Janua r y 2 2
14.45 - 15.30 Refreshments
Plenary Session – Kino Room
15:30 - 15:35 Opening Remarks
15:35 - 15:55 Report Presentation EU Key Energy Indicators. Current Trends and EU 2030 Objectives Assessment
15:55 - 17:10 Plenary Session The Common EU Energy Policy: Wishful Thinking or Reality?
17:10 - 17:40 Coffee Break
Renewables and Environment – Room 6.30
17:40 - 17:50 Film presentation “CO2 emissions bury the UN summit” commissioned by the World
Business Council for Sustainable Development and produced by Carbon Visual
17:50 - 18:50 Discussion Panel Clean Coal Technologies - Prospects for Development
18:50 - 19:00 Break
19:00 - 20:00 Discussion Panel How Much Will the Climate Package Cost
20:00 - 20:20 Presentation The Strategy for the Energy Effectiveness in a Global and Local Context
Investments and Energy Security – Room 6.31
17.20 - 17.35 Lecture Regional Operational Programs vs. 2014 - 2020 Energy Sector Financial Perspective
17:40 - 18:50 Discussion Panel Civic Energy and Competitiveness
18:50 - 19:00 Break
19:00 - 20:10 Discussion Panel Competitiveness on the Power Market
Exploration and Production – Room 6.33
17:40 - 18:50 Discussion Panel The Geopolitical Importance of the Aegean - Baltic Energy Interconnection
18:50 - 19:00 Break
19:00 - 20:00 Discussion Panel International Financial Institutions and their Role in Energy Projects
in CEE
20:00 - 20:20 Presentation Energy-Efficient Buildings – Definition and Simulation Occupant Behavior in Buildings
20:30 - 21:30 Energy Forum Awards Ceremony and Concert
21:30 Reception Room 7/38, Level 7
Janua r y 2 3
Renewables and Environment – Room 6.30
9:00 - 10:00 Discussion Panel Energy Effect Agreement Code of Conduct in “Transperense” Project
10:00 - 10:10 Coffee Break
10:10 - 11:10 Discussion Panel Innovations in Renewables – Investment Costs Versus Future Profits
11:10 - 11:20 Coffee Break
11:20 - 12:20 Discussion Panel Waste-to-Energy Projects - Eco-Friendly or Just Economy?
12:20 - 12:30 Coffee Break
12:30 - 13:40 Thematic block Wind Farms in Central and Eastern Europe
13:40 - 14:40 Lunch Room 7/38, Level 7
14:40 - 15:40 Discussion Panel EU Climate Package 2030 and its Impact on the European Industry
15:40 - 15:50 Coffee Break
15:50 - 16:50 Discussion Panel Low Emissions Policy – at What Price?
16:50 - 17:00 Coffee Break
17:00 - 18:15 Discussion Panel Smart Cities – Investment for the Future Generations
18:15 - 18:30 Presentation Samsoe – the Danish Renewable Energy Island
20:00 Reception Room 7/38, Level 7
Investments and Energy Security – Room 6.31
9:00 - 10:00 Discussion Panel The Electricity Market. New Challenges for the CEE Countries
10:00 - 10:10 Coffee Break
10:10 - 11:10 Discussion Panel Risk Management in the Energy and Resources Industry. How to
Succeed?
11:10 - 11:20 Coffee Break
11:20 - 12:20 Discussion Panel The Rule of Law in the International Energy Policy – the Role of
International Treaties and Agreements
12:20 - 12:30 Coffee Break
12:30 - 13:40 Discussion Panel Perfect Balance - In Search of an Optimal Energy Mix
13:40 - 14:40 Lunch Room 7/38, Level 7
14:40 - 15:40 Discussion Panel Together or Alone? Towards Energy Security in Europe
15:40 - 15:50 Coffee Break
Janua r y 2 3
15:50 - 16:50 Discussion Panel R&D and Innovation in the Energy Sector: a Treasure Trove for Industry and other Stakeholders
16:50 - 17:00 Coffee Break
17:00 - 17:20 Presentation Doing Energy Business in Kazachstan
17:30 - 18:30 Discussion Panel Energy as an Integrating Factor
20:00 Reception Room 7/38, Level 7
Exploration and Production – Room 6.33
9:00 - 10:00 Discussion Panel Shale Gas – a Chance or an Illusion?
10:00 - 10:10 Coffee Break
10:10 - 11:10 Discussion Panel Nuclear Energy in Europe – How Much Politics, How Much Economy?
11:10 - 11:20 Coffee Break
11:20 - 12:20 Discussion Panel Mining Industry Restructuring in Central Europe: A Mission Impossible?
