Annexure III: Public Hearing Notice, Attendance
Sheets, Proceedings and Replies
Summary/details of public hearing in tabular form:
Issues raised by the
Public
Response/Commitment of
Project Proponents
Suggestions made by the
Public Hearing Panel
Shri Mohan Singh, R/o
Thakur
The rate of royalty of bajri is
Rs. 550/tractor trolley which
is very high.
The rates of royalty for minor
minerals are determined by the
state government and the project
proponent / lessee has no locus
standii over this exclusive policy
matter.
It is the policy matter of the
state and the view of the
public
shall
be
communicated
Shree Pankaj Sharma, R/o
Pali
By auctioning lease for
mining of bajri to one person
only, there would be
adverse impact to the
environment. It would have
been better if the lease were
granted to 3 to 4 parties /
contractors.
By resorting to e-auction the letter
of intent has been granted to the
P.P. for the single riverbed mining
project under the tehsil with the
view to control the illegal mining
and also with the sole objective for
carrying out the sustainable
project activity by protecting the
environment.
It is the policy matter of the
state and the view of the
public
shall
be
communicated
-
Shree Ramlal, Sarpanch,
R/o Thakurla
The copy of the lease be
make available to the
concerned gram sabha
Shree Shanker Jangaid
Where the plantation is
proposed and with whom
the
responsibility
of
maintenance rests with.
At this juncture no lease deed has
been entered with the P.P.
However the P.P. can produce the
copy of LoI on the asking of the
gram sabha.
The plantation shall be carried out
as per green belt development
plan contained in the EMP. The PP
shall be responsible for the
maintenance of the plantation
carried out during the project
period.
As per approved mine plan, the
transportation of minerals shall be
carried through covered trucks
and overloading avoided beyond
the stipulated capacity. It is the
responsibility of the state mine
department and the transport
department
to
ensure
no
overloading of trucks. For effective
control on overloading of trucks,
the Hon’ble High Court of
Judicature for Rajasthan at Jaipur
Bench vide Judgment dated
14.08.2014 has made the P.P.
solely responsible and passed
instructions to other departments
like mining , transport and police to
The PP shall show the copy
of LoI / Lease deed if
demanded by the gram
sabha.
-
The PP shall be responsible
for the maintenance of the
plantation during the project
period.
Section 9.3
(Green
Belt
Development
Plan – Rs. 11
lac per annum)
Approved mining plan shall
be strictly complied with.
Periodical
checking
of
loaded trucks at proper
“Naka” shall be carried out
by mining as well as
transport department.
Section 4.10.2
Shree Raju, R/o Rupawas
No overloading of the trucks
should be allowed and
these shall be covered to
avoid spilling of minerals.
Action Plan
Reference in
EIA Doc
-
Shree Sardar Banjara, R/o
Devaliya
Management Plan should
be made available to the
gram sabha.
Shree Mahendra Singh, R/o
Thakur
The royalty on mineral
should be dispensed with.
Shree Kuppa Ram Lohar,
N.T. Pali
By mining in 3m depth the
water table shall be lowered
therefore mining depth
should be restricted to 2
yard
Shree
Shankar
R/o
Hemawas
Only local people should be
employed
ensure strict compliance of the
order.
The work stipulated under the
management plan shall be
discussed with the concerned
gram sabha and undertaken after
taking them into the confidence.
It is policy matter of the state and
thus no action rests with the P.P.
In general the water table of
neighboring area gets lowered in
case of mining in the bed of
influent river which is not the
present case as the river(s) in
question are ephemeral in nature.
During monsoon and in post
monsoon season the water table
rises in comparison to premonsoon water depths. The
mining upto 3 m is envisaged in
the approved mining plan.
The EIA document vouches for
deployment
of
manpower
indigenously available during the
lease period.
The work proposed under
CSR initiative shall be
carried out after taking
locals into confidence.
Section 9.2.6.1
(CSR Activities
– Rs. 20 lac)
-
-
Approved mining plan shall
be strictly complied with.
Section 2.10
and
Section
4.5.1
The local people shall get
the
employment
for
executing mining activities
as well as labour oriented
works
under
the
management plans.
Section
and 8.3.1
4.9