FREE THE TRUTH IS ALWAYS FAIR Crogan’s long ordeal finally over... but it was a .... DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 07, 2015 VOL. 15, NO. 50 FREE 2 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 Mike Hudson Crogan Prosecution Further Evidence Of Political Influence on Justice System The media firestorm that accompanied the arrest of local promoter Rick Crogan on felony charges in June has pretty much turned out to be much ado about nothing. Crogan pleaded guilty late last week to a charge of petit larceny, a misdemeanor. He was sentenced to perform 50 hours of community service and given a one year conditional discharge by North Tonawanda Judge William R. Lewis. In October, Crogan paid $10,000 in restitution as part of the plea agreement. Formerly the head of the Main Street Business Association, Crogan left that organization to launch the Niagara Falls Music & Arts Festival, a for profit enterprise. The festival was a huge success, drawing 18,000 people in 2013 despite the fact that no big name musical acts performed. When Niagara Falls Mayor Paul Dyster offered Crogan $30,000 to help underwrite this year’s festival, Crogan turned him down flat. And that may have been the beginning of his problems. Up popped a woman named Becky Marchetti, who had worked as a volunteer on the festival. A strong supporter of Dyster, Marchetti is also involved with Niagara Rises, an organization that has backed the mayor and accepted city money in the past. Marchetti went to police claiming Crogan had taken $15,000 in festival money donated by a local business and spent it on himself, an allegation Crogan vehemently denied. He was charged with third- and fourth-degree grand larceny and first-degree scheme to defraud, all felonies, after what authorities said was a four-month investigation. Dyster immediately announced the arrest on his Facebook page along with No good deed goes unpunished in Niagara Falls. Promoter extraordinaire Rick Crogan produced two of the most successful concert events in Niagara Falls history without a dime of taxpayer money, but his independence insulted the sensibilities of certain maligners. A witch hunt ensued. what he said was a mugshot of Crogan following an alleged arrest on unknown charges in Longwood, Fla., in Seminole County, way back in 1996. Perhaps coincidentally, the Seminole Tribe of Indians owns the Hard Rock Cafe, competitors of Crogan for outdoor festivals and music events in Niagara Falls. Florida police records show Crogan was never convicted of any crime in connection with the purported 1996 mug shot. Reaction from Dyster’s Facebook friends was swift and pretty brutal. Dozens commented that the mayor was attempting to convict the festival promoter without the benefit of a trial. “Let me clear--the City has not supported the festival financially, but lots of good people have a lot of time, money NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER “The Truth is Always Fair” CHAIRMAN & EDITOR IN CHIEF Frank Parlato PUBLISHER Peter Mio MANAGING EDITOR Dr. Chitra Selvaraj SENIOR EDITOR Tony Farina PHONE: (716) 284-5595 P.O. Box 3083, Niagara Falls, N.Y. 14304 Phone: E-mail: [email protected] Website: www.niagarafallsreporter.com All contents copyright © 2014 Niagara Falls Reporter Inc. and effort invested in making this event a success,” Dyster responded lamely. “It has been and I hope will in the future be a positive thing for the City. The volunteers associated with the festival are trying to keep something positive happening here regardless of the outcome of this situation. I shared this post because I was hoping someone could shed some light on previous history.” To this day, Dyster has not revealed where the purported mugshot came from, but there can be little doubt that the Crogan investigation was politically motivated. While the Hard Rock Café has never had to account for the more than $700,000 in taxpayer funding it has received for its downtown concert series, and Idaho promoter Mark Rivers was never asked to account for the $480,000 in public money he got to stage his disastrous 2011 Holiday Market fiasco here, Crogan’s personal bank records, along with those of the festival were seized and examined by a forensic accountant. Unsurprisingly, Dyster was a vocal advocate of both the Hard Rock concert series and the Holiday Market. And right up until Crogan turned down his offer of a public subsidy, he was also a strong supporter of the Niagara Music & Arts Festival, a fact underscored by an enthusiastic letter he wrote that was entered into evidence at the sentencing by Crogan’s attorney, Joseph L. Leone Jr. It’s an old saw among prosecutors that you can indict a ham sandwich, but they know better than most that getting a conviction is a different matter entirely. Still, to have three felony counts reduced in a plea agreement to a single count of petite larceny, a charge that would be brought against someone who took a pack of cigarettes from a convenience store, is virtually unheard of. For his part, Crogan said he accepted the deal only to spare his family the ordeal of a lengthy jury trial. The future of the festival is uncertain at this point, he added. “We have not decided on anything on the status of the festival right now,” Crogan said outside the courtroom. Judge Lewis said he was impressed by materials submitted to the court on Crogan’s behalf, including more than two dozen letters attesting to Crogan’s character. “I believe that your client is a good citizen who made bad choices,” Lewis said in court. The strange case of Rick Crogan offers further evidence that, in Niagara Falls at least, it’s not what you do, it’s who you are. And where’s the justice in that? NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 Crogan succeeded where others failed 3 Instead of being praised and honored for creating an event that “set the night on fire” in Niagara Falls, Crogan was attacked by people with political influence and charged with three felonies that prosecutors later learned they could never prove. When Crogan wouldn’t back down, they dropped the felonies and gave him a single shoplifting charge. The judge gave Crogan a conditional discharge. All this pain and suffering for Crogan, who really did nothing wrong, but maybe accidentally mislead a few people into thinking his operations were not for profit. But let’s be clear, no one delivered any money to him under false pretenses and no one lost any money. This should have never been prosecuted. At the end of the day, Renewal by Andersen got plenty of advertising and a business write-off. Andersen wrote checks to Crogan’s for profit business and clearly should have known his was not a not for profit. It is characteristic of Rick Crogan that, despite doing a great deal of good for the community, for which he should be praised not condemned, he took his chastisement in stride, sought to review his own mistakes- which were slight - and apologize for these (see below). The malicious people who went after him and tried to destroy his work are, in this publication’s view, far more culpable... An Apology From Rick Crogan I would like to personally reach out to the community, my friends and my family. Those who know me, know I am the type of person that takes responsibility for my actions and that is what I have done. I made the decision to accept a plea deal after careful consideration. I had to make the decision that was best for my family , my own personal health and the good of the community. Were things done wrong? Yes there were and I have learned from my mistakes and I have tried to make them right. There are many things that contributed to this happening and I so sorry that they got to where they ended up. I have let down so many people but I hope you all understand I never did anything intentionally or out of malice or greed. I know now what I did wrong and I take full accountability for those actions and ask that the community forgive me. I will continue to work whole heartedly for our city and I hope people will begin to trust me again. They will see my intentions have always been for the good of the community and the betterment of our city. I want to thank everyone that knows me and believes in me. I am humbled daily when people I don't know stop me on the streets to let me know that they support me and tell me that I need to stay strong, believe in myself and keep working hard for our city. That is what I plan on doing. Thank you again for your continued support and continued trust. Richard "Rick" Crogan 4 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 Mike Hudson Casino Cash Could be Used as Spur For Genuine Economic Development New York residents pay the highest average state and local taxes in the nation, averaging $9,718 per year, a whopping 39 percent higher than the national median. And if you’re unfortunate enough to live in Niagara County, and Niagara Falls in particular, you’re paying the highest taxes in the state. If you’re working and own property, that is. Well over half of Niagara Falls residents are on the receiving end of the equation, living on government benefits covered by those paying the nearly $200 a week surcharge imposed by the state, county and city governments for the privilege of living here. That tax burden, which is even worse for businesses than it is for individuals, is the single largest factor driving people away from New York and Niagara Falls in particular. Seriously, why would anybody who had a choice pay 39 percent more to live in a place where the weather is miserable, the crime rate is spiraling out of control and half the population is living on food stamps? They wouldn’t. Which is why the population of the city drops by around a thousand each and every year, a number that has remained fairly consistent for more than half a century. They go to Florida or North Carolina or Nevada, lured as much by the low tax rates as by the balmy weather. Niagara Falls Mayor Paul Dyster, who claims membership in the genius society Mensa, has offered up a novel approach to the problem: He has raised or attempted to raise taxes during most of his five years in office and squandered more than $100 million in revenue from the Seneca Niagara Casino on a number of windmill tilting projects that have brought no relief whatsoever to the city’s beleaguered taxpayers. Dyster argues that the casino cash can be used only for economic development. His idea of economic development has included free rock concerts by washed up bands no one would actually pay to see, a wintertime holiday market that cost $500,000 to stage and generated no revenue whatsoever, an Underground Railroad museum that’s been funded to the tune of nearly a million dollars in recent years and shows no sign of being open anytime soon and a multimillion dollar train station to serve the dozen or two Amtrack riders who come and go each day. After spending $100 million, Dyster’s economic development policies cannot lay claim to having created a single permanent, well paying job. Apparently not occurring to the mayor despite his high IQ is an economic development approach that would almost certainly result in the immediate creation of jobs and lure hard working, taxpaying residents back to the city: Using the casino revenue to cut taxes. Overnight, Niagara Falls could go from being perhaps the highest taxed municipality in the nation to the lowest. It would be a story the national media would eagerly cover, and entrepreneurs seeking tax relief would flock to the city from all across the country. No longer would Seth Piccirillo, the city’s community development director, have to pay recent college graduates to relocate to Niagara Falls, they’d come here on their own for the newly created jobs. And the city’s lending arm, NFC Development, would no longer need to dole out millions of taxpayer dollars to shady campaign contributors and political sycophants seeking to open saloons or remodel