EZxhibit
-e-ems---
A
-
-
‘roduct
lealing Garden White Te
otion, Sanctuary
h Tao Body Wash
Revlon Love Pat Moisturi
:reamy Ivory
ingredient is safe for use in cosmetic products
until the appropriate safety data have been
obtained and evaluated,” CIR at 10.
product use. The CIR Expert Panel cannot
conclude whether Arachidonic Acid is safe for
Exhibit A (Page 1 of 15)
Exhibit
A
i Product
8philosophy hope in a jar, therapeutic
,moisturizer for drv sensitive skin
PHYTOSPECIFIC Beauty Styling Creme
Ingredient
arachidonic acid
CIR Conclusion
See id.
arachidonic acid
See id.
PHYTOSPECIFIC Hydra-Repairing
.Shamooo
ABBA Gelsential Maximum Support
Styling Gel
arachidonic acid
See id,
azulene
Alba Botanica Sea Kelp Toner
Avalon Natural Products, Rosemary/Mint
atulene
atulene
“The CIR Expert Panel concludes that the
availabe data are insufficient to support the
safety of Azulene for use in cosmetic
oroducts.” CIR at 27.
See id.
See id.
azulene
See id.
azulene
See id.
azulene
See id.
azulene
See id.
azulene
azulene
See id.
ISee id.
f Nature’s Gate Roll-On Deodorant, Spring lazulene
ISee id.
Jason Natural Cosmetics Tea Tree
(Deodorant Stick
Jason Natural Cosmetics Witch Vera,
84% Aloe Gel
JASON Natural Cosmetics, Fresh
Botanicals Hairsorav
JASON Natural Cosmetics,
Swimmer’S/Soort Shamooo
Nature’s Gate Antiseptic Liquid Soap
iNature’s Gate Cool Mint Gel Natural
en Gel Natural
ng Azulene Oil, F
alendula Officinalis for use in cosmetic
AHAVA Time Line Age
Andrea FaceQ’s Face M
Aussie Knot Forqotten Detangler
Aussie Moist Conditioner for
Drv/Damaaed Hair
Aussie Shampoo, Moist for Dry/Damaged
-Hair
Avalon Natural Products, Lavender
Calendula officinalis
Calendula officinalis
See id.
See id.
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Calendula offrcinalis
See id.
Exhibit A (Page 2 of 15)
exhibit A
Product
Avalon Natural Products
,& Bodv Lotion
Avalon Natural Products,
.Conditioner
Avalon Natural Products
.Deodorant
Avalon Natural Products,
Hand & Bodv Lotion
Avalon Natural Products
Aveda Brilliant, Universal Styling Creme
Calendula officinalis
IAveda Color Enhancing Conditioner,
ICalendula officinalis
ISee id.
Calendula offlcinalis
6
See id.
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Calendula offtcinalis
Calendula officinalis
See id.
See id.
Calendula offlcinalis
Deiux Beauty Tintstik For the Lips,
Bubbles SPFl5
Delux Beauty Tintstik For the Lips, Dot
Calendula officinalis
SPF15
Delux Beauty Tintstik For the Lips, Pinky Calendula officinalis
See id.
Aveda Shampoo, Camornile for
Hiahliahts & Blondes
Back to Basics Sunflower, Moisture
Jnfusina Shamuoo for all hair tvoes
DDF Sensitive Skin Cleansing Gel
Delux Beauty Tintstik For the Lips, Betty
Delux Beauty Tintstik Tintstik For the
Calendula
Lips. Darlina SPFl5
Delux Beauty Tintstik Tintstik For the
Calendula
/Lit% Flossv SPF15
Elizabeth Arden Green Tea Honey Drops Calendula
Bodv Cream
Fresh Suqarbath Body Lotion, Lemon
Calendula
Fresh Sugarbath Body L.otion, Lily
Calendula
Fresh Sugarbath Body Lotion, Lychee
Calendula
[Calendula
IFresh Sugarbath Body Polish, Brown
Herbal Essences Shampoo, Extra Body
/for Fine, Limp Hair
Jack Black Face Buff, Energizing Scrub
Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel
Jason Natural Cosmetics Satin Soap,
See id.
