Halloween and the Adopted Child: A Costume is More than It Appears | Portrait of an Ad... Page 1 of 7
Welcome to
ChicagoNow.
Portrait of an Adoption
Meet our bloggers,
post comments, or
pitch your blog idea.
Sign in
Pitch your idea
Halloween and the Adopted
Child: A Costume is More than
It Appears
1
Tweet
6
Like
467
View comments
“BULLIED” WINS BOOK AWARD!
By Carrie Goldman, October 12, 2012 at 12:30 pm
There is a curious pattern to
almost all of the characters
that my daughter Katie has
chosen for her Halloween
costumes.
At age three, she wanted to
be Superman. At age four,
she dressed up as Hermione
Granger from the Harry
Potter series. At age five,
she was Hermione again. At
age six, she paraded around
as Princess Leia. As a
seven-year-old, she held
court as Queen Lucy from
Narnia. At age eight, she was
once again Princess Leia.
TOP 25 BOOK AUTHOR MOMS
All of her characters have been heroic in nature. They have magical
powers or the ability to do things that regular mortals cannot. And none of
them have had strong biological parental figures.
Superman, her first hero, was adopted. He saves people from disaster
time and again. Hermione is a brilliant young woman who has magical
http://www.chicagonow.com/portrait-of-an-adoption/2012/10/halloween-and-the-adopted... 10/18/2013
Halloween and the Adopted Child: A Costume is More than It Appears | Portrait of an Ad... Page 2 of 7
powers, unlike her parents. Hermione helps Harry save the wizarding
world from Lord Voldemort. Princess Leia was adopted and is a leader in
the rebellion against the evil galactic Empire. Lucy is a young girl who was
sent away from her parents during World War II and discovers a magical
land where she is destined to be a good queen.
Katie, who is well aware that she was adopted, has never wanted to dress
up as a duck or a fairy or a pumpkin. Nor does she want to be a puppy or a
kitten. And certainly not a ghoul, a vampire, a mean witch or a goblin. She
is not interested in bloody makeup or scary masks.
From the time she was old enough to express her wishes, she has wanted
to dress up as superhuman characters that have a history of being
separated from their birth parents.
Coincidence? I think not.
It is not uncommon for adopted children to fantasize about their birth
families. Every child yearns to be special and different, but this need can
be magnified with a child who was placed for adoption. I think Katie’s
choice of Halloween costumes reflects a subconscious fantasy about who
she is and what she will become.
She does not want to dress up as someone scary or evil, because she
already fears abandonment and rejection. She is terrified of the possibility
that she is “bad” and has no interest in putting a face to the fear. Katie’s
dream is to discover that she has secret powers, that she is not just good
but superhuman. She wants to save the day and earn the love and praise
of everyone.
But this year, there has been a change to the pattern, and I was thrown for
a loop in my theories about Halloween and my adopted child. Katie told
me, in no uncertain terms, that she wanted to be a Stormtrooper.
A bad guy! Was this a fundamental change in her views? Was this about
her pre-adolescent rebellion? I was fascinated.
And then Katie told me why she wants to be a Stormtrooper. “I want to
stick up for the Star Wars fans who were picked on for dressing in their
costumes at the Star Wars convention. They stood up for me, so I’ll stand
up for them.”
Katie is referring to the Great Star Wars Cyberbullying Incident of 2012,
when a news station in Miami made the mistake of running a slideshow of
photos of Star Wars fans that contained cruel, mocking captions. The news
station ultimately took down the slideshow and apologized.
It all made sense to me. And, in Katie’s mind, the Stormtroopers are the
heroes of the 501st. As an added bonus, Katie is thrilled with the idea that
she is bucking gender norms yet again by wearing a costume traditionally
associated with boys.
SUBSCRIBE BY EMAIL
ex: [email protected]
Create Subscription
Completely spam free, opt out any time.
30 ADOPTION PORTRAITS IN 30 DAYS – 2012
For the second straight year, in honor of
November being National Adoption
Awareness Month, Portrait of an Adoption
is running a special series called 30
Adoption Portraits in 30 Days. Designed to
give a voice to the many different
perspectives of adoption, this series will
feature guest posts by adoptees, birth
parents, adoptive parents, waiting
adoptive parents, and foster parentsturned-adoptive parents. Painful and
beautiful, these stories will bring you a
deeper understanding of what adoption
looks like, allowing you to appreciate the
many brushstrokes that comprise a family
portrait.
