEART
CENTER
JOURNAL
ISSN 0118-9034
Volume 9, January - December 2002
Official Publication of the Philippine Heart Center
EDITORS
AND
CONSULTANTS
Editor-in-Chief
Jose A. Yulde, MD
Associate Editors
Aristides G. Panlilio, MD
Jerry M. Obaldo, MD
Editorial Board
Ricardo G. Agbayani, MD
Noe A. Babilonia, MD
Milagros S. Bautista, MD
Annette P. Borromeo, MD
Teofilo C. Cantre, MD
Ma. Belen O. Carisma, MD
Ma. Lourdes SR. Casas, MD
Emerenciana C. Collado, MD
Ma. Bernadette O. Cruz, MD
Marcelito L. Durante, MD
Raul D. Jara, MD
Ma. Encarnita C. Blanco-Limpin, MD
Florante B. Lomibao, MD
Alexander A. Tuazon, MD
Belle C. Rogado, RN
The Philippine Heart Center Journal is published
annually by the Philippine Heart Center
Advisory Editorial Board
Avenilo P. Aventura, MD
Teresita S. De Guia, MD
Romeo A. Divinagracia, MD
Ludgerio D. Torres, MD
Adrian Dela Paz, MD
Ma. Linda G. Buhat, RN, EdD
Business Manager
Belinda P. San Juan, MD
Technical Staff
Mercedita A. Parazo
Don A. Batigan
Sonia S. Arellano
Lay-out/Circulation Manager
Suzette R. Manuel
Copyright 2003 by the Philippine Heart Center, East
Avenue, Quezon City, Philippines
PHILIPPINE
HEART
CENTER
JOURNAL
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Volume 9, January - December 2002
Editorial
Publish or Perish
Aristides G. Panlilio, MD
1
Original Articles
Absolute Neutrophilia as Predictor for the Development of Early-Onset Congestive
Heart Failure in Patients Admitted for Acute Myocardial Infarction
Wilfredo M. Ypil Jr. MD, Ramoncito Tria MD, Santos Jose G. Abad MD.
2
Profile of Patients with Suspected Neurocardiogenic Syncope Undergoing Head-up
Tilt Test: The Philippine Heart Center Experience
Nannette R. Rey MD, Ma. Belen O. Carisma MD
8
The Clinical Profile and Outcome of PTCA (with or without stent) in Diabetic and
Non-diabetic Patients with Coronary Artery Disease: The Philippine Heart Center
Experience
Karla Rhea G. Rillera-Posadas MD, Ramoncito B. Tria MD, Raul D. Jara MD.
14
Profile of a High-Risk Subgroup in Acute Inferior Wall Myocardial Infarction:
Multi-Center Study
Valentin G. Yabes MD, Santos Jose G. Abad MD, P J Agunod-Cheng MD, R R Torres
MD
19
A Comparative Review of Standard Coronary Bypass Grafting under
Cardiopulmonary Bypass and Off-Pump Coronary Artery Bypass Grafting in the
Management of Multivessel Coronary Artery Disease : Philippine Heart Center
Experience
Joseph J. Bautista MD, Lorenzo Rommel G. Carino MD, Avenilo P. Aventura MD,
Florante B. Lomibao MD, Gerardo S. Manzo MD
24
Six-Minute Walk Distance of Filipino High School Students
31
Ma. Tanya V. Pura MD, Percival A. Punzal MD, Milagros S. Bautista MD,
Nerissa A. de Leon, MD
An Analysis of Maximum Oxygen Consumption Determination in Filipino
Schoolchildren
Ma. Ohara P. Juaneza-Dulos MD, Percival Punzal MD, Ma. Encarnita Blanco-Limpin
MD, Milagros Bautista MD, Teresita De Guia MD.
35
Continuous Positive Airway Pressure (CPAP) Among Patients with Cardiogenic
Pulmonary Edema: Philippine Heart Center Experience
Christina A. Uy MD, Aileen V. Guzman MD, Ma. Encarnita B. Limpin MD, Teresita
S. De Guia MD
41
Serum Uric Acid Levels among Patients with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary
Disease
Inocencio H. Lopez MD, Ma. Encarnita Blanco-Limpin MD, Percival Punzal MD,
Teresita De Guia, MD
48
i
Case Study
ii
A Case of Total Anomalous Systemic Venous Connection to the Left Atrium
Julia Berba-Maape MD, Ludgerio D. Torres MD, Eduardo Manrique MD, John
Reganion MD, Juliet Balderas MD, Aurora Gamponia MD, Ma. Lourdes SR.
Casas MD, Orlando Ignacio MD, Wilberto Lopez MD.
55
Information for subscribers
65
Information for authors
66
Editorial
“Publish or Perish”
T
hat was what Dr. Camilo I. Porciuncula used to say
to us when he took over the Editorship of the
Philippine Heart Center Journal after being appointed
the Assistant Director for Education and Research shortly after
Dr. Ludgerio Torres became the Director of the Philippine
Heart Center (PHC) and expressed his intention of “reviving”
the PHC Journal. And so the story goes with Dr. Jose A. Yulde
as he assumed the Editorship of the PHC Journal from Dr.
Porciuncula after he succeeded him as Assistant Director for
Education and Research. A tradition of excellence in research
is now continued with this issue of the PHC Journal.
The Philippine Heart Center or the Heart Center has
always been the Center of cardiovascular care in the
Philippines. Over the years since 1975 or for the last 30 years,
many training centers have risen to meet the demand for
cardiovascular training and sophistication in cardiovascular
diagnosis and treatment. But the Heart Center has withstood
the “competition” and has evolved with the current trends in
Cardiovascular Science to become the standard from where
other Institutions base and pace their own research and training.
This is evident in the clamor for papers for presentation in
international and local Meetings
Research has always been a difficult challenge for all of
us who are students of Cardiology and its allied disciplines.
Often, during our training years, we try to take the easy way
out in doing research work and dismissing the completion of
a research paper as a mere “requirement” or “formality” for
promotion or graduation. It is not a question of a trainee’s
priority or whether Training goes ahead of Research in
preference. In fact, it is from research that we get our best
training. And there is really no “easy” way out. The value of
research is no better emphasized than by the contents of this
issue of the PHC Journal.
The research work presented in this issue of the PHC
journal is an excellent compilation of the modest work of the
Fellows and Medical Consultants and crosses all inroads of
Cardiology and the Allied specialties that make up the services
for patient care that only the Heart Center can provide. The
Heart Center, therefore, remains foremost in Cardiovascular
Research. The PHC Journal will likewise remain the testament
to this.
The tradition of excellence continues.
Aristides G. Panlilio, MD
Associate Editor
ISSN 0018-9034
Copyright 2002 Philippine Heart Center Journal
Original Article
Absolute Neutrophilia as Predictor for the
Development of Early-Onset Congestive Heart
Failure in Patients Admitted for Acute
Myocardial Infarction
Wilfredo M. Ypil Jr. MD, Ramoncito Tria MD, Santos Jose G. Abad MD.
BACKGROUND: The occurrence of congestive heart failure (CHF) during hospitalization for acute myocardial infarction (AMI) is an important factor influencing morbidity and mortality. AMI is frequently associated with leukocytosis.
Studies have shown that the cytokines released from neutrophils have negative inotropic effects and hence, contribute
to the development of CHF. This study aims to determine if there is an association between absolute neutrophil count
(ANC) on admission of patients with AMI and the development of early-onset CHF in such patients.
DESIGN AND SETTING: Retrospective, case-control study at Philippine Heart Center (PHC), tertiary medical center.
Patients: A total of 152 patients discharged with a diagnosis of AMI who presented initially as Killip 1 on admission
between January 1,1996 to December 31,2000, were included. Main Outcome Measure: Development of CHF within 4
days from hospital admission documented in the medical records as clinical symptoms (progression to Killip 2, 3 or 4)
confirmed by chest radiologic and/or echocardiographic findings.
RESULTS: Statistical analyses were performed to examine the relation between the ANC and the development of
CHF in the first 4 days after AMI while controlling for baseline characteristics and therapeutic interventions. The mean
ANC is 12.3 +/-0.5 X 109/L in the group of patients who developed CHF compared with 7.8 +/-0.3 x 109/L in those who did
not. Multivariable analysis revealed a significant correlation with increasing ANC and subsequent development of CHF
(adj. OR = 10.8; 95% CI = 5.08-22.97). Other factors found to have a strong association with devel opment of CHF are the
presence of diabetes mellitus (adj. OR = 2.48; 95% CI=1.44, 5.38) and use of nitrates (adj. OR = 3.12 95% CI = 1.5-6.47).
Subgroup analysis further revealed that ANC is directly correlated with Killip class on day 4 ( r = 0.565; p < 0.001).
CONCLUSIONS: High ANC on admission in patients with AMI is associated with the early development of CHF,
which may help in the identification of high risk patients who might benefit from more aggressive interventions to
prevent or reduce the risk of CHF.
Phil Heart Center J 2002;9:2-7
Keywords: acute myocardial infarction (AMI), congestive heart failure (CHF), leukocytosis, neutrophilia, absolute neutrophil count
he identification of factors that can be used to predict prognosis of patients with acute myocardial
infarction (AMI) has been a challenge since the late
1960's. The occurrence of heart failure during hospitalization
for AMI is an important factor influencing short- and longterm morbidity and mortality. Previous studies observed that
the incidence of heart failure during AMI either in the intensive care unit or before discharge is 22%.1 After hospital discharge, heart failure occurs at a rate of 2% per year thereafter
up to 10 years.2 A study by Ali et al observed a bimodal distribution of heart failure after a first AMI with an initial increased
occurrence on the first day and again 4 to 7 days after the event.3
Acute myocardial infarction is frequently associated with
T
Correspondence: Wilfredo M. Ypil, MD. Division of Adult Cardiology, Philippine Heart
Center, East Avenue, Quezon City, Philippines 1100
ISSN 0018-9034
leukocytosis and an elevated peripheral neutrophil count.4,5
Neutrophils may, in part, mediate the vascular injury with
subsequent ischemia, and the neutrophil count could thereby,
reflect the intensity of that process. Neutrophils may also occur in response to myocardial necrosis, which is a potent acute
phase stimulus that is associated with a local and systemic inflammatory response.6 Activated leukocytes are postulated to
be involved in the rupture of atherosclerotic plaques and to be
responsible for the acute coronary syndromes.7
In prospective studies from the U.S., France and Japan, total
leukocyte count was seen to be positively correlated with future occurrence of AMI, reinfarction, and/or in-hospital death.813
Surviving patients with AMI are at an increased risk for
the occurrence of congestive heart failure (CHF), reinfarction,
arrhythmias, and sudden cardiac death.14-16 However, CHF conCopyright 2002 Philippine Heart Center Journal
tinues to be the prominent clinical problem after AMI, with a
poor long-term prognosis, as indicated by the 5-year mortality
rate of @ 50% from the time of diagnosis.17 In the United
States, the associated costs are in excess of $40 billion dollars
in health care per year.6
Accumulating evidence suggests that oxidative stress and
the release of proinflammatory mediators/cytokines are known
to have negative inotropic effects, such as interleukins (IL-6,
IL-2, IL-1b), and tumor necrosis factor a, during myocardial
ischemia probably contribute to the development of CHF.16, 18-19
Significance and Objectives of the Study
Relatively few studies have examined the relation between
leukocytosis (or neutrophilia) and the short-term risk of cardiac events such as CHF after AMI. A recent study by
Kawaguchi et al. found a strong association between the band
neutrophil count and the presence and severity of coronary
atherosclerosis demonstrated at angiography.20 In a prospective study of patients with chest pain, relative lymphocytopenia and relative neutrophilia were found to be accurate early
markers of AMI.5 The recent study by Kyne et al. demonstrated that the presence of relative neutrophilia on admission
to the hospital in patients with AMI may be a useful early indicator of patients at high risk for developing CHF.6
With such results, absolute neutrophilia may serve as a
simple, inexpensive, non-invasive marker to identify patients
who are at high risk for development of CHF and early inhospital mortality after AMI. Furthermore, if the peripheral
neutrophil count truly reflects the myocardial inflammatory
response, further interventions that are designed to limit this
response could help to reduce morbidity and mortality rates
associated with CHF occurring after AMI.
Assuming that the peripheral leukocyte count, particularly
the absolute neutrophil count is a marker of the intensity of
the peri-infarction myocardial inflammatory response, our objective is to test the hypothesis that there is an association
between high absolute neutrophil count on admission and early
development of post-infarction CHF.
Methodology
Study design and Selection of Study Population
This is a retrospective, case-control study conducted at
Philippine Heart Center, a tertiary hospital. From the hospital
records registry, a total of 1053 patients were diagnosed to
have acute myocardial infarction (ICD-9-CM Code 410) admitted between January 1, 1996 to December 31, 2000. Only
860 charts (81%) were retrieved and individually evaluated.
A total of 788 patients fulfilled the WHO criteria for the
diagnosis of AMI, of which, 340 patients were eliminated
either because interventions were already done at a primary
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
or secondary health care unit or time interval from onset of
chest pain was more than 12 hours on presentation. Additional 242 patients were further eliminated because they were
in Killip Class 2-4 on presentation. Furthermore, 54 patients
(39, with documented infection; 8, with chronic renal insufficiency; 3, with gastrointestinal hemorrhage; 2, with documented
malignancies; and 2, with no complete blood count determination taken) were eliminated. A final cohort of 152 patients was
included in the study.
Data Collection, Outcome Measures and Variable
Classification
Based on the patients’ records, the following data were
obtained: age, sex, location of infarct by ECG, coronary risk
profile (hypertension, diabetes mellitus, smoking history), laboratory results (total WBC count, % neutrophils in the differential count, absolute neutrophil count, total CK and CK-MB)
and therapeutic regimen used on admission (use of reperfusion
strategies such as thrombolysis and PTCA, use of anticoagulants, antiplatelets, beta blockers, nitrates, ACE inhibitors and
calcium channel blockers).
Outcome measures include the development of CHF, as
described by clinical signs and symptoms with radiologic evidence of pulmonary congestion and/or echocardiographic finding of contractile dysfunction (Ejection fraction <0.40), within
4 days from admission. Four days was chosen as cutoff because after this time, the development of CHF may be influenced by therapeutic intervention and/or other post-infarction
complications and therefore, the neutrophil count might be less
relevant.5-8, 13 Furthermore, the 4th day coincides with the later
peak of the bimodal distribution of the occurrence of heart failure after an AMI which is reflective of the short and long-term
prognosis of these patients.3
Age, total CPK, CK-MB values, total WBC count, percentage neutrophil count, and absolute neutrophil counts were
recorded as continuous variables. To improve power for analysis across the groups and to adjust for the fact that anterior
infarcts are often associated with a worse prognosis and increased risk of development of systolic dysfunction, location
of infarct was dichotomized into anterior versus other (inferior, posterior, RV).
The other variables that were categorized: sex (male vs.
female); hypertension, diabetes mellitus, smoking history
(present vs. absent); use of thrombolytic agents, PTCA, ASA
and other antiplatelet agents, heparin, beta blockers, ACE inhibitors, nitrates and calcium channel blockers (use vs. nonuse); and the development of CHF within 4 days from admission (present vs, absent). For the purpose of analysis, those
who developed CHF were further trichotomized to Killip Class
(2, 3 or 4).
Statistical Analysis
The distribution of age, sex, comorbidities, location of
infarct, laboratory values and therapeutic interventions were
3
analyzed by means of standard deviations for continuous variables and proportions for categorical variables. The Student ttest was used for comparison of the mean total WBC counts,
percentage neutrophil counts and absolute neutrophil counts
of patients who did have postinfarction CHF and those who
did not have postinfarction CHF.
We compared other candidate predictors by using Chisquare or Fisher’s exact test for binary variables, the MantelHaenszel chi-square trend test for multicategory variables and
Student t-test for means of continuous variables of patients
who had CHF versus those who did not. Correlations between
continuous variables were assessed by use of Spearman’s correlation. An a level of p<0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Absolute neutrophil count and all covariates with a value
of p<0.05 were entered into a multivariable stepwise logistic
regression analysis. This was checked for confounding and effect modification. Adjusted odds ratios were computed using
two-by-two table analysis using software by Jerry Keightley
and Robert Centor. The 95% confidence intervals were computed using the Sato method.
Results
Baseline Characteristics of Study Cohort
The study cohort was predominantly male (78%) with a
mean age of 57 + 12.6 years (range 27 to 94). Majority (62%)
had anterior location of infarction. More than half were known
hypertensives (58%) and were previous smokers (66%).
More than half of these patients received heparin (95%),
aspirin (90%), nitrates (91%) and ACE inhibitors (57%). Only
2 out of 5 patients received reperfusion therapy, either with
the use of thrombolytic agents or primary PTCA (Table 1).
The other significant positive predictor of CHF is the presence of diabetes mellitus. Patients who received beta-blockers
and nitrates at the time of admission were apparently protected
against the development of CHF. There was no association
between the admission total CPK, CPK-MB and leukocytosis,
absolute or relative neutrophilia or between total CPK, CPKMB values and development of CHF.
Table I. Baseline characteristics of the study cohort
Characteristics
(n=152)
Mean or %
Age (years)
Sex (male)
AMI location (anterior)
Hypertension
Diabetes Mellitus
Smoking history
Labs on admission: Total WBC count
Percent neutrophil
Absolute neutrophil count
Total CPK
CPK- MB
Therapeutics: Thrombolytic agents
PTCA
Aspirin
Ticlopidine or clopdogrel
Heparin
Nitrates
Beta blockers
ACE inhibitors
Calcium channel blockers
56.9 + 12.6
119 (78%)
95 (62%)
88 (58%)
35 (23%)
100 (66%)
12.9 + 4.11
0.75 + 0.12
9.96 + 4.12
1190.5 + 1331.7
95.3 + 199.7
59 (39%)
3 (2%)
137 (90%)
10 (7%)
144 (95%)
139 (91%)
73 (48%)
86 (57%)
5 (3%)
25
Univariate Predictors of CHF
In 74 (49%) patients, CHF developed within the first 4
days of hospital admission, documented as clinical signs and
symptoms compatible with the diagnosis of CHF. Of these,
46 (62%) had radiologic evidence of pulmonary congestion
and 34 (46%) had echocardiographic findings of systolic dysfunction (EF<0.40)
Out of these 74 patients who developed CHF, 54 (73%)
progressed to Killip II, 15 (20%) progressed to Killip III while
the remaining 5 (7%) progressed to Killip IV.
The total WBC count, percentage neutrophil and absolute
neutrophil count on admission was found to be highly significant predictors of subsequent development of CHF. (Table 2)
Subgroup analysis of those who developed CHF further revealed that high absolute neutrophil count is moderately correlated with increasing Killip class on day 4 (r=0.565; p<0.001).
(Figure 1)
4
Absolute Neutrophil Count
72
20
15
10
5
0
N=
78
54
15
5
I
II
III
IV
Killip Class on D4
Figure 1. The association of absolute neutrophil count with the
development of congestive heart failure categorized further into
Killip class on the 4th day post-infarction. (r=0.565; p<0.001)
WM Ypil, et al
Multivariable Analysis
The absolute neutrophil count (adjusted OR=10.8; 95%
C.I.=5.0826-22.9709) remained significantly associated with
subsequent development of CHF even after adjusting for diabetes mellitus and for other predictors such as the use of beta
blockers and nitrates. The presence of diabetes mellitus was
also associated with development of CHF which persisted after multivariable analysis (adjusted OR=2.4804 95%
C.I.=1.1441-5.3774). Patients who received nitrates and/or
beta-blockers had a reduced likelihood for the development of
CHF. Interaction terms designed to assess whether the effect
of absolute neutrophilia was different among those who received beta-blockers and nitrates compared with those who did
not receive these agents revealed contrasting results. Significant correlation was noted with the use of nitrates (adjusted
OR=3.1169 95% C.I.=1.5013-6.4710) but none was observed
with the use of beta-blockers in the final analysis (p=0.0544).
(Table 3)
Table II. Variables associated with development of early-onset
CHF post-AMI
Characteristics
CHF
(N=74)
No
(N=78)
CHF
P value
Age (years)
Sex (male)
AMI location (anterior)
Hypertension
Diabetes Mellitus
Smoking history
Admission lab values:
-Total CK (Mean)
-CPK-MB
-Total WBC count
-% Neutrophil
-Absolute Neutrophil Count
Therapeutics:
Thrombolytic agents
-PTCA
-Heparin
-ASA
-Ticlopidine, clopdogrel
-Beta blockers
-ACE inhibitors
-Nitrates
-Calcium channel blockers
58.5 + 1.6
56 (76%)
50 (68%)
46 (62%)
23 (31%)
51 (69%)
55.4 + 1.3
63 (81%)
45 (58%)
42 (54%)
12 (15%)
49 (63%)
0.13 NS
0.45 NS
0.28 NS
0.38 NS
0.02*
0.53 NS
1256.45
110.66
15.2 + 0.5
0.8 + 0.01
12.3 + 0.5
1127
80.73
10.8 + 0.3
0.71 + 0.01
7.8 + 0.3
0.55 NS
0.36 NS
<0.001**
<0.001**
<0.001**
31 (42%)
2 (3%)
70 (95%)
67 (90%)
5 (7%)
29 (39%)
41 (55%)
64 (86%)
2 (3%)
28 (42%)
1 (36%)
74 (95%)
70 (90%)
5 (6%)
44 (56%)
45 (58%)
75 (96%)
3 (4%)
0.55 NS
0.61 NS
1.00 NS
0.87 NS
1.00 NS
0.034*
0.78
0.033*
1.0 NS
Table III. Variables associated with development of early-onset
CHF post-AMI
Variable
Adjusted OR
Absolute neutrophil count
Diabetes Mellitus
Nitrates
10.8
2.48
3.12
95% C.I.
5.0826, 22.9709
1.441, 5.3774
1.5013, 6.471
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
Discussion
Our study has clearly shown that increasing absolute neutrophil count is strongly associated with early development of
CHF in patients with AMI. This significant correlation persisted even after adjustment with covariates such as diabetes
mellitus and the use of beta-blockers and nitrates. This result
further strengthened previous reports that show prognostic
importance of the neutrophil count for coronary events.5-7, 11, 13,
20, 21
In a prospective trial by Thomson, et al. of patients admitted to the hospital with chest pain, relative lymphocytopenia
and relative neutrophilia were found to be accurate early markers of AMI.5
Kawaguchi, et al., found a strong association between the
band neutrophil count but not the total leukocyte count and the
presence and severity of coronary atherosclerosis demonstrated
at angiography.20
Studies carried out in small patient samples and one large
population-based study have suggested that increasing leukocyte count is associated with increased short and long-term
mortality following AMI.7 Kyne et al. demonstrated that the
presence of relative neutrophilia was found to be a useful indicator of patients at high risk for development of systolic dysfunction.6 The study by Maisel et al. further showed that increased initial leukocyte count during AMI predicts early ventricular fibrillation.21
All these previously mentioned studies have utilized both
total leukocyte and relative neutrophil counts only. Considering the variability of the total leukocyte count and the arbitrariness of the relative neutrophil count, our study utilized the
absolute neutrophil count, which we deem to be more reflective of the actual neutrophil population.
The pathophysiologic basis for the association between
neutrophilia and the risk of coronary events including the development of CHF has been studied in several animal models.22 Neutrophil infiltration into the ischemic myocardium
remains an integral component of the post-AMI inflammatory
response. Once activated, these neutrophils adhere to the vascular endothelium. By increasing the vascular resistance and
impairing dilation of small coronary arterioles, they may aggravate further myocardial ischemia.23 Neutrophils, moreover,
undergo cellular respiratory bursts and release oxygen-derived
free radicals, which are toxic to cells, in an antioxidant-deficit
milieu.16 Interactions between infiltrating neutrophils and resident inflammatory cells within the myocardium may occur
resulting in the release of lysosomal enzymes and arachidonic
acid metabolites, which may increase coronary artery resistance, leading to development of myocardial dysfunction.24
Our study, though, cannot possibly determine whether
there is a causal relation between neutrophilia and CHF. Neutrophils may not directly contribute to contractile dysfunction
but may be a proxy measurement for other mediators of
5
inflammation that may be directly involved. A growing body
of evidence now suggests that proinflammatory cytokines such
as interleukin (IL)-6, IL-2, IL-1B, tumor necrosis alpha and
low-molecular-weight inflammatory cytokines of the IL-8 family have negative inotropic effects.16, 25, 26 These cytokines are
released during AMI and during reperfusion of the damaged
tissue.
Tanaka et al. had demonstrated that heparin can negate
the proinflammatory actions of these cytokines.27 Unfortunately, this was not demonstrated in our study. Several investigators have suggested that reperfusion of ischemic myocardium augments the inflammatory reactions described above
and may cause reperfusion arrhythmias and postischemic contractile dysfunction, also known as “myocardial stunning.”28,29
Our study also failed to demonstrate effects of reperfusion
therapy, whether use of thrombolytic agents nor primary PTCA.
ACE inhibitors have antioxidant properties in addition to
and unrelated to their effect on the renin-angiotensin system.14,30
Hence, the effect of neutrophilia on the development of CHF
may be attenuated by treatment with ACE inhibitors. This was
demonstrated in the study by Kyne et al.6 However, the current study failed to demonstrate evidence of effect modification by these agents.
The early use of beta blockers exert a modestly favorable
influence on infarct size and diminished short-term mortality
as shown in the first International Study of Infarct Survival
Study (ISIS-1).31 This could be the reason for the trend towards benefit in reducing risk of developing CHF in our study.
However, we did not have sufficient statistical power to analyze and formulate generalizations on the effect of the use of
such agents.
There is experimental and clinical evidence that intravenous nitroglycerin may reduce infarct size and improve regional
myocardial function. It has also been suggested that nitroglycerin may prevent LV remodeling that frequently occurs
after a large transmural MI.32 In addition, the reduction in right
and left ventricular preload resulting from peripheral vasodilation, decreases cardiac work and lowers myocardial oxygen
requirements.33 All these hemodynamic effects could have contributed to the protective effect of nitrates from development
of CHF demonstrated in our study.
It was previously demonstrated that the myocardial response to acute ischemic stress is different in older animals
compared with younger animals.34 On the basis of these findings and on our knowledge of the observed increase in the
incidence of CHF associated with aging, we hypothesized that
the association between neutrophilia and CHF may be different in older adults compared with younger individuals. However, we demonstrated no significant difference in between
the two groups.
Cigarette smoking was previously shown to be associated
with leukocytosis and risk of ischemic events.9 However, our
study had not shown its association with the absolute neutrophil count and risk of developing CHF.
6
The total CPK and CPK-MB values might reflect myocardial infarct size, however, no correlation with the absolute
neutrophil count was noted. Same observation was noted in a
previous study done by Recto et al.35 in the same institution.
The excessive in-hospital mortality in diabetic patients experiencing AMI correlates primarily with an increased incidence of CHF, although increased reinfarction, infarct extension, and recurrent ischemia also contribute.36 This further
strengthened the findings in the study by Ali et al. in which,
diabetes mellitus, aside from increased age and tachycardia, is
a predictor for occurrence of the delayed phase of heart failure
in AMI.3
This study has some limitations. It is generalizable only
to similar populations in a tertiary referral centers. Selection
bias may have occurred because sicker patients are often referred to this hospital. This could explain in part the higher
rate of CHF that was observed in this population (49% compared with the 17% to 23% that was reported in other studies).
37, 38
Another limitation of this study is that the neutrophil count
was measured at only one point in time, and this point (although within 12 hours of symptom onset) was not consistent
in all patients studied. Serial neutrophil counts, including presymptom onset counts, might be more helpful in identifying
high-risk individuals early. A prospective clinical study of
patients with chest pain, in whom prior neutrophil counts are
available, would address these issues.
Measurements and correlations with other markers of
myocardial injury and neutrophil activation such as C-reactive
protein, serum neutrophil elastase, or myeloperoxidase could
give a more complete picture of the inflammatory process.
Conclusion
Despite all these limitations, this study demonstrated a significant association between absolute neutrophilia in patients
admitted for AMI and the subsequent development of CHF
within four days, after adjusting for the presence of diabetes
mellitus and therapeutic interventions.
The results suggest that absolute neutrophilia may serve
as a simple, readily available, inexpensive and noninvasive
marker to identify patients at high risk for development of CHF
after myocardial infarction. Since neutrophilia reflects extent
of myocardial injury and inflammatory process, future interventions that are designed to limit this response could help in
reducing morbidity and mortality associated with CHF occurring after AMI.
WM Ypil, et al
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
Fresco C, Carinci F et al. on behalf of the GISSI investigators. Very early
assessment of risk for in-hospital death among 11,483 patients with acute
myocardial infarction. Am Heart J 1999;138:1058-64.
Ho KKL, Pinsky JL, Kannel WB, Levy D. The epidemiology of heart failure:
The Framingham study. J Am Coll Cardiol 1993; 22(suppl A):6A-13A.
Ali AS, Rybicki B, Alam M et al. Clinical predictors of heart failure in patients
with first acute myocardial infarction. Am Heart J 1999;138: 1133-9.
Braunwald E. Acute Myocardial Infarction. In: Heart disease: a textbook of
cardiovascular medicine, 6th ed. Philadelphia: WB Saunders, 2001.
Thomson SP, Gibbons RJ, Smears PA, et al. Incremental value of the leukocyte differential count and the rapid CK-MB isoenzyme for the early diagnosis
of AMI. Ann Int Med 1995;122:335-341.
Kyne L, Hansdorff J, Knight E et al. Neutrophilia and CHF after AMI. Am
Heart J 2000;139(1): 94-100.
Furman M, Yarzebski BR et al. Effect of elevated leukocyte count on inhospital mortality following acute myocardial infarction. Am J Cardio
1996;78:945-48.
Friedman GD, Klatsky AL, Siegeland AB. The leukocyte count as a predictor
of AMI. New Engl J Med 1974;290:1275-78.
Zalokas JB, Richard JL, Claude JR. Leukocyte count, smoking and AMI. N
Engl J Med 1981;304:465-68.
Kostis JB, Turkevich D, Sharp J. Association between leukocyte count and
the presence and extent of coronary atherosclerosis as determined by coronary angiography. Am J Cardiol 1984;53:997-9.
Ernst E, Hammerschmidt DE, Bagge U et al. Leukocytosis and the risk of
ischemic heart disease. JAMA 1987;257:2318-24.
Gillum RF, Ingram DD, Malivic DM. WBC count, coronary heart disease and
death: the NHANES I Epidemiologic follow-up study. Am Heart J
1993;125:855-63.
Grimm RH, Neastor JD, Ludwig W. Prognostic importance of the WBC count
for coronary, cancer and all-cause mortality. JAMA 1985; 254:1932-7.
Rutherford JD, Pfeiffer MA, Moys LA et al. On behalf of the SAVE Investigators. Effects of captopril on ischemic events after AMI. Circulation
1994;90:1731-38.
Pfeiffer, MA, Pfeiffer JM, Gervasso, AL. Development and prevention of CHF
following AMI. Circulation 1993;87(suppl IV):IV-120-IV-125.
Hill MF, Sengal PK. Right and left myocardial antioxidant responses during
heart failure subsequent to AMI. Circulation 1997;96:2414-2420.
Armstrong PW, Moe GW. Medical advances in the therapy of CHF. Circulation 1994;88:2941-2952.
Mann DL, Young JB. Basic mechanism in CHF: recognizing the role of
proinflammatory cytokines. Chest 1994;105:897-900.
Kelly RA, Smith TW. Cytokines and cardiac contractile dysfunction. Circulation 1997;95:778-81.
Kawaguchi H, Mori T, Kawano T et al. Band neutrophil count and the presence of coronary atherosclerosis. Am Heart J 1996;132:9-12.
.
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
20. Maisel AS, Gilpen A, Le Winter M et al. Initial leukocyte count during AMI
independently predicts early ventricular fibrillation. Circulation 1985; 72:414.
21. Dreyer W, Michael LH, West MS et al. Neutrophil accumulation in ischemic
cardiac myocardium: Insights into time course, distribution and mechanism of
localization during early reperfusion. Circulation 1991;84: 400-11.
22 Sheridan FM, Dauber IM, McMurty IF et al. Role of leukocytes in coronary
vascular endothelial injury due to ischemia and reperfusion. Circulation
1991;69:1566-74.
23. McCord JM. Oxygen-derived free radicals in post-ischemic tissue injury. N
Engl J Med 1985;312:159-63.
24. Neuman FJ, Olt I, Gawaz M et al. Cardiac release of cytokines and inflammatory responses in acute myocardial infarction. Circulation 1995; 92:748-55.
25. Andreassen AK, Nordog I, Simonsen S et al. Levels of circulating adhesion
molecules in congestive heart failure and after heart transplant. Am J Cardiol
1998;81:604-8.
26. Tanaka Y, Adams DH, Hubscher S et al. T-cell adhesion induced by
proteoglycan-immobilized cytokine MIP-1 beta. Nature 1993;361:79-82.
27. Hanson PR. Myocardial reperfusion injury: experimental evidence and clinical relevance. Eur Heart J 1995;16:734-40.
28. Braunwald E, Kloner RA. Myocardial reperfusion: a double-edged sword? J
Clin Invest 1985:76:1713-9.
29. De Cavanagh EM, Fraga CG, Ferder L et al. Enalapril and captopril enhance
antioxidant defenses in mouse tissues. Am J Physiol 1997; 272:R514-8.