See id.
officinalis
See id.
offlcinalis
See id.
officinalis
See id.
officinalis
officinalis
officinalis
officinaiis
See
See
See
ISee
id.
id.
id.
id.
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Calendula officina,lis
See id.
Calendula officinalis
See id.
JASON Natural Cosmetics, Citrus 6 In 1
Calendula offlcinalis
See id.
JASON Natural Cosmetics, Healthy
Calendula offlcinalis
See id.
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Calendula offlcinalis
See id.
Calendul& officinalis
See id.
-Aoricot
Mouth Mouthwash
JASON Natural Cosmetics, K Spray Plus
,For Leas
JASON Natural Cosmetics, Satin Soap
JASON Natural Cosmetics, Satin Soap
I
Chamomile
Exhibit A (Page 3 of 25)
I
I
&hibit
A
Product
JASON Natural Cosmetics, Skin-Amins
Ingredient
Catendula offtcinalis
CIR Conclusion
See id.
Mustela Special Maternit
Soecific Suo~ort Bust
Nivea for Men A
I
v
Plumper
Sundari Rose and Lavender Hydrating
Mask
Te Tao Toning Gel, Sargasso Seaweed
and Dana Gui
Visage Nature1 Skin Cleansing Serum
Calendula officinalis
Catendula off3cinalis
See id.
See id.
Calendula officinaiis
See id.
Calendula officinalis
See id.
(Achilles Millefolium)
avaiiabe data are insufficient to support the
safety of Yarrow (Achilles Millefolium) Extract
for use in cosmetic products,” CIR at 275.
Weleda Calendula Baby
Shampoo
Barieile Therapy For Ha
Hand Creme SPF 15
Exhibit A (Page 4 of 15)
Eichifiit
A
safety of Cocamidopropylamine Oxide for use
in cosmetic products,” CIR at 63.
3ATHerapy BATHerapy L
’ cocamidopropyiamine
oxide See id.
TIGI Bed Head, Dumb Blonde Shampoo
cocamidopropylamine
oxide See id.
Umberto Giannini Big & Beautiful
Amazina Volume Mousse Mini
Fresh Rice Face Cream
cocamidopropylamine
oxide See id.
PHYTO Phytobrush Anti-Frizz Shampoo
Fresh Sugar Face Polish
Banana Boat Baby Magic Sunblock
Lotion, SPF 50
Neutrogena Healthy Defense Oil-Free
Sunblock s’orav. SPF 30
Neutrogena HeaItby Defense Oil-Free
Sunblock Stick, SPF 30
Corylus avellana (hazel)
seed oil
“The CIR Panel concludes that the available
data are insufficient to support the safety of . .
Hazel (Corylus Avellana) seed oil . .. in
cosmetic products,” CIR at 108.
Corylus avellana (hazel)
seed oil
dibutyl adipate
’
See id.
dibutyl adipate
“The CIR Expert Panel concludes that the
availabe data are insufficient to support the
safety of Dibutyl Adipate for use in
cosmetics.” CIR at 71.
See id.
dibutyl adipate
See id.
Exhibit A (Page 5 of 15)
Ekhibit
A
Woduct
1Ingredient
CIR Conclusion
?evlon ColorStay Overtime Lash Tint,
3lack
Revlon ColorStay Overtime Lash Tint,
3lackened Brown
Revlon ColorStay Overtime Lash Tint,
3lackest Black
4gree Conditioner, Intensive Moisturizing
Swimmers Solution
ldibutyl adipate
See id.
dibutyl adipate
dibutyl adipate
Consort Hair Spray for Men, Extra Hold,
Unscented. Aerosol
Consort Hairspray for Men, Regular Hold,
4erosol
Sebastian Shaper Plus Hair Spray,
Styling Mist for Super Hold and Extra
Control
Neoteric Beautiful-Nail Herbal Skin
Doctor
dimethyl stearamine
‘The CIR Expert Panel concludes that the
lvailabe data are insufficient to support the
safety of Dimethyl Stearamine and its
lydrochloride salt as used in cosmetics,” CIR ~
3t 79.
