editor: Robert B. Bradfield, international Nutritional status of the Puerto master sample survey1’2 Nelson and A. Irma Fern#{225}ndez,3 Rosa,5 M.D., Jos#{233}C. Burgos,3 M.D., search team chemistry the from and University of Department and the of Health, and personnel districts. of the opportunity rapid to assistance Puerto Rico of the Puerto medical various the Rican prove current health Rico study growth economic the the from may for public Puerto of Medicine, with of status significance tion and the world. Rico, Research Bio- of School of paramedical island health This study nutritional Department Nutrition, of Puerto Office to diet be and of great problems in nutriin different parts of furnishes the unique the relationships of and nutritional sta- tus. This tional publication status and pects of 1966, compares the summarizes related Puerto Rican our the nutri- socioeconomic as- in population findings with a similar carried previous nutrition problems Socioeconomic observed between and of the nutritional discrepancies status and A more Both eco- growth. the As 848 detailed Bulletin of sociation (2). the publication Puerto was Rico made Medical 952 Ph.D., the stated families. Supported tional and socioeconomic survey was done developed by the using Office The American a stratified of Research Journal master of the of Clinical clinical and the laboratory procedures (4-9). studies described were in our information before, the final sample Of these, 405 or 47.8% consisted of were urban, in As- Methodology The sample Asenjo,4 out using publications by Institutes Biochemistry Methodology information F. Commonwealth Department of Health (3). The study was carried out in two basic steps: 1) Family interviews. From July through September 1966, 848 families were interviewed in their homes. The data recorded included socioeconomic information such as family income, educational level, family composition, waste disposal, and facilities for cooking, serving, storing, and consuming foods. Data on dietary patterns and the frequency of consumption of foods including the various kinds of milk, meat, seafoods, eggs, cheese, cereals, legumes, vegetables, fruits, fats, desserts, and beverages were also collected. 2) Clinical and biochemical examinations. These were done during October and November 1966 in a stratified subsample of 142 families selected systematically from the original master sample. The clinical data were recorded on punch cards similar to the Interdepartmental Committee on Nutrition for National Defense (ICNND) detailed examination forms, and biochemical tests included hemoglobin, hematocrit, and plasma values of total proteins, albumin, carotene, vitamin A, and vitamin C. Urinary excretion rates of thiamin, riboflavin, and N’-methylnicotinamide/g creatinine were done in casual urine specimens. Stools for ova and parasites were examined quantitatively in 543 subjects. study carried out in 1946 by Roberts and Stefani (1), and provides some practical recommendations for the solution of the existing nomic population: Grant of and Health Nutrition, AM-06032 to the School from the Na- Department of of Medicine, University of Puerto Rico, San Juan, Puerto Rico 00905. 2 Presented at the 2nd Western Hemisphere Nutrition Congress held at San Juan, Puerto Rico, August 26-29, 1968. Assistant Professor. ‘Professor and Head of Department. Research Dietitian. Nutrition 24: AUGUST 1971, pp. 952-965. Printed in U.S.A. Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on October 6, 2014 out July resentative lation. Conrado nutrition B.S. islandwide nutrition survey was carried through November 1966 in a repsample of the Puerto Rican popuThe survey was conducted by a re- An Rican Ph.D. NUTRITIONAL and 443 distribution or STATUS lived in the rural zone. The by annual income was as follows: under $500, 8.4%; $500 to 999, 13.0%; $1,000 to 1,999, 21.6%; $2,000 to 2,999, 17.8%; $3,000 to 3,999, 1 1.6% ; $4,000 to 4,999, 6.2%; $5,000 to 5,999, 3.9% ; $6,000 to 6,999, 3.9%; over $7,000, 13.5%. Family size was classified in four different groups and the distribution of the families was as follows: 1 to 3 members, 35.4%; 4 to 6 members, 42.7%; 7 to 10 members, 17.9% ; and over 10 members, 3.9%. Larger families were more prevalent in the rural areas. 52.2% of families Cooking facilities are summarized in Table 1. Gas, electric, and kerosene stoves were the most popular. Gas stoves were used by the highest percent of the families (45.5%). The use of the ‘fog#{243}n”or Regarding the different kitchen and Cooking 1 and kitchen storage facilities, 953 At an income over $5,000 dollars, all owned refrigerators. Kitchen storage space is also described lies had the higher better facilities the income were. Regarding the than level, of families Cooking Gas stove Electric stove Kerosene stove Cement hearth Three stones None Storage Built-in cabinets Movable cabinets Sets of shelves Improvised None the the sanitary rural better ones the facilities, and facilities about halt (50.5%) had flush toilets in their homes and 48.5% used latrines. Only 0.5% among the rural families disposed of human wastes by using a hole in the ground, and 1.6% reported a Of the complete families lack of a waste disposal five percent of the rural and 73% used latrines. of the homes had flush 22% used latrines. facility. Twenty- families had flush toilets In the urban zone, 78% toilets, and the remaining #{182} Dietary findings Information obtained food different about by two consumption methods. In was recorded. a 24-hr family diet history The other method consisted in recording frequency with which the families foods such as milk, cheese, meats, reals, legumes, oils, desserts, ceding week. fruits, vegetables, beverages Milk obtained information dividual and was one, the consumed eggs, cefats and the prewas the only during consumption quantitatively on an in- basis. of families Annual income families Rural , Number in Ta- ble 1. Only 7.4% of all the families had no storage space at all. The remaining 92.6% had some kind of storage facility, from built-in cabinets to simplc, improvised facilities. In general, urban fami- Zone All families eating utensils owned by the family, we can state that income determined the amount and variety found in the house. Families of low income usually cooked simple meals that required few utensils. As income increased, the menus became more varied and more utensils were needed. The situation in relation to refrigeration facilities showed that 82.3% of the families had a refrigerator. The remainder did not have refrigerators, but 5.5% used one in a nearby store or one belonging to a neighbor. The percent of urban families that owned a refrigerator (92%) was much higher than that for rural families (73%). The proportion owning refrigerators increased with income. In those families earning less than $500 a year only 53.8% had a refrigerator. TABLE RICANS PUERTO 848 443 Urban 405 Under $2,000 371 45.5 24.6 22.8 2.4 1.3 2.2 46.3 9.5 33.4 4.0 2.3 2.9 44.7 1.5 41.2 9.4 37.2 4.3 2.6 3.5 30.3 36.1 9.1 17.1 14.4 41.1 10.2 24.8 47.7 30.6 7.9 8.6 9.7 39.3 12.9 24.5 7.4 9.5 5.2 13.5 41.2 11.1 0.5 0.2 $2,00Co 362 i $7,000 and 113 56.4 26.0 13.8 1.1 0 1.7 25.7 70.8 3.5 0 0 0 34.5 84.0 40.3 11.5 7.7 14.1 0.9 2.7 3.3 0.9 Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on October 6, 2014 cement hearth had come down to a mere 2.4% of the families, mostly rural. Higher income families used mostly electric and gas stoves, whereas the use of kerosene stoves was more frequent in the lower income groups. OF 954 FERN#{193}NDEZ ET TABLE 2 Milk consumption, cups per person per AL. day Zone Age group, years Urban <1 year 1-5 6-12 13-18 20-39 40-59 i Amount of milk 3.6 3.3 4.7 2.9 748 654 2.0 2.4 1.7 1.9 2.0 2.0 2.3 2.2 2.2 1.6 1.8 1.8 345 2.0 3,928 2.2 2.2 2.4 1.7 2.0 consumed to 4.3 cups. However, children of the lowest income $500) showed a considerably gestion. Also, in the income $4,000 the daily ingestion by 12 years old was less than 2 preschool level (under low milk ingroups below children 6 to cups. Among adults, among milk intake was consistently deficient low and low-middle income subjects. Above 60-years old, only those belonging to the highest bracket (over $7,000) had an intake of more than 2 cups/day. As a whole, fresh milk was consumed by a larger percentage of subjects and families. Evaporated milk was next in order of consumption. The smallest percentage of individuals consuming fresh milk was found in the infant group, in which less than one-half (42.6%) drank it. Evaporated milk was consumed by 34% of them. The proportion of subjects consuming dry whole milk was also higher in infants (19%) than for the remaining age groups. As in the case of evaporated milk, the dry whole The milk proportion of milk decreased frequency was low All of them families drank subjects consuming as age increased. of consumption of dry skim in all age groups. included, fresh milk. income we found Even that 86% in the lowest #{176} $2,000 $l.?ed 3.5 3.9 4.2 2.8 3.3 4.1 1.5 1.5 2.0 2.1 4.0 3.0 1.7 1.6 1.9 2.0 2.6 2.4 1.7 1.8 1.7 2.3 2.3 2.9 income groups, 69 % of the families consumed fresh milk. Evaporated and dry whole milk were consumed by 12% and 10%, respectively. Skim milk was used by only 5%. Ninety-one percent of the urban families and 82% of the rural ones consumed fresh milk. Among welfare beneficiaries we observed that the consumption of the fresh product was also higher than of any other type of milk. The proportion of families consuming fresh milk increased with higher incomes. Skim milk was consumed the most by the poorest ones of families was found The fresh The (13%). highest percentage that did not drink in the lowest income proportion milk of decreased However, milk level. families as their that size (3.8%) drank augmented. even in the largest families of over 74% consumed fresh milk. The ingestion of evaporated, dry whole, and dry skim milks showed the opposite relation. Families were also asked which type of milk they liked most and it was found that 80.2% preferred fresh milk. Evaporated was next with 7.4%. Dry whole and dry skim were preferred by 6.1% and 2.7%, respec10 members, tively. Fresh milk among all families, zone, or whether they fits or not. Dietary the regardless received most popular of income, welfare bene- patterns Several food appear more supper, and hr family viewers. was combinations frequently between diet history were at breakfast, meals, recorded based found to lunch, on the 24- by the inter- Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on October 6, 2014 Table 2 shows the average milk consumpby age group, zone, and income. All age groups consumed at least 2 or 3 cups of milk daily; infants were the best consumers as they drank 3.9 cups. Income did not seem to be a determinant of milk consumption in infancy. One-year-old children in all income levels consumed daily amounts that ranged 2.4 Under 3.9 3.1 tion from Rural 91 541 934 615 Allages Annual All families Number NUTRITIONAL At breakfast, we found milk and bread was the highest proportion Next was which This coffee appeared means that with milk coffee that coffee combination of families with milk, OF with Food used by (22. 1 %). egg, and bread in 14.9% of the families. most of the homes used plus some other food for breakfast. Less not breakfast. have the STATUS than 1% of the families did containing coffee with milk, cereal, fruit, and eggs were observed more frequently in urban households; but also, more of these skipped breakfast. The elaborate Breakfasts proportion breakfasts of families having increased directly more with income. meat. The rural popular families, first in one was more whereas urban ones. increased, families their lunches vegetables. such It was common the As among latter was a rule, included more other foods as meat, milk, and in the lowest income in salad level that we found the highest percentage having only rice and beans. However, the largest proportion of families (13.4%) skipping lunch was observed in the upper income At supper, combination centage of the of rural supper, age rice cluding more beans with meat was by the highest per(15.3%). Fifteen percent had for urban but was and eaten families ones very low. three or common in variety was of also only rice and dwellers Supper beans this for percent- combinations four different urban than in- foods in were rural fami- lies. The pertime In the lowest of the supper, families whereas it less was groups, ilies it was included the foods included directly related to income 1 sup- income. level, over one-fourth had only rice in the highest than at In %. more elaborate meat, milk, the and beans for income group upper and and more income fam- vegetables, in addition to rice and beans. The most popular was coffee. Coffee with in 31 % of all families, rural ilies dwellers. did not between-meals milk was particularly snack the Regarding the frequency of consumption of foods by the families during the week preceding the interview, the following relevant findings were obtained: Eggs favorite among Nearly one-fourth of the famhave anything between meals. were used more frequently than any other protein food. Families of the lowest income bracket ate them about three times a week, and the wealthiest families had eggs almost daily. Among the meat products, smoked ham was the most frequently used on all levels. Beef was