Female agency, mobility and Socio-cultural change

Conference
Female Agency,
Mobility and
Socio-cultural
Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Cover Photographs:
© UNU-GCM Photo/Tatiana Diniz
Barcelona, 2015
The feminisation of migration is one of the most
significant social patterns to have emerged in
the course of the last century. Too often, female
migrants occupy vulnerable positions in their
host societies, engaging in domestic work, sex
work and other unregulated sectors. Despite
being so vulnerable and despite established
patterns of exploitation, the numbers of women
who choose to migrate is rising. This conference
focuses on this phenomenon, in order to better
understand why and how migration may offer
routes to empowerment to women. Specific
areas of focus include the extent to which
migration offers women new sociocultural
horizons as they move between different
regions of the world, while also considering links
between mobilities and mobilisations through
for example, digital mobilities and mobilisations
of women and ideas. This conference will
address issues including female agency,
diasporas and transnationalism, labour and
decent work, processes of identity construction,
the sociocultural reconstruction of home, work
and urban spaces and policy responses to
female mobilites. It will put academic research
into dialogue with debates in the United Nations
that address gender discrimination and the role
of female migrants in development agendas.
In addition to keynote lectures and panel
presentations, the conference will feature events
that engage with artistic representations
of the themes.
4
5
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Keynote speakerS
Thematic areas
Professor Maggie O’Neill
Durham University
1. Multi-lateral Policy Engagement
on Gender and Mobility
Professor of Criminology in the School of Applied
Social Sciences and Fellow of the Wolfson Research
Institute for Health and Wellbeing
2. Women, Diasporas
and Transnationalism
Dr. Maria Jaschok
University of Oxford
3. Narratives and Visual Representation
of Female Mobility
Director, International Gender Studies Centre,
Lady Margaret Hall
Professor Christiane Timmerman
University of Antwerp
Professor of Anthropology and Director of the
Center of Migration and Intercultural Studies (CeMIS)
Professor Maria Paradiso
University of Sannio
Professor of Geography and Planning
4. Gender, Migrant Labour
and Empowerment
5. Legal Discourses on Gender
and Migration
6
7
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Contents
Conference Schedule 6
Summaries of Thematic Areas and Panels 16
Alphabetical List of Contributors
with Abstracts and Biographies 20
For your
Information
UNU-GCM is pleased to welcome you
to this conference on Female Agency,
Mobility and Socio-cultural Change. All
participants should be aware that:
»»Filming and photography will be taking
place during the event. The photographs
and videos produced may be used in
the public dissemination of the work of
UNU-GCM.
»»This is an academic conference. As such,
the opinions expressed and discussions
arising represent personal opinions and
not those of UNU-GCM. UNU-GCM asks
that all contributions be responsible and
substantiated by research.
List of Participating Institutions 50
9
CONFERENCE
SCHEDULE
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
11th JuNE
09:00Registration
09:45 Welcome and Opening Addresses
12th JuNE
10:00 Keynote Presentation 1
09:30 Keynote Presentation 3
11:00Coffee
10:30Coffee
11:30 Parallel Sessions 1
11:00 Parallel Sessions 3
13:15 Group Photograph
13:30Lunch
13:00 Inauguration of Women of the
World
15:00 Parallel Sessions 2
13:30Lunch
16:30Coffee
15:00 Keynote Presentation 4
17:00 Keynote Presentation 2
16:00 Session 4
18:15 Bus to CCCB
17:45Coffee
19:00 The New Barcelonians: Migration,
Work and Family in the City,
followed by reception at the CCCB
18:00 Screening of Becky´s Journey
and Q&A
19:00 End of Conference
11
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
11th June
10
REGISTRATION
09:00-09:30
Official Opening
9:45-10:00
11:00-11:30
Hammarskjöld
Room
Parallel
SESSIONs 1
Welcome and Opening Addresses
Prof. Parvati Nair, Director, UNU-GCM
Mr. Manuel Manonelles, Director General
for Multilateral and European Affairs,
Generalitat of Catalonia
Mr. Joaquim Llimona, Commissioner for
International Relations and Cooperation,
City Hall of Barcelona.
KEYNOTE
PRESENTATION 1
The Hammarskjöld Room is the large room
found on the mezzanine level of the UNUGCM office space.
The Thant Room is the round room found
to the right as you enter the UNU-GCM
office space.
The Official Opening will be held in the
Hammarskjöld Room.
coffee
11:30-13:15
Thematic Area 1: Multi-lateral
Policy Engagement on Gender
and Mobility
»»Discourses and Practices about Marriage,
Gender and Sexuality. Mothers and
Daughters between Morocco and Italy,
Giulia D’Odorico, University of Padua
(Italy)
Panel 1: Multi-lateral Policy
Engagement on Gender and
Mobility
HAMMARSKJÖLD
ROOM
»»Making Claims on Duty Bearers: Migrant
Women Workers Advocacy and Organising Strategies, Sarah Gammage, UN
Women (USA)
Chair: Parvati Nair, UNU-GCM
Panel 2: Transnational Families
Chair: Reyes Cruylles de Peratallada,
Toledo International Centre for Peace
(CITpax)
Chair: Parvati Nair, UNU-GCM
Professor Maggie O´Neill, Durham
University
Thematic Area 2: Women,
Diasporas and Transnationalism
Hammarskjöld
Room
10:00-11:00
Women, Well-being and
Community: Enacting and
Building Cultural Citizenship
Using Participatory Arts and
Participatory Action Research
(PAR) with Women Seeking
Asylum and Refuge
Thant Room
»»Women in Trafficking in Persons; Results
from the UNODC Global Report on
Trafficking in Persons, Fabrizio Sarrica,
United Nations Office on Drug and Crime
(Austria)
»»Migration, Gender and Social Inclusion in
India, Marina Faetanini, UNESCO (India)
»»METROPOLIS Women International
Network, Montserrat Pallarès Parellada,
Metropolis (Spain)
»»The Struggles and Strategies of Syrian
Refugee Women in the Context of Displacement in Egypt, Nourhan Abdel Aziz,
American University in Cairo (Egypt)
»»The Feminization of Migration from Moldova and the Implications for Children
“Left Behind”, Michaella Vanore, Maastricht Graduate School of Governance/
UNU-MERIT (The Netherlands)
group
photograph
13:15
lunch
13:30-15:00
12
13
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
PARALLEL
SESSIONs 2
15:00-16:30
Hammarskjöld
Room
Thematic Area 3: Narratives
and Visual Representations of
Female Mobility
Panel 3: Narratives of Female
Mobility
Chair: Dominika Gasiorowski,
Queen Mary University of London
»»Liminal Spaces and Moving Subjects in a
Context of Crisis: Gender, Emotions and
Agentic Transnational Cultural Production in Eastern European Migration to
Greece, Anastasia Christou, Middlesex
University (UK)
»»New Narratives of the Mediterranean:
the woman gaze, Federica Frediani, Università della Svizzera italiana (Switzerland)
»»Home-Work: The Gender Politic of Urban
Immigrant Relocation, Parvati Nair, UNUGCM
KEYNOTE
PRESENTATION 2
17:00-18:00
Thant Room
Thematic Area 5: Legal
Discourses on Gender and
Migration
HAMMARSKJÖLD
ROOM
Panel 4: Legal Discourses on
Female Migration
Sources of Authority of Female
Leadership in Islam – Female
ahong and qingzhen nüsi
(Women’s Mosques) in China
Chair: Lorenzo Gabrielli,
Pompeu Fabra University
Dr. Maria Jaschok,
University of Oxford
»»Who are the “Virtuous” Taiwanese Women? Surveillance, Survival and Law, YiChien Chen, Shih Hsin University (Taiwan)
Chair: Parvati Nair, UNU-GCM
»»Forced Displacement, Transitional Justice
and Women’s Empowerment, Marta Gil,
University of Valencia (Spain)
18:15
»» Women, Work and EU Citizenship,
Sandra Mantu, Radboud University
Nijmegen (The Netherlands)
»»Women in the Flemish Labour Market:
Disempowerment through Sticky Floors?,
Kate Neyts, UNU-CRIS (Belgium)
coffee
16:30-17:00
Coach to CCCB
Transportation by coach to Centre de
Cultura Contemporània de Barcelona
(CCCB) in the city centre (one way only)
Montalegre 5, 08001 Barcelona
Women of the
World
19:00
The New Barcelonians: Migration, Work
and Family in the City
15
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
12th June
14
PARALLEL
SESSIONs 3
11:00-13:00
Hammarskjöld
Room
Thematic Area 2: Women,
Diasporas and Transnationalism
Panel 5: Female Diasporas and
Socio-cultural Change
KEYNOTE
PRESENTATION 3
9:30-10:30
HAMMARSKJÖLD
ROOM
Dynamics in Female Migration
and Integration. A Case Study
from Belgium
Prof. Christiane Timmerman, University of
Antwerp
Chair: Parvati Nair, UNU-GCM
coffee
10:30-11:00
Thant Room
Thematic Area 4: Gender,
Migrant Labour and
Empowerment
Panel 6: Female Mobility, Agency
and Empowerment
Chair: Herman Bashiron Mendolicchio,
University of Barcelona (Spain)
Chair: Isolina Ballesteros,
City University of New York (USA)
»»Status Beyond Labour: The Empowerment of Filipina Women in Barcelona,
Megha Amrith, UNU-GCM
»»Internally Displaced Women in Ayacucho: Their Key Role in Peacebuilding
and Social Reconstruction, Eva Gracía
Cordoba and Juncal Fdez-Garayzábal,
Comillas Pontifical University (Spain)
»»Intersections between Gender, ‘Home’
and Activism among Women’s Organizations on the Myanmar-Thailand Border,
Annabelle Wilkins, Queen Mary University of London (UK)
»»Community Activism among Black Young
Women in Portugal: Daily Engagements
towards Citizenship and Social Cohesion,
Rosana Albuquerque, Universidade
Aberta (Portugal)
»»The Gendered Burden of Poverty: Unravelling the Relationship between Women,
Family, and Economics in Cambodia,
Brandais York, University of Melbourne
(Australia)
»»The Experience of Women Diasporas:
Integration, Civil Society Participation
and Socio-cultural Change, Valeria Bello,
UNU-GCM
»»Migration, Stigma and Empowerment:
Former Global Factory Workers Negotiating New Identities in Sri Lanka’s Villages,
Sandya Hewamanne, University of Essex
(UK)
»»Afghan Women in Germany betwixt
Border Crossing, Media Coverage and
Gender Shifting(s), Diana Sherzada, Ludwig Maximillians University (Germany)
»»Emotions in Care Work: a Worker’s Best
Asset or Biggest Threat?, Nina Sahraoui,
London Metropolitan University (UK)
16
17
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Inauguration
of Women of
the World
Session 4
13:00-13:30
16:00-17:45
Home and Work in Barcelona Photograph
Exhibit
Hammarskjöld
Room
Lunch
13:30-15:00
KEYNOTE
PRESENTATION 4
Thematic Area 3: Narratives
and Visual Representations of
Female Mobility
Panel 7: Visual Representations of
Female Mobility
15:00-16:00
Chair: Parvati Nair, UNU-GCM
HAMMARSKJÖLD
ROOM
»»Female Transnational Migrations and Diasporas in European “Immigration Cinema”, Isolina Ballesteros, City University of
New York (USA)
Emotional Geographies of
Female Mobilities and Agency in
the Mediterranean: Explorative
Narratives from Muslim Migrant
Women in an Italian Case Study
Professor Maria Paradiso, University of
Sannio
Chair: Parvati Nair, UNU-GCM
»»Between Borders and Desires. Artists in
the Contemporary Mediterranean, Herman Bashiron Mendolicchio, University
of Barcelona (Spain)
»»The Body of Evidence: Maya Goded’s
Photography of Sex-Workers in Mexico,
Dominika Gasiorowski, Queen Mary
University of London
coffee
17:45-18:00
Screening of
Becky´s Journey
and Q&A
18:00-19:00
With Director Sine Plambech
Chair: Aishih Wehbe Herrera
End of
Conference
19:00
Optional Tour of Sant Pau Modernist Site
19
SUMMARIES
OF THEMATIC
AREAS
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Thematic Area 2:
Women,
Diasporas and
Transnationalism
Thematic Area 1:
Multi-lateral Policy
Engagement on
Gender and Mobility
This panel brings together experts working on gender and mobility from different
UN agencies and other international
bodies, in order to consider frameworks
that work towards the Sustainable Development Goals, in particular that of achieving gender equality and empowering
all women and girls. The panel will bring
together perspectives from a range of
international and multilateral organisations
that share priorities in the formation of
policies relating to female mobility. Issues
under discussion will include questions
of advocacy, the responsibilities of home
and host societies, risks faced by women
migrants, such as trafficking, and the steps
needed in policy formation to ensure
dignity and well-being.