30. ISIS(International Studies of Infarct Survival) Pilot Study Investigators. Randomized factorial trial of high-dose intravenous streptokinase, of oral aspirin
and of intravenous heparin in acute myocardial infarction. Eur Heart J
1987;8:634-42.
31. Yusuf S, Collins R, MacMahon S, Peto R. Effect of intravenous nitrates on
mortality in acute myocardial infarction: an overview of randomized trials.
Lancet 1988;1:1088-92.
32. Yusuf S, Wittes J, Friedman L. Overview of results of randomized clinical
trials in heart disease. Treatments following acute myocardial infarction. JAMA
1988;260:2088-93.
33. Liu L, Azhar G, Goa W et al. Bcl-2 and Bax expression in adult rat hearts after
coronary occlusion: age-associated differences. Am J Physiol 1998;275: R3
15-22.
34. Recto CS III, Abola, MT, Abarquez R et al. White blood cell count as predictor
of acute myocardial infarct size and complications. PHC-R-06-92.
35. Malmberg K, Ryden L. Myocardial infarction in patients with diabetes mellitus.
Eur Heart J 1988;9:259-64.
36. O'Connor CM, Hathaway WR et al. Clinical characteristics and long-term
outcome of patients in whom congestive heart failure develops after thrombolytic therapy for acute myocardial infarction: development of a predictive
model. Am Heart J 1997;133:563-73.
37. GUSTO investigators. An international randomized trial comparing 4 thrombolytic strategies for acute myocardial infarction. N Engl J Med 1993;329;67382.
38. Garfinkel SK, Kestem S, Chapman R, Rebuck AP. Physiologic and nonPhysiologic determinants of aerobic fitness in mild to moderate asthma. Am
Rev Resp Dis 1992;145:741-745.
39. Ludwick SK, Jones JW, Jones TK. Normalization of cardio-pulmonary endurance in severely asthmatic children after bicycle ergometry therapy. J Pedia
.
1986;109:446-457.
7
Original Article
Profile of Patients with Suspected
Neurocardiogenic Syncope Undergoing Head-up
Tilt Test: The Philippine Heart Center Experience
Nannette R. Rey MD, Ma. Belen O. Carisma MD
BACKGROUND: Head-up tilt test (HUTT) remains a cornerstone in the diagnosis for unexplained syncope since its
introduction in 1986. Several factors have been elucidated as possible predictors of a positive tilt test, which include
among others, age, sex, and early heart rate rise. Investigations have also been undertaken to observe response to
different medications used in the evaluation of syncope during head-up tilt test.
OBJECTIVE: It is the objective of this study to determine the profile of patients with suspected neurocardiogenic
syncope undergoing head-up tilt test and the factors that may predict a positive test outcome.
METHODS AND RESULTS: There were 86 patients included in the study. Majority presented with symptoms of
syncope and presyncope. Total case findings rate was 37% for all cases, which increased to 74% in patients presenting
with a classical prodrome. Age, sex, and ECG did not correlate with a (+) HUTT while the presence of prodrome and
early heart rate rise correlated significantly with the outcome. The complication rate was 1%.
CONCLUSIONS: HUTT is a useful tool in suspected neurocardiogenic syncope with 74% case finding rate. The
presence of classical prodrome and an early heart rate rise may be a useful guide in predicting a positive outcome for
the test.
Phil Heart Center J 2002;9:8-13
Keywords: hypotension; syncope; neurocardiogenic syncope; tilt test
yncope is defined as a sudden transient loss of conscious
ness and postural tone with spontaneous recovery. The
mechanism has been described to be due to a reduction
of blood flow to the reticular activating system of the brain,
which leads to subsequent loss of consciousness within approximately 10 seconds.1
A problem not uncommonly encountered in clinical practice, syncope poses a major concern as it is costly, potentially
disabling, can possibly result to injury and may be the only
warning before the occurence of sudden cardiac death.1 The
causes of syncope have been classified into four primary types:
vascular, cardiac, neurologic/cerebrovascular and metabolic/
miscellaneous. Of particular interest is the reflex-mediated
syncope, which consists of increased vagal tone leading to
bradycardia, vasodilation, subsequently leading to hypotension
and ultimately, presyncope or syncope.
The neurally-mediated hypotension/syncope; also known
as neurocardiogenic, vasodepressoer and vasovagal syncope;
including carotid sinus syndrome have been recognized as important causes of syncope.2 This particular type of syncope is
described as an abnormality of blood pressure regulation characterized by abrupt onset of hypotension with or without bradycardia usually associated with either reduction of vetricular
filling or increased catecholamine secretion. Positive results
S
Correspondence: Nanenette R. Rey, MD. Division of Adult Cardiology,
Philippine Heart Center, East Avenue, Quezon City, Philippines 1100
ISSN 0018-9034
are subdivided into three types of neurally mediated syncope:
cardioinhibitory, vasodepressor and mixed type. Some identified triggers include sight of blood, prolonged standing, pain,
warm environment and stressful conditions. In a recent study,3
evidences pointed to the possibility of syncope being associated with lateralization in the delta frequency of the left side of
the brain with the onset of bradycardia and hypotension suggesting the possibile role of the brain with the onset of bradycardia and hypotension suggesting the possible role of the central nervouse system in neurally medicated syncope.3
Often, evaluation of syncope is difficult and expensive.
Recent experience still showed that a significant number of
primary care physicians and even specialists would tend to go
for neurologic examinations first (CT scan, MRI) as compared
to cardiovascular tests in the evaluation of syncope.4
Head-up tilt table testing, introduced in 1986 is an efficient, well-tolerated, and safe tool in the evaluation of patients
with unexplained syncope.5,6 Recent studies have shown 3045 minutes at an angle of 70 degrees (Westminster protocol).
The positive response is the development of syncope or
presyncope in association with hypotension and/or bradycardia. The test sensitivity can be increased with fall in specificity by the use of longer duration, steeper tilt angle and provocative agents including isoproterenol, nitroglycerin and
edrophonium. The specificity in the absence of provocative
agent is estimated at 90%.
Copyright 2002 Philippine Heart Center Journal
In the Philippine Heart Center, earliest records of head-up
tilt test protocol consists of an initial 10-minute observation in
supine position with vital signs monitoring every minute for a
duration of 45 minutes. The patient is then placed back on a
supine position and infused with 1-3 mg/min of isoproterenol,
atropine 1 mg or sublingual 5 mg nitrate and the tilt portion
repeated for another 15 minutes. Indication to stopping the
procedure is the occurence of syncope or presyncope associated with hypotension and/or bradycardia.
Indeed, the head-up tilt test (HUT) has already been considered as the gold standard in the evaluation of syncope. Some
characteristics shown to predict a high likehood of positive
outcome indicating neurally mediated syncope include: (1) at
least two syncopal episodes; (2) no structural heart disease and
normal baseline ECG; (3) age <65 years; (4) typical history of
neurally mediated syncope, triggering factors plus premonitory signs; and (5) short duration of symptoms and fast recovery without neurologic sequelae. The best predictor however
of a positive outcome was noted to be the duration of interval
between syncopal episode and baseline HUTT test (p<0.003).7
Trends have shown that among patients undergoing HUTT,
age >65 years old appear to have higher incidence of vasodepressor response.8 Age and sex on the other hand appear to
have no effect on the rate of positive test.9, 6 An early heart rate
rise (>18 beats /min) had also been implicated as a 100% sensitive marker for a positive response at <15 minutes of tilt with
low specificity (61%).10
As we currently have no available local data on our patients with suspected neurocardiogenic syncope undergoing
head-up tilt test. Additional emphasis will be placed on determining the rate of positive outcome and correlating factors that
may possibly predict a positive result of the test.
Objectives
To determine the clinical profile of patients at the Philippine Heart Center with suspected neurocardiogenic syncope
undergoing head-up tilt test.
Specific Objectives
1. To describe the presenting symptoms of patients with
neurocardiogenic syncope.
2. To determine the overall rate of positive results for
the head-up tilt test further subdivided into the positive for
baseline tilt and positive after infusion of isoproterenol.
3. To describe the clinical characteristics of patients with
positive head-up tilt test.
4. To determine the characteristics of patients that may
predict a positive outcome of the test.
5. To determine the complication rate and the complications encountered during the procedure.
6. To determine the rate of response of patients to tilt
test using different medications (isoproterenol, atropine and
nitroglycerin).
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
Methods
Research Design
This is a retrospective study.
Study Population
Patients with suspected neurocardiogenic syncope undergoing head-up tilt test (HUTT)
Exclusion Criteria
1. Patients undergoing head-up tilt test who are already on
medication with beta-blockers.
2. Patients with significant carotid artery disease.
3. Patients undergoing repeat head-up tilt test after starting
treatment with beta-blockers.
Study Setting
Tertiary center (Philippine Heart Center) with facility for
head-up tilt test. Time period is from the first time HUTT was
done in this center (1996) until present.
Data Collection
All cases with suspected neurocardiogenic syncope referred to the Electrophysiology Section of the Philippine Heart
Center who underwent head-up tilt test were identified. The
results of the tilt test of these patients were then retrieved and
reviewed. Some subjects were excluded according to the stated
exclusion criteria. Results of included subjects were reviewed
to determine the baseline characteristics including symptomatology, co-morbidity and outcome of the study. The different
characteristics were then compared to the outcome of the tilt
test to determine possible association between the characteristics and a positive HUTT. A positive head-up tilt test response
was defined by syncope or near syncope associated with the
following hemodynamic changes: a decrease in systolic blood
pressure >60% from baseline values or an absolute value <80
mmHg (vasodepressor response) an/or a decrease in HR >30%
from the baseline value or an absolute value <40 beats/min
(cardioinhibitory response).11
Data Analysis
Data were described as means and standard deviation, frequency and percent distribution. Association of the different
factors to the outcome of the tilt test was compared. Using
independent t-test and chi-square test. For all statistics, a p<0.05
was considered significant.
Results
A total of 91 patients were identified. Two were excluded
due to absence of test results while three were repeat tilt on
beta-blockers. Eighty-six patients were then included for final
9
analysis. Ages of patients ranged from nine to 86 years old
with a mean age of 47 + 21 years (Table I). There was almost
equal sex distribution among included subjects with males
comprising 51% of the total study population.
Table I.
Distribution of patients according to age
Age Range
Number
Percentage
No data
< 18
18-60
> 60
Total
15
5
43
23
86
17.5
5.8
5
26.7
100
Cumulative %
17.5
23.3
73.3
100
Majority of the patients (58 or 67.4%) presented with a
history of recurrent syncope (Table II) and 38 (44%) presented
with the classical prodrome prior to the onset of syncope. A
total of 17 (19.8%) patients had existing co-morbidity and all
of whom are hypertensive with two having minimal carotid
artery disease. Sixty-nine (80.2%) of the patients were without co-morbidity. Among the different provocative agents,
isoproterenol was the most frequently used in 63 (73%) patients with one (1%) patient given nitrates before isoproterenol and three (3.5%) patients given atropine. The remaining
only underwent baseline tilt.
A total of 32 (37%) patients had a positive head-up tilt test
(Table III) with 21 (66%) of cases manifesting with positive
result during baseline tilt and an additional 11 (34%) being
positive on provocative test. Of the 38 patients who presented
with a classical prodrome, 28 (74%) had a positive HUTT. Of
these, 19 (50%) had positive HUTT on baseline study with an
additional 9 (24%) patients becoming positive on provocative
examination.
The other four patients with a positive HUTT did not
present with any prodrome. Two became positive on baseline
HUTT and the remaining two became positive on provocative
testing.
Table III. Outcome of tilt test
Outcome
Number
Percent
Negative HUTT
Positive HUTT
(+) on baseline
(+) on provocative
54
32
(21)
(11)
63
37
Total
86
100
Of the patients with a positive HUTT outcome, majority
were classified as mixed type of neurogenic syncope (Table
IV). Most patients complained of a combination of dimming
of vision and dizziness with note of diaphoresis prior to the
onset of symptoms and manifested with either near syncope or
frank syncope (19 patients/61%). Of the positive HUTT patients, regain of consciousness was immediate in 31 (97%) of
cases with no evidence of disorientation.
Most patients with a positive HUTT presented with simultaneous occurrence of bradycardia and hypotension while
others presented with a variety of combination of blood pressure and heart rate changes (Figure 1).
Table IV.
Classification of syncope among (+) HUTT patients
Type of Syncope
Number
Cardioinhibitory
Vasodepressor
Mixed type
Total
5
9
18
32
Percentage
16
28
56
100
47
50
40
Table II. Distribution of patients according to presenting
history
Presenting history
Number
Percent
Syncope
Seizure
Presyncope
Dizziness
Combination of symptoms
Others
Total
58
1
7
8
6
6
86
67.4
1.2
8.1
9.3
7
7
100
Cumulative %
30
10
67.4
68.6
76.7
86
93
100
22
22
20
6
3
0
1
hypotension before bradycardia
bardycardia w ith hypotension
hypotension before bradycardia
bradycardia before hypotension
bardycardia afterhypotension
Figure. I. Manifestation of positive HUTT test
10
NR Rey, et al
Table V. Comparison between patient variables and HUTT outcome
Factor/Variable
Age
Mean + SD
Gender
Male
Female
Prodrome
Present
Absent
Prodrome (n=86)
Present
Absent
Prodrome (n=65)
Present
Absent
Early heart rate rise
Present
Absent
ECG
Normal
Abnormal
QT interval
Normal
Abnormal
Carotid sinus massage
Normal
Abnormal
Negative HUTT Positive HUTT
(n=32)
(n=54)
p-value
0.11
51 years + 18.89 43 years + 24.28
0.889
28 (32%)
26 (30%)
16 (19%)
16 (19%)
10 (12%)
44 (51%)
(-) baseline tilt
19 (22.1%)
46 (53.5%)
(-) provocative tilt
4 (6.2%)
50 (76.9%)
28 (32%)
4 (5%)
(+) baseline tilt
19 (22.1%)
2 (3.1%)
(+) provocative tilt
9 (13.8%)
2 (3.1%)
10 (12%)
44 (51%)
17 (20%)
15 (17%)
51 (59.3%)
3 (3.5%)
26 (30.2%)
6 (7%)
40 (46%)
0 (0%)
27 (31%)
1 (1%)
19 (22%
3 (4%)
6 (7%)
3 (4%)
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
0.002
0.072
0.412
0.32
Correlation of the different variables to the outcome of
HUTT showed significant correlation between HUTT outcome
and occurrence of early heart rate rise. The presence of classical prodrome likewise correlates significantly with a positive
HUTT outcome. Age, gender, normal ECG and QT interval
did not correlate with HUTT outcome (Table V). The mean
age of the different types of neurocardiogenic syncope were as
follows: cardioinhibitory (35 + 29.85 years), vasodepressor (44
+ 36.79 years) and mixed (31+ 21.62 years) with p = 0.35.
Discussion
Data gathered from this investigation showed that in the
group of patients that this institution caters to, neurocardiogenic
syncope appears to affect both genders nearly equal in contrast to the previous observation in foreign studies that this
condition has a predilection to affect females more than males.8
The mean age of patients is 43 + 24.28 years indicating that it
indeed appears to affect the relatively younger age group. On
further analysis of the data, there was no significant correlation established between age and sex versus the outcome of
HUTT indicating that the outcome of head-up tilt test is independent of the patients age and sex. This collaborates the findings of McGavigan et al and Petersen et al.8,9
It has been previously proposed that patients with classical prodrome tend to manifest with positive results more
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
during the baseline tilt test rather than the provocative test.12 It
has likewise been elucidated that more of the patients with a
classical prodrome would have a (+) baseline tilt. This study
indeed showed that 70% (19 cases) of patients with classical
prodrome manifested with positive HUTT outcome during
baseline testing, which correlated significantly with a (+) HUTT
(p < 0.001). Of the remaining patients who were negative on
baseline tilt, additional 9 (10.5%) cases became positive on
provocative test. Similar to patients with (+) baseline tilt, the
presence of classical prodrome correlated significantly with a
(+) HUTT on provocative examination. Looking at these data,
the total case finding rate of the head-up tilt test has been established at 74%, that is, 28 (+) HUTT cases among 38 patients presenting with a classical prodrome. There was however no difference in the case finding rate between patients
without prodrome during the baseline and provocative tests.
In this investigation, there was an equal case finding rate between the two phases of the test in patients not presenting with
a classical prodrome (two cases of (+) HUTT both in baseline
and provocative tests). Correlation analysis further showed a
statistically significant correlation between the presence of classical prodrome and the total positive HUTT results (p < 0.001)
confirming the observation that the presence of classical prodrome increases the likelihood of a positive HUTT result.
The total case finding rate of head-up tilt test as seen in
this investigation is 37%, i.e. 32 positive HUTT cases out of
86 patients undergoing head-up tilt test. Of these, 66% (21
cases) were documented during the baseline HUTT with an
additional 34% (11 cases) being documented on provocative
examination. Development of the symptoms occurred with a
mean tilt time of 20-30 minutes with shortest tilt time of four
minutes and longest at 43 minutes. As expected, regain of
consciousness is immediate in the documented cases (97%) of
neurocardiogenic syncope with the exception of one patient
who actually developed seizure shortly after syncope and was
in post-ictal state for about five minutes after regain of consciousness. This patient had evidence of seizure-like activity
on previous electroencephalogram (EEG) manifesting with
changes in the delta frequency, which may be in support of
earlier findings of possible central nervous system involvement, in neurally mediated syncope.3 Data however are still
inadequate to make a conclusion regarding this proposed
mechanism.
Previous evidences showed that patients with neurally mediated syncope more often than not, would have normal electrocardiogram (ECG) and structurally normal hearts, which was
further supported by the findings of this investigation. It has
likewise been previously proposed that the presence of long
QT syndrome may predispose patients to developing
neurocardiogenic syncope.13 In this study, one patient had a
prolonged QT interval on baseline ECG and manifested with a
positive HUTT. Such finding appears to be compatible the
previous observations, however, the number of patients with
long QT in this study was clearly inadequate to make this
11
generalization. Although most patients with a positive HUTT
had normal ECG with normal QT interval and structurally normal hearts, none of these factors correlated significantly with
a (+) HUTT result.
Of particular interest in the investigation of head-up tilt
testing are the attempts to establish possible factors that may
predict a positive outcome. One of the variables that have
been proposed to predict for a positive outcome is the occurrence of early heart rate increase during HUTT.14, 15 The early
heart rate increase is determined as the maximum difference
between the heart rate on the first five minutes of the tilt portion of the test and the heart rate on supine position just before
putting the patient on tilt position. Aerts et al.5 showed that no
specific heart rate would predict for a positive outcome.
Sumiyashi et al.10 on the other hand states that an early heart
rate rise >18 beats/min is a sensitive marker for a positive response at <15 minutes of tilt with 100% sensitivity and 61%
specificity. This study showed that there was indeed a positive correlation between an early heart rate increase and a positive HUTT outcome (p<0.001) indicating that this may be a
useful predictor of a positive outcome of the test. The mechanism proposed for an early excessive increase in the heart rate
during HUTT was possibly a aroreflex-mediated response triggered by the early decrease in systolic blood pressure that was
more pronounced in the positive group.11 As earlier mentioned,
there has been no established correlation between age and a
positive HUTT. It has been shown however that the
vasodeppresor type of syncope appear to have a predilection
to affect those who are >65 years old.8 Although this was not
confirmed in this study, it has been observed that patients manifesting with vasodepressor syncope appeared to involve the
older subjects with a mean age of 44 + 21.62 years. This is in
contrast the cardio-inhibitory type of neurocardiogenic syncope and the mixed type of syncope which appears to affect a
younger age group (35 + 29.85 and 31 + 21.62 years, respectively). The differences however in age involvement did not
correlate significantly with a positive HUTT result (p=0.35).
Majority of the patients (97%) were given isoproterenol
as a provocative agent with only three patients receiving atropine, hence, no adequate comparison could be made between
these two populations. Only one patient experienced a complication, which was the occurrence of seizure establishing the
complication rate at 1%.
Conclusion
Results of this study showed the clinical profile of patients
at the Philippine Heart Center with suspected neurocardiogenic
syncope referred for head-up tilt testing. Majority of the patients affected was in the relatively young age group with a
mean age of 47 + 21 years presenting more often than not with
syncope or presyncope.
12
The overall case finding rate is established at 37%, which
increased to 74% in patients presenting with classical prodrome.
Age, sex, a normal ECG and normal QT interval did not correlate significantly with the outcome of tilt. It was shown however that the vasodepressor type of syncope appears to affect
the older age group. The presence of a classical prodrome and
an early heart rate rise on the other hand clearly correlated
significantly to a (+) HUTT outcome.
Indeed, the head-up tilt test remains a very useful tool in
the evaluation of suspected neurocardiogenic syncope with a
very high case finding rate in the presence of symptoms of
classical prodrome. Its presence together with an early heart
rate increase may be a useful guide in predicting outcome of
the test.
Recommendations
The findings of this study established the local baseline
data on the profile of patients with suspected neurocardiogenic
syncope undergoing head-up tilt test in the Philippine setting.
The results appear to be comparable to the findings noted in
foreign literature. With these data, the baseline characteristics
of the patients have been established, which may be used in
determining future studies on head-up tilt test that may be done
corollary to these findings.
References
1. Braunwald E. Heart disease. Textbook of cardiovascular medicine. 6th ed.
2001.
2. Eltrafi A, King D, Silat JM et al. Role of carotid sinus syndrome and
neurocardiogenic syncope in recurrent syncope and falls in patients referred
to an outpatient clinic in a district general hospital. Postgrad Med J 2000;76
(897):405-8.
3. Mercader MA, Varghese PJ, Potalicchi SJ, Vankatranan GK. New insights
into the mechanism of neurally mediated syncope. Heart 2002; 88(3):217221.
4. Pires LA, Ganji JR, Jarandila R, Steele R. Diagnostic patterns and temporal
trends in the evaluation of adult patients hospitalized with syncope. Arc Int
Med 2001;161(15):1889-95.
5. Fang BR, Kuo LT. Usefulness of head-up tilt test in the evaluation and management of unexplained syncope or pre-syncope. Japan Heart J 2000;
41(5):623-31.
6. Koller ML, Meesmann M. Neurocardiogenic convulsive syncope differential
diagnosis, pathophysiology and therapy based on a case report. Z Kardiol
2000;89(11):1032-8.
7. Perez-Paredes M, Pico Aracil F et al. Head-up tilt test in patients with high
pretest likelihood of neurally mediated syncope: an approximation to the real
sensitivity of this testing. PACE 1999;22(8):1173-8.
8. McGavigan AD, Hood S. The influence of sex and age on response to headup tilt table testing in patients with recurrent syncope. Age Ageing
2001;30(4):295-8.
9. Petersen ME, William TR et al. The normal response to prolonged passive
head-up tilt testing. Heart 2000;84(5):509-14.
10. Sumiyashi ME, Nakata Y et al. Does an early increase in heart rate during
tilting predict the results of passive tilt testing? PACE 2000;23(12):1046-51.
11. Bellard E, Fortrat J-O et al. Early predictive indexes of head-up tilt table testing
outcomes utilizing heart rate and arterial pressure changes. Am J Cardio
2001;88:903-906.
NR Rey, et al
12. Graham LA, Kenny RA. Clinical characteristics of unexplained syncope and
their relationship to tilt table test outcomes. Clin Auton Res 2002;12(2):8893.
13. Hermosillo AG, Falcon JC et al. Positive head-up tilt table test in patients
with the long QT syndrome. Europace 1999;1(4):213-7.
14. Mallat Z, Vicut E et al. Prediction of head-up tilt test of early heart rate variations. Circulation 1997;96:581-84.
15. Alvarez JB, Asensio JE et al. Early heart rate variations during head-up tilt
table testing as a predictor of outcome of the test.
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
13
Original Article
The Clinical Profile and Outcome of PTCA (with
or without stent) in Diabetic and Non-diabetic
Patients with Coronary Artery Disease: The
Philippine Heart Center Experience
Karla Rhea G. Rillera-Posadas MD, Ramoncito B. Tria MD, Raul D. Jara MD.
BACKGROUND: Retrospective case-control study conducted at Philippine Heart Center (PHC). This study aims to
determine the clinical profile, outcome and survival between diabetic and non-diabetic patients who underwent PTCA.
METHODS AND RESULTS: A total of 128 patients who underwent angioplasty from 1995-2000 were included with
60 diabetic and 68 non-diabetic patients. Males predominated with ages between 58-59 years. Mean duration of Diabetes Mellitus (DM) was eight years. Among the diabetic patients, 63% were smokers, with 32% presenting with hypercholesterolemia and 55% were found to be hypertensive. However, in the non-diabetic group, 8% were obese and 47% were
hypertensive. Both the diabetic and non-diabetic groups had predominantly one-vessel involvement. Mean Ejection
Fraction (EF) of 57% in diabetic and 59% in non-diabetic group were found in this study. Furthermore, diabetic patients
were more likely to be in the New York Heart Association (NYHA) functional class (FC) II on admission, while nondiabetic patients were in the NYHA FC I. Complication rate of 40% was noted in the DM group whereas 24% was found
in the non-DM group. The case success rate was 95% in the DM group and 96% in the non-DM group (p=NS). Three
patients (5%) in the DM and three cases (4%) in the non-DM group died during hospitalization. Over-all major adverse
cardiac events were not different between the two groups (16% vs. 8% p=NS).
CONCLUSION: Long-term and event-free survival rates were not significantly different between the diabetic and
non-diabetic patients (81 vs. 89%) up at six years follow-up.
Phil Heart Center J 2002;9:14-18
Keywords: Angioplasty, Transluminal, percutaneous Coronary; coronary disease; diabetes mellitus
oronary artery disease (CAD) is the most common
cause of death in adults with diabetes mellitus (DM).
Percutaneous Transluminal Coronary Angioplasty
(PTCA) (with or without stent) is used to revascularize the
occluded vessels of these patients to improve their survival.
There is an increased incidence of large vessel atherosclerosis
and myocardial infarction in patients with DM. Non-invasive
procedures such as PTCA are often done to improve the quality of life as well as survival in such patients. Diabetes mellitus is a strong risk factor for the development of CAD, that
diabetic patients demonstrate a three-fold increase in atherosclerotic disease, as well as the risk of cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. Medical opinion presently suggests that diabetic patients with coronary artery disease are likely to have
diffusely diseased and inoperable vessels.1,2,3,4 Due to the prevalence of CAD, diabetic patients constitute an important segment, (10-25%) 5 of the population undergoing coronary
revascularization procedures; posing a challenge, as the long-
C
Correspondence: Karla Rhea G. Rillera-Posadas, MD. Division of Adult Cardiology Philippine
Heart Center East Avenue, Quezon City, Philippines 1100
ISSN 0018-9034
term event rates in these patients are known to be higher than
in the non-diabetic patients.6 Hence, the need for a study to
demonstrate the outcome of PTCA between diabetics and nondiabetic. Coronary angioplasty is effective in relieving symptoms in patients with single vessels and multivessel coronary
disease, even when applied to stenosis with relative high-risk
characteristics.7
Research Objectives
The objectives of this study are to determine the clinical
profile and outcome of diabetic and non-diabetic patients with
CAD following PTCA and to review the factors that will influence the outcome and survival between diabetic and non-diabetic patients who underwent PTCA.
Methodology
This is a retrospective case-control study involving diabetics and non-diabetic patients 30 years old and above who
Copyright 2002 Philippine Heart Center Journal
had CAD and subsequently underwent PTCA (with or without stent) at the Philippine Heart Center from January 1995 to
December 2000. The patients' course were followed up from
the time of PTCA up to the time of the study.
The demographic profile of the patients included age, sex,
duration of DM (years), smoking history, presence of hypercholesterolemia, coronary artery involvement, obesity, hypertension, ejecyion fraction and New York Heart Association
Functional Classification (NYHAFC). Variables for clinical
outcome are duration of hospital stay after the PTCA, presence or absence of complications, restenosis, occurence of MI
and mortality, and event-free survival rates.
Chart review for data collection and follow-up through
telephone contacts with the patients in this study as well as
through their attending physicians were made. Patients were
asked about the presence of symptoms, hospitalizations subsequent to the index angioplasty, the occurrence of myocardial
infarction (MI), and additional angioplasty or coronary surgery. Patients were followed up for up to six years.
Table I.
Category
Diabetic
(n=60)
Non-diabetic
(n=68)
P value
Age in years
Smoking
Hypercholesterolemia
Obesity
Hypertension
59
38 (63%)
19 (32%)
0
33 (55%)
58
37 (54%)
10 (15%)
6 (8%)
32 (47%)
0.6378
0.4549
0.0421
0.0289
0.52
One-vessel disease (IVD) was seen more frequently in the
diabetic patients (83%) compared to the non-diabetic group
(73%) (p = ns). However, two-vessel (2VD) as well as
multivessel disease were noted more in non-diabetic patients.
Diabetic patients have a lower ejection fraction (EF) compared to the non-diabetic (57 vs. 59%). (See Table II)
Table II. Ejection fraction
Statistical Analysis
Association of different factors with occurrence of DM
was determined using t-test, chi-square and Fisher exact probability test. Event-free survival rates were computed using
Kaplan-Meier analysis.
Results
Baseline Characteristics
One hundred twenty-eight (128) patients who underwent
angioplasty from 1995-2000 were included in this study. Nondiabetic patients (53%) predominated in this study, compared
with diabetics (47%). Most of them were males (44 and 64
non-diabetics), whereas females were only 16 and 4, respectively.
Diabetic patients have the disease for a mean duration of
eight years, fulfilling any of the following criteria: patients on
oral hypoglycemic therapy, insulin therapy, fasting blood sugar
(FBS) of 140 mg/dL or GTT 200 mg/dL or more at two hours.
Diabetic patients were older, and more likely current smokers.
However, the association was not significant. Obesity on the
other hand, was found more often in the non-diabetic group
but the rate of hypercholesterolemia in excess of 250 mg/dL
was higher in diabetic than in non-diabetic group. No significant difference was encountered with respect to the presence
of hypertension in both groups. A non-significant trend of
concomitant risk factors were seen more in non-diabetic compared with diabetic patients.
One-vessel disease (IVD) was seen more frequently in the
diabetic patients (83%) compared to the non-diabetic group
(73%) (p = ns). However, two-vessel (2VD) as well as
multivessel disease were noted more in non-diabetic patients.
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
Diagnostic profile
EF
Diabetic
(n=6)
Non-diabetic
(n=34)
< 20
21-30
31-40
41-50
51-60
61-70
1 (2%)
1 (2%)
5 (8%)
8 (14%)
19 (32%)
15 (25%)
0
3 (4%)
2 (3%)
11 (16%)
20 (29%)
24 (35%)
P value = 0.5782
Analysis of patients' functional status revealed a significantly higher number of patients from the non-diabetic group
in New York Heart Association Functional Class I (NYHA
FC) on admission whereas more diabetics were found in NYHA
FC II. Higher NYHA classification is a significant predictor
of inferior clinical outcome after PTCA (p=0.000001). See
Figure 1
60
N
u
m
b
e
r
P
a
t
i
e
n
t
o
s
f
50
40
30
20
10
0
I
II
III
IV
NYHA Functional Class
DM
Non-DM
Figure 1. New York Heart Association Functional Class Status
15
Clinically successful procedures was performed in 36
(60%) diabetic patients and 52 (70%) non-diabetic patients
(p=ns). The presence of complications such as restenosis, conversion from PTCA to CABG, aborted PTCA due to failure to
cross wire, groin complications and periprocedural bleeding
as well as death were noted in 24 diabetic compared to 16 in
non-diabetic patients. See Table III
Table VI.
Hospital stay
Number of Days
DM
(n=60)
Non-DM
(n=67)
0-7
14-Aug
15-21
>21
27 (45%)
19 (32%)
8 (13%)
6 (10%)
50 (75%)
13 (19%)
3 (4%)
1 (1%)
p value =0.001
Table III.
Complications
Complications
DM
(n=60)
Non-DM
(n=68)
Without complications
With complication and death
36 (60%)
24 (40%)
52 (70%)
16 (24%)
In-hospital complication rate didn't differ significantly between the two groups (37 vs. 20%). See Table 4
Table IV.
Complications
DM
(n=57)
Non-DM
(n=65)
36 (63%)
21 (37%)
52 (80%)
13 (20%)
Mortality rate in both the diabetic and non-diabetic groups
during the follow-up period was low. However, more diabetics underwent revascularization from the time of index percutaneous coronary revascularization (PCR) (16 vs 4%; p=ns).
Furthermore, event-free survival rates in the diabetics and nondiabetics were high (81 vs. 89%; p=ns). In other authors,8,9
mortality rate in the comparable time is much higher, being
significantly higher in diabetic patients who had undergone
revascularization both PTCA and coronary artery bypass graft
(CABG).8,9 See Table VII
Table VII. Long term outcome
Without complications
With complications
DM
(n=57)
Non-DM
(n=65)
P-value
Mortality
0
1 (2%)
1
Revascularization from index
- CABG
- PTCA
PCR
9 (16%)
0
3 (4%)
1 (2%)
0.08
Lost to follow-up
Event-free survival
2 (3%)
56 (81%)
2 (3%)
58 (89%)
1
0.29
p value = 0.062
The survival rate between the 2 groups (95 vs. 96%) were
comparable and didn't differ significantly. Mortality rate likewise didn't diverge considerably between the diabetic and nondiabetic (5 vs. 4%) patients. See Table V
Table V.