Nov. 1: I Never Told Any of My Friends
About My Sons. By Cindy Williams
Nov. 2: Why Do I Have To Be Adopted? By
Jessie Bishop Powell
Nov. 3: We Realized That We Couldn't
Wait Any Longer By Michelle Mercurio
Nov. 4: Lessons Learned from An
Imaginary Redhead By Elisabeth O'Toole
Nov. 5: Clark's Voice By Jay D. Lenn
Nov. 6: I Am That Baby By Tab Curtis
Nov. 7: My Cell Phone Rang: Could I Come
Pick Up the Baby? By Gina Sampaio
http://www.chicagonow.com/portrait-of-an-adoption/2012/10/halloween-and-the-adopted... 10/18/2013
Halloween and the Adopted Child: A Costume is More than It Appears | Portrait of an Ad... Page 3 of 7
Five-year-old Annie Rose told me, “Katie cannot wait to go to school and
then take off her bucket head to reveal that she is a girl!” Two-year-old
Cleo, who idolizes Katie, was planning to dress up as Yoda, but now she
wants to be “Stomtwoopah.”
Nov. 8: I Was Just A Regular Fifteen-Year-
We have a perfect record for Katie dressing up as characters that she
perceives to be heroes and heroines. My theory (as it pertains to my child)
is still intact for now.
Nov. 10: A Letter to My Son's Birth
Find Carrie on Facebook
Marianna
Old Girl By Haley
Nov. 9: I Couldn't Understand Why They
Got to Go Home and I Didn't. By Amy
Guimond
Mother By Merrin Donahue
Nov. 11: Stop Asking Adopted Kids If We
Want To Find Our Real Parents. By
Nov. 12: Why A Loving Parent Raises a
Child's Expectations in Life. By Exavier
Find Carrie on Twitter
Pope
Nov. 13: The Grief in Knowing I Will
Never Be Called Mom. By an Anonymous
Birthmother
Filed under: Uncategorized
1
Tweet
6
Like
467
Nov. 14: We Were Told to Leave Nina in
the Playroom, All by Herself, and Depart.
View comments
MORE FROM CHICAGONOW
FROM AROUND THE WEB
This Is What It Looks Like When Your
Kid Has A Nut Allergy
Charlie Hunnam's 'Over the Top' '50
Shades' Demands Don't Make Sense |
Adventures in Oral Therapy: The
Masque Challenge, Part 2
Dear Child Being Bullied, These Notes
R 4 U. Love, NY Comic Con
CafeMom
'Teen Mom' Star Confesses to Being
Mentally Destroyed by Fame | CafeMom
Brave Girls in New York: Times Square,
United Nations and Comic-Con
Wife ruins husbands tax scam after
posting their wedding photos on
Facebook | Daily Dot
Bullying Prevention To Take Over New
York Comic Con This Weekend!
Daughter is brutally honest about mother
in obituary. It's gone viral. | Daily Dot
Kendra Wilkinson: Why I Don’t Talk to
Holly Madison Anymore | Hollyscoop
[what's this]
By Jiyer
Nov. 15: We Had ‘Married In’ Through
Caroline. By Sarah Werthan Buttenwieser
Nov. 16: Opening a Can of Worms By
Bonnie S. Schwartz
Nov. 17: But While You Fly, You Still Wait
By Kelley Porter
Nov. 18: To meet or not to meet? By
Melissa Flanagan
Nov. 19: But Then the Greatest Moment of
My Whole Life Occurred By Bruce Ellis
Nov. 20: How Can We Convince Her We
Are THE ONES? By Sheila Quirke
Nov. 21: This Tug of War Was Destroying
Him By Danielle
Nov. 22: The Walls of Secrecy Dissolved
Naturally By Sara Hylton
Nov. 23: This crazy, wonderful, hectic,
loving open adoption By M
Nov. 24: Time Seems To Be Standing Still
By Kathy Bright
Nov. 25: Why My Son Has A Closed
Adoption By Anonymous
Nov. 26: One By One, My Friends’
Children Were Having Babies. By Nanci
Stein “Granci”
Nov. 27: We Didn't Get To Keep the Other
Leave a comment
Baby, But This One Is Ours Forever By
Lindsey Redfern
Nov. 28: Someday I Hope That She Will
Seek Me Out By Tamara Tranowski
Nov. 29: She's My Girl, Just As If She Were
Born To Us By Andrew
http://www.chicagonow.com/portrait-of-an-adoption/2012/10/halloween-and-the-adopted... 10/18/2013
Halloween and the Adopted Child: A Costume is More than It Appears | Portrait of an Ad... Page 4 of 7
13 comments
Add a comment
Nov. 30: I Had My Mother's Name! By
Chad Cottle
Gina Canady
Please tell Katie thank you from us. She is going to make one heck of a Lady
Stormtrooper! ♥ :D
FACEBOOK PAGE FOR PORTRAIT OF AN
Stormtrooper TK1548, 501st Legion.
