1. science
2. ecology
3. pollution

Subscribe
56°
H: 57°
Help
L: 52°
Sunday, March 22, 2015
Credible. Compelling. Complete.
Sign Out

Search Site
STATE & REGIONAL GOVT & POLITICS
State qualifies Falcons, Braves for sales tax exemptions on stadiums
 LATEST HEADLINES 
HOME / NEWS
Resize text A
A
A
Few penalties, lax oversight for chicken plants that pollute
State favors self-regulation over fines for chicken processors. EPA finds multiple Clean Water Act
violations at one plant.
Posted: 12:00 a.m. Saturday, March 21, 2015
By Shannon McCaffrey ­ The Atlanta Journal­Constitution
One of Georgia’s largest chicken
processors has for years exceeded pollution standards for storm water runoff feeding into Lake Lanier — a
major source of drinking water for metro Atlanta — with few consequences from state regulators, an Atlanta
Journal-Constitution investigation has found.
The AJC’s findings raise questions about the state’s practice of allowing the chicken processors to essentially
regulate themselves and spot test their own storm water runoff, which can contain the bacteria found in
chicken feces.The state has just two inspectors overseeing industrial storm water pollution permits at some
3,000 sites.
+
CURTIS COMPTON
A water tank touts Gainesville as the poultry capital of the world. Nearby Lake Lanier provides drinking water to metro
Atlanta. ... Read More
Indeed, the most aggressive water testing at Lake Lanier is conducted by volunteers — local residents who
sample the lake water monthly at 24 sites.
“It’s a sad state of affairs when the federal government and the state government place the main water testing
responsibility on a group of volunteers, but that’s what happens here,” U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’
Operations Project Manager for Lake Lanier Tim Rainey said.
The Chattahoochee Riverkeeper, an environmental watchdog that has also found high pollution levels coming
from two chicken processors in the area, has complained for years that the state is too lax.
+
CURTIS COMPTON
A truck loaded with chickens makes it’s way in the south gate truck entrance at the Pilgrim’s Pride chicken processing plant
... Read More
Those concerns were validated this year when surprise federal inspections found that Pilgram’s Pride and MarJac Poultry were failing to do enough to prevent waste and manure from washing into a north Georgia creek
that empties into the southern end of Lake Lanier.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) discovered multiple violations of the Clean Water Act by the
two plants, which together slaughter and process millions of chickens a week at plants in Gainesville. Georgia is
the leading supplier of chickens in the nation, producing 1.3 billion birds a year for consumption.
Documents reviewed by the AJC found that since 2006 Pilgrim’s Pride has regularly dumped more pollutants
into Flat Creek than the state allows but has not been hit with a fine. Records show Mar-Jac did not exceed the
state limits as frequently as Pilgrim’s Pride. But independent testing on water flowing from the Mar-Jac site by
the Riverkeeper recorded higher bacteria levels than the company reported in its own documents.
+
CURTIS COMPTON
The federal Environmental Protection Agency found that chicken manure can wash into a stream that feeds Lake Lanier
when trucks carrying ... Read More
“These facilities need to comply with clean water laws to protect public health and water quality downstream of
the facility,” Chattahoochee Riverkeeper Jason Ulseth said.
The state “has been less than forceful in making sure they are complying,” he said. “There are few consequences
beyond telling them to improve.”
The poultry industry wields considerable political clout in the state. Three years ago, it prevailed on state
regulators to back off a more aggressive timetable for getting polluters to comply with clean water benchmarks.
+
BRANT SANDERLIN
The water quality testing on Lake Lanier is left up largely to volunteer groups such as the Lake Lanier Association. BRANT ...
Read More
State officials finally notified Pilgrim’s Pride last June it had to make improvements to its plant to reduce the
contaminated discharge. But the company has three years to comply, state records show.
“We are diligently working on that area so we can have clean water,” said James Capp, head of the state
Environmental Protection Divisions’s water branch said.
Pilgrim’s Pride did not return repeated calls seeking comment. Mar-Jac declined to comment.
+
BRANT SANDERLIN
Lake Lanier Association volunteer Denny Nicholls pilots his boat to a water testing location on Lake Lanier. Nicholls, and his
wife ... Read More
Mike Giles, head of the Georgia Poultry Federation, said the plants are not the only ones to blame for high levels
of bacteria in the creek, which runs through one of the city’s heaviest industrial stretches. And he questioned
whether fecal coliform, common in human and animal feces, was a reliable pollution benchmark.
