1. religion and spirituality
2. christianity
3. catholicism

Price € 1,00. Back issues € 2,00
L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO
WEEKLY EDITION
IN ENGLISH
Unicuique suum
Forty-eighth year, number 10 (2386)
Non praevalebunt
Vatican City
Friday, 6 March 2015
At the General Audience Pope Francis speaks of the importance of grandparents and their difficult situation today
We are the elderly
“Attention to the elderly is what makes
the difference in a civilization”: the
catechesis on Wednesday, 4 March, at
the General Audience in St Peter’s
Square was dedicated to the elderly.
Pope Francis chose to focus this week
on the problems in today’s throw-away
culture that threatens the dignity of our
grandparents, aunts and uncles. The
following is a translation of the Pope’s
catechesis which was delivered in
Italian.
Dear Brothers and Sisters,
Good Morning,
Today’s catechesis and next Wednesday’s will be dedicated to the elderly, who in the family are the grandparents, aunts and uncles. Today we
will reflect on the current problematic condition of the elderly, and next
time, that is, next Wednesday, on a
more positive note, on the vocation
pertaining to this stage of life.
Thanks to the progress of medicine life-spans have increased: but
society has not “expanded” to life!
The number of elderly has multiplied, but our societies are not organized well enough to make room
for them, with proper respect and
practical consideration for their
frailty and their dignity. While we
are young, we are led to ignore old
age, as if it were a disease to keep
away from; then when we become
old, especially if we are poor, if we
are sick and alone, we experience
the shortcomings of a society programmed for efficiency, which consequently ignores its elderly. And the
elderly are a wealth not to be ignored.
Benedict XVI, visiting a home for
the elderly, used clear and prophetic
At the Angelus
Happiness
after the Cross
Ferdinand Georg Waldmüller, “The request of the child” (1860)
words, saying in this way: “The
quality of a society, I mean of a
civilization, is also judged by how it
treats elderly people and by the
place it gives them in community
life” (12 November 2012). It’s true,
attention to the elderly makes the
difference in a civilization. Is there
attention to the elderly in a civilization? Is there room for the elderly?
This civilization will move forward if
it knows how to respect wisdom, the
wisdom of the elderly. In a civilization in which there is no room for
the elderly or where they are thrown
away because they create problems,
this society carries with it the virus
of death.
In the West, scientists present the
current century as the aging century:
children are diminishing, the elderly
are increasing. This imbalance challenges us, indeed, it is a great challenge for contemporary society. Yet a
culture of profit insists on casting
off the old like a “weight”. Not only
do they not produce — this culture
thinks — but they are a burden: in
short, what is the outcome of thinking like this? They are thrown away.
It’s brutal to see how the elderly are
thrown away, it is a brutal thing, it
is a sin! No one dares to say it
openly, but it’s done! There is
something vile in this adherence to
the throw-away culture. But we are accustomed to throwing people away.
We want to remove our growing fear
of weakness and vulnerability; but
by doing so we increase in the elderly the anxiety of being poorly tolerated and neglected.
During my ministry in Buenos
Aires I was in direct contact with
this reality and its problems: “The
elderly are abandoned, and not only
in material instability. They are
abandoned out of a selfish incapacity to accept their limitations that
reflect our own limitations, because
of the numerous difficulties that
must be overcome in order to survive in a society that does not allow
them to participate, to have their
say, or be referents in the consumer
model of ‘only the young can be
useful and enjoy’. These elderly persons throughout society ought to be
a reservoir of wisdom for our
people. The elderly are the reservoir
of wisdom for our people! How easily the conscience falls dormant
when there is no love!” (Solo l’amore
ci può salvare, Vatican City, 2013, p.
83).
And it happens like that. I remember, when I was visiting a retirement home, I spoke with each
person and I frequently heard this:
“How are you? And your children?
Well, well. How many do you have?
Many. And do they come to visit
you?. Oh sure, yes, always, yes, they
come. When was the last time they
came?” I remember an elderly woman who said to me: “Mmm, for
Christmas”. It was August! Eight
months without being visited by her
CONTINUED ON PAGE 3
Italian cooperatives must commit to an economy of honesty
When one plus one makes three
“Christianity has marvellous strength”.
Using the words of Leo XIII, the Pope
called the Confederation of Italian Cooperatives to action, asking them to
strive for globalized solidarity. Francis
met with the 6,000 members in the Paul
VI Hall on Saturday, 28 February.
PAGE 8
North African Bishop’s ad limina
Cardinal-Archbishop of Addis Ababa
The antidote to violence
Living in peace
PAGE 5
Cardinal-Archbishop of Yangon
A rainbow nation
L’Osservatore Romano’s collaborators in India
To our readers in Australia
PAGE 12
We are happy to announce that as of 1 March, the Carmel International
Publishing House (CIPH) in Kerala, India, assumed responsibility for the
printing and distribution of our edition in Australia and other islands in
Oceania. CIPH began its collaboration with L’Osservatore Romano in 2002
by publishing the English Edition in India. In 2008, they began translating the English Edition into Malayalam, constituting the first non-latin
script edition of L’Osservatore Romano.
For more information or to subscribe, contact CIPH: [email protected]; and visit their website: www.carmelpublications.com.
NICOLA GORI
ON PAGE
4
Josephine Quintavalle and
reproductive ethics in the UK
Feminism can only be
pro-life
LAURA GOTTI TEDESCHI
ON PAGE
6/7
L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO
page 2
Friday, 6 March 2015, number 10
VATICAN BULLETIN
AUDIENCE
Saturday, 28 February
Cardinal Crescenzio Sepe, Archbishop of Naples, Italy
Monday, 2 March
Members of the Regional Bishops’
Conference of North Africa (CERNA),
on a visit ad Limina Apostolorum:
— Archbishop Ghaleb Moussa Abdalla Bader of Alger, Algeria
— Archbishop Vincent Landel, SCI,
of Rabat, Morocco
— Archbishop Santiago Agrelo
Martínez, OFM, of Tanger, Morocco
— Archbishop Ilario Antoniazzi of
Tunis, Tunisia
— Bishop Claude Rault, M.Afr, of
Laghouat, Algeria
— Bishop Paul Desfarges, SJ, of
Constantine, Algeria
— Bishop Jean-Paul Vesco, OP, of
Oran, Algeria
Pope Francis’
visit to Pompeii
and Naples
Pope Francis will be travelling to
Naples and Pompeii on 21 March
for a pastoral visit. The visit will
be divided into three main moments: a stop at the foot of Our
Lady of the Rosary, one with the
people of Scampia and another
with the inmates of the Poggioreale Prison. The schedule was
announced in the Holy See Press
Office on Tuesday, 3 March.
As was previously announced,
the visit will begin at the Shrine
of Pompeii where the Pontiff will
arrive by helicopter on Saturday
morning, 21 March. There he will
pray in front of the venerated image of Mary. Then he will travel
by helicopter to Naples, where he
will deliver six addresses: the first
at the sports field in Scampia,
one during a meeting with the
people and various social categories of the neighbourhood. Mass
at 11 am at the central square,
Piazza del Plebiscito, will be followed by lunch with inmates
from the Poggioreale District
Prison. In the afternoon the Pope
will go to the city’s cathedral
where he will venerate the remains of St Gennaro and will
meet the clergy, religious and permanent deacons of the Archdiocese. The day will conclude
with a meeting with the sick in
the Basilica of Gesù Nuovo and
then with the youth on the Caracciolo seafront. Then the Pope
will return to the Vatican.
L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO
WEEKLY EDITION
Unicuique suum
IN ENGLISH
Non praevalebunt
— Bishop Sylvester Carmel Magro,
titular Bishop of Saldae,
Apostolic Vicar of Benghazi, Libya
— Bishop Giovanni Innocenzo
Martinelli, OFM, titular Bishop of
Tabuda, Apostolic Vicar of Tripoli,
Libya
— Fr Mario León Dorado, OMI,
Apostolic Prefect of Western Sahara
OFM,
Bishop Janusz Urbańczyk, Holy
See’s Permanent Observer to the International Governmental Organizations in Vienna
Ms Irina Bokova, Director-General
of UNESCO, with her entourage
H.E. Mr Nechirvan Barzani, Prime
Minister of the Kurdistan Regional
Government in Iraq
CHANGES
IN
EPISCOPATE
The Holy Father appointed Bishop
Charles Jude Scicluna as Archbishop
of Malta. Until now he has been titular Bishop of San Leone and
Apostolic Administrator of the Archdiocese of Malta (27 Feb.).
Archbishop Scicluna, 55, was born
in Toronto, Canada. He was ordained a priest on 11 July 1986. He
was ordained a bishop on 24
November 2012, subsequent to his
appointment as titular Bishop of
San Leone and Auxiliary of Malta.
The Holy Father accepted the resignation of Bishop Nunzio Galantino
of Cassano all’Jonio, Italy. He is
currently the Secretary General of
the Italian Episcopal Conference (28
Feb.).
The Holy Father appointed Fr
Francesco Savino from the clergy of
the Archdiocese of Bari-Bitonto,
Italy, as Bishop of Cassano all’Jonio,
Italy. Until now he has been parish
priest-rector of the Santi Medici
Shrine-Parish in Bitonto, Italy (28
Feb.).
Bishop-elect Savino, 60, was born
in Bitonto, Italy. He holds a licence
in theology. He was ordained a
priest on 24 August 1978. He has
The Holy Father appointed Msgr
Marek Marczak as Auxiliary of
Łódź, Poland, assigning him the titular episcopal See of Lentini. Until
now he has been rector of the Major
Seminary in Łódź (28 Feb.).
Bishop-elect Marczak, 46, was
born in Piotrków Trybunalski, Poland. He was ordained a priest on 11
June 1994. He holds a doctorate in
dogmatic theology. He has served in
parish ministry and as: lecturer at
the Major Seminary in Łódź; president of the Commission for the Laity;
visitator for the Catechesis; collaborator of the pastoral care of university
professors.
The Holy Father appointed Fr Fidencio López Plaza from the clergy of
Querétaro, as Bishop of San Andrés
Tuxtla, Mexico. Until now he has
been parish priest and episcopal
vicar for pastoral ministry (2 Mar.).
Bishop-elect López Plaza, 64, was
born in Capullín, Mexico. He has a
specialization in pastoral ministry
and catechesis. He has served in
parish ministry and as: diocesan coordinator for evangelization and catechesis; professor at the Conciliar
Seminary in Querétaro; head of the
deanery in Guanajuato and member
of the Presbyteral Council and of
the College of Consultors; team coordinator for the permanent continental mission in Mexico; and member of the permanent Council of the
Bishops’s Conference.
The Holy Father appointed Bishop
Robert Walter McElroy as Bishop of
San Diego, USA. Until now he has
been titular Bishop of Gemellae in
Byzacena and Auxiliary of San Francisco, USA (3 Mar.).
Bishop McElroy, 61, was born in
San Francisco, California, USA. He
was ordained a priest on 12 April
1980. He was ordained a bishop on
7 September 2010, subsequent to his
appointment as titular Bishop of
Gemellae in Byzacena and Auxiliary
of San Francisco.
