THE CHICAGO JEWISH NEWS www.chicagojewishnews.com June 5-11, 2015/18 Sivan 5775 Chicago connection to JFK assassination One Dollar Where kids can play with Chagall masterpieces Summer Arts Preview Preview of Chicago Jewish Film Festival Listings of events of Jewish interest Americans who fought for Israel in 1948 Where Barack and Bibi went sour Rabbi Conover on humility of Moses Lebron’s Jewish coach 2 Chicago Jewish News - June 5-11, 2015 For Israeli war volunteers, service was most important act of their lives By Tom Tugend JTA In May 1948, I was walking down Market Street in San Francisco when I passed a small movie theater with a marquee that announced “The Jews Fight for Their State.” For the first time, it fully hit me that the Jews – by the gentile consensus of the time, mainly cowards and draft dodgers – were actually taking on five vastly superior armies. I took the train back to Berkeley but had a hard time focusing on my studies at the University of California. With the school year nearing its end, I decided to go join the fight. I was among some 4,000 volunteers from 57 countries who volunteered during Israel’s War of Independence, a group collectively known as Machal, the Hebrew acronym for volunteers from abroad. But while these overseas volunteers certainly played a role in Israel’s victory, I believe that the major contribution of these volunteers was to lift the morale of the Israelis by showing them that their Diaspora brethren – along with a fair number of nonJewish volunteers – were with them, atoning in a small way for their elders’ inaction during the Holocaust. As with all men who go to war voluntarily, our motives were mixed – and not always idealistic. After the emotional intensity of fighting as a U.S. infantryman in France and Germany during World War II, I found it hard to settle down. My early exposure to Zionism in Berlin in the mid1930s had also left an imprint. And since a new Jewish state is established only every 2,000 years or so, I figured I probably wouldn’t be around for the next one. Sunday, June 14, 2015 he E et A00pm 4: 11:30am u Anshe Emet Synagogue 3751 N. Broadway in Chicago Kosher BBQ Competition Live Music & Entertainment Dunk Tank Chicago Boyz Acrobatic Team Pickle & Hot Dog Eating Contests Face Painters Stilt Walkers Milt’s Food Truck Bizar Entertainment Hi-Five Hoops Basketball and NFL Flag Football Clinics And More! for more information and full event schedule visit www.chikosherbbq.org Host Sponsors Presenting Sponsors A $5 donation for entry is suggested with the proceeds going to this year’s designated charity, Maot Chitim. My first step was to figure out how to get there. The U.S. State Department, which did not share my enthusiasm for Israel, stamped most passports “Not good for travel to Palestine” and warned that serving in a foreign army might well entail loss of American citizenship. My journey took me from the offices of the butchers’ union in San Francisco, whose business agent doubled as a secret recruiter, to Israel’s so-called “Land and Labor” headquarters in Manhattan, and then by ship across the Atlantic to the French port of Le Havre. There we were met by an Israeli contact who put us on a train to Paris, and from there on to Marseilles. At the city’s train station, another contact conveyed us to Camp Grand Arenas, which served as a transit point for North African Jews and European Holocaust survivors waiting for boats to take them to Israel. At the time, a temporary armistice had been declared between Jewish and Arab forces, supervised by a U.N. contingent which was to ensure that neither side brought in reinforcements. Nevertheless, we set out under tight security on the Pan York, a creaky former banana carrier. The ship’s hold had been reconfigured with planks, stacked four levels high, that served as beds – an arrangement familiar from concentration camp photos. Nobody was allowed up on deck, and the Israelis in charge, laboring under the delusion that the English and American volunteers represented a sane and stable element, assigned us to keep order until the ship cleared the harbor. When the ship arrived in Haifa, the genuine refugees passed quickly through immigration inspection, while we foreign volunteers were taken by a circuitous route around the U.N. inspectors enforcing the armistice rules. The Israeli manpower distribution system, as least for foreign volunteers, was a throwback to feudal times, when the local baron recruited troops by promising certain bounties. My recruiter was Lester Gorn, a Hollywood scriptwriter who had served as a U.S. Army major during World War II. Gorn had persuaded Israel’s army command to let him organize something called the 4th Anti-Tank Troop, which was to consist solely of English-speaking volunteers, or “Anglo-Saxim” in local parlance. The troop would be a “democratic” outfit, Gorn said, with no ranks or saluting and with all major decisions to be taken by majority vote – except in combat. For a lowly ex-GI with little fondness for military punctilio, the offer was too good to turn down and off I went in Gorn’s Tom Tugend, fourth from left, and fellow foreign volunteers during Israel's War of Independence. (JTA) jeep. We soon arrived at the unit’s encampment and I quickly noticed that something was missing: There were no anti-tank guns in sight, only one wooden replica of a cannon. When I pointed out the omission, Gorn assured me that as soon as the Israeli infantry captured a gun from the enemy, we would be in business. Indeed, within a short time, the unit welcomed a 17-pound artillery piece that had been seized from the Jordanian Legion. We made do with this venerable weapon until the battle of Faluja, where Israeli troops surrounded a sizable Egyptian force under the command of one Col. Abdel Nasser, later to become president of Egypt. The beleaguered Egyptians fought stubbornly, but one day our unit, part of the encircling Israeli force, received a perfect present – a shipment of anti-tank guns from Czechoslovakia that was originally destined for Germany’s Wehrmacht. The weapons were so new, they were still wrapped in the original oilcloth, which we quickly ripped off to discover a curious emblem stamped into the side of the gun barrel – a big, fat swastika. Irony doesn’t get much better than that – a bunch of Jewish guys firing a swastika-emblazoned gun at the enemy. Our unit was a strange mixture of men, all from Englishspeaking countries. The youngest member was Jason Fenton, a downy-cheeked 16-year-old Brit who later became a professor of English in Southern California. The oldest guy, probably in his mid-40s, was a Polish-born immigrant to the United States who upon spying a young female urged us to “clean those rusty pipes.” To get a little closer to the enemy, I joined an Israeli infantry squad in a night patrol to feel out the Egyptian defenses. We got near enough to hear the voices of the Egyptian guards – there was an exchange of gunfire, but no casualties. “I am intensely alive and aware of everything,” I wrote of the experience a few weeks later. “Every movement or noise makes a sharp impression. Everything I see, hear and smell etches itself into my memory.” On the way back, the mood is quite different. “After a few hundred meters,” I wrote, “my stomach muscles loosen, the tenseness is slowly drained from my body and in its place creeps a heavy tiredness. The senses are dulled and the box of ammunition gets heavier with every step.” In what proved to be the last major action of the war, our unit drove down the eastern edge of the Negev, along the Jordanian border, heading for the Red Sea. Around 5 a.m. on March 11, 1949, we crested the final hill and spread out below us was the village of Um Rash Rash, consisting of two mud huts and a flagpole – the site of the future bustling city of Eilat. On both sides of the bay, craggy mountains flanking the waters of the Red Sea were turning reddish in the early sunlight. After weeks of dirt and dust, we stripped off our fatigues and jumped buff naked into the sea. After the war, the role played by the foreign volunteers was largely ignored by historians. Hollywood had the opposite problem – their renderings tended to exaggerate their contribution. Make no mistake – the Israelis won their own war, and paid the price in dead and wounded. Still, for most of us, our small part in the creation and survival of the Jewish state represents, I believe, the most important act of our lives. During World War II, GIs scrawled on the shattered walls of European battlefields the words “Kilroy Was Here.” In a similar sense, the surviving volunteers of the War of Independence can affirm with some pride that we were there. 3 Chicago Jewish News - June 5-11, 2015 Where the Obama-Netanyahu relationship went wrong By Ron Kampeas JTA WASHINGTON – When David Axelrod, then a senior adviser to President Barack Obama, first learned that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu reportedly had referred to him and White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel as “self-hating Jews,” he remembers feeling stung. “For people to suggest that I would be anti-Israel or worse, anti-Semitic – it hurts,” Axelrod recalled of the 2009 episode. Robert Wexler, the former Florida congressman who was Obama’s Jewish community liaison in the 2008 and 2012 elections, remembers his own oh-no moment with Netanyahu. It was in May 2011, when Netanyahu, irritated by Obama’s call for an Israeli-Palestinian peace deal based on the 1967 lines, decided to use an Oval Office photo opportunity to publicly lecture Obama on Middle East history. “I was embarrassed, as an American, that an American president is forced to sit and listen to a reciting of a point of view,” Wexler said. “Had Prime Minister Netanyahu been the prime minister of probably any other nation on earth, the president would have gotten out of his chair and walked away.” The interviews with Axelrod and Wexler are part of a series of recent conversations with top figures in the Obama camp, including the president himself, that offer new details about the breakdown in the relationship between the U.S. president and the Israeli prime minister – and lay bare just how troubled that relationship has become. The interviews were conducted by Ilana Dayan, who hosts the newsmagazine show “Uvda,” Israel’s version of “60 Minutes.” “The trust is gone on both sides; there’s too much water under the bridge between those two leaders now,” said interviewee Martin Indyk, who served as the administration’s special envoy for Israeli-Palestinian peace in 2013 and 2014. Indyk, now a vice president at the Brookings Institution, said Netanyahu suffers similar dysfunctional relationships with other world leaders, citing tensions between Netanyahu and European leaders otherwise seen as Israel-friendly. “It’s that mutual lack of trust which has poisoned the relationships,” Indyk said. Indyk did not lay all the blame on Netanyahu, saying Obama committed the original sin by leaving Israel out of his Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu meeting with President Barack Obama in the Oval Office of the White House. (JTA) first multi-day trip to the Middle East as president, when he visited Cairo and Saudi Arabia in June 2009. “He reached out to the Arab and Muslim world and then he didn’t go to Israel. That was the original miscalculation,” Indyk said. “He lost them there and he never got them back. It sent a message that he didn’t like them that much, that he wanted to put some distance between the United States and Israel.” For their part, Israeli government officials say Netanyahu’s stance toward Obama is all about policy, not personality, and that his No. 1 concern is ensuring Israel’s security – even if it means ruffling feathers with the president. They say Netanyahu will not hold back about expressing his concerns with U.S. policies he believes do not account for the brutal realities of the Middle East – especially the looming deal with Iran, which Netanyahu says will leave Israel’s most strident enemy on the threshold of a nuclear weapon. “The bottom line is that the Obama administration believes that the deal they are currently negotiating with Iran blocks Iran’s path to the bomb,” Ron Dermer, Israel’s ambassador to the United States, said in an appearance at the conservative Heritage Foundation. “Israel believes that this deal paves Iran’s path to the bomb.” In his interview with “Uvda,” Obama said, “The best way to prevent Iran from having a nuclear weapon is a verifiable tough agreement. A military solution will not fix it, even if the United States participates.” He added, “I can say to the Israeli people: I understand your concerns and I understand your fears.” Indyk said Obama feels hurt by the way he is portrayed in Israel. “He’s deeply offended by the notion that he’s anti-Israel or anti-Semitic,” Indyk said. “He’s hurt by it now. It’s finally got to him, the ingratitude of Israelis to this president.” Other interviewees included media personalities such as Jeffrey Goldberg of the Atlantic and David Remnick of The New Yorker; U.S.