H ED A CRAFT ND IL D S OA PM AKERS GU SoapMaker 2009-2 HANDCRAFTED The Journal of the Handcrafted Soapmakers Guild How Time & Temperature Affect the Soapmaking Process by Kevin M. Dunn, John Campbell, Andrew Basinger, and Tyler Bowman What is the time scale for the saponification process? Does it take minutes, hours, days, or weeks for the alkali to be consumed? What role does temperature play in the saponification reaction? Why does soap sometimes gel to a Vaseline-like consistency and other times remain the consistency of cookie dough? These are the questions to be addressed in this article.1 Method In order to study the effects of time and temperature, we held some things constant to avoid being fooled by variations in materials and techniques. This study used an oil blend dubbed “Delight,” consisting of 39% olive, 28% palm, 28% coconut, and 5% castor oil. Each test bar was made from 100.0 g of Delight and 28.8 g of Lye (50.0% NaOH, 50.0% de-ionized water) along with a varying water portion. Since the 1 This article has been adapted from a chapter of the forthcoming book, Scientific Soapmaking, by Kevin M. Dunn. In This Issue How Time and Temperature Affects The Soapmaking Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . cover From the President . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . inside cover Manufacturer's Safety Data Sheets Do You Need Them? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Welcome New Members . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 How To Select The Right Shrink Film For Your Products . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Feeding Frenzy: Using RSS Feeds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 2010 Annual Conference . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Lye was 50.0% NaOH, the ratio of NaOH to oil was 144 to 1000, that is, 144 parts per thousand (ppt).2 We determined the (sodium) saponification value of this oil to be 150.8 ppt NaOH.3 This meant that the NaOH used was (144/150.8 = 0.95) of that required for complete saponification. Thus, the lye discount was 5%. Each bar was designated by a formula, Delight1000Lye288AqX, where X was varied from 0 ppt (low-water) to 288 ppt (high-water).4 We considered these soaps to be realistic representatives of soaps produced in the handcrafted soap community. We might expect the low-water soap (0 ppt Aq) to be harder initially than the high-water soap (288 ppt Aq), as explored in reference [6]. It will be seen that the water concentration dictates much of the behavior of a saponifying oil. Our soap formula expresses the water portion in ppt, as if the water portion is a separate ingredient from the lye. But it is possible to calculate the equivalent lye concentration that would be necessary to produce the same soaps from oil and dilute lye. It is also possible to express the moisture concentration as a fraction of the total soap weight. A survey of several handcrafted soap books revealed that the 2 1 ppt = 0.1%; 500 ppt = 50.0%. 3 Method adapted from AOCS Official Method Cd 3-25, reference [5] 4 It is important to keep in mind that any time "Lye" is referred to in the formulations, it refers to a 50% solution of NaOH and water. The water designated by Aq is in addition to the water in the Lye solution. Since the Lye used for all soaps was 50.0% water, Aq0 was designated low-water, not no-water. (continued on page 8) Contact Us Handcrafted Soapmakers Guild, Inc. P.O. Box 5103 Portland, OR 97208-5103 Toll Free: (866) 900-SOAP (866) 900-7627 Direct: (503) 283-7758 Fax: (503) 286-0236 E-mail: [email protected] Board of Directors: Leigh O'Donnell, President [email protected] Maria Gelnett, Vice-President [email protected] Sr. Cathleen Timberlake, Secretary [email protected] Feleciai Favroth, Treasurer [email protected] Elaine Koronich [email protected] Gillian DeConto [email protected] Delores Harris [email protected] Public Website www.soapguild.org Members Only Website www.soapguild.org/login.php Renew Membership www.soapguild.org/renew HSMG Blog www.soapguild.org/blog Member Forum www.soapguild.org/forum HSMG Store www.soapguild.org/store Journal Advertising www.soapguild.org/journal.php [email protected] The Handcrafted SoapMaker is a publication of the Handcrafted Soap Makers Guild, Inc. published for the HSMG membership. From the President Have you ever fallen victim to the gloom that sometimes surrounds us and let it start to run your life and your business? My family recently fell victim to the H1N1 Virus. I have two kids (10 & 13) and it started with my 13 year old. It's been 3 weeks now and it's worked it's way through the entire family, even me. Nothing like a flu virus to slow you down, it can feel like your whole house is infected. This got me thinking that 2009 has been a very gloomy year. It's very difficult to find some good news in the sea of overwhelming negativity. Every time we turn on the news we're bombarded by negativity; the economy is bad, swine flu, food recalls, shooting sprees, plane crashes and the list goes on and on. What is important to remember is that as unpleasant as all of this is, it's a part of modern life and that we, as individuals and business owners, can't let it get us down. For our businesses, if we let the gloom get us down, it shows. No matter how upbeat we try to be at our craft fairs or in our blog posts and emails, the darkness is going to show to your customers and your sales will reflect it. That's why it's important to stay strong and focused, even when the days are dark and rainy. Breathe some new life into your business: take a class, try a new technique, research new products or packaging, update your website and stay positive. It is the business people that can do this that will come out stronger on the other side. Share the load with other small business people in your area, get together with other local soapmakers and keep your mind fresh, new and alert to the good things on the horizon. Since I have been a member of the HSMG (2004), I have always been uplifted by the amount of support that members give to each other. The HSMG has been involved in various forms of social media over the last year (Facebook, Twitter, forum, blog) and I love to read the comments of encouragement and offers of assistance that HSMG soapmakers give to each other. It is in the HSMG mission statement to act as a center of communication for soapmakers and HSMG members are making this really