Cover Page Emporia State University Teacher Work Sample Analysis of Student Learning Candidate Name: xxx Candidate Phone Number: xxx Candidate ID Number: xxx Name of School where data was collected: xxx Middle School TWS Content Area: Physical Education Tennis Unit Grade Level: 6th and 7th Grade xxx Date Submitted: (to be filled in by ESU staff) TWS Number: (to be filled in by ESU staff) This is verification that the candidate submitting this TWS is a student teacher/intern at this school and that to the best of my knowledge this is the work of the candidate submitting the TWS. Signature of Supervising/Mentor Teacher: Emailed xxxx Middle School Physical Education My signature verifies that this TWS is my own authentic work. I understand that obtaining, or attempting to obtain, a passing grade on a TWS by falsification or misrepresentation may result in a failing grade in a course or expulsion from the teacher education program. You should NOT expect your supervising/mentor teacher to verify your TWS without having an opportunity to review it. Signature of Candidate Submitting the TWS: Emailed xxx Student Teacher Page 1 Demographic Information Sheet Please indicate: Semester (Fall or Spring) xxx Year: xxx_ Your certification/licensure level (check all that apply): _____ Early Childhood (Birth - Grade 3) _____ Secondary (Grades 6 - 12) _____ Elementary (Grades K - 6) __X__ Dual (Elem. and Secondary, Grades PK - 12) _____ Middle School (Grades 5 - 8) Your certification/licensure area(s) (check all that apply): _____Art _____Lang. Arts, Middle Level _____Physics _____Biology _____French _____Psychology _____Business _____Health _____Science, General _____Chemistry _____Journalism _____Science, Middle Level _____Early Childhood Ed. _____Mathematics _____Social Studies-Middle Level _____Early Child., handicap _____Mathematics, Middle Level _____Social Studies _____Earth-Space Science _____Music _____Spanish _____Elementary __X__Physical Education _____Speech and Theatre _____Language Arts _____Physical Science _____Other:_______________ _____ESOL Identify the course, unit content area, (e.g., “Language Arts,” “Biology,” “Math,” Social Science,” etc.), and grade level(s) of your Teacher Work Sample. Course: Girls Physical Education Content Area: Physical Education Tennis The grade(s)/level of students in your classroom (check all that apply): _____Preschool _____4th Grade _____9th Grade _____Kindergarten _____5th Grade _____10th Grade _____1st Grade __X__6th Grade _____11th Grade _____2nd Grade __X__7th Grade _____12th Grade _____3rd Grade _____8th Grade Page 2 Factor 1: Contextual Information and Learning Environment A) Explanation of community factors that impact my planning and teaching. xx Middle School is located in xxx, Kansas, a city with a population of xxx people. The middle school is located in the Hi-Crest neighborhood correlated to high-crime, drug activity and violence, including a large police presence. The Hi-Crest neighborhood also includes a large population of single parent families ranging from middle to low socioeconomic status. B) Explanation of district, classroom, and school population factors that impact my planning and teaching. xxx Middle School is one of eight schools that serve sixth, seventh, and eighth grade students from the age of eleven to fourteen. An estimate of children living under the poverty level in xxx is twenty-seven percent. xxx Middle School serves a large portion of these families. It is eligible for state and federal financial aid via school wide Title I program, which assists with low-income and at-risk students. The funds are designed to improve teaching and learning for students farthest from meeting Kansas state standards. Eisenhower academic staff offers a targeted assistance program, where the school identifies students who are failing, or most at risk of failing, to meet the State’s performance standards. It is designed to create instructional opportunities to meet the needs of targeted students. There are four hundred and forty-nine students enrolled in the school, which eighty percent qualify for either free meals at sixty-four percent (277 students) or reduced price meals, sixteen percent (67 students). In addition, the impact of planning and teaching is affected by family values. Many families do not value education; hence a daily attendance rate of eight-five percent. Additionally, an average of thirty students can be counted tardy after the bells rang to begin advisor base in the morning. The greatest classroom factors that affected planning, teaching, and learning at xxx Middle School was the temperature due to no air condition in the boys’ and girls’ locker rooms plus the gymnasium. The sunny September afternoon temperatures rose to ninety-seven degrees with up to Page 3 ninety-five percent humidity. There were two small fans to circulate air in the locker rooms, which did not reduce temperatures. This lead to minimal time spent in the locker rooms or gym to use technology like the projector. This factor also affected the amount of time the students wanted to be on the tennis courts. C) Explanation of the classroom setting that impacts my planning and teaching. Another factor that impacts planning and teaching are the student characteristics. The racial outlook of the school is diverse with forty-eight percent African American, one hundred ninety three students, thirty-one percent White with one hundred and thirty-three students, and fifteen percent Hispanic or sixty-six students in the entire school. The numbers reflected the classroom of seventeen girl with seventy percent African American, twelve percent white and sixteen percent Hispanic and two percent of another race. D) QPA / NCA school improvement plan and state assessment data Eighteen schools within the district did not make Annually Yearly Progress (AYP) for the 2009-2010 school years including xxx Middle School and the three feeder elementary schools. Due to the above data, the district implemented a new school improvement plan aligned with the school’s Quality Performance Accreditation (QPA). First, the staff was trained during in-service prior to the school year on three of Marzano’s 9 Instructional Strategies. The three strategies were targeted to enhance and engage cognitive skills of students during daily instruction: 1) Summarization 2) Recognize Effort 3) Cooperative Learning. Second, staff and student teachers were encouraged to use the three strategies routinely. I plan to use guided reading strategies to comprehend various forms of text, provide formative instruction and assessment, as well as, helping students solve real life problems during