See id.
dimethyl stearamine
Tee id.
dimethyl stearamine
I
See id.
drometrizole
‘The safety of this ingredient has not been
documented and substantiated for cosmetic
oroduct use. The CIR Expert Panel cannot
:onclude that Drometrizole is safe for use in
cosmetic products until such time that the
appropriate safety data have been obtained
and evaluated,” CIR at 86.
Back to Basics Basic Style, Curl Catalyst
glucose glutamate
“The CIR Expert Panel concludes that the
availabe data are insufficient to support the
safety of Glucose Glutamate for use in
cd smetic r due
Back to Basics Basic Style, Sleek Creme
glucose glutamate
Back to Basics Basic Style, Up Hold
Back to Basics final fix
glucose qlutamate
glucose glutamate,
lecithin
“On the basis of the animal and clinical data
presented in this report, the Expert Panel
concluded that Lecithin’ and Hydrogenated
Lecithin are safe as used in rinse-off products,
safe for use in leave-on products at
concentrations (less than or equal to) 15%,
and that the data are insufficient to determine
the safety for use in cosmetic products where
Lecithin or Hydrogenated Lecithin are likely to
be inhaled. Lecithin and Hydrogenated
Lecithin should not be used in cosmetic
products in which N-nitroso compounds may
be formed,” CIR at 136.
Back to Basics Basic Style, Liquid Lift
glucose glutamate, sodium
benzoate, lecithin
“The available data are insufficient to support
the safety of these ingredients in cosmetic
products in which a primary route of exposure
is inhalation,” CIR at 32.
dimethyl stearamine
Alpha Hydrox AHA Enhanced Creme, Anti glyceryl dilaurate
Wrinkle Exfoliant
Exhibit A (Page 6 of 15)
“The Expert Panel concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to support the safety of
Glyceryl Dilaurate . .. for use in cosmetic
grdc
o
”
gxhibit A
Product
Ingredient
Alpha Hydrox Moisturizing Daily Lotion,
SPF 15
Copper-tone Sunscreen Lotion, SPF 4
Cure1 Smooth Legs, Shave Minimizing
Moisturizer
Dove Face Care Essential Nutrients, Day
Cream SPF 15
Dove Face Care Essential Nutrients, Day
glyceryl dilaurate
Essentiel
Dream
Essentiel
Relaxina,
Essentiel
UDliftino,
1CIR Conclusion
[See id.
olyceryl dilaurate
glyceryl diiaurate
See id.
See id.
glyceryl dilaurate
I(glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
I
ISee id.
Elements Body Lotion, Citrus
glyceryl dilaurate
Elements Body Lotion,
Joie de Lavender
Elements Body Lotion,
glyceryl dilaurate
See id,
glyceryl dilaurate
See Id.
glyceryl dilaurate
9lyceryl dilaurate
See id.
See id.
Jergens Ash Relief Moisturizer
Jergens Extra Moisturizing Body Wash
with Jeraens Lotion
Jergens Extra Moisturizing Hand Wash,
Cherrv Almond Scent
Jergens Naturally Smooth Shave
Minimizina Moisturizer
Jergens Original Scent Lotion with
Cherrv Almond Scent for Drv Skin
Jergens Skin Cooling Moisturizer with
Cucumber Extract
Jerqens Skin Firming Moisturizer
Jergens Soft Shimmer Moisturizer
Jergens Soothing Aloe Lotion for Very
Drv Skin
Jergens Ultra Healing Extra Dry Skin
Moisturizer
Neoteric Oxygenated Therapeutic
Moisturizer Lotion, SPF 15
Pond’s Dramatic Results Skin
Brightening Age Defying Moisturizer with
Aloha Hvdroxv. Retinol & Vitam
SkinCeuticals Daily Sun Defense, SPF 20
Glysomed Hand Cream
glyceryl dilaurate
glyceryl dilaurate
,glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
I
1
I
I
I
\
See id.
