EPA PE R NATIONAL: FARMERS SEEK JUSTICE FROM UN ✪4 First INDEPENDENT English daily www.elevenmyanmar.com THURSDAY, January 22, 2014 INSIDE Worsening health NATIONAL Restarting clinics last month, MSF has treated over 3,000 patients in Rakhine State A woman holds a Rakhine flag to welcome President Thein Sein to Sittwe in December. President urges education law rethink in face of protests ✪2 BUSINESS Illegal trade suppresses official trade volume: commerce minister ✪5 ASEAN+ EPA Creaking education system pushes students overseas ✪7 LIFESTYLE DPA, MYANMAR ELEVEN CONDITIONS for patients in Myanmar’s western province of Rakhine have worsened since the expulsion of medical aid group Doctors Without Borders (MSF), the group said Wednesday after restarting medical clinics in the area. The group was expelled by authorities in February after treating victims from both sides of clashes between Buddhist locals and members of the Muslim ethnic Royingya community. “We learn that, during our suspension, just a few patients received medical care from government,” said Reshma Adatia, operational adviser to MSFHolland on Myanmar. “It’s like we have to start from a minus situation.” MSF is also the largest provider of HIV/AIDS care in Myanmar, currently treating over 35,000 HIV patients nationwide, as well as 3,000 people for tuberculosis. Outside assistance is deemed necessary given that the country’s public spending on healthcare is below 10 per cent of gross domestic product which is estimated at around US$57 billion. The group restarted primary health clinics on December 17 after talks with the government. In the past four weeks it has treated more than 3,480 outpatients and consulted more than 550 pregnant women, MSF said on Tuesday. MSF also provides healthcare to all ethnic groups in Shan and Kachin states as well as Yangon, in the mission started in 1992. It offers services including basic healthcare, reproductive care, emergency referrals, and malaria treatment. Since 2004, MSF has treated more than 1.2 million people across Rakhine State for malaria. Through primary clinics in Rakhine State, the group hopes to extend medical care to Tens of thousands of people. MSF has worked in Rakhine state since 1992 to provide basic healthcare, reproductive care, emergency referrals, and tuberculosis and HIV care. MSF has also treated over 1.2 million malaria patients in the state since 2004. All medical services have been provided based purely on the severity of individuals’ medical need. On the opening of the clinic, Martine Flokstra, MSF Myanmar Operational Adviser in Amsterdam, welcomed the progress it has made so far, referring to the negotiation with the government. “There is space to do more, space we at MSF are willing and able to fill,” said Flokstra. “We hope to continue this dialogue with the authorities to ensure that those who need it most in Rakhine state are able to access the healthcare they need.” Among the first batch of outpatients, numbering 3,480, they are predominately people with watery diarrhoea, respiratory infections, and patients with chronic conditions who used to get the medications they need to manage their disease from MSF Holland before those services were suspended. After the forced suspension in February, MSF Holland has worked together with the Ministry of Health in Rakhine by providing medicine and personnel to support mobile primary health care teams in Sittwe and Pauktaw Townships, and continued its support of HIV patients in Buthidaung and Maungdaw. Throughout the 9-month period MSF also continued to provide direct care and treatment to more than 35,000 HIV/AIDS patients, and more than 3,000 tuberculosis patients, most of whom are also HIV positive, across Myanmar. Myanmar’s king of laughs ✪10 2 NATIONAL MYANMAR ELEVEN, Thursday, January 22, 2014 President urges education law rethink in face of protests MYANMAR ELEVEN, AFP Myanmar students start their march in Mandalay. AFP PRESIDENT Thein Sein sent a message to the parliament on January 20 requesting that parliament reconsider the National Education Law following demands from students and teachers. In his message to parliament, the president mentioned that there are stakeholders who demand decentralisation of education policies, the elimination of the National Educational Commission, the freedom to form students and teacher associations and the promotion of ethnic minority literature in schools. The president also said that since the Ministry of Education has not been able to fulfil the demands of these stakeholders and because the law is still not enforced in practice, the legislation should consider amending it. He sent the message on the same day that dozens of students started a 575-km march from Mandalay to Yangon in protest of the law. They renewed the protest as the government did not act to complete their demands within 60 days. The Union parliament approved the National Education Law on September 30, 2014. Forty-six per cent of the law’s provisions were drawn the parliament, and remaining 54 per cent were drawn by the Ministry of Education. On Tuesday dozens of young campaigners began an unauthorised cross-country protest march to the commercial hub Yangon, in a show of defiance by students, who have historically been at the forefront of political activism in the former junta-run nation. Protesters said the statement - which suggested adding “inclusive education” to the law without elaborating on who would be affected - fell short of their demands. “It’s not enough. We need a genuine way to change,” Phyo Phyo Aung, secretary of the All Burma Federation of Student Unions, told AFP by phone from the central town of Kyaukse as around a hundred protesters made their way south from the second city of Mandalay. Students, who staged almost a week of rallies in November over the law which they say curbs academic freedom, renewed their campaign Tuesday, saying that government had failed to meet their demands for talks. They want the law altered to include free and compulsory education until children reach their early teens, permission to form student and teacher unions, and teaching in ethnic minority languages. Myanmar was rocked by massive student-led demonstrations against authoritarianism in 1988 that propelled Aung San Suu Kyi into the democracy fight, but were ended with a brutal military crackdown. Outright army rule ended in 2011 and the country has seen Western sanctions largely dropped in response to reforms, including releasing most political prisoners and allowing Suu Kyi into parliament. President’s response to six-party meeting proposal welcomed MYANMAR ELEVEN Lawmakers anticipate the six-party political talks soon, following President Thein Sein’s response to parliament’s proposal. “When I read the message of the President, it reflected his goodwill, but it took two months for him to issue it. I found his words on the six-party meeting to be a good sign. He wrote that the parliament was the most responsible body to deal with this matter. There are different opinions within parliament on the proposal for a six-party meeting. Some say we must rely on these six figures, while others say a meeting including only these six figures would silence the different