Steady-State Error Analysis How to evaluate steady-state errors for unity feedback systems How to evaluate steady-state errors for non-unity feedback systems How to evaluate steady-state errors for disturbance inputs How to specify a system’s steady-state error performance Static Error constants and System Type Definition and Test Inputs Steady-state error is the difference between the input and output for a defined or prescribed test input to a system as t. There may be different types of test inputs. Test waveforms for evaluating steady-state errors of control systems 1 Application The analysis is aimed at systems that can reach a steady state value and hence stable systems. Here the natural response approached zero as t. Since unstable systems indicate a loss of control, steady state analysis is not applicable. Stability should be tested first. Steady-state error: a. step input; b. ramp input Closed-loop control system error: a. general representation; b. representation for unity feedback systems Show practical (hand) 2 System with: a. finite steady-state error for a step input; b. zero steady-state error for step input System with: a. finite steady-state error for a step input; b. zero steady-state error for step input (a) C (s) K R( s) 1 K E (s) 1 R( s) 1 K 1 ess due to a step input 1 K (b) C (s) K R( s) K s E (s) s R( s) K s ess 0 due to a step input 3 Unity Feedback R( s) 1 G (s) ess e() lim e(t ) E (s) t sR ( s ) s 0 1 G ( s ) lim (a) Step Input s (1/ s ) 1 G (s) 1 1 lim s 0 1 lim G ( s ) 1 Kp e( ) lim s 0 s 0 The term lim G ( s ) is the dc gain of the forward TF G ( s ) s 0 or the position error constant K p For e() to be zero, lim G ( s ) K p s 0 (b) Ramp input s (1/ s 2 ) s 0 1 G ( s ) 1 1 lim lim s 0 s sG ( s ) s 0 s sG ( s ) 1 lim s 0 sG ( s ) The term lim sG ( s ) is the velocity error constant K v e( ) lim s 0 For e() to be zero, lim sG ( s ) K v s 0 (c) Parabolic input e( ) s (1/ s 3 ) 1 G ( s) 1 lim 2 s 0 s s 2 G ( s ) 1 lim 2 s 0 s G ( s ) lim s 0 The term lim s 2 G ( s ) is the accleratrion error constant K a s 0 For e() to be zero, lim s 2 G ( s ) K a s 0 4 Example e() lim s 0 sR ( s ) 1 G (s) 5 s 5 5 5 e() lim s 0 1 lim G ( s ) 1 20 21 (a) Due to a step input 5u (t ), LT is s 0 sR ( s ) s 0 1 G ( s ) e() lim (b) Due to a ramp input 5tu (t ), LT is e() lim s 0 5 s2 5 5 lim sG ( s ) 0 s 0 5 e() lim s 0 sR ( s ) 1 G (s) (c) Due to a parabolic input 5t 2 u (t ), LT is 10 s3 10 10 2 s 0 lim s G ( s ) 0 e() lim s 0 Example (with integrator) e() lim s 0 sR ( s ) 1 G ( s) (a) Due to a step input 5u (t ), LT is e() lim s 0 5 s 5 5 0 1 lim G ( s ) s 0 5 (previous eg.) which is finite is now zero. 21 The plant has an integrator or is now a Type 1. Without the integrator, the plant is type 0. Note the value 6 e() lim s 0 sR ( s ) 1 G (s) (b) Due to a ramp input 5tu (t ), LT is 5 s2 5 5 1 s 0 lim sG ( s ) 100 20 e() lim s 0 With Type 0, the value is , now the value is finite since the plant Type is 1. sR ( s ) s 0 1 G ( s ) e() lim (c) Due to a parabolic input 5t 2 u (t ), LT is e() lim s 0 10 s3 10 10 2 lim s G ( s ) 0 s 0 No improvement over the Type 0 plant Feedback control system for defining system type 7 Relationships between input, system type, static error constants, and steady-state errors Error Constants Example Fig. 7.10 8 A Routh Hurwitz test should be conducted to ensure stability. Do this!! Example 9 Example 10 Example Feedback control system showing disturbance We need to evaluate E(s)/R(s). Two inputs exist R(s) and D(s). 11 C ( s) R( s) E (s) Also, C ( s ) E ( s )G1 ( s )G2 ( s ) D ( s )G2 ( s ) Solving for E ( s ) from these two Eqs. E (s) G2 ( s ) 1 R( s) D( s) 1 G1 ( s )G2 ( s ) 1 G1 ( s )G2 ( s ) Now, the steady state value of error can be solved as e() lim sE ( s ) lim s 0 s 0 sG2 ( s ) s R( s ) lim D( s) s 0 1 G ( s )G ( s ) 1 G1 ( s )G2 ( s ) 1 2 e() eR () eD () Error due to input R( s) s eR () lim R( s) s 0 1 G ( s )G ( s ) 1 2 Error due to disturbance D( s) sG2 ( s ) eD () lim D( s) s 0 1 G ( s )G ( s ) 1 2 Assuming the disturbance D( s) eD () 1 s 1 1 lim lim G1 ( s ) s 0 G ( s ) s 0 2 The steady state error due to D( s ) can be reduced by (a) increasing the dc gain of G1 ( s ) (b) decreasing the the dc gain of G2 ( s ) It is worth noting that the denominators of the two TFs are the same E (s) E (s) and R( s) D( s) 12 Steady State Errors Disturbances - examples Non unity feedback (without disturbances) Non unity feedback (with disturbances) Examples Example eD () 1 1 lim lim G1 ( s ) s 0 G ( s ) s 0 2 1 1 0 1000 1000 Note that the dc gain of G2 ( s ) =K p 2 is infinite since the system is of Type 1. 