START
OF
MISSION
On 11 December 2014, Archbishop
Santo Gangemi, titular Archbishop
of Umbriatico, began his mission as
Apostolic Nuncio in Mali with the
presentation of his Letters of Credence to H.E. Mr Ibrahim Boubacar
Keïta, President of the Republic.
NECROLO GY
Bishop André Vallée, PME, Bishop
emeritus of Hearst, Canada, at age
84 (28 Feb.).
Director-General
of UNESCO
in audience
On Monday morning, 2 March,
Pope Francis received Ms Irina
Bokova, Director-General of the
United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization
(UNESCO), who was accompanied
by Mr Hao Ping, President of the
37th of the General Conference of
UNESCO, and by Mr Mohamed
Sameh Amr, President of the Executive Committee.
In the Cathedral of Bogotá
José de Jesús Pimiento Rodríguez created cardinal
Ninety-six-year-old José de Jesús Pimiento Rodríguez,
Archbishop emeritus of Manizales, was created a cardinal
in Colombia on Saturday, 28 February. The ceremony —
which has never before been held in Colombia — took
place in the Cathedral of Bogotá and was presided by
Apostolic Nuncio, Archbishop Ettore Balestrero. Cardinal
Rubén Salazar Gómez, Archbishop of Bogotá, imposed
the biretta on and consigned the ring to the new cardinal.
A few weeks ago, Pope Francis created 19 cardinals at the
Consistory in St Peter’s Basilica on Saturday, 14 February.
The Archbishop emeritus was unable to come to Rome
due to his age.
GIOVANNI MARIA VIAN
Editor-in-Chief
Giuseppe Fiorentino
Assistant Editor
Mary M. Nolan
Vatican City
[email protected]
www.osservatoreromano.va
served as: vicar of San Silvestro-Crocifisso parish; member of the College of Consultors; member of the
diocesan presbyteral council and the
Ministry of Health Commission for
palliative care. He founded the
“Fondazione Opera Santi Medici
Cosma e Damiano Bitonto” ONLUS.
Editor
Editorial office
via del Pellegrino, 00120 Vatican City
telephone +390669899300, fax +390669883675
TIPO GRAFIA VATICANA EDITRICE
L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO
don Sergio Pellini S.D.B.
Director General
Photo Service
[email protected]
www.photo.va
Advertising Agency
Il Sole 24 Ore S.p.A.
System Comunicazione Pubblicitaria
Via Monte Rosa 91, 20149 Milano
[email protected]
Subscription rates: Italy - Vatican: € 58.00; Europe: € 100.00 - US$ 148.00 £ 80.00; Latin America, Africa,
Asia: € 110.00 - US$ 160.00 - £ 88.00; Oceania, North America: € 162.00 - US$ 240.00 - £ 130.00.
Management Office: phone +390669899480; fax +390669885164; e-mail [email protected].
For India: The weekly English Edition of L'Osservatore Romano is published and distributed in
India by Carmel International Publishing House, Cotton Hill, Trivandrum- 695 014, Kerala-India;
phone: +914712327253, fax: +914712328191; e-mail: [email protected].
For North America: L’Osservatore Romano (USPS 016-419) is published fifty times per year (weekly, except third week in
August and last week in December) by Our Sunday Visitor, L’Osservatore Romano, English Edition, 200 Noll Plaza,
Huntington, IN 46750. Periodicals Postage Pending at Huntington, IN, and additional mailing offices, USA – phone:
800-348-2440 x2171; fax: 866-891-7390 – e-mail: [email protected].
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Our Sunday Visitor, 200 Noll Plaza, Huntington, IN 46750
L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO
number 10, Friday, 6 March 2015
General Audience
CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1
children, abandoned for eight
months! This is called mortal sin,
understand? Once as a child, a
grandmother told us the story of
an old grandfather who got dirty
while eating because he couldn't
easily bring the spoonful of soup
to his mouth. And his son, that
is, the father of the family, had
decided to move him from the
dinner table and set up a little
table in the kitchen to eat alone,
so he couldn’t be seen. In this
way he wouldn’t make a bad impression when friends came over
to lunch or dinner. A few days
later, he came home and found
his youngest child playing with
some wood and a hammer and
nails, he was making something
there, he said: “What are you
making? — I’m making a table,
papa. — A table, why? — To have
one for when you grow old, so
that you can eat there”. Children
are more aware than we are!
In the tradition of the Church
there is a wealth of wisdom that
has always supported a culture of
closeness to the elderly, a disposition of warm and supportive
companionship in this final phase
of life. This tradition is rooted in
Sacred Scripture, as these passages from the Book of Sirach attest: “Do not disregard the discourse of the aged, for they themselves learned from their fathers;
because from them you will gain
understanding and learn how to
give an answer in time of need”
(Sir 8:9).
The Church cannot and does
not want to conform to a mentality of impatience, and much less
of indifference and contempt, towards old age. We must reawaken
the collective sense of gratitude, of
appreciation, of hospitality, which
makes the elder feel like a living
part of his community.
Our elders are men and women, fathers and mothers, who
came before us on our own road,
in our own house, in our daily
battle for a worthy life. They are
men and women from whom we
have received so much. The elder
is not an alien. We are that elder:
in the near or far future, but inevitably, even if we don’t think it.
And if we don’t learn how to
treat the elder better, that is how
we will be treated.
We old people are all a little
fragile. Some, however, are particularly weak, many are alone, and
stricken by illness. Some depend
on the indispensable care and attention of others. Are we going to
take a step back? Abandon them
to their fate? A society without
proximity, where gratuity and affection without
compensation —
between strangers as well — is disappearing, is a perverse society.
The Church, faithful to the Word
of God, cannot tolerate such degeneration. A Christian community in which proximity and
gratuity are no longer considered
indispensable is a society which
would lose her soul. Where there
is no honour for elders, there is
no future for the young.
SPECIAL
page 3
Fr Theodore Hesburgh dies
An influential leader
GREETINGS
I greet the English-speaking
pilgrims and visitors taking part
in today’s Audience, including
those from Great Britain, Austria,
Denmark, Sweden, Japan, Korea
and the United States of America. Upon you and your families
I cordially invoke joy and peace
in the Lord Jesus. God bless you
all!
Dear friends, may our time,
marked by many shadows, be
ever illuminated by the sun of
hope, which is Christ. He promised to always be with us and
manifests his presence in many
ways. It is our task to proclaim
and witness to his love which accompanies us in every situation.
Hence, never tire of entrusting
yourselves to Christ and spreading his Gospel in every environment.
I greet young people, the sick
and newlyweds. Dear young people,
may this Lenten journey be an
occasion for authentic conversion
so that your faith in Christ might
fully mature. Dear sick people, by
participating lovingly in the very
suffering of the Son of God incarnate, may you henceforth
share in the joy of his Resurrection. And may you, dear newlyweds, find in the covenant that
Christ, at the cost of his blood,
made with his Church, find the
foundation of your marital bond.
Even though he had more honorary
degrees than anyone else in history
and, as The New York Times opined,
he was “for decades considered the
most influential priest in America”, he
preferred to be called simply Fr Ted.
Fr Theodore M. Hesburgh, CSC,
passed away in South Bend, Indiana,
on Thursday night, 26 February. He
was 97 years old.
Fr Hesburgh was President of the
University of Notre Dame for 35 years
(from 1952 to 1987) and held numerous presidential appointments, also
serving as a member of the Civil
Rights Commission from 1957 to 1969.
In 1967, he led the university movement which called for autonomy and
academic freedom from any authority,
both secular and clerical. He was also
a key figure in protesting the treatment of Vietnam draft evaders. A
peaceful protester, he pledged to stay
within the limits of the law, taking a
tough stance on antiwar protests.
In 1968, Pope Paul VI appointed Fr
Hesburgh head of the Vatican representatives attending the 20th anniversary of the Universal Declaration
of Human Rights in Tehran, and in
1974 named him a member of the
Holy See’s UN delegation.
From 1977 to 1982 Fr Hesburgh
headed the Rockefeller Foundation,
and President Jimmy Carter appointed him chairman of the of the Select
Commission on Immigration and
Refugee Policy. In 1983, Pope John
Fr Ted singing ‘We Shall Overcome’ with Martin
Luther King Jr at a civil rights rally in 1964
Paul II appointed him to the Pontifical Council for Culture. He was one of
the founders of the People for the
American Way, and from 1990-96 took
part in the Knight Commission which
promotes athletic programmes at colleges and universities. He also helped
make Paul VI’s dream for an ecumenical institute for theological research
and pastoral studies a reality. When
the Tantur Ecumenical Institute
opened in the Holy Land Fr Ted led
the International Ecumenical Advisory Board.
News agencies in recent days have
been commemorating the important
and influential role Fr Hesburgh
played, both in American politics and
in the Catholic Church, through the
second half of the 20th century.
Cardinal Winning Lecture at the University of Glasgow
Rediscovering the mother tongue of Europe
For almost 600 years the University
of Glasgow (Scotland), founded by
the Papal Bull of Nicholas V, has
proclaimed to all who visit it the
motto “Via, Veritas, Vita”. Although
it is now a secular university, the original motto remains visible across
the campus. The motto was recently
translated into practical ideas when
academics, school leaders, university
students and young people gathered
on 14 February to hear Archbishop
Rino Fisichella, President of the
Pontifical Council for the Promotion
of the New Evangelization, give this
year’s Cardinal Winning Lecture.
Cardinal Thomas Winning, Archbishop of Glasgow from 1974 —
2001, was a strong supporter of
Catholic education. This annual lecture, which takes place during the
national Catholic Education week in
Scotland, marks Cardinal Winning’s
robust contribution to Catholic Education. The lecture was organized by
the St Andrew’s Foundation for
Catholic Teacher Education of the
University of Glasgow.
During the lecture, Archbishop
Fisichella discussed the many challenges facing the Catholic Church in
a society driven by the search for
novelty. He pointed out that New
Evangelization is an opportunity for
all the baptized to carry out what
should be their primary mission: the
proclamation of faith in Jesus
Christ. Setting his key themes within
the context of the traditional Chris-
tian countries of Europe, the Archbishop quoted Goethe’s observation
that Christianity is the ‘mother
tongue’ of Europe. As the Christian
faith of Europe seems to fade away,
how can the Church re-engage with
her children?
Archbishop Fisichella made special mention of two areas. First, critical thinking on what ‘New Evangelization’ means cannot remain isolated within universities. It is necessary for the Church to transform this
way of thinking into a firm culture
of humanism — a culture which can
meet the hopes and expectations of
all people. In this way, the Church
acts at the service of humanity.
A second issue is the Christian response to the phenomenon of the
‘new media’. Few people today can
live apart from the influence of the
various forms of communication
clustered under the heading ‘new
media’. Yet, it is not enough, argued
the Archbishop, simply to use them
as tools in the mission of evangelization. What is needed is a radical
thinking on how the Church can
evangelize a culture which has been
shaped by the new media and, thus,
transmit a culture rich in humanism
to a culture where technology reigns
supreme? So what is the meaning of
faith to the ‘digital’ person? Christianity has always been the communication of an event and an experience: how can we render faith intelligible to one whose needs are met,
it seems, online?
