uwn zay e"dl 1116 mi kx a n Third decade Second thousand d"ryz'd `xa ziy`xa elqk g"k Dec 19-20 '14 OU Israel Center • 22 Keren HaYesod • POB 37015 • Jerusalem • (02) 560-9100 Thursday, 2nd day of Chanuka, December 18th, 8:00am Festive Shacharit including Hallel by Rabbi Neil Winkler, refreshments on the occasion of the yahrzeit of Phil's father, l"f ikcxn x"a wgvi dyn 'x Friday, Erev Shabbat Chanuka, December 19th, 12:05pm MINCHA GEDOLA, to facilitate davening Mincha before candle lighting see box on page 12 JERUSALEM in/out times for Mikeitz - Shabbat Chanuka Candles 4:04PM • Havdala 5:19PM • Rabbeinu Tam 5:51PM Pi x ParshaP Explanations further Capacity 25 cars Shabbat Chanuka, we bench Rosh Chodesh Tevet, which is two days this year - MON & TUE, the 6th and 7th day of Chanuka - December 22 & 23. :daFh ¨ l§ l`¥ x¨U§ i¦ lM¨ l©re§ Epi«l¥ r¨ `¨Ad© iWi ¦ l¦ W§ mFiaE § i¦pW¥ mFiA§ d¤id§ i¦ z¥ah¥ ycŸ¤ g W`Ÿx The molad is Sunday (Dec 21) 22h 31m 0p ( 10:10pm Israel time) .xU¤ ¤ r ix£ ¥g`© zFwc© zg© `© e§ miWŸl ¦ W§ ,(Sun nite) i¦pW¥ li¥l d¤id¦ § i c©lFOd© In Rambam notation: gpwz:c 'a Actual (astronomical) molad: Monday, 12:37am Candles Parshat Mikeitz - Shabbat Chanuka Havdala Vayigash Ranges are 11 days, Wed-Shabbat 4:04 Yerushalayim / Maale Adumim 5:19 4:07 5:23 25 Kislev - 5 Tevet • Dec 17-27 4:21 5:22 4:25 5:26 The Aza area (Netivot, etc.) Earliest Talit & T'filin 5:38-5:43am 4:18 5:20 4:22 5:23 Gush Etzion Sunrise 6:33-6:37½am 4:18 Raanana / Tel Mond / Herzliya 5:20 4:22 5:24 Sof Z'man K' Sh'ma 9:03-9:08am 4:19 5:20 4:23 5:24 (Magen Avraham: 8:25-8:30am) Beit Shemesh / RBS 4:18 5:19 4:22 5:23 Sof Z'man T'fila Netanya 9:54-9:59am 4:18 5:19 4:22 5:23 (Magen Avraham: 9:22-9:27am) Modi'in / Chashmona'im 4:19 5:20 4:23 5:24 Chatzot Rehovot 11:35-11:40am (halachic noon) 4:23 5:26 4:19 5:22 Be'er Sheva / Otniel 12:06-12:11pm 4:04 5:20 4:07 5:24 Mincha Gedola Petach Tikva (earliest Mincha) 4:17 5:19 4:21 5:23 Ginot Shomron Plag Mincha 3:34½-3:39½pm 4:17 5:18 4:21 5:22 Gush Shiloh Sunset 4:43-4:48pm 4:07 5:18 4:10 5:22 (based on sea level: Haifa / Zichron 4:37-4:42½pm 4:19 5:20 4:23 5:24 Chevron / Kiryat Arba OU Israel and Torah Tidbits do not endorse the 4:18 5:19 4:22 5:23 political or halachic positions of its editor, columnists, Giv'at Ze'ev advertisers, nor guarantee the quality of advertised 4:21 5:22 4:25 5:26 orservices Ashkelon or products. Nor do we endorse the kashrut 4:04 5:16 4:08 5:19 of hotels, restaurants, caterers or food products that Tzfat are advertised in TT (except, of course, those under 4:19 5:21 4:23 5:24 OU-Israel hashgacha). Any "promises" made in ads are Yad Binyamin the sole responsibility of the advertisers and not that R' Tam (Jerusalem) - 5:51pm • next week: 5:55pm of OU Israel, the Israel Center or Torah Tidbits We must learn to distinguish between calm and becalmed. We must some- times "blink" our minds to clear them, just as we do our eyes. Not many are able to prosper in silence. There are too many things that we must do just to prove to ourselves that we are not missing anything by not doing them. from "A Candle by Day" by Rabbi Shraga Silverstein z"l by Benjy Caplan = xiW ¦ n§ gª Now Joseph did well, it would seem And knew how to size up a dream Since Egypt was 'bout To suffer a drought They followed his 7-year scheme. FRONT PAGE NOTES For Jerusalem only, some suggest lighting Shabbat candles 20 min. after the official posted time and Chanuka candles right before the Shabbat candles. See Pull-Out from TT 1115. Chanuka stamps - left to right: This year's Israeli stamp in honor of Chanuka. The Chanuka stamp from a few years ago. A joint issue of a Chanuka stamp in Israel and the US (1996). Over 100,000,000 were issued in the US. What do Yechizkiyahu and Amatziya have in common? They dreamed of them; she gleaned them Cucumber, tangerine, radish Tigers, giraffes, hippos, and pandas - oh my! Perspective on Victory and Oil Miracles Picture a parent, grandparent, or uncle or aunt walking in the street hand-in-hand with a 5 year old child - their son, grandson, or nephew. All of a sudden, the kid pulls his hand out of that of the adult and runs into the street. Right into the path a a car. The adult reacts quickly, lunges for the child, grabs him roughly by the arm and pulls him out of harm's way... just barely. Immediately thereafter, the father or mother or grandfather or grandmother or aunt or uncle takes the child into a fierce hug and whispers in his ear, I love you. Which of the two actions - the rough grab and pull or the hug and whisper is the more important one for the survival of the child? The rough pull - agreed? Which of the two actions is both unnecessary for the child's survival and, at the same time the more special and remembered action? The hug and whisper - we assume that you would agree here also. MASHAL L'MAH HADAVAR DOMEH? (as is said when giving a MASHAL, a parable, an analogy) To what can this be compared? The Chanuka story involves two different events. The first was the NEIS HANITZACHON, the Miracle of the Victory. The victory of the few over the many, the weak over the strong... and other phrases which we recognize from AL HANISIM. OU Israel Center TT 1116 The second event is the Miracle of the Oil - A one-day supply lasting for eight days. Which event was necessary for the survival of the Jewish People? No doubt it was the military victories of the Chashmona'im over the Yevanim. We would have been gone via death and or assimilation. And which event was technically unnecessary? As the story goes, the Chashmona'im entered to defiled Mikdash and had a lot of work ahead of them in order to get the Beit HaMikdash up and running. One of many of the functions of the Mikdash was the lighting of the Menorah. Can't find any usable oil? No problem. It takes eight days to get new usable oil, so we'll have to wait. Can't light the Menorah if we have no oil. No big deal, really. Wait, there is defiled oil, but in a situation of widespread state of ritual impurity, Tamei oil is usable. Don't want to use it? Keep looking. Wait, here is a flask of untainted oil. Great joy! Only a one day supply, so let's do the best we can and we'll have to wait for the new supply. Miracle! The one day supply lasts for 8 days! A miracle that saved the people from annihilation? No, but maybe that's why it is extra special. That miracle was G-d's hug of the people. It was his whisper that He loves us and approves of our actions. We will always be thankful to G-d for helping us in battle. But His smile and nod of approval is what gives us the greatest joy. page 4 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 Mikeitz 10th of 54 sedras; 10th of 12 in B'reishit Written on 254.6 lines in a Torah, rank 6 Mikeitz is a one Parsha P'tucha (open) (the longest parsha in the whole Torah) 146 p'sukim - ranks 8th (5th in B'reishit) tied with B'reishit (the sedra) 2022 words - ranks 3rd (2nd) 7914 letters - ranks 2nd (first) Mikeitz's p'sukim are unusually long for a big sedra. That's why it is so high in the rankings for words and letters. On the other hand, with no parsha breaks, the "number of lines" drops a bit. None of the 613 mitzvot in Mikeitz - one of 17 sedras without mitzvot [P> X:Y (Z)] and [S> X:Y (Z)] indicate start of a parsha p'tucha or s'tuma. X:Y is Perek:Pasuk of the beginning of the parsha; (Z) is the number of p'sukim in the parsha. Kohen - First Aliya 14 p'sukim - 41:1-14 [P> 41:1 (146)] Two years have passed since Yosef had asked the wine steward to put in the good word for him to Par'o. Extra years of languishing in prison, for OU Israel Center TT 1116 putting too much faith in a human at the expense of complete faith in G-d (and possibly creating a Chilul HaShem in Yosef's case, because of who he was and the specific circumstances being what they were). Let's clarify... In "normal" circumstances, a person in Yosef's situation should take steps to get himself out of prison by asking the wine steward (or whomever) to help. But in this case, we can see that the Sar HaMashkim spoke condescendingly about Yosef, calling him a NAAR IVRI. This probably means that he relished the idea that the "Jew boy" relied on him to get out of jail. This, after Yosef's giving G-d credit for the dream interpretation. We can imagine that in Yosef's particular situation, his asking the Sar HaMashkim for help would not be the right way to go. Par'o has two dreams - 7 emaciated cows consuming 7 fat cows without showing the effect of their "meals", and 7 scorched ears of grain consuming 7 fat, good ears. These dreams upset him very much. He summons his counselors who fail to ease his mood with their unsatisfactory interpretations. The wine steward finally remembers Yosef and approaches Par'o with his story. "With us there was this Jewish kid..." Par'o orders Yosef's removal from prison and Yosef is prepared to meet Par'o. page 5 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 Rashi points out (actually, he curses) that wicked people, even when they are acknowledging good that was done for them, will belittle those to whom they owe a debt of gratitude. The Wine Steward refers to Yosef as a NA'AR (connotation of a fool), IVRI (a foreigner who doesn't belong amongst us), EVED (a slave unworthy of leadership). There is a Tradition that Yosef was "remembered" on Rosh HaShana and removed from prison to the palace of the king. What happened to Yosef was part of the Divine Plan for enslavement and subsequent redemption of Bnei Yisrael. Perhaps, this gives Rosh HaShana one of its claims to be called ZEICHER LITZI'AT MITZRAYIM, commemorative of the Exodus, as we say in Kiddush. (Also, the Plagues began on Rosh HaShana, and actual slavery ended then). When Yosef was brought before Par'o, the Torah tells us that he shaved. Rashi says that it was a sign of respect to royalty. Some say that Yosef was a NAZIR, and he did not drink wine or cut his hair. Nonetheless, he shaved for Par'o. Levi - Second Aliya 24 p'sukim - 41:15-38 Par'o tells Yosef about his dreams (making some significant changes which Yosef corrects, thus signaling to Par'o the Divine origin of Yosef's dream interpretations). OU Israel Center TT 1116 Yosef tells Par'o that his two dreams are in fact a single message from