Early outcome
Favorable outcome
Death
DM
(n=57)
Non-DM
(n=65)
57 (95%)
3 (5%)
65 (96%)
3 (4%)
P value = 1.000
Non-diabetic patients (75%) remained for 0-7 days in hospital compared to 45% of the diabetic patients. Furthermore, a
significant number of the latter group had longer hospital stay
(8 days and above) than the former group. This can be attributed to the complications encountered periprocedurally. See
Table VI
16
Survival function
On follow-up, both the diabetic and non-diabetic groups
had a cumulative survival rate of 0.955. There were 6 mortalities (three from the diabetic and three from the non-diabetic
group) at some point of the first year of follow-up from the
index revascularization and only one mortality thereafter. See
Figure 2
On the first year of follow up, the non diabetic group had
a cumulative survival of .955 which decreased to .940 for the
succeeding follow up years. The diabetic group's cumulative
survival remained stable at 0.950 throughout the follow up
period. See Figure 3
KRG Rillera-Posadas, et al
Survival Function
101
Cummulative Survival
100
G roup
99
1
98
2
97
96
95
94
0
1
TOTAL YRS
2
3
4
5
6
Figure 2. Hazard function (Kaplan Meier Curve)
Survival Function
101
Cummulative Survival
100
99
98
97
96
95
94
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
TOTAL YRS
Figure 3. Survival Function (Kaplan-Mier Curve)
Discussion
Any coronary revascularization strategy must be evaluated in terms of two treatment goals: to provide a safe and
durable treatment of flow-limiting epicardial coronary obstructions and to prevent future morbidity and mortality arising from
ongoing atherosclerosis in non-treated coronary segments.
A given target lesion was safely treated, whereby the atherosclerotic segment was converted to a vascular scar virtually
incapable of future renarrowing via atherosclerosis. Long-term
patency can be practically guaranteed after the six-month vasPhil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
cular repair period was reached without significant narrowing.2 Thus, PCR has been viewed almost as a "cure" for obstructive coronary disease provided the offending lesion remained patent after six months of follow-up.
Similar to smoking and hypercholesterolemia, diabetes is
an independent risk factor that confers cardiovascular death
through atherosclerosis and its effect is potentiated by hyperglycemia and lipid abnormalities. In diabetic patients without
coronary disease, the risk of death has been shown to be equivalent to that of non-diabetic patients with prior myocardial infarction.
There are conflicting data on safety and efficacy of coronary angioplasty in diabetic patients. Numerous studies did
not substantiate meaningful differences in the early outcome
between diabetic and non-diabetic patients10,11,12 but several
analysis confirmed higher periprocedural mortality and the incidence of myocardial infarction in diabetic patients.6
The effectiveness of PTCA in diabetics with multivessel
disease is highly sensitive to severity of atherosclerosis present
at initial therapy.13
In choosing the best treatment for both diabetic and nondiabetic patients, one must consider the force of atherosclerosis progression that may cause future clinically important coronary narrowings and plaque raptures. The clues that can be
used to predict high-probability atherosclerosis progression are
not exact and include the extent of the disease, seen at coronary angiography, and the patient's risk factor profile, including the presence of DM.
Results of the BARI trial,8 RITA-114 and EAST15 suggest that diabetic patients especially those taking oral hypoglycemic agents with minimally apparent multivessel disease (twovessel disease) could be considered for PCR.
Presently, it is considerably accepted that given the stateof-the-art technology and availability of stents, diabetes mellitus does not appear to adversely affect the immediate outcome
of percutaneous coronary interventions.
Long-term outcome seems to be affected, however. In
diabetes, increased blood viscosity, increased synthesis of
thromboxane A2, and decreased prostacyclin production are
encountered. Levels of fibrinogen, Factors VII, VIII and fibrinopeptide A is elevated in connection with decreased antithrombin III activity.16
Due to the endothelial dysfunction, coagulation and fibrinolytic disturbances, platelet aggregation and thrombus formation are enhanced. Kornowski, et al17 showed that the reason for increased restenosis in diabetes was the exaggerated
intimal hyperplasia.
The study identified hypercholesterolemia, obesity, NYHA
FC and duration of hospital stay as associated with morbidity
and cardiac mortality.
This study also presented the results of diabetic patients
who underwent angioplasty. These results were compared with
those of non-diabetic patients who underwent PTCA in the
same institution during the same period.
17
Diabetic patients constituted 47% of the population group
(53% in the non-diabetic group) with a mean duration of eight
years of diabetes mellitus. Hypercholesterolemia was significantly noted in the diabetic group (32% vs. 15% p=0.0421)
but the non-diabetics were more often obese. Diabetic patients
have a lower NYHA FC status on admission (53% in Class II)
compared to the non-diabetics (79% in Class I). Hospital stay
among the diabetics was longer (55% stayed eight days and
longer) than the former group. Complication rates were noted
to be higher in the diabetics compared to the non-diabetic patients (21 vs. 13% p = ns).
Higher re-intervention rate in the present study (16% in
the diabetic and 6% in the non-diabetic group) is due to the
non-significantly higher restenosis rate and atherosclerosis rate
in the diabetic patients. This was corroborated by the results
of other studies.6,9 Furthermore, although Alderman, et al18
pointed out diabetes mellitus to be a risk factor in atherosclerosis progression within a five-year follow-up period, no significant atheroslerosis progression was noted in the follow-up
period of four years in the study of Engelman, et al.19 Longterm, event- free survival rate was not significantly different
between diabetics and non-diabetics (81 vs. 89%) at six years'
follow-up. Similarly, Barsness, et al.20 showed a five year survival among PTCA patients at 76% in the diabetic and 88% in
the non-diabetic patients.
Mortality rate in both the diabetic and non-diabetic groups
do not differ and remain low. This contrasted from other authors19,20 who noted significantly higher mortality rates in the
diabetic group. However, in the study of Przewlocki, et al.,21
low mortality was also noted in the diabetic group whose mean
age was 53.9 years. In the present study, the mean age was 59
years versus 58 years in the non-diabetic group.
Technologies such as the use of glocoprotein IIb/III a inhibitors and stents22 brachytherapy23 as well as aggressive hypoglycemic and hypolipemic therapy24 may significantly enhance the results of coronary intervention in patients with diabetes mellitus.
Nonetheless, despite the state-of-the-art processes being
presented, the effective therapy of coronary artery disease in
diabetic patients presents a problem, requiring development
of sufficient methods to attenuate the risk in these patients.
Until further evidence is available, all resources should be
exhausted to determine treatment strategies for patients with
coronary artery disease. Observational databases are important resources in medical decision-making, providing a broad
perspective that can enhance randomized trials and provide
useful data to patients and physicians.
The present study, suffers from all the attendant disadvantages of a retrospective analysis. Nonetheless, the present
study can provide some insight into the differences in prognosis and long-term results between diabetic and non-diabetic
patients.
18
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
Alonzo D et al. Factors Associated with Long Term Survival of Diabetics.
JAMA 1970;214:133.
Kannel WB et al. Diabetes and Cardiovascular Disease: The Framing- ham
Study. JAMA 1979;241:2035-2038.
Emmacher et al. Longevity of Diabetic Patients in Recent Years. Diabetes
1964;13:373.
Welch Co et al. Coronary Arteriographic Findings in 1,000 Women Under
Age 50. Am J Cardio 1970;25:211-215.
Stern B et al. Influence of Diabetes mellitus on Early and Late Outcome After
PTCA. Circulation 1995;91:979-89.
Kip KE et al. Coronary Angioplasty in Diabetic Patients. The National Heart,
Lung and Blood Institute PTCA Registry. Circulation 1996;94:1818-25.
Waller BF et al. Status of the Coronary Arteries at Necropsy in DM with
Onset 30 Years. Am J Med 1980;69:498-506.
Brooks et al. Predictors of Mortality and Mortality from Cardiac Causes in the
BARI Randomized Trial and Registry. Circulation 2000;101: 2687-2689.
Weintraub et.al. Outcome of CABG vs. PTCA in diabetic patients with
Multivessel CAD. J Am Coll Cardiol 1998;31:10-19.
Ellis SG et al. Causes and Correlates of Death After Unsupported Coronary
Angioplasty: Implications for Use of Angioplasty and Advanced Support Techniques in High-risk Settings. Am J Cardiol 1991;68:1447-51.
Tenaglia AM et al. Long-term Outcome Following Successful Re-opening of
Abrupt Closure After Coronary Angioplasty. Am J Cardio 1993;72:21-5.
Wolfe MW et al. Length of Hospital Stay and Complications after PTCA.
Circulation 1995;92:311-9.
Zabat R. Angiographic Characteristics of Coronary Disease in Female Diabetics and Non-Diabetics. Philippine Heart Center Research Paper 1991.
Henderson et al. Long term results of RITA-1 Trial: Clinical and Cost Comparisons of Coronary Angioplasty and CABG. Lancet 1988;352: 1419-1425.
King et al. A Randomized Trial Comparing Coronary angioplasty with CABG:
Emory Angioplasty Vs. Surgery Trial (EAST). N Eng J Med 1994; 331:10441050.
Goldberg S et al. The Interventional Cardiologist and the Diabetic Patient.
Have We Pushed the Envelope Too Far or Not Far Enough? Circulation 1996;
94:1804-6.
Kornowski et.al. Increased Restenosis in DM After Coronary Interventions is
Due to Exaggerated Intimal Hyperplasia. Circulation 1997;95:1366-9.
Alderman et al. Five-year Angiographic Follow-up Factors Associated with
Progression of CAD in the Coronary Artery Surgery Study (CASS). J Am Coll
Cardiol 1993;22:1141-54.
Engelman RM et al. The Influence of DM and Hypertension on the Results of
Coronary Revascularization. J Am Cardiol 1975;35:135.
Barsness et al. Relationship between DM and Long-term Survival After Coronary Bypass and Angioplasty. Circulation 1997;96(8):2551-2556.
Przewlocki et al. Long-term Outcome of Coronary Balloon Angioplasty in
Diabetic Patients. Int J Cardio 2000;76:7-16.
Nairns et al. Does Abciximab Improve Outcome Following Angioplasty in
Diabetics? Long-term Follow-up Results in the EPIC Study. Circulation 1997;
96(suppl 1):1162.
Terstein PS et al. Catheter-based Radiotherapy to Inhibit Restenosis After
Coronary Stents. N Eng J Med 1997;336:1697-703.
Hassinger et al. Outcomes and their predictors after PTCA in patients with
type II DM. Circulation 1996;94(suppl):1436.
KRG Rillera-Posadas, et al
Original Article
Profile of a High-Risk Subgroup in Acute Inferior
Wall Myocardial Infarction: Multi-Center Study
Valentin G. Yabes MD, Santos Jose G. Abad MD, P J Agunod-Cheng MD, R R Torres MD
BACKGROUND: The incidence of High-Grade AV block (HGAVB) in inferior wall myocardial infarction (MI) is 16%
with a positive correlation on J/R ratio >50%. We would like to validate this statistics as well as the correlation of J/R
ratio >50% to HGAVB in the Philippine setting, wherein mortality and duration of hospitalization were considered as
endpoints.
METHODS AND RESULTS: All patients admitted at Philippine Heart Center, Veterans Memorial Medical Center,
Philippine General Hospital, East Avenue Medical Center, Fort Bonifacio General Hospital, and Jose Reyes Memorial
Medical Center from January 1997 to December 2000, who presented with inferior wall MI were entered in the study.
Patients with onset of symptoms within 48 hours of admission with anginal chest pains and elevated cardiac markers
were included. The demographic profile, Killip class on admission and use of thrombolytics were noted. Pressure
highest ST segment elevation on electrocardiograms (ECG's) were classified into pattern 1 (J/R ratio <50%), pattern 2
(J/R ratio >50% in 2 or more leads) and pattern 3 (presence of early Q waves). The incidence of HGAVB, hospital stay
and mortality were also assessed. Four hundred and eight patients were included in the study. ECG pattern 1 was seen
in 160, pattern 2 in 98, and pattern 3 in 150. HGAVBs were found in 9.4% with pattern 1, 46.9% with pattern 2, and 24.9%
with pattern 3. Of 150 the patients who had early Q waves, 37 (24.9%) had HGAVB, 26 (14.3%) out of 182 with J/R ratio
<0.5 had HGAVB while 35 (46.7%) out of 75 with J/R ratio >0.5 had HGAVB. Among patients with right ventricular
Infarction (RVI) 60% had HGAVB in contrast to those without RVI, 20%. On average, patients with HGAVB were hospitalized for 10.2 days versus 8.3 days for those without.
CONCLUSION: Patients with HGAVB had a higher Killip class and longer hospital stay. Multivariate regression
analysis showed that worst Killip (p=0.0019), JR ratio average >50% (p=0.0004), ECG pattern 2 (p=0.000***) and hospital
stay (p=0.0441) were independent by associated with HGAVB. Thus, JR ratio average >50%, ECG pattern 2 and RVI
were predictors of the development of HGAVB among patients with inferior wall MI.
Phil Heart Center J 2002;9:19-23
Keywords: myocardial unfarction, heart block
atients with acute inferior wall myocardial infarction
(MI) generally have a better outcome than those with
acute anterior wall MI, but some of those with inferior
wall MI have an increase risk for complications. For instance,
in high-degree (second degree type II and higher) Atrio-ventricular (AV) block developing in inferior wall MI carries a
poor prognosis. Although high-degree AV block is usually
not permanent, it has been associated with up to 20% in hospital mortality.1 Early appearance, with the first 24 hours, compared with late appearance of high-degree AV block has been
shown to carry higher rates of mortality, left ventricular failure and cardiogenic shock.2 Thus, the subset of acute inferior
wall MI patients with an increased risk for high-degree AV
block should be identified early. Inferior wall MI account for
40% to 50% of all acute MI. And patients with acute inferiror
wall MI patients with high degree AV block possess a higher
m o r t a l i t y r i s k . 3,4 R e f e r r a l t o a t e r t i a r y h o s p i t a l i n
P
Correspondence: Valentin G. Yabes, MD. Division of Adult Cardiology,
Philippine Heart Center East Avenue, Quezon City, Philippines 1100
ISSN 0018-9034
patientswith acute inferior wall MI who develop high-degree
AV block.5 Revascularisation may be considered in this subset because mortality is high despite thrombolysis.6,7 Studies
in the local setting to evaluate clinical and electrocardiographic
indices that identify acute inferior wall MI patients with increased risk of developing high-degree AV block is needed.
Bassan, et al.1 who studied 51 patients with inferior wall
MI noted that patients with left arterior descending (LAD) coronary artery obsstruction were more likely to develop AV block.
Furthermore, patients with inferior MI and LAD coronary artery obstruction have a 6-fold greater chance of developing
heart block.
Bilbao, et al. 9 studied 44 patients with posterior inferior
wall AMI to determine the anatomic basis of AV block. The
results showed lack of correlation between block and lesions
of the specialized conducting system. But there was a strong
association of block with necrosis of the atrial prenodal myocardium and twenty-nine or 97% with AV block showed necrosis of this area.
Birnbaum, et al.7 studied 2603 patients with acute
Copyright 2002 Philippine Heart Center Journal
MI treated with thrombolytic therapy. The patients were classified into two groups - those with and those without distortion
of the terminal portion of the QRS complex in two or more
consecutive leads, i.e. the emergence of J-point at a level above
the lower half of the R wave in leads with qR configuration or
disappearance of the S wave in leads with an Rs configuration.
They found that an interval of more than two hours from symptom onset to thrombolysis was associated with increased hospital mortality only among patients with QRS distortion, not
in those without this ECG finding. Conversely, distortion of
the terminal portion of the QRS complex on admission ECG is
an independent predictor of hospital mortality, only among
those treated with thrombolysis more than two hours after symptom onset. Their study suggest that earlier thrombolysis will
improve survival of this subset of patients. This study, however, involved patients who suffered either an anterior or inferior acute MI.
Christian et al.11 used T-99m sestamibi among 67 patients
diagnosed with ST segment elevation acute MI to provide an
estimate of infarct size. And he noted that the larger the infarct, the higher was the ST segment elevation.
Birnbaum et al.7 reported that among patients treated with
thrombolytics for inferior wall acute MI, a simple ECG sign of
J-point / R-wave ratio >0.5 in more than two inferior wall leads
is a reliable predictor for the development of high-degree AV
block. Other variables associated independently with highdegree AV block included female gender, Killip class >2, and
absence of abnormal Q waves on admission. However, this
study, as with the previous one, was limited to patients with
acute inferior wall MI who received thrombolytic treatment.
Solodky et al.8 assessed variables on admission to predict
the development of high-degree AV block within the first 24
hours of hospitalisation in 205 patients with acute inferior wall
MI. ECG's taken on admission were divided into two patterns:
pattern I: J-point/ R-wave <0.5, and pattern 2: J-point/ R-wave
>0.5 in at least two inferior leads. They encountered significantly more frequent high-degree AV block in patients with
pattern 2 (19%) as compared to patients with pattern 1 (10.2%).
By multivariate regression analysis, the variables independently
associated with high-degree AV block were initial ECG pattern 2 (odds ratio, OR = 4.47, p = 0.028), age (OR=1.06,
p=0.025), and absence of thrombolytic therapy (OR=0.32,
p=0.037). There have been no other previous studies that have
directly studied variables that might predict high- degree AV
block.
c. Hypertension
d. Diabetes mellitus
e. Smoking history
f. Pattern (J-point/ R-wave ratio > 0.5) on highest ST
ECG
g. Presence of pathologic Q waves on admission
ECG
h. Killip class on admission
i. Thrombolysis
j. Time to ER from onset of symptoms
k. Right ventricular infarction (RVI)
2. To determine the prevalence of high degree AV block
in ECG pattern 1 and pattern 2
3. To determine the differences in clinical outcome in patients with and without high-degree AV block:
a. Total in-hospital mortality
b. Cardiac mortality
c. Non-cardiac mortality
d. Killip class >2
Methodology
Study Design
A multi-center retrospective study was used to determine
the objectives.
Research Objectives
Objectives of this study were:
Study Sample
The medical charts of patients admitted at Philippine Heart
Center, Veterans Memorial Medical Center, Philippine General Hospital, East Avenue Medical Center, Fort Bonifacio
General Hospital, and Jose Reyes Memorial Medical Center
from January 1997 to December 2000 were retrospectively
reviewed. The diagnosis of inferior wall MI was made based
on the following:
(1) Anginal chest pain
(2) Elevated Cardiac enzymes
(3) ST segment elevation in more than two inferior leads.
Patients with the following criteria were excluded:
(1) Negative T wave in more than two inferior leads on
admission ECG, as only patients in the acute stages of
inferior wall MI were included.
(2) Concomitant acute anterior wall MI.
(3) Intraventricular conduction defect.
(4) Ventricular paced beats (patients with permanent pacemakers).
1. To determine if the following variables contribute to
the development on high grade AV block in patients with acute
inferior wall MI:
a. Gender
b. Age
Identification of Study Variables
For the first objective, the dependent variable is the development of high-degree AV block. The independent variables
include:
a. Gender - Male or female
20
VG Yabes, et al
b. Age
c. Hypertension
d. Diabetes mellitus
e. Smoking history
f. Killip class on admission
g. Thrombolysis
h. ECG criteria - The ECG's will be recorded with a 0.1mv
sensitivity and a 25 mm/sec paper speed. Single lead ECG
monitoring will be done on patients during their stay at the
ICU.
h1. Pattern (J-point/R-wave ratio> 0.5) on selected ECG.
h2. Presence of pathologic Q waves on admission ECG.
h3. Presence of ST segment elevation in V3R and V4R.
For the second objective, the patients with the presence or
abscence of high-grade AV block. were compared by the following:
a. Total in-hospital mortality - the total number of deaths
from cardiac and non-cardiac causes divided by the total
number of patients.
b. Cardiac mortality - the number of deaths from cardiac
causes divided by the total number of patients.
c. Non-cardiac mortality - the number of deaths from
noncardiac causes divided by the total
number of patients.
d. Worst Killip class.
Description of Data Collection
All patients admitted from January 1997 to December 2000
were entered in the study. The following variables were noted:
a. Gender-Male or female
b. Age in years
c. Hypertension - presence or absence of hypertension,
defined as a systolic pressure >140 mm Hg or a diastolic
BP >90mm Hg.
d. Diabetes mellitus (Insulin-requiring or non-insulin
requiring) presence or absence of
e. Current smoking - Yes or no
f. Killip class on admission
g. Thrombolysis - Received or not received
h. ECG criteria
h1. Pattern (J-point/R-wave ratio >0.5) on selected ECG
h2. Presence of pathologic Q waves on admission ECG
h3. Presence of ST Segment elevation V3R and V4R
Patients who developed high-degree AV block, or experienced any cardiac or non-cardiac mortality, and the worst Killip
class during the hospital stay.
Data Handling
Data were obtained in the data collection form, then tabulated in the necessary tables. All electrocardiograms and rhythm
strips were analyzed.
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
Statistical Analysis
Patients were dichotomised according to whether they experienced high-degree AV block or not. For continuous variables, the mean + SD were computed, and statistical significance between groups were analysed using the two tailed ttest. For dischotomous variables, the absolute and relative frequencies were obtained, and differences analyzed by the chisquare or Fisher's exact test. Multivariate analyses were done.
For both models, the dependent variable was the development
of high-grade AV block. One model included the following
independent variables: gender, age, hypertension, diabetes
mellitus, present smoking, Killip class on admission, thrombolysis, time to ER from onset of symptoms, pattern (J-point/
R-wave ratio >0.5) on highest ST ECG and presence of pathologic Q waves and Right Ventricular Infarction on ECG. The
p values, ODD'S ratios, and 95% confidence intervals were
computed. A p-value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Results
Four hundred and eight patients (n=408) were included in
the study. The youngest was 29 years old and the oldest was
92 years old with a mean of 60 years. Eighty out of 330 males
had high grade AV block (HGAVB) while 18 only (23%) out
of 78 for females. Among the 239 patients with hypertension,
54 (23%) had HGAVB, while in 169 patients without hypertension, 42 (25%) had HGAVB. (Table I)
Thirty three (30%) of diabetic patients had HGAVB while
65 (22%) of the 298 non-diabetics had HGAVB. Sixty two
(23%) of the 269 smokers had HGAVB, while 36 (25.9%) of
the 130 non-smokers had HGAVB. Time to emergency room
data showed the earliest time at 0.3 hours and the latest at 48
hours with a mean duration of 14.8 hours and a median of 6
hours. Admission Killips were recorded and 205, 85, 21 and
37 patients were in Killips Classes I, II, III, and IV, respectively. Fifty seven (21.5%) in Killip I, 25 (30%) in Killip II, 5
(9.5%) in Killip III and 14 (37.8%) in Killip IV had HGAVB.
Eight (20%) of the 40 patients who were given
thrombolytics had HGAVB while 85 (21.45%) out of 358 patients without thrombolytics had HGAVB. Electrocardiogram
pattern 1 was seen in 160, pattern 2 in 89 and pattern 3 in 149.
HGAVBs were found in 10% with pattern 1, 46% with pattern
2, and 24% with pattern 3. Of the 149 patients with early Q
waves, 36 (24%) had HGAVB, 36 (14.3%) out of 182 with J/
R ratio <0.5 had HGAVB while 35 (46.7%) out of 75 with J/R
ratio >0.5 had HGAVB.
On the average, patients with HGAVB were hospitalized
for 10.2 days versus 8.3 days for those without. Likewise more
patients with HGAVB had Killip class >2 (36 vs. 19%) during
hospitalization. Increased cardiac mortality was noted for
21
patients with HGAVB compared with those without (20 vs.
10%).
Multivariate analysis showed that the only variables to be
associated with HGAVB were: presence of RVI (p<0.001),
highest ST ECG pattern 2 versus pattern 1 (p<0.001), JR ratio
average >50% (p=0.004), worst Killip class >2 (p=0.00019),
and duration of hospital stay (p=0.0044).
Table I. Demographic comparison of patients in acute infarction
wall MI in the presence or absence of HBGAV
Gender
Male
Female
Age years( mean )
Hypertension
No
Yes
Diabetes mellitus
No
Yes
Smoking Hx
No
Yes
Killip on admission
1
2
3
4
HGAVB (-)
(n=310)
HGAVB (+)
(n=98)
p value
250 (76%)
60 (77%)
59.287
80 (25%)
18 (23%)
60.67
127 (75%)
183 (77%)
42 (25%)
56 (23%)
NS
233 (78%)
65 (22%)
33 (30%)
NS
77 (70%)
103 (74%)
207 (77%)
36 (26%)
62 (23%)
NS
208 (79%)
60 (70%)
19 (91%)
23 (62%)
57 (22%)
25 (30%)
2 (10%)
14 (38%)
NS
NS
NS
Table II. Clinical and ECG comparison of patients in acute
infraction wall MI
J/R Average
0
<0.5
>0.5
Cardiac Mortality
No
Yes
Hospital Stay (mean)
Thrombolysis
No
Yes
Pattern on ECG
1
2
3
RV infarction
No
Yes
Non-cardiac Mortality
No
Yes
HGAVB (-)
(n=310)
HGAVB (+)
(n=98)
p value
113(75%)
156(86%)
40(53%)
37(25%)
26(14%)
35(47%)
<0..0001
0.004*
280(90%)
30(10%)
8.376
79(80%)
19(20%)
10.389
0.016
0.4175*
0.0042
0.0441*
273(68.6%)
32(8%)
85(21%)
8(2%)
0.718
NS
144(36%)
48(12%)
113(28%)
16(4%)
41(10%)
36(9%)
<0.0001
293(82%)
17(40%)
72(20%)
26(61%)
<0.0001*
302(76%)
3(0.75%)
93(23%)
0 (0%)
NS
NS - no significance
HGAVB - high grade atrioventricular block
22
Discussion
There was no association noted between gender, age, presence or absence of hypertension, diabetes, thrombolytics and
smoking history with high degree AV block. The data in this
study validated the results of previous studies except for thrombolytic therapy and age. Wherein, other studies showed both
parameters correlated with high degree AV block. Age and
thombolytic therapy were not predictors of high grade AV block
(HGAVB) in this study. Twenty one percent of those without
thrombolytic therapy had high grade AV block compared to
20% patients who were given thrombolytics. A decreasing
trend of AV block was noted for those with thrombolysis but
this was not statistically significant. This suggests that thrombolytic therapy does not alter the progression to high grade
AV block of patients with inferior wall MI. Thus,
otherrevascularization procedures should be done because
thrombolytics is inadequate. The limitation of this study is
that only 40 out of 408 patients were given thrombolytics.
A higher incidence of high grade AV block in inferior
wall MI was noted in the local setting. Ten percent for pattern
1 and 46% for pattern 2, in the local study, against 10.2% (pattern 1) and 1% (pattern 2) for the foreign literature. Other
studies who reported patients with inferior wall MI who underwent thrombolysis were seen within a 24-hr period.
Whereas, this study included patients who had no pharmacologic intervention and who had symptoms up to the 48th hour.
This study included patients up to the 48th hour after the
onset of symptoms because 101 out of 408 patients were only
referred and admitted in our institution after the 12th hour.
Thus, a significant percentage of patients with inferior wall
MI were seen or referred beyond the window period for which
thrombolytic therapy could have been given. This study was
unable to do a pre-hospital profile to determine the reasons
behind the delay of referral.
There is a significant difference in the incidence of high
grade AV Block for patients with pattern 1 compared with
pattern 2. This validates previous studies which showed ST
elevation to be correlated with incidence of HGAVB and a
reflection of the extent of myocardial damage.4,9
A higher percentage (46%) of patients with pattern 2 had
HGAVB compared to only 16% in foreign literature. Because
highest ST ECG was used in this study instead of admission
ECG. This suggests that highest ST ECG is a better predictor
of HGAVB than admission ECG.
Thus, serial ECG with ST monitoring (for the first 72 hrs)
and J/R ratio determinations should be done to identify patients with pattern 2 ECG. Because pattern 2 ECG is a predictor of HGAVB.
Forty sixty percent of patients (local setting) with pattern
2 progressed to HGAVB which suggest left anterior descending (LAD) artery involvement.1 Furthermore, a multivessel
coronary artery disease (left circumflex or right coronary
VG Yabes, et al
artery with LAD) was predicted in this subgroup (Inferior wall
MI with HGAVB). Thus, early invasive diagnostic or therapeutic procedures should be done in inferior wall MI patients
with pattern 2 ECG.
Worst Killip classification was correlated with HGAVB
because patients with block, as previously mentioned have,
LAD involvement and therefore a larger myocardium at risk
which leads to myocardial failure. Further studies should be
done to determine the echocardiographic parameters.
The J/R average of >0.5 was correlated with HGAVB. This
was studied to assess the use of taking the average of all the
inferior leads and set a level at which significant HGAVB arises.
Higher incidence of block was noted only at a ratio greater
than or equal to fifty percent. This data validates the study by
Christian11 correlating ST elevation with extent of myocardial damage.
Patients with HGAVB have prolonged hospital stay
because they require a longer time to stabilize and rehabilitate.
Conclusion
Thus, RV infarction, JR ratio average >50% and ECG
pattern 2 were predictors of the development of HGAVB
among patients with inferior wall MI. And patients with
HGAVB have higher Killip class and prolonged hospital stay.
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
References
1. Bassan R, Maia I G, Bozza A, Amino J C, Santos M. Atrioventricular block in
acute inferior wall MI: Harbinger of associated obstruction of the left anterior
descending coronary artery. J Am Coll Cardiol 1986;8:773-8.
2. Behar S, Zissman E, Zion M, Hod H, Caspi A, Kaplinsky E, et al. Inferior
myocardial infarction: high risk subgroups. Circulation 1990;81:401-11.
3. Berger P B, Ruocco N A, Ryan T J, Frederick M M, Jacobs A K, Faxon D P.
Incidence and prognostic implications of heart block complicating MI treated
with thrombolytic therapy: results from TIMI II. J Am Coll Cardiol 1992;20:53340.
4. Strasberg B, Pinchas A, Arditti A, Lewin R, ewin R, Sclarovsky S, Hellman C,
et al. Left and right ventricular infarction in acute inferior wall MI and significance of advanced atrioventricular block. Am J Cardiol 1984;54: 958- 87.
5. Sclarovsky S, Birnbaum Y, Herz I, Chetrit A, Olmer L, Barbash G I, et al. Advanced early and late atrioventricular block in inferior wall MI. Am Heart J
1984;108:19-24.
6. Birnbaum Y, Herz I, Sclarovsky S, Chetrit A, Olmer L, Barbash G I, et al. Prognostic significance of the admission ECG in Acute MI. J Am Coll Cardiol
1996;27:1128-32.
7. BirnbaumY, Herz I, Sclarovsky S, Chetrit A, Olmer L, Barbash G I, et al. Admission clinical and electrocardiographic characteristics predicting in hospital
mortality development of high degree AV block in inferior wall acute MI. Am J
Cardiol 1997;80:1134-38.
8. Solodky A, Abid A, Herz I, Hasdai D, Kusniec J, Sulkes J, et al. Early development of high degree atrioventricular block in inferior wall AMI is predicted by a
J-point / R-wave ratio above 0.5 on admission. Cardiol 1998:90:274-79.
9. Bilbao F J, Zabalda I E, Vilanova J R, Froufe J. Atrioventricular block in posterior acute MI: a clinicopathologic correlation. Circulation 1987:733- 36.
10. Bassan R, Maia I G, Bozza A, Amino J C, Santos M. Acute Inferior wall MI with
high degree AV block: angiographic profile. J Am Coll Cardiol 1988; 10:77080.
11. Christian T F, Gibbons R J, Clements I P, Berger P B, Wagner G S. Estimates
of myocardium at risk and collateral flow in AMI using electrocardiographic
indexes with comparison to radionuclide and angiographic measures. J Am
Coll Cardiol 1995;26:388-92.
23
Original Article
A Comparative Review of Standard Coronary Bypass Grafting under Cardiopulmonary Bypass and
Off-Pump Coronary Artery Bypass Grafting in the
Management of Multivessel Coronary Artery
Disease : Philippine Heart Center
Experience
Joseph J. Bautista MD, Lorenzo Rommel G. Carino MD, Avenilo P. Aventura MD, Florante B. Lomibao MD,
Gerardo S. Manzo MD
BACKGROUND: There is a worldwide trend in the management of coronary artery disease with off-pump coronary
artery bypass grafting without using the cardiopulmonary bypass circuit (CPB). This paper aims to compare the clinical profile and outcome of patients operated for multivessel (more than three) bypass off-pump coronary artery bypass
grafting (OPCABG) with those who underwent such procedure by standard coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG)
under cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB).
METHODS AND RESULTS: This is a prospective cohort study based on hospital and operating room records of
thirty-four (34) consecutive patients who underwent multivessel (more than three) OPCABG at the Philippine Heart
Center from January 1, 2001 to August 31, 2001. The control group was composed of 108 patients operated by multivessel
standard CABG, who were properly matched and operated within one week of the time that the OPCABG patients were
operated. The frequency, mean and standard deviation were calculated for the dependent and independent variables.
Comparison between the two groups was analyzed using Chi-square and student's t-test .