I
See id.
iglyceryl dilaurate
See id.
I
ISee id.
glyceryl dilaurate
glyceryl dilaurate
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
See id.
See id.
glyceryl diiaurate
See id.
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
glyceryl distearate
“The Expert Panel concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to support the safety of
Glyceryl Distearate .. . for use in cosmetic
products,” CIR at 96.
See id.
See id.
I
.
/Glysomed Hand Cream, Unscented
glyceryl distearate
[Neutrogena Pore Refining Cream, A Daily glyceryl distearate
Moisturizina Treatment
Neutrogena Visibly Younger Hand Cream glyceryl distearate
ISee id.
RoC Retinol A&f Pur Anti-Wrinkle
glyceryl distearate
See id.
glyceryl ricinoleate
“The CIR Expert Panel concludes that the
availabe data are insufficient to support the
safety of Glyceryl Ricinoleate as used in
cosmetics.” CIR at 101.
See id.
glyceryl ricinoleate
Exhibit A (Page 7 of 15)
exhibit A
Ingredient
CIR Conclusion
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
Lips, Amazon (Sheer Tropical MagentaCARGO+care HydraTint HydraTint for
Lius, Danube (Sheer Hvdranaea PinkCARGO+care HydraTint HydraTint for
Lies. Rhine (Sheer Burnished CoooerCARGO+care HydraTint HydraTint for
Lips, Thames (Sheer Muted Blackberry-
glyceryl ricinoleate
Gly Derm GLY Masque with Glyco
/ Citrates
Lola Highlighter Pencil For the Face,
I
See id.
I
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
glyceryl ricinoleate
qlyceryl ricinoleate
See id,
I
1See id.
1Lola Lip / Cheek Pencil Two in One, Doll 1glyceryl ricinoleate
pee id.
ILORAC I(encil for
See id.
Eyes, if01 Dark Brown
LORAC Pencil for Eyes, #02
LORAC Pencil for Eyes, #15
Shimmer
LORAC Pencil for Eyes, #16
Jhimmer
LORAC Pencil for Eyes, #17
I
glyceryl ricinoleate
Black
Blue
qlyceryl ricinoleate
glyceryl ricinoleate
/See id.
Lavender
glyceryl ricinoleate
Light Pink
glyceryl ricinoleate
/See id.
I
ISee id.
qlyceryl ricinoleate
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
See id.
LORAC Pencil for Lips, #07 Auburn
?Jyceryl ricinoleate
LORAC Pencil for Lips, #08 Taupe
glyceryl ricinoleate
glyceryl ricinoleate
LORAC Pencil for Lips, #09 Peachy
Brown
LORAC Pencil for Lips, #I1 Hot Pink
glyceryl ricinolezite
qlyceryl ricinoleate
LORAC Pencil for Lips, #12 Red
LORAC Pencil for Lips, #14 Plum
qlyceryl ricinoleate
LORAC Pencil for Lips, #18 Nude
glyceryl ricinoleate
Eucerin QlO Anti-Wrinkle Sensitive Skin glyceryl stearate citrate
Creme
glyceryl stearate citrate
Nivea Body Sheer Moisture Lotion,
Normal to Drv Skin
glyceryl stearate citrate
Nivea Visage Coenzyme QlO Plus
Wrinkle Control Niaht Creme
Nivea Visage Multiple Results All In One glyceryi stearate citrate
Anti-Aaina Treatment
Amplify by Matrix Volumizing System
,hydrolyzed rice protein
Color XL Shampoo
See id.
See id.
The Expert Panel concludes that the ayailabe
data are insufficient to support the safety of
Glyceryl Stearate Citrate for use in cosmetic
Ed;.,
CIR at 96.
“’
1
See id,
“...the available data are insufficient to support
the safety of .. . Hydrolyzed Rice Protein for
,use in cosmetic products,” CIR at 168.
Amplify by Matrix Volumizinq System
hydrolyzed rice protein
ISee id.