voices of the parliament,” Myint Tun said. The proposal for a six-party meeting was submitted to the Union parliament in November by MP Myint Tun to the Union parliament and was later approved. Aung San Suu Kyi, the chairperson of the National League for Democracy (NLD), said on January 20 that she will later officially respond to the president’s message. In his response to the proposal to hold a six-party talk, President Thein Sein said the meeting must be acceptable to civic organisations, to political forces and to the public. Some interpret the president’s message as evidence that he will continue to delay the sixparty meeting. Myint Tun considered it differently. “I suppose the president wants to lay down detailed prin- ciples the people and political forces long for. The MPs must gather these points. If these six figures meet, the right answer will appear,” the MP said. “The parliament and the people want the six-party talk to go ahead. The 14-party and 48-party talks were heavily criticised. The parliament already approved the six-party talks, so it should happen soon. Truth be told, six-party meetings should be held from time to time, always with the same six figures. If they do this, they can win much support from the people,” Myint Tun said. The six-party talks were proposed after President initiated political talks on October 31. Some called it a “show business” given that each of the 14 participants were given only 10 minutes to speak their mind. Suu Kyi herself proposed four-party to involve the president, parliament, the commander-in-chief of Defence Services. The six-party talks will involve the President, the Lower Houseparliament speaker, the Upper House speaker, the chairperson of the opposition National League for Democracy (NLD), the MP representing all ethnic groups and the Commander-in-Chief of the Defence Services. Aye Maung was chosen by ethnic parties to represent them at the six-party meeting. “Fourteen ethnic parties held discussions about tasks to be done in the future. The outcomes of these discussions will be submitted to the speaker of the Union parliament,” said Aye Maung. MYANMAR ELEVEN, Thursday, January 22, 2014 3 National 4 NEWS DIGEST Activists protest Letpadaungtaung mine in Yangon MYANMAR ELEVEN, Thursday, January 22, 2014 Myanmar monk’s UN whore rant “could hurt Buddhism” Seventy eigh lawyers were suspended or disbarred for violating codes of ethics between 2011 and 2014, said Deputy Attorney General Tun Tun Oo. Tun Tun Oo spoke in response to a question by lower house MP Mi Myint Than during a parliamentary session in Nay Pyi Taw on Monday. The MP asked whether lawyers associations and bar councils could be established in various states and regions so that the public could hire lawyers in criminal or civil cases. “Local associations can apply for registration at their relevant departments under the law for association registration. Therefore, lawyers can also apply to their respective townships, districts, regions and states for the formation of a lawyers’ associations,” said Tun Tun Oo. However, he stressed the need for lawyers to follow codes of ethics. He said complaints could be filed against lawyers who breach the codes of lawyers’ ethics, which would lead to investigations and legal action taken against such lawyers. He did not mention whether such action had also been taken against government lawyers. One ministry’s office to become museum The Myanmar Investment Commission (MIC) has given permission to 20 foreign and local investment firms, including Anawmar Art Group Co Ltd, to rent the offices of several ministries. One will be turned into a museum and the rest will be used for other purposes. They will be leased under the build-operatetransfer (BOT) agreement. The MIC decision was announced on January 16. It said the permits are granted after receiving recommendations and comments from regional or state governments and relevant ministries. Wirathu REUTERS A Myanmar Buddhist monk who called a UN human rights envoy a “whore” has violated his monastic code and could damage his religion, another prominent monk said. Wirathu denounced Yanghee Lee, the UN special rapporteur on human rights in Myanmar, in a speech in Yangon on Friday, after she questioned draft laws that critics say discriminate against women and non-Buddhists. “Just because you hold a position in the United Nations doesn’t make you an honourable woman. In our country, you are just a whore,” Wirathu told a cheering crowd of several hundred people in Yangon on Friday. The monk also accused Lee of bias towards Rohingya Muslims, a stateless minority in the western Myanmar state of Rakhine. “You can offer your arse to the kalars if you so wish but you are not selling off our Rakhine State,” he said. Kalars is a derogatory word for people of South Asian descent. His speech was condemned by Thawbita, a leading member of the progressive Saffron Revolution Buddhist Monks Network in Mandalay, where Wirathu is also based. “The words used that day are very sad and disappointing. It is an act that could hurt Buddhism very badly,” Thawbita told Reuters on Tuesday. The network was formed by Yanghee Lee monks who helped lead the 2007 Saffron Revolution, a nationwide democracy uprising brutally crushed by the military. It is influential among educated Buddhists, but has little power. A senior official at the Ministry of Religious Affairs told Reuters there were no plans to act against Wirathu. “Of course, he has the right to express his opinion but he shouldn’t have used these terms,” said the official, who requested anonymity due to the sensitivity of the issue. “It can tarnish the image of our religion among those who don’t really understand its essence.” Famed for his fiery speeches, Wirathu belongs to a radical anti-Islamic group whose monks EPA 78 lawyers suspended or fired in four years REUTERS A group of democracy activists marched in protest of the Letpadaungtaung copper mine project and Wanbao, the Chinese company that operates the project, on January 20. The protestors expressed their lack of confidence in the Myanmar government, which they said protects Wanbao and kills Myanmar citizens. Some of the activists were arrested. “We marched from Pyay Road to the Dagon Township court peacefully. We were arrested peacefully,” said a protestor Than Swe who was among the arrested. The death of Khin Win during a protest in December sparked a series of protests. Days after the incident, protests were staged outside the Chinese embassy in Yangon. Earlier this month, six people were charged for the unautorised protests. Khin Win was killed on December 22 when police opened fire on protesters trying to stop the mine company building a fence in territory disputed with local farmers. preach that Muslims will one day overrun Myanmar. Buddhism is the country’s predominant religion and its monks are revered. A quasi-civilian government now runs Myanmar after nearly half a century of hardline military rule. But its reforms have been marred by deadly religious clashes, with rights activists warning that hate speech could foment further violence. Lee responded indirectly to Wirathu’s remarks in a statement released by her office on Monday. “During my visit I