12:20 - 12:30 Coffee Break
12:30 - 13:40 Discussion Panel Infrastructure and Investments in the Energy Sektor
13:40 - 14:40 Lunch Reception Room 7/38, Level 7
15.20 – 15.25 Break
15.25 - 15.40 Presentation India’s Quest for ‘Power for All’: Lessons for Europe
15.40 - 15.50 Break
15:50 - 16:50 Thematic block Connecting Europe’s Energy Corridors: Political Premises and Business Opportunities
16:50 - 17:00 Coffee Break
17:00 - 18:30 Thematic block Challenges for the European Gas Market
17:00 - 17:45 Discussion Panel Challenges for the European Gas Market
17:45 - 18:30 Discussion Panel Innovations in the Gas Industry: Current Situation and Future Trends
20:00 Reception Room 7/38, Level 7
Janua r y 2 4
Investments and Energy Security – Room 6.31
8:30 - 9:00 Coffee Break
9:00 - 9:20 Presentation Local energy system using geothermal and geothermic energy in the holiday mountain resort
9:20 - 9:30 Presentation Renewable energy in the context of implementation opportunity in Lower
Silesia
9:30 - 9:40 Break
9:40 - 10:40 Closing Session Energy Storage Options for Future Sustain able Energy Systems
Programme
Januar y 22
12
Plenary Session
14:45 - 15:30 R efreshments
15:30 - 15:35 O pening R emarks
Speakers:
• Cezary Przybylski, Marshal, Dolnoslaskie Region’s Marshal’s Office, Poland
• Radosław Jecek, Mayor, City Hall of Karpacz, Poland
• Zygmunt Berdychowski, Chairman of the Economic Forum Programme
Council, Institute for Eastern Studies, Poland
15:35 - 15:55 R eport P resentation
EU Key Energy Indicators. Current Trends
and EU 2030 Objectives Assessment
Key Energy Indicators are shaken with fluctuant economic and political conditions. Nevertheless, medium
and long term trends depend mostly on market fundamentals and structural decisions and policies. CO2
emissions, energy mix, renewables, energy efficiency… :
Where do we stand early 2015 ?
How can we assess EU 2020 trends and 2030 objectives ?
P a r t n e r : Enerdata
Moderator:
• Pascal Charriau, CEO, Enerdata, France
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 22
13
Plenary Session
15:55 - 17:10 P lenar y S ession
The Common EU Energy Policy: Wishful
Thinking or Reality?
In the face of the crisis in Ukraine EU members realised that a common approach to it is needed as geopolitical threats can weigh on their future. So perhaps there is also hope for the successful implementation of a
common energy policy that will make EU resistant to pressure from outside? So far, divergent interests of
individual member states, as well as activities of the climate lobby kept delaying its introduction. Perhaps in
the new political situation we will finally manage to build a solidarity mechanism in the event of a disruption of supplies, make any necessary infrastructure upgrades, step up shale gas exploration efforts, reestablish the dignity of coal and introduce a policy of joint power purchase.
Moderator:
• Boguslaw Chrabota, Editor-in-Chief, “Rzeczpospolita” daily, Poland
Speakers:
• Selim Kuneralp, Deputy Secretary General, Energy Charter Secretariat,
Brussels
• Marcin Moskalewicz, President of the Board, PERN „Przyjaźń” S.A., Poland
• Soren Mouritsen, CEO, ROMO Wind, Switzerland
• Herbert Wirth, President & CEO , KGHM Polska Miedź S.A., Poland
• Christopher Huhne, Chairman, Europe, Zilkha Biomass Energy, United
Kingdom
• Ireneusz Lazor, President of the Management Board, Polish Power Exchange, Poland
17:10 - 17:40 Coff E e B reak
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 22
14
Renewables and Environment
17:40 - 17:50 F ilm presentation
“CO2 emissions bury the UN summit” commissioned by the World Business Council
for Sustainable Development and produced by Carbon Visuals
17:50 - 18:50 discussion panel
Clean Coal Technologies - Prospects for
Development
Coal has been and for many years will remain one of the most important energy resources and the base
component of energy security in many countries, including Poland. However, traditional coal-based technologies do not make the most of “black gold” – especially in terms of energy efficiency potential and environmental challenges. New, so called clean coal technologies should lead to more efficient combustion of
coal with reduced emissions - perhaps even elimination - of greenhouse gases. What are the short, medium
and long term perspectives for clean coal technologies? What is the Polish experience in this respect? What
lies beneath mysteriously looking acronyms like: IGCC, DCFC, SCR, CCS or USPC?
Moderator:
• Aleksander Sobolewski, Director, Institute for Chemical Processing of Coal,
Poland
Speakers:
• Olivier Guillon, Director, Institute of Energy and Climate Research, Research Centre Juelich, Germany
• Zbigniew Kasztelewicz, Head of Surface Mining Departament, AGH University of Science and Technology in Cracow, Poland
• Tomoho Umeda, Member of the Borad, YOHO Sp. z o.o., Japan
• Vladimir Zuberec, Policy Officer, Directorate-General for Energy, EC , Slovakia
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 22
15
Renewables and Environment
18:50 - 19:00 B reak
19:00 - 20:00 discussion panel
How Much Will the Climate Package Cost?
The European Union will reduce CO2 emissions by at least 40 percent by 2030 relative to 1990 and will
increase the share of renewables to 27 percent. Besides that, less wealthy EU countries, including Poland,
will not bear the costs of ambitious climate policy on a par with the rich states - these are the main points of
the compromise reached by EU leaders at the EU summit in October. The climate and energy package still
arouses controversy. The dividing line is the impact of energy policy on the competitiveness of EU economies and the cost of energy transformation.
Moderator:
• Edwin Bendyk, Head of the Research Departament, “Polityka” weekly, Poland
Speaker:
• Gabor Baranyai, Ministerial Commissioner, Ministry of Justice, Hungary
• Jaroslaw Gowin, Member, Parlament, Poland
• Cezary Lejkowski, Director of Climate and Energy Development,
Wrocławskie Centrum Badań EIT+ Sp. z o.o., Poland
• Konrad Szymanski, Member, Law and Justice Party, Poland
• Jadwiga Wisniewska, Member, European Parliament, Poland
20:00 - 20:20 presentation
The Strategy for the Energy Effectiveness
in a Global and Local Context
Speaker:
• Günter Schlagowski, Owner, Nestwärme-Gruppe Dipl. Ing. Günter
Schlagowski, Germany
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 22
16
Investments and Energy Security
17.20 - 17.35 L E C T U R E
Regional Operational Programs vs. 2014 2020 Energy Sector Financial Perspective
In the years 2014-2020, regional governments will manage approximately 40 percent funds from cohesion
policy – it is over 31 billion euro. They will invest the money within the regional operational programs. According to the draft of the Partnership Agreement, in order to reduce the emissivity of the economy (CO2),
activities that increase the energy efficiency of the economy will be supported, in particular: energy efficiency (public and residential buildings, businesses sector, municipal infrastructure), the effective transmission
(smart grid, heating network), effective production (cogeneration).