“I am not aware of any other private regulated entity in the Flat Creek watershed that is required to take such
concrete steps to reduce fecal coliform concentrations in storm water runoff, even though water quality
sampling in the Flat Creek watershed demonstrates that there are many sources of fecal coliform impacting the
creek,” Giles said.
He pointed to independent studies showing fecal coliform levels decreasing as water reaches Lake Lanier.
+
BRANT SANDERLIN
Lake Lanier Association volunteers Bev Nicholls and her husband Denny collect a water sample on Lake Lanier
Wednesday March 18, 2015. ... Read More
A ‘critical’ basin for Atlanta
Levels of fecal coliform bacteria are so high in Flat Creek that the state Environmental Protection Division lists it
as an impaired waterway. Ulseth and others acknowledge the poultry plants aren’t the sole source of the
bacteria in the stream. But the group’s testing shows that bacteria levels skyrocket near the chicken plants after
it rains.
Pilgrim’s Pride and Mar-Jac are the only two poultry processors along the creek that slaughter live birds. A
frequent cause of fecal coliform bacterial contamination in waterways is manure, and the bacteria can live in
the intestines of warm-blooded animals. Drinking water contaminated with the bacteria can cause diarrhea,
nausea, vomiting, cramps and other gastro-related distresses. Exposure can cause rashes and other skin
problems.
+
BRANT SANDERLIN
Bev Nicholls, volunteer director of the Lake Lanier Association prepares a water sample, taken form Lake Lanier,
Wednesday March 18, 2015. ... Read More
Flat Creek flows into the southern end of Lake Lanier, home to beaches and boat launches and a popular
recreation destination.
The lake stretches over 58 square miles but the state samples water at just 10 sites once a month from April to
October. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers conducts water quality testing along Lanier’s beaches and only
during the recreation season.
The most extensive testing is conducted, instead, by volunteers with the Lake Lanier Association.
“We would like to see the state and the federal governments take a bigger role,” the group’s leader Joanna Cloud
said.
Cloud said Flat Creek has been an ongoing problem. Sometimes after rains the creek is so choked with garbage
you can barely see the water, she said.
The city of Gainesville is moving to do more, launching plans for a clean up program. But the creek also passes
through unincorporated Hall County which complicates the effort.
Flat Creek and Lake Lanier are part of the Chattahoochee River basin, which supplies water to much of metro
Atlanta. Constructed by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in the 1950’s, Lake Lanier is a multi-purpose lake used
for for flood protection, power production, water supply, navigation, recreation and fish and wildlife
management.
The Chattahoochee Riverkeeper began to focus on Flat Creek in 2009 when more than 100 fish turned up dead
in the stream near the plants. Volunteers with the group recently began collecting their own water samples
from areas near the chicken plants.
“The health of this river basin is absolutely critical (for metro Atlanta),” said Sally Bethea, former head of the
environmental group.
Surprise federal inspections
Tipped off about chronic issues at the Gainesville poultry plants, federal investigators in August made a a pair of
unannounced visits.
In a report obtained by the AJC, inspectors who visited the Pilgrim’s Pride plant noted maggots in drains and
pipes as well as “red water” — presumably contaminated with blood — on the site. Large chicken parts, such as
legs, were seen being dumped into lines leading to water treatment on the site, the report found.
Some of the issues were the result of sheer volume. Fifty trucks full of chickens ready for slaughter arrive at the
site daily. Inspectors said that, with such heavy traffic, some of the trucks sit waiting in the open, the birds
dropping feather and manure on the ground. To cool the birds, they were hosed down with water that could
ultimately find it’s way to the creek. All tolled, the EPA noted two dozen Clean Water Act violations at Pilgrim’s
Pride, the report found.
At Mar-Jac, a separate EPA report found the company had not properly updated it’s storm water prevention
plan. Additionally, there were questions about red or rust stained water observed gushing from a discharge
point from the plant which the company had said was inactive. The company argued the discharge may have
come from another source.
Under Georgia’s practice of self-regulation, companies are required to collect their own water samples when it
rains and provide them for testing to see if they exceed certain benchmarks. State records show Pilgrim’s Pride
regularly failed to deliver the required number of samples, a finding also confirmed by the EPA.
Fecal coliform bacteria must arrive at the lab within six hours of being collected for reliable testing. The
company said that tight timeline makes testing difficult. But the EPA dismissed that explanation.
“This reason does not carry much weight because the facility operated 5-6 days per week from 4:55 a.m.-4:30
a.m. … and is not located a long way from the lab,” the EPA report said. “Facility representatives indicated that
the lab is located at a location where Pilgrims Pride trucks go between every day as part of normal operations.”