G-d of His intention to bring seven years of plenty which will be followed by seven years of devastating famine. The years of plenty will not even be remembered (unless measures are taken to properly prepare for the famine). The doubling of the dream indicates that the events are soon to occur. Yosef suggests what to do during the years of plenty to prepare for the famine. Par'o is highly impressed by the godly person, Yosef. There is an impressive list of parallels between the story in this sedra and Megilat Esther. Specifically, in Par'o's treatment of Yosef and Achashveirosh's instructions to Haman about how to parade Mordechai through the street. E.g. the king gives a special ring to Yosef/Mordechai. Special gaments for the parade. Proclaiming before him... The textual similarities are extensive and startling. Shlishi - Third Aliya 14 p'sukim - 41:39-52 Par'o, convinced that Yosef is the wisest person around, appoints him as viceroy over all of Egypt. Par'o gives Yosef his royal ring and special garments (again garments!) and parades Yosef through the streets so that the Egyptians will know of the authority that the king page 6 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 has given to Yosef. Yosef is given A-s’nat as a wife. (Some say that she was Deena's daughter - raised in the house of Potifar.) At age 30, Yosef is master over Egypt. A-s’nat bears Yosef two sons, before the years of the famine - Menashe and Efrayim. A note on the pronunciation of the name of Yosef's wife. Many people mistakingly break the name into syllables of ALEF-SAMACH and NUN-TAV. That would be the case if the SH'VA under the SAMACH were NACH (which it isn't). And that would mean that the KAMATZ under the ALEF is KATAN (which it isn't). And that would make the first syllable sound like the first syllable of the words Austin or austerity (which it doesn't). The SH'VA is NA. This means that the ALEF-KAMATZ is the first syllable and that the KAMATZ is GADOL and in Israeli pronunciation of Hebrew is sounded like a PATACH, making the first syllable of her name like the first syllable of A-VO-CA-DO. And in Ashkenazic pronunciation, the first syllable is sounded like the English word 'awe'. The second syllable is S'NAT, with the SAMACH sound separated from the NUN sound. S - NAT, and not like a consonant blend of English which would render the second syllable like... okay, we won't mention the slang term for nasal discharge, but it might explain why Americans and other Anglos do not choose the name of this exemplary woman for their own daughters. OU Israel Center TT 1116 Note that Par'o acknowledges that G-d is the source of Yosef's wisdom. Apparently, not all Egyptian rulers had the disdain for the G-d of Israel that a successor of this Par'o had years later. We can say that the 'new king arose who did not know Yosef', chose not to know G-d either. This phenomenon seems to be repeated in Jewish History. Of relevance to the Chanuka story is the attitude towards G-d and the People of Israel of Alexander the Great compared with some of his successors. R'vi'i - Fourth Aliya 23 p'sukim - 41:53-42:18 The seven years of plenty end and the famine begins. All neighboring countries are devastated by the famine, but Egypt has prepared well. Yosef manages the distribution (and sale) of food supplies and amasses great wealth for Par'o. Meanwhile, Yaakov, aware that there is food in Egypt, sends "the brothers" (but not Binyamin) to buy provisions. The Torah says that Yaakov SAW that there was plenty... Rashi asks: What is the meaning of SAW; would not HEARD be more accurate? (before CNN and FOX) Rashi answers that Yaakov SAW in a prophetic-like vision that there was plenty in Egypt. Rashi adds that this was not full, clear prophecy, as Yaakov still did not SEE that Yosef was on the scene. A prophet sees page 7 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 only what G-d wants him to see, and understands only that part of a vision that he does see. The Gemara in Taanit says that Yaakov was still well-supplied with food at this stage in the famine. Yet he sent them to Egypt, rather than inflame the jealousy of others. When others have not, don't flaunt what you have. Yosef sees his brothers, recognizes them, (they do not recognize him,) and remembers his dreams. He treats them harshly and accuses them of being spies. They deny the charges and tell Yosef of their family history and honorable intentions. Rashi says that the brothers (unknowingly) uttered a prophetic statement saying "WE are all the sons of one man". Consciously, they were talking about themselves. But the statement is very true when Yosef is included - We are ALL... Yosef proposes a test of their sincerity - they must bring their younger brother down to him. He locks them up for three days to "think things over". The Baal HaTurim points out that the phrase VAYISHTACHAVU LO, and they (the brothers) bowed to him (Yosef) has the same numeric value (772) as B'CHAN NIT-KAYEIM HACHALOM, with this, the dream (Yosef's) was actualized. TT adds that VAYIT-NAKEIR ALEIHEM, And he (Yosef) acted like a stranger to OU Israel Center TT 1116 them (the brothers), is also 772. Part of what Yosef did to complete the Divine plan expressed by his dreams, was to hold back in revealing himself for a while. SHEVA SHANIM, seven years, a significant feature of this episode, is also 772. B'ZOT, with this you shall be tested. Yosef said that the children of Israel will be tested B'ZOT. With ZOT. ZOT = 7 + 1 + 400 = 408. The three major "tools" to achieve forgiveness from G-d are T'FILA, T'SHUVA, TZEDAKA. This is what we say in Musaf of Rosh HaShana and Yom Kippur. Some machzorim have another set of words printed above these three. They are not said, but they are there. Prayer = KOL (voice). Repentance is aided by TZOM (fasting). And TZEDAKA is performed with MAMON (money). Each of these three words is numerically equal to 136. 100+6+30 = 90+6+40 = 40+40+6+50. The G'matriyas of these synonyms being equal speaks of an equality of significance in the quest for Divine forgiveness. Add them up and you find 136+136+136 = 408. B'ZOT TIBA-CHEINU - This is how we are tested - with Prayer, Repentance, and Acts of Kindness are the Children of Israel tested. Chamishi 5th Aliya 35 p'sukim - 42:19-43:15 Yosef tells them that one of them shall remain as a hostage (Yosef selects Shimon, so as to split the dangerous team of Shimon and Levi) and the others are to return page 8 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 to Canaan to bring "the little one" down to Egypt. The brothers express sincere remorse for what they had done to Yosef (considering their present predicament as a punishment for that). Reuven says the equivalent of "I told you so". All are unaware that Yosef is listening and understanding their conversation. Yosef goes off on his own and weeps (for what he is putting his brothers through). Yosef commands that their bags be filled with food and that their money be returned to them too. When each brother opens his sack, he is frightened to find his money there. They return to Yaakov and report to him what has happened. Yaakov laments the loss of Yosef and now Shimon and announces that he will not risk losing Binyamin as well. He refuses to permit his sons to return to Egypt, in spite of (or because of) Reuven's ridiculous suggestion that his own sons be put to death if anything happens to Binyamin. The Gemara says that the curse of a wise (righteous?) person, even when made conditional, comes true (in some way or other). Reuven offered that his sons should die if Binyamin is not returned. The offer was refused. And Binyamin did return to his father. Nonetheless, Reuven said what he said. His "two sons" can refer to two infamous descendants of his who DID die OU Israel Center TT 1116 Datan and Aviram. One has to be exceedingly careful of what one says! (Not only did they die in the wake of Korach's rebellion, but even earlier, they are referred to as dead. G-d tells Moshe to return to Egypt because those who were after him had died. Rashi says this means Datan and Aviram, who became poor and were considered as dead they died twice!) The famine in Canaan intensifies and Yaakov finally agrees to entrust Binyamin into the hands of Yehuda for the return trip to Egypt. Yaakov gives them twice as much money as they will need and sends gifts of the finest spices to the "Egyptian leader". Yaakov blesses his sons; they return to Egypt and present themselves to Yosef. Shishi - Sixth Aliya 14 p'sukim - 43:16-29 Yosef sees Binyamin and tells his attendant (probably Menashe) to prepare dinner for them all. The brothers fear the summon to Yosef, convinced that it has to do with the returned money from the previous trip. They tell Yosef what had happened in order to forestall his anger. Yosef asks them about their aged father. The brothers bow to Yosef, thus again fulfilling the essence of his dreams (and this time it includes Binyamin). Yosef sees Binyamin, asks about him and blesses him. page 9 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 Sh'VII Seventh Aliya 22 p'sukim - 43:30-44:17 Yosef is having a hard time controlling his emotions. He cries in private again, washes his face and returns to the brothers. At the dinner, he seats his brothers in age order (which alarms them - "How could he know?"). He gives them gifts, more to Binyamin. Yosef was creating the potential for jealousy so that the brothers would be put into a similar situation as previously. This sets the stage for "complete" repentance. Was he acting consciously, subconsciously, divinely guided...? He next orders that food and their money be put into their respective sacks and that his (Yosef's) special cup be placed among Binyamin's baggage. He sends the brothers on their way to Canaan, and then sends his "man" after them to accuse them of stealing the cup. The brothers are appalled by the accusation and pledge that if the cup is found with them, the "guilty" party shall be put to death and the others would become slaves to Yosef. Yosef offers to enslave only the guilty one; the others would be free to go. The search reveals that Binyamin has the cup. Yehuda, as spokesman, offers that all should become