After the lecture, Bishop John
Keenan of Paisley, chaired a question and answer session which
proved to be an engaging conclusion to the morning. Archbishop
Fisichella spoke passionately of the
need to tell people about Jesus, to
encounter them in the street and to
raise our eyes away from the touchscreen of new media to meet the
eyes of those who pass by. Only in
this way will we evangelize culture
and turn the motto “Via, Veritas,
Vita” into a way of life for those living in the 21st century. (Leonardo
Franchi)
L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO
page 4
Friday, 6 March 2015, number 10
A conversation with Cardinal Souraphiel, Archbishop of Addis Ababa
Christians and Muslims living in peace
NICOLA GORI
Is the Church able to take a leading
role in interreligious dialogue?
Today Ethiopia is a model of peaceful coexistence between Christians
and Muslims, who for centuries have
lived next to each other, working together to fight poverty and fundamentalism which leads to tension
and conflict. The newly-created cardinal,
Archbishop
Berhaneyesus
Demerew Souraphiel of Addis
Ababa, spoke to our our newspaper
about this reality.
The Catholic Church in Ethiopia,
even if numerically a minority, is
very much appreciated by the
Ethiopian
Tewahedo
Orthodox
Church, by all Christian denominations, and by Muslims. We serve all
without any discrimination: in our
schools, health institutions, and social centers. This fact helps the
Catholic Church to be a bridge in
its various roles of mediations and
interreligious dialogue because of
the trust it has in the Ethiopian society. The Catholic Church was a pioneer in the establishment of the Interreligious Council of Ethiopia.
Is your appointment an encouraging
sign for the country’s Catholic minority?
I felt humbled by Pope Francis’
appointment to become a cardinal
of Our Holy Mother Catholic
Church. Pope Francis works for the
inclusion of everyone in the Church.
I am grateful to him for remembering and including the Catholic
Church in Ethiopia. It is great encouragement
for
Catholics
in
Ethiopia.
What can Catholics do to stop the violence of religious fundamentalism?
Ethiopia has a good tradition of
peaceful co-existence between Christians and Muslims. Christianity was
introduced in Ethiopia during the
Apostolic Age and became a state
religion when St Athanasius ordained St Frumentius, the first Bishop of Ethiopia. Islam was introduced during its birth in Mecca,
where the first Muslims were persecuted, and when they came to Christian Ethiopia as refugees and were
welcomed. Since then, with the exception of a few conflicts, Christians
and Muslims have lived peacefully
together. Even though fundamentalists have tried to cause divisions and
conflicts among the Christians and
Muslims, the peoples of Ethiopia
have not accepted them nor followed them. This does not mean
that fundamentalists are not trying
to stop or have stopped their acts of
causing tensions and conflicts.
The role of Catholics is to remind
society of the fruits of peaceful coexistence, especially when Ethiopia
is now fighting poverty, our common enemy, and developing the
country by laying down basic infrastructures.
With Cardinal Charles Maung Bo, Archbishop of Yangon, Myanmar
A rainbow nation
NICOLA GORI
A Church of the poor and for the
poor which defends the dignity of
those facing injustice. This is the
reality of the Catholic community
in Myanmar, as described by Cardinal Charles Maung Bo, Archbishop of Yangon, who was created a
cardinal in the Consistory on 14
February.
You are the first bishop of Myanmar
to become a cardinal. What does this
mean for you?
I personally feel that this move
springs from Pope Francis’ life and
mission. He has been writing about
“the peripheries” and this radical interpretation of the Church’s life and
mission animates all his decisions. As
the press has pointed out, the Holy
Father chose the cardinals with this
preference in mind. It is certainly an
honour for the people of Myanmar.
For five decades we were under a
suffocating dictatorship with crippling discrimination against Christians. The Church’s survival and
growth is a miracle to many. So this
honour is actually a call to service to
our country’s men and women. It is
also a tribute to my brother bishops
whose patience and wisdom allowed
the Church to survive. By bestowing
this honour, the Holy Father has
called us to greater service to the
Church and the nation in this critical
time in our history.
Christians are a minority in the country. What do you do to promote dialogue with other religions?
We have a three-fold approach to
dialogue: dialogue with the poor,
dialogue with cultures and dialogue
with religions. Our dialogue with
the poor is extensive. We are a
poor Church, we live among them,
we educate them, we empower
them through various social programs. In many areas, the Church
is the only one present among the
poor in the remote areas. Our dialogue with cultures is very important. We are a rainbow nation: we
have seven major tribes with 135
sub-tribes. We are a colourful
Church. This element brings both
blessings and challenges. The
Church needs to be inculturated
and also to forge a common identity. We have strong ethnic ecclesial
communities. Common gatherings
like the 500th anniversary are a
source of interaction. Annual National Youth conferences, religious
gatherings are arranged. Buddhists
are in the majority in our country.
We are constantly in contact with
like-minded monks, through a
group called Religions for Peace.
Regular meetings are held and the
youth come together. National and
international meetings are also regularly held. We continue to raise
our voice against violence, against
attacks against Muslims by fundamentalist groups.
The vast majority of people are impoverished. How is the Church close to
these people?
Sixty percent of our people are
very poor. Absolute poverty is
around 40 per cent. Many people
are either internally displaced or
have relocated to other countries,
some through modern forms of
slavery. Our nation was not always
like this. In the 50s and early 60s
Burma was one of the richest
countries in Southeast Asia. There
are still an abundance of natural
and human resources. Our great
leaders who took power in the 60s
were experts in working out the
miracle of making a rich country
St Frumentius, first Bishop of Ethiopia
How can the Church help fight poverty?
We are still trying every day to be
evangelizers, to bring the Gospel
values to our society, especially the
poor and marginalized. Our institutions: schools, health centers, social
centers, development programs, food
security strategies, working with others in environmental protection
schemes, clean water provisions, etc.,
are based in our Christian values
and serving all, especially the poor,
without discrimination.
Do the Oriental Catholic Churches
play an important role in ecumenism?
The logo from the fifth centenary of the Catholic
Church in Myanmar
into one of the poorest countries in
the world. Poverty in Myanmar is
a man-made disaster. What is lacking is not charity but justice. So
the Church needs to raise its voice,
together with like-minded groups
to bring in economic justice,
stressed by so many Popes and international human rights instruments. The Church needs to play a
major role in advocacy and we have
taken up two major issues: land
rights and the right to education.
Regarding the poor, our Caritas
networks in 16 dioceses are working
hard. We are also major supporters
helping
internally
displaced
people. But in Myanmar, poverty
is an injustice inflicted on our
people and we cannot rest until
justice is done for the poor.
What can Catholics do to help build
the nation?
We have contributed a lot to nation building. The Church has
reached out to the remotest corners,
educating
ethnic
communities.
Now they are well educated and
confident communities, providing
teachers, priests, nuns and development workers. Our contribution to
CONTINUED ON PAGE 10
The Oriental Catholic Church in
Ethiopia is trying to become a
bridge for ecumenism by giving due
respect to the Ethiopian Tewahedo
Orthodox Church. We are in close
contact with the Patriarchate and the
Orthodox Bishops and clergy.
Above all, there is a strong ecumenism of life with the ordinary Orthodox Christians with whom our Catholics live as good neighbours, sharing their daily experiences of joy
and sorrow. The Catholic Church in
Ethiopia does not proselytize where
the Orthodox Church is traditionally present, but works by attraction
especially in areas of the first evangelization in the country.
As a Lazzarist, what contribution do
you think consecrated men and women
can offer to the development of society
and progress in Ethiopia?
The Catholic Church in Ethiopia
is very grateful to pioneer missionaries in Ethiopia who, in the beginning were Lazarists and Capuchins.
They have worked in difficult and
very challenging circumstances to
spread the Gospel.
At present both Ethiopian religious men and women, together
with some expatriate religious men
and women, are working very hard
for the integral human development
and human formation of the people
they serve, with special emphasis in
fighting poverty, illiteracy, and disease. They work in defence of human dignity and human life, from
conception to natural death. They
teach that God created men and women as equals. No one is created inferior. Ethiopian society has great respect for religious men and women
because of the great monastic tradition in the country. They listen to
them when they stand for the respect of women and children and
when they protect them from violence, trafficking, and abuse.
L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO
number 10, Friday, 6 March 2015
page 5
To prelates of North Africa on their ‘ad limina’ visit the Pope recalls that diversity should be accepted as a treasure
The antidote to violence
And he praises the courage and fidelity of the bishops, priests, consecrated and laity in Libya
“The most effective antidote to every
form of violence is education in the
discovery and acceptance of difference”.
This was the Pope’s recommendation to
the Bishops of the Episcopal Conference
of North Africa (CERNA), whom he
received in audience on Monday
morning, 2 March, on the occasion of
their visit ‘ad limina Apostolorum’. The
following is a translation of the Pope’s
speech, which was consigned in French.
Dear Brothers in the Episcopate,
It is with joy that I welcome you in
these days of your ad limina visit. I
hope that your pilgrimage to the
Tombs of the Apostles reaffirms
your faith and strengthens your
hope in order to continue the ministry entrusted to you in each of
your countries. I thank Archbishop
Vincent Landel of Rabat, President
of your Conference, who expressed
on behalf of all of you, sentiments
of communion with the Successor of
Peter. Through you, I join the faithful of your dioceses of North Africa.
Bring them the Pope’s affection and
the assurance that he remains close
to them and encourages them in the
generous witness they render to the
Gospel of the peace and love of Jesus. My cordial greeting also goes to
all inhabitants of your countries, especially to those who are suffering.
For several years, your region has
been undergoing significant developments, which have provided hope
in realizing certain aspirations for
greater liberty and dignity and the
for fostering of greater freedom of
conscience. But some of these developments have led to outbursts of violence. I would like to particularly
commend the courage, devotion and
perseverance of the Bishops in
Libya, as well as the priests, consecrated and laity who remain in the
country despite the many dangers.
They are the authentic witnesses of
the Gospel. I deeply thank them,
and I encourage you all to continue
in your efforts to contribute to peace
and reconciliation throughout your
region.
Your Episcopal Conference, which
regularly convenes the pastors of
Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia and
Libya, is a forum of important exchange and dialogue, but it must
also be an instrument for communion, allowing a deepening of brotherly and trusting relations among
you. Your pilgrimage to Rome is a
propitious occasion to renew your
shared commitment to serving the
mission of the Church in each of
your countries. You realize this mission with your priests, your direct
collaborators. Originating from numerous countries, they sometimes
have difficulty adapting to situations
which are so new for them. It is
therefore particularly necessary that
you be close to each one of them
and attentive to their continuing
formation so that they can live out
their ministry fully and peacefully.
To each of them I convey my
warmest greetings and I assure my
prayers to all.
Men and women religious also
play a special role in the life and
mission of your Churches. I am
grateful to them for their witness of
fraternal life and their most generous commitment to serving their
brothers and sisters. In this Year of
Consecrated Life, I invite them to renew their awareness of the importance of contemplation in their lives
and thereby let the beauty and the
holiness of their vocation shine.