was personally subjected to the kind of sexist intimidation that female human rights defenders experience when advocating on controversial issues,” she said. Myanmar farmers seek help from UN Ye Yint Aung MYANMAR ELEVEN Shwebo Kantbalu farmers’ lawyer is seeking the United Nations’ help, saying it is difficult to find justice in the home country. “We are going to write the report on Kantbalu farmers’ issue by the end of February. The translated version will be submitted to the UN before March 25,” said Thein Than Oo, a law expert, while meeting with the farmers. He said that the petition would be submitted through the Global Justice Centre. He noted that farmers are in a worse condition even when the nation is undergoing democratic changes. Many farmers have been sued and imprisoned since the incumbent government took office, he said. In the agro-based country like Mynamar, there remains a big gap and poor farmers are generally ignored. More than 10,000 acres of farmlands in Kantbalu Township, Sagaing Region, were grabbed to implement the Army’s Sugarcane Project at the time of previous government era. “I’m sorry when I heard a farmer’s voice saying that they were hopeless. As for justice, the constitution must be amended. According to the current constitution, the judicial pillar is not free and fair,” he added. With the aims to know the international community about taking responsibility and giving pledges, the report to be submitted to UN will include Kantbalu farmers’ affair and Letpadaungtaung issue. “13,000 acres of farmland were grabbed. Although we negotiated with the authorities again and again, they broke out their promise. Afterwards, the farmers were being charged and sentenced. Due to the reasons, the farmers’ lives are getting worse and worse. When Thura Shwe Mann (Union Speaker) visited there, we tried to submit him the problem but we faced obstruction to do so,” said farmer Than Htike. Among laws related to land ownership enacted in successive era, the 2012 Land Law is the worst for farmers, critics said. They viewed that the law not only failed to solve existing problems but also invited more troubles. Thein Than Oo reviewed that to effectively solve the farmers’ problems, it was very important that a farmer union be established. In August, about 1,000 farmers from Kantbalu Township staged a protest to ask for the return of confiscated lands and fair trials. Earlier, 56 farmers were given prison sentences of up to two years following protests against confiscation of land by the state and military. In the township, it was reported that over 450 farmers faced various charges last year. 5 BUSINESS MYANMAR ELEVEN, Thursday, January 22, 2014 Illegal trade suppresses official trade volume:commerce minister Myanmar designates five-year transition period of stock market Commerce minister Win Myint giving speech at the SocioEconomic Life Improvement Meeting. MYANMAR ELEVEN MYANMAR ELEVEN COMMERCE minister Win Myint said the huge volume of illegal trade in Myanmar is responsible for the country’s low trade figures compared to China and Thailand. The minister spoke at the SME Development and Socio-Economic Life Improvement Meeting on January 20. “Myanmar is the country with the lowest tax revenue in the region. Our trade volume is also the lowest compared to neighbouring countries. This is because of illegal trade. Much illegal trade takes place at the borders with China and Thailand. Our trade volume is about US$1 billion lower than Thailand’s and over US$1 billion lower than China’s,” said the minister. Myanmar’s total trade volume in the 2010-2011 fiscal year was US$15 billion, and it rose to $25 billion in the 2013-2014 fiscal year. For the 2014-2015 fiscal year, as of the first week of January, Myanmar’s trade volume is $21 billion. However, Myanmar’s import volume is higher than its export volume because many materials needed for foreign investment firms must be imported from foreign countries. Illegal trade and commodity imports have been seized by the Customs Department, as well as by mobile teams organised by the Ministry of Commerce and related departments along sea routes and border trade routes. “Illegal trade affects consumer protection, those in the market who operate legally and pay taxes, as well as local SMEs,” said the minister. Myanmar’s trade deficit before the end of the 2014-2015 fiscal year is more than $3.6 billion, which is higher than last year’s deficit, according to the Ministry of Commerce. AFP EMG The Securities and Exchange Commission of Myanmar has already designated a five-year transition for Stock Exchange Certificates Market (SECM). “It [period] may be increased or reduced. Under the transition period, SECM will be under the Finance Ministry. The expected transition period could be five years. But the period may be increased or reduced. At the moment, the process seems quite successful. “Although there are some pending issues which we need to inform the Finance Ministry to get permission. But in accordance with the law, SECM is the SECM. The Finance Ministry needs to provide assistance to SECM. Currently, we need experience and we have weak points. If the Securities Exchange succeeds gradually, the current situation may change,” said Dr Maung Maung Thein, chairman of SECM. The Union Parliament enacted the law of Stock Exchange Certificates in 2013. The exchange will be established with a 51 per cent stake held by Myanmar Economic Bank and 49 per cent by Japan-based Daiwa Group and Japan Exchange Group. The bilateral agreement was signed last December. It is learnt that the stock exchange market will be launched in October this year. People walk past a building in downtown Yangon where Myanmars government hopes to locate the countrys first stock exchange, in Yangon. MYANMAR ELEVEN Chicken and eggs imported through Myanmar-Chinese border area will be analysed over bird flu concerns starting this month. Myanmar’s Livestock Breeding and Veterinary Department (LBVD), in co-operation with UN’s World Food Programme, will inspect all poultry products for bird flu imported through trade routes along the border till the end of the year. The imports of poultry products and the effects of the bird flu will be studied to prepare for countermeasures. The officials from the Ministry of Health, poultry suppliers and dealers will also join hands in inspecting the import- ed poultry products. “Firstly, we will analyse and study the causes of the disease. Then preventive measures will be prepared. The knowledge of how the poultry products enter our country is vital to set up the countermeasures,” said Dr Kyaw Naing Oo from the Research and Disease Control Division, LBVD. Currently, the new strains of bird flu detected around the world and the neighbouring countries like China and India have struggled with the flu last year. According to the statement of World Organisation for Animal Health, the bird flu hit Cambodia, Vietnam, Lao, Nepal, Japan, Korea, Canada, Australia, Italy and Germany in 2014. A meat market near MyanmarChinese border. EMG Chinese poultry imports checked over bird flu concerns Business 6 Ministry to monitor oil transport with drones MYANMAR ELEVEN KTB keen on expansion of GMS business Sucheera Pinijparakarn