slaves. Yosef insists that only OU Israel Center TT 1116 Binyamin should be; the others should ret urn to their father. Deja vu all over again! Once again, the brothers can go to Yaakov without one of Rachel's sons and claim extenuating circumstances. And this time, it would be true! Not contrived, as it was with Yosef. This sets the stage for the possibility of real T'shuva. [Rambam, in his Hilchot T'shuva, presents various components of T'shuva. He then introduces the concept of T'shuva G'mura - complete T'shuva, which he says can only be achieved (or at least, recognized) if the same (or very similar) conditions exist as when the original sins were committed.] Will the brothers see this as an opportunity to save themselves and claim that they were powerless to do anything, or will they stand up to this enigmatic ruler of Egypt and be prepared to fight for Binyamin? And this time, it would be easier to just leave, because they did nothing wrong. In "cliffhanger" style, the parsha ends with this question. Stay tuned to the same station, same time next week, for the answer. Maftir 2nd Torah 6 p'sukim Bamidbar 7:24-29 When Shabbat Chanuka is not the first and last day of Chanuka - in other words, when there is only one Shabbat Chanuka, then Maftir is the 6-pasuk portion of the gifts of the tribal leader of the day to the page 10 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 Dedication of the Mishkan. (The readings for the first and last day include more. When Shabbat is also Rosh Chodesh, the maftir is in the third Torah, but still a 6-pasuk piece. For day 4 of Chanuka (ours and Chanukat HaMizbei'ach the first time around), the leader of the tribe of R'uven offered his gifts. Elitzur b. Sh'dei'ur brought exactly what each of the other Nesi'im brought, but the Torah repeats the details, so that each tribe "has its day", so to speak. Some commentaries describe different significances to the same items, for each tribe, further highlighting the individual natures of the tribes. Haftara 21 p'sukim Zacharia 2:14-4:7 The special Haftara for Shabbat Chanuka is "borrowed" from B'ha'alot'cha, the Menora being the obvious connection. Chanuka has parallels throughout history. The opening words of the Haftara are G-d's promise to dwell among us. This is the purpose of having built the Mishkan and the Beit HaMikdash in the first place, and this is the purpose of rededicating it, as we did on Chanuka. The Haftara contains the vision of olive oil miraculously flowing into the gold menora flanked by olive trees. This vision matches so much of the Chanuka story. OU Israel Center TT 1116 It is also the basis of the emblem of the State of Israel. This is particularly significant in light of the meaning of the vision. The message to the king, to Jewish leaders in general, is that our success is not measured by might and power, but rather by the spirit of G-d. This was an important message for the Chashmona'im and it remains a vital message for the leaders of today's Israel. Aside from the obvious connection between Chanuka and the original Chanukat HaMizbei'ach of the Mishkan - as in Dedication and Rededication of the Mikdash, there is another, more specific connection, which tightens things up neatly. It is said that... The original Mishkan was completed and "ready to roll" on the 25th of Kislev, more than 8 months out of Egypt. The dedication was post- poned until the first of Nisan, in honor of Yitzchak Avinu, who was born during Nissan. To inaugurate the Mishkan in honor of Yitzchak, is a good choice, because he was actually placed on a Mizbei'ach and was to be offered as an Olah. Yitzchak is like the parton of the Mikdash. Over 1100 years later, Kislev 25 finally got its Chanuka. So the Torah reading of Chanuka is particularly appropriate. And there is also a connection to 25 Kislev from the original building of the second Beit HaMikdash. Chanuka is a perfect fit, just where it is in the calendar. page 11 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 mgpn ixac Divrei Menachem [email protected] Often we are challenged to distinguish between two pivotal concepts contemporaneous in our in Jewish way of life, namely, Emunah and Bitachon - Faith in G-d's existence and Trust in G-d. It seems that it is one thing to know Hashem, but it is an entirely different matter as to how and when we put our trust in Him. Our parsha opens with the very precise statement that two years to the day that Pharaoh's chamberlain was released from prison the Egyptian king had a dream (which led to Yosef's release from jail). Rashi, citing the Midrash, already noted that the incarcerated Yosef was forgotten by the king's cupbearer for this precise length of time because he put his trust in the chamberlain, rather than in G-d, to secure his freedom. Now, on the one hand, the Psalmist tells us that one who puts his trust in G-d is praiseworthy (Tehillim 40:5) but, on the other hand, our rabbis teach us not to depend on miracles (Yerushalmi; Ramban). After all, even our Yaakov Avinu made provision for his family and appeased Eisav before his reunion with his wicked brother. Notes the Netziv of Volozhin: There is no contradiction. A Jew should do whatever's necessary to achieve his goals - but he should also pray to Hashem for help and success. Yosef was different, however: He is known as "Yosef HaTzadik" for his extraordinary Bitachon and ability to overcome every obstacle and temptation. And, according to the Talmud, a Tzadik who is extremely scrupulous in a certain behavior trait is meticulously judged on that account (Sanhedrin 24a). Surely a sobering message for those striving, hopefully, to adhere to the highest standards. gny dkepge mely zay OU Israel Center TT 1116 Vebbe Rebbe Chanuka Candles / Havdala Question: I never got a clear answer as to whether, on Motzaei Shabbat, we light Chanuka candles before or after Havdala. Can you clarify the matter? Answer: In terms of practice, we can clarify only a few things. The minhag in shuls is to light Chanuka candles first (based on T'rumat HaDeshen 60, Shulchan Aruch and Rama, Orach Chayim 681:2). Regarding the home, S'fardim do Havdala before Chanuka candles (Kaf HaChayim, OC 681:4; Yalkut Yosef; Mikraei Kodesh (Harari), Chanuka 11:10). Among Ashkenazim, some schools of thought have clear rulings (which vary one from another); we will not provide lists of the opinions. However, the standard approach, to which we subscribe is that this is a case where one may follow the approach he wants (see Mishna Berura 681:3). We note that not only are both approaches well grounded, but also the question is only of preference; following the "incorrect" approach is not a "violation". We will survey some of the indications presented by prominent protagonists. The T'rumat HaDeshen's reason for lighting Chanuka candles first is the gemara's (Pesachim 105b) concept that we delay Havdala (i.e., put it at the end of the series of b'rachot) and, thereby, the exit of Shabbat, so that Shabbat not appear as a burden. The Taz (OC 281:1) counters the T'rumat page 12 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 HaDeshen's assumptions on two fronts. First, he argues that TADIR - a more common b'racha is recited before a less common one - is a stronger factor than delaying the end of Shabbat. Additionally, argues the Taz, doing Chanuka candles before Havdala is not even a correct application of delaying the end of Shabbat. This is because lighting candles itself contradicts the continuation of Shabbat, for if it were still Shabbat, lighting a candle would be forbidden. The following discussion in Tosafot (Shabbat 23b) can shed light on the relative strength of the factor of TADIR. The gemara says that if one has enough money only for Chanuka candles or wine for Kiddush (which is more tadir), Chanuka has precedence because pirsumei nisa (publicizing the miracle) is more important. Tosafot asks why, regarding Rosh Chodesh on Chanuka, we read the haftrara of Chanuka, yet read the Torah portion of Rosh Chodesh before that of Chanuka. Tosafot's first answer, which the Taz cites as support, is that the advantage of pirsumei nisa prevails when only one of the mitzvot can be fulfilled, whereas TADIR is the key factor regarding the order when both are done. However, points out the Eliyah Rabba (681:1), Tosafot's other two answers diminish the importance of pirsumei nisa only regarding the Torah/haftara readings. This implies that when pirsumei nisa applies, as it does to Chanuka candles, it has order precedence over the more OU Israel Center TT 1116 common Havdala. R. Yaakov Emden (Mor U'ktzi'ah 681) rejects the Taz's claim that lighting Chanuka candles contradicts the idea of delaying Havdala (end of Shabbat). He points out that after Havdala in davening or Hamavdil, we are allowed to do work (including Yom Tov candles and Borei M'orei Ha'eish) before doing Havdala over wine, and yet we delay the b'racha of Havdala. Some cite a proof that Chanuka lighting precedes Havdala from the Yerushalmi (cited by the Shulchan Aruch, OC 581:1), that one should not use the Chanuka candles for Borei M'orei Ha'eish. This implies that the Chanuka candles are lit first. Is there any logic, other than minhag, to switch the orders in shul and at home, as S'fardim and some Ashkenazim do? The Maharal (Ner Mitzva, p. 28) cites, as a reason to do Havdala first, the concern that one who one did not say Havdala in Shemoneh Esrei will light in violation of Shabbat. The Eliya Rabba points out that in shul, we trust that the person appointed to light will be a diligent person who will not forget. It is also possible that since pirsumei nisa is a heightened element and exists for a shorter time in shul, we do it as soon as possible. The Kaf HaChayim (681:4) claims that after men have heard Havdala in shul, delaying the one at home is less important. Rav Daniel Mann, Eretz Hemdah Institute page 13 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 Rabbi Weinreb's Weekly Column: Shabbat Chanuka "...But By My Spirit..." It is a common scene in the United States at this time of year. The shopping malls, television commercials, and all public venues are transformed visually. As December 25 approaches, we see the evidence