consumed at least once a week by the lower income families and as income increased, it was eaten more often, reaching an average of 3.5 times a week in the highest income group. Poultry was less popular than beef in upper income levels, whereas in the poorer families the opposite was true. Liver was not commonly contwo at any or income three families of level. times and Codfish a week slightly in the higher more income consumption by other eaten low than levels. of was the income once The a week frequency seafoods very was low. Red kidney beans were preferred above other legumes. In general, families ate all them groups. the consumption sumed as income 955 RICANS three beans were the poorer by the peas or four times a week. White navy eaten less than once a week by families and even less frequently upper not gardless ones. to be Chick very were were very eaten popular three weekly at all Banana income, income was eaten all families. eaten at wealthier five times/week. very as plantain, bananas, and or two times levels. favorite to fruit four regardless times of by weekly Oranges and pineapples were least once or twice a week by families, but for the poorest ones frequency also eaten fresh families, Among the two tion was about levels. Grapefruits, other re- in all families. to Other starchy vegetables, such breadfruit, taniers, yams, green sweet potatoes were eaten one the were pigeon and popular, of income. Potatoes They income seem did fruits was much lower. in season and their once a week West were Indian seldom at Mangoes consumpall income cherries, used and by the particularly the lower income ones. the cereals, rice was consumed frequently. Only families with annual Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on October 6, 2014 Including all the families, the most popular lunch combinations were starchy vegetables with codfish, and rice and beans with PUERTO 956 incomes above $6,000 every day. Bread was did not FERN#{193}NDEZ ET rice subjects consume also frequently eaten, especially by families with higher incomes. Lard was frequently used by all families, but it was more popular among the less privileged ones. Vegetable oils, on the contrary, were preferred Only families by the higher of the higher ets more ate dessert cream was annual cream pastes, the than preferred income income a week. one. Those were the wealthier consumed at least once with a week by families. Coffee was drunk more all income levels. Families as often as 9 to 10 times than once daily at consumed coffee during the week. Carbonated beverages and malt beer were also used, particularly by the upper income families who consumed these over 4 times a week. Higher income families also drank alcoholic beverages more often than the less privileged in persons the also over tongue. more In signs there was prevalence) and of frequent signs associated with follicular hyperkeratosis vitamin was with Dental prevalence de(62% with associated ficiencies. a low specific caries were nutritional common increasingly age. Among the A deficiency, the of from most 15%. common, This 2 years junctival infection with sign up was to old (3%) a general prevalence observed age. and regularly Bilateral xerosis con(4%) of the skin were less frequent. Gingivitis, papillary atrophy, and bleeding of the gums were commonly associated with poor oral hygiene and pyorrhea. Only 9% of the subjects showed diffuse gum inflammation be related to vitamin C deficiency. seborrhea was the most common boflavin groups deficiency. It was present with an overall prevalence It was mostly that could Cutaneous sign of riin all age of 15%. nasolabial; but in a large numboth nasolabial and retroauricular lesions were found. Teeth malposition was a consistent finding in all age groups except infants. One hundred and thirty-seven ber of subjects, thiamin, small cases over possible protein the bilateral knee and Eight-one bilateral 40-years-old. Other deficiency thiamin, riboflavin, deficiency occurred ilies; whereas those vitaminosis C and areas. Also, niacin, of deficiency income extremely prevalence deficiency to vitamin and protein in urban famhypo- possible more in per the higher a slightly signs of person in the groups. The height, salient weight, a high prevalence particularly was in signs were more often related to D prevailed there percent appeared edema rare. Rural people showed a lower of clinical signs associated with than urban subjects. Signs related A, edges was older persons. related to a de- children. of persons Twenty-two tip and atrophy absence or ankle reflexes common (7%). The finding prevalent among older was not found among in- of the and the upper general, among possibly Glos- particularly of age. the signs the most particularly women. Edema fants condition. only the papillary prevalent of average Clinical data 60 years were was rural ones. the Tongue diminution of showed in 27 individuals, or 8 1 % involved cases of 2 1% found clinical findings and skin-fold women dation of growth in cent standard weights of obesity (10); children. (Table and in relation thickness, among to were adults, a slight retarThe mean per- 3) showed that moderate undernutrition, 10 to 20% underweight, prevailed among children and adolescents. Adults, particularly women, showed adequate weights for their heights. Children 6 to 12 years old had the lowest mean percent standard weight. The percent standard weight was calculated in terms of weightfor-age up to 18 years, and weight for height above that age. Body length and weight were close to the standard in early infancy (3 months) but afterward fell progressively below the standards, with some recovery during adolescence. At age 17, urban youngsters had attained a complete weight recovery, whereas the rural ones at age 18 were 9 lb below the standard. Men were about 5 inches taller than women on the average, and young people tended to be taller than their elders, particularly women. An elevated prevalence of obesity was ob- Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on October 6, 2014 they or was ficiency Ice incomes above $6,000 consumed ice over 2.5 times a week. Cake, sweet fresh and canned fruits, and cookies not used as often as ice cream, but were sitis Among homes. brack- once AL. NUTRIIIONAL TABLE 3 Clinical data Agegrotp, years <1 Sex STATUS 2-5 0-12 OF 13-18 MF 13 5.2’ 15 15.4 168 9.0 39 15.0 45 15.3 Mean height, inches Mean weight, lb Mean % standard wt % 10- to 20 overweight % over 20% overweight Mean skin fold, mm Arm Back 24.9 14.6 96.5 30.0 21.6 91.7 67 3.6 38.2 31.2 90.7 50.5 62.3 61.1 57.5 102 108 87.8 88.1 97.1 5 3 5 9.2 6.3 PF to 69.2 females. 