-Israeli businessman Haim Saban, an Obama confidant; Alan Solow, a top Chicago backer of Obama since the 1990s, when he chaired the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations; Rep. Nita Lowey of New York, the top Democrat on the powerful U.S. House of Representatives Appropriations Committee; and Netanyahu confidant Dore Gold, who was recently named the director general of Israel’s Foreign Ministry. Saban described the relationship between Netanyahu and Obama as like “oil and water” and said the crisis in relations is not in the future; it is here already. In a recent private meeting with the president, Saban noted, Obama described the Palestinians as “oppressed people in occupied territories.” The “Uvda” program identified several key low points in the Obama-Netanyahu relationship: Netanyahu’s Oval Office “lecture” to Obama in May 2011; Netanyahu’s embrace of Mitt Romney during the 2012 U.S. election campaign; and Netanyahu’s speech to Congress in March, which Netanyahu and Republican leaders scheduled without the White House’s knowledge and went ahead with over the objections of administration officials. Interviewees also cited Netanyahu’s warnings on Election Day in March about Arab voters going to the polls in “droves” and late in the campaign about the impracticality of the two-state solution as further undercutting trust between the two leaders. “There is this chasm of trust, and this chasm of trust grows wider when you wink and nod before an election,” Axelrod said. Lowey said she agreed with much of the skepticism expressed by Netanyahu over the Iran deal in his speech to Congress and has asked the White House to tamp down the tensions with Israel. “I told the White House to dial it down,” the veteran congresswoman said. But she, too, expressed frustrations with Netanyahu. Lowey recalled a call with the prime minister on a Friday in February during which she offered to set up a private briefing with Congress to replace the public speech because tensions over the address were undercutting the U.S.-Israel relationship. “I said to Bibi, call within an hour because I knew we were approaching Shabbat,” Lowey said. “I’m still waiting for the return phone call.” Axelrod described Netanyahu’s speech to Congress, which came two weeks before Israeli elections, as a “highly political exercise.” Solow and others suggested that Netanyahu made a political calculation early on to play rough with Obama, figuring it would serve him well politically at home. “He was going to make sure that for political purposes in Israel that he was characterized as somebody who was a strong defender of Israel against a president with whom he knew he was going to have some substantive disagreements,” Solow said of Netanyahu. Indyk said Netanyahu has taken a highly risky gamble by ringing the alarm bell on Iran in a manner that has come at the expense of the U.S.-Israel relationship. “If Israel is really threatened by Iran, then he should be doing things that ensure Israel’s security, starting with making sure the U.S.-Israel relationship is on solid ground,” Indyk said of Netanyahu. “He should read the map, because if he’s not going to succeed it will have screwed up the relationship between the United States and Israel, opened up a gap between Israel and its most important friend and most important strategic ally – its force multiplier, its greatest deterrent.” FairCHI 1-5 page.ai 1 2/23/2015 9:49:19 PM We will take care of her as well as you do cRc Certified Kosher Kitchen 200 North Columbus z Chicago, Illinois 60601 312-565-6633 z [email protected] themillenniumparkhotel.com/weddings 4 Chicago Jewish News - June 5-11, 2015 Contents Jewish News ■ The Israeli military admitted its error in punishing a soldier from the United States who brought non-kosher sandwiches on his base. “Bottom line, we were wrong,” Israel Defense Forces spokesman Moti Almoz said. “The IDF will continue to remain kosher, while not snooping in the sandwiches of its soldiers,” Almoz said. “There are tensions in Israeli society, and there are different positions and opinions. In the IDF there is a place for everyone.” It is against IDF rules to bring non-kosher food on its bases, which are kosher. The soldier, who said he was given the pork sandwiches by his grandmother, who lives on a kibbutz, reportedly told the army he was not aware of the rule. The soldier, who is participating in a commander’s course, originally was sentenced to 11 days in military jail for the infraction. ■ The Jewish Community of Rome has compiled a blacklist with the names of people who sold or denounced Jews to German and Italian persecutors during World War II. The blacklist, which will be not published, covers the period from Oct. 16, 1943, when more than 1,000 Roman Jews were caught and deported to Nazi concentration camps, until June 4-5 the following year, when the city was liberated. Research by historians uncovered the exact number of Jews deported from Rome during the war. “The gravestones show the number at 2,091 deportees, but the exact number is 1,769: 1,022 in the October 16th raid, and 747 in the following months when Roman Jews were arrested in the capital,” Claudio Procaccia, director of the Cultural Department of the Jewish Community, said. ■ Indian ice cream lovers are putting their favorite treat in a cone named after Adolf Hitler. The boxes of Hitler ice cream cones bear the unsmiling image of the Nazi leader dressed in a military uniform. The cones are available throughout India. The name of the cones is not shocking to Indians because of the lack of Holocaust education in the country. In 2012, municipal authorities in the Indian state of Gujarat removed the sign for a men’s clothing store named Hitler. The sign – on which the letter “i” was dotted with a swastika – was removed after hundreds of complaints from both within and outside of the Jewish community. A year earlier, an Indian network premiered a daily soap opera called “Hitler Didi,” or “Auntie Hitler,” in which the lead character is a young woman known in her locality as a strict disciplinarian who takes a no-nonsense attitude with her family. ■ New York City’s Department of Health and Mental Hygiene is investigating reports of food sickness following an event at a Manhattan synagogue dedicated to exotic kosher cuisine. The dinner, held at Congregation Shearith Israel, known as the Spanish-Portuguese synagogue, was meant to highlight animals and other foods that are kosher but rarely consumed by observant Jews, such as oxtail, locusts, quail eggs and organ meat from calves, chickens, ducks and other animals. The so-called Halakhic Dinner combined the exotic dishes with Jewish teachings about them and was led by the synagogue’s rabbi, Meir Soloveichik. Similar dinners have taken place in past years. After the dinner, about 20 people reported gastrointestinal distress, according to Vos Is Neias, an Orthodox blog and news site. The blog cited Dani Klein, who runs the YeahThatsKosher blog and attended the dinner, as saying that his wife tested positive after the dinner for campylobacter, a bacteria associated with raw or uncooked poultry, unpasteurized dairy products or contaminated water, poultry or produce. A spokesman for the city’s Department of Health, Christopher Miller, said, “We’re investigating and working with the synagogue. “Did you know that giraffes are kosher? How about locusts? They are!” read a promotion for the event on Shearith Israel’s website. “Rabbi Soloveichik will entertain and enlighten with a special lecture over dinner. We’ll learn about some far out there kosher foods, and we’ll eat a few of them too. Goat, venison, bison and squab are just a few of the expected featured ingredients. Come hungry and adventurous.” ■ Two Jewish experts have been appointed belatedly to a government panel in Germany on anti-Semitism following protests by Jewish groups. Germany’s Interior Ministry announced that it had named psychologist Marina Chernivsky and historian Andreas Nachama to the panel, whose mandate is to report regularly on antiSemitism and efforts to combat it in Germany. It will also make recommendations based on best practices and consultations with other experts. The panel was established in 2009, with rotating membership. Chernivsky is the director of Change Your Outlook, an educational initiative against intolerance and anti-Semitism for the Frankfurt-based Central Welfare Council of Jews in Germany. Nachama, an ordained rabbi, is the director of Topography of Terror, a museum and archive about the Gestapo in Berlin, and is frequently asked to comment on issues regarding anti-Semitism. JTA THE CHICAGO JEWISH NEWS Vol. 21 No. 35 Joseph Aaron Editor/Publisher 6 Torah Portion Golda Shira Senior Editor/ Israel Correspondent Pauline Dubkin Yearwood Managing Editor 7 Death Notices Joe Kus Staff Photographer 8 Cover Story Roberta Chanin and Associates Steve Goodman Naomi Ben-Ari Advertising Account Executives Denise Plessas Kus Production Director 12 Community Calendar Kristin Hanson Accounting Manager/ Webmaster Jacob Reiss 12 CJN Classified Subscriptions Manager/ Administrative Assistant Ann Yellon of blessed memory Office Manager 14 By Joseph Aaron www. chicagojewishnews .com Some of what you’ll find in the ONLINE version of Chicago’s only weekly Jewish newspaper DAILY JEWISH NEWS For the latest news about Jews around the world, come by everyday and check out what’s making headlines. ARCHIVES Look back at articles from the past, including recipes, Torah portions, Joseph Aaron’s column and more. Product and establishment advertising does not constitute a Kashrut endorsement or endorsement of products or services. Believing in providing our readers with a range of viewpoints, the Chicago Jewish News does not take editorial stands on issues. The opinions expressed by any of our columnists are theirs and theirs alone and do not necessarily represent the position of the newspaper. The Chicago Jewish News (ISSN 1084-1881) is published weekly by the Chicago Jewish News Front Page Council in Memory of Chaim Zvi. Office of publication: 5301 W. Dempster, Skokie, Ill. 60077. Subscription by mail: $40 for one year. Periodical postage paid at Skokie, Ill. POSTMASTER: send address changes to Chicago Jewish News, 5301 W. Dempster, Skokie, Ill. 60077. PHONE NUMBER (847) 966-0606 Advertising Ext. 18 Circulation Ext. 21 Editorial Ext. 13 Production Ext. 19 THE FORUM Express your views on a Jewish issue in the news or about any article you’ve read in the Chicago Jewish News. You can even get into a discussion with others. MAZEL TOVS Someone you know celebrating a simcha, a bar/bat mitzvah, engagement, wedding, birthday, anniversary? Send them congratulations. Classified Ext. 16 Accounting Ext. 17 FAX (847) 966-1656 CONDOLENCES Send a message of condolence to those who have lost a loved one. COMMUNITY CALENDAR You can not only check out what’s coming up in the Jewish community but you can add your event to this comprehensive calendar. PERSONALS Find Mr. or Ms. Jewish Right. For Israel Advertising Information: IMP Group Ltd. 972-2-625-2933 Like Chicago Jewish News on Facebook. 