that we do indeed live in a predominantly Christian country. Images of Santa Claus and his reindeers, evergreen trees with dazzling decorations, crucifixes illuminated by bright lights, and depictions of the Nativity are everywhere and are inescapable. The sounds of the songs of the season fill the air. True, in recent times, and especially in cities where Jewish people are a significant presence, consideration is given to Chanuka. Symbols of our holiday and its music are also in evidence. We are thankful for that. It is also true that many of our Christian friends, including the gentleman I am about to introduce to you, find all this public fanfare objectionable. They think of it as garish, commercially motivated, and inconsistent with the spiritual message of their faith. But the reaction of many to this situation is similar to the one that my gentile friend Paul, with whom I worked closely during the years I was employed by the public school system, expressed to me some time ago. It was on a day in the OU Israel Center TT 1116 middle of December, and we were walking around one of the malls in suburban Washington, D.C. He remarked, "Don't you and other Jews feel a bit outnumbered and overwhelmed at this time of year? It seems to me that your Chanuka candles make little impression in contrast to the lights on our trees and the jingle of our bells." I told him that I appreciated his candor, and that he gave me cause for reflection. At the time, I did not think that it would be tactful for me to tell him the truth; namely, that I had long ago reflected upon this phenomenon. And I had long ago concluded that the relatively modest manner in which Judaism celebrates Chanuka is nothing less than the essence of our religion. This week is Shabbat Chanuka, and the weekly portion is Mikeitz, which we supplement with verses from the book of Bamidbar that relate to the Chanuka, or inauguration, of the Mishkan. But for me, the highlight of the scriptural readings for this Shabbat has always been the words of the prophet Zechariah which constitute this week's haftara. Zechariah was a man who saw many mysterious visions. He would typically ask either the angel to whom he had access, or he would inquire of the Almighty Himself, to tell him what these visions meant. And so we find, near the end of the passage we read this week, the following vision: page 14 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 "I see a lamp stand full of gold, with a bowl above it. The lamps are seven in number; each has seven pipes above it, and by it are two olive trees..." Characteristically, Zechariah asks the angel who talked with him, "What do these things mean, my lord?" The angel, like a good psychotherapist, asks him what he thinks the dream means. But the prophet confesses that he has no clue. The angel finally responds, "This is the word of the Lord: 'Not by might, and not by power, but by My spirit, says the Lord of Hosts.'" This is the lesson of Chanuka. The mighty are subdued by the weak, and the many by the few. As a public demonstration of our holiday and its miracle, we eschew lavish displays and extravagant celebrations. Instead, we kindle humble chanukiyot in the windows of our homes. It is true that the mitzva requires pirsum haneus, a public ceremony, and that the candles be lit for all passersby to behold. To that extent, our celebration is not totally modest and discrete. However, as the Talmud tells us, when the outside world is especially hostile, we are permitted to take the menorah "and place it on our table, indoors, and that is sufficient." For many centuries, Jews did just that, so that their celebrations of Chanuka were painfully private. OU Israel Center TT 1116 But even today, when most of us can practice our religion publicly, a few modest candles suffice. We wish to make the point, to ourselves if not for the rest of the world, that "a little light can drive away much darkness." We are content to let other religions celebrate their holidays as they wish; colorfully, dramatically, and publicly. We understand the power of the ubiquitous symbols and of the songs loudly sung. But for ourselves, we prefer the softer sounds of the spirit and the quiet environment of our own homes. The mitzva is ISH UVEITO, every man and his house, each person with his family. The lesson of the power of the single little candle is especially important in this day and age. We are bombarded by the images and sounds of cyberspace, and their message is often pernicious and malicious. The negative effects of most of what we hear and see on the internet and via other media are typically devastating to our hearts and souls, if not to our minds. How do we counteract the immense influence of such overwhelming forces? We can only do so if each of us is committed to use the power of modern technology to assert tolerance, kindness, morality, and ethical behavior. Our voices may be soft, but they will be heard. The positive images that we present may be dim, but they will be seen. page 15 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 The year after my encounter with my gentile friend, we met again and wandered through the same mall in the middle of December. This time I decided to put my inhibitions aside. I openly shared my reflections about the discrepancy between the commercially motivated displays of the symbols of his faith and the softer, smaller, and gentler displays of our tradition's symbols. He heard me, although I cannot say that he fully agreed with me. He did agree with me about one thing, though. "A little light can dispel much darkness." Happy Chanuka the Festival of Lights Chanuka: Religion or Nation; Spirituality or Materialism? by Dr. Meir Tamari Even today, both Jews and non-Jews often fail to recognize that Judaism is a nation that is a religion, and a religion that is a nation. This failure to recognize what is unique and special to Judaism is evident also in Israel's political world, both internal and external. In the early years of our return to Eretz Yisrael there were consistent attempts to make Shalosh Regalim into purely agricultural celebrations and Rosh HaShana a time of financial accounting. By the same thought process, the religious world talks today about Pesach, not as national freedom from physical OU Israel Center TT 1116 slavery and living in Egyptian exile but as freeing ourselves from our spiritual bonds; Mitzrayim becomes Meitzarim-straits. Chanuka is perhaps the most extreme example of these attempts to separate the twin concepts inherent in our chagim. One Israeli Chanuka song tells of the miracles wrought by the Maccabees. There is also one about "in those days Maccabees saved and redeemed and in our days Am Yisrael arose and redeemed". Religious teachers consider Purim as our deliverance from material and physical danger while seeing our religious and spiritual values endangered by the Greeks at Chanuka. The celebration of Purim with material things - seuda, mishlo'ach manot and matanot laEvyonim is contrasted to Chanuka's Menorah and its lights, clear symbols of spirituality. There is a detailed account in Megillat Esther of the Jews battling and killing their enemies. Similarly, the wars of the Maccabim are clearly documented in our sources. Nevertheless, there is a nusach of Al HaNisim without any mention of milkhamot. Despite these examples of the attempted separation of religionspiritual from national-material, our sources demonstrate that both Purim and Chanuka reaffirm the unity of these four concepts. The villain of Purim, HamanAmalek-Eisav, is the spiritual contradiction to Yaakov-Israel, so that the struggle and deliverance in the Megila, even when expressed as page 16 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 physical-material, must also be seen as spiritual-religious. The Books of the Maccabees, the authoritative record of what actually happened on Chanuka, make it clear that the Syrian-Greek kings threatened the Jews materially, physically and spiritually. Their decrees were aimed at promoting a foreign value system, forbidding Torah study and the observance of mitzvot, and defiling the Beit HaMikdash. These decrees were equally aimed at stealing Jewish wealth, oppressing them severely and sexually exploiting their daughters. "Then Hashem saved us through the saintly Chashmona'im Kohanim who battled and defeated the army of the Greeks. This [military] victory on 25 Kislev was a Neis and not achieved through natural causes [given the numerical and physical disparity between the armies]. The second Neis of Chanuka was that of the cruse of oil" (Orekh Hashulchan, Hilchot Chanuka 670:1-2). The Al HaNisim that we recite during all the days of Chanuka, gives thanks to G-d for fighting our battle, avenging us and for judging our enemies. It acknowledges the Neis of the victory of the warrior kohanim; "the many given to the few, the strong to the weak, the wicked to the righteous, t'mei'im to t'horim and the scoffers to the followers of Torah. The lights lit by them in the holy courtyards were expressions of their praise of His Name. The lights in our Chanukiot are in memory of the 2nd OU Israel Center TT 1116 Neis, that of the cruse of oil and a testament to the spiritual aspects of the purification and rededication of the Mikdash by the same warrior kohanim. These two Nisim of Chanuka, unite the national-material to spiritual-religious. Chazal were clearly not very favorable to the Hasmonean kings, descendants of the Maccabees or of their political mistakes and religious errors. Yet Rambam cites as part of the Chanuka miracle that "the Maccabim appointed a kohen king and thereby renewed kingship in Israel which lasted for over 200 years" (Hilchot Megila v'Chanuka, 3:1). A similar honor given even to a sinful king out of regard for Jewish statehood is shown by Eliyahu running before the chariot of king Achav who is regarded as unsurpassed evil. The unity nation-religion rests upon the intrinsic sanctity of the Land on which it was destined to come to fruition. The sanctity of Eretz Yisrael effects the ritual of Chanuka in two ways. "Why is there no prophecy in the golah? The kedusha that exists in the inanimate soil of Eretz Yisrael elevates the