1. food and drink
2. desserts and baking

Frequently
Asked Questions
Additional
FAQ Questions
How do I place an order?
You may place an order three ways: (1) on our secure website
www.BethelBakery.com, (2) in our retail store or (3) call us and
speak with one of our sales associates.
Should I refrigerate my cake?
If your celebration is same day or the next day, there is no reason to
refrigerate unless your cake is custard filled, chocolate fudge filled or
iced, cream cheese or whipped cream iced. If your celebration is more
than two days away, your cake will keep better in the refrigerator. On
hot, humid days of summer it is always best to refrigerate your cake.
How soon do I need to order a cake?
We suggest ordering 2-3 days in advance (order earlier for major
holidays and weekends) in order to get your preference of cake
batter, icing and decoration.
What if I need a cake today?
We have standard decorated and undecorated cakes available in
our store that we can write an inscription on top.
How do I change my order?
You can call the bakery to make changes to your order. Please
remember we require a 48 hour notice on any change or
cancellation of your order.
What is included in the price of a decorated cake?
Along with your inscription, we offer standard decorations such as:
Roses, Balloons, Crazy Daisies, Tropical Fish, Black and Gold
Balloons, Fondant Dots & Swirls, Sugar Tools, Champagne Bubbles,
Baseball Diamond, Football Field, Golf, Stars & Swirls and
Pittsburgh Penguins. We also offer beautiful seasonal and holiday
standard decorations. These designs can be viewed on our website at
www.BethelBakery.com.
Where can I see your decorations?
Our website www.BethelBakery.com is a great resource.
Can I design my own cake?
Certainly! We do offer custom decorating which does incur an
additional charge, based on how time consuming the design would
be to decorate.
Can you draw a copyrighted design on my cake?
We uphold copyright regulations so we offer officially licensed
figurines or Edible Images of popular images.
Can I put a picture on the cake?
Yes, we can scan a picture or logo on any size cake for an additional
charge. Pictures can be dropped off at Bethel Bakery or emailed to
[email protected] in a jpg or gif format. Size of pictures
on cakes are scaled to size of cake with the maximum of a 7”x10”
image on half sheet cakes or larger. Create a theme and order
picture cookies with your cake.
What is half and half?
Half and Half traditionally refers to yellow batter and chocolate
batter. For no additional charge you may also have white batter
and chocolate batter. Our sheet cakes have the batters side by side
and round cakes are one layer yellow or white on top and one layer
of chocolate underneath. NEW! For an additional charge we also
have almond as a choice in your half and half cakes.
Can I get a filling in a sheet cake?
Yes, we will split the sheet cake and fill with your choice of one of
our delicious fillings for an additional charge.
Can I get an inscription on a dessert cake?
Certainly! If your favorite is Chocolate Mousse, Victorian Torte,
Chocolate Cascade Cake or any other delicious dessert cakes, we can
add an inscription for an additional charge.
Do you sell candles?
We offer an assortment of candles to enhance your celebration. Some
of our popular candles are black for over the hill cake, magic
relighting, number and sports themed. We also carry traditional
candles in assorted colors.
Can I place an order for pickup at the McMurray Dairy Bar (MDB)?
YES! Orders for Decorated Cakes, No Cut Cakes, Itty Bitty Cakes
and Cookie Cakes need to be placed through Bethel Bakery and
prepaid when placing your order. All other orders such as cookies,
dessert cakes, cupcakes, etc. need to be placed through the McMurray
Dairy Bar. Orders through Bethel Bakery require 48 hours notice.
For more information and cut off times for the McMurray Dairy Bar
visit our website at www.BethelBakery.com.
Front Cover Cakes:
Dinosaur, Barbie Doll Cake, 3D Cupcake, No Cut Football, Heart
of Flowers, Grill.
When traveling with your cake keep cakes
cool, avoid quick stops or starts and keep
cake level.
DISCLAIMER:
• Our cakes are hand decorated. Cake designs may vary slightly depending on
the personal technique of the cake decorator that customizes your cake. Size and
shape of cake will also determine the amount of decoration on your cake. All
of our cakes are shown to the customer for final approval when the cake
is picked up.
• Large amounts of dark colors of icing such as red, black and royal or navy
blue, etc. may temporarily stain your mouth and could permanently stain
clothes, carpeting and furniture.
Store Hours:
Monday - Friday 7am - 7pm • Saturday 7am - 6pm
The Perfect Gift of Good Taste
All menu, pricing and designs subject to change.
Order online @ www.BethelBakery.com
5200 Brightwood Road • Bethel Park, PA 15102
Baking life sweeter since 1955
Decorated Cakes
Both our round layer cakes and sheet cakes are iced with our
Famous French Buttercream. Optional icings and special
fillings are available for an additional charge. Sheet cakes
can be split and filled with your choice of filling, if desired.