THE NATION State-owned Krungthai Bank (KTB), the country’s largest bank by assets, is placing importance on payments, product development and partnership in its drive towards inclusive business development in the Greater Mekong Subregion (GMS). Kittiya Todhanakasem, the bank’s first senior executive vice president, said KTB was currently the only foreign bank in Kunming assigned as the financial centre for southern China. The Kunming operation will, therefore, have an increased role in supporting business activities in Yunnan province, which forms the northernmost part of the GMS, she said. “The outstanding progress that we have seen is the rising financing demand for infrastructure in Kunming, and KTB is working with its partner bank in Kunming, Fudian Bank, in offering the first syndicated loan to a major Chinese construction company,” she said. Partnership is one of KTB’s development strategies in the GMS, she said, adding that last year its Kunming branch was able to sell Thai banknotes through Fudian Bank, while the Kunming branch received a yuan licence from the China Banking Regulatory Commission to facilitate entrepreneurs in conducting business transactions with their trading partners in China. KTB sells between Bt30 million and Bt40 million monthly in Thai banknotes through its alliance bank, and has been asked by another Chinese bank to sell banknotes to them, as well as to develop other products. KTB itself also requires more partners in Yunnan, said Kittiya, as this would help strengthen its payment products in the GMS because the bank does not have a network in all countries in the subregion, she explained. Payment products The payment products it offers include remittances, banknotes and foreign-currency deposit accounts. KTB targets 20-per-cent growth annually for its banknote business in the subregion. In Laos, KTB offers payment products in partnership with a local bank, Banque Pour Le Commerce Exterieur Lao, while in Myanmar, six partner banks facilitate remittances from Myanmar workers in Thailand. “There is no reason not to do [something similar] in Cambodia and Vietnam in order to cover the GMS. The payment system will be expanded to co- branded ATMs as the next step,” she said. Meanwhile, KTB also offers credit cards of its subsidiary Krungthai Card to wealthy Laotians. The bank is active in Laos, especially in the role of financing infrastructure projects, and has submitted an application for a licence to open a subsidiary in the country, she said. Kaskornbank has already set up a subsidiary in Laos, enabling it to open more branches and ATM machines. If approved, KTB hopes the subsidiary licence will help strengthen its payment and banknote business, said the executive. The bank is also planning to reactivate its relationship with Acleda Bank, its partner in Cambodia, for promoting transactions in Cambodian riel and Thai baht, particularly in crossborder trade payments, she said. KTB signed a collaboration agreement with Acleda Bank in 2009. In Cambodia, KTB has a branch in Phnom Penh and a sub-branch in Siem Riep. In Vietnam, however, while the bank is interested in having its own branch, it could take time to achieve this because Vietnamese banks are slow when it comes to seeking foreign partners, she added. REUTERS THE Energy Ministry said it will use drones to monitor the loading and unloading of oil at the Shwe Gas Project in Maday Island, Rakhine State, in order to detect and address spills if they occur. Meanwhile, locals plan to protest if a spill occurs. “We just asked Zayyar Aung, the energy minister, whether oil spill rules and regulations in line with international norms have been set up for the protection and conservation of the environment. He said the ministry will be using drone for monitoring and taking action against spills,” said Rakhine Ethnic Affiars Minister Zaw Aye Maung on Janurary 20 at Maday Island. He added that in Singapore, a fines for oil spills cost companies millions of dollars. “As Myanmar’s rules and regulations are weak, it is likely that oil will be carelessly spilled by a company into the ocean, and the com- pany will pay [a meager] US$ 4,000 and 5,000 for the spill. This could lead to environmental damage around Kyaukphyu area,” Zaw Aye Maung continued. An oil tanker operated by the China National Petroleum Corporation (CNPC) is set to dock 24 miles from Kyaukphyu, Rakhine State, on January 24 to transport oil to China through the pipelines of the Shwe Gas Project. The tanker is carrying a total of 150,000 tonnes of oil from Middle Eastern countries. This operation is the pilot project for oil transportation using through the Shwe Gas Project pipelines, said local resident Tun Tun Naing. The authorities have not explained the details and impact of the project on locals yet, said Tun Kyi, a leader of the local pipeline watch. He also said the authorities have not fulfilled the requests of the locals. MYANMAR ELEVEN, Thursday, January 22, 2014 A man walks past the Solar Impulse 2 during its presentation at the Al Bateen airport in Abu Dhabi. Solar Impulse 2, a plane powered by the sun, will attempt an unprecedented flight around the world next month, the project’s founders said, seeking to prove that flying is possible without using fossil fuel. Solar Impulse 2 is set to take off from Abu Dhabi with stopovers in India, Myanmar and China before crossing the Pacific Ocean and flying across the United States and southern Europe to arrive back in Abu Dhabi. The plane, which has the weight of a family car and a wingspan equal to that of the largest passenger airliners, will take off in late February and return by late July. Its journey will span approximately 25 flight days at speeds between 50 and 100 km (30 to 60 miles) per hour. ASEAN+ 7 MYANMAR ELEVEN, Thursday, January 22, 2014 Creaking education system pushes students overseas WEARIED by the rampant cheating, endless rote learning and mandatory Leninist ideology classes, Vietnam’s middle-classes are fleeing the country’s school system for overseas education. Every year, Vietnamese parents spend more than $1 billion sending their children to schools and colleges abroad, according to data from independent monitors, shunning a local system so backwards that experts say it is impeding economic growth. From teenagers sent to secondary schools in Singapore to university students studying at prestigious American institutions, at least 125,000 Vietnamese students are studying overseas, according to ICEF Monitor, which tracks the international education industry. The figure represents just a fraction of the nation’s near-17 million school and university students, but it is growing fast - up 15 per cent year-on-year in 2013 alone. Civil servant Nguyen Thi Thu sold family property to cover the hundreds of thousands of dollars needed for her two sons to study overseas. “I had to get my kids out of this education system which is all pressure and cheating,” she told AFP. When her sons -- who both now study in the UK - were attending state schools in Hanoi, Thu says she had to regularly miss work to take them to additional private classes held by poorly-paid state teachers. “Once, my son asked me why he never got the top score even though