October 2014 Mentorship Roundtable A “Super Dine-Around” with Members of Lawyers Club’s Advisory Board and San Diego’s Legal Leaders By Patricia P. Hollenbeck George Brewster Hon. Patricia Cowett Hon. Maureen Hallahan Hon. Margaret McKeown Every year, the new Lawyers Club president outlines those initiatives which are particularly important. At the Annual Dinner in May, I mentioned how proud I am to follow in the footsteps of the women and men who have helped us to advance our mission over the past 42 years. It was my hope that, as someone who has practiced law for over 25 years, my experience will help our collective efforts to increase our profile, and to encourage collaboration and involvement. I told you that, to me, Lawyers Club is about an awareness of our mission, leadership, and working together. We all recognize that the challenges are still there, but it’s time to make a difference. And I encouraged you to find your passion, and to recognize the women – and men – who step up to support and mentor you. It is probably obvious that mentorship is extremely important to me, and I believe that for Lawyers Club to be the best it can be, our organization has to include newer attorneys and law students, as well as more experienced lawyers, judges, and other members of the community. We are so fortunate that Lawyers Club has a wealth of riches in the men and women who founded and supported our organization and those who have, and continue to, advance our mission. It is with this in mind that we announce a tremendous, and new, program for October’s Mentorship Luncheon. You may know that a year ago, we created a hugely successful program called Dine-Arounds, where our membership had the opportunity to sign up for small-group dinners with What? When? Where? Johanna Schiavoni prominent Lawyers Club members. The event was so popular that it sold out in less than half an hour after registration opened. Spoiler alert: We are planning two sets of Dine-Arounds this year! You may also know that Lawyers Club has an Advisory Board. The history of the Advisory Board is outlined in the wonderful article, infra, on Charlie Bird. The precursor to the Advisory Board was the Strategic Planning Committee, formed in 1988; its purpose was to address whether there was still a need for a “cause-based” bar association. The Strategic Planning Committee morphed into the Advisory Board, an informal group “serving at the pleasure of the President and advising her on key issues facing Lawyers Club”. I am so fortunate to be mentored and advised by this illustrious group. Continued on page 4 What: Lawyers Club’s Annual Mentorship Luncheon When: Thursday, October 16, 2014; 12:00 p.m. – 1:30 p.m. Where: The U.S. Grant, 326 Broadway, San Diego, CA 92101. Cost: Members, $30; Non-members, $45; Students, $45; (at the door subject to availability) RSVP: www.lawyersclubsandiego.com. What’s Inside Upcoming Events: The Professional Advancement Committee hosts, “Negotiating Your Career” with Ann marie Houghtailing, see page 5. Lawyers Club hosts Fall Judicial Reception for San Diego Judiciary and the National Association of Women Judges on October 17, the details are on pages 12-13. Of Note By popular demand, we have republished Janine Sarti’s speech from the June Luncheon’s General Counsel Roundtable discussion on pages 6-7. Past Events Lawyers Club shines at California Women Lawyers 40th Anniversary Dinner; all the details and photographs on pages 14-15. Find out what happened 30 years ago in Lawyers Club history on page 4. Lawyers Club News 2 october 2014 President’s Message to Members Escaping the Marzipan Layer: Mentors, Sponsors, and Champions Patricia P. Hollenbeck I was born on Torrejon AFB in Madrid, Spain, thirteen years after my two older brothers. I was, as they say, a “surprise.” My mother says it was the water, but I think that may be a fib. My dad took up golf when I was six, and as it turned out, so did I. We’d go to the local Par 3 course, which had giant lights to facilitate night golf. I’d tag along to hit balls on the range. Girls really didn’t play then; it was a man’s sport. But one day something happened that changed my future—we played with a man and woman. So I asked my dad, “If she can play, can I?” My dad was all for it. He took me to Sears Roebuck, because Big 5 and stores like it didn’t exist, and bought me a “short set” of clubs. They came in a tiny red plaid bag. After that, I played all the time. Years later I had the opportunity to compete all over the country, and ultimately I went to Stanford on a golf scholarship, thanks to the enactment of Title IX. Neither of my parents attended college, but they made it clear to the three of us that we would. I really never considered not going; I started kindergarten the same fall my “younger older” brother went to college. My dad must have told me a thousand times how important it was for a woman to be self-supporting. He had three sisters, and no brothers, and was particularly attuned to women. One of his sisters endured a difficult marriage, eventually deciding to divorce at a time when divorce was disfavored. My dad understood the challenges that are unique to women. He was a feminist before the term existed. He was my champion. There are no lawyers in my family, so when I started working at a law firm, it was all brand new. And like any young lawyer, I had to figure out how to succeed—on a myriad of levels. There is the practice of law, but there is also business development, and relationships within the firm. While my law school class was 50% women—yes, that statistic has been around for 30 years—it was not that way in practice. There weren’t that many women, particularly at the partner level. But I was lucky. I was assigned to work for Judy Haller, who is now an Associate Justice on the 4th District Court of Appeal. Judy’s job was to train me. It took two years and at least a gross of red pens, but I still recall the day she proofed a letter I wrote and didn’t make a single edit. My assistant gleefully offered to frame it. Judy was instrumental to my career. She taught me the foundation of law practice. I turn to her for advice, even now. Judy Haller is my mentor. So what is a sponsor? When I was a younger lawyer, the term “sponsor” didn’t exist. But it does now. In 2013 the New York Times published: “Mentors Are Good. Sponsors Are Better.” http://www. nytimes.com/2013/04/14/jobs/sponsors-seen-as-crucial-for-womenscareer-advancement.html?_r=0. The article summarizes a two-year study conducted by the Center For Talent Innovation, which concludes that women, in particular, need a sponsor—a powerfully positioned champion—to help us escape the “marzipan layer” which is apparently located just below the glass ceiling. As I understand the difference, mentors act as a sounding board, and give advice whereas sponsors invest and advocate, but expect outstanding performance. Forbes publishes a Most Powerful Women list every year. In 2012 the issue included the article: “Got a mentor? Good. Now Find a Sponsor” which offers tips for finding a sponsor, including building on a mentoring relationship, identifying those who inspire you, and asking for guidance. See, http://fortune.com/2012/09/21/got-a-mentor-goodnow-find-a-sponsor/. One of the women profiled included the senior vice president of global business services at IBM. She described mentoring as good advice. But her sponsor did more; he took action by recommending her for a significant global position. While not many of us have sponsors with global reach, her story is illustrative. Sponsors are men and women who have power and influence. They go a step further because the relationship merits it, and they offer affirmative help with career advancement. What I hope to convey is that mentoring is key to career advancement and to your happiness quotient. As with any career, practicing law isn’t a sprint, it’s a marathon. You may start in one area of the law, and change to another. You may start in private practice, and move to the public sector. Perhaps your goal is partnership, or your life-long dream is to be a judge. Whatever your circumstances, mentoring is important. And if one of your goals is to find a sponsor, you first need to connect with others. Developing a mentoring relationship is the perfect place to start. So how do you find a mentor? Well, Sheryl Sandberg says you can’t just pop the question. You know, like the children’s book Are You My Mother? But I want to suggest that mentoring isn’t random. It’s a relationship that develops. It takes time, but it’s worth it. At the Equal Pay Day luncheon last April, Ann marie Houghtailing made a telling observation—being glued to your desk hoping against hope that someone will notice you is not enough. It takes effort to stand up, raise your visibility, and accept suggestions. When a person you know reaches out to you, it’s because you’ve made an impression, and you have forged a connection. Whether that person is a mentor, sponsor, or champion, it’s an opportunity. Lawyers Club is a great place to start building relationships, which will in turn help you increase your business and referral network, and elevate your profile. We have a highly successful mentoring initiative called Circles of Influence. We pair groups by interest, in an effort to encourage connections. Our October lunch is also devoted to mentorship. Our special guests this month are prominent members of the legal community, and the Lawyers Club Advisory Board—our founders, past presidents, and other long-time supporters of our mission. They devote their time to advise and mentor the Lawyers Club president. Yep, that’s me, and it’s incredible. At our October luncheon their focus is you. Please join us for a remarkable opportunity. Patricia P. Hollenbeck, President of Lawyers Club, is a Partner at Duane Morris LLP. www.lawyersclubsandiego.com Lawyers Club News 3 About Us Lawyers Club Members Making News By Jodi Cleesattle Anna Romanskaya Vickie Turner Hon. Irma Gonzalez Elected Lawyers Club vice president Anna Romanskaya was elected secretary of the American Bar Association’s Young Lawyers Division at the ABA annual meeting in Boston in