materialistic body of mankind thereby making possible prophecy, whereby the material body and spirituality become connected. Since no other country possess such intrinsic kedusha, that connection can never exist outside Eretz Yisrael" (Shem MiShmuel, Vayeitzei). page 17 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 Perhaps that can explain why Hallel is said on Chanuka but not on Purim which occurred in the galut. "The Beit Din of the Maccabim sat in Lishkat HaGazit in Yerusalyim, so they had the power to make decrees which are Torah obligations, whereas Mordechai and Esther were in galut where the Beit Din does not have such powers. Therefore the mitzvot of Chanuka did not need popular consent whereas the Megila tells us that they wrote to all the Jews to accept those of Purim and only then did these become obligatory" (Shem MiShmuel, 5th night of Chanuka, 5672). The following is from Sapphire from the Land of Israel A New Light on the Weekly Portion from the Writings of Rabbi Abraham Isaac HaKohen Kook by Rabbi Chanan Morrison Waiting for the Dream Adapted from Ein Eyah vol. II, p. 268 It took a long time, but Yosef’s dreams eventually came to pass. How long did it take? Yosef became viceroy of Egypt at age thirty, and nine years later (after seven years of plenty and two years of famine), his brothers came to buy food. So Yosef’s dreams that his brothers would one day bow down before him and recognize his greatness were fulfilled when he was 39 years old. Since he had dreamt those dreams of future greatness at age 17, we see that his dreams took 22 years to come true! OU Israel Center TT 1116 Rabbi Levi taught: One should wait as long as 22 years for a good dream to come true. This we learn from Yosef (B'rachot 54a). What is special about the number 22? In what way is it connected to the fulfillment of dreams? Rav Kook noted that the Hebrew alphabet contains 22 letters. Through myriad combinations and permutations of these 22 letters, we are able to express all of our thoughts and ideas. If we were to lack even one letter, however, we would be unable to formulate certain words and ideas. The ancient mystical work Sefer Yetzira offers an intriguing insight into the functioning of the universe. Just as hundreds of thousands of words are formed from a small set of letters, so too, the vast array of forces that govern our world are in fact the result of a relatively small number of fundamental causes. If 22 letters are needed to express any idea, then 22 years are needed for the universe’s elemental forces to bring about any desired effect. Thus it is reasonable that we should allow a dream as long as 22 years to be realized. Rabbi Levi is also teaching a second lesson: nothing is completely without value. One should not be hasty to disregard a dream. In every vision, there resides some element of truth, some grain of wisdom. It may take 22 years to be revealed, or perhaps its potential may never be realized in our world; but it always contains some kernel of truth. page 18 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 Maharal on the Sedra Aliya and Yerida B'reishit 42:2 - And he said, "Behold, I heard that there is food in Egypt. Go down there and provide for us from there, and we will live and not die." Rashi: The verse says R'DU [go down] rather than L'CHU [go], hinting at the 210 years that they served Egypt, corresponding to the gematriya of R'DU. Gur Arye: It would be more appropriate for the verb to be the more positive "go" than the negative "go down", a language that means descent. Yaakov, signaling the inception of a new stage of the history of his people, might have chosen a more positive verb. Hashem's first utterance in the Torah is "Let there be light!" and David tells us, "The introduction of your words illuminate" [T'hilim 119:130], interpreted by the rabbis [Sh'mot Rabba 50:1] to mean that the righteous begin their speech with light. Yaakov's term R'DU must be telling us something that supercedes the principle of the illuminating, positive introduction. Rashi's midrash supplies the message - 210 years. The Land of Israel is the highest of all the lands, and the Holy Temple is the highest point in the Land of Israel. How can this be? Surely Mt. Hermon is taller than Mt. Moriah, and Switzerland has more altitude OU Israel Center TT 1116 than the Land of Israel! This can be understood in terms of spirituality. Consider that the Earth is a sphere, say, a rubber ball floating on top of the water. If there is a spot on the surface of the ball that is lighter than the rest of the ball, that spot will rise to the top. Spirituality has no linear dimension and no mass, and the place it is concentrated is lighter and rises to the top. Therefore, anywhere you come from on the face of the Earth, you are making aliya [rising] when you come to the Land of Israel. This is what is meant in the Mishna [Kidushin 69a], "Ten genealogical classes rose [ALU] from Bavel", on which Rashi comments "the Land of Israel is higher than all the other lands. Column prepared by Dr. Moshe Kuhr TOWARDS GREATER CALENDAR AWARENESS Last week, in the Word of the Month box on page 2, we began with some details of one aspect of the Jewish Calendar. We said we'd continue this week, and we are. But let's first put an important Chanuka spin (pun very definitely intended) on it Chanuka is the celebration of the victory of the Jewish People - via the partnership between G-d and the Chashmona'im - over the Greeks, thereby ending the very oppressive Greek decrees against Jewish Law and Life. One of the main 'targets' of the Greeks was the Jewish Calendar. By page 19 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 banning Kiddush HaChodesh (among other mitzvot, such as Learning Torah, Shabbat, Brit Mila), the Greeks hoped to destroy the hold of Torah Judaism on our people and ease our Hellenization and assimilation into Greek culture. It is with this in mind, that we present this piece about the Calendar specifically in the Chanuka issue of Torah Tidbits. The first part of what follows is repeated (with modifications) from TT 1115. There are 385 dates possible on the Jewish Calendar. 353 of them occur in every year. If we add the variable dates (the ones that occur only in some, but not all years) - namely, the 30 days of the additional Adar, the 30th of Marcheshvan and Kislev that's 32 more dates, bringing the total number of dates to 385. The 295 dates from 1 Adar Alef through 29 Marcheshvan are governed by the LO ADU ROSH rule of Rosh HaShana, which results in those 295 dates being able to fall on four days of the week and not on three days of the week. LO ADU ROSH means that in our fixed calendar, Rosh HaShana cannot fall on a Sunday (ALEF), Wednesday (DALET), or Friday (VAV). There are 7 variations to LO ADU. Just as an example, if the first day of Tishrei cannot be on Sunday, then the second day of Tishrei cannot be on a Monday. Nor on a Thursday nor on Shabbat. So the 'rule' for 2 Tishrei would be LO B'Ha"Z. So it goes for OU Israel Center TT 1116 the five other variations, until we get to the 8th of Tishrei, which have the same day of the week yes or no as 1 Tishrei. Because of the variable situation with 30 Marcheshvan, it can only fall on 3 days of the week, Sunday, Tuesday, Thursday (and not on four days - the only date of the year so restricted). But, the on/off status of 30 Marcheshvan, results in 1 Kislev being able to fall on any of 6 days of the week. And 2 through 29 of Kislev follow suit and each has one day of the week they cannot fall on. As a result, the first day of Chanuka can be on any day of the week except Tuesday. That means the first candle can be on any night of the week except for Monday night. And so it goes for all of these 29 days of Kislev. Which brings us to 30 Kislev, which exists in most years, but not all. The 30th of Kislev (which we have this year), because of its on/off status, is not as 'free' as the other 29 days of Kislev. It happens to follow LO ADU - but not one that's connected to the 295 dates that are part of the same series of dates. And a further result of the on/off situation of 30 Kislev, is that 1 Tevet can occur on any of 5 days of the week, but not on only two days. Specifically, for 1 Tevet, it cannot fall on Thursday or Shabbat. So too for 8, 15, 22, and 29 of Tevet. It follows that the other Tevet days have two impossible days of the week each. Again, as an example, 2 Tevet cannot be on Friday or Sunday page 20 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 (since 1 Tevet cannot be Thursday or Shabbat. And so on. The and so on pattern continues not just for all of Tevet's 29 days, but also for Sh'vat's 30 days. Those 59 dates each have a variation of a day of the week and two days later, that they cannot fall on. Which brings us to the first of Adar. Here's the tricky part. 30 Sh'vat can fall on 5 days of the week - Sunday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday, but not on Monday or Shabbat. The day that follows 30 Sh'vat should also be able to occur on five days of the week. We would expect Monday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, and Shabbat as possible days of the week for 1 Adar. However, the 30th of Sh'vat in a 12-month year cannot fall on a Wednesday. For that to happen, RH would have to be on a Thursday AND the year would have to be CHASIER (missing 30 Kislev). THU & CHASEIR only happens in a Shana M'uberet, a 13-month year. So the 1st of Adar in a one-Adar year can only be on Monday, Wednesday, Friday, and Shabbat - but not on Sunday, Tuesday, of Thursday - thus putting 1 Adar and all the days that follow it until 29 Marcheshvan, back into the LO ADU ROSH system - which is what we started with. And the 30th of Sh'vat in a 2-Adar month can fall only on Sunday, Tuesday, Wednesday, or Friday (but not on a Thursday, which would be possible only in a year that begins on Thursday and both Marcheshvan and Kislev would have their normal OU Israel Center TT 1116 29 and 30 days respectively. But that happens only in a Shana P'shuta - a 12-month year. so the first of Adar Alef (in a 2-Adar year) can only fall on Monday, Wednesday, Thursday, and Shabbat - but never on a Sunday, Tuesday, or Friday - thus putting the calendar dates back into the LO ADU system (until 30 Marcheshvan). It you have a headache, don't worry. Just know that our Calendars (both during the time of Sanhedrin, as well as between Sanhedrins) are imbued with Sanctity and are the very special gift from G-d to His people from before we came out of Egypt. Appreciate and value it. Happy Chanuka! OzTorah Ten Brothers There was a famine in the land. Yaakov sent his sons to Egypt to buy grain. Food supplies in Egypt were in the hands of their own brother Yosef, but they did not know it. Long before, they had sold him as a slave, and there had been no communication with or from him for years. In due course they were to discover his identity and to see the family reunited, but not yet. In the meantime, the delegation set off from Canaan on the shopping expedition that would hopefully enable the family to eat. What does the Torah say? "And Yosef’s ten brethren went down to buy grain from Egypt" (B'reishit 42:3). But why only ten of them? Where page 21 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 was the eleventh, Binyamin? And why are they described as "Yosef’s brothers" and not "Yaakov’s sons"? To answer the first question, Yaakov would not let Binyamin accompany them for fear that some danger would befall him (verse 4). Rashi makes the important point that harm can befall a person at home too. (Don’t we know it in our own generation, when more accidents happen at home than on the roads?). However, adds Rashi, the "Satan" is especially ready to make mischief when people are on the road, where there are many outside forces that one cannot predict or control. Another way of looking at the number ten is to link it with the concept of the minyan; a minyan brings together ten otherwise separate individuals and unites them for a common purpose. Here, as Rashi also points out, there were ten separate people who had found it difficult to agree on family policy such as their feelings for or against Joseph, but when an economic challenge faced them they were able to make common cause. Perhaps this is why they are called "Yosef’s brothers"; there is something sarcastic about the phrase, because the one thing on which they had hitherto not been united was their brotherliness towards Yosef. Reprinted (with permission) from Shabbat Shalom Parsha Booklet (4) by Rabbi Berel Wein Yosef's dramatic ascent to power in Egypt is recorded for us in this week's parsha. What is noteworthy is that Yosef does not appear to be at all surprised or amazed by the sudden turn of events in his fortunes. A person who lives by dreams is never surprised when the dream turns into reality. Yosef always expected his dreams to come true in this world. So did his father Yaakov. And in truth so did the brothers and that is why he discomfited them so deeply. Had they felt the dreams of Yosef to be utter nonsense they would not have reacted as strongly when he related the dreams to them. They were threatened not because the dreams were nothing but rather because they were something. Their apparent blindness and stubbornness, at not recognizing Yosef standing before them, stemmed from their necessity to deny the validity of his dreams. When Yosef will reveal himself to his brothers they will instinctively believe him because of the stock they subconsciously placed in his dreams all along. Practical people are afraid of dreamers not because of the dreamer's impracticality but OU Israel Center TT 1116 page 22 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 because the dreamer may turn out to be right after all. This has been proven time and again in Jewish history. The holiday of Chanuka, that we are currently celebrating, proves the dreams of the Maccabees overcame the practicalities of the Hellenist Jews who chose to survive by becoming more Greek than Jewish. Jews over the ages could have reasonably quit and given up the struggle to survive as Jews countless times. It was always the dreamers that persevered and they have always been proven to be right and practical. The Torah attributes the success of Yosef to the fact that he remembered his dreams. It is one thing to remember dreams of grandeur when one is poor and imprisoned. Then the dream provides hope and resilience to somehow continue. Yosef's greatness lies in his ability to remember and believe those dreams when he has risen to power. He could easily have ignored his brothers and put all of his past behind him. He was now a great success. So why continue to pursue his dreams, which could ultimately sorely endanger his position and achievements? But Yosef doggedly pursues the full realization of his dreams. Many times in life we are frightened of advancing because we think we might risk what we already have. Judaism preaches caution in tactics and how to achieve certain goals, OU Israel Center TT 1116 both spiritual and physical. But it never advocates compromising the great Jewish dreams as outlined in our Torah and tradition. We are bidden to be prudent about life's decisions but the goal of ascending the ladder of Yaakov is never erased from our consciousness. When seeing his brothers before him, Yosef has the choice to leave everything as it is. But he chooses to pursue his dreams to their fateful end. That has become a lesson for all later generations of Jews as well. The full realization of Yosef's dream is the catalyst for reuniting all of Israel as a nation. EvA§ w§ i¦ e§ Part of Yosef's plan to handle the years of plenty so they would be able to survive and even thrive during the years of famine included their gathering the food and grain from the years of plenty... The above word means, And let them gather, or And they shall gather... The word YIKB'TZU is future tense - They shall/will gather. The VAV prefixed to the word is the conjunctive VAV (VAV HACHIBUR) and is NOT the tenseflipping VAV so common in the Torah. The SH'VA under the conjunctive VAV stays - or becomes a SHURUK - but does not change to page 23 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 a PATACH, as the tense-flipping VAV does. Therefore, this word and others like it - calls for caution not to say VA- but keep it at V'-. winery, then, translates VAYEISHEV's 112 p'sukim. TtRiDdLeS This is one of the RJJ schools. RJJ stands for Rabbi Jacob Joseph, or Yaakov Yosef. We find the phrase (if we play around with the punctuation) in the beginning of Vayeishev: EILEH TO-L'DOT YAAKOV YOSEF... Previous (Vayeishev) TTriddles: [1] Snow in the Torah: Vayeishev, Sh'mot, B'haalot'cha The Hebrew word SHELEG occurs twice in the Torah, both as a description of ZORAAT, which includes the skin turning white. In Sh'mot, it is Moshe's hand which turns TZORAAT like snow and then back to normal, when Moshe puts his hand inside his robe on his chest and then a second time. In B'haalot'cha, it is Miriam who is afflicted with TZORAAT, and again, its coloring is compared to snow. There are 19 other occurrences of the word SHELEG in the rest of Tanach, most often referring to the white fluffy percipitation or a white color like snow. So what does this have to do with Parshat Vayeishev? Not a thing. In Vayeishev, we find the Hebrew word S'NO - twice - in describing the growing hatred that the brothers had for Yosef. The word occurs nowhere else in Tanach. [2] Eliezer's winery (we mistakenly used the word vineyard elsewhere) ELIEZER = 1+30+10+70+7+200 = 318. VAYEISHEV = 6+10+300+2 = 318. YEKEV (which means winery KEREM is a vineyard, sorry for the mix-up) = 10+100+2 = 112. Eliezer's OU Israel Center TT 1116 as [3] Yeshiva Merkaz Hatorah of Staten Island [4] Yosef, Yaakov, R'chav-am, Y'hoshafat, Y'ho-achaz b. Yeihu, Pekach b. R'malyahu Search a Tanach database for 17 years (Yosef's age at the beginning of Vayeishev), and you will find 5 other occurrences. Yaakov was in Egypt for 17 years until his death. R'chav-am, son of Shlomo HaMelech, was 41 years old when he began his reign, which was 17 years long in Jerusalem. Achazyahu son of Achav reigned over the kingdom of Israel for 2 years; he began his reign in the 17th year of Y'hoshafat's reign over Judah. Y'ho-achaz b. Yeihu was king of Israel for 17 years. In the 17th year of the reign of Pekach b. R'malyahu (Kingdom of Israel), Achaz b. Yotan began his reign over Judah. BTW, Every occurrence in the Tanach of SH'VA ESREI (17, feminine form) refers to 17 years. There are seven occurrences of SHIVA ASAR (17, masculine) referring to different things. [5] Avraham, Yitzchak, Yaakov, Yosef, Moshe... and Eisav Not page 24 as easy as the previous Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 TTriddle. One would assume that there are many actions these six people did. The hard part is finding that which only these six did. On the other hand, if you think about for a moment, you might come to the 'obvious' answer. VAYEISHEV. The word occurs many times in the Torah, but it is followed by the name of a person (not the nation) only for these six people. The word refers to KAYIN, YISHMAEL, and LOT, but these names do not follow the word VAYEISHEV in the same phrase. That's how we cut down on the number of people in a TTriddle presentation. [6] All but SHIN and PEI This was the TTriddle in the upper-left of the front page. With SHIN and PEI in the pre-Chanuka issue, one's immediate association would be to the letters on the dreidel and sivivon respectively. Even, master TTriddler MM/Bklyn, who got all the others, assumed this one was about Chanuka. No, sorry. Not at all. If you add up the numeric values of the 22 letters of the ALEF-BET, you get 1495. (Challenge the right children with finding the gimatriya of the ALEF-BET - don't make it easy for them.) If you add up all the letters besides SHIN and PEI, which you can do by adding the other 20 letters together, or by subtracting 380 from 1495, you will get 1115, the issue number of the Vayeishev 5775 Torah Tidbits. Parsha Points to Ponder by MK Rabbi Dov Lipman Mikeitz 1) Why did Par'o tell Yosef that in his dream he was standing ON THE BANKS OF THE NILE (41:17) when in the dream he was was standing ON THE NILE itself (41:1)? 