Low Cost Enceladus Sample Return Mission Concept - LCPM-10

Low Cost
Enceladus Sample Return
Mission Concept
P. Tsou1, D. E. Brownlee2, C. P. McKay3,
A. Anbar4, H. Yano5, Nathan Strange7,
Richard Dissly6, and I. Kanik7
1Sample
Exploration Systems ([email protected])
2University
3Ames
4Arizona
LCPM-10
Pasadena, CA
June 18-20, 2013
Image: NASA/JPL-Caltech/SSI
5Japan
6Ball
7Jet
of Washington
Research Center
State University
Aerospace Exploration Agency
Aerospace & Technologies Corp.
Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology
Enceladus
Saturnian Moon with water
vapor geysers erupting from
“Tiger Stripes” on its South pole
Plumes are very likely fed by a
liquid subsurface saltwater
ocean with a significant and
persistent heat source
Cassini INMS measurements
of the plume have found simple
organic compounds
2
Image: NASA/JPL-Caltech/SSI
The Plumes
Cassini has provided strong evidence that Enceladus has an
ocean with an energy source, nutrients, and organic molecules.
From everything we know, Enceladus should be habitable. We
want to know if it is inhabited, and if not, why not. Either way,
sample return is essential.
Lucky for us, Enceladus is already ejecting samples into space.
We just have to go get them.
3
Image: NASA/JPL-Caltech/SSI
The value of a sample
 
 
 
4
Determining the presence or absence of life requires
multiple analyses that are too complex to fly, and the
optimal analytical sequence to follow depends on what
you learn at each step of the sequence
The exact same logic holds for studying any potential
pre-biotic chemistry of Enceladus
Regardless of any biological content of the sample, this
would be the first sample from the Outer Solar System
and would provide invaluable clues to the origin and
evolution of the Solar System
Aerogel Sample Collection
 
The Stardust heritage aerogel
collection mechanism could be
augmented for Enceladus sample
return by:
 
 
Reducing the initial shock energy
by reducing aerogel entry density
(e.g. with Japanese Tanpopo
aerogel)
Carrying a volatiles trapping and
sealing deposition collector to seal
the samples at capture (e.g. the
metal sealing technology that will
be employed on Hayabusa-2)
Strong
particle
5
Weak
particle
Spacecraft Concept
Graphic: Raul Polit Casillas
 
 
 
 
 
 
Spacecraft 3 m HGA used to
shield main body of spacecraft
from plume particles
ASRG power source
800 kg dry mass, 3 km/s ΔV
Hibernation during interplanetary
cruise
Dual-use science and engineering
instruments such as a navigation
camera and radiometric tracking
Design also compatible with in
situ instruments such as dust
counter and mass spectrometer
View From
Ram Direction
6
Plume Particles
Mission Description
 
 
15 year mission, launching in
early 2020s
8.5 years to Saturn (Venus &
Earth flybys)
 
 
 
 
 
7
Example 2021 VEEGA
trajectory to Saturn
multiple trajectory options exist
2 years in Saturn orbit
 
 
5. Saturn Arrival
May 2030
multiple Enceladus flybys
sample collection from multiple
jets possible
4.5 year Earth return
trajectory
Earth entry capsule for sample
return
Sample curation and analysis
1. Launch
Nov. 2021
3. Earth Flyby
Mar. 2023
2.Venus Flyby
Apr. 2022
4. Earth Flyby
June 2026
Saturn Orbit Phase
 
8
Titan gravity-assists used to set up favorable geometry for
Enceladus sample collection
Trajectory: Brent Buffington
Planetary Protection
 
 
 
 
9
Developing a method to avoid inadvertent backward
contamination is a huge challenge
Our current strategy is to tune the sample impact
velocity such that large molecules would survive, but
structures such as bacteria or viruses would not
Additional layers of safety would be achieved through
trajectory biasing and entry system reliability
Non-destructive return of extraterrestrial life forms
would likely require multi-mission investments to develop
new planetary protection technologies
Low Cost Approach
 
 
Sample return is the most cost effective means for
detection or non-detection of life in the plume material
Tightly focused on astrobiology and plume composition
science objectives
 
 
 
 
 
10
Important science such as studying the interior of Enceladus,
the plume mechanism, etc. is left for other missions.
Low spacecraft dry mass
Low spacecraft power design
New spacecraft design, but built from existing
components and subsystem designs
Hibernation during long periods of spacecraft inactivity
Concluding Remarks
 
 
 
 
Detection of life from Enceladus would change the world
Conclusive non-detection of life in the Enceladus’ ocean
would be almost as significant
The best way to get either of the above results in a single
mission requires a sample return
Elements critical to making this possible include:
 
 
 
 
11
High priority in Decadal Survey
RPS power systems
High Performance TPS
International collaboration