U.S.- India Joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) Multi Utility Evaporative Cooler with Diabatic Contacting Device Milind V Rane, Narendra Singh IIT Bombay, Mechanical Engineering Department ASHRAE Hot Climates Conference Millennium Hotel, Doha, Qatar February 24 to 26, 2014 This page is intentionally left blank Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge the assistance and thank all the reviewers, in particular, the following organisations, for their advice and continued support. The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) and the Department of Science and Technology (DST), Government of India (GOI) provided joint funding for work under the U.S.–India Partnership to Advance Clean Energy Research (PACE-R) program’s “U.S.–India Joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development” (CBERD) project. The Assistant Secretary for Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Office of Building Technology, State and Community Programs, of the U.S. DOE under Contract No. DE-AC02-05CH11231 supports the U.S. CBERD activity. The DST, GOI, administered by Indo-U.S. Science and Technology Forum, supports the Indian CBERD activity. Please cite this document as: Rane M V, Singh N, “Indirect Evaporative Precooling of Fresh Air Using Heat Exchangers with Enhanced Flow Passages”, Proceedings of ASHRAE Hot Climates Conference, Millennium Hotel, Doha, Qatar, February 24 to 26, 2014, Paper # 12605 Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) This page is intentionally left blank Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) Heat Pump Laboratory at Indian Institute of Technology Bombay Document No.- Task 3.1/04/13-14 Multi Utility Evaporative Cooler with Diabatic Contacting Device Author Milind V Rane, PhD; Narendra Singh April, 2014 Team Member Milind V Rane, Darren I Pinto, Deepa M Vedartham, Shreyas A Chavan, Narendra Singh, Prathamesh T Manave, Mukesh Bharadwaj Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) ABSTRACT Experimental and theoretical investigation of an evaporative cooler using patented diabatic contacting device with high surface density, 410 to 550 m2 / m3, will be presented in this paper. Heat and mass transfer coefficients have been reported. High surface density of the heat and mass transfer surface helps keep the unit compact and air flow parallel the wavy surface of the rotating disks helps achieve high heat and mass transfer coefficients while keeping the pressure drops low. Carryover of liquid in to the air stream is also avoided in this design. The diabatic contacting device involves multiple disks assembled on a non-circular shaft rotated at 5 to 40 rpm using a low speed low wattage rotor motor. Multi stage contacting is possible with several diabatic contacting devices assembled in series. Cooling capacity of the assembly can be increased by increasing the number of parallel trays or increasing the length of each contacting tray. Assembly of the rotating disks dips in the water in the trough as it rotates and then comes in contact with the air passing perpendicular to the shaft. Evaporation of water cools the remaining water in the trough and this in turn cools the fluid being passed through the passages of the diabatic contacting device. This cooling effect has been used to cool liquids, condense refrigerant or process vapours which simultaneously aerating and / or evaporating effluent streams in a once through flow arrangement. The system is economically viable and involves less maintenance cost. The analysis presented in the paper confirms the benefit of indirect evaporative coolers for hot and humid climate conditions. Keywords: Multi utility evaporative cooler, diabatic contacting device, rotating disks Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) CONTENT ABSTRACT vi CONTENT vii NOMENCLATURE viii 1. INTRODUCTION 1 2. DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS 2 2.1 Experimental Set Up 2 2.2 Instrumentation 5 3. THEORETICAL INVESTIGATION 4.2 Assumptions 5 6 5. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 7 6. CONCLUSION 9 REFERENCES Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) 10 NOMENCLATURE A area, m2 BICL building integrated closed loop cp specific heat capacity at constant pressure, kJ/kg.K d diameter, m EWC evaporative water cooler G mass of water transferred, kg/s (lb/h) h enthalpy, kJ/kg, (BTU/lb) KD mass transfer coefficient, kg/m2s (lb/ft2h) lmtd log mean temperature difference lmwd log mean humidity difference m mass flow rate, kg/s n number P power, W p pressure, Pa Q heat transfer rate, kW t temperature, oC U heat transfer coefficient, kW/m2.K u velocity, m/s w specific humidity, g H2O/kg.da Greek Letters Ø relative humidity, % Suffixes a cw da db ewc hme thk tot tr w wb air cooling water dry air dry bulb evaporative water cooler heat and mass exchange thickness total tray/trough water/moisture wet bulb Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) 1. INTRODUCTION Evaporative cooling is an energy efficient alternative, which can be successfully employed in hot and dry regions where difference between dry bulb temperature and wet bulb temperature is significant. In addition to difference between DBT and WBT, thermal comfort for occupants can be achieved where WBT is less than required temperature for thermal conditions. The numerous advantages of evaporative cooling over the mechanical vapor compressions systems such as low cost, fresh air supply, less power consumption make it a viable option (Heidarinejad, G et al., 2008, 2009) for achieving the goal of thermal comfort. It is also an environmental friendly approach of conditioning the air. Ideally, if no heat is lost to the surroundings, air can be sensibly cooled, although it absorbs latent energy of water vapor being picked up. Many researchers have investigated evaporative cooling and a variety of designs have been proposed. Aluminum plate-type heat exchanger was proposed by Watt and Brown (1997). Scofield and DesChamps (1984) investigated the dry surface plate heat exchanger to be used for direct/indirect evaporative cooling and showed 30% saving in the energy cost. AlJuwayhel et al. (1997) showed that the thermal effectiveness of two-stage evaporative cooler was high with cooling tower. Thermal performance was shown to improve with increase in packing thickness and mass flow rate in air pre-cooler. Many researchers have proposed mathematical models by theoretically investigating different systems. In case of direct evaporative cooling, air gets contaminated with impurities. Some of these models include finite difference method based analysis by Baker and Shryock (1961), Kettleborough and Hieh (1983) model using enthalpy potential, Dai and Samathy (2002) model for predicting liquid gas interface temperature and correlations of heat transfer coefficients of wet and dry surfaces by Maclaine-cross and Banks (1981). Most of the designs and models proposed in literature have low packing efficiencies, thus have lesser area for heat and mass exchange per unit volume. In the current paper we present experimental and theoretical investigation of Diabatic Contacting device as an evaporative cooler having high surface density, 410 to 550 m2 / m3 which is 120 to 185% higher than conventional ones (Reddy 2003). Note that diabatic device refers to the device allowing heat exchange with the surroundings contrary to adiabatic device where no heat transfer to or from surrounding is allowed. High surface density of the heat and mass transfer surface helps keep the unit compact. Air flow parallel to the wavy surface of the rotating disks helps achieve high heat and mass transfer coefficients while keeping the pressure drops low 50 to100 kPa. The system offers multiple benefits such as co-generation of cold water suitable for drinking in air conditioning applications. In another application, circulation of sewage water in the troughs will help reuse the waste water avoiding the need for fresh water. The remaining waste water in the trough having high organic matter can be treated separately to