2) Why did Yosef present it as a given that the famine would come to Egypt and advise to take drastic steps to prepare for it (41:33) if we know that prayer and repentance can undo a negative decree as we see in the story of Yonah with the people of Ninveh? 3) Why did Yosef choose to accuse his brothers as being spies and not some of committing some other criminal offense (42:9)? Suggested answers 1) The Chatam Sofer teaches that Pa'ro was concerned that Yosef would not believe that he had this dream if he related that something completely impossible happened (consistent with the teaching in B'rachot 55 that dreams that contain meaning are not related through dreaming about the impossible). Thus, he changed it from standing on the water which is impossible to standing along- side the water. Pa'ro did not realize that his standing on the water was because of the water rising and coming to meet his feet on dry land. 2) The Meshech Chochma answers OU Israel Center TT 1116 page 25 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 that according to our tradition positive decrees are never undone and in this case, with Yosef's plans for Egypt to be well-prepared for the famine, the famine would actually lead to great prosperity for Egypt and turned into a positive decree which cannot be undone. 3) The Kli Yakar explains that Yosef feared that his brothers would start searching all around Egypt for clues regarding what had happened to him. To prevent this, he accused them of spying and now, to make sure they did not appear as spies, they would stay away from traveling around and searching for him. The Menora: Symbol of the Jewish State by Rabbi Ephraim Sprecher Dean of Students, Diaspora Yeshiva Our Chanukiya has 8 lamps to commemorate the 8-day miracle of Chanuka. However, in the Beit HaMikdash, the Menora had only 7 lamps. What is the significance of the 7 branched Menora and why is it the symbol of the State of Israel? The Torah commands Aharon, the Kohen Gadol, "When you light the lamps, towards the center of the Menora shall the seven lamps cast light" (Bamidbar 8:2). Why must the 6 lights bend towards the center light? According to the Maharal and Rabbi Yonatan Eybishuts, the 7 branches of the Menora in the Mikdash represent the 7 pillars of secular wisdom, OU Israel Center TT 1116 knowledge and science. The Rambam in Hilchot Yesodei HaTorah, ch. 2, states that when you study nature and the natural sciences, you fall madly in love with the One above. In fact in his Moreh Nevuchim, the Rambam explains that if you want to see G-d, study the incredible wisdom, found in nature. Thus, the word for nature in Hebrew, HATEVA, has the same gimatriya of ELOHIM (G-d). That is how the Rambam explains the verse in Parshat Ki Tisa when Moshe asked G-d, "Show me Your Glory." G-d answered him, "I will make all My goodness pass before you…, and you will see My back…" The Rambam explains G-d's answer. "If you want to see G-d, it's only by an indirect way through the study of nature and the natural sciences. That's how one comes to know and love G-d, as the popular song goes, "To know Him is to love Him." Ed. note: song written by Phil Spector, 1958, was inspired by words on his father's tombstone, "To Know Him Was To Love Him". Rabbenu Bechaye explains the 7 sciences as follows: (1) the Wisdom of Logic and Language, (2) the Study of Mathematics, (3) The Study of Physics and Chemistry, (4) The Science of Geometry and Trigonometry, (5) The Study of Music, (6) The Study of Astronomy, (7) The Study of Divine Wisdom and Theology. The center lamp of the Menora represents the light of Torah which all the other branches face. Rabbenu page 26 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 Bechaye explains that the central shaft of the Menora that holds all the other branches together is the knowledge of the Wisdom of G-d. The other branches of the Menora are only the offshoots of that Divine Wisdom. As T'hilim 111 states, "Reshit Chochma Yir'at HaShem" - "The source of all wisdom is the fear of G-d." The Vilna Gaon's disciple, Rabbi Yisrael of Shklov, writes in Pe'at HaShulchan, "The Vilna Gaon explained that all secular wisdom is essential for our Holy Torah and is included in it. He indicated that the Vilna Gaon had mastered all the 7 branches of secular wisdom and knowledge, including algebra, trigonometry, geometry and music." The Talmud has many examples of how our Sages used science and mathematics to assist them in their understanding of Torah. To cite an example, in Sanhedrin 5b, it states that the great sage, Rav, spent many months among the shepherds studying the types of blemishes on animals, which heal and which do not, for the purpose of determining the Sanctity of the firstborn kosher animals. The Talmud in Shabbat 75a also criticizes one who knows how to calculate the calendar and positions of the constellations but does not do so. The message of the Menora is that the light of Torah and the light of secular knowledge complement each other, as long as the Torah is the central focus, foundation, and basis of all secular OU Israel Center TT 1116 wisdom. Therefore, perhaps, this is the reason why the Menora was chosen as the symbol of the State of Israel, because the light of Torah has to beintegrated into all aspects of daily life, including technology and science. MACHON PUAH Eight Days of Miracles There is a famous question posed by Rabbi Yosef Karo in his book Beit Yosef. He asks why Chanuka is eight days and the usual answer is that the oil lasted for eight days, but in fact the Maccabees found oil that was sufficient for one day and so the miracle lasted "only" seven days. Really Chanuka should be 7 days, not eight. There are many answers to this question and one of them is that the first day we celebrate the fact that the Maccabees found the jug of oil. This was itself a miracle and it should be celebrated. On Chanuka we light candles and speak about the grand miracles, but we need to recognize the simple, daily miracles that we take for granted. We are so used to them that we call them nature and forget that they are no less miraculous. Today we can use technology to achieve a pregnancy in cases where there is a genetic abnormality that until recently would have been fatal. This is a wonder and amazes us. But is a natural pregnancy where a child is born healthy any less miraculous? Even page 27 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 the doctors or nurses who work in the delivery room and are used to seeing births every day still retain the wonder of childbirth. I have been privileged to be involved with helping couples who face huge challenges getting pregnant. With medical intervention and a lot of Divine assistance these couples have realized their dreams of becoming parents. It really is a zechut to attend their celebrations on the occasion of the birth of their children and we tend to use the term "a precious pregnancy". But the truth is that every single pregnancy is precious and the birth of one child is not really any more remarkable than the birth of any other baby. When we study biology and realize the complex path of human reproduction we are amazed and see the hand of God in each and every conception and birth. As I often say to many audiences, "It is a wonder that any of us are here." On Chanuka when we light the candles and spend time with our families we should take a moment to consider the many miracles and blessings that surround us; both the supernatural events and the obvious miracles, as well as the mundane natural miracles that we have got so used to that we forget that they are no less miraculous and no less wonderful. We thank God and celebrate for both types of miracles on all eight days of Chanuka. Rabbi Gideon Weitzman, Director, Puah Institute OU Israel Center TT 1116 CHIZUK ! IDUD Divrei Torah from the weekly sedra with a focus on living in Eretz Yisrael Chizuk for Olim & Idud for not-yet-Olim A person's life trajectory can assume many shapes and forms. For some, life swings back and forth like a pendulum constantly changing direction and speed. Such an individual will find that, totally unannounced, he is forcefully propelled in the opposite direction than that he had been accustomed to. Sometimes this change will be a positive one, while on other occasions the opposite is the case… Perhaps no one could have attested to this more than Yosef HaTzadik: From beloved darling - the apple of his father's eye - he was thrust without warning into the ignoble and mute existence of slavery. He had become a commodity passed on without hesitation to the highest bidder. Thus he moved from one master to another until he finally began to slowly make his mark. Having earned his master's respect , and having achieved a place of distinction within Potiphar's household - he must contend once again with disaster… Twelve long years later, after having languished in the dungeon as a result of not having succumbed to Potiphar’s wife’s allurements, the pendulum has wildly swung around in a new direction. In Bereishit 41:14 we read: “Pharoah sent for Yosef and he was hurriedly (Vay'ritzuhu) brought from the dungeon.” Moments later after having page 28 Mikeitz - Chanuka 5775 been shaved and his clothes changed, he stands before Pharoah! A Breslov Chassid would no doubt learn from this, never to be "mitya'esh", never despair. Even when there seems to be no hope left things can change with dramatic suddenness. The Midrash Tanchuma (Mikeitz 3), as quoted by Rabbenu B’chayei, says that this Biblical episode teaches us that out of despair comes deliverance - out of darkness emerges the light, out of being downtrodden, the righteous emerge elevated. Thus, Daniel who was thrown to the lions was saved and elevated; Mordechai went from wearing sack cloth to donning royal garments. So too Yosef as the verse in Kohelet 4:14 states: “From the dungeon he emerged to rule.” It is not only great Biblical figures who experience such a quick change of status, for as the S'forno tells us (on the word “Vay'ritzuhu”), the Divine salvation always comes speedily. This ancient pattern has famous modern day exemplars. They too went from a BIRA AMIKTA to an IGRA RAMA, from the lowest depths of imprisonment to unbelievable elevation. Anatoly Sharansky was whisked out of solitary confinement in