QUID
NOVI
Journal des étudiant-e-s
en droit de l’université McGill
Published by the McGill Law
Students’ Association
Volume 36, no 8
18 novembre 2014 | November 18, 2014
QN
18 NOV 2014
QUID
NOVI
QUID NOVI
3644 Peel Street
Montréal, Québec H2A 1X1
[email protected]
EDITORS IN CHIEF
Ying Cheng
Nathan Cudicio
IN-HOUSE DIVA EMERITUS
Charlie Feldman
LAYOUT EDITORS
Fortunat Nadima
Sunny Yang
ASSOCIATE REVIEWERS
Journal des étudiant-e-s
en droit de l’université McGill
McGill Law’s Weekly Student Newspaper
Volume 36, no 8
18 novembre 2014 | November 18, 2014
WHAT’S INSIDE ?
QUEL EST LE CONTENU ?
ÉDITO
WE CONDEMN ATTACKS ON WOMEN AT WORK...
DÉNONCIATIONS : QUELQUES DISTINCTIONS S’IMPOSENT
EN RÉPONSE AU PROFESSEUR LECKEY
POUR UNE CRITIQUE DE LA “TECHNICISATION”
THE LEARNING CURVE: EXAM WRITING
CONFÉRENCE FRANCOPHONE DE LA REVUE DE DROIT DE MCGILL
MENTAL ILLNESS AS A LAW STUDENT
PUBLIC INTEREST PRESTIGE
SOIS SAGE
MCGILL LAW JOURNAL: NOVEMBER 12 INFO SESSION RECAP
A GUIDE FOR TOLERABLE FEMINISM
OVERHEARDS
MCGILL LAW MEMES
FACULTY DOPPELGANGERS
Kaishan He
Andrew Stuart
STAFF WRITERS
Linda Agaby
Allison Render
Suzanne Zaccour
WANT TO TALK ?
TU VEUX T’EXPRIMER ?
3
4
6
7
8
10
13
14
15
16
17
20
21
22
23
Co-Editor-in-Chief
YING
CHENG
PAENULTIMUS
“La majestueuse égalité des lois, qui interdit au riche
comme au pauvre de coucher sous les ponts, de mendier
lity, the law forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under
bridges, beg in the streets, and steal loaves of bread.] –
Anatole France
Privilege. In some of this week’s submissions from
students and Faculty, we encounter various manifesta-
-
by Margaret Atwood
I would like to watch you,
with you, to enter
of both accuser and accused.
slides over my head
inclined to tough it out instead of seeking resources
highlights an alarming class divide in the choice of
-
and walk with you through that lucent
wavering forest of bluegreen leaves
with its watery sun & three moons
towards the cave where you must descend,
towards your worst fear
I would like to give you the silver
rest work a gated community of sorts?
from the grief at the center
of your dream, from the grief
at the center. I would like to follow
again & become
the boat that would row you back
few.
to where your body lies
beside me, and you enter
it as easily as breathing in
I would like to be the air
that inhabits you for a moment
& that necessary.
QN
18 NOV 2014
Professor
ANGELA
CAMPBELL
becomes a new law.
Hill.
QN
18 NOV 2014
WE CONDEMN ATTACKS ON WOMEN
Professor
ROBERT
LECKEY
que tous les silences sont les mêmes. Tous les gestes de briser le
une chose. Ce geste aide à nous sensibiliser. Il amoindrit la honte
tous et de toutes.
QN
18 NOV 2014
Law II
SUZANNE
ZACCOUR
EN RÉPONSE AU PROFESSEUR
LECKEY
délicat et commande un débat de société. En ce sens, contrai
trigger warning
QN
18 NOV 2014
Law II
AURÉLIE
LANCTÔT &
ANNE-SOPHIE
OUELLET
POUR UNE CRITIQUE DE LA
Law School
égard.
cohorte de la rentrée 2013.
QN
18 NOV 2014
doit
Du devoir social des futurs juristes
vraie
1
2
3
.
1
Je ne suis pas une PME - plaidoyer
pour une université publique.
2
“L’université et l’idée de culture”, dans Dans les
ruines de l’université
3
Freitag, Michel, Le naufrage de l’université et autres essais
QN
18 NOV 2014
Law IV
ALLISON
RENDER
Policy/Theory
on an issue.
1.
2.
3.
QN
18 NOV 2014
4.
any debate.
Solve the Problem
The Big Day
QN
18 NOV 2014
Physician Assisted
Suicide and Bill 52:
A Discourse
Dr. Patrick Vinay
McGill Faculty of Law
New Chancellor Day Hall
Room 100 (Moot Court)
Dr. Daniel Weinstock
5:30 p.m. - 8:00 p.m.
Wednesday, November 26th
REVUE DE
DROIT DE
MCGILL
CONFÉRENCE FRANCOPHONE DE LA REVUE
Loi
électorale du Canada
Loi électorale du
Canada.
Charte canadienne des droits et
libertés.
QN
18 NOV 2014
ANONYMOUS
MENTAL ILLNESS
AS A LAW STUDENT
struggle to balance my mental health needs with the demands
QN
18 NOV 2014
Law II
JACOB
SCHWEDA
1
.
3
. It seems
troubling.
working-class students need not apply.
1
2
.
2
well.
3
QN
18 NOV 2014
Law I
ELIZABETH
ROBERTSON
1
come with being nice. You see, while I was worrying about hur
6
Now this
7
2
8
. So
right eyelid twitch.
10
. Hey,
mously. It was cowardly, dishonest and needed to be called out.
3
11
4
QN
18 NOV 2014
4
6
that you get it.
7
1
8
2
10
11
3
MCGILL LAW
JOURNAL
SESSION RECAP
-
editors.
Why join the McGill Law Journal?
QN
18 NOV 2014
leur mandat.
lawjournal.mcgill.ca.
WHY JOIN THE MCGILL LAW JOURNAL, YOU ASK?
Our Volume 60 Team says…
QN
18 NOV 2014
Amanda Wright, Managing Editor
In-House Diva
OVERHEARDS
CHARLIE
FELDMAN
Y’all – it’s been a rough week in Charlie land. New lows were hit – I actually Googled “things in fridge” and was upset when the Inter-
Prof. Adamski:
Quid:
hear about MIT the worse it gets.
Prof. Gold:
Ellenborough Park
Ellenborough Park
Prof. Gold:
Me. Barbeau:
Prof. Khoury
Prof. Jukier:
Prof. Jukier
Quid:
Langelier v. Demers.
Prof. Lamed
Prof. Adams:
Quid:
Class: No.
Prof. Lamed:
Class: No.
Prof. Lamed:
Prof. Adamski:
Prof. Anker:
LLM:
Prof. Anker:
Me. Barbeau:
Prof. Raizenne:
QN
18 NOV 2014
Dean Jutras
notes.
Dean Jutras: ...or maybe I am wrong and we are all going to
seems cool too.
Law I
PATRICK
LLOYD
BRENNAN
QN
18 NOV 2014
QN
18 NOV 2014
Can’t get enough Quid?
On est sur Facebook !
Search “Quid Novi – Droit McGill
Law”
or type
https://www.facebook.com/quidnovi.mcgill.
Add us today – vous ne savez jamais ce que nous
pourrions mettre en ligne!
The final issue of the semester will
be published on November 25.
Deadline for submission:
Thursday, November 20 at 5pm