he performed better than his friend. I couldn’t explain that his friend’s mother took better care of the teacher, giving her much money,” she said. Vietnam’s Confucian lineage means education is something of a national obsession, but experts say schools are failing students, leaving parents desperate to get their children into western institutions that will give them the qualifications they need to find employment. Some 20,000 Vietnamese now study in Australia, 16,500 in the United States and 5,000 in the UK - small but significant numbers from a communist country where only the elite have traditionally had access to foreign education. Yet despite the increased exodus, foreign universities still remain out of reach for most families in Vietnam, where average per capita income is just over $1,500. Vietnam’s state education does score well in some indices - the country ranked 17th out of 65 for mathematics and science accord- Students from a local college pose during a graduation ceremony at the temple of literature, Vietnam’s first university, in Hanoi. ing to the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) chart, ahead of many wealthy western countries including the US. But top officials have warned these test results do not accurately reflect the quality of overall education in a nation where central control has cramped policy innovation. “We have to be honest and admit that if fully assessed, Vietnamese students’ capacity is still poor,” Nguyen Vinh Hien, deputy minister of education and training was quoted in Tuoi Tre newspaper in 2013. Four decades after the end of the Vietnam War in 1975, officials have yet to fully reform an education sector, which critics say still works to promote the Party rather than create skilled workers. Authorities have kept in place a system heavy on rote learning, regurgitation of facts to pass exams, and obedience to authority -- with little room for critical thinking. Students rely on outdated, leaden text books, cheating is routine in exams while underpaid teachers are renowned for withholding chunks of the syllabus to instead impart in private classes they can charge for. “University education is so bad. Text books are full of unnecessary, tedious theory,” former education minister Pham Minh Hac told AFP, warning that the books were so information-heavy they turned students off studying. With very few top-quality private schools in Vietnam, escaping the dysfunctional state edu- cation system is a priority the better off. “They have changed a lot in their thoughts, their lifestyle, their performance, behaviour and viewpoints,” businessman Nguyen Quang Thinh said of his two sons studying in the US at a cost of $40,000 a year. Lu Thi Hong Nham, director of study abroad consultancy firm Duc Anh added: “Many students were fed up when studying inside the country, but overseas they gained very good results.” Unless communist Vietnam is prepared to let the education system be run by experts not politicians, things are not going to change, renowned teaching expert Pham Toan warned. “You can do nothing... when education is in the communist party’s resolution,” he said, referring to a paper passed in 2013 that calls for a “comprehensive renovation” of the education system, without specifying changes. “I am truly desperate” with the system, he added. Indonesia reinstates local elections THE STRAITS TIMES Indonesia’s Parliament has reinstated direct local elections that allow voters to elect office-holders from district chiefs to provincial governors. The reversal came after MPs in the outgoing Parliament passed a Bill last September to scrap direct elections for local leaders in a move seen as a setback to Indonesia’s democratisation as well as to newly elected President Joko Widodo. Then president Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono came under fire because a walkout by MPs from his Democratic Party had allowed the legislation to go through. He issued an emergency decree - known as a perppu in short soon after, to cancel the controversial legislation. The move, allowed in the Indonesian system, sent the legislation back to Parliament, which voted yesterday to make the perppu a permanent law. Dr Yudhoyono took office in 2004 as the country’s first directly elected president. In 2005, direct elections were also held for district chiefs, city mayors and provincial governors across Indonesia. Until then, the office-holders were picked by the respective local assemblies and this, critics said, made them beholden to the assemblymen instead. Yesterday’s outcome was cheered by political analysts, including Arie Sudjito of the University of Gadjah Mada in Yogyakarta. “This is a victory of the people. It saves democracy,” Arie told tribunenews.com. Lawyer Teguh Santosa told The Straits Times: “The direct election system is the best choice. We have to guard this so it will always stay this way going forward. Don’t let anyone try to change it again.” Teguh and other observers also saw it as a political victory for Joko, whose Indonesian Democratic PartyStruggle does not command a majority in Parliament. The leaders of the main opposition parties - Gerindra and Golkar - said last month that they supported direct elections after the Democrats threatened to leave the opposition coalition. Under the just-ratified perppu, local elections must all be held simultaneously across Indonesia for efficiency. Those who want to contest the elections must be able to stand up to public scrutiny and pass tests for integrity before they can do so. After the vote, Speaker Setya Novanto pledged to revise clauses in the perppu that stipulate February as the month for simultaneous five-yearly direct elections to take place. The National Election Commission has proposed that all local elections be held at the same time in December this year. “The passing of the perppu is part of the success brought about by the people’s movement. When SBY (Dr Yudhoyono) issued the perppu, it was because of public pressure. People want to stick with direct elections,” Titi Anggraini, executive director of Perludem, a Jakarta-based think-tank that promotes fair elections and democracy, told The Straits Times. “Our next job now is to ensure that those candidates running in the elections are leaders who have quality and integrity.” AFP AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE Hanoi ASEAN+ 8 Vietnam sentences eight drug traffickers to death: state media AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE Hanoi A Vietnamese court has sentenced eight members of a smuggling gang to death for trafficking heroin and five others to life in prison, state media said Tuesday. The court in the northern province of Hoa Binh also jailed 17 other defendants -- all Vietnamese members of the same gang -- to between six and 20 years in prison after a two-week trial that ended Monday, the state-run Tuoi Tre newspaper said. The ring had smuggled more than 200 kilograms (440 pounds) of heroin into Vietnam before their arrest in 2011, the report said, without specifying where the heroin was sourced or how long the group had operated. Communist Vietnam has some of the world’s toughest anti-drug laws. Anyone found guilty of possessing more than 