In the light of UN discussions on the role
of women in the world, these panels
gather contributions from researchers who
investigate whether migration can offer
ways to empower women and, consequently, whether women migrants are able
to influence sociocultural change in countries of origin and countries of residence.
The research findings in this area are of
great importance to policy-makers in
order to understand what role women play
and how policy-making could adjust to further empower women in diverse societies.
The panel relates to existing debates on
the role of women on a variety of research
questions, including women diasporas,
the gender-related aspect of prejudice
towards immigrants, women diasporas
as promoters of socio-cultural change
in countries of origin and of destination,
women migrants and those left behind,
health issues related to women migrants,
the role of women migrants for sustainable
development. .
20
21
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Thematic Area 4:
Thematic Area 3:
Narratives
and Visual
Representations of
Female Mobility
These panels focus on narratives and
cultural media as modes of representation
through which the gendered experiences
of mobility and change are articulated.
Through such efforts, often shaped in and
through migration, the subjects extend the
established contours of their own agency
and so reconfigure locales and contexts.
Furthermore, the narrative acts that women engage in, as well as the cultural representations that center upon female experiences of mobility, often pave the way for
revised configurations of gender, identity
and power. The papers here all explore,
therefore, the idea that engagement with
narratives and with cultural production can
lead to a transformation of the status quo.
For women, who have historically been
under-represented, (self-)representation
and the narrative act can be ways of making sense of mobility and socio-cultural
change, as well as of redefining gender
and identity.
Gender, Migrant
Labour and
Empowerment
This thematic area examines the relationship between gender, migration and
empowerment. Female migrants often find
themselves in precarious conditions of life
and work; their labour is often stigmatised,
poorly valued and vulnerable to exploitation; yet migration may also provide a
space for migrants to pursue their aspirations and seek avenues for empowerment
in the face of entrenched racialised and
gendered stereotypes. This section examines firstly how female migrants might be
agents in contesting normative discourses
on gender relations, in offering opportunities for new solidarities and engendering
change in different contexts. It also explores the limits to empowerment and the
persistence of gendered forms of vulnerability. Secondly, it considers experiences
of labour in a range of precarious and
‘feminised’ sectors of global and regional
labour markets. It focuses on migrants
employed in domestic, care and cleaning
work in private homes and institutional
settings, exploring ethnographic understandings of labour; labour conditions and
professional identities; and the political
economy of care, intimacy and affective
labour.
Thematic Area 5:
Legal Discourses
on Gender and
Migration
This panel examines, from an academic
perspective, legal and policy discourses
on gender and migration. It considers
questions of justice, regional frameworks
for rights and citizenship, and normative
discourses that impact on nationality
and citizenship policies, drawing upon
cases from different parts of the world. In
particular, it includes discussions of who
the beneficiaries of free movement rules
are, questions of forced-displacement and
how naturalization laws are connected
with gender discrimination.
23
ALPHABETICAL LIST OF
CONTRIBUTORS WITH
ABSTRACTS AND SHORT
BIOGRAPHIES
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Nourhan Abdel Aziz
American University in Cairo (Egypt)
Changing Homes, Changing
Roles: The Struggles and
Strategies of Syrian Refugee
Women in the Context of
Displacement in Egypt
Refugees from Syria constitute the largest
refugee flow in the Middle East and North
Africa region since the escalation of the
conflict in 2011. In certain cases, women
and children were compelled to leave
Syria without the head of the family due
to various restrictions and challenges.
In other instances, Syrian women were
divorced or separated once displaced.
A significant number of Syrian women
in Egypt fall in these two categories. As
a result, it is significant to shed light on
the experiences of single, divorced, and
separated Syrian women who are not only
facing the challenges of displacement but
also experience the changes of their roles
in the household.
This paper examines the role of Syrian
women who are the primary care-takers of
their households. Firstly, the paper examines the socio-economic difficulties faced
by Syrian women in Egypt. This includes
an examination of the major livelihood
issues such as employment, education,
and healthcare. Secondly, the paper
exposes the most common forms of sexual
and gender based violence (SGBV) that
Syrian women are subjected to in Egypt. It
is significant to address SGBV due to the
fact that it is one of the most widespread
human rights violations among displaced
communities. Thirdly, the paper concludes
with an analysis of the coping strategies
employed by Syrian refugee women to
provide for their families’ needs. All three
objectives will aim at contextualizing the
feminization of the refugee experience in
Egypt as more women are becoming the
main providers for their families.
Nourhan Abdel Aziz is a researcher in the
Center for Migration and Refugee Studies
in the American University in Cairo (AUC)
whose main areas of research interest and
experience are on migration and refugee
policies and practices, irregular migration,
and refugee protection and livelihoods.
She received her B.A in political science,
with a double specialization in political
economy and international law, and her
M.A in Migration and Refugee Studies from
AUC and is currently finishing her L.L.M.
Her current projects focus on irregular
migration in Africa, Europe, and the GCC.
Rosana Albuquerque
Universidade Aberta (Portugal)
Community Activism among Black
Young Women in Portugal: a Daily
Engagement towards Citizenship
and Social Cohesion
In this paper I intend to discuss how
community activism among black young
women, descendent of African immigrants, is a daily practice of weaving
solidarities, resisting discrimination and
striving for full citizenship in Portuguese
society. My research collected life stories
of young women and men assuming
leader positions in youth, immigrant or
descendants associations. Life trajectories
did not reveal gender differences regarding catalyst factors for activism, but make
clear that women play an irreplaceable
role as community leaders fuelling social
24
25
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
change. Activism and associational life are
a kind of ‘schools of citizenship’, as they
empower young people to strive for their
rights, encourage female leaderships in
society and foster informal learning on
politics and democracy.
By analysing young women´s narratives
and trajectories, we can observe that
the main motivation to become involved
in community activism is to tackle discrimination and social disadvantages of
everyday life, by developing their own
civic informally structured projects or
joining in formal associations. Activism is
a strategy to resist structural constraints,
such as racialized sexism and inequality
reproduction, felt ‘under the skin’, and
damaging their ‘body and soul’. Activism
is based on strong ties and bonding social
capital, collective and community-centered values, and trust on democratic
institutions and political action. Thus, we
must consider ethnic ties and a sense of
belonging around migrant background
and blackness as stimuli to engage in civic
projects and intentional claims for equality
and full citizenship, while also contribute
to promote equity and social cohesion in
Portuguese society, as a whole.
Rosana Albuquerque holds a Degree
in Social Policy, a Master in Intercultural
Relations and a PhD in Sociology. She is
lecturer of Sociology and Social Policy at
the Department of Social Sciences and
Management of Universidade Aberta, in
Portugal, and a researcher at the Research
Centre on Migration and Intercultural Relations, at the same university. She has done
research about associations, social movements and political participation, focusing
on immigrants and their descendants,
with a gender sensitive approach. As a
volunteer, she collaborates with NGOs
such as SOS Racismo and ACEP in training
activities on anti-racism, human rights and
intercultural education.
Megha Amrith
UNU-GCM
Status Beyond Labour: The
Empowerment of Filipina Women
in Barcelona
This paper addresses the empowerment
of Filipina migrant women in Barcelona.
Based on in-depth interviews in the Raval
neighbourhood, this paper explores the
central role that Filipina migrant women
play in facilitating the establishment of
their family networks in the city and in
securing a sense personal, familial and
community wellbeing. A commonly heard
narrative is that, given the gendered
characterisation of the domestic work
sector, it is easier for migrant women to
find work. Many have college degrees,
yet arrive with a reluctant readiness to
perform domestic work as a route to
building an independent life abroad. The
fact that the majority perform domestic
work also serves as an ‘equaliser’, reducing
divisions based on labour. Migrant women are aware of their labour rights and
are able to exercise them. In contrast to
experiences of migrant domestic workers
in other destinations, they are able to
assure dignity in their conditions of life
and work in Barcelona, thus fostering a
wider sense of empowerment. Women
hold numerous positions of status and
leadership within the Filipino and urban
communities in which they are embedded.