August. Romanskaya, a partner at Stark & D’Ambrosio, LLP, will serve a year as secretary, then will take the position of chair-elect, then as chair of the division in 2016-17. Lawyers Club past president Vickie Turner, a partner with Wilson Turner Kosmo LLP, was elected chair of the National Bar Association Commercial Law Section and also elected to serve as a member of the Board of Governors of the National Bar Association during the association’s annual convention in Atlanta in July. The Commercial Law Section brings members together with in-house counsel at major corporations who seek to increase the diversity of their outside counsel ranks. Robert Francavilla Denise Asher Fausta Albi and Diana Vellos Coker, partners with Larrabee Albi Coker LLP, have been selected by their peers for inclusion in The Best Lawyers in America 2015 in San Diego in the field of immigration law. Their practice focuses on employment-based immigration matters including immigration compliance. On the Move Denise Asher has joined the panel of mediators, arbitrators and private judges at Judicate West. Asher helps parties resolve complex and highly emotional cases, with particular subject matter expertise in elder abuse, employment, personal injury, and professional malpractice matters. Jodi Cleesattle is a deputy attorney general with the California Department of Justice and Lawyers Club’s Press Liaison. Honored Retired U.S. District Judge Irma Gonzalez, a Lawyers Club sustaining member, received a Latino Spirit Award from the California Latino Legislative Caucus at the State Capitol in Sacramento in May. Gonzalez, who served on the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California from 1992 to 2013 and served as Chief Judge from January 2005 to January 2012, was recognized for achievement in law and public service. “Best Lawyers” Casey Gerry Schenk Francavilla Blatt & Penfield partner Robert Francavilla has been named as San Diego’s “Lawyer of the Year” for plaintiffs’ products liability litigation by Best Lawyers in America. He also is recognized in the plaintiff’s personal injury litigation category. A total of five Casey Gerry partners, all Lawyers Club members, are featured in the 2015 edition of Best Lawyers, including Gayle Blatt, David S. Casey Jr., Thomas Penfield and Frederick Schenk. Blatt, Casey and Penfield are recognized in the plaintiff’s personal injury litigation section, and Schenk is listed in the plaintiffs’ mass tort litigation/class action category. Have you... ...changed jobs? ...spoken at a conference? ...won any recent awards? Don’t be shy about sharing your good news. Submit information regarding your or your colleagues’ career accomplishments for our “About Us” column – awards, promotions, job changes, board appointments, published articles, presentations, etc. – to Jodi Cleesattle at [email protected]. The deadline for each issue of Lawyers Club News is the first of the month prior to that issue. 4 Lawyers Club News Mentorship Roundtable - “Super Dine Around” Continued on page 4 Our program is using the Dine-Around concept— the small group “nosh” with prominent Lawyers Club members—so you can meet the Advisory Board and other leaders in the legal community. They will serve as table leaders, and you will have the chance to talk to them about a host of topics. The members of the Advisory Board include Hon. Katherine Bacal, Hon. Cynthia Bashant, Wendy M. Behan, Charles Bird, Sarah Boot, George Brewster, Hon. Jill Burkhardt, Hon. Patricia Cowett (Ret.), Hon. Cindy Davis, Christina Dyer, Stacy Fode, Hon. Irma Gonzalez (Ret.), Hon. Maureen Hallahan, Hon. Anthony Joseph (Ret.), Hon. Judith McConnell, Lilys McCoy, Hon. M. Margaret McKeown, Hon. Paula Rosenstein, Hon. Lynn Schenk, Johanna Schiavoni, Hon. Stephanie Sontag, Hon. Randa Trapp, and Vickie Turner. They are our founders, pastpresidents, and leaders—and they are AWESOME, and I mean that. (If you’ve not seen the TED talk on how people overuse awesome, search for “TED talk and awesome”.) So far, fourteen Advisory Board members have committed to attend to meet and greet. A host of community leaders have also volunteered. Please join us for this highly anticipated event. Patricia P. Hollenbeck, President of Lawyers Club, is a partner at Duane Morris LLP. october 2014 Lawyers Club of San Diego 701 B Street, Suite 224, San Diego, CA 92101 (619) 595-0650 phone (619) 595-0657 fax [email protected] President Patricia Hollenbeck Vice Presidents Deborah Dixon Renee Galente Jessica Jagir Anna Romanskaya Tamera Weisser Treasurer Jennifer Chang Secretary Bhashini Weerasinghe 30 Years Ago in Lawyers Club History By George W. Brewster Jr. The October 1984 addition of the Lawyers Club News is jam-packed. The sense of it is that the organization has really taken off, with a swirl of activities and opportunities. The front page highlights the popular Wine and Cheese Reception—at that time, still held in the homes of members (in October 1984, it was the home of Hon. Sheridan Reed). As noted in the Board Briefs, Lawyers Club had 280 regular members and 39 student members. County Bar Association but as its compliment. In the safe environment of Lawyers Club, members feel comfortable. They ask the “dumb” questions otherwise answered by experience. They are free to share their successes and challenges, to be understood and to understand.” Speaking of student members, this issue launched two new programs by the Lawyers Club Student Committee: (1) Student Law Clerkship Referral Service (linking attorney members with students seeking law clerk opportunities); and (2) Ride Along (to give student members “the chance to participate in the day-to-day world of legal practice by observing attorney members in their actual work place”). The October Lawyers Club luncheon featured the President of California Women Lawyers (Meredith Taylor). A former Lawyers Club president and also then a member of CWL’s executive board, Cheryl Ruffier was featured in a separate article, promoting a lecture she was giving on wrongful termination. At the time, Ruffier was a litigation partner in a private firm. Later on she joined the Office of the District Attorney, and currently serves as a Chief Deputy (Administration) for District Attorney Bonnie Dumanis. Helen Rowe became the new editor of the newsletter. For many years Helen authored a social news column for the San Diego County Bar Association’s monthly magazine, DICTA (and hosted an annual holiday party at her home for DICTA staff). She served on the Lawyers Club Board and was Lawyers Club President in 1987. Helen had a number of articles in this particular issue, including a brief interview with Lawyers Club President Bonnie Dumanis. When Dumanis was asked how Lawyers Club fit into the San Diego legal community in 1984, her response included: “Lawyers Club works with and for its members facing gender bias. It does not act as a substitute for membership in the San Diego Also of note in this issue is the promotion of a play by the Gaslamp Quarter Theatre Company called “The Third Party”, based on the life of Belva Lockwood (the namesake of Lawyers Club’s service award). Among other things, Lockwood was the first woman to be admitted to practice before the U.S. Supreme Court, advocated for equal pay for equal work (in 1870), and in 1884 ran for President of the United States on the “National Equal Rights Party” ticket (receiving 4,149 votes). George W. Brewster Jr., is a member of the Lawyers Club History & Archives Committee. Directors Amanda Allen Olga Alvarez Jennifer Chang Eric Ganci Shalini Kedia Jamie Quient Susan Swan North County Chapter President: Danielle Hultenius Moore Editor Tara (Jacobson) Duester Associate Editor Carla Sanderson Executive Director Elaine Lawrence Administrative Coordinator Vicky Frank Lawyers Club News is published monthly 11 times a year, with a combined July/August issue. Lawyers Club welcomes contributions to the newsletter, as well as your comments and suggestions regarding Lawyers Club News; contact Tara (Jacobson) Duester at Duester@ brownlawgroup.com and Carla Sanderson at [email protected]. The deadline for articles is the 1st of the month prior to the month of publication. Articles should be submitted in Microsoft Word. The advertising deadline is the 8th of the month prior to the month of publication. For advertising information, contact Elaine Lawrence at [email protected]. www.lawyersclubsandiego.com Lawyers Club News 5 “Negotiating Your Career” Sponsored by Professional Advancement Committee By Frann Setzer Negotiating on your own behalf can make all the difference in achieving what you want and what you deserve in your career. Ann marie Houghtailing, CEO of the Millionaire Girls’ Movement, will explain how to craft an elegant, professional “ask,” how to manage your beliefs around negotiating and how to be an agent of your own success. Whether it’s discussing salary, obtaining credit for your work, asking for a career-related opportunity or flexible work hours, the ability to negotiate your career impacts your bottom line as well as the quality of your life. Houghtailing’s program will detail how to construct a communication plan and become more expansive in your thinking about negotiation. In addition to serving as the CEO of the Millionaire Girls’ Movement, Houghtailing is the author of How I Created a Dollar Out of Thin Air. Houghtailing’s writing has appeared in the Yahoo! Finance, Daily Worth, Huffington Post, San Diego Business Journal, and Daily Transcript. The program will be held on October 23, 2014 at Hughes Marino, 1450 Front Street, San Diego CA, 92101. It will begin at 5:30pm and end at 7:00pm. More details will follow. Registration is open to Lawyers Club Members only. For more information or to join at the committee level, please contact Frann Setzer ([email protected]) or Stephanie Reynolds ([email protected]), Co-Chairs of the Professional Advancement Committee. Frann Setzer is a partner at Lewis, Warren & Setzer, LLP, a boutique family law firm and is Co-Chair of the Professional Advancement Committee. Who? What? When? Where? Who: Ann marie Houghtailing, CEO of the Millionaire Girls’ Movement and author of How