the Tennis Unit instruction. Contextual Factor Table Contextual and Environmental Factors Identify source of Factor: Community, Implications for Instruction Page 4 District, School, or Classroom Low Socioeconomic Population Community/Classroom Failure to make AYP District Developmental Characteristics of Adolescents Community/Classroom Mixed Ethnic Make-up Classroom Gender Make-up (17 girls) Classroom Students with Learning Disabilities (1) Classroom Student diagnosed with Mental Retardation (1) Classroom Student diagnosed with Other Health Impairment (OHI) Classroom Student At-Risk for Failure (11) Classroom No air-condition in locker room and gym Classroom with increasingly high temperatures outdoors. Factor 2: Unit Goals and Objectives Allow students to keep items in personal lockers. Provide extra gym suits, tennis shoes, deodorant. Request donations for locker room. Apply for grants to receive new equipment. Provide activities that offer daily success to enhance student achievement. Plan daily opportunities to read, write and comprehend text with integration of task cards, exit slips and/or mathematics and language arts. Students at this age are at different developmental stages emotionally, socially and physically. Provide individual instruction. Provide re teach opportunities. Preplan various ways to group students daily. Use active demonstration for skills Provide guidance and opportunities for cooperation among all students. Preplan various ways to group students daily. Use proper non-gender specific titles. Increase self-esteem with positive feedback and compliments for effort. Allow student more time to finish either reading or writing activities. Pair students up with different partners daily. Small groups will remain under four students. Provide Peer Teach Activities. Gain student attention prior to instruction. Adapt activities to individual’s motor skills. Provide peer tutor during integration activities. Use appropriate cooperation activities to increase self-esteem and peer awareness. Use modified equipment to increase skill success. Adapt activities to individual motor skills Use developmentally appropriate equipment. Provide peer tutor for reading and writing. Use cooperation activities to increase esteem. Offer activities with maximum participation that lead to success. Create lessons to show students the enjoyment of physical activity. Take attendance and give instruction under the shade trees. Allow time for water breaks during game play. Provide clean towels to students. Allow time for students to shower at end of hour. A) Course, unit content area, and grade level of the Teacher Work Sample: Page 5 The Unit Learning Goals and Objectives are addressed during a middle school Physical Education course for sixth and seventh grade female students. The Unit covers Tennis skills. B) Rationale for choice of unit objectives: I chose the objectives according to what students will learn how to do during the Tennis Unit. The low objectives 1.2 and 2.2 are the basis of tennis play. Students should be able to identify parts of the tennis court and name etiquette related to the game. The middle objective 4.4 was selected because it is important to emphasize physical activity to promote a life-long love of movement, exercise, with the pursuit of health and fitness. The other middle objectives 5.2 and 6.2 increase students ability to assess themselves and others. Objective 7.1 and 8.1 were chosen because students must be self directed to practice, correct and refine sports skills like the forehand to improve at the sport. Additionally, the other high level objective 9.4 gives students opportunities to use personal goal setting daily. C) Standards that the outcomes are aligned with: For the school year, 2010-2011, all objectives will be aligned with the National Association of Sport and Physical Education (NASPE) standards, as well as the district’s new physical education standards Kansas has no state standards so I will use the following guidelines: Standard 1: Demonstrates competency in motor skills and movement patterns needed to perform a variety of physical activities. Standard 2: Demonstrates understanding of movement concepts, principles, strategies, and tactics as they apply to the learning and performance of physical activities. Standard 3: Participates regularly in physical activity. Standard 4: Achieves and maintains a health-enhancing level of physical fitness. Standard 5: Exhibits responsible personal and social behavior that respects self and others in physical activity settings. Standard 6: Values physical activity for health, enjoyment, challenge, selfexpression, and/or social interaction. Goal(s): Tennis Unit Page 6 TWS Objective Number/ NASPE standard Stated Objective Level of objective The student will be able to: Domain of objective * 1.2 Name parts of a tennis court used during game play on a diagram. Low * 2.2 Lists three rules according to tennis etiquette. Low 3..6 Recognizes physical activity as a positive opportunity for social interaction in dynamic settings. Middle Affective Middle Psychomotor Middle Affective/ Cognitive Middle Cognitive High Psychomotor High Psychomotor High Cognitive High Cognitive * 4.4 * 5.2.5 * 6.2 * 7.1 * 8.1 * 9.4 10.2 Participates in physical activity, to improve cardiovascular endurance. Applies external feedback to improve tennis skills of peers in dynamic settings. Applies internal knowledge to improve self with tennis skills in a dynamic setting. Corrects tennis stroke, the overhand serve during practice, so it can be repeated without error. Refines the tennis stroke, the forehand, during a rally. Develops and implements goal setting to improve or maintain a healthy lifestyle. Incorporates the physiological indicators associated with exercise related to tennis play. Cognitive Cognitive Factor 3: Instructional Design and Implementation Design for Instruction Table Page 7 Time Day 1 Day 2 Learning Objectives Instructional Activities, including interdisciplinary activities Maintain control of tennis ball with Brain-X cross lateralization drills. Cooperative Game of All TWS Catch & Throw Tennis to Objectives acquire social skills necessary to work together in a positive manner. 