Trichomonas vaginalis: An Important but Often Neglected STI Charlotte A. Gaydos, MS, MPH, DrPH Professor Division of Infectious Diseases Johns Hopkins University Baltimore, Maryland, USA AMP Long Beach, CA October 24 , 2012 Disclosure • Dr. Gaydos’ participation in this talk is as a paid speaker for GenProbe. • All opinions expressed and implied in this presentation are solely those of Dr. Gaydos. • The content of the talk does not represent or reflect the views of the Johns Hopkins University or the Johns Hopkins Health System. Objectives • To review pathogenesis, prevalence, epidemiology, public health issues, and association with adverse outcome for Trichomonas vaginalis • To discuss association of TV with HIV transmission and BV • To provide data from a multisite study to determine the prevalence in women by age, race, and region in the U.S., as well as the multivariate logistic regression analysis of risk factors associated with TV in women Trichomonas vaginalis • More prevalent than CT or GC: 7-8 million cases annually in U.S. WHO global estimates are 173 million cases/yr Not a reportable disease True prevalence unknown • Women: Preterm birth, low birth weight (Cotch STD 1997) PID (Cherpes STD 2006) Post-hysterectomy infection HIV (Van Der Pol OR 2.7, 2008; McClelland OR 1.5, 2008, Hughes OR 2.57, 2012) ~50% asymptomatic or discharge • Men: ~50% asymptomatic, NCNGU Prostatitis, epididymitis Assoc w/ decrease in sperm motility and viability Pathology of Trichomonas • Trichomonas attaches to epithelial cells – releases proteins which destroy the cell and elicits an intense local cellular immune response with inflammation resulting in • punctate mucosal hemorrhages • Lymphocyte recruitment including CD4+ cells – bind HIV to gain access – increases cervical HIV shedding – Inflammation-related factors • cytokines – implicated in pathology » prostate cancer Trichomonas Pathogenesis • Desquamation of vaginal epithelium Leukocytic inflammation; may persist for years • Symptoms: -Women: asymptomatic or itching, burning, frothy discharge, worsens after menses, chronic, symptoms and parasite can be persistent -Men: asymptomatic or mild urethritis: rare to detect by wet prep in men due to urine flow • Strawberry hemorrhage in 5% of infected women w/ no discharge - pathogenesis is not well understood Prevalence of Trichomonas in NHANES studies in the United States •Sutton et al. CID 2007 Prev Tric: 2001-2004 3.1% in 3754 women; 13.3% Black, 1.3% White •Allsworth et al. STD 2009 Trich & STDs: 2001-2004 3.2% in 3648 women; If Tric+ HSV more common; syphilis +6X; HIV 13X risk; attenuated after adjustment for race, age, PN Prevalence of Trichomonas Among Young Adults in the U. S.: Adol Health (N = 12,449) (2.3%) Prevalence % Male Female Black Female White Latino Black Asian Native American 1.7 2.8 10.5 1.2 2.1 6.9 1.8 4.1 Miller et al STD 2005;32:593-598 Prevalence % 18–20 yr 21–22 23–24 > 25 1.5 2.6 2.2 4.0 West Midwest South Northeast 1.4 2.2 2.8 2.0 % of Positive TV Tests by Wet Mount vs. APTIMA TV (n=1,086) 25 * 21.6 20 15 * 11 Wet Mount AP TIMA TV 10.4 10 5 7 4.3 9 5 6 *P<0.0002 0 O utpatient P hys . G rp E merg ency Dept A E merg ency Dept B Urg ent C are facility Overall rate of TV detection by APTIMA TV was more than double that of wet mount (14.5% vs. 7%, p<0.0002) Munson, et al. J Clin Microbiol 2008;46:3368. Female Trichomonas via Internet Recruitment using Vaginal swabs TV 10%; CT 10%; GC 1.0%; Any STI 18.0% 10.3% Infected 11.5% Infected 10.4% Infected 8.3% Infected Gaydos et al. STD 2011 8.6% Infected 13.2% Infected 5.6% Infected N = 1525 Female Vaginal Trichomonas via