Moderator:
• Jan Cienski, Journalist, “The Economist”, United Kingdom
Speaker:
• Marceli Niezgoda, Undersecretary of State, Ministry of Infrastructure and
Development, Poland
17:40 - 18:50 discussion panel
Civic Energy and Competitiveness
The aim of the debate is to try answer the question about how the civic energy sector might influence the
competitiveness of the Polish economy. Can the civic energy sector become a driving force of Polish innovations? It is vital to determine the impact of the prosumer energy generation on the local development,
especially in the context of creating new jobs, increasing energy efficiency and energy security (distributed
generation). It is also necessary to set up the regulatory environment, including barriers that hamper the
development of the civic energy sector, and to identify mechanisms shaping that environment. The issue is
also to be discussed what would be the model of collaboration between large-scale energy producers and
prosumers and what financial instruments can support its development.
Moderator:
• Jerzy Spyrka, CEO, Photovoltaik Solar Polska Sp. z o.o., Poland
Speakers:
• Johannes Lackmann, Managing Director, Lackmann Phymetric, Germany
• Maiusz Ruszel, Delegate, Chancellery of the President of the Republic of
Poland, Poland
• Jan Wiater, Expert, National Fund for Environmental Protection and Water
Management, Poland
• Adam Olszewski, Head of Innovation Departament, ENERGA-OPERATOR
SA, Polska
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 22
17
Investments and Energy Security
18:50 - 19:00 B reak
19:00 - 20:10 discussion panel
Competitiveness on the Power Market
The dynamic growth of the market results in strong competition. Is there only room for large companies in
the electricity sector or is it possible for small and medium-sized enterprises to succeed there? What to do in
order to be more competitive in thepower market? How to invest to make a profit and to bring benefits to
customers? What do buyers expect from power traders “How can their needs be met?”
Moderator:
• Grzegorz Onichimowski, Business Development, EnerNOC, Inc., Poland
Speakers:
• David Kucera, Secretary General, Power Exchange Central Europe, Czech
Republic
• Aleksander Grad, Vice-President of the Management Board, Tauron Polish
Energy SA, Poland
• Wolfgang Krewel, Director Strategy & Marketing, Alstom Grid, Germany
• Grzegorz Cydejko, Senior Staff Writer, Forbes, Poland
• Jaroslaw Wajer, Partner, EY, Poland
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 22
18
Exploration and Production
17:40 - 18:50 discussion panel
The Geopolitical Importance of the Aegean - Baltic Energy Interconnection
The crisis in Ukraine has reconfirmed the need for a common European approach on energy security. The
development of energy infrastructure within the EU makes it possible for Central Europe to benefit from
diverse sources and routes, thus increasing the energy security. In 2014 in Budapest (Hungary) and later in
Narva (Estonia) foreign ministers discussed the concept of the Aegean-Baltic Energy Interconnection. The
goal of the corridor would be to create a robust energy infrastructure on the Eastern side of the EU which
would also be connected with the Southern Corridor. The recent developments in Lithuania (the Independence LNG) underline the raison d’être of this very concept. The panel aims to broaden the discussion and
confront a variety of point of views.
P a r t n e r : Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade of Hungary
Moderator:
• Andras Szorenyi, Senior Advisor on Energy Security, Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade of Hungary
Speakers:
• Grzegorz Zielinski, European Bank for Reconstruction and Development,
Poland
• Lachezar Matev, Ambassador-at-Large for Energy, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Bulgaria
• Nolan Theisen, Natural Gas Analyst, Regional Centre for Energy Policy Research, Hungary
• Ilian Vassilev, Managing Partner, Innovative Energy Solutions Ltd., Bulgaria
18:50 - 19:00 B reak
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 22
19
Exploration and Production
19:00 - 20:00 discussion panel
International Financial Institutions and
their Role in Energy Projects in CEE
International Financial Institutions are playing an important role in financing energy projects in CEE. However, we should still consider whether their role in financing renewable energy and energy efficiency in the
region is sufficient, and whether IFI could do more to promote transition to an energy efficient and low
carbon economy despite growing doubts over continuing political support for RE projects.
Moderator:
• Jan Cienski, Journalist, “The Economist”, United Kingdom
Speakers:
• Ana Maria Mihaescu, Regional Manager for Romania, Bulgaria, Czech Republic, Hungary, Moldova, Poland and Slovakia, International Finance Corporation, Romania
• Szymon Ostrowski, Deputy Head of CEE Corporate and Investment Banking, Industrial and Commercial Bank of China ICBC, Poland
• Yngve Soderlund, Senior Manager, Nordic Investment Bank, Finland
• Beata Szydlo, Member, Vice-Chairperson of the Committeee on Public Finances, Parliament, Poland
20:00 - 20:20 presentation
Energy-Efficient Buildings
Energy related occupant behavior in buildings is a key issue for building design optimization, energy diagnosis and performance evaluation due to its significant impact on real energy use and indoor environmental quality in buildings. However the influence of occupant behavior is under-recognized or over-simplified
in the design, construction, operation, and retrofit of buildings. Occupant behavior is complex, stochastic
and multi-disciplinary. Having a deep understanding of occupant behavior and being able to model and
quantify its impact on use of building technologies and energy performance of buildings is crucial in the
design process and usage of low energy buildings.