1.2 2.2 4.4 9.4 Day 3 2.2 4.4 9.4 Day 4 1.2 2.2 4.4 9.4 Assessments Resources and Technology Teaching and reading adaptations for specific students and subgroups, based on identified contextual and/or preassessment needs Read assessment out loud to subgroup of Pre-Assessment students. Allow more time to Assess student take tests. Reduce prior knowledge distractions by giving on the sport of test away from entrance Tennis and exits. Allow students to take test in resource center. Pedometers Pedometers offer Summarize CD Player individual Racquet Skills to Music CD comprehension of steps a Peer taken during class time. Overview of Racquet Safety Racquet Stretches Drills to practice the control of tennis ball on Review Cause racquet face. and Effect of Bring Them Home Race, Racquet motion the proper method of holding a tennis racquet Teacher Check while learning court areas. student step logs Tennis Volleyball Review Tennis Cues Open Ended Racquet Skill Stations Questions on Forehand drill to fence Cause and Effect Perform the forehand using Self checklistproper form and technique. Forehand Last Girl Standing (groups) Verbal Check Tennis Baseball Name three stretches used with a racquet 200 Passes- Practice forehands rally with a partner. Small Group 4 Square Tennis Court Quiz Review Parts of the Tennis Court Verbal Response Achieve 2000 steps Tennis Cues Tennis Drills and Skills Text Use peers to help with pedometer reading for any students struggling with the devices at end of class time. Pedometers Digital Photos of Proper Forehand Technique Peer helpers to read tennis cue cards to students struggling with reading. Peer helpers to assist reading during skill stations. Provide handouts on Tennis Skills Pedometers Predesigned small groups with individual CD Player assignments Music CD Tennis cue cards written with cues for student diagnosed with MR and OHI Page 8 Day 5 Day 6 Day 7 1.2 2.2 4.4 9.4 4.4 5.2.5 7.1 9.4 4.4 6.2 7.1 9.4 Day 8 2.2 4.1 7.1 8.1 9.4 Day 9 All TWS Objectives Tennis BINGO Relate tennis etiquette to games Know Your Courtindividual students identify parts of court. Playground Tennis Pedometers PowerPoint allows students to watch short PowerPoint clips on Tennis Skills Exit Slip and Game Play, highly 3 Tennis Projector effective to not only Etiquette Rules gain knowledge but also offer information through auditory and visual learning for all students. Mixed groups to vary ability for reading task sheets. Tennis BINGO Pedometers Predesigned peer . Perform a serve to a partner partners to assist Informal Peer with a bean bag 25 Task struggling readers. Assessment on Provide feedback to a Sheets Pedometers offer the Serve partner to assist in skill Copied for individual Verbal Response development BINGO comprehension of steps Tennis Baseball with Serve taken during class time. Initiates a rally with a serve Pedometers Charts allow for Incorporates the Rate of students to physiological indicators Perceived independently read associated with moderate Exertion information covered. Rubric activity Chart Small groups of Assessment Works responsibility students will be mixed Playground Tennis to allow for strong readers to read aloud to at risk readers. Ladder Tournament Student Review Pedometers Lower skilled students Integrate math to compute Tennis Mean Rate of will be paired with average steps achieved Perceived higher skills students during Tennis Unit Exertion for tournament. Chart Higher skilled math students will peer assist Calculators all other students. Use tennis skills during game play Applies rules and strategies Queens Court Teacher observation Summative Assessment Modified Summative Assessment Review Tennis Handout in Locker Room prior to test. Reading test aloud to sub group of students. Make peer teacher available to assist with re reading test questions. Resource Room B) Narrative Page 9 1) The instructional plan was designed for a Tennis Unit outside during physical education class time. Students will work individually and in pre-designed small groups assisted by the student teacher to achieve the unit objectives. Each learning domain was addressed daily (affective, cognitive, and psychomotor); furthermore, fitness concepts will be associated with every activity. Various forms of learning will occur through direct instruction, cooperative learning, guided discovery, task teaches, and peer teaches. Students of all abilities will be able to participate daily in class activities. 2) All reading within the tennis unit will be modified for pre-designed small groups of students. Each student will be able to work with different partners of varying abilities. All task sheets were typed with directions numbered for students to follow. Students with a lesser degree of skill in reading will always be partnered with a peer. Students with special needs and at-risk learners will be offered extra assistance with reading and mathematics by means of modified reading, and extra time to complete assessments. 3) The Tennis Unit offered each student opportunities for students to assess their own skill. At the beginning of every class, students determined a step goal for the forty minute class time. Next, students jogged to the tennis courts to practice independent cognitive and a psychomotor skills with task teaches. Then students identified their personal skill level with self checklist and rubric. After that, student learning will be enhanced with peer teachers, to apply affective skills like cooperation among peers of different race or ability while practicing tennis skills in small groups and peers. 4) The Tennis Unit combines student comprehension with short reading segments applied to skill performance. Comprehension will be enhanced by students reading the content, hearing the content cues, and then reviewing content with a peer, small group, and/or the teacher. For Page 10 instance, the students will read task cards, watch a peer’s active demonstration, and then be able to assess another student’s form. 5) Technology will be used daily to aid student learning. Pedometers will encourage students to monitor individual achievement; Objective 4 participate in physical activity, to improve cardiovascular endurance. Since the Tennis Unit is outdoors, the students will be able to listen to music during instant activities. Lastly, the students will be able to view a PowerPoint of tennis skill footage on a projector in the locker room. 6) During the physical education course, all three learning domains plus fitness concepts will be taught. Students arriving new to the district or returning after an absence will learn the same concepts just with different units. Students will be offered the chance to use technology either the first time or repeated time with teacher assistance at stations. Factor 4: Demonstration of Integration Skills A) Content areas being integrated: Reading, Mathematics, and Health B) Topics within the subject being integrated: fitness concepts: cardio respiratory endurance, flexibility, muscular endurance, and muscular strength. C) The instruction plan created learning experiences