Many volunteer in associational life, partic-
ipate in transnational solidarity networks
and advocate for rights to the city. Others
participate in wider intercultural initiatives
in Barcelona. Alongside stories of hard
work, struggle, misrecognition and familial
or community politics, there is ultimately
recognition that migration opens routes to
transformation and wellbeing.
immigrant women to the development of
a future workforce and that their limited
representation within mass media reduces
significantly their impact on policy making.
Female Transnational Migrations
and Diasporas in European
“Immigration Cinema”
In order to bridge the gap between women and the media, an increasing number
of female (and some male) filmmakers
have become engaged with the issue of
immigration in an attempt to give voice to
female immigrants, counteract their social
invisibility and media indifference, and
generate strategies of positive self-representation. In my presentation I will
expose some of the commonalities found
in immigration films made by European
filmmakers. Regardless of nationality or
ethnicity, they share similar concerns and
representation patterns: they emphasize
female immigrants’ agency, survival strategies, mechanisms of identity construction,
and integration into the receiving society
over exit-less instances of subordination
and domination. Their characters’ growth
is always contingent on the construction
of affective links with other women, whether they are immigrants or natives, and
the formation and upholding of female
communities and associations. I argue
that what these women filmmakers add to
“immigration cinema” is a gendered perspective that is still lacking in most media
representations of female migration.
Female immigration to the European
Union has increased exponentially since
the 1980s, yet political and media discourses consistently depict female immigrants as dependent, economically passive subjects, often contextualized solely
in terms of family reunification, domestic
service, and sexual work. Sociologists
have shown that the existing literature on
immigration ignores the contributions of
Isolina Ballesteros is Associate Professor
at the Department of Modern Languages
and Comparative Literature and the Film
Studies Program of Baruch College, and
the Graduate Center of CUNY. Her teaching focuses on Modern Peninsular Studies
(19th and 20th century literature and film),
Comparative Literature and Spanish and
European film. She is the author of three
books: Escritura femenina y discurso au-
Megha Amrith is a Research Fellow at
the United Nations University Institute on
Globalization, Culture and Mobility (UNUGCM). She holds a PhD in Social Anthropology from the University of Cambridge
and has thematic interests in migration,
cultural diversity, citizenship, labour, cities
and civil society activism. She is currently
working on projects that examine the
inclusion of low-income migrants in cities,
and the experiences of female migrant
labour in domestic and care work sectors.
She has conducted ethnographic fieldwork with migrants in a number of cities,
including Singapore, Manila, São Paulo,
Mumbai and Barcelona.
Isolina Ballesteros
City University of New York (USA)
26
27
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
tobiográfico en la nueva novela española
(1994), Cine (Ins)urgente: textos fílmicos y
contextos culturales de la España postfranquista (2001), and Immigration Cinema in
the New Europe (2015
Valeria Bello
UNU-GCM
The Experience of Women
Diasporas: Integration, Civil
Society Participation and Sociocultural Change
This paper aims to understand the contribution of immigrant women associations
to socio-cultural change both through
transnational activities and through their
involvement in the collective action of civil
society in the host country. In the light of
UN discussions on the role of women in
the world, this work investigates whether
women diasporas are empowered by
the Country system in order to be able to
establish social networks and capitals to
influence socio-cultural change and thus
play a relevant role in the world. It relates
to the academic debate on Immigrant
Diasporas in International Relations and
investigates through documents analysis,
in-depth interviews and ethnographic
research the cases of Women’s Immigrant
Associations in Catalunya, such as “Asociación de Mujeres Inmigrantes subsaharianas (ADIS)” and “Asociación Cultural
Educativa Social y Operativa de Mujeres
Pakistaníes (ACESOP)”. From the findings it
is clear that contribution to the civil society
of the host country depends, to a great extent, on the personal attributes of women
leaders, which can then affect positively
the socio-cultural change in both homelands and host countries.
Valeria Bello is a Political Sociologist who
has taught and published in the fields
of Sociology, International Relations and
Political Science. Her main research interests
concern the role of both identity and nonstate actors in the area of migration and
interethnic relations, as well as in the area of
international and human security. She is the
main editor of the book “A Global Security
Triangle: European, African and Asian Interactions” (Routledge, 2010, with Belachew
Gebrewold) and co-editor of the book “Civil
Society and International Governance: The
Role of Non-State Actors in the EU, Africa,
Asia and Middle East” (Routledge, 2011,
with David Armstrong et al.).
Yi-Chien Chen J.S.D.
Shih Hsin University (Taiwan)
Who are the “Virtuous” Taiwanese
Women? Surveillance, Survival
and Law
This project intends to draw together
public discourses around “Foreign Brides”,
sexuality and nation-building with a discussion of the law as an institution in which
“virtuous” Taiwanese women are shaped
and actively produced.
A recent case has caught both scholarly
and societal attention when the Ministry of
the Interior of Taiwan revoked the Taiwanese nationality of a Vietnamese woman
who had been naturalized, due to her
adulterous behavior in her previous marriage, though there was no criminal charge
or record. One requirement for naturalization is that “he/she behaves decently and
has no records of crime”. Within five years
after naturalization, the naturalization can
be withdrawn/revokes if the requirement
is found not conformed. In a word, this
woman of Vietnamese origin is no longer
Taiwanese because she did not behave
decently. The NGOs advocated to amend
the law to delete such phrases as “behaves
decently” but in vain.
Sex, love, marriage, migration, and feminism are some aspects of the changing
gender relations that shape people’s lives
in the Asia Pacific region, especially in
Taiwan. This project further explores the
current global and national narratives of
Southeast Asian women in Taiwan and
locates its research focuses also on nationality law and practices in Taiwan. The
author wishes to propose a Nationality law
and cultural reform aiming at achieving
a more realistic, open-defined, diverse
imagination of Taiwan Republic of China)
as a Nation far different from China (People’s Republic of China).
Yi-Chien Chen is the chair of the Awakening Foundation, a 33-year old Taiwanese
feminist organization, and works as Associate Professor in the graduate institute
of Gender Studies in Shih Hsin University
in Taipei. Her research interests focus on
gender and law and comparative law and
culture studies, including sex, love and
law, LGBTIQ rights topics.
Yi-Chien has LL.M. degrees both from Heidelberg University, Germany and Cornell
Law School, USA. She received her J.S.D.
(Doctor of Science of Law) degree in 2001
from Cornell Law School and returned to
Taiwan in 2002.
Anastasia Christou
Middlesex University (UK)
Liminal Spaces and Moving
Subjects in a Context of Crisis:
Gender, Emotions and Agentic
Transnational Cultural Production
in Eastern European Migration to
Greece
Based on a “Gendered Histories of Resilience and Resistance: Eastern European
Women’s Narratives of Mobility and
Survival” Oral History Project, a narrative
ethnography of Albanian, Bulgarian, Romanian and Polish migrant women living
in Greece, the paper explores life stories,
memories and experiences, in both ancestral homelands as well as country of
settlement, in order to examine the intersections of gender and identity in how the
recollection of socialist pasts informs the
understanding of living present but also
future capitalist lives.
The post-socialist imagination is both a
fascinating and a contested one. It is a
story of ordinary people in mundane circumstances who led lives that remain extraordinary as we still encounter silences,
gaps and voids in the rendering of such
histories. Precisely, it is ‘his/stories’ that we
often come across as women’s livelihoods
and agencies are not always made readily
available, yet, they are stories of strength,
resilience, endurance and empowerment.
28
29
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
The paper gives voice to such fascinating
stories while developing core theorizations of gender, citizenship and social
justice in unpacking the past into the
present. Through captivating narratives by
women in their 30s, 40s and 50s grown up
in Albania, Bulgaria, Romania and Poland,
the study is an empirically grounded
and theoretically illuminating account of
processes of democratization, marketization, globalization and migration in how
gendered representations of citizenship
can highlight the complexities of social
and cultural histories of the nation.
The analysis explores the messiness of
ordinary lives that account for how global
historical transformations of Eastern and
Southern Europe are filtered through the
lived experience of im/mobilities.
Anastasia Christou is Associate Professor
of Sociology, member of the Social Policy
Research Centre and the FemGenSex
research network at Middlesex University.
Anastasia has engaged in multi-sited,
multi-method and comparative ethnographic research in the United States,
Denmark, Germany, Greece, Cyprus,
and recently in Iceland. Anastasia has
widely published research on issues of
diasporas, migration and return migration;
the second generation and ethnicity;
space and place; transnationalism and
identity; culture and memory; gender
and feminism; home and belonging;
emotion and narrativity; ageing/youth
mobilities, care, trauma, ‘race’/racisms and
intersectionalities, embodiment, sexualities, motherhood/mothering. Her most
recent book is a jointly authored research
monograph entitled Christou, A. and King,
R. “Counter-diaspora: The Greek Second
Generation Returns ‘Home’”, appearing in
the series Cultural Politics, Socioaesthetics,
Beginnings, distributed by Harvard
University Press (2014).
Eva Gracía Córdoba
Comillas Pontifical University
(Spain)
Internally Displaced Women
in Ayacucho: Their Key Role
in Peacebuilding and Social
Reconstruction. (with Juncal FdezGarayzábal)
In conflict situations, the ecological model
proposed by Bronfenbrenner is broken,
given that the interaction between individuals and their context through economic,
social and psychological factors is rendered impossible.
Such was the case in Ayacucho (Peru).
Twenty years of conflict between the
armed forces and Shining Path resulted
in large numbers of internally displaced
persons (IDPs) who were forced to resettle
in different parts of the country, in areas
where their participation both in the
labour market and the political sphere are
prevented. This is especially the case for
women, who on the one hand became
head of households due to the disappearance of men, and on the other hand saw
their rights violated due to war crimes.
Several interviews carried out in Ayacucho
in 2013 reveal the role of women during
conflict, and also give an insight into the
current situation of internally displaced
females in the area. Based on a human
rights perspective, the aim of analysing
the aforementioned interviews is to identify gaps and flaws regarding the treatment
given to the situation of Ayacuchan female
IDPs. The fact that they are, for instance,
not considered to be war victims already
depicts the way in which social structures
are not being treated in a comprehensive
manner.
The slow active participation of these
women in daily political processes has
resulted in a faulty reconstruction of
Ayacuchan society, given that the peace
process has been far from inclusive and
has forgetten about the rights and obligations of determined social sectors.