easy to fulfill. Keep focused on why you became a soapmaker and business owner in the first place: it's fun, rewarding and you are in control of your own destiny. Remember that while we can't control Mother Nature, the news or the occasional case of the gloomies, we CAN control our businesses and someday soon the sun will shine again. Leigh O'Donnell President Manufacturer's Safety Data Sheets Do you need them? A very common question when you get into soap industry is: should I collect Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) or not? The best way to answer that question is with a thorough understanding of what a MSDS is designed to do. The MSDS is a single document prepared by the manufacturer containing all the information about the chemical make-up, use, storage, handling, emergency procedures and the potential health effects related to raw materials. MSDS were originally intended for hazardous materials only; however, now many materials with no hazards have a MSDS simply for product liability purposes alone. An ingredient that has an MSDS is not necessarily a hazardous material or one that causes health effects in personal care products. The MSDS is simply giving information about the safe handling of the ingredient at full concentration, which does not translate to normal cosmetic usage. A perfect example of how the MSDS does not translate to the finished product is with lye. The MSDS would show that it causes eye, skin, digestive, respiratory burns however; in the finished product it causes no ill effect to the consumer. Unfortunately, MSDS information has been misused by some to spread negative propaganda about many ingredients that are perfectly safe in the finished product. All MSDSs are required to contain the same uniform categories of information including: chemical identity, health hazard data, manufacturer information, precautions for safe handling and use, hazardous ingredients, exposure controls/personal protection, physical/chemical properties as well as fire and explosion hazard data. The purpose of an MSDS is to inform you of proper handling of a material, first aid treatment, accident response protocol, effect on human health, chemicals with which it can adversely react, as well as the chemical make-up and physical properties prior to usage. And when new regulatory information or health effects information becomes available the MSDS must be updated. by Kayla Fioravanti I often hear people complain that MSDSs are hard to interpret. That's because they were originally for industrial hygienists, chemical engineers and safety professionals who were trained to read them. Now they have become more widely used, but the language was never changed to laymen terms. Sometime you will find MSDSs that are formatted differently by some manufacturers, but they all contain the exact same information that is required by law. Once you get the hang of reading MSDS you won’t even notice the differences. If you are manufacturing with raw materials you should get a copy of the MSDS for your knowledge and records. The most important parts to read include the name of the material, hazards, safe handling and storage requirements. Store the MSDS in a file that will be easy to reach if emergency responders such as fire fighters, hazardous material crews, emergency medical technicians and emergency room personnel need to access them. If you have employees, you are required by law to maintain readily accessible MSDS for any hazardous materials “known to be present” in the workplace. MSDS are designed for employees who will occupationally come in contact with hazardous materials. OSHA Hazard Communication Standard requires that safety training on proper handling of materials be conducted, that all hazardous material is labeled appropriately and, if you have contractors on the premises, you must inform them of the potential hazards. The MSDS is designed to help employers and employees protect themselves from hazardous chemical exposures and to teach them to handle material safely. Not only is it important to take all those steps but it is critical that you log it or document it all. Are you left wondering if you need to collect MSDS sheets are not? The answer is simple. Do any of the ingredients you use have a hazardous rating above zero? Do you use lye? Do you have employees? If you answered yes to any of these questions, then you should maintain a file of the MSDS sheets for the raw ingredients you use. (continued on page 20) 1 Welcome New Members! Sheila Aaron Prairie Soap Company Handcrafted From The Heart To Nourish The Soul Sisa Essence A diverse selection of pure, handmade and natural soaps, bath and body products for self-indulgence or wonderful gifts. John Adams www.latheredup.com Nadia Abrahamson Lui Ada Soap Impressions Vickie Adams Patricia Anderson Soaps Etc. by Dolly & Me, LLC Scott Anderson Oils By Nature Leslee Avery-Beausoleil RainTree Botanicals LLC Tanya Azzaro Iconic Skincare Kathleen Backus Aromadies Olga Barba SoapScents Designs, Inc. Brenda Barrow Sea Mist Ltd Michelle Baxter Peone Soap Barn M a k e Yo u r D R E A M S Come TRUE! . . . S o l u t i o n s Ta i l o r e d F o r Yo u Beginner, Intermediate or Professional... Soap Making Kits Starting at $210 Custom Professional Systems Accessories and More! Ever y t h ing Fo r th e Handcrafted Body Care Industr y Visit Us Today at www.SoapEquipment.com or Call... 765-886-4640 972-620-1108 12873 W.E. Oler Road Hagerstown, IN 47346 2 How to Select the Right Shrink Film for Your Products by Art Marko With many different kinds of shrink films each having different properties, it can be difficult to choose the best one for your product. This article can help you understand the qualities of the different types of shrink films, so you can evaluate the options and choose the one that's most appropriate for your particular use. Common Film Types The two most prevalent film types for wrapping soap are Polyolefin and PVC. Either type will wrap soap neatly, but secondary considerations should determine which you opt for. sealed. If you want the glossy finish PVC gives you, but would still like the scent to come through, you can use perforated PVC which will give you the best of both worlds. All the perforated films allow air to escape from your package, eliminating the need to manually puncture the film to allow any air trapped inside the package to escape. You can also eliminate this "pillowing" by squeezing