Reading with English Language Learners

Literature and Reading with
English language learners
PUCESE English Language Conference
Esmeraldas, Ecuador 2014
Ali Cullerton, Ph.D.
Qualities of Outstanding
Literature
!   Good books:
!   Expand awareness
!   Provide an enjoyable read that doesn’t overtly teach or
!  
!  
!  
!  
moralize
Tell the truth
Embody quality
Have integrity
Show originality
Genres of Literature
!   Folktales
!   Realistic fiction
!   Fantasy
!   Poetry
!   Historical fiction
!   Biography
!   Information
!   Graphic Novel
How well do you know your genres of literature?
Contemporary
Realistic
Fiction
Folk Literature
Easy Reader
Concept Book
Historical
Fiction
Informational
Text
Fantasy
Science Fiction
Biography
Picture Book
Multicultural
Graphic Novel
Multicultural Literature
About people who are
not in the mainstream
(although there is no
consensus on what
constitutes
mainstream).
Culturally-authentic
books are written by
authors who have
developed a “culturally
conscious” way to
“provide exceptional
aesthetic experiences:
to entertain,
education inform; and
…engender racial
pride” (Harris, 1990).
Good/Bad MT
Insider/Outsider
Perspective
Stereotyping
Criteria for Evaluating and Selecting
Multicultural Literature
Do the author and illustrator present authentic perspectives?
Is the culture portrayed multi-dimensionally?
Are cultural details naturally integrated?
Is the collection balanced?
Is language used authentically?
Are details accurate and is the interpretations current?
Who is the publisher? Has the book won any awards?
Reading Literature in
Secondary School
“A PRIMARY function of literature in the secondary schools is to
produce a particular kind of citizen-GLOBAL CITIZEN”
!   Often, we think of YA literature and English Class comes
to mind…
!   “Back-to-basics” schooling defines reading in a very narrow-
minded manner
!   Teachers must account for the changing realities of the
demographics in their classrooms and challenge notions of
“common culture”
Globalization
!   Teaching and reading of literature in secondary school
has been shaped by globalization.
!   Classrooms can no longer be considered as bound sites,
with students entering from fixed locations (Pennycook,
2005)
!   Globalization creates a PULL/PUSH between its
desired outcomes of standardization and
diversification.
Globalization
!   We view globalization as a set of complex economic
and cultural processes with both positive and negative
implications on the teaching and learning of literature.
!   Forces us to redefine who counts as a relevant, desirable
and global citizen.
!   Expands the interpretive positions that students take up
in the study of literature.
!   New technologies redefine the selection, genres and
dissemination of literary texts
Literature Resources
http://www.alexiscullerton.com/book-lists.html
Why might it be important to use genre-diverse literature
in the classroom for learning a new language?
Role Play
!   Scenario #1: Public Speaking Unit.
!   Scenario #2: Historical Lesson on World War II.
!   Scenario #3: Personal narratives-essay writing.
!   Scenario #4: Grammar Unit. Future tense.
1.  Think of the objectives of the unit.
2.  What type of genre might be a good fit and why?
Ways to Support Reading for
English language learners…
Three principles of
comprehension instruction
EXPLICIT
MORE
KNOWLEDGEABLE
OTHER
SCAFFOLDED
Comprehension strategies
Background Knowledge:
“What do I already know that helps me step into the
world created by this text?”
• Text-processing:
“What can I do to make sense of the text as I move
through this text world?
• Monitoring strategies:
“How do I know if the meanings I’ve created make
sense?
Background knowledge
Concepts of
print
Developing
vocabulary
Making
intertextual
connections
Making
predictions
Using
context
clues
Text-processing strategies
!  
Sequencing
!  
Visualizing
!  
Identifying Key Events
!  
Making inferences
!  
Understanding literary elements
!  
Using genre knowledge
!  
Using perspective
!  
Using knowledge of text structure
Monitoring strategies
!   Evaluating and adjusting predictions
!   Asking questions
!   Clarifying
inferences
“He put down $10.00 at the window.
The woman behind the window gave
$4.00. The person next to him gave
him $3.00, but he gave it back to her.
So, when they went inside, she
bought him a large bag of popcorn.”
Inferences
It was so cold I could barely feel my fingers.
I stood there, rocking my legs back and forth
and doing a little jump to keep my blood
moving. Every so often I would walk out
into the middle and look as far as I could to
see if it was coming.
Inferences
!   When I walked inside, my eyes were drawn in a million
different directions. There was too much to take in, my
surroundings were magnificent. There were stone sculptures
etched into the walls, ceilings so high I couldn’t even see
where they ended and more detail than one could ever truly
appreciate. Eventually, I made my way to the winding staircase
and leaned against the wall. A couple speaking Catalan walked
by, saying something I could not understand. But they too, the
locals, were just as amazed as I was by our surroundings. In
that moment, I started to understand how something could
take over 100 years to build, how someone could commit their
whole lives to one project, and it all made sense.
La Sagrada Familia
Making inferences (Durkin,
1993).
!   Text Based: made from information that the author supplied
in the text
!   Knowledge-based: made from knowledge about the world
!   We use inferences to create “internal text” (personal thoughts
about what is happening in the text.)
!   Readers construct internal texts as they connect the
information in the “external text” (the printed information)
with what they already know.
Our goal is to use strategies so
that students can connect the
external text with the internal
text.
Remember we talked about
EXPLICIT teaching?
!   Strong readers make inferences, visualize and
use many other strategies to comprehend the
text in front of them.
!   Struggling readers are not as good at using
those strategies.
!   As a teacher, it is your job to teach and model
the strategy so that students can learn to do it
on their own.
Questions?
references
!   Children’s Books in Children’s Hands: An
Introduction to Their Literature by: Charles Temple,
Miriam Martinez and Junko Yokota
!   Reading Literature in Secondary School: Disciplinary
Discourses in Global Times by: Cynthia Lewis and
Jessica Dockter