Eva Gracía Córdoba is a social integrator
and social worker with experience in social
intervention through her work in several
organizations. Nowadays, she is studying
for a MSc in International Cooperation
for Development in Comillas Pontifical
University. Also, she is collaborating at the
Institute of Development and Cooperation
of Complutense University and at the
Institute for the Studies on Migrations of
Comillas Pontifical University. She has participated in several studies on migrations
and her main area of research is based on
the role of women in the Ayacucho society
after the conflict.
Tatiana Diniz
UNU-GCM
Women of the World: Home and
Work in Barcelona
Tatiana Diniz holds a Bachelors degree
in Social Sciences, with further studies in
Visual Anthropology (Universitat de Barcelona), a Master’s degree in Social and Cultural Anthropology (Universitat Autònoma
de Barcelona) and a Master’s degree in
Diplomacy and Public Civil Service (Centre
d’Estudis Internacionals, Barcelona). She
also has diplomas in technical and creative
photography.
She is interested in issues relating to
migration and gender, the empowerment
of women and feminism. Prior to joining
the UNU-GCM, she was project assistant at
the International Organization for Migration. At UNU-GCM, she works as Research
Assistant on the “Women of the World:
Home and Work in Barcelona” project,
with responsibility for creating the core
archive of oral histories and photographic
material. By combining ethnographic
research with documentary photography,
the project creates a set of audiovisual
representations of first generation female
immigrants, and investigates the boundaries between home and work, as well as
themes of gender and the city, so as to
create narratives through which immigrant
women may trace their cultural identities.
30
31
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Giulia D’Odorico
University of Padua (Italy)
Discourses and Practices about
Marriage, Gender and Sexuality.
Mothers and Daughters between
Morocco and Italy
This contribution is based on the main
results of my PhD research project. It
explores the processes of construction of
gender and sexuality among two generations of women of Moroccan origin living
in Italy - pairs of mothers and daughters.
Furthermore, it illustrates the ongoing
transformations of family structures
and dynamics within the framework of
globalized migrations. The research is
based on 29 biographical narratives that
have been collected through in-depth
interviews and participant observation in
Italy and Morocco between February 2012
and September 2013. This study stands
at the crossroads between family and
migration studies (Kofman 2004; Grillo
2008; Palriwala, Uberoi 2008; Kraler et al.
2011) with the aim of contributing to a
shift in the methodological and theoretical
frame usually adopted to interpret family
discourses and practices of migrants and
their descendants. Most of the research
tends to adopt exclusively “nation-based”
lenses (Levitt, Glick Schiller 2004; Anthias
2009) without considering the complexity
of social positions and positionings that
all subjects, including researchers, face in
the current global context. Thus, this study
adopts a “translocal” approach as developed by Floya Anthias (2002; 2008). In this
paper I will cast light on one of the major
institutions lying within the gender and
sexual structures and helping to reproduce them - marriage. I will illustrate the
changes in marriage markets, with particular attention to the meanings attributed to
partner selection and marriage strategies
without losing view of some other aspects
of marriage life such as sexual intimacy
before and after marriage.
Giulia D’Odorico graduated in International and Diplomatic Studies at the
University of Trieste, completed a master
in Governance and Development at the
University of Antwerp and a PhD in Social
Sciences at the University of Padua. Her
main areas of interest and expertise cover
Gender, Gender-based Violence, Development and Migration.
She gained significant professional experience in these areas while working
at Amnesty International in Brussels, the
UNDP in Quito, the University of Padua. At
the moment, she is conducting a research
on Chinese migrations in Italy, with a focus
on the life stories of Chinese workers in
the textile and leather sectors.
Marina Faetanini
UNESCO (India)
Migration, Gender and Social
Inclusion in India
Internal migration in India accounts for a
large population currently estimated at
approximately 400 million, or nearly 30
percent of the total population. These
figures are indeed staggering when
compared with estimates of Indian emigrants, i.e. 11.4 million. The constraints
faced by seasonal migrants in particular
(estimated at 100 million) are many – lack
of formal residency rights; lack of identity
proof; lack of political representation;
inadequate housing; low pay, insecure
or hazardous work; extreme vulnerability
of women and children to trafficking
and sexual exploitation; exclusion from
state-provided services and entitlements
such as health and education; inability to
access banking facilities; and discrimination based on ethnicity, religion, class or
gender. Being constantly on the move,
migrants, of which nearly 70 percent are
women, lose access to social security
benefits linked to the residence, falling
through the cracks of development policies and programmes focused on settled
populations. The underlying assumptions
of a majority of city officials and local
authorities are that inhospitable and harsh
cities are the best deterrent to migration
flow. The Internal Migration in India Initiative (IMII) was therefore launched in 2011
to address the multiplicity of challenges
faced by migrants, men, women and
children, and support their social inclusion in the economic, social, political and
cultural life of the country, using a threelegged approach combining research,
policy and advocacy. The informal network
created under the IMII has been recently
transformed into a new web-portal titled
Gender, Youth and Migration (GYM) which
functions as a sub-community of practice
of the United Nations Solution Exchange
Gender Community on gender, youth and
migration in India (http://www.solutionexchange-un-gen-gym.net).
Marina Faetanini has headed the Social
and Human Sciences Sector (SHS) since
2007 at the UNESCO New Delhi Office,
where she has developed a new programme of activities focusing on social
protection, urban poverty, the right to the
city, social inclusion and internal migration,
using a three-legged approach, combining research, policy and advocacy. She has
published policy briefs, training manuals
- Social Inclusion of Internal Migrants in
India (2013); Internal Migration: A Manual
for Community Radio Stations (2015) - as
well as several videos and films, such as
Breaking Silence (2013); Floating People
Building Blocks (2014); Changing Climate
Moving People (2014).
Prior to joining UNESCO in 2003, Marina
Faetanini worked on climate change related issues (WWF-France) and as a diplomat
at the United Nations (NYC) and at the
Council of Europe (1992-1999). She graduated from the Ecole Normale Superieure
of Saint-Cloud, France (ENS) in Lettres et
Sciences Humaines (Humanities) in 1983
and holds a D.E.A (equivalent to M.A.) in
Romance Studies from the University of La
Sorbonne Nouvelle, Paris, France (1987).
32
33
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Sarah Gammage
Juncal Fdez-Garayzábal
Comillas Pontifical University (Spain)
Internally Displaced Women
in Ayacucho: Their Key Role
in Peacebuilding and Social
Reconstruction. (with Eva Gracia
Cordoba)
Juncal Fdez-Garayzábal has MSc in
International Cooperation for Development and in European Democracy and
Legitimacy. She is currently also a PhD
candidate at Comillas Pontifical University
(Madrid, Spain). Her fields of study include forced migrations, organised crime,
conflicts and security, knowledge she
has combined with field experiences in
different countries. She has participated in
several international conferences, focusing on the political, social and economic
consequences of human trafficking. Moreover, she has collaborated with different
research institutes at a national (Institute
for the Studies on Migrations of Comillas
Pontifical University) and international
level (The Hague Centre for Strategic
Studies – HCSS).
Federica Frediani
Università della Svizzera italiana
(Switzerland)
New Narratives of the
Mediterranean: The Women Gaze
The Mediterranean undergoes continuous transformation. Women, who often
represent a powerful driving force of
change, contribute in a crucial way to this
transformation. Nevertheless, the World
Economic Forum Gender Gap Report 2014
has brought to light that the majority of
Mediterranean countries are still far from
reaching gender equality. The new and
unstable configurations of the present-day
Mediterranean impose the necessity of new
maps and new narratives. The recourse to
old categories describing such a variable
and unpredictable reality is inadequate
both at the theoretical and practical levels.
The aim of this proposal is to illustrate that
new narratives and new maps are already
present in the works of some women artists,
directors and writers (for instance Mona
Hatoum, Karin Albou, Assia Djebar).
The presentation focuses on theoretical
aspects and on the analysis of some works
that in different ways represent and predict
the complexity of the Mediterranean reality
Federica Frediani is researcher and lecturer at the Laboratorio for Mediterranean
Studies of the Università della Svizzera
italiana. She obtained an M.A. in Literature
at the University of Siena (1997), where she
achieved a Ph.D. in Comparative Literature
(2005). Her interests are focused on travel
literature and women’s travel, on the representations and images of the Mediterranean and the Mediterranean cities. She also
carries out research with the Department
of Comparative Languages, Literature and
Cultures at the University of Bergamo. She
is author Go Out. Women travel writings:
from the mythical paradigms to the orientalist images (2007) and she co-edited
Space Signs Words. Paths of Italian Women
Traveller (2012). She edited the volume
Mediterranean city between Myth and
Reality (2014).
UN Women (USA)
Making Claims on Duty Bearers:
Migrant Women Workers’
Advocacy and Organizing
Strategies
This article analyses migrant women
workers’ advocacy and organizing to make
claims on duty bearers to improve the
terms and conditions of their employment
in host and home countries. The article
draws on EC-funded research supported
by UN Women in Mexico, Moldova and
the Philippines and highlights other examples of migrant women’s organization and
advocacy to make strategic claims on duty
bearers.
The increasingly complex nature of migration and international labour recruitment
has far-reaching implications for governments in sending, receiving and transit
countries as they define policies and
programmes to manage and control migration. Migrant women’s organizing and
advocacy strategies directed at improving
the terms and conditions of employment
is emblematic of their ability to exercise
voice and wrest agency from within these
processes and to engage duty bearers
nationally and internationally in designing
labour and migration policy and programmes. Across the globe groups of
migrant women have organized to make
claims on duty-bearers and strategically
leverage partnerships to improve the
terms and conditions of employment. This
article looks at the multiple forms of resistance and the multiple sites of claims-making by migrant women to achieve these
ends. We focus specifically on the use
of CEDAW General Recommendation
26 and Convention 189 on decent work
for domestic workers. We deconstruct a
number of experiences using these instruments to examine what has worked and
where as part of an anatomy of success for
future claims-making by migrant women’s
organizations and advocates.
Sarah Gammage is a Policy Advisor
working with UN WOMEN in New York.
Previously she worked for the sub-regional
office of the ILO in Chile. She has written
academic and policy research articles on
gender and trade, poverty, labour markets,
migration and environment. She has a PhD
in Development Economics from the Institute of Social Studies in The Hague and
a Master’s degree in Economics from the
London School of Economics and Political
Science. She has worked with and for a
number of international and multilateral
organizations and is an active member of
the International Association for Feminist
Economics.
Dominika Gasiorowski
Queen Mary University of London
(UK)
The Body of Evidence: Maya
Goded’s Photography of SexWorkers in Mexico
Maya Goded is one of the most renowned
contemporary Mexican photographers.