Internet, N = 1222 Variable Age Characteristic Adjusted OR (95% CI) 14-19 yr 0.80 (0.43-1.46) 20-24 yr 0.62 (0.36-1.07) 25-29 yr 1.18 (0.64-2.17) >30 yr. 1.0 Black 2.69 (1.71-4.23)* White, Asian, Other 1.0 Health Insurance Without 1.57 (1.06-2.35)* Education Without BS Degree 5.53 (2.18-14.00)* Race *P<0.05 Female Vaginal Trichomonas via Internet, N = 1222 Variable Characteristic Adjusted OR (95% CI) Condom Use During Sex Most, Some, Never 3.04 (1.35-6.85) PN had STI Yes 1.71 (1.02-2.86)* Number PN Past Year 0-1 1.0 2-15 1.60 (1.03-2.51)* >16 3.51 (1.30-9.47)* Yes 2.00 (1.05-3.80) Bisexual *P<0.05 Other significant variables in Bivariate analysis which were Not Significant in Multivariate Analysis: Having TV previously, Having STI in past T. vaginalis infection and PID (N=736) • Endometrial bx and hysterosalpingitis results • Women diagnosed with TV at enrollment were more likely to have histologic evidence of acute endometritis Cherpes et al. STD 2006;33:747-753 Trichomonas and low birth weight / preterm delivery • 13,816 women enrolled; TV prevalence 12.6% • Low birth weight OR 1.3 (95%CI 1.1-1.5) • Preterm delivery OR 1.3 (95%CI 1.1-1.4) • Preterm delivery of a LBW infant OR 1.6 (95%CI 1.1-1.6) • Attributable risk of TV assoc with LBW in Blacks was 11% vs. 1.6% in Hispanics, and 1.5% in Whites. *Cotch et al STD. 1997;24:353-360 Association of Trichomonas with low birth weight / preterm delivery 20 18 % of women 16 14 12 BV- TVBV+ TVBV- TV+ BV+ TV+ 10 8 6 4 2 0 LBW Preterm Del Cotch et al STD. 1997;24:353-360 Preterm LBW Trichomonas and BV • Women with abnormal flora (BV) with 3 mo f/u are increased risk of acquiring TV infection • Abn to Abn OR 9.0 • Normal to Abn OR 7.1 • Abn to normal OR 4.5 • Rathod et al STD 2011; 38:882-886 •TV associated with vaginal microbiota consisting of low proportions of lactobacilli and high proportions of mycoplasma, Parvimonas Sneathia and other anaerobes •Brothman et al. STD 2012 Association of Trichomonas with Duration of HPV Infection • 3 city STD clinics 49 HPV-infected adolescents tested • Concurrent infections were measured •Prolonged HPV infection (during the HPV infection) was associated with AHR 0.58 (95%CI 0.39-0.84) Oncogenic HPV Low (<60%) condom use AHR 0.53 (95%CI 0.33-0.84) Coinfection wtih CT AHR 0.58 (95% CI 0.31-0.89) Coinfection with Trichomonas AHR 0.32 (95% CI 0.16-0.64) •HPV infections associated with concurrent T. vaginalis were slower to clear than those not associated with the infection (median time to disappearance was 436 days and 172 days, respectively) *Shew. Archiv Ped 2006;160:151-156 Persistence of Trichomonas: Trichomonas vaginalis infections detected among women in intervals during which they were not having sex. (3,6,9,12 mo f/u) Each row represents the history of 1 woman. Shaded areas are intervals during which the woman reported not having sex. Positive (+) and negative (−) culture test results for T. vaginalis are indicated for each woman. Peterman et al. CID 48(2):259-260 Trichomonas and Risk for HIV • Trichomonas treatment reduces vaginal HIV shedding • TV+ and TV- women matched on ART; TV+ women treated for TV effectively less likely to shed HIV vaginally at 3 mo. RR 0.034, p=0.03; no change for TV- women Kissinger et al STD. 2009;36:11-16 • Of 60 HIV + women 18.3% were TV positive after 1 month vs. of 301 HIV – women, 8% were TV + at 1 month Kissinger et al. Repeat infections with TV among HIV + and HIV – women CID 2008;46:994-999 Trichomonas and Risk for HIV • Relative Risks in per-Act Probability Transmission, N = 3297 couples RR P value Plasma HIV copies.ml 2.89 <0.001 Condon Use in F/U 0.22 <0.001 Age, per 5 yr 0.82 0.006 HSV-2 + enrollment 2.14 0/012 GUD 2.65 0.004 Trichomonas 2.57 0.002 Cervicitis/vaginitis 3.63 0.005 Circumcision 0.53 0/37 HIV Infected PN HIV Uninfected PN Hughes et al. Determinants per-coital act HIV infectivity in African serodiscordant couples JID 2012;205:358-365. 