At the heart of your mission and
at the source of your hope are first
and foremost the personal encounter
with Jesus Christ and the certainty
that He is at work in the world
where you have been sent in his
name. The evangelical vitality of
your dioceses depends therefore on
the quality of the spiritual and sacramental life in each one. The history
of your region has been marked by
many holy figures, from Cyprian
and Augustine, the spiritual heritage
of the whole Church, to Blessed
Charles de Foucauld, the centenary
of whose death we will celebrate
next year; and closer to us, by those
men and women religious who gave
everything to God and to their
brothers and sisters with the sacrifice
of their lives. It is up to you to develop this spiritual heritage, first of
all among your faithful, but also by
opening it to all. I am also delighted
Miniature of the
martyrdom of
St Cyprian
to know that in recent years, it has
been possible to restore several
Christian shrines in Algeria. By welcoming everyone as they are, with
benevolence and without proselytism, your communities manifest the
desire to be a Church with open
doors, one which ever “goes forth”
(cf. Evangelii Gaudium nn. 46-47).
In the midst of the difficult situations at times facing your region,
your ministry as shepherds experiences a number of joys. Like this,
the welcoming of new disciples who
join you, having discovered God’s
love manifested in Jesus, is a beautiful sign given by the Lord. By sharing with their compatriots the concern for building a more fraternal
and open society, they show they are
all children of the same Father. I
greet them in a special way and I assure them of my affection, with the
wish that they may take up their
place in the lives of your dioceses.
Universality is also a characteristic
of your Churches, whose faithful
come from many nations to shape
very lively communities. I invite
them to show the joy of the Gospel
on their faces, the joy of meeting
Christ who gives them life. This is
also an opportunity for you to marvel at the work of God, which is disseminated among all peoples and in
all cultures. I would like to offer my
encouragement to the many young
students from Sub-Saharan Africa,
who form an important part of
your communities. By remaining firm in the faith,
they will be able to establish
bonds
of
friendship,
trust
and respect with
everyone,
and
thereby contribute to the building of a more
fraternal world.
Interreligious
dialogue is an
important
part
of the life of
your
Churches.
Here, too, the creativity of charity is
able to find countless ways of bringing
the newness of the Gospel into cultures and into
the most diverse corners of society (cf. Apostolic Letter to all consecrated people on the occasion of the Year
of Consecrated Life, 21 November
2014). You know how much mutual
ignorance can be a source of so
many misunderstandings and at
times even clashes. Yet, as Benedict
XVI wrote in the Apostolic Exhortation Africae Munus, “If all of us who
believe in God desire to promote reconciliation, justice and peace, we
must work together to banish every
form of discrimination, intolerance
and religious fundamentalism” (n.
94). The most effective antidote to
every form of violence is education
in the discovery and acceptance of
difference as a treasure and a fertile
ground. Moreover, it is essential that
the priests, religious and laity of
your dioceses be trained in this
field. And in that regard, I am
pleased to note that the Pontifical
Institute for Arabic and Islamic Studies
(PISAI), which is celebrating its 50th
anniversary this year, was born in
your region, in Tunisia. Support and
use this much-needed institution in
order to be immersed in the language and culture which will allow a
dialogue to expand in truth and in
love
between
Christians
and
Muslims. Dialogue is something you
even experience day by day with
Christians of different confessions.
May the Ecumenical Institute, Al
Mowafaqa, founded in Morocco to
promote ecumenical and interreligious dialogue in its own context,
also contribute to greater mutual understanding!
As a Church of encounter and
dialogue, you also want to be at the
service of all without distinction.
With often humble means, you
demonstrate the charity of Christ
and Church among the poor, the
sick, the elderly, women in need and
prisoners. I sincerely thank you for
the part you play in coming to the
aid of the countless immigrants originating from Africa who seek a
place of passage or of welcome in
your countries. By recognizing their
human dignity and striving to
reawaken consciences to so much
human tragedy, you reveal the love
that God bears for every one of
them.
Dear Brother in the Episcopate, I
would lastly like to assure you of the
entire Church’s support in your mission. You are “at the peripheries”,
with the particular service of manifesting Christ’s presence to his
Church in this region. Your testimony of life in simplicity and
poverty is a prominent sign for the
whole Church. Be assured that the
Successor of Peter accompanies you
on your arduous journey and encourages you to always be men of
hope.
I entrust you to the protection of
Our Lady of Africa, who watches
over the whole continent, and the
intercession of St Augustine, Blessed
Charles de Foucald and to all the
saints of Africa. With all my heart I
impart my Apostolic Blessing to you
and to all the faithful in your dioceses.
L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO
number 10, Friday, 6 March 2015
page 6/7
A conversation with Josephine Quintavalle of the think tank Comment on Reproductive Ethics
Detail of the “Presentation at the Temple”,
Giovanni Bellini (1460)
Feminism cannot be anything but pro-life
Procreation
A body born from another body: this is what the word
“procreation” means. It is women who procreate, when they give
birth to another human being. For centuries novels, poetry,
science and technology have examined, reflected, studied and
plumbed the depths of this fundamental moment of human life
that remains mysterious and — at the same time — visible and
tangible, universal yet simultaneously intimate and personal.
It is common to procreate, but for numerous reasons it is still
not easy, for it can bring death and illness to many women and
newborns throughout the world. Josephine Quintavalle, who
founded CORE (Comment on Reproductive Ethics), wonders why
science and technology that could even help procreation actually
persecute it. Yet, in spite of all, in spite of the old and persistent
dangers of backwardness and those, more ambiguous but equally
serious, of modern times, procreation has kept its mystery and
power even in the most difficult and tragic situations. Silvina
Pérez tells the story of Aria, a Yazidi teenager persecuted,
deprived of everything and raped by Islamic State militants.
After realizing that she was pregnant, she ends her tale by
affirming: “but I’m moving forward. In a few months I shall
have to give this child a name. I shall never be able to return to
Mosul. I shall never ever be able to wipe away my shame. I am
dead but the light of life is within me”. The light to which Aria
refers and which dawns in the relationship between mother and
child, does not remain entangled in the relationship between
bodies — also important — but is successfully transmitted outside
them too. Motherhood can become spiritual. The motherhood
of women religious is just as profound. And it is the greatest
example of how faith can exalt and broaden a sentiment to the
point of making it universal, permeating the lives of all those
who deeply accept its value. (Ritanna Armeni)
LAURA GOTTI TEDESCHI
The idea to found CORE (Comment on
Reproductive
Ethics)
came
to
Josephine Quintavalle when the Human Fertilization and Embryology Authority, the national authority in the
United Kingdom which makes ethical
evaluations of proposals concerning fertilization, held a national consultation
on removing gametes from live female
donors, corpses or foetuses in order to
cure infertility or for scientific research.
So CORE started distributing cards with
the statement: “No, I do not authorize
you to use my gametes”. Scandalized
by the fact that it was possible only to
even think of such a proposal, and distressed by the harm the abortion law
was causing to British women,
Quintavalle decided to devote herself
to the battle of defending human life
and to the fight against the exploitation of the female body and human
embryos which reproductive techniques
entail. She also worked for 20 years as
a volunteer for Life, an organization
which provides counselling to more
than 7,000 women who are experiencing a crisis pregnancy. Although the
Abortion Act of 1967 had come into
force, in the UK abortion can be performed virtually on request until the
24th week. Moreover 98 per cent of
women abort for personal reasons, not
clearly specified as a “risk to physical
and mental health”.
How do you assess the results of the
European “One of Us” campaign that has
attracted 1.8 million supporters in 20
countries?
It is absolutely marvellous that so
many signatures have been gathered in
defence of embryos and of the inviolability of human life. Italy in particular
is to be complimented for stimulating
and generating this reaction throughout
Europe, and for managing to collect
such a large number of supporters. In
addition to the immediate goal of prohibiting Europe from funding research
which destroys human embryos, this
initiative has been extraordinary in
gathering together so many pro-life
groups across Europe, creating a very
powerful network of people that aims
to defend human life.
Among these 20 countries, the UK had
one of the lowest numbers of signatures
gathered: 28,000 in comparison with the
more than 630,000 collected in Italy.
Why do you think that is?
We really worked hard to convince
our pro-life colleagues that it was necessary to support this campaign.
There is a very strong pro-life movement in the UK but we are an island in
more senses than one: we don’t feel
very European in the political arena
and we haven’t succeeded in making
people understand the importance of
this campaign.
What is the situation in the field of
bioethics?
The UK was the first country in the
world to approve legislation on in vitro
fertilization and on the numerous controversial ethical issues that emerge
from artificial reproduction. British
laws have always been sadly progressive
and liberal: it is really difficult to find
cases in which liberal proposals in the
bioethical field have been prohibited.
The story of a young woman from chains in Mosul to the refugee camp in Dohuk
Sixteen and six months pregnant
SILVINA PÉREZ
“Desperate screams and sobs could be
heard coming from the streets nearby.
We were frightened, we didn’t know
what to do. Many people ran to seek
refuge and were hit by a volley of machine gunfire, others sought shelter in
the small school gymnasium. We knelt
in silence, whispering words of faith”.
“The jihadists burst in and a deafening barrage rose above the people’s
screams: a few metres from me, my
father was shot dead. All the others
were thrown out of the school and
gathered in the courtyard. Only one
poor woman was unable to get out because her legs were paralyzed. She was
to keep my father company, desperately
thrashing about in vain, her arms in
the air, asking for clemency, nailed to
her seat”.
For 16-year-old Aria, who belonged
to the Iraqi Yazidi community, the real
nightmare began on the day her village
was attacked by men of Islamic State.
She saw her father and brother killed
and since then has had no news of her
mother or her two sisters. She is now
in a refugee camp in Dohuk, she is six
months pregnant and recounts her
nightmare consisting of torture, rape
and degradation.
“It was 9 June — she recounts on
Skype, filling the computer screen with
her thin face and large blue eyes —
when Mosul, our city, was hit. During
the attack the militia killed dozens of
people. We women were the most
frightened, we knew what would happen to us if they caught us. We had no
time to flee. The men of the Islamic
State gathered the prisoners together,
dividing them by sex and age. The first
group consisted of young boys, another
of girls, and a third of older men and
women. From the latter the jihadists
took all they had: money, gold and cell
phones. Then they left them there. As
for us, they loaded us on to lorries,
after having shot all the young men in
the first group, including my brother”.
Aria, together with a group of about
25 girls, was taken to Baaj, a town west
of Mosul, and locked into an old threestorey building. “Here they divided us
again. I was left with the group of the
youngest, and I believe, the prettiest.
Our prison guards told us that after
our conversion to Islam, we were
destined to marry a glorious fighter.
The other girls were condemned to become sex slaves of the militants. One
of them hanged herself in despair and
yet another attempted to do so but the
jihadists stopped her and beat her until
she bled”, Aria said, explaining that
after this episode no other girl attempted to end her life.
“For almost 10 days we were locked
up practically in the dark. We slept on
the ground and ate only once a day.
The jihadists of the Islamic State”, she
recounted, “asked us several times to
convert to Islam, threatening that if we
didn’t they would kill all the members
of our family. Some gave in to their
blackmail in order to save their father,
husband or brother.
The United Nations have in fact calculated that after the fall of Mosul
1,500 women and children suffered violence. Forms of sexual violence were
committed on a vast scale: among the
victims were women, girls and boys.
The crimes perpetrated ranged from
rape to forced marriages and sexual
slavery. The Caliphate’s militants are
supporters of total female submission
and impose it on the young women
they kidnap and brutalize in the fighting zones. They even resort to blasphemous misinterpretation in order to
give rape a theological justification
(with the ploy of “temporary marriage”
in war zones).
