How to talk to politicians so they will listen

How to talk to politicians so they will listen
– how to listen to politicians so they will
talk to researchers?
Anna Sarkadi, M.D., Associate professor
Uppsala University
Politicians …
and scientists
•  Want to make a
difference
•  Want to make a
difference
•  Want to keep their
promises to the
people who have
elected them
•  Want to keep their
promisesto their
grant suppliers by
answering the
research question
•  Want to get reelected
•  Want to get new
grants
Politicians …
and scientists
•  To make a difference:
ideology, power and
effective services
•  To make a difference:
politicians
•  To get re-elected:
sensitivity to issues
important to people
•  To get new grants:
publications & track
record
•  To answer the research
•  To keep their promises:
question: skill, integrity
intelligent compromises
and peer review as well
and a skill in explaning
as explaining why the
why things turned out
question was really
differently
something different
It all starts with listening:
Politicians are sensitive to opinion…
•  The timeout debate
had to be handled with
care – no one wants to
be conected with
programs that ”violate
children’s rights”
•  It was important to
early on include the
voice of parents and
practitioners
How to listen:
Politicians are sensitive to timing…
•  Long-term benefits are
desirable, but politicians
want results within four
years
•  The short-term benefits
have to outweigh the
emotional/political cost
•  Local problems
dominate,the local press
rules
How to talk: make theory
comprehensible
Selective
Universal
Universal programs?
High
vulnerabi
lity
Barriers to access may
prevent all from benefiting
EDI
Low
vulnerabi
lity
Disadvant
aged
Potential to
steepen
the gradient
SES
Advanta
ged
Proportionate Universality
Universal access at a scale and intensity that
addresses barriers at every level.
High
vulnerabi
lity
Barriers to access
EDI
10 -15%
Low
vulnerabi
lity
Disadvant
aged
SES
Gradient flattened
at both ends of the
SES spectrum, but
proportionate to
level of risk
Advanta
ged
How to talk: make the global local
•  Proportionate
universality around
the corner…
How to talk: money makes the
world go around…
•  Local, concrete
costs and benefits
•  Models for longterm savings and
how the current
investment plays
out in that model
How to talk: make politicians talk to
other people and reflect
•  Politicians: What do you need to know more
about to make informed decisions about
universal parenting support in your community?
•  Officials: What is the most important obstacle
for your community to succeed in delivering
universal parenting services?
•  Practitioners: What would you need in your
everyday work to be able to deliver adequate,
high quality universal parenting support?
So politicians … and scientists
can very well work together:
•  Politicians gain
–  Accountability
–  Precise measures of
outcome
–  Qualified description
of processes with
analyses of enabling
and hindering
factors
–  Calculations of cost
–  Credibility
•  Scientists gain
–  Learning to deal with
real life settings
–  Being able to make an
impact on practice
•  And maybe even
some new grants!