not only in physical education but also correlated with reading, mathematics and health. In objective 4 students had to use basic math formulas, with addition and multiplication, to find their individual mean for steps achieved. Students were challenged to apply the formula to find the mean of the entire class, even other classes. Factor 5: Analysis of Classroom Learning Environment A) Description of classroom environmental factors that affect learning. The physical education tennis unit was planned during girls’ tennis season in September. At this time, the Kansas weather conditions may vary from high temperatures and humidity to rain and strong winds. Either weather conditions may cause distraction among the students. More students complained in the afternoon modules than in the morning modules about playing tennis in the heat. Page 11 One major complaint arose from afterschool sports practices being cancelled for the heat index over one hundred. The second environmental factor that affected student learning was the location of the tennis courts; surrounded by family housing, interstate 470, and a school parking lot. The housing caused distractions from the neighbors talking, to the preschool bus honking daily, and the neighbor’s dog stealing the tennis balls. The interstate noise affected the listening skills of students while the staff parking lot led to distraction from parents and staff in their vehicles. B) Description of individual student motivation strategies Positive encouragement was one motivational strategy used for students in the physical education classroom. Students were taught with enthusiasm, as well as, consistent motivational feedback. Similarly, all students’ names were used with positive recognition either for daily effort, skill improvement, or time on task. In addition, students were continuously prompted to challenge their best effort. C) Description of group motivation strategies Students were grouped prior to instruction into cooperative pairs or small groups of students. They were expected to complete activities to achieve a common goal while using appropriate collaboration for each activity. Another motivational strategy incorporated into teaching was rewarding groups for good effort and respectful behavior by allowing more time in the locker room. This allowed some students to cool down, shower or socialize a few extra minutes prior to lunch. D) Description of how verbal communication among students was developed Verbal communication among students was applied to each lesson in the Tennis Unit. Kagan Cooperative Learning Structures were used to increase verbal communication among students. The cooperative groups allowed discussions in a controlled and positive learning atmosphere where each student could share knowledge. Students were prompted to reiterate cues to partners or small groups. For example, in the next thirty seconds, the tallest partner states the cues for the tennis serve (Palm Up, Scratch Your Back, and High-five). Now, the other partner has thirty seconds, to state the cues to Page 12 the forehand (Open the door and Shut the door). Next, both pairs have two minutes to discuss which skill is more difficult the overhand serve or the forehand and why. Other ways students used verbal communication were through performance peer check-list. Students were directed to discuss the technique used by their partners. Finally, students were prompted to use motivational terms like good job and thank-you directed to classmates. For instance, turn to your partner and say, “thanks for being a good partner!” E) Description of how non-verbal communication among students was developed Students needed daily encouragement to respond with appropriate non-verbal communication among classmates. During instruction students were expected to show respect by paying attention; look at speaker or demonstrator. Other non-verbal communication arose from the daily discussion of the term good sportsmanship with real world examples. Students were prompted to not only high-five teammates but also give thumbs up. Lastly, the students were encouraged to smile more often instead of eye rolling as a response to classmates. F) Description of at least three classroom management strategies that will provide evidence of a sufficient and comprehensive classroom management plan. One method of classroom management used was proximity to students. When students were struggling to learn a concept, I made myself readily available for questions or assistance. Likewise, if students were off-task, I will use proximity for students to correct their own behavior. For example, when students talked during instruction, I would stand near them, make eye contact and shake my head for them to discontinue the off-task behavior. The second classroom management strategy was for students to log daily steps; be accountable for learning. Everyday students were expected to be physically active while achieving personal goals. Students that did not complete tasks lost daily points. Students that executed assignments earned points toward a pick an activity day. The third classroom management strategy is immediate behavior correction. Students that became off-task, unsafe or failed to use Page 13 equipment safely are pulled aside, away from other students. The problem may be verbally discussed or written on a worksheet. Upon a solution, the student could return to the activity. G) Description of motivational techniques used and how they are applied in the unit. The main motivational technique in the Tennis Unit allowed for students to be in cooperative learning groups with different skilled students every day. Occasionally, close friends were allowed to be partners after showing good character traits like respect, which was modeled through daily instruction. Furthermore, student names were used with performance and motivational feedback, which is known to increase self esteem by building on student strengths. Equally, students were given ways to show positive feedback to peers like cheering for teammates. Also, students were given opportunities to find enjoyable forms of physical activity with varying small cooperative groups. H) Evidence of effective student-to-student communication specific to learning Effective student communication was shown through cooperative groups. One activity was designated as Tennis B.I.N.G.O. Students were paired up to complete fitness tasks on a life size Bingo Board. The letter B was designated for tennis skills, I for flexibility, N for strength, G for cardio and O for sharing favorites with their partner. Students enjoyed playing the life size activity because