How to treat children with severe attachment trauma?

How to treat children with severe attachment
disorders after multiple early experiences of
trauma?
A model of treatment in an intensive care unit of
psychotherapy
Brisch, K. H.; Erhardt, I.; Kern, C; Formichella, A;
Paesler, U.; Quehenberger, J.
International Attachment Conference August 29-Sept 1, 2013 Pavia/Italy
Outline
• Developmental trauma disorder – a new
diagnosis?
• Concept of an intensive psychotherapy unit
• Study „Moses“
• Treatment of a boy with early
traumatisation and later extreme aggressive
behavior
• Conclusions
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
Developmental trauma disorder
(Bessel van der Kolk) – a new
diagnosis?
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Chronic early maltreatment by caregivers
Threatening living conditions
Changing care systems
Loss of caregivers
Inadaquate care
Physical and emotional deprivation
Abuse and violence by caregivers
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
Symptoms of Developmental
Trauma Disorder
• Disorders in
– Delay in physical growth
– Delay and disorders in neural networking and brain
development
– Attachment
– Affect regulation
– Attention
– Cognitive functioning
– Mentalization and empathy
– Interpersonal relationships with aggression
– Dissociation
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
What is the basic fault in
developmental trauma disorder?
• No fromation of secure attachment
• Attachment disorder due to early
traumatisation by attachment figures
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
Window of Tolerance of Stress-Regulation
Hyper-Arousal
Dissociation
Sympathetic Nervous System
FREEZE
Panic state
Fear of death,
Activated Attachment System
+
Hyper-Arousal
Dissociation
Parasympathetic Nervous System
COLLAPSE
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
© zptn-Lutz-Ulrich Besser
Attachment traumatization in early
childhood
– „psychic cancer of the brain“
• Extreme damage to the brain, the body, the
psychic and social development
– Physical „death“
– Psychic „death“
– Social „death“
• Chronification
• Is healing possible with a special
„psychotherapeutic intensive care unit“?
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
„Pediatric Intensive Care Unit of Psychotherapy“
for early disorders of attachment and traumatization
Components of treatment
– Somatic treatment
– Social work
– Milieu therapy
– Individual psychotherapy
– Group-psychotherapy
– Trauma-therapy (EMDR)
– Education
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
Milieu-therapy
Safty and structure
New attachment figures –
individual attachment nurse
and 2 therapists
Psychodynamic and
attachment-based
understanding
Affect and stress regulation
Developmental support
New group experiences with
peers
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
Individual Psychotheray
• Psychodynamic –
attachment based play
therapy 4-5x /week
• Traumatherapy
• ParentCounselling/Education
• Familiy-Therapy 1x/week
• External individual therapy
for mother/father
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
Creative Therapy
•Art Therapy
•Musik Theray
•Movement Therapy
• Individual sessions (individual
frequency)
• Group sessions,
3 x /week
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
B.A.S.E.® - Babywatching
• 1x a week observation of
mother/father – baby –
interaction
• Promotion of sensitivity,
empathy, mentalization
• Decrease of aggression
• Decrease of anxiety
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
Schooling
• Mon – Fri 8:30 - 12:00 a.m.
• Max. 6 students
• Individual teaching
• Group teaching
• 3 Teachers are team members
• Team-supversion
• Case-supervsion
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
External supervision and
training
• Team-Supervision (every 2nd week)
• Case-Supervision (3x/week)
– Nurses
– Therapists
– All staff members
• Training and supervision in
psychotraumatology and attachment
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
CAMPUS INNENSTADT
KINDERKLINIK UND KINDERPOLIKLINIK
IM DR. V. HAUNERSCHEN KINDERSPITAL
Evaluation of a treamtent model
Intenvive Care Unit of Psychotherapy
for early traumatized children aged 6-13 years
„Moses“ Study
Sample
Children age 6-13 years
Intervention group, waiting control group, healthy control group
Sample size 3 x N = 24 (total sample size N = 72)
Inclusion criteria:
Severe early traumatisation with violence, abuse, neglect by
primary caregivers
Chronification of posttraumatic stress disorder PTSD
Attachment disorder
Exclusion criteria:
Previous inpatient treatment
Severe autism, addiction, mental disability (IQ < 85)
Treatment of 6 children in a group setting
Duration of in-patient treatment: 6 months
16
02.09.2013
Study design
4 points of measurement
T0= 6 months before in-patient treatment (only
waiting group)
T1= Admission to in-patient treatment
T2= Discharge
T3= Follow-up: 6 months after discharge
