Transforming lives through learning

Transforming lives through learning
Curriculum for Excellence
Primary School Leadership Conference
Keynote presentation
Graeme Logan
September / October 2014
Transforming lives through learning
evidence of impact of Curriculum for Excellence
Between September 2013 and June 2014, in almost all schools
inspected (91%), one or more aspect of children’s/young
people’s positive attributes (e.g. confidence, ambition,
motivation) and/or learning experiences are reported as a key
strength.
Transforming lives through learning
primary school inspection findings 2013-14
key strengths
 126 schools: positive attributes of children
 81 schools: the impact of the leadership of the headteacher
 60 schools: teamwork and commitment of staff to ensure
positive experiences/improvements for children
 44 schools: aspects of support and care
 42 schools: impact of partnerships with parents
 41 schools: impact of partnerships with the community,
including local businesses
 27 schools: children’s learning experiences
 18 schools: children’s attainment in literacy and English
 15 schools: outdoor learning
Transforming lives through learning
primary school inspection findings 2013-14
areas for improvement
 93 schools: continue to develop the curriculum
 65 schools: need more effective systems for improvement
through self-evaluation
 51 schools: improve approaches to meeting the learning needs
of all children
 49 schools: improve approaches to tracking and monitoring
children’s progress to ensure they attain as highly as possible
 38 schools: improve children’s learning experiences, including
opportunities for responsibility and leadership
 31 schools: raise attainment
(numeracy/mathematics with the most specific mentions)
 8 schools: improve partnerships with parents
Transforming lives through learning
primary school inspection findings
Sept 2013-June 2014
unsatis.
weak
satis.
good
vg
exc.
1.1
1
12
27
54
38
1
2.1
0
4
21
55
49
4
5.3
1
17
18
61
31
5
5.1
3
18
30
57
24
1
5.9
1
25
31
49
22
5
133 inspections carried out
Transforming lives through learning
Inspection Advice Note 2014-15





year of ‘consolidation’ in terms of expectations
reducing bureaucracy
clear strategy for assessment
planning progression
skills for learning, life and work
Transforming lives through learning
Transforming lives through learning
continuing to implement Curriculum for Excellence





pathways not tramlines
informed personalisation and choice
a broad general education for all
reduction in assessment
building on the success of this year’s national
qualification results
Transforming lives through learning
Transforming lives through learning
In Curriculum for Excellence, learners make progress by:
 continually building on their prior learning;
 accessing enriching, stimulating, relevant and appropriately
challenging learning experiences and;
 having opportunities for applying, consolidating and reinforcing
learning.
Learning is usually not linear and learners may progress along
different routes and pathways through the Experiences and
Outcomes.
Expectations and milestones are important.
Transforming lives through learning
‘Mountains of bumph are no
substitute for clarity.’
Transforming lives through learning
tracking and monitoring
Your analysis and intervention to
help every child make the best
possible progress, based on
a range of assessment evidence.
Transforming lives through learning
your school assessment strategy







purpose and principles of assessment
links between learning, teaching and assessment
place of formative assessment
range of assessment methods
place of summative or standardised methods
arrangements for moderation
arrangements for tracking and improving children’s
progress
 reporting, recognising achievement, profiling
Transforming lives through learning
The leader of the
school is also the
narrator of the
school.
Transforming lives through learning
‘Many organisations are
over-communicating and
under-conversing.’
Richard Reeve
Transforming lives through learning
professional dialogue





criticality
challenging, questioning, debating
identify, conceptualise and define
best practice or best problems?
apply your skills in enquiry to professional
dialogue in your school and cluster
Transforming lives through learning
classroom interventions which seem to have most impact…
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
accessing prior knowledge and utilising prediction
authentic engagement
reinforcing and modelling high expectations
differentiated challenge
enquiry and high quality questioning
finding excellent solutions or products
metacognition
land-marking progress against agreed outcomes
purposeful assessment and feedback
rehearsal, consolidation and transfer
Alistair Smith 2014
Transforming lives through learning
dependent