Reply ·
9 · Like · October 16, 2012 at 3:04pm
Portrait Of An Adoption
Allisha Price Larsen
Like
My daughter, Brittanie, has been trooping with the 501st for about a year and a
half. She has Scout Trooper armor and has a blast. One of our favorite moments
was last year at a Halloween event when a teenage girl came up and asked to
feel her muscles. Britt lifted her bucket off her head as replied "You do know I'm
a girl right?" Hysterical. So Miss Katie, you go girl. All the girl troopers are behind
you...and their Moms too.
Reply ·
6,854 people like Portrait Of An Adoption.
6 · Like · October 16, 2012 at 3:35pm
Kevin Skiera · TK-9336 at 501st Midwest Garrison
No one is ever too young to make a difference, or be a stormtrooper. Kidos
Katie!
-PFC Skiera, Kevin R. US Army/ TK-9336, Midwest Garrison, 501st Legion.
Reply ·
Tweets by @cmgsart
5 · Like · October 16, 2012 at 7:06pm
Romain Harlock Rousse ·
Top Commenter
MEET THE BLOGGER
Exactly ! Keep up with your dreams and spray the fun everywhere ;)
TK-3375, French Garrison
Reply ·
1 · Like · October 17, 2012 at 12:03pm
Heidi Henning
Awesome! Katie is an intelligent and compassionate young lady. Sounds like
Halloween will be an exciting venture! And yay for non traditional gender roles
for costumes! I am dressing up as Hawkeye from the Avengers. (:
Reply ·
3 · Like · October 14, 2012 at 9:22am
Christopher Marino · Monrovia, California
I love your articles and as someone who was adopted I love reading about Katie
she really is an amazing girl. For her being a Stormtrooper for Halloween there
just cool.
Reply ·
3 · Like · October 12, 2012 at 12:19pm
Bruce Ellis · Works at Warrior Author and Druid Knight
In some religions Halloween is seen as a time to dress to express those things
you wish to bring out in yourself in the future. That being the case it appears
that Katie has made some great choices.
Reply ·
2 · Like · October 12, 2012 at 1:06pm
Brian Held Jr · Delgado CC
Mini Trooper costume article mid way down the page - http://www.tk409.com/
tk409.html.
Good luck on being a Stormtrooper, I know I enjoy being one. ;)
TK-9855
Reply ·
1 · Like · October 16, 2012 at 5:44pm
Karrie Tyler · University of New Orleans
how awesome is that!
Reply · Like · October 16, 2012 at 9:03pm
Maria Krogstrup Hareskov ·
Top Commenter · Danmarks Biblioteksskole,
Aalborg
Personally I always wanted to be a snowtrooper (when it comes to the Imperial
side). ;) Some day I will be. It's a promise I have made to myself. But my
childhood hero was also Princess Leia; she showed that women could be strong
leaders and heroes, and I just fell in love with her spirit. :) Leia is a fighter. I
think Katie is a fighter, too.
Reply ·
1 · Like · October 12, 2012 at 12:28pm
Kim Z. Dale ·
Top Commenter · Author/ Writer at Listing Toward Forty
Carrie Goldman
I am a writer and artist living
north of Chicago. My husband
Andrew and I have three
daughters -- Katie, Annie Rose
and Cleo. My first book, which
is an exploration of bullying,
will be published by Harper Collins in 2012.
RECENT POSTS
Talking Adoption With a Four-Year-Old
Boy »
Carrie Goldman on Portrait of an Adoption
Posted today at 9:43 am
Halloween Costumes for Girls: Sexy Witch,
Sassy Princess, or Sultry Superhero? »
Carrie Goldman on Portrait of an Adoption
Posted Thursday at 8:54 am
Brave Girls in New York: Times Square,
United Nations and Comic-Con »
Carrie Goldman on Portrait of an Adoption
Posted Tuesday at 8:54 pm
Dear Child Being Bullied, These Notes R 4
U. Love, NY Comic Con »
Carrie Goldman on Portrait of an Adoption
Posted October 12, 2013 at 9:57 pm
Bullying Prevention To Take Over New
York Comic Con This Weekend! »
Carrie Goldman on Portrait of an Adoption
Posted October 8, 2013 at 7:41 am
I was Darth Vader when I was in grade school. I guess I'm just evil. (I was
nugget-head Leia a few years later, so perhaps I was reformed.) I love all of
Katie's costume choices. I just hope she's not the Stormtrooper who hits his
head on the door What a dork!