In particular women who belong to
religious minorities, such as the Yazidi
or Assyrian Christians, are kidnapped
from their villages, locked in prisons
and given an unbearable choice. Those
Can you give us a few examples of laws
that should have been prohibited?
Pablo Picasso, “Blue nude” (1902)
who decide to convert to Islam are sold
as brides to combatants of the Islamic
State, for a price that varies between 25
and 150 dollars. Female prisoners who
refuse to convert are raped daily and
condemned to a slow and agonizing
death.
Her gaze lost in emptiness, Aria told
us how after 10 interminable days she
was sold for 35 dollars to Hassan, a
young jihadist from Syria who took her
to the house where he lived with other
militants.
CONTINUED ON PAGE 8
women church world women church world women church world
abortion; Hungary has inserted in its Constitution
the defence of the human
embryo; and in Spain numbers are slowly changing,
thanks to a very active and
dynamic pro-life movement.
And in the
UK?
Here, unfortunately, there
is very little to celebrate.
Besides the most liberal application of IVFET imaginable, with the colossal destruction of human life from
its very earliest stages, voluntary terminations of pregnancy are in no way diminishing. Abortion is permitted until the 24th week and,
in certain circumstances
even until the last week of
Detail of Windsor Codex (1509) by Leonardo da Vinci
pregnancy. In 2012, out of a
total of 160 post-24th week
of coalitions with groups of women abortions, 28 took place after the
who — even though they do not com- eighth month of gestation.
pletely share our principles in defence
of human life — recognize and de- In an interview with “The Observer” in
nounce with us the exploitation of wo- 2005, you said you wanted to “wake up
men and of their bodies in assisted re- this nation’s conscience” concerning aborproduction, the collection of egg cells tion laws. Has the nation woken up?
from (presumed) female donors and
No, unfortunately not. Indeed today
the recourse to using surrogate moththe situation is even more urgent. The
ers.
UK has fallen completely into the grip
of utilitarianism while it is discussing
CORE is a sort of ethical lens that aims
to create awareness of the reality of as- euthanasia, abortion and the genetic
sisted reproduction, such as in vitro fertil- manipulation of human embryos. And
ization and embryo transfer (IVFET). there’s no real academic debate on
What is the unspoken truth about IVFET? bioethics. This is surprising when one
thinks that the average European citThat it is permeated by a eugenic lo- izen looks to us as a model of demogic. More egg cells are fertilized cracy and virtue.
through IVFET than those that would
be fertilized naturally: several of the Perhaps this limitation is due to the fact
embryos that are subsequently pro- that pro-life movements in the UK seem to
duced are immediately rejected for not be composed solely of Catholics, who are at
being sufficiently “suitable”. From times a little too “outspoken”?
among those that remain, the best are
There are various pro-life movements
implanted immediately, whereas the
others are frozen for future use. Those in the country and it’s true that many
of them have a religious basis, especially Catholics and Evangelical Christians, which tend to raise their voices a
little too high. Their voices in the discussion are important, but it’s necessary
to fight harder also from a political and
academic level. In any case the pro-life
instinct that exists in every human being has gained momentum in recent
years. For example, there has been an
increase in the number of young
people without specific religious affiliations who are opposed to the prochoice policy.
What are the main bioethical battles you
are facing in the UK today?
There are two important battles.
One against the proposal to minimize
the doctor’s role in evaluating the motivations driving women to abort. The
second is against the proposal to create
embryos from three “parents”. This will
be a really tough battle for us because
the problem is camouflaged with a language so highly scientific that it is incomprehensible to ordinary people. We
must therefore translate the reality of
what is proposed in such a way that
our supporters can understand that
once again a scientific innovation is in
actual fact an attack on the human embryo.
Belgium recently legalized child euthanasia. The British Government is putting less
money into healthcare for the elderly and
sick. Where are we headed?
The fight against euthanasia is another of our many battles. Fortunately
there is a strong coalition of pro-life
groups in England, united under the
slogan “Care not Killing” and headed
by Dr Peter Saunders who directs the
Christian Medical Fellowship. The
shadow of euthanasia is expanding
throughout Europe. We must truly
wake up.
At the outset human cloning was
considered an excessive step and was
accordingly forbidden, but today there
is great enthusiasm about the possibility of creating embryos with the genetic
material of three or four different
adults. This procedure, however, involves techniques similar to those of
cloning. Hence the initial prohibition
has evidently been bypassed. Just think
that in the UK today embryos for research purposes may be created from
human spermatozoa and cow egg cells.
You describe yourself as a pro-life feminist,
yet most people believe that feminists themselves are the greatest champions of women’s right to abort.
If feminism is based on the defence
of women’s rights, then a feminist cannot be anything but pro-life: abortion
is a true exploitation of the female
body and it should therefore be fought
against. CORE has created an international network of people and groups in
different countries, particularly in
Europe, the United States and Australia. The result has been the creation
selected for implantation are often subjected to a further genetic diagnosis
that entails the removal of cells when
the embryo has reached the stage of
eight cells. Furthermore this intervention might damage the embryo.
Remaining on the topic of the defence of
life, how do you see the situation in
Europe today?
The general perception is that the
pro-abortion lobbies in the world are
gradually losing ground. Just look at
the United States: half of the States
have passed restrictive legislation on
Born in New Zealand 74 years ago, Josephine Quintavalle grew up surrounded by relatives who were priests and
women religious. After earning a degree
in English at Birkbeck College, London, she worked in the British Pro-Life
Movement and on the international scene for about 40 years. In 1994 she founded CORE (Comment on Reproductive
Ethics), an international think tank that
deals with the numerous problems that
have ensued from the practice of
in vitro fertilization.
women church world women church world women church world
L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO
page 8
Friday, 6 March 2015, number 10
The Pope calls Italian cooperatives to commit to an economy of honesty
When one plus one makes three
A great leap forward in solidarity
In the Paul VI Hall on Saturday
morning, 28 February, Pope Francis
received in audience 6,000 members of
the Confederation of Italian
Cooperatives. The following is a
translation of the address, which he
delivered in Italian.
Brothers and Sisters,
Good morning,
This last one [referring to the choir]
was the most melodic “cooperative”!
My compliments!
I appreciate this encounter with
you and with the organization you
represent, that of cooperation. Cooperatives challenge everything, even
mathematics, because in a cooperative one plus one makes three! And
in a cooperative, a failure is half a
failure. This is the beauty of cooperatives!
You are first of all the living
memory of a great treasure of the
Church in Italy. Indeed, we know
that at the origins of the Italian cooperative movement are many farming and credit cooperatives which,
by the 19th century, had been wisely
established and promoted by priests
and pastors. To this day, in various
Italian dioceses, cooperation is still
employed as an effective remedy to
the problem of unemployment and
to the various forms of social disadvantage. It is routine today, I do not
say normal, customary.... but too often one sees: “Are you looking for
work? Come, come to this company”. Eleven hours, 10 hours of
work, 600 Euros. “Do you like it?
No? Go home”. What is to be done
in a world that functions like this?
Because there is a line, a file of
people looking for work: if you do
not like it, the next one will. It is
hunger, hunger makes us accept
what they give us, working under
the table.... To give an example, I
could ask about domestic service:
how many men and women who
work in domestic service have a retirment pension?
All this is very well known. The
Church has always recognized, appreciated and encouraged cooperatives. We read it in the Magisterium
documents. We remember the appeal launched in 1891 by Pope Leo
XIII in Rerum Novarum: “All proprietors and not all proletariat”. And there
are certainly the well-known pages
of the Encyclical Caritas in Veritate,
in which Benedict XVI expresses his
opinion in favour of credit unions
and consumer cooperatives (cf. nn.
65-66), highlighting the importance
of the economy of communion and
of non-profit sector (cf. n. 41), in order to affirm that the god-of-profit
is by no means a divinity but only a
compass and measuring stick for the
appraisal of entrepreneurial activity.
Pope Benedict also explained that
our world needs an economy of giving (cf. nn. 34-39), meaning an economy capable of giving life to busi-
Sixteen and six months pregnant
CONTINUED FROM PAGE 6
“He wanted to force me to
marry him, but he could not do so
prior to my conversion. He said
that a true believer does not marry
an infidel. For him, my Yazidi faith
made me a sinner. I refused and so
he began to beat and rape me; ever
more often, ever more harshly. One
day he told me that he would wait
another week and then have me
taken to the other women, those
who serve all the militants enabling
them to vent their desires. I was
desperate, I could only think of
dying. “I paid 35 dollars, do you
understand? You’re useless, you’re
no good to me”, he said. One
night the area was heavily attacked.
The men all left and I suddenly
found myself on my own. I went
outside and started running in the
dark. I ran toward the sound of
mortar fire. I did not know what I
would find but I thought that
nothing could be worse. I ran and
I cried. I ran and I prayed, ever
more insistently without ever looking back. I don’t quite know how,
but I arrived in the part of the city
controlled by the Kurds. A group
of female guerrillas took care of me
for a couple of days and then
helped me cross the Turkish border. From there I made it to this
refugee camp.
After a few months I found out
I was pregnant. I wept bitterly. I
thought once again I would end
my life. Despite my escape, despite
my freedom, I felt profoundly defeated. I thought of my father. I
know that I died in that cursed
prison in the hands of the militants; but I’m moving forward. In a
few months, I shall have to give
this child a name. I shall never be
able to return to Mosul. I shall
never ever be able to wipe away
my shame. I am dead, but the
light of life is within me”.
nesses inspired by the principle of
solidarity and capable of “creating
sociality”. In order to accomplish
this, as Leo XIII exclaimed, in blessing the beginnings of the Italian
Catholic cooperative movement:
Christianity has marvellous strength
(cf. Encyclical Rerum Novarum, n.
15); this exclamation, therefore, resounds through you.
These and many other affirmations of recognition and encouragement addressed to co-operators on
behalf of the Church are valid and
timely. I also think of the extraordinary social teachings of
Blessed Paul VI. We are able to confirm and consolidate these statements. Thus it is not necessary to repeat or restate them in full.
Today, I would like our dialogue
to look not only at the past but
above all to be directed forward: to
new perspectives, to new responsibilities,
to new forms of initiatives of cooperative enterprises. It is a true mission
which asks us for creative imagination in order to find forms, methods,
attitudes and instruments, to combat
the “throw-away culture”, that we
are living in today, the “throw-away
culture” cultivated by the powers
which uphold the economic and financial policies of the globalized
world, at the centre of which is the
god of money.
Today globalizing solidarity — this
must be globalized, solidarity! —
means thinking about the spiraling
increase of unemployed people, of
the unending tears of the poor, of
the need to resume development
that is both a true, integral progress
of the person who certainly needs
income, but not only income! Let us
think of health needs, which traditional welfare systems no longer
manage to satisfy; of the urgent
need of solidarity, placing once
again the dignity of the human being at the centre of the economy, as
you have said. As Pope Leo XIII
would still say today: Christianity has
marvellous strength to globalize solidarity!
Therefore, do not stop to look
only at what you have been able to
achieve. Continue to refine, to
strengthen and to update the good
and solid businesses that you have
already built. However, also have
the courage to move outside of
them, charged with experience and
good methods, to carry cooperation
to the new frontiers of change, to
the existential peripheries where
hope needs to emerge and where,
unfortunately, the current sociopolitical system instead seems fatally
destined to suffocate hope, to steal
hope, increasing risks and threats.