CONCLUSION: OPCABG is comparable to standard CABG for the management of coronary artery multivessel
(more than three vessel) bypass procedures in terms of improved clinical outcome, incidence of post-op complications
and mortality rate and thus, is a safe alternative means of myocardial revascularization. It has the added advantages of
diminished operative cost, blood transfusion requirements, and provision for lesser amount of blood components. The
operative time, duration of post-operative ventilatory support, recovery room/surgical intensive unit stay and postoperative hospital stay were observed to be shorter in OPCABG compared to standard CABG but are not statistically
significant.
Phil Heart Center J 2002;9:24-30
Keywords: angioplasty, transluminal, percutanelous coronary; cardiopulmonary bypass; coronary artery bypass
oronary artery disease remains a leading cause of
mortality and morbidity in the Philippines.1 The efficacy of Coronary Artery Bypass Grafting (CABG) in
the management of Coronary Artery Disease (CAD) has been
proven in several international studies. Coronary artery grafting when compared with medical therapy in the management
of coronary artery disease not only improves the quality of life
but also prolongs life in selected patients. Interestingly, CABG
has remained essentially unchanged for more than 25 years.
At present, there is a worldwide trend to revive cardiac
C
Correspondence: Joseph J. Bautista, MD. Division of Thoracic and Cardiovascular
Surgery. Philippine Heart Center, East Avenue, Quezon City, Philippines 1100.
ISSN 0018-9034
revascularization without cardio-pulmonary bypass (CPB) due
mainly to its deleterious effects, which brings about a diffuse
inflammatory response that affects multiple organ systems.
Kolessov2 in Russia performed the first left internal mammary artery (LIMA) grafting to the left anterior descending
artery (LAD) on the beating heart through an anterior thoracotomy incision for the management of angina pectoris. Goetz
and colleagues3 and Sabiston4 were among the early pioneers
of coronary bypass grafting performed on the beating heart.
In the early 1990's, two centers in South America,
Buffolo 5 and co-workers and Benetti,6 reported more than
1,000 cases of successful "off-pump" CABG in selected
Copyright 2002 Philippine Heart Center Journal
patients, basically to one or two vessels on the anterior wall.
With the revival of off-pump coronary artery bypass grafting (OPCABG), there is also a growing trend to introduce innovative instruments and techniques to stabilize the heart while
cardiac revascularization is being performed. One of these
new instruments is the Medtronic Octopus II Tissue Stabilization System, which was introduced in March 1997 by Spooner
and colleagues7 in the USA. It was also tried and tested by
Jansen and colleagues8 in Utrecht, Netherlands in1995.
On May 1, 1999, OPCABG using this innovative instrument was performed for the first time at the Philippine Heart
Center (PHC). Since then, there was an increase in the number of such procedures performed at PHC. The initial experience with this technique was done for one-vessel and two-vessel coronary artery disease with good results.9 This was due
to the fact that the target vessels-left anterior descending artery (LAD) and its branches were accessible anteriorly and
using the stabilizer did not bring much hemodynamic compromise as the anastomosis was being accomplished.
Initially there were reservations in the performance of this
procedure for multivessel (three-vessel disease) coronary artery disease especially for lesions involving the coronary vessels located posteriorly (i.e. right posterior descending arteryRPDA, right posterolateral-RPL, left circumflex-LCx and obtuse marginal-OM). Anastomosis in these vessels requires displacement of the heart from its pericardial cradle and doing
this procedure under beating heart causes hemodynamic problems.
But as surgeons slowly gained experience through training, practice, refinement in techniques and coupled with proper
intra-op communication and coordination with the anesthesiologist, the performance of such procedures for multivessel
coronary artery disease is slowly gaining acceptance as an alternative to standard coronary artery disease after proper patient selection. At present, more cardiac centers abroad are
performing such procedures. Some centers have adopted
OPCABG as the initial approach for coronary artery disease
and reserve the standard CABG for difficult cases (i.e. poor
target vessels which prevent complete revascularization) or
perform this procedure initially but convert to standard CABG
once hemodynamic problems or graft malfunction are encountered intra-operatively.
Objectives
The purpose of this study is to compare the clinical outcomes namely, mortality, morbidity (post-operative complications), duration of operation, duration of post-operative ventilatory support, duration of recovery room/ surgical intensive
care unit (RR/SICU) stay, total post-operative blood loss based
on total post-op chest tube output, blood transfusion requirements, total blood component requirements and operative cost
of patients with multivessel coronary artery (three or more
coronary artery vessel involvement) who underwent OPCABG
to that of control subjects who underwent standard CABG
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
under cardiopulmonary bypass.
Methods
This is a prospective cohort study comparing the clinical
profiles and outcome of patients with coronary artery disease
who underwent multivessel (more than three vessel distal coronary anastomosis) OPCABG and those done under standard
CABG at the Philippine Heart Center from January 1, 2001 up
to August 31, 2001. The ratio of OPCABG to control group is
1:3. The control group, composed of at least three (3) properly matched patients who underwent multivessel standard
CABG, for operated within one week during the time a patient
underwent OPCABG. Only patients with multivessel coronary artery bypass grafting (more than three) who were operated on an elective and urgent basis are included.
Emergency operations, re-operations, CABG with other
concomitant operations (e.g. carotid endarterectomy) and
CABG with surgery for myocardial infarction complications
(e.g. ischemic ventricular septal defect, acute mitral regurgitation, and left ventricular aneurysm) were excluded. A datacollecting form was completed per patient. The data included
demographic variables, diagnosis (coronary vessels involved
and New York heart Association [NYHA] functional class),
pre-operative ejection fraction and cardiac events, co-morbid
and other risk factors.
Operative data gathered include date and acuity of operation, number of distal anastomosis performed, vessels bypassed,
duration of operation, use of intra-aortic balloon, conversion
to CABG under CPB for patients who underwent OPCABG
with the corresponding reason for conversion and operative
cost. Post-operative data include total blood components transfused, total postoperative blood loss measured from the chest
tubes output, duration of postoperative ventilatory support
(from the end of the operation up to time of extubation), duration of recovery and surgical intensive care unit stay, postoperative hospital stay complications and mortality.
Statistical Analysis
The frequency, mean, and standard deviation were calculated for the independent and dependent variables. Comparison between the two groups was analyzed using Chi-square
test and student's t-test.
Surgical Technique
OPCABG PCABG was carried out through a full sternotomy incision under general endotracheal anesthesia. The left
internal mammary artery (LIMA) and the saphenous vein grafts
(SVG) are harvested and prepared. Three deep pericardial traction stitches using silk 4-0 sutures are applied near the left upper and lower pulmonary veins and to the left of the inferior
vena cava, thereby achieving vertical displacement of the heart
25
apex. With perfectly placed stitches and aggressive traction,
the apex of the heart should be elevated to approximately 90
degrees. Opening of both pleural cavities and placing the
patient in a gentle right decubitus Trendelenburg position helps
provide good presentation of target arteries on the lateral and
inferior aspect of the heart.
The Octopus Tissue II (Medtronic, Minneapolis, MN) stabilizer is then attached to the sternal retractor and positioned
according to the target vessel to be anastomosed. Prior to anastomosis, ischemic preconditioning is performed whereby the
target vessel is temporarily occluded for five minutes by tagging it with a Prolene 4-0 suture proximally and distally and
reperfused for another five (5) minutes. During this period,
the heart and the patient's hemodynamic status are observed.
Any untoward events such as hemodynamic instability, ST
segment elevation and arrhythmia may be enough reasons to
convert the procedure to CPB-assisted.
If there is no untoward event, the heart is immobilized by
mechanical and medical methods. Medical reduction of heart
rate and myocardial contractility are achieved by giving a shortacting beta-blocker esmolol with a dose of -1 mg/kg bodyweight
(BW). Esmolol has a duration of action of 10 -15 minutes.
The heart rate should be maintained equal or less than 60 beats
per minute. The blood pressure should be maintained at a range
of 100-110 systolic and this may be achieved by giving Nitroglycerine drip (25 mg NTG/250 cc D5W=0.1 mg/cc) given at
1-4 mg to titrate the BP to the desired level. Nicardipine drip
(0.1-5 mg/kg) may also be used.
Mechanical stabilization is achieved with the aid of the
Octopus II tissue stabilizer. Stabilization is accomplished by
suction domes underneath two parallel paddles, which are attached by tubings to a suction apparatus. The ideal suction
should be able to generate a pressure of negative 400 mm Hg
to fix the target site.8 The suction paddles are applied on both
sides of the target vessel. The suctioning effect lifts up the
heart rather than push it against the pericardium and this prevents hemodynamic problems. When applied on the anterior
surface, the suspended anterior wall did not impede left ventricular diastolic filling.7
The coronary arteries are opened longitudinally and anastomosis is performed using prolene 7-0 continuous running
suture. For a relatively dry field, the target coronary vessel is
temporarily snared with a Prolene 4-0 suture or metal clips.
Additional technique to ensure a relatively bloodless field is
the use of the heart lung machine generated filtered blower
(HLMG Fil-blo, PHC).
The proximal aorto-SVG anastomosis is accomplished
under partial occlusion using continuous running Prolene 6-0
suture. During aortic partial cross clamping, there may be transient increase in blood pressure and this may be controlled by
deliberate hypotension by giving either NTG, nicardipine or
esmolol. Upon release of the aortic cross clamp, the patient is
given sodium bicarbonate (1mg/kg BW) and calcium gluconate. The patient is then started on inotropic supports and NTG
26
as the need arises. Intra-operative problems are dealt with accordingly. Premature ventricular contractions are treated with
lidocaine bolus given at 1mg/kg BW or as a drip at 1-4 mg/
hour. For ST wave elevations, bolus doses of either glyceryl
trinitrate or isosorbide dinitrate is given. Hypotension brought
about by cardiac manipulation may be treated with
Trendelenburg maneuver (redistribution of blood volume), fluid
supplementation o inotropic drug support.
After the anastomoses are accomplished, doppler flow
studies of the grafts are done and once the patient is hemodynamically stable, a French 36 chest tube is inserted and the
sternum is closed. The chest tubes are later attached to a thoracic (Emerson) pump at the recovery room and maintained at
a pressure of negative 20 cm water. The chest tubes are removed within 24-48 hours when the output is negligible.
Standard CABG is performed using a median sternotomy
for access. Heparin is administered prior to cannulation at a
dose of 300-400 units/kg. The goal of adequate heparinization is to maintain an activated clotting time (ACT) of 480
seconds. In all cases, the ascending aorta is cannulated for
arterial return and the right atrium is cannulated using a single
two-stage venous cannula for venous drainage. These cannulae are connected to the cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) machine for circulatory support.
The CPB circuit contains a membrane oxygenator and a
centrifugal pump. Coronary revascularization with CPB is
performed under moderate hypothermia (32-340C). Myocardial preservation is achieved by delivery of hyperkalemic cold
cardioplegic blood solution through the aortic root antegradely
and through the coronary sinus at the right atrium retrogradely.
After achieving global myocardial arrest, the anastomoses are
accomplished. Intermittent cardioplegia is given retrogradely
every 15-30 minutes. After the procedure, the patient is rewarmed to 350C before weaning the patient from CPB.
Results
There were thirty-four (34) consecutive patients who underwent multivessel OPCABG at Philippine Heart Center from
January 1, 2001 up to August 31, 2001. The control group
consisted of one hundred eight (108) patients operated on by
standard CABG during the same period. (Ratio of 3.2 patients
operated by standard CABG per patient operated by OPCABG).
Three (3) patients in the OPCABG group were converted to
standard CABG under cardiopulmonary bypass with a conversion rate of 8.82%.
The reasons for conversion were bradycardia and hypotension in two patients while the other patient presented with arrhythmia (premature ventricular contractions). The first two
patients underwent LIMA to LAD anastomosis under
OPCABG but when the anastomosis was being performed
for the posteriorly located vessels, the patients went into
JJ Bautista, et al
hemodynamic instability thus the immediate conversion to standard CABG under cardiopulmonary bypass. The third patient
was undergoing anastomosis for the LIMA to LAD but was
converted to standard CABG due to premature ventricular contractions. The comparison of patient profiles is shown in Table I.
Table I. Demographic Profiles
CHARACTERISTICS
AGE (years): RANGE
STANDARD
CABG
(n=108)
34-81
OFF-PUMP
CABG
(n=34)
PVALUE
39--80
MEAN+SD
59.47 + 10.11
57.7 + 10.16
0.39
SEX: Male
84 (80.77 %)
30 (88.24%)
Female
20 (19.23 %)
4 (11.76 %)
Patient Category:
Service (Dd)
11 (10.58%)
7 (20.59%)
Private ( A)
93 (89.42%)
27 (79.41%)
1.48
Functional Class Mean
2.39
2.26
0.23
Ejection Fraction(Mean)
64.02 + 24.09
65.0 + 23.86
0.71
History of Myocardial
Infarction
52 (50%)
19 (55.88%)
0.69
Pre-operative
Cardiac Events
74 (71.15%)
23 (67.64%)
0.56
Presence of
Co-morbid Factors
26 (76.47%)
95 (91.36%)
0.64
0.46
Table II . Pre-Operative Cardiac Events
Cardiac Event
Chronic Stable Angina
Standard CABG
(n=108)
PCABG
(n=34)
Total
36
11
47
Unstable Angina
37
11
48
Congestive Heart Failure
0
1
1
1
0
1
30
11
41
104
34
138
Arrhythmia
None
Total
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
Table III. Co-Morbid Factors
Standard CABG PCABG
Co-Morbid Factors:
(n=108)
(n=34)
39
10
Diabetes Mellitus
65
19
Hypertension
43
9
Smoker
4
0
Bronchial Asthma
2
1
Chronic
0
1
Pulmonary Tuberculosis
3
0
Chronic Renal Insufficiency
1
0
End Stage Renal Disease
1
0
Diabetes Mellitus Nephropathy
5
0
Cerebrovascular Disease
1
0
Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm
2
0
Thoracic Aortic Aneurysm
1
0
Complete Heart Block
1
0
Chronic Venous Insufficiency
0
2
Dyslipidemia
9
7
None
Total
49
84
52
4
3
1
3
1
1
5
1
2
1
1
2
16
The two groups were comparable with regards to patient
profile and clinical characteristics. There were more males
than females and more private patients than service patients in
both groups. The pre-operative cardiac events and co-morbid
factors for the two groups are presented in Tables II and III,
respectively.
The target vessels or coronary arteries that were grafted
for each group is shown in Table IV.
The perioperative data are shown in Table V. There were
more elective operations in each group. There were more grafts
anastomosed (vessels bypassed) in the standard group than
in the OPCABG group which was significant. More intra-aortic balloon was inserted pre-operatively in the standard
group and this may be attributed to the fact that there were
more patients with left main coronary artery involvement with
left ventricular dysfunction in this group.
Although the mean duration of operation, ventilatory support duration, recovery/surgical ICU stay and post-operative
hospital stay was relatively shorter for the OPCABG group, it
was not statistically significant. A statistical significance is
noted regarding post operative blood loss, blood transfusion
requirements and operative costs between the two groups. It
was lesser for the OPCABG group.
The clinical outcome of the two groups as shown in Table
VI was comparable. The number of patients with improved
status, mortality rate and the incidence of immediate post-operative complications like peri-operative myocardial infarction
and re-operation for post-operative bleeding were not statistically significant for the two groups.
The post-operative complication per organ system is shown
in Table VII. Although there were more complications noted
in the standard CABG group, it was not statistically significant.
27
The number of blood components used per group is presented in Table VIII. Except for the requirement for fresh whole
blood and cryoprecipitate which was comparable for the two
groups, there were more units of fresh frozen plasma and packed
RBC and platelet concentrate consumed among patients who
underwent standard CABG than OPCABG.
Table IV. Target Vessels
Coronary Arteries
Standard
CABG (n=108)
OPCABG
(n=34)
Left Anterior Descending
Ramus
Diagonal
Right Coronary
Right Posterior Descending
Right Posterolateral
Left Circumflex
Obtuse Marginal
Left Posterior Descending
Total
102 (26.98%)
4 (1.06%)
71 (18.78%)
24 (6.35%)
56 (14.85%)
14 (3.70%)
46 (12.17 %)
60 (15.87%)
1 (0.26 %)
378
34 (29.31%)
1 (0.86%)
14 (12.07)
9 (7.76%)
21 (18.10%)
Table V. Perioperative Data
Standard
CABG
Parameters
(n=108)
Acuity:
Elective
Urgent
Mean Number of
Grafts Anastomosed
Mean Duration of
Operation (Minutes)
Use Of Intra-Aortic
Balloon Pump (Pre-Op)
Blood Transfusion:
Yes
No
Mean Total
Post-Operative
Blood Loss (Cc.)
Mean Ventilatory Support
Duration (Minutes)
Mean Duration of Rr/Sicu
Stay ( Days)
Mean Post-Op
Hospital Stay (Days)
Mean Operative Cost
(Philippine Pesos)
28
2 (1.72%)
21 (18.10%)
14 (12.07%)
0
116
OPCABG
(n=34)
P- value
103 (99%)
1 (1%)
33 (97.06%)
1 (2.94%)
0.43
3.64 + 0.56
3.42 + .609
0.02
334.67 + 78.96
320 + 86.74
0.37
13 (12.5%)
2 (5.89%)
0.36
102 (98.08%)
2 (1.92%)
26 (76.74%)
8 (23.53%)
<0.01
0
490.35 +
488.18
975.30 +
1303.55
338.09 +
266.137
664.31 +
545.65
4.5 + 2.36
3.76 + 1.18
9.49 + 4.67
135,732.36 +
7.65 + 2.47
81,451.65 +
0.056
87,014.44
14,289.98
<0.01
Table VI. Clinical outcome
Standard
CABG
(n=108)
OPCABG
(n=34)
P-Value
34 (100%)
0
4 (11.76%)
0
1
1
0.54
1
1 (2.94%)
1.0
Standard
CABG
(n=108)
OPCABG
(n=34)
Total
1
1
0
1
1
2
Pneumonia
Pleural Effusion
Neurologic:
Hypoxic
Encephalopathy
2
4
1
0
3
4
1
0
1
Seizures
Delirium
Stroke
Gastrointestinal:
Acute Gastritis
Acute Pancreatitis
Wound Infection:
Sternal Dehiscence
Sternal Infection
Acute Renal Failure
Total
1
1
2
0
0
0
1
1
2
1
1
1
0
2
1
1
0
2
0
1
0
1
1
2
19 (17.59%)
4 (11.76%)
23
Parameters
Improved
101 (97.12 %)
Died
3 (2.88 %)
Complications
19 (17.59 %)
Perioperative
0
Myocardial Infarction
Reoperation For
4 (3.85%)
Postoperative Bleeding
Table VII. Post-Operative Complications
Complications
Pulmonary:
Atelectasis
Pulmonary
Congestion
Table VIII . Blood Components Transfused
0.032
Blood Component
(Mean Units + Sd)
Standard
CABG
(n=108)
OPCABG
(n=34)
P-Value
Fresh Whole Blood
Fresh Frozen Plasma
Packed RBC
Platelet Concentrate
Cryoprecipitate
1.34
3.05
2.35
4.48
0.23
1.12
0.32
1.38
0.53
0
0.98
<0.01
<0.001
<0.001
1.0
0.05
0.22
+
+
+
+
+
1.75
2.99
1.79
3.94
1.05
+ 1.32
+ 94
+ 2.18
+ 1.26
JJ Bautista, et al
Discussion
With the revival of beating heart or off-pump coronary
artery bypass grafting, there has been a worldwide resurgence
in interest to do coronary revascularization without cardiopulmonary bypass even for multivessel involvement. OPCABG
has been offered as an alternative to standard CABG. Several
clinical studies show that off-pump CABG is safe and effective in selected cases.10-15 At the Philippine Heart Center, initial experience with OPCABG was performed for single and
anterior cardiac vessels but as surgeons gained experience, more
multivessel cardiac anastomoses were performed. As expected, there were conversions from OPCABG to
standard CABG. The conversion rate in this study is about
8.82%. Most of these patients were service patients. In the
study of Hart et al.15 their conversion rate was between 2-6%.
According to these authors, the decision to proceed to off-pump
CABG was an intraoperative decision after evaluation of the
coronary anatomy and the patient's tolerance to cardiac displacement.15 Ideal indications for OPCABG include no calcified coronary arteries, no intramuscular arteries, target vessels
not less than 1.5 millimeter and severe left ventricular hypertrophy is contraindicated due to difficulty of displacement of
the heart.16
In the study of Soltoski et al,17 their conversion rate was
about 25% and they have classified the reasons of conversion
as follows: Class I-Surgeon considered complete
revascularization impossible by off-pump; Class II-converted
due hemodynamic instability during the procedure and Class
III-graft malfunction determined by the flow measurements or
clinical evidence. The conversions in this study were mostly
Class II.
In this study, the patient population studied were matched
except for the vessel grafted. There were more anastomosis
performed in the standard CABG. This has been the observation in other studies.18 Many cardiac surgeons still feel comfortable doing multivessel CABG especially for more than
three-vessel anastomosis under CPB.
With regards to the peri-operative data, it was noted that
there was a shorter operative time in OPCABG but it was not
significant. The shorter operative time is expected in OPCABG
due to elimination of cardiopulmonary resuscitation, rewarming and termination of cardiopulmonary bypass which may
save about 45-60 minutes.16 In this study, one factor that may
have an effect on the length of operative time is the learning
curve of the surgeon since this is relatively a new technique
and takes quite sometime and practice to master.
Most international studies point to shorter ventilatory support duration, recovery room and surgical ICU and postoperative hospital stay in the OPCABG group.10,13,14,21 The shorter
ventilatory support time was due mainly to the absence of
cardiopulmonary bypass which may bring about diffuse
inflammatory response which may affect the lungs and cause
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
neutrophil and complement activation, surfactant degradation,
increased capillary permeability, interstitial edema, decreased
pulmonary compliance and atelectasis.10 Although this was
noted in this study, the shorter ventilatory support time was
not significant. The longer post-operative hospital stay for most
patients who underwent standard CABG has also been attributed to the use of cardiopulmonary bypass in these patients
with concomitant systemic inflammatory side effects.
There were three important significant findings in this
study. The operative cost, post-operative blood loss, blood
transfusion requirements and blood components used were
relatively lesser in the OPCABG group than the standard
CABG. With the absence of cardiopulmonary bypass, a lower
cost is expected since materials (i.e.heart-lung machine, cannulae, tubings, membrane oxygenator, priming solutions, blood
components, etc.) for this procedure are not used. Blood contact with the artificial surface of the CPB circuit brings about a
diffuse inflammatory response with release of cytokines and
activation of complement system as well as destruction of RBC,
platelets and consumption of coagulation factors. This is one
reason why blood cells and coagulation factors are deranged
with an expected higher requirement for blood transfusion. In
this study, about 76% of OPCABG patients had blood transfusion compared to almost all patients in standard CABG. The
number of patients who required blood transfusion in OPCABG
was also low as noted in the studies of Puskas (50%),10 Hart
(13.6-14.5%).14 Ascione noted that less than 5% of patients
who underwent OPCABG required fresh frozen plasma and
platelet transfusion compared to 30% and 25% respectively in
the standard CABG group.20 The mortality and morbidity rate
for OPCABG is within acceptable limits and is comparable to
standard CABG. The mortality rate in the study of Cartier12
was 1.3% while that of Hart15 was 1.0%. The incidence of reoperation for bleeding in this study was 2.94% while that of
Hart15was 1.2% (0.6-1.0%). Although there were more systemic complications in OPCABG than standard CABG, (Table
VII) it was not significant.
Off-pump coronary artery bypass grafting (OPCABG) is
a safe alternative in the management of properly selected patients with multiple coronary vessel involvement including
those with lesions located in the posterior wall of the heart
(circumflex, obtuse marginal and right posterior descending
and right posterolateral coronary arteries). The clinical outcome, morbidity and mortality rates are comparable to standard CABG. The blood transfusion requirements and operative costs were lesser than standard CABG.
Although it was noted in this study that patients operated
had shorter operative time, duration of ventilatory support, RR/
SICU stay, post-operative hospital stay and lesser post-operative blood loss, it was not statistically significant. OPCABG
may be done safely in properly selected patients by competent
cardiac surgeons. The surgeon should not hesitate to convert
to standard CABG when intra-operative morphologic evaluation of target vessels and hemodynamic events warrant doing
29
the myocardial revascularization safely under a globally arrested heart under CPB assisted CABG.
References
1. Department of Health Annual Report , 1997.
2. Kolessov VI. Mammary artery-coronary artery anastomosis as method of
treatment for angina pectoris. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1967;54:535-44.
3. Goetz RH, Rohman M, Haller JD, DEE R, Rosenak SS. Internal mammarycoronary artery anastomosis a nonsuture method employing tantalum rings.
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1961;41:378-86.
4. Sabiston DC Jr. The coronary circulation. John Hopkins Med J 1974; 134:31429.
5. Buffolo E, Andrade JCS, Succi J, Leao LEV, Galluci L. Direct myocardial
revascularization without cardiopulmonary bypass. Thorac Cardiovasc Surg
1985;5:334-9.
6. Benetti FJ. Direct coronary surgery with saphenous vein bypass without either cardiopulmonary bypass or cardiac arrest.
7. Spooner TH, Dyrud PE, Monson BK, Dixon GE, Robinson LD. Coronary
Artery Bypass on the Beating Heart with the Octopus: A North American
Experience. Ann Thorac Surg 1998;66:1032-5
8. Jansen EWL, Borst C, Lahpor JR, Grundeman PF, et al. Coronary Artery
Bypass Grafting without Cardiopulmonary Bypass Using the Octopus : Results in the First One Hundred Patients.
9. Bautista JJ, Aventura AP, Lomibao FB, Cariño LR, Manzo GS. Comparative
Review of Off-pump Coronary Artery Bypass Grafting (OPCABG) and Standard Coronary Artery Bypass Grafting Under Cardiopulmonary Bypass in the
Management of Coronary Artery Disease Involving Single and Double Bypass Operation. Phil Heart Center (unpublished).
10. Puskas JD, Wright CE, Ronson RS, Brown WM, Gott JP, Guyton RA. Offpump Multi-vessel Coronary Bypass via Sternotomy is Safe and Effective.
Ann Thorac Surg 1998;66:1068-72.
30
11. Diegeler A, Volmar F, Merajoddin M, Battelini, R Walther T, Rudiger A, Mohr
FW. Minimally Invasive Coronary Bypass Grafting Without Cardiopulmonary Bypass: Early Experience and Follow-up. Ann Thorac Surg
1998;66:1022-5.
12. Cartier R, Brann S, Dagenais F, Martineau R, Couturier A. Systematic OffPump Coronary Artery Revascularization in Multivessel Disease : Experience
of Three-Hundred Cases. J Thoracic Cardiovasc Surg 2000.
13. Magovern J, Benckart D, Landreneau R, Sakert T, Magovern G. Morbidity,
Cost and Six-Month Outcome of Minimally Invasive Direct Coronary Artery
Bypass Grafting. Ann Thorac Surg 1998;66:1224-9.
14. Hart J, Hayden A, Spooner T, Whitman G, et al. Uniform Safety of Beating
Heart Surgery Utilizing the Octopus Tissue Stabilization System (OTS). Literature Handout, Medtronic Octopus II Tissue Stabilizer, 1998.
15. Hart JC, Spooner TH, Pym J, et. al. A Review of 1,582 Consecutive Offpump Coronary Bypass Patients. J Ann Thorac Surg 2000; 70: 1017- 20.
16. Kit VA, Flavin TF, Emery RW, Vibhu RK, Peterson RJ, et. al. Is Low Ejection
Fraction Safe For Off-pump Coronary Bypass Operation? Ann Thorac Surg
2000;70:1021-5.
17. Soltoski P, Salerno T, Levinsky L, Schmid S, Hasnain S, Diesfeld T, et al.
Conversion to Cardiopulmonary Bypass in Off -pump Coronary Artery Bypass Grafting: Its Effects and Outcome. J Card Surg 1998; 13(5): 328- 34.
18. Talwalkar NG, Cooley D, Ott DA, Livesay JJ. Limited Access Coronary Artery Bypass Grafting. Texas Heart Inst J 1998;25(3):175-180.
19. Nader ND, Khada WZ, Reich NT, Bacon DR, Salerno TA, Panos AL. Blood
Products Use In Cardiac Revascularization: Comparison of On and Off-Pump
Techniques. Ann Thorac Surg 1999;68(5):1640-3.
20. Ascione R, Williams S, Lloyd CJ, et al. Reduced Post-operative Blood Loss
and Transfusion Requirements After Beating Heart Coronary Operations: A
Prospective Randomized Study. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2001;121:68996.
21. Puskas JD, Thourani VH, Marshall J, et al. Clinical Outcomes, Angiographic,
Patency, and Resource Utilization in 200 Consecutive Off-Pump Coronary
Bypass Patients. Ann Thorac Surg 2000.
JJ Bautista, et al
Original Article
Six-Minute Walk Distance of Filipino High
School Students
Ma. Tanya V. Pura MD, Percival A. Punzal MD, Milagros S. Bautista MD, Nerissa A. de Leon MD
BACKGROUND: Timed walk test has enjoyed widespread clinical application because of their convenience of
administration, their close similarity in daily activity than tests of maximal exercise capacity and lack of need for sophisticated equipment. It has been suggested that six-Minute Walk Test (6-MWT) provide a useful alternative method
for assessing exercise tolerance and oxyhemoglobin desaturation in chronically ill children awaiting heart-lung or lung
transplantation. It has commonly been employed as an outcome measure for cardiac and pulmonary rehabilitation
program. While there are available data for adults from which adult patients with cardiopulmonary disease can be
compared with, reference values for healthy pediatrics are not yet available. The objective of this study is to determine
reference values for six-Minute Walk Distance (6-MWD) among Filipino children, to investigate the influence of demographic and anthropometric parameters on 6-MWT in children, and to determine the relationship between physical
activity and 6-MWD in Filipino children.
METHODS AND RESULTS: All students aged 12-18 years old from Carlos P. Romulo High School were included in
the study. Those who were not given parental consent and those with any medical disorder particularly history of
asthma and other pulmonary disease, exertional chest pain or syncope, heart disease, neuromuscular disease, FEV1 or
FVC < 80% of predicted on spirometry were excluded. There were 125 students included in the study.
CONCLUSION: The mean 6-MWD by Filipino high school students (12 -18 years old) was 490.77 + 53.66 meters.
From this study, the only variable that was statistically significant was gender. The best 6-MWD by boys was greater
than girls by an average of 32 meters. This study did not show any significant correlation between 6-MWD and age,
height, BMI and pulmonary function tests. The 6-MWD in this study was not related to the daily activities nor to the
subject's smoking habits.
Phil Heart Center J 2002;9:31-34
Keywords: oxyhemoglobins; walking; exercise test
xercise testing has the potential of providing important
information for gauging the impact of many childhood
and adolescent disorders. The progressive exercise testing on a cycle ergometer or treadmill remains the cornerstone
of most exercise testing in childhood and adults. However, it
is becoming increasingly apparent that peak or maximal exercise test is not representative of pattern of physical activity
actually encountered in the lives of children. Children are engaged in very short bursts of high intensity physical activity
interspersed with varying intervals of low and moderate intensity. Sustained heavy exercise from which the peak / maximum oxygen uptake during traditional exercise testing is measured, rarely occurs in children. Other viable alternatives to
traditional adult-modeled maximal test are available for children.
Cooper propose that brief constant work rate exercise
protocols (lasting several minutes of less) serve as an initial
screening test.
E
Correspondence: Ma. Tanya V. Pura, MD. Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine
Section of Pediatric Pulmonology, Philippine Heart Center East Avenue, Quezon City,
Philippines 1100
ISSN 0018-9034
Timed-walk tests have enjoyed widespread clinical
aplication because of their convenience of administration, their
close similarity to daily activity than tests of maximal
exercise capacity and lack of need for sophisticated equipment.
Walk test, provides an estimate of functional capacity and has
been shown to predict morbidity and mortality.
It has been suggested that 6-Minute Walk Test (6MWT)
may provide a useful alternative method for assessing exercise
tolerance and oxyhemoglobin desaturation in chronically ill
children awaiting heart-lung or lung transplantation.
Previous studies have shown walk distances to correlate
significantly with some measures of resting pulmonary function with aerobic fitness (as measured by peak oxygen uptake)
and with minute ventilation during exercise testing. It has commonly been employed as an outcome measure for cardiac and
pulmonary rehabilitation program.
At Philippine Heart Center Pediatric Pulmonary Program,
6-minute walk test is one of the parameters utilized as an outcome measurements.
Reference values have been published among healthy
adults. Gibbus, et al.1 have shown the Best 6-Minute Walking
Distance (6-MWD) in 79 healthy subjects (22-79 years old)
Copyright 2002 Philippine Heart Center Journal
ranging from 474-1,040 meters (average 698 + 96 m). In
Troosters et al.6 50 subjects (50-85 years old) have showed an
average 6-MWD to be 631+ 93 meters (383 - 820 meters).
From the Guinness Book of Records, 40th edition, typical 6MWD for a competent marathon runner is 1,500 meters and
for a person walking along a street it is 700 meters.
These are available data for adults from which adult patients with cardiopulmonary disease can be compared with.
Reference values for healthy pediatrics are not yet available.
