SOFT MAGNETIC COMPOSITES FOR ELECTRICAL MACHINE APPLICATIONS

SOFT MAGNETIC COMPOSITES
FOR ELECTRICAL MACHINE
APPLICATIONS
Alan Jack, Barrie Mecrow, Glynn Atkinson,
Bogi Jensen
University of Newcastle upon Tyne
[email protected]
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
An SEM picture of SMC powder
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Parts Production
1 Powder
2 Compaction
3 Heat treatment
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
B-H curves
1.8
B (T)
Other
SMC properties:
1.6
ƒ 1.4Density 7.54 g/cc
(solid steel = 7.85)
1.2
ƒ Transverse
rupture
1
strength = 83MPa –
0.8
weak
ƒ 0.6Conductivity = 384
0.4
S/m (solid steel =
0.2
5x106)
0
ƒ Thermal
conductivity
oC – 100
10
20W/m/
same as
laminations
H (A/m)
Somaloy 700 3p
EN 10106 (M330 35A)
0.5mm polycor
1000
10000
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Iron Loss:
SMC 5mmx5mm sample - lams manufacturers data
Iron loss at 50Hz
Iron loss at 100Hz
100.0
1.0
0.1
1.0
10.0
Loss (W/kg)
Loss (W/kg)
10.0
Somaloy 700 3P
M330 35A
0.5mm polycor
0.1
10.0
1.0
0.1
0.1
B (T)
B (T)
Iron loss at 400Hz
Iron loss at 200Hz
100.0
Loss (W/kg)
Loss (W/kg)
100.0
10.0
1.0
0.1
1.0
10.0
1.0
1.0
B (T)
10.0
0.1
1.0
10.0
B (T)
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
10.0
Properties (45id 55od x 5mm ring)
Core loss @ 1T [W/kg]
Material
Resistivity TRS
[MPa]
[µΩm]
B@
10kA/m
[T]
µmax
100 Hz 400 Hz 1 kHz
Somaloy 700 1P
400
40
1,56
540
10
44
131
Somaloy 700 3P
200
125
1,61
750
10
46
137
Latest development
700
60
1,57
600
6
32
104
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Compared with laminations:–
good bits
ƒ Isometric properties – 3D flux
ƒ Net shape – no extra operations
ƒ Tight tolerance – can fit core sections
together with no magnetic effect
ƒ Smooth surface finish – minimises insulation
requirements
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Compared with laminations:–
bad bits
ƒ Poorer magnetic properties
ƒ Low mechanical strength and brittle
ƒ Practical limits on shapes which can be pressed
e.g. 6:1 aspect ratio
ƒ More expensive than a laminated stack
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Permanent Magnet
Machines
Magnetic circuit is dominated by the
magnets
Servo motors - Mk 1
ICEM 1996
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Coils are die compacted – same
Mk from
2 pressure
effect
impregnation
Separately wound, high fill,
bobbin
coilsto slot area
78%
copper
IEEE IAS
2000
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Mk 3 style of construction
Allows radial tooth compaction
keeps teeth press-able
IEE PEMD 2004
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Comparison with laminated single tooth winding m/c
laminated
SMC
ƒ Shorter, fatter teeth make copper shorter for the same tooth area = 20% reduction
ƒ 20% shorter allows 20% smaller copper area for the same resistance = 36% less
copper volume
ƒ Slot area is 17% smaller in SMC case – but 20% less copper area
ƒ Machine is shorter - 30%
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
ƒ Compressor motor
ƒ Teeth simply butt-jointed to core back impregnated
in prototype but aimed at over-moulding
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
Shorter
Less copper
More iron loss
Efficiency about 2% lower
Efficiency should be higher with latest materials
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Two part
IEE PEMD 2004
Three part
Cutting down the no of parts
to keep the cost down
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
BLDC Radial flux motor
Producer: ABB
Application: Industrial servo motor
Benefits
• Reduction of manufacturing costs
• More compact (33% shorter)
• Lighter
• Improved performances (25% lower
inertia, lower losses)
Somaloy®
stator
component
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
BDC ABS Motor – Aisin Seiki Co., Ltd
Axially extended tooth tips use magnet
better
36 %
Offset core back
provides room for
internal
commutator
Shorter machine
allows 1 less
bearing
Weight
Weight
Conventional ABS Motor
17 %
New Type of ABS Motor
Over-moulded plastic (light blue) provides ground
wall insulation and mounting of stator on splined
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
shaft
Courtesy LAING GmbH,
BLDC Pump Motor – Laing GmbH:
Germany
• Patented spherical motor design
• Single and self-adjusting ceramic bearing
• Mostly water film bearing self pumped
• Rotor/Impeller the only moving part
Centrifugal pump wheel
Permanent
Magnet rotor
Ceramic
bearing
Stator and Controller
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Axial flux motors are difficult to
laminate - real opportunity for SMC
SMC + Laminations
“strip” core back “rolled
up” holds teeth
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Modulated Pole
Machines e.g.
IEEE IEMDC ‘97
Transverse flux & claw
poles
•Modulate two poles into many All poles see all the current high electric loading
•High torque/unit volume
•High frequency
IEE PEMD 2002
•Not easy to laminate
•Two pressings and a simple hoop
coil
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Claw pole stepping motor actuator
2-Phase Claw pole stator
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Courtesy Lyng Motor,
Motor,
Norway
Claw pole armature
machines from Hitachi
Japan
First motor aimed for air moving home
appliance application, start of production
mid 2009
Half the axial length
An efficiency improvement of 5%
Easy Recycling
Easy assembly
Lower cost
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Latest thoughts
ƒ high torque (13.5Nm/kg)
ƒ good reactance - 0.92pu
ƒ looks rather promising
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Actuators:
Bosch diesel injector solenoid valve
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Flux in radial/axial plane – laminations in
axial/radial
plane – implies varying
thickness
Moving
Magnet—existing
commercial
laminations…..
designs
ƒ Only
not east
to get
coil in→either….
magnet
moves
very light
ƒ mover
Easy in SMC
ƒ Magnetic
Permanentcircuit
magnetnot
- low
permeability
not a
well
used
problem
ƒ
Linear tubular
motors for pumps
core
magnet
Coil in this space
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Linear Compressor – Twinbird Corporation:
• Free Piston Stirling Cooler (FPSC) – FPBC TB-40
•Similar performance as laminated
• Easier assembly and cheaper
• Reduced weight and noise
Up to -120°C
SMC Inner stator
Permanent
magnet
SMC Outer stator
Coil
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Courtesy Twinbird Corporation,
Japan
Other possible toplogies e.g.
Buried magnet style
ƒ Simpler magnets, strong mover,
better magnetic circuit
ƒ But heavier mover
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
magnet
moving
One buried magnet
Lots of new design ideas possible!
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group
Conclusions
ƒ SMC properties getting better B-H,
coercivity & resistivity
ƒ More known of features but more needs to
be known
ƒ SMC allows new design and production
freedoms - advantage if design is right
ƒ Cost of part manufacture crucial – pushing
applications away from conventional shapes
ƒ BH (saturation & permeability) not a show
stopper for permanent magnet machines or
for some chokes
Newcastle Drives and M achines Group