5 Chicago Jewish News - June 5-11, 2015 Why the NBA Finals are a lose-lose situation for David Blatt away anything from Blatt’s ability. In theory, the finals offer a chance for some face-saving redemption. But in reality, the series is shaping up as a lose-lose By Gabe Friedman JTA After the last game of an impressive series sweep of the Atlanta Hawks, Cleveland Cavaliers coach David Blatt talked with broadcaster Ernie Johnson in front of an arena of joyous hometown fans. “So let’s be honest,” Johnson said. “This hasn’t always been easy this year, David. But to be standing here, going to the finals, just tell me how that feels to you tonight.” “Well, we’re in Cleveland,” Blatt said with a smile. “Nothing is easy here.” As candid as that sounds, it’s almost an understatement in terms of describing Blatt’s tumultuous first season as an NBA coach. Somehow, despite parlaying a stellar European coaching career into a trip to the NBA Finals in just one season, Blatt finds himself on the hot seat, with something to prove. How does that happen? The crazy ride started with Blatt, 56, a four-time Coach of the Year in Israel, leading Maccabi Tel Aviv to an improbable Euroleague title in 2014. Blatt, who played point guard at Princeton and professionally in Israel’s Super League, initially thought he’d transfer to the NBA as an assistant to new Golden State Warriors coach Steve Kerr (whom he’ll now oppose in the finals) – but the Cavaliers took a chance and hired him as head coach in June 2014 to helm a team with modest expectations. Quickly, however, things advanced to another level. Just weeks after Blatt was hired, LeBron James – a northeastern Ohio native, a four-time MVP and one of the best players in NBA history – announced that he was leaving the Miami Heat (after two titles and four straight trips to the finals) to return to the Cavaliers, where he started his pro career as a teenager. Overnight, the Cavaliers were draped with championship-size expectations. The preseason acquisition of All-Star Kevin Love to join LeBron and Kyrie Irving, among the top point guards in the league, only added to the hype. As the stars adjusted to playing together, the season started slowly – the club was 19-20 in January and lost its starting center to a year-ending injury. While the growing pains were predictable, Blatt’s job was rumored to be in jeopardy. Rumors that LeBron wanted Blatt fired swirled in the media, which seemed eager to pounce on the NBA newcomer. After weathering the storm, Blatt said that he needed to situation for Blatt: If the Cavs win, it’s all about LeBron. If they lose – even though the Warriors have played at a historically high level all season – Blatt will be the obvious scapegoat. At least Blatt has the support of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who told him recently that “all of Israel is behind the Cavaliers.” NOT YOUR PARENTS’ HEBREW SCHOOL! David Blatt make big adjustments in the NBA. “I’ve gone through my own learning curve that I’ve obviously worked through,” Blatt said. “I’ve become a lot more comfortable, and a lot more cognizant of the things that are necessary to make a winning situation on an NBA team.” Now he’s in the finals, facing a Warriors squad with the best record in the league and the MVP, Stephen Curry. Looking back, LeBron’s decision to return to Cleveland may have doomed Blatt’s NBA transition from the start by casting him as second fiddle to the game’s best player, with his outsized personality and extraordinary talent. That doesn’t take LOOKING FOR A PROGRESSIVE, CULTURAL EDUCATION FOR YOUR CHILD? Join the Chicago Workmen’s Circle School Discover our unique program focused on Jewish heritage, holidays, and social justice. Parents of kids ages 5-13 are welcome. OPEN HOUSE Sunday, June 14 11am-1pm Refreshments & childcare provided. RSVP to Kate O’Brien: [email protected] (646) 291-8371 Address provided with RSVP The Workmen’s Circle @workmenscircle 6 Chicago Jewish News - June 5-11, 2015 4 Torah Portion CANDLELIGHTING TIMES June 5 8:02 June 12 8:06 ALL JUNK REMOVED WE CLEAN OUT BASEMENTS, ATTICS, GARAGES, AND APARTMENTS ETC. LARGE BUILDINGS AND HOARDER CLEANUP SPECIALISTS ! The lower vessel One of Moses’ greatest virtues was his humility HIRE OUR CREW OR RENT A 50 YARD DUMPSTER! WE ALSO PROVIDE MOVING LABOR TO LOAD & UNLOAD YOUR RENTAL TRUCK OR POD WHILE DOING A CLEANOUT! 50 YARD JUNK REMOVAL TRUCKS 24-7-365! ILLINOISJUNKREMOVAL.COM 847-338-0588 AMYRA WEISSBERG HENRY Licensed Clinical Social Worker Educational Consultant • Extensive experience in special education and with learning challenged students. • Conducting full individual evaluations for all educational needs. • Bringing fresh eyes to academic problems. • Providing educational consultation related to learning difficulties and academic underachievement. Amyra W. Henry, LCSW 847.380.2591 [email protected] L & L APPLIANCE MART Slightly Blemished NEW Appliances & Rebuilt Used Appliances in EXCELLENT CONDITION Refrigerators • Stoves • Heaters Bedding • Freezers • Washers Dryers • Air Conditioners Large Quantities Available For Developers & Rehabs Lowest Prices • 773-463-2050 FREE DELIVERY IN CHICAGO 3240 W. LAWRENCE Mon. - Sat. 10-7 Closed Sun. 4250 W. MONTROSE Mon. - Sat. 10-6 Closed Sun. 2553 W. NORTH AVE. Mon. - Sat. 9-5:30 Closed Sun. By Rabbi Shoshanah Conover Guest Torah Columnist Torah Portion: Beha’alotecha Numbers 8:1-12:16 As a rabbi in Lakeview, I have the opportunity to serve the Jewish people by working with cherished colleagues and communities across the spectrum of Judaism. We gather on many occasions celebrating Shabbat together with Shabbat on the Lake in August and studying all night together in a Tikkun Leil Shavuot. Our communities overlap significantly in two day schools: Bernard Zell Anshe Emet Day School (BZAEDS) and Chicago Jewish Day School (CJDS). I enjoy serving on the Rabbinic Advisory of CJDS with Rabbis David Wolkenfeld, Michael Siegel, and Edwin Goldberg. Each year, we engage in a dynamic evening of learning with parents of CJDS students. Some weeks ago, we explored the question: “How does my identity inform my actions?” A provocative and enriching conversation ensued – especially as we explored our own identities amidst the public conversation on race in America. Some years ago, with the evening’s proximity to Shavuot, we pondered the ultimate significance of Moses and the power of the Ten Commandments. The panel began with this question: “What was the most important virtue of Moses that made him such a great leader?” Rabbi Asher Lopatin (then the rabbi of Anshe Sholom B’nai Israel) spoke of Moses’ keen moral compass. I talked about Moses’ ability to focus on his legacy: the perpetuation and evolution of Jewish identity. While these are extremely important aspects of Moses’ success in leadership, they are also obvious. Anyone who is familiar with the heroic stories of Moses would immediately think of these virtues. Yet Rabbi Segal named a dif- Rabbi Shoshanah Conover ferent virtue of Moses, one that is mentioned in this week’s Torah portion: humility. In this week’s Torah portion, in verse 3 of chapter 12 from the Book of Numbers, we read: “The man Moses was very humble, more than any other man on earth.” Yeshayahu Leibowitz of blessed memory, a prominent Israeli scientist and brother of Torah scholar Nechama Leibowitz, wrote at length about this aspect of Moses’ personality. He explained in “Accepting the Yoke of Heaven” that humility is a high level of human character because most ordinary people “consider themselves — if not consciously, then subconsciously — to be worthy and (sometimes overly) important. It is not natural for a person to be humble.” (page 135). So, here are two questions to ponder: Why was Moses humble? And why is humility an important aspect of a great leader’s personality? So, first things first: Why was Moses humble? It seems amazing that someone who had attained the highest humanly comprehension of G-d would remain humble. In plain fact, in this regard Moses had achieved superiority over all others. The Talmud states that he was superior to all other prophets. “All other prophets looked at G-d through a murky glass. Only Moses looked at G-d through a clear glass.” (BT Yebamot 49b). So how was he still humble? The Torah tells us more than once that G-d spoke to Moses face to face. Some may believe that that would cause a person to become arrogant. Yet, can you imagine how Moses felt during these encounters? Talk about May we lower ourselves to allow the words of Torah to be poured into us as vessels ready to be filled with lessons of righteous living. a humbling experience! Commenting on the passage from Yebamot, Rashi wrote: “All the other prophets looked through a murky glass and thought that they saw. Only Moses looked at G-d through a clear glass and knew that he had not seen G-d face to face.” In other words, Moses was the only prophet who realized that G-d is beyond human comprehension. Yet, why is humility such an important aspect of a great leader’s personality? Moses understood that by remaining humble, he allowed himself greater spiritual understanding. However, this edification in and of itself would not make him a good leader. Leaders don’t go on selfish pursuits of spiritual learning. Their role is to share with others what they have learned through constant teaching. Humility allows that teaching never to stagnate because remaining humble allows a person to continue to learn from others. As the great educator Rabbi Susan Freeman wrote in “Teaching Jewish Virtues,” mastering humility creates “more room for other people — better listening skills, more compassion, more understanding, more willingness to help those in need. Pulling ourselves back, contracting our ego … give(s) us greater sensitivity.” (page 10) What a beautiful model of leadership. I am proud to claim that as a Jewish model of leadership. I believe that this is the ultimate message of Moses’ leadership and the lasting virtue of the Ten Commandments that provided our people its first moral compass and lasting legacy. Rebbe Refael of Bershed said, “Some people pursue acclaim and thrive on being honored. Little do they realize that in order to receive honor, you must actually lower yourself. One can only pour into a vessel when it is held lower.” May we lower ourselves to allow the words of Torah to be poured into us as vessels ready to be filled with lessons of righteous living. May this kind of living allow a sense of wonder and awe to enter our lives as we humble ourselves to notice the natural beauty in the world around us. And may we learn to make room for other people as we build a world of more compassion, more understanding — a world ready for G-d’s blessing of peace. Rabbi Shoshanah Conover is the assistant rabbi of Temple Sholom of Chicago (Reform) in Chicago. 