REPORT Council Date: October 15, 2014 To: Warden Thompson and County Council Prepared By: Adam McCue, Manager of Planning & Technical Support Reviewed By: Mobushar Pannu, Director of Transportation & Waste Management Approved By: Elizabeth Savill, Chief Administrative Officer Subject: Seymour Transfer Station – Change to Days of Operation 2011-14 Strategic Plan: Sustainable Infrastructure and Services Council Recommendation: WHEREAS staff has undertaken a review of the usage of the Seymour Transfer Station, following its transition from a landfill to a transfer station in April of 2013; WHEREAS the findings of this review suggest that the Seymour Transfer can be operated four (4) days per week during the months of April to November, and three (3) days per week during the months of December to March, while still maintaining daily usage rates that are equal to or lower than those encountered at the Bewdley Transfer Station and Brighton Landfill; and WHEREAS the busiest days of operation for the Seymour Transfer Station are Saturdays, Mondays and Fridays, respectively. NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT County Council approves changing the days of operation for the Seymour Transfer Station to the following: Mondays, Wednesdays, Fridays and Saturdays during the months of April through to, and including November; and Mondays, Fridays and Saturdays during the months of December through to, and including March. Purpose Receive Council approval to change the days of operation for the Seymour Transfer Station. Background As part of the 2014 budget process, staff prepared an issue paper on operational changes at the Brighton Landfill, Bewdley and Seymour Transfer Stations and Roll-off Truck operations. Within the Issue Paper, which was supported by Council, it was noted that usage of the Seymour Transfer Station had reduced since it had become a Transfer Station in April of 2013, and that even prior to its transition from a Landfill to a Transfer Station, the Seymour site had the lowest usage, in comparison to the Brighton Landfill and the Bewdley Transfer Station. Because of its historically lower usage and its recent decrease in usage resulting from the change in operations, staff recommended that in January of 2015, the Seymour Transfer Station go from operating six (6) days per week (Monday to Saturday), to operating no more than 4 days per week, with one of those operational days being Saturday. The hours of operation were recommended to remain unchanged at 8:30 a.m. until 5:00 p.m. As part of the Issue Paper, staff suggested that a detailed review of the site’s usage be undertaken in 2014, with a follow-up report to Council in late summer of 2014, containing recommendations on precisely what days the Seymour Transfer Station should be operated on, on a weekly basis. Options/Consultations As committed to in the 2014 Issue Paper, staff undertook a review of the usage of the Seymour Transfer Station and compared its usage to that of the Brighton Landfill and Bewdley Transfer Station. The review covered the period of August 1, 2013 to July 31, 2014. Below is a summary table showing the average number of patrons to visit each of the three sites, on a day by day basis, during winter, summer, and combined time periods. Usage (Patron Visits per Day) Days of the Week WINTER (Dec 1 to Mar 31) Mon. Avg. Tue. Avg. Wed. Avg. Thur. Avg. Fri. Avg. Sat. Avg. TOTAL Loads Operating Days Avg. # of Loads/Day SUMMER (Apr 1 to Nov 30) Mon. Avg. Tue. Avg. Wed. Avg. Thur. Avg. Fri. Avg. Sat. Avg. TOTAL Loads Operating Days Avg. # of Loads/Day WINTER & SUMMER Mon. Avg. Tue. Avg. Wed. Avg. Thur. Avg. Fri. Avg. Sat. Avg. TOTAL Loads Operating Days Avg. # of Loads/Day 75 75 75 Seymour Theoretical Bewdley TS Brighton LF Seymour TS n/a 84 51 57 73 155 6,814 82 83 69 54 46 48 54 77 5,678 99 57 43 31 28 32 40 63 3,856 99 39 3,856 54 71 163 153 144 137 164 302 35,549 202 176 115 107 101 99 106 153 23,122 204 113 80 65 64 64 74 128 16,109 204 79 16,109 136 118 163 131 114 113 132 254 42,363 284 149 98 90 83 83 89 128 28,800 303 95 66 55 52 54 62 107 19,965 303 66 19,965 190 105 - Highest Usage Day - Second Highest Usage Day - Third Highest Usage Day From the above table it can be seen that: between late fall and early spring (December 1 to March 31) the Seymour Transfer Station gets, on average 39 patrons per day, compared to 57 at the Brighton Landfill and 83 at the Bewdley Transfer Station; between early spring and late fall (April to November 30) the Seymour Transfer Station gets, on average 79 patrons per day, compared to 113 at the Brighton Landfill and 176 at the Bewdley Transfer Station; the busiest days at the Seymour Transfer Station are Saturdays, Mondays and Fridays, respectively; theoretically, if the Seymour Transfer Station were operated three (3) days per week (Mondays, Fridays and Saturdays) between late fall and early spring, it would receive, on average, 71 patrons per day; and theoretically, if the Seymour Transfer Station were operated four (4) days per week (Mondays, Wednesdays, Fridays, and Saturdays) between late spring and early fall, it would receive, on average, 118 patrons per day. From a review of the usage of the Seymour Transfer Station in winter and summer months, in comparison to usage at the Bewdley Transfer Station and Brighton Landfill for the same time periods, it seems logical to suggest that the Seymour Transfer Station can be operated three (3) days per week (Mondays, Fridays and Saturdays) during the months of December to March, and four (4) days per week during the months of April to November, and still provide an adequate level of service to the local community. Risk/Safety Considerations N/A. Legal/legislative Requirements N/A Financial Impact It is anticipated that reducing the days of operation at the Seymour Transfer Station, as described above, would result in operational savings of approximately $80,000 annually. Staff Recommendation Staff is recommending that County Council approve changing the days of operation for the Seymour Transfer Station to the following: Mondays, Wednesdays, Fridays and Saturdays during the months of April through to, and including November; and Mondays, Fridays and Saturdays during the months of December through to, and including March.
© Copyright 2024