Objectives
1. To determine reference values for 6-MWD among
Filipino children.
2. To investigate the influence of demographic and anthropometric parameters on 6-MWT in children.
3. To determine the relationship between physical activity and 6-MWD in Filipino children.
Methods
All students aged 12-18 years from Carlos P. Romulo High
School were included in the study. Parental consent forms
were given to determine inclusions. Those who were not given
consent and those with any medical disorder particularly history of asthma and other pulmonary disease, exertional chest
pain or syncope, heart disease, neuromuscular disease, FEV1
or FVC < 80% of predicted on spirometry were excluded.
The age, sex, standing height in centimeters and weight in
kilograms self-reported habitual activity or any form of habitual exercise and smoking history were taken and recorded.
For the purposes of this study, the subjects' physical activity
was classified as ACTIVE if very active in both house and
school and engage in regular sports activity 2-3 times a week;
MODERATELY active if active both in house and school but
no regular sports activity and SEDENTARY if not very mobile in both house and school and no regular sports activity.
Spirometry was performed using a microloop to determine
forced vital capacity (FVC) and expired volume in one sec.
(FEV1).
Functional Exercise Test
A 6-minute walk test was performed twice with a 30minute interval rest. Subjects were asked to walk at their own
pace along a 35 meter long gymnasium. Subjects were asked
to walk from end to end covering as much ground as they could
during the allotted time without running. Encouragement was
standardized every minute. Subjects were given feedback on
time progression and were encouraged to keep on walking.
During the test, oxygen saturation and heart rate were measured by transcutaneous pulse oximetry. The percentage maximum heart rate (maximum heart rate based on Nelson Textbook of Pediatrics, 15th edition) was calculated and recorded.
32
The protocol stated that the testing was to be interrupted
if threatening symptoms appeared. The subjects were told they
could rest if they were too exhausted to continue the test. No
test, however was interrupted. The distance covered in six
minutes was recovered. The test was repeated with equal encouragement and the best of two tests was used for further
analysis.
Analysis
Data was reported as group means + standard deviation.
The greatest distance covered in six minutes by each subject
was identified from the two 6-MWD trials performed (best 6MWD) and then used as the primary outcome variable in the
analysis. Statistical equation done to determine associations
of 6-MWD to the different variables were t-test, analysis of
variance and correlation analysis. Regression analysis was
determined to compute for the predicted values for 6-MWD.
A p-value of equal or less 0.05 was considred significant.
Results
Two hundred (200) students were screened. Seventy-five
(75) students were excluded from the study because of low
FVC and or FEV1 (73 students) and history of asthma (2 students). There were 125 students included in the study.
Patient characteristics are summarized in Table I. There
were 72 (57%) boys and 54 (43%) girls. The age of the subjects ranges from 12-18 years (mean 14.06 + 1.78). The mean
height, weight and BMI were 154.18 + 10.87, 43.91 + 10.49,
and 18.29 + 2.89, respectively. The pulmonary function was
all within normal limits for all subjects (FEV1=100.0 4 +
11.35% predicted and FVC 89.67 + 9.37). During the best 6MWD, patients reached 101.15 + 14.02 % of their maximal
predicted heart rate. Oxygen saturation remained unaltered
throughout both tests (mean of 97.13 + 1.48%). The mean
best 6-MWD was 490.77 + 53.66. There were 24 students
(19.2%) who are smoking (minimum of one stick per week for
a year and a maximum of 2.5 pack years). Six (4.8%) students
are classified as active. Most of them are engaged in basketball and one plays badminton 2-3 times a week. One hundred
nineteen (95.2%) students are moderately active.
Table II shows the mean walking distances of the first and
second tests are 465+56.06 and 474+55.4 meters (p=0.081).
Fifty-two (42% of students had the best 6-MWD at first trial
and 73 (58%) of students had the best 6-MWD at the second
trial.
Table III shows the mean best 6-MWD for boys and girls
which was statistically significant.
Table IV shows no significant correlation between 6MWD and the various patient variables such as age, height,
weight, BMI and pulmonary function tests (FEV1 and FVC).
Tables V and VI show the 6-MWD was not related to the
MTV Pura, et al
classification of daily activity nor to the subject's smoking habits.
(Mean + SD)
Smoking History
Table I. Characteristics of study subjects
Total number of subjects
125 students
SEX (no./%)
Male
Female
Age (yrs) (mean+SD)
Height (cms) (mean+SD)
Weight (kgs) (mean+SD)
BMI (kg/m2)
FEV1 (% predicted)
FVC (% predicted)
% max. heart rate at Best 6-MWD
O2 sat. at best 6-MWD (%)
Best 6-MWD (meters) mean+SD
With smoking history (no/%)
Level of activity (no/%) moderately active
Table V. Best 6-MWD in meters as a function of the presence or
abscence of smoking history
72 (57)
54 (43)
14.06 + 1.78
154.18 + 10.87
43.91 + 10.49
18.29 + 2.89
100.04 + 11.35
89.67 + 9.37
101.15 + 14.02
97.13 + 1.48
490.77 + 53.66
24 (19)
6 (48)
119 (95.2)
With
Without
Best 6 MWD
p-value
486 + 48.70
491.75 + 54.95
0.68 NS
Table VI. Best 6-MWD in meters as a function of daily activity
(Mean+SD)
Active
Moderately active
Best 6 MWD
467.27 + 46.76
491.95 + 53.88
p-value
0.273 NS
Table VII. Reference equations for 6-MWD in Filipino children
BOYS: 6-MWD= 584.37 - 5.703 ( age in years)
Table II. Mean First and second 6-MWD in meters among high
school students
AGE (yrs)
BOYS
GIRLS
p-value
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Mean + SD
468.22 + 34.69
521.31 + 78.36
508.04 + 60.9
479.56 + 18.39
509.5 + 37.68
466.84 + 27.51
499.56 + 71.54
500 + 58.71
482.39 + 41.08
483.55 + 50.87
483.48 + 39.97
480.5 + 18.66
431 + 35.37
——
475.33 + 36.17
478.58 + 43.79 0.026
AGE (yrs)
FIRST
6MWD
SECOND
6MWD
p-value
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Mean + SD
460.98 + 11.07
471.48 + 10.44
486.32 + 12.99
466.61 + 7.95
442.73 + 11.98
444.96 + 11.70
451.98 + 25.30
465 + 56.06
461.40 + 9.62
483.87 + 11.03
479.97 + 12.06
466.54 + 7.02
472.42 + 15.24
461.39 + 8.72
481.90 + 21.92
474 + 55.4
0.968
0.287
0.574
0.995
0.116
0.181
0.128
0.08
Table IV. Univariate Correlation Cofficient between the 6-MWD and patient variables
6-MWD
p-value
Height
(cms)
0.08
0.35
Weight
(kgs)
-0.01
0.9
BMI
FEV1
(kg/m2)
-0.08
0.09
0.38
0.31
Alternate equations
using height: 6-MWD= 427.54 + 0.414 ( height in cms)
using BMI: 6-MWD= 518.10 - 1.46 ( BMI)
Discussion
Table III. Best 6-MWD in meters as a function of age among
high school students
Age
(yrs)
-0.09
0.33
GIRLS: 6-MWD= 540.22 - 4.597 ( age in years)
FVC
0.09
0.33
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
The present study was able to determine 6-MWD among
Filipino high school students (12-18 years old) ranging from
366-676 meters. On average, the 6-MWD was 490.767 + 53.66
meters.
This study did not show any significant correlation between 6-MWD and age, height, BMI and pulmonary function
tests as against the study done by Gibbons et al.1 He has shown
a significant inverse relationship between best 6-MWD and
age and BMI and a significant direct relationship between best
6-MWD and height.
In the present study, best 6-MWD was found to be significantly different between boys and girls (p value= 0.026) which
was comparable to the study of Gibbons et al. among 88 healthy
adults. In their study, they had shown that age, gender accounted for 41% of the between subject variance in best 6MWD in the healthy adults. Likewise Troosters et al.6 showed
6-MWD among males to be 84 meters greater than females.
Guyatt et al.8 have shown that multi-test repetition provides test familiarity ("the learning effect") significantly influence intra-individual variability in 6-MWD. Nixon et al.3 cited
that at least three walks are needed to minimize intra-individual
variability in 6-MWD. However, in this present study the 6MWD of first and second trials were not statistically
33
significant (p value=0.081) and this is because encouragement
was equally given in both tests. The present findings were in
agreement with Guyatt et al. who showed that when encouragement was unaltered, the 6-MWD did not improve significantly after the second walking test. Hence, they have cited
the use of only one practice walk in well motivated subject
was believed to be valid.
As in the study of Troosters, the 6-MWD in this study was
not related to the daily activities not to the subject's smoking
habits.
Conclusion
The mean 6-MWD by this Filipino high school student
(12-18 years old) was 490.77 + 53.66 meters. From this study,
the only variable that was statistically significant was the gender. The best 6-MWD by boys was greater than girls by an
average of 32 meters. This study also showed best 6-MWD
was not related to the subject's daily activity.
34
Recommendation
A larger study population to represent the population characteristics is recommended.
References
1. Gibbons WJ, Fruchter N, Sloan S, Levy RD. Reference Values for a Multiple
Repetition 6-Minute Walk Test in Healthy Adults Older Than 20 Years. J
Cardiopulmo Rehab 2001;21:87-93.
2. Hamilton DW, Haennel RG. Validity and Reliability of the 6-Minute Walk Test
in a Cardiac Rehabilitation Population. J Cardiopulmo Rehab 2000;20:156164.
3. Nixon PA, Joswiak ML, Fricker FJ. A Six-minute walk test for assessing exercise tolerance in severely ill children. J Pedia 1996;129(3):362-6.
4. Hass M, Zugck C, Kubler W. The 6-minute walking test: a cost-effective alternative to spiro-ergometry in patients with chronic heart failure? Z Kardiol
2000;89(2):72-80.
5. Steven D, Elperin E, Sharma K, Szidon P, Ankin M and Kesten S. Comparison of Hallway and Treadmill Six-Minute Walk Tests. Am J Resp Crit Care
Med 1999;160:1540-1543.
6. Troosters T, Gosselink R, Decramer M. Six minute walking distance in healthy
elderly subjects. Europ Resp J 1999;14:270-274.
7. Enright PL, and Duane SL. Reference Equations for the Six-Minute Walk in
Healthy Adults. Am J Resp Crit Care Med 1998;158:1384-1387.
8. Redelmeier DA, Bayoumi AM, Goldstein RS, and Guyatt GH. Interpreting
Small Differences in Functional Status: the Six Minute Walk Test in Chronic
Lung Disease Patients. Am J Resp Crit Care Med 1997;155:1278-1282.
MTV Pura, et al
Original Article
An Analysis of Maximum Oxygen Consumption
Determination in Filipino Schoolchildren
Ma. Ohara P. Juaneza-Dulos MD, Percival Punzal MD, Ma. Encarnita Blanco-Limpin MD, Milagros Bautista MD, Teresita
De Guia MD.
BACKGROUND: The Multistage Fitness Test (MFT), a 20-meter shuttle run test adopted from Leger and Lambert
and introduced by the National Coaching Foundation, is a simple means to determine maximum oxygen consumption
(V02 max). The MFT requires the subject to exercise maximally in accordance to the loading pattern of a maximum
oxygen consumption testing. This study was conducted to: (1) obtain baseline data on V02max in a group of Filipino
schoolchildren using the Multistage Fitness Test and; (2) to determine the correlation of V02max to respiratory symptoms, respiratory diseases, physical activity and FEV1 among Filipino schoolchildren.
METHODS AND RESULTS: Four hundred nine high school students aged 12-16 years participated in the study.
There was no significant difference in the mean age between the sexes. However, boys were on average 3.8 kg. heavier
and 4 cm. taller than girls. Boys had significantly higher VO2 max (32 ± 2.87 vs. 28. 85±2.11 ml/kg/min, p<0.001) and
FEV1 (2.61±0.50 vs. 2.18±0.31L, p<0.001) than girls. On the other hand, girls reported a significantly higher prevalence
of chronic cough (10.9 vs. 4.1%, p=0.020) and a higher proportion of physical inactivity (53.4 vs. 37.4%, p=0.002) than
boys. Because the number of adolescents who reported positive for respiratory symptoms and/or diseases was small,
boys and girls were combined in the analysis. No significant differences in VO2max nor FEV1 were observed in children
with respiratory symptoms/diseases compared to those without. Physical inactivity, as an independent factor, was
significantly associated with decreased VO2max (p<0.001). However, no significant correlation was noted between
VO2max and FEV1 (r=0.253).
CONCLUSION: The maximum oxygen consumption (VO2max) among Filipino schoolchildren was lower compared
with those of their Caucasian counterparts. This was attributed to the differences in height, weight and physical
activity.
Phil Heart Center J 2002;9:35-40
Keywords: exercise test; V02max, FEV1, V02max
aximum oxygen consumption (VO 2 max) is a
useful measure of cardiorespiratory capacity.
It reflects the ability of the cardiorespiratory system to deliver oxygen from the air to the working muscles.
Thus, a person with a high VO2max is regarded as having good
"aerobic fitness" or "cardiorespiratory fitness".1 The most accurate determination of maximum oxygen consumption is obtained by measuring it directly in the laboratory where patient
is made to exercise either on a treadmill or bicycle ergometer.
As work rate increases (speed and grade on a treadmill or resistance and tempo on a bicycle ergometer), the rate of oxygen
uptake (VO2) also increases, until it plateaus. This maximal
rate of oxygen uptake is the maximum oxygen consumption
(VO2max) and represents a physiologic limit. VO2max is measured by analysis of the patient's expired gases via a mouthpiece attached to the gas analyzer and is expressed in ml/kg/
min or liters/min.2 However, since testing large numbers of
people in the laboratory is not easy and requires high level
of expertise and equipment, many attempts have been made
M
Correspondence: Ma. Ohara P. Juaneza-Dulos, MD, Pediatric Pulmonary Medicine, Philippine Heart
Center, East Avenue, Quezon City, Philippines 1100
ISSN 0018-9034
to predict maximum oxygen consumption from simple field
tests.3
In 1982, Leger and Lambert introduced the concept of a
progressive shuttle run test for the prediction of maximum oxygen consumption.4 They compared the VO2max values obtained from three methods: the directly measured VO2max (an
inclined walking treadmill test), the retroextrapolated VO2max
(maximum O2 consumption assessed by establishing O2 recovery curved following maximum multistage test) and the
VO2max predicted from the maximal speed achieved during
the 20-meter shuttle run test using the appropriate regression
equation. Results showed that the 20 meter shuttle run test
yielded results similar to a conventional inclined treadmill test
and from the retroextrapolated VO2max. Following this publication, the test was adopted by the Council for Europe as part
of its range of cardiorespiratory and motor fitness tests for assessing the physical development of schoolchildren.5
In 1986, a validation study was done by van Mechelen, et
al6 where eighty-two subjects (41 boys and 41 girls) aged 1214 years performed the 20-meter shuttle run test and the 6minute endurance run and had their V02max or more days
Copyright 2002 Philippine Heart Center Journal
directly measured during maximal treadmill running. They
noted a higher correlation between V02max and the 20-MST
(r=0.76) than the 6-minute endurance run (r=0.53). Thus, the
20-MST was considered to be a more suitable tool for the evaluation of maximal aerobic power.
In 1988, the National Coaching Foundation, in partnership with Loughborough University introduced the Multistage
Fitness test (MFT), a 20-meter shuttle run test adopted from
Leger and Lambert as a simple means to determine VO2max.5
The subjects were required to exercise maximally by the end
of the test, similar to the loading pattern of a VO2max test.
Results of subsequent validation studies had shown that this
test was reliable. The values were highly correlated with the
measured VO2max, with correlation coefficients ranging from
0.8-0.9 in adults 1, and 0.8 in children.7
Since then the MFT has been used to determine the cardiopulmonary fitness in large numbers of children in European and North American countries. In Hong Kong Wong, et
al.3 published the first and only study in Asia among 8-12 years
old schoolchildren. They showed that the mean VO2max values obtained from the test were relatively low in Hong Kong
Chinese schoolchildren com- pared with the Caucasians. They
attributed this to racial differences and a lower level of physical activity among their study population. They likewise
showed that a reduced V02max was significantly associated
with respiratory diseases and habitual physical inactivity.
This research study was undertaken to obtain baseline local data for VO2max in Filipino schoolchildren using the MFT,
without the use of sophisticated equipment and the required
expertise.
Research Objectives:
(1) To provide baseline data on VO2max in a group of
Filipino schoolchildren using the Multistage Fitness Test from
ages 12-16 years.
(2) To determine the correlation of VO2max to respi- ratory
symptoms, respiratory diseases, physical activity, and FEV1
among Filipino schoolchildren.
Research Hypothesis:
The Multistage Fitness Test (MFT) is a useful method to
evaluate cardiorespiratory fitness in children. The mean
VO2max values obtained from the tests is lower among Filipino adolescents compared with their Caucasian counterparts.
The reduced VO2max is significantly correlated with respiratory symptoms, respiratory diseases, and habitual physical inactivity and FEV1.
Methodology
Study Design
An experimental study.
36
Study Sample
All high school students of the Iloilo National High School
were invited to participate. A consent from the parent/
guardian was obtained prior to inclusion in the study. The
parents/guardian were also requested to answer a questionnaire.
The student was then asked to perform lung function test followed by the Multistage Fitness test (MFT).
Inclusion Criteria
1. High school students in the selected school.
2. Able to follow instructions in doing spirometric studies and MFT.
3. With written informed consent and a parent-completed
questionnaire.
Exclusion Criteria
1. Inability to perform the prescribed testing procedures.
2. Those afflicted with any injury or illness that would
contraindicate participation in the Multistage Fitness Test.
Study Setting and Time Period
Iloilo National High School, Iloilo City from January- February 2002.
Identification of Study Variables
The parameters evaluated in this study included anthropometric measurements (weight and height), spirometric studies specifically FEV1 , presence or absence of respiratory symptoms or diseases, level physical activity and the VO2max.
Detailed Description of Data Collection
A written approval was obtained from the school principal prior to the conduct of the study. Questionnaires together
with the consent forms were distributed to the parents of each
student a week before the tests were performed. Consent for
lung function and exercise tolerance tests were given by parents for their children to participate in each of the tests.
Questionnaire
The questionnaire included a history of children's respiratory symptoms in the previous year, respiratory diseases that
occurred from birth to the time of the survey, and habitual physical activities. Both parents (when possible) were asked to complete their questionnaires jointly at home.
Health outcome variable was considered positive when
"yes" is given to one or more of the following questions 3 :
1. Chronic cough: did the child cough on most days (4 per
week) for as much as 3 months of the year, in the previous
year?
2. Chronic sputum: did the child bring up phlegm on most
days (4 or more days per week) for as much as 3 months of the
year, in the previous year?
3. Wheezing: did this child ever sound wheezy or whistling apart from colds.
MOP Juaneza-Dulos, et al
4. Did the child ever had asthma and or bronchitis diagnosed by a doctor?
Definition of Habitual Physical Activity
Depending on the frequency and duration of organized
sports and vigorous free play, habitual physical activity was
categorized as active and inactive. Active children were defined as those who actively participated in sports and or vigorous free play at least 3x a week for at least 30 minutes each
time. Inactive children were those who did not fulfill the
preceeding criteria.
Lung Function Test
Spirometry was performed using a portable spirometer
(Microloop 2 Spirometer #3874 by Micromedical Company,
Ltd. England). Three spirometric trials were done and the best
FEV1 result from the 3 trials was recorded.
Multistage Fitness Test
All participants came in their complete PE uniforms as
requested. The MFT was conducted in a partially shaded open
field within the school campus. The field surface was dry and
nonslippery. Twenty-meter tracks were measured on the
ground and each end was marked by flaglets. One participant
was assigned to a track. In this test, subjects were asked to
carry out a series of shuttle runs between the two markers at an
exact distance of 20-meters. The running pace is set by audio
signals (bleep sounds) emitted at set intervals from a recorded
compact disc. (The Multi- stage Fitness Test-The National
Coaching Foundation).
The following instructions were given to the partici- pants.
The test begins with a five second countdown to the start.
Thereafter, single bleeps are emitted at regular intervals. The
subjects should aim to be at the opposite end by the time the
first bleep sounds. They should then continue running at this
speed, being at one end or the other each time there is a bleep.
The participants should always place one foot either on or
behind the 20-meter mark at the end of each shuttle. If the
participants arrive at the marker before the bleep sounds, they
should turn around and wait for the bleep, then resume running and adjust their speed.
After each minute, the time interval between bleeps will
decrease, so that the running speed will need to be increased.
The first running speed is referred to as level 1; the second
speed as level 2 and so on. Each level last approximately 1
minute. The end of each shuttle is denoted by a single bleep;the
end of each level is denoted by a triple bleep and by the taped
voice message. The frequency of sound signals is increased at
a rate correspon- ding to an increase in running speed of 0.5
km hr-1 each minute from a starting speed of 8.5 km hr -1.
Thus the timing begins very slowly but becomes progressively
faster each minute, so that it becomes increasingly difficult to
maintain the set pace.
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
The MFT was performed in groups of 5 students who
were instructed to run at the pace of the audio signal and to
give their maximum effort when performing the test and therefore attempt to reach as high a level as possible before stopping. The runner stops when he or she can no longer maintain
the running speed or is withdrawn from the test when he or she
was no longer complying with the test regulations. Two verbal warnings are given if they fail to reach the line before the
audio signal and are then with- drawn from the test after a
third failure.
The number of shuttles completed at the highest level attained was then recorded. VO2max was derived from the
level (maximal speed) and the number of shuttles achieved
during the multistage test based on the table provided by Brewer
et al, of Loughborough University.5 There were observers assigned to each participant to help the author take note of the
level and the number of shuttles into the level at which each
participant withdraws from the test.
Description of Data Handling
Data were described as mean standard deviation, or frequency and percent distribution. Baseline anthropo- metric
data, exercise levels, VO2max, FEV1, and the prevalence of
respiratory symptoms and diseases were compared between
boys and girls using two-tailed t-tests and Chi- square tests.
The VO2max and FEV1 of children with reported respiratory illnesses (symptoms and/or diseases) and those without
were compared by analysis of covariance, adjusted for age,
gender, height, and weight. Association of FEV1 with VO2max
was determined using Pearson correlation analysis. P value <
0.05 were considered statistically significant.
Results
A total of 946 high school students were invited to participate, of which 529 (56%) responded with parent- completed questionnaire. Of those who responded, 522 students
were allowed by their parents to participate in the research
study. Subsequently, 462 students were able to participate in
the multistage fitness test. Sixty students did not participate
because of various reasons (39 were absent, 7 were involved
with other activities, 10 were not feeling well, 4 had dysmenorrhea). Data from 409 students were subsequently entered
into the study and analyzed (53 participants were not able to
reached level 4 of the MFT, which is the minimum level
where a corresponding predicted VO2max value is assigned.
Level below this correlates poorly with the VO2max).
Table I presented the anthropometric characteristics, performance data of the MFT, the VO2max and FEV1 among 409
adolescents. There was no significant difference in the meanage
between the sexes. However, boys were on average 3.8 kg
heavier and 4 cm. taller than girls. Boys had significantly
37
higher mean values of VO2max (32 + 2.87 vs. 28.85 + 2.11 ml/
kg/min) and FEV1 (2.61 + 0.50 vs. 2.18 + 0.31 L) than girls.
Table I. Anthropometric, performance and FEV1 data of
Filipino schoolchildren
Age (years)
Height(cm)
Weight(kg)
Exercise level
VO2max (ml/kg/min)
FEV1(L)
Boys (n=171)
Mean + SD
Girls (n=238)
Mean SD
p-value
14.39 + 1.24
157.90 + 7.10
48.20 + 11.50
5.30 + 0.95
32.00 + 2.87
2.61 + 0.50
14.31 + 1.10
153.90 + 5.30
44.40 + 7.30
4.40 + 0.64
28.85 + 2.11
2.18 + 0.31
0.508
< 0.001
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
Figure 2 presents the prevalence of reported respiratory
symptoms, diseases and physical inactivity. Girls reported a
significantly higher frequency of chronic cough (10.9 vs. 4.1%,
p=0.020) than boys. Likewise, a significantly higher
proportion of girls was physically inactive (53.4 vs. 37.4%,
p=0.002).
(%)
60
50
40
Boys
30
Girls
20
10
The age specific values for height and weight are shown
in Figure 1-A and 1-B, respectively. In general, mean height
and weight for boys increase with age. Similar observation
was also noted in girls.
0
chronic
chronic
cough
phlegm
wheezing
asthma
bronchitis physical
In activity
Figure 2. Prevalence of reported respiratory symptoms, disease
and habitual physical inactivity
165
H 160
E
I
155
G
H
150
T
(cm)
Boys
Girls
145
140
12
1
3
14
15
16
Age ( years)
Figure 1-A. Age specific valuse for height
Table II shows a comparison of the values of VO2max
and FEV1 between adolescents with at least one respiratory
symptom (either chronic cough or phlegm or wheezing),
disease (either asthma or bronchitis), and those without. As
the number of adolescents who reported positive for respiratory
symptoms and/or diseases was small, boys and girls were
combined in the analysis. No significant differences in either
VO2max or FEV1 were observed between the children with
respiratory symptoms or diseases and those without. Presence
of one symptom or at least one disease did not affect the
VO2max and FEV1 values.
Table III shows the comparison of mean VO2max and
levels of physical activity. The mean VO 2 max was
significantly decreased among physically inactive school
children in both sexes.
60
W 50
E
I 40
G
H 30
T 20
(kg)
Boys
Girls
10
0
12
13
14
Age (years)
15
Figure 1-B. Age specific values for weight
38
16
Table II. VO2max and FEV1 in relation to respiratory
symptoms and diseases in schoolchildren
Mean+SD
VO2max (ml/kg/min)
FEV1 (L)
At least one symptom
Yes (n=45)
No (n=364)
p- value
29.61 + 3.19
30.24 + 2.87
0.170 NS
2.35 + 0.50
2.36 + 0.44
0.813 NS
At least one disease
Yes (n=49)
No (n=360)
p- value
30.36 + 3.49
30.14 + 3.49
0.629 NS
2.36 + 0.47
2.36 + 0.45
0.932 NS
MOP Juaneza-Dulos, et al
Table III. Mean VO2max in relation to physical activity
Active (VO2max)
Boys
Girls
Both sexes
32.76 + 2.71
29.18 + 2.24
30.94 + 3.06
Inactive (VO2max)
30.74 + 2.68
28.56 + 1.95
29.29 + 2.45
p-value
<0.001
0.02
<0.001
Figure 3 shows the correlation of the VO2max with FEV1.
There was no significant correlation between VO2max values
and FEV1 (r=0.253).
Figure 3. Correlation of VO2max and FEV1
Discussion
This study showed the VO2max in a group of Filipino
schoolchildren aged 12-16 years, using the Multistage Fitness
Test (MFT). VO2max reflects the maximum capacity of the
cardiorespiratory system for oxygen uptake during exercise.
The MFT has been shown to be highly correlated to VO2max
measured in the laboratory. The simplicity of the MFT and its
applicability to a large population render it a suitable tool for
epidemiologic studies.
The mean VO2max in our subjects using the MFT was 32
+ 2.87 ml/kg/min for boys and 28.85 + 2.11 ml/kg/min for
girls aged 12-16 years. The mean height and VO2max in boys
were significantly higher than girls. The significant difference of VO2max between boys and girls is closely related to
the differences in height, mainly due to discrepancy in leg
length, leg muscle mass and cardiac output, 3 and physical inactivity.
Studies on the validity of the MFT to predict the VO2max
have been done among children of different ages and races.
The study by Wong C 3 reported that the mean values of
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
VO2max among Hong Kong Chinese school children was 30.3
+ 5.2 ml/kg/min for boys and 28.6 + 3.6 ml/kg/min for girls
aged 8-12 years. Our VO2max values were higher than those
of Hong Kong Chinese schoolchildren. However, it is difficult to compare the two groups because of the differences in
age range. The study by van Mechelen et al6 showed that in
82 Caucasian children (41 boys and 41 girls) aged 12-14 years,
the VO2max was 41-43 ml/kg/min for boys and 34-36 ml/kg/
min for girls. Another study by Mahoney7 showed that the
VO2max values for boys were 47.4 ml/kg/min and 31.3 ml/kg/
min for girls aged 12 years. The 103 subjects in this study
consisted of a multiracial UK population composed of Indian,
Afro-Carribean and mixed races. Based on these studies, the
VO2max values using the MFT was lower among Asian (Hong
Kong Chinese and Filipino) children when compared with
Caucasian and non-Caucasian children living in the United
Kingdom. Several factors could possibly explain the differences in the VO2max values obtained.
The MFT does require well-motivated subjects with some
knowledge of pace judgement and an understanding of the test
requirements. In our study, the participants were instructed to
give their maximum effort when performing the test and should
attempt to reach the highest level possible before stopping.
Differences in height among different races could be a
possible explanation for the differences in the VO2max obtained from the MFT. We compared our 12 year old subjects
with the multiracial (non-Caucasian) UK population of the
same age 7. It was noted that their subjects were taller (152.5
vs. 148 cm for boys and 153.8 vs. 149 cm for girls) than our
study population. Cooper, et al.8 in 1984 also stated that
VO2max obtained using breath-by-breath analysis highly correlated with increasing height, in their study of 109 children of
mixed races.
Another factor that explained the difference in VO2max
was physical inactivity. A study comparing 9-11 year old welltrained swimmers with untrained children of similar age, height
and body mass, showed that the former had a significantly
higher VO2 max.9 Relatively high VO2max values had been
obtained in children involved in exercise training.10 A significant correlation between physical inactivity and lower
VO2max was shown in our study. Our subjects did not have
any regular exercise training before the MFT was performed.
In fact, 37.4% and 53.4% of the boys and girls respectively,
were physically inactive. In contrast, among the 12-year old
multiracial UK population, 42% of the subjects played organized sports, 20% completed housework and 10% had parttime jobs.7 Also, it is well-known that Caucasian children are
in general physically more active than their Asian counterparts.11 A small study of 16 moderately active Japanese 12year olds reported a VO2max of 41.2 ml/kg/min, a much higher
value than that obtained in our 12-year old subjects.12 However, the sample size in their study was too small for any meaningful inference.
In our study, no significant association was found between
39
reporting of respiratory symptoms, (chronic cough and chronic
phlegm) VO2max and FEV1. There was also no association
between the reporting of at least one disease (asthma or bronchitis), VO2max and FEV1. This is in contrast with the findings of Wong et al.3 who reported a small but significant association between respiratory diseases and VO2max. Children
with asthma or bronchitis had a significantly lower VO2max
compared to those without. Their finding however, is not consistent with other studies that reported normal exercise
capacity and aerobic fitness in adolescents with mild to moderate asthma.13 Our findings showed that there was no significant correlation between VO2max and FEV1. This is consistent with the study of Ludwick, et al.14 which showed that
abnormalities in cardiopulmonary endurance did not correlate
with historical features commonly used to define severe asthma
or degree of airways obstruction. Likewise, similar observation was reported by Wong et al.13 Ludwick, et al.14 showed
that VO2max can be markedly increased by appropriate training of children. Their study consisted of 65 children with severe asthma, whose cardiopulmonary fitness improved after
bicycle ergometry training. Physical exercise is beneficial for
both healthy children and children with respiratory diseases.3
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
Ramsbottom R, Brewer J, Williams C. A progressive shuttle run test to estimate maximal oxygen uptake. Brit J Sports Med 1988;22:141-144.
Holly R. Measurement of the Maximal Rate of Oxygen Uptake. In: Blair SN,
Painter P, Pate RR, editors. Resource Manual for Guidelines for Exercise
Testing and Prescription. Philadelphia: McGrawHill; 1988. p.171 -1 77.
Wong TW, Yu TS, Wang XR, Robinson P. Predicted Maximal Oxygen Uptake in Normal Hong Kong Chinese Schoolchildren and Those With Respiratory Diseases. Pedia Pulmo 2001;31;126-132.
Leger LA, Lambert JA. Maximal multistage 20-m shuttle run test to predict
VO2max. Eur J Appl Physio Occup Physio 1982;49:1-12.
Brewer J. A Progressive shuttle-run test for the prediction of maximum
oxygen uptake. Loughborough University and The National Coaching Foundation. 1998. p. 1-13.
van Mechelen W, Hlobil H, Kemper HC. Validation of two running tests as
estimates of maximal aerobic power in children. Eur J Appl Physio Occup
Physio 1986;55(5):503-6.
Mahoney C. 20-MST and PWC 170 validity in non-caucasian children in the
UK1992. p.26.
Cooper D, Weiler-Ravell D. Gas exchange response to exercise in children.
Am Rev Resp Dis 1984;129(Supp):S47-48.
Baltaci C, Ergun N. Maximal oxygen uptake in well-trained and untrained 9 11 year old children. Pedia Rehab 1997;1:159-162.
Shephard RJ. Test of maximum oxygen intake: a critical review. Sports Med
1984;1:99-124.
Del Mundo F. Growth and development. In: Textbook of Pediatrics and
Child Health. Manila: Philippine Pediatric Society, 2000. p.47-48.
Baba R, Nagashima M, Ngano Y. Role of oxygen uptake efficiency slope in
evaluating exercise tolerance. Arc Dis Child 1999;81:73-7.