they smiled and laughed with partners. Another activity that showed effective student-to-student communication was during playground tennis. Students associated about how to keep score, plus the days gossip while playing tennis on the tennis court. I) Description of examples of inquiry learning that show an environment that involves students in inquiry learning activities. During a day the students could not go out to the rain soaked tennis courts, they voted on finding other ways to incorporate the game of tennis indoors. The students were allowed to choose from an assortment of equipment (e.g. bowling pins, noodles, jump ropes, scooters, tennis racquets, tennis balls, volleyballs) from the storage closet. The only rule given was to use the equipment in a safe manner. Part of the students sat down, attempting to hit tennis balls from the ground, better known as Page 14 Floor Pong. Another portion of the class used scooters to push one another around to hit the tennis ball. The last group of students created obstacles to knock down while practicing the forehand. J) Description of how students are actively involved in most learning activities and in cooperative or group work. In the educational setting, all students were given perimeters to complete task within a given time frame. Initially, all students moved through instant activities with pre assigned partner for at least five minutes. Next, all students were required to perform various forms of exercise before moving into the skill activity. Then the student pairs switched to another partner to practice skills like the overhand serve. After that, students combined with another pair to move into game play like four square tennis. The pre-assigned groups allowed for quick transitions, quicker pacing between activities and less time spent on off-task behavior. Pre-assessment and Post-assessment Score _____/45 Name: ___________________________________ Module: _______________________ True or False Read each statement and decide if the statement is TRUE or FALSE. Write TRUE or FALSE on the line provided. Each question is worth 2 points. 1.__FALSE__ If your serve lands outside the tennis court you receive 1 point. 2. __FALSE__A server aces 3 serves out of 15; her average is 70%. 3.__TRUE__ A forehand is with your dominant hand. 4. __FALSE_ While playing Singles, you may hit the ball into the alley. 5. _ TRUE__ In a game of tennis, each player has two chances to serve the ball over the net. Matching Each question is worth 2 points On the line provided, write the letter that fits the description of each object. Each letter will only be used once. A. Rally B. Service Box C. Doubles Alley D. Net E. Strings 6. B This box is used to identify where the ball served should land into. 7. C This area is only used when playing doubles tennis. 8. A To hit back and forth when playing the game of tennis 9. D This divides the court in half. 10. E These are the things that make-up the face of a tennis racket. Multiple Choice Each question is worth 2 Read each question. Circle the answer that fit in the blank. There is only one answer for each question. points. 11. A tennis game is started by ________while the opponent chooses up or down. a. spinning the racket b. playing rock-paper-scissors c. juggling the tennis ball d. hitting the tennis ball into the air 12.A singles game of tennis has _______people on the tennis court at one time. a. 1 b. 4 c. 2 d. 6 Page 15 13. A doubles game of tennis has ______people on the tennis court at one time. a.1 b. 4 c. 2 d. 6 14. A(n) ______serve is used to put the tennis ball into play before each serve. a. Overhand b. Underhand c. Tossed d. Elevated 15. Another name for the tennis score 0-0 is_______. a. Fifteen-forty c. Thirty all b. deuce d. love-love 16. ______is a scoring term in tennis that is used when the score is tied and both players have received 40 points in a single game. a. love-love b. love all c. deuce d. forty-forty 17. Perform four overhand serves, self-assess, what do you need to correct? 18. Watch a partner perform four forehand strokes to the fence, what do they need correct? 19. Describe 3 rules of etiquette during tennis activities: 1. Do not run across the tennis court while a game is being played. 2. Roll the tennis ball to players on a different court. 3. During doubles play, do not leave a tennis ball on the court. 20. Write your average step goal for the Tennis Unit___________________. How did you find it?_________________________ 21. Draw a tennis court in the space below. Label the right service box and the left service box on both sides. Shade inside the doubles alley Place an O behind the right baseline for the server. Place an X where the tennis ball should land after the serve. Factor 6: Analysis of Assessment Procedures A) Graphic representation of pre-assessment and post-assessment data. Page 16 B) ASSESSMENT PLAN TABLE Assessments 1. Preassessment 2. Formative Assessment 3. Formative Assessment 4. Informal Assessment 5.Formative assessment 6. PostAssessment TWS Objectives Type of Assessment All TWS objectives. Forty-five point paperpencil test.. The preassessment measures students’ prior knowledge of Tennis 6.2 Middle Self Checklist 70% Mastery Tennis Diagram-students will draw a tennis court, label key terms. 80% Mastery Exit Slip Students will write a list of tennis etiquette rules in exercise journal. 100% Mastery 1.2 Low 2.2 Low 5.2 Middle Peer Assessment 70% Mastery All TWS objectives. Same as Pre Assessment 80% Mastery Summative Adaptations Provide modified test with word bank Highlight key concepts Bold and italicize key words Use read aloud testing Allow sufficient wait time Offer sub-groups opportunities to ask questions. Repeat instructions Modify instructions Provide multiple explanations. Use active demonstration Repeat instructions Modify instructions Provide multiple explanations and hints Repeat instructions Modify instructions Provide multiple explanations. Use active demonstration of skills. Peer reads checklist Use small cooperative groups to discuss answers. Provide read aloud assistance with peer groups. Use active demonstration for key fitness concepts Review key fitness concepts with sub-groups. Provide modified test with word bank Highlight key concepts Bold and italicize key words Use read aloud testing Allow sufficient wait time Offer sub-groups opportunities to ask questions. C) MASTERY LEARNING TABLE TWS Objectives Low level objectives: Name parts of a tennis court used during game play on a diagram.(Cognitive) List three rules according to tennis etiquette.