7 Chicago Jewish News - June 5-11, 2015 Death Notices Rabbi Byron Sherwin, Jewish scholar and ethicist at Spertus Rochelle Shoretz, Sharsheret founder Poland and its president Lech (JTA) – Rabbi Byron Sherand cancer advocate win, a Jewish scholar and ethicist who served on the faculty of Chicago’s Spertus Institute for Jewish Learning and Leadership for more than 40 years, has died at the age of 69 following a long illness. He served as Distinguished Service Professor and Director of Doctoral Programs at the Spertus Institute and had been on its faculty since 1970. Sherwin, who graduated from Columbia University, earned his doctorate in the History of Culture from the University of Chicago. He was ordained at the Jewish Theological Seminary of America, where he studied under Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel. Sherwin studied Jewish philosophy, mysticism and Jewish Milton M. Ostroff, MD, died June 1, in Chicago. World War II veteran, long time family physician; husband of Rabbi Byron Sherwin ethics; was involved in inter-religious dialogue and was the author of dozens of books and articles. He was awarded a presidential medal, the Officer’s Order of Merit, in 1995 by the Republic of Elaine, father of Sandy (Pam) and Randy (Audrey) Ostroff; grandfather of Melissa Ostroff; brother of the late Why did two Jewish funeral businesses in Skokie close in the last year? Perhaps it is in part that we left! Walesa for his work in improving Polish-Jewish and Catholic-Jewish relations in Poland and the United States. In 1996 he received an honorary Doctor of Hebrew Letters from JTS and an honorary Doctor of Humane Letters from the Spertus Institute. “It is difficult to imagine Spertus Institute without Byron Sherwin. Long before he became my colleague at Spertus, Byron was my teacher. He challenged his students to traverse the bridge between theory and practice, demanding that they bring scholarly sensibilities to their communal work, and realpolitik to their scholarship,” Spertus President and CEO Hal Lewis said in a statement. NEW YORK (JTA) – Rochelle Shoretz, whose own breast cancer diagnosis at age 28 led her to found the national cancer organization Sharsheret, has died. She was 42. The cause of death was complications from breast cancer. Shoretz founded Sharsheret in 2001 while undergoing chemotherapy. The organization provides health information and support services for Jewish women living with breast cancer or ovarian cancer, or who are at increased risk for those diseases. “When I was diagnosed [in July 2001], there were a lot of offers to help with meals and transport my kids, but I really wanted to speak to another young mom who was going to have to explain Rochelle Shoretz to her kids that she was going to lose her hair to chemo,” Shoretz said in 2003 of her decision to start Sharsheret. The organization’s name is Hebrew for chain. Ruth Moel. Arrangements by Lakeshore Jewish Funerals (773) 625-8621. Mitzvah Memorial Funerals 630-MITZVAH (630-648-9824) Lloyd Mandel Seymour Mandel Bill Goodman I. Ian “Izzy” Dick Larry Mandel Names you have trusted for decades... Still here to serve you when needed Mitzvah Memorial Funerals has the most experienced staff of Jewish funeral directors in Chicago with over 200 years of combined experience. We have all previously worked at either one, or both of these businesses that recently closed. The Mandel family has been in the funeral business for 4 generations! Lloyd Mandel Mitzvah Memorial Funerals also provides the lowest price! In most cases we save families $2000-$5000 versus what Chicago Jewish funeral homes with chapels charge for the same or similar services and casket. We do this because we don’t have the overhead that multi-million dollar funeral homes with chapels have. As Jewish families often have graveside services, or service from their Synagogue, using a funeral home with chapels isn’t necessary. For families that want an indoor service, but that are not members of a Synagogue, there are several available to non-affiliated families and several Jewish cemeteries that have chapels that we can use. You can view how our price compares to all of our competitors by going to www.comparemitzvah.com. 3rd generation Jewish Funeral Director, Past President of the Jewish Funeral Directors of America (J.F.D.A.) (Formerly with Piser) If your Synagogue has a discounted funeral plan that we are not currently a provider of you can still choose us. We guarantee to be at least 25% less!* If you have already made pre-arrangements elsewhere you can easily switch to us. In most cases we will refund your family thousands of dollars. We also offer pre-arrangements and fund through Homesteaders Life. * Guarantee is on base price of funeral plan including services, casket and miscellaneous items. Not included in this are the cemetery charges, vault and cash advance items. Founder, 4th generation Jewish Funeral Director, also licensed in Florida (no longer with Levayah Funerals or Piser) Seymour Mandel William Goodman Funeral Director, Homesteaders Insurance Agent (no longer with Goodman Family Funerals, Chicago Jewish Funerals, Weinstein or Piser) Ian “Izzy” Dick Oldest licensed Jewish Funeral Director in the State of Illinois (no longer with Levayah Funerals or Piser) coming together to better serve our community. WITH MORE THAN 200 YEARS of combined service, Weinstein & Piser Funeral Home is dedicated to honoring heritage and faith. Let us help you and your loved ones create a meaningful service that truly captures the essence of the life it represents. Proudly serving your family (clockwise from left) are William Barr, Licensed Funeral Director; Alan Yaffe, Former Owner and Licensed Funeral Director; Robert Sheck, Manager and Licensed Funeral Director; Todd Lovcik, Licensed Funeral Director; Jamie Greenebaum, Licensed Funeral Director; and Arlene Folsom, Licensed Funeral Director. Lawrence “Larry” Mandel 4th generation Jewish Funeral Director, Homesteaders Insurance Agent (Formerly with Piser) 847-778-6736 Find out why Mitzvah Memorial Funerals was entrusted to direct more than 900 funerals since opening in 2010. Deerfield 500 Lake Cook Road., Suite 350 • Skokie 8850 Skokie Blvd. 630-MITZVAH (630-648-9824) • www.mitzvahfunerals.com WEINSTEIN & PISER Funeral Home 111 SKOKIE BLVD., WILMETTE 847-256-5700 Proudly owned and operated by Alderwoods (Chicago North), Inc. 8 Chicago Jewish News - June 5-11, 2015 SUMMER ARTS PREVIEW Upcoming events of Jewish interest Stories by Pauline Dubkin Yearwood Managing Editor Exhibits Spertus Institute for Learning and Leadership presents exhibition by Liana Finck of her illustrations, sketches and etchings in “A Bintel Brief: Love and Longing in Old New York” inspired by the Bintel Brief letters to the editor that ran during the turn of the last century in the Yiddish Daily Forward. Through July 19 in the Spertus First Floor Vestibule Gallery, 610 S. Michigan Ave., Chicago. Spertus.edu or (312) 322-1756. Anita Miller Gallery presents “Art With Sound!” a solo show of artwork by Anita Ivy Miller. Show runs June 7-28 with preview party 2-5 p.m. Sunday, June 7 and Open Studios 5-9 p.m. Friday, June 12. Fine Arts Building, Second Floor Gallery, 410 S. Michigan Ave., Chicago. anitaivymiller.artspan.com or (847) 767-6875. Kohl Children’s Museum presents “Chagall for Children,” exhibit exploring the artwork of Jewish painter, printmaker and designer Marc Chagall. Through Sept. 6, 2100 Patriot Blvd., Glenview. For museum hours and costs, (847) 832-6600. (See separate story.) Film “Felix & Meira” runs for a limited engagement at Century 12 Evanston/ CineArts 6 & XD, 1715 Maple, Evanston, (847) 491-9751 and Landmark’s Renaissance Place Cinema, Highland Park, 1850 2nd St., Highland Park, (847) 432-7903. Directed by Maxime Giroux, it is the story of an unusual romance that blossoms between two lost souls who inhabit the same neighborhood but vastly different worlds. Call theaters or show times and tickets. “The Farewell Party,” a film by Sharon Maymon and Tal Granit about a group of friends at a Jerusalem retirement home who decide to help their terminally ill friend, opens Friday, June 12 at the Music Box Theater, 3733 N. Southport, Chicago, (773) 8716607 and Renaissance Place, 1850 Second St., Highland Park. (847) 432-7903. JCC Chicago presents 2nd Annual Chicago Jewish Film Festival running from Saturday, June 20 through Sunday, June 28. Venues for the festival are: Century 12 Evanston/Cine Arts 6 and XD, 1715 Maple Ave., Evanston; Landmark Century Centre Cinema, 2828 N. Clark St., Chicago; Illinois Holocaust Museum and Education Center, 9603 Woods Drive, Skokie and Victory Gardens Theater, 2433 N. Lincoln Ave., Chicago. $64 for festival pass (includes eight films); single films, $12, adults; $10 seniors or students. For complete list of films, www.chicagojewishfilm.org. (See separate story.) Chicago YIVO 2015 Summer Festival of Yiddish Culture shows film, “Lost Embrace” (with English subtitles) telling the story of Ariel Makaroff, grandson of Holocaust-era Polish refugees, who is currently on a complex search for his personal and cultural identity. 2 p.m. Thursday, June 25, Skokie Public Library, 5215 Oakton, Skokie. (847) 637-7774. Lectures Chicago YIVO 2015 Summer Festival of Yiddish Culture presents Professor Joseph Shanes speaking on “Di Galitsiyaners: The Jews of Galicia, 1772-1914.” 2 p.m. Thursday, July 16, Evanston Public Library, 1703 Orrington, Evanston. (847) 4488600. ELI Talks presents new “inspired Jewish ideas” including the neuroscience of ritual, race relations, the moral imagination of the Talmud and Ladino proverbs. To be filmed at 6:30 p.m. TuesdayThursday, June 16, 17 and 18 at studios of WTTW Channel 11, 5400 N. St. Louis, Chicago. Guests can be part of the live studio audience at 6 p.m. for a light kosher reception with chance to meet and mingle with the speakers. Tickets $18, advance; $20, door. eventbright.com/e/elitalks-chicago-jewish-life-andlearning-tickets-16635512265. Music Chicago YIVO 2015 Summer Festival of Yiddish Culture presents Duo Controverso featuring Annette Bjorling and Kurt Bjorling. Program includes liturgical music, celebratory dances and instrumental versions of traditional folk songs. 2 p.m. Wednesday, June 10, Indian Trails Public Library, 355 S. Schoenbeck Road, Wheeling. (847) 459-4100. Chicago YIVO 2015 Summer Festival of Yiddish Culture presents Duo Controverso featuring Annette and Kurt Bjorling. Congregation Solel presents “The Voice of Song,” a concert to benefit Kol Zimrah Community Singers conducted by its music director, Richard Boldrey. 