Garfinkel SK, Kestem S, Chapman R, Rebuck AP. Physiologic and nonPhysiologic determinants.
Ludwick SK, Jones JW, Jones TK. Normalization of cardio-pulmonary endurance in severely asthmatic children after bicycle ergometry therapy. J
Pedia 1986;109:446-457.
Conclusion
In conclusion, we have shown that the MFT is a useful
method to evaluate cardiorespiratory fitness in Filipino schoolchildren. The mean VO2max values were 32 + 2.87 ml/kg/
min for boys and 28.85 + 2.11 ml/kg/min for girls aged 12-16
years. No significant association was found between VO2max,
FEV1, respiratory symptoms, and respiratory diseases. However, there was a significant association between physical inactivity and VO2max.
Another study with a bigger population and under range
of groups is recommended to further validate the results of the
study.
40
MOP Juaneza-Dulos, et al
Original Article
Continuous Positive Airway Pressure (CPAP)
Among Patients with Cardiogenic Pulmonary
Edema: Philippine Heart Center Experience
Christina A. Uy MD, Aileen V. Guzman MD, Ma. Encarnita B. Limpin MD, Teresita S. De Guia MD
BACKGROUND: Severe cardiogenic pulmonary edema is a frequent cause of respiratory failure especially in the
Philippine Heart Center. Many patients with this condition require endotracheal intubation and mechanical ventilation.
The authors investigated whether continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) could reduce the need for endotracheal
intubation, reduce the number of complications, and shorten ICU and hospital stay. They also investigated factors that
could predict successful outcome among patients subjected to CPAP.
METHODS: Thirty-one patients with cardiogenic pulmonary edema were randomly assigned to two groups: those
receiving CPAP and those who underwent intubation. Improvement in oxygenation 30 minutes and 2 hours after initiation of mechanical ventilation (PaO2 / FiO2 and SaO2), duration of mechanical ventilation, length of ICU stay and length
of hospital stay between the two groups were compared. Likewise, the Simplified Acute Physiologic Score II (SAPS),
age, smoking history, tolerance to CPAP and co-morbidities were compared between the non-invasive group requiring
endotracheal intubation and those who did not.
RESULTS: CPAP was able to reduce the need for endotracheal intubation in 47% of patients. The noninvasive
group had a shorter duration of mechanical ventilation (46.28 ± 17.56 vs. 156 ± 159 hours; p=0.01) and ICU stay (3.0 ± 2.5
vs. 9.6 ± 4.9 days; p=0.03) compared to the invasive mechanical ventilation group. The SAPS II, co-morbidities, age,
blood gas parameters were not significantly different between the failed and successful CPAP groups. Improvement in
oxygenation and tolerance to CPAP were the main factors noted to predict successful outcome of non-invasive mechanical ventilation. The numbers of complications were not statistically significant between the invasive and noninvasive mechanical ventilation groups (p = 0.16).
CONCLUSION: CPAP reduced the need for endotracheal intubation by 47%. Furthermore, a shorter duration of
mechanical ventilation use and ICU stay among these patients were noted. The major factors for CPAP success were
improvement in oxygen saturation and tolerance to the procedure.
Phil Heart Center J 2002;9:41-47
Keywords: Respiration, artificial; pulmonary edema; tracheal disease; ventilation, mechanical
racheal intubation and mechanical ventilation can successfully provide support and allow the survival of many
patients suffering from acute respiratory failure. However, nasotracheal or orotracheal intubation or tracheostomy
may by themselves, be a source of added morbidity, and severe complications have been described with the use of these
techniques. Furthermore, the endotracheal tube itself, may increase work of breathing and subsequently prolo ng the duration of weaning from the respirator by inducing respiratory
muscle fatigue. Recently, a non-invasive positive-pressure ventilation technique using facial or nasal mask without tracheal
intubation has been described. It is safe and effective in improving gas exchange in selected patients with varying types
T
Correspondence: Christina A. Uy, MD. Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine,
Philippine Heart Center East Avenue, Quezon City, Philippines 1100
ISSN 0018-9034
of respiratory failure. In patients with acute respiratory failure, the therapy slightly decreases the rate of intubation and
improves survival but the effect was not statistically significant.
In another study done by Meduri, et al,1 they showed that
Continuous Positive Airway Pressure (CPAP) was as effective
as conventional ventilation in improving gas exchange and is
associated with shorter stay in the intensive care unit. One of
the common conditions where its use has been widely studied
is hypoxemic respiratory failure secondary to cardiogenic pulmonary edema.1
As a cardiac referral center, various cardiac conditions are
admitted to the intensive care units daily. Acute Coronary
Syndrome and Rheumatic Heart Diseases are the two most
common cardiac conditions encountered. Majorities of these
patients present with pulmonary edema often resulting to acute
hypoxemic respiratory failure and subsequent endotracheal
Copyright 2002 Philippine Heart Center Journal
intubation. Several prospective controlled studies done have
proven that noninvasive ventilation such as CPAP had resulted
to reduced need for endotracheal intubation in these patients.
A review of the different studies (Pang et al, 1998)2 on the use
of CPAP in patients with cardiogenic pulmonary edema
suggests that there is a modest amount of favorable evidence
to support its use, due to the decrease in the need for intubation
and a trend toward a decrease in mortality. The authors further add that the greatest benefit may be obtained in those patients with severe ventilatory failure.2 In a local case-control
study by Dimacutac, et al. (1995)3 involving 6 patients, they
have shown that CPAP may be an option that can be utilized in
patients with cardiogenic pulmonary edema. There has been
no similar study done locally so far.
With the paucity of data regarding the use of noninvasive
positive airway pressure in patients with cardiogenic pulmonary edema, this study was undertaken.
Objectives
The main objective of this study is to determine the efficacy of noninvasive Continuous Positive Airway Pressure
(CPAP) via nasal mask in improving oxygenation of patients
with acute hypoxemic respiratory failure secondary to cardiogenic causes in conjunction with aggressive medical therapy
and who require mechanical ventilation.
Specifically, this study would like to determine its efficacy in terms of improvement in gas exchange, frequency of
complications, duration of mechanical ventilation, duration of
stay at the ICU, and length of hospital stay as compared to
conventional mechanical ventilation by endotracheal intubation.
Furthermore, this study aims to determine the predictors
for successful outcome in these patients who received continuous positive airway pressure.
Methodology
This is a randomized controlled trial involving patients
aged 19 years old and above admitted at the Philippine Heart
Center (Emergency and Intensive Care Units) from January to
September 2002 with acute hypoxemic respiratory failure secondary to cardiogenic pulmonary edema. The following were
the inclusion criteria
1. Patients with known cardiac diseases (e.g. Coronary
Artery Disease, Valvular Heart Disease, etc)
2. Acute respiratory distress (RR>25/min, active contraction of the accessory muscles of respiration or paradoxical
abdominal motion) that continue to deteriorate despite aggressive medical management (diuretics, oxygenation, inotropics,
etc).
42
3. Ratio of the partial pressure of arterial oxygen to the
fraction of inspired oxygen (PaO2: FiO2) of less than 300 while
breathing through face mask.
4. Hemodynamically stable (SBP = / > 90 mm Hg, HR
<100/min, absence of cyanosis).
Patients with any of the following were excluded in the study:
1. Those requiring emergency intubation for cardiopulmonary resuscitation, respiratory arrest, severe hemodynamic
instability or encephalopathy.
2. Respiratory failure caused by neurologic disease, status asthmaticus, or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
(COPD)
3. Those with two or more new organ failures (e.g. Simultaneous presence of renal and cardiovascular failure)
4. Those patients who underwent tracheostomy or recent oral, esophageal, or gastric surgery (< 6 months)
5. Patients with Glasgow coma scale < 13 or who were
unable to expectorate or clear secretions
6. Those with facial deformity (e.g. Micrognathia, etc)
Patients who met the inclusion criteria were assigned into
two groups by blocked randomization. Group 1 comprised the
noninvasive (CPAP) group and Group II were patients placed
on mechanical ventilation. Appropriate standard medical management was given to both groups as deemed necessary. Written informed consent was obtained from each patient. Data
collected included age, sex, co-morbidities, Simplified Acute
Physiologic Score (SAPS II), causes of respiratory failure and
smoking history.
Invasive Mechanical Ventilation
Patients randomized to the invasive mechanical ventilation (MV) group were intubated using cuffed endotracheal tubes
with internal diameter ranging from 7.5-8.0 cm. Sedation with
diazepam 5 mg IV was given. No paralyzing drug was administered. Mechanical ventilators used were Puritan Bennett 7200
and Newport Breeze. The initial ventilatory setting was assist/
control with an FiO2 of 100%, tidal volume calculated at 6-8
ml/kg, RR of 14-18 breaths per minute, and initial Positive
end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) of 8 cm H2O. The patients'
heads were elevated at 45 degrees. Depending on the arterial
blood gas results, the PEEP was increased at an increment of
2-3 cm H2O up to 20 cm H2O until an adequate oxygenation
(PaO2 > 60 mm Hg; O2Sat > 90%: or P/F ratio>300) was obtained. When adequate oxygenation was maintained and patients' condition stabilized, the FiO2 was gradually decreased
by decrements of 10% until 40% or less was reached. With
oxygen still maintained at an acceptable level, PEEP was slowly
reduced at decrements of 2-3 cm H2O up to 5 cm H2O. Weaning using T-piece was started when weaning parameters were
fulfilled. Extubation was done after 2 hour weaning was tolerated (with RR<30/min and PaO2 > 75 mm Hg).
CA Uy, et al
Noninvasive ventilation: continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP).
Patients randomized to Non-invasive ventilation were
hooked to CPAP (Good Nite machine) using nasal mask. After the mask had been secured, the initial positive pressure applied was 6 cm H2O at 10 L/min. The head of the bed was
elevated at 45 degrees angle. For patients with nasogastric
tubes, a seal connector was used to minimize leakage. The
positive pressure was increased at an increment of 2-3 cm H2O
(maximum of 20 cm H2O) until adequate oxygenation was
achieved. The FiO2 was then gradually decreased until 6 L/
min is attained and positive pressure to 5 cm H2O maintaining
adequate oxygenation. At that level, CPAP was discontinued
and patient shifted to nasal cannula.
CPAP was considered failed when patient was subsequently intubated. Criteria for switching to conventional (invasive) mechanical ventilation were:
1. Failure to maintain a PaO2 above 60 mm Hg with an
FiO2 of 0.6 or less
2. Development of conditions necessitating endotracheal
intubation to protect airways (coma or seizure disorders)
or to manage copious tracheal secretions
3. Hemodynamic or electrocardiographic instability
4. Inability on the part of the patient to tolerate face mask
because of discomfort.
Monitoring of Oxygenation
Both groups were hooked to pulse oximeter to provide
continuous monitoring of patient's oxygen saturation (SaO2)
with SaO2 maintained > 90%. Arterial blood gases were taken
at: (1) baseline prior to intubation, (2) 30 minutes after the
initial set up of mechanical ventilation; (2) 30 minutes after
each adjustment of MV or CPAP; (4) 2 hours after study entry;
(4) during weaning; and (5) when oxygen dasaturation was
noted on pulse oximetry. Based on the arterial blood gas (ABG)
results, the ventilator set up was adjusted accordingly. Standard management for acid-base imbalance was given.
Endpoints and Definitions
The primary endpoints were oxygenation (PaO2, O2 saturation, PaO2/ FiO2 ratio) and the need for invasive mechanical
ventilation. Improvement in gas exchange is defined as the
ability to increase the PaO2:FiO2 ratio to >/= 200 or an increase
in the ratio of >100 from baseline. This evaluation was done
within 1 hour after initiation of either invasive or non-invasive
mechanical ventilation (initial improvement) and over time
(sustained improvement). Sustained improvement in gas exchange is defined as the ability to maintain the abovementioned
improvement in PaO2:FiO2 ratio until mechanical ventilation
is discontinued. Acceptable oxygenation is defined as PaO2>
60 mm Hg or SaO2> 90%.
The secondary end-points include survival, frequency of
complications, duration of mechanical ventilation, the duration of stay at the intensive care unit (ICU) and the length of
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
hospital stay.
The SAPS II was calculated 24 hours after admission to
the emergency room or ICU. The score takes into account the
following variables: age, heart rate, systolic blood pressure,
body temperature, urinary output, white blood cell, Glasgow
coma score, serum potassium, sodium, bicarbonate, urea
nitrogen concentration. A range of 0 to 4 was assigned to
each variable (possible score: 0 to 56). Higher score indicates
higher risk for death.
Statistical Analysis
Univariate analysis comparing the two groups (CPAP vs.
Mechanical Ventilator; CPAP success vs. CPAP Failure) was
done using the Chi square and Fisher Exact Test for nominal
data and t-test for continuous data.
Results
Between January to September 2002, a total of 415 patients were admitted to the intensive care units (ICU). Of the
415 patients admitted, 263 had hypoxemic respiratory failure.
Only 47 patients met the inclusion criteria, of which, 31 gave
their written informed consent and were enrolled into the study.
Fifteen (15) were randomized to the noninvasive mechanical
ventilation group (NIV) and sixteen (16) to the invasive ventilation group (IMV).
The baseline demographic and clinical characteristics of
the two groups were comparable as shown in Table I with the
exception of mean body temperature which was noted to be
higher in the mechanical ventilation group (p<0.04) but is still
within the normal range.
Eight (8) of the 15 patients in the noninvasive group (53%)
were eventually intubated within the first 30 minutes after initiation of CPAP. Five (67.5%) of these patients were unable
to tolerate the said procedure while 3 patients (37.5%) developed hypotension (BP<90/60 mm Hg).
The initial mean change in PaO2:FiO2 ratios between successful invasive and CPAP groups were comparable (Figure
1). All seven (7) patients in the successful NIV group showed
an increase in their P:F ratio from baseline to 30 minutes after
initiation of CPAP (mean increase of 56.2) but only 2(28.57%)
showed significant improvement in gas exchange (an increase
of 100 or more from their baseline P:F ratio). Two hours after
initiation of CPAP, 5 patients (71.43%) were able to achieve
sustained improvement in gas exchange (P:F ratio). In the invasive mechanical ventilation group, 14 (87.5%) patients
showed an increase in their P:F ratio within 30 minutes of
mechanical ventilation (mean increase of 96.79) but only 8
(50%) had significant improvement in gas exchange. Two
hours after invasive mechanical ventilation, 15 (93.75%) patients were able to sustain improvement in their P:F ratio. The
43
difference in the number of patients achieving improved gas
exchange (30 minutes and two hours after mechanical ventilation) between the two groups is not statistically significant
(p=0.40 and 0.21 respectively).
Table I. Baseline demographic and clinical characteristics of the
two groups
Noninvasive
Ventilation
Group (n=15)
Invasive
Ventillation
Group (n=16)
Age (yrs) (Mean + SD)
Male : Female Ratio
SAPS II
Heart Rate ( beats/ min)
Systolic Blood Pressure
(mm Hg)
Temperature (0C)
Urine output (L/ 24H)
Hematocrit
WBC count
Serum Creatinine (umol/L)
Serum Potassium (mmol/L)
Serum Bicarbonate
pH
PaCO2 (mmHg)
P:F ratio
66.60 + 11.47
5:01
63.40 + 16.47
5:03
34.20 + 7.91
96.20 + 12.32
129.27 + 17.99
36.48 + 0.37
2.16 + 1.38
0.41 + 0.05
10.50 + 2.80
0.14 + 0.56
4.12 + 0.50
23.47 + 8.22
7.37 + 0.09
41.64 + 11.02
100.46 + 52.99
32.81 + 8.13
100.06 + 22.80
124.06 + 28.31
36.91 + 0.43
1.59 + 0.84
0.38 + 0.07
11.33 + 5.50
0.21 + 0.15
4.49 + 1.12
21.56 + 3.52
7.34 + 0.12
45.50 + 14.00
119.26 + 54.43
10 (62.50%)
No. of smokers
(Ex- or current)
Causes of ARF
Pneumonia
Cardiogenic Pulm
Edema
Post-op. RF
COMORBIDITIES
Diabetes milletus
Pneumonia
Bronchial Asthma
Hypertension
Bronchiectasis
Nephropathy
10 (66.67%)
VARIABLES
1
15
1
8
1
2
1
2
6
1
1
6
0
15
0
6
0
0
0
0
4
0
0
7
600
P:F 500
R 400
A
T 300
I
200
O
100
0
Base line
30 mins
afte r
2 hours
afte r
Figure 2. P:F ratios at baseline, 30 minutes and 2 hours after
among patients on Invasive Mechanical Ventilation (Initial and
sustained improvement in gas exchange)
Overall, 24 patients (eigth patients from the NIV group
with failed CPAP and 16 patients from the conventional mechanical ventilation group), underwent endotracheal intubation. One patient in the invasive mechanical ventilation group
died of hypovolemic shock due to ruptured abdominal aortic
aneurysm within six hours after intubation and one patient was
discharged (against medical advice) before treatment was completed. The duration of mechanical ventilation (Figure 2) in
noninvasive group with successful CPAP was shorter compared to failed CPAP and invasive mechanical ventilation
groups (46 + 17 vs. 148 + 151 vs. 156 + 159 hours; p = 0.02
and 0.01, respectively).
P= 0.01
P= 0.48
P= 0.02
160
P:F
R
A
T
I
O
400
140
350
120
300
100
250
80
200
60
150
CPAP failed
Invasive MV
40
100
20
50
0
0
Baseline
30 mins
2 hrs after
Figure 1. P:F ratios at baseline, 30 minutes and 2 hours after
among patient with successful CPAP (Initial and sustained
improvement in gas exchange)
44
CPAP success
Figure 3. Duration of mechanical ventillation (Hrs) in successful and failed CPAP and invasive mechanical ventilation
groups
CA Uy, et al
Figure 3 showed that the length of ICU stay was significantly shorter in the successful CPAP group compared to both
failed CPAP and invasive mechanical ventilation groups (3.0
+ 2.5 vs. 8.0 + 4.9 vs. 9.6 + 4.9 days, respectively; p = 0.03).
However, no statistical difference was noted in the length of
ICU stay of failed CPAP to that of invasive mechanical ventilation (8.0 + 4.9 days vs. 9.6 + 4.9 days; p=0.48). The mean
duration of hospitalization was lower among patients with successful CPAP compared to the patient with failed CPAP and
conventional ventilation groups (9 + 4.9 vs. 22 + 18 days vs.
24 + 21 days; p=0.11 and 0.31, respectively).
P=0.12
P= 0.33
25
P=0.11
20
15
10
CPAP success
P
=
0.
P=0.48
0
P=3 0. 02
CPAP failed
Invasive MV
5
0
Length of ICU stay
(Days)
Table II showed the factors that may predict outcome of
non invasive positive airway pressure. Mean age (64 + 10
years vs. 68 + 12; p=0.48), SAPS II (34 + 5 vs. 35 + 10;
p=0.83), mean change (Baseline and 30 minutes after) in systolic blood pressure (-9.66 vs. -10.16 mm Hg ; p=0.952) and
diastolic blood pressure (-8.75 vs. + 10.75 mm Hg: p=0.863)
were comparable between the successful and failed CPAP. On
the other hand, the mean change in oxygen saturation (SaO2)
from baseline to 30 minutes after initiation of CPAP was noted
to be significantly different between the successful and failed
CPAP. The successful CPAP group attained an increase in
SaO2 of 4.58% whereas failed CPAP had further reduction in
oxygen saturation by 8.80% from baseline (p=0.952). Likewise, the number of patients who were able to tolerate the said
procedure was also statistically significant between the two
groups (p=0.026) with all patients in the successful CPAP and
only 3 patients in the failed CPAP group able to tolerate the
strategy.
The complications noted in each study group were shown
in Table III. There were more patients in the invasive mechanical ventilator group who had complications compared
to those in the successful CPAP group but this was not statistically significant (68% vs. 28%: p=0.17). The most common
complication noted in any of the ventilatory strategy groups
was pneumonia: 2 (28.5%) in the successful CPAP; 6 (75.0%)
in failed CPAP; and in the invasive mechanical ventilation, 10
(62.5%).
Length of Hospital
Stay (Days)
Figure 4. The Length of ICU and Hospital Stay in successful
and failed CPAP and Invasive MV groups.
Table III. Comparison of factors that may predict outcome of
non invasive positive airway pressure
VARIABLES
Table II. Comparison of factors that may predict outcome of non
invasive positive airway pressure
VARIABLES
SUCCESSfUL FAILED
P value
CPAP n=7
CPAP n=8
Age (yrs)
SAPS II
Tolerability
Yes
No
SaO2(% sat)
Mean change
Systolic BP (mm Hg)
Mean change
Diastolic BP (mm Hg)
Mean change
64.29
34 + 5
68.62
35 + 10
0.48
0.83
7
0
3
5
0.026*
4.58
-8.8
0.002**
-9.66
-10.16
0.952
-8.75
10.75
0.863
* significant using Chi square
** significant in Chi square and Fisher exact test
* - not significant; P>0.05 compared with CPAP success
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
Patients with
complications -# (%)
Patients w/ complications
causing death at ICU
COMPLICATIONS
Cardiogenic shock
Sepsis
Renal Failure
Phlebitis
Arrythmia
Pneumonia
Sinusitis
Pulmonary embolism
Cerebrovascular
Accidents
Massive blood loss
Noninvasive Ventillation
Group (n=15)
Success
Failure
P value
(n=7)
(n=8)
2(28.6%)
6(75.0%)*
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2(28.5%)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
6(75.0%)
0
0
0
0
1(6.25%)
1(6.25%)
1(6.25%)
1(6.25%)
1(6.25%)
0
1(6.25%)
1(6.25%)
0
0
1(6.25%)
* - not significant compared with CPAP success
45
Discussion
In this study, noninvasive ventilation using Continuous
Positive Airway Pressure (CPAP) had reduced the need
forendotracheal intubation to 47% in patients with cardiogenic
pulmonary edema. This result is similar to the study done by
Meduri, et al.1 where seven of the 32 patients receiving CPAP
had cardiogenic pulmonary edema as the underlying cause.
CPAP was successful in 4 (57%) of these patients. The success rate of CPAP was higher in a study done by Lin, et al.4
(1995) where among the 50 patients with cardiogenic pulmonary edema receiving CPAP, 41 (82%) successfully avoided
endotracheal intubation. Other studies reported varying success rate from 60% in 30 patients (Carlucci, et al. 2001) 5 to
100% in 19 patients (Bersten et al, 1991). 6
Success in CPAP has been associated with several variables. Meduri, et al.1 reported a significantly lower age group
(47 vs. 67 years) and SAPS II (12 vs. 16) among patients with
successful CPAP compared to those who failed. Likewise,
Carlucci et al5 also noted SAPS II to be a significant variable
for successful noninvasive mechanical ventilation by CPAP.
In our study, however, the age and SAPS II of successful and
failed CPAP were not statistically significant. The reason for
this could be the homogeneity of the study population involving patients developing acute hypoxemic respiratory failure
secondary to cardiogenic pulmonary edema. Age range was
likewise limited ranging from 5th to 6th decade.
Other variables that were cited by Carlucci and coworkers5 include encephalopathy score, pH at admission, clinical
toleration of noninvasive ventilation (NIV) and the presence
of air leaks. Both high severity score and presence of air leaks
have been shown to predict failure in other similar studies. In
this study, air leaks did not occur in any of the patients studied.
This study showed that both initial and sustained improvements in gas exchange did not differ significantly between successful non-invasive and invasive mechanical ventilation
groups. This points to the fact that non-invasive mechanical
ventilation will provide the same improvement in gas exchange
similar to invasive mechanical ventilation. This result somehow differs from the result of Meduri and co-workers that reported a higher initial and sustained improvement in gas exchange among the noninvasive ventilation group.
A multiple regression analysis for prediction of NIV failure found that severity score, SAPS II and poor toleration of
NIV were independent risk factors for secondary intubation.
It added that severely ill patients with higher SAPS II are poor
candidates for noninvasive ventilation.5 In another study, Soo
Hoo, et al.7 reported that there was a more rapid decrease in
PaCO2 in patients where NPPV was successful whereas Meduri,
et al.8 reported that PaCO2 increased when NPPV failed and
decreased when NPPV was successful. Furthermore, Poponick,
et al.9 reported that an improvement in PaCO2 and pH 30 min
after initiation of NPPV predicted success. Among the vari-
46
ables considered as predictors, only oxygen saturation change
(baseline and 30 minutes after) and tolerability were found to
be significant between successful and failed CPAP groups.
Among patients in whom CPAP failed, all of them were intubated within 30 minutes from initiation of CPAP. This supports the report of Hess, et al. (2001)10 that the initial response
to Non-invasive Positive Pressure Ventilation (NPPV) may
predict success or failure. In this report, he cited the study of
Brochard, et al.11 showing that most patients who failed NPPV
were intubated within the first 12 hours of therapy.
This study, furthermore, showed a significantly shorter
duration of mechanical ventilation use (46 vs. 156 hr; p=0.02)
and intensive care unit (ICU) stay (3 vs. 9.6 days; p=0.02)
among patients receiving noninvasive ventilation compared to
the invasive mechanical ventilation group. Meduri, et al.1 cited
several factors that may have been involved in shortening the
duration of mechanical ventilation: avoidance of sedation,
elimination of extra work of breathing imposed by endotracheal tube, the lower rate of ventilator-associated pneumonia
and earlier removal from mechanical ventilation.
Likewise, these could also probably explain the lower frequency of complications among the successful CPAP group (2
vs. 11 patients) although this was not statistically significant
(p=0.16). Meduri, et al.1 also reported a lower rate of serious
complications, particularly related to intubation (pneumonia
and sinusitis) among the noninvasive group. He emphasized
that endotracheal intubation is the single most important predisposing factor for ventilator-associated pneumonia. This
group also had shorter duration of mechanical ventilation and
ICU stay. In addition, he noted that there were more patients
with respiratory acidosis in the invasive ventilation group and
this may have affected the duration of mechanical ventilation
and outcome of this group. However, this was not noted in our
study. The same findings were reported by Carlucci et al,5
wherein the duration of ventilation and the length of ICU stay
were shorter in NIV group. Both studies reported a lower
mortality rate among the noninvasive group.
The study did not look into the mortality outcome since
there was only one mortality in the invasive mechanical ventilation group and none in the noninvasive group. Another concern raised by some authors of similar studies is the impact of
CPAP on the cardiac condition of the patients. Pang et al2
reported that the potential for harm exists if CPAP leads to
greater myocardial demand in the setting of an acute myocardial infarction. An increase in myocardial demand could occur if the work of breathing is greater in patients treated with
CPAP than those intubated and sedated. He further added that
this increase in demand could cause more severe and extensive ischemia resulting to malignant dysrrhythmias, cardiac
arrest, and / or death. In survivors, more extensive myocardial
damage may result in worse left ventricular function and long
term disability. Only one of the three trials that this group
reviewed addressed the potential for harm. In our study,
CA Uy, et al
myocardial infarction or other cardiac complications mentioned above were not noted. While there is currently no evidence that CPAP causes harm in patients with cardiogenic pulmonary edema, the evidence available is insufficient to exclude this concern.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Conclusions
9.
10.
On the basis of the preliminary results, noninvasive mechanical ventilation with the use of Continuous PositiveAirway
Pressure (CPAP) can achieve improvement in oxygenation
without the need for endotracheal intubation in 47% of patients with hypoxemic respiratory failure secondary to cardiogenic pulmonary edema. Furthermore, the duration of mechanical ventilation and length of ICU stay was significantly
shortened thereby reducing hospital costs. Improvement in
oxygen saturation
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
References
19.
20.
1.
2.
3.
4.
Antonelli, Meduri, et al. A Comparison of Noninvasive Positive Pressure Ventilation and Conventional Mechanical ventilation in Patients with acute Respiratory failure. N Eng J Med;339(7):429-435.
Pang, David et al. The Effect of Positive Pressure Airway Support on Mortality and the Need for Intubation in Cardiogenic Pulmonary Edema: A Systematic Review. Chest 1998;114(4):1185-1192.
Dimacutac Z, et al. The role of face mask CPAP in the Management of Acute
Respiratory Failure due to Cardiogenic Pulmonary Edema. PHC Research
Paper 1995 (Unpublished).
Lin, et al. Reapraisal of Continuous positive Airway pressure Therapy in
Acute Cardiogenic pulmonary edema. Chest 107(5):1379-1386.
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
21.
22.
23.
24.
Carlucci, et al. Noninvasive versus Conventional Mechanical ventilation. An
epidemiologic survey. Am J Resp Crit Care Med 163(4):874-880.
Bersten et al. Treatment of Severe Cardiogenic pulmonary edema with Continuous Positive Airway pressure (CPAP) delivered by face mask. N Eng J
Med 325(26):1825-1830.
Soo Hoo GW, et al. Nasal Mechanical ventilation for hypercapneic respiratory failure in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: determinants of success. Crit Care Med 1994;22:1253-1261.
Meduri GU, et al. Noninvasive Positive Pressure Ventilation via face mask
First line intervention in patients with acute hypercapneis and hypoxemic respiratory failure. Chest 1996;109:179-193.
Poponixk, JM et al. Use of ventilatory system (BiPAP) for acute respiratory
failure in the Emergency Department. Chest 1999;116:166- 171.
Hess Dean, et al. Noninvasive Positive Pressure Ventilation for Acute Respiratory Failure. Am Thorac Soc Post Grad Course 2002.
Brochard L. et al. Noninvasive Ventilation for Acute Exacerbations of Chronic
obstructive Pulmonary Disease. N Eng J Med 1995;333:817-822.
Keenan SP. Noninvasive positive Pressure Ventilation in Acute respiratory
failure. JAMA 284(18):2376-2378.
Wysoki, M. et al. Noninvasive Pressure Support Ventilation in Patients with
Acute Respiratory Failure. Chest 1995;107(3):761-766.
Meduri, G. et al. Noninvasive Face Mask Ventilation in Patients with Acute
Respiratory Failure. Chest 1989;95(4):865-870.
State of the art: Noninvasive Ventilation. Am J Resp Crit Care Med 163: 540577.
Kindgen-Miles D. et al. Nasal Continuous Positive Airway Pressure. Chest
2000;117(4):1106-1111.
Kramer N. Randomized Prospective Trial of Noninvasive Positive Pressure
Ventilation in Acute Respiratory Failure. Am J Resp Crit Care Med 151:17991806.
Brochard L, et al. Noninvasive Ventilation for Acute Exacerbations of Chronic
obstructive Pulmonary Disease. N Eng J Med 1995;333:817-822.
Keenan SP. Noninvasive positive Pressure Ventilation in Acute respiratory
failure. JAMA 284(18):2376-2378.
Wysoki M. et al. Noninvasive Pressure Support Ventilation in Patients with
Acute Respiratory Failure. Chest 1995;107(3):761-766.
Meduri, G. et al. Noninvasive Face Mask Ventilation in Patients with Acute
Respiratory Failure. Chest 1989;95(4):865-870.
State of the Art: Noninvasive ventilation. Am J Resp Crit Care Med 163: 540577.
Kindgen-Miles D. et al. Nasal Continuous Positive Airway Pressure. Chest
2000;117(4):1106-1111.
Kramer N. Randomized Prospective Trial of Noninvasive Positive Pressure
Ventilation in Acute Respiratory Failure. Am J Resp Crit Care Med 151: 17991806.
47
Serum Uric Acid Levels among Patients woth
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Diseases
Inocencio H. Lopez MD, Ma. Encarnita Blanco-Limpin Md, Percival Punzal MD, Teresita De Guia MD.
BACKGROUND. Elevated serum uric acid levels were observed in clinical conditions associated with hypoxia
such as heart failure, primary pulmonary hypertension and congenital heart disease but no such observation was
reported among COPD patients. Therefore, we aimed to determine whether serum uric acid levels correlate with
hypoxemia and COPD severity in stable and exacerbating COPD patients.
METHODS. Included are 110 diagnosed COPD patients based on spirometry, grouped into stable COPD, and in
acute exacerbation. Simultaneous blood extractions for serum uric acid and ABG’s were determined with the patient
in a steady state and in upright position. Independent t-test was employed to determine the association between
serum uric acid levels with blood gas variables, age and sex. The correlation between serum uric acid levels with
COPD severity was explored using ANOVA.
RESULTS. There was a highly significant correlation between hypoxemia and serum uric acid levels in both
stable and exacerbating COPD patients (p <0.000 and 0.004 respectively). There was no significant correlation of age
and sex with that of uric acid levels (p value > 0.05). The relation of COPD severity and serum uric acid levels showed
that the higher the serum uric acid level, the more severe the COPD is among subjects in the stable COPD group (p
<0.000). However, the same does not apply among the subjects in acute exacerbation (p 0.070).
CONCLUSION. There is a strong correlation between hypoxemia and the severity of COPD with serum uric acid
level among stable COPD patients. Thus, elevated serum uric acid levels may serve as a noninvasive indicator for the
severity of COPD and hypoxemia in non-exacerbating COPD patients.
Phil Heart Center J 2002;9:48-55
Keywords: Obstructive pulmonary disease, chronic; serum uric acid
hronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) is a
disease state characterized by airflow limitation that is
not fully reversible. The airflow limitation is usually
both progressive and associated with an abnormal
inflammatory response of the lungs to noxious particles or
gases.1
COPD is a major cause of chronic morbidity and mortality
throughout the world. COPD is currently the fourth leading
cause of death in the world and further increases in the
prevalence and mortality of the disease can be predicted in
the coming decades.