Speakers:
• Khee Poh Lam, Profesor, Carnegie Mellon University School of Architecture,
USA
20:30 - 21:00
Energy Forum Awards Ceremony
and Concert
21:00
R eception
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
20
9:00 - 10:00
Renewables and Environment
discussion panel
Energy Effect Agreement Code of Conduct
in “Transperense” Project
The Energy Efficiency Directive 2012/27/EU obliges Member States to renovate public buildings, to introduce energy efficiency obligations and to establish financing facilities for energy efficiency measures. The
binding measures contained within the Energy Efficiency Directive require considerable investment by
Member States at an early stage. Experience has demonstrated that Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) can
be used to yield energy savings in the public sector; the main features of Energy Efficiency PPPs are similar
to those of accommodation PPPs. They use Energy Performance Contracts (EPCs) and the private partners
in these arrangements are known as Energy Service Companies (ESCOs). The panel discussion shall focus
on the major challenges in Energy Performance Contracting.
P a r t n e r : Institute for Public Private Partnership
Moderator:
• Bostjan Ferk, Founder and Managing Director, Institute for Public Private
Partnership, Slovenia
Speakers:
• David Hirst, Director, EY UK, United Kingdom
• Christian Panzer, Corporate Development Specialist, Wien Energie GmbH,
Austria
• Jacek Rynski, President of the Board, Polski Solar S.A., Poland
• Erwin Solleder, Head of Energy & Environment, Kommunalkredit Austria
AG, Austria
• Zbigniew Szpak, Chairman of the Board, Polish National Energy Conservation Agency, Poland
10:00 - 10:10 Coffee B reak
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
21
Renewables and Environment
10:10 - 11:10 discussion panel
Innovations in Renewables – Investment
Costs Versus Future Profits
Any investment in renewables, whether it is a micro-installation or a regular power plant, requires funding
from a banking institution or a entrepreneur. However, both entrepreneurs and banks are afraid today of
long-term investments, as they are not able to guarantee sales volumes and green certificates on predictable terms. Therefore, the question is whether, and for whom, such investments are profitable today, and
how the new regulations will unlock the market in order to encourage long-term investments.
Special Guest:
• Jerzy Witold Pietrewicz, Secretary of State, Ministry of Economy, Poland
Moderator:
• Pawel Kuglarz, Partner, WOLF THEISS P. Daszkowski, Poland
Speakers:
• Rut Bizkova, Chairwoman, Technology Agency of the Czech Republic
(TACR), Czech Republic
• Agnieszka Jasiowka, Director, Malopolska Regional Development Agency
(MARR SA), Poland
• Christian Labie, Director, RAEE-Rhônalpénergie-Environnement, France
• Mieczysław Ciurla, Head of the Economy Department, Dolnoslaskie Region, Poland
11:10 - 11:20 Coffee B reak
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
22
Renewables and Environment
11:20 - 12:20 discussion panel
Waste-to-Energy Projects - Eco-Friendly or
Just Economy?
In last years, we have been observing in Poland an increased interest in waste-to-energy projects. Several
municipal waste incinerators are being constructed right now. Apart from this, we must take into consideration the existing systems, used by energy-intensive industries producing construction materials. The panel
will try to answer the question whether the increasing number waste-to-energy projects are motivated by
ecological reasons, or perhaps it is just a good, economically well-founded and profitable business. Waste
has become a major problem in modern society. Is there a chance, that new technologies will transform it
into a valuable source of cheap energy?
Moderator:
• Magdalena Rogulska, Senior Researcher, Swedish-Polish Sustainable Energy Platform, Poland
Special Guest:
• Janusz Ostapiuk, Undersecretary of State, Ministry of Environment, Poland
Speakers:
• Johan Bonnier, Member, CEWEP - Confederation of European Waste-toEnergy Plants, Belgium
• David Dornbusch, President, CleanTuesday, France
• Anna Larsson, Market Director for Poland, Green Business Norway, Norway
12:20 - 12:30 Coffee B reak
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
23
Renewables and Environment
12:30 - 13:40 T hematic block
Wi n d Fa r m s i n Ce n t ra l a n d Ea s te r n Eu r o p e
According to the Energy and Climate Package imposed by the European Commission on its member states,
Poland is required (by 2020) to produce 15% of energy in the national energy balance from renewable
sources (of which 1/3 produced by wind turbines). This means that Poland has to almost quadruple the
installed capacity of wind power by 2020. As the development potential of wind energy in Poland is considered high the crucial question of the discussion is how this development should be conducted on an equal
footing with regard to economic, social and environmental factors.
P a r t n e r : CJR WIND
12:30 - 12:40 presentation
CJR Wind, Wind farms construction in Eastern and Central Europe
Moderator:
• Paulo Silva, General Manager , CJR Renewables / CJR Wind, Portugal
12:40 - 13:40 discussion panel
Wind farms in Eastern and Central Europe
Moderator:
• Marcello Deplano, Energy & Sustainability Lead for Poland, Accenture, Poland
Speakers:
• Joachim Binotsch, General Manager and Owner, BBB Environment Technology, Germany
• Stefan Hain, President of the Board, Proxy, WSB Neue Energien Holding
GmbH, WSB Parki Wiatrowe Sp. z o.o., Germany
• Paulo Silva, General Manager, CJR Renewables / CJR Wind, Portugal
• Dariusz Mikielewicz, Professor, Gdansk University of Technology, Poland
• Soren Mouritsen, CEO, ROMO Wind, Switzerland
• Anna Zalewska, Member, Parliament, Poland
13:40 - 14:40 LU N C H
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
24
Renewables and Environment
14:40 - 15:40 discussion panel
EU Climate Package 2030 and its Impact on
the European Industry
The implementation of the EU’s Climate and Energy Package is strictly connected with attempts to establish
a new worldwide contract about climate protection and greenhouse gases emission reduction. This policy
framework aims to make the EU’s economy and energy system competitive and secure. The transition to a
low-carbon economy is crucial for the project of reindustrialising Europe and it needs greater mobilisation
of the European budget and the EU’s financial instruments.