apartments, because private investors would be willing to put up their own cash for such enterprises, knowing they’d turn a profit. The value of real estate, which has fallen even faster than the population numbers, would skyrocket once the onerous tax burden was lifted. No longer would the state Parole Board send registered sex offenders and other felons to Niagara Falls because of the availability of cheap housing. All that said, what are the odds of Mayor Paul Dyster using casino cash to create a tax friendly enclave in Niagara Falls that would solve the myriad problems now confronting the city? Slim to none, and Slim just left town. Because Dyster doesn’t trust the free market, and believes that government is the solution to, not the cause of, the social and economic problems faced by the city. A child of the 60s, he’s a firm believer in the socialist concept that big government is better government, and that City Hall knows best when it comes to spending people’s hard earned money. He thinks that he and his appointees know best when it comes to developing business in the city, despite the fact that no one at City Hall has ever developed a business in real life. So long as he is mayor, Niagara Falls will remain one of the highest, if not the highest taxed municipalities in the entire country. Hardworking taxpayers will continue to flee, and business people will continue to shun the city as though it were diseased. Which is a shame, because it doesn’t have to be that way. NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 5 Falls Taxpayers can Learn a Casino-Cash Lesson From Sesame Street Anna M. Howard Niagara Falls - When one considers the condition of city government in particular, and of local politics in general, it’s only appropriate to use a children’s television program in order to illustrate a teachable moment regarding Mayor Paul Dyster’ abuse of taxpayer casino cash. There is a sing-song learning lesson on the Sesame Street show called “One of these things is not like the other.” It features for example three objects such as an apple, a banana and a shoe as the host sings: “One of these things is not like the other one of these things does not belong.” On Sesame Street the visuals are easy to grasp because they’re prepared for a pre-school audience. In the Dyster administration the casino cash visuals are quite tricky with those visuals appearing to be exactly alike, one to the other, with only Paul Dyster able to solve the difference. Woe to anyone – elected official, media, resident – who tries to tell the mayor, he’s wrong in his assessment, because the mayor will then spout nonsense about “I’m the casino cash gatekeeper… I won’t allow state law 99-H to be violated!” Consider these three items: Isaiah 61 allocation for a condemned fire hall, Community Missions allocation to defray a tax lien, and city public safety overtime allocation. Which one of these three was rejected by Dyster as not based in economic development and therefore ineligible for casino cash funding? Answer: public safety overtime. Yes, Mayor Dyster considers a casino cash award of $500,000 to fix up an old Mayor Paul Dyster says he decides what is proper use of casino cash for economic development. And lowering taxes just is not the plan. firehouse for the not for profit housing rehabilitation program operated by Isaiah 61 and a cash award to Community Missions of $150,000 to help relieve an IRS lien to be matters of economic development. In Dyster’s world using casino cash for police and fire protection is not economic development It gets even more confusing. Also considered casino cash eligible as matters of “economic development” are tree trimming, tree stump removal, rebidding the train station, constructing the train station, new automobiles for Code Enforcement, police overtime in the tourism district, parking consultants, pot hole machine rental, repaving the city hall parking lot, and the building of cart paths on the golf course, to name but a few. New Yorkers pay the highest average state and local taxes, at a wallet-busting $9,718 per year; that’s 39% higher than the national median. Even when adjusted for cost of living, New York still comes in dead last. Just this week the mayor added the $23,000 purchase of police body cameras to his list of eligible casino cash expenditures based, he claims, on economic development. So, no overtime for police and fire with casino cash, but overtime for police in the tourism district is okay and police body cameras are also acceptable casino cash expenditures. We aren’t going to debate the pros and cons of police body cameras, that’s not the subject of this article. We’re questioning the absolute capriciousness, the pure whimsy, with which Dyster approaches the taxpayer casino cash account. Confused? That’s because Mayor Dyster wants you to be confused. As long as the casino cash is confused and the legalities of the spending are unsettled law then he's free to refer to himself as “the gatekeeper of the casino cash account.” Nowhere in all of this foolishness is the Dyster administration hypocrisy more on display than in how the city controller and mayor first funded and then defunded (2011) and then re-funded (2014) the positions in the city’s economic development department. Prior to 2011, the economic development positions were paid for by casino cash. In 2011, Dyster declared that this was inappropriate use of casino cash and that salaries should not be funded. This year he said that casino cash should fund economic development positions. This funding and de-funding of the city hall economic development positions is the smoking gun that proves, beyond question, that the casino cash expenditures are written on the wind and solely in the control of Paul Dyster. With the adoption of the 2015 city budget it became clear that Mayor Dyster sees the taxpayer casino cash as his money to do with as he wishes. We now see, more clearly than ever, that he will continue to operate what in reality are two parallel, but never intersecting (unless he wants them to intersect) city budgets: one based on city casino money and the other based on “regular” city money. While the one budget suffers and taxes rise, the other budget is used to pay for train station re-bids, parking studies, new cars for city hall, awards to not for profits and other unsettled expenditures all carried out with Caesar-like authority by Dyster. It’s time to call a foul on the mayor and demand an end to his absolute control of the taxpayer casino account. 6 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 Dyster: “I’m The Gatekeeper of Casino Funds!” Anna M. Howard Niagara Falls Mayor Paul Dyster thinks he is the “gatekeeper of the casino cash.” I know this because he said so on the Tom Darro show last Wednesday. Allow me to explain why the mayor is wrong. First, there are no gates at city hall. The mayor’s office on the first floor has a door and inside sits the mayor. One floor above the mayor is the city council office. And, directly down the hall from the mayor’s office is the Council Chambers, where the council meets and deliberates before voting on items of city business. Many, if not most, of those items awaiting a council vote are from the mayor: such as casino cash expenditures that require council approval. The approval of casino cash expenditures are, a collaborative effort, a blending of two branches of government: the legislative Council and the executive Mayor. So, the mayor can’t spend casino cash without authorization of the city council. That council authorization should be by no means a rubber stamp. It should arrive after deliberation and the voting process. Like love and marriage, or a baby and a baby car- riage, the mayor and the council go together on casino expenditures…or they don’t go at all. While the mayor would have us believe that the casino cash is “mine all mine” to be divvied up as he sees fit via a routine procedural council vote that guarantees his profligate ways, the reality is quite the opposite. The casino funds are “city funds” that move to the city like bed tax, property tax, sales tax, state or federal appropriations and so on. The office of the mayor has no special hold or authority with regard to these casino monies…no more so than the usual responsibility to spend the funds honestly and in good faith with total transparency and with the support of a majority of the elected five members of the council. During his Darro performance the mayor went one step further to illustrate how he believes he is indeed the “decider in chief” when it comes to casino dollars. The mayor said, “the casino cash is like a family trust fund and I have to guard it.” No, Mr. Mayor, you aren’t the attorney for the Ford Foundation, you were elected to serve as mayor until such time as your term ends or you resign. A trust fund is a trust fund and a casino cash account is a casino cash account. That’s why they’re called by different names. As Malcolm X famously said, “You can put a shoe in an oven but that doesn’t make it a biscuit.” Mayor Dyster’s use of the language is troubling. Troubling not because it’s manipulative and heavyhanded, but troubling because his remarks betray a fundamental misunderstanding of mayoral powers…the mayor is over-reaching and he thinks we don’t notice. The casino cash resulted from the “city” losing 52 acres of prime downtown land and their convention center. The city’s “take” from the Seneca Niagara casino is 25% of the state’s 25% of casino slot revenue. That is city taxpayer money. No, Mr. Mayor you are not the “gatekeeper” and you are not a “trust fund” attorney and you do not have unilateral powers to spend casino dollars, because the very process you use to spend those dollars sends you through the “gate” of the city council…a gate the council can figuratively close in your face if they choose. And then you’d be unable to spend those casino dollars. Mr. Mayor, let’s have less talk about gate keeping and lawyers and trust funds and more talk about cooperation, transparency and what’s good for the residents of Niagara Falls. Another Skrlin Masterpiece: Budge It The artist continues his masterful use of language as a double edged sword. In this case he is posing "budge" against "budget" while presenting comical yet realistic - in terms of the two power positions they hold within Niagara Falls City Hall - images of the City Controller and the Mayor. How better to illustrate the perceived relationship between the all knowing, all powerful, all controlling Controller and Mayor than to feature her happily aboard the Mayor as she directs him to the "money" to the "cash" to the, as it were, the "love" that has so sadly driven Paul Dyster's City Hall...at great expense to the residents as they most recently were handed tax increases by the Mayor and Controller. The artist is saying that the city government has given in to the craven drive for money and personal power which comes at the cost of both good government and taxpayer dollars. Like a monstrous turtle (note the Frankenstein Monster head of the mayor) that moves slowly but inevitably toward the brink of the falls the entire sad scenario is in the reins (or is it cleverly "reigns") of the city controller. --Rockwell Peabody NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 2015 Budget Wrap-Up Glenn Choolokian Niagara Falls Councilman Now that the 2015 city budget process is behind us, there’s one thing that we – residents, media, elected officials – can agree on: the process was a glaring example of bad government and poor communication. Non-transparency, shifting financial information and a working document that the mayor withheld from the council for 37 days guaranteed that the end product would be costly to the residents through increased taxes and mismanaged taxpayer dollars. While the confusion over the budget was constant throughout its preparation, I want to note that steps were taken