HVDC Transmission Line for Wind Energy Delivery Southeast Clean Power Summit

HVDC Transmission Line for
Wind Energy Delivery
Southeast Clean Power Summit
New Orleans – February 16, 2012
Pattern and Market Background
Pattern Energy
Pattern is
Committed to
Renewables and
Transmission
•  An independent, fully integrated energy company that
develops, constructs, owns, and operates clean
energy and transmission assets in the United States,
Canada and Latin America
•  Formed in June 2009 by Riverstone and a premier
management team with a proven track record
Riverstone
Holdings LLC
•  Energy focused private equity firm with the largest
renewable energy fund in the world
•  Committing a significant amount of capital to support
and expand Pattern’s business
•  Pattern is the sole wind energy platform for
Riverstone in North America
Growth Projected
Strong & Steady
•  520 MW of installed capacity operational within first
18 months
•  Over 1000 MW expected in construction in next 12
months
•  Pipeline projects diverse in geography and markets
•  Transmission is a key growth area for Pattern
2
Renewable Energy Market Drivers
• 
Despite a lack of federal or state renewable mandates, renewables procurement is
advancing in the Southeast due to attractive pricing and providing fuel and
environmental risk hedges
• 
TVA and Southern Company have contracted for long-term wind energy
purchases from the Midwest (Iowa, Kansas, North Dakota, etc.)
• 
TVA ‘s board approved an IRP calling for 1000+ MW of additional renewables
• 
Louisiana utilities are conducting an LPSC mandated renewables RFP, and
SWEPCO has presented a PPA for LPSC approval
• 
Texas has outstanding wind resources and leads the nation in installed capacity, with
available resources likely exceeding in-state demand
• 
CREZ transmission development that is underway will allow access to additional very
high capacity wind resource areas
• 
All CREZ lines projected to be installed by end of 2013
3
Wind Energy Resource Map:
Limited Options for the Southeast
Source: National Renewable Energy Laboratory, 2010.
4
Limited Transmission Development to Support
Importing Renewables into SERC
Source: Ventyx 2011 and other public announcements
5
Southern Cross Project
Overview
Project Development Background
• 
• 
Pattern teamed with Burns & McDonnell in 2008 to study transmission routes eastward
from the central United States wind resource areas:
– 
Wind resources in Kansas, Oklahoma, Texas and all of the Southeast
– 
Studied SPP, ERCOT, and SERC transmission systems
– 
Cost and load flow analyses on many combinations of source points (Central Plains,
ERCOT), sink points, size (1000 – 3000 MW) and technologies (500 kV, 765 kV, HVDC)
Based on those studies, Pattern concluded:
– 
There are very limited economically efficient wind resources in SERC
– 
Capability for delivery via existing SPP networks is limited
– 
Dedicated transmission lines from Central Plains are substantially longer, more expensive
and technically challenging
– 
Utilizing Texas wind resources transmitted via the ERCOT transmission system provides
significant cost advantages over other alternatives
7
Preliminary Southern Cross Map Project Overview
ERCOT
transmission
utilized
Proposed
500-kV DC
Transmission
Line
8
Proposed Southern Cross Project Overview
• 
Western Interconnection: New 345 kV ERCOT Switchyard in
Rusk County, Texas
• 
Eastern Interconnection: One or more Existing 500 kV
Switchyards in Northeastern Mississippi
• 
Technology: Conventional HVDC Bipole
• 
Sizing:
– 
Initially targeting 1500 MW with Anchor Tenants
– 
Expandable up to 3000 MW (subject to reliability study and to
Open Season subscriptions)
• 
Target Markets: TVA, Southern Company, Entergy, Others in
SERC or FRCC
• 
Target Online Date: 2016
9
ERCOT Interconnection Overview
Texas
Louisiana
New Rusk Switchyard
Interconnection
10
ERCOT Interconnection Overview
New 345-kV
AC Line(s)
Louisiana
New HVDC
Converter Station
New 345-kV
AC Switching Station
New 345-kV
Rusk County
AC Switching Station
Existing ERCOT
345-kV AC Lines
Texas
New HVDC Line
To Mississippi
Converter Station
Oncor - Owned
Facilities
GP&L – Owned
Facilities
Southern Cross - Owned
Facilities
-  ERCOT Facilities
-  PUCT Siting
-  PUCT Rate Recovery
-  CCN Exempt
-  ERCOT Facilities
-  Private ROW acquisition
-  Private Funding