follows instructions
must get it right
wants the answer
follows the teacher’s logic and tries to
get it right
follows teacher’s pace
answers teacher’s questions
grouped by the teacher
rewarded upon completion
is given a mark, level or grade
assessed by the teacher
focus is on becoming a better
performer
concerned with status and pecking
order
Transforming lives through learning
independent




makes decisions
must have a go
wants the method
learns incrementally and by trial and error







controls own pace
answers own questions
elects who to learn with
rewarded by effort
interprets own mark, level or grade
assessed by teacher/self/peers
focus is on becoming a better learner
 concerned with progress and capacity to
improve
Local Shop Learning
‘If you were running a supermarket instead of a school and
saw that 30 out of 100 customers each day left your shop
without buying anything, you would think about changing
your inventory. But that does not happen easily in schools
because of deeply rooted, even if scientifically unsupported,
beliefs that learning can only occur in a particular way.’
Lord Knight of Weymouth, quoted
Education Britain: The Journey to Education Reform,
Education Foundation 2011
Transforming lives through learning
strong self-evaluation is often…




precise and focused
forensic in the analysis of children’s progress
practice-based rather than just paper-based
able to generate specific strengths and areas for
improvement, for example in relation to active learning
Prioritises time and energy on learners’ experiences
and outcomes.
Ensures low internal variability in core areas.
Transforming lives through learning
Additional in-service day (primary)
 Film clips of headteachers describing their journeys in developing the curriculum relative
to their own context available on the Education Scotland website.
 The assessing progress and achievement professional learning resource assessment,
including tracking and monitoring.
 Evaluating and Improving the Primary Curriculum toolkit.
 Resources to support the implementation of 1+2 languages model: resources for P1-P7
 SSLN Professional Learning Resource on numeracy published recently and the national
numeracy framework will to be published in the autumn.
 Annotated exemplars of assessing progress through the various levels for each
curriculum area have now been published on Glow.
Transforming lives through learning
http://www.educationscotland.gov.uk/resources/e/evaluatingandimprovingourcurriculumprimary/introduc
tion.asp?strReferringChannel=educationscotland&strReferringPageID=tcm:4-713590-64
Transforming lives through learning
http://www.educationscotland.gov.uk/learningteachingandassessment/assessment/progressandac
hievement/professionallearningresource/curriculum/languages/literacyandenglish/progress.asp
Transforming lives through learning
http://www.educationscotland.gov.uk/video/r/reducingteachersplanning.asp?strReferringChannel
=educationscotland&strReferringPageID=tcm:4-615801-64
Transforming lives through learning
http://www.educationscotland.gov.uk/keycfesupport/index.asp
Transforming lives through learning
http://www.educationscotland.gov.uk/resources/p/polaar/introduction.asp?strReferringC
hannel=educationscotland&strReferringPageID=tcm:4-615801-64
Transforming lives through learning
major deliverables 14/15





HGIOS 4
Opening Up Great Learning series
refresh of Glow
more examples of planning progression
new range of e-bulletins, including monthly
digest for headteachers
Transforming lives through learning
your primary curriculum
 rationale: clear, compelling story of how you have
designed the curriculum; vision; purpose
 programmes and courses: best possible progression
for all children across all curriculum areas
 transitions: designed to ensure continuity in learning
 four contexts for learning/totality of the curriculum
helps all children to achieve as well as they can
Transforming lives through learning
The vision
Learners in Scotland will progress in
one of the most effective education
systems in the world, renowned for
the ability of national and local
partners to work flexibly together to
achieve high quality and equitable
outcomes for all
Transforming lives through learning
Transforming lives through learning
Keep the focus on outcomes for learners!
 educational outcomes
for all learners are
improving
 inequity in educational
outcomes is eradicated
 public confidence in
education is high
Transforming lives through learning
Never forget the important of what you say and do
as headteacher!
Control (is s/he in charge?)
Clarity (is s/he sure of her ground?)
Coherence (can I align my aspirations with his/hers?)
Concern (does s/he understand the challenges I face?)
Consistency (will s/he adopt the behaviours she espouses?)
Transforming lives through learning