600 grams (21 ounces) of heroin, or more than 20 kilograms of opium, can face the death penalty. Convictions and sentences are usually revealed only by local media, which is strictly under state control. MYANMAR ELEVEN, Thursday, January 22, 2014 Thailand’s gay-friendly image ‘superficial’ amid discrimination DEUTSCHE PRESSE-AGENTUR DESPITE its gay-friendly image, conservative and Buddhist-majorityThailand is not always a welcoming place for the local lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) community. In the lively Silom district of central Bangkok, customers pile into a small, noisy gay bar on a busy Saturday night. Chakgai Jermkwan and his partner Sean L’Estrange co-own the popular venue, which is located on a narrow street lined with gay bars. The couple has been together for eight years and was legally married three years ago in Boston, Massachusetts. “We are a married couple in the US but here in Thailand, we are just two friends in the eye of the law,” Chakgai said. “If something bad happened to him tomorrow, I wouldn’t have a say in anything,” Sean added. “I would be nothing.” Thailand welcomes lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT)visitors: its tourism authority targets the LGBT market, and Bangkok is often the only Asian city included on lists of gay-friendly tourist destinations around the world. There is no law against homosexuality in Thailand, unlike in some other countries in the region. However, Thai society is less accepting of its own lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender communities. Among Thais between 15 and 24 years old, 56 per cent think homosexuality is wrong, according to recent research by Khon Thai Foundation, a non-profit organisation. By comparison, more than 70 per cent of young people in Japan, South Korea, the Philippines and western European countries think that homosexuality should be accepted by society at large, according to the Pew Research Centre, an American think-tank. In a country where nearly 95 per cent of people are Buddhists, some believe that gay or transgender people suffer from bad karma for committing adultery in their past lives. “I find it surprising that Thailand, being one of the most gay-friendly countries (for foreigners), does not have laws that support and protect the LGBT community,” said L’Estrange, an Irish-American who has lived in Thailand for almost 10 years. Thailand has no laws against discrimination toward LGBT people, and a recent surrogacy bill defines parents as members of heterosexual couples only. Same-sex marriage is neither licensed nor recognised.Although a partnership bill has been drafted and will be submitted to the parliament, gay rights activists have concerns about it. The Anjaree Group, Thailand’s largest lesbian and gay rights activist organisation, has criticised the bill for not granting homosexual couples the same rights as heterosexual couples. The proposed Civil Partnership Act includes the right to use one’s spouse’s surname, the right to end the partnership and property rights. But it also raises the age of legal consent from 17 to 20 and does not include joint adoption or parental rights. Transgenders, locally referred to as “kathoey,” are more common in Thailand than perhaps in any other country in the world, but they too complain of discrimination. It is estimated that 1 in 166 men in Thailand is kathoey, compared to1 in 2,500 in the United States, according to research by the University of Hong Kong. It was not until 2011 that the Ministry of Defence stopped classifying kathoey - men living as women, not limited to those who have undergone gender reassignment surgery - as people with permanent psychological problems. Again, the legal framework seems to lag behind. Transgender females are still identified as male in their passports, for instance, although there have been hints that kathoey may get formal recognition under the country’s next constitution. “Society seems to have space for transgenders (only) specific to the entertainment and tourism industry,” said Kath Khangpiboon, the only transgender lecturer at Bangkok’s Thammasat University. “I am very fortunate that the university considered me for my ability, but most transgenders do not get that chance,” said the social welfare professor. “I have heard many stories of employers telling transgender women to go cut their hair or dress like a man in order to get the job.” “The country’s liberal image is superficial,” she said. Changing image into reality may require a more concerted effort from the authorities and the LGBT community. “There are no openly gay people in high-ranking offices who can influence the change in both law and attitude,” said Suppakorn Chudabala, a gay rights researcher. “The local LGBT community needs to be more active as well.” Kertchoke Kasemwongjit, from the Ministry of Justice, the head of the team drafting the same-sex partnership bill, agrees that more activism is needed. “We need more support from LGBT people to implement changes in the law,” he said.”The first step in advocating for LGBT rights is to educate people that being homosexual or transsexual is not wrong,” Suppakorn said. “People need to stop thinking that heterosexual is a norm and understand that sexuality is diverse.” “We are not asking for any privileges,” said Chakgai, the bar owner. “We just want to be treated equally, like everyone else.” Doomed AirAsia jet’s climb echoes Air France disaster Revelations that AirAsia Flight QZ8501 climbed too fast before stalling and plunging into the sea point to “striking” similarities between the Java Sea accident and the 2009 crash of an Air France jet, analysts said Wednesday. Indonesian Transport Minister Ignasius Jonan said the Airbus A320-200 was ascending at a rate of 6,000 feet (1,800 metres) a minute before stalling, as it flew in stormy weather last month from Indonesia’s Surabaya to Singapore. “In the final minutes, the plane climbed at a speed which was beyond normal,” he told reporters Tuesday. That ascent is about two to three times the normal climb rate for a commercial jetliner, according to experts. Indonesian divers recovered the plane’s black boxes a week ago, after an arduous search for the jet that crashed on December 28 with 162 people on board. The cockpit voice recorder and the flight data recorder are now being analysed, with a preliminary report due next week. While they stressed the difficulty of drawing conclusions without seeing the full black box AFP AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE A member of search and rescue team walks past wreckage of AirAsia recovered at sea and stored in a warehouse for investigators. data, analysts said the accident had strong echoes of the crash of Air France flight 447 into the Atlantic in 2009, with the loss of 228 lives. “The similarities are pretty striking,” Daniel Tsang, founder of Hong Kong-based consultancy Aspire Aviation, told AFP. In that case, the Airbus A330 en route from Rio to Paris vanished at night during a storm. The aircraft’s speed sensors were found to have malfunctioned, and the plane climbed too steeply, causing it to stall. As with the AirAsia disaster, the accident happened in what is known as the “intertropical