P a r t n e r : Baker & McKenzie
Moderator:
• Peter Olajos, Vice President, SME Europe, Hungary
Speakers:
• Kevin Welch, Senior Vice President Strategy, Innovation and Environmental
Responsibility Energy Europe, GDF SUEZ, Belgium
• Matteo Mazzoni, Senior Market Analyst, NE Nomisma Energia, Italy
• Hans-Joachim Reck, CEO, German Association of Local Utilities (VKU), Germany
• Oskar Waluskiewicz, Lawyer, Senior Associate, Baker & McKenzie, Poland
15:40 - 15:50 Coffee B reak
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
25
Renewables and Environment
15:50 - 16:50 discussion panel
Low Emissions Policy – at What Price?
The structural reform of the EU ETS, which is currently under negotiations, aims to level out a disparity between CO2 allowance supply and demand, while also stimulating the CO2 allowance growth rate on the
European market. The European Commission and the Western European countries want the EUA prices to
go up, producers who seek to be competitive – quite the opposite. As for the investors, they expect stability and predictability. Is there a CO2 allowances price rate which would satisfy all market players? How to
achieve the goals of the climate package while also enhancing the competitive advantage of the European
economy?
Moderator:
• Maciej Gomolka, Owner, MGPL, Poland
Speakers:
• Daniel Milstein, Director, European Regional Office, US Department of Energy, USA
• Philipp Ruf, Lead Analyst EU Carbon Markets, Tschach Solutions GmbH, Germany
• Robert Sikorski, Trading Department Director, ZE PAK S.A. (Zespół Elektrowni Pątnów-Adamów-Konin), Poland
• Margus Vals, Member of the Management Board, Eesti Energia AS, Estonia
• Maciej Wisniewski, CEO., Consus Brokerage House, Poland
16:50 - 17:00 Coffee B reak
17:00 - 18:15 discussion panel
Smart Cities – Investment for the Future
Generations
Moderator:
• Bartlomiej Derski, Journalist, wysokienapiecie.pl, Poland
Speakers:
• Peter Christensen, Project Manager, Samsoe Energy Academy, Denmark
• Tadeusz Jarmuziewicz, Member, Parliament, Poland
• Khee Poh Lam, Professor, Carnegie Mellon University School of Architecture, USA
• Anh Vu, Smart Cities Program Manager, Réseau et Marché de l’Electricité
(ERDF), France
• Alyona Zubaryeva, Project Manager, EURAC Research, Italy
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
26
Renewables and Environment
18:15 - 18:30 presentation
Samsoe – the Danish Renewable Energy Island
The island of Samsoe, Denmark, won in 1997 a government competition to become a model renewable
energy community supplied with 100% renewable energy within the next decade. At the time Samsø was
entirely dependent on oil and coal, both of which it imported from the mainland. The experiment succeeded
and now Samsoe Model is something that inspires people throughout the world.
Denmark has set out an ambitious plan to make the country fossil independent within the year of 2050.
Samsoe will show how to do it in the year of 2030. Besides that, during the presentation, the Samsoe Energy
Academy representative will share the experience on making Samsoe an energy efficient island and give us
all a lesson on how to live sustainable.
P a r t n e r : Samsoe Energy Academy
Moderator:
• Peter Christensen, Project Manager, Samsoe Energy Academy, Denmark
20:00
R eception
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
Investments and Energy Security
9:00 - 10:00
27
discussion panel
The Electricity Market. New Challenges for
the CEE Countries
Completing the competitive, single electricity market is one of the main objectives of the EU energy policy.
Ever since the formulation of these objectives, this process has been running with a different intensity and
different dynamics, depending mostly on the level of development or possibilities of regional markets. As
a result of connecting of national markets, the liquidity and transparency of the regional markets has improved in recent time. Advanced connection of the markets in the Western part of the EU forces CEE countries to a more dynamic adjustment of the level of integration and cooperation.
Moderator:
• Daria Nochevnik, EU Energy Policy Expert, European Energy Review, Belgium
Speakers:
• Sergiu Ciobanu, General Director, National Energy Regulatory Agency, Moldova
• Kalle Kukk, Strategy Manager, Elering AS, Estonia
• Jaroslaw Wajer, Partner, EY, Poland
• Tudor Adascalitei, Head of Electricity Transmission Departament, Transelectrica Romania, Romania
10:00 - 10:10 Coffee B reak
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
28
Investments and Energy Security
10:10 - 11:10 discussion panel
Risk Management in the Energy and Resources Industry. How to Succeed?
The debate will discuss the latest trend models and the complexity of risk management in the energy and
resources industry. What are the management challenges? What is the key characteristic for successful
companies and how to succeed? How to reduce the risk and finally how to change the risk into growth
opportunities? Speakers will also focus on specific strategic risks that we can see across the whole energy
industry and how companies can use such knowledge to make them competitive and profitable.