I Created a Dollar Out of Thin Air What: “Negotiating Your Career” Where: Hughes Marino, 1450 Front Street, San Diego CA, 92101 Date: October 23, 2014, 5:30pm-7:00pm STRONG ADVOCATES As a member of this community for nearly 40 years, we are proud to support the Lawyers Club of San Diego and their mission of advancing the status of women in law and in society. Quality. Expertise. Solutions. www.knlh.com 350 10th Ave., Suite 1300, San Diego, CA 619-231-8666 6 Lawyers Club News october 2014 Janine Sarti - Speech from General Counsel Roundtable Forward by Tara Jacobson Duester, open letter by Janine Sarti At Lawyers Club’s June 19 luncheon, “Direct from the C-Suite: Tips for In-House Counsel and Lawyers in the Trenches,” Janine Sarti, Chief Legal Officer of Palomar Health identified tips for professional advancement. Sarti spoke about leadership. Sarti’s mantra: “talent is a gift, but leadership is a choice.” Sarti had the following to share in reflection on her involvement in the 2014 General Counsel roundtable and those of years’ past: Hello everyone. I’m Janine Sarti. I feel the need to introduce myself to you, because in the flyer for this program, I am a blonde. Thank you to Lawyers Club for the kind invitation to speak at this event. I see the familiar faces of many of my friends; I also see the new faces of the friends I have not yet met. I attended the past two General Counsel Roundtables. The prior years’ speakers, Carol Lam and Phil Rudolph are esteemed attorneys who enhance the reputation of our profession. I am humbled to be considered among their number and aspire to their lofty standards. At this year’s luncheon, I was asked to speak about tips from the trenches, and share with you what I have learned in my career, and I will. But first, I want to give you a context about me and how I was raised. My parents were immigrants and money was tight. We were so poor, we’d joke that we didn’t eat chicken unless we were sick, or the chicken was. My dad was illiterate in both Italian and in English. My mother’s parents believed that girls should not be educated, as they would only get married, and that education would be wasted. I was raised by two parents who believed that education and hard work were next to godliness, and they were hell-bent to get me to deification. My parents taught me to be nice. Tell the truth. Always do your best. My parents never expected that I would be the smartest person in the room, but they sure as heck demanded that in any situation no one would ever outwork me. Regardless of the circumstance, I was always to be gracious. Those principles shaped who I am today, in my career, with my family, and with my friends. In addition, in the 30 years that I have been an attorney, I have learned some important lessons from the boardroom, about how to get there, and how to stay there. It is those lessons that I want to share with you today. My goal for you today: the next time you speak with a client, they recognize you as a trusted advisor. They embrace you as an indispensable member of the team. And I want you to be able to create for them an atmosphere of confidence in you and your advice. I’m not asking for much, so listen up. There is no substitute for hard work and competence. I know that every person in this room is smart and hardworking. That is not enough – just being smart and hardworking will never be enough to succeed. What I found over the course of my career is that in order to be what I considered a success, I needed something more. I needed to bring value beyond my job description. I found the path to what I considered a success was actually a journey of discovery about who I am and what I stand for. I learned these lessons more from my failures than from my conquests. My values about how I live my life are what made me more respected by and successful to the organization, over and above anyone else who applied for my job. These may be unique just to me and I do not expect that they would be a fit with everyone. Your path to what you consider “success” is a journey for you of discovering your own values, and using them to benefit others. This is who I am and this is how I got here: 1.It’s about leadership. Leadership has nothing to do with power or control. Leadership has nothing to do with your title or reporting relationships. Leadership is quite simply the ability to create an environment where others succeed, and in that regard that makes every one of you in this room a leader. Talent is a gift, but leadership is a choice. Do you know the fastest route to the C-Suite? Help someone else get there first. 2.Believe in yourself. Have the confidence that you are valuable. That confidence will precede you whenever you enter a room. Confidence is an observable quality and speaks volumes before you open your mouth. Confidence is a habit. One TED talk that I listened to said that before you go into an important meeting, to take a superman stance with your feet apart, hands on your hips, and chest out. Hold this position for three minutes and tell yourself that when you go into that meeting that you are going to rock their world. This physical stance and positive affirmation trains your brain to get in a habit of being confident. 3.Know your truth, and don’t be afraid to live it. My truth: I will live my life as an example to my son, and at the end of each day, I must be able to look in the mirror and say “job well done, good and faithful servant.” 4.Be passionate. Whatever you do in life, do it with all your heart and trust me, the world will notice. If the work environment that you are in isn’t conducive to your being passionate about it, quit. You will never make it to the C-suite if you aren’t passionate about what you do. And, life is far too short to spend it being lukewarm. 5.It’s all about relationships. If you come to work for me, you will hear me tell you that for every dollar I pay you, 1 penny of that dollar pays you for your technical skills. With the other 99 cents, I pay you for your ability to get along. 6.Determine your brand and be proud of it. Are you Sandra Day O’Connor? Are you Beyoncé? Whatever it is, accept that you are uniquely and beautifully you. Go out there and shake what your mama gave you. To help me determine my brand, I hired an image consultant, because Honey, I don’t wake up looking like this. She helped me figure out how to project the look of a successful leader from my hair to my shoes. It was one of the best investments I made in myself and in my career. Lawyers Club News www.lawyersclubsandiego.com 7.Never, ever give up on yourself. Not many people know that I was going quit law school after my first year. It was my wonderful husband who helped me through. Whatever your goals are, from your career to your education to your love live, don’t ever give up. Don’t ever give in. Don’t ever sell out. Don’t ever stop trying. Surround yourself with people who believe in you. And if you find yourself surrounded by naysayers, tell them to kiss your grits and carry on. But never, ever give up on yourself and your dreams. 8.Be courageous. Courage is not the absence of fear. Courage is doing what you are afraid to do. Comfort and success rarely go hand in hand. Courage is finding your voice to speak the truth to power. Courage is grace under pressure. Take the plunge, however small. I’ve been scared lots of times to the point where I wanted to pee my pants. Just don’t let the fear paralyze you, and be sure to always wear Depends. 9.Well behaved women rarely make history. It’s the successful person who is able to determine which rules to follow, and which 7 rules are actually mere suggestions. Rules are just words on the page, begging, and yearning for you to rewrite them. You make the call. 10. Be kind to yourself and to each other. You never know the load that someone else is bearing. You don’t know what is happening in their lives. I believe that whatever you put out in the world comes back to you ten-fold. Be kind, because in the end, only kindness matters. So those are my tips for career success. If you believe that what you saw at the luncheon panel table are images of “success,” then I want you to know you can do that too. Every one of you in this room can do that. And every single one of you in the room is worthy of every success. In the words of Winnie the Pooh, there is something you must always remember, “you are braver than you believe, stronger than you seem, and smarter than you think.” Thank you Lawyers Club. I wish you all every good thing, Tara Jacobson Duester is an associate at the Brown Law Group and the Lawyers Club News Editor. A special thank you to Janine Sarti, Chief Legal Officer of Palomar Health for sharing her perspective. wcrg_8w x 6h_LC_Judy_2014_new W E S T C OA S T R E S O L U T I O N G R O U P Her Resolve: Finding Customized, Efficient and Creative Solutions Your Resolution: Judy Copeland “Judy’s expertise, creativity and skill in handling difficult participants saved the day and avoided protracted and unpredictable litigation.” -San Diego Probate Litigator Judy’s Featured Practice Areas: Probate, Conservatorship and Trust Disputes; Will and Trust Contests exceptional service DOUG BARKER RICK BARTON JIM CHODZKO JUDY COPELAND JOHN EDWARDS Dispute Resolution. It’s what we do and we take it personally. HON. SUSAN P. FINLAY (RET.) A Division of NCRC Our Resolve. Your Resolution. westcoastresolution.com 619.238.7282 8 LC Ad v1.0 BW 1 Lawyers Club News october 2014 8/22/14 4:51 PM www.lawyersclubsandiego.com Lawyers Club News 9 Fund for Justice Spring 2014 Grants: Purposeful Giving Gives Lawyers Club Members Purpose By Rupa Singh What does it mean to have purpose? Daniel Pink, author of Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us, defines it as a universal desire to do what we do in service of something larger than ourselves. [Dan Pink: The puzzle of motivation, TEDGlobal, July 2009 (http://www.ted.com/talks/dan_ pink_on_motivation).] In Lawyers Club parlance, that something larger than us necessarily includes, if not begins with, the Fund for Justice. Established in 1997 as the Lawyers Club charitable foundation, and managed through a donor-advised