(Cognitive) Low Level Mastery Objective Index Sub-category score. Middle level objectives: Participates in physical activity, daily step log, to improve cardiovascular endurance. (Psychomotor) Applies external feedback to improve tennis skills of peers in dynamic settings.(Affective) Students Achieving Mastery Average Percentage of Students Achieving Mastery Number of Students Who Achieved Mastery with Adaptations 88% 1 100% 0 94% 100% 0 29% 2 Page 17 Applies internal knowledge to improve self with tennis skills in a dynamic setting.(Cognitive) Middle level Mastery Objective Index Sub-category score. High level objectives: Develops and implements goal setting to improve or maintain a healthy lifestyle. Corrects the tennis stroke, the overhand serve during practice. Refines the tennis stroke, the forehand, during a rally. High Level Mastery Objective Index Sub-category score. Objective Mastery Index (Average of percentage of students achieving mastery using all TWS objectives. 100% 0 76% 82% 1 88% 94% 2 1 88% 85% 7 D)Pre and Post Assessment Scores Learning Gain Scores STUDENT A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q PRE-TEST 5 40 15 20 35 10 40 35 35 42 10 15 10 40 15 42 5 PRE-% 11% 89% 33% 44% 78% 22% 89% 78% 78% 93% 22% 33% 22% 89% 33% 93% 11% CLASS POST-TEST 20 N/A 28 32 45 30 45 45 40 45 42 32 40 42 35 45 25 POST-% 44% N/A 62% 71% 100% 67% 100% 100% 89% 100% 93% 71% 89% 93% 78% 100% 56% GAIN SCORE 0.22 N/A 0.43 0.48 1.00 0.57 1.00 1.00 0.50 1.00 0.91 0.57 0.86 0.40 0.67 1.00 0.50 GAIN SCORE 65.4 E) Subgroup performances TWS Objectives Low Middle High Subgroup 1: At-Risk Students (11) 100% 82% 91% Subgroup 2: Sixth Graders (8) 100% 63% 83% Both subgroups had similarities on the mastery level of the lower level objects 1.2 and 2.2 Student had to name or list parts of the tennis court and tennis etiquette. These were concepts that were taught Page 18 everyday during the lesson with multiple non-formal assessments. On the other hand, there were two differences between the two subgroups. First, the at-risk students were mostly seventh graders who mastered all the objectives because the information was a repeat from the prior year while the subgroup 2 was all sixth graders who were new to the Tennis Unit. Second, the sixth graders did not master the three middle objectives because they had no prior experience to peer assessments in physical education. They struggled with any type of feedback that applied to their own skill and their peers’ skills. F) Explanation of how student progress was monitored by pre-assessment data and used appropriately in instruction and decision-making. The pre-assessment data was used to guide decision-making by revealing which students had prior experience to the sport of tennis, seventh graders. For these students, skill review and refinement were to be targeted while the sixth graders needed to learn all the basic game concepts. The pre-assessment data showed the student progress in instructional decision-making because it showed what was most important concepts to spend more time teaching, less time reviewing skills already mastered. G) Explanation of how student progress is monitored by assessment data and used in instructional decision-making. The assessment data showed areas that student needed assistance learning. The special needs students struggled with the cognitive tasks, yet performed well with verbal questioning during review. For example, they could list tennis etiquette verbally, yet did not write the answers on the exit slips. The same goes for peer assessment, the special needs students could point out the incorrect form of peers but could not complete this task for assessment purposes. This assessment data offered insight to make changes to the unit; add open ended questioning with Kagan, and real life situation questioning as a whole group. H) Explanation of how student progress is monitored by appropriate post-assessment data and is used appropriately in instructional decision-making or planning. Page 19 The post-assessment data was used for future instructional decision-making. During the year, many of the same objectives would be covered in future unit plans. When students did not master the middle objectives in the tennis unit, the first unit of the school year, I know to adjust teaching to make students better prepared for peer and self assessments by using them routinely. Students that did not master the high level objectives needed more skill experience instead of game play in the future. I) I) Explanation why you have chosen each assessment you used to measure your TWS Objectives. The assessments chosen for the TWS allowed student progress to be monitored. The pre-assessment was basic tennis knowledge that middle school student should understand about the sport. When students did not know the vocabulary words, I knew to teach each concept in the following lessons. The Self Checklist, Objective 6, was the first self assessment for the year and for the unit. The students were to answer five basic questions about the forehand; the cues, racket position, and hand position. To make tennis enjoyable the forehand is the most used stroke, one they are expected to be proficient at. The Tennis Diagram, Objective1, allowed a better understanding of students’ awareness about the surface area, the court. This assessment was given with small groups, the entire group standing on the areas of the court, and then individually. Students should know where to serve in tennis for game play. Exit Slip, Objective 2, was a follow-up on previous skills taught. Students had to review Peer Assessment, Objective 5, students were learning to analyze other students stroke performance. Critiques are a major part of life in both school and the workplace. Students should experience positive ways to assess others performance. Finally, the post-assessment showed the degree which the tennis unit was successful. It also showed what could be taught and reviewed better in future tennis units. J) Justify your assessment adaptations The assessment adaptations were guided by various types of students: students with special needs, sixth graders, seventh graders and at-risk students. Verbal assessments encouraged special needs students to share their knowledge more readily. Read aloud assessments with peers or the teacher Page 20 increased struggling readers’ comprehension. All students were allowed longer amounts of time to complete any assessment, while other students were allowed the extra time to practice skill. Factor 7. Reflection and Self-Evaluation A) Successful activities and assessments and plausible reasons for their success. A successful activity at the middle school was the psychomotor activities as quizzes. In Know