the Gulag, to suddenly find himself visiting the Kotel which thronged with a multitude of well-wishers. From a taunted prisoner he became a world celebrity feted by the leaders of the free world. However there are other less well known examples as well. I am reminded of the story of the personal salvation of an anonymous Syrian Jew, related to me some twenty years ago when I met him at a Merkaz Klita. He had attempted to flee Syria bound for Eretz Yisrael, when he was captured and imprisoned for five years. While in prison he never forgot his goal, and once he was released he again attempted to realize his dream - this time he was successful. When I met him and heard his story, I asked him what it was that motivated him to be willing to put life at risk. His answer was as simple as it was inspiring: "My whole being longed to be in the Holy Land - how could I not try again." I wish all such stories had a happy ending. Jonathan Pollard has been imprisoned for thirty years now for helping the State of Israel. Reportedly, back in 1993 shortly after President Clinton's inauguration, his release was almost finalized. Pollard had agreed to the condition of signing a letter in which he would clearly express his remorse, but the deal fell through since he would not declare that he had violated Jewish Law. I pray that we will shortly see the day he too will be let free and be allowed to come home. Sadly there are many others today who hope and dream of Aliya but feel that they too are imprisoned against their will. These self-imposed "Prisoners of Zion" are entrapped by the exigencies of life in the Diaspora. To these I say: It is time to make the pendulum swing around in a new direction. The examples cited above go to prove that if you will it, it is no dream. It is time to break free and come home! Rabbi Yerachmiel Roness, Ramat Shiloh, Beit Shemesh Portion Chanuka and Jewish Sovereignty Chanuka is the anniversary of the rededication of the Beit HaMikdash during the time of the Greek ruler Antiochus Epiphanes. It celebrates not only the military victory and the restoration of Jewish self-government against the mightiest power at that time - but it also celebrates a spiritual victory, the victory of Jewish faith over enforced assimilation. But not until the miracle of the flask of oil, were the Rabbis willing to decide that these military and political events were worthy to justify declaring an eight-day yearly holiday in memory of those special events, Chanuka. We as religious Jews put more emphasis on the spiritual aspect of the holiday - the small cruse of oil lasting for the 8 days of the rededication of the Temple. But we mustn't forget the other aspect of the holiday. Having Jewish self-government is something we must be thankful for. Our Rabbis taught us that even though the Macabees rule over Israel was short-lived, it was something to give thanks for. We must not take it for granted that we are able to live in Israel now and are able to elect our own leaders. Every Chanuka, I read something from the book xe`d `xp jxe`a, a compilation of articles published in memory of Danny Cohen HY"D, a soldier who was killed on 11 Kislev 5763. I always learn something new from this lovely book - this year it was especially moving learning from it - since I was reading it in Hevron, where Danny was killed. Although he is not physically alive, his spirit lives on through the words of Torah inspiration people are able to learn from the book written in his memory. This year I chose to read a drasha written by Harav Yitchak Nissenbaum HY"D, who was a Rabbi in Europe before the war and actually delivered his drashot in Warsaw in Hebrew. In his drasha he writes that Yehuda the Maccabee went out to "save the Torah from destruction and the nation from annihilation - this type of victory is eternal. Rav Nissenbaum, who lived under the Nazi persecution and was murdered by them, felt that Yehuda the Maccabee fought for Jewish Sovereignty because without national freedom for the nation and the land there is also no freedom of religion. He also felt that the battles of the Maccabees gave us national pride. This ties in to a story I recently heard on the radio (I turned on the radio in the middle of the story so I don't have all the names) - I believe it was about Netanyahu. During an election campaign where he was a candidate he went to meet a big Rabbi in Bnei Braq. Before Netanyahu arrived at the Rabbis house, the Rabbi took off his weekday coat and put on his Shabbat coat. The Rabbi's students could not understand this behavior and they asked him what he was doing. He answered that Netanyahu as the prime minister of Israel was similar to a Jewish King, therefore the Rabbi wanted to show him respect by dressing up to greet him. A Jewish leader deserves respect and brings honor to the nation. The Rabbi's behavior is in dire contrast to certain people in the Knesset who choose to berate Netanyahu - e.g. the speeches given when the Knesset was disbanded where everyone said how bad Netanyahu is as a leader - are just one example. And in the current elections the theme seems to be Netanyahu bashing. While each of us might have complaints about Netanyahu as a leader, that doesn't mean we should insult him and put him down. As a Jewish leader we should still respect him and hold him with a bit of awe. I for one don't envy him his job. Although not all the Maccabees remained holy we refer to them as HaKohanim HaK'doshim we sing their praises. We should try our best to find positive things to say about our leaders today as well and not just try to cut them down with our words. Having Jewish sovereignty is one way that God "gives God great and holy renown in His world". If we can't show our leaders respect - who else will? SINCE CHANUKA is a holiday of lighting candles, here is a recipe for something that is also burning flamed apples. They are also fried and can be served with dairy whipped cream in keeping with the custom to eat dairy on Chanuka. FLAMED APPLES 6 apples ¼ cup oil or butter 2 Tbsp brown sugar 2 tsp cinnamon 1 Tbsp lemon juice 4 Tbsp brandy Whipped cream Peel and core the apples and cut into ½" slices. Saute the apple slices in butter or oil for 1 minute on each side. Sprinkle with brown sugar, cinnamon and lemon juice and continue frying, basting with the syrup until apples are soft. Arrange on a serving dish. Warm the brandy in a small saucepan. Set alight and pour over the apples. Serve the apples with syrup from the dish and whipped cream. PPx Top-left is the Davka Judaica graphic of Paro and his dream(s) • Mickey Mouse, the sorcerer's apprentice, for the wizards of Egypt who were unable to satisfactorily interpret Par'o's dreams • When the Wine Steward finally told Par'o about Yosef, he (Yosef) was brought up from the dungeon and cleaned up. Tradition tells us that it was Rosh HaShana when he came before Par'o hence, the Shofar... • and he shaved for the occasion - hence the electric shaver with the Shofar • To the right of the Shofar & shaver is a scarab ring, like the one Paro gave Yosef when he decided to appoint Yosef "over Egypt" • 20% was part of Yosef's plan for Par'o, to take a fifth from each producer during the years of plenty, so that there would be enough to go around during the famine • 10+1+? was the brothers' answer to Yosef's question about their family. We are 10 brothers, son of one man. Plus one other brother who is at home, plus another who's whereabouts are unknown • Botnim (now peanuts but originally pistachio - Biblical Hebrew and modern Hebrew differ on occasion) were part of Yaakov's gift package. Today, pistachios are called FISTUKIM in Hebrew. It obviously is not a Hebrew word, since no Hebrew word can start with an F sound • The silver cup is Yosef's (did he get it as a Bar Mitzva gift?), used to frame Binyamin • The sack of coins is for the double portion of money the brothers found returned to their sacks • At the bottom is a scene from Megilat Esther, with Haman leading Mordechai through the streets. There are many similarities between that Megila scene and what was done with Yosef. This one is particularly obvious - parading him... calling before him... Then there is the king giving a ring... and more • The bell (under the two items whose names start with SH) is for the word VATIPA'EM RUCHO, his (Par'o) spirit was troubled. The word appears only one other place in Tanach, in the book of Daniel, where it has the same context: being troubled as a result of a dream. Rashi in Mikeitz explains it as having the feeling of a bell ringing inside (one's chest or heart, perhaps) • The shirt with the 6 on it is a play on BIGDEI SHEISH, garments of linen, that Par'o clothed Yosef with • Club 365 is associated with the department store HAMASHBIR. That is what Yosef was for the Land of Egypt - HAMASHBIR (B'reishit 42:6) • The key with the picture of ET stands for the pasuk in which Yosef instructs his people that the brothers will eat with him, the words are KI ITI YOCHLU HA'ANASHIM • The emblem of the State of Israel comes from the haftara, which comes from the prophecy of Zechariya • Part of Zechariya's message is LO B'CHAYIL, not with military might - hence, the Xed out soldier. This is not to say that we shouldn't have the best army possible. That is our Hishtadlus. But we must understand that our greatest weapon, so to speak, is G-d's spirit on our side - something we get when we are faithful to Him. The leaders of the State whose emblem comes from the Navi should learn the lesson of the prophecy of the same source • Hess logo is for the similarity to the words in the haftara: Hass kol basar. Hess, meat - get it? • Tide is recommended for Yehoshua KG's soiled garments • The guitar-like stringed instrument is an OUD, a word from the haftara (with a different meaning) • Lower right is a play on Yaakov's telling his sons that there was Shever b'Mitzrayim (SHEVER means 'provisions' and also fraction - the particular fraction has no significance • Kettering University is in Flint (Michigan). Flint is TZUR. With the LE you get one of the Nesi'im: ELITZUR • Olive Oyl is a give-away • Parking sign with max. of 25 cars is CHANU-KAF-HEI, i.e. CHANUKA and the MazalPic
© Copyright 2024