Round
Round Servings
7”
8”
9”
6-8
10-12
16
Round
Servings
10”
12”
8” Single
layer
24
30-36
5-6
Sheet
Sheets
Servings
*Quarter (12”x 8”)
16
*Half (12”x16”)
30-36
*¾ (12”x24”)
45-50
*Full (16”x24”)
60-72
*Available in Half & Half for $1.50 Additional
Servings are based on a 2”x2” cut.
Also available in flavored batters for an additional charge.
** ¾ Sheet Half & Half is 2 quarters yellow and 1 quarter chocolate
Itty Bittys
Available in yellow or
chocolate batter. (1-2
servings) Pricing Varies. Free
yellow batter itty bitty with
your 1st birthday cake. Will
be decorated with a #1 in a
pastel blue or pink.
No Cut Cakes
No knife, no fork! 24 cupcakes cleverly arranged. Available in
Yellow, Chocolate or Half & Half.
Current Designs
#1
#2
Baby Rattle
Beer Mug
Birthday Balloons
Bowling
Bouquet of Roses
Butterfly
Cat
Chalice
Champagne
Cross
Cupcake
Diploma
Dog
Dump Truck
Elmo
Flag
Flower Pot
Football
Golf
Hockey
Martini
Monkey
Palm Tree
Purse
Rattle
Smiley Flower
Teddy Bear
Visit www.BethelBakery.com for our complete list of No Cut Cakes.
Cake
Batters
*Additional Charge
Chocolate
Half & Half
Marble
White
Yellow
*Almond
*Banana
*Coconut
*Lemon
*Orange
*Pineapple
*Raspberry
*Red Velvet
*Strawberry
Delicious Fillings
*Fillings are an additional charge, ** Double filling charge applies
Apple
Apricot
Blood Orange
Blueberry
Caramel
Cherry
Cherry and Nut**
Cherry Mousse
Chocolate Buttercream
Chocolate Fudge
Chocolate Mousse
Chocolate Raspberry
Truffle**
Chocolate Truffle
Coconut Buttercream
Cookies and Cream
Cream Cheese
Crushed Almond
Custard
French Buttercream
German Chocolate
Hazelnut
Lemon
Mango
Mocha
Nut
Peanut Butter
Buttercream
Peppermint
Buttercream
Pineapple
Pineapple Nut**
Pumpkin Spice
Raspberry (European)
Raspberry and Nut**
Raspberry Buttercream
Strawberry
Strawberry and Nut**
Strawberry Mousse
Tiramisu
Toffee Crunch
White Chocolate
Mousse
Icings
All cakes are iced in our Famous French Buttercream icing.
For an additional charge we also offer:
Chocolate Buttercream • Chocolate Fudge • Whip Topping
New For an additional charge, tint the French buttercream
filling pink or blue for a baby gender reveal cake! Bring in a
sealed envelope from your doctor & even you can be surprised!
Decorated Chocolate
Chip Cookie Cakes
Thick and Chewy, loaded with chocolate chips.
7” Round - serves 8
8” Heart - serves 8
Quarter sheet - serves 12
10” Round - serves 14
12” Round - serves 18
Wedding Style
Available on any size 2 layer round
cake for an additional charge. The
wedding style decoration is a elegant
look with icing drapes on the sides
and a cluster of roses in the center. A
perfect look for a special celebration.
Stacked Sheet Cakes
Perfect for anniversaries, special occasions, or showers.
Stacked Sheets
Servings
Double Layer Quarter Sheet
Half Sheet with 8” Heart (Single Layer)
Half Sheet with 6” Cake on Pillars
Half Sheet with Quarter Sheet on Top
Half Sheet with Quarter Sheet w/ 6” on Pillars
Double Layer Half Sheet
Full Sheet with 10” Heart (Single Layer)
Full Sheet with 6” Cake on Pillars
Full Sheet with Half Sheet on Top
Full Sheet with Half Sheet with 6”Cake on Pillars
30-36
40
40
45-50
50-60
60-72
80
70-80
90-100
100-110
Half Sheet with
8” Heart on Top
(single layer)
Novelty Cakes
Visit www.BethelBakery.com for our complete list of novelty cakes.
3D Baby Block
3D Disney Fairies
3D Spiderman Skyscraper
3D Tombstone
Animated 3D Dinosaur
Barbie Doll
Beehive
Beer Mug
Bible
Bowling Lane
Butterfly
Cross
Dinosaur
Drum
Fire Truck
Fish
Hamburger 8”, 9”, 10”, 12”
Hoagie & Chips
Keyboard
Lady Bug
Lego Cake Small
Lego Cake Large
Madeline Hat
Money Bag
Nascar
Noahs Ark
Number 1
Pan Pizza
Pick Up Truck
Pig Cake
Pirate Ship
Poppyseed Bagel
Present Cake
Princess Castle
Puppy Dog
Purse Cake
Rosebox
Scooby Doo Mystery Machine
SpongeBob Crabby Patty
Swiss Cheese & Mice
Taco
Tank
Tool Box
Turtle
Van
Watermelon Slice
X-Box