13 Example G1 ( s ) 1000; G2 ( s ) eD () s2 s4 1 1 lim lim G1 ( s ) s 0 G ( s ) s 0 2 1 9.98e 4 2 1000 Steady State Error – Nonunity Feedback 14 Forming an equivalent unity feedback system from a general nonunity feedback system Ge ( s ) Example – non unity feedback G (s) 100 1 ; H 2 (s) s ( s 10) s5 G (s) 1 G (s) H (s) G (s) 100( s 5) 3 s 15s 2 50 s 400 The equivalent TF Ge ( s ) = The system is Type 0, the static error constant is K p lim Ge ( s ) s 0 e( ) 100 * 5 1.25 400 1 1 4 1 K p 1 1.25 15 Example – non unity feedback Evaluate e() for a unit step input. Repeat for a unit ramp. OR, the equivalent TF can also be solved using Ge ( s ) = subst. G ( s) Ge ( s ) G ( s) 1 G ( s) H ( s) G ( s) 100 1 and H ( s) in the above s4 s 1 100 s4 100 1 100 1 s 4 s 1 s 4 100( s 1) s 2 95s 4 16 Nonunity feedback control system with disturbance E ( s) R( s) C ( s) H ( s) C ( s ) E ( s )G1 ( s )G2 ( s ) D( s )G2 ( s ) G1 ( s )G2 ( s ) G2 ( s ) E ( s ) 1 R( s) D( s) 1 G1 ( s )G2 ( s ) H ( s ) 1 G1 ( s )G2 ( s ) H ( s ) Now, the steady state value of error can be solved as G1 ( s )G2 ( s ) G2 ( s ) e() lim sE ( s ) lim s 1 R( s) D( s) s 0 s 0 1 G1 ( s )G2 ( s ) H ( s ) 1 G1 ( s )G2 ( s ) H ( s ) For both R ( s ) D( s ) 1 s lim G1 ( s )G2 ( s ) lim G2 ( s ) s 0 s 0 e() lim sE ( s ) lim 1 s 0 s 0 lim 1 G ( s ) G ( s ) H ( s ) lim 1 G ( s ) G ( s ) H ( s ) 1 2 1 2 s 0 s 0 For zero e() lim G1 ( s )G2 ( s ) s 0 lim 1 G1 ( s )G2 ( s ) H ( s ) s 0 1 and lim G2 ( s ) s 0 lim 1 G1 ( s )G2 ( s ) H ( s ) 0 s 0 17 Sensitivity Analysis How will changes in the system parameters affect the dynamic behavior of the system? The degree to which changes in the system parameters is called Sensitivity. The higher the sensitivity, the less desirable the effect of this parameter change on the system or transfer function Feedback can provide reduces sensitivity to parameter changes Assume F K / ( K a) If K 10 and a 100, evaluating F 0.091 If a 300 (increasing by 3 times), F 0.032 The change in the parameter a is 300-100 *100% a 200% change 100 causes a change in the parameter F is 0.032-0.091 *100% a -65% change 0.091 Definition Sensitivity is the ratio of fractional change in the function F to the factional change in a parameter P as the fractional change in the parameters approaches zero. This is expressed as S F , P lim P 0 Fractional change in the function F Fractional change in the parameter P lim P 0 F/ F F/ P P F lim P/ P P 0 P/ F F P 18 Example – Sensitivity of a CLTF Given the block diagram, calculate the sensitivity to changes in the parameter a. Explain how to reduce the sensitivity. T (s) SF ,P K s as K P F F P 2 Using the sensitivity equation (the function is T and the parameter is a ) ST ,a a T T (s) a a Ks K s 2 as K 2 2 s as K ST ,a as s 2 as K The sensitivity of the CLTF to changes in the parameter a can be reduced by increasing K . Example – Sensitivity of a steady state error with ramp input Find the sensitivity of e() due to changes in K and a with a ramp input First, determine the function F 1 1 a F e( ) K v lim sG ( s ) K SF ,P P F F P s 0 The sensitivity of the function e() to changes in the parameter a (of course P a ) is Se,a a e a 1 1 e a a K K 19 SF ,P P F F P The sensitivity of the function e() to changes in the parameter K is (now P K ) Se, K K e K a 1 a K 2 e K K Changes in either parameter a or K on e() results in no reduction or increase in sensitivity of the TF. The negative sign indicates a decrease in e() as K increases. Example – Sensitivity of a steady state error with a step input Find the sensitivity of e() due to changes in K and a with a step input The steady state error for this Type 0 is e() = 1 1+K p 1 K 1 ab ab ab K The sensitivity of e() due to changes in a is Se,a a e e a ab K b ab a K * 2 ab ab K ab K ab K 2 20 The sensitivity of e() due to changes in K is Se, K K e e K K ab K * 2 ab ab K ab K ab K The equations show that the sensitivity due to changes in K and a is less that unity for positive a and b. 21
© Copyright 2024