Her documentary work on prostitution in
Mexico, which spans nearly two decades,
evidences a hidden phenomenon revealing an exploitative gendered undercurrent
within Mexican society. The work shows
a community in flux and a vibrant and
sinister commercial underworld, populated by women who migrate in and out of
34
35
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Marta Gil
University of Valencia (Spain)
Mexico’s red-light districts called zonas
de tolerancia. Through a close analysis of
several images from Goded’s vast body of
work on prostitution, a connection will be
forged between representations of individual stories of empowerment or suffering and the established social patterns of
exploiting female migrants. This will help
to show how their vulnerability and their
agency are played out in different regions
of the country, particularly in the capital
and along the US border. The images’
potential for empowerment as well as
exploitation will be considered within the
frame of their subjects’ internal displacement. The main goal of this examination is
to tease out the ethical intricacies of representing and looking at images of migrant
sex workers with a particular focus on how
their bodies fit within the borders of Mexico and within the established patterns of
female exploitation.
Dominika Gasiorowski recently successfully defended her PhD thesis entitled
Representing Mexican Otherness: Subalternity in Maya Goded’s Socially Engaged
Photodocumentary, which she completed
at Queen Mary University of London under
the supervision of Professor Parvati Nair.
After obtaining a BA in Hispanic Studies
from Queen Mary University of London,
she completed her MPhil degree in
European Literature and Culture at King’s
College, University of Cambridge. Her
research interests include Latin American
cultural studies and visual culture, as well
as critical theory, particularly in relation
to concepts of gender, race, identity, violence and difference.
Forced Displacement,
Transitional Justice and Women’s
Empowerment
The fields of forced displacement and
transitional justice have remained disconnected. My contribution associates these
two issues from a gendered perspective.
All conflicts have an immense human cost.
One of the principal problems is the situation of displaced people, asylum seekers
and refugees. According to the UNHCR
Global Trends Report, 51.2 million people
were displaced at the end of 2013. Women and girls in conflict-affected settings
face an enormous risk of being victims of
human trafficking and sex labour. Other
problems include: forced marriage (sometimes families think that they may protect
young girls from sexual violence this way);
discriminatory gender-based norms; or
lack of basic services for women and their
families (usually are women who take care
of the elderly or the children).
Another focus of injustice is the vulnerability of civil rights during forced displacement situations. Often, there are preexisting inequalities: women lack citizenship
rights, so this involves more difficulties
in accessing identity documents, asylum,
and so on. Similarly, they experience legal
and civil injustices regarding birth, death,
marriage, divorce, property rights, etc.
Transitional justice measures can be a
valuable tool in order to ensure an adequate engagement of displaced women in
designing justice processes. Giving suitable hearing to marginalized voices can
subvert the role of women from passive
victims to right bearers and active citizens
in its own right. Enhancing women’s
participation and leadership in displaced
settings is crucial. Transitional justice has
a transformative potential to address
gender-based violations, but also to fight
deeper structural disparities and injustices.
Marta Gil earned her Bachelor’s Degree
in Philosophy from the University of Barcelona. After that, she moved to the University of Valencia, where she studied for a
Master’s degree in Ethics and Democracy.
During her doctoral studies she developed
research in several topics related to Polical
Philosophy and Democracy. She earned
a Ph.D with a thesis about Martha Nussbaum and the role of emotions in public
life. She has been a visiting researcher at
Oxford University and at the Max Planck
Institute for Human Development in Berlin.
Currently, she is developing research in the
field of Transitional Justice in the University
of Valencia and the Centro Internacional
Toledo para la Paz.
Sandya
Hewamanne
University of Essex (UK)
Migration, Stigma and
Empowerment: Former Global
Factory Workers Negotiating New
Identities in Sri Lanka’s Villages
This paper explores how former migrant
global factory workers negotiate new
identities in villages as new brides, mothers
and daughters-in-law after 5-6 years of
employment in an urban Free Trade Zone.
I argue that their performances of self-discipline and disavowal of transgressive
knowledges allow them to make use of
the limited social economic, and political
spaces available while gradually reshaping
local understandings about the good
daughter-in-law. Combining their FTZ
earnings and other forms of capital many
become successful local entrepreneurs
who provide part time work for local women, even while daily managing the stigma
of migration. This creative manipulation of
varied forms of capital -- symbolic, social
and monetary—is one of the reasons behind
new social status markers and novel forms
of disparities among groups of people
within villages. Analyzing non-migrant and
migrant narratives of entrepreneurship the
paper argue that the migration to work in
global factories is the differentiating factor
between success and failure.
Sandya Hewamanne is a Cultural Anthropologist specializing in gender and
sexuality studies, Economic Anthropology and Anthropology of Globalization
and Development. She is the author of
Stitching Identities in a Free Trade Zone:
Gender and Politics in Sri Lanka (University
of Pennsylvania Press: 2008). She has
also published peer-reviewed articles in
journals such as Ethnology, Ethnography,
Social Text, Identities, Feminist Studies,
Cultural Dynamics and Anthropology of
Work Review. She is currently finishing her
second manuscript titled “Manipulating
Capital: Sri Lanka’s Former Global Factory
Workers Negotiating New Identities.” She
teaches Anthropology at the University of
Essex, United Kingdom and is a visiting
scholar at Cornell University, USA.
36
37
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Sandra Mantu
Maria Jaschok
Radboud University Nijmegen
(The Netherlands)
University of Oxford (UK)
Sources of Authority of Female
Leadership in Islam – Female
ahong and qingzhen nüsi
(Women’s Mosques) in China
The main factors which have contributed to the enduring longevity of female
ahong-led women’s own mosques in
predominantly, but not exclusively so,
Hui Muslim communities in central China,
lie in the historical needs of a besieged
Chinese Muslim Diaspora for women’s
active participation in a collective project
of Islamic revival and Muslim survival.
Developments over time led from learned
women’s ad hoc roles as religious instructors of girls and women, guided by fathers
and husbands, to the institutionalisation of
female leadership in the early 20th century
in both teaching and ritual guidance. From
the earliest beginnings, the active role of
women was controversial and, as on-going
internal dissension in the Chinese Muslim
Sunni community over the concept of
bid’a (principle of innovation in Islam)
demonstrates, women’s public visibility
in organized Islam remains divisive. It is
argued that despite on-going tensions
over legitimacy of Muslim women’s own
traditions of worship, education and
congregation, their continued existence
owes much to a growing assertion of a
Chinese Muslim identity within the ummah
as well as to strategic alliance at the local
level with Communist Party/State officials,
conferring authority to female ahong-led
women’s mosques by legal and administrative means.
Women, Work and EU citizenship
Maria Jaschok is a Research Fellow and
Director of International Gender Studies
Centre at Lady Margaret Hall, University
of Oxford. She obtained her PhD from
SOAS, University of London. Her areas of
research interest are in religion, gender
and agency; gendered constructions
of memory; feminist ethnographic and collaborative practice; marginality and identity. Long years of research collaboration
with the Chinese Hui Muslim sociologist of
religion Shui Jingjun have produced numerous journal articles and book chapters
on the history and anthropology of China’s
uniquely female-gendered Islamic spaces. Their current fieldwork concerns the
significance of sound, silence and voice
in the culture of Hui women’s mosques.
Among recent book publications, Women,
Religion and Space, co-authored with Shui
Jingjun (Routledge, 2011) and The History
of Women’s Mosques in Chinese Islam: A
Mosque of Their Own, co-authored with
Shui Jingjun (Curzon, 2000/2002, Chinese
edition) provide a comprehensive introduction to China’s female-led women’s
mosques. Given the scarcity of historical
scholarship in this area of work, apart
from consultation of Chinese-language
(published and private) source materials
as well as of Western-language secondary
literature, the most important basis for
reconstruction of the history of Chinese
Muslim women have been oral history and
fieldwork in China.
EU citizens are entitled to move and reside
freely in another Member State irrespective of their engagement in economic
activities but their rights remain contingent on them having sufficient resources
not to become an unreasonable burden
on the welfare system of the host Member
State. EU citizens who move as workers
enjoy better rights and better protection
in comparison with economically inactive
mobile citizens, a fact that led authors to
describe EU citizenship as ‘market citizenship’. The manner in which EU citizenship
and the rules adopted in secondary
legislation to give it affect reflect gender
issues is relatively understudied in EU law
scholarship. Although the legal definition
of EU citizenship is formulated in a general
fashion, the initial beneficiaries of free
movement rules were understood to be
men in their capacity as workers, begging
questions as to the position of women in
relation to the market as the epitome of
EU integration. More recently, EU case law
suggests that the time has come to examine EU citizenship as a gendered legal
status in order to analyze the intersectionality of gender, work and citizenship
in the construction and application of the
legal status of EU citizenship. This paper
seeks to understand how the legal rules
on EU citizenship and their interpretation
by the European Court of Justice shape,
influence and/or constrain the capacity of
women EU citizens to make use of their EU
citizenship rights.
Sandra Mantu is researcher at the Centre
for Migration Law, Radboud University
Nijmegen. In 2014, Sandra defended her
PhD thesis that dealt with the legal rules
and practices of citizenship deprivation
in a selection of EU states. She has beensearch centres on the intersection between natural resource politics and social
welfare, with a particular interest in the
implications of global processes on local
livelihoods. Fundamental to her work are
questions concerning equity and natural
resource access. She is a lecturer in Human-Environment Relations in the School
of Geographical Sciences at the University
of Bristol, UK.
Herman Bashiron
Mendolicchio
University of Barcelona (Spain)
Between Borders and Desires:
Artists in the Contemporary
Mediterranean
There are several stories of borders and
desires, boundaries and hopes, which are
placed, sometimes hidden and veiled,
under the relentless flow of the Mediterranean waters. The plural, diverse and
intercultural language of art constitutes
the key to access these stories and the way
to discover other narratives and perspectives. People lost in mobility; subjectivities
and identities that live the border, the
language and the translation as a permanent status of being here and elsewhere;
stories of journeys, transits and migrations;
metaphors of sufferings, privations and
wars; attempts to belong to, and struggles
to escape from, are some of the issues
narrated by the artists and that will be
38
39
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
analysed in the research. The paper wants
to address these subjects throughout
images, words and narrations, questioning
the aesthetical and cognitive role of art, as
well as the role of female artists as generators of alternative narratives. The paper
focuses on artists that are looking for
other experiences, emotions, breaths and
desires, to catch, share, interpret and narrate. The artistic practices of women like,
among others, Gülsün Karamustafa, Emily
Jacir, Zineb Sedira, Bouchra Khalili, Lamia
Joreige, Rima Maroun and Mona Hatoum,
will help us to reveal those hidden stories
caught in between the hardness of borders and the sensitivity of desires.