Volumizinq System
hydrolyzed rice protein
See id.
Amplify by Matrix Volurnizing System
hydrolyzed rice protein
See id.
Exhibit A (Page 8 of 15)
I
I
Exhibit
A
the following ingredients in cosmetic products
Acacia Dealbata Leaf Wax...,” CIR at 2.
availabe data are insufficient to support the
rforatum Extract and
Oil for use in cosmetic
%emoval System AT956
Radio Bath &
SkinCeuticais Daily Mois
PHYTOMEN After-Shave
Remover For the Body
use in cosmetic products,” CIR at 132.
r use in cosmetic
Albert0 VOS Herbal Sha
Hair, Sun Kissed Raspber
,:
Exhibit A (Page 9 of 15)
lixhibit
A
Product
Ingredient
CIR Conclusion
Lierac Face Restructurizer
Juniperus communis
extract, Hypericum
perforatum oil, Calendula
officinalis
PEG-15 cocamine
See id.
L’Oreal Studio Line Invisi-Gel Styling
Gel, Strong Hold
Anna Sui Mascara, 001
ydro Touch Refill For the Face,
e Lash Mascara,
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
“The CIR Expert Panel concludes that the
availabe data are insufficient to support the
safety of PEG-2, -3, 5, -10, -15 and -20
Cocamine for use in cosmetic products,” CIR
at 176.
“The CIR Expert Panel concludes that the datz 1
availabe on Pentaerythrityl Rosinate are
insufficient to support the safety of this
ingredient as used in cosmetic products,” CIR
at 190.
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See ‘id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id,
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
PPG-9 diethylmonlum
chloride
-~
L
~
“The CIR Expert Panel concludes that the
lavailabe data are insufficient to support the
safety of PPG-9, -25, -40 Diethylmonium
Chloride for use in cosmetic products,” CIR at
1210.
Exhibit A (Page 10 of 15)
Ekhibit
A
aunmtnodipropionate
Millefolium)
Extract
Exhibit A (Page 11 of 15)
Exhibit
A
,Cream, Wild Fire
modern organic products basil mint
shampoo for normal to oily hair, Basil
Millefoliuml Extract
Yarrow (Achilles
Millefolium) Extract
modern organic products form foaming
Me
ael. heavv hold
Yarrow (Achilles
ill foliu
Exhibit A (Page 12 of 15)
See id,
See id.
exhibit A
Product
Nioxin Bionutrient Actives Cleanser, for
Normal Hair
Nioxin Bionutrient Protectives For
ChemicaUy Enhanced Hair, Structure b
‘HYTO PhytoMousse Volume Foam
Ghamuoo
‘HYTO Phytovolume with Yarrow Extract,
:ine and Limp Hair
sexy Hair Concepts Big Sexy Extra Big
loume Shamuoo
sexy Hair Concepts Big Sexy Hair Blow
It-v Volumizina Gel
;kinCeuticals cleansing cream
St. Ives Hair Repair Hot Oil Moisturizing
rreatment for Dry Damaged Hair
Ingredient
Yarrow (Achilles
Millefoliuml Extract
Yarrow (Achiilea
Millefolium) Extract
‘arrow (Achilles
4illefoliumI Extract
‘arrow (Achilles
4illefoliumI Extract
‘arrow (Achilles
4illefolium~ Extract
farrow (Achilles
4illefoliumI Extract
farrow (Achilles
Jlillefolium) Extract
(arrow (Achilles
dlillefolium) Extract
(arrow (Achilles
ulillefolium) Extract
larrow (Achilles
Yiilefolium) Extract
{arrow (Achilles
yillefolium~ Extract
Yarrow (Achilles
Nella Lifetex Wellness Flash Flood
vlillefolium1 Extract
Yarrow (Achilles
Nella Lifetex Wellness, Level Headed
Millefolium) Extract
yarrow (Achilles
Nella Lifetex Wellness, Look Alive
Millefollum~ Extract
Yarrow (Achilles
iNella Lifetex Wellness, Wake-up Call
MillefoliumI Extract
Dioxin Bionutrient Actives Scalp Therapy, Yarrow (Achilles
Millefolium) Extract,
‘or Normal Hair
Calendula officinalis
Yarrow (Achilles
Andre For Men Instant Wax Hair
Millefolium) Extract,
Remover Strips For the Body
Hypericum perforatum
extract, Juniperus
mmunis extract
zrrow (Achilles
4ussie 3 Minute Miracle, Original
Millefolium) Extract, sodium
lauriminodipropionate
UGI Bed Head, Chocolate Head
CIR Conclusion
See id.
