The Truth about Veneers and Solid Wood in Fine Furniture Prepared by: www.furniturebydovetail.com 2 Is this furniture solid wood? It’s one of the most common questions asked of furniture makers because somewhere along the line, veneers got a bad reputation. The popular perception is that furniture that incorporates veneers is lower quality than solid wood pieces. In reality, most fine furniture is made of a combination of veneers and solid wood. If you study the elegant antique furniture showcased in museums, you will see expertly crafted veneered furniture that has withstood the test of time. Solid woods and veneers are both excellent materials when used in the proper place and well-constructed. This paper will help you discern the difference between the two materials, understand their proper usage, and recognize quality craftsmanship. furniturebydovetail.com | 508 - 829 - 8947 3 What is veneer? Wood veneer is a thin slice of wood cut or peeled from a log. The slice can be as thin as a piece of paper or thick enough to accommodate sanding and refinishing down the road. The veneer is adhered to another wood surface. Typically, the outer layer is made from the most beautiful or exotic woods, while the substrate is made from utilitarian woods or particle board. Veneers are not a new invention. Elaborate veneers were discovered in King Tut’s tomb in Egypt and were used extensively during the Renaissance. By the 18th century, veneers had become an art form. Master cabinetmakers such as Chippendale and Hepplewhite inlaid exotic woods in intricate patterns to create visual interest in their delicately crafted furniture. When fine lumber was scarce during World War II, veneers became the only way to create furniture affordably. Unfortunately, a lack of good craftsmen and inadequate adhesives led to substandard results. Perhaps that is when veneers gained the reputation for poor quality that they are still plagued with today. This commode was believed to have been handcrafted by Thomas Chippendale around 1778. It is exhibited in the Carnegie Museum of Art in Pittsburgh, PA. Why not use solid wood? Solid wood is essential for posts or legs that support furniture, for framing, or whenever carving is involved. Because of this, every piece of fine furniture is comprised of at least some solid wood. But consider these issues: • Solid wood bows and warps over time. • Heat and humidity changes can make solid wood contract, leading to splits along the grain known as “season cracks”. • Woods with the most beautiful natural patterns are often saved to make veneers as a way to stretch the value of the lumber. • Solid wood is expensive. • Solid wood is heavy. • Solid wood does not bend easily. Veneers are simply a better choice when a cabinet maker wants to incorporate curves, reduce warping or use exotic woods. In this kitchen island, we used solid wood to frame the island and create the braces for the counter top, but used veneer for the curved insets in the base. furniturebydovetail.com | 508 - 829 - 8947 4 How Solid Woods and Veneers Compare When shopping for furniture, most people are looking for a combination of beautiful design and materials, durability, value and, increasingly, environmentally sensitive materials. Let’s compare solid woods and veneers according to these criteria: 1. Aesthetics Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. If you are looking for the simple lines, plain woods, and solidness of Shaker or Mission style furniture, solid wood is a great option. If you want some curves in your furniture, matched grain patterns, inlaid woods or exotic woods, you’re going to be drawn to pieces that incorporate veneers. Veneers offer the following design advantages: • Finer graining – The best logs are used for veneers simply because you can stretch the wood much farther. A single log sliced or peeled into veneer can provide the material for numerous pieces of furniture. We used exotic wood veneers on the headboard of this bed and table drawer and top to create eye-catching, distinctive pieces. • No defects – Defects in the wood are eliminated during the manufacturing process. • Great for patterns – Sheets of veneers can be combined to form interesting designs that would be impossible to achieve with solid wood Veneers are often used for stability on surfaces that may warp if made from solid wood. Panels, sides and fronts of cases are typically made from veneers. Veneers are very durable, as illustrated by the many pieces of antique veneered furniture that are still in use today. However, since veneers are made up of a thin piece of wood over a substrate, sometimes deep scratches cannot be sanded out without exposing the substrate. This limitation makes solid wood desk and table tops a better choice in settings where furniture receives heavy use. 2. Durability Solid wood furniture will last forever if it is made well. Years of heavy use may lead to dents, dings or scratches, but the beauty of solid wood is that surface imperfections may be sanded out and the furniture can be refinished. On the flip side, solid wood furniture is susceptible to warping and cracking if proper humidity is not maintained at all times. 