3 p.m. Sunday June 14, 1301 Clavey Road, Highland Park. Spertus Institute presents an exhibition of illustrations in “A Bintel Brief: Love and Longing in Old New York” inspired by the Bintel Brief letters to the editor that ran during the turn of the last century in the Yiddish Daily Forward. $20 and $36, contact Michael, [email protected] or Monica, [email protected] or (847) 297-5745. Chicago Loop Synagogue presents An Intimate Evening with its High Holiday Cantor and Broadway Performer Dudu Fisher. 7 p.m. Sunday, June 21, 16 S. Clark St., Chicago. $65, main floor; $35, balcony. www.chiloopsyn.net or (312) 346-7370. Theater Theater Wit presents “Bad Jews,” a play by Joshua Harmon about a battle between two cousins over a treasured family heirloom. Continues through Sunday, June 21, 1229 W. Belmont, Chicago. $24-36. www.theaterwit.org or (773) 975-8150. Continues at North Shore Center for the Performing Arts, 9501 Skokie Blvd, Skokie from June 26-July 19. $20-$58. NorthShoreCenter.org or call (847) 673-6300. Kimberly Senior’s new, intimate production of “The Diary of Anne Frank” continues at Writers Theatre through Aug. 2. 664 Vernon Ave., Glencoe. (847) 242-6000 or writerstheatre.org. Genesis Theatrical Productions presents Stephanie Liss’ play “Jihad,” a story of Hamas terrorist actions against Israelis as seen through the eyes of Israelis and Hamas. July 5-Aug. 2 at Theater Wit, 1229 W. Belmont, Chicago. $30, discounts for students, seniors and groups. theaterwit.org or (773) 975-8150. Kokandy Productions presents “Loving Repeating,” an intimate exploration of Gertrude Stein’s legacy and her lifelong relationship with Alice B. Toklas, with lyrics by Gertrude Stein. July 18 through Aug. 30 at Theater Wit, 1229 W. Belmont, Chicago. $25 preview performances, $38 regular run. www.kokandyproductions.com or (773) 975-8150. Hell in a Handbag productions presents “Bette, Live at the Continental Baths” featuring Caitlin Jackson in a musical tribute to Bette Midler. Runs Friday, July 24 through Friday, Aug. 2. Mary’s Attic, 5400 N. Clark St., Chicago. $20 advance, $22 door. www.handbagproductions.org. 9 Chicago Jewish News - June 5-11, 2015 Unanswered questions Chicago author delves into new JFK information More than 50 years after the fact, are you one of a large number of Americans still wondering who killed John F. Kennedy? Chicago investigative reporter Hillel Levin counted himself among that number. In 2010, Levin, a writer specializing in crime, wrote an article for Playboy magazine in which he uncovered new information about the tragedy that is often described as “the crime of the century,” information that he says ties the assassination to Chicago and shines a new light on its most Jewish player, Jack Ruby. Levin has turned his findings into a play, “Assassination Theater.” It will open in August at Chicago’s Museum of Broadcast Communications. The genesis of the drama is the Playboy article, Levin, a former editor of Chicago magazine, said in a recent telephone interview. In the piece, he uncovered the role of Chicago mobster Tony Accardo in the assassination, he says. After the story was pub- lished, Zechariah Shelton, one of the FBI agents featured in the article, contacted Levin. “Now you need to do a real story about the mob,” he told him. “How they killed JFK.” Naturally Levin – who has written many articles and two books about organized crime, “When Corruption Was King” and “In With the Devil” – was intrigued. What he found out, he says, is that the Chicago Outfit, or mob, was instrumental in the plot to kill Kennedy to squash investigations into its dealings in Las Vegas. “Most people are not aware of how important Chicago was in building Las Vegas,” Levin says. “At that point (1963) almost every casino on the Strip was owned by Chicago. The money they got for building and expanding those big casinos came from the Teamsters pension fund, which had its offices here.” Meanwhile, Attorney General Robert Kennedy was aggressively going after organized crime, particularly in the union movement, and the mob, Levin says, was eager to get rid of the entire Kennedy administration. FBI agent Shelton and several other agents told Levin they had stumbled on someone who claimed to be the second shooter from the famous grassy knoll and was still alive in an Illinois prison. They couldn’t disclose the information while they were still with the bureau, they told him. Levin spent the next several years trying to confirm this information and reading files that had been released in the 1990s. He says those documents prove that more than one person fired at the president and that organized crime figures were “the most likely people behind the assassination.” The new information, he says, shined a particularly bright light on Jack Ruby, Lee Harvey Oswald’s killer and a Jewish man originally from Chicago’s West Side. “I think we now have a real different take on Ruby,” Levin says. “He is a real key to what really happened. The Warren Commission (that investigated the assassination) said he had no significant ties to organized crime. He had very significant ties to organized crime leaders in Chicago, and for the Warren Commission to contend otherwise is just ridiculous.” Levin has his own circuitous connection to Jack Ruby: He grew up in Hartford, Conn., where his family attended Emanuel Synagogue, whose longtime rabbi, Morris Silverman, ed- Chicagoan Jack Ruby shooting Lee Harvey Oswald. ited the “Silverman Machzor,” the Conservative movement’s official High Holiday prayer book during the first half of the 20th century. Silverman’s son, Hillel Silverman, also became a rabbi with a pulpit in Dallas, where Jack Ruby was one of his congregants. “Ruby was fairly observant. He would go to minyamin quite a bit,” Levin says. “A lot of the Jewish side of Ruby has been kind of forgotten.” Ruby shot and killed Oswald at the Dallas Municipal Building, where the alleged presidential assassin was being held, on Nov. 24, 1963. He was tried for murder (the conviction was later overturned and he died of cancer in prison) with Hillel Silverman testifying at the trial. That testimony “was used to puncture conspiracy theories,” Levin says. “The idea was that (Ruby) cared so much about President Kennedy he felt the need to do this.” Hillel Silverman went on to lead major congregations in several cities. “His claim to fame was that he testified in Ruby’s trial and got TV exposure,” Levin says. “He testiSEE JFK ON PAG E 1 2 Hands on great art Chagall ‘teaches’ kids fun lessons at museum exhibit Usually children are instructed to “look, don’t touch” when visiting a museum. At Kohl Children’s Museum’s recently opened “Chagall for Children” exhibit, the instructions are just the opposite: Please touch. At 14 stations corresponding to some of the great Russian-Jewish artist’s most famous works, kids can rearrange pieces, play on a stage while videotaping themselves, create their own paintings and flower arrangements, manipulate figures from paintings, weave and sew, press light-up touch screens and otherwise engage with Chagall’s works in a way that goes far beyond just looking. Parents and teachers, meanwhile, can learn about the artist through narrative wall panels designed just for them and set at adult height. The exhibit, which continues through Sept. 6 at the museum at 2100 Patriot Blvd. In Glenview, was developed by the Kohl Museum in 1996 at its for- mer location and has been shown six times, the last in 2012. It also goes on the road, traveling to other museums around the country. It’s a popular attraction wherever it goes, says Sheridan Turner, the museum’s president and CEO. “It’s a timeless exhibit that’s absolutely gorgeous. Kids and families love it,” Turner said in a recent telephone interview. “While the children are playing, parents can read the history of the life of Marc Chagall and the impact he had on art.” Why Chagall? For one reason, Turner says, museum founder Dolores Kohl is Jewish and feels strong ties to a quintessentially Jewish artist like Chagall, whose work she wanted to celebrate. His life story also makes a dramatic tale. Born in Belarus in 1887, Chagall bridged styles and periods and worked in numerous artistic media, from paintings to etchings to stained glass windows to sets for plays and ballets. His work often depicted characters from Jewish folktales in dreamlike settings. As he developed his unique style, Chagall and later his wife, Bella, traveled from St. Petersburg to Berlin, Paris and other European locations and were living in France when the Nazis began their campaign against modernist art. Many of Chagall’s works were confiscated from museums as “degenerate art” and “an assault on Western civilization.” Eventually he was among many Jewish artists, writers and intellectuals rescued by the United States from occupied France, and he began a new life in America in 1941. “His art is understood as a response to the situation that has long marked the history of Russian Jews and everything that happened during World War II,” Turner says. “The beauty of the selections is how they depict different times and periods during Chagall’s life. We have been able to take these wonderful, significant pieces of art and take the ideas expressed by them” and create an exhibit designed for children ages 2-12. (The artworks are licensed reproductions of original Chagall pieces.) Kids, Turner says, “have a different way of interacting with art and are especially fascinated with Chagall’s works. “They are in awe of the colors, the beauty, the fact that they are not being told ‘don’t touch.’ Learning about and interacting with Marc Chagall’s ‘Green Violinist.’ At first some can be hesitant to actually engage (with the exhibit) until that affirmation is given to them by teachers or parents, allowing the children to express their creativity,” she says. Each of the 14 stations has a different activity associated with it. At the “America Windows” exhibit, kids can explore the ef- fects of light on stained glass by rearranging puzzle-like pieces of the famous work, a Chicago treasure that some may have already seen at the Art Institute of Chicago. “At the Circus” features silk-screened capes young visitors can don to seemingly beSEE CHAGALL ON PAG E 1 2 10 Chicago Jewish News - June 5-11, 2015 Summer Arts Preview Film fest fun Be all-Jewish, all the time at the movies Simon Wiesenthal Center Honoring Robert A. Mariano and Christopher G. Kennedy A middle-class, white Jewish woman who discovers a shocking truth about her background. A preteen Holocaust survivor starting a new life in America. A young boy collecting baseball equipment for boys in Cuba. A German-Jewish immigrant who makes a life for himself in America’s “Wild West.” A Jewish superstar whose prodigious talents and outrageous demeanor predate Madonna and Lady Gaga. Those are some of the actual and fictional characters you can meet during the Chicago Jewish Film Festival, which offers 17 films over nine days at four venues, plus discussions and special events with several directors. The festival, produced by JCC Chicago, runs from Saturday, June 20 to Sunday, June 28 at Century Cinema, Evanston; Victory Gardens Theater, Chicago; Illinois Holocaust Museum and Education Center, Skokie; and Landmark Century Centre Theatres, Chicago. (For a complete list of films and venues, visit chicagojewishfilm.org.) Before last