9.2 7.4 pregnant in years. = served in adults. cent, respectively, over 19 years 9.4 6.6 9.2 6.5 LF of age and the were 7 87 28.8 60.9 127 107 11 3 7 18 22 8.0 7.2 16.9 13.1 12.6 16.3 21.1 20.0 females. 12 women and above 20% lence raries. showed of obesity regard difference rural a than to height in the adults. family United over- higher rural there mean no significant of urban those over preva- contempo- was heights However, income much their with $7,000 an were and annual almost 2 inches taller, on the average, than adults with yearly incomes below $1,000. In children and adolescents there was a direct relationship between the percent standard heights and weights and annual incomes up to $7,000. Above increase was In and increased up to $7,000. in both was with ever, that annual showed prevalence income observed. the mean adults, weight also Mean LF M F M 8 2 50 49.0 31 27.0 47 50.6 31 28.8 68.8 59.3 121 104 62.6 132 108 0 64.6 59.5 64.3 141 131 102 112 19 20 136 99.6 16 69.2 58.7 124 108 13 0 9 38 10 29 19.0 15.5 12.0 14.9 22.5 23.8 8.9 11.5 20.0 18.0 17.1 17.6 age 6V in months. (1 1, States standards (13) were evaluation of height Laboratory findings Mean 12) and used in and F age from 3.6 Puerto the weight Rican preceding data. Women communities In a permen 40 to 59 years of age showed the highest prevalence of obesity (38%). Among men, moderate and marked overweight was more common in the 19 to 39 age group. Obesity was more prevalent in urban people, but among young adults (19 to 39 years old) the occurrence was about the same. School children, adolescents, and persons over 60 years of age from the urban weight. PF 60 29.6 66.0 149 105 20 lactating = Twenty-eight of F 40-59 the general in incomes a that further percent standard of obesity income a decrease of families relation to income Children of $3,000 consistent of obesity. no prevalence direct Over observed. level and increase up, howin the A low prevalence of anemias was observed (Table 4). Only 5.0% and 7.2% showed low-deficient levels of hemoglobin and mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentrations (MCHC), respectively. All the anemias were of the hypochromic type, as shown by the mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentrations. Fourteen percent of the subjects examined had low hematocrit values, but only less than 1 % was deficient. Infants showed the highest low-deficient hematocrit values. A considerable prevalence of deficient mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentrations was found in one-year-old children. Above that age, the hypochromias observed were mostly in the low range. The most severe forms of iron deficiency anemias were concentrated among infants and preschool children. In general, there was a higher prevalence of low-deficient hematologic values in the lower income families. However, a considerable prevalence of low and of low-deficient mean centrations was observed income groups. deficient MCHC families with The values corpuscular among the conhigher highest values an hematocrit annual was occurrence of found among income above Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on October 6, 2014 MF age 21-32 M MF Mean M 957 RICANS 19-39 MF Number PUERTO 9S8 FERN#{193}NDEZ TABLE ET AL. 4 Hematologic findings Age group, years Sex <1 1 5 6-12 ME MF MF 7 11.2 14.3 14.3 76 12.0 5.2 6.5 7 13-18 Zone 19-39 M F M 162 13.4 0 1.2 39 14.7 20.5 0 42 13.8 0 0 61 16.1 1.6 0 85 13.6 0 2.4 75 35.5 20.0 2.7 162 38.9 1.9 0.6 39 42.8 43.6 0 42 40.5 21.4 0 61 46.8 1.6 0 75 33.8 162 34.2 3.7 1.2 39 34.4 42 34.1 7.7 0 40-50 FPF 60 Urban Rural 412 13.8 3.4 2.2 LF M F M F 8 12.4 12.5 0 2 12.9 0 0 46 15.8 2.2 0 50 13.9 0 0 31 15.1 12.9 6.5 31 13.9 0 0 219 14.1 2.7 1.4 85 39.9 18.8 1.2 8 36.5 25.0 0 2 37.5 50.0 0 46 45.8 4.3 0 50 41.1 12.0 0 31 31 219 411 44.1 40.6 41.0 40.4 25.8 0 16.1 0 14.6 0.5 13.6 1.0 61 85 8 2 46 50 31 31 219 411 34.0 34.1 34.0 34.3 34.4 33.7 34.3 34.2 34.3 34.1 7.1 6.6 7.1 12.5 0 2.2 8.0 9.7 0 4.1 7.1 0 0 2.4 0 0 0 0 0 0 1.4 1.2 = mean Hemoglobin, g/l00 ml Number Mean % Low % Deficient PF concent = 32.0 42.9 14.3 7 34.6 0 0 pregnant ations. 9.4 5.3 females. LF = lactating females. MCHC $7,000. Urban mean hemoglobin, hematocrit, and MCHC were always slightly higher than the corresponding rural values. The hematologic findings were evaluated according to Wintrobe (14), except those for pregnant women, in which ICNND guides (15) were used. Severe hypoproteinemia was very rare, but a considerable number of low total proteins and albumin levels were observed (Table 5). Children 2 to 5 years old showed the highest prevalence of low total plasma proteins, but and deficient examined values appeared among school chil- dren, adolescents, and young adults. All pregnant and lactating women had adequate plasma total proteins. Hypoalbuminemia was present in all age groups with a general prevalence of 9.6%. Subjects over 60 years old and small children showed the highest cccurrence of low albumin values. Only 3 cases fell in the deficient range. The highest percentage of deficient total proteins was observed in families with an annual income above $6,000, and all the three cases of deficient plasma albumin values fell in this same income group. With the exception of the $5,000 to 5,999 income group, the mean albumin levels of the poorer families were higher than those of the wealthier; corpuscular hemoglobin the prevalence of hypoalbuminemia was the low income families than in the two upper income groups. In regard to zone, a higher percentage of low and deficient levels of total proteins and albumin was observed in the urban families. lower All in three subjects with less than 2.8 ml albumin, and four out of the with total proteins below 6 g/100 from urban areas. Vitamin A levels were higher pected, values, with less showing however, than low were 1% values. much of the Low more g/ 100 five ml, cases came than ex- subjects carotene common, particularly among small children. Plasma ascorbic acid levels were adequate. The highest prevalence of low carotene concentrations was observed in the lowest income family group. Also, families with an annual income above $7,000 had the highest mean vitamin A concentration. Mean ascorbic acid plasma levels increased with income from 1.2 to 1.6 mg/ 100 ml. Urban mean values of carotene and vitamin A were higher than the rural ones. Vitamin C plasma levels were slightly higher in the rural communities. Table 6 summarizes the data on urinary vitamin excretion rates. The urinary excretion of thiamin was low-deficient in 35 sub- Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on October 6, 2014 Hematocrit, % Number Mean % Low % Deficient MCHC, g/100 ml Number Mean % Low % Deficient NUTRITIONAL TABLE STATUS OF PUERTO 959 RICA.NS 