3. Value Furniture made completely from solid wood is more expensive than furniture made from a combination of veneers and solid wood. This stands to reason since more high-quality lumber is needed. In the case of exotic woods with limited availability, solid wood options may not even be available or may be so costly that very few people would consider a purchase. • Accommodates curves – Veneers are thin enough to bend and can be shaped by the cabinet maker. • Wide range of exotic woods – Exotic woods such as Tiger Maple, Maple burls, Ebony and others are often available only as veneers, or are fabulously expensive if purchased as solid wood. furniturebydovetail.com | 508 - 829 - 8947 5 When buying furniture, be sure to weigh the use that the piece will receive against the cost. A desk in a college library will receive far more use (and abuse) than a desk tucked in the corner of a family room in a residence. Furniture components that can be repeatedly sanded and repaired justify the extra expense of solid wood in the library setting, but are less important in a home. 4. Environmental Considerations If conserving natural resources is a priority, then furniture made of wood veneers is a great choice. The veneering technology makes it possible to get 15 to 20 tables out of the same lumber used to create just one solid wood table. The substrate used as the base for the veneer is an ecofriendly way to use lower-grade lumber or particle board made up of recycled sawdust. Proper Usage is Key Solid woods and veneers are both quality materials for fine furniture, but they must be used correctly. A craftsman will choose the best material to use depending upon the application. When you are purchasing fine furniture, look for solid woods and veneers used in the following ways: Solid Wood Wood Veneer Structural components • Framing • Turnings • Curved pieces • • Panels • Exotic woods • Matching grains • Panels • Shelves • Table & desk tops • • Drawer facings • • Chair seats • furniturebydovetail.com | 508 - 829 - 8947 6 How to Recognize Wood Veneer High quality wood veneers can be tough to differentiate from solid wood. In fact, some stores that advertise their furniture as “solid wood” are actually selling pieces that are a combination of solid wood and wood veneers. Here’s how you can tell if furniture incorporates some veneers: 1. Look for banding – Are large surfaces such as table tops edged with a band of wood or veneer going the opposite direction from the grain? If so, the banding is probably covering up the unfinished edge of the veneered wood. 2. Look under and behind – If the underside or backside of the furniture’s surfaces has a different wood than the top or front, you know that a veneer was used. You will often notice a nicer wood on the top and a less attractive wood on the bottom. 3. Check the grain – If the grain goes all the way through the top, bottom and sides of the wood surface, you are looking at solid wood. Otherwise, the piece is made at least partially from veneer. Chair seats and framing are typically solid wood. Pull out a drawer and see if the wood grain goes all the way from front to back to determine if veneers are used. The banding on the top of this reception desk is a clear indicator that high quality wood veneers were used to create the desktop surface. furniturebydovetail.com | 508 - 829 - 8947 7 The Signs of Quality The local discount furniture store sells furniture made from wood veneers. So do high-end furniture artisans such as Furniture by Dovetail. What’s the difference? Here are 5 telltale signs of quality: 1. Thickness of the veneer –Mass produced furniture is often covered by veneers that are as thin as 1/128th of an inch. These veneers are too thin to permit sanding or refinishing. If the surface is damaged, you just dispose of the furniture and buy a new piece! Hand-crafted furniture will incorporate veneers that are thicker and can accommodate light sanding for a lifetime of use and enjoyment. 2. Construction – Wood veneers on inexpensive furniture are typically fastened together with staples or cheap nails. Quality furniture will be constructed with veneers on real wood substrates that are fastened using durable woodworking techniques such as dovetailing, doweling or tongue and groove joints. 3. Mix of solid wood and veneer – High quality furniture uses solid wood in structural elements such as furniture legs, posts, arms and frames. Less expensive counterparts will use wood veneers throughout a piece of furniture. 4. Type of wood - Craftsmen use high-end wood veneers for their superior grains and the ability to use exotic woods that are unavailable or unstable as solid pieces. Wood veneers are specified for their exceptional beauty, whereas the local furniture superstore tends to use more mundane veneers and apply dark stains to hide defects and as a way to keep costs to a minimum. 5. Design – While mass furniture makers will use veneers purely because they are more affordable than solid wood, craftsmen often employ veneers for specific effects that would otherwise be extremely difficult to achieve. Handcrafted furniture will incorporate wood veneers for curves, patterns and for intricate inlays and detailing. When evaluating the quality of furniture, the most important question to ask should not be “Is it solid wood?” Instead, ask: • Where are wood veneers used on the piece? • How thick are the veneers? • What type of wood is used? • How is the piece constructed? The answers to these questions will reveal much more about the true quality of the furniture. This reception desk at The Hyatt uses wood veneer to create the curved bands and matched grains that give the piece its unique character. furniturebydovetail.com | 508 - 829 - 8947 8 About Furniture by Dovetail Furniture by Dovetail creates handcrafted furniture for residences, offices and academic institutions. Since the company was founded in 1988 by Robert and Annette Loring, we have remained dedicated to our mission to create exceptional furniture of unparalleled quality and lasting beauty. We use hand-selected hardwoods and wood veneers, time-honored joinery and the most durable finishes to craft heirloom furniture of distinction. We offer our own collection of furniture, or we build custom pieces to meet the specific requirements of our clients. Our standard collections are available at our showrooms in Holden and Newton Lower Falls, Massachusetts or online at www.furniturebydovetail.com. For more information about wood veneers, solid woods or Furniture by Dovetail, please contact us at: Furniture by Dovetail 70 Industrial Drive Holden, MA 01520 508-829-8947 [email protected] www.furniturebydovetail.com furniturebydovetail.com | 508 - 829 - 8947
© Copyright 2024