year, Chicago, unlike most major American cities, didn’t really have a Jewish film festival, David Chack, the festival’s artistic director, said during a recent telephone interview. Well known to arts-loving Chicagoans, Chack is a professor of theater at DePaul University and the artistic director of ShPieL-Performing Identity, a multicultural theater project. In his new role with the film festival he has traveled to other such events and seen films with Jewish con- tent from all over the world to pick the best for the Chicago fest, now in its second year. What he looks for, first of all, is the quality of the film. “It’s really important for us to be showing top-notch films,” he says. “There are lots and lots of documentaries and films with Jewish content and Holocaustrelated films. We want to be ranked with the great festivals here in Chicago and be connected to film festivals worldwide, like Sundance and Toronto. We’re looking for highquality films – that is paramount.” “Jewish content,” which seems like it may be easy to define but isn’t always, means “Jewish interest of one kind or another – storyline, narrative, culturally, historically, Jewish identity or even some kind of strong Jewish performer like Natalie Portman,” Chack says. He also looks for topics that Jewish audiences might be particularly interested in in any given year. This year that meant the attacks on the Charlie Hebdo magazine and on a Jewish grocery store in France. “I thought, this is a tremendous opportunity to promote healing, knowledge and awareness of what goes on to Jews in France,” Chack says. He reached out to the French Consulate in Chicago and together they will sponsor the June 25 showing of “24 Days (24 Jours),” a fictional film based on real events – the kidnapping of a young Jewish man in France. After the film, which Chack describes as “searing,” a panel will discuss the upsurge of antiSemitism in Europe with representatives from the French consulate and the AJC-Chicago. CONTINUED O N N E X T PAG E June 11, 2015 Standard Club, Chicago www.wiesenthal.com/2015ChicagoDinner or call 312.981.0105 for more information A scene from “Theodore Bikel: In the Shoes of Sholom Aleichem.” 11 Chicago Jewish News - June 5-11, 2015 Summer Arts Preview CONTINUED F RO M P R E V I O U S PAG E Not to forget the family audience, there’s “Havana Curveball,” a documentary about a baseball-loving boy whose grandfather was saved from the Holocaust and spent several years in Cuba. The teen decides that for his bar mitzvah project he wants to send baseball equipment to boys in Cuba, a project that “gets him in all sorts of troubles” and makes him think about what it really takes to change the world, Chack says. Chicagoans might be particularly interested in “Compass Cabaret 55,” a behind-the-scenes look at the Compass Players and its Jewish comedians, forerunners of Second City and Saturday Night Live. The documentary was shown once at the Gene Siskel Film Center but deserves a wider audience, Chack says. That’s also the case, he says, with “Theodore Bikel: In the Shoes of Sholom Aleichem,” which was shown once at Spertus. It chronicles the beloved entertainer’s return to Vienna for the first time since the Holocaust and his strong connection to the “Fiddler on the Roof” author. YIVO is a co-sponsor of the screening. Another film Chack thinks viewers will find intriguing is “Little White Lie,” the true story of Lacey Schwartz, brought up as a white Jewish woman in a closeknit New York family. Lacey’s unusually dark skin was “the elephant in the room” in that family, but when her biological father dies just before her 30th birthday, the family secret can no longer stay hidden, and Schwartz and her family must come to terms with questions of identity and race. Schwartz will be present via A scene from “24 Hours.” Skype after the showing. Three other directors – Mark Siska from “Compass Cabaret 55,” Adam Zucker from “The Return,” the story of a renaissance of Jewish culture in Poland, and Steven Bram of “Kaballah Me” – will attend in person and speak after the screenings of their films. “Kaballah Me” tells the story of Bram’s unlikely journey to Jewish spirituality and observance and how it created profound changes in his life. The showing is co-sponsored by the JCC’s group of Jews in their 20s and 30s, many of whom “are really into Jewish spirituality,” Chack says. Also notable, he says, is “Nora’s Will,” a black comedy from Mexico about how a woman’s plan to bring her family together – a plan that must be carried out by her ex-husband – emerges after her death just before Passover. Writer/director Mariana Chenillo is the first woman director to win Mexico’s Best Picture award. Over the next five years, Chack says, he and the JCC plan to expand and broaden the reach of the festival and have received several grants enabling them to do so. Meanwhile this year, “it’s really a feast of films,” he says. “People can dip in and try the ones they like. It’s all about celebrating Jewish film worldwide.” The Chicago Jewish Film Festival, produced by JCC Chicago, runs from Saturday, June 20 to Sunday, June 28 at four venues. For a complete list of films and venues and to buy tickets, including a festival pass that includes eight films for $64, visit chicagojewishfilm.org. Single films are $12 adults, $10 seniors or students. NEW TICKETS ADDED FOR A LIMITED TIME! Tickets starting at $25 ELVIS PRESLEY | JERRY LEE LEWIS | CARL PERKINS | JOHNNY CASH CALL 773.935.6100 OR VISIT TICKETMASTER.COM MILLIONDOLLARQUARTETLIVE.COM • 2540 N LINCOLN AVE, CHICAGO • FULLERTON ‘L’ STOP 12 Chicago Jewish News - June 5-11, 2015 JFK CONTINUED F RO M PAG E 9 fied that (Ruby) was capable of doing this on his own.” Levin felt that the public should have access to the new information about the Kennedy assassination and thought that theater would be a good way to do it. In a play, “you have people’s undivided attention,” he says, adding that he wants the public to know “how much of this information is now available on the Web and through archives that people can pull down themselves.” The play he eventually wrote, “Assassination Theater,” has an actor portraying Levin, another playing FBI agent Shelton and two other actors portraying a number of individuals connected with the assassination, including Robert Kennedy, Lyndon Johnson and Herbert Hoover. “They say only things we know they have really said through transcripts and memoirs,” Levin says. Three large screens project images, historical photos and diagrams. Last year, Levin staged a showcase for the play in an Oak Park venue, which more than 300 people attended. Among them was Bruce DuMont, founder and Chagall CONTINUED F RO M PAG E 9 come part of the painting via a video camera and monitor. At “The Blue House,” a painting depicting Chagall’s original house in Belarus, kids study form and structure by creating their own three-dimensional house with Lincoln Logs against the backdrop of the painting. A “Flowers” exhibit, inspired by the paintings, lets visitors create their own flower arrangements and experiment with floral scents. “The Birthday” encourages viewers to compare art forms such as oil paintings and bas-reliefs. They can also create a rubbing from a steel engraving of a bas-relief. Art forms other than the visual are not overlooked. In “The Concert” station, visitors select musical instruments represented in the painting of the same name and blend sounds the way Chagall blended colors. One of the most beloved exhibits, and iconic Chagall, is “The Flying Sleigh,” Turner says. “Chagall was telling the story of a family riding on a magic sleigh,” she says. In a computerized activity, kids can press different components on a touch screen. “It will change into something different,” she says. They can make up their own story.” Without realizing it, Turner president of the Museum of Broadcast Communications in Chicago. “He left feeling there was really more I could tell about the assassination,” Levin says. “He said we had to think about doing (the play) at the museum.” DuMont committed to upgrading the lighting and set on the museum’s second floor, the Radio Hall of Fame, where “Assassination Theater” will have a 12-week run beginning with previews on Aug. 11. Aside from offering the public new information about the JFK assassination, Levin says the play gives fascinating bits of information on the Jewish connections to the tragedy, involving Ruby and other Jews. The Chicago mob, which Levin says figured so prominently in the JFK killing, included not just Italians but Germans, Greeks and Jews. “It wasn’t just Jews, but Jews were pretty important,” he says. “It was very multi-ethnic compared to what was in New York.” Just one more forgotten fact you night learn from viewing “Assassination Theater.” “Assassination Theater” opens with previews Aug. 11 at the Museum of Broadcast Communications, 360 N. State St., Chicago. For ticket information call (708) 405-9181 or visit AssassinationTheater.com. Community Calendar Sunday June 7 Congregation Beth Judea presents Danny Siegel speaking on “116 Practical Mitzvah Suggestions and How to Choose the Charity that is the Very Best for You.” 10 a.m., Route 83 and Hilltop Road, Long Grove. RSVP required, lneiman@ bethjudea.org or (847) 634-0777. SPOTLIGHT The second annual Chicago Kosher BBQ Festival & Competition will be held on Sunday, June 14 at Anshe Emet Synagogue in Chicago. With an anticipated 15-20 BBQ teams competing, trophies will be awarded for Best Brisket, Best Ribs, Best Chicken, Best Beans, Most Original Team Name, Best Booth Decoration and Grand Champion. Events will include pickle and hot dog eating contests, sports clinics, and a kid zone featuring face painters, stilt walkers, balloon artists, a dunk tank and more. All food is under CRC supervision. For more information, visit www.chikosherbbq.org. Monday Chicago Jewish Historical Society presents Richard Reeder discussing “The Saul Bellow Centenary.” 2 p.m., Temple Beth Israel, 3601 W. Dempster, Skokie. $10. Free for TBI and CJHS members. (312) 663-5634. Illinois Holocaust Museum and Education Center presents Lincolnwood Chamber Orchestra performing compositions by famous Russian composers. 2-3:30 p.m., 9603 Woods Drive, Skokie. $30, $20 members. Reservations required, ilholocaustmuseum.org/even ts. says, kids are learning something at each station. In “I and the Village” it’s all about the concept of symmetry and the different ways people view the world. “The Juggler” imparts a subtle lesson about the world as viewers use a touch screen to find corresponding pieces in the picture. A “Job Tapestry” involves creating a cooperative tapestry by using weaving and sewing. “Creativity can’t be taught by flash cards,” Turner says. “This gets children out of the traditional setting into an environment that is very colorful and whimsical, and where they experience the transformational power of play.” She recounts the story of one young woman who grew up in Glenview and is now working in Johannesburg, South Africa creating a children’s museum there – a task that she said was directly influenced by visiting the Chagall exhibit at the Kohl Museum as a child. Turner thinks there must be many Chicagoans who have such memories about the impact the museum and the exhibit create – and she would love to hear them. Agudath Israel of Illinois hosts Unity Dinner and Midwest Leadership Awards. More information, [email protected]. “Chagall for Children” continues through Sept. 6 at Kohl Children’s Museum, 2100 Patriot Blvd., Glenview. $11 children and adults, $10 seniors, free for children under one. More information, www.kohlchildrensmuseum.org or (847) 832-6600. Shalom Memorial Park 3 plots in Section 3 Ramah $2500 each Will split Call Davina (702) 834-7478 Temple Beth–El hosts lecture by U.S. Rep. Ed Royce, chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, on “The U.S. and Israel: Standing Together?” 