to limit that confusion and improve the budget as received by the council from Mayor Paul Dyster. After receiving the mayor’s budget I contacted my council colleagues and requested that we discuss ways to improve the mayor’s document. For days I emailed and spoke to my fellow council members regarding the need for us to act quickly in light of the 37-day delay. After we got together I presented more than 80 budget resolutions. The only way a proposed mayoral budget can be changed is through such resolutions. I was sincerely trying to improve the budget that the mayor handed us: a budget with job cuts, services threatened, and big tax increases. At the end of this difficult budget process the council adopted many of my resolutions. Many of those resolutions involved the use of casino funds to address problem areas. I won’t use this column to debate the mayor’s use of casino cash except to say that until the mayor and council work together to write a casino cash spending plan, the confusion over what is and isn’t acceptable as a casino cash expense will only increase. Having said that I believe the mayor has no intention of writing a casinospending plan because he seems to enjoy the confusion regarding these funds. That confusion gives him cover as he disburses the cash. The Dyster administration is suffering not only from a serious fiscal deficit but also from an unacceptable transparency deficit. How can the council improve the budget, and how can the residents understand the city finances when the deficit and budget numbers are a moving target that begin their confusing movement in August before coming to rest as the budget is approved in December? Monday morning budget quarterbacks like to say “The budget figures are available to the council any time they want them and they have no excuse for being confused!” Recent city budget history has shown that the city deficit, city revenue, and the delivery of the working budget by the mayor has been an exercise in non-transparency and administrative irregularities. At the end of the day I believe this nontransparency is practiced to frustrate the good intentions of the council and the interests of concerned residents. Which brings me to the 2013 audit of city finances by the New York State Comptroller. That audit was the result of hundreds of hours of work performed by the Comptroller’s staff out of Buffalo. Chief among the audit recommendations was that the city should stop using “one-shot” gimmicks to close operating deficits. The audit reported that the city was paying out more money than it was taking in and had created a recurring structural deficit. After the audit was delivered the Dyster administration refused to fix the problem and to this day is still using oneshot gimmicks to close the repeating deficit. If that weren’t bad enough the mayor keeps handing out overtime, raises and stipends as if it was Christmas. And on top of this he’s built more parks, created more over-head, and still has not addressed how he will fund the operation of his train station. In the meantime the mayor continues to hire consultants while contracting out increasing amounts of law and engineer The evolution of the Niagara Falls taxpayer.... work. Incredibly, he now wants to open his own animal shelter! Transparency, communication, a casino cash-spending plan and the good advice of the NYS Comptroller are all we 7 need to improve our finances. This city is failing and it’s failing in the face of a casino cash windfall. It looks like Mayor Dyster didn’t get the memo. 8 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 Frank Parlato It was a year of breaking stories, railing against injustice and taking on the big shots. That's what the Niagara Falls Reporter does. Every year. Over the course of the year we exposed some wrongdoings that got addressed, some that got partly addressed and some that continued on their merry way despite exposure that in a cleaner more transparent kind of government with alert people - would have died from the sunlight. Throughout the year we harped on general injustice. The growing fascist state that is America, the lack of respect for its people, the lack of understanding of freedom principles that made this nation great. And the ignoring of them - while creating the nanny big government state which is destroying America. We believe in freedom. Among the topics we wrote about is the legalization of the plant known as marijuana - based on freedom principles. The repeal of the monstrous SAFE Act, which curbs the people's second amendment rights with a form of arbitrary and capricious meddling by government into the people's right to bear arms. We wrote about the First Amendment and of lowering taxation. One of our stories was "Income Equality Another Name for Communism" and we railed against the DREAM Act and Cuomo's plan for taxpayers to pay for college for convicts. And we got into the topic of jury nullification, where the jury can veto laws on a case by case basis. We started our series in March with "Jury Nullification, legalization of marijuana and high taxes." But our main work was local coverage. We inveigled against the stupendous waste of money that Niagara Falls Mayor Paul Dyster seems to love. After all, Niagara Falls get some $20 million per year in casino cash and it is broke. The headlines tell the story - of the almost one million words we wrote this year: Among the headlines were: "City Rolls Through Casino Windfall in Short Order; Dyster Administration Squandered Millions" (April1) "There But For the Grace of the Casino Goes Dyster" (Sept 2) "A Simple Plan: Use Seneca Casino Money To Reduce Property Taxes, Period! (Sept 2) "Niagara Falls Needs a Casino Cash-Spending Plan...Yesterday”(Sept 9); "Gaming Industry Future Uncertain While City Pins Hopes on Comeback; Competition Stiffens for Seneca Niagara As New Casinos Open Just About Everywhere" (Sept 16) "Controller's Report Reflects Drop in Casino Cash", "Casino Revenue Cut by $1.4 Million; Dyster Wants $1.5 Million for State", "Dyster Use of FastDisappearing Casino Funds Shape Shifts From Economic Development to Day-to Day Expenses" (Nov 4). Occasionally the Niagara Falls council would listen and refuse to heap casino The Year 2014; It was a Very Good Year The Reporter frequently criticized Mayor Paul Dyster’s use of taxpayer money to throw concerts and beer parties. money on Dyster's hare brained schemes, but for the most part it was a waste of ink: the majority of the council are not convinced that tax reduction is economic development. We also harped on the new train station, saying it is unneeded. We alone of all media revealed that only about nine passengers come to Niagara Falls per day and we alone took the position that this is hardly justification for building a $45 million train station. While the other media argued for Dyster saying that most of the money is provided by federal and state money to build the new train station, we pointed out that the city still has to kick in millions to build it and will have to pay millions more to maintain and operate it. We predict that the train station will be a huge, empty and expensive to maintain building and may perhaps be one day shuttered. We wrote about it frequently: "Groundbreaking Event for Train Station Attracts 150; Number at ceremony far exceeds expected ridership (June 10) "Train Station Just Wasteful Foolishness" (June 17) and "Dyster Poetic As He Exaggerates New Train Station Impact." Throughout the year we fought Covanta Niagara's expansion plan to bring New York City garbage to Niagara Falls by the trainload. The Reporter broke the story of how rats were besieging the LaSalle neighborhood and many believed that Covanta garbage was the reason. We broke the story of the rats, exposed how Covanta was getting huge tax breaks, and, as one of our stories’ headline read, "Despite the Spin, Covanta Is a Polluter." We predicted Covanta will expand further, with more air pollution and more rats. Some of our stories: "Dead Babies, Pollution, Rat Infestation, All Part and Parcel of Covanta's Business... But They're Giving us $25k for a Park" (May 6) "Rats Invade, Torment Neighborhood in LaSalle" (Sept 16) "Dyster Plays King as Rats Take Control in LaSalle" (Sept 23) "Covanta Expansion a Done Deal? Magic Eight Ball Says YES!" (Oct 7) We had better success against Quasar's plan to spread human manure on farms in Niagara County. In this we were aided by thousands of people who protested it. We wrote "Quasar Trying to Feed Us a Load of Equate, Company Wants to Spread Sewage Extract on Farm Fields" (Apr 08) "Quasar Hires Top Environmental PR/Crisis Management Firm," "Company Faces Opposition over spreading human manure on local farms." (May 6) and other stories. Throughout the year, we poked fun at Dyster and his love of beer with stories such as "State of the Art of Beer," "The Art of Beer Coming Soon," All Beer All the Time in Dyster-World" "Beer, Football and Facebook, Mayor's Interests like College Student" and "Dyster At and On Oktoberfest - and its Beer". When we read an interview with Dyster saying he gave his phone number out which we knew to be untrue - we gave it out for him. On March 11 we wrote, "Reporter Provides Dyster's Home Phone Number to Man with a Problem," and on June 24 "Dyster's Cell Phone and Private Email Addresses Revealed So He Can be the Man of the People He claims." And we pointed out how, while the rest of the free world loved Nik Wallenda, Mayor Dyster sought to (successfully ) keep him from developing in Niagara Falls. We wrote: "Nik Wallenda: Beyond Paul Dyster" and "Was Dyster Really Against Wallenda?" (Feb 25) "Niagara Falls Let Wallenda Get Away, And for that, Darien Lake is Happy" (April 15). In January we took a contrarian position with our story on Robert Elder: "On Elder Sex Abuse Case, Slow Down He May Be Innocent" Elder a former council candidate was accused (and we believed falsely) by a young girl of fondling her. We did some investigation and discovered it appeared to be a lie. We wrote it as we saw it. Later in the year the charges were dismissed against Elder. On September 9 we had the pleasure of publishing "Elder Exonerated of Child Sex Charges Just as we Thought." We hit again with "Petrolgate" a scandal about how Lewiston town officials kept gas thefts by two policemen a secret. We not only exposed the thefts but named the two officers involved and what their penalties were: One was fired and the other suspended for 45 days. Early in the year we also were first to break the story that Niagara Falls was ranked as One of the Most Dangerous Cities in America by Neighborhood Scout, and later broke the story that it was ranked as the most dangerous in the state by My Life. We had our share of shocking stories like "Teacher Convicted of Attempted Statutory Rape Gets Job at Niagara Falls Water Board" and "Child Protective Services Keeps Mom Away From Terminally Ill Daughter" (Feb 11) the latter which was the inside story on how a young girl with cancer was denied the right to see her mother. Last week, we reported on how it all ended, "Bureaucratic Indifference, New York Style Contributes to Little Girl's Suffering, Death" with the death of the 8year-old and how she might have been saved by medical marijuana. And in February, while pipes were freezing on 72nd St in LaSalle and Mayor Dyster was making it sound mysterious, we went over there, checked it out, talked to contractors and figured it out: When the Dyster administration did the road work, they did not bury the water lines below the freeze line. Our stories "Frozen Water Lines on 72nd Street Caused by Another Botched Engineer-less Dyster Road Job" and "Frozen Water-Gate... Icy Deception Real Blame for Frozen Lines Belongs to Water Board" did not fix the problem but it at least stopped Dyster from blaming it on everyone but himself. Throughout the year, we wrote about sex offenders in Niagara Falls - which has the