86 transmissions; MTF 0.0019; FTM 0.0010 Impact of Trichomonas on HIV Model • HIV patients interviewed about risk factors baseline, 3 & 6 mo. • Mathematical Model to estimate number of HIV infections attributable to TV in care in NC • TV prevalence 7.4%; incidence 2-3% at f/u • Model predicted that 0.062 HIV transmission events occur/ 100 HIV-infected women without TV vs. 0.076 HIV transmissions in women with TV • Indicating 23% of HIV transmission events may be attributable to TV when 22% of women are co-infected with TV Quinlivan et al. Modeling Impact of TV on HIV transmission in HIV-infected individuals. STD 2012;39:671-677. TV Therapy on Genital HIV Burden • Estimated annual number new HIV transmissions in US attributable to TV cofactor effect of 2-5 fold increased risk (Shafir, Clin Micro Rev 2009; Chesson STD 2004) • 557 women not receiving antivirals; 46 f/u; 80% cured; Plasma viral load not significantly different •Genital viral load decreased significantly 0.5 log10 • After therapy, mean genital tract load decreased from 4.66 to 4.18 log10 (p <0.01) Anderson et al. Effect TV Therapy on Genital HIV Burden STD 2012;39:638-642. Estimates of Direct Cost/Case and Burden of Trichomonas in US Extracted private insurance claims 2001-2005 MEDISTAT Market Scan database Outpatient costs: visit $97; drug $9 Most common Dx wet prep Avg. total cost for women 15-24 yr ($120) significantly higher all other ages (p<0.01) Estimated : Overall annual economic burden of trichomonas to be $18.9 million among all U.S. women; Incidence rate: all ages 92/100,000 (higher 25-29 yr @185/100,000 ) Owusu-Edusei, K. et al. Sex Transmit Dis 2009;36:395-399 Estimates of Sequelae Costs for Trichomonas in US? • If direct estimated overall annual economic burden of trichomonas is $18.9 million among all U.S. women, what about the population attributable cost for possible sequelae, if there are 7.4 million cases of TV /year? •Cost of premature infant’s hospitalization? [550,000 babies/ yr] $49,000 in yr 1 (March of Dimes 2009) $26 billion /yr (IOM) •Cost of PID? •Cost of HIV? $1378 (Rein-RTI & Gift-CDC) -$1410 (IOM, 2000) /case $4 billion /yr (AHRQ 2002) [1.2 million visits/yr] $618,900 /yr [50,000 new HIV infections /yr] [1.1 million living with HIV/AIDS] •(Cost of Cancer; association with HPV infection?) ??? •Do we need a C-E study to convince public health officials and law makers of the necessity of a trichomonas control program in the US? A Newly Cleared FDA NAAT Assay for Trichomonas Now Available Trichomonas NAAT FDA Clinical Trial (N= 933) •IRB approval multisite study; prospective samples tested with APTIMA Trichomonas vaginalis (ATV) assay on the TIGRIS DTS ® Instrument; compared to wet prep & culture; mean age 24 yr; prev 11.4-12.7% Sample type Sensitivity Specificity Endocervical 100% 99.4% Urine Vaginal PreservCyt Liquid Pap 98.9% 99.0% 99.6% 95.2% 100% 100% 59.9% Symptomatic Schwebke et al. JCM 2011;49:4106-4111 U.S. Multisite Prevalence Study: Methods •IRB approval for using consecutive de-identified remnant APTIMA Combo 2 CT/NG samples from females were obtained by sites •Clinics: Obstetrics/gynecology, emergency departments, hospital in-patient, family practice clinics, internal medicine clinics, jails, STD clinics •Samples from women ages 18-89 yr. in 21 States were tested retrospectively