7 p.m., 3610 Dundee, Northbrook. Preregistration recommended. (847) 205-9982. CJN Classified MISCELLANEOUS SEEKING SPANISH SPEAKING KABBALAH TEACHER For weekly lessons WRP or Skokie area Please call 262-374-3469 CEMETERY LOTS Thursday June 8 June 11 Ezra-Habonim, the Niles Township Jewish Congregation holds Clothing and Textile Recycling Drive. 9 a.m.-5 p.m. Also June 9, 10 and 11, 4500 W. Dempster, Skokie. (847) 675-4141. Chicago YIVO Society presents Kurt Bjorling and Chicago Klezmer Ensemble. 2 p.m., Evanston Public Library, 1703 Orrington Ave. (847) 448-8652. Tuesday June 9 Buffalo Grove Post #89 & Auxiliary hosts luncheon for installation of 2015 officers. Noon, Dover Straits Restaurant, 890 E. Route 45. $25. (847) 668-0101. North Suburban Synagogue Beth El shows documentary film “Roadmap Genesis.” 7:45 p.m., 1175 Sheridan Road, Highland Park. (847) 432-8900. Wednesday June 10 Chicago YIVO Society presents Duo Controverso featuring harpist Annette Bjorling and clarinetist Kurt Bjorling. 2 p.m., Indian Trails Public Library, 355 S. Schoenbeck Road, Wheeling. (847) 459-4100. The Oriental Institute holds “Epic Wednesday” exploring the ancient Near Eastern cosmopolitans with gallery tours, artisan food, live music and craft beer. 5-8 p.m., 1155 E. 58th St., Chicago. Free for members, $10 students, $12 UChicago staff, faculty, alumni, $15 nonmembers. (773) 702-9520. Northwest Hadassah Chapter Book Club holds discussion on “The Light Between Oceans” by M. L. Stedman. 7 p.m., Buffalo Grove Youth Center, 50 ½ Raupp Blvd., Buffalo Grove. Elizabeth Gordon, [email protected]. Simon Wiesenthal Center Midwest Region holds 2015 Spirit of Courage Benefit honoring Robert A. Mariano. 5:30 p.m., The Standard Club, 320 S. Plymouth Court, Chicago. $350. (312) 981-0105 or kferrell@ wiesenthal.com. Jewish Child and Family Services holds workshop on Financial and Future Planning for People with Disabilities presented by Ron Dickstein, Hoopis Financial Group, Mass Mutual. 6-8 p.m., 5150 Golf Road, Skokie. EmilyTegenkamp@ jcfs.org or (773) 467-3741. Friday June 12 Congregation B’nai Tikvah holds musical Kabbalat Shabbat Service followed by Oneg. 6:30 p.m., 1558 Wilmot Road, Deerfield. (847) 945-0470. Sunday June 14 Illinois Holocaust Museum and Education Center presents Holocaust survivor Ralph Rehbok telling his personal story. 12:30 p.m., 9603 Woods Drive, Skokie. Free with museum admission. ilholocaustmuseum. org or (847) 967-4800. Congregation B’nai Tikvah hosts light supper and discussion of the movie “Ida” followed by screening. 5:30 p.m., 1558 Wilmot Road, Deerfield. $15. RSVP, (847) 945-0470. 13 Chicago Jewish News - June 5-11, 2015 By Joseph Aaron CONTINUED F RO M PAG E Specialized 14 him “a holy vessel.” There is something very wrong with the Jewish world when society shows that it has a lower and lower tolerance for unseemly behavior, that there is a higher and higher price to pay when one does not act as we expect leaders to act, while the Jewish community excuses away and looks away from and rationalizes away the most disgusting of behaviors. What in the hell is the matter with us? And moving from the personal to the political, I need someone to please explain to me why we so often make such big deals out of nothing and so often fail to make big deals out of something. Jews are normally very big into anniversaries. It doesn’t take much for us to have a lecture, throw a party, make a tsimmes about the anniversary of almost anything. And yet here we are celebrating the 50th anniversary of two amazing events, and you hear barely a peep about them in the Jewish world. The first 50th anniversary is the issuing by the Catholic church of Nostra Aetate. The document rejects the charge that Jews are guilty of killing Jesus and prohibits teachings in which Jews are seen as accursed, condemns anti-Semitism, affirms Christianity’s Jewish roots and validates G-d’s eternal covenant with the Jewish people. Considering that for almost 2,000 years the Church said exactly the opposite, and that the Church’s pinning Jesus’ killing on us resulted in pogroms against and the persecution of Jews, culminating in the Holocaust in very Catholic Germany, this was an earth shattering development. Indeed it changed everything for Jews. Look at the last 50 years, at three popes visiting Israel, at three popes going to shul, at a pope solemnly apologizing for the Church’s role in the Holocaust while bowing to survivors at Yad Vashem. That is a 50th anniversary we should be trumpeting, celebrating, thanking G-d for, making a very big deal about. And yet basically nothing. So it is with the 50th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic relations between Israel and Germany. The same Germany that had set up an elaborate extermination machine that resulted in the murders of six million Jewish men, women and children. It was a nation whose goal was to destroy the Jewish people. And yet 50 years ago, Germany and Israel, a country that rose out of the ashes of the Holocaust, established diplomatic ties. That came after Germany paid Israel $6 billion in reparations. Of course, no amount of money could atone for what Germany did to us, but that money in a very real way made it possible for Israel to create its state. That was a lot of money back then, and Israel put it to very good use, building roads and hospitals and schools and infrastructure and the very foundations of a modern country. How wondrous and almost unbelievable it was to see Israeli president Reuven Rivlin go to Berlin to mark the 50th anniversary. The head of a sovereign Jewish state going to the capital of the Nazi Reich to be welcomed with honors. Indeed, one could hardly believe one’s eyes, remembering how Nazi newspapers like Der Steurmer would publish the most vicious anti-Semitism, to see Germany’s most widely read newspaper featuring Hebrew on its front page during Rivlin’s visit. The Bild newspaper included a bold headline in Hebrew – “Good Day, Israel!” as part of a special issue marking 50 years of diplomatic relations with the Jewish state. A cuddly photo of Rivlin and his German counterpart, Joachim Gauck, appeared under the headline. In the days after the Holocaust, with the blood and tears of six million of our people soaking Germany, Poland and elsewhere in Eastern Europe, it was impossible to imagine a Jewish state, let alone that Germany would have diplomatic ties with it, or that the Catholic Church would have said Jews did not kill Jesus and that the Jewish people had an eternal covenant with G-d. And yet 50 years ago, both those things happened before our very eyes. How blessed is this generation of Jews. We need to not let those milestones go by without notice, indeed without much cheering and gratitude. The Jewish people these days are worried, about Isis and Iran, about Hamas and Hezbollah, about Jewish apathy and lack of identity. I myself am most worried about no peace process, pervasive political corruption and economic manipulation in Israel, an often cowardly and never inspiring national Jewish leadership in America. But whatever you choose to worry about as a Jew, it would be nice if you took some time this year to feel joy about two wondrous things that happened 50 years ago for the Jews. It would also be nice if you took some time to feel disgust when things like Rabbi Rosenblatt occur, recognize it is our Jewish duty to speak out, to speak up, to express outrage and horror, to condemn his behavior and so warn others to always behave as a Jew should, no matter how famous or powerful they are. The Vatican and Berlin gave us something to kvell about 50 years ago. This year, Rabbi Rosenblatt and how the Jewish world has reacted to him, have given us something to cry about. Dementia Care You can take a much-needed break, knowing your loved one’s daily needs are being met by a professional team that can keep them engaged. Mitch Abrams Managing Director Helping the whole family, who are now living with dementia Call us to schedule a free evaluation. ; Caregivers with intensive training and experience www.TheHomeCareSpot.com (847) 480-5700 ; Activities based on social history, hobbies ; Help with daily living needs ; Interactive, engaging care experience The Chicago Jewish News gratefully acknowledges the generous support of RABBI MORRIS AND DELECIA ESFORMES 14 Chicago Jewish News - June 5-11, 2015 By Joseph Aaron Vatican, Berlin and the sauna See for yourself! Best Independent Living Community for Active Jewish Seniors At Park Plaza, our residents enjoy a full schedule of activities that keep them involved with their new community. From exercise classes to enriching discussions to celebrations that bring families together, we create an engaging lifestyle that makes us the premier independent living community in the heart of the city. With a choice of luxury apartment rentals, social events, chauffeur services and cultural outings, our residents thrive in a vibrant, care-free environment. Call to arrange a visit and see how senior living is meant to be! Pri startces in at g $ 1,750 6840 N. Sacramento Avenue, Chicago www.park-plaza.org Y 773.465.6700 www. chicagojewishnews .com The Jewish News place in cyberspace What in the hell is the matter with us? To everyone’s utter shock, we recently learned that former House Speaker Dennis Hastert has been charged with paying millions of dollars to someone, evidently to keep him quiet about some kind of abuse he suffered while Hastert was a teacher and wrestling coach down in Yorkville, Illinois. We know absolutely no details about the abuse and can’t even be sure there was abuse, though that does seem very likely to have been the case. We do know it happened a very long time ago. Despite the lack of details, just knowing what we know, a college that had dedicated a center in Hastert’s name immediately took his name off the center, and the lobbying firm in Washington for which Hastert had worked for years, immediately cut their ties with him. Now we can debate all we want about the fairness of Hastert’s prosecution, with some legal experts saying he never would have been charged for the crimes of withdrawing his own money from his own bank accounts in amounts designed to avoid it being reported to authorities, then lying to the FBI about why he did it, if he wasn’t so well known. And we can debate all we want about the rush to judgment by the college and lobbying firm, before Hastert has been found guilty of anything and without us even knowing what it.is he was trying to cover up. But just the suggestion of him having abused a student was enough for that college and that lobbying firm to quickly take serious action. Not the way the Jewish community seems to work. The very same week we learned about Hastert, we also learned about a New York rabbi named Jonathan Rosenblatt. Rosenblatt is one of the most well-known and respected rabbis in New York, the great