-  CCN Exempt
-  LA, MS State Siting
-  FERC Regulated
-  Merchant OATT
(Bilateral shippers)
Points of Interconnection
(Two Separate Interconnection Agreements)
sian
Loui
AC Switchyard
Texa
s
a
ERCOT Interconnection Overview
DC Transformers
And Converter
Benefits to ERCOT from the
Southern Cross Project
• 
FERC disclaimer of jurisdiction
• 
Expand Texas’s traditional role as an energy supplier
• 
Economic development of incremental wind investment in Texas
• 
Better utilization of CREZ transmission investment
• 
Reliability benefits from access to diverse SERC generation resources
• 
Cost of 345kV AC line and HVDC line will not be included in ERCOT transmission rates
• 
Export charges paid by Southern Cross shippers
• 
Facilitates economic dispatch between the two markets
13
Benefits to SERC from the
Southern Cross Project
• 
Access to the highest capacity factor wind resources in the country, providing stable low
cost electricity that is also a hedge against higher fuel prices and future environmental
regulations
• 
Closest and most robust path for large scale delivery of renewable energy
• 
Materially cheaper than local renewable options, and competitive with conventional
generation options
• 
Economic development in Louisiana and Mississippi from HVDC line and converter
stations
• 
Project funded through transmission charges to shippers and not broad region-wide
ratepayers
• 
Facilitates economic dispatch between the two markets
• 
Allows access to diverse ERCOT generation resources for added reliability
14
Southern Cross Project
Development Status
Development Status – General
• 
Obtained FERC 210/211 order to ensure ERCOT regulatory status quo
• 
Established project configuration, technology (HVDC) and endpoints
• 
Selected optimal project sizing based on evaluation of available technologies and scale
efficiencies
• 
Selected primary and alternative route corridors after comprehensive corridor study
• 
Developed feasible target schedule based on permitting, land acquisition and
construction constraints
• 
Met with numerous stakeholders throughout Texas and the Southeast
• 
Commenced transmission interconnection studies in ERCOT and SERC
• 
– 
RPG Introduction August 2011, Initial Economic Study Complete November 2010
– 
Oncor Reliability Studies Underway
Ongoing discussions with potential Southeastern shippers
16
FERC 210/211 Order Overview
• 
Response to Offer of Settlement from Pattern, Garland Power & Light, and Oncor
• 
Substantive comments offered by PUCT, TIEC
• 
Order issued in December 2011 incorporating PUCT and some TIEC comments
• 
Garland Power & Light – Interconnect Southern Cross to ERCOT system at Louisiana
border
• 
Oncor – Provide transmission service into and out of ERCOT across its network
• 
Contains clear Disclaimer of Jurisdiction confirming actions of ERCOT market
participants does NOT change status quo or increase FERC jurisdiction
• 
Order will be final upon completion of definition of interconnection facilities
17
FERC Negotiated Rate Order
• 
FERC regulates rates for interstate transmission, including Southern Cross
• 
Approval for Southern Cross to charge negotiated rates
• 
Approval to subscribe up to 1500 MW with anchor tenants
• 
Committed to make additional capacity available through open season
• 
Demonstrated that we will satisfy four tests:
– 
Just and Reasonable Rates
– 
Prevention of Undue Discrimination
– 
No Undue Preference and Affiliate Concerns*
– 
Regional Reliability & Operational Efficiency (transmission planning, etc)
• 
* Will commit that no affiliate of Southern Cross Transmission LLC will be an anchor
tenant
• 
Merchant transmission framework not affected by FERC Order 1000 (national
transmission planning and cost recovery)
18
Development Status – Road Ahead
• 
Complete ERCOT and SERC transmission planning studies and interconnection
agreements
• 
Complete anchor tenant marketing and/or open season to establish tenants
• 
Finalize line routing within selected corridor and acquire right of way
• 
Complete all necessary local, state, and federal permitting
• 
Build it!
19
Questions?
Contact Information
Kellie Metcalf, Director of Marketing
(713) 308-4200
[email protected]
David Parquet, Executive Sponsor
(415) 283-4000
[email protected]
Matt Dallas, Media Relations
(917) 363-1333
[email protected]
21