Herman Bashiron Mendolicchio, PhD,
University of Barcelona, is a faculty member
at Transart Institute (NY-Berlin) and was
Post-Doctoral Visiting Researcher at United
Nations University - Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility. His lines of investigation involve the subjects of intercultural
processes, globalization and mobility in
contemporary art and cultural policies, the
cultural interactions in the Mediterranean
and the cultural cooperation between
Asia and Europe. As an art critic and independent curator he writes extensively for
several international magazines.
Parvati Nair
UNU-GCM
Home-Work: The Gender Politic of
Urban Immigrant Relocation
Based on the Women of the World: Home
and Work in Barcelona project (to be
exhibited at the Sant Pau Art Nouveau
site and available via the website of UNUGCM: gcm.unu.edu), this paper examines
processes of relocation engaged in by
the subjects who took part. My focus
here is on the ways in which, for female
immigrants, the private and the public, the
home and the world, the familiar and the
strange become intertwined, as they seek
to build, or re-build, their lives in new contexts. Processes of migration, relocation,
gender adaptations and cultural hybridization become the modes through which a
gendered politic of relocation, understood
as strategies through which to negotiate
new terrains, is shaped. In turn, this gendered politic contributes to the weave of
the city, confirming the modern metropolis
as a fluid site of cultural uncertainties and
possibilities, where the uprootings of
globalization and its inherent mobilities
are witnessed in the everyday.
Central to the ideas explored in this paper
is the notion of the unhomely. I shall make
reference here to Homi Bhabha’s reworking of Freud’s concept of the unheimlich,
as also to the ways in which the idea of the
unhomely forces an implication between
private and public spheres, most especially in contexts of mobility. Such an implication immediately impacts at multiple levels
– the subjective, the collective, the social,
and the urban, overturning demarcations
between natives and immigrants, self and
other. In turn, the city propagates itself on
this dynamic of the unhomely.
Parvati Nair directs the United Nations
University Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility. She is also Professor of
Hispanic, Cultural and Migration Studies at
Queen Mary, University of London, where
she directed the Centre for the Study of
Migration. Her research is in Cultural Studies, with a particular interest in theories
and representations of migration, mobility,
urban spaces, displacement, ethnicity and
gender. She writes mainly on photography, film and music in these contexts and
relies on an interdisciplinary approach that
includes fieldwork. She is the founder and
Principal Editor of Crossings: Journal of
Migration and Culture. Her publications
include the co-edited books Migration
Across Boundaries: Linking Research to
Practice and Experience (co-edited with
Tendayi Bloom, forthcoming in July 2015
from Ashgate Publishing), Hispanic and
Lusophone Women Filmmakers (2013,
co-edited with Julian Gutiérrez Albilla and
published by Manchester University Press),
and Gender and Spanish Cinema (2006,
co-edited with Steven Marsh and published by Berg). She has authored Configuring Community: Theories, Narratives
and Practices of Community Identities in
Contemporary Spain (2004, MHRA), Rumbo al norte: inmigración y movimientos
culturales entre el Magreb y España (2006,
Edicions Bellaterra) and A Different Light:
The Photography of Sebastião Salgado
(2011, Duke University Press).
Kate Neyts
UNU-CRIS (Belgium)
Women in the Flemish Labour
Market: Disempowerment through
Sticky Floors?
In this presentation, a study that investigated whether employer preferences
regarding the gender of their employees
are important in the explaining of “sticky
floors” in the Flemish labour market is
presented. Sticky floors can be described
as the pattern that women are, compared
to men, less likely to (start to) climb the job
ladder, and on the basis of an extensive
field experiment, unequal treatment based
on gender could be identified. A similar
study on unequal treatment between
native and immigrant men is also presented, leading to connect the findings of both
studies. From this, we draw conclusions
regarding immigrant women in the Flemish labour market and elaborate on the
“double burden of discrimination” they
face for being both women and migrants.
The presentation will reflect upon the
structural and discriminatory dimensions
that affect the participation of immigrant
women in the labour market and its consequences for policy.
Kate Neyts is a research intern at the United Nations University Institute on Comparative Regional Integration Studies (UNUCRIS), where she works as a researcher
for the UNU-UNESCO Chair on Migration,
Free Movement and Regional Integration.
She holds a Master of Science in Economics from Ghent University and has shortly
worked as a research assistant with the
UNU-GCM, where she contributed to the
“Women of the World: Home and Work
in the City” project. Her research interests
include migration, gender studies, labour
economics and social policy.
40
41
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Maggie O´Neill
Durham University (UK)
Women, Well-being and
Community: Enacting and
Building Cultural Citizenship
Using Participatory Arts and
Participatory Action Research
(PAR) with Women Seeking
Asylum and Refuge.
Committed to exploring democratic ways
of doing research with migrant women
and taking up the theme of ‘enacting
citizenship’ for theory and practice, this paper draws upon a participatory arts-based
research project with women seeking
asylum in the North East of England.
Together we developed a participatory
arts and participatory action research
project that focused upon well-being and
community in order to: better understand
women’s experiences of living in the North
East; challenge and change sexual and
social inequalities; stimulate high quality
research and art; and impact upon policy
and praxis. In sharing some of the images
and narratives created by women participants that offer multi-sensory, dialogic
and visual routes to understanding, this
paper suggests that arts-based methodologies, including walking biographies,
might counter exclusionary processes and
practices, generate greater knowledge
and understanding of women’s resources
in building and performing cultural citizenship; and deliver on social justice by
facilitating a radical democratic imaginary.
Maggie O´Neill is Professor in Applied
Social Sciences and co-directs the Centre
for Sex, Gender and Sexualities at Durham
University. She Chairs the ESA Research
Network 3 ‘Biographical Perspectives on
European Societies’. Recent publications
include: Advances in Biographical Methods: creative applications (Routledge)
edited with Brian Roberts and Andrew
Sparkes; Asylum, Migration and Community (Policy Press); a special section on the
Slow University in Forum for Qualitative
Research and with photographer John
Perivolaris ‘A sense of belonging: walking
with Thaer through migration, memories
and space’ in Crossings: Journal of Migration & Culture Volume 5.
Maria Paradiso
University of Sannio (Italy)
Emotional Geographies of
Female Mobilities and Agency in
the Mediterranean: Explorative
Narratives from Muslim Migrant
Women in an Italian Case Study.
The presentation focuses on migrant residents and citizenship identities and agency behaviour, and how these are shaped
by emotional and relational experiences
of being women in Muslim communities
in Italy.
In this paper, an exploratory case for
further research steps, I explore the residentiality narratives of women from North
African countries in Italy and examine how
lifeworlds are shaped in their community
by values, social codes and interactions
with the hosting places, people and
own community members. Specifically
I address their geography of emotions
highlighted as a result of the interplay of
the spatial and social boundaries which
form their daily mobility and practices and
the embodied troubles or opportunities of
their condition of gendered not privileged
migrants. I am interested in the condition
of Muslim women in migrants community
as a result of being detached from native
place and encountering ‘difference’ event
still asked to perpetuate traditional habits
in Muslim observant family. The condition
of migrants women is a main factor in
coping with difference in contemporary
Western life and have many implications
for a better society.
Acknowledgement: This presentation
relates to research project on going under
Mediterranean changing relationships:
global change, networks and border
openings MEDCHANGe (FP7 IRSES- Marie
Curie)
Maria Paradiso, born in Naples (Italy),
1966, is a Doctor in Political Geography
(University of Trieste, Sorbonne and other
Consortiated), Professor of Geography
and Planning at the University of Sannio
in Benevento (Italy), Member Academia
Europaea Social Sciences Committee, she
is founder and the first Chair of the International Geographical Union (IGU) Commission ‘Mediterranean Basin’. She has
served as Vice Chair of the IGU Commission ‘Geography of Information Society’
till 2012 and has been contributing since
2001 to the development nationally and
internationally of this new field of research
in Geography with an interdisciplinary
perspective. Currently she is Primary
Coordinator of FP7 People Marie Curie
IRSES MEDCHANGe – Euromediterranean
changing relationships 612639, a research
and mobility Euromediterranean partnerships with nine Universities from Europe,
North Africa, Middle East. Maria got teaching, conference, and research invitations
by several Universities and Academies
from all over the world such as the Uni-
versity of Bordeaux Montaigne, Lexington
University, Sorbonne Paris, University of
Toulouse, Le Havre, the National University
of Seoul, University of Tokyo and Waseda,
University of Ankara, Istanbul, Hassan
II Mohammed Casablanca, Cadi Ayyad
Marrakesh, CERES Tunis, Israeli Academy
of Science and University of Cape Town.
Her main interest now is the exploration
of changes in the Mediterranean relationships through narratives of people
in mobilities across the Mediterranean
and the better understanding of cultural
dialogue and human development.
Montserrat Pallarès
Parellada
METROPOLIS (Spain)
METROPOLIS Women
International Network
The METROPOLIS Women International
Network is a forum for sharing experiences and co-operation between women
working at a local and metropolitan level
as managers of METROPOLIS member
cities, public policy leaders, businesswomen, professionals, civil society leaders and
academics.
The network was set up in 2005 as part
of the METROPOLIS World Association
of the Major Metropolises in order to
introduce the gender perspective into the
association’s debates and activities – gender mainstreaming – as an action strategy
to achieve real and effective equality
between men and women and safer and
more inclusive cities.
The network has two fundamental aims:
firstly, to promote women’s active partici-
42
43
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
pation in decision-making in METROPOLIS
and in relation to local policies in member
cities; and secondly, to motivate these
cities to make a commitment to gender
equality.
Its main areas of work are: 1) Encouraging
and promoting urban development that is
sensitive to the social, economic, cultural,
environmental and all other aspects of
gender-related issues, and 2) Working to
establish a global agenda and specific
agendas for each region that will make
it possible to defend women’s rights in
the various international forums on which
METROPOLIS is represented.
The network includes 15 regional antennas that play a strategic part in increasing
and improving our capacity for social
transformation. The exchanges and
partnerships forged within the network
prevail over any geographical and cultural
distance or difference, thereby strengthening the empowerment of women and
the promotion of gender equality in major
cities around the entire world.