Moderator:
• Wojciech Fedko, Advisor, Kancelaria Radców Prawnych i Adwokatów Głuchowski Siemiątkowski Zwara i Partnerzy, Poland
Speakers:
• Dirk Elvermann, Managing Director, BASF Poland
• Jan Ondrich, Partner, Candole Partners, Czech Republic
• Jan Talaska, Head of Department, Advisory, Development and Academy Poland, Det Norske Veritas Poland
• Ana Stanic, Director, E&A Law Limited, United Kingdom
11:10 - 11:20 Coffee B reak
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
Investments and Energy Security
29
11:20 - 12:20 discussion panel
The Rule of Law in the International Energy
Policy – the Role of International Treaties
and Agreements
The rule of law is a fundamental part of the way in which many of our societies are governed. Yet applying
and enforcing the rule of law in relations between sovereign states is a notch harder than managing lawbased societies within such sovereign states. When it comes to international energy cooperation, relations
between countries are often governed by either bilateral or multilateral treaties, and in the case of relations
between host governments and investors, concessional agreements of one type or another. Governance
in international energy relations has never been easy, however. Power politics has often moved ahead of
law-based relations in the global oil and gas business, given the extremely high stakes of the game. That
said, the rule of law struck back last year, when international arbitration rulings compelled the Russian government to pay out some $50 billion in compensation to former-shareholders of once powerful Russian oil
company, YUKOS. The courts ruled that the manner in which the Russian government expropriated YUKOS
assets had breached the Energy Charter Treaty, an investment protection instrument by which Russia was
judged to have been bound. The YUKOS case has therefore demonstrated just how powerful the rule of law
can be when it comes to the global energy game. Panellists will discuss the risks and benefits of the rule of
law in international energy relations, how effectively treaties and agreements underpin such ties between
countries, and what implications follow for both governments and investors in both the shorter and longer
term. Moderator:
• Marat Terterov, Principal Coordinator, Energy Charter Secretariat, Belgium
Speakers:
• Andrzej Dycha, Undersecretary of State, Ministry of the Economy, Poland
• Ana Stanic, Director, E&A Law Limited, United Kingdom
• Robert Jedrzejczyk, Legal Counsel, Managing Partner, Robert Jędrzejczyk &
Partners Law Firm, Poland
• Robert Wheal, Partner, White & Case LLP, United Kingdom
12:20 - 12:30 Coffee B reak
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
30
Investments and Energy Security
12:30 - 13:40 discussion panel
Perfect Balance - In Search of an Optimal
Energy Mix
A well-designed energy mix is a backbone of a country’s energy strategy. On the one hand, it provides energy security and diversification of supply, on the other hand – a favourable environment for the development of domestic industry. Poland’s energy policy remains in the line with the European policies. What
should be the resultant force of cost efficiency, supply security and climate protection in the production
of energy in Poland? What are the possible scenarios? What is the role of the national energy mix against
the EU background? What should be taken into account when composing the optimal mix? Are we able to
cooperate regionally?
Moderator:
• Jaroslav Neverovic, Chairman of Management Board, Integrante, Lithuania
Speakers:
• Jean-Pierre Favennec, Professor, IFP (French Institute of Petroleum) School,
France
• Jerzy Ignaszak, Deputy Chairman of the Board, The Regional Fund for Environmental Protection & Water Management in Wrocław, Poland
• Volker Stehmann, Senior Advisor Energy Policy, RWE AG, Germany
• Jaroslaw Wajer, Partner, EY, Poland
13:40 - 14:40 LU N C H
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
Investments and Energy Security
31
14:40 - 15:40 discussion panel
Together or Alone? Towards Energy Security in Europe
How important element of energy security is cooperation between states and international and intergovernmental organizations? Does one may act alone or rather, the cooperation is the only good solution?
How in this context is the cooperation within the EU and within its regions, including the Visegrad Group
as well as the Baltic and the Nordic states?
Moderator:
• Vytautas Nauduzas, Ambassador to Kazachstan, Ministry of Foreign Affairs,
Lithuania
Speakers:
• Mehmet Kinaci, Strategic Analyst, NATO HQ Supreme Allied Command, Turkey
• Daria Nochevnik, EU Energy Policy Expert, European Energy Review, Belgium
• Steve Rank, Senior Trade Commissioner, Australian Trade Commission, Australia
• Richard Wheeler, Managing Director, Center for Energy Security Dialogue,
USA
15:40 - 15:50 Coffee B reak
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
32
Investments and Energy Security
15:50 - 16:50 discussion panel
R&D and Innovation in the Energy Sector:
a Treasure Trove for Industry and other
Stakeholders
Energy targets in Europe are highly determined by climate change and increasing scarcity of resources at
least on the long run. More energy efficiency and energy saving measures need to be implemented by all
stakeholders such as industry, transport, public authorities and private households. To face this challenge
innovative and intelligent products and services are needed. The panel will discuss best practices, chances
and barriers on market introduction and provides expertise to funding opportunities for entrepreneurs,
researchers and consultants.