5 Plasma proteins Age group, yea’s 6-12 PF LF M F M F 58 157 39 41 60 83 8 2 46 50 31 31 7.0 13.8 7.4 7.6 5.1 0 7.5 4.9 2.4 7.6 1.7 1.7 7.6 3.6 2.4 6.9 0 0 8.1 0 0 7.5 6.5 0 7.4 8.0 0 7.5 3.2 7.7 3.2 7.5 5.8 7.5 5.2 0 0 2.4 0.3 4.2 4.2 4.1 4.0 4.9 0 3.3 1.7 4.1 10.8 0 3.6 2.6 0 4.1 4.3 0 4.0 10.0 3.9 19.3 0 3.9 22.6 0 3.9 10.6 1.4 4.1 8.3 0 3.8 3.8 13.8 4.0 7.0 1.7 0.6 lactating = females. of 6 in and TABLE 6 Urinary vitamin of Thiamin, agg Number Median % Low % Deficient Riboflavin, ag/g Number PF = 0 Values females. nary 0 of <6.0 and <5.5 g/l00 Values <3.50 were ml were used used for preg- excretion rates of were years uri- N1-methylnicotina- mide, but, only 0.5% was in the deficient range. Low excretions were distributed fairly evenly among the various age groups with prevalences varying from 11 to 20%. The highest occurrence was observed in young creatinine Age group, 2-5 6-12 MF MF 3 156 38 43 1,167 762 505 385 2.7 3.8 3.8 7.9 2.6 7.0 5.4 38 1,225 18.4 2.6 158 501 13.3 12.7 38 352 13.2 7.9 35 156 4.0 16.0 1.3 38 4.0 13.2 0 Sex 0 cient prevalences of more than 20% observed in individuals from 2 to 39 of age. Sixteen percent showed low-deficient in excretion/g 0 a in the case of pregnant examined. Poor all the age higher proportion prevailed in school children. urinary excretion rates were in 23% of the cases. Fifty subwere deficient. The highest deficient values was observed to 12 years old and among lactating women. Low-defiobserved 25.0 13-18 years Zone 40-59 19-39 M >60 Urban Rural 204 366 0 3.4 1.0 4.6 2.5 F PF LF M F 60 83 1.7 347 2.4 8 636 0 2 285 50.0 44 379 0 2.4 0 0 50 415 2.0 0 367 3.3 0 43 263 11.6 9.3 60 287 25.0 3.3 84 298 19.0 9.5 8 2 82 0 50.0 42 50 29 29 205 366 326 0 12.5 341 9.5 606 6.9 271 10.3 10.3 13.2 15.0 7.1 415 10.0 6.0 2.9 11.2 41 4.0 17.1 58 3.0 24.1 83 3.0 9.6 1.2 7 2 50.0 0 30 2.0 23.3 0 362 0 0 50 4.0 18.0 0 200 2.0 44 3.0 6.8 0 28 6.0 3.0 17.9 0 16.5 14.6 0 0.8 M 259 9.1 0 F M 30 3.4 29 238 3.4 ‘g pregnant 5.0 11 .4 0 females. LF = 0 lactating 0 females. Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on October 6, 2014 groups, but a preschool and Riboflavin low-deficient jects or 8.6% Median ‘ Low % Deficient N’-methylnicotinamide, mg Number Median % Low % Deficient 387 F of all subjects were children pregnant 208 M 1.3 or 6.0% prevalence Rural F PF = pregnant females. LF as low and deficient, respectively, nant fenales. excretions Urban M <2.8 jects (0 ml % <3.528 % 40-59 MF Number % <6.0#{176} Albumin, g/100 Mean 19-39 13-18 ME Sex Total proteins, g/l00 ml Mean % <6.5#{176} Zone 960 FERN#{193}NDEZ low excretions ban families. Regarding was slightly severe prevalence prevailed occurrence were more in the ur- of intestinal parin all age groups, but the highest was observed in children 2 to 14 years old. The general preyalence of trichuriasis was 39.7% . Ascariasis was also particularly prevalent among the younger age groups, showing a very low cccurrence after 1 9 years of age. Moderate and asites, the higher trichuriasis cases prevalent in children 2 to 14 years old, and the highest prevalence was observed among preschool children. Hookworm infestations were observed from 2 years of age to adulthood. The highest. prevalence was found between 6 and 14 years of age. The general prevalences of Ascaris and hookworm were 12.4% and 13.1 %, respectively. Endamoeba coil was considerably prevalent from preschool children to old age with prevalences varying from 9 to 20.5% in the various age groups. This protozoan had a general prevalence of 13.6%. Giardia lamblia cases occurred mostly in children up to 14 years of age. Endamoeba histoiytica was mainly a problem of schoolchildren and adolescents, and its general prevalence was low (2.6%). Endoiimax nana was regularly prevalent from preschool-age to old age, with a general occurrence of 6.4%. The prevalence distribution of intestinal parasites by income groups showed that the lower income families had a much higher AL. parasitic the prevalence. prevalence festations Ascaris. with prevalence than in This of was moderate also and Trichuris, true severe hookworm, for inand There was a significantly higher of intestinal parasites in the rural the urban families. Discussion and recommendations Discussion Socioeconomic information. We sought to compare the socioeconomic and dietary findings of our survey with those of Roberts and Stefani in 1 946 (1) in order to find out what changes occurred during the past 20 years. As mentioned previously, our final sample consisted of 848 families, 47.8% of which were urban and 52.2% of which lived in the rural zone. These figures represented a marked increase in the proportion of urban families in comparison with the 1 946 study. At that time 57.5% of the families were rural dwellers and 42.5% were urban. Family income showed a dramatic increase. In 1946, about 44% of the families had annual incomes under $500, whereas in 1966 only 8.4% lived with such low income. In Roberts and Stefani’s study approximately three-fourths of the families lived with less than $1 ,000 a year and a few (8 %) had incomes above $2,000. In our survey only 21.4% of the families earned under $1,000 yearly and over one-half of them surpassed $2,000. Fifty-one percent had annual incomes between $ 1 ,000 and $4,000. The proportion of families composed of 4 to 6 members was about the same in 1946 and 1966 (41.9% and 42.7%, respectively). The main differences were an increase in the proportion of families with 1 to 3 members from 26.1% to 35.4% and a decrease of those composed of 7 to 10 members from 27.6% to 17.9%. The mean number of members per household diminished from 5.4 in 1946 to 4.8 in our study. In comparing the cooking, serving, refrigeration, and storage facilities of the families, we found that in 1946 the modern types of cooking fixtures were rare in the Puerto Rican homes. Only 3.6% of the families had electric or gas 70.1 % had either Charcoal was the stoves, one most whereas in 1966, the other of them. frequent cooking fuel or Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on October 6, 2014 adult males (24. 