reduce Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) Page 1 of 10 Biochemical Oxygen Demands, BODs and Chemical Oxygen Demands, CODs, thus reducing the cost of further water treatment while the same unit serves as an evaporative cooler or evaporative condenser. The cold water can be utilized for providing the cooling effect to structure thus reducing load on AC resulting in less power consumption and operating cost. In addition to this, the design can find application with sea water for desalination as well. Suitable plastic coatings can ensure reasonable life of various components of the contacting device. Multi stage contacting is possible with several diabatic contacting devices assembled in series. Cooling capacity of the system can be increased by increasing the number of parallel trays or increasing the length of each contacting tray. Assembly of the rotating disks dips in the water in the trough as it rotates and then comes in contact with the air passing perpendicular to the shaft. Evaporation of water cools the remaining water in the trough and this in turn cools the fluid being passed through the cooling passages of the diabatic contacting device. This cooling effect can be used to cool liquids, condense refrigerant, building or process vapors. Buildings consume 24% to 40% energy of the total energy consumption in a country (PerezLombard et al. 2008). Of this nearly half is consumed in meeting the thermal comfort. Most of the cooling load that needs to be taken care by HVAC is the consequence of solar energy gain. Readers can refer to Islam et al. (2009) for radiation data in middle-east countries. This system can be integrated well with buildings reducing the cooling load without requiring any blower or fan. The system is economically viable and involves less maintenance cost. The analysis presented in the paper confirms the benefit of indirect evaporative coolers for hot and humid climate conditions. 2. DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS 2.1 Experimental Set-up Rane et al, 2002 developed and tested the novel contacting device as an absorber and regenerator of liquid desiccant bed dryer. In the current paper the design has been improved. Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) Page 2 of 10 The EWC prototype used for the experiment has rotating disks of 142 mm diameter mounted on a square shaft. The shafts rotate at 5 to 40 rpm using a low speed low wattage of 10 W rotor motor. Aluminium troughs have water filled in with disks dipped typically 1/3rd of height of water in trough as shown in Figure 1. The remaining portion is exposed to incoming air for heat and mass exchange. Three passages are provided under the Aluminium trough to uniformly circulate hot water running in building integrated closed loop. Water to be cooled, transfers heat to the water in the trough. This circulated water cools down as it flows through the passages and is obtained as chilled water which can be used for various utilities. The water in the trough in turn transfers heat to the ambient air coming in contact with the disk. Auxiliary power consumption is minimized as no blowers are used to circulate the air. Figure 1 shows rotating disk mounted on a shaft. As the disk rotates, it picks up water from the trough and brings it in contact with incoming hot and dry air. The injection molded disks prevent any carryover of the liquid. Figure 3 is the set up used for carrying out experiments with five trays in parallel. Figure 1: Schematic of Rotating Disk in Trough Design specifications of the experimental set up have been listed in Table 1. Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) Page 3 of 10 Table 1. Specifications of Indirect Evaporative Cooler Parameter Symbol Unit Description/Value Trough length Pitch circle diameter of trough Inner hydraulic diameter of trough channel ltr dtr.i mm mm 2133 150 dcp.i mm 8.6 Number of trays in system Type of contacting disk (CD) Diameter of CD Thickness of CD Number of Contacting disk per tray Speed of contacting disk ntr.dh _ 1 _ ddisk thkdisk _ mm mm plastic 142 1 ndisk.tr _ 500 rpmdisk rpm 40 The schematic of the setup is shown in Figure 2. The BICL in the schematic represents the closed loop which is extracting solar thermal load from structures. The figure shows an arrangement of five troughs placed in parallel. Note that authors have presented analysis with only one trough in the entire paper. Figure 2: Schematic of Indirect Evaporative Cooler Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) Page 4 of 10 2.2 Instrumentation a) One 24 DC motor with rated power of 36 W were used to rotate the shaft having perforated disks mounted. b) In order drive one DC motor, DC power supply with following specification was used: TRIO PS/1AC/24DC/10 Order No : 2866323 Input 100-240 V ~ 3 to 1.5 A/50-60Hz Operational voltage: 85 to 264 V D rating: <90V~2.5%/V Output: 24V DC /10 A Sno: 3012923231 Rev: 04 c) RTDs with an accuracy of ± 0.3 ºC have been used to measure the temperature of water in trough, tw.tr and cooling water at IEC inlet, tcw1 and outlet, tcw2. For evaluating log mean temperature/humidity difference, temperature of water at the sides, tw.tr.1 and tw.tr.2 have also been measured using RTDs. d) A rotameter with an accuracy of ±2% of reading has been used to measure flow rate of water. The range and resolution of the instrument is 0 to10 lpm and 0.1 lpm, respectively. e) An anemometer with an accuracy of ±2% of reading was used to measure the velocity of the air at inlet and outlet to EWC. The range and resolution of the instrument are 0.4 to 30m/s and 0.1m/s respectively. f) For pressure measurement, manometer is utilized with a resolution 1mm of water column. 3. THEORETICAL INVESTIGATION Heat transfer coefficient of the system has been evaluated based on the heat exchange area provided by cooling passage. As mass transfer is taking place over the mass exchange area provided by disks, the total area provided by the disks has been used to evaluate mass transfer coefficient. Temperature and humidity obtained during the experimental investigation have been utilized for evaluation. m.w.disk.tot = rpm mw.disk ndisk.tr lmtd = [(t1 – tw.tr.1) – (t2 – tw.tr.2)]/ [ln (t1 – tw.tr.1)/(t2 – tw.tr.2)] Q = mcw cp.cw (tcw1- tcw2) U = Q/ (Acp * lmtd) lmwd = [(w1 – wtr.1) – (w2 – wtr.2)]/ [ln (w1 – wtr.1)/ (w2 – wtr.2)] G = ma (w2 – w1) KD = G/ ( Ahme lmwd) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 . Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) Page 5 of 10 3.1 Assumptions For analysis of the experimental results obtained, following assumptions have been made: a) Injection molded disks providing heat and mass exchange area are acting as plain disks. b) The heat loss to surroundings from cooling water from back side to environment is negligible. Under the assumptions stated, energy released by cooling water should be equal to the energy gained by water rotating with disks. This can be expressed in following manner: Q = mw.disk.tot cp.w ( tw.tr.1- tw.tr.2) 8 Note that water holding capacity of single contacting disk is 1.2g. This together with rpm of rotating disk can be utilized to evaluate the total mass of water rotating in a contacting trough, using geometry presented in Figure 1. This analysis is omitted for the sake of brevity. Under the above mentioned assumptions, theoretical value of heat and mass transfer coefficient was estimated with different conditions. Average overall heat transfer coefficient was obtained to be 8 kW/m2K and mass transfer coefficient to be 150 g/m2s based on the area of the cooling passages. Figure 3: Picture of Indirect Evaporative Cooler Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) Page 6 of 10 4. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION One trough was used in the system for experimentation as this was sufficient to take care of the cooling requirement. Flow rate of the cooling water was kept at 5 lpm. As the tap water was sufficient to provide required head, no pump was used. Natural wind at an average speed of 1 to 4 m/s provided the required flux of air to draw heat and mass from the disks dipped in water inside trough. Heat duty of 0.38 kW was observed to be removed from cooling water at a pressure drop of 2.0 m of water column. Heat transfer coefficient Ui, 4.8 kW/m2K and mass transfer coefficient, 16.5 g/m2s were evaluated based on the temperatures and humidity obtained during experimentation. A typical result of experimentation is presented in Table 1 Table 1 a: Experimental results t1 ºC tw2 ºC Ø1 % w1 g/kg h1 J/kg t2 ºC tw2 ºC Ø2 % w2 g/kg h2 kJ/kg tcw1 ºC tcw2 ºC tw.tr.1 ºC tw.tr.2 ºC ua m/s 28.3 36.8 38.1 32.3 31.6 24.8 25.1 25.7 24.3 25.2 76 39.5 38 52.8 60.3 18.5 15.4 15.9 16.1 17.7 75.6 76.6 79.3 73.7 77.1 26.5 34.1 36.0 30.1 30.2 25.2 24.9 25.2 23.8 24.6 90 45 43 69 64 19.7 15.9 16.1 16.2 17.9 76.9 76.1 77.5 71.6 76.1 28.2 31.2 31.4 31.1 31 27.1 29.3 29.0 29.2 29.1 26.4 28.4 28.5 28.2 28.1 26.1 28.2 28.2 27.9 27.6 2.3 1.3 2 1.8 3 Table 1 b: Experimental results lmtd lmwd mcw Q Ui KD. 2 ºC g/kg kg/s kW kW/m K g/m2s 0.96 2.52 0.08 0.38 4.8 16.5 1.7 8.98 0.05 0.63 4.1 33.7 1.45 9.47 0.12 0.72 5.9 100 1.89 8.33 0.15 1.1 1.1 59.8 2.12 6.51 0.18 1.4 12 29.0 Table 1 a: Experimental results (in Imperial Units) t1 ºF tw2 ºF Ø1 % w1 lb/ lbda h1 BTU/ lb t2 ºF tw2 ºF Ø2 % w2 lb/ lbda h2 BTU/ lb 82.9 98.2 100.6 90 88.9 76.4 76.6 78.3 75.7 77.4 76 39.5 38 52.8 60.3 0.0185 0.0154 0.0159 0.0161 0.0177 0.0325 0.0330 0.0341 0.0317 0.0331 79.7 93.4 96.8 86.2 86.4 77.4 76.8 77.4 74.8 76.3 90 45 43 69 64 0.0197 0.0159 0.0161 0.0162 0.0179 0.0331 0.0327 0.0333 0.308 0.0327 Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) tcw1 ºF tcw2 ºF tw.tr.1 ºF 82.8 88.2 88.5 88 87.8 80.8 80.8 83.3 82.8 82.6 79.5 83.1 83.3 82.8 82.6 Page 7 of 10 tw.tr.2 ua ºF ft/h 79 82.8 82.8 82.2 81.7 27165 15354 23622 21259 35433 Table 1 b: Experimental results (in Imperial Units) lmtd lmwd mcw Q Ui KD. 2 ºF lb/ lbda lb/h BTU/h BTU(th)/h ft ºF lb /ft2h 1.7 0.003 635 1296.6 845 12.2 12.7 0.009 397 2150.0 722 24.8 15.6 0.009 952 2456.7 1039 73.7 5.4 0.008 1190 3753 194 44.1 5.5 0.007 1429 4776 211 21.8 The analysis can be confirmed by employing the energy equation, Eq 8. rotating with disk was found out to be 362.7 g/s. The total mass On an average, solar insolation of 650 W/m2 falling on building of say 12 m2 area can easily be met by the presented evaporative cooler with three trays in parallel, assuming a reflection coefficient of 0.8. The heat transfer coefficients reported are based on the area of cooling passage having hydraulic diameter of 8.61 mm. Based on experimentally obtained mass transfer coefficient and heat transfer coefficient, the potential of the system can easily be realized in different countries. Table 2 shows the monthly averaged solar insolation for various cities. Table 2. Climatic conditions in different cities City t1 ºC tw1 ºC Ø1 % w1 g/kg h1 kJ/kg *I MJ/m2/day Bahrain Riyadh AbuDhabi Doha Baghdad 41.4 43.4 40.4 41.5 44.0 28.7 20.1 33.4 31.2 25.1 40.0 10.0 63.0 49.0 22.0 20.16 5.47 30.6 25.0 12.5 93.54 57.7 119 106 91.5 35.2 35.2 36.2 35.2 36.1 Wind speed ft/h 5.07 5.17 4.78 4.91 5.07 Note: * Have been taken from Islam et al., 2009. Table 2. Climatic conditions in different cities (in Imperial units) City t1 ºF tw1 ºF Ø1 % w1 lbm/lbm h1 BTU/lbm *I BTU/ft2/day Bahrain Riyadh AbuDhabi Doha Baghdad 106.5 110.1 104.7 106.7 111.2 83.7 68.2 92.1 88.2 77.2 40.0 10.0 63.0 49.0 22.0 0.0202 0.0055 0.0306 0.0250 0.0125 40.2 24.8 51.2 45.6 39.4 3101 3101 3190 3101 3181 For cities such as Doha, monthly average insolation is around 35.2 MJ/m2/day. Even after considering a reflection coefficient of 0.8 from exposed surface of buildings, 7.04 MJ/m2/day gets trapped in structures. This incurs huge cost in maintaining thermal comfort inside Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) Page 8 of 10 Wind speed m/s 59882 61063 56457 57992 59882 buildings. Indirect evaporative cooler can remove the part or whole of that load. Authors have also presented wind speed in Table 2. The system requires no fan or blower and can easily run on natural winds. The obtained heat and mass transfer