Moderator:
• Philip Lowe, Non-Executive Director, UK Competition and Markets Authority, United Kingdom
Speakers:
• Alessandro Costa, Member of Studies Committee, World Energy Council
(WEC), Italy
• Tim Patterson, CEO, Fuel Economy Solution Limited, United Kingdom
• Mariusz Filipowicz, Head of the Department of Sustainable Energy Development, AGH University of Science and Technology in Cracow, Poland
• Christian Labie, Director, RAEE-Rhônalpénergie-Environnement, France
Commentator:
• Daniel Schade, Vice Chairman, Project for Democratic Union, United Kingdom
16:50 - 17:00 Coffee B reak
17:00 - 17:20 presentation
Doing Energy Business in Kazakhstan
Speakers:
• Daurzhan Augambay, General Director, Association of Service Companies
of Kazakhstan, Kazakhstan
• Oleg Chervinskiy, Editor-in-Chief, Petroleum Journal, Kazakhstan
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
33
Investments and Energy Security
17:30 - 18:30 discussion panel
Energy as an Integrating Factor
There are different types of regional cooperation. A pillar of success are common interests and finding
compromise on contrasting issues. The BTC pipeline and the BTE pipeline have connected Azerbaijan,
Georgia and Turkey to launch joint business in the field of energy with follow up projects such as the BakuTbilisi-Kars railway. The potential of these and other cooperation in the energy sector will be discussed at
the panel.
Moderator:
• Michael Maier, Publisher, Deutsche Wirtschafts Nachrichten, Germany
Speakers:
• Zuzanna Brocka-Balbi, Legal Counsel, NE Nomisma Energia, Italy
• Ricardas Sargunas, Member of Energy Commission, Seimas, Lithuania
• Emmet Tuohy, Research Fellow, International Centre for Defence and Security (ICDS), Estonia
20:00
R eception
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
34
9:00 - 10:00
Exploration and Production
discussion panel
Shale Gas – a Chance or an Illusion?
Shale gas has as many supporters as opponents. Is the threat described by environmentalists real? Will the
energy security of Europe and Poland improve by the effective operation and use of shale gas? Can the US
shale revolution be repeated on the old continent?
Moderator:
• Boguslaw Sonik, President, Association “Maj 77”, Poland
Speakers:
• Claudiu Munteanu-Jipescu, Partner, Dentons Bucharest, Romania
• Artur Rogozik, Partner, TGC Corporate Lawyers , Poland
• Michael Stephenson, Director of Science and Technology, British Geological Survey, United Kingdom
• Pawel Turowski, Analyst, National Security Bureau, Poland
• Bart Van Vooren, Senior Associate of EU Regulatory and Trade Departament, Altius, Belgium
10:00 - 10:10 Coffee B reak
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
35
Exploration and Production
10:10 - 11:10 discussion panel
Nuclear Energy in Europe – How Much Politics, How Much Economy?
The panel aims to answer the following questions:
- Given the delays at the Olkiluoto and Flamanville projects, can new nuclear power plants in Europe
ever be built on time and budget?
- Even if nuclear energy is cheap and climate-friendly, can the European general public be persuaded
to accept it? - To what extent do you believe that heavily-subsidised renewable energy in Europe poses a threat to
nuclear power? - Are politicians out of step with the general public - is there actually more support for nuclear than they
believe?
Moderator:
• Steve Kidd, Senior Partner, East Cliff Consulting, United Kingdom
Speakers:
• Stephan Klement, Head of Unit for Nuclear Safety Architecture and Multilateral and International Co-operation, Energy Directorate General, European Commission, Luxembourg
• Bulat Nigmatulin, Former Deputy Minister of Energy of Russia, General Director, Institute of Problems of Power Engineering, Russia
• Jean-Pol Poncelet, Director General, FORATOM, Belgium
• Eugenijus Uspuras, Chairman of Scientific Council, Lithuanian Energy Institute, Lithuania
11:10 - 11:20 Coffee B reak
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
36
Exploration and Production
11:20 - 12:20 discussion panel
Mining Industry Restructuring in Central
Europe: A Mission Impossible?
The transition from a fossil based energy production to renewable energies is a process carried out in different speeds in Central Europe. While some countries have entered into a rapid transition process other countries follow a different path and consider fossil fuels and other conventional energies as indispensable, also
in the long term. The countries following different strategies are all members of the EU and have agreed to
work towards a single market for energy in Europe. The panel shall discuss: What are the possible synergies
from these different approaches? What role will coal play in this process? How can such different strategies
be made compatible?
P a r t n e r : German Agency for International Cooperation (GIZ)
Moderator:
• Fabian Joas, Project Manager Energy, German Agency for International Cooperation (GIZ), Germany
Speakers:
• Jan Dziekoński, Project Manager, Roland Berger Strategy Consultants, Poland
• Philip Lawrence, Chief Executive, The Coal Authority, United Kingdom
• Frank Peter, Senior Project Manager, Head of Power Market Analysis, Prognos AG, Germany
• Janusz Steinhoff, Chairman of the Programme Council, Polish Chamber of
Commerce, Poland
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
37
Exploration and Production
12:20 - 12:30 Coffee B reak
12:30 - 13:40 discussion panel
Infrastructure and Investments in the Energy Sector
In the new financial perspective, the priority for the EU energy sector will be to invest in the country’s energy
security and therefore, energy security is the overriding theme that will be discussed. The participants are
to touch upon the issues concerning the development of the European, as well as national electro-energy
system, including the scope and the nature of the planned national network investments, expansion of
cross-border connections, network corridors and areas such as smart grids.