1 % ) and men over 60 years old (23.3%). Lower income did not necessarily mean lower urinary excretion values. In the case of thiamin and riboflavin, the higher prevalences of low-deficient excretion rates were observed mostly among the middle income families. However, the general prevalence of deficient excretions of these two vitamins was higher in the lower income groups. The low excretion rates of N’-methylnicotinamide were somewhat evenly distributed among the various income groups. In general, middle income families tended to be better off than those with a lower or higher income. There was a higher prevalence of lowdeficient excretion rates of thiamin and riboflavin in the rural areas. In the case of N’-methylnicotinamide, the prevalence of ET STATUS NUTRITIONAL 1946. utilized At that it, but in dropped to showed marked time, 36.6% of the homes in 1966 use of charcoal than 1% Rural dwellers less of their PUERTO 961 RICANS sisted solely of coffee alone 3 1 .3 % of the families, but dropped to only 8% in 1966. . improvement OF cook- the of ing families had or with milk in such proportion In 1946, 14.4% black coffee only for breakfast, whereas in our data less than 1% of the families did so. As in Roberts and Stefani’s study, in 1966 coffee with milk and bread still remained the favorite breakfast combination, although in a smaller proportion. The percentage of homes having other foods added to their breakfasts was much higher in 1966 than in 1946. Lunches also showed improvement since 1946. Starchy vegetables with codfish remained as the most popular combination, but the percent of families that used it was much lower in 1 966 (1 2.9 and 8.3 % , respectively). In 1946, less than one-half of facility. homes included Consequently, using latrines the dropped. proportion of The propor- of rural dwellers with a sanitary facilities was reduced 1946 to just 1.6% in 1966. Dietary findings. As mentioned average intake of milk showed groups consumed at least 2 daily. Roberts and Stefani did total from tion per capita groups is not people almost milk In intake from 1946, and spectively. 19.5 and regard to 10.4 were of milk in as we did, therefore possible. Nevertheless, 8.1 doubled to 15.4 7.5 and other kind. Breakfasts than in 1946. and the various consumption cups/person rural age comparison in 1966 our of per week. averaged day, reOur corresponding figures were 16 ounces. The characteristics in milk preferences and consumption similar in both studies. The majority of families, regardless of zone or income, the preferred urban of in before, the that all age or more cups not record the such the lack 27% families ounces/person consumed were In per fresh milk over much better in our that year, breakfast any survey con- the households included codfish, meat, or some other protein food in their lunches, whereas in 1966, 71.2% of them did so. In 1 946, supper was even poorer than lunch. At had that only 14.9% their of of food. the families In our the practice tween meals when 83.4% ever, in the supper increased not of the 1966, the included survey, of was of families supper and only a protein food in 1966, almost three- for included meal. In in come. The 47.4% foods them evening fourths tein time, starchy some variety with having some food very common in families 76.5% of had them none. had pro- of foods the in- be1946 Howhabit. In regard to the frequency with which different kinds of foods were included in the diet; both in 1946 and 1966, the family income was the most important determining factor. As income increased, the frequency of use of certain foods and the variety of the diet also increased. In our study, several food products that were luxury foods in 1946 were now available to a large portion of our population. Eggs only some used high to be income a luxury product families could that afford to have daily. The lowest income families had them only once in 2 weeks or even less often. In 1966, we found that even families with incomes under $500 a year ate eggs at least three times a week. In Roberts and Stefani’s study very few families could afford to have meat or meat Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on October 6, 2014 facilities. A striking improvement was found in relation to the owning or use of a refrigerator. In Roberts and Stefani’s study, only 1 1 % of all the families owned or could use a refrigerator. In 1966 that percentage had risen to 87.8 % . This remarkable change was also observed in relation to zone and income. All families with annual incomes above $5,000 owned a refrigerator. However, in the lowest income group, earning less than $500 a year, we found that nearly one-half (46.2%) of them still lacked this facility. The availability of storage space in the homes also revealed marked advancement since 1946. At that time, a total of 40.6% of the families had no storage facilities at all. In our study the proportion was reduced to just 7.4%. Sanitary facilities showed great progress in our study. In 1 946 flush toilets were uncommon in Puerto Rico and only 20% of the families had one. Twenty years later we found that one-half of them (50.5%) had this 962 FERN#{193}NDEZ products daily and a high percentage of them had it very rarely or never. In 1966, families in all income levels ate meat or meat products at least once a day. Special reference must be made to poultry, which in 1946 was also a luxury food, particularly for the low income homes. In 1966, it had become a popular food that was included more than once a week in the diet of families from all income levels. Among the seafoods, codfish remained the most popular, as in 1946. In that time about three-fourths of the families included codfish as a regular part of their diet. In our study, the situation was about the same, esfor the low income homes, which included codfish two or three times in the week. Legumes have always been preferred by our families and constitute an important part of the diet at all income levels. Unfortunately, those with a higher protein nutritive value, like pigeon and chick peas were not consumed so frequently. At all times, starchy vegetables have made up the bulk of the diet of many of our families, especially the poor rural ones. Eaten in large amounts, they constitute a good source not only of calories, but also of vitamins such as B and C. It should be noted that in the rural communities surveyed by our group they were the explanation for the C (4-8). In preference it was found that, both and in 1966, the most favored were green plantain, green bananas, and consumption of vitamin adequate order of in 1946 potatoes, ripe ba- nanas. Tropical fruits are very common in Puerto Rico and therefore one would expect a high consumption. However, in 1946, although many families could have them free of charge, they were not consumed as often as desirable. In 1966 the consumption of fresh fruits was still low. It was found that only bananas were eaten more than once a week at all income levels. Oranges, pineapples, and mangoes were eaten more than once a week only by the high income families. In our study the consumption of canned fruits had diminished considerably. Among the cereals commonly used by our families, rice was the favorite in both studies. In AL. 1946, 90.8% of the families ate it daily, and in 1966 