The late stages of COPD are characterized by a marked
decline in pulmonary function and a decrease in reversibility
of obstruction following administration of inhaled
bronchodilator. As lung function declines, the alveolar-arterial
gradient for oxygen increases, primarily because of an increase
in abnormal ventilation-perfusion relationships. Hypoxemia,
pulmonary hypertension and cor pulmonale develop.2
Serum uric acid (UA), the final product of purine
degradation has been shown to be increased in hypoxic states
C
Correspondence: Inocencio H. Lopez, MD Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine,
Philippine Heart Center East Avenue, Quezon City, Philippines 1100
ISSN 0018-9034
such as chronic heart failure, cyanotic congenital heart disease
and obstructive pulmonary disease.3 Because tissue ischemia
and hypoxia deplete adenosine triphosphate (ATP) and
promote degradation of adenosine nucleotides to inosine,
hypoxanthine, xanthine and UA, increased serum UA levels
may reflect impaired oxidative metabolism in such diseases.
Interestingly, serum UA levels have recently been shown to
have strong independent association with long-term mortality
of patients with chronic heart failure4 but not with COPD
patients hence this study.
Review of Related Literature
Hyperuricemia may be defined as a plasma (or serum)
urate concentration greater than 420 umol/L (7 mg/dl). This
definition is based on physicochemical, epidemiologic and
disease-related criteria. Physicochemically, hyperuricemia is
the concentration of urate in the blood that exceeds the
solubility limits of monosodium urate in plasma, 415 umol/L
(6.8 mg/dl). In epidemiologic studies, hyperuricemia is
defined as the mean plus 2 standard deviations of values
determined from a randomly selected healthy population.
Copyright 2002 Philippine Heart Center Journal
When measured in unselected individuals, 95% have serum
urate concentrations below 420 umol/L (7 mg/dl). Finally,
hyperuricemia can be defined in relation to the risk of disease.
The risk of developing gout or urolithiasis increases with urate
levels greater than 420 umol/L (7 mg/dl) and escalates in
proportion to the degree of elevation.5
It is useful to classify hyperuricemia in relation to the
underlying physiology, whether the hyperuricemia results from
increased production, decreased excretion or a combination
of the two.
Accelerated purine nucleotide degradation cause
hyperuricemia. Nucleic acids released from cells are
hydrolyzed by the sequential activities of nucleases and
phosphodiesterases, forming nucleoside monophosphates, and
then are degraded to nucleosides, bases and urate.
Hyperuricemia can result from excessive degradation of
skeletal muscle ATP after strenuous physical exercise or status
epilepticus and in glycogen storage diseases types 111, V and
V11. The hyperuricemia of myocardial infarction, smoke
inhalation and acute respiratory failure also may be related to
accelerated breakdown of ATP. Most of literature reviewed
revealed an association of increased serum uric acid levels
with chronic heart failure, primary pulmonary hypertension
and congenital heart disease. Related literature reviewed was
on the association of urinary uric acid: creatinine ratio in sleep
associated hypoxemia.
Hasday and Grum6 measured overnight changes in
urinary uric acid: creatinine ratio in 17 patients with
documented sleep associated hypoxemia, 13 control patients
who remained normoxemic during polysomnography and 14
normal volunteers. The urinary uric acid: creatinine ratio
increased overnight in patients with sleep associated
hypoxemia, whereas it decreased in the control subjects with
negative sleep studies and in the normal volunteers.
The above study was validated by Braghiroli7 et al in
1993. They selected 10 normal volunteers, 29 COPD patients
and 49 subjects with obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). The
patients underwent standard polysomnography, which was
repeated in 14 subjects with nasal continuous positive airway
pressure (CPAP), and were subdivided into 2 groups: Group
D included desaturating subjects who spent at least 1 hour at
oxygen saturation <90% and 15 minutes below 85%, and
Group ND were non-desaturating subjects. The overnight
change in the uric acid: creatinine ratio was negative in normal
subjects and ND groups. In both COPD and OSA Group D,
the ratio was usually positive despite 4 of 15 false negative
results in COPD and 8 of 20 in OSA. CPAP effective treatment
induced a marked reduction in change in urinary uric acid:
creatinine ratio, leading to a negative value. They concluded
that the change in uric acid: creatinine ratio seems to be a
promising index of significant nocturnal tissue hypoxia with
good specificity but poor sensitivity (about 30% false
negative), which might be useful for the long-term follow-up
of outpatients on nasal CPAP with a positive ratio at baseline.
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
Changes in oxygen tension such as those associated with
hypoxic ischemia or hyperoxia may potentially modulate
purine nucleotide turnover and production of associated
catabolites. Elsayed8 et al used an isolated perfused rat lung
preparation to evaluate the effect of oxygen tension on
pulmonary uric acid production. Three oxygen concentrations
(21% normoxia; 95% hyperoxia; 0% hypoxia) were utilized
for both pulmonary ventilation and equilibration of
recirculating perfusate. All gas mixtures contained 5% carbon
dioxide and were balanced with nitrogen. After a 10-minute
equilibration period, uric acid levels were measured at 0 and
60 minutes in lung perfusate and at 60 minutes in lung tissue.
After 60 minutes of ventilation/perfusion, they observed
significant uric acid accumulation in both lung tissue (25-60%)
and perfusate (8-10 fold) for all 3 oxygen regimen. However,
hypoxia produced substantially greater net uric acid
concentration than either normoxia or hyperoxia.
Elevated serum uric acid concentration has been observed
in clinical conditions associated with hypoxia such as chronic
heart failure 9 , primary pulmonary hypertension 10 and
congenital heart disease11.
Research Objectives
General: To determine the association of serum uric acid
levels to the severity of COPD and blood gas variables among
COPD patients.
Specific:
1. To correlate the relationship of serum uric levels
with COPD severity and blood gas variables among
stable COPD patients.
2. To determine the relationship of serum uric acid
levels with COPD severity and blood gas variables
among COPD patients in exacerbation.
Research Hypothesis
High serum uric acid level is related to the severity of
COPD, low PaO2, and low SaO2.
Definition of Terms
1. COPD - a disease state characterized by airflow
limitation that is not fully reversible.
2. Serum uric acid - the final product of purine
degradation
3. COPD severity - classified as mild, moderate or
severe. Mild COPD is characterized by mild airflow
limitation (FEV1/FVC <70% but FEV1 >80% predicted)
and usually but not always, by chronic cough and sputum
production. Moderate COPD is characterized by
worsening airflow limitation (30% <FEV 1 <80%
predicted) and usually the progression of symptoms with
shortness of breath typically developing on exertion.
Severe COPD is characterized by severe airflow
limitation (FEV1 <30% predicted) or the presence of
respiratory failure or clinical signs of right heart failure.
49
4. Normal uric acid group - a group of individuals,
whether male or female, who belong to the normal serum
uric acid level (0.21-0.51 mmol/l).
5. High uric acid group - a group of individuals, whether
male or female, who belong to the upper serum uric acid
level (>0.51 mmol/l).
6. Arterial blood gas - blood extracted directly from an
artery for determination of pH, PaCO2, PaO2, HCO3 and
SaO2.
7. Hypoxemia - calculated by the PaO2 and FiO2 ratio
and the result should be less than 400 to say that the
person is hypoxemic.
8. Stable COPD - characterized by no episodes of
increasing dyspnea, no increase in sputum production
or no change in the color of the sputum
9. COPD in exacerbation - characterized by increasing
episodes of shortness of breath, increase in the amount
of sputum production or with change in the color of the
sputum.
Methodology
A. Study Design
This is a prospective, cross-sectional study of the
relationship of serum uric acid among COPD patients.
B. Study Sample
All patients diagnosed to have COPD: stable, in acute
exacerbation or in
respiratory failure, in the OPD or in the wards will be included
in the study. COPD is diagnosed if patients have symptoms
of cough, sputum production or dyspnea and/or a history of
exposure to risk factors with a postbronchodilator FEV1 <80%
of the predicted value in combination with an FEV1/FVC
<70%.
Patients with any of the following are excluded in the
study: presence of renal failure (serum creatinine >1.5 mg/
dl), those who are taking drugs which could decrease serum
uric acid excretion such as salicylates, diuretics, alcohol,
levodopa, ethambutol, PZA, nicotinic acid and cyclosporine,
and those with coronary risk factors, which might influence
serum uric acid levels such as hypertension, hyperlipidemia
and diabetes mellitus.
An informed consent will be obtained from all of the
subjects.
C. Study Setting and Period
This is a 12-month study period to be conducted at the
Philippine Heart Center. All patients diagnosed to have COPD
from January 1, 2002 to December 31, 2002 will be included
in the study. They will undergo serum uric acid level
50
determination as well as ABG determination.
D. Sample Size and Basis for the Calculation
With the uric acid abnormality rate of 95% and the total
width of confidence interval (@ = 0.05), the following is the
calculated sample size:
%
5
10
15
20
n
292
73
32
18
E. Identification of Study Variables
A. Independent variable - serum uric acid level
B. Dependent variable - COPD
C. Confounding variables - COPD severity, ABG
(PaO2 and SaO2)
F. Detailed Description of Data Collection
After obtaining results of spirometry, these patients are
classified according to severity whether they are mild,
moderate (stage llA or llB) or severe COPD patient. Venous
blood will then be drawn after an overnight fast for
measurement of serum UA levels. Serum uric acid levels were
determined by a 2-step sequential enzymatic reaction measured
by spectrophotometry (uricase-peroxidase method). Because
of sex difference in serum uric acid levels, different median
values for men and women were used to separate the high
uric acid group from the low uric acid group.
Simultaneous with venous blood extraction for serum uric
acid, an arterial blood gas (ABG) will be determined with the
patient in a steady state and in upright position. ABG analysis
is determined thru an ABL 600 machine.
Statistical Analysis
Independent t-test was employed to determine the
association between serum uric acid levels with blood gas
variables, age and sex. The correlation between serum uric
acid levels with COPD severity was explored using ANOVA.
Results
112 COPD patients were recruited for the study, however,
2 patients declined to sign the consent thus were excluded.
The patients were then categorized to stable group or in
exacerbation group. These groups of patients were further
subdivided according to their serum uric acid levels whether
normal or high.
Among the stable COPD patients, the mean age with
Lopez I, et al.
normal serum uric acid was 67.28 years while the mean age with high uric acid was 68.52 years. Concerning COPD patients
in exacerbation, the mean age with normal serum uric acid was 66.9 years while those with high uric acid were 69.81 years.
(Table 1)
Table 1. Characteristics of COPD Patients (Stable or in Exacerbation) in Relation to Serum Uric Acid Levels as to Age and Sex
Variable
Age
(yrs)
Sex
Male
Female
Both Sexes
STABLE COPD PATIENTS
COPD IN EXACERBATION
Normal Uric Acid
Mean
SD
High Uric Acid
Mean SD
P value
Normal Uric Acid
Mean
SD
High Uric Acid
Mean
SD
P value
67.28
9.34
68.52
8.06
0.588
66.9
10.02
69.81
8.14
0.348
N
37
2
39
%
95
5
100
N
24
1
25
%
96
4
100
N
10
0
10
%
100
0
100
N
35
1
36
%
97
3
100
0.348
1
Among males, 37 patients (95%) had normal uric acid
while 24 patients (96%) had high uric acid whereas among
females, 2 patients (5%) belong to the normal uric acid group
while 1 patient (4%) belonged to high uric acid group among
stable COPD patients.
With regards to COPD patients in exacerbation, 1 male
patient (100%) had normal uric acid while 35 patients (97%)
had high uric acid; however, only 1 female patient (3%)
belonged to the high uric acid group as shown in Table 1.
Using the t-test as a statistical tool, there was no significant
correlation between the 2 COPD groups (stable and in
exacerbation) with either normal or high uric acid levels about
age (p value of 0.588 and 0.348 respectively). As to sex, there
was also no significant correlation between the 2 COPD groups
with either normal or high uric acid levels (p value of 1.000
and 0.348 respectively) using the chi-square test.
As to COPD severity distribution, 64 were stable COPD
patients, majority of whom belonged to the moderate stage
11-A COPD with 34 patients (53.13%). Forty-six COPD
patients were in exacerbation, majority of whom belonged to
moderate stage 11-B COPD with 19 patients (41.30%) as seen
in Table 2.
Partial pressure of oxygen (PaO2) among stable COPD
patients showed decreasing results from a high of 83.40 mmHg
to a low of 58.33 mmHg among the different categories of
COPD (mild, moderate 11-A, moderate 11-B and severe
COPD). In the analysis of variance, there was significant
correlation between PaO2 and COPD severity among stable
COPD patients (p value 0.000). (Table 3)
Table 3. Comparison of the 2 COPD Groups as to PaO2 and COPD
Severity
COPD Severity
STABLE COPD
PATIENTS
PaO2
Mean
SD
COPD IN
EXACERBATION
PaO2
Mean
SD
Mild
Moderate 11-A
Moderate 11-B
Severe
P value
83.4
81.68
65.59
58.33
0.000***
78
67.5
65
61.36
0.131 NS
COPD Severity
Table 2. Distribution of Patients of the 2 COPD Groups as
to Severity
COPD Severity
Stable COPD Patients
n = 64
%
COPD in Exacerbation
n = 46
%
Mild
Moderate 11-A
Moderate 11-B
Severe
5
34
22
3
2
14
19
11
7.81
53.13
34.38
4.69
Mild
Moderate 11-A
Moderate 11-B
Severe
P value
11.63
11.36
7.67
1.53
SaO2
5.66
9.27
11.84
8.8
Mean
SD
SaO2
Mean
SD
96.16 1.12
95.15 2.1
89.99 7.02
91.3 1.13
0.000***
95.15
91.73
91.72
92.16
1.06
5.68
2.5
3.04
0.155 NS
4.35
30.43
41.3
23.91
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
51
PaO2 among COPD patients in exacerbation also showed
decreasing results from a high of 78.00 mmHg to a low of
61.36 mmHg among the different categories of COPD.
However using ANOVA as a statistical tool, there was no
significant correlation between PaO2 and COPD severity
among COPD patients in exacerbation (p value 0.131).
Oxygen saturation (SaO2) among stable COPD patients
also showed decreasing results from a high of 96.16% to a
low of 91.30% among the different COPD severities. There
was a highly significant correlation with regards to SaO2 and
COPD severity among stable COPD patients (p value 0.000).
SaO2 among COPD patients in exacerbation likewise
showed decreasing results among the different COPD
severities. However, when tested using ANOVA, there was
no significant correlation between SaO2 and COPD severity
among COPD patients in exacerbation (p value 0.155) as
shown in Table 3.
Blood gas variables, namely PaO 2 and SaO 2, were
analyzed in relation to the serum uric acid level (Table 4).
Using the independent t-test, there was significant correlation
between hypoxemia and elevated serum uric acid level (p value
0.000) among stable COPD patients. The more hypoxemic
the patient is, the higher will be his uric acid. Inversely, the
more normoxemic the patient is, the lower is his uric acid
level.
Table 4. Correlation of Serum Uric Acid Levels with Oxygenation in COPD Patients who are Stable and
Exacerbating
Variables
Stable COPD
Normal Uric Acid High Uric Acid
Oxygenation Mean
SD
Mean SD
P value
COPD in Exacerbation
Normal Uric Acid High Uric Acid
Mean SD
Mean SD
P value
PaO2
83.85
8.79
61.68 3.35
0.000*** 73.7
11.28
63.17
9.25
SaO2
95.82
1.24
89.3
0.000*** 95.43
1.37
91.02
3.7
6.1
0.004
**
0.001
**
Figures 1 and 2 represent the relationship between oxygenation
and uric acid levels whereby it is noted that in stable COPD
patients, the higher the uric acid level, the lower is the PaO2
and SaO2. This observation does not apply among COPD
patients in exacerbation where there is no such trend noted.
Figure 1. Correlation between individual serum uric acid
values and PaO2 depicted for all patients with stable COPD
52
Figure 2. Correlation between individual serum uric acid
values and PaO2 depicted for all patients with COPD in
exacerbation
Lopez I, et al.
This observation was also noted among COPD patients in
exacerbation where there was significant correlation
between hypoxemia and elevated serum uric acid level (p
value of 0.004).
The correlation of the severity of COPD among the
2 COPD groups with that of serum uric acid is shown in
Table 5.
Table 5. Correlation of Serum Uric Acid Levels with COPD Severity
in Patients who are Stable and Exacerbating
Variable Stable COPD
Quantitative Uric
Acid Level (mmol/L)
COPD
Mean
SD
Severity
Mild
0.38
0.044
IIA
0.433
0.081
IIB
0.566
0.103
Severe
0.657
0.07
P value
0.000***
COPD in Exacerbation
Quantitative Uric
Acid Level (mmol/L)
Mean
SD
0.425
0.504
0.619
0.565
0.070 NS
0.035
0.099
0.068
0.245
Serum uric acid among stable COPD patients showed
increasing results ranging from a low of 0.380 mmol/L to a
high of 0.657 mmol/L among the different COPD severities.
Using ANOVA as a statistical tool, the higher the serum uric
level, the more severe is the COPD with a p value of 0.000
which is highly significant among stable COPD patients.
Among COPD patients in exacerbation, serum uric acid
levels also showed increasing results from a low of 0.425
mmol/L to a high of 0.565 mmol/L among the different COPD
severities. When tested using ANOVA, there was no
significant correlation between serum uric acid and COPD
severity among COPD patients in exacerbation (p value
0.070).
A Bonferroni test was used to compare the different stages
of COPD severity with serum uric acid levels. There was
significant differences between: mild and moderate stage 11B (p value 0.000), mild and severe (p value 0.000), moderate
11-A and 11-B (p value 0.000), moderate 11-A and severe (p
value 0.000) among stable COPD patients. However, there
were no significant differences between: mild and moderate
stage 11-A (p value 1.000), moderate 11-B and severe (p value
0.586) among stable COPD patients.
Among COPD patients in exacerbation, there was no
significant differences between the different stages of COPD
severity with serum uric acid levels: mild and moderate 11-A
(p value 1.000), mild and moderate stage 11-B (p value 0.401),
mild and severe (p value 1.000), moderate stage 11-A and 11B (p value 0.141), moderate stage 11-A and severe (p value
1.000), and moderate 11-B and severe (p value 1.000).
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
Discussion
COPD refers to a constellation of clinical and pathologic
findings, that individually or in combination, produce chronic
airflow obstruction, disability and sometimes death. It is
characterized by chronic inflammation throughout the airways,
parenchyma and pulmonary vasculature. Pathological changes
in the lungs lead to corresponding physiological changes
characteristic of the disease.
In advanced COPD, peripheral airways obstruction, and
pulmonary vascular abnormalities reduce the lung’s capacity
for gas exchange thereby producing hypoxemia.
Hypoxemia is one of the numerous factors that might
influence serum uric acid levels and have to be considered
when discussing these observations. The other common
conditions known to be associated with elevated serum uric
acid levels such as renal failure, drugs which could decrease
serum uric acid excretion (salicylates, ethambutol,
pyrazinamide, nicotinic acid, etc.) and coronary risk factors
which might influence serum uric acid levels were not present
in our patient. Thus the observation in this study suggests
that elevated serum uric acid is a result of COPD per se.
An intensive literature search was done utilizing the
internet using PubMed and Cochrane as well as case series,
reviews, and this search did not yield any published literature
on the relationship of serum uric acid level with hypoxemia
and COPD severity. The only published articles that were
noted were those of primary pulmonary hypertension,
Eisenmenger syndrome and chronic heart failure. A study
conducted by Hardy6 and Braghiroli7 correlating uric acid and
severity of hypoxia in patients with COPD and obstructive
sleep apnea made use of urinary uric acid:creatinine ratio as
an index of significant nocturnal tissue hypoxia.
In the present study, we demonstrated that serum uric acid
levels had a significant correlation with hypoxemia as well as
with the severity of COPD among stable COPD patients. Ross
and colleagues have shown that hyperuricemia in cyanotic
congenital heart disease is attributable to enhanced urate
reabsorption secondary to abnormal intrarenal hemodynamics.
An increase in lactate in hypoxic states has also been shown
to inhibit tubular uric acid secretion.12 The reduced excretion
of uric acid because of impaired intrarenal dynamics contribute
to hyperuricemia, however, those patients with renal failure
were already excluded at the start of the study. This
observation may be applied in COPD patients where
hypoxemia is a part.
Alternatively, overproduction of uric acid could be
responsible for increased serum uric acid in these patients.
Earlier studies have shown that tissue ischemia deplete ATP
and activate the purine nucleotide degradation pathway to uric
acid, resulting in urate overproduction in the heart, lungs, liver
and skeletal muscle.8,13,14,15 In fact, production of uric acid has
been shown to increase in proportion to the severity of hypoxia
53
in patients with COPD and obstructive sleep apnea as reported
by Hardy and Braghiroli respectively. Hypoxia leads to
accumulation of the precursors of uric acid (hypoxanthine and
xanthine)16 and activation of xanthine oxidase/dehydrogenase.
Although the liver is the principal source of uric acid, the
endothelium also contributes to its production. Accordingly,
elevated serum uric acid would be expected to reflect the
metabolic effects of hypoxia on the microvasculature. It is
possible that tissue hypoxia will induce overproduction of uric
acid in a variety of organs in patients with COPD.
Earlier studies have shown that an increase in serum uric
acid levels is related to hypertension, hyperlipidemia and
diabetes mellitus. 17 In this study, those patients with
hypertension, hyperlipidemia and diabetes mellitus were
excluded outright at the start of this study so as not to allow
these conditions to affect the actual serum uric acid levels of
the patients included. However, multivariate analysis
demonstrated that serum uric acid levels did not independently
correlate with hypertension, hyperlipidemia and diabetes
mellitus among patients with primary pulmonary hypertension
and Eisenmenger syndrome.
Drugs such as salicylates, levodopa, ethambutol,
pyrazinamide, nicotinic acid and cyclosporine can influence
serum uric acid levels. Diuretic therapy is also known to affect
serum uric acid metabolism.18 Previous reports showed that
there was no independent correlation between serum uric acid
and diuretic treatment in patients with primary pulmonary
hypertension10 and Eisenmenger syndrome.9
This study demonstrated that elevated serum uric acid
levels correlated with COPD severity among stable COPD
patients, however, no significant correlation were shown
between serum uric acid level and COPD severity among
COPD patients in exacerbation. Therefore, the more severe
the COPD is the more elevated would be the serum uric acid
levels. This is particularly true since hypoxia is usually present
at the end of the spectrum of COPD severity. No significant
correlation was noted between serum uric acid levels and
COPD severity among COPD patients in exacerbation since
this group of patient’s exhibit only transient hypoxemia.
During the episodes of hypoxemia, there was a greater fall in
PaO2. This can be caused by a change in variation of
ventilation-perfusion ratios between different alveoli. The
classic theory of gas exchange depends upon steady-state
conditions and such conditions do not apply during transient
episodes of hypoxemia as can be found among COPD patients
in exacerbation. A follow-up on these patients should be done
to correlate serum uric acid levels with morbidity and mortality
as shown in previous study by Nagaya et al correlating serum
uric acid levels with the severity and mortality of primary
pulmonary hypertension. An echocardiogram is useful in
determining the degree of pulmonary hypertension and
hypoxemia which may be related to mortality. Moreover,
future studies should be done on the effect of long term oxygen
therapy on serum uric acid levels among COPD patients.
54
Thus serum uric acid is an important tool in correlating
the degree of hypoxemia as well as the severity of COPD
among non-exacerbating patients. It can be measured
routinely, is simple to perform and relatively inexpensive. It
may also serve as a noninvasive indicator for the severity of
COPD.
Conclusion
There is a strong correlation between serum uric acid and
hypoxemia as well as to the severity of COPD among stable
COPD patients. This association suggests that in COPD, serum
uric acid concentrations reflect an impairment of oxidative
metabolism. Elevated serum uric acid levels may serve as a
noninvasive indicator for the severity of COPD among nonexacerbating COPD patients.
Recommendations
The following recommendations are made:
1. Further studies should be undertaken on the effect of longterm oxygen therapy on serum uric acid levels among stable
COPD patients.
2. Further studies should be done on the correlation of serum
uric acid on the outcome of COPD patients (morbidity/
mortality).
3. An echocardiogram should be done to determine the degree
of pulmonary hypertension and hypoxemia.
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Lenfant C, Khataev N. Global Strategy for Prevention of COPD : NHLBI/
WHO Workshop Report.
Fishman A. Pulmonary Diseases and Disorders. New York:McGrawHill, 1998:685.
Nagaya N, et al. Serum Uric Acid Levels Correlate with the Severity and
the Mortality of Primary Pulmonary Hypertension. Am Respir Crit Care
Med 1999; 160:487-492.
Anker SD, Leyva F, Poole-Wilson P.A. and Coats AJS. Uric Acid as
independent predictor of impaired prognosis in patients with chronic heart
failure. J. Am. Coll.Cardiol 1998. 31:154A.
Fauci A. et al. Harrison’s Principles of Internal Medicine. New
York:McGraw-Hill, 1998:2159-2160.
Hasday JR, Grum CM. Nocturnal Increase of Urinary Uric Acid:Creatinine
Ratio. A Biochemical Correlate of Sleep Associated Hypoxemia. Am Rev
Resp Dis 1987;135 (3):534-538.
Braghiroli A, Sacco C, Erbetta M, Ruga V, Donner CF. Overnight Urinary
Uric Acid:Creatinine Ratio for Detection of Sleep Hypoxemia. Validation
Study in COPD and OSA Before and After Treatment with Nasal CPAP.
Am Rev Resp Dis 1993;148 (1):173-178.
Elsayed NM, Nakashima JM, Postlethwait EM. Measurement of Uric Acid
as a Marker of Oxygen Tension in the Lung. Arch Biochem Biophys
1993;302 (1):228-232.
Lopez I, et al.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
Leyva F, Anker S, Swan JW, et al. Serum Uric Acid as an Index of Impaired
Oxidative Metabolism in Chronic Heart Failure. Eur Heart J 1997;18(5):858865.
Nagaya N, Uematsu M, Satoha T, et al. Serum Uric Acid Levels Correlate
with the Severity and the Mortality of Primary Pulmonary Hypertension.
Am Res Crit Care Med 1999;160:487-492.
Oyaa H, Nagayaa N, Satoha T, et al. Hemodynamic Correlates and
Prognostic Significance of Serum Uric Acid in Adult Patients with
Eisenmenger Syndrome. Heart 2000;84:53-58.
Emmerson BT, Ravenscroft PJ. Abnormal renal urate homeostasis in
systemic disorders. Nephron 1975;14:62-80.
Anker SD, Leyva F, Poole-Wilson PA, Kox WJ, Stevenson JC, and Coats
AJS. Relation between serum uric acid and lower limb blood flow in patients
with chronic heart failure. Heart 1997;78:39-43.
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
13. Huizer T, de Jong JW, Nelson JA, Czarnecki W, Serruys PW, Bonnier
JRRM, and Troquay R. Urate production by human heart. J Mol Cell Cardiol
1989;21:691-695.
14. McCord JM. Oxygen-derived free radicals in post ischemic tissue injury.
NEJM 1985;312:159-163.
15. Hassoun P, Shedd A, Lanzillo J, Thappa V, Landman M, Fanburg B.
Inhibition of pulmonary artery smooth muscle cell growth by hypoxanthine,
xanthine and uric acid. Am J Res Cell Mol Biol 1992;6:617-24.
16. Messerli F, Frohlich E, Dreslinski G, Suarez D, and Aristimuno G. Serum
uric acid in essential hypertension: an indicator of renal vascular involvement.
Ann Intern Med 1980;93:817-821.
17. Darlington, L.G. Study to compare the relative hyperuricemic effects of
frusemide and bumetanide. Adv Exp Med Biol 1986;195:333-339.
55
Case Report
A Case of Total Anomalous Systemic Venous
Connection to the Left Atrium
Julia Berba-Maape MD, Ludgerio D. Torres MD, Eduardo Manrique MD, John Reganion MD, Juliet Balderas
MD, Aurora Gamponia MD, Ma. Lourdes SR. Casas MD, Orlando Ignacio MD, Wilberto Lopez MD.
T
his is a case of a 15-year old, female, from
Novaliches, Quezon City, who came in because
of cyanosis upon crying at two months old (Figure 1).
Consulted with a private physician who referred the patient to
Philippine Heart Center, however, the parents did not comply
not until 4 months of age when the nailbeds were cyanotic.
Patient was then worked-up and cardiac catheterization was
done at seven months old and was found out to have anomalous
systemic venous return to the left atrium (Figure 2). She was
scheduled for operation of the anomalous systemic venous
return but a day before the OR schedule, the patient acquired
varicella infection and was sent home. She was then lost to
follow-up. From then on, there was no note of frequent
respiratory tract infection, nor any hospitalization (Figure 3).
There were no episodes of “blue spells” but had exercise
intolerance as the patient grew older. Until at 11 years old,
she complained of easy fatigability with hypercyanosis, muscle
cramps and shortness of breath when doing strenuous activities
which were becoming more frequent thus sought consult at
Philippine Heart Center at 14 years old and subsequently
admitted (Figure 4).
Figure 1. Pt at 4 mos.
Figure 2. Cath Result at 7 mos.
Correspondence: Julia Berba-Maape, MD. Department of Pediatric Cardiology.
Philippine Heart Center East Avenue, Quezon City, Philippines 1100
ISSN 0018-9034
Figure 3
Figure 4
On physical examination, patient was conscious,
coherent, ambulatory, and not in respiratory distress with a
weight of 39kg (p25), Height: 152 cm (p75). She had suffused
palpebral conjunctivae, with cyanotic lips, clear breath sounds.
Cardiovascular findings showed a dynamic precordium, apex
beat at 5th intercostals space left midclavicular line, (-) thrill,
(-) heave, S1 normal, S2 single with normal P2, (-) murmur.
Nailbeds were clubbed and cyanotic.
Repeat work up was done on admission. The chest x-ray
was normal (Figure 5). The ECG was otherwise normal except for the leftward P axis (-) 75 (Figure 6). Echocardiogram
showed a suspicious drainage of systemic veins to the left
atrium (Figures 7,8). The initial cardiac cath which was done
on the 3rd hospital day, showed a persistent left superior vena
cava (SVC) and a suspicious membrane at the right atrium
(RA) was noted probably a cortriatriatum dexter was entertained versus an anomalous drainage of systemic veins to the
left atrium (Figure 9). Transesophageal echocardiography
was done to investigate the RA and it showed that the RA was
small, their was no membrane thus cor tritriatum dexter was
ruled out (Figure 10). Contrast echo were then done to delineate well the drainage of the systemic veins. Using an agitated saline solution 15-20 ml was injected into the vein of the
right hand showing the microbubbles which were first seen at
the left atrium then shunted into the right atrium thru the atrial
septal defect (ASD) (Figure 11). Another injection done at
the vein of the left hand and the solution drains into the left
atrium but the entrance of the drainage is different from that
of the right right hand, hence a possible persistent left SVC
was considered. Lastly, injection of saline solution at the right
foot which also showed the drainage of microbubbles into the
Copyright 2002 Philippine Heart Center Journal
left atrium first then to the RA. These strengthened the
impression of Anomalous drainage of systemic veins to the
left atrium (LA).
Figure 5. CXR
Figure 7. 2Decho- Subcostal View
Figure 9. Initial Cath Result
Figure 6. ECG
Figure 8. 2D echo- Apical
View
On the 9th hospital day, repeat cardiac catheterization and
digital subtraction angiography (DSA) were done to further
define the precise location or drainage of the systemic veins.
This was done with simultaneous transeophageal
echocardiography. During cardiac catheterization, the
intravenous catheter was manipulated from the right femoral
vein into the inferior vena cava which then enters into the left
atrium instead of right atrium. This was confirmed by
simultaneous transesophageal echo in which the tip of the
intravenous catheter was found at the LA instead of RA (Figure
12). The intravenous catheter was further manipulated and
entered into a persistent left SVC. Injection of dye into the
brachial vein of the left arm was done which opacified a
persistent left SVC draining into the coronary sinus then into
the LA which further opacifies the ascending aorta (Figures
13,14). A guide wire was manipulated at the right brachial
vein thru the IV site and with the simultaneous transesophageal
echocardiography, it showed that the tip of the catheter was
found out in the LA instead of the RA. This catheter was
manipulated further below into the hepatic vein which had a
separate entry as that of the inferior vena cava. Injection of
dye was also done at the right arm showed a right SVC which
opacifies the LA and further opacifies the aorta (Figures 15,16).
No innominate vein noted. The IVC catheter was manipulated
and entered into a sinus venosus ASD. Injection of dye at this
area opacifies the small RA then into the small RV then into
the main pulmonary artery and its branches which were of
good sizes (Figure 17). Therefore, repeat cardiac cath with
DSA and simultaneous Transesophageal Echocardiography
confirm the diagnosis of Total Anomalous Systemic Venous
Return (IVC, Right and Left SVC, hepatic vein) into the left
atrium as shown in schematic diagram on Figure 18.