This great leap forward which we
propose the cooperatives take, will
give you the confirmation that all
that you have already done is not
only positive and vital, but also continues to be prophetic. For this reason
you must continue to invent — this
is the word: invent — new forms of
cooperation, because the maxim,
“when a tree has new branches, the
roots are deep and the trunk is
strong”, also applies to cooperatives.
Here, today, you represent valuable experience in many sectors:
from agricultural development to the
promotion of building new homes
for the homeless, from social cooperatives to credit unions, here
broadly represented, from fishing to
industry, to business, to communities, to consumption, to distribution
and many other types of service. I
am well aware that this list is incomplete, but it is rather useful in order
to understand how precious the cooperative method is, which must go
forward, creative. It has revealed itself in the face of many challenges.
And it still will! However, all appreciation and all encouragement instead risks being generic. I want to
offer you some practical encouragement
instead.
The first is this: cooperatives must
continue to be the motor that lifts
and develops the weakest part of your
local community and of civil society.
Sentiment is not capable of this.
Thus it is necessary to give first priority to the foundation of new cooperative enterprises, along with the
further development of those in existence, especially in order to create
new
employment
opportunities,
which are lacking today.
My thoughts go first and foremost
to young people, because we know
that the dramatically high unemployment among the young — let us
consider, in several European countries, 40, 50 percent — destroys hope
in them. But let us also consider the
many women who have the need and
the will to enter the world of work.
Let us not overlook the adults who
are often prematurely out of work.
“What are you?” — “I’m an engineer” — “Ah, how nice, how nice.
How old are you?” — “49” — “You
aren’t needed, go on”. This happens
every day. In addition to new businesses, let us also look at the companies that are in difficulty, those for
whose elderly owners it is more convenient to let the business die, which
can instead be revived with the initiatives that you call “workers buyouts”, in my language “empresas recuperadas”, saved companies. And, as
number 10, Friday, 6 March 2015
I said to their representatives, I am a
fan of empresas recuperadas!
A second point of encouragement —
not in order of importance — is to
become active as leaders in creating
new welfare solutions, particularly in
the field of healthcare, a delicate
field where so many poor people do
not find adequate responses to their
needs. I know what you have been
doing for years with heart and with
passion, in the peripheries of the cities and of our society, for families,
children, the elderly, the sick and
people disadvantaged and in difficulty for various reasons, bring heart
and aid into their homes. Charity is
a gift! It is not a simple gesture to
calm the heart, it is a gift! When I do
charity, I give myself! If I am not
capable of giving myself, that is not
charity. It is a gift without which
one cannot enter the home of one
who suffers. In the language of the
social doctrine of the Church this
means building on subsidiarity with
strength and consistency: it means
joining forces! How beautiful it
would be if, starting in Rome, an effective network of assistance and
solidarity could be created among
the cooperatives, for parishes and
hospitals, I am thinking of “Bambin
Gesù” in particular. And the people,
starting from the most needy, would
be placed at the centre of all this
solidary movement: the people at
the centre, the neediest at the centre.
This is the mission we are proposing
to ourselves! It is your task to invent
practical solutions, to make this network function in the actual situations of your local communities,
starting from your history, with your
wealth of knowledge in order to
carry out this endeavour and at the
same time not to forget that the person
is at the centre of it all.
You have done so much, and
there is still so much to do! Let us
forge ahead!
The third point of encouragement is
in regard to the economy, its relationship to social justice, to the dignity
and value of people. It is well known
that a certain liberalism believes it is
necessary to first produce wealth, no
matter how, to then promote some
policy of redistribution by the State.
First fill your glass and then give to
L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO
page 9
others. Others think it is the entity fourth century, and then taken up by lenges of the global market? How
itself that should lavish the crumbs St Francis of Assisi, that “money is can cooperatives participate in the
of accumulated wealth, thereby ab- the devil’s dung”! Now the Pope also development of cooperation safesolving itself of so-called “social re- repeats it: “Money is the devil’s guarding the principles of solidarity
sponsibility”. One risks being de- dung”! When money becomes an and justice? I say this to you in orceived by doing good while, unfor- idol, it commands the choices of der to say it to all the world’s cotunately, continuing to only market, man. And then it destroys man and operatives: cooperatives cannot stay
without going outside of that fatal condemns him. It renders him a ser- locked up at home, but neither can they
circuit of the selfishness of people vant. Money at the service of life leave home as if they are not cooperatand of companies which have the
ives. This is the twofold
god of money at the centre.
principle: they cannot
Doing
this
also
means
helping
women
stay locked up at home
Instead we know that establishing
but neither can they leave
a new quality of economy will enfully develop themselves within their
home as if they are not
able people to grow to their full povocation
and
bring
their
own
talents
to
cooperatives. No, we cantential. For example: a member of
the cooperative must not be only a
fruition. Women free to be leaders, both not consider a cooperative
as double-sided. We must
supplier, a worker, a well-treated
in business and in the family!
have courage and imaginuser; he must always be a protagonist, he must grow, through the coation to build the right
operative, grow personally, socially
road to integrate, in the
and professionally, in responsibility, can be managed in a just way by a world, development, justice and
in actualizing hope, in working to- cooperative, if however, it is an au- peace.
gether. I am not saying that one’s thentic, true cooperative, where capitLast, do not allow the cooperative
income need not increase, but that is al is not in command over men but movement’s cooperation with your parnot enough: it is important that the men over capital.
ishes and your dioceses to live only in
business managed by the cooperative
For this reason I tell you that you your memory. The forms of cooperatruly grow in a cooperative way, that is are doing well — and I also tell you tion need to be different from the
by involving everyone. One plus one to always do more of it — to counter original forms, but the journey must
makes three! This is the logic.
and combat the false cooperatives, always be the same! Where there are
In Latin etymology, “cooperari” those which prostitute the very name old and new existential peripheries,
means to operate together, to co- of cooperatives, namely of a truly where people are underprivileged,
operate, and therefore to work, help, good organization, in order to de- where people are alone and discontribute to achieve an end. Never ceive people with aims of profits carded, where people are disrespecbe satisfied with the word “cooperative” contrary to those of true and au- ted, extend a hand to them! Cowithout having knowledge of the true thentic cooperation. Do well, I tell operate together, in accordance with
substance and spirit of cooperation.
you, because, in the field you oper- each one’s vocational identity, holdThe fourth suggestion is this: if we ate in, to take on an honourable ing hands!
look around us it never happens façade but to instead pursue dishonI know you have been collaboratthat the economy is renewed in a so- ourable and immoral aims, often dir- ing for several years with other cociety that is aging than than grow- ected at exploiting labour, or at ma- operative-type associations — even
ing. The cooperative movement can nipulating the market, and even at though not tied to our history and
play an important role in sustaining, scandalous and corrupt trafficking, our traditions — to create an Allifacilitating and also encouraging the is a shameful and extremely serious ance of Italian cooperatives and
life of families. Realizing conciliation, lie that is absolutely unacceptable.
partners. For now it is an evolving
or better perhaps, harmonization Fight against this! How do you
Alliance, but you hope to arrive at a
between work and family, is a task you fight? With words alone? With
single Association, an ever expandhave already begun and which you ideas? You fight with fair and true
ing Alliance between partners and
must increasingly achieve.
cooperatives. The Italian cooperative
Doing this also means helpThe fifth point of encouragement may movement has a long tradition coming women fully develop
pared to that of international cothemselves within their vocaperhaps surprise you! It takes money operatives in the world. The coopertion and bring their own talative mission in Italy from its very
to do all these things ... the Pope
ents to fruition. Women free
beginnings has been strongly tied to
to be leaders, both in busitells you: you must invest, and you
the identities, values and social
ness and in the family! I
powers present in the country.
must invest well!
know well that cooperatives
Please,
respect
this
identity!
already offer so many services
However, often the choices which
and so many organizational formu- cooperation, the kind which always separate and divide have long been
lae, akin to national health services, prevails.
stronger than the choices which into meet the needs of everyone, of
The cooperative economy, if it is stead bring together and unite everychildren and the elderly in particu- authentic, if it wants to play a
one’s efforts. Now you believe you
lar, from day-care centres to home powerful social function, if it wants
are able to give priority instead to
care. This is our way to manage the to be a protagonist of the future of a
common goods, those goods that must nation and of each local community, what unites you. And precisely
not be the property of only the few and must pursue transparent and clear around what unites you, which is
the deepest, most authentic, most vimust not seek speculative purposes.
aims. The economy of honesty must be tal part of the Italian cooperatives,
The fifth point of encouragement may fostered! A healing economy in the you wish to build your new associatperhaps surprise you! It takes money insidious sea of the global economy.
ive form.
to do all these things! Cooperatives A true economy supported by
You do well to plan like this, and
in general are not established by people who have only the common
like this you are taking a step forlarge capitalists, but rather it is often good in their heart and mind.
ward! Of course, there are Catholic
said that they are structurally underCooperatives have a strong inter- cooperatives and non-Catholic cocapitalized. Instead, the Pope tells
you: you must invest, and you must national tradition. In this too you operatives. But is faith saved if we
invest well! In Italy of course, but have been true pioneers. Your inter- remain closed? I ask: is faith saved if
not only, it is difficult to obtain national associations were formed we remain closed? Remaining only
public funds to compensate for a well in advance of those which other among ourselves? Experience your
shortage of resources. This is the businesses created in much later Alliance as Christians, as a fearless
solution I propose to you: bring good times. Now there is the new, great response to your faith and to your
means together with determination in globalization, which is reducing identity! Faith and identity are the
order to accomplish good works. Col- some inequalities but creating many foundation. Go forth, therefore, and
laborate more among cooperative others. The cooperative movement, walk together with all people of
banks and businesses; organize re- therefore, cannot remain unrelated good will! This is also a Christian
sources to enable families to live to economic and social globalization call, a Christian call to all. Christian
with dignity and serenity; pay fair whose effects reach every country values are not only for us, they are
wages to workers, investing above all and even into our homes.
for sharing! For sharing with others,
in initiatives that are truly necessary.
But do cooperatives participate in with those who do not think as we
It is not easy to speak about globalization like other businesses? do but who want the same things
money. It was said by Basil of Is there an original way which allows that we want. Go forth, have courCaesarea, a Church Father of the cooperatives to face the new chal- age! Onward, be creators, “poets”!
L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO
page 10
Friday, 6 March 2015, number 10
Morning Mass at the Domus Sanctae Marthae
Monday, 2 March
Shame and mercy
Feeling shame and blaming oneself,
instead of assigning fault to others,
judging and condemning them. This
is the first step on the path of Christian life which leads us to ask the
Lord for the gift of mercy. The Pope
suggested this examination of conscience at Mass in the chapel of
Casa Santa Marta on Monday
morning.