it was also consumed daily at all income levels. Bread was used daily by about two-thirds of the families in 1946. In 1966 it was used less frequently, particularly by those of low income. Crackers were also popular in 1946 and in 1966. Lard continues to be the most used fat in Puerto Rico, although in 1 966 the higher income families preferred vegetable oils. In 1 946, oil, butter, and even margarine, seemed to be luxury products used only by families that could afford to buy them. In 1966 it was found that such fats were consumed at homes from all income levels and even the lowest income families used them more than once a week. Both in 1946 and 1966 desserts played a minor role high once income a week. were sweet in Puerto Rican families ate The favorite pastes, fruits. In 1 966 followed closely dietaries. Only dessert more desserts in than 1946 preserved and canned the favorite was ice cream, by cake. Clinical data. Clinical and biochemical studies were not done in 1 946. In our survey, a low prevalence of specific deficiency signs and symptoms was observed. However, a greater occurrence of signs associated with vitamin A, riboflavin, and niacin deficiency was found as compared with our rural studies (4-8). With the exception of vitamin A deficiency signs, which showed an equal distribution between urban and rural groups, the urban population was mostly affected. An interesting observation was the higher prevalence of deficiency signs in families with yearly incomes above $4,000. The considerable prevalence of obesity found in our study represents a new public health problem. It was considerably high even in middle income families. It was more common in urban families and increased with income, therefore appearing to be a problem of affluence. A disturbing finding was that over 22% of our children, mostly adolescents belonging to middle class families, were becoming obese. In our opinion this problem merits prompt action, and measures to curb this trend should not wait. In regard to growth, it was encouraging to find that young people were growing taller Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on October 6, 2014 pecially ET NUTRITIONAL STATUS minimum the high In requirements. prevalence of older children, intestinal parasites was a major contributing factor to anemia, whereas in pregnant women the increased requirements for iron were probably not met. The decreased prevalence of hypochromic anemias as income augmented cannot be explained on a dietary basis alone. Better sanitation and general health care were undoubtedly involved. Vitamin A levels were higher than expected with less than 1 % of the subjects examined showing low values. However, it is suspected that these higher values were a result of prolonged storage of the samples. Adequate ascorbic acid levels in serum were expected. Rural people obtained a large share of this vitamin from starchy vegetables which they consumed in appreciable quantities, whereas in the urban area there was a larger consumption of citrus fruits, juices, and concentrates. The excretion of B vitamins in PUERTO urine followed the communities. nant or 963 RICANS pattern Preschool lactating found children showed females in and the rural preglowest excretions. Recommendations According to our findings, higher ecostandards and greater food availability do not necessarily mean better nutrition. Perhaps this is due to an ineffective coordination between our present food and nutrition programs and the rapid economic growth experienced in Puerto Rico in recent years. Thus, the islandwide establishment of food and nutrition policies based on the true prevailing needs of our population and of continuous health and nutrition surveillance mechanisms are indispensable in order to correct the existing nutritional problems and to prevent the appearance of new ones. A better coordination among governmental agencies such as Health, Agriculture, Education, Economic Development, Consumer’s Protection Administration, and so forth is highly desirable. Related professional organizations (medical, dietetic, and other health societies) and private food industry (dairy, fabricated foods) should be involved. nomic A strong organized body, either voluntary like the Puerto Rico Nutrition Committee, or created by legislation, but with enough authority and official governmental support to assure optimum efficiency, would be the ideal instrument for achieving adequate coordinalion and for establishing sound food and nutrition policies to satisfy the real needs of our people. Staple and nutritious foods at the lowest possible price should be made available to the population with emphasis on preschool children and pregnant women. Milk should be priced low enough to be readily available to low income families. This could be accomplished by allowing the production of adequate milk substitutes such as filled milk, by means of food stamps for this product, by expanding the existing milk distribution programs, particularly those serving preschool children and pregnant women, or by subsidy. Milk, which is consumed in insufficient quantities, would represent an ideal supplement for our people and would help Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on October 6, 2014 than their elders. Infants from the upper economic levels tended to be longer at birth and continued in this growth pattern, resulting in taller adults, on the average. Children from the lower economic groups lagged below both Puerto Rican and North American standards, catching up partially during adolescence, but resulting in shorter adults by 2 to 2.5 inches. This retardation of growth in regard to chronological age in the low income group was similar to the one observed in our studies of isolated rural communities, which indicated the existence of a problem of borderline undernutrition. These findings contrasted with the high occurrence of obesity discussed above. The higher prevalence of nutritional deliciency signs in middle and upper class penple, accompanied by a high prevalence of excess weight, makes an interesting situation as well as a new public health challenge. Puerto Rico is a country of rapid mobility towards higher social and economic standards; therefore the coexistence of problems of undernutrition and overnutrition demands our greatest concern. Laboratory findings. The low prevalence of anemia in adults can be explained by an adequate intake of iron. Anemia in infancy was frequently due to intakes below the OF 964 FERN#{193}NDEZ consumers. Educational programs should expand to include problems of unbalanced diet resulting in obesity, atherosclerosis, and other degenerative diseases; and proper mechanisms should be