convergence zone”, an area around the equator where the north and south trade winds meet, and thunderstorms are common. MYANMAR ELEVEN, Thursday, January 22, 2014 9 ASEAN+ Appetite for luxury wanes in China CHINA DAILY SALES of luxury goods slowed in China during 2014, with the growth rates falling for the first time amid slowing economic growth and brand proliferation, a new study said on Tuesday. China’s luxury market is undergoing a fundamental shift, brought on by evolving customer dynamics, an influx of new, emerging luxury brands, and an economic slowdown, said the study released by global consultancy firm Bain & Co. Based on a survey of 1,400 respondents across China, Bain said shoppers spent around 380 billion yuan ($61.13 billion) on luxury products worldwide in 2014, up 9 per cent year-on-year. Of this, about 30 per cent of the purchases were made within China from brick-and-mortar stores and online shops. However, the total consumption fell by 1 per cent on a year-onyear basis to 115 billion yuan, marking the first time that the domestic luxury market has shown such low growth numbers. Among luxury goods, watch sales fell by 13 per cent, the biggest among all categories, while men’s wear purchases declined by 10 per cent during the same period, particularly at premium price points. Leather goods sales remained flat for most of last year. The slump in luxury goods sales are primarily a result of the ongoing anti-corruption and fru- gality campaigns, factors that have undermined luxury gifting, said Bruno Lannes, a partner with Bain. Though jewellery sales showed a 2 per cent growth in 2014, the sale of high-end products especially for women fell sharply. The growth in mid-level product sales, however, helped offset the weakness in higherend products, said Lannes. Last year also saw the highest number of store closings by luxury brands in China, with men’s categories being the most affected, he said. Hugo Boss closed seven stores in China and Zegna six. Most of the well-established brands remained conservative on new store openings after wit- Vangvieng tourism bounces back nessing a decline in like-for-like sales. Emerging brands, on the other hand, were more aggressive in new store openings, the report said. More than 80 per cent of the respondents said they were more interested in emerging luxury brands and styles, with 44 per cent keen on buying more emerging brands in the next three years. This is largely because the Chinese consumers are becoming more sophisticated, better informed and weighing purchase decisions on the design of the products, said Lannes. Brands such as Balenciaga, Michael Kors and Jimmy Choo are gaining more popularity with Chinese consumers, the report said. VIENTIANE TIMES Rolexes fly off Singapore shelves as Swiss franc surges AFP A man walks in front of the Rolex watch retail shop at a shopping mall in Singapore. AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE Rolexes and other Swiss luxury watches are flying off the shelves in Singapore after the Swiss franc surged against other currencies, retailers said Tuesday. Enthusiasts and investors are splurging on the fine timepieces before retailers adjust their price tags to reflect the strengthening franc. The franc has shot up 20 per cent against the euro and the US dollar since Thursday after the Swiss central bank stunned global markets with its bombshell decision to abandon the minimum rate of 1.20 francs against the European common currency. Sales staff at Singapore luxury watch retailer The Hour Glass told AFP they had experienced an increase in sales of Swiss brands, with Rolexes thriving in particular. Most of its retail outlets located along Orchard Road, Singapore’s main shopping district, sold 25-30 Rolex watches a day on Saturday and Sunday, compared to the usual four to five daily. Among the favourites were entry-level models costing upwards of Sg$10,000 ($7,500). One Rolex retailer located at a five-star hotel told AFP that Datejust and GMT Rolex models sold briskly and stocks were thinning. Another shop at a high-end shopping mall along Orchard Road sold 10 Franck Muller watches per day over the weekend, a sharp increase over its usual one or two, sales staff said. Vietnam prioritises co-operation with Japan VIET NAM NEWS Vietnam hopes to further deepen its friendship and multidimensional co-operation with Japan, and considers doing so one of its top foreign affairs pri- orities, deputy prime minister Hoang Trung Hai yesterday told Katayama Satsuki, chairwoman of the Japanese Committee for Foreign Affairs and Defence. While noting that the two countries lifted their relations to a bilateral strategic partnership for peace and prosperity in Asia in March 2014, Hai thanked Japan for its support over the last two decades on many significant projects. Satsuki said she hoped the “The buyers are aware that retailers would soon raise the prices of our Swiss models,” a watch store manager told AFP on condition of anonymity. “About half of our customers enquire when it will happen and many are willing to make purchases in anticipation of this price rise.” Affluent Singapore has a per capita income of $55,230, one of the highest in the world, and is also a key shopping destination in the region. Vietnamese government would help Japanese companies invest and operate in Vietnam. She also said Japan would always support Vietnam’s implementation of economic co-operation pacts, including infrastructure and energy projects, and would continue to be a ODA provider for Vietnam. The popular tourist destination of Vangvieng district, Vientiane province, is eyeing revenue growth of 5-6 percent this year thanks to returning backpackers and an increasing number of high-end tourists. In 2013-14, tourism income reached 15 billion kip, an increase of 10 percent over 2011-12, the year when many entertainment venues along the Nam Xong river were closed down by authorities, Head of the Vangvieng district Tourism Department, Bounmy Phommasa, reported recently. He pointed out that actual tourism revenue was higher than the department’s estimate of 13 billion kip. The district’s tourism sector can thank the growing number of tour groups from Asia for the increase, with more Koreans, Chinese, and Thai visitors coming to the town. Korean tourist numbers especially have increased, up by 60 per cent in 2014 and 30 per cent in 2013. European visitors were also up 45 percent and those from other countries 10 percent, which shows the town’s tourism industry is springing back to life. Bounmy believes the surge in the number of Korean visitors can be put down to their love of nature and interest in the local culture and lifestyle. They are also good word-of-mouth promoters of the town as they tell their friends about the enjoyable experience upon their return home. The department expects a continuous flow of Korean visitors this year as they don’t require a Lao entry visa and can take a direct flight from Seoul to Vientiane. He said more tourists from China were expected next month during the Chinese New Year holiday. As tourism picks up, Bounmy said the department would work to improve services and tourist attractions, as well as allowing more restaurants to open along the