using the APTIMA Trichomonas vaginalis (ATV) assay on the TIGRIS DTS ® Instrumentation Endocervical Urine Vaginal PreservCyt liquid Pap National Prevalence Study of Trichomonas Using Gen-Probe ATV •N = 7,593 women ages 18-89 yr. 21 States •Overall Prevalence TV CT NG 8.7% 6.7% 1.7% Ginocchio et al. JCM, 50:2601-2608, 2012 APTIMA TV Study Sites x Prevalence of TV, CT, and NG Infections by Age N = 7,593 Overall Prevalence N* TV+ CT+ NG+ 7593 8.70% 6.70% 1.70% % (n/N*) (663/7593) (508/7588) (129/7579) Age (yr) Mean 29.82 23.4 24.0 8.50% 8.30% 7.90% 11.30% 13.00% 14.40% 8.00% 2.50% 1.90% 0.90% 3.30% 2.00% 0.80% 0.10% 1.20% Prevalence (%)* by Age Group 18-19 20-29 30-39 40-49 50+ 907 3972 1667 720 324 * In the calculations of prevalence, the denominator may be less than that the N shown due to missing or invalid assay data. % Prevalence Prevalence of TV, CT, and GC Infections by Age 16 14 12 10 CT 8 GC 6 TV 4 2 0 18-19 20-24 25-29 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 >50 National Prevalence Study of Trichomonas Using Gen-Probe ATV RACE/Ethnicity Black White Hispanic Asian Prevalence 20.2% 5.7% 5.0% 3.8% Region Southeast U.S. Southwest U.S. Midwest U.S. Northeast U.S. Prevalence 14.4% 9.5% 9.5% 4.3% Prevalence of TV, CT, and GC Infections by Race Overall Prevalence % (n/N*) Prevalence (%)* by Race American Indian/ Alaskan Native Asian Black/African American Hispanic/Latino Native Hawaiian/ Other Pacific Island White Other/Unknown N* 7593 TV+ CT+ GC+ 8.70% 6.70% 1.70% (663/7593) (508/7588) (129/7579) 19 10.50% 0.00% 0.00% 131 1382 718 3.80% 20.20% 5.00% 9.90% 12.10% 5.90% 2.30% 4.00% 0.70% 14 7.10% 7.10% 0.00% 1668 3658 5.70% 6.70% 5.70% 5.20% 1.60% 1.10% * In the calculations of prevalence, the denominator may be less than that the N shown due to missing or invalid assay data. Prevalence of TV, CT, and GC Infections by Collection Site % Prevalence 25 20 15 10 5 0 CT Positive GC Positive TV POSITIVE Geographic Prevalence of TV CT and GC Infections 16 14 12 10 CT Positive 8 GC Positive 6 TV POSITIVE 4 2 0 midwest northeast southeast southwest Multivariant Analysis: Trichomonas Risk Factors % Prevalence Multivariant OR Age (YR) 18-<20 8.49 1 20-<30 8.33 1.03 30-<40 7.92 1.03 = > 40 11.78 1.51* White 5.70 1 All others/unknown 6.59 0.92 Black 20.22 4.04* Hispanic/Latino 5.01 0.88 Race *P < 0.05 Ginocchio et al. JCM 50: 2601-2608, 2012 Multivariant Analysis: Trichomonas Risk Factors % Prevalence Multivariant OR Clinic Type Family Planning 5.36 1 ED, In patient 16.63 3.50* Family Practice, Int’l Med 6.12 1.27 OB/GYN 7.29 1.33 Jail, STD Clinic 16.41 2.59* Other/Unknown 5.85 1.67* Northeast 4.30 1 Southwest 9.51 1.88* Southeast 14.44 6.32* Midwest 9.48 2.00* Region *P < 0.05 Conclusions •Trichomonas is highly prevalent in many populations; often associated with race and acquisition of HIV •Diagnostic tests are improving; there is now an FDA cleared, commercially available NAAT •In a females screened for CT/GC by NAAT, TV was highly prevalent: • Blacks 20.2% and older women (11-13%) •Public health awareness of TV as associated health and cost outcomes needs to be increased, especially with health disparities and HIV “Optimal prevention and control strategies for T. vaginalis infection should be further explored as a means of closing the racial disparity in prevalence and decreasing other adverse outcomes associated with this sexually transmitted infection” Sutton et al. CID 2007 National Center HIV/AIDS, CDC Acknowledgements and ? Mathilda Barnes Yu-Hsiang Hsieh Quinn, Nicole Mary Jett-Goheen Jeff Holden Laura Dize Perry Barnes Billie Masek Justin Hardick Christine