Your Court, the students had to stand on certain areas of the court as a group. When right service area court was called the students all had to be in that box and so on. A similar activity was also successful called Bring Them Home relay. Bean bags were placed on certain areas of the court. The first student begin in a ready position, as baseline was called the students had to shuffle to the baseline grab a bean bag and return to the team. These were used for a warm-up and closure activities, which led to all students at the mastery level, at the end of the unit. Another successful activity was Tennis Bingo, a life sized bingo fitness station game. Students enjoyed moving every thirty seconds to a different letter. Some stations had skill, fitness, while other stations had test questions in an informal assessment. Students enjoyed this activity because it gave them time to practice at their own level without and be successful at applying knowledge or finding the answer from peers. Two types of assessments that were successful were exit slips and critical thinking questions and responses. The exit slips worked because students could write what they learned from the day. It helped by creating a way to know if the students understood the concepts. The critical thinking questions were appropriate because they allowed students to use higher ordered thinking. Unsuccessful activities and assessments and plausible reasons for their lack of success. The peer assessment, paper pencil, on the overhand serve was the least successful assessment in the unit. Students did not understand the concept of positive critique nor did they accept criticism. They did not want to rate friends according to skill level. This was unsuccessful because the students had no experience with peer assessments, plus struggled with appropriate comments to peers of different ability or ethnicity. The second unsuccessful assessment procedure was the pre-assessment. Students Page 21 complained about taking a test in physical education. Both age groups were not accustomed to being tested in physical education or tested on concepts they did not know. This led to feelings of failure since many students did not know any of the content on the pre-test. B) Explanation of use of evidence and data to support conclusions that student learning was impacted, including description of any mid-unit adaptations. Explanation of two or more hypotheses for why some students did not meet subject matter goals. Student 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 14, and 16 were seventh graders who mastered the objectives. On the other hand, four students failed to reach mastery level, students with special needs 1 and 17 while 6 and 13 were at-risk for failure. These students did not meet subject matter goals because it was relatively new concepts to the physical education program. They had never performed any type of formal assessment during sports activities. Students did not understand the importance of carrying a pencil out to the tennis courts to assess each other. One adaptation that was made allowed students to peer assess with Kagan cooperative learning by asking verbal questions, “Did your partner open the door with a flat racket?’ Students then answered only to their partner. Then the next assessment question was asked. Five students, 1, 3, 6, 12, and 15 did not correctly complete the independent peer assessment on the post-assessment, which correlated with the high level objectives not being met. Another challenge was student 6. She failed to attend school regularly and attended in school suspension for two days, which impacted the learning because the tennis unit was mostly hands on activities that could not be made up. It seemed as though the student gave little effort during performance tasks because she missed four out of nine days of the tennis unit. C) Three appropriate ideas for redesigning learning goals, instruction, or assessment and explanation of why these changes would improve student learning. First, the tennis unit could be redesigned for a longer amount of time, more than nine days. The amount needed for assessments was not adequate because many students struggled with academics. Second, I would place the active inquiry during the first week and on the tennis courts. This would allow students to investigate ways to play tennis, before skill instruction. It would also pre-assess the Page 22 type of skills students were interested in performing. Third, I would change the post-assessment into sections to be given on different days. This would allow more time spent on second part of the test, the middle and high objectives. D) Explanation of specific details of interactions with all three types of individuals: students, parents and other professionals. First type of interactions with individuals was positive reinforcement with the students. As a student teacher it was difficult to experience parent interactions when many are not involved at all. The teacher and the parent interaction is often only during parent teacher conference; however, I was allowed to listen to the mentor teacher routinely call parents to gain support. She would update the parents on the issue of students not dressing out, and then relate this to the grade the student received. Then she would explain how easy it is for students to put on the gym suit and just try. Then she would change the subject to a compliment about the student. Another type of interaction was with professionals like the social worker that attended the class to monitor student behavior. I would greet the social worker, ask if there was anything I could help her and the student with, and then carry out instruction. I would make myself available every day just in case a behavior issue was about to arise that could affect the learning environment. For example, Student 6 was agitated, ready for negative attention, and did not want to be at school. After the social worker explained, I knew to avoid confrontation and negative student interactions. I placed the student on the backboard alone to practice skill. E) Explanation of the QPA/NCA school improvement process and the role of the teacher in it. The quality assurance plus performance criterion equals accreditation. Schools must meet the percentage identified by the Kansas State Board Education to increase overall achievement among students. The schools plan is to incorporate reading and mathematics into every class. The role of a physical educator is to integrate reading and mathematics into physical activities. Page 23 F ) Explanation of two professional development goals that clearly emerge from the