P a r t n e r : Spanish Energy Club
Moderator:
• Pawel Wrabec, Editor-in-Chief, Rynek Infrastruktury, Poland
Speakers:
• Włodzimierz Mucha, Director of the Department of System Development,
Polskie Sieci Elektroenergetyczne S.A., Poland
• Arcadio Gutierrez Zapico, Director General, Spanish Energy Club, Spain
• Jacek Podkanski, Senior Engineer, Energy Generation and Networks, European Investment Bank, Poland
• Eamon Ryan, Senior Associate, E3G, Ireland
13:40 - 14:40 LU N C H
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
38
Exploration and Production
15.25 - 15.40 presentation
India’s Quest for ‘Power for All’: Lessons for
Europe
Speaker:
• Ritwik Mukherjee, Member of The Managing Board, Energy Ensemble, India
15:50 - 16:50 T hematic block
C o n n e c t i n g E u r o p e ’s E n e r g y C o r r i d o r s :
Political Premises and Business Opportunities
There are significant commonalities among the Eastern European members states of the EU with regard to
their energy dependence on an external monopolistic supplier of natural gas, their sizeable reliance on coal,
and their limited interconnectedness with each other and Western Europe. Will CEE and SEE states coordinate with each other in terms of energy and environment policies, both in
terms of joint common projects and in front of EU institutions? Will they be able to prioritize joint energy
projects and the common market design in front of separate deals with external state actors? Are the ensuing regional electricity and gas markets going to be able to integrate smoothly into the broader European
markets, or will they face compatibility issues?
How is state-centered planning going to be able to accommodate and make place to trans-national, market driven hubs and trade patterns? Will states in the region transition to a reduced role of strategic goalmakers, or will they continue to be significant asset owners?
P a r t n e r : Energy Policy Group
15:50 - 16:00 presentation
The Need for Polish-Romanian Energy Cooperation in the Region – Political and
Business Opportunities
Speaker:
• Radu Dudau, Director, Energy Policy Group, Romania
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
39
Exploration and Production
16:00 - 16:50 discussion panel
Connecting Europe’s Energy Corridors: Political Premises and Business Opportunities
Moderator:
• Laurentiu Pachiu, Managing Partner, Pachiu and Associates, Romania
Speakers:
• Kamil Blazek, Chairman, Association for Foreign Investment (AFI), Czech
Republic
• Anna Bulakh, Researcher, International Centre for Defence and Security
(ICDS), Estonia
• Radu Dudau, Director, Energy Policy Group, Romania
• Julian Popov, Chairman, Buildings Performance Institute Europe, Bulgaria /
United Kingdom
• Naill Trimble, Managing Director, Energy Contract Company, United Kingdom
16:50 - 17:00 Coffee B reak
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
40
Exploration and Production
17:00 - 18:30 T hematic block
Challenges for the European Gas Market
Fulfilling the European consumers’ needs until renewable resources will be widely used implicates implementing balanced and coherent policy aiming to develop gas infrastructure. Progressive liberalization and
integration of the European gas market raise concerns about the security of supply. How to ensure it? What
is the significance of unconventional gas sources for the European energy? What should be the role of gas
in the energy mix of European countries?
17:00 - 17:45 discussion panel
Challenges for the European Gas Market
Special guest:
• Jerome Ferrier, President , International Gas Union (IGU), France
Moderator:
• Greta Monika Tuckute, Director, Center for Geopolitical Studies, Lithuania
Speakers:
• Igor Tomberg, Professor, Moscow State Institute of International Relations
(MGIMO), Russia
• Andrej Pustisek, Professor of Energy Economics, Stuttgart University of Applied Sciences, Germany
• Konrad Szymanski, Member, Law and Justice Party, Poland
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 23
Exploration and Production
41
17:45 - 18:30 discussion panel
Innovations in the Gas Industry: Current
Situation and Future Trends
Moderator:
• Ole Gunnar Austvik, Professor, BI Norwegian Business School / NUPI , Norway
Speakers:
• Sergiu Maznic, Senior Consultant, Sund Energy AS, Norway
• Andrej Pustisek, Professor of Energy Economics, Stuttgart University of Applied Sciences, Germany
• Vladimir Revenkov, Expert, Foundation Institute for Energy and Finance,
Russia
20:00
R eception
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 24
42
Investments and Energy Security
8:30 - 9:00
Coffee B rea K
9:00 - 9:20
presentation
Local energy system using geothermal and
geothermic energy in the holiday mountain resort
P a r t n e r : Karpacz Community
9:20 - 9:30
presentation
Renewable energy in the context of implementation opportunity in Lower Silesia
P a r t n e r : Lower Silesia
Speaker:
• Paweł Karpiński, Deputy Head of Unit for Environment in Marshal’s Office
of Lower Silesia
9:30 - 9:40
B rea K
www.economic-forum.pl
Januar y 24
Investments and Energy Security
9:40 - 10:40
43
C losing S ession
Energy Storage Options for Future Sustainable Energy Systems
One of the great challenges in a non-fossil energy system with a high share of fluctuating renewable energy
is to align consumption and productionat timescales from seconds to years. Storage brings a wide spectrum of benefits to the electricity system as a whole and, utilities can employ them to integrate and optimise
all types of renewable energy resources and energy storage systems can contribute to grid stability and reliability. The investment costs of energy storage are considerable, however they will partly be offset as energy
storage reduce the cost of upgrading the transmission and distribution infrastructure.
9:40 - 10:00 presentation
Energy Storage Options for Future Sustainable Energy Systems
Moderator:
• Hans Hvidtfeldt Larsen, Vice Dean, DTU National Laboratory for Sustainable Energy, Denmark
10:00 - 10:40 discussion panel
Energy Storage Options for Future Sustainable Energy Systems
Moderator:
• Hans Hvidtfeldt Larsen, Vice Dean, DTU National Laboratory for Sustainable Energy, Denmark
Speakers:
• Andreas Luczak, Managing Director, Vanadis Power GmbH, Germany
• Lars Stephan, Senior Manager for Regulatory Affairs, Younicos AG, Germany
• Philip Pasler, Scientific Researcher in Energy , Technical University in Berlin,
Germany
• Anna Carolina Tortora, Head of Innovation and Storage, Terna Plus, Italy
www.economic-forum.pl