Methods
Questionnaires and test
Attachment interviews und behavioral observations
(f)MRi
Oxytocin and cortisol in saliva and in blood (1x at T1)
17 02.09.2013
Methods 1
Questionnaires (e.g. PTSD, CBCL 4-18, depression,
anxiety)
Outcome and process (6-weeks intervall)
Tests: e.g. intelligence
Attachment Interviews with parents and children:
Adult Attachment Interview- AAI (George, C., Kaplan, N. & Main, M., 1985/2001)
Adult Attachment Projective Picture System-AAP (George, C., West, M. & Pettem, M.,
2012)
Child Attachment Interview- CAI (Shmueli-Goetz,Y., Target, M., Fonagy, P., & Datta,
A., 2008)
Story Stem Completion Task (Gloger-Tippelt & König, 2009)
Parent-child play interation (video)
Parental Sensitivity (Ainsworth Maternal Sensitivity Scales- AMSS; Ainsworth, 1969)
18 02.09.2013
Methods 2
Structural and und functional fMRI alt all points of
measurement
Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI): micro-myelinisation
Functional connectivity
Anatomy of hippocampus
Paradigm associated (f)MRI sequenz (stimulus: 60 picture of the
International Affective Picture Systems IAPS; 20 pictures each
pleasure, distress, neutral)
fMRI with matched-pair healthy control
children
19 02.09.2013
Methods 3
Oxytocin und Cortisol in saliva pre- and post
attachment interviews
4 points of measurements:
before, after, 15 min. and 30 min. post interview
Oxytocin–method:
High performance liquid chromatography with mass
spectrometry (MSMS).
Questions and aims 1
Global aim: Evaluation of the treatment programme of the
intensive care unit of psychotheray for early traumatized
children with attachment disorders
What kind of attachment representation do these children
present?
Can we change their attachment respresentation to „earned
secure“?
How does the attachment representation influence the HPA
axis and oxytocin secretion?
Can we develop and optimize ressources like intelligence,
social competence in groups?
Questions and aims 2
Can we influence psychopathology (PTSD symptoms,
dissociation, anxiety, depression)
Can we observe changes in neural structures, function
and connectivity of the brain?
„Jonas“, 8 years
History
• Deprivation and extreme phyical maltreatment
during 1st and 2nd year of live by his mother
• Mother drug and alcohol addiction
• With foster parents: 2nd year of live – later
adoption by these foster parents
• Development of extreme selfharm and aggression
against others.
• No admission to kindergarten because of
aggression
• Parents seek ouf for help
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
Symptoms
• Indifferent attachment disorder
• No affect regulation
• No stress-tolerance
• No schooling
• Communiction with mother by picture cards
• Many food allergies
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
Intensiv-Psychotherapy Unit
• Nurse and therapists become new attachment
figures
• Milieu-therapy: time-intensive instead of time-out
• NO – medication
• Schooling (from minutes to hours)
• Intensive work wiht adoptive parents (both with
unresolved trauma in AAI)
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
Follow-up
• After discharge:
– Disorganized attachment
– Continuous individual psychotherapy in out-patient department
– Schooling: class for children with special needs with school companion
• After 1 year:
– Ambivalent attachment
– normal school with companion
– Social integration into family, peers at school
• After 2 yerars:
– normal school without companion
• After 3 years:
– Secure attachment
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
Conclusion
• Treatment should start early
• Intensive treatment
• In-patient with new intensive positive sensitive
attachment experiences
• Affect and impuls control
• Stress regulation
• Social integration
• Healthy bio-psycho-social development
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
Reference
Brisch, Karl Heinz (2012)
Treating Attachment Disorders.
From Theory to Therapy. 2nd Edition
Guilford Press, New York, London
Gradiva Award Nomination
National Association for the Advancement of
Psychoanalysis
Japanese, Korean, Italian, Slowakian, Russian, Urkainian
translation available!
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
Thanks!
• Children and their
parents!
• Team and co-workers
• Supervisors
• E. Epping, P. Bründl,
L. Besser
Cooperation:
MRI- LMU:
Birgit Ertl-Wagner, Daniel
Keeser, Ute Coates
Endocrinology LMU:
Martin Bidlingmaier
Psychiatry LMU:
Peter Zill; Sylvia de Jonge
Oxytocin Lab Olgemöller:
Elfriede Schuhmann
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
International Conference
October, 11-13, 2013 in
Munich/Germany
Attachment and
Psychosomatics
Information and Program
www.khbrisch.de
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved
Thank you
for your
attention!
• Further information
• www.khbrisch.de
• www.safe-program.org
• www.base-babywatching.de
© Copyright K.H. Brisch Munich/Germany 2013. All Rights Reserved