established to assure the participation of the private food market and the advertising industry in consumer education. It is necessary to enlist the assistance and cooperation of the food industry in introducing new foods or altering current food habits. New fabricated foods will continue to appear and our governmental agencies will never be able to satisfactorily counteract the tremendous public impact of food advertisements through the press, radio, Our and television. should concentrate its milk consumption in particular among the poorer families. It should also stimulate a greater preference for cheaper forms of milk, such as evaporated or dried milk. Milk, as previously mentioned, is an ideal dietary supplement for the leading deficiencies now prevalent. Other foods that should be strongly recefforts government in increasing AL. ommended are: chick and pigeon peas, yellow and green vegetables, and fruits and juices rich in vitamins A and C. These food items are not being consumed either regularly or in desirable amounts. Summary An islandwide nutrition survey was carried out in 1 966 in a representative stratifled sample of the Puerto Rican population. The survey included the collection of socioeconomic, dietary, clinical, and biochemical data. Eight hundred and seventy-seven famiies were interviewed at their homes, and information in regard to income, occupation, educational level, family composition, and waste disposal facilities was obtained. Detailed data about dietary patterns, frequency of consumption of all kinds of foods, and the facilities of the families for the storage, preparation, and serving of foods were also recorded. Clinical and biochemical tests were done in 663 and 655 subjects, respectively, from a highly representative stratified subsample of 142 families. The clinical data were recorded on punch cards similar to the ICNND detailed examination forms. Biochemical tests included hemoglobin, hematocrit, and plasma values of total proteins, albumin, carotene, vitamin A, and vitamin C. Urinary excretion rates of thiamin, riboflavin, and N1-methylnicotinamide per gram of creatinine were done in casual urine spec-. imens. Stools for ova and parasites were examined quantitatively in 528 subjects. All data were transferred to a format designed for electronic data processing and subjected to detailed evaluation. This study reveals very interesting information regarding the various patterns of food consumption among the different socioeconomic levels and the urban and rural people. It shows that higher economic standards do not necessarily improve the nutritional value of the diet. People from remote rural communities were better fed than urban people from slums in regard to several nutrients. References 1. ROBERTS, Living Puerto L. J., and in Puerto Rico: Univ. R. L. STRFANI. Rican Families. Puerto Rico Press, Patterns San of Juan, 1949. Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on October 6, 2014 alleviate the main nutritional deficiencies (vitamin A, riboflavin, and calcium). Other measures to increase the availability of desirable foods would be to allow the importation of staple and nutritious foods at the lowest possible price to the consumer by eliminating or modifying existing trade restrictions that raise the cost of imported foods, and to stimulate the enrichment of natural or synthetic food products with the nutrients most frequently deficient in the Puerto Rican diet. Also, all food distribution programs should be based on the existing nutritional problems and all decisions on nutritional needs and values of foods in relation to these programs should be made by nutrition experts and not by administrators. It is urgent to intensify nutrition education programs at all levels, including government workers and consumers, both in relation to existing problems and new ones that have arisen as a result of the rapid changes occurring in Puerto Rico. Emphasis must be given to preschool children and pregnant women. Administrators of food programs should be acquainted with or educated on the nutritional needs and problems of the to ET STATUS NUTRITIONAL 2. AND Rican I. Asoc. 5. BuRoos, status sample ROSA. Nutritional population: master Med. 3. Redesign 4. N. A., J. C. FERN#{193}NDEZ, Labor of Force tistics, Dept. C. F. Asniijo of . 8. the Puerto survey. Bol. Puerto Rico, Suppl., 1971. the Household Sample for Survey. Bureau of Labor Labor, OF Commonwealth of 9. PLOUGH, N. L. J. A., J. ROBERTS C. BURGOS, AND C. F. I. C. ASENJO. ERTS AND C. F. ASENJO. people in isolated areas of Barrio Masas 2, Gurabo, Bol. Rico Asoc. Med. Puerto of Nutritional Puerto Rico: Puerto status of survey Rico. 59: 503, 1967. A., J. C. BURGOS, ASENJO. Nutritional L. J. RoBstatus of N. A., J. C. BURGOS, L. J. ROBF. ASENJO. Nutritional status in Rican slum area. Am. I. Clin. Nutr. FERN#{193}NDEZ, ERTS AND C. 21: 646, 1968. N. A., J. C. BURGOS AND C. F. ASENJO. Obesity in Puerto Rican children and adults. Bol. Asoc. Med. Puerto Rico 61: 153, 10. FERN#{193}NDEZ, 11. NELSON, 1969. ed.). W. Philadelphia: E. Textbook Saunders, of Pediatrics 1959. (7th HATHAWAY, M. L., AND E. D. FOARD. Heights and Weights of Adults in the United States. U. S. Dept. Agr. Home Econ. Res. Rept. No. 10, Washington, D.C.: U.S. Govt. Printing Office, 1960. 13. KNorr, V. B. Stature, leg girth and body weight of Puerto Rican private school children. Growth 27: 157, 1963. 14. WINTROBE, M. M. Clinical Hematology. Philadelphia: Lea & Febiger, 1961. 15. Interdepartmental Committee on Nutrition for National Defense. Manual for Nutrition Surveys (2nd ed.). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Govt. Printing Office, 1963. 12. Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on October 6, 2014 Nutritional status of people in isolated areas of Puerto Rico: survey of Barrio Naranjo, Moca, Puerto Rico. A,n. J. Clin. Nutr. 19: 269, 1966. 6. FERN#{193}NDEZ, N. A., J. C. BURGOS, L. J. ROBERTS AND C. F. ASENJO. Nutritional status of people in isolated areas of Puerto Rico: survey of Barrio Duey Alto, San German, Puerto Rico. Arch. Latinoamer. Nutr. 17: 215, 1967. 7. FERN#{193}NDEZ, N. A., I. C. BURGOS, L. J. ROB- N. C. F. AND Puerto FERN#{193}NDEZ, FERN#{193}NDEZ, FERN#{193}NDEZ, people in isolated areas of Puerto Rico: survey of Barrio Montones 4, Las Piedras, Puerto Rico. I. Am. Dietet. Assoc. 53: 119, 1968. Puerto Rico, Mimeograph. Rept., March, 1963. N. A., J. C. BURGos, I. C. PLOUGH, L. J. ROBERTS AND C. F. ASENJO. Nutritional status of people in isolated areas of Puerto Rico: survey of Barrio Mavilla, Vega Alta, Puerto Rico. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 17: 305, 1965. 965 RICANS ERTS the Sta- PUERTO
© Copyright 2024