http://www.chicagonow.com/portrait-of-an-adoption/2012/10/halloween-and-the-adopted... 10/18/2013
Halloween and the Adopted Child: A Costume is More than It Appears | Portrait of an Ad... Page 5 of 7
LATEST ON CHICAGONOW
Richard O’Brien’s The Rocky Horror Show
(pH Productions): Don’t dream it…go see
it!
from The Fourth Walsh by Katy Walsh
posted today at 1:49 pm
Cubs Notes: MLB Draft, Scouting info on
Alex Jackson and Suk-Min Yoon; status on
Mike Olt
from Cubs Den by John Arguello
posted today at 1:16 pm
Fashion Focus-Taking it to the
Streets...Chicago Style!
from Moveyourbody by Eric Smith
posted today at 1:16 pm
Giovanni Canaletto: A Virtuoso of
Venice...Does His Name Ring a Bell?
from The Quark In The Road by Aquinas wired
posted today at 1:15 pm
SIGHTINGS: Will Ferrell at Del Frisco’s
from Pop Buzz! by Lashonda
posted today at 12:59 pm
RELATED POSTS
From Lifestyle: Parenting »
15 years ago, and today. »
Janet Dahl on Janet Dahl, et al.
Posted Thursday at 8:59 am
CPS Eases Retention Reqs »
Alexander Russo on District 299: The Inside
Scoop on CPS
Posted today at 8:23 am
Pumpkin Palooza taking place at the
Chicago Flea MKT on October 6th »
Caitlin Giles on Wee Windy City
Posted September 30, 2013 at 10:35 pm
It's not Maria Kang's fault I'm fat »
Jenna Karvunidis on High Gloss and Sauce
Posted Tuesday at 11:30 pm
Dear 20-Year-Old Self, You Should Have
Enjoyed Your Perky Boobs »
Karen Putz on Barefoot In The Burbs
Posted September 25, 2013 at 10:03 pm
RELATED BLOGS
Janet Dahl, et al.
http://www.chicagonow.com/portrait-of-an-adoption/2012/10/halloween-and-the-adopted... 10/18/2013
Halloween and the Adopted Child: A Costume is More than It Appears | Portrait of an Ad... Page 6 of 7
Life in the slow lane.
District 299: The Inside Scoop
on CPS
News & commentary on Chicago
schools
Wee Windy City
Family-friendly activities in Chicago
High Gloss and Sauce
If the Duggars were liberal
Barefoot In The Burbs
Running around barefoot in the
'burbs and on the water too.
More from Lifestyle: Parenting
READ THESE CHICAGONOW BLOGS
Plant Strong Diva Chicago
Live Well, Eat Well, Pay it Forward
• 3 Minute No Sugar Added Blackberry Chia Fresca
Whatchoo Got To Say?
A Hancock High School Blog
• Should teens fit in at Chicago Public Schools?
Black Church Culture
Does culture dictate the way we
worship?
• Mass Confusion
READ THESE CHICAGONOW BLOGGERS
Brandi Wall
from Recipes For The Home Cook:
http://www.chicagonow.com/portrait-of-an-adoption/2012/10/halloween-and-the-adopted... 10/18/2013
Halloween and the Adopted Child: A Costume is More than It Appears | Portrait of an Ad... Page 7 of 7
John Boehner Speaks For
America? Not for me!
DougThonus
from Chicago Bulls Confidential:
Derrick Rose puts on a show for
the home crowd
Tatiana's Tails
from Tatiana's Tails:
Paul & Victoria Shaffer - Meet
Their Shelter Pets
TODAY'S FLYERS
Menards
Target
2 Days Left
2 Days Left
Family Dollar
JCPenney
2 Days Left
Brand New Flyer
Flyer alerts and shopping advice from ChicagoShopping.com
Enter your email
Subscribe
About ChicagoNow • FAQs • Advertise • Recent posts RSS • Privacy policy • Comment policy • Terms of service •
Chicago Internet Marketing Services
©2013 CTMG - A Chicago Tribune website - Crafted by the News Apps team
http://www.chicagonow.com/portrait-of-an-adoption/2012/10/halloween-and-the-adopted... 10/18/2013