Ginocchio Kimberle Chapin Jane Schwebke GenProbe, Inc Another Recent Study: TV in Different Age Groups •Trichomonas PCR in FL, NJ, TX (N = 78,428) •TV Prevalence: 4.3% (CT 3.8%; GC 0.6%) •Group with highest prevalence : •Age 46-55 yr 6.2% •Age 56-65 yr 6.1% •Age 12-26 yr 4.6% Stemmer et al. Amer Soc Colpos and Cervical Path 16, 2012 Female Trichomonas via Internet Recruitment •Of 1525 self collected vaginal swabs collected in the home using mailed kits •Tested positive 2006-2010 using NAAT assays TV 10.0% CT 10.0% GC 1.0% Any STI 18.0% Gaydos et al. STD 2011 Internet Rectal Kits- Females In January 2009, IWTK offered self-collected rectal kits in addition to vaginal kits From 1,084 women submitting vaginal swabs 2009-10 to IWTK , 194 (17.9%) reported anal intercourse (AI) in the last 90 days. Of these women, 113 (58.2%) also ordered and returned rectal kits; 95 additional kits were ordered and returned by women who did not report recent AI From a total of 406 rectal kits ordered by women overall, 208 (51.2%) were returned; 3 had no consent form; 205 were tested. Ladd et al. ISSTDR 2011 Internet Rectal Kits- Females (N=205) •Of those tested, 18.5% were rectal test positive •12.7% for chlamydia •2.4% for gonorrhea •6.3% for trichomonas •5 co-infected •Of those infected women who also returned vaginal swabs, 70.5% were positive for at least one of the three STIs vaginally; multivariate analysis indicated risk factors were black race and having a vaginal infection Female Rectal TV To Date 536 6.5% Trichomonas vaginalis Diagnostics POC vs. culture OSOM XenoStrip Affirm VPIII Wet Preparation: 50-72% sensitive Culture: 70-78% Sensitive PCR TMA Sensitivity 83-99% 77-90% 80% 97% Sensitive 96.7-98.2% Sensitive Scanning Electron Microscopy Tests for Trichomonas Range of sensitivity and specificity of tests for trichomonas in women Test Assay Sensitivity (%) Specificity (%) Wet Preparation* 50-72 100 Culture* OSOM** XenoStrip** Affirm VPIII** PCR*** TMA**** 70-78 83-99 77-90 80 97 96.7-98.2 100 100 93-99 98 98 98 *compared to NAATs; ** compared to culture; ***Compared to culture and other primer sets for trichomonas;-Madico JCM 1998;36:3205-3210; ****Compared to research PCR— Huppert CID 2007 & Hardick JCM 2006 Gaydos, C. Rapid Tests for STDs Current Infect Dis Reports 2006;8:115-124 % positive Trichomonas ASR NAAT Performance in Two Published Studies 98.4 96.6 100 90 75.4 75 80 83 82.0 70 60 50.8 54.6 50 40 30 20 10 0 Wet mount Culture OSOM Huppert Huppert, et al. CID 2007; 45:194-198; PCR APTIMA Nye Nye, et al. Am J of Obstet Gynecol, Feb 2009 Current Estimation of Types of Trichomonas Testing Performed Wet mount/ culture 48% BD Affirm 13% NAAT ASR 2% OSOM 8% Pap Smear % ? InPouch 29% Prevalence of TV in Low STI Setting STI Prevalence n= 1676 Chapin et al. Expert Rev Mol Diagn 11:1-10, 2011 TV CT GC 4.6% 5.3% 0.4% Time to change in order to do better at diagnosing TV in our patients? Wet Prep to Amplified Technology Time for Value Added for our Patients for a Undervalued STI? A Combined Concerted Effort PUBLIC HEALTH LABS HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS PATIENTS Coinfection of TV, CT, and GC Infections by Age Overall Prevalence % (n/N*) Age Mean Median Prevalence (%)* by Age Group 18-19 20-29 30-39 40-49 50+ N* CT+GC+TV+ CT+TV+ CT+GC+ GC+TV+ 7593 0.24% 1.30% 0.61% 0.61% (18/7577) (97/7588) (46/7577) (46/7579) 907 3972 1667 720 324 22.00 21.5 23.41 22 21.89 21 23.15 21.5 0.20% 0.40% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 2.10% 1.70% 0.40% 0.40% 0.00% 1.30% 0.83% 0.10% 0.00% 0.00% 0.90% 0.90% 0.20% 0.00% 0.30% * In the calculations of prevalence, the