highest percentage of registered sex offenders in New York with stories as (Mar 11) "Man Shares Concerns Over Sex Offenders Living in LaSalle" (May 6) "More Sexual Predators on Chilton Avenue? Dyster Props up Population Once Again" (May 27) "More New Sex Offenders Than College Grads Under Piccirillo, Dyster Plans" (July 22) "Sex Offender Epidemic Reporter Reviews It’s Coverage for the year Growing Larger Here With Every Passing Day" (Nov 18) Pescrillo's Chilton Ave. Warehouse For Sex Offenders Now Strictly a Money Maker" Our hard hitting stories on the dereliction of the Lewiston Town Board under the leadership of former supervisor Steven Reiter was widely credited for the sudden resignations of two board members Ernie Palmer and Mike Marra. On Mar 4, we predicted that William Conrad would replace Palmer: "Conrad Seen As Possible Favorite Among Candidates to Replace Palmer". Among our breaking stories on Reiter -which for the first time got the former supervisor on the record explaining his theft of gas from the people of Lewiston were (Feb 25) "Former Supervisor May Have Stuffed His Pockets With More Than Gas" (Mar 4) "What Else Did He Steal? Comptroller's Office Looking Into Reiter" (Mar 11) "State Auditors Looking at Joseph Davis Park, More Than $1.5 Million Spent, Much of it Missing, (April 8) "New Scandal Hits Lewiston; Worker's Use of Diesel Fuel Questioned, His Job Terminated" . While the stories were entertaining, and the former supervisor a colorful and lovable rogue, it did not mean too much. People shook their heads and laughed and waited for out next edition. Then we sunk out teeth into something more meaty in Lewiston: The planned Senior complex on Reiter's mother's land happened to have been rezoned (by Reiter) and was, we suspected, sure to be other than what was promised. We wrote a series of stories: We began with (Mar 25) "Modern Lawsuit Names Reiter, Town, in Battle over Zoning of Reiter Land; Washuta Seeks Injunction to Halt Senior Complex As Illegally ReZoned". From there we wrote about it almost every week, finding out new facts: (April 1) "New Revelations in Reiter Modern Lawsuit Make the Entire Matter Curious; Reiter Said He Had No Ownership Interest but Documents Say Otherwise" (April 22) "The Story Behind Lewiston's Bridgewater Estates … Reveal More Reiter Subterfuge" (April 29) "Reiter, 19 Percent a Liar? Who's the Owner? Timeline Shows Sloma, Reiter Deeply Involved In Bridgewater's Raft of Surprisingly Lax Approvals" (May 6) "Plot Thickens as Reiter's Planned Senior Housing in Lewiston Looks More Like Low Income Housing Project" (May 13) "The Scam At Reiterville Worsens as Facts Emerge, Media Catches On" (May 20) "Judge Asks Pointed Questions About Reiter's Involvement in Bridgewater Project," (May 27) "Bridgewater Lawyer Claims Reiter Not an Owner But Facts, Common Sense Tell a Different Story" (June 3), "Crucial Day Coming for Bridgewater, Zoning Board Can Send Developers Packing" (June 10) "Lewiston Bridgewater Project Set for Town Zoning Showdown" (June 17) "Bridgewater Site was Pre-70's Gas Station and Body Shop Yet No Environmental Study!" and finally we wrote the death knell story on June 24, "Future Looking Bleak for Bridgewater". It was bleak. Town Board Cancels Bridgewater SEQRA Approvals, Developers Must Start From Scratch! (July 1) The ill advised project was withdrawn. Sometimes no matter how often we write about it, no one in power pays attention. Take the case of the overrated maybe - never- to-be-built Hamister hotel. Not only did we not stop the city from giving away a multi-million dollar piece of city-owned land to corporate welfare developer Mark Hamister for a mere $100,000 and not only did we rightly predict that Hamister would downgrade his hotel, but it did not matter: the government gave him more money and no one seems to have caught on that the taxpayers got the shaft on this one. That did not stop us from trying. We wrote "All Quiet on the Hamister Front, Too Quiet" (May 20); "Hamister Hotel Project Just a Hyatt? Developer Announces Even More Delays"(June 24); "Hamister's Proposed Hyatt Place More Appropriate Near Airport," (July 1) "Hamister's Hotel Not Quite a Game Changer"; (July 15) "Hamister's Hyatt Place Still Not a Done Deal"; "WGRZ 10 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 Reporter year-end review (cont): win some, lose some.... Joins Reporter and Gets it; Hamister Hotel Doubtful." (Oct 7); "Hamister Hotel Project Scaled Back, No Comment From Dyster, Cuomo," (Oct 28) and "Hamister Project Falls Short of Hype". Keep in mind the jury is still out. Hamister is more than a year late in getting started. It remains to be seen whether he builds next year or at all. Then there was the scandals at the state park. The Reporter is the only publication that calls out the Niagara Falls State Park for being a business in competition with the city, and favoring Albany interests over the city, while pretending to be a partner with the city. We broke the shocking story about how the Niagara Falls State Park was being "improved" by tearing out the old limestone paths and installing $60 per square foot granite only available from one supplier in Albany. "Prospect Point Improvement Plan Includes Use of Overpriced Granite" (Mar 4) "Granite-Gate Part 2 Saratoga Husband and Wife Team Develop and Execute Plans for Expensive Granite in State Park" (Mar 25), "Saratoga Springs Reaps Big Rewards From Niagara Falls State Park Project" (April 29) and other stories told a tale of waste if not corruption. Other stories condemned the park’s plans such as "New One-Way Robert Moses South Parkway Plan Directs Motorists to State Park, Avoiding City and its Businesses" (April 1) "De-Olmsteding Park Promotes Short Stays" (June 3) "Reporter Calls on State Park to Restore Public Access to All of Three Sisters Islands" (Nov 18) and many others. Then there was the story of how Gov Andrew Cuomo gave the Maid of the Mist owner a $100 million gift of taxpayer money when he handed a 30 year lease to the politically connected James Glynn. We wrote plenty on this: "Sleek, Modern Hornblower Fleet A New Standard in Niagara Basin, Elderly Maid of the Mist tubs harken back to 1970s", "Ontario gets Millions While New Yorkers Settle for Broken Down Boat Ride in Deal", "Hornblower Appeal to be Heard Sept 3, Seeks to overturn Glynn no bid Maid of the Mist deal", "Politicos Here Love Maid of the Mist Deal That Cost Taxpayers Millions in Revenue", were some of the stories we wrote this year. Another was "State Park for Sale: Glynn Gets More Than Half the Total Revenue in the Niagara Falls State Park," (June 3) and "Hornblower Lawyer 'We Will Pay $100M more than Glynn!'" (Aug 5). One of our biggest victories of the year was breaking the story of the State Parks Police plan of building new barracks right on the gorge. The resultant outcry from the people and other media following our story stopped the project. We broke the story with "New State Parks Police Barracks to Mar Niagara Gorge, Proposed Building Mockery of Development Plans", (May 27). Later we wrote: "Plans Halted for Parks Police Barracks" (June 17). Over the summer, we took on Artpark The Reporter opposed the Covanta plan to bring in NYC garbage. and their ridiculous need to burden taxpayers with their concerts. With the help of Lewiston Supervisor Dennis Brochey, we scored some success as Artpark's subsidies were reduced. Our stories included "Tax, Drugs and Rock and Roll - Brochey Calls Out Artpark (Apr 29) "Fight Continues Over Subsidizing Artpark & Company", "Ringo Starr Concert is Subsidized by the Town" (June 24) "Megadeth slated to Perform at Artpark Next Week, Decadent band to be subsidized by Lewiston, State" (July 8) "Erie County Business Leaders Run Artpark like Some Private Club," (July 8). In July we broke the inside story on George Maziarz's sudden retirement and wrote the comprehensive "Maziarz Retirement Marks End of Era in Niagara County Politics (July 15). We opposed Mayor Dyster's mania to fund with the people's money concerts by Hard Rock and other concert promoters. In this we scored some victories, thanks in large part to councilman Andrew Touma who wouldn't support giving the billion dollar Hard Rock Corp. the taxpayers' money. "Dyster Attempt to Revive Hard Rock Concerts Shot Down by City Council (May 13) "Taxpayers Sing the Blues as Dyster Squanders Their Cash" (July 8) "Dyster Hastily Pulls Funding Resolution After Touma Puts $10K Cap on Blues Funding" "Fuzzy Math Behind Dyster's Argument to Throw Public Money at Blues Concert" (July 22) "Taxpayers to Foot Bill for Dyster's New Year's Eve Hard Rock Gala (Dec 9) were some of the stories we loved to write. A series of stories on the city budget started in October when Mayor Paul Dyster was supposed to deliver his budget. We continued to criticize Dyster on his lack of a spending plan for casino cash and his lack of transparency on all budget matters. "Exploding the City Budget and Finance Myths," "Dyster's Disappearing Budget Demands Explanation," "The Reporter Offers to 'Restructure' City Finances" and "No Rhyme or Reason to Justify Dyster's Casino Cash Spending", were some of our favorite stories. One of our more popular stories this year was the revelation of the true reason why former Lockport Mayor Michael Tucker resigned suddenly. "Former Lock- port Mayor's Resignation Alleged as an Attempt to Reign in Scandal" broke on May 13. Our next story "Lockport Woman Describes Sexual Degradation at Hands of Ex-Mayor, Says Tucker used office to coerce sexual gratification" (May 20) was equally well read. Like many stories which are more entertaining than change-oriented, this one quickly ran its course. We "discovered" cartoonist Gerald Skrlin, who rose to celebrity, as it were, when a cartoon of his lampooning Acting City Controller Maria Brown got Acting Mayor Kristen Grandinetti and Brown so upset that they tried to have the distributor of the cartoon arrested. While the offending cartoon was not published in other media, naturally the Reporter published it, despite it being what some might call in bad taste. We reported on crime, from the very serious to the minor, almost laughably stupid criminality that often happens here. Mike Hudson's This Week in Stupid Crime was a popular column throughout the year. We published guest views from a series of distinguished local residents and opinion makers such as Councilmen Glenn Choolokian and Robert Anderson, Memorial Hospital CEO Joseph Ruffolo, NF School Supt. Cynthia Bianco, political writer Roger Stone, Hornblower CEO, Terry MaCrae, and Hornbower lawyer Richard Jacobs, attorney Robert Restaino, Former Councilman Sam Fruscione, ExFBI Agent J. Gary DiLaura, former City administrator Tom Lizardo and many others. We broke the story of Dyster's planned reelection campaign when we reported his first ultra private fund raiser at the Red Coach. The Reporter also did a series of stories on the streets of Niagara Falls: "Prostitutes Interviewed While at Work" (Nov 4) "Police Work in the 'Most Dangerous' City" (Nov 18) "Drug Culture Seen Through the Eyes of Local Addicts" (Dec 03) were among our best read stories of the year. We also wrote about the travesty at Jayne Park with "Me Dyster, You Jayne Park, Will Mayor revisit Unpopular Plan?" (Aug 5) "Jayne Park Plans Not Final But City is Moving Fast Forward to Spend Grant" (Aug 19) "Sunday in the Park with Paul, The Mayor Discovers Cayuga Island in Time for Reelection" (Sept 2) and other stories on the decimation of the once beautiful local park in order to blow off some grant money. We also broke the story of Dyster's reverse sized garbage totes and his new trash plan. It led ultimately to the council allowing residents to have larger totes for refuse. Some of our stories were "Dyster Garbage Plan Utter Trash" (June 3) "Possible Solutions to the Flawed Garbage Plan" (June 17) "Garbage Plan is Set, City Forging Ahead for Aug 1 Deadline Without Regard to the