Francis began his reflection from
the day’s First Reading from the
Book of Daniel (9:4-10). He explained that the People of God “ask
for forgiveness, but not a forgiveness
with words: this request for forgiveness is for a forgiveness that comes
from the heart because the people
feel they are sinners”. The people
“do not feel they are sinners in theory — because all of us can say ‘we
are all sinners’, it’s true, it’s the
truth: everyone here! — but before
the Lord they tell of the bad things
they have done and the good things
they have not done”. Indeed, the
Giorgio De Chirico, “The Prodigal Son” (1922)
Scripture reads: “We have sinned,
been wicked and done evil; we have
rebelled and departed from your
commandments and your laws. We
have not obeyed your servants the
prophets, who spoke in your name
to our kings, our princes, our fathers, and all the people of the land”.
A rainbow nation
CONTINUED FROM PAGE 4
education was curtailed by a nearsighted policy of nationalization
which denied quality education to
the people of Myanmar. The
Church has the capacity to work in
education, health and human development, and the government
must treat the Church as a partner
in nation building. We have
offered our services. The government of Myanmar needs the
Church. We work in areas where
not even the government goes. For
true peace and development the
Church’s role is vital and CBCM
(the Bishops’ Conference) has decided to play that role.
What role can religious play in promoting human development during
this Year of Consecrated Life?
There are more than 2500 religious in this country. Women religious have done great work in remote communities. Their accompaniment of the poor is one of the
reasons for robust nature of these
communities. But as the country
opens up, women religious need
more resources, greater education
and empowerment. Their commitment is commendable but they
need competence. We also foresee
greater role in the sector: education and Health, as teachers and
health workers.
How can the Church be missionary
as Pope Francis insists?
Francis insists on a Church that
looks forward. In the Joy of the
Gospel he says that the Church is
not a museum of mummies and he
explains the need to get out of the
tomb.
Despite the five-decade
challenge, the Church in Myanmar
has never failed in her missionary
duty. From 200,000 Catholics we
have grown to 800,000. But we
also follow the advice of the Pope
in accompanying the poor. Ours
is a Church of the poor and for
the poor. This social mission is vibrant in our dioceses. Pastorally
most of the dioceses have diocesan
plans, and are developing pastoral
and social plans. We are also empowering our catechists — an army
of nearly 3,000 men and women —
to be socio-pastoral workers. Our
work among the migrants and internally displaced persons has
already taken Christ to them. Now
we are involved in the work of “the
Evangelized becoming the Evangelizers'” that is empowering our
laity to reach out to remote areas.
In substance, Francis noted, in
the words of the people there is a
“description of all the evil they have
done”. Thus, “the People of God, in
this moment, blame themselves”.
They do not criticize “those who
persecute us”, or their enemies. Instead they look at themselves and
say: “I blame myself before you,
Lord, and I am ashamed”. Such
clear words also appear in the passage from Daniel: “O Lord, we are
shamefaced”.
The Pope indicated that this passage “makes us reflect on a Christian
virtue, indeed more than one virtue”. In fact “the capacity to blame
oneself, self-blame” is “the first step
to walking as a Christian”. However,
“we are all masters, we are all experts” when it comes to “justifying
ourselves”. We use expressions such
as: “It wasn’t me; no, it isn’t my
fault; yes, but not very much....
That’s not how things are...”.
In short, Francis said, “we all
have an alibi” to justify “our shortcomings, our sins”. What’s more, he
added, we so often respond with an
“‘I don’t know!’ face”, or with an “‘I
didn’t do it, it must have been
someone else!’ face”. In other words,
we are always ready to “play innocent”. The Pope warned, however,
that like this, “we don’t go forward
in the Christian life”.
Thus, he reiterated, the capacity
for self-blame is “the first step”.
Surely it is good to do so in confession with a priest. However, Francis
asked, “before and after confession,
in your life, in your prayer, are you
able to blame yourself? Or is it easier to blame others?”.
This experience, the Bishop of
Rome pointed out, gives rise to
something a bit odd but which, in
the end, gives us peace and health”.
Indeed, “when we begin to look at
what we are capable of, we feel bad,
we feel disgust”, and we ask
ourselves: “Am I capable of doing
this?”. For example, “when I find
envy in my heart and I know this
envy is capable of speaking ill of another and morally killing him”, I
A monument to the victims of the 2008 attack
The martyrs of Orissa
The Christians of the village of Tiangia
(Orissa) have built the first monument
honouring the seven martyrs, victims of
the anti-Christian pogrom of Kandhamal in 2008. Archbishop John Barwa
of Cuttack-Bhubaneswar blessed the
commemorative plaque in the presence
of many priests and hundreds of faithful. “These seven martyrs”, said the
Archbishop, “are pillars of testimony for
the people of Kandhamal and beyond.
We thank God for giving us such men,
who sacrificed their precious lives for
the love of Jesus. Rather than give up
their faith, they clung to Christ with
passion. For us, they are a source of inspiration and hope”.
The seven martyrs, all from Tiangia, are: Fr Bernard Digal, Trinath
Digal, Bikram Nayak, Parikhit Nayak, Darasantha Pradhan, Dibyasing
Digal and Dinabandhu Pradhan. They were killed following the murder
of the Hindu leader Saraswati Laxanananda on 23 August 2008 by a
Maoist group. From the beginning, the Maoist group admitted to the
murder, however the Hindu radicals blamed Christians, who — along
with bishops, priests and nuns — were criticized by the guru for their
social work with tribals and outcasts of proselytising.
have to ask myself: “Am I capable
of it? Yes, I am capable!”. This is
precisely “how this knowledge begins, this wisdom to blame oneself”.
Therefore, Francis said, “if we do
not learn this first step of life, we
will never make progress on the path
of Christian life, of spiritual life”.
This is because “the first step” is
“blaming oneself”, even if unsaid
and kept between “my conscience
and me”.
To illustrate, the Pope gave a
practical example. When we pass by
a prison, he said, we might think
that the inmates “deserve it”. But, he
asked: “do you know that were it
not for the grace of God, you would
be there? Have you thought that
you too are capable of doing the
things that they did, even worse?”.
This “is to blame ourselves, not to
hide from ourselves the roots of sin
that are in us, the many things we
are capable of doing, even if they
aren’t visible”.
This attitude, Francis continued,
“leads us to feel shame before God,
and this is a virtue: shame before
God”. In order to feel ashamed, we
must say: “Look, Lord, I am disgusted with myself, but You are great:
to me belongs shame, to you — and
I ask for it — mercy”. Just as the
Scripture says: “O Lord, we are
shamefaced, for having sinned
against you”. We can also say, “because we are capable of sinning and
of doing so many bad things: “But
yours, O Lord, our God, are compassion and forgiveness! Shame is
mine, and mercy and forgiveness are
yours”. It is a “dialogue with the
Lord” that will “do us good during
this Lenten season: self-blame”.
“Let us ask for mercy”, the Pope
said then, referring to the day’s Gospel Reading from Luke (6:36-38).
Jesus “is clear: be merciful as your
Father is merciful”. After all, Francis
explained, “when one learns to
blame himself he is merciful with
others”. And he is able to say: “Who
am I to judge him, if I am capable
of doing worse things?”. This is an
important phrase: “Who am I to
judge another?”. This is understood
in the light of Jesus’ words: “Be
merciful, just as your Father is merciful”, and with his call “not to
judge”. Instead, the Pontiff recognized, “how we like to judge others,
to speak ill of them!”. Yet the Lord
is clear: “Stop judging and you will
not be judged. Stop condemning
and you will not be condemned.
Forgive and you will be forgiven”. It
is certainly not an easy road, which
“begins with blaming oneself, it begins from that shame before God
and from asking forgiveness from
Him: ask forgiveness”. Precisely
“from that first step we arrive at
what the Lord asks us: to be merciful, to judge no one, to condemn no
one, to be generous with others”.
From this perspective, the Pope
prayed that “the Lord, in this Lenten season, give us the grace to learn
to blame ourselves, each in his
solitude”, asking ourselves: “Am I
capable of doing this? Am I capable
of doing this, with this attitude?
With this feeling that I have inside,
am I capable of doing worse
things?”. He also invited this prayer:
“Have compassion for me, Lord,
help me to feel shame and give me
mercy, so that I may be merciful
with others”.
number 10, Friday, 6 March 2015
L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO
page 11
International conference at the Pontifical Gregorian University on the challenges posed to evangelization
Theology of the
suffering servant
GEORGE FRANCIS MCLEAN
The road to listening
RICHARD ROUSE
Listening, discerning, welcoming and
serving, these are the four verbs weaving together the working sessions of
the International Conference “Renewing the Church in a Secular Age:
Holistic Dialogue and Kenotic Vision” held at the Pontifical Gregorian
University under the High Patronage
of the Pontifical Council for Culture
as a key milestone in a project of The
Council for Research in Values and
Philosophy, 4-5 March 2015. With keynote addresses by Cardinal Gianfranco Ravasi which focused on the
“Word was made flesh” — theme of
the Holy See’s Pavilion at the Venice
Biennale in 2015 — and the kenosis
(Philippians 2:5-11) and by Charles
Taylor who spoke on authenticity, the
organisers foresee a series of conversations outlining these characteristic
verbs of the Church today.
Taylor, winner of the Templeton
Prize in 2007, is best known for his
tome A Secular Age now required
reading for academics worldwide. Distinguishing between secularity (positive affirmation of the secular sphere),
secularism (ideology desiring to remove religion from public life) and
secularisation
(historical
process
which once foresaw the decline of religion) following Taylor allows those
interested in the New Evangelization
— that is all of us — to read better the
signs of the times and establish
stronger bonds with our contemporaries; trying to make an alliance with
men and women in their cultural contexts, the accusation is often raised
that the post-conciliar church either
imitated the secular or closed ranks in
a conservative reaction following defensive identity processes. Instead, a
third way, an approach balanced on
the basis of the recognition of the
complexities of the current historical
situation, allows for multiple processes and different and various
strategies, drawing on rich theological
resources, in an engaging effective
dialogue, such as will take place in
the Courtyard of the Gentiles on
“The Piazza and the Temple” (American Study Center, 6 March) analysing the coexistence of spiritual and
secular needs, with Giuliano Amato,
Charles Taylor, José Casanova, Alessandro Ferrara, Giacomo Marramao
and François Bousquet.
Modernisation does not lead to religious decline, but to a pluralisation
of the how we believe. A study of
modernity teaches not so much about
the separation of religion from the
public square, or changes in ecclesial
practice, but the emergence of a preference for subjective choice and per-
sonal, spiritual options. It is in light
of this latter category, certainly in the
West, that members of the Council for
Research in Values and Philosophy, an
organization founded and presided by
George McLean, OMI, that in the past
had the support and contributions of
men of culture such as Paul Ricoeur
and Hans-Georg Gadamer and today
is helped by thinkers such as Charles
Taylor, Jose Casanova, Tomáš Halík
and other intellectuals coming from
different continents, have identified
four disjunctions whereby the People
of God, they affirm, has suffered:
between seekers and dwellers; personal, not just individual, responsibility
playing against the aurora of a hierarchical call for obedience; praxis and
ethics as historicised issues rather
than universals; and finally a sphere
of spiritual pluralities against certain
rigid Christologies. To break out from
the constrictions of the Western viewpoint, the scholars are now launching
a series of research projects looking at
the different secularisations taking
place in Africa, Asia and Latin America. If the processes of diverse secularisations are the necessary starting
points for our quests for self-understanding, growth and holiness, then it
is necessary to turn to the support of
the social sciences who give us that
historicity: we are who we are, as
much as who we would be and who
we were.