Montserrat Pallarès Parellada received a
degree in Social Security and Labour Law
from Pompeu Fabra University (UPF) in
Barcelona in 1992. In 1993 she joined the
Socialist Party of Catalonia (PSC). In 1999
she joined the Local Executive Commission of Castelldefels and was appointed
Secretary of Communication, a post she
held until 2002. She was a member of the
National Council of the PSC from 2003 to
2006.
From 2003-2007 she was chosen as
Councillor for Castelldefels Town Hall as
well as a Metropolitan Council member
of the Association of Municipalities of the
Barcelona Metropolitan Area. She has also
served as President of the Board of Communication of Castelldefels (2003-2005),
President of the Sectorial Council on Civic
Participation and Institutional Relations
(2003-2007) and President of the Sectorial
Council on Tourism (2003-2007).
In April 1998 she joined the Secretariat
General of Metropolis in Barcelona, where
she worked until 2003. She is currently
employed as an expert on Institutional
Relations at the Association of Municipalities of the Barcelona Metropolitan Area,
and has been the Institutional Relations
Manager for Metropolis since June 2007,
as well as Coordinator of the Metropolis
Women International Network since
September 2011.
Sine Plambech
Danish Institute for International
Studies (Denmark)
Becky’s Journey (2014)
This film is about Becky, a 26-year-old
Nigerian woman who made two attempts
to go to Europe to sell sex. The first time
she was intercepted with counterfeit
documents in the airport in Lagos, Nigeria,
by immigration authorities. This made her
decide to begin a deadly journey through
the Sahara desert hoping to embark on a
smuggler boat bound for Italy. The film is
about migration, sex work and human trafficking seen from the perspective of Becky.
We meet Becky as she contemplates what
to do next.
The film has been screened or is selected
for screenings at a number of film festivals
around the world, including the Copenhagen International Sex Worker Film Festival
(2014) (Opening film) and Just Gather Film
Festival March 2015 (Edinburgh).
Sine Plambech is a social anthropologist
and filmmaker. She is currently a post-Doc
research fellow at the Danish Institute
for International Studies and a previous
research fellow at Columbia University in
New York. She works in Nigeria on the topic of deportation of Nigerian sex workers
from the EU, and among Nigerians selling
sex in the streets of Copenhagen. She also
works in Thailand on sex work and marriage migration of Thai women to the EU.
Becky´s Journey is her fifth film. Her other
films on marriage migration, sex work
migration and humanitarianism have won
several awards, screened at numerous
festivals and sold to national television
broadcasters in most European countries.
Becky´s Journey is her latest film and
selected for several film festivals.
Nina Sahraoui
London Metropolitan University (UK)
Emotions in Care Work:
A Worker’s Best Asset or Biggest
Threat?
This paper analyses migrant care workers’
discourses around emotional labour in
London, Paris and Madrid. It is based upon
84 semi-structured interviews conducted
in these three cities with care workers
employed in private residential and domiciliary care. The underlying conceptualisation of care as an extension of women’s
domestic work created a gendered sector
that is characterised by precarious employment terms and working conditions.
Moreover, the articulation of migration,
employment and social care regimes,
underpinned by the neoliberal dynamics of market extension and consumer
choice, fostered the growth of for-profit
care providers that rely on a migrant
workforce. Against this background, this
paper analyses how emotional labour is
rendered invisible. This paper argues that
committment, love and attachment play a
particular role in building up care workers’
occupational identity, dignity and pride.
The ‘ethics of care’ that emerges from respondents’ discourses enters in this regard
in contradiction with professionalization
attempts that teach detachment and deem
emotional commitment unprofessional.
The paper further argues that the dominant professional norms reflect gendered
conceptualisations of what constitutes
work and fail to acknowledge the centrality of emotional labour. Building upon this
analysis, the paper calls for an extension of
the concept of ‘emotional labour’ in order
to address theoretically the complexity
of care workers’ narratives in which they
are active agents performing emotional
labour, in which they portray a use of emotions and attachment that render the work
bearable and finally, in which they account
for the emotional distress that their interactions with residents can trigger.
Nina Sahraoui studied at the Institute of
Political Science in Paris and graduated in
International Affairs. She worked for two
years as Project Officer in the Rabat School
of Governance and Economics in Morocco. Nina is now a Marie Curie Early Stage
Researcher and PhD candidate at London
44
45
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Metropolitan University. Her doctoral
research focuses on migrant workers’
experiences in elder care in London, Paris
and Madrid. Her research interests revolve
around a gendered political economy
analysis of the articulation of employment,
care and migration regimes.
Fabrizio Sarrica
United Nations Office on Drug and
Crime (Austria)
Women in Trafficking in Persons;
Results from the UNODC Global
Report on Trafficking in Persons
Since the year 2006, UNODC has published four Global Reports on Trafficking in
Persons, the latest published in November
2014. UNODC is currently working on the
next edition of the Report that will focus on
trafficking, migration and diasporas.
The Global Reports reported about the
criminal exploitation in forced labour and
sexual exploitation of women, domestically
and internationally. About 70 per cent of
detected victims of trafficking around the
world are females. Females are clearly trafficked for sexual exploitation. At the same
time, women and girls in large number are
also exploited in forced labour, as 35% of
all detected victims of trafficking for forced
labour are females. The share of adult
women among total victims detected has
decreased since 2004. However, this is partially offset by the increased share of young
girls, passing from 10 per cent to 21 per
cent since 2004. The Global Report pointed
at the role of the women not as traffickers.
Data for the period 2010 to 2012 indicate
that traffickers are mostly men but the
share of suspected and convicted female
offenders (38 per cent) is distinctively high,
especially when compared to the female
offending rates in other types of crime
(about 18 per cent). In the different editions
of the Report, UNODC has explored the
reasons and the roles women have in the
exploitation of other women.
Fabrizio Sarrica is a Research Officer for
the Global Report on Trafficking in Persons
Unit of the United Nations Office on Drugs
and Crime (UNODC). Mr. Sarrica holds a
PhD in Criminology, a Master degree in
Economics and International Relation and a
University degree in Economics. Mr. Sarrica has been working as a researcher for
UNODC since the year 2002. In this role, he
has conducted research and assessments
on corruption, organized crime, smuggling
of migrants and trafficking in persons
in different parts of the world. He is the
co-author of four UNODC Global Reports
on Trafficking in Persons.
Diana Sherzada
Ludwig Maximillians University
(Germany)
Afghan Women in Germany
betwixt Border Crossing, Media
Coverage and Gender Shifting(s)
As the anthropologist Lila Abu-Lughod
raised up her doubts about the images of
Muslim and especially Afghan women that
are offered in the West she felt the urge to
question: “Do muslim women (really) need
saving?” (2003; 2013) In drawing attention
to the media figurations campaigning on
human/women´s rights and the prevailing
politics of violence, she marked out that
women in Afghanistan have long been
portrayed as passive victims awaiting
liberation from the West.
Many actors still foster this monodirectional view on gender, agency and ethnicity.
While casually referring to shrouded figures and signs as the “battleflag of burqa”
(Toynbee 2002) they fail to explain the
fluidities of Afghan women´s identities in
the Afghan Diaspora. In drawing them out
alongside iconographic symbols of oppression they dismiss the many challenges
members of the Afghan diaspora have to
face traversing cultural and biographical
processes, gender orders and social relations. Nearby one year past 9/11, Lawanga
told me she feels unseen by the German
majority society and simultaneously
irritated amongst the Afghan community
because of shifting gender and family relations since living abroad and residing in
Germany. Her words marked out her very
special reaching out for new and radical
ways of looking at (orfor) gender identity
as she explained: “In Germany one has to
be male and female!”
Invoking an ethnographic outlook, my approach is to reach out the nexus of migration, female agency and gender identity
amongst an Afghan diaspora community
in Germany. Across the subjectivities of
body experience and place-making the
scale of the transnational multilayered
regiments of border crossing(s), subjectivities and gender identity politics have to be
recognized throughout case studies that
have been gathered since 1996.
Diana Sherzada studied Social and
Cultural Anthropology, Studies of Religion
and Philosophy at the Ludwig-Maximillians-University in Munich (M.A.2003). Her
PhD thesis “Afghan Women in Germany
betwixt gender shifting and border cross-
ing” focuses on female agency and gender identity amongst an Afghan diaspora
community in Germany and was accompanied by Iranian Studies and Sociology. Her
research interests on Postcolonial Studies,
Subjectivity and Identity, Gender and
Migration follow the scale of the transnational multilayered regiments of border
crossing(s), subjectivities and gender
identity politics and are currently focused
on South Asia and Europe.
Christiane
Timmerman
University of Antwerp (Belgium)
Dynamics in Female Migration
and Integration. A Case Study
from Belgium.
In this contribution I want to focus on
the central position of social change
in understanding gendered migration
dynamics. Gender transitions at several
levels (macro, meso and micro) in both the
region of origin and destination (Belgium)
structure the migration processes of men
and women. A second important element
that has to be taken into consideration is a
longitudinal perspective, where migration
and integration are no longer considered
as sequential distinct phases, but as one
migration career. From this perspective,
we can analyze how gender identities
(but also identities related to the legal
status and social class) change over time
(before and after migration; over time
in Belgium) and on several life domains
(labor and family). In this respect, identities
are approached as social constructions,
shaped and modified in interaction with
46
47
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Michaella Vanore
Maastricht Graduate School of Governance/ UNU-MERIT (The Netherlands)
The Feminisation of Migration
from Moldova and the
Implications for Children ‘Left
Behind’
the direct surroundings and the broader
transnational context.
Christiane Timmerman holds a MA in
Psychology and a MaNaMa and a PhD in
Social and Cultural Anthropology (University of Leuven). Currently, she is a fulltime
research professor (ZAP-BOF) in charge of
the Centre for Migration and Intercultural
Studies (CeMIS), University of Antwerp.
She coordinates (coordinated) several
large scale (inter)national research projects: The FP7 - project EUMAGINE ‘Imagining Europe the Outside’ (2010 – 2013),
the FP7- project RESL.EU ‘Reducing Early
School Leaving in Europe’ (2013 – 2018),
the IWT – project BET YOU (2009 – 2012)
on school careers of youngsters with and
without an immigration background; the
BELSPO – project FEMIGRIN (2009 – 2011)
on female migration and integration. She
is also one of the supervisors of the Policy
Centre on Civic Integration (2012 – 2015)
which focuses on integration dynamics in
Flanders from an interdisciplinary perspective. Christiane Timmerman is also
supervisor of a substantial amount of PhD
research projects. She teaches Anthropology and Interdisciplinary Perspectives on
Migration and Integration at University of
Antwerp.