the air out (forcing a hole into the film) or purposely melting a tiny hole into the film while shrinking, but perforated films eliminate this step entirely. PVC is a shiny, glossy, crisp film, well suited to packaging single bars, multi-packs, and is the ONLY film for Melt & Pour Soaps gift baskets and trays. OK, maybe that's a bit dramatic, but it's what people seem to expect in the look and feel Wrapping melt-and-pour soaps is more difficult of gift baskets and trays. PVC inhibits the exchange of than cold process. Since the make-up of each bar is air, letting virtually none of the scent come through. It subject to the recipe, methodology and the whims of isn't as soft as the polyolefin but works very well. The the individual, there is no set rule for wrapping them. 6x6 shrink bags many soapmakers use are made of PVC. When wrapping bars with moist spots, the film For candles, PVC is the best choice in terms of the tends to stick to the wettest areas and results in an smooth and glossy finish of the film, which typically irregularity on the film surface. looks better against the surface of your candle. PVC Most melt and pours, like Olive, Aloe, Honey, with micro-perforations or a "scent hole" will allow the fragrance through, while still providing protection from Oatmeal , and other non low-sweat varieties, should be allowed to dry to the touch before they are scars, nicks and dings. wrapped. This will eliminate many of the issues with Polyolefin, is an acid-free, food grade film that comes glycerine and other "sticky" melt & pours. in various weights. Typically it feels like a baggie-type For M&P sold mail-order, or in a retail store, with sandwich bag and in thinner versions, feels like a a controlled environment, this exchange of moisture thickish Saran-type wrap. Polyolefin allows air to pass through, and allows moisture in and out. The exchange in or out of the bar is a non-issue. On the other hand, if you take your product to the local farmers of moisture is inhibited, as compared to a bare, naked bar, but takes place nonetheless. The fact that air passes market every weekend, and the bars sit exposed to through polyolefin makes it most suitable for situations the elements for hours on end, beware the extremes of humidity. You'll want to use non-perforated films where there are no sample bars to sniff, so it's imporhere. tant that the scent permeates and exudes through the film. Presentation Pin-Perforated Films Both PVC and polyolefin films are available with micro perforations evenly spaced throughout the film, allowing the scent through, even when completely ANY film works well with CP. Let the secondary considerations; scent, strength, look and feel and personal taste determine which is best. (continued on page 4) 3 Welcome New Members! Karen Bedell Karen's Naturals Annette Bell Home, Health & Beauty Alternatives Anne Bembenek Circle A Naturals Malia Bennett The Phat Bath Shop Vicki Bergstresser Silvia Betancourt Kerry Biglin Sagegold Soaps Judy Bird Judy Bird Fine Art Arlene Bishop-Giese Stacie Blair-Nelson Missy Bly Clean City Soap Debbie Borges Can't Resist Marla Bosworth Back Porch Soap Co. Tiffanie Bourassa Compass Rose Soap Company 4 Shrink Film (continued from page 3) Glycerin, which is found in both MP and cold process soaps, is a humectant. An unwrapped bar attracts moisture in a humid environment and promotes the appearance of actual beads of water on the surface, which in turn may promote microbial growth. In a dry environment, humectants lose moisture, possibly dulling the finish and drying out your product. The goal is to strike a balance between protecting the bar from the environment it will be displayed in, and displaying the merchandise in its most advantageous and attractive light. If you only wrap bars and loaves, 60 gauge polyolefin is strong enough to stand up to the handling but thin enough to seal and shrink easily. For wrapping trays and various containers, 60 gauge polyolefin is a bit on the thin side; 75 gauge polyolefin is better as it will stand up to the sharp corners and edges trays and boxes present. It's also better to use if you'll be bundling your bars, making single package, multi-bar samplers and promotions, or if your bars get handled frequently. Biodegradable Polyolefin For several years PLA, a corn-based shrink film, has been available for outer wrapping on bottles of sports drinks and similar products where a plastic container is banded with a printed label. Unfortunately, tests have shown that while PLA does break down, it still leaves tiny plastic particulates. PLA has raised consumer awareness and enticed socially conscious soapers, but the film is too thick, and doesn't seal or shrink easily, rendering it unsuitable to package bars of soap. (continued on page 13) Feeding Frenzy Using RSS Feeds Regularly reading blogs is a great way to keep up-todate on the news within the Soapmaking Community, but constantly going to each site to check what's new can be time consuming. So, instead of going to check, have the news come to you! It's easy if you use RSS (Really Simple Syndication). RSS is a system that goes out and checks the blogs and news sites you specify and retrieves any updates, which you can view at your leisure. News Readers To use RSS feeds, you'll need a news reader, also called a news aggregator. Google and Yahoo provide the two most popular news aggregators, but there are other options available. To access Yahoo!'s news reader, you need to have a Yahoo! account. Once you have the account, click on the tab for My Yahoo! (my.yahoo.com). You can customize the page with your local weather, TV schedules, sports scores, stock prices, RSS feeds and more. Google offers two ways to use its news reader (you have to have a Google account for either of them). iGoogle (www.google.com/ig) is like My Yahoo! in Home of the Original 2-Day Soapmaking Boot Camp People travel from all over to take our popular 2-day Soap Intensive, which includes 3 classes taught by Lori Nova: Cold Process 101 (all the basics & more); CP 201: Intermediate Design techniques like Swirling & Layering, Hot Process Crock Pot Soap, & Big Batch CP Soap with David Critchfield. We also offer private lessons & phone consulting. Located in historic Point Richmond, CA (near San Francisco). w w w.T h e Nova Stud io .co m 510-234-5700 that you can bring together content from across the web, including your RSS feeds. The other option with Google is the