insights and experiences described in this Factor and description of one activity to meet each goal. In the future, I would enjoy attending a Kansas Association of Physical Education Recreation and Dance (KAPHERD) convention, for professional development, to learn more high interest activities for middle school students. I choose this goal because I need more games and ideas to motivate students to enjoy learning new activities. In the future, I would have to remain a member, keep up to date with publications, and then attend the conference next fall. The second professional development goal would be to attend a Kagan Cooperative Learning Seminar. I would like to discover other ways to get students active and communicating in class more readily .Kagan Cooperative Learning Seminars are hosted by local school districts. By talking to professionals, Kagan will be hosting another clinic for the district on the first Monday in November 2010. Page 24 Appendix 4: TWS Scoring Sheet Name: TWS ID# Rater: Content Area: Grade: School: Factor 1: Contextual Information and Learning Environment Factor 2: Learning Goals and Objectives Adaptations Checklist Items (0 or 1) The candidate describes: Checklist Items (0 or 1) For goals and objectives: Community Specifies the grade level of the TWS unit District Unit learning goals & unit objectives are clearly stated Unit learning goals & unit objectives developmentally Classroom physical setting appropriate given the grade level and classroom context Unit learning goals & unit objectives aligned with state School population, including SES make-up standards (or other standards if no state) Focus of unit learning goals & unit objectives is on what Classroom ethnic/cultural make-up student will learn/be able to do (not as activities) Classroom gender make-up A rationale for the choice of the unit objectives is provided Classroom students’ with special needs/at-risk TWS objectives are identified Classroom students’ developmental characteristics QPA/NCA school improvement plan & available assessment data Total Checklist Scores (7 possible) Total Checklist Score (9 possible) Rubric Demonstrates awareness of community environmental factors & implications for teaching, instruction, & student learning x1 Demonstrates understanding of district, school, & classroom environmental factors & implications for teaching, instruction & student learning. x1 Rubric Low level cognitive, affective & psychomotor objectives x2 Middle level cognitive, affective and psychomotor objectives x2 Total Rubric Score (4 possible) High level cognitive, affective and psychomotor objectives x2 Total rubric score (12 possible) Total Score for Standard 1 (13 possible) Total Score for Standard 2 (19 possible) Factor 3: Instructional Design and Implementation Checklist Items (0 or 1) Instruction & implementation: Aligned with unit learning goals & TWS objectives that are stated TWS objectives in Factor 2 Progressively sequenced Developmentally appropriate (intellectually, socially and physically) Include evidence of deliberate checking for understanding Include evidence of method of providing feedback Include a pre-assessment aligned with unit learning goals and TWS objectives as stated in Factor 2 Total Checklist Score (6 possible) Factor 4: Demonstration of Integration Skills Checklist Items (0 or 1) The Candidate: Rubric Rubric: Demonstrates the ability to integrate instruction across and within subject matter fields x2 Multiple learning strategies x2 Identifies content areas being integrated Identifies topics that are being integrated Total Checklist Score (2 possible) Provide and adapt instructional strategies x2 Active inquiry and learner centeredness x2 Reading instruction adaptations x2 Technology x2 Knowledge of factors in the students’ environment outside the school x1 Total Rubric Score (22 possible) Total Rubric Score (4 possible) Total Score for Standard 3 (28 possible) Total Score for Standard 4 (6 possible) Page 25 Factor 5: Analysis of Classroom Learning Environment Checklist Items (0 or 1) The Candidate Describes: Factor 6: Analysis of Assessment Procedures Checklist Items (0 or 1) The Candidate: Provides graphic representation of pre-assessment and postassessment data Mastery learning table with accurate percentages of students who attained mastery for each objective Includes average percentage of students achieving mastery of low level, middle, and high TWS objectives including objective mastery index (must accurately calculate all three levels) Includes average percentage of students achieving mastery of all TWS objectives Includes the number of students who attained mastery with adaptations Includes accurate calculation of gain scores including overall average in a table Provides disaggregation of data for at least one pair of subgroups (e.g. ESL vs. native speakers) Provides a explanation of why subgroup performances are difference or similar Total Checklist Score (8 possible) Classroom environmental factors that affect learning Individual student motivation strategies that are used Group motivation strategies used The development of verbal communication among students The development of nonverbal communication between and among students Methods used to communicate with parents & other professionals regarding student learning & assessment Total Checklist Score 6 possible) Rubric Classroom management skills Classroom motivation skills Encourages effective communication among students Rubric Formative assessment is utilized for instruction & evaluation Variety of assessments Alignment among TWS objectives, instruction and assessment Assessment criteria x2 x2 x1 Creates a learning environment that encourages active inquiry x1 Provides an environment supportive of student interaction in learning activities x2 Total Rubric Score (16 possible) Justification of assessments Justification of adaptations Total Score for Standard 5 (22 possible) x1 x1 x2 x2 x1 x2 Total Rubric Score (18 possible) Total Score for Standard 6 (26 possible) Factor 7: Reflection and Self-Evaluation Additional Notes for any Factor: Rubric Effects of decisions on instruction and assessment x2 Effects of decisions on student learning x2 Implications for future teaching of this unit x2 Communications with students, parents and other professionals x1 Information from QPA/NCA process x1 Implications for professional development/ continuous learning x2 Please add 1 point Total Rubric Score(21 possible) Total Score for Standard 7 (21 possible) 1 Reported Total Gain Score: Objective Mastery Index % TOTAL SCORE FOR THE TWS (134 possible) H/TC/Common/TWS/ESUNewTWSScoringSheet2Page Page 26
© Copyright 2024