The working sessions at the Pontifical Gregorian University, organized
by members of its School of Philosophy, are put into a dialogical frame
and will count on input from thinkers
such as José Casanova, Hans Joas,
Tomáš Halík, William Desmond, Adela Cortina, Juan Carlos Scannone
and Louis Caruana just to name a
few. The focus was on how we listen
and to whom we listen, and how we
understand the human person in
midst of the ongoing scientific, digital
and communicational revolutions.
There was discernment on a biblical
basis, particularly the beatitudes, and
a stance of welcoming shaped into an
embracing of both the enjoyable and
the harsh realities of existential peripheries, using narrative, imagination
and literature in an act of kenotic service. Concluding the conference
Taylor delivered a keynote developing
the theme of “Authenticity: The Life
of the Church in a Secular Age” indicating pastoral ramifications for the
People of God. Criticised as disjunctions in earlier times, these are rapidly
becoming conjunctions, trademarks of
the holistic Church in the era of Pope
Francis; but further overcoming, renewing the Church, will require a
stance of authenticity.
manifesting an endless willingness
to suffer in order to serve.
Yet these same challenges lead
others “as dwellers” to seek the
constant guidance available in a
Church tradition and the desire
to have this articulated as amply
as possible. This places Church
leadership
uncomfortably
between two — and more —
groups with quite different needs
and expectations.
In terms of interior self-consciousness this is in effect the
formation of one’s very identity
as described in Charles Taylor’s
Sources of the Self. Here the truly
challenging task is to relate the
ecclesial and the secular in ways
that are mutually complementary
and enriching. For example, can
the role of the Church be not an
alternative to that of the secular
state but, as John Rawls and Jür-
The general phenomenon of progressive secularization over the
last 400 years must be seen in the
light of: first, the broad human
processes of the Reformation reacting against hierarchy, and the
corresponding affirmation of individual authenticity and equality;
second, the Enlightenment’s disjunction of human reason from
the unitive influences of wisdom
and faith; and third, democracy
and human freedom in the evaluation and guidance of human action. All these came together after
World War II upon the development of the pervasive personal
communication system which bypassed the parish church as the
dominant context for the formation of one’s personal outlook.
Hence, it became especially common for young persons
to set out on life with
the attitude of seekers
embarking on the exciting, if at times threatening, adventure of constructing their own life
in their own terms.
More threatening to
their effort than the
danger of occasional
mistakes, they consider
to be the imposition of
a predetermined pattern
of life or culture which
one is destined to follow.
The first set of disjunctions/conjunctions
begins then with the
Ford Madox Brown, “Jesus Washing
seekers in contrast to
Peter’s Feet” (c. 1852–1856)
those focused on dwelling within the Church
and its traditions. The
enigmas of existence emphasized gen Habermas have come to see,
by contemporary theory and cul- a helpful enablement of the huture and the many and develop- man democratic endeavor. Indeed
ing challenges to be faced in life one can go still further with Jürgenerate in the seeker a sense of gen Habermas and Robert Bellah
the inadequacy of universal laws. to recognize the presence of
This leads increasingly to a search proto-religious modes of ritual
to build life with the individual- and myth in the very origins of
istic coordinates of modernity.
humanness itself, e.g., in the
Here the seekers can be seen emergence of the ability to be
less as having left the people of conscious of and to express the
God, than as struggling to live unitive relation to others that
the deep inspiration of the Spirit founds and constitutes humane
in facing their multiple responsib- social life and behavior.
ilities in the Church and the
An alternate path sees living
world, internal and external. The one’s Catholic identity no longer
cost of their search for authenti- as being part of an institution
city can be very high as it takes that is superior and opposed to
them beyond the following of au- the efforts of the people to build
thorities and the cultural attitudes their nation from the ground up,
of neighbors and confreres. Their but rather in the supportive terms
need is not for a Church as an of leaven and narrative. This enideal institution, but one that is tails a theology of Church in the
no longer enchanted and in many kenotic terms of suffering servant.
ways is a fallible, human and hu- Thus it might be regretted that
mane way of living the gospel the nation has become more of a
values. This is a community law enforcing than a political enmarked not by power and con- tity built on the will of the
trol, but by acceptance and en- people, and similarly that the
couragement of those who look Church has come to be more of a
to it in the midst of the needs moral than a spiritual institution.
they experience in their search. Together they leave “a world
Here Christ on the Cross is the without forgiveness and without
kenotic model for the Church in project”.
L’OSSERVATORE ROMANO
page 12
Friday, 6 March 2015, number 10
At the Angelus the Pope speaks of the end of the Lenten journey
Happiness comes after the Cross
And he calls for peace in Syria and Iraq, and an end to tension in Venezuela
At the Angelus in St Peter’s Square on
Sunday, 1 March, the Pope spoke
about the Gospel account of the
Transfiguration and pointed to the aim
of the Lenten journey of conversion
which is, he said, “participation in
Christ’s glory”. Jesus’ path “always
leads us to happiness”. The following is
a translation of the Pope’s reflection,
which was given in Italian.
At the end of the Marian prayer, the
Pope launched an appeal for peace in
Syria and Iraq, and called for an end
to social tension in Venezuela.
Dear Brothers and Sisters,
Good morning.
Last Sunday the Liturgy presented
Jesus tempted by Satan in the
desert, but victorious over temptation. In the light of this Gospel, we
are again made aware of our condition as sinners, but also of the victory over evil for those who undertake the journey of conversion and,
like Jesus, want to do the Father’s
will. In this second Sunday of Lent,
the Church points out to us the end
of this journey of conversion,
namely participation in the glory of
Christ, which shines on the face of
the obedient Servant, who died and
rose for us.
The Gospel page recounts the
event of the Transfiguration, which
takes place at the height of Jesus’
public ministry. He is on his way to
Jerusalem, where the prophecies of
the “Servant of God” and his redemptive sacrifice are to be fulfilled.
The crowds did not understand this:
presented with a Messiah who contrasted with their earthly expectations, they abandoned Him. They
thought the Messiah would be the
liberator from Roman domination,
the emancipator of the homeland,
and they do not like Jesus’ perspective and so they leave Him. Neither
do the Apostles understand the
words with which Jesus proclaims
the outcome of his mission in the
glorious passion, they do not understand! Jesus thus chooses to give to
Peter, James and John a foretaste of
his glory, which He will have after
the Resurrection, in order to confirm
them in faith and encourage them to
follow Him on the trying path, on
the Way of the Cross. Thus, on a
high mountain, immersed in prayer,
He is transfigured before them: his
face and his entire person irradiate a
blinding light. The three disciples
are frightened, as a cloud envelops
them and the Father’s voice sounds
from above, as at the Baptism on
the Jordan: “This is my beloved
Son; listen to him” (Mk 9:7). Jesus
is the Son-made-Servant, sent into
the world to save us all through the
Cross, fulfilling the plan of salvation. His full adherence to God’s
will renders his humanity transparent
to the glory of God, who is love.
Jesus thus reveals Himself as the
perfect icon of the Father, the radiance of his glory. He is the fulfillment of revelation; that is why beside Him appear transfigured,
Moses and Elijah appear; they represent the Law and the Prophets, so
as to signify that everything finishes
and begins in Jesus, in his passion
and in his glory.
Roberto Alabiso “Transfiguration” (2012)
Their instructions for the disciples
and for us is this: “Listen to Him!”.
Listen to Jesus. He is the Saviour:
follow Him. To listen to Christ, in
fact, entails taking up the logic of his
Pascal Mystery, setting out on the
journey with Him to make of oneself
a gift of love to others, in docile
obedience to the will of God, with
an attitude of detachment from
worldly things and of interior freedom. One must, in other words, be
willing to “lose one’s very life” (cf.
Mk 8:35), by giving it up so that all
men might be saved: thus, we will
meet in eternal happiness. The path
to Jesus always leads us to happiness, don’t forget it! Jesus’ way always leads us to happiness. There
will always be a cross, trials in the
middle, but at the end we are always
led to happiness. Jesus does not deceive us, He promised us happiness
and will give it to us if we follow
His ways.
With Peter, James and John we
too climb the Mount of the Transfiguration today and stop in contemplation of the face of Jesus to retrieve the message and translate it
into our lives; for we too can be
transfigured by Love. In reality, love
is
capable
of
transfiguring
everything. Love transfigures all! Do
you believe this? May the Virgin
Mary, whom we now invoke with
the prayer of the Angelus, sustain us
on this journey.
Dear brothers and sisters, dramatic
news of violence, kidnapping and
harassment aimed at Christians and
other groups continues to arrive
from Syria and Iraq. I want to assure those suffering in these situations that we will not forget them,
we are close to them and we are
praying that a stop be put to this intolerable violence of which they are
victims. Together with members of
the Roman Curia last Friday I
offered the last Mass of the Spiritual
Exercises for this intention. At the
same time I ask all, according to
their capacities, to work to alleviate
the suffering of those being tried,
often only because of the faith they
profess. Let us pray for these our
brothers and sisters who are suffering for the faith in Syria and Iraq....
Let us pray in silence....
I would also like to call to mind
Venezuela, which is again undergoing moments of acute tension. I
pray for the victims and, in particular, for the boy killed a few days ago
in San Cristóbal. I exhort everyone
to reject violence and to respect the
dignity of every person and the sacredness of human life and I encourage them to take up the common
path for the good of the Country,
opening again space for encounter
and sincere and constructive dialogue. I entrust that beloved nation
to the motherly intercession of Our
Lady of Coromoto.
I address a cordial greeting to all
of you — families, parish groups, associations — pilgrims from Rome,
from Italy and from different countries.
I wish a good Sunday to all.
D on’t forget, please, to pray for me.
Have a good lunch and goodbye!
At the conclusion of the Spiritual Exercises
A piece of Elijah’s mantle
The meditations on Friday morning, 27 February, in Ariccia were the
last of the Spiritual Exercises in
which the Pontiff and members of
the Roman Curia participated.
Meditations were led by Carmelite,
Fr Bruno Secondin in the chapel of
the House of Divin Maestro belonging to the Pauline Fathers. At
the end of his reflection, Pope
Francis thanked the preacher. “On
behalf of everyone, myself included,” the Pope said, “ I would
like to thank the Father, for his
work with us in the exercises. It
isn’t easy to lead priests in [spiritual] exercises! We are all a little
complicated, but you managed to
do some sowing. May the Lord
make these seeds that you gave us
grow. And I also hope, and I wish
for us all that we may
leave here with a little
piece
of
Elijah’s
mantle, in our hands
and in our hearts.
Thank you, Father”.
The last stop of the
itinerary of reflection
and prayer proposed
by Fr Secondin was
centered on the biblical narrative in the
Second Book of Kings (2:1-14)
which describes Elijah’s final
farewell to his disciples and to
Elisha, his ascent in the chariot of
fire and the start of the mission of
Elisha, who disrobes himself and
puts on the mantle of his master
and, on the River Jordan, he is recognized as the true heir of the
prophet. It is an intense story, filled
with tenderness, in which the characteristic hardness of Elijah melts a
little. The Prophet in some way
learns — and we too should learn,
Fr Secondin suggested “to offer
embraces of hope and tenderness”
— from his disciple who is affectionate and patient.