Google Reader (www.google.com/ reader) which just focuses on RSS feeds. If you use the FireFox browser, there are several news aggregator plug-ins that work directly through the FireFox browser, such as Sage and SRR. The Wikipedia (www.wikipedia.com) also has an extensive list of available RSS readers. After you've chosen a news reader, you're ready to begin subscribing to blogs and news feeds. As you visit blog or news sites you are interested in, look for the orange RSS feed icon (shown above). You'll typically see a link to subscribe beside it. Click the link, then select your news reader. As you surf the web, watch for sites that have the RSS icon. When the news arrives, your reader display the feed and the items. Most readers show the feeds you've subscribed to and the number new items. Once you view an item, it's marked as "read". Now instead of going from site to site to see what's up, you can just sit back and know that the news will come to you! • On-Line Marketing Make Your Website Sell! www.Search-Engine-Friendly.com Talk to an Expert Free Initial Consultation Call Now! (541) 572-2569 5 Welcome New Members! Britton Boyd Haus of Gloi Kristin Brayman Ina Brinkmann Bella Bina Natural Essentials Joan Broughton Joan's Garden Hope Brown Kristy Brown Barely Gentle Bath Bars Lisa E Bruecks Bella's Homemade Soap Colleen Buck Buck Ridge Soaps LLC Angela Buckley Celtic Naturals,LLC A Special "Thank You" to our Conference Sponsors! Tara Bukowsky Chestnut & Bay Natural Products Carolyn Burgess Tim Burk Burk's Crafts Robin Caino Leah Capezio Blushing Goat Botanicals, LLC Michael Cappelli The Lebermuth Company www.lebermuth.com Soapzees Angela Carillo Debbie Chialtas SoapyLove Tony Cipolla Tony's Finest Eretta Clark Narrow Chance Jeff Cohen The Soap Gift Shoppe, Inc. Deena Coile-Parham Deena-n-Emily Christina Collins Mold Market www.moldmarket.com www.fromnaturewithlove.com Sharon Collins Southern Soapers Pamela Comeau Elizabeth Corning www.southernsoapers.com Judi Cote www.brambleberry.com Selena Cozart Shay and Company Cedar Lane Farm A Perfect Scent, LLC Salome's Simply Delightful Creations Lori Curry Magellan's Gift Robert Davis Mary Delmonico Core Studio 291 Stratus Insurance www.stratusinc.com From Nature With Love Southern Sundries Sharon Collins/Sole Proprietor 6 Diamond Sponsor www.essentialwholesale.com Bramble Berry www.shayandcompany.com New Directions Aromatics www.newdirectionsaromatics.com Soapers Choice Columbus Foods www.soaperschoice.com 2010 Conference Highlights See www.soapguild.org/conference for all the details! ▶▶ Conference is open to members and non-members. ▶▶ Registration includes attendance to all classes, demonstrations and workshops, participation in door prizes, drawing and prize awards, sponsored events, optional participation in Soaper's Showcase and meals and snacks. ▶▶ Main keynote speaker, Ambassador Carol Moseley Braun, owner and founder of Good Food Organics, former US Senator from Illinois, and former US Ambassador to New Zealand. ▶▶ Second Keynote Speaker, Robert Tisserand, author of two important books on Aromatherapy: The Art of Aromatherapy: The Healing and Beautifying Properties of the Essential Oils of Flowers and Herbs; and The Art of Aromatherapy: To Heal and Tend the Body. ▶▶ Sixteen (16!) different speakers, each a professional in their field, covering a wide array of subjects of interest to all soapmakers. ▶▶ Twenty-two (22!) sessions ▶▶ Vendors and Suppliers ▶▶ Goodies and Prizes ▶▶ Essential Wholesale special event ▶▶ Wholesale Supplies Plus special event ▶▶ HSMG Annual Membership Meeting (HSMG members only) ▶▶ Soapmaker Certification Testing (HSMG members only) ▶▶ Annual Awards Dinner 7 Welcome New Members! Luisa DePaiva Purple Rain Vineyard Danielle Devore-Haden Devore Soaps Time and Temperature (continued from page 1) recommended lye concentration averaged between 260 ppt (26.0% reference [1]) and 340 ppt (34.0%, reference [3]). For this study, five water portions were used, with equivalent lye concentrations between 25.0% and 50.0%. Table 1 shows the equivalent lye concentrations and moisture concentrations for these soaps. JoAnn Diaz Table 1. DSC Samples Palm Beach Soaps, LLC Darlene Dollins Moisture Content (ppt) Delight1000Lye288Aq0 (Low-Water) 500 112 JMC2009.3.4.A72 Delight1000Lye288Aq72 417 159 JMC2009.3.4.A144 Delight1000Lye288Aq144 (Medium-Water) 333 201 JMC2009.3.4.A216 Delight1000Lye288Aq216 292 239 JMC2009.3.4.A288 Delight1000Lye288Aq288 (High-Water) 250 274 Formula Michelle Donohue JMC2009.3.4.A0 Mary Ehlenfeldt Homesteaders Cache Estelril Enterprises Pamela Elliott Guyde M. Evasco Molly Favret Sally Feihel Adirondack Suds & Scents Lisa Fitzgerald The Glycerin Soap Company Mark Fleischman Fleischman's Handmade Trina Floyd Chinaberry Dreams Soapworks Ellen Foote Fleeta Fore 8 Effective Lye Concentration (ppt) Batch Code Doll Babies Farm Ingredients for each soap were added to a 500 mL polypropylene bottle which was then shaken for 15 seconds using a modified paint shaker. The raw soap was then poured into a nest of 6-8 Styrofoam coffee cups fitted with a Styrofoam lid, observation window, and thermometer. The nest of coffee cups attempted to insulate the soap, preventing it from losing heat to the surroundings and simulating the environment found in a large block mold. Soaps were mixed at several starting temperatures and the temperature of each soap was recorded as a function of time. (continued on page 9) Time and Temperature (continued from page 8) The less moisture concentration, the harder that bar of soap will be. If you place that bar into a bowl of water, however, two phases are in evidence. The bar picks up some water and softens; the water picks up some soap and becomes cloudy. The softened soap may contain 15% water and the soapy water may contain 1% soap, the exact proportions depending on the relative sizes of the bar and the bowl. on page 9) (continued Figure 1. Delight/Water Phases 60 o 80 200 neat (gel) 160 curd + neat 120 40 20 0 80 curd (solid) Temperature / C 100 300 F Moisture Content / ppt 200 100 o Ice, water, and steam exemplify the common phases: solid, liquid, and gas. If you were to drink a cup of hot chocolate, you would have no trouble distinguishing the phases involved. You would say that the cup in your hands is a solid, the hot chocolate in that cup is a liquid, and the steam wafting its way to your nose is a gas. But what about the marshmallows? When in the bag, they