fund at the San Diego Foundation, the Fund for Justice awards grants to nonprofits dedicated to education, research, and programming for “at-risk” women and children. The Fund for Justice embraced early-on an idea that has now gained wider acceptance—that investing in women and girls is a highly effective strategy for creating social change [High-Impact Giving to Women and Girls, a Guide for Donors, U.S. Trust Bank of America Private Wealth Management (http://www.ustrust.com/Publish/Content/ application/pdf/GWMOL/ARA36DE4.pdf).] Not surprisingly, then, giving to women and girls is growing at a faster pace than overall foundation giving by all types of donors. [Accelerating Change for Women and Girls: The Role of Women’s Funds, The Foundation Center and the Women’s Funding Network (2009).] “I contribute to the Fund for Justice because I have seen that even small grants made to the selected women’s organizations have a big impact,” says Lawyers Club immediate past President and Fund for Justice Committee member Johanna Schiavoni. The Fund for Justice is financed by tax-deductible donations from Lawyers Club members, annual contributions from various events directed to it by the Lawyers Club Board of Directors, and the Lawyers Club signature charitable fund raiser, the Annual Holiday Luncheon. It awards grants twice a year, in the fall and in the spring. In its Spring 2014 cycle, it awarded seven grants totaling $12,500, as follows: (1) $1,000 to Break the Silence, which operates a social media forum for domestic violence survivors; (2) $1,500 to Generate Hope, which provides shelter, counseling, and rehabilitation services to sexually trafficked women; (3) $1,500 to Palomar Health-Forensic Health Services, the only facility in North County to provide forensic examination and specific preservation for victims of domestic violence, child abuse, and sex trafficking; (4) $2,500 to Kids’ Turn, which runs workshops to help children experiencing divorce and military transitions; (5) $2,500 to Street of Dreams: Musicians for Education, which supports high-risk teen mothers in graduating high school and entering college; (6) $2,500 to Hannah’s House, which provides a safe venue for families with domestic violence issues to have parentchild visitations; and (7) $1,000 to Dress for Success, which furnishes homeless and indigent women with clothes to enter or re-enter the workplace. “I know my money is being put to good work!” says Deborah Dixon, a long time Fund for Justice Committee Member and Lawyers Club Board member. Michelle Ialeggio, a former Lawyers Club Board member and Co-Chair of the Fund for Justice Committee, says that the Fund for Justice exponentially increases her ability to help, making my “dollar stretch” to help “more people who need it.” Ann Parode Dynes, who was involved in establishing the Fund for Justice under the San Diego Foundation and is one of the original donors, particularly likes contributing to the Fund for Justices “because, as a retiree, I can leverage my support of Lawyers Club with a tax deductible contribution.” But the fact that the Fund for Justice leverages members’ support for needy and underserved women and children is only part of the story. The impact that such purposeful giving has on the donors, is separately noteworthy. Research indicates that donors cite not just the perceived outcomes and effects of their charitable activity as reasons for philanthropy, but also the personal fulfillment and empowerment that their charitable activity engenders. [The 2011 Study of High Net Worth Women’s Philanthropy and The Impact of Women’s Giving Networks, Research and Written by The Center on Philanthropy at Indiana University, Sponsored by Bank of American Merrill Lynch (Nov. 2012).] “I believe that charitable activity by a professional organization like Lawyers Club provides valuable philanthropic experience to its volunteers, makes a statement to its community as to its values, harnesses the financial resources of its members, and is the right thing to do,” says Dynes. Not surprisingly, others echo Dynes’s sentiment that it is not just what the Fund for Justice does for the collective good, but also how it empowers them to be meaningful agents of social change, that sustains them. “The Fund for Justice is such an important part of why I belong to Lawyers Club,” says Ialeggio, who particularly values the dedication necessary to vet grant applications and direct the organization’s giving. Separate from the substantive impact of the Fund for Justice, Dixon also derives fulfillment from her work on the Committee, whose “hard work, due diligence and analysis of each grant request” allows her to impact the work of organizations she might otherwise never encounter. “I personally give to Fund for Justice because it allows me to feel confident in my charitable giving,” she says. Schiavoni adds that working on the Fund for Justice Committee brings the added benefit that it helps everyone learn “about nonprofits in San Diego doing muchneeded work to support underserved women, youth and children.” Lawyers Club Board member, Erika Hiramatsu, says, “I contribute to Fund for Justice because—and I’ll shamelessly borrow from a commercial—with a great career comes great responsibility. I feel so fortunate to live in San Diego, doing work I enjoy. Through the Fund for Justice, I can contribute to the community on a larger scale than I could on my own.” And that, of course, brings us full circle to having purpose, and the desire to serve something larger than ourselves. Rupa Singh is a staff attorney at the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals and a member of the Lawyers Club Fund for Justice Committee. Any views expressed herein are her own. Please visit www. lawyersclusandiego.com to learn more about the Fund for Justice. 10 Lawyers Club News october 2014 www.lawyersclubsandiego.com Lawyers Club News 11 Join SDVLP’s Task Force to Assist Vulnerable Women and Children By Leslie J. Mackay San Diego Volunteer Lawyer Program is seeking volunteers to plan the 2015 Women’s Resource Fair. If you are interested, please attend the next Task Force meeting on October 24 at 12:00 p.m. at Sheppard Mullin Richter & Hampton LLP, 501 West Broadway, 19th Floor, San Diego 92101. The Task Force is a group of approximately sixty volunteers who organize the annual one-day event for the benefit of homeless, battered, and indigent women and their children. Task Force members recruit volunteers, recruit funders, plan seminars, arrange childcare, organize transportation, coordinate legal and social services, arrange and coordinate publicity, and help with all aspects of the event. The Task Force meets monthly, and then with greater frequently immediately prior to the Fair. The first Women’s Resource Fair, established and produced by SDVLP with the assistance of Lawyers Club members, was held 26 years ago in 1989. It was inspired by Stand Down, a similar weekend project for veterans. Up to 1000 homeless, battered, and indigent women and children are served each year. This year’s Women’s Resource Fair, co-sponsored by Lawyers Club, will be held on February 28, 2015. For more information about the event visit our website: wrfsandiego.org. Women’s Resource Fair 2014 We hope you will join us at our next meeting to learn more about the Task Force and how you can be involved. For more information, please contact Task Force co-chairs Sarah Weber (sarah.p.weber@ gmail.com) or Collette Cavalier ([email protected]). Leslie J. Mackay is a Staff Attorney at San Diego Volunteer Lawyer Program. Welcome New Lawyers Club Members Ms. Stephenie Alexander Ms. SharonAnn Hamilton Ms. Vanessa Negrete Ms. Julia Schneider Ms. Andrea Auclair Ms. Jamie Handrick Ms. Van Nguyen Ms. Danielle Erica Short Ms. Marci Bair Ms. Katherine Hart Ms. Phuong Vien Nguyen Ms. Kristen Silverman Ms. Christina Cameron Ms. Christina Diane Hess Mr. Jake Novack Ms. Shawn Skillin Ms. Emily Campbell Ms. Nikki Hlavin Ms. Bethsaida Obra-White Ms. Autumn Springfield Mr. Rafael Castellanos Mr. Yousaf Husain Ms. Lauren Ogata Mrs. Shannon Stein Ms. Helaina Lynn Chinn Ms. India Jewell Ms. Jin Hee Park Ms. Jamie Anne Steward Ms. Julia I De Beers Ms. Laura MacNeel Ms. Jacquelyn Emilia Quinn Ms. Sherry Thompson Ms. Michelle Dicks Ms. Marie Kathleen Maloney Mr. Adam Radtke Ms. Pua Uyehara Ms. Shay Dinata-Hanson Ms. Erica Martin Ms. Stephanie Monique Ramirez Ms. Laura Vogltanz Ms. Amy Drapkin Ms. Kim McDonnell Ms. Anne Lorentzen Rauch Ms. Colleen A. Warren Ms. June C Fan Ms. Sharon Regina Mehlman Ms. Heather Ray Ms. Monica Willian Ms. Amber Helena-Therese Ms. Lindsey Bronwyn Mercer Ms. Julie Remer Ms. Stephanie Winemiller Gardina-Quintanilla Ms. Dionne Mochon Ms. Jessica A Rowland Ms. Ziwei Xiao Mrs. Grace Gower Ms. Beth Amanda Molloy Ms. Genevieve Ruch Ms. Jessica Bea Yang Ms. Jawid Habib Mrs. Natalie N. Mueller Ms. Lana Rudakova Mr. Roger C Haerr Ms. Dana Nassiri Ms. Joanna Schneider 12 Lawyers Club News october 2014 Lawyers Club Hosts Fall Judicial Reception for San Diego Judiciary and the National Association of Women Judges (NAWJ) By Laura Castillo Lawyers Club is pleased to announce a wonderful opportunity for our membership. On Friday, October 17, Lawyers Club will host an event for both our local judiciary as well as for attendees of the National Association of Women Judges (NAWJ) 36th Annual Conference. Many members of the San Diego judiciary are involved in planning the conference, including conference chairs Superior Court Judges Tamila E. Ipema and Margie G. Woods. The theme of the NAWJ Conference this year is “Protecting and Advancing Meaningful Access to Justice”. The reception will honor members of the judiciary, allowing our local judges to meet NAWJ attendees from across the country and around the world. Likewise, Lawyers Club members will have the opportunity to mix and mingle with our San Diego judges and NAWJ attendees. Lawyers Club created the annual Fall Wine & Cheese reception to provide attorneys and law students with the rare and valuable opportunity to talk with judges outside of the courtroom. After over forty years of success, the Fall Judicial Reception continues to foster interaction between our legal community and judges in an informal, yet professional setting. This year, the Wine & Cheese committee adopted a new name—the Bench Bar Committee, which will not only organize the fall and spring judicial receptions, but which will organize ongoing events with the judiciary, with the assistance and guidance of Bench Bar Committee liaison, Hon. Katherine Bacal. The reception is free for all Judicial Officers and NAWJ attendees. For Lawyers Club members, the reception fee is $10. Due to security reasons, all attendees must register and pay in advance by October 10. No late registrations or substitutions will be permitted. All guests should RSVP by registering online at www.lawyersclubsandiego.com. Laura Castillo is a Staff Attorney at the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals and is Co-Chair of Lawyers Club’s Bench Bar Committee. The Fall Judicial Reception will be held from 5:00 to 7:00 p.m., at the beautifully appointed United States District Court Annex Jury Assembly Room, and the adjacent outdoor terrace, located at 333 West Broadway. 