Market Commentary - Medallion Wealth

Second Quarter Comments
Checking returns for most US equity indexes for the
first quarter of 2015 was like watching a duck swimming
on a pond – very little visible change, but a lot of action
under the surface. For the first quarter, the S&P 500
turned in a 1.0% total return. Below the relatively benign
move in the S & P 500, sector and style returns were
more defined. On the positive side, Healthcare was up a
solid 6.5%, followed by Consumer Discretionary turning
in a respectable plus 4.8%. On the other end of the
spectrum, Utilities were down (-5.2%) over concern with
the Federal Reserve ending Quantitative Easing (QE)
and beginning to raise interest rates sometime in 2015.
With the Fed Funds rate currently at, or near, zero for the
past six years, interest rate concerns have weighed on
those sectors with slower growth profiles. Consumer
Staples and Materials matched the market returns at 1%.
Dominating the headlines for more than a quarter
has been oil price declines, and that has spilled over into
the Energy sector, driving it down by (-2.9%).
It was a quarter that saw disparate performance by
style, size and location. S&P Growth was up 2.5%, with
Value down (-0.7%). The S&P 600 small cap was up
4.0%, and the Mega cap 100 was a negative (-0.1%). It
paid to have funds allocated overseas, for a change.
Germany, France, China “A” shares markets and Japan
were up 22.0, 17.8, 15.9 and 10.1 percent, respectively.
While the US monetary authorities are trying to unwind
an easy money policy, the European Central Bank (ECB)
and the Bank of Japan are ramping up their QE
programs. The ECB began to purchase bonds at the rate
of $65 billion per month until the middle of next year, and
if they don’t think they have done enough, they will
continue at whatever pace they think necessary.
When deciding on a topic to review in the Q1 market
comment, we discussed the inclusion of the usual top
issues of the day, the huge move in energy prices, the
outlook for interest rates, speculation on when the Fed
will begin “lift off,” and dollar strength and concomitant
weakness in the Euro and Yen. Although they are all
important, “top-of-mind” topics, we feel there has been,
2605 Nicholson Road, Building 2, Suite 103,
Sewickley, PA 15143
724-934-8600
April 2015
and continues to be more than enough written and said
about these significant issues. To be honest, our ability
to add great insight to these issues and touch on nuance
not available elsewhere is unlikely. Consequently, we
have chosen a road less traveled.
The typical pattern for analysts and companies to
issue earnings estimates involves a sort of “Kabuki
dance,” where estimates are released several quarters in
advance of when they are to actually be reported. The
dance begins as we approach reporting date. Usually,
the company begins by trying to lower expectations by
guiding analysts to lower their estimates. As time
passes, the established trend continues with lowered
guidance leading to lowered estimates, so when earnings
are actually reported – Surprise! -- actual earnings are
better than the most recently revised estimates, and –
Low and Behold! -- the company beats the estimates.
This year, however, estimates have been reduced at
an accelerated rate. Please see the following chart
(Chart A). According to Zack’s, at the end of 2014, Q1
earnings growth was expected to be 4.3%. As we enter
reporting season, that projection has fallen to (-4.6%).
And worse, Q2 expectations have declined from an
earnings increase of 5.3% for the S&P 500 to a now
negative (-1.9%). As seen in the past, there is still plenty
of time for further downward revisions to second quarter
estimates. There is little doubt that the topics of the day,
as mentioned above, have had a significant impact on
these earnings expectations.
Also to be considered, we believe the long cold
winter experienced by the entire Eastern United
States, and the extended slow down at West Coast
ports created a potent witch’s brew and put corporate
earnings growth into “Sleeping Beauty” stasis. We
believe that several of these issues are temporary, like
the port strike and the weather. The negative impact
from the others is a result of the rate of change, not
the change itself. In other words, it can be argued that
lower energy costs and a stronger dollar are positive
events; it’s the trauma of getting there that is the
negative.
PAGE 1
Second Quarter Comments
April 2015
CHART A
Chart courtesy of Strategas Research Partners LLC
That leaves us with the Fed and the concern over the
impact of a “lift off” in interest rates, sometime in 2015.
We would suggest that before they commit to increasing
rates, the economy will need to be on a sound footing.
That being the case, we don’t believe slightly higher
interest rates will ultimately be a major negative.
So where does that leave us? If the decline in
earnings estimates has gone too far, then perhaps the
first quarter pause in the major stock indexes will be the
pause that refreshes. This will be true especially if Q2
earnings estimate revisions are overdone and this year
turns out to be one of the exceptions as we approach Q2
reporting. Should estimate revisions stop going down
and reverse into July, perhaps the market may surprise
us as 2015 progresses.
Securities offered through Cambridge Investment Research, Inc., a brokerdealer, member FINRA/SIPC. Advisor services offered through
Cambridge Investment Research Advisors, Inc., a Registered Investment
Adviser. Cambridge and Medallion Wealth Management, Inc., are not
affiliated. Asset allocation and diversification strategies cannot assure
profit or protect against loss in a generally declining market, and past
performance does not guarantee future results. Indices mentioned are
unmanaged, do not incur fees, and cannot be invested into directly.
Material discussed herewith is meant for general illustration and/or
informational purposes only. Please note that individual situations can
vary; therefore, the information should be relied upon when coordinated
with individual professional advice.
PAGE 2