maintain their apparently-solid shapes. When placed into the hot chocolate, they gradually slump into apparently-liquid goo. Placed into a microwave oven, they expand like balloons. The phase structure of the marshmallow is more complicated than you might have thought. The phase structure of soap is no less so. Figure 1 shows the phases present under the conditions of temperature and moisture found in the soap pot. Temperature / Phases 40 Aq 0 Aq 144 Aq 288 (continued on page 10) You would still have no trouble saying that the bar is a solid and the soapy water a liquid. But what if the soap were to become so soft that it slumped into a goo at the bottom of the bowl? What if the water became so thick with soap that it could no longer be poured from the bowl? Soap chemists have identified many, many phases of soap, some of which are clearly solid, others that are clearly liquid, and some that seem to cross the boundary between solid and liquid.5 Two phases in particular are central to our discussion of time and temperature. Your solid bar of soap may contain as many as three distinct solid phases at room temperature. The differences between these phases are subtle, however, and need not concern us. Soapmakers refer to this mixed solid phase as soap curd. When heated, curd melts into a gelatinous phase, neat soap, that looks something like petroleum jelly. The temperature at which soap curd melts into neat soap depends on the moisture concentration. 5 For a detailed discussion of the phase structure of soap, see reference [8]. 9 Welcome New Members! Debra Fox Berkeley Soapworks Pamela Franklin CahabaWaters Bath & Body Cheryl Fraser Essence Soap Carissa Fulkerson Michelle Gambler Lather Lovely Lynn Gardipee Natural Beauty of Las Vegas, LLC Katherine Gavin Soap For The Soul, LLC Teri Gibson Body Products by Celeste Kendra Gilbert Fae Bae Joyce Gilmore Victorian Charm Karyn Gold Pirouette Heidi Goldberg Bodygoodies Kim Gonzaga Stella Marie Soap Company Michael Goonan Tracey Gurley Kim Hall Virtues of Nature Carol Hamilton Up North Scents Tara Hansen Dr Angela Harpe DAE Natural Soaps Robert Hastings WonderBar Health & Beauty Jill Hennig Sweet Pea Creations, LLC Tim Hering Soap Alchemy LLC Sheila Higgins Sinclaire's Soap Cynthia High M'Lady's Caroline Ho Elizabeth Hogensen Ambrosia Soap Company Katherin Hunter The Earth's Cauldron Rebecca Hunter Pearlcreek Goat Milk Soap Co. Patricia Hyland Nilda Irizarry Fruitful Essence 10 Time and Temperature (continued from page 9) At low temperature, soap appears as soap curd, regardless of its moisture concentration. At high temperature, it appears as neat soap. The “melting point,” however, is very dependent on moisture concentration. Low-water soaps melt at temperatures near the boiling point of water; high-water soaps melt at significantly lower temperatures. Medium-water soaps like Delight1000Lye288Aq144 begin melting at about 60±C, but the phase change is not complete until about 70±C. Between these two temperatures, both phases are present—pockets of interspersed neat and curd soap. It might be said, then, that soap curd begins melting at one temperature and finishes at a higher temperature. Similarly, neat soap begins freezing at one temperature and finishes at another, lower temperature. A high-water soap, however, melts and freezes at approximately the same temperature. Studying Figure 1 allows us to understand the phase changes that occur in the soap pot during saponification. Temperature Saponification is an exothermic reaction—it releases heat. Some of this heat is absorbed by the raw soap and its temperature rises. Some of the heat is lost to the mold and to the room; their temperatures also rise. And if the temperature of the soap is in the appropriate range, some of the heat is absorbed as the raw soap melts. In thinking about time and temperature, it will help us to remember that the heat produced will either raise the temperature of the soap and its surroundings or it will change the soap from one phase to another. Let us imagine that we mix the oil and lye for a low-water formula at a relatively low temperature. Let us imagine, as well, that the container is so well insulated that we may initially neglect heat lost to the mold and the room. As the saponification reaction proceeds, the heat produced warms the raw soap and its temperature rises. At the same time, however, the oil and lye are consumed and, as they are depleted, the reaction eventually slows. (continued on page 12) Supply Business for Sale Established niche market, consistently grossing over $80,000 per year. Comes with high-end e-commerce site with excellent google rankings, solid customer base, existing stock and training in the business. Excellent add-on to an existing business or as a standalone entity. [email protected] Gertrude Johnson Katherine Johnson Farm Maid Soap Joshua Jones Liberty Artisan Brands Robert Jones The Kingston Soap Company Vicki Jurica Prairie Belle's Cottage Jennifer Kam Sheun DOBO Company Nora Kantwerk Prairie Essence Kathy King Elissa Klaver SALUS Victoria Koehmlein Victorian Divine Indulgence Elke Lagace Elke's Essentials Shila N Laing Betty Lamm K'Bees Cheryl Laneres Bubbles & Bubbles Dawn Lawrence Aurora Naturel Dawn Lawson Country Crow Arts & Crafts Patty Ledbetter Nature Soapworks Camille Lee Soyphisticated Candles Jeffrey Lee Fizzles Bath And Body Heather Lewis Lucky Bamboo Monica Logsdon Delaware Candle & Soap Co. Alexandra Lucas Christine Lyons CL Apothecary Patricia Manley F o Temperature / C o 120 40 Aq0 Aq72 Aq144 Aq216 Aq288 20 0 0 80 40 50 100 150 Time / min 200 The highest curve tracks the temperature of a low-water soap, Delight1000Lye288Aq0,with the oil and lye mixed at 40±C (104±F). After 37 minutes in the mold, the temperature peaks at 84±C (183±F). If the mold had been better insulated, it might have peaked later and at a higher temperature. But even this peak temperature is nowhere near the melting point of this low-water soap and so the temperature simply rises for a while, peaks, and falls. The lowest curve in Figure 2 tracks the temperature of a high-water soap, Delight1000Lye288Aq288. The temperature of this soap rises only to 45±C (113±F) a mere 24 minutes after mixing. Clearly, this high-water soap must saponify more slowly than its low-water cousin. Because they contain the same quantities of oil and lye, both reactions must release the same amount of heat, but the low-water soap does so in a short amount of time while the high-water soap releases heat gradually over a longer period. Delight1000Lye288Aq216 is particularly interesting—it maintains a nearly constant temperature for a long period of time. The lesson of Figure 2 is pretty clear: low-water soaps saponify more quickly than high-water soaps. What happens if we Figure 3. Low-Water Saponification increase the temperature of the oil and lye before 100 they are mixed? Figure 3 80 tracks the temperatures of 60 three soaps, all Delight1000Lye288Aq0, identical except for 40 their mixing temperatures. hot 20 warm The soap labeled cold was cold 0 mixed at 40±C (104±F), 0 50 100 150 Time / min that labeled warm at 58±C (136±F), and that labeled hot at 65±C (149±F). 