denominator may be less than that the N shown due to missing or invalid assay data. Coinfection of TV, CT, and GC Infections by Race CT+GC+TV+ CT+TV+ Overall Prevalence % (n/N*) CT+GC+ GC+TV+ 0.24% 1.30% 0.61% 0.61% (18/7577) (97/7588) (46/7577) (46/7579) Prevalence (%)* by Race American Indian/ Alaskan Native Asian 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.80% 0.80% 0.00% Black/African American 0.70% 3.60% 1.70% 1.70% Hispanic/Latino Native Hawaiian/ Other Pacific Island White Other/Unknown 0.00% 0.60% 0.00% 0.10% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.10% 0.20% 0.60% 0.90% 0.40% 0.40% 0.50% 0.40% * In the calculations of prevalence, the denominator may be less than that the N shown due to missing or invalid assay data. Estimates of Sexually Transmitted Infections in the US Placement of Trichomonas in the Test Menu • Educate healthcare providers Don’t know the prevalence or the sequelae • Highlight the prevalence in older age STD diagnosis vs vaginosis • Educate the public The most common treatable STI is one that your physician may not be testing for?? What STD is a college student’s MOM more likely to have then their college student? • Combine it with CT/GC testing in age groups where STIs is a consideration Make it easy to collect and order Validate it for as many specimens as possible What do labs need to adopt Trich? • Physician education Differences in different risk populations Highlight the sequelae and high prevalence Cost of another public health screening test Not reportable • Lab education FDA-cleared test Review workflow and capacity Providers familiar with CT/GC TAT Budget Currently reimbursed Trichomonas vaginalis Wet Preparation Scanning Electron Microscopy Trichomonas and Risk for HIV • 213 women who experienced HIV seroconversion (cases) longitudinal study; 4450 HIV - women in Uganda & Zimbabwe were matched (controls) • Prevalence T. vaginalis infection before HIV infection was 11.3% in cases and 4.5% in controls (P = .002) • Controlling for hormonal contraception, other STIs, behavioral, and demographic factors, the aOR for HIV acquisition was 2.74 (95% CI 1.25– 6.00) for TV cases. Van Der Pol et al. Trichomonas vaginalis Infection and Human Immunodeficiency Virus Acquisition in African Women CID 2008;197:548-54 • Infection w/ TV increases risk of HIV acquisition • aHR 1.52 (95% CI 1.04-2.24 ) in 1335 women in Mombasa McClelland et al. JID 2007;195:698-702.) Trichomonas vaginalis Infection: Can We Afford to Do Nothing? •Many calls for control strategy; many questions; consider PH response •Can we afford to undertake a program? Can we afford not to? •Should Tric become a reportable disease? McClelland JID 197:487-9, 2008 •“Optimal prevention and control strategies for T. vaginalis infection should be further explored as a means of closing the racial disparity in prevalence and decreasing other adverse outcomes associated with this sexually transmitted infection” Sutton et al. CID 2007 National Center HIV/AIDS, CDC In Summary •TV: 18-39 yr: >40 yr: 7.5 - 8.6% 9.8% •TV most Prevalent @ all ages except for ages 18-19 yr. (CT 14.3%; TV 8.5%) •Family Planning Clinics •Jails •Coinfection: 5.4% 22.3% <1% most ages •Overall Trichomonas Prevalence 8.7% Conclusions •Routine screening for TV should be considered for all women being screened for CT/GC •Screening all high-risk women over 40 for TV should also be considered •The use of the highly accurate, fully-automated ATV assay for testing non-invasive samples that can be run together with APTIMA CT/GC assays will facilitate co-testing of TV with CT and GC in the U.S.
© Copyright 2024