grandson of the cantor considered the greatest of all time, married to a woman who is a member of two rabbinic dynasties. In a very lengthy article, the New York Times revealed that Rosenblatt, for many years, would get naked with male congregants, who were often teenage boys, as well with university students who he was supposed to mentor. Rosenblatt liked to play squash or racquetball with males as young as 12-years-old and then ogle them as they showered. He would sit with them naked in the gym’s sauna for prolonged periods of time and talk about their personal lives and issues. As he spoke, he sometimes placed his hand on a boy’s thigh or shoulder in a way some found uncomfortable. This has been going on for about 30 years and a lot of people knew about it, officials of his synagogue, officials of a major rabbinical organization, congregants, and, of course, the boys themselves, some of whom told the Times how traumatized they were and still are by it, and how some left Judaism because of it. Now, there has been no allegation from anyone that Rosenblatt physically abused the boys, though the mental abuse seems clear. And Rosenblatt has not been charged with any crime. But at the barest minimum, his behavior has clearly been bizarre, inappropriate, unbecoming and just plain not right. One boy told the Times how uncomfortable it was for him to be taking a shower while Rosenblatt sat naked in the sauna staring at him. Not the way a rabbi should behave. And yet absolutely nothing has been done to Rosenblatt. Nothing. The synagogue has not suspended him, let alone fired him. Indeed, if you go to the synagogue’s website, you will find that even after the Times article told us what we know now, it refers to their rabbi as a “kli kodesh,” a holy vessel. Because of the nature of the still unproven, still unspecified charges against him, the college and the lobbying firm quickly cut off Hastert, felt it best to immediately show their disapproval. And yet, even as no one, including the rabbi, has disputed the facts in the Times story, even as no one is denying that the rabbi, for three decades, has taken young boys into the sauna with him as he and they sat naked, that he would ogle them as they showered, no action at all has been taken against the rabbi. He continues to serve the synagogue and has not been disciplined in any way by anyone. I thought Jews lived by a higher standard and that rabbis are expected to live by an even higher standard. And yet knowing what we now know about how Rosenblatt has behaved, the Jewish community in New York has simply shrugged it off, his synagogue has done nothing at all, he still presides over services, indeed they continue to call SEE BY JOSEPH AARON ON PAG E 1 3 15 Chicago Jewish News - June 5-11, 2015 ADVERTISEMENT A Letter the World Jerusalem ThreetoCard Montefrom Happy Dance “... but if you do not drive out the inhabitants of the Land before you, those of them that you leave shall be barbs in your eyes and thorns in your sides, and they will harass you upon the Land in which you dwell and it shall be that what I had meant to do to them, I shall do to you.” Numbers 33:55 The War of Independence for Israel in reality began on November 30, 1947, the day after the United Nations vote for the reestablishment of the homeland for the Jewish people. Until the U.N. vote the Arabs and their British allies had been on their best behavior … after the vote the gloves came off. It should be remembered that the original agreement regarding the reestablishment of the Jewish State was previously confirmed under the provisions of the Balfour Declaration (1917) with the agreement being fully implemented at the conference in San Remo, Italy in 1920, under the powers vested by the League of Nations called thereafter the Mandate for Palestine. In 1920, the homeland of the Jews was to be “on the banks of the Jordan River…” on both the west and the east banks of the Jordan. In 1922, Winston Churchill, the British Colonial Secretary and Alex Kirkbride, acting Governor of Moab, in disregard of Britain’s obligations under the Mandate, lopped off 78% of the land designated for the National homeland of the Jewish people thereafter calling it Trans-Jordan. … for Britain, one could only say, “agreements were made to be broken” and so the area left for the reestablishment of the Jewish homeland was only 22% of the original Mandate, the areas west of the Jordan river. In 1947, Britain and the successor organization to the League of Nations, the newly created United Nations again attempted to re-divide the remaining 22% into a Jewish State and a second Arab State. After the U.N. vote of 1947, with the instigation of the Arab leadership, Arabs who had been living in the area designated for the Jewish State were told to move to the area designated as the Arab State clearing the way for five Arab armies to enter the Jewish areas to slaughter the Jews. In the interim, the surrounding Arab states closed all their borders to any Arabs trying to leave Palestine. The so-called “refugees” never crossed the borders of 1948! The 1948 war in Palestine was a big story with hundreds of reporters from Europe, Britain and the United States on the scene. Today there are often hysterical memories by Arabs of the evil Jews pushing the “mythological” Palestinians out of their land where they had lived “from time immemorial”. Yet the obvious question is, if the Jews had violently pushed the “poor defenseless Arabs” out, might there be news accounts and articles attesting to these actions? In the book” Battleground” by Shmuel Katz, z’l he writes, “… the fabrication can most easily be detected by the simple fact that at the time the alleged expulsion of the Arabs by Zionists was in progress, nobody noticed it. Foreign newspapermen abounded in the country… but even those most hostile to the Jews saw nothing to suggest that the flight (of the Arabs) was not voluntary. In the months that the flight took place, the London Times, a newspaper most notably hostile to Israel, published 11 leading articles on the situation in Palestine… in none was there even a remote hint that the Zionists were driving Arabs from their homes… Even more pertinent, no Arab spokesman made such a charge. The Palestinian Arabs’ chief U.N. representative, Jamal Husseini, made a long political statement on April 27, 1948, that was not lacking in hostility toward the Zionists but he did not even mention” the refugees”… The Secretary-general of the Arab League, Azzam Pasha, also made a fiercely worded political statement on Palestine at the United Nations and not a word about “ refugees”. When playing “Three Card Monte”, the question is always who’s the mark and who’s the con…if you tell a lie often enough…and so our enemies have. Yet, interestingly, corroborating the findings from Shmuel Katz’s z’l exhaustive study of various news sources was our very own, less than Israelloving, Chicago Tribune, then owned and run by Colonel Robert R. McCormick, a personage not particularly fond of Jews. If, as some believe, the Tribune is biased today, it was worse under McCormick’s ownership and so an associate of mine spent over two months at the Harold Washington Library in Chicago combing thru every back issue of the Chicago Tribune from January 1, 1947 through December 31, 1949, photocopying each and every article (over 420) about Palestine, Zionists and the establishment of the State of Israel. Between 1947 and 1949, the Tribune had its very own Middle East foreign correspondent in Palestine by the name of E.R. Noderer. He was one of the Tribune’s most valued foreign correspondents and a loyalist when it came to the Tribune agenda. Quoting the Tribune’s own archives, “Noderer was in Palestine for the Jewish-Arab war, which saw the birth of the State of Israel.” In addition to Noderer, the Tribune had numerous dispatches from the Associated Press (AP) and United Press International (UPI). From all these sources over a three year period – not one report – not one sentence –about the Palestinian Jews (as they were referred to) throwing the Arabs (as they were referred to) out of the country. The only sentence that referred to Arabs leaving was written by Noderer on May 10, 1948 under the headline “Palestine Jews Say Their Star Rose on Jan. 15” (January 15th is when the British Army left Tel Aviv). Noderer writes: “One hundred fifty thousand Arabs were estimated (perhaps inflated) to have left the areas of Palestine assigned to the Jews in the partition plan”. That’s it! Would hundreds of news sources conspire to keep such an expulsion secret? Why is it that all the “accounts” of the brutality inflicted on the poor, displaced “Palestinians” were, in fact, written years afterward by “revisionist historians” with an agenda? Where was the need to establish a Palestinian Arab State from 1948 through 1967, when Jordan controlled the West Bank? As the Muslim cleric Abu Hamid al-Ghazali, considered the greatest Muslim after Mohammed, wrote, “If a lie is the only way to obtain a good result, it is permitted. We must lie when truth leads to unpleasant results.” (Jerusalem Post, March 1, 1997) In Arabic the noble lie is called “Al-Taqiya”…. And in a miraculous conversion, famed revisionst historian Benny Morris, in a January 9, 2004 Haaretz interview stated: “The majority of those who call themselves Palestinian refugees never left the boundaries of the western Land of Israel in 1948. This has frightening significance for leftist intellectuals because it means the myth of Palestinian ‘exile’ is false, and as a result, the ‘right of return’ means nothing”. Goebbels would be proud … If you repeat the lie often enough, people will begin to believe it, and so they have. Displaced refugees have been created where few existed in history. Al-Taqiya – the art of the lie… It is not just on the street corners of New York that the game of “Three Card Monte” is played. In “Three Card Monte” – the con – is a con in which a shill pretends to conspire with the mark to cheat the dealer, while in fact conspiring with the dealer to cheat the mark. In the refugee game of lies the shill is the head of UNRWA, Johnny “Quick-fingers” Ging and his merry band of Hamas pranksters… the dealer is the mythological Palestinian refugees – the larger the number the more funding from the mark…and the mark is the American taxpayers. “Three Card Monte” for Palestinian refugees is a con game in which the mark (the American tax payer) is tricked into giving aid on the assumption that there are more “refugees” getting more aid to split between the dealer and the shills, UNRWA and the Palestinian / Hamas leadership. It was Prince Hassam bin Tal, the younger brother of the late King Hussain of Jordan who when interviewed on the BBC by Stephen Sackur on the program Hard Talk in 2008 made the point, “We come from a Byzantine civilization, from centuries of dissimulation. I mean we Middle Easterners are professional liars.” UNRWA and the mythological Palestinians may not be very good at math, but are very creative when it comes to multiplication…Remember their happy dance after two airplanes slammed into the World Trade Center. The poor Palestinian leadership has been happy dancing on the American tax payer since the infamous handshake on the White House lawn 19 years ago called Oslo. Shabbat Shalom 06/05/15 Jack “Yehoshua” Berger 16 Chicago Jewish News - June 5-11, 2015
© Copyright 2024