200 solid 160 120 80 F Mary Johnson Retriever Soapworks 160 60 o Linda Jines "Sweet Cakes Soaps, Inc." 200 80 Temperature / Morgan Street Temperature / Pamela Jameson Sharon Jenkins Figure 2. Low-Temperature Saponification 100 C SoapArt At some point, heat will be lost to the mold and room at the same rate that it is produced by the reaction; the temperature will stop rising and, as the rate of heat production falls further, the soap will begin to cool. We can see this behavior in Figure 2. o Jamie Jackson Time and Temperature (continued from page 10) Temperature / Welcome New Members! 40 200 The lowest curve of this graph is identical to the highest curve of Figure 2. From these curves we can see that the warmer the starting temperature, the sooner and higher the temperature peaks. This trend indicates that warmer soaps saponify more quickly than cooler ones. Coupled with the information from the previous figure, we can say that warm, low-water soaps saponify more quickly than cool, high-water soaps. This would be the end of the story were it not for the possibility of a phase change during saponification. Felicity Bath & Body (continued on page 14) 12 Shrink Film (continued from page 4) The newest innovation in wrapping soap is truly biodegradeable polyolefin, now produced by Bolore under the Biolefin label. It is an "oxo-biodegradable" film. It contains a new, non-toxic, food-safe additive (TDPA) that will break down in 3 - 5 years in any recyclable environment, completely returning the film and all the plastic in it to the bio-cycle. Unlike PLA, it does not leave plastic particulates — all parts of it break down completely. With the new Biolefin product, biodegradable shrink film is within the grasp of the soapmaking community. It is even available with micro-perforations! The shelf-life of this biodegradable film is approximately 18 months to 2 years in a controlled environment. The cost of wrapping your typical bar is roughly 2-3 cents per bar using smaller, converted, 500' rolls Purchasing in larger rolls can further reduce the cost. Summary The sniffy customer that touches nose to soap can inadvertently leave bacteria behind which can take on a life of its own. Bacteria encourages signs of "soap gone bad" (spotting, mold, and/or odor) — a veritable "flu stew". Nearly every soapmaker has stories about customers sniffing and then putting that bar back on the pile to pick up a "fresh" one to actually buy. If that's not a strong reason to wrap soap and still keep it sniffable, what is? • Botanical specialist, Herbal Teas, Bulk Herbs, for all your cooking, personal experiments, arts and crafts for pleasure or just to appreciate the natural scents. We also offer a great choice of oils, fragrances, clays, containers etc.. www.dermakreme.com - www.aromesbeaute.com 370 Rue du Moulin, Kingsbury Qc. Canada J0B 1X0 819-826-3535 1-800-668-4534 13 Olive Leaf Soap Aydilien Martina Rija Soap Cheryl Masani Natural Approaches Wendy McCullough Sally B Farms Kelly McDowell-DeVires Terri McGavock Kiss Soaps Jennifer McMullen The Land of Milk and Honey Kathy McQueen Elvenred Steve Meka STEM Eka Meyer Elise Meys Susan Miles Maple Hill Soap Christina Miller Patricia Millix Millix Family Farm D J Mims Thomas Moeller Left Coast Soap & Candle Tamila Morgan Urban Farm Naturals Christelle Munnelly Moon Root Carolyn Mutin-Schexnayder Kara Nelson Red Rock Springs Ryan North Temecula Soap & Candle Co Veronica Nourse Cupertino Soap Co Cindy Novack Candles and Supplies.com, Inc. Merryn Oliveira Body by M Randall E. Oliver Rituale Soapworks Denise Orloff Joanna Ormond Ocean Treasures Glycerine Soaps 14 In the following discussion, we make the simplifying assumption that soap is produced as oil and lye react, and that the melting behavior of this oil/soap/water mixture is similar to that of a soap/water mixture. Let us see how far this assumption can take us in understanding soaps that undergo phase changes during saponification. F Victoria Marsted Christine Martin o Left Coast Soap and Candle Co. Temperature / Cynthia Markham Neil Marshall 20 0 hot warm cold 0 40 50 100 150 Time / min 200 Aq 144 (Medium-Water) 100 200 80 neat solid 60 160 120 40 20 hot warm cold 80 Temperature / oF Clean Getaway Soap Company Before we consider this possibility, however, I must point out that the melting points of Figure 1 were determined by heating Figure 4. Medium-Water Saponification finished soaps, not raw Aq 72 ones. The technique used 100 200 to produce this phase neat solid diagram, Differential 80 160 Scanning Calorimetry (DSC), would be much 60 complicated were we to 120 40 use it while the soap was still saponifying. 80 Temperature / oC Lyndsey Mann Time and Temperature (continued from page 12) Temperature / oC Welcome New Members! Figure 4 tracks the 40 0 temperature for two soaps, 0 50 100 150 200 Time / min Delight1000Lye288Aq72 and Delight1000Lye288Aq144, each at three starting temperatures. In each graph, a horizontal line shows the boundary between soap curd and neat soap.6 The Aq72 soap behaves much like a low-water soap. The temperature of the hot soap rises quickly to a peak and then cools relatively rapidly. The cold soap warms more slowly and stays warm longer, indicating that the saponification is slower at low temperature. Even the hot soap, however, is just shy of the boundary between curd and neat soap. Given our simplifying assumption, we expect that this soap solidifies after mixing and remains solid throughout the saponification. This is exactly what was observed for this soap. We suppose that if the soap had been a little warmer, it would have entered the neat phase. The Aq144 soaps mixed at the lowest two starting temperatures behave as we might expect. They warm and cool more slowly than their low-water cousins and their peak temperatures are lower. At the highest temperature, however, the peak temperature is nearly as high as that of Aq72 at the same starting temperature. 