18th Annual Halloween Read-In with Lawyers Club This year Lawyers Club’s Halloween Read-In will be extra special, with the event taking place on the actual day of Halloween! Friday, October 31, 2012 from 11:45 a.m. to 1:15 p.m. at Central Elementary. Don’t miss this favorite Lawyers Club event on October 31! If interested in volunteering please contact the Co-Chairs of Lawyers Club’s Community Outreach & Special Projects Committee, Michele Macosky at [email protected] or Dana Grimes at [email protected]. www.lawyersclubsandiego.com Lawyers Club News Fall RECEPTION Friday October 17, 2014 5:00 PM – 7:00 PM U.S. District Court Annex | Jury Assembly Room 333 West Broadway In Conjunction with the National Association of Women Judges (NAWJ) Conference Title Sponsor Free for all Judicial Officers and NAWJ attendees. $10 for Lawyers Club members. This event is expected to sell-out so please register early. Lawyers Club members must RSVP by registering online at www.lawyersclubsandiego.com by Friday, October 10, 2014. No refunds or cancellations allowed after October 10, 2014. Due to security reasons, late registrations cannot be accepted. Absolutely no entrance will be permitted for non-Judicial Officers whose names are not on the list. Last-minute substitutions will not be permitted. 13 14 Lawyers Club News october 2014 Lawyers Club shines at California Women Lawyers 40th Anniversary Dinner By Renee Galente As a state-wide organization, California Women Lawyers’ annual dinner celebration travels throughout the state; it is held on the first night of, and in the same locations as, the State Bar Annual Meeting. Having the 40th Anniversary Dinner in San Diego was a return “home”, in a sense. Lawyers Club founders Justice Judith McConnell and Hon. Lynn Schenk also helped to found CWL just two years after starting Lawyers Club. And this year San Diego was represented at the dinner in force! The 600 attendees included many local attorneys, judges, law school representatives, and businesses, all of which lent their support and helped celebrate 40 years of hard work. Justice Joyce L. Kennard giving the keynote address The Keynote Speaker of the evening was Justice Joyce Kennard, who recently retired from the California Supreme Court. Twenty five years ago Justice Kennard (Ret.) delivered her maiden speech as a Justice at the California Women Lawyers dinner—and also signed up as a lifetime member! This year, she gave what she called her Farewell Speech. She shared her personal story with the attendees of her struggles growing up during World War II, losing her leg, losing her mother and her fight to achieve her dream of getting an education. After moving to the United States from Holland, Justice Kennard started her career path as a receptionist; she ended a State Supreme Court Justice. On the bench, Justice Kennard has been a steady supporter for equality, and a staunch supporter of personal rights. Her love for the United States was palpable. She inspired and filled the room with reverence, particularly given that the dinner fell on the 13th anniversary of September 11. Justice McConnell gave a warm and witty introduction to this year’s recipient of the Fay Stender Award, Hon. Lynn Schenk. Lawyers Club members may know of Schenk’s accomplishments in breaking down barriers at the Grant Grill and as a former U.S. Congresswoman. But they may not know that she was the first woman hired as in-house counsel by SDG&E, she gave up her term as President of CWL when she was appointed as a White House Fellow, and she served in the Offices of Vice Presidents Rockefeller and Mondale. She was also the first female Chief of Staff to Governor Gray Davis. Schenk’s lifelong commitment to public service and her ability to change unacceptable status quos made her a perfect honoree for an award meant to honor a woman committed to the representation of women, disadvantaged groups and unpopular causes whose courage, zest for life and demonstrated ability to effect change as an individual make her a role model for women attorneys. Outgoing President, McManis Faulkner partner Neda Mansoorian turned over leadership of the organization to Past Lawyers Club President, CaseyGerry partner Wendy Behan. Behan articulately described CWL as a relevant organization which provides a unified voice for women in the law throughout the state and in the nation through legislation affecting issues important to women. Throughout the evening, Behan repeatedly acknowledged that her time with Lawyers Club of San Diego prepared her for her upcoming Presidency of CWL. “The support from Lawyers Club and the San Diego legal community as a whole at the CWL dinner was overwhelming,” Behan noted, “I was so honored to be sworn in as President of CWL Hon. Judith McConnell, Kelly Spoon, and Hon. Keri Katz amongst my good friends and colleagues in San Diego and introduce CWL to a broader audience.” Michelle Ialeggio, a former Lawyers Club board member, was sworn in as the District 9 Governor and Renee Galente was sworn in as Treasurer, joining the Executive Board. If you attended and enjoyed the Dinner, please consider joining CWL as a member. Lawyers Club members receive a reduced membership price with CWL, as an affiliate member. Joining now at www.cwl.org will provide a membership which is valid through the end of 2015. Want to try it before you buy it? CWL will be in Beverly Hills on October 10, 2014 from 1:00 p.m. to 5:00 p.m. at the Feminist Majority Foundation for its inaugural “Elect to Run” program featuring San Diego-local and former Lawyers Club president Sarah Boot, Compton Mayor Aja Brown, and Senate candidate Sandra Fluke, among others. The Keynote Speaker is the Hon. Toni Atkins. The program will be followed by a reception at The Avalon Hotel Beverly Hills. The event is FREE. Watch for more on Lawyers Club members making news at the State Bar Annual Meeting in the November issue of Lawyers Club News. Renee Galente is an owner and trial lawyer at Galente Ganci, APC, Lawyers Club Vice President and CWL Treasurer. Lawyers Club News www.lawyersclubsandiego.com 15 Left: Fred Schenk and Hon. Lynn Schenk Below: Hon. Tamila Ipema, Hon. Katherine Bacal, and Meryl Maneker Above: Eran Bermudez, Loren Freestone, and Lizette Herrera Castellanos Right: Rachel Cano and CWL Board Member Michelle Ialeggio Photos by Melissa Jacobs Access all of your Case 24/7™ even when you are out of the office. • View all your case documents • View your deposition calendar • Find directions to your deposition • View details and status of your invoices • Contact our team 800.939.0080 101 ego, california 92101 telephone 800.939.0080 619.239.0206 telephone facsimile pp ad a y! lo amm da wn kr to do ee nes fr u e it th rom f get free mobile access to all your case documents on your iphone and ipad call us to schedule your next deposition and start using our new mobile app to your advantage. 619.239.0206 kramm.com facsimile web kramm.com web Lawyers Club News 16 october 2014 Lunch and Learn: Lawyers Club’s New Website Email in-box overflowing with Lawyers Club notifications? Interested in making connections? Curious what the committees are doing? Unsure of how to log-in to the new Lawyers Club website? Join your website liaisons, as we host a hands-on “Lunch and Learn” for members looking for help using the new Lawyers Club website. We will cover a number of topics including: • Logging-in What? When? Where? What: Lawyers Club Lunch and Learn When: November 12, 2014, 11:45 a.m. – 1:30 p.m. • Paying membership dues • Updating your profile Where: Hera Hub Mission Valley, 8885 Rio San Diego, Suite 237, San Diego, CA 92108 • Accessing your groups • Registering for events Bring your laptop, tablet or other personal computing device, along with your lunch and a “can do” attitude--we will get you comfortable with using the new Lawyers Club website in no time! Drinks and dessert will be provided. Cost: Free for Lawyers Club Members This event is co-sponsored by: Kristin Beattie Legal Advisor, San Diego Sherriff’s Department Lawyers Club of San Diego Mary Wenzel, JD www.lawyersclubsandiego.com Lawyers Club News 17 Mentorship is a Critical Component of Your Career; Join Influence to Become or Connect with a Mentor By Cassandra Hearn Lawyers Club is lucky to have many members who inspire us. They make us think about where we have been and where we are going, and if we are very fortunate, they advise us personally. The Lawyers Club Mentorship committee asks you to think about who has taught you, and where would you be without their influence? And we also ask that you take a step further and think about how you have influenced others. Lawyers who are savvy understand the importance of having a mentor—someone who can give you advice from time to time and who has an impact on you and your career. We can all agree that practicing law is difficult. The law is nuanced and, Cassandra Hearn at times, daunting. Understanding the practice of law, and becoming a polished and capable practitioner takes time and effort. And legal practice is only part of what we all need to learn to be successful. Other topics, such as business development, networking, community service, professional advancement, career goals, workplace politics, professional recognition, and career satisfaction are all significant components of legal practice. It is for precisely these reasons that having a mentor is so important. A New York Times best-selling author, Brendon Burchard, who writes about high performance and motivation, made a statement about one of the most highly recognized business visionaries in the world, and noted how critical it is for him to get input from trusted advisors and mentors. Burchard said, “I’ve seen that phenomenally successful people believe they can learn something from everybody. I call them ‘mavericks with mentors.’ Richard Branson, for instance, is a total maverick but he surrounds himself with incredibly successful, smart people and he listens to them.” Last year, the Mentorship Committee launched a new, year-long mentorship initiative called “Influence”. The name of the initiative was taken from the definition of the word: A person or thing with the capacity or power to have an effect on someone or something. The mentorship circles we formed last year were organized around the following practice areas: (1) Government/Non-Profit/In-House, (2) Solos, (3) Large Firm, (4) Small Firm (less than 20), and (5) Elected/ Appointed Office and Boards. We connected fifty new attorneys with twenty experienced attorneys. Our first year of Influence will be finishing this fall. We are currently accepting suggestions for the next group of mentorship circles. In addition, by the end of October we will post sign up information on the Lawyers Club website for the next year of Influence. We will also remind you to sign up through the Lawyers Club Weekly E-news and Noteworthy. Space is limited. Please submit your mentorship circle ideas to [email protected]. Please also consider joining the mentorship committee. Whether you are a new lawyer or you have been practicing law for seven or more years we would like to partner with you. The mentorship committee has a huge year planned. In addition to Influence, we organize speed mentoring events, and other mixers. We also partner with other Lawyers Club committees including Networking, Student, and Bench/Bar. The fall is the perfect time to get involved. Join Influence, the mentorship committee’s program. Come to our luncheon this month. It just might change your life, and you might change someone else’s. Cassandra Hearn is the owner of Law Offices of Cassandra Hearn, APC and is co-chair of the Mentorship Committee along with Sasha Kamfiroozie of Hickman & Robinson LLP. DAVID CASEY L E A D I N G T H E W A Y Meet David S. Casey, Jr., one of the country’s most respected trial lawyers. Relentless in his pursuit of justice, he is committed to taking on the region’s most challenging serious personal injury and wrongful death cases – in a wide spectrum of industries, from maritime to sports. Call 800-292-5865 to arrange co-counsel or to refer a case. caseygerry.com San Diego Office: 110 Laurel Street, San Diego North County Office: 1901 Camino Vida Roble, Ste. 121, Carlsbad 18 Lawyers Club News october 2014 Lawyers Club Endorses Two Impressive Candidates for the 2015 San Diego County Bar Association Board of Directors Election By Justine Phillips and Rebecca Church Lawyers Club is pleased to endorse two exceptional candidates in the upcoming San Diego County Bar Association (“SDCBA”) Board of Directors elections: Jodi Cleesattle and Lilys McCoy. A 19-member Board of Directors governs SDCBA. Directors are elected at large by the membership and elections are held in November of each year. All attorney members of the SDCBA who maintain active status with the State Bar of California are eligible to vote in the election. There is one open regional (North County) seat for the 2015 Board of Directors. The elected candidate will serve a three-year term. Lawyers Club’s Endorsements & Nominations Committee is co-chaired by Justine Phillips of Sheppard Mullin and Rebecca Church of Duane Morris. The esteemed members of the committee include Betty Boone, Abby Silverman-Weiss, Cindy Freeland, Kate Kowalewski, and Shanna Pearce. The committee reviews applications for endorsement and thoughtfully assesses each candidate before making recommendations for endorsement to Lawyers Club’s Board of Directors. This year, the Board accepted the Committee’s recommendation and voted to endorse these two remarkable leaders in our legal community, each of whom exemplifies Lawyers Club’s mission “to advance the status of women in the law and in society.” Below are brief bios that demonstrate each candidate’s commitment to our San Diego legal community. Jodi Cleesattle Lilys D. McCoy Jodi Cleesattle is a deputy attorney general in the California Department of Justice’s Civil Division, in the Employment and Administrative Mandate section. She defends state agencies in employment lawsuits, represents state agencies in challenges to disciplinary actions filed with the State Personnel Board, and handles various types of administrative law cases. Before joining the Attorney General’s Office in 2007, she was a partner at Ross, Dixon & Bell LLP, where she litigated complex cases nationwide, including insurance coverage and bad faith, commercial litigation, employment law, libel and defamation, and First Amendment cases. Prior to becoming a lawyer, she was a daily newspaper reporter covering politics and legal issues and was editor and co-founder of a national magazine for law students, The National Jurist. Lilys D. McCoy is the Director of the Thomas Jefferson School of Law (TJSL) Center for Solo Practitioners. She also supervises TJSL’s award-winning Trial Team. Prior to entering academia, McCoy practiced consumer law with the firm of McCoy, Turnage & Robertson, LLP. McCoy was president of Lawyers Club from 2002 to 2003 and received the Lawyers Club’s Belva Lockwood award in 2007. She served as co-president of the Tom Homann LGBT Law Association from 2005 to 2007 and received the THLA Co-Presidents’ award in 2008. In addition to her varied volunteer activities with the local bar, McCoy has also been a career-long delegate to the Conference of Delegates of the Conference of California Bar Associations. From 2009 to 2010, McCoy served as the Chair of the CCBA. Cleesattle was named a Top Attorney in Municipal & Government Practice by the San Diego Daily Transcript from 2009 to 2012, and has been named a Bar Star by the San Diego County Bar Association. She volunteers extensively in the legal community as well as the broader community, and she was honored with Lawyers Club’s 2014 Community Service Award for her volunteer work. She is co-chair of the California State Bar’s Council of State Bar Sections, and is the immediate past chair of the Public Law Section. As chair of the Public Law Section, Cleesattle was the lead organizer of the first annual California Public Records and Open Meetings Conference, a daylong CLE program held in Los Angeles in 2013. She also served as editor of the Public Law Journal for two years. McCoy has a passion for community service, especially with respect to guiding and mentoring law students and new lawyers. Toward that end, McCoy also volunteers her time as a member of the Board of Directors of the San Diego Inn of Court, where she has co-chaired the Evidence Program and the Trial Practice Program and serves as a workshop leader. She is currently the co-chair of the Lawyers Club History & Archives Committee. McCoy has recently been recognized by California Women Lawyers as a 2012- 2013 Woman of Achievement. In addition, she was named a San Diego Daily Transcript Top Attorney in 2006 and 2013 and listed in Super Lawyers in 2007 and 2009. Cleesattle is active in Lawyers Club and currently serves as press liaison, working to promote the activities and achievements of Lawyers Club and its members. She previously served as a Lawyers Club board member from 2008-2011, co-chaired the Leadership Development Committee for six years, and edited Lawyers Club News for three years. Justine Phillips is an attorney with Sheppard Mullin Richter & Hampton LLP and is co-chair of the Endorsement Committee with Rebecca Church, an attorney with Duane Morris LLP. www.lawyersclubsandiego.com Lawyers Club Calendar of Events Lawyers Club News 19 Information for your calendar. All dates subject to change. For latest information, contact Lawyers Club at (619) 595-0650 or visit our website at www.lawyersclubsandiego.com. October 2014 Wednesday, 10/15/14 – 10/19/14 National Association of Women Judges 2014 Conference 12:00 p.m. – 1:15 p.m. The Westin San Diego Gaslamp Quarter 910 Broadway Circle, San Diego, California 92101 Join NAWJ for a multi-day exploration of current topics in access to justice from leading local and national jurists, scholars and experts; visits to major legal landmarks; presentation of annual NAWJ awards; and many fun social receptions and hospitality activities to join and meet fellow conferees. Register at www.nawj.org/annual_2014.asp. Thursday, 10/16/14 Lawyers Club Monthly Luncheon 12:00 p.m. – 1:15 p.m. The US GRANT Hotel, 326 Broadway, San Diego, CA, 92101 Please join us for our annual Mentorship luncheon featuring the LC Advisory Board. Register at www.lawyersclubsandiego.com. Friday, 10/17/14 Fall Judicial Reception 5:00 p.m. – 7:00 p.m. U.S. District Court Annex, Jury Assembly Room 333 West Broadway, San Diego, California 92101 Register at www.lawyersclubsandiego.com. Thursday, 10/23/14 “Negotiating Your Career” 5:30 p.m. – 7:00 p.m. Hughes Marino 1450 Front Street, San Diego, California 92101 The Professional Advancement Committee presents “Negotiating Your Career” with Ann marie Houghtailing. Houghtailing will address a variety of issues relating to how women can build and advance their legal careers including discussion points on preparing for an annual review and salary negotiations, and how to get exposure in the workplace. This program is exclusive to Lawyers Club members only and is free. Register at www.lawyersclubsandiego.com. Tuesday, 10/28/14 SDLRA Prof. Mariano-Florentino