Within transnational family studies, a
growing body of literature has investigated how children in spatially-separated
families function given the absence of
their migrant kin, chiefly parents. Much of
this literature has explored the potential
consequences of parental migration for
different aspects of child well-being,
including psychological health. In some
countries, the study of the ‘left behind’ has
occurred against a backdrop of negative
public discourses about (female) migration.
Using Moldova as a case study, the links
between gendered mobility patterns and
the potential consequences for children
who remain in the home country following
parental migration are explored. Using
data collected in 2011/12, this paper uses
binary and multinomial logit regression
models to predict the migration propensities of men and women. Analyses reveal
that while Moldovan women are significantly less likely to migrate than men, they
do have much higher odds of migrating
to a country beyond the Commonwealth
of Independent States, and certain factors
(i.e. divorce) corresponded to higher
migration odds among women but not
men. The selectivity of certain kinds of
individuals into migration is likely to carry
implications for the well-being of children
‘left behind’.
Annabelle Wilkins
Queen Mary, University of London (UK)
Secondly, the psychosocial health of
children with migrant parents is compared
to that of children without migrant parents
using probit models. The results find that
maternal migration is not significantly
associated with worse child psychosocial
health outcomes, whereas the paternal
migration increased the probability that
boys expressed worse emotional symptoms and conduct problems. These results
suggest that the distinctly gendered nature of migration can carry different consequences for children ‘left behind’ and that
assumptions about the deleterious effects
of female migration for children should be
more critically examined.
Michaella Vanore (PhD expected 2015) is
a research fellow at the Maastricht Graduate School of Governance/UNU-MERIT,
where she has worked on a series of
research projects related to migration
and development for the past five years.
In the course of her work at the School
of Governance, Michaella has worked on
projects commissioned and funded by
the European Commission, IOM, Dutch
Ministry of Foreign Affairs, OxfamNovib,
UNICEF, UNDEF, and Dutch entrepreneurial development bank (FMO). Within
these projects Michaella has gained
competence in analysing the intersection
between migration and development,
migration and family, and migration and
gender. Michaella’s own research interests
focus on the potential consequences of
migration for the well-being of children
remaining in the home country, the feminization of migration, migration and health,
and diaspora studies.
Intersections between Gender,
‘Home’ and Activism among
Women’s Organizations on the
Myanmar-Thailand border
This paper examines the intersections between gender, activism and ‘home’ among
migrant women on the Thailand-Myanmar
border. Drawing upon ethnographic
research conducted within a non-governmental women’s organization in Northern
Thailand, the paper demonstrates that on
their frequently perilous journeys across
the border, women gain access to skills,
knowledge and social networks that
enable them to influence socio-cultural
change within their communities. This
paper is framed within critical geographies
of home, mobility and border studies, and
extends previous research on migrant
women’s activism in the Thailand-Myanmar
borderlands. First, the paper addresses
the strategies developed by women in
order to negotiate State regulation, and
the multiple tensions that exist between
their pursuit of political recognition and
the precarious conditions of life on the
border, particularly for women of irregular migration status. Second, the paper
considers the ways in which the porous,
liminal space of the border is utilized
by migrant women as a resource in their
campaigns. I propose that women’s activism
on the Thailand-Myanmar border disrupts
understandings of home, (forced) migration and gender. Through their collaborative work across borders, women gain
new perspectives on gender and nation
and are empowered to contest traditional
discourses on the position of women in
48
49
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Myanmar. The paper concludes with a
discussion of how migrant women activists
are leading socio-cultural change in their
communities, influencing the region’s shifting political landscape.
Annabelle Wilkins is a PhD candidate in
the School of Geography at Queen Mary,
University of London. Her current research
examines relationships between home,
work and the city for Vietnamese migrants
in East London, and she has previously
conducted ethnographic research on the
Thailand-Myanmar border. Her research
interests include gender, mobility and
Southeast Asian studies, and she has
collaborated with museums, non-governmental and community organizations.
Brandais York
University of Melbourne (Australia)
The Gendered Burden of Poverty:
Unravelling the Relationship
between Women, Family, and
Economics in Cambodia
In the three decades that have passed
since Pol Pot’s brutal rule of Cambodia,
the contours of life have been drastically
reshaped by social, political, and economic developments. One of these has been
the rise of the female-headed household,
which has seen a drastic shift in the roles
women now assume in modern Cambodian society. Perhaps most visible has
been the important position females now
hold within the Cambodian labour sector,
particularly in the migrant labour industry. This paper will describe how while
women have become increasingly vital to
Cambodia’s rapidly growing economy, the
traditional role of Khmer women in society
remains prescribed in the conservative
tradition of ChbapSrey (the sister’s law).
The code of the ChbapSrey reflects the
Theravada Buddhism belief that women
hold a lower status than men, and includes
details on how a woman should behave
within the family, especially in relation to
her husband. Under the code, a Khmer
woman is expected to do whatever is
necessary to support the financial wellbeing of her family, mandating that all work
ultimately be done in service to her husband and family. This paper will argue that
for the modern Cambodian woman, the
synonymous relationship of marriage, family, and income has created a situation in
which she bears the full burden of poverty.
This relationship has created an undefined
and blurred relationship between consent
and coercion within the economic market,
the consequence of which has been a
predictable rise in the vulnerability of
women – particularly for those that choose
the route of migration.
Brandais York holds an MA in Public Policy and International Affairs from The American University of Paris (’11), and an MSc in
Global Migration from University College
London (’12). She worked as a researcher
on labor migration, development, and
gender for a local NGO in Phnom Penh
for three years before relocating to Melbourne to pursue her PhD in Law. Brandais
expects to complete her dissertation on
International Marriage Migration in 2017.
50
51
Female Agency, Mobility and Socio-cultural Change
11th and 12th June 2015
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Women of the
World: Home and
Work in Barcelona
gcm.unu.edu/women-of-the-world
June 12th 2015: Photograph
Exhibit Inauguration
Programme
June 11th 2015: The New
Barcelonians: Migration, Work
and Family in the City, Centre
de Cultura Contemporània de
Barcelona (CCCB)
What are the lives of immigrant women in
Barcelona like? How have they established
themselves and made a new home in
this city? The United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and
Mobility (UNU-GCM), based in Barcelona,
has carried out research with immigrant
women from diverse social and cultural
origins to see how they have constructed
personal and professional lives in our city,
placing special emphasis on those aspects
that affect women. The result is an impassioned panorama of the trajectories of
women from all over the world, who have
made Barcelona their home and that we
now present for the first time to the public
at the Centre for Contemporary Culture in
Barcelona.
*Interpretation will be available in English
and Catalan
19:00 Introduction by Parvati
Nair, Director of the United
Nations University Institute on
Globalization, Culture and Mobility
(UNU-GCM), Barcelona
19:15 Women’s mobile lives: walking,
sensing and belonging in urban
spaces, Opening address by
Maggie O’Neill, Professor at the
School of Applied Social Sciences,
University of Durham
19:40 Presentation of “Women of
the World. Home and Work in
Barcelona”
UNU-GCM is pleased to collaborate
with the Sant Pau Art Nouveau Site in
presenting the exhibition Women of the
World: Home and Work in Barcelona, a
collection of images and oral histories
collected by Tatiana Diniz as part of the
research project of the same title run by
UNU-GCM and directed by Parvati Nair.
Women of the World: Home and Work in
Barcelona explores the trajectories and
experiences of first-generation immigrant
women to Barcelona through the axes of
gender, home, work and the city. Through
the means of photographs taken at city
locations of their choice and through oral
narratives that they shared, the women
who took part in this project explore and
recount their perspectives, experiences
and memories of migration, relocation and
finding work in the city. Their reflections
throw light on Barcelona, as a city that
evolves through diversity and the everyday efforts of its citizens.
19:50 Discussion with the participants in
the research project: Deepti Golani
(India), Bombo Ndir (Senegal), and
Joice Ortuño (Venezuela)
This exhibition forms one of the outputs of
the Women of the World: Home and Work
in Barcelona research project. It will be
held at the San Rafael Pavilion of the Sant
Pau Art Nouveau Site.
Moderator Luis Benvenuty, journalist
Reception to follow
Tatiana Diniz is a visual anthropologist with
expertise in documentary photography.
Photographs:
© UNU-GCM Photo/Tatiana Diniz
Barcelona, 2015
Inauguration
June 12th, 13:00h: San Rafael Pavilion,
Sant Pau Art Nouveau Site
Programme
13.00h
Brief Opening: Parvati Nair, Director of
UNU-GCM
Introduction: Tatiana Diniz, Photographer
of Women of the World: Home and Work
in Barcelona
Opening Address: Jordi Baiget, Chair of
the Board of the Sant Pau Foundation
Inauguration address: Ivet Castaño, Territorial Coordinator of Barcelona, Catalan
Women’s Institute
53
List of participating
institutions
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
American University in Cairo (Egypt)
Centre de Cultura Contemporània de Barcelona (Spain)
City University of New York (USA)
Comillas Pontifical University (Spain)
Danish Institute for International Studies (Denmark)
Durham University (UK)
London Metropolitan University (UK)
Ludwig Maximillians University (Germany)
Maastricht Graduate School of Governance/ UNU-MERIT (The Netherlands)
Metropolis (Spain)
Middlesex University (UK)
Pompeu Fabra University (Spain)
Queen Mary, University of London (UK)
Radboud University Nijmegen (The Netherlands)
Shih Hsin University (Taiwan)
Toledo International Centre for Peace (Spain)
UN Women (USA)
UNESCO (India)
United Nations Office on Drug and Crime (Austria)
United Nations University- CRIS (Belgium)
United Nations University- GCM (Spain)
Universidade Aberta (Portugal)
Università della Svizzera italiana (Switzerland)
University of Antwerp (Belgium)
University of Barcelona (Spain)
University of Essex (UK)
University of Melbourne (Australia)
University of Oxford (UK)
University of Padua (Italy)
University of Sannio (Italy)
University of Valencia (Spain)
Notes
United Nations University
Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
Sant Manuel Pavilion, Sant Pau Art Nouveau Site
C/Sant Antoni Maria Claret, 167
08025 Barcelona, Spain
Tel: (+34) 93 556 59 91
gcm.unu.edu
[email protected]
UNU Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
@unugcm
UNU Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility
#womenoftheworld
#UNUGCM