Figure 10. TEE
Figure 12. Simultaneous Transesophageal ECHO and Cath
Figure 11. TEE with contrast study
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
57
Fig. 13. Angio. Left SVC drains
Fig. 14. L SVC to LA
then to LA opacifies
aorta
Fig.15 Wire guide at the
She underwent Bilateral Bidirectional Glenn Shunt
(Fig.19) with the interatrial septum enlarged and converted
into a common atrium, and then atrial baffle using a pericardial
patch was used to divert IVC and hepatic veins to the right
atrium (Fig.21).
Post-operatively, there was marked improvement of O2
saturation from pre-op of 80% to 98% post-op. She was
extubated after 24 hours and transferred to PICU. On the 5th
post-op day repeat CXR showed haziness at the right lower
lung field probably due to pleural effusion. Post-op 2D echo
showed minimal to moderate pericardial effusion. An ESR
was taken showed an elevated ESR. Post pericardiotomy
syndrome was entertained; hence, the patient was started on
aspirin. On the 8th post-op day, there was progression of pleural
effusion such that CTT was inserted. Serosanguinous fluid
was drained. Augmentin was started. On the 16th post-op day,
there was complete resolution of the pleural and pericardial
effusion. She was then discharged on the 20th post-op day
improved.
Fig.16 R SVC drains to RSVC
LA
Fig.17. Dye injected at
Venosus
Fig. 18 Schematic DiagramASD cath result
On the 15th hospital day, the patient underwent surgery
with the following intra-op findings (Figure 20).
- bilateral SVC of good size, no innominate vein
in between
- Right SVC drains to the left atrium with sinus
venosus ASD adjacent to it
- left SVC drains into the coronary sinus and then
into the LA
- IVC drains to the LA with separate hepatic vein
which also drains into the LA
- small patent foramen ovale
- small RA and right ventricle
- good size main pulmonary artery, as well as
right and left pulmonary artery
- all 4 pulmonary veins drain to LA
58
Fig 19. Bilateral Bidirectional Glenn Shunt (Modified from McElhinney D.
Bidirectional Cavopulmonary Shunt in Patients with Anomalies of Systemic
and Pulmonary Venous Drainage. Ann Thorac Surg 1997;63:1676-84) 1
Fig. 20. Schematic Diagram
(Intra-op Findings)
Fig. 21. Schematic Diagram
(Post-op Findings)
Presently patient is doing well who had regular followup at the PHC-OPD department. She is now a fourth year
high school student with good scholastic performance (Fig.
22).
JBerba-Maape et al
Fig. 22. Patient post-operatively
Discussion
Presenting a case of a 15 y/o female who had cyanosis
and clubbing. There was no history of hypoxic spells or
squatting. No signs of congestive heart failure. Only exercise
intolerance noted during strenuous activities. Physical
examination revealed a well-developed child, weight 39kg (25
percentile) and height 152 cm (75 percentile). Cardiovascular
findings revealed a dynamic precordium with normal S1 with
single S2 and no murmur appreciated. Peripheral O2 saturation
was 80%. Hemoglobin was 17.9g/L and hematocrit was 56%.
Chest roentgenogram showed normal findings and
electrocardiogram was otherwise normal except for the
leftward P axis (-75).
Differential Diagnosis
Given these data now we should rule out pulmonary causes
of cyanosis like pulmonary vascular obstructive disease in
which they may also present as dyspnea or fatigue on exertion
with cyanotic and clubbed nailbeds. This may also present as
normal heart size on CXR unless CHF supervenes. However,
PVOD patient will present a characteristic loud P2 with
ejection click, a PR or TR murmur with signs of right-sided
heart failure with RAD RAE and RVH on ECG which is not
found in our patient thus PVOD is ruled out. For the cardiac
causes of cyanosis we will be focusing on cyanotic type of
CHD with normal or decrease pulmonary blood flow. Like
TOF or DORV with PS were also be one of the considerations
with history of cyanosis and normal heart size but it is ruled
out since their was no history of spells nor squatting and on
PE their was no SEM at the LUSB which is characteristic
findings of TOF due to the PS murmur and it showed RVH in
CXR and ECG which is not found in this patient thus this is
ruled out. Other cyanotic CHDs would be TVA or PVA with
IVS but this is ruled out since these would present as enlarge
heart due to RAE and LVH which contradicts to the findings
of the patent. TGA with PS could be one of the, considerations
with the history of cyanosis and single S2 on PE but this is
Phil Heart Center J Vol.9, issue 1, January-December 2002
ruled out since this would present as biventricular hypertrophy
on ECG and CXR and the 2D echo did not present as such. So
another close differential diagnosis will be those cyanotic heart
disease with normal heart size which would include pulmonary
arterio-venous fistula, cortriatriatum dexter and anomalous
drainage of systemic veins to left atrium.
In pulmonary arterio-venous fistula, the desaturated
systemic blood from the pulmonary arteries reaches the
pulmonary veins, bypassing the lung tissue and resulting in
systemic arterial desaturation and cyanosis. The PBF and
pressure remain unchanged, and there is no volume overload
to the heart thus the chest x-ray films and ECG would show a
normal heart size which are found in our patient. However, a
faint systolic or continuous murmur may be audible in 50%
of patients with pulmonary arterio-venous fistula which was
absent in our patient. It is only by angiography which is the
definitive method for locating pulmonary AV fistula in which
we can rule this out. The angiography of our patient did not
show any pulmonary AV fistula, thus this was ruled out.
Another consideration is cortiratriatum dexter, a rare
congenital anomaly associated with complex right heart
abnormalities, characterized by a membrane that divides the
right atrium into two chambers. This would present as
exertional fatigue, cyanosis, clubbed and cyanotic nailbeds
which were present in our patient, however the S2 is usually
split and a systolic murmur is usually heard at LUSB which is
not a finding in our patient. This can be ruled out only by
transesophageal echocardiography. This is ruled out in our
patient because the TEE showed otherwise- TOTAL
ANOMALOUS SYSTEMIC VENOUS RETURN TO
LEFT ATRIUM.
Before discussing the anomalous systemic venous return
per se and their clinical significance. The embryology of the
systemic venous system will be briefly reviewed
59
Fig. 23. Differential Diagnosis:
CYANOSIS
Cardiac causes
Pulmonarycauses
- PVOD
Cyanotic CHD w/ Normal or Decrease PBF
RVH
LVH
- TOF
- DORV w/ PS
- Ebstein
-Eisenmenger
- TVA
- PVA w/ IVS
CVH
-TGA w/ PS
- TA
- SV w/ PS
Normal Ventricles
- Pulm. arterio-venous
fistula
- Cortriatriatum dexter
- Total Anomalous
Systemic Venous
Return
EMBRYOLOGY
Normal venous development is a process of progressive
appearance of a series of paired venous structures, development
of anastomotic channels between them and the eventual
selective regression of certain segments.
innominate vein (Fig.25). The development of innominate vein
is usually followed by the involution of the left SVC which
becomes the ligament of marshall.
Development of Systemic Venous System
The atria are located dorsally and the ventricular chambers
are ventrally located. The sinus venosus lie dorsal to the atria.
The sinus venosus has right and left sinus horns and empties
into atrial segment of the tube. Three major venous channels
drains into the sinus venosus at this stage: the
omphalomesenteric (vitelline) veins, the umbilical veins, and
the common cardinal veins. Each common cardinal vein is
formed by the union of the anterior and posterior cardinal veins
which drain the cephalic and caudal regions of the embryo
respectively.
At the beginning of the 4th week 2of embryonic life (Fig.
24), the left sinus horn and the transverse portion of the sinus
venosus will make a rightward shift and become separated
from the left side of the atrium. There is now preferential
flow to the right sided structures. There then follows gradual
regression of the left umbilical and vitelline veins and the right
umbilical vein. The right and left anterior cardinal vein
connects an anastomosing vein called the brachiocephalic or
60
Fig. 24. (From Abdulla Ra-id. Embryology, Pediatric Cardiology. Rush
Children’s Heart Center Home Page
JBerba-Maape et al
In the case of our patient, these are the following anomalies
seen: (Figure 27)
1. Bilateral SVC of good size, no innominate vein in
between
2. Persistent left SVC drains to coronary sinus which
then drains to the LA
3. Right SVC drains to LA
4. IVC drains to LA
5. Hepatic vein drains to LA
Fig. 25. (Modified From Abdulla Ra-id. Embryology, Pediatric Cardiology.
Rush Children’s Heart Center Home Page)
At 8th week (Figure 26), The distal end of the left cardinal
vein degenerates and the more proximal portion of it will
now connect through the anastomosing vein (left
brachiocephalic vein) to the right anterior cardinal vein, thus
forming the superior vena cava. The left posterior cardinal
vein also degenerates, and the left sinus horn receiving venous
drain from the heart become the coronary sinus. The right
vitelline vein becomes the IVC (Inferior Vena Cava) and the
right posterior cardinal vein becomes the azygos vein. All
these is completed in the 8th week gestation.
L ant. →
Cardinal V
(distal end)
L post.Cardinal V →
Figure 26. (Modified From Abdulla Ra-id. Embryology, Pediatric
Cardiology. Rush Children’s Heart Center Home Page)
Phil Heart Center J Vol.9, issue 1, January-December 2002
Figure 27. Schematic Diagram of Patients Systemic Venous Drainage
Anomaly. . (Modified From Abdulla Ra-id. Embryology, Pediatric
Cardiology. Rush Children’s Heart Center Home Page)
Possible embryologic explanations of these anomalies are the
following:
1. There is persistence of the left horn of the sinus
venosus and the left common and anterior cardinal veins with
incorporation of the sinus venosus into the left atrium. (By
Miller, from Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 1965)3
2. This anomaly is also thought to result from
malposition of the right horn of the sinus venosus in a leftward
and cephalic direction, so that the dominant superior and
inferior caval veins connect to the left rather than to the right
atrium (Kirsch et al, 1961).4
3. There is persistence of the valves of the sinus venosus.
In the normal heart, the remnants of the sinus venosus valves
are the Eustachian and Thebesian valves and the crista
terminalis. Pathologic overgrowth of the valves may cause
complete subdivision of the right atrium; consequently, the
inferior and superior vena cava and coronary sinus are
excluded from the RA with channeling of the systemic venous
return into the LA (By Gueron, Journal of Thoracic Cardiovasc
Surg, 1969).5
61
Anomalous Systemic Venous Connection (ASVC)
Represents a wide range of malformations, whose
physiological consequences may vary from nil to the most
severe form of systemic arterial desaturation. They may occur
in isolation or with other congenital cardiac anomalies, in situs
solitus, or with cardiac malpositions with or without atrial
isomerism.
Of considerable interest are the very rare instances just
like in our case in which both the vena cava empty into the
LA together with the coronary sinus and the pulmonary veins.
An organized classification of venous anomalies can be
most easily achieved by using anatomic rather than
embryologic subdivisions.
Classification of Systemic Venous Anomalies:
(From Anderson RA et al. Anomalous Systemic Venous
Return. Pediatric Cardiology) 6
I. Anomalies of the SVC
a. Left SVC to RA
- Bilateral Superior caval veins (slide)
- absent right SVC (slide)
- Left SVC with localized coronary sinus defect
b. Left SVC to LA
c. Right SVC to LA
d. Superior caval veins accepting pulmonary veins
e. Aneurysm of SVC
II. Anomalies of the IVC
a. IVC to LA
b. Absence of infrahepatic segment of the IVC with azygos
continuation
c. IVC accepting pulmonary veins
III. Anomalies of the Coronary sinus
IV. Total Anomalous Systemic Venous Return
V. Anomalies of the valves of the sinus venosus
Epidemiology
A review of literature revealed only 9 patients in the world
literature with complete anomalous systemic venous drainage
into the LA. Presence of an atrial septal defect is obligatory
th
for survival. Pearl and Spicer reported the 9 case in 1980
(Southern Medical Journal 73: 259-261). De Leval et al7in
1975 who reviewed 100 patients with anomalous systemic
venous connection who underwent operation reported only 3
patients with total anomalous venous connection to LA (Mayo
Clinic Proceedings, 1975). They found out that associated
cardiac anomalies were present in all patients except one. ASD
is the most common associated cardiac anomaly. It has an
equal sex distribution.
62
It is also worthwhile mentioning that persistence of a left
SVC draining to the coronary sinus is the most common
systemic venous anomaly. This lesion has been noted in 0.30.5% of the general population (Geissler and Albert, 1956;
Burski et al, 1986) and is said to occur in 2-4.3% of patients
with congenital heart disease. (Campbell et al8 1954; Fraos et
al, 1961; Cha and Khoury9 1972). Electrocardiograms of
patients with persistent left SVC show a leftward P axis in
35% (Momma & Linde101969) to 70% (Hancock111964) of
patients. This abnormal P wave axis has been referred to as
“coronary sinus rhythm” and may be a result of persistence of
left-sided embryonic pacemaker tissue.
Pathophysiology:
Communication between the superior vena cava (Right
and Left SVC) as well as the IVC and hepatic vein into the
left atrium results in right to left shunts and a decrease in
systemic arterial oxygen saturation, therefore cyanosis is
obligatory.
In the normal circulation, the entire systemic venous return
passes through the vena cava and enters the right side of the
heart, while blood flow into the left side of the heart is derived
entirely from pulmonary veins. If one of the cava enters the
left atrium, the right side of the heart is effectively bypassed
so that right ventricular output and pulmonary blood flow
should fall. The ventricular output theoretically remains
unchanged because the increment in anomalous caval flow
into the left atrium is matched by a reciprocal decrement in
pulmonary venous flow into the left atrium. In other words,
as systemic venous return to the LA increases, pulmonary
venous return decreases by the same amount so that total flow
to the left side of the heart remains unchanged. In the absence
of compensatory mechanisms, anomalous caval drainage into
the LA should be associated with reduced pulmonary flow
and normal systemic flow. These would explain why the ECG
is normal with no cardiac enlargement as well as the CXR
result in our patient.
Clinical Manifestations:
Physical appearance is normal except for symmetric
cyanosis and digital clubbing. Growth and development are
normal. All these characteristic findings are found in our
patient.
Murmurs are absent or unimpressive. Theoretically, a soft
midsystolic murmur might result from increased flow into the
aorta, but left ventricular volume is seldom large enough to
achieve such murmurs. In our patient we didn’t appreciate
any murmur. The second heart sound has been described as
single just like our patient. To explain this observation, this is
due to the reduced right ventricular stroke volume and decrease
pulmonary capacitance result in early pulmonary valve closure
and synchrony or near synchrony with aortic closure, thus
producing a single S2. The intensity of the pulmonary
component of the second heart sound is normal or diminished,
JBerba-Maape et al
because pulmonary arterial pressure is normal or low. intensity
of the pulmonary component of the second heart sound is
normal or diminished, because pulmonary arterial pressure is
normal or low.
Electrocardiogram
The ECG is often entirely normal. P waves are usually
normal, but when a persistent left SVC connects to the coronary
sinus just like our patient (P axis-75), there is often a leftward
deviation of the P wave axis (+15 or less) with an incidence of
70-80% as opposed to 5-10% in normals (Hancock EW, 1964).
Momma and Linde, reported an incidence of 35%, and Furuse
et al12found out 37% of patients with persistent left SVC with
superior leftward P wave and 67% in patients with absent IVC.
Hence, in the presence of a superiorly leftward orientation of
P wave vector, systemic venous anomalies must be carefully
looked for. Thus, this would explain the leftward P axis of our
patient.
Right ventricular hypertrophy is uniformly absent because
flow into the right side of the heart is normal or reduced and
pulmonary arterial pressure is normal or low. The increment
in left ventricular flow is seldom sufficient to cause left
ventricular hypertrophy.
CXR
In view of the relatively modest hemodynamic
derangements, it is not surprising that the size and
configuration of the heart are usually normal. Because
pulmonary arterial flow tends to be reduced or usually normal,
the vascularity of the lungs maybe reduced or normal.
A left superior vena cava may form a recognizable shadow
before entering the left atrium or coronary sinus. This shadow
is concave or crescentic as it emerges from beneath the middle
third of the clavicle and passes downward toward the left upper
border of the aortic arch.
Echocardiogram and Contrast Echocardiography
A non-invasive approach to the patient with CHD, which
provides detailed information concerning systemic vnous
return would be useful. Alerted to the presence of one
abnormal systemic venous segment, the echocardiographer
will pay particular attention to the cardiac connections of all
the systemic and pulmonary veins. The first stage in any
systematic approach in the diagnosis of systemic venous
abnormalities must be diagnosis of the atrial arrangement
(situs) which may be accurately predicted based on the position
and connections of the inferior caval and hepatic veins.
Particular attention to the suprasternal examination should also
be emphasized to identify abnormalities in superior caval
segments and their connections.
Contrast echocardiography is a very useful technique to
diagnose anomalous systemic venous connection to the left
atrium. Just like what we did in our patient. When a left superior
vena cava drains directly into the left atrium, injection of a
Phil Heart Center J Vol.9, issue 1, January-December 2002
bolus of agitated saline into the left antecubital vein is followed
by immediate opacification of the left atrium. Conversely
when a right SVC drains directly into the left atrium, injection
of agitated saline into the right antecubital vein promptly
opacifies the left atrium. When the inferior vena cava connects
to the left atrium, injection of contrast material into the femoral
vein, the left atrium opacifies first. Thus, with the use of these
contrast echocardiographic studies, we were able to arrive at
the diagnosis of anomalous systemic venous connection to
the left atrium. It could not be determined, however, whether
an isolated right SVC or persistent left SVC alone was present
or whether both were present.
Cardiac Catheterization and Angiography
Cardiac catheterization and angiography remains to be
the most useful procedures to confirm the diagnosis. It provides
precise definition of systemic venous connection which is
important in congenital heart disease to enable proper surgical
correction. Complete knowledge of the systemic venous
connections before commencing to open heart surgery
certainly enables the surgeon to plan venous cannulation and
the surgical approach in a better fashion. The table below
showed the summary of reported cases of TASVC to LA from
different authors, the common presentation was cyanosis and
clubbing, the cardiovascular findings were essentially normal
as reported by Rojas and Pierre Vart, while single S2 was noted
in a report of Gueron just like our patient, while Miller and
Roberts reported a holosystolic murmur. The CXR in almost
all authors showed normal or slightly enlarged heart with
normal PVM. The ECG were usually normal, however
leftward P axis were reported by Gueron, Roberts & Pierre
Vart which is also found in our patient.
Surgical Options
Surgical correction of Total anomalous systemic venous
connection to LA is succesfully achieved byapplying similar
principles to those that are used for TAPVR. A baffle
repartitioning using a pericardial patch in such a way that the
pulmonary veins drained into the left atrium and the systemic
veins and coronary sinus drained into the right atrium. The
operation can be performed safely under profound
hypothermia and circulatory arrest.
Other surgical option is bidirectional glenn shunt of right
or left SVC or both. This had the same principle of patients
who will undergo univentricular repair like Fontan. Since our
patient had hypoplastic and underdeveloped RA and RV thus
it can’t accommodate all the systemic venous return. Thus
BGS done, followed by intra-atrial baffle using pericardium
to redirect IVC drainage, hepatic vein and CS to the RA.
63
64
JBerba-Maape et al
Age
5
15
5
20
3
15
Author/
Date/ Place
Miller et al1
1965
London,
England
Gueron3
1969
Israel
Roberts12
1972
England
Rojas13
1965
Connecticut
Pierre
Viart14
1977
Belgium
BerbaMaape
2002
PHC,
Philippines
F
M
F
F
M
F
Sex
Cyanosis
clubbing
Cyanosis,
clubbing
Cyanosis,
Clubbing
,
Mentally
retarded
Cyanosis,
clubbing,
Dyspnea
on
exertion
Cyanosis,
clubbing,
mild
dyspnea
on
exertion
Cyanosis,
clubbing
Presenta
-tion
S2
single,
No
murmur
Normal
Normal
Gr 3/6
HSM
right
LSB
S2 single,
no
murmur
Gr 3/6
SM left
LSB
Cardiovascular
normal
Slightly
enlarged
heart,
Normal
PVM
Normal
Slightly
enlarged
heart
Mod
cardiome
galy
normal
PVM
Fullness
L upper
part of
mediastin
um
X-ray
P axis (-) 75
P wave
inverted in
II,III,aVF
Atrial rhythm
Normal
except for
sinus tachy
P axis (-)125
LVH
by
voltage
P
wave
inverted in II
III aVF RCL
P axis (-) 45
Normal
ECG
L SVC to CS
then drains to
LA; R SVC,
IVC, hepatic
vein drains to
LA, ASD
L SVC, IVC
drains to LA,
absent R SVC,
ASD
R innominate
vein joined w/ L
innominate vein
to L SVC which
drains to LA,
ASD, atresia of
R SVC
L SVC, R SVC,
IVC,
azygos,
CS drains to LA
ASD,
Dextroversion
ASD,
obstruction at
TV suspected
ASD, persistent
L SVC, absent
R SVC
Angiography
Table. Reported Cases of Total Anomalous Systemic Venous Connection to the Left Atrium
L SVC to CS then
drains to LA; R
SVC, IVC, hepatic
vein drains to LA,
ASD
L SVC, IVC & CS
drains to LA, Absent
R SVC, large ASD
Small R SVC to CS,
Huge L SVC drains to
LA, no IVC but 2
hepatic veins entered
to LA, huge azygos
vein joined L SVC,
ASD
Dextroversion
Both vena cava drains
to LA, ASD
secundum,
RA small
L SVC to CS then to
LA, IVC Pulm. veins
drains to LA, absent R
SVC, ASD
Intra-op findings
Septal defect
enlarged, intraatrial baffle with
pericardium to
redirect IVC,
hepatic V and
CS;
Bilateral BGS
Septal defect
enlarged
pericardial baffle
redirect veins to
RA,
Septal defect
enlarged
pericardial baffle
redirect veins to
RA, coronary
sinus cut back
Septal defect
enlarged intraatrial baffle
redirect veins to
RA
Septal defect
enlarged, intraatrial baffle to
redirect veins to
RA
Surgery
Successful
Successful
Successful
Successful
Successful
Results
A study done by Florentino Vargas et al13 who reviewed
170 patients who underwent modified Fontan- Kreutzer
procedure who had complex CHD ( SV, D-TGA, L-TGA,
DORV) with co-existent anomalous systemic venous return.
The study revealed 17 patients with anomalous systemic and
pulmonary venous connection. Of the 17 patients, 7 of them
had bilateral SVC in which the left SVC drains to LA. Four
patients underwent patch diversion of which 2 of them expired
due to systemic venous return (SVR) obstruction. There were
3 patients who underwent modified Glenn shunt all of them
were doing well.
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Summary
A very rare case of Total Anomalous Systemic Venous
Drainage to the Left Atrium was presented. The malformation
is a form of a cyanotic congenital heart disease in which the
only clinical significant features of the anomaly are cyanosis
and clubbing with otherwise normal cardiac findings. The
ECG is usually normal except for some cases of leftward
deviation of the P wave axis. The CXR reveals a normal
cardiac silhouette, normal or diminished pulmonary vascular
markings. Contrast echocardiography establishes specific
patterns of systemic vein connection to the left atrium which
was seen in this patient and was confirm by angiography. The
patient was then successfully operated upon and the anomaly
was corrected.
Phil Heart Center J Vol.9, issue 1, January-December 2002
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
McElhinney D. bidirectional Cavopulmonary Shunt in Patients with Anomalies of Systemic and Pulmonary Venous Drainage. Ann Thorac Surg
1997;63:676-84.
Abdulla Ra-id. Embryology. Pediatric Cardiology. Rush Children’s Heart
Center Home Page. http://www.rchc.edu/rmwebfiles/embryology.htm
Miller GA et al. Surgical Correction of Total anomalous Systemic Venous
Connection. Report of Case. Mayo Clinic Pro 1965;40:532-538.
Kirsch WM et al. A case of Anomalous Drainage of the Superios Vena Cava
into the Left Atrium. J Thorc Cardiovasc Surg 1961;41:550-556.
Gueron M et al. Total Anomalous Systemic Venous Drainage into the Left
Atrium. Report of a Case of Successful Surgical Correction. 1969;58:570574.
Anderson RA et al. Anomalous Systemic Venous Return. Pedia Cardiol:
497-508.
De Leval MR et al. Anomalous Systemic Venous Connection. Surgical Consideration. Mayo Clinic Proceedings 1975;50:599-609.
Campbell M, Deuchar DC. The Left-Sided SVC. Bri Heart J 1954;16:423439.
Cha ME, Khoury GH. Persistent Left Superior Vena Cava. Radiology
1972;103:375-381.
Momma K, Linde LM. Abnormal Rhythm Associated with Persistent Left
Superior Vena Cava. Pediatric Res 1969;3:210-216.
Hancock EW. Coronary Sinus Venous Defect and Persistent Left Superior
Vena Cava. Am J Cardio 1964;14:608-615.
Furuse et al. Coronary Sinus Rhythm in Anomalous Systemic Venous Connection. Japan Heart J 1968;9:200-2007.
Vargas FJ et al. Anomalous Systemic and Pulmonary Venous Connection in
Conjunction with Atriopulmonary Anastomosis (Fontan-Kreutzer). J Thorac
Cardiovasc Surg 1986;93:523-532.
Roberts KD et al. Surgical Correction of Total Anomalous Systemic Venous
Drainage. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1972;64:803-810.
Rojas RH and Hipona FA. Anomalous sytemic Venous Return. J Thorac
Cardiovasc Surg 1965;50:590-595.
Pier Viart et al. Total Anomalous Systemic Venous Drainage. Am J Dis Child
1977;131:195-198.
65
Information for Subscribers
The Philippine Heart Center Journal is published annually for physicians and clinical investigators. Readers within the Philippines may subscribe at the annual rate of Php400.00. Readers from abroad may subscribe at
$20 for institutions and $15 for individuals. For further information on charges, please see the Business Information page.
RENEW: I wish to renew my annual subscription. (Affix mailing
label and enclose check for P400.00 domestic; $20 for institution
and $15 for individual foreign).
_______Payment
ADD: Please add my name to your mailing list. Enclosed, find
my check for (Php400 domestic; $20 for institution and $15 for
individual foreign).
DELETE: Please delete my name. (Affix mailing label or write
name and address as they appear on label).
CHANGE ADDRESS: Please change my mailing address (affix
CURRENT ADDRESS:
Name:___________________________________________________________________________
House/Bldg. No., Floor No., Bldg./Apt. Name___________________________________________
Unit/Apt. No., Block No., Street Name ________________________________________________
Village/Subdivision________________________________________________________________
Barangay/Barrio___________________________________________________________________
City / Municipality / Province ________________________________________________________
Country_____________________________________Zip Code_____________________________
Clip and send:
PHILIPPINE HEART CENTER JOURNAL
8/F Medical Arts building
Philippine Heart Center
East Avenue, Quezon City
66
Are you a physician? _____ YES
_____ NO
What is your professional specialty:
____________________________
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
INFORMATION
FOR
AUTHORS
EDITORIAL POLICY
Scope of the Journal
The Philippine Heart Center Journal is devoted to the publication of original articles related to cardiovascular diseases
and allied fields. It will also consider for publication studies
done in the Philippines that have been published in other local
journals, with the permission of the publisher and principal
author. The scope of articles includes original publications,
editorials, current reviews and case reports.
General Policies
Contributions are reviewed by a group of cardiologists,
cardiovascular surgeons and physicians of allied specialties with
recognized academic and clinical expertise. Each manuscript
is evaluated by at least two reviewers and may be edited for
scientific accuracy and clarity.
Statements and opinions expressed in articles and communications are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily
reflect those of the editor or publisher. Neither the publisher
nor the editor guarantee any product or service advertised in
the publication.
No part of the articles and communications published in
the journal may be reproduced without the written permission
of the publisher.
Copyright Release and Authorship Responsibilities
All manuscripts must be accompanied by the following
statements signed by all authors.
1. The undersigned author(s) transfer(s), assign(s) or otherwise convey(s) all copyright ownership of the manuscript [title
of article] to the Philippine Heart Center Journal in the event
the work is published. The undersigned author(s) attest(s) that
the article is original in form and substance and is not under
consideration by another journal.
2. The undersigned author(s) certifies (certify) that I (we) have
participated to a sufficient degree in the design of this work,
analysis of data, and the writing of the manuscript, and that I
(we) am (are) taking responsibility for its contents.
Conflict of Interest Disclosure Statement
All authors are requested to disclose any relationship with
an individual or organization with direct financial interest in
the subject matter or materials discussed in the manuscript,
because a perceived or real conflict of interest may otherwise
arise. Disclosure of such relationship will be held in confidence during the review process of the work ifaccepted for
publication. Disclosure of financial interest will appear as an
annotation to the published manuscript.
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002
MANUSCRIPT PREPARATION AND SUBMISSION
Manuscripts and all communications to the Editor should
be addressed to:
JOSE A. YULDE, MD
Editor-in-Chief
Philippine Heart Center Journal
2nd Floor, Medical Arts Building
Philippine Heart Center
East Avenue, Quezon City
Philippines
Submitting the manuscript in the correct format will expedite the reviewing process and obviate undue delay in publication. Please adhere to the following requirements:
General Guidelines
One original and two duplicate manuscripts and three full
sets of tables and labelled illustrations should be submitted to
the above address.
The Editorial Office will be responsible for the proper
handling of manuscripts so that confidentiality is preserved.
Manuscripts and figures will be returned only upon the written
request of the authors. Please provide a self-addressed stamped
envelope for this purpose.
Manuscripts should be typed double-spaced throughout
(including title page, abstract, text, references, tables and legends) one side only on 22 x 28 cm (8 1/2 x 11 inches) opaque
bond paper with 3 cm (1 1/4 inch) margins all around.
The manuscript should be arranged as follows:
1. Title page
2. Abstract page
3. Text
4. Acknowledgement (if any)
5. References
6. Figures and legends
7. Tables
Number the pages consecutively on the upper right corner
beginning with the title page.
Title Page
The title page must contain:
1. Title of the article
2. Names of authors plus highest academic degree of
each
3. Each author's official academic and/or clinical title
and institutional affiliation
4. Name and address of the institution/s where the
research work was conducted
5. Name, address and telephone/fax number of the
author to whom correspondence should be sent
67
Abstract
All original articles must contain an abstract of not more than
250 words. The abstract should include statements on the background, objectives, method of study, results and conclusion.
Abstracts for case reports should be shorter (75-80 words).
Include several (3-7) keywords to assist in cross-indexing the
article.
Text
Generally, the text should be organized as follows:
a. Introduction
b. Materials and Methods
c. Results
d. Discussion or comments
e. Conclusion
The Introduction should describe the purpose of the study
and its relation to previous work in the field. It should not
include an extensive literature review. The description of the
methods should be concise, but sufficiently detailed to permit
repetition by other investigators. Results should present positive and relevant negative findings of the study, supported when
necessary by reference to tables and figures. The Discussion
should interpret the results of the study, with emphasis on their
relation to the original hypothesis and to previous studies.
Abbreviations or acronyms such as CAD, AMI, LVH may
be used after the terms are spelled out once each in the abstract
and text followed by the abbreviation or acronym in parentheses. All measurements should use the International System
(SI) of units. Alternative units may be indicated in parentheses if necessary.
Manuscripts that describe studies on humans must indicate that the study was approved by an institutional review
committee and that subjects gave their written, informed consent. Studies on both humans and animals must indicate that
the procedures followed were in accordance with the institutional guidelines.
References
References are to be cited consecutively in the text with
numbers enclosed in parentheses. At the end of each article,
references should be listed consecutively in the numerical order in which they were cited in the text. The form of references should be as follows:
a. For Journal References:Surname and initial of author(s),
title of article, name of journal, volume number, first page or
inclusive pages. If there are more than three authors, list the
first three authors and add et al.
68
Braunwald E and Rutherford JD. Reversible ischemic left ventricular dysfunction: evidence for the "hibernating myocardium." J Am Coll Cardiol 1986;8:1467-1470.
Dilsizian V, Rocco TP, Freedman NM et al. Enchanted detection of ischemic but viable myocardium by the reinjection of
thallium after stress -redistribution imaging. N Engl J Med
1990;323:141-146.
b. For Books: Surname and initial of author(s), title and subtitle, editor, city, publishing house page, year as specific reference.
Dillman WH. The Cardiovascular System in Thyrotoxicosis.
In Braverman LE and Utiger RD, eds. The Thyroid - A fundamental and Clinical Text. 6th ed. Philadelphia: JB Lippincott
Co; 1991,759-770.
Figures
Illustrations should complement the text. The illustrations
should be sharp and professionally rendered. Letters, numbers and symbols must be clear and of sufficient size to retain
legibility after reduction. Glossy photographs of the original
artwork, between 3-1/2 x 5 in. and 8 x 10 in. in size, should be
submitted. Each illustration should be numbered and cited
consecutively using Arabic numerals. Colored photographs
will be considered for publication.
Legends
Caption for the figures must be typed, double-spaced, and
must not appear in the figure. For photomicrographs, the legend should include the original magnification and the stain used.
Tables
Tables should be self-explanatory and should supplement, not
duplicate the text. They should be numbered consecutively
using Roman numerals.
REPRINTS
Authors will receive ten (10) copies of reprints free of charge.
Individual reprints of article must be obtained from the author.
The corresponding author will receive a price schedule and
order form at the time of publication. Reprints in quantity
must be ordered from the publisher with the author's consent.
Phil Heart Center J, Vol. 9, January-December 2002