Cuellar Luncheon 12:00 p.m. – 1:30 p.m. The Bristol Hotel 1055 First Avenue, San Diego, California, 92101 California Supreme Court nominee Professor Mariano-Florentino Cuellar on “Tomorrow’s Yesterday.” Register at www.sdlrla.com. Friday, 10/31/14 18th Annual Halloween Read In 11:45 a.m. – 1:15 p.m. Central Elementary 4063 Polk Ave. San Diego, CA 92105 Celebrate Halloween by reading to children at Central Elementary. If interested in volunteering please contact the Co-Chairs of Lawyers Club’s Community Outreach & Special Projects Committee, Michele Macosky at [email protected] or Dana Grimes at dana@gwdefense. com. November 2014 Thursday, 11/20/14 Lawyers Club Monthly Luncheon 12:00 p.m. – 1:15 p.m. The US GRANT Hotel, 326 Broadway, San Diego, CA, 92101 Please join us as we review and discuss our annual Equality Survey results. Registration to open soon at www.lawyersclubsandiego.com. December 2014 Wednesday, 12/3/14 Lawyers Club East County Chapter Holiday Judges Reception 5:00 p.m. – 7:00 p.m. Ronald Reagan Community Center, 195 E. Douglas Avenue, El Cajon, CA, 92020 Registration to open soon at www.lawyersclubsandiego.com. Thursday, 12/11/14 Lawyers Club Monthly Luncheon 12:00 p.m. – 1:15 p.m. The US GRANT Hotel, 326 Broadway, San Diego, CA, 92101 It’s time for Lawyers Club’s annual Holiday luncheon! Registration to open soon at www.lawyersclubsandiego.com. January 2015 Thursday, 1/15/14 Lawyers Club Monthly Luncheon 12:00 p.m. – 1:15 p.m. The US GRANT Hotel, 326 Broadway, San Diego, CA, 92101 Registration to open soon at www.lawyersclubsandiego.com. Wednesday, 11/12/14 Website Lunch and Learn Session 11:45 a.m. – 1:30 p.m. Hera Hub Mission Valley 8885 Rio San Diego, Suite 237, San Diego, California 92101 Email in-box overflowing with Lawyers Club notifications? Unsure of how to log into the new Lawyers Club website? Interested in making connections through Lawyers Club? Curious what the committees are up to? Join your website liaisons on November 12 at Hera Hub in Mission Valley as we host a hands-on “Lunch and Learn” for members looking for help using the new Lawyers Club site. Lawyers Club of San Diego is a State Bar of California-approved MCLE provider. (619) 595-0650. Email: [email protected]. Lawyers Club News 20 october 2014 Member Profile: Tanya Joyce Giving New Meaning to the Word Retirement By Lauren T. Ogata For recently-retired Deputy County Counsel, and Lawyers Club member Tanya Joyce, retirement is proving to be busier than she imagined. Since her retirement in May 2014, Joyce has become involved in a significant amount of pro bono work through the San Diego Volunteer Lawyer Program. She takes on cases of her own, and also helps individuals navigate the confusing world of restraining orders at weekly clinics. In addition, Joyce volunteers at Casa Cornelia, a non-profit organization that takes on cases of political asylum and immigration. To top it off, Joyce strives to improve the lives of abused and neglected children at Casa De Amparo, a residential facility tasked with caring for every aspect of a dependent child’s life from therapy and tutoring to daily living, through her position on the organization’s policy committee. Joyce’s clear desire to give back to her community has been a lifelong pursuit. After emigrating from civil war-ridden Nicaragua to the United States at the age of 17, Joyce was thrust into an entirely new world of public co-ed high school where students spoke English exclusively. Despite the self-described “culture shock” that Joyce experienced during her senior year of high school, Joyce thrived. She earned admission to the prestigious UCLA where she eventually discovered her calling. While at UCLA, Joyce read a book called Executioner’s Song that guided her toward a career in public service. “It talked about a probation officer. I learned about what they do,” Joyce recalls, “And I fell in love with the concept.” Not surprisingly, after graduating from UCLA, Joyce became a Deputy Probation Officer for Los Angeles County. Though Joyce loved her job, after several years she decided she wanted to work on the other side, as an attorney. So for three and a half years, she was a probation officer by day and law student by night. Upon graduating from Southwestern University in 1992, Joyce became a Deputy Public Defender in Riverside County. During her rotation representing juveniles, Joyce became hooked. She fell in love with the work and was determined to find a way to make a career of working with youths. Fortuitously, she found the Riverside Office of County Counsel where she handled all aspects of juvenile dependency cases from detention hearings to hearings for the termination of parental rights. “It was an amazing career. But it was also a very emotional profession. Some things are hard to erase.” After over twenty years as an advocate for juveniles, Joyce looks forward to being able to spend more time with her own children – a son, a junior at Cal Poly Pomona and a daughter, a graduate student at Cal State San Marcos – and foster new relationships with fellow Lawyers Club members. Lauren T. Ogata is a Deputy District Attorney for San Diego County. Abridged Proust Questionnaire. What is your idea of perfect happiness? Having a life in which I’m able to perfectly balance a rewarding career in which I make a positive difference in people’s lives with tons of hiking, backpacking, and family time. What talent would you most like to have? To be an accomplished violinist. What is your greatest fear? Degenerative disease including memory loss and the loss of self-sufficiency. What is your greatest achievement? Raising two compassionate, loving, amazing children. What is your greatest extravagance? Travel. What is your most treasured possession? A plastic tortilla-warmer given to me by my daughter years ago. What do you consider the most overrated virtue? Round-the-clock productivity. Which words or phrases do you most overuse? “Oh my goodness!,” and “Oh, Lordy.” What is your greatest regret? Not doing more to avoid family estrangement. When and where were you happiest? Living with my grandmothers while I was in fourth grade. I’ve never been spoiled like that before or since! Tanya Joyce is a Deputy District Attorney and Lawyers Club member. What is your current state of mind? Ecstatic and yet terrified to begin a new career on my own. Where would you most like to live? On the beach in Central America, close to my grandmother and cousins, with multiple trips to San Diego a year. What is your most appreciated trait in friends? Loyalty. What is your idea of misery? Being stuck anywhere with nothing to read. For what fault have you the most toleration? Foolhardiness. www.lawyersclubsandiego.com Lawyers Club News 21 Member Profile: Charles A. Bird By Lawyers Club History & Archives Committee When reflecting on the path Lawyers Club has taken over its 42-year history, attorney Charles Bird recalls Cindy Abbott, a competitor in the 2013 Iditarod, the famed dog-sled race in Alaska. Abbott, who trekked over 600 miles half-blind and with a broken pelvis, “just kept mushing.” So too it was with the original members of Lawyers Club, who just kept “mushing” in the face of adversity. Bird began practicing law in San Diego in 1974 at Luce, Forward, Hamilton & Scripps. When Bird learned of Lawyers Club, he was already involved in the San Diego County Bar Association (SDCBA). He heard whisperings of the formation of a separate bar association dedicated to women’s issues, and wanted to support the effort. Bird remembers attending some of his first Lawyers Club lunches at Tom Ham’s Lighthouse. In addition to himself, Bird recalls two other men who attended regularly. Bird has remained active in Lawyers Club since those early days. Reflecting on his long involvement, he is particularly proud of his service on a strategic planning committee that addressed whether a need remained for a separate bar association dedicated to advancing women in the profession. In the late 1980’s, many young women entered practice with the impression that the generation before them fought all the important battles. They did not want to be known as “feminists.” They expected that their success depended only on their personal efforts in a world blind to gender, and many of them had little interest in Lawyers Club. Bird was writing a semi-monthly opinion column in the Daily Transcript, which continued until 1995. A 1988 column entitled “The Sorry State of Feminism”, reported Bird’s experiences with weaknesses in the movement for women’s equality in the legal profession. The resulting controversy led to creating the strategic planning committee. After all, some questioned what was the need for a cause-based bar association if there was no longer a cause to fight. Why not merge with the SDCBA, a general-interest regional association that enjoyed numbers-based clout and economies of scale? The committee, which was comprised of Bird, Justice Judith McConnell, Betty Boone, and Paula Hui, produced a report documenting many ways in which important battles, e.g., the glass ceiling, were only beginning. The report emphatically supported the need for professional organizations with missions like Lawyers Club’s and for Lawyers Club in particular. The committee gave Bird the privilege of being primary drafter of the final report. The report helped several presidents and boards of directors rejuvenate Lawyers Club and reaffirm its mission. One practical consequence was upgrading the function of the Endorsements Committee, which primarily supported candidates for directorships in the SDCBA. Bird chaired that committee for many years, starting just after the strategic planning process. Before then, as Bird recalls, there were “really very few bar associations and the SDCBA was the giant among them.” Not having access to leadership positions in local bar associations was contributing to the glass ceiling impeding the advancement of women in the law. The Endorsements Committee ultimately proved pivotal in getting many women elected as SDCBA directors and to a series of outstanding women presidents. The strategic planning committee morphed into the Advisory