See id.
See id.
See id,
iee id.
Tee id.
1 Tee id.
Tee id.
See id.
See id.
See idE
See id.
See id.
See id.
SkinCeuticals Equalizing Toner, For
Combination or Oily Skin
benzoic acid
“The available data are insufficient to support
the safety of these ingredients in cosmetic
products in which a primary route of exposure
is inhalation,” CIR at 32.
SkinCeuticals Revitalizing Toner, For
Normal or Drv Skin
Sun-In Super, Spray-In Hair Lightener
benzoic acid
See id.
benzolc acid
See id.
Band-Aid Fast Relief Calamine Spray
benzyl alcohol
“The available data are insufficient to support
the safety of these ingredients in cosmetic
products in which a primary route of exposure
is inhalation,” CIR at 32.
Exhibit A (Page 13 of 15)
Exhibit A
?
ZIR Conclusion
Tee id.
See id.
See id.
Aloe
FDS Feminine Deodorant.
Fresh
FDS Feminine Deodorant: Spray, White
Blassom
FDS Pursonals Feminine Deodorant
Spray 2-Pack Purse Size, Extra Strength
See id.
benzyl alcohol
See id.
benzyl alcohol
+
See id.
benzyl alcohol
See id.
Itch-X Dual-Acting Anti-Itch Spray, Aloe benzyl alcohol
See id.
Old Spice Cologne Spray, Original
Summer’s Eve Feminine Deodorant
Swrav, Intimate Whisoer
Summer’s Eve Feminine Deodorant
Sorav, Sensitive Skin
Almay Luxury Finish Loose Powder,
Beige
1benzyl alcohol
benzyl alcohol
See id.
benzyl alcohol
See id.
lecithin
“On the basis of the animal and clinical data
presented in this report, the Expert Panel
concluded that Lecithin and Hydrogenated
Lecithin are safe as used in rinse-off products,
safe for use in leave-on products at
concentrations (less than or equal to) 15%,
and that the data are insufficient to determine
the safety for use in cosmetic products where
Lecithin or Hydrogenated Lecithin are likely to
be inhaled. Lecithin and Hydrogenated
Lecithin should not be used in cosmetic
products in which N-nitroso compounds may
be formed,” CIR at 136.
FDS Pursonals Feminine Deodorant
Spray 2-Pack Purse Size, White Blossom
See id.
Almay Luxury Finish Loose Powder, Ivory lecithin
See id.
Almay Luxury Finish Loose Powder,
Translucent
CARGO Loose Powder For the Face, Oi
lecithin
See id.
lecithin
See id.
CARGO Loose Powder For the Face, 02
lecithin
See id.
CARGO Loose Powder’For the Face, 03
lecithin
See id.
CARGO Loose Powder For the Face, 04
lecithin
See id- -~
lecithin
See id.
I
CARGO Loose Powder For the Face, 05
I
Exhibit A (Page 14 of 15)
Exhibit
A
ason Natural Cosmetics Conditioner,
‘hin-To-Thick Hair & Scalp Therapy
.”
is inhalation,” CIR at 32.
Finesse Extra Hold Hairs
4erosol
on.ic Facial Mist
sodium benzoate
Reference
Cosmetics’Ingredient
Review (CIR) (2003). 2003 CIR Compendium, containing abstracts, discussions, and
conclusions of CIR cosmetic ingredient safety assessments. Washington DC.
Exhibit A (Page 15 of 15)