6 Recall from Figure 1 that these soaps begin melting at about 60±C. The boundaries shown here are the temperatures at which the melting is complete. (continued on page 16) 15 Elise Pearlstine Tambela, LLC Erica Pence Carolyn Penrose Carma Soap Co. Crystelle Perlas Eleanor Phillips Soma and Soul Katherine Phillips Elder Forest Soap Mary Phipps Pleasant River Soap Company Julie Pieper The Parsonage Vickie Pierce The Stone Wytch Claude Poissonniez Sky Valley Farm, Inc. Dian Poitras The Gingham Turtle Soaps & Such David Powers Stone Cottage Soapworks Inc Ashley Quinn ertha Harold Rader Rader Soap Company Tracy Ragan Ashfield Soap Company Ashley Ray Ruth Redmon Anton Karl Farms, Inc. Michelle Rhoades Jennifer Riter Butterfly Creations Adrianne Roberts Fragrant Offering LLC Gina Roberts Soapcraft Geraldine Robinson Stacey Root Good Natured Soaps LLC Ann Rose Botany Bath Works Kellie Rowe Sherol Roy Soap Me Up! 16 Given our earlier observations, it is easy to explain the behavior of the high-water soaps detailed in Figure 5. The boundary between curd and neat soaps is approximately the same for both soaps. Soaps that begin at or above this temperature enter the neat phase, though some earlier than others. When they enter neat phase, the temperatures of these soaps increase as the rate of saponification increases. Soaps started at a low temperature, however, warm only slightly and stay warm for a long period of time, never entering the neat phase. We may expect high-water soaps to enter the neat phase as long as their starting temperatures are sufficiently high. We may now generalize the phase behavior of soap during saponification: ◊ For soaps that begin at the same temperature, low-water soaps saponify more quickly than high-water soaps and, as a consequence, reach higher peak temperatures. ◊ The peak temperatures of low-water soaps, however, are below their melting points and we do not expect them to enter the neat phase. ◊ The neat phase is attained only by highwater soaps heated to sufficiently high initial temperatures. ◊ A soap may be forced into the neat phase by simultaneously raising its temperature and its moisture concentration. The exact temperature required, however, will depend on the size and shape of the mold, on the mix of oils, and on the presence of any scents or additives that hasten or retard saponification. Figure 5. High-Water Saponification Aq 216 100 200 80 neat solid 60 160 120 40 20 0 80 hot warm cold 0 F Millcreek Valley Farm o TinCup Arts. LLC Heidi Owens Hart Garaleen Parks Temperature / Ann OSullivan Christie Ott 40 50 100 150 Time / min 200 Aq 288 (High-Water) 100 200 80 neat solid 60 160 120 40 20 0 80 hot warm cold 0 Temperature / oF World Label.com Moreover, the peak temperature of this soap is higher than its melting point. We would expect to see this soap enter the neat phase; that is exactly what was observed. A small spot of darker, gelatinous soap grew larger and larger until the entire soap looked like Vaseline. The increase in temperature as the soap melted indicates that the rate of saponification is higher in the neat phase than in the curd. We are also vindicated in our simplifying assumption—the observed phase change in the raw soap coincides with that in finished soap of the same composition. Temperature / oC Russell Ossendryver Time and Temperature (continued from page 14) Temperature / oC Welcome New Members! 40 50 100 150 Time / min 200 (continued on page 18) 30%#) LYE Suppliers ! ,4 ) % 3 3 ) . # % for the Handcrafted Soap Maker Potassium Hydroxide (Liquid & Flakes) Sodium Hydroxide (Beads) Available to soap makers in convenient UPS and freight approved containers. Up to 24 lb shipped without Hazmat fees. (800) 323-3040 www.BoyerCorporation.com PO Box 10 LaGrange, IL 60525 VISA and MasterCard accepted The Quality Name in Chemical Specialties for 95 Years 17 Welcome New Members! Nancy Ruiz-Hudson Semblance Soaps Annmarie Rung Goodnight Moon Soaps Meghan Runyon Dreaming Tree Soapworks Charleen Satkowski Harper Hill Farm Diana Sauer Goat Milk Therapy LLC Julie Scarpato Bare Scentsations Jennifer Schoenfeld Naked Body Care Inc Jean Scholtes KIND Soap Company Lisa Seaman The Velvet Pod Carole Serotzke Olive Leaf Soap Elizabeth Sewell Scents & Sensilbility, Inc. Arcana Shanks "Bubble Hut, Inc." Cari Shannon Coquette Bath & Body Kathy Sholders LP Duo, LLC Lesley Sierra Brookes Forest House Herbals Silvia Simpson Sinami Soap Company Emilitza Singh Melanie Skelton SkinTastic Creations Ruth Small Nature's Silk Judy Smallwood Smallwood Simples Becky Snell Botanica Apothecary Amanda Snyder Primitive Earth Soap Co LLC Renee Solano-Szuba Michael Spurgeon Michaels CWD Linda Steadman Scrub Jay Naturals Jeannie Steele The OV Soap Company Louise Storkey Herbal Escents Melissa Stowe Mellabelle Designs Time and Temperature (continued from page 16) To Gel or Not To Gel We have yet to consider whether or not neat (gel) soap is desirable. Three of our formulas produced soaps that melted at the highest initial temperature, but not at the lowest. We compared the hot and cold varieties of Aq144, Aq216, and Aq288 but found no differences in appearance, alkalinity, or texture between soaps of the same formula. Only in one respect did we find a difference between soaps that had melted and those that had not. Following an experiment described in reference [7], we cut cylinders of finished soap and suspended them in cups of water for a period of 6 hours. In each case, the soaps that had melted (reached gel stage) swelled less than those that had not. The picture (to right) shows five Aq216 soaps with starting temperatures ranging from 40±C to 70±C. The three leftmost soaps remained solid during saponification while the two rightmost ones melted during saponification. Even between the soaps started at 60±C and 65±C, there is a striking difference in swelling between the soaps that did and did not melt. We might wonder whether hot soaps swell less than cold ones, regardless of whether they melted. Hot and cold varieties of low-water soaps (none of which melted) showed no difference in swelling behavior, so we believe that melting, not temperature alone, is responsible for this difference. While we might expect the melted soaps to maintain their