Board, conceived as an informal group serving at the pleasure of the President and advising her on key issues facing Lawyers Club. So it remains, and every President since the group’s creation has asked Bird to continue to serve. Parenthetically, the first woman president of SDCBA was Melinda Lasater in 1985. Bird was one of her vice-presidents, as well as a supporter and mentor. Lawyers Club member Judy Copeland was another change-agent on the board that elected Lasater. Besides supporting the women’s movement, there are other areas where Bird sees a need for Lawyers Club, especially in partnering with other groups seeking to advance equality. In addition, Bird notes that the recent economic downturn has “forced the legal industry to be more concerned with financial issues, particularly maintaining the prosperity of equity owners of law firms.” Firms’ reactions to the downturn have impaired and sometimes destroyed work-life balance programs, reduced hiring of entry-level lawyers, and increased emphasis on growing firms by lateral acquisition of partners with big books of business. Bird observed, “If you are not hiring associates at all, you don’t have to worry about how you are going to make sure that minority associates are welcomed at your firm. And if you are doing all hiring at a lateral level, you don’t have to worry about mentoring.” In Bird’s opinion, these shifts disproportionately disadvantage women and ethnic minorities. Bird cites to several of the early leaders in Lawyers Club, naming Lynn Schenk, Justice Judith McConnell, and Betty Boone, calling them practitioners in the “art of the possible.” Whatever degree of anger or frustration they may have felt, they understood the need to keep moving forward with civil adamancy. “There was no golden era of advancement,” Bird noted, “but rather stepping stones along the way to equality.” These stepping stones included the first large cohort of women appointed to the bench in the late 1970’s and early 1980’s, in which Lawyers Club had influence far out of proportion to its size. Bird fondly recalls another woman well versed in the art of the possible: Annette, his client in Sharon S. v. Superior Court (2003) 31 Cal.4th 417. Annette wanted to adopt her same-sex partner’s biological son, Joshua. This was long before same sex marriage or even the statute allowing registered domestic partners to use the step-parent adoption process. The second-parent adoption process had worked for more than 10,000 same-sex couples, but Annette incurred just about every bad break she could in the trial and appellate court until Bird took over her fully and badly briefed case 10 days before argument. That was on Labor Day weekend, 2001. Although they lost a 2-1 decision in the Court of Appeal, holding all second-parent adoptions void, the California Supreme Court granted Bird’s petition for review and then upheld the second-parent adoption process. The case was hard-fought, extremely emotional, and professionally intense. “Annette just keeps on mushing,” Bird states with a smile: “She fits the mold of Betty Boone and the woman who did the Iditarod with a cracked pelvis.” And, as Lawyers Club moves through its 42nd year, its members continue in the tradition of Charlie Bird and so many others, driving the sled past societal checkpoints, both large and small, to finish the race for equality. Special thanks to Erin DeNatale for interviewing Bird and providing an initial draft of this article. 22 Lawyers Club News october 2014 Awards Corner Help Us Recognize The Accomplishments Of Our Members! By Alara Chilton Do you know of a Lawyers Club member deserving of an award? Then we want to hear from you! This year, we continue our tradition of recognizing the diverse accomplishments of our members through the Awards Committee, which is committed to facilitating the recognition of Lawyers Club members by nominating those who have made important contributions to the community, the legal profession, or who otherwise best fit the specific award criteria. The Committee would like your help in recognizing Lawyers Club members for their accomplishments. We will keep you posted of awards throughout the year. Two awards that the Committee will soon evaluate are the California Lawyer Attorney of the Year (“CLAY”) Awards and the 2015 San Diego Daily Transcript Young Attorney publication. The CLAY Award is given to attorneys in various practice areas. To be eligible, the attorney must be an active member of the State Bar of California whose work was completed or resolved between November 2, 2013 and November 3, 2014. The lawyer’s achievements during this time period must have had a significant impact on the law, the profession, a particular industry, or the general good of the public. The deadline for nominations is Monday, November 3, 2014. For more information visit the website: http://www.callawyer.com/clayawardNominations.cfm. The Daily Transcript Young Attorney award is given to young attorneys in practice for 7 years or less, and who possess the following criteria: hard-working, detail-oriented, knowledgeable, enthusiastic, ethical, professional, and committed to furthering the interests of justice in society. Nominations are due October 31, 2013. For more information visit the website: http://www.sddt. com/microsite/youngattorneys13/finalists.cfm#.VAkHu8JdU7z. If you know of a Lawyers Club member deserving of these award nominations, please contact the Awards Committee at [email protected]. Alara Chilton and Amy Lepine are the Co-Chairs of the Lawyers Club Awards Committee. Lawyers Club News www.lawyersclubsandiego.com Lawyers Club Supporters Annual Benefactor + 2014 Annual Dinner Title Sponsor Hughes Marino Annual Benefactor + 2014 Annual Dinner Platinum Sponsors Casey Gerry Schenk Francavilla Blatt & Penfield LLP Duane Morris LLP Heisner Alvarez, APC Jones Day President’s Circle 2014 Annual Benefactors Best Best & Krieger LLP California Western School of Law Fish & Richardson PC Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy LLP Gomez Trial Attorneys Klinedinst PC Littler Mendelson PC Procopio Cory Hargreaves & Savitch LLP Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd LLP University of San Diego School of Law Wilson Turner Kosmo LLP Mr. Charles Bird Ms. Betty Evans Boone Ms. Candace Carroll Patrons 23 Annual Trifecta + 2014 Annual Dinner Gold Sponsors Fisher & Phillips LLP Knobbe, Martens, Olson and Bear, LLP Millenium Settlements Union Bank Annual Trifecta Sponsors Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP Foley & Lardner LLP Higgs Fletcher & Mack LLP Jones Lang LaSalle Kirby Noonan Lance & Hoge LLP Latham & Watkins LLP Mr. Ezekiel Cortez Ms. Heather Humble Forward Mr. Josh Gruenberg Mintz Levin Cohn Ferris Glovsky & Popeo PC San Diego Gas & Electric Shustak & Partners PC Thomas Jefferson School of Law Wingert Grebing Brubaker & Juskie Annual Corporate Sponsors Aptus Court Reporting Dolan Xitco DTI Global Esquire Inventus LLC Kramm Reporting Ms. Virginia Nelson Hon. David Oberholtzer Hon. Lynn Schenk Ms. Tamera Weisser Ms. Deborah Wolfe Ms. Gayle M. Blatt Hon. Carol M. Frausto (Ret.) Ms. Janice Ingold Lau Ms. Elizabeth Schulman Ms. Sarah Boot Hon. Patricia Garcia Ms. Kathryn R. Maas Mr. Edward I. Silverman Hon. Jill L. Burkhardt Hon. Irma E. Gonzalez (Ret.) Ms. Michele M. Macosky Ms. Abby Silverman Weiss Mr. Guillermo Cabrera Ms. P. Camille Guerra Hon. Barbara Major Ms. Jacquelyn H. Slotkin Ms. Rachel Cano Ms. Kristin Guthrie Ms. Jerrilyn Malana Ms. Beatrice L. Snider Ms. Lesa Christenson Hon. Judith L. Haller Hon. Margaret M. Mann Hon. Stephanie Sontag Ms. Linda Cianciolo Ms. Cassandra Hearn Ms. Lilys McCoy Ms. Kelly J. Spoon Ms. Jodi Cleesattle Ms. Karen P. Hewitt Hon. M. Margaret McKeown Mr. Todd F. Stevens Ms. Diana Vellos Coker Ms. Erika Hiramatsu Hon. Pennie K McLaughlin Ms. Kimberly Stewart Ms. Judith Copeland Hon. Marshall Y. Hockett Ms. Julie S. Mebane Hon. Ronald Styn Hon. Patricia Cowett (Ret.) Mr. Lawrence A. Huerta Ms. Danielle Hultenius Moore Ms. Susan Swan Ms. Tracy Skaddan Hon. Karen Shichman Crawford Mr. Richard Huver Ms. Sandra J. Morris Ms. Vickie E. Turner Sustaining Members Ms. Cynthia H. Cwik Hon. Joan K. Irion Mr. Ron H. Oberndorfer Hon. Theodore Weathers Mr. Marc Adelman Ms. Ann Parode Dynes Ms. Joan Friedenberg Hon. Maureen F. Hallahan Ms. Danielle Hickman Ms. Patricia P. Hollenbeck Hon. Evan Kirvin Hon. Sharon Majors-Lewis Hon. Judith McConnell Hon. Paula Rosenstein Ms. Darragh Davis Hon. Carol Isackson Hon. Christine Pate (Ret.) Ms. Claudette G. Wilson Hon. Cynthia Aaron Hon. Cindy D. Davis Ms. Angela Jae Chun Ms. Anne Perry Hon. Joel R. Wohlfeil Mr. Steve Allen Mr. Ken H. Dillingham Jr. Ms. Jessica Jagir Ms. Natalie Prescott Hon. Margie Gunthardt Woods Ms. Kimberly Arouh Ms. Deborah Dixon Mr. Jay Jeffcoat Ms. Jamie Quient Ms. Patricia L. Zlaket Ms. N. Denise Asher Hon. Bonnie M. Dumanis Hon. Anthony C. Joseph (Ret.) Ms. Carra Lassman Rhamy Hon. Katherine A. Bacal Ms. Ann Crane Durham Ms. Sharon Kalemkiarian Ms. Heather Sullivan Riley Hon. Jeffrey B. Barton Ms. Tina L. Dyer Ms. Rebecca S. Kanter Hon. Charles G. Rogers Hon. Cynthia Bashant Ms. Amber L. Eck Ms. Julia Craig Kelety Ms. Tracy Rogers Ms. Wendy Behan Ms. Elizabeth C. Eldridge Mr. Gregory E. Knoll Mr. Robert C. Ryan Mr. Harvey C. Berger Ms. Jessica Fawver Mr. James D. Koerber Hon. Janis Sammartino Ms. Sharon Blanchet Hon. Susan P. Finlay (Ret.) Ms. Catherine J. Kowalewski Ms. Johanna S. Schiavoni We appreciate our annual sponsors and events sponsors! To learn more about sponsoring Lawyers Club, contact Elaine Lawrence at 619-595-0650 or [email protected] 24 october 2014 www.lawyersclubsandiego.com Change Service Requested PRESORTED STANDARD U.S. POSTAGE PAID PERMIT NO. 2325 SAN DIEGO, CA 701 B Street Suite 224 San Diego CA, 92101 www.esquiresolutions.com 619.234.0660 501 West Broadway | Ste. 400 | San Diego | CA | 92101 Bay Mitchell, Esq. Regional Litigation Consultant Mobile 619-517-0240 [email protected] Sheila K Wise Regional Litigation Consultant Mobile 619-717-0542 [email protected] Emerald Plaza | 402 West Broadway | Suite 1600 | San Diego | CA | 92101 DTI Visit us online at dtiglobal.com
© Copyright 2024