A history of high readings
State officials have found shortcomings in Pilgrim’s Pride’s pollution control practices since at least 2006, state
records reviewed by the AJC show.
Since 2006, the processor has exceeded pollution benchmarks in nearly one out of every two tests they have
conducted, according to an AJC analysis of 95 readings collected by the company and provided to the state. Still,
the state did little more than tell them to conduct additional tests.
In most cases Mar-Jac’s readings have been within the required pollution caps. But Riverkeeper’s own testing
near the Mar-Jac plant detected levels well above the caps. On three instances in 2013 and 2014 the company
and the environmental group sampled on the same day and came up with vastly different readings. On April 14,
2014, for example, Mar-Jac reported fecal coliform levels of 280 and 220 — well under the cap of 4,000. But
Riverkeeper’s readings were 20,000 and 46,000, five to 10 times higher than the required pollution cap. On
Oct. 3, 2014, Mar Jac reported levels of 130 and 109 while Riverkeeper’s testing showed levels of 41,060 and
6,700.
The poultry industry wields considerable clout in state politics. In 2012, state environmental officials moved to
put in place tighter regulations for facilities that repeatedly exceed water quality benchmarks.
While it did give the state more muscle to punish chronic polluters it also gave them plenty of time to do so.
Originally, the proposal would have given facilities 12 months to bring their discharges into compliance with
benchmarks. But the Georgia Poultry Federation came in and successfully lobbied the state to get that timeline
stretched to three years.
Giles, of the state poultry federation, said the group asked for additional time so that companies can make
sometimes costly capital improvements such as paving, curbs or pumping systems to better control storm
water flow.
HOW WE GOT THE STORY
Tipped off about recurring environmental concerns at chicken plants along Flat Creek in north Georgia, Atlanta
Journal-Constitution investigative reporter Shannon McCaffrey reviewed state and environmental files detailing
the scope of the problem. The files included water quality readings reported to the state Environmental
Protection Division by the chicken plants themselves. The AJC also analyzed independent testing data
conducted by the Chattahoochee Riverkeeper, which contradicted some company reports. While the two
companies declined to comment, the AJC spoke to the Georgia Poultry Federation to provide perspective from
the industry. The AJC also spoke to volunteers who conduct water quality testing on Lake Lanier.
Go to myAJC.com to meet some volunteers who test water quality at Lake Lanier in a special video for AJC
subscribers.
Go to myAJC.com to meet some volunteers who test water quality at Lake Lanier in a special video for AJC
subscribers.
In this Section
Atlanta Traffic from the WSB 24­hour Traffic Center
Hundreds march in Atlanta seeking boost in minimum wage
Man killed in Atlanta home invasion
Cause of death of UGA student still undetermined
Accused killer of Fulton officer waives first appearance in court
Driver killed in 285 fatality in Atlanta identified
Some southbound 400 lanes reopened at Lenox Road
Cherokee sheriff’s office investigating Saturday CVS robbery
Man struck, killed trying to cross Ga. 92 in Cherokee County
1 killed in car vs. tractor­trailer crash on I­285 in Fulton County
PREVIOUS:
OPINION
NEXT:
LOCAL
America’s future has arrived in Gwinnett
Community Voices: Library system educates,
entertains on many levels
Popular on MyAJC.com
Top Workplaces 2015 Rankings
Arkansas' private option: the red state solution?
Thousands vanished from official’s campaign report — and no...
NFL­bound Gurley reflects on his UGA career
The scapegoat
All Comments (0)
Post a Comment
COMMENTS
Post comment
Post Comment
Living Intown Magazine – a product of the
Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Gain an insider’s perspective into the unique neighborhoods of in town Atlanta.
Our lifestyle magazine explores all the things that make in-town living so
appealing – from restaurants and attractions to the neighborhoods and their
distinct personalities. Available on your desktop, tablet and smartphone and at
select outlets around town.
Learn More
NEWS
MyAJC.com
Living
Metro/State
Nation/World
Sports
AJCePaper
Business
Archives
Investigations
Living Intown
Magazine
Opinion
ajc.com
CUSTOMER SERVICE
MARKETPLACE
Subscribe
Cars
Subscriber Services
Jobs
Contact Us
Homes/Real Estate
Web site feedback
Classifieds
Digital Products
Kudzu
FAQ's
Advertise With Us
Work Here
Shopping
SOCIAL MEDIA
Pinterest
Find Five
Google+
The Vent
Tumblr
LinkedIn
Facebook
Twitter
© 2015 Cox Media Group. By using this website, you accept the terms of our Visitor Agreement and Privacy Policy, and understand your
options regarding Ad Choices.
Learn about careers at Cox Media Group