coefficients are with wind speed of 0 to 4 m/s. As the wind data shows higher wind velocities in cities presented, higher heat and mass transfer coefficients can be obtained. This makes the system an ideal choice for cities such as Doha. 5. CONCLUSIONS The paper presents experimental investigation of a novel indirect evaporative cooler which can be integrated in buildings to meet the solar thermal load. Evaporative cooler can successfully be employed to maintain thermal comfort in structures in various cities presented. The system offers several benefits which can be enlisted as follows: a) System has high mass transfer coefficient of average 47.8 g/m2s and heat transfer coefficient of 5.58 kW/m2K b) Pressure drop across the evaporative cooler in cooling water line can be used by using multiple shorter trays in parallel. c) System requires no fan or blower and can easily run on natural winds. This reduces the energy throughput of the system making it cost effective. d) It is easily scalable. Number of troughs can be increased or decreased depending upon the requirements. e) Carryover of water in the air stream is avoided by keeping gap between the rotating disk assembly and the bottom of the tray mounted above. The above mentioned advantages coupled with ease of fabrication make it a viable option for cooling the structures simultaneously deriving multiple benefits in many parts of the world. REFERENCES 1. Al-Juwayhel F I, Al-Haddad A A, Shaban H I, & El-Dessouky H T. 1997. Experimental investigation of the performance of two-stage evaporative coolers. Heat transfer engineering, 18(2), 21-33. 2. ASHRAE. 2005. ASHRAE Handbook-Fundamentals. Atlanta: American Society of Heating Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Engineers, Inc. 3. Baker D R & Shryock H A 1961. Comprehensive approach to the analysis of cooling tower performance. Marley Co., Kansas City, MO. 4. Dai Y J, Sumathy K. 2002. Theoretical study on a cross-flow direct evaporative cooler using honeycomb paper as packing material, Applied Thermal Engineering. 22 1417– 1430 Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) Page 9 of 10 5. Heidarinejad G, Bozorgmehr M, Delfani S, & Esmaeelian.J 2009. Experimental investigation of two-stage indirect/direct evaporative cooling system in various climatic conditions. Building and Environment, 44(10), 2073-2079 6. Heidarinejad G & Bozorgmehr M 2008. Modeling, evaluation and application potential of two stage indirect/direct evaporative air coolers. In Proceedings of the 6th international energy conversion engineering conference (IECEC), Cleveland, Ohio. 7. Islam M D, Kubo I, Ohadi M, & Alili A A. (2009). Measurement of solar energy radiation in Abu Dhabi, UAE. Applied Energy, 86(4), 511-515. 8. Kettleborough C F, Hsieh C S. 1983. The thermal performance of the wet surface plastic plate heat exchanger used as an indirect evaporative cooler. J. Heat Transfer 105 366–373. 9. Maclaine-cross I L, Banks P J 1981. A general theory of wet surface heat exchangers and its application to regenerative cooling, J. Heat Transfer 103, 579–585. 10. Perez-Lombard L, Ortiz J, & Pout C. 2008. A review on buildings energy consumption information. Energy and buildings, 40(3), 394-398. 11. Rane M V, Kotta Reddy. S.V. 2002. Contacting Device for Effective Heat and Mass Transfer. Indian Patent Grant # 203949 12. Rane M V, Reddy S V K & Bajaj J S. 2002. Cooling and dehumidification using liquid desiccant, Proceeding of International Sorption Heat Pump Conference. Shanghai P R China, pp. 414–418. 13. Reddy S V K. 2003. Development of energy efficient solar/desiccant based drying system, Ph.D Thesis. Mechanical Engineering Department, IIT Bombay, India. 14. Scofield C M & DesChamps. N.H. 1984. Indirect evaporative cooling using plate type heat exchangers. ASHRAE transactions, 90(1B), 148-153. 15. Watt J R, Brown W K, 1997. Evaporative air conditioning handbook. Fairmont Press. . Annexure_051_March 2014 U.S.-India joint Center for Building Energy Research and Development (CBERD) Page 10 of 10
© Copyright 2024