People's Protests" (July 1) "Complicated New Garbage Ordinance To Penalize Landlords, Small Business" "Dyster trash plan and enforcement dumps on residents" (July 8). "Big Brother In Your Garbage Cans? New Totes Have RFID Chips to Monitor Recycling" "What Kind of Green is Dyster's Garbage Plan?" "New Recycle Totes: Big Green and Insatiable" (July 22). From the start, we criticized Community Development Director Seth Piccirillo's bizarre plan to have taxpayers pay recent college graduates to live in Niagara Falls and predicted it would be a dismal failure. On April 8 we got the pleasure of saying "I told you so" with our story "Bold Initiative to Pay People to Live Here Attracts Just Seven Lost Souls." We did a lot of one shot stories that had big impacts such as "Lewiston Residents Paid for Tango, Moonwalking, Abacus, Records Show" (June 3); "Failed Parking Lot at Joe Davis Leads to Investigation," (July 1); "Albion Gun Shop Records Taken, Gun Owner Arrested, as SAFE Act Enforcement Barrels Down" (Sept 2); "Bid Rigging in Lockport? RFP for Voting Booth Storage Seemed 'TailorMade' to Favor Ulrich" (September 9); "Isaiah 61 Storefront Condemned, While Dyster Does God's Work With Casino Cash," (Sept 23) "Isaiah 61 Founder Slips Out of Town After City Approves Casino Cash Deal", (Oct 7) "Muslim Center, Mosque May be Coming to Wheatfield … at Location of Suzanne's Fine Dining," (Oct 21) and "Water Board Bigwigs Take Pay, Benefits Hikes Back to Where They Really Live", (Nov 4). Finally we tried to explain the budget process to the residents of this city. Stories such as "With $9 M Deficit, Cuts Won't Come Easy", "Late Budget Should Come as no Surprise Neither Should Size of Deficit", "Dyster Deficit by Any Other Name Means Higher Taxes" "Oh, Budget How do I Cut Thee... Let Me Count the Ways" and "Reporter Proposes to Solve City Budget Woes”. The Reporter wishes to thank its able writers - Mike Hudson, Tony Farina, Anna M. Howard, Chitra Selvaraj and James Hufnagel and of course its readers. We had a pretty good year. Stick around. Next year promises to be even better. 12 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 13 16 DAILY PROGRAMS O/N BOCES **There are no fees for these programs. **ADULT BASIC EDUCATION/HIGH SCHOOL EQUIVALENCY This course is designed for the adult learner interested in completing their High School Equivalency diploma. It is also recommended for anyone who has been away from school for a long period of time or for those who feel they need prior preparation for the TASC Exam. The course reviews the basics of English, Mathematics and Reading. Applications are available at the Community Education Center. The course and TASC exam are free of charge. New York State has selected a new high school equivalency test called the TACS™ to replace the GED® as the primary pathway to a NYS High School Equivalency Diploma. Stephanie Bevacqua Call for information: 286-0768 **ENGLISH AS A SECOND LANGUAGE FOR THE FOREIGN BORN Developed for the adult learner to read and speak the English Language. Joan Caldwell Call for information: 286-0772 **NATIONAL EXTERNAL DIPLOMA PROGRAM (NEDP) This is a non-instructional program that incorporates a variety of assessment techniques, which are designed for the adult learner who has acquired academic skills through life experiences. The techniques include home projects, performance assessments, interviewing and documentation review. NEDP provides competent adults with the opportunity to earn a regular, High School diploma. Qualifications: 21 years and older. Erica Kopp Call for information: 278-8154 Stephanie Bevacqua Call for information: 286-0768 CERTIFIED NURSING ASSISTANT PROGRAM The program consists of ten weeks of instructional classes held at the Niagara Falls City School District Community Education Center. The clinical instruction is held at Our Lady Peace Nursing Home. You will receive a New York State certification upon successful completion of the program. Cost to be determined. Qualifications: 21 years and older with no high school diploma Terry Josker Call for information: 731-4176 ext. 4445 SPECIAL INTERESTS SO YOU WANT TO BE A CLOWN – PART I Come one, come all. This hands-on, interactive class will have you on your way to becoming a great clown. Get introduced to the art of clowning by exploring the history of clowning and learning about the different types of clowns. Discover your own clown persona and receive helpful hints on putting together a fascinating costume and the art of developing your clown face using grease paint. Other items covered but not limited to, are: balloon animals, basic magic tricks, plate spinning and juggling. (Minimum of 5 students required.) Beverly Eiler NFHS Weds., 5 weeks, 1/14 – 2/11, 6:30 – 8:30 pm $35.00 SO YOU WANT TO BE A GREAT CLOWN - PART II This class is designed as a continuation of Clowning – Part I for students that would like to expand their knowledge and skills. In this class we will continue with balloon animals, magic tricks, juggling, puppetry, storytelling, skits and performing at birthday parties. Students continue to learn skills enabling them to become a great clown. At the end of this five-week session, all clowns will participate in a graduation ceremony, enabling all students to show off their skills in front of family, friends and other clowns. Supply costs vary depending on the skills the students want to pursue. (Minimum of 5 students required.) Beverly Eiler NFHS Weds., 5 weeks, 2/18 – 3/18, 6:30 – 8:30 pm $35.00 INTRODUCTION TO COMPUTERS FOR SENIOR CITIZENS If learning how to use a computer is something you have been putting off, this is the class for you! This class is designed as an introduction to computers for beginning students ...like you! Class 17 starts with “Here’s the on button.” You will become familiar with the very basics that include parts of the computer, how to use the mouse, games, searching the Internet & email. Class size will be limited to a small group for more one-on-one help and instruction. (Maximum of 7, minimum of 5 students required for each class.) Carol Hartwig CEC 205 6 weeks, Tues. Jan. 13 – Feb. 17 3:00-5:00 pm $45.00 Fitness program targeting upper and lower body, abs, legs and buttocks – plus cardiovascular workout (bring hand weights). Susana Nicholas CEC (60th St.) Gym Tues & Thurs 7:008:00 pm $45.00 SWIMNASTICS Have fun getting fit with stretching, toning, water exercise in the pool. This program is suitable for those with or without swimming background. Experience increased flexibility, stomach, and cardiovascular benefits. (Limit 12) Each class is $30.00. FITNESS ACTIVITIES GOLF FOR BEGINNERS AND INTERMEDIATES The grip, stance, and basic mechanics of swing taught along with club use, rules, etiquette, and procedure of play and other facets of golf. Bring a 2’ x 2’ rug sample (mat), a wood #5, 6, or 7 iron club and 6 or more wiffle balls. Please wear soft sole shoes. (Minimum 6, Limit 12 students). Tom Etopio at CEC (60th St.) Gym 7:00-8:00 pm $30.00 TOTAL BODY WORKOUT Mon., Susana Nicholas Susana Nicholas Susana Nicholas Susana Nicholas Susana Nicholas Susana Nicholas Susana Nicholas Susana Nicholas Susana Nicholas CEC Pool CEC Pool CEC Pool CEC Pool CEC Pool CEC Pool CEC Pool CEC Pool CEC Pool Mon 10:00-11:00 am $30.00 Mon 11:00-12:00 pm $30.00 Mon 6:30-7:30 pm $30.00 Tues 9:00-10:00 am $30.00 Tues 10:00-11:00 am $30.00 Wed 11:00 am-12:00 pm $30.00 Wed 6:30-7:30 pm $30.00 Thurs 10:00-11:00 am $30.00 Thurs 11:00-12:00 pm $30.00 AEROBIC DANCE (DANCE IT) Is there a closet dancer hidden deep inside you? Join Dance It, and set her free!! Dance It’s a well-balanced, whole body workout that allows you to strengthen your cardiovascular system, using all the muscles in your body. The up-beat, inspirational music carries us through the movements needed to release our everyday stresses. This program is geared for dancers and non-dancers who thrive in an atmosphere where FUN is a big part of fitness. Susana Nicholas CEC (60th St.) Gym Mon & Wed 5:30-6:30 pm $45.00 Susana Nicholas CEC (60th St.) Gym Tues & Thurs 6:00-7:00 pm $45.00 WATERWALKING Exercise your entire body with added benefit of water resistance. One-half hour equals two hours of street walking. (Limit 10) Susana Nicholas Susana Nicholas CEC Pool CEC Pool Mon. Noon-1 pm Wed. Noon-1 pm $30.00 $30.00 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 It Took a While, but Cuomo Bans Fracking Tony Farina It took six years, but at the end of the day Gov. Andrew Cuomo has risked the wrath of the energy industry and made permanent the ban against hydraulic fracturing in New York. The experts in health and conservation under Cuomo were in agreement that there was an absence of reliable health studies or proof that drillers can protect the public as well diminishing economic prospects associated with fracking. Hydraulic fracturing is a well-stimulation technique in which rock is fractured by a hydraulically pressurized liquid to extract shale gas, tight gas, tight oil, and coal steam gas. While the energy industry supports fracturing for its economic benefits, opponents have raised concerns about the environmental impact of the process including contamination of ground water. According to poll figures, New Yorkers are about equally divided about fracking, but Cuomo has supported his health commissioner’s view that he wouldn’t want his family to live near it [fracturing] and 19 suggested it could be like secondhand smoke, which studies have found to be harmful. “If the state health commissioner [Howard Zucker] doesn’t want his kids living there, then I don’t want my kids living there and I don’t want any New Yorker’s kids living there. I am not going to put health at risk for jobs. I’m not going to make that choice.” While Cuomo has come under fire for his decision from business interests in the Southern Tier, some of whom may see his decision as one based in politics, he has won praise from environmentalists who say he made the right decision for the safety of New Yorkers. The decision by the governor certainly plays well among his liberal followers in New York and maybe beyond the state’s borders as many believe he still harbors presidential ambitions down the road. Dyster Press Release May Signal Intention to Overturn Frackwater Ban Frack waste water treatment not banned by Cuomo decision James Hufnagel There's no doubt that Gov. Andrew Cuomo wanted fracking in upstate New York. He wanted fracking so bad he could taste it. Fracking is practiced in dozens of other states, particularly presidential election swing states like Ohio and Pennsylvania. It wouldn’t have looked good on a presidential candidate to be banning the practice outright. Last year’s State Energy Master Plan draft, prepared by the Cuomo administration, indicated that fracked natural gas will play a key role in the state’s energy portfolio over the next decade. Fracking probably could have provided a short-term windfall of jobs and tax revenues in certain economically-depressed southern tier counties, gold rushstyle. Like most gold rushes, it would have meant five or ten years of prosperity, and ruined land and water for good. That’s why Cuomo's first policy position on fracking, years ago, was to prohibit it on hundreds of square miles of New York City watershed. “But if the rednecks of Tioga and Steuben counties want to frack, let ‘em frack,” the governor can be imagined saying. When the Reporter first broke the story in July of 2011 that the Niagara Falls Water Board was planning to import millions of gallons of produced water from gas wells (“frackwater”) for treatment and discharge into the Niagara River, we were aware of two trips Water Board Executive Director Paul Drof had made to Albany to meet with Cuomo’s people on the proposal. A full year later, it was learned from a Water Board insider that Drof had, in fact, made multiple trips to Albany, and the logistics of importation and processing of frackwater at the Buffalo