shapes better in the soap dish, the difference is so subtle that we can find little reason to prefer soaps that have melted over those that have not. Within a partially-melted soap, however, there may be a visible boundary between the areas that melted and those that did not. For this reason, soapmakers may prefer to make soap that has melted completely or not at all. This study has focused on a single, unscented oil blend. The temperature boundary between neat and curd soap will be different for other blends. The rate (continued on page 19) 18 Time and Temperature (continued from page 19) of heat loss, and hence the peak temperature, will also depend on the size and shape of the mold. For this reason, we can make no dogmatic claim in favor of one particular starting temperature or moisture concentration. But we expect the relationship between temperature, moisture concentration, phase behavior, and time to be similar for other oil blends. If you have a blend that melts in a particular mold at a particular starting temperature, you may expect that decreasing the temperature and the water portion may prevent the next batch from melting. If you have a blend that does not melt, increasing the temperature and water portion may cause the next batch to melt. And if you have a blend that melts partially, you may adjust the temperature and moisture to ensure that the next batch behaves as you wish. For delicate scents, you may prefer a soap that stays warm without getting too hot. A soap that has melted, however, may maintain its shape better in the soap dish. The results of this study will allow you to choose the conditions of temperature and moisture that best suit your needs. Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank Mike Lawson and Columbus Foods [9] for the donation of oils that supported this research. They would also like to thank Jody Aiken, Steve Sealschott, David Bohlen, Kassy Pelzel, and Pauline Vu of Proctor and Gamble for the DSC and XRD data that made the construction of Figure 1 possible. References [1] Ann Bramson, Soap: Making it, Enjoying it, 1972, ISBN 0-911104-57-7. [2] Susan Cavitch, The Soapmaker’s Companion, 1997, ISBN 0-88266-965-6. [3] Robert McDaniel, Essentially Soap, Krause Publications, Iola, WI, 2000, 125 pp., ISBN 0-87341-832-8. [4] Anne Watson, Smart Soapmaking, 2007, ISBN 978-0938497-42-4. [5] Official Methods and Practices of the AOCS, American Oil Chemists’ Society, Champaign, IL, 2003. [6] Kevin M Dunn, “The “Water Discount””, Journal of the Handcrafted Soap Makers Guild (http://soapguild.org), 2008, 2008-2. [7] R. H. Ferguson, F. B.. Rosevear, and R. C. Stillman, “Solid Soap Phases”, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry, 1943, 35, (9), pp. 1005-1012. [8] Antonio Neto and Silvio Salinas, The Physics of Lyotropic Liquid Crystals, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2005, ISBN 0198525508. [9] Columbus Foods, (www.SoapersChoice.com/). 19 Welcome New Members! Lisa Tarris Seascape Soap Company Shari Taylor L'air Bleu Rashunda Tramble Zehra Trncic-Cedar Enigma Soap & Bath Shih Yun Tuan-Ebert Evergood Farm Patricia Tyson Snowy Owl Cove Roberto Valdez Earthistry Andrew Van Nest Faith's Charity Soap Company Jessica Vazquez I'NARU' Bath & Body Kristin Wahlne 3 Walnuts Heather Walls Honu Naturals, LLC Marc Washburn Natural Bath & Body Shop Julie Weghorn Just Specialty Products Amy Westrick Vivid Mystics Donnetta Whitney Sherri Wibert Carrie Wilkison Ella G. & Co. Jennifer Williams Bullfrogs & Butterflies Baby Boutique Kat Wiranowski Sudstress Christi Wollin Karen Woods Suki Soap of Sweetwater Farm Sonia Worthington Herbal Bliss Soaps Stacie Wyatt Luster Canyon, Inc. Jennifer Yates Eileen Yehlik e.j. Prim Cedric Young Mother Nature Health Products Rebecca Youngberry Bubbles & Stuff Pamela S Zeirott In addition to having MSDS sheets on hand for any hazardous materials on hand, proper signage is also a good idea. You don’t really want your emergency responder to have to read the whole sheet instead if they are there trying to deal with a fire, flood or other emergency situation! The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) believes that MSDSs and labeling of materials with the NFPA hazard diamond are relevant for anything flammable. The NFPA hazard diamond uses a standard (blue) system for identification of hazards of materials for emergency response. By seeing the hazard diamond and/or other signage, they know exactly how to handle the materials. (red) 3 The Hazard Diamond for both sodium (NaOH) and potassium (KOH) hydroxide is shown here. The blue box (left side) signifies the health hazard, the red box shows the flammability, the yellow box shows reactivity and the white box on the bottom shows other hazard information. A complete explanation of the hazard diamond ratings is available here: http://safety.nmsu.edu/programs/chem_ safety/hazcom_NFPA_labels.htm. The page also has a link to a searchable database of chemicals to get their rating(s). 0 (white) 1 (yellow) NaOH or KOH Hazard Diamond Of course, all lye containers should also be labeled as corrosive, both for your protection and for the protection of your employees, contractors and any emergency responders. Essential and fragrance oils may also pose health or safety issues in the event of a major spill, fire or other emergency. Your supplier should provide you with MSDS sheets that will give you the pertinent information. If you have large quantities of flammable essential or fragrance oils, they should be appropriately labeled so they can be properly dealt with in an emergency. Understanding your raw ingredients, knowing the safety issues they might present in the case of a fire or other disaster is the first step in keeping you, your employees, family and emergency responders safe. Getting and reading the MSDS sheets for your ingredients (especially those that could be hazardous in large quantities) is the first step. If you have any questions about your raw materials, contact your supplier for more information. Resources Soaps 'n Such http://www.nfpa.org/ Tanya Zito http://www.msdssearch.com/DBLinksN.htm Canticle Herbs and Botanicals 20 MSDS Sheets (continued from page 1) http://www.osha.gov/ http://safety.nmsu.edu/programs/chem_safety/hazcom_NFPA_labels.htm. Handcrafted Soapmakers Guild, Inc. PO Box 5103 Portland, OR 97208-5103 (See pages 6 - 7 for more info) PRSRT STD US POSTAGE PAID PORTLAND, OR PERMIT #3540
© Copyright 2024