Nam Song River. The department is also planning to open a zip-line at Tham Lom cave, to go along with other adventure activities such as tubing, kayaking, climbing, cycling, trekking, boat riding and quad bike riding. These activities will increase the number of attractions on offer, helping to draw even more tourists to Vangvieng and boost business in the years ahead. LIFESTYLE 10 MYANMAR ELEVEN, Thursday, January 22, 2014 A Yine plays Ko Tint in 'Ko Tint Doe' Super Yatkwat'. Foreign tourists stunned by marvels of the Mergui Ye Myint Win MYANMAR ELEVEN Kawthaung stood many aspects [of the filming] exception one thing: we just started to use HD cameras so we needed to cope with the technical differences that had arisen in like the camera frame and the frame that will appear on the big screen. The rest was okay. In the scenes with costars and film stars, there were many people but everything was fine. Except for the tempo of the plot, all of the characters are active people. They had to portray what’s happening in the ward. This is one of the advantages. MYANMAR ELEVEN WITH his extensive background as a noted “anyeint” (a comedic show combining jokes, music and dance) comedian, A Yine has appeared in countless entertaining capers as one of the most sought-after comedic actors for many years. In “Ko Tint Doe’ Super Yatkwat” (“The Super Ward of Ko Tint”), the veteran actor takes on the lead role as Ko Tint, a famous character in a popular comic book series of the same name that is being adapted for the big screen. In this exclusive interview with the Myanmar Eleven, the comedian relates how he’s maintained his stellar career through the decades. ■ How did you come to play in “Ko Tint Doe’ Super Yatkwat” (“The Super Ward of Ko Tint”)? After playing the character of Ko Tint in eight direct-to-home videos, I had a discussion with Ko Moe Oo (Kyaw Zaw Linn) to bring this comic book series to the big screen. When I want to offer something that the audience likes and is satisfied with, I want them to have a sense of longing for more. I don’t like showing the same thing over and over again. I always think about presenting a new version of the art [form] that the audience likes. When we started thinking about making a film about Ko Tint, we talked about using popular film stars to play the residents of Ko Tint’s ward. We asked for their help when we started planning the film. At that time, all the film stars told us that they would happily take part in the film without taking any fees. After negotiating with them, we had to negotiate with Ko Shwe Htoo [the comic book’s artist] and Wai Thar [the novelist]. It took a year just for planning. Only then can we start the filming. ■ Were there any difficulties during the filming given that there were many film stars in it? There weren’t many difficulties. Back in the days we used film, Ko Moe Oo has plenty of experience of making notes as he is from the A-One family. We also have extensive experience gained from having worked with veteran film directors like Ko Wunna and U Aung Myint Myat. So we under- ■ When the film debuted in cinemas, it has broken a new record since so many people came to watch it. How do you feel about this? I’m happy and overjoyed because I play the lead role in the film and I have never obtained that level of success even though I’ve been working in the film industry for a long time now. This film has not only set a new record, but also offered new ways to fulfill the needs of the film industry. You can say a new method has come up for the people working in the film industry. We now know that the audience will accept any film as long as it’s close to reality – whether a drama, a romantic comedy or a family film. We’re happy to learn how to create such kind of films about what’s happening in real life with a much less budget. ■ Will there be a sequel? I’m still thinking about it. I’m satisfied that we could give full entertainment to the audience. I’m very satisfied that they went home with lots of happiness after watching the film. But I don’t want to eat the same delicious snack over and over again. We’re thinking about how to present this in a new style. Maybe we will make this into a TV series. We’re also thinking about doing another comedy film with a strong plot. ■ Does this film mark a turning point in your career? Yes, you can say so. I was so successful [as a comedian] of Anyeint that I ended up in jail. I was able to speak on behalf of the audience. I was able to use my comedy routines to aid the reform of the country. By that time think I had gone past my turning point. Even now, I’m trying to revive the art form at Anawmar Thukhuma Tabin. In the direct-to-home video, I wrote the script for “Hnin Si Wine” (“Rose Wine”). I also wrote the script for “A Kywan Tawin” (“Intimately”) with the late actor Ko Thar Gyi (aka Dway). The audience recognised my efforts. When I was writing the script for “Hnin Si Wine”, I’d just graduated from university. So I wrote about all the pranks I’d been pulling back in my university days. It was a very fun script to write. In “Ko Tint Doe’ Super Yatkwat”, I got to play the lead role. It was a big success so you can say this is another turning point for me. EMG Myanmar’s king of laughs Holidaymakers from the Bahamas’ cruise ship Ms the World visited Makyonegalet Island, home to the Salone tribe, as part of their tour of the Mergui Archipelago earlier this month. After a trip to Lanpi Island, more than 80 tourists landed on Makyonegalet Island through dinghies and made donations to the island community. The villagers staged a ritualistic performance known as “nat pwe” in return, according to the Hotels and Tourism Development Department (HTDD) in Kawthaung District. On the island, they checked out the Salone’s tradition boats, visited the local school and monastery, said Hlwan Moe, HTDD’s Assistant Director. Makyonegalet Island village is a scenic spot with a monastery at the front end, a school in the centre and a traditional dockyard on the edge of the village. Next to the village is a hill with an observation platform, which affords a panoramic view of the village and other outlying islands. Passengers from the cruise ship MS the World tour several islands of Myanmar’s Mergui Archipelago. Tribute album celebrates Aung San’s birth centenary Bo Bo Music Production has released a tribute album to Gen (Bogyoke) Aung San to celebrate his birth centenary and legacy. “The tribute songs to Bogyoke that were added to last year’s Art of Freedom Film and Music Festival didn’t reach the public as we had intended. As the centennial of his birth falls on this year, we’re going to release the award-winning songs and six other songs on the shortlist from a music contest. We will try to release the music videos before his birthday,” said Zarganar, director of the Aung San tribute album project. Held last year as part of the Art of Freedom Film and Music Festival, the music contest sought to find the best tribute songs to the independence hero in three categories: traditional, modern and rap. Four awards including People’s Choice were handed out. The tribute album features 10 songs including the four winning songs and six tunes from the shortlist.
© Copyright 2024