Avenue plant had reached an advanced stage of planning. All these clues, and others, led many to believe that the governor was going to allow fracking on some limited basis. So last week's decision came as something of a surprise. There are three reasons Cuomo jilted the frackers. The first was the enormously effective and diverse coalition of opponents, including farmers, teachers, parents, sportsmen, health professionals, local elected officials, scientists and even wineries, applying unrelenting political pressure. The second was the proliferation of town and village “frack bans”, and the courts’ finding them constitutional, making drilling in New York State far too risky and economically unfeasible. The third was the long-awaited NYS Dept. of Health report released last week, that details fracking’s deleterious impacts on respiratory health, drinking water, earthquake activity and climate change, as well as soil contamination, noise and air pollution, distressing increases in both traffic fatalities and birth defects. The body of evidence against fracking is large and growing, and peer-reviewed science doesn’t lie. Apparently, even Gov. Cuomo couldn’t stomach the idea of significant portions of upstate becoming an environmental Hooverville a few short years from now when the natural gas is depleted and the oil and gas men And who will volunteer to take the first drink? have all gone back to Texas and Oklahoma. Democrats all over the state, particularly those who consider themselves “moderates” (such as those who lost US Senate seats last month in the Republican landslide), broke their longstanding silence on fracking practically within minutes of the Governor’s announcement. Public officials who had kept silent on fracking, expressing no opinions or leadership over the entire four years Cuomo mulled over his options, suddenly came to life, heaping effusive praise on the governor. It was like a Christmas miracle – a week early! For example, Mayor Paul Dyster that afternoon issued a press release which read, in part, “(We applaud) New York Governor Andrew Cuomo’s decision to ban the natural gas extraction technique known as “hydraulic fracturing,” “hydrofracking,” or simply “fracking,” for short.” Actually, “hydraulic fracturing” has been practiced all over New York and other states for many years prior to the development of “High volume, horizontal hydraulic fracturing”, the technique at issue. It goes on: “The City Council unanimously passed an ordinance in March 2012 banning… the treatment, storage, transfer, and disposal of fracking wastewater in the city’s wastewater treatment plant, one of only two locations in Western New York said to be capable of treating the material. Fracking wastewater is a mix of water, sand, and potentially unsafe chemicals which is used to blast through layers of underground rock in order to access natural gas deposits.” Pointing out that the Niagara Falls wastewater treatment plant is “one of only two locations… said to be capable of treating the 'material' (i.e. highly toxic and radioactive fracking wastewater)” is neither necessary nor relevant to the subject of the press release, which is a state ban on a specific natural gas drilling method. And the “’potentially’ unsafe chemicals” include over thirty listed carcinogens. In fact, Mayor Dyster has been consistently noncommittal over the years when it comes to the desirability of the Water Board accepting and “treating” fracking wastewater. With fiscal distress the watchword for the city for the foreseeable future, and steep tax increases on its residents and businesses looming ahead, is it possible the Mayor, with his council majority, is poised to overturn the city’s ban on frackwater importation? 20 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 Progress Hinted in Probe of Hit-Run Death of NT Student Tony Farina There are still no arrests but aroundthe-clock police work by the Niagara County Sheriff’s Dept. may soon crack the veil of secrecy surrounding the tragic hit-and-run death of a North Tonawanda teenager last month that has left his school and the community grieving at his loss. “We’re still looking for clues but we are making headway,” said Niagara County Undersheriff Mike Felicetti on Monday night (Dec. 22) concerning the probe into the hit-run death of 16-year-old Ryan Fischer on the evening of Nov. 20 on Krueger Road in the Town of Wheatfield. Felicetti’s statement is the first hint that authorities are making progress in the case. “One Niagara County resident has put up $5,000 in reward money to go with the $1,000 of Crime Stoppers, Inc. money to help find the driver of that car,” said Felicetti. Fischer died from his injuries shortly after being taken to Erie County Medical Center by ambulance. Authorities believe the car that struck Fischer may be a white or light silver sedan, with right front passenger side damage. Fischer, a popular North Tonawanda High School student, was walking with a female friend shortly after 7 p. m. on Nov. 20 on Krueger Road when he was fatally injured by the hit-run driver. Grief counselors and social workers have gone to North Tonawanda High School to work with students on the terrible tragedy that took the life of their classmate who was described on Facebook by the mother of a friend as a “friendly, funny, and hard-working young man. He loved his family and friends with all his heart and was very protective. He will live forever in our hearts. He will be missed.” Undersheriff Felicetti said police have been working tirelessly to break the case, and while he stopped short of saying an arrest was imminent, he did say that the investigation is making headway and he urged anyone who may have information to contact the sheriff’s department at 438-3327 or 4383394. Ryan FIsher, 16, was the victim of a hit and run. Somewhere, the driver lurks, conscious of his or her brutal, cowardly crime. If the whole world stands against you sword in hand, would you still dare to do what you think is right? “Because God has made us for Himself, our hearts are restless until they rest in Him.” ― Augustine of Hippo NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 Craft is Wrong About Lewiston This letter is in response to Ron Craft's letter in the Niagara Falls Reporter of Dec. 16. Mr. Craft states that somehow the Historical Society was involved in the welcome center in Lewiston that no one wanted, including the chamber of commerce. He also stated that the same group used $1 million of Greenway money for their own recognition. What he fails to do is get the facts correct. First of all, the organization he is writing about is the Historical Association of Lewiston. Secondly, the association he incorrectly named, had nothing to do with the welcome center in Lewiston. Some members did some volunteer work at that building, but was done strictly as an individual for the Village of Lewiston, not the Historical Association. He went on to mention the Lewiston Council of the Arts and the Lewiston Jazz Festival as recipients of tax dollars over the last five years. However he fails to mention the amount of money that goes to the Chamber of Commerce, which exceeds the Arts Council, or the Sanborn Historical Society on a yearly basis. He apparently likes those two organizations. Mr. Craft moved to Lewiston to run his antique shop in Lewiston because the quality of life here. The quality of life here is because organization such as the Historical Association, the Lewiston Jazz festival, and the Council of the Arts, not to mention the other volunteer organizations in Lewiston. It amazes me that a shop owner on Center Street would complain about supporting organizations that bring people past his store to visit the Freedom Crossing Monument, or the thousands that view the Lewiston Art Festival, not to mention the thousands that enjoy the Lewiston Jazz Festival. Of course, if those were to one day go away, he would complain the politicians ran all " his customers" out of the area. I do understand that those who attend the festivals we have in Lewiston don't patronize all the shops and restaurants that we have here when they attend a festival. However I know many of them return on a different date to visit the shops, eat in the restaurants, and yes visit the monuments and museums. Also, the Historical Association has never had a stand on Chemical Waste Management. If a past or present member has had an opinion not in favor of CWM, that is considered a personal opinion, and has nothing to do with the Association. The Greenway money he speaks of that came to the Association not only came from the town, but also the Niagara County Legislature. Mr. Craft, Greenway funds are not intended to replace taxes, nor can they be used to fund programs normally funded through taxes. The Historical Associations projects funded with Greenway funds were gifts to the Village and Town of Lewiston, the Tuscarora Nation, and future generations. For those who do not know Mr. Craft's recent history, he was appointed a Trustee on the village board to finish the Letters to the Editor term of Ron Winkley. After serving the remainder of Mr. Winkley's term, Mr. Craft ran for that seat on his own as an incumbent. He failed in his election bid, and has been a critic of everything in Lewiston since that day. Mr. Craft, don't assume what you hear in a coffee shop is always correct; the people that volunteer in this community do so to make Lewiston a better place to live, not because of a hidden agenda. Perhaps he should follow the code of ethics from the Lions Clubs organization he is so fond of: "Be careful with my own criticism, and liberal with my praise; to build up, and not destroy." Robert Welch Lewiston resident. ---------------Activist Thanks Cuomo for Banning Fracking What better gift could Governor Cuomo have given the citizens of New York this holiday season than the assurance that the dirty drilling practice known as fracking will not be coming to the Empire State? Across the country, this rolling environmental disaster has been poisoning families, destroying rural and wild landscapes, and deterring our critical transition to a clean energy economy. Thankfully, after five years and more than 100,000 face-to-face conversations, New Yorkers Against Fracking has helped shaped the conversation so that this fundamental threat to our land, air, and water has been deemed too significant of a risk to public health to permit. Despite the power of the oil and gas industry, Gov. Cuomo has chosen to respect the many communities concerned about the potential impacts of fracking and the latest science that backs them up. As cities and states across the country consider this issue, we urge them to show the same courage and foresight to reject fracking and protect health in 2015. Heather Leibowitz, Director Environment New York ------------- Body Cameras Prevent Mistreatment The massive public reaction to the tragic deaths of three black teens at the hand of white police officers has led to a national call for use of body cameras to record and prevent any future mistreatment of suspects. There is ample precedent. Animal protection activists have used body cameras to document egregious atrocities and safety violations by workers in the meat, dairy, and egg industries. The resulting videos have led to a number of corrective actions, as well as felony convictions, meat recalls, and even a $500 million civil settlement. How ironic then that agribusiness interests in seven states (Idaho, Iowa, Kansas, Missouri, Montana, North Dakota, and Utah) have now enacted "ag-gag" laws imposing severe penalties for using body cameras in their agricultural facilities. The language is typically drafted by the anti-consumer American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC). Let’s hope that other vested interests do not impose similar restrictions on the use of body cameras by law enforcement officers. Nelson Gustavo Niagara Falls ----Kane Praised Thanks a lot Niagara Falls Reporter for publishing the article on John Kane. It was great to see your words. He deserves all of them. My great thanks as a reader. Chaz Kader, Akwesasne 21 21 Ceretto Keeps Word, Files Campaign Disclosures Walker Now Only Elected Official in WNY to Not File Lewiston's councilwoman elect, Beth Ceretto, a member of the Independence Party closely aligned with Republicans, was identified in a Niagara Gazette story two weeks ago as having failed to file her campaign disclosure forms with the NYS Board of Elections. She told the Gazette she would pursue the matter of filing adding, "I'm going to have someone else complete it for me." Last Friday she did as she promised and filed all five of her legally required disclosure reports. Ceretto, who was elected this year, was a few months late. Last week, prior to her filing, the Niagara Falls Reporter brought a little light to bear on her and the only other elected official in WNY to not file campaign disclosure forms - Niagara Falls Councilmember Charles Walker. Walker is nearly two years late. He was re-elected in 2013. And as of press time he has still failed to comply. Following our story, Walker was asked on the Vince Anello WJJL radio show when he would file his campaign disclosure reports and the councilman said he was working in it. This was not unlike the answer he The Chief Resident of the University at Buffalo’s Obstetrics and Gynecology Residency Program is joining the medical staff at Niagara Falls Memorial’s OB/GYN Center. Meaghan M. Aalto, M.D., will begin working at Memorial next summer. An experienced teacher and researcher, she also has been honored for clinical excellence. Dr. Aalto is a graduate of McGill University, Montreal, and Ross University School of Medicine in Dominica, West Indies, where she received highest honors. She has been a primary investigator at the University at Buffalo, a research assistant at Rotman Research Institute, Toronto, and a study coordinator at Montreal General Hospital, Montreal. Her research has been published in several peer reviewed journals including Surgical Science and Journal of Robotic Surgery. Beth Ceretto filed her disclosures. Charles Walker is working on it. gave last July to the Niagara Gazette. Walker said he was going "to sit down this week or next week to get that figured out." This was not unlike what he told the Buffalo News in the fall of 2013, when he said, "he would check with the two people helping to manage his campaign about the unfiled paperwork." Walker has been a councilman for 17 years. Internet records suggest he has not filed disclosure forms for more than a decade. Campaign disclosure forms show who donated to a candidate, how much they received and how the candidate spent the money. By failing to file disclosure forms, Walker is in violation of New York State election law. According to New York State Election Law 14-126 (1) "Any candidate who willfully and knowingly fails to file required forms can be fined $1000 per failure." In addition (EL 14-126 (4) provides that a candidate can be charged with a misdemeanor. Walker is now distinguished as the sole elected official in WNY who has not filed his campaign disclosure forms. Dr. Aalto to Join OB/GYN Center at Falls Memorial Meaghan M. Aalto, M.D., will begin working at Memorial next summer. Dr. Aalto is a recipient of the Mauricio’s Young Professional Award and the Buffalo Gynecologic and Obstetric Society Award for academic and clinical excellence. She is a member of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and the Arnold P. Gold Foundation, which works with healthcare professionals to instill a culture of respect, dignity and compassion for patients and professionals. NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 Mad Dash for Council Chairmanship is Shaping Up Anna M. Howard Niagara Falls City Council Chairman Charles Walker, now in the first year of his fifth four-year term, is sitting on something that fellow council members Kristen Grandinetti and Andrew Touma are believed to covet: the chairman’s seat. Grandinetti, presently in the first year of her second council term, and Touma, now in the first year of his first term, have never served as council chairman. Both current councilmen Bob Anderson and Glenn Choolokian have served in the past as chairman with Choolokian putting in his time in the big chair just last year. Walker, the current chairman, has served as chairman in the past, previous to his current term. In 2014 Walker snatched the chairman’s gavel from Grandinetti’s hand, in a last minute crafty ploy, as Grandinetti, the only female council member was been poised to ascend to the chairmanship. Reliable sources within city government informed the Reporter at the time that Ms. Grandinetti was quite upset as to how Walker did an end-around her by gathering the supporting votes of Anderson and Choolokian in order to block her from the big seat. Sources now tell us that council freshman Andrew Touma has written to his fellow council members respectfully asking for their support to make him chairman for 2015. How does this sit with Kristen Grandinetti? Will she stand idly by as the gavel, for the second Who will be the next council chairman? L-R Kristen Grandinetti, Andrew Touma or Charles Walker? consecutive year, is slipped from her hands? She is concluding her fifth year as a council member and has yet to sit as chairman. Touma, in spite of only one year of service, and in light of one or two well-intended errors he may have made this year, has presented himself as one of the more vocal and involved council members. In contrast Ms. Grandinetti has appeared to be more concerned with those things that have nothing to do with administering the city budget and guiding the city, such as, Planned Parenthood, women’s rights, gender equality and the ilk. Admirable as he her work in those areas may be she brings nothing to the city government table by im- mersing herself in those social activist areas. So, while she has five years on the job compared to Touma’s one year, Touma has made more noise and raised more questions in 12 months than Grandinetti has in 60 months. Just saying. Add to this the fact that Ms. Grandinetti has damaged herself by consistently, some would say blindly, supporting the mayor in everything he recommends. In fact she is so supportive of Dyster that we scratched our collective head here at the Reporter and we can’t think of a single issue or occasion where she took serious issue with Mayor Dyster. Given that fact alone we believe that Touma, based on all the evidence at hand, would make the better choice for chairman. Having said that the choice for chairman will be made by the five council members with, as odd as it seems, Anderson and Choolokian, being in the catbird seats, poised to make either Touma or Grandinetti the chairman for 2015…as long as Touma, Walker and Grandinetti remain split as to which of them gets to hold the gavel. For all of 2014 Anderson and Choolokian have been at the consistent short end of the 3-2 voting block, but they now have the power to select the next chairman. Politics is strange and what we now see with the selection of the 2015 council chairman is about as strange as it gets, but no one ever said politics – let alone Niagara Falls politics – wasn’t odd and unpredictable. Alzheimer’s Association Offers Free Workshop in Niagara Falls Alzheimer’s disease is not a normal part of aging. It is a progressive and fatal brain disease that is the most common form of dementia. “The Basics: Memory Loss, Dementia and Alzheimer’s disease” is a workshop presented by the Alzheimer’s Association Western New York Chapter for anyone who would like to know more about the disease and related dementias. Complete Senior Care at 1302 Main Street in Niagara Falls will be hosting this workshop from 6:30-7:30 p.m. on Wednesday, January 28, 2015. Workshop information includes: • Symptoms and effects of Alzheimer’s disease and other types of dementia • How Alzheimer’s affects the brain • Causes and risk factors • How to find out if it’s Alzheimer’s disease • The benefits of early detection • How to address a diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease • Stages of the disease • Treatment • Hope for the future • Ways the Alzheimer’s Association WNY chapter can help VATICAN CITY- One of the largest Franciscan religious orders, the Order of Friars Minor, founded on the teachings of St. Francis of Assisi more than 800 years ago, announced it is on the brink of bankruptcy after admitting some of its monks embezzled funds from its accounts. The Italian news magazine Panorama on Friday (Dec. 19) reported that tens of millions of dollars were missing from the Order of Friars Minor and had been invested in offshore companies. Panorama claimed Swiss prosecutors had seized Franciscan accounts in Switzerland because the account holders had allegedly invested in illegal operations that could include arms and drug trafficking. Brother Michael Perry, the American head of the order, said an internal inquiry was begun in September and revealed “a number of questionable financial activities that were conducted by friars entrusted with the care of the patrimony of the order.” In a letter posted on the order’s website, Perry said the order was in “grave, and I underscore grave, financial difficulty, with a significant burden of debt.” The letter, addressed to all friars and published in both English and Italian, said the order’s general treasurer Father Giancarlo Lati had resigned but gave no further details. The Order of Friars Minor is one of several branches of the Franciscan order founded by St. Francis in the Italian town of Assisi in 1209. It is active in 110 countries and had more than 14,000 members. The workshop is free and open to the public, but because seating is limited, reservations are requested by calling 1.800.272.3900. Franciscan Order on Verge of Bankruptcy After Financial Fraud is Uncovered 23 24 Kristen Grandinetti, fresh off her “I can’t breathe” rally, is now going to hold her “I can’t keep my mouth shut” rally to be followed by her “I can’t seem to get elected as council chairwoman” rally. We understand that with Dyster’s $20,000 cash retirement incentive in place that there’s been non-stop retirement parties at city hall with little work getting done. In other words it’s business as usual. NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 More Jokes on City Hall room physicians had to pry the disc jockey’s lips from Dyster’s hindquarters. Cayuga Island residents tell the Reporter that the Jayne Park plan has made a complete mess of the park. Well, $280,000 doesn’t buy what it used to. If Dyster succeeds in opening his own animal shelter then it will be official: Niagara Falls will have gone to the dogs. Heard at a council budget meeting: “Councilman Walker looks like he’s dead.” “Nah, he’s just sleeping. Again.” Heard at a council meeting: “Donna Owens looks like she’s sleeping.” “That’s because she’s sleeping.” Dyster wrote on his Facebook page as to how he was tragically conflicted over having to choose between cheering for the Buffalo Bills and the Green Bay Packers while sitting in his executive box at Ralph Wilson Stadium. It’s tough being Mayor Paul Dyster. The theme music of the 2015 budget “players” is as follows: Maria Brown – “I did it my way” Paul Dyster – “Mr. Cellophane” Donna Owens – “The tears of a clown” Charles Walker – “Dazed and Confused” Kristen Grandinetti – “Thick as a Brick” City Residents – “The Sounds of Silence” Tom Darro and Paul Dyster were rushed to the hospital immediately following the appearance of the mayor on Darro’s show last week. Emergency Paul Dyster told Darro “I’m the gatekeeper of the casino money.” That title is not to be confused with his other two titles of “Grand Poobah of Outer Slabovia” and “Supreme Beer Judge of the Free World.” US Executions Drop to Lowest Level in Two Decades Mayor Dyster was really, really upset that he had to withdraw his resolution to give the Hard Rock $27,000 of taxpayer money for a New Year’s Eve Party. Looks like he’ll have to find a different taxpayer-sponsored event at which to announce his reelection campaign. By KEVIN JOHNSON WASHINGTON (RNS) the 35 people executed in the U.S. this year marks the fewest in two decades, according to a year-end report by the Death Penalty Information Center. The center, which opposes capital punishment, also found that the 72 death sentences issued in 2014 represents the fewest in 40 years. The declining numbers come as several states and the federal government are locked in disputes over their use of lethal injection drugs. The state of Oklahoma halted executions for the remainder of 2014 after a botched execution in April. The federal government, involved in a legal challenge to its lethal injection protocol, has not used its execution chamber since 2003. Texas — the nation’s perennial leader in carrying out the death penalty — was no longer alone at the top after 17 years. It tied with Missouri for the most executions, with 10. Meanwhile, the seven states that carried out executions this year marked the lowest number in 25 years. NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 Mike Hudson The Santa hat caper City police arrested Antonio Dwight Porter, 50, of 2202 LaSalle Ave. last week on shoplifting charges. The unemployed and tattooed Porter was picked up after a short foot chase on Portage Road, running from the Dollar Tree store, which was the scene of the crime, towards the Trott Vocational building. Porter made it easy for police. A tall black male dressed all in red with a black vest was a description few could match. His booty, $19.44 worth of batteries and a red Santa hat, apparently designed to match the rest of his outfit, was recovered by officers. Porter was charged with petit larceny, possession of stolen property and obstruction for his brief and unsuccessful run. After being booked, he was held in lieu of $1,500 bail. Toy dog stolen, abandoned Jose Antonio Irizarry, 29, of 610 24th St., was arrested on shoplifting charges after trying to steal a toy dog from the Super Walmart outlet on Military Road over the weekend. When he realized he’d been spotted by one of Walmart’s crack loss prevention specialists, he fled the scene, dropping the cuddly stuffed pooch, valued at $79.88 and was scene getting into a red Ford Explorer, which then pulled out onto Military Road. This Week in Stupid Crime Cops spotted the vehicle and pulled it over at the Ollie’s Plaza. Irizarry folded immediately under questioning. “I’m going to tell the truth,” he said. “I was going to take something, but I saw they were watching me and I dropped it. It was stupid.” Stupid indeed. Irizarry, who is gainfully employed, was charged with petite larceny and issued an appearance ticket. The toy dog named Zoomer, will end up costing him far more than if he’d have just paid for it, and, since it was returned to the store, the child he’d likely planned on giving it to won’t even get to see it. Don’t you just love how Christmas brings out the best in us all? The Grinch stole Christmas Police were called to a residence in the 600 block of 15th Street last week and arrived to find a 38 year old woman sobbing on the front lawn. She told cops that when she went to bed the night before, a lighted, 8-foot-tall inflatable Santa Claus and a 6-foot tall inflatable snowman were spreading Christmas cheer on her front lawn. When she got up the next morning and went outside to have a cigarette, both were gone, the tent stakes that had secured them to the ground now forlornly scattered about the lawn. Cops knocked on doors only to find the houses were mostly vacant or nobody home. They drove around the neighborhood, hoping to find some sign of the missing Santa and snowman, but came up empty. The madness. A missing C-note Pedro Torres, an employee of the 7Eleven store on Niagara Street, was caught by a store surveillance camera pocketing a $100 bill from out of the till. The store manager lured Torres back to the store with an offer to allow him to pay the money back, then called cops to have him arrested instead. Torres admitted to stealing the money. 25 “It was stupid,” Pedro told the arresting officer. “I owed someone money, but I was going to pay it back. I’m really sorry. It was really stupid.” Torres, 27, of 635 25th St., was booked on a charge of petit larceny and jailed in lieu of $250 bail. Needless to say, he no longer works at 7-Eleven. So just remember, boys and girls. The creeps they stay active on these cold winter nights. Merry Christmas to all and to all a good night. 26 NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER DEC 23, 2014 - JAN 06, 2015 Ask Dr. Ann Dr. Ann Aswhipe PHD All the world over, people are seeking advice on the problems that confront them, hoping that someone kind and knowing will guide them to make the right decisions. Generally the people who write to a perfect stranger who writes is newspaper column are among the least intelligent and therefore are likely the ones who need the most help. If you have a problem write Dr. Ann Aswhipe, PO BOx 3083, Niagara Falls NY 14303, or email [email protected]. DEAR Dr. Ann: I have been married 21 years. I have a 17-year-old daughter. For the past year, my family life has been a living hell. My wife and daughter refer to me –and all men –- as "stupid." At first, I took it as a joke, but it has escalated to the point where I can't open my mouth without hearing, "You men are so stupid!" If I ask what's for dinner, it's, "Don't be so stupid. Look for yourself." If I ask the time, it's, "Men are so stupid. You don't even know how to tell time!" My wife and daughter enjoy their "jokes" and even do "high-fives" to congratulate themselves on their cleverness. I have asked them to stop, but they say I am "too sensitive." I started keeping a diary of their remarks. I was told I was stupid 35 times in four weeks! I love my wife, but I can't stay in this marriage if they continue to insult me. It is poisoning my relationships. Before this, my daughter was a good kid. She is now a little monster with my wife's blessing. I suggested that we get counseling. My wife said no and told my daughter, who then accused me of being the "oppressor." Dr. Aswhipe, what should I do? Vexed Hubby in the Falls. DEAR Hubbie: You are clearly one stupid fellow to tolerate this kind of behavior. Don't bother going to counseling, you can't fix stupid. DEAR Ann: I am a great-grandmother with a unique hobby. A large number of four-leaf clovers grow in my yard. I pick them and give them to people who are sick, or mail them to friends just to let them know I care. I picked 14 of them and mailed them in a card to my favorite author, Stephen King, when he was injured. Most people seem to enjoy them, and I hope he did. My friend says that people will think I'm strange or superstitious, but I think most of us like to know someone cares and is thinking of us. I have never had anyone refuse a bouquet of four-leaf clovers, but maybe they are just being kind. Do you think I should stop sending them? –- CURIOUS in Lewiston DEAR CURIOUS: I'm quite sure that any person who receives a bouquet of four-leaf clovers from you thinks you are a perfect idiot. I flushed the ones you sent me right down the toilet. DEAR Ann: Please tell me how many times it is necessary to say "God bless you" after someone sneezes continuously. Must you "bless" someone every time he or she sneezes, or is it OK to stop at one? I work in an office full of sneezers -– and I'd really like to know. –- Perplexed in Ransomville DEAR Perplexed: You must proclaim "God bless you" after each sneeze no matter how many times a person sneezes. If a person sneezes too quickly to insert a “God bless you” in between each sneeze, keep count and say “God bless you” the exact number of times the person sneezed when they finish. Keep count. That's real important. Cuomo Wants Taxpayers To Pay for Medicaid Sex Change Operations Gov. Andrew Cuomo approved a new policy last week requiring New York taxpayers to pay for Medicaid recipients' sex-change operations and other transgender services. State officials estimated the services to cost taxpayers an extra $6.7 million a year. Some critics of the administration said the cost will be more than $10 million per year as out of state transgender individuals relocate to New York for free sex change operations. There are presently 353 men (who want to be women) and 308 women (who want to be men) on Medicaid and who secured a diagnoses of persistent gender dysphoria (not feeling one’s gender identity is consistent with their physical sex), which is what is needed to get taxpayers to pay for sex change operations or hormone therapy. The proposed new Medicaid regulations would require a medical professional to document that a patient not only has persistent gender dysphoria but received hormone therapy for at least a year, has lived a minimum of one year in their preferred gender role and has received mental health counseling. Sex-change operations — which include testicle removal, breast augmentation and mastectomy — range from $15,000 to $60,000 plus hormone maintenance and counseling services. Taxpayers will pay, through higher property taxes in the counties they live in, for this new Medicaid plan but only for transgender people who are over 18; patients must be 21 to get taxpayerfunded surgery that results in sterilization. “New York state has always been "Male and female created he them; and blessed them, and called their name Adam, in the day when they were created," Genesis 5:2. a progressive leader and ensuring that all New Yorkers — regardless of gender identity — are treated fairly will continue this legacy,” Cuomo said. New York joins Oregon, Massachusetts, Vermont, Washington, DC, and Maryland in requiring taxpayers to pay for sex change services to residents who can't pay for it themselves. Michael Silverman, director of the Transgender Legal Defense & Education Policy, objected to Cuomo limiting the transgender services to adults while excluding youths. New York’s $55 billion Medicaid program is the costliest in the USA contributing in large part to New York State being the highest taxes state in the USA. The public will have 45 days to comment on the proposed Medicaid regulation. New York State also recently revised its birth certificate policy to allow transgender people to step back in time and “correct” their birth certificates to reflect their chosen biological sex. Impress Your Friends: Math Trick Always Works Wow .. it works! I love math tricks and this one really works and will only take you about ten seconds! Amazingly, it really works and will reveal your all-time favorite movie. I'm pretty good at math, so I did it in my head, then on paper, and finally on a calculator just to confirm my numerical capabilities. Each time I got the same answer, and sure enough it IS my very favorite movie EVER! DO NOT cheat. DO YOUR math, THEN compare the results to the list of movies at the bottom You will be AMAZED at how scary true and accurate this test is 1. Pick a number from 1-9. 2. Multiply that number by 3. 3. Add 3. 4. Multiply by 3 again. 5. Your total will be a two digit number. Add the first and second digits together to find your favorite movie (of all time) in the list of 17 movies below: Movie List: 1. Gone With the Wind 2. E.T. 3. Blazing Saddles 4. Star Wars 5. Forrest Gump 6. The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly 7. Jaws 8. Grease 9. The Obama Farewell Speech 10. Casablanca 11. Jurassic Park 12. Shrek 13. Pirates of the Caribbean 14. Titanic 15. Raiders of the Lost Ark 16. Home Alone 17. Mrs. Doubtfire Now, isn't that something? This world is the great gymnasium where we come to make ourselves strong. ― Swami Vivekananda
© Copyright 2024