Media Release Productivity Commission report shows no evidence

Media Release
Productivity Commission report shows no evidence to support
recommendations from McClure and Commission of Audit reports
9 April 2015
The release of the Productivity Commission’s report into Housing Assistance and
Employment in Australia shows that there is no evidence to support a key
recommendation of both the Commission of Audit and McClure welfare reviews, says
the Community Housing Federation of Australia (CHFA), the national industry body
representing not-for-profit housing providers in Australia.
Both the Commission of Audit and the Welfare Review claim that the income-based
rents in social housing constitute a workforce disincentive, and recommend that social
housing tenants be transitioned from income-based to market-based rents. However
a report released today by the Productivity Commission that uses modelling based on
data from Centrelink and state housing authorities paints a different picture. The
Productivity Commission found that once variables such as age and disability are
taken into consideration there are only very small differences in employment
participation between social housing tenants and those in the private rental market.
“The evidence is clear that income-based rents do not constitute a workforce
disincentive as claimed by the Commission of Audit and the Welfare Review,” said
CHFA’s Chairperson John McInerney. “Shifting social housing tenants to market rents,
will, however, dramatically increase tenants’ housing costs and reduce the afterhousing income of some of our most vulnerable citizens. What is needed is an
increase in the supply of affordable rental housing, not a punitive measure that will
further disadvantage the lowest